Intertemporal Model: Applications: Econ302, Fall 2004 Professor Lutz Hendricks
Intertemporal Model: Applications: Econ302, Fall 2004 Professor Lutz Hendricks
We deepen our understanding of how the model works by studying two applications: 1. Fiscal policy: government expenditure changes. 2. Productivity shocks. The results will tells us something about the sources of business cycle uctuations. .
Fiscal Policy
Goals: Practice how the model works. Determine the eects of government spending. Learn about the dierence between temporary and permanent shocks. Understand how expectations aect current economic activity. .
2.1
Temporary Increase in G
The experiment:
G " but G0 stays unchanged. This must be nanced to satisfy the government budget constraint. Assume that T 0 ".
Important: A policy experiment must specify an entire path of policy variables. The path must satisfy the budget constraint. It does not make sense to ask: what are the eects of a change in G alone? .
2.1.1
G (small
2.1.2
Y d = C d + I d + G.
Most likely Y d " because the income eect is small for a temporary G ". .
2.1.3
2.1.4
No change in N d (M PN schedule). Direct eect on N s: positive (we already saw that). Indirect eect on N s: higher r above).
) higher N s (see
2.1.5
Summary: Eects of G
Current period: Output increases. Consumption and leisure fall ! utility loss for households. Investment falls. Next period: Taxes must rise to nance higher government debt. K 0 is lower ! Y is lower. Policy implication: Using scal policy to pull an economy out of recession comes at a cost. .
2.2
Future Increase in G
Key point: Expectations of future shocks aect today s equilibrium. Experiment: G0 rises, nanced by higher T 0.
2.2.1
Labor market
Labor supply: rises (for xed w; r) b/c of lower W . Labor demand: no change. Labor market clearing: N " and w #.
Real Wage Ns
w*
Nd N* Employment
10
2.2.2
Goods market
Output supply: rises b/c of lower higher supply. C d falls b/c of lower W (not by much b/c change in G0 is not permanent). I d: no change in target capital stock. Output demand curve shifts left.
r Ys
Yd Y
Total eect: Y "; r #. This is not exactly right: I d will shift because rms expect a change in w0 and therefore in N 0! .
11
2.3
Permanent Increase in G
G. This is nanced
This is the "sum" of the previous two experiments. Therefore, the total eects are:
G " # " " G0 " # # G and G0 "" ## " ?
Ns Nd Cd Id G Yd
12
2.3.1
Direct eect: G ". Indirect eect: C d # because of lower W . Permanent income hypothesis suggests: C d should fall by the change in the present value of taxes. Then: Y d curve unaected by scal policy. Surprise result: Permanent scal stimulus raises GDP not through aggregate demand, but through labor supply!
13
2.3.2
Direct eect: Lower W increases N s. Indirect eect: lower r reduces labor supply (higher W ).
How do we know labor supply does not fall overall? If it did, output supply would decrease. This is not a circular argument. The shift of N s for xed r is the shift in the Y s curve. The second shift (change in r) is a movement along Y s. .
14
2.3.3
Goods market: GDP rises due to higher supply. Interest rate falls ) I "; C " (movement along Y d). Note: No crowding out, in contrast to temporary G ". Labor market: Higher labor supply ) higher N and lower w. Note: Doing more of the same (raise G for 2 periods instead of 1) does not simply magnify the eects of G. .
15
Productivity Shocks
3.1
Temporary increase in z
Labor demand rises: higher M PN . Labor supply: no direct eect. w change is move along the N s curve. Result: For xed r, higher N and higher w. Y s curve shifts right.
16
3.1.1
Goods market
I d: no change in target K 0. G: no change. C d: rises because of income eect, but not by much for a transitory z ". (The book omits this.)
Yd Y
17
18
3.1.2
With productivity shocks: consumption, investment, employment, wages, interest rates should be pro-cyclical. This is true in the data. This is the key idea of Real Business Cycle theory, which we study later.