Page 1 of 31

USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

UE College of Law
SY 2014 2015,
Second Semester

COURSE SYLLABUS IN
PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS*
(With All Relevant
Jurisprudence)
Prepared by:

USEC Josephus B. Jimenez

FPM, AB, LLB, MPA, CESO, AVA, AMVA
Former DOLE Undersecretary and Labor Arbiter,
Labor Attach to Malaysia, Taiwan and Kuwait,
Now NCMB Voluntary Arbitrator
Former Vice President, Pepsi Cola Products Philippines,
Director for Labor Relations and Assistant Vice President, San Miguel Corporation
Senior Labor Attorney & HR Manager, Petron, PNOC and Petrophil

(* Formulated and updated by USEC JBJ on Nov 07, 2014, incorporating all
amendments and all relevant cases in2015, 2014, 2013, 2012, 2011, 2010 and
earlier JURISPRUDENCE )

Page 2 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

I. COURSE OBJECTIVES

At the end of
semester
students

the
the
shall have:

1.

Read, understood and mastered the philosophy, objectives and implication

of Philippine Labor Laws, with special focus on LABOR STANDARDS,

2.

Read, understood and mastered Articles 1 to 216 of the Labor Code, as

amended,

3.

Read, analyzed and presented at least five (5) cases each meeting on
topics to the subject matter of the day, using JBJs format of
F - Facts
I - Issue
L- Law applicable/Legal Principle
CCase History
RRuling by the SC
OOpinion of the Student

4.

Recited and reported on at least two (2) provisions (per student) and at
least one case each meeting,

5.

Taken, passed and completed all examinations, including Mid Terms and
Finals and one written test every month,

6.

Written, submitted and reported on compilation of FILCRO cases,

7.

Attended the minimum number of days required by the UE College of Law,

8.

Complied with all the other requirements of the University and the College
of Law.

II. COURSE OUTLINE

Page 3 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

First and Second Meetings

[Focus on Labor and Social Legislation and

Social Justice]
Tentative Dates: November 14 and 21, 2015
Subject Matter
Coverage
1.1Introduction to Philippine Labor Constitution
Laws: Basic Principles
Article XIII, Sections 3, 1, 2 and
1.2Philosophy,
Objectives,
and
14
Legislative Intent
Preamble
1.3Constitutional Provisions (Rights of
Article II, Sections 4, 9, 10, 11
Labor)
and 18
1.4CASE LIST A (FILCRO)
Article III, Sections 1, 8, 11 and
1.5Contemporary Events relevant to
Section 18 Number (2)
topic
Article XII, Sections 1, 6, 12, and
1.6States Protection to Labor: Five
14
Dimensions of USEC JBJ (pages 97 to
Labor
Code
111 Philippine Labor Relations by
Articles 1 to 11
JBJ)
Civil Code
1.7Other Research Material by JBJ
1.8 FIRST WRITTEN TEST ON NOV 28,,
Articles 1700 and 1701
2015
1.9Constitution

Third, Fourth and Fifth Meetings [Focus on Recruitment and

Employment Laws]
Tentative Dates: November 28, December 5 and 12, 2015
Subject Matter
Coverage
2.1 Articles 12 to 39 of the Labor Code
2.a Illegal Recruitment under Art 13 (b)
2.2 Articles 40 to 42 of the Labor Code
LC
2.3 RA 8042, The Migrant Workers and 2.b Illegal Recruitment under Articles
Overseas Filipinos Act of 1995
34 and 38 of the LC, Section 5 of RA
2.4 RA 10022 amending RA 8042
10022 and Section 6 of RA 8042
2.5 Read the first 5 cases listed in 2.c Economic Sabotage
CASE LIST B (FILCRO)
2.d Illegal Recruitment Syndicate
2.6
Contemporary
Events
on 2.e Large Scale Illegal Recruitment
Recruitment
2.g Latest Cases
2.7 Function of DOLE, POEA, OWWA,
POLO, PE and Labor Arbiter
2.8 SECOND WRITTEN TEST ON DEC 12,
2014
2.9 Related Laws on Illegal Trafficking
2.10 Impact of ASEAN Integration

Sixth Meeting

[Focus on HR Development Programs and the TESDA

Law]
Tentative Date: December 19, 2015
Subject Matter
Coverage
3.1 Skip Articles 43 to 56 of the LC 3.a The Law on Apprentices
(superseded by RA 7796)
3.b The Law on Learners
3.2 Read Articles 57 to 72 of the LC
3.c The Law on Handicapped Workers
3.3 Read Articles 73 to 77 of the LC
3.d Related Laws
3.4 Read Articles 78 to 81 of the LC
3.5 CASE LIST C (BOOK II)

Page 4 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

Seventh Meeting [Focus on Hours of Work, etc.]

Tentative Date: January _09_, 2016
Subject Matter
Coverage
4.1 Read Articles 82 to 90
4.a Hours of Work
4.2 Read Articles 91 to 93
4.b Hours Worked
4.3 Read Articles 94 to 96
4.c Meal Periods
4.4 Read CASE LIST D Hours of Work 4.d Night Shift
(FILCRO)
4.e Overtime Work
4.5 Controversial Issues regarding 4.f Under time and Overtime
Hours of Work, Rest Periods and 4.g Emergency Overtime
Benefits
4.h Rest Days
4.i Holidays
4.j Leaves

Eight and Ninth Meetings [Focus on Wages]

Tentative Dates: January 16 and 23, 2016
Subject Matter
Coverage
5.1 Read Articles 97 to 101
5.a Wage
5.2 Read Articles 102 to 111
5.b Minimum Wage
5.3 Read Articles 112 to 119
5.c Rules on Payment of Wages
5.4 Read Articles 120 to 129
5.d Prohibitions regarding Wages
5.5 Read Articles 130 to 136 (as 5.e NWPC
amended by RA 8292 and 8187)
5.f RTWPB
5.6 Read Articles 137 and 138
5.g Benefits for Special Workers
5.7 Read Articles 139 to 150
5.h Women Workers
5.8 Read Articles 151 to 161
5.i Minor Workers
5.9 Read CASE LIST E Rest Days and 5.j Homeworkers
Holidays (FILCRO)
5.k Job Contracting
5.10 THIRD WRITTEN TEST ON JAN 23, 5.l Labor-Only Contracting
2015 (Coverage Articles 82 to 161 of
the LC)
5.11 Kasambahay Law (RA 10361)
5.12 Department Order 18-A on Job
Contracting
5.13 Department Order 119-C S 2012
on Night Workers
5.14 Special Look on Call Centers and
BPOs

Tenth Meeting

[Focus on Cases Related to Wages and Benefits]

Tentative Date: January 30, 2015
Subject Matter
Coverage
REPORT
6.a Wage Formulations
6.1 CASE LIST F (Cases on Wages)
6.b Wage Distortions
6.2 CASE LIST G (Cases on Benefits)
6.c Diminution of Wages
6.3 CASE LIST H (Cases on Women 6.d Cases on Overtime
and Minors)
6.e Cases on Rest days
6.4 CASE LIST I (Cases on Job 6.f Cases on Holiday Pay
Contracting)
6.g Cases on 13th Month Pay
6.5 CASE LIST B (Cases on Illegal 6.h Cases on Commissions and Bonuses
Recruitment)
6.i Cases on Money Claims
6.6
CASE
LIST
A
(Cases
on 6.j Cases on Technical Issues

