Hand-Out in Categorical Sylogism
Hand-Out in Categorical Sylogism
* Violation of Rule 4 of the basic rules of categorical syllogism is a commission of n of fallacy of undistributed middle. Rule 5. Two affirmative premises cannot give a negative conclusion (meaning: only an affirmative conclusion can be drawn from two affirmative premises) Rule 6. From two negative premises, no conclusion can be inferred. * Violation of Rule 6 of the basic rules of categorical syllogism is a commission of fallacy of two negative premises Rule 7. No conclusion can be drawn from two particular premises. *Violation of Rule 7 is commission of either fallacy of illicit major or fallacy of undistributed middle. Rule 8. Conclusion must be particular, if one of the premises is particular, and negative, if one premise is negative (conclusion follows the weaker side). Note : Minor term (S) Major term (P) Middle term (M)
THE FOUR POSSIBLE POSITIONS OR ARRANGEMENTS WHICH GIVE RISE TO FOUR SYLLOGISTIC FIGURES ARE Figure 1. The middle term is the subject of the major premise and the predicate of the minor premise. M-P S-M ____ S-P
Figure 2. The middle term (M) is the predicate of both premises P-M S-M ____ S-P Figure 3. The middle term is the subject of both premises M-P M-S ____ S-P Figure 4. The middle term is the predicate of the major premise and the subject of the minor premise P-M M-S ____ S-P
Note: 1. Categorical syllogism is not the same as categorical proposition because a syllogism consists of proposition.
2. The minor premise comes second after the major premise. 3. The middle term should not be found in the conclusion. 4. The syllogism must contain three terms only. 5. From two negative premises, no conclusion can be inferred. 6. There can be no conclusion from two particular premises. No conclusion can be drawn from two particular premises