How To Select Shares Guide
How To Select Shares Guide
uk
CONTENTS
CONTENTS
pg 3
Introduction Why pick shares? What this guide will tell you Part A. Get the idea Method 1: Economic cycle Method 2: Big Themes Method 3: Scuttlebutt Method 4: Directors dealings Method 5: Newspapers and magazines Method 6: Excessive falls Get the idea - Summary Part B. Analyse the Company Fundamental Analysis 1. Performance (Prot Margin) 2. Sustainability (Gearing) 3. Value (PE Ratio) Fundamental analysis - Summary Technical Analysis 1. Trends 2. Support/Resistance Fundamental or technical analysis? Conclusion
pg 4
pg 12 pg 12
pg 16
pg 19 pg 19
IMPORTANT INVESTMENT NOTES All investments should be held for the long term as their value can fall as well as rise, therefore you could get back less than you invested. Unless otherwise stated investments do not provide the capital guarantees of a deposit account. Similarly any yields will vary over time, so income is variable and not guaranteed. This is designed as a guide for information purposes only and is not a personal recommendation. If you are unsure you should seek advice. May 2012
INTRODUCTION
INTRODUCTION
Why pick shares?
In 2008 the FTSE All Share Index fell 33%. It was a terrible year for shares. However, in that year 225 of the 570 shares in the FTSE All Share beat the Index. The share price of three shares, Telecom Plus, Randgold Resources and BTG, increased over 50%; pharmaceutical giant AstraZeneca rose 30%. In the following year, 2009, the market bounced back and the FTSE All Share Index increased 25%. That year 340 of the 570 shares in the FTSE All Share beat the index, with 100 shares increasing by over 100%. The lessons we can draw is that in every year the overall index can mask the performance of individual shares. Even in a disastrous year like 2008 there will be some shares that perform strongly. The challenge for investors is to identify those shares.
PART A
If you are thinking of investing in cyclical shares, look for those companies: with strong balance sheets and little or no debt that anticipate downturns or react quickly by reducing staffing levels, cutting poor selling lines or abandoning unprofitable markets that do not expand too rapidly in an upswing and thus avoid overstretching their financial and management resources where you believe the fall in the share price has factored in all the bad news and then some more ii). Defensive shares Defensives are companies that sell pretty much the same amount of goods or services whatever the state of the economy. They do not enjoy the boom times as cyclical shares do but neither are they set back so badly in tougher times. They are referred to as defensives because they are seen as a potential line of defence when share prices are falling. The introduction to this guide mentioned that shares in the pharmaceutical company AstraZeneca rose 30% in the otherwise dismal 2008. It didnt take a genius to work out that even in a financial crisis people still need to buy pharmaceuticals a good example of a defensive share. It is also a good example of how much of investing is just common sense. Of course, no sector is entirely recession-proof. Supermarkets seem superficially to be immune from a downturn as we all still have to eat, but we can switch to cheaper foods and drinks, thus putting pressure on profit margins. Therefore defensives can also fall in value too. One significant difference between the two types
of company is worth noting: defensive shares tend to have greater visibility of earnings; that is they have contracts that guarantee revenue for months or even years to come. Such companies generally represent more stable investments than those living hand to mouth. If you are thinking of investing in defensive shares, look for those companies: with good visibility of earnings selling goods or services that are in continuous demand with a good geographic spread of markets with attractive dividend yields The following table gives some examples of the major cyclical and defensive sectors. Cyclical sectors
Aerospace Automotive Banks Construction Engineering and Industrials Media Manufacturing Mining Property Retailing Travel & Leisure
Defensive sectors
Food Beverages Healthcare Household goods Insurance Pharmaceuticals Support Services Tobacco Water
TIP
When considering shares to buy, bear in mind the prevailing stage of the economic cycle. In theory, when the economy is growing strongly, cyclical shares tend to perform well; while in a downturn defensive shares should if not perform strongly at least outperform cyclical shares.
companies will thrive while others will fail to take advantage and get left behind losing money for their investors. Investments made using Big Themes thinking should only be made with the longer term in mind. Company examples
Pearson
Theme
Education is soon to become an integrated, global, digital business with demand and innovation driven as in so many (other) areas - by the emerging markets. Global healthcare spending is set to soar with a combination of people living longer in developed countries and middle-class consumer populations growing in emerging markets. The urbanisation and infrastructure development of China and other emerging markets is likely to provide strong demand for resources for a period of many decades.