Page 5 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

Fundamental Principles)
6.7 CASE LIST J (Cases on 13th Month
Pay)
6.8 Special Legislation for Women

Eleventh and Twelfth Meetings [Focus on Health, Safety and Welfare,

Occupational Health and Safety, Employees Compensation and State
Insurance Fund]
Tentative Dates: February 6 and 13, 2016
Subject Matter
Coverage
7.1 Read Articles 172 to 181
7.a Employees Compensation vs
7.2 Read Articles 182 to 190
Workers Compensation
7.3 Read Articles 191 to 200
7.b State Insurance Fund
7.4 Read Articles 201 to 216
7.c SSS Law
7.5 CASE LIST K (FILCRO): Cases on 7.d GSIS Law
Death due to Diseases
7.e ECC Law
7.6 CASE LIST L (FILCRO): Cases on 7.f Medical Benefits
Death due to Accident or Crime
7.g Disability Benefits
7.7 CASE LIST M (FILCRO): Cases on 7.h Death Benefits
Permanent
and
Temporary
Total 7.i Beneficiaries
Disability
7.j Dependents
7.8 CASE LIST N (FILCRO): Cases 7.k Procedures in Filing Claims
Involving Seafarers and other OFWs on 7.l Denials and Appeals
Death and Disability
7.9 FOURTH WRITTEN TEST ON FEB 13,
2015

Thirteenth and Fourteenth Meetings [Focus on Cases relevant to the

Employees Compensation and the State Insurance Fund]
Tentative Dates: February 20 and 27, 2016
Subject Matter
Coverage
Individual Report
8.a Death due to Diseases
8.1 CASE LIST K (Granted)
8.b Reasons for Denying Death Benefits
8.2 CASE LIST K (Denied)
8.c Death due to Accident
8.3 CASE LIST L (Granted)
8.d Reasons for Denial
8.4 CASE LIST L (Denied)
8.e Permanent Total Disability
8.5 CASE LIST M (Granted or Denied)
8.f Permanent Partial Disability
8.6 CASE LIST N (Granted)
8.g Seafarers Death and Disability
8.7 CASE LIST N (Denied)
8.h Reasons for Denial

Fifteenth and Sixteenth Meetings [Integration of all subject matters

and Review of all past lessons]
Tentative Dates: March 6 and 13, 2016
Subject Matter
Coverage
9.1 BOOK ONE : Pre-Employment As stated, plus Case Lists K to N
(Articles 12 to 42)
9.2 BOOK TWO: Human Resources
Development Program
Skip
Articles
43
to
56
(Superseded by RA 7796, TESDA
Law)
Converge Articles 57 to 81
9.3 BOOK THREE: Conditions of
Employment (Articles 82 to 161)

Page 6 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

9.4 BOOK FOUR: Health, Safety, and

Social Welfare Benefits (Articles 162 to
216)
9.5 FIFTH WRITTEN TEST ON MARCH 13,
2015
9.6 Submission of all Term Papers:
March 13, 2015
9.7 Completion of all Deficiencies:
March 13, 2015

III. METHODOLOGY
1) Lectures
point) by
2) FILCRO
Students:
per
per meeting (to be collected in soft copies, USB)

(Power
USEC JBJ
Analysis by
5 cases
student

F - Facts
I - Issue
L- Law applicable/Legal Principle
CCase History
RRuling by the SC
OOpinion of the Student
Note: Only one page (Legal Size) per case
3) Graded Recitation/ Oral and no readin g notes
4) Written Tests on (Tentative)
a) 21 November 2014 (On Fundamental Principles)
b) 12 December 2014 (On Recruitment Laws and Cases)
c) 23 January 2015 (On Book III, Articles 82 to 161)
d) 13 February 2015 ( On Book IV, Articles 162 to 216)
e) 13 March 2015 (On Entire Labor Standards Book I to IV)
5) Submission of FILCRO of 50 Cases (Term Paper)
a) Fundamental Principles (5 Cases)
b) Illegal Recruitment (10 Cases)
c) Wages (10 Cases)
d) Benefits (10 Cases)
e) Death, Disability and Decease Cases (10 Cases)
f) Procedural and Technicalities (5 Cases)
6) Mid Term Exams: All Principles, Codal and Doctrines
7) Final Exams: All Cases
8) Attendance will be strictly monitored
9) Make up classes will be held to comply with total number of hours for the entire
semester
10)
Three absences (maximum) can be excused by submission of ten (10) FILCRO
Cases, in addition to Term Paper BUT in no case shall reach four or more .

Page 7 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

1. CLASS
(25%)
a.

IV GRADING SYSTEM
(Components)

Attendance (5%)
b. Five Exams (10%)
c. FILCRO 50 Cases (10%)
2. MID TERM EXAMS Principles and Law (35%)
a. Fundamentals Intro (10%)
b. Recruitment Book One (15%)
c. HR Development Program Book Two (5%)
d. Hours of Work Part of Book Three (5%)
3. FINAL
a.
b.
c.
d.
e.
f.
g.

EXAMS (All Cases) (40%)

Cases on Fundamentals (2%)
Cases on Recruitment (8%)
Cases on Hours of Work (8%)
Cases on Wages (8%)
Cases on Benefits (8%)
Cases on Disease, Disability and Death (4%)
Cases on Procedures (2%)

STANDING
Recitation
and

Page 8 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

V CASE LISTS
CASE LIST A:

FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES
A.

DEFINITIO
N OF LABOR
STANDARDS AND
OTHER TERMS
1. MATERNITY

CHILDREN'S HOSPITAL VS. THE HONORABLE SECRETARY OF LABOR [G.R.

NO. 78909 JUNE 30, 1989]
2. BALANCING OF INTERESTS: P.I. MANUFACTURING, INCORPORATED VS. P.I.
MANUFACTURING SUPERVISORS AND FOREMAN ASSOCIATION AND THE
NATIONAL LABOR UNION [G.R. NO. 167217 FEBRUARY 4, 2008]
3. APPLICABILITY OF JURISPRUDENCE UNDER OLD LAW ( ARTICLE 8 CIVIL
CODE)
4. APPLICABILITY OF AMERICAN JURISPRUDENCE: BOY SCOUTS OF THE
PHILIPPINES, VS. JULIANA V. ARAOS [G.R. NO. L-10091 JANUARY 29, 1958]
B. SOCIAL JUSTICE, POLICE POWER AND LABOR LAWS
5. NATIONAL FEDERATION OF SUGAR WORKERS (NFSW), VS. ETHELWOLDO R.
OVEJERA, CENTRAL AZUCARERA DE LA CARLOTA [G.R. NO. L-59743 MAY 31
1982]
6. MARCOPPER MINING CORPORATION VS. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS
COMMISSION [G.R. NO. 103525 MARCH 29, 1996]
7. CRUZVALE, INC., VS. HON. BIENVENIDO E. LAGUESMA [G.R. NO. 107610
NOVEMBER 25, 1994]
8. ASSOCIACION DE AGRICULTORES DE TALISAY-SILAY, INC. VS. TALISAY-SILAY
MILLING CO., INC., [FEBRUARY 19,1979, 88 SCRA 294]
9. PHILIPPINE GEOTHERMAL, INC VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 106370 SEPTEMBER 8,
1994]
10.EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION OF THE PHILIPPINE AMERICAN LIFE INSURANCE
COMPANY (EMAPALICO) AND NAPOLEON CAPARAS VS NLRC [G.R. NO.
82976 JULY 26, 1991]
11.EASTERN SHIPPING LINES, INC VS POEA [G.R. NO. 76633 OCTOBER 18,
1988]
12.PIER 8 ARRASTRE & STEVEDORING SERVICES, INC. VS. HON. MA. NIEVES
ROLDAN-CONFESOR [G.R. NO. 110854 FEBRUARY 13, 1995]
13.SAN MIGUEL CORPORATION EMPLOYEES UNION-PTGWO, DANIEL S.L.
BORBON II, HERMINIA REYES, MARCELA PURIFICACION, ET AL., VS. HON.
JESUS G. BERSAMIRA [G.R. NO. 87700 JUNE 13, 1990]

