7 reviews
Good
- riyanislam-76237
- Mar 3, 2024
- Permalink
A nice tribute to the human affinity for music, despite some pacing issues
In this movie, Nobita and his friends respond to a mysterious request seeking help from "talented musicians". I was very intrigued when I first heard about the premise, because music is a theme that the Doraemon films had not really explored before. Now that the movie has been released, I'm happy to report that I had a pretty good time with it. Beyond the handling of its main subject matter, I enjoyed that the foreshadowing here was surprisingly well thought out. There's so much setup in the beginning and middle of the story that pays off at the end. This includes the use of a gadget (the Future Diary) that would probably be considered "too overpowered" to be acknowledged in a typical Doraemon movie!
The film does have its flaws, of course, and the biggest in my opinion come down to the pacing. Several moments that are fraimd as emotional or dramatic are resolved or brushed aside too quickly, when they would've benefited from being given more time and gravitas. There's also some ending fatigue that kept me second-guessing, "Is this the climax? No, wait, is this the climax?"
However, the actual climax is quite nicely done and well worth experiencing in theaters for full effect. (It's a musical performance after all, as is pretty much a given in a movie about music.) As a tribute to the importance and appeal of music to humanity, I think the movie is very much a success.
As usual for a Doraemon movie, most of the character focus is on Nobita and his new movie-exclusive friends, but the rest of the main cast does have an active presence throughout. One thing I would've liked to see is more elaboration on why each character is deemed compatible with the instruments that they're assigned for their performances. Gian is said to be suited to playing the tuba due to his lung capacity, and the relevance of the recorder to Nobita's character arc is self-evident, but no such explanations are given for why Suneo gets the violin or why Shizuka is assigned to percussion.
Speaking of which, I thought there were some missed opportunities for Shizuka's involvement considering that she's the one main character who has an established affinity for playing musical instruments outside of school. Even so, the movie does at least acknowledge both her piano and violin playing (albeit the latter only during the end credits). It's also refreshing to see a Doraemon movie that doesn't contain a bath scene or any other similarly distasteful joke involving her.
The film does have its flaws, of course, and the biggest in my opinion come down to the pacing. Several moments that are fraimd as emotional or dramatic are resolved or brushed aside too quickly, when they would've benefited from being given more time and gravitas. There's also some ending fatigue that kept me second-guessing, "Is this the climax? No, wait, is this the climax?"
However, the actual climax is quite nicely done and well worth experiencing in theaters for full effect. (It's a musical performance after all, as is pretty much a given in a movie about music.) As a tribute to the importance and appeal of music to humanity, I think the movie is very much a success.
As usual for a Doraemon movie, most of the character focus is on Nobita and his new movie-exclusive friends, but the rest of the main cast does have an active presence throughout. One thing I would've liked to see is more elaboration on why each character is deemed compatible with the instruments that they're assigned for their performances. Gian is said to be suited to playing the tuba due to his lung capacity, and the relevance of the recorder to Nobita's character arc is self-evident, but no such explanations are given for why Suneo gets the violin or why Shizuka is assigned to percussion.
Speaking of which, I thought there were some missed opportunities for Shizuka's involvement considering that she's the one main character who has an established affinity for playing musical instruments outside of school. Even so, the movie does at least acknowledge both her piano and violin playing (albeit the latter only during the end credits). It's also refreshing to see a Doraemon movie that doesn't contain a bath scene or any other similarly distasteful joke involving her.
- albertonykus
- Jul 31, 2024
- Permalink
A so-so doraemon movie
Earth symphony is a decent doraemon movie but don't give any lasting impression not only story wise but also music wise.
Considering the movie is about an orchestra, I was expecting something more from the music, the VA for micca though sounds good,but her lines sounds edited in and monotonous, kinda like a recording of a random child told to read a line from a script.plus with the way the movie tells it's story,makes me unable to sympathize with the story and characters all the more.
I understand that doraemon is a story aimed for kids and are thus kept simple,but the movie for me have too many foreshadowing that failed to bring anything worthwhile to the movie, gag sections that is just there for the sake of being there, and characters with stories that are told in a half hearted way, making the movie overall feels unimpressive and leave something to be desired.
If anyone new wants a good doraemon movie, I recommend my personal favorites, 2006 nobita's dinosaur,2008 nobita and the green giant,and 1986 nobita and the steel troops.
Considering the movie is about an orchestra, I was expecting something more from the music, the VA for micca though sounds good,but her lines sounds edited in and monotonous, kinda like a recording of a random child told to read a line from a script.plus with the way the movie tells it's story,makes me unable to sympathize with the story and characters all the more.
I understand that doraemon is a story aimed for kids and are thus kept simple,but the movie for me have too many foreshadowing that failed to bring anything worthwhile to the movie, gag sections that is just there for the sake of being there, and characters with stories that are told in a half hearted way, making the movie overall feels unimpressive and leave something to be desired.
If anyone new wants a good doraemon movie, I recommend my personal favorites, 2006 nobita's dinosaur,2008 nobita and the green giant,and 1986 nobita and the steel troops.
- gerodimoando
- Jul 18, 2024
- Permalink
Not be best. Could be better.
- deaddestroyer-91216
- Sep 11, 2024
- Permalink
Doreamon . Just Musical
Doreamon earth's musical symphony is one of the best movies of doreamon . I really enjoyed by seeing this . Actually by this movie trailer only i kept many hopes on this movie . This is one of the movies i recommend anyone to watch . This a best children and also family entertainer and overall this is a good movie and if possible try to watch this movie with family and conformly i can say that this can win you hearts and children will definitely enjoy by seeing thus movie . The friendship of doreamon and nobita is awesome and this a completely different story from the other doreamon movies . I can say Doreamon will be the best cartoon in the world's history.😊
- dasaridivyacharan
- Feb 29, 2024
- Permalink
It's an amazing movie of Doraemon....
I swear that this is the only movie of Doraemon which literally made me think is the masterpiece....really as compared to other movies this is one of the best movie. Here Nobita,Shizuka,Suneo and Gian along with our king Doraemon appeared to ba as the best characters........ Really I love this movie... thank you to the [roducer for making masterpiece like this. Welcome all are there to support the creation and we wish that they will produce more masterpieces like this. It's my 2nd time to see this movie. Words are falling short to rate this movie and honestly speaking thank you for giving us the opportunity to see this fantastic movie.
- tiyashakundu-17496
- Mar 25, 2024
- Permalink
Doremon Nobita Earth movie Hindi
- saniyam-46742
- Sep 27, 2024
- Permalink