18
Metascore
11 reviews · Provided by Metacritic.com
- 38Movie NationRoger MooreMovie NationRoger Moore“Vanishing” is ambitious, but in every trite, pat and melodramatic way you can think of.
- 33The PlaylistThe PlaylistWhile there are a few intriguing themes and ideas at play in The Vanishing of Sidney Hall, once the viewer perseveres through the over-editing the final product is disappointing.
- 30The Hollywood ReporterBoyd van HoeijThe Hollywood ReporterBoyd van HoeijWhile the precociously talented Sidney, played by Logan Lerman, is not an uninteresting character, the artificially constructed nature of the narrative gives the supposedly shocking revelations way too much importance, essentially subjugating any sense of character development and flaws to its mystery-type structure.
- 30VarietyGeoff BerkshireVarietyGeoff BerkshireSidney Hall strings its audience along on a tedious journey that runs out of steam long before reaching an embarrassingly overwrought finale.
- 30The New York TimesJeannette CatsoulisThe New York TimesJeannette CatsoulisHandsome cinematography and a highly competent supporting cast — including Michelle Monaghan, Nathan Lane and Alex Karpovsky — can’t save The Vanishing of Sidney Hall, a tortured mystery dripping with pretentiousness.
- 30Village VoiceTatiana CraineVillage VoiceTatiana CraineThe Vanishing of Sidney Hall fails to give its characters depth, leaving viewers with little more than a shallow white guy troubled by his fame.
- 25The Film StageJordan RuimyThe Film StageJordan RuimyA manipulative mess from start to finish.
- 25Slant MagazineDerek SmithSlant MagazineDerek SmithThe seesaw of effect of oscillating between extolling Sidney’s genius and lingering on his anguish begins to feel like a child slowly burning an ant with a magnifying glass, occasionally taking breaks to truly savor the harm he or she is committing.
- 20Los Angeles TimesRobert AbeleLos Angeles TimesRobert AbeleThe many ridiculous tragedies are just there to slather showy woundedness on a weak, annoying character, leaving The Vanishing of Sidney Hall a mystery-free mystery with an inexhaustible supply of eye-rolling postures.
- 16IndieWireKate ErblandIndieWireKate ErblandInitially it seems as if Sidney Hall will just be another film about lone geniuses trapped in worlds where they’re misunderstood or undervalued, but the film then unspools into nearly two hours of baffling narrative choices, weak character development, and so many offensive cliches that it would be funny if it wasn’t so, well, offensive.