Page 9 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

C. PROTECTION TO LABOR
14.ARIS (PHIL.) INC. VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 90501 AUGUST 5, 1991]
15.BPI CREDIT CORPORATION VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 106027 JULY 25, 1994]
16.GLOBE-MACKAY CABLE AND RADIO CORPORATION VS NLRC [G.R. NO.
82511 MARCH 3, 1992]
17.FILIPINAS PORT SERVICES, INC VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 97237 AUGUST 16,
1991]
18.DBP VS NLRC: DISSENTING OPINION OF JUSTICE ISAGANI CRUZ, QUOTING
HIMSELF IN REPUBLIC VS PERALTA, [150 SCRA 37 G.R. NOS. 82763-64
MARCH 19, 1990]
19.HOLIDAY INN MANILA VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 109114 SEPTEMBER 14, 1993]
D. PROTECTING LABOR AGAINST UNFAIR AND UNJUST EMPLOYERS
21.EVELYN J. GARCIA VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 119527. JULY 3, 1996.]
22.THE HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION VS NLRC [G.R.
NO. 116542 JULY 30, 1996.]
23.PIZZA HUT/PROGRESSIVE DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION VS NLRC [G.R.
NO. 117059. JANUARY 29, 1996]
24.FEM'S ELEGANCE LODGING HOUSE VS MURILLA [G.R. NOS. 117442-43
JANUARY 11, 1995]
25.ORIENTAL MINDORO ELECTRIC COOPERATIVE, INC VS NLRC [G.R. NO.
111905 JULY 31, 1995.]
E. PROTECTING LABOR FROM THEIR OWN UNIONS AND FEDERATIONS
26.CARMELITO L. PALACOL, ET AL. VS CALLEJA [G.R. NO. 85333 FEBRUARY 26,
1990]
27.LIANA'S SUPERMARKET VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 111014. MAY 31, 1996]
28.ALLIANCE OF NATIONALIST AND GENUINE LABOR ORGANIZATION (ANGLOKMU) VS. SAMAHAN NG MGA MANGGAGAWANG NAGKAKAISA SA MANILA
BAY SPINNING MILLS AT J.P. COATS (SAMANA BAY) [G.R. NO. 118562 JULY 5,
1996]
29.INDUSTRIAL SERVICES, INC VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 117418. JANUARY 24, 1996
STELLAR]
30.JAG & HAGGAR JEANS AND SPORTSWEAR CORPORATION VS NLRC [G.R. NO.
105710 FEBRUARY 23, 1995]
F. PROTECTING LABOR FROM THEIR PROTECTOR, THE GOVERNMENT
31.ESALYN CHAVEZ, VS. HON. EDNA BONTO-PEREZ [G.R. NO. 109808 MARCH
1, 1995]
32.SULPICIO LINES, INC. VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 117650. MARCH 7, 1996]
33.B. STA. RITA AND CO., INC. AND TIDE SHIPPING CO., LTD. VS NLRC [G.R.
NO. 119617 AUGUST 14, 1995]
34.EL TORO SECURITY AGENCY, INC. VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 114308. APRIL 18,
1996]
35.RAMON PRIETO VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 93699 SEPTEMBER 10, 1993]
G. PROTECTING LABOR FROM UNSCRUPULOUS LAWYERS
36.ATTY. WILFREDO TAGANAS VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 118746 SEPTEMBER 7,
1995]
H. PROTECTING LABOR FROM THEIR OWN IGNORANCE, HASTY JUDGMENT,
RECKLESSNESS AND NAIVETE
37.WYETH-SUACO LABORATORIES, INC. VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 100658. MARCH 2,
1993]
38.VELOSO, ET AL. VS. DEPARTMENT OF LABOR [200 SCRA 201, 202 (1991)]

Page 10 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

39.PAL EMPLOYEES SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSOCIATION, INC. (PESALA) VS NLRC

[G.R. NO. 105963. AUGUST 22, 1996]
40.VENANCIO GUERRERO VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 119842. AUGUST 30, 1996]
41.JGB AND ASSOCIATES, INC. VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 109390. MARCH 7, 1996]
42.LOURDES G. MARCOS VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 111744 SEPTEMBER 8, 1995]
43.ARTEMIO LABOR VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 110388 SEPTEMBER 14, 1995]
44.GENERAL RUBBER AND FOOTWEAR CORP. VS. DRILON [169 SCRA 808
(1989)]
45.JMM PROMOTION AND MANAGEMENT, INC VS CA [G.R. NO. 120095
AUGUST 5, 1996]
46.PAKISTAN INTERNATIONAL AIRLINES CORPORATION, VS. HON. BLAS F. OPLE
[G.R. NO. 61594 SEPTEMBER 28, 1990]
I. INTERPRETING LABOR LAWS IN FAVOR OF LABOR
47.ABELLA V. NLRC [G.R. NO. 71812, JULY 20, 1987, 152 SCRA 140, 146]
48.MANILA ELECTRIC COMPANY, VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 78763 JULY 12,1989]
49.PHILIPPINE TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE CORPORATION V. NATIONAL
LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION [183 SCRA 451 [1990]]
50.AQUINO V. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION [G.R. NO. 87653,
FEBRUARY 11, 1992, 206 SCRA 118]
51.INTERNATIONAL PHARMACEUTICALS INCORPORATED VS. THE SECRETARY
OF LABOR [205 SCRA 59, 65-66 [1992]]
52.PALEA VS PAL [G.R. NO. L-31341 AND 31343 MARCH 31, 1976]
53.PHILIPPINE NATIONAL CONSTRUCTION CORPORATION (PNCC) VS NLRC
[G.R. NO. 112629 JULY 7, 1995]
54.PLASTIC TOWN CENTER CORPORATION V. NLRC, [G.R. NO. 81176, APRIL
19, 1989, 172 SCRA 580]
55.MARCOPPER MINING CORPORATION VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 103525 MARCH 29,
1996]
J. COMPASSION FOR LOWLY WORKERS, CASUALS, PROBATIONARY, ETC.
56.CEBU ROYAL PLANT (SAN MIGUEL CORPORATION) VS MINISTER OF LABOR
[G.R. NO. L-58639 AUGUST 12, 1987]
57.CARMELCRAFT CORPORATION VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 90634-35 JUNE 6, 1990]
58.FIRESTONE TIRE AND RUBBER COMPANY OF THE PHILIPPINES, VS.
FIRESTONE TIRE AND RUBBER COMPANY EMPLOYEES UNION [G.R. NO.
75363 AUGUST 4, 1992]
59.CLARITA V. CRUZ VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 98273 OCTOBER 28, 1991]
60.MARINA PORT SERVICES, INC. VS. NLRC [193 SCRA 420 [1991]]
K. PROTECTION TO LABOR WITHOUT OPPRESSION OF CAPITAL
61.MANILA ELECTRIC COMPANY (MERALCO) VS HM DEJAN [G.R. NO. 194106 18 JUNE 2012]
62.PLDT VS NLRC [GR NO 53532 - 18 OCT 1988]
63.RPN INC VS RUTH F YAP [G.R. NO. 187713. AUGUST 1, 2012]
64.ERNESTO G. YMBONG VS ABS CBN [G.R. NO. 184885 - 7 MARCH 2012]
65.AUTOBUS WORKERS' UNION (AWU) VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 117453 JUNE 26,
1998]
66.PHILIPPINE GEOTHERMAL, INC. VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 106370 SEPTEMBER 8,
1994]
67.NATIONAL SUGAR REFINERIES CORPORATION VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 101761.
MARCH 24, 1993]
68.ADMIRAL REALTY COMPANY, INC. VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 112043. MAY 18,
1999]
L. NO COMPASSION FOR UNDESERVING WORKERS

Page 11 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

69.PHILIPPINE LONG DISTANCE TELEPHONE COMPANY VS NLRC [G.R. NO.

