Case Study Ek Ruka Hua Faisla

Prepared by : Rajesh Srivastava Roll No. : 20 (EPGDIM IIFT, New Delhi) 1

Ek Ruka Hua Faisla

Introduction : Ek Ruka Hua Faisla ( ) is a Bollywood film of 1986, directed by Basu Chatterjee. It is a remake of the Golden Bear winning, American motion picture 12 Angry Men (1957), which was directed by Sidney Lumet. Ek Ruka Hua Faisla
Directed by Produced by Written by Music by Cinematography Editing by Release date(s) Running time Language Basu Chatterjee Basu Chatterjee Screenplay: Ranjit Kapur Basu Chatterjee Dialogue: Ranjit Kapur [1] Basu Chakravarti Ajay Prabhakar Kamal A. Sehgal 1986 117 min. Hindi

The Golden Bear is the highest prize awarded for the best film at the Berlin International Film Festival. Bears are the symbol of Berlin,

Re - take

Re-take :
Few Facts the Character
The story moves around a boy who is 19 years old. Lives in slums Belongs to minority Childhood was in miserable conditions His mother died when he was 9 years old His father was a drinker, quarrelsome & a cruel person, used to beat him daily He hit a stone on his teacher when he was 10 years old Engaged in Car theft & gambling Expert in knife playing He was sent to Reformity School for 1.5 years against a case.

The Character Background : There is a 19 yrs old boy who has been alleged as murder of his father by the court . Court Decision : A panel of 12 Juror appointed to decide that, the boy has actually murdered his father or not. Clause in Courts statement : Jurors have to make One Decision either murder or not-murderer.
4

Juror of the Case

C. D. Sindhu

Deepak Kejriwal 5

Amitabh Srivastava 6 7

Pankaj Kapur 8

S. M. Zaheer

Subhash Udghate

Hemant Mishra

M. K. Raina

K. K. Raina

10

11

12

Annu Kapoor

Subbiraj

Shailendra Goel

Aziz Qureshi

Key evidences in the Murder Case

The knife; the tool used to murder the old man

Eye witness 1 an old man who was the neighbor of the victim

Eye witness 2 a lady who lives opposite to the victims house

Sitting arrangement
1 2 3 4

Jurors Sitting Arrangement

Lawyer Contractor Contractor (House painting)

Deepak Kejriwal 5

Amitabh Srivastava

4
7

Pankaj Kapur

6
8

S. M. Zaheer

1
Subhash Udghate
Moderator

7
Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina K. K. Raina

12

10

11

10

11

8
Architect Architect

12

Professional (Advertising)

Annu Kapoor

Subbiraj

Is the Boy a murder ?

Shailendra Goel Aziz Qureshi
7

(Voting was taken as a criteria)

Root Cause
1 2 3 One of the Jurors voted against the motion 4 that the Boy might not be a murder.

Contractor (House painting)

Deepak Kejriwal 5

Amitabh Srivastava

4
7

Pankaj Kapur

6
8

S. M. Zaheer

1
Subhash Udghate Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina

7
K. K. Raina

12

10

11

10

11

8
Architect

12

Annu Kapoor

Subbiraj

Shailendra Goel

Aziz Qureshi

Jurors Decision
1 2

Voting ~ 1
3 4
7 Pankaj Kapur

Contractor (House painting)

Deepak Kejriwal 5

Amitabh Srivastava 6

6
8

S. M. Zaheer

1
Subhash Udghate Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina

7
K. K. Raina

12

10

11

10

11

8
Architect

12

Annu Kapoor

The Boy might not be a murder.

Subbiraj

Shailendra Goel

Aziz Qureshi

1 /129

Jurors Decision
1 2

Voting ~ 2
3 4
7 Pankaj Kapur

Deepak Kejriwal 5

Amitabh Srivastava 6

6
8

S. M. Zaheer

1
Subhash Udghate Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina

7
K. K. Raina

12

10

11

10

11

12

Annu Kapoor

The Boy might not be a murder.

Subbiraj

Shailendra Goel

Aziz Qureshi 10

2 /12

Jurors Decision
1 2

Voting ~ 3
3 4
7 Pankaj Kapur

Deepak Kejriwal 5

Amitabh Srivastava 6

6
8

S. M. Zaheer

1
Subhash Udghate Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina

7
K. K. Raina

12

10

11

10

11

12

Annu Kapoor

The Boy might not be a murder.