Pharmaceuticals
GlaxoSmithKline
Mining
Rio Tinto
The global middle class is set to expand rapidly as emerging economies Burberry become wealthier. As this happens consumption will increase, especially the discretionary element where brand names are all-important. China is investing billions in Africa's resources which will help trade and economic growth there for decades. But Africa is also growing internally with a booming middle class that should drive consumption. PZ Cussons
Method 3. Scuttlebutt
Peter Lynch was a fund manager who believed that you can turn personal experiences as a consumer into good investment opportunities. For example, he liked the doughnuts at Dunkin Donuts and the beds at a particular motel chain so much that he bought the shares. It obviously worked for him; he managed the Fidelity Magellan Fund one of the most successful funds in history. Lynch said: Every time you shop in a store, eat a hamburger or buy new sunglasses you're getting valuable input. By browsing around you can see what's selling and what isn't. This idea of using personal experience to influence your investing decisions was originally proposed by Philip Fisher who called the process scuttlebutt*. The great thing about scuttlebutt is that all investors can use it, and their experience can be just as valid as highly-paid fund managers (who probably dont get out that much anyway). Scuttlebutt research is easy. Next time youre in the high street, see which shops seem to be busy or those shops that seem rather too quiet and just generally unattractive. If you take easyJet flights and find them nearly always full, perhaps the company is worth looking at. If budgets are biting and you decide to stay in a little more frequently and order a Dominos pizza, perhaps others are doing the same. Scuttlebutt may seem too easy, but dont dismiss it often this subjective experience can be more valuable than the seemingly more objective, but academic, views of analysts and newspaper columnists. Stock market research is often based on historical performance, but your own experiences can show you exactly whats happening right now.
TIP
The internet offers great opportunities to extend the power of scuttlebutt research beyond personal consumer experience to see feedback from thousands. Obviously, one must weigh carefully anything on the internet, but it is certainly a useful additional tool to research a companys products or services.
Throughout the year there are certain periods when directors are not allowed to buy and sell shares in their company because they have access to certain privileged information (e.g. in the period just before results are announced) but for the rest of the year directors can deal in their company shares just like any other investor. The LSE must be informed of all such dealings and this information is then widely disseminated. Some investors closely follow the dealings of directors, in the not unreasonable belief that the
*Scuttlebutt is an old naval term for gossip or rumour. Sailors would talk around the scuttlebutt (water barrel on a ship) and
people who understand a company best are its own directors. There are many ways to interpret directors
dealings. In some cases, such as the chart below, after a quiet period director buying activity can signal that something is about to happen. Note: Past performance is not a guide to future returns.
(p)
Shares bought
In other cases, directors buying after a big fall in the shares can indicate that the directors simply believe the extent of the fall is unwarranted and that the company is still sound. On 9 November 2011 Admiral shares fell over 25% following a negative reaction to the companys
third quarter results. Seven directors felt the selloff was overdone and invested a combined 11.1m in the shares. In the following months the shares recovered most of their losses from that day, and in March the company released record profits for the eighth consecutive year.
ADMIRAL ADM
1500 1400 1300 1200 1100 1000 900 800 700
Sep 11 Oc t 11 11 Nov 1 Dec 1 12 Jan 1 Feb 2 M ar 12 12 Apr
(p)
Shares bought
This can also sometimes be seen market-wide. In retrospect we can see that after the financial crisis of 2008 the market bottomed in March 2009 and then bounced back strongly. However, at the time, in March 2009, it wasnt at all obvious that that was the bottom it never is obvious at the time. But an exceptional number of directors bought shares in their own companies between January and March 2009. They evidently did not
believe that the level of share prices reflected the underlying fundamentals of their companies this was a great signal that shares had been oversold. Directors dont always get it right. In March 2006 there was a frenzy of excited directors buying shares in Paragon at a price which turned out to be a bubble peak for the shares. Their error was compounded when they tried to double up by buying on the way down as well.