80609 AUGUST 23, 1988]
70.BM REALDA V. NEW AGE GRAPHICS, INC. ET. AL. [G.R. NO. 192190, APRIL
25, 2012]
71.C. ALCANTARA & SONS, INC VS CA [G.R. NO. 155109 - MARCH 14, 2012]
72.BEST WEAR GARMENTS VS A DE LEMOS [G.R. NO. 191281. DEC 15,
2012]
73.MYLENE CARVAJAL VS. LUZON DEVELOPMENT BANK [G.R. NO. 186169, 1
AUGUST 2012]
74.WUERTH PHILIPPINES, INC VS RODANTE YNSON [G.R. NO. 175932]
75.ANTONIO A. ABOC VS METROPOLITAN BANK AND TRUST COMPANY [G.R.
NOS. 170542-43]
M. THE POWER OF THE STATE: POLICE POWER
76.BOGO-MEDELLIN SUGARCANE PLANTERS ASSOCIATION, INC VS NLRC [G.R.
NO. 97846. SEPTEMBER 25, 1998]
77.JUDY PHILIPPINES, INC VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 111934. APRIL 29, 1998]
78.FELIX VILLA VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 117043. JANUARY 14, 1998]
79.ASIAN ALCOHOL CORPORATION VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 131108 MARCH 25,
1999]
80.JANG LIM VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 124630. FEBRUARY 19, 1999]
N. NEW CASES INVOLVING FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES
81.ST. MARYS ACADEMY OF DIPOLOG CITY VS TERESITA PALACIO [G.R. NO.
164913]
82.PAMELA FLORENTINA P. JUMUAD VS HI-FLYER FOOD, INC [G.R. NO. 187887]
83.BEBINA G. SALVALOZA VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 182086 - NOV 24, 2010]
84.PHILIPPINE LONG DISTANCE TELEPHONE COMPANY VS JOEY B. TEVES [G.R.
NO. 143511 - NOVEMBER 15, 2010]
85.THE COCA-COLA EXPORT CORPORATION, VS. CLARITA P. GACAYAN [G.R.
NO. 149433, DECEMBER 15, 2010]
86.COCA-COLA BOTTLERS PHILIPPINES, INC VS ANGEL U. DEL VILLAR [G.R.
NO. 163091 - OCTOBER 6, 2010]
87.ROYAL PLANT WORKERS UNION VS. COCA-COLA BOTTLERS PHILIPPINES,
INC [G.R. NO. 198783 - APRIL 15, 2013]
88.MANILA JOCKEY CLUB EMPLOYEES LABOR UNION- PTGWO VS MANILA
JOCKEY CLUB [G.R. NO. 167760 - MARCH 7, 2007]
89.SAN MIGUEL BREWERY SALES FORCE UNION (PTGWO) VS BLAS OPLE [G.R.
NO. L-53515 FEBRUARY 8, 1989]
90.WISE AND CO., INC UNION VS WISE AND CO., INC [G.R. NO. L-87672
OCTOBER 13, 1989]
91.INSULAR HOTEL EMPLOYEES UNION-NFL VS WATERFRONT INSULAR HOTEL
DAVAO [G.R. NOS. 174040-41 - SEPTEMBER 22, 2010]
92.BIBIANO C. ELEGIR VS PAL [G.R. NO. 181995 JULY 16, 2012]
93.TEMIC AUTOMOTIVE PHILIPPINES, INC. VS. TEMIC

AUTOMOTIVE

PHILIPPINES, INC EMPLOYEES UNION-FFW [G.R. NO. 186965 - DECEMBER

23, 2009]
94.UNIVERSITY OF THE EAST V. PEPANIO, [G.R. NO. 193897, JAN. 23, 2013]
95.ATOK BIG WEDGE COMPANY, INC. VS. JESUS P. GISON, [G.R. NO. 169510,
AUG. 8, 2011]
96.GOYA, INC. VS. GOYA, INC. EMPLOYEES UNION-FFW.

[G.R. NO. 170054.

JANUARY 21, 2013]

97.BANKARD, INC. VS. NLRC, ET. AL., [G.R. NO. 171664, MARCH 6, 2013]
98.DUNCAN ASSOCIATION OF DETAILMAN-PTGWO AND PEDRO A. TECSON VS
GLAXO WELCOME PHILIPPINES, INC [G.R. NO. 162994 SEPTEMBER 17,
2004]

Page 12 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

99.RONALD MANLIMOS VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 113337 MARCH 2, 1995]

100. VARORIENT SHIPPING CO INC. VS GIL A. FLORES [G.R. NO. 161934 OCTOBER 6, 2010]

CASE LIST B:
CASES

RECRUITMENT AND RELATED

1. SECRETARY

OF

LABOR,

HON

PATRICIA

STO.

TOMAS

VS

REY

SALAC [G.R. NO. 152642]

