1.2 History and Industrial Experience: Pinch Analysis and Process Integration 2
1.2 History and Industrial Experience: Pinch Analysis and Process Integration 2
with cooling no longer required. The design is as safe and as operable as the traditional one. It is simply better.
Results like this made pinch analysis a hot topic soon after it was introduced. Benefits
were found from improving the integration of processes, often developing simpler, more
elegant heat recovery networks, without requiring advanced unit operation technology.
There are two engineering design problems in chemical processes. The first is the
problem of unit operation design and the second is the problem of designing total
systems. This book addresses the system problem, in particular design of the process
flowsheet to minimise energy consumption.
The first key concept of pinch analysis is setting energy targets. Targets for
energy reduction have been a key part of energy monitoring schemes for many years.
Typically, a reduction in plant energy consumption of 10% per year is demanded.
However, like productivity targets in industry and management, this is an arbitrary
figure. A 10% reduction may be very easy on a badly designed and operated plant
where there are many opportunities for energy saving, and a much higher target
would be appropriate. However, on a good plant, where continuous improvement
has taken place over the years, a further 10% may be impossible to achieve. Ironically,
however, it is the manager of the efficient plant rather than the inefficient one who
could face censure for not meeting improvement targets!
Targets obtained by pinch analysis are different. They are absolute thermodynamic
targets, showing what the process is inherently capable of achieving if the heat
recovery, heating and cooling systems are correctly designed. In the case of the flowsheet in Figure 1.1, the targeting process shows that only 1,068 kW of external heating should be needed, and no external cooling at all. This gives the incentive to
find a heat exchanger network which achieves these targets.