Shares bought
TIP
Directors dealings can sometimes provide great signals for share price movements. But remember, the buying signals are more reliable than the selling signals.
(p)
As can be seen, just three weeks later the shares had bounced back to their previous levels. This is fairly common. The market can over-react to profit warnings and the shares become over-sold. The opportunity here was to recognise that the shares had been greatly over-sold and to buy them after they had fallen 19% on the day of the announcement. A similar behaviour can also be seen sometimes when companies announce good results. There is an old stock market adage which says: buy on the
rumour, sell on the news investors cash in on good news and their selling forces the price down, which can then create opportunities for the nimble and level-headed investor. This method of selecting shares is not without danger. Sometimes shares fall for a very good reason and continue falling. The skill is in finding companies that are fundamentally sound but have been over-sold in the short term.
SUMMARY
PART B
Fundamental Analysis
When planning to buy a second-hand car, you might think of three things: 1. Performance. How fast does the car go? How efficient is it? 2. Reliability. What are the chances of the car breaking down? 3. Value. Is the seller asking too much? We are going to look at analysing a company using the same three criteria (although instead of reliability, in the case of shares well call it sustainability). The car-buying analogy is not perfect, but its good enough to get us started. One way to do this is to look at how much profit a company makes for every 100 of goods or services it sells. This is called the profit margin and is defined as: profit margin = net profit sales revenue
When analysing a company the first thing we want to do is to assess whether the company is any good! Is it making good profits?
The result is usually expressed as a percentage. The average profit margin for companies in the FTSE 100 Index is around 17%. Currently Next has a profit margin of 16%, while Diageo has a profit margin of 24%. Profit margins do differ somewhat between sectors; supermarkets tend to have margins in the single digits, while pharmaceutical companies can have margins over 30%. Profit margins are not usually calculated for financial companies.
TIP
When assessing the profit margin of a company it is useful to compare it with the margins of other companies in the same sector.
If the company passes the first performance test, the next criterion to address is sustainability. There are many ways of looking at this; in this guide we will focus on the size of a companys debt. A certain level of debt can be beneficial for a
2. Sustainability (Gearing)
company, but beyond a certain point there is a danger of a company being overwhelmed by too much debt. To assess debt we will use a measure called gearinggearing = total borrowings cash shareholders equity
scramble to reduce debt when the cycle turns down, especially if interest rates are rising. There is no set level for gearing, nor even a guide level at which alarm bells should start ringing, although you would normally expect gearing to be less than 100%. However, companies with particularly high capital costs such as plant hire or construction groups always have high gearing, usually above 100%. Typically, bankers and lenders have liked to see gearing of no more than 50%. If gearing is above this level, investors would have to consider whether a company would have problems borrowing more money at reasonable rates.
Where shareholders equity is the companys total assets less its liabilities. Again, the result is usually expressed as a percentage. The higher the figure, the more potentially overstretched the company is. The lower the figure, the less onerous the interest burden will be. Gearing goes in and out of fashion. Running up debts to gear up the business magnifies profits in the good years but it has the opposite effect in the bad years. Thus gearing tends to be popular when the economic cycle turns upwards but there is a
We may find an attractive company (one that is profitable and has low debt), but it will not be useful to us if the shares are priced very high because many other investors have already bought the shares. So, now we need to look at value. We need to assess whether the shares are priced cheaply or expensively in the market.