2. SECRETARY OF LABOR, HON PATRICIA STO. TOMAS VS HON. JOSE G. PANEDA
[GR. NO. 152710]
3. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES VS PASEI [GR. NO. 167590]
4. BECMEN SERVICE EXPORTER AND PROMOTION, INC., VS SPS SIMPLICO [GR
NOS. 182978-79]
5. SPOUSES SIMPLICIO AND MILA CUARESMA VS WHITE FALCON SERVICES INC.
[G.R. NOS. 184298-99]
6. PEOPLE VS DOLORES OCDEN [G.R. NO. 173198 - JUNE 1, 2011]
7. PEOPLE VS. YABUT [374 PHIL. 575, 586 (1999)]
8. PEOPLE VS GALLO [GR NO 187730, 29 JUNE 2010]
9. PEOPLE VS. MELISSA CHUA [GR. 187052, SEPT. 13, 2012]
10.PEOPLE VS BENSON ONG, [G R 119594, 18 JAN 2000]
11.DELIA D. ROMERO VS. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, ROMULO PADLAN AND
ARTURO SIAPNO, [G.R. NO. 171644, NOV. 23, 2011]
12.PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. CARMELITA ALVAREZ [G.R. NO. 142981.
AUGUST 20, 2002]
13.PEOPLE V. LALLI, [G.R. NO. 195419, 12 OCTOBER 2011]
14.PEOPLE V. PANIS AND ABUG, [142 SCRA 664]
15.IMELDA DARVIN VS CA [G.R. NO. 125044 JULY 13, 1998]
16.PEOPLE VS LOMA GOCE [G.R. NO. 113161, AUGUST 29, 1995]
17.PEOPLE VS TERESITA TESSIE LAOGO [G.R. NO. 176264, JANUARY 10, 2011]
18.PEOPLE VS HERNANDEZ [GR NO 141221-36 : MARCH 7, 2002]
19.PEOPLE VS. TAN TIONG MENG ALIAS "TOMMY TAN" [G.R. NO. 120835-40 APRIL 10, 1997]
20.PEOPLE VS ROGER SEGUN AND JOSEPHINE CLAM [G.R. NO. 119076. MARCH
25, 2002]
21.PEOPLE VS. BULU CHOWDURY [G.R. NO. 129577-80. FEBRUARY 15, 2000]
22.PEOPLE OF VS. NIMFA REMULLO [G.R. NOS. 124443-46. JUNE 6, 2002]
23.PEOPLE VS. SAMINA ANGELES Y CALMA [G.R. NO. 132376. APRIL 11, 2002]
24.PEOPLE VS. DUQUE [G.R. NO. 100285, AUGUST 13, 1992, 212 SCRA 607]
25.PEOPLE V. TURDA [233 SCRA 702]
26.PEOPLE VS. VILLAFUERTE [232 SCRA 225, 236, MAY 6, 1994]
27.PEOPLE VS. ALFORTE [219 SCRA 458 1993]
28.PEOPLE VS. CABACANG [243 SCRA 640 1995]
29.PEOPLE VS. DE LEON [225 SCRA 651 1993]
30.EQUI-ASIA PLACEMENT INC. VS. DFA [G.R. 152214, 19 SEPT 2006]
31.EASTERN SHIPPING VS. POEA [G.R. NO. 76633 OCTOBER 18, 1988]
32.PHILSA VS. SECRETARY OF LABOR [G.R. 103144 - 04 APRIL 2001]
33.FINMAN VS. INOCENCIO [G.R. NOS. 90273-25, 15 NOV 1989]
34.JMM PROMOTIONS VS. NLRC [G.R. 109835, 22 NOV 1993]
35.EASTERN ASSURANCE VS. SEC OF LABOR, [G.R. 79436-50, 17 JAN 1990]
36.SORIANO VS. OFFSHORE SHIPPING, [G.R. 78409, 14 SEPT 1989]
37.SEAGULL MARITIME, [G.R. 82252, 28 FEB 1989]
38.TRANS ACTION OVERSEAS VS. HON. SECREATARY OF LABOR, [G.R. 109583, 5
SEPT 1997]
39.CATAN VS. NLRC, [G.R. 77279, 15 APRIL 1988]

Page 13 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

40.SIGMA PERSONNEL SERVICES VS. NLRC, [G.R. 108284, 30 JUNE 1993]

41.FACILITIES CORP. VS. DELA ROSA [89 SCRA 131, 1979]
42.MANALO VS. ROLDAN CONFESOR, [215 SCRA 805, 1992]
43.SUZARA VS. BENIPAYO; [G.R. 57999; 01 AUG 1989]
44.CHAVEZ VS. PEREZ, [G.R. 109808, 01 MAR 1995]
45.DEE C CHUAN AND SONS VS. [CIR, 85 PHIL 431]
46.PSBA VS. NLRC, [G.R. 106621, 08 JUNE 1993 223 SCRA 305]
47.FARLE P. ALMODIEL VS. NLRC, [G.R. NO. 100641, 14 JUNE 1993]
48.GENERAL MILLING CORP VS. HO. RUBEN TORRES, [G.R. 9366, 22 APRIL 1991]

CASE LIST C:

CASES ON BOOK III

1. NITTO
ENTERPRISES
NLRC

[G.R.

VS
NO.

114337
SEPTEMBER 29, 1995]
2. FILAMER CHRISTIAN INSTITUTE VS. HON. INTERMEDIATE APPELLATE COURT
[G.R. NO. 75112 OCTOBER 16, 1990.]

CASE LIST D:

HOURS OF WORK

A.

EMPLOYER

EMPLOYEE
RELATIONSHIP
1. "BROTHERHOOD" LABOR UNITY MOVEMENT OF THE PHILIPPINES VS ZAMORA
[G.R. NO. L-48645 JANUARY 7, 1987]
2. MA. WENELITA S. TIRAZONA, VS. PHILIPPINE EDS TECHNO- SERVICE INC. (PET
INC.) [G.R. NO. 169712 JANUARY 20, 2009]
3. DANILO B. TABAS VS. CALIFORNIA MANUFACTURING CO., INC. [G.R. NO. L80680 - JANUARY 26, 1989 - 169 SCRA 497]
4. COCA-COLA BOTTLERS, PHILS INC., VS. DELFIN HINGPIT [G.R. NO. 127238.
AUGUST 25, 1998]
5. MAFINCO TRADING CORPORATION VS.OPLE, ET AL. [GR NO. L-37790, MARCH
25, 1976, 70 SCRA 139]
6. PHILIPPINE GLOBAL COMMUNICATIONS, INC., VS. RICARDO DE VERA [G.R. NO.
157214. JUNE 7, 2005]
7. ENCYCLOPAEDIA BRITANNICA (PHILIPPINES) INC VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 87098
NOVEMBER 4, 1996]
8. INTEL TECHNOLOGY PHILIPPINES, INC. VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 200575 FEBRUARY
5, 2014]
9. SOUTH EAST INTERNATIONAL RATTAN, INC. VS JESUS J. COMING [G.R. NO.
186621. MARCH 12, 2014]
10.ANGELINA FRANCISCO V. NLRC [GR NO. 170087 - AUGUST 31, 2006]
11.ZAMUDIO VS. NLRC [GR NO. 76723. MARCH 25, 1990]
12.EFREN P. PAGUIO VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 147816 MAY 9, 2003]
13.GREAT PACIFIC LIFE ASSURANCE CORPORATION VS. HONORATO JUDICO [G.R.
NO. 73887 DECEMBER 21, 1989]

Page 14 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

14.CITIZENS' LEAGUE OF FREE WORKERS VS HON. MACAPANTON ABBAS [G.R.

NO. L-21212 SEPTEMBER 23, 1966]
15.OSCAR VILLAMARIA, JR. VS CA [G.R. NO. 165881 APRIL 19, 2006]
16.MAKATI HABERDASHERY, INC VS NLRC [G.R. NOS. 83380-81 NOVEMBER 15,
1989]
17.CAURDANETAAN PIECE WORKERS UNION V. LAGUESMA, [G.R. NOS. 113542
AND 114911, FEBRUARY 24, 1998, 286 SCRA 401, 432]
18.MARAGUINOT JR VS NLRC [GR NO 120969 : JANUARY 22, 1998]
19.ORLANDO FARM GROWERS VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 129076. NOVEMBER 25, 1998]
20.NATIONAL SUGAR REFINERIES CORPORATION VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 101761.
MARCH 24, 1993]
B. HOURS OF WORK
21.MANILA TERMINAL COMPANY, INC. VS. THE COURT OF INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS
[G.R. NO. L-4148 JULY 16, 1952]
22.SAN JUAN DE DIOS HOSPITAL EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION-AFW VS NLRC [G.R.
NO. 126383 NOVEMBER 28, 1997]
23.INTERPHIL
LABORATORIES
EMPLOYEES

UNION-FFW

VS

INTERPHIL

LABORATORIES [G.R. NO. 142824. DECEMBER 19, 2001]

24.DURABUILT RECAPPING PLANT & COMPANY VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 76746 JULY 27,
1987]
25.ARICA VS NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, [170 SCRA 776, 783,
FEBRUARY 28, 1989]
26.OPULENCIA ICE PLANT AND STORAGE VS NLRC [G.R. NO. L-98368 DECEMBER
15, 1993]
27.PRICE STABILIZATION CORPORATION VS. COURT OF INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS
[G.R. NO. L-13806 MAY 23, 1960]
28.PHILIPPINES INTERFASHION INC.

