Wikipedia:Bots/Requests for approval/Seppi333Bot 2: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
→Discussion: re |
→Discussion: c |
||
Line 58:
: The justification for the [[Wikipedia:Bots/Requests for approval/BogBot 3|parenthetical redirects]] was very clear: provide an unambiguous mechanism for locating [[Gene Wiki]] articles. Most of these redirects have already been created. Hence it would very useful to provide redirects for the newly created articles and update redirects for the rare cases where the official gene has changed. The redirects provide an efficient mechanism to find Gene Wiki articles. Why is necessary to create and maintain lists of tens of thousands of genes? Who is going to use these lists and for what purpose? [[User:Boghog|Boghog]] ([[User talk:Boghog|talk]]) 15:08, 24 December 2019 (UTC)
::Hmm; I don't think it's that rare TBH; I saw around half a dozen gene symbols change when I updated those gene lists today. That said, the gene lists aren't relevant to this task in any way; I'm just proposing the creation of redirects. But, to answer your questions, it's not any more or less necessary than creating and maintaining any other article on Wikipedia. I do it voluntarily because I know there are some who would find it useful/interesting for the same reason I do. I suspect that people who would "use" these lists are readers who are interested in human genes. The alternative is [https://biomart.genenames.org/martform/#!/default/HGNC?datasets=hgnc_gene_mart&attributes=hgnc_gene__hgnc_gene_id_1010%2Chgnc_gene__status_1010%2Chgnc_gene__approved_symbol_1010%2Chgnc_gene__uniprot__uniprot_accession_1036&hgnc_gene__locus_group_1010=protein-coding+gene HGNC's gene browser] which cuts off the list at 1000 entries and utilizes such an excessive amount of pagination so as to render the viewer relatively useless. As for the purpose, I can't say; I only know what I
|