HOW TO SELECT SHARES | 13
Imagine you are a billionaire and you are thinking of buying a whole company for 200m, what sort of profit would you want to see that company make annually? Perhaps, 20m. 40m would be better. But if the company was only making, say, 5m would you still buy the company for 200m? Perhaps not. If the company was making a profit of 20m, youd be paying 10 times (200/20) the annual profits to buy the company. If the company was making, say 40m profits, then youd be paying 5 times (200/40). And, if the company was only making, say, 5m profits youd be paying 40 times (200/5). This relationship between the value of the company in the market and its profits is one of the most important in share investing and is called the PE ratio, or just PE in most cases. The formula is usually expressed as: PE ratio = share price earnings per share
How to calculate the PE ratio When we come to calculate the PE ratio, the share price is easy to determine - we just look at the stock market and see what price the shares are currently trading at. But we have a choice when it comes to the figure for earnings per share of using: Historic earnings these are the actual earnings reported in the most recent company report Future earnings these are the forecast earnings for the coming year The choice of which earnings figures to use can have a significant effect on the calculated PE. For example, at the time of writing the engineering services company Babcock has a historic PE ratio of 26 and a forecast PE ratio of 12. The attraction of the historic ratio PE (i.e. the PE ratio calculated using historic earnings) is that the earnings figure is historic fact and easy to find. The PE ratio will
14 | HOW TO SELECT SHARES
also vary depending on the share price. Therefore it is important to calculate the PE ratio using the most recent share price. The PE ratio quoted in the fundamental data of a company will be based on the share price at the time of the report. How to use the PE ratio The PE ratio is useful as it allows us to compare the market price of a company with those of other companies, a sector or the stock market as a whole. As a general principle, the lower the PE, the
cheaper the shares are but beware, as there may be a reason why shares are going cheaply. The average PE for the UK market tends to settle around 14 but it partly depends on the outlook for the economy. Many companies, including sound ones, were down to single figures in the recession because investors fretted over whether earnings could be maintained. PE ratios differ between sectors. For example, slow growing utility companies usually have low PE ratios (below 15), while high growth companies, like technology companies, have high PE ratios (over 30). Investors can use PE ratios to compare shares. For example, if Sainsbury has a PE ratio of 9 and
Morrisons a PE ratio of 12, one could say that Sainsbury is undervalued relative to Morrisons (if one also believes the prospects for both companies are similar). However, if one believes that the growth prospects for Morrisons are better than Sainsbury, then it is a case of trying to quantify how much better they are and whether Morrisons deserves a PE ratio 30% higher than Sainsbury. Investors looking for share price gains will want to find fast growing companies. And, fortunately, its not difficult to find them. The problem is that in most cases that fast growth will already be reflected in the high price of the shares (i.e. the shares will have a high PE ratio). The challenge for the investor is to find companies whose growth is not yet fully reflected in the share price.
SUMMARY
Fundamental Analysis
In this section we looked at three ratios used in fundamental analysis. In practice, there are many more ratios that investors can use the three here were chosen because they are straightforward and accessible.
Criteria
Performance Sustainability
Ratio
Prot margin Gearing
Notes
The higher the better. Gearing can be good when the economy is strong and dangerous when the economy is weak. Be wary of very high gearing. High PE ratios can be justied if a company is growing fast. Investors look for companies where the PE ratio does not fully reect the growth prospects.
Value
PE ratio
As investors become more experienced they can use more complex ratios, and those customised to their particular investing approach. However, more complex does not always mean better. The key for investors is to use a disciplined approach that they are comfortable with.
1. TRENDS
Technical Analysis
Some investors (often called chartists) believe that an understanding of the past price behaviour of shares can give a clue to future performance. Chartists do not believe that all price movements are random; they believe that prices occasionally form patterns that can affect how a price will behave in the future.
In this guide we will look at two basic concepts of technical analysis: 1. Trends 2. Support and resistance levels These can be useful tools but should not be used on their own. Investors should also concentrate on a companys future prospects.
1. TRENDS Share prices rarely move in straight lines a typical share price chart displays a series of jagged moves. However, in the chart below it doesnt take a huge imagination to see a pattern: the line moves fairly steadily from the bottom left of the chart to the top right. Drawing some lines on this chart to highlight the pattern helps. Although the price has not been moving in an absolute straight line, it has been moving steadily in a certain direction within a fairly tight range. The outside straight lines drawn on this chart are sometimes called trend lines.