VS.

NATIONAL

LABOR

RELATIONS

COMMISSION [G.R. NO. L-59847, 18 OCTOBER 1982, 117 SCRA 659]

29.ADELO EBUNA VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 103599 JULY 6, 1995]
30.JULIO N. CAGAMPAN VS NLRC [G.R. NOS. 85122-24 MARCH 22, 1991]
31.UNIVERSITY OF PANGASINAN FACULTY UNION, VS. UNIVERSITY

OF

PANGASINAN [G.R. NO. L-63122. FEBRUARY 20, 1984]

32.DELIA R. SIBAL, VS. NOTRE DAME OF GREATER MANILA [G.R. NO. 75093
FEBRUARY 23, 1990]
C. OVERTIME PAY
33.CALTEX REGULAR EMPLOYEES AT MANILA OFFICE VS. CALTEX PHILS. INC. [247
SCRA 398]
34.NATIONAL SHIPYARDS AND STEEL CORPORATION VS CIR [3 SCRA 890]
35.PNB V PNB EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION [115 SCRA 507 JULY 30, 1982]
36.BISIG NG MANGGAGAWA NG PHILIPPINE REFINING CO., INC. VS. PHILIPPINE
REFINING CO [G.R. NO. L-27761 SEPTEMBER 30, 1981]
37.CEZAR ODANGO VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 147420. JUNE 10, 2004]
38.JERRY E. ACEDERA VS INTERNATIONAL CONTAINER TERMINAL SERVICES, INC.
(ICTSI) [G.R. NO. 146073 - JANUARY 13, 2003]
39.GLOBAL INC. VS. ATIENZA ET AL [G.R. NO.L-51612-13 JULY 22, 1986]
40.RADIO COMMUNICATION OF THE PHILIPPINES, INC. V. NLRC, [223 SCRA 656,
JUNE 25, 1993]
41.CORMERO VS COURT OF APPEALS, ET AL., [247 SCRA 291 [1995]]
42.FUENTES VS. NLRC, [167 SCRA 767 - NOVEMBER 24, 1988]
43.ENGINEERING EQUIPMENT, INC., VS. MINISTER OF LABOR [G.R. NO. L-64967
SEPTEMBER 23, 1985]
44.STOLT-NIELSEN MARINE SERVICES (PHILS.) INC VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 109156.
JULY 11, 1996]
45.NAWASA VS. NWSA CONSOLIDATED UNIONS, [GR L-18938, 31 AUGUST 1964,
11 SCRA 766]

Page 15 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

46.ABDULJUAHID R. PIGCAULAN,* VS SECURITY AND CREDIT INVESTIGATION,

INC. AND/OR RENE AMBY REYES [G.R. NO. 173648 JANUARY 16, 2012]
47.WILLIAM LINES, INC. V. LOPEZ, [96 SCRA 593]
48.ANTONIO M. SERRANO VS. GALLANT MARITIME SERVICES, INC. AND MARLOW
NAVIGATION CO., INC. [G.R. NO. 167614, MARCH 24, 2009]
49.DAMASCO VS NLRC [GR NO 115755 - DECEMBER 4, 2000]

CASE LIST E:
HOLIDAYS

CASES ON REST PERIODS AND

1. JOSE RIZAL
COLLEGE VS NLRC
[G.R. NO. L-65482
DECEMBER 1,

1987]
2. MERCURY DRUG CO., INC., VS. NARDO DAYAO [G.R. NO. L-30452 SEPTEMBER
30, 1982]
3. INSULAR BANK OF ASIA AND AMERICA EMPLOYEES' UNION (IBAAEU) VS
INCIONG [G.R. NO. L-52415 OCTOBER 23, 1984]
4. VILLUGA VS. NLRC, [225 SCRA 537 - 1993]
5. THE CHARTERED BANK EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION, VS. HON. BLAS F. OPLE
[G.R. NO. L-44717 AUGUST 28, 1985]
6. UNION OF FILIPRO EMPLOYEES (UFE), VS. BENIGNO VIVAR, JR. [G.R. NO. 79255
JANUARY 20, 1992]
7. DE AGBAYANI VS PNB, [38 SCRA 429]
8. MANTRADE/FMMC DIVISION EMPLOYEES

AND

WORKERS

UNION

VS

BACUNGAN, [GR NO. L-48437, SEPTEMBER 30, 1986, 144 SCRA 510]
9. CBTC EMPLOYEES UNION, VS. THE HONORABLE JACOBO C. CLAVE [G.R. NO. L49582 JANUARY 7, 1986]
10.WELLINGTON INVESTMENT AND MANUFACTURING CORPORATION VS TRAJANO
[G.R. NO. 114698 JULY 3, 1995]
11.FAR EASTERN UNIVERSITY EMPLOYEES LABOR UNION, VS. FAR EASTERN
UNIVERSITY [G.R. NOS. L-69224-5 APRIL 15, 1988]
12.CEBU INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY (CIT), VS. HON. BLAS OPLE [G. R. NO. L58870 APRIL 15, 1988]
13.CITIBANK PHILS. EMPLOYEES UNION NATU, VS. THE HONORABLE MINISTER
OF LABOR [G.R. NO. L-50184 APRIL 11, 1980]
14.OCEANIC PHARMACAL EMPLOYEES UNION (FFW) VS HON. AMADO G. INCIONG
AND OCEANIC PHARMACAL INC [G.R. NO. L-50568 NOVEMBER 7, 1979]
15.BONIFACIO MURILLO VS SUN VALLEY REALTY, INC. [G.R. NO. L-67272 JUNE 30,
1988]
16.NICANOR M. BALTAZAR, VS. SAN MIGUEL BREWERY, INC [G.R. NO. L-23076
FEBRUARY 27, 1969]
17.DAVAO INTEGRATED PORT STEVEDORING SERVICES, VS. RUBEN V. ABARQUEZ
[G.R. NO. 102132. MARCH 19, 1993]
18.DONALD KWOK, VS. PHILIPPINE CARPET MANUFACTURING CORPORATION
[G.R. NO. 149252. APRIL 28, 2005]
19.REPUBLIC PLANTERS BANK NOW KNOWN AS PNB-REPUBLIC BANK VS NLRC
[G.R. NO. 117460 JANUARY 6, 1997]
20.ESTEBAN CUAJAO V. CHUA LO TAN [G.R. NO. L-16298 - SEPTEMBER 29, 1962]
21.RADA VS. NLRC, [205 SCRA 69, JANUARY 9, 1992]
22.NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT COMPANY VS COURT OF INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS
AND NATIONAL TEXTILE WORKERS UNION, [G.R. NO. L-15422 -6 SCRA 763]

Page 16 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

23.ARICA VS NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, [170 SCRA 776, 783,

FEBRUARY 28, 1989]
24.TAN VS LAGRAMA, [G.R. NO. 151228, AUGUST 15, 2002, 387 SCRA 393, 406]

CASE LIST F:

CASES ON WAGES

A. WAGES IN
GENERAL
1. ROSARIO

A.