Subbiraj

Shailendra Goel

Aziz Qureshi 11

5 /12

Jurors Decision
1 2

Voting ~ 4
3 4
7 Pankaj Kapur

Deepak Kejriwal 5

Amitabh Srivastava 6

6
8

S. M. Zaheer

1
Subhash Udghate

Hemant Mishra

50 : 50
10
11

7
K. K. Raina

M. K. Raina

12

10

11

12

Annu Kapoor

The Boy might not be a murder.

Subbiraj

Shailendra Goel

Aziz Qureshi 12

6 /12

Jurors Decision
1 2

Voting ~ 5
3 4
7 Pankaj Kapur

Deepak Kejriwal 5

Amitabh Srivastava 6

6
8

S. M. Zaheer

1
Subhash Udghate Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina

7
K. K. Raina

12

10

11

10

11

12

Annu Kapoor

The Boy might not be a murder.

Subbiraj

Shailendra Goel

Aziz Qureshi 13

9 /12

Jurors Decision
1 2

Voting ~ 6
3 4
7 Pankaj Kapur

Deepak Kejriwal 5

Amitabh Srivastava 6

6
8

S. M. Zaheer

1
Subhash Udghate Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina

7
K. K. Raina

12

10

11

10

11

12

Annu Kapoor

The Boy might not be a murder.

Subbiraj

Shailendra Goel

Aziz Qureshi 14

8 /12

Jurors Decision
1 2

Voting ~ 7
3 4
7 Pankaj Kapur

Deepak Kejriwal 5

Amitabh Srivastava 6

6
8

S. M. Zaheer

1
Subhash Udghate Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina

7
K. K. Raina

12

10

11

10

11

12

Annu Kapoor

The Boy might not be a murder.

Subbiraj

Shailendra Goel

Aziz Qureshi 15

11 /12

Jurors Decision
1 2

Final
Lawyer

Contractor

Deepak Kejriwal 5

Amitabh Srivastava

4
7

Pankaj Kapur

6
8

S. M. Zaheer

1
Subhash Udghate
Moderator

7
Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina K. K. Raina

12

10

11

10

11

8
Architect

12

Professional (Advertising)

Annu Kapoor

The Group jointly decided Subbiraj Shailendra Goel The Boy is not a murder

Aziz Qureshi 16

12/12

Learning...

Learning
Different People Different Background Different Profession Different Age Groups Different Mindsets Deepak Kejriwal
5
Lawyer Contractor

Amitabh Srivastava

4
Parts 7

Pankaj Kapur

6
R&D

S. M. Zaheer 8

Sales 6

Service

Marketing

1
Subhash Udghate
Moderator HEAD

Business Organisation
Hemant Mishra M. K. Raina
Finance Operations Manufacturing HR

7
Purchase Raina K. K.

12

10

SIS

11

10

11

8
Architect

12

Advertising

Annu Kapoor

Subbiraj

Shailendra Goel

Aziz Qureshi 18

Reason for Difference

Different People Different Background Different Profession Different Age Groups Different Mindsets Deepak Kejriwal
5 1 2

Voting
3 4
7 Pankaj Kapur

Contractor (House painting)

Amitabh Srivastava 6

6
8

S. M. Zaheer

Conflict Power Politics

10
11
M. K. Raina

1
Subhash Udghate Hemant Mishra

7
K. K. Raina

12

10

11

8
Architect

12

Annu Kapoor

The Boy might not be a murder.

Subbiraj

Shailendra Goel

Aziz Qureshi 19

1 /12

Conflict in Juror

20

Conflict
Why Conflict Occurs : Differences in information, beliefs, values, interests, or desires. A scarcity of some resource. Rivalries in which one person or group competes with another

Either Convince / Get convinced

21

Ways to Manage Conflict

There are 5 ways to manage conflict

Avoidance (just leave it) Competition (I win, you lose) Accommodation (I lose or give in) Compromise (we both get something) Collaboration (we both win)

Tips to Manage Conflict

Build good relationships before conflict occurs Do not let small problems escalate; deal with them as they arise Respect differences Listen to others perspectives on the conflict situation

Acknowledge feelings before focussing on facts

Focus on solving problems, not changing people If you cant resolve the problem, turn to someone who can help Remember to adapt your style to the situation and persons involved

23

Power & Politics

Power :

(Make things happen in the way you want)

A capacity that A has to influence the behavior of B so that B acts in accordance with As wishes.

Politics :
Behavior to influence or attempt to influence the distribution of advantages and disadvantages within the organization/group

24

Way to win

25

Be the Change

Personal oriented to goal oriented Individual driven to team driven Enforcement to facilitation

Present oriented to future oriented

26

Feedback for improvements

Thanks for given an opportunity to present the case.