CARILLION CLLN
500 450 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0
03 Jan 03 Sep May 04 05 Jan Sep 05 May 06 07 Jan 07 Sep
(p)
This pattern lasted for a fairly long time, almost ve years. Some chartists hope to spot such patterns and will buy the shares to ride the trend. A popular saying in these circles is the trend is your friend. This saying is sometimes extended to the trend is your frienduntil it ends.
But when does a trend end? Much work is put in by chartists involving complicated calculations trying to judge when a trend has ended. At its simplest, we could say that a trend ends when the share price breaks decisively through a trend line. The following chart has extended the period of the chart to January 2009.
1. TRENDS
CARILLION CLLN
600 500 400 300 200 100 0
J an 03 Jan 04 Jan 05 J an 06 J an 07 J an 08 J an 09
(p)
We can see that the break through the trend line in December 2007 was the decisive end of the upward trend, and the shares fell afterwards.
Trading with trends is one of the most popular strategies for chartists. Whole books have been written on how to
2. SUPPORT/RESISTANCE
Sometimes one can see price levels on a chart through which the share price seems reluctant to break.
As can be seen, throughout a seven-month period the share price of United Utilities repeatedly moved up towards a level around 635p and each time fell away. After a while such behaviour becomes self-fullling: as more traders notice that the price failed to break through this level before, when the price moves again up towards
this level traders will be tempted to sell (in anticipation of the price falling away again), and their action of selling will put downward pressure on the price. Other participants may at least hold o buying the shares near this level which will lead to weak demand and enable the price to fall away easily. This level through which the price is reluctant to move is called a resistance level.
(p)
2. SUPPORT/RESISTANCE
A similar thing can also happen below the price. Take a look at the following chart. Over four months, the share price of Spirax-Sarco
Engineering fell repeatedly to the 1800p level, each time to bounce up o it. This 1800 level is called a support level. Again, after a while, such behaviour can become selffullling as more traders notice what is happening.
(p)
Sometimes resistance and support levels can form at the same time and the price can bounce between them in a range. For a few months the Yule-Catto share price seemed unable to break out of the range 148-180p.
The theory is that after such a range has become established, when the price does eventually break out of the range, the price can move decisively further in the same direction. In this case in January 2012 the price broke through the resistance level of 180p and moved quickly higher.
Oct
De c
Jan
CONCLUSION
The main lessons of this guide are: 1. Be open to investment opportunities everywhere. This guide lists six methods commonly used by investors, but dont feel constrained to use only these. 2. Having identied an interesting company, do the research. You are far more likely to succeed if you learn about any company before you invest in it. 3. There is no overriding need to have a methodology for buying shares. If hit and miss or a pin in the FT Share Price pages works well for you, thats ne. However a more structured approach should aid performance. 4. The most important attributes of successful investors are common sense and discipline. No method of picking shares gives you a guarantee of success every time. However we hope you are able to pick more winners than losers if you follow, and build on, the information in this guide.
per deal
Whether you're share dealing for the rst time or an active trader you'll receive low cost share dealing in all our Vantage Accounts together with a range of additional features, research and information.
Benets of share dealing with Hargreaves Lansdown:
n Low cost share dealing - Online share dealing from just 5.95 per deal and never pay more than 11.95
per deal online. Alternatively, you can trade shares by phone or post.
n Wide investment choice and overseas share dealing - You make your own investment decisions. Choose
from thousands of UK, American, Canadian and European shares, as well as gilts, corporate bonds, investment trusts and exchange traded funds.
n Stop loss and limit orders - Set the price at which you would like to buy or sell particular shares up to 30
days in advance.
n No inactivity fee - You can deal as much or as little as you want. We do not charge an inactivity fee. n Mobile dealing - Deal on your mobile with our FREE app for iPhone and Android. n Easy to manage - Hold all your shares in one place and manage them online whenever you choose.
Receive simple bi-annual statements to help you keep track of your investments.
prices, graphs, news, research updates, broker forecasts, annual reports and much more.
n Research updates - We provide research updates and email alerts on
Investors Chronicle every week together with sector reports and featured tips from Shares Magazine.
Android is a trademark of Google Inc. iPhone is a trademark of Apple Inc.