GAA VS COURT OF APPEALS [GR. NO. L-44169 DECEMBER 3, 1985] AND

a. MAYON HOTEL & RESTAURANT, PACITA O. PO AND/OR JOSEFA PO LAM,
VS. ROLANDO ADANA [G.R. NO. 157634 MAY 16, 2005]
2. JOSE SONGCO VS NLRC [G.R. NO. L-50999 MARCH 23, 1990] AND
a. NORMA MABEZA VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 118506 APRIL 18, 1997]
3. SORIANO V. NLRC [G.R. NO. 75510, 27 OCTOBER 1987, 155 SCRA 124] AND
a. LIDUVINO M. MILLARES VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 122827 MARCH 29, 1999]
4. ALIPIO R. RUGA VS NLRC [G.R. NO. L-72654-61 JANUARY 22, 1990]
5. PHILIPPINE AGRICULTURAL COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL WORKERS UNION
(PACIWU)-TUCP, VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 107994 AUGUST 14, 1995]
6. BOIE-TAKEDA CHEMICALS, INC., VS. HON. DIONISIO DE LA SERNA [G.R. NO.
92174 DECEMBER 10, 1993]
7. PHILIPPINE FUJI XEROX CORP., VS. CRESENCIANO B. TRAJANO [G.R. NO. L102552 DECEMBER 10, 1993]
8. PHILIPPINE AIRLINES, INC. VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 55159 DECEMBER 22, 1989]
9. SOCIAL SECURITY SYSTEM, VS. SSS SUPERVISORS' UNION-CUGCO [G.R. NO. L31832 OCTOBER 23, 1982]
10.J.P. HEILBRONN CO. VS NLRC [G.R. NO. L-5121 JANUARY 30, 1953]
11.STATES MARINE CORPORATION AND ROYAL LINE, INC., VS. CEBU SEAMEN'S
ASSOCIATION, INC [G.R. NO. L-12444 FEBRUARY 28, 1963]
12.ATOK-BIG WEDGE MUTUAL BENEFIT ASSN. VS. ATOK BIG WEDGE MINING CO.,
INC., [97 PHIL. 294]
13.NORMA MABEZA VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 118506 APRIL 18, 1997]
14.PLASTIC TOWN CENTER CORPORATION VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 81176 APRIL 19,
1989]
15.INTERNATIONAL

SCHOOL

ALLIANCE

OF

EDUCATORS

(ISAE),

VS.

HON.

LEONARDO QUISIMBING [G.R. NO. 128845 JUNE 1, 2000]

16.RILECO, INC., VS. MINDANAO CONGRESS OF LABOR-RAMIE UNITED FARM
WORKERS'

ASSOCIATION

(LOCAL)

AND

THE

COURT

OF

INDUSTRIAL

RELATIONS [G.R. NO. L-22243 NOVEMBER 29, 1968]

17.VICTORIAS MILLING COMPANY, INC., VS. COURT OF INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS
[G.R. NO. L-17281 MARCH 30, 1963]
18.DEL ROSARIO V. COURT OF INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS, [GR NO L-23133, JULY 13,
1967, 20 SCRA 650]
19.CELESTIAL, ET AL. VS SOUTHERN MINDANAO EXPERIMENTAL STATION, ET AL.,
[106 PHIL 696; G.R. NO. L-12950, DECEMBER 9, 1959]
20.CEBU AUTOBUS COMPANY VS. UNITED CEBU AUTOBUS EMPLOYEES ASSN.,
[GR NO L-9742, OCT. 27, 1955]
B. WAGE FORMULATION
21.EMPLOYERS CONFEDERATION OF THE PHILIPPINES, VS. NATIONAL WAGES AND
PRODUCTIVITY

COMMISSION

AND

REGIONAL

TRIPARTITE

WAGES

AND

Page 17 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

PRODUCTIVITY BOARD-NCR, TRADE UNION CONGRESS OF THE PHILIPPINES

[G.R. NO. 96169 SEPTEMBER 24, 1991] AND
a. METROPOLITAN BANK AND TRUST COMPANY, VS NWCP [G.R. NO.
144322 FEBRUARY 6, 2007]
22.JUANA T. VDA. DE RACHO VS MUNICIPALITY OF ILAGAN [G.R. NO. L-23542
JANUARY 2, 1968] AND
a. NORKIS FREE AND INDEPENDENT WORKERS UNION, PETITIONER, VS.
NORKIS TRADING COMPANY, INC. [G.R. NO. 157098 JUNE 30, 2005]
23.RIZALINO P. UY VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 117983. SEPTEMBER 6, 1996] AND
a. NASIPIT INTEGRATED ARRASTRE ANDSTEVEDORING SERVICES, INC.
(NIASSI) VS NASIPIT EMPLOYEES LABOR UNION (NELU)-ALU-TUCP [SEP
3, 2014 - G.R. NO. 162411, JUNE 30, 2008]
24.DEVELOPMENT BANK OF THE PHILIPPINES V. NLRC [G.R. NOS. 100376-77,
JUNE 17, 1994, 233 SCRA 250]
25.GENERAL BAPTIST BIBLE COLLEGE V. NLRC, [219 SCRA 549 (1993)]
26.GARCIA VS. NLRC, [234 SCRA 632., 1994]
27.C. PLANAS COMMERCIAL VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 144619, NOVEMBER 11, 2005]
28.DAVAO INTEGRATED PORT STEVEDORING SERVICES, VS. RUBEN V. ABARQUEZ
[G.R. NO. 102132. MARCH 19, 1993]
29.SEVILLA TRADING COMPANY, VS. A.V.A. TOMAS E. SEMANA, SEVILLA TRADING
WORKERS UNION [G.R. NO. 152456 APRIL 28, 2004]
30.HONDA PHILS., INC., VS. SAMAHAN NG MALAYANG MANGGAGAWA SA HONDA
[G.R. NO. 145561 JUNE 15, 2005]
31.NESTL PHILIPPINES, INC VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 91231 FEBRUARY 4, 1991]
32.REYNALDO TIANGCO AND VICTORIA TIANGCO VS. HON. VICENTE LEOGARDO,
JR [G.R. NO. L-57636 MAY 16, 1983]
33.ARCO METAL PRODUCTS CO. INC. AND MRS. SALVADOR UY VS SAMAHAN NG
MGA MANGGAGAWA SA ARCO METAL [G. R. NO. 170734]
34.MARCOPPER MINING CORPORATION VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 103525 MARCH 29,
1996]
35.MEYCAUAYAN COLLEGE VS HON. FRANKLIN N. DRILON, [185 SCRA 50]
36.LAGNITON, SR. V. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, [G.R. NO.
86339, FEBRUARY 5, 1993, 218 SCRA 456, 459]
37.REPUBLIC PLANTERS BANK NOW KNOWN AS PNB-REPUBLIC BANK VS NLRC
[G.R. NO. 117460 JANUARY 6, 1997]
38.DAVAO FRUITS CORPORATION, VS. ASSOCIATED LABOR UNIONS (ALU) [G.R.
NO. 85073 AUGUST 24, 1993]
39.HINATUAN MINING CORPORATION AND/OR THE MANAGER VS NLRC [G.R. NO.
117394. FEBRUARY 21, 1997]
40.LEXAL LABORATORIES VS CIR [GR. NO. L-24632 OCTOBER 26, 1968]
41.MAMERTO B. ASIS, VS. MINISTER OF LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT [G.R. NO.
58094-95 MARCH 15, 1989]
42.PHILIPPINE DUPLICATORS, INC VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 110068 FEBRUARY 15,
1995]
43.BUSINESSDAY INFORMATION SYSTEMS AND SERVICES, INC VS NLRC [G.R. NO.
103575. APRIL 5, 1993]
44.GLOBE MACKAY CABLE AND RADIO CORPORATION VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 74156
JUNE 29, 1988]
45.SAMAHANG MANGGAGAWA

SA

TOP

FORM

MANUFACTURING

UNITED

WORKERS OF THE PHILIPPINES VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 113856 SEPTEMBER 7,

1998]
46.INSULAR HOTEL EMPLOYEES UNION-NFL VS WATERFRONT INSULAR HOTEL
DAVAO [G.R. NOS. 174040-41 - SEPTEMBER 22, 2010]
47.ROLANDO Y. TAN VS. LEOVIGILDO LAGRAMA [G.R. NO. 151228. AUGUST 15,
2002]

Page 18 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

48.AVELINO LAMBO VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 111042. OCTOBER 26, 1999]

C. RULES ON PAYMENT OF WAGES
49.BERNARDO JIMENEZ AND JOSE JIMENEZ, AS OPERATORS OF JJ'S TRUCKING VS
NLRC [G.R. NO. 116960 APRIL 2, 1996]
50.CONGSON VS. NLRC, [243 SCRA 260, 270, APRIL 5, 1995]
51.VIRGINIA G. NERI AND JOSE CABELIN VS NLRC [G.R. NOS. 97008-09 JULY 23,
1993]
52.AFP MUTUAL BENEFIT ASSOCIATION, INC VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 102199 JANUARY
28, 1997]
53.MANILA WATER COMPANY, INC. VS. HERMINIO D. PENA [G.R. NO. 158255 JULY
8, 2004]
54.FRAMANLIS FARMS, INC., ELOISA SYCIP VS MINISTER OF LABOR [G.R. NO.
72616-17 MARCH 8, 1989]
55.MERCER V. NLRC, [244 SCRA 376 (1995)]
56.DREAMLAND HOTEL RESORT VS STEPHEN R JOHNSON [G.R. NO. 191455
MARCH 12, 2014]
57.LEO A. GONZALES VS. SOLID CEMENT CORP. [G.R. NO. 198423. OCTOBER 23,
2012]
58.EASTERN TELECOMS PHIL INC VS EASTERN TELECOMS EMPLOYEES UNION,
[G.R. NO. 185665, FEBRUARY 8, 2012]
59.HYPTE R. AUJERO V. PHILIPPINE COMMUNICATIONS SATELLITE CORPORATION
[G.R. NO. 193484, 18 JANUARY 2012]
60.DBP VS NLRC [229 SCRA 350 (1994)]
61.ROBREDO VS NLRC, [238 SCRA 52, 1994]
62.COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 74965 NOVEMBER
9, 1994]
63.DBP VS NLRC [242 SCRA 59 (1994)]
64.DBP VS NLRC [236 SCRA 117 (1994)]
65.NEW PANGASINAN REVIEW INC. VS. NLRC, [196 SCRA 55 (1991)]
66.DEVELOPMENT BANK OF THE PHILIPPINES, VS. HON. LABOR ARBITER ARIEL C.
SANTOS [G.R. NO. 78261-62 MARCH 8, 1989]
67.DBP VS NLRC [GR NO 108031 (1995)]
68.REPUBLIC VS PERALTA [150 SCRA 37 (1987)]
69.PNB VS CRUZ [GR NO 80593 (1989)]
70.KAISAHAN AT KAPATIRAN NG MGA MANGGAGAWA AT KAWANI SA MWC-EAST
ZONE UNION VS MANILA WATER COMPANY, INC. [G.R. NO. 174179 NOVEMBER 16, 2011]
71.JOSE MAX S. ORTIZ VS SAN MIGUEL CORPORATION [G.R. NO. 151983-84

JULY 31, 2008]

72.PRUBANKERS ASSOCIATION VS. PRUDENTIAL BANK AND TRUST COMPANY,
[302 SCRA 74 (1999)]
73.COMMANDO SECURITY AGENCY VS NLRC, [G.R. NO. 95844, 20 JULY 1992, 211
SCRA 645, 650]
74.MERCURY DRUG CO., INC. V. DAYAO, [117 SCRA 99, 116]
75.APODACA VS. NLRC, [172 SCRA 442]
D. PROBLEMS RELATED TO WAGES
76.GENESIS TRANSPORT SERVICE, INC VS UNYON NG MALAYANG MANGGAGAWA
NG GENESIS TRANSPORT (UMMGT), AND JUAN TAROY [G.R. NO. 182114 APRIL 5, 2010]
77.LMG CHEMICALS CORPORATION V. SECRETARY OF THE DEPARTMENT OF
LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT, [G.R.

NO. 127422, 17 APRIL 2001, 356 SCRA

577]
78.PRODUCERS BANK OF THE PHILIPPINES V. NLRC, [G.R. NO. 100701, 28 MARCH
2001, 355 SCRA 489]

Page 19 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

79.SHS PERFORATED MATERIALS, INC., WINFRIED HARTMANNSHENN VS MANUEL

F. DIAZ [G.R. NO. 185814 - OCTOBER 13, 2010]
80.RED V COCONUT PRODUCTS V. COURT OF INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS, [GR NO L21348, JULY 30, 1968, 17 SCRA 553]
81.ENGINEERING EQUIPMENT INC VS MINISTER OF LABOR [138 SCRA 616 (1985)]
82.ROSARIO BROTHERS, INC. V. OPLE, [G.R. NO. 53590, JULY 31, 1984, 131 SCRA
72]
83.WISE AND CO., INC., VS. WISE & CO. UNION [G.R. NO. L-87672 OCTOBER 13,
1989]
84.BIBIANO C. ELEGIR VS PAL [G.R. NO. 181995 JULY 16, 2012]
85.DREAMLAND HOTEL RESORT VS STEPHEN R JOHNSON [G.R. NO. 191455
MARCH 12, 2014]
86.ABDULJUAHID R. PIGCAULAN, VS. SECURITY AND CREDIT INVESTIGATION, INC.
[G.R. NO. 173648: JANUARY 16, 2012]
87.DARIO NACAR VS. GALLERY FRAMES [G.R. NO. 189871. AUGUST 13, 2013]
88.ATCI OVERSEAS CORPORATION, AMALIA G. IKDAL AND MINISTRY OF PUBLIC
HEALTH-KUWAIT, VS. MA. JOSEFA ECHIN [G.R. NO. 178551 - OCTOBER 11,
2010]
89.WESLEYAN UNIVERSITY-PHILIPPINES, VS. WESLEYAN UNIVERSITY-PHILIPPINES
FACULTY AND STAFF ASSOCIATION [G.R. NO. 181806 MARCH 12, 2014]

CASE LIST G:

CASES ON BENEFITS

A. OVERTIME PAY
1. SHELL

OIL

WORKERS
UNION VS. SHELL COMPANY OF THE PHILIPPINES, [GR NO L-30658-59, MARCH
31, 1976, 70 SCRA 238] AND
a. SAN MIGUEL CORPORATION VS. LAYOC [G.R. NO. 149640. OCT. 19,
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.

2007]
PAMPANGA SUGAR DEVELOPMENT CO., INC. VS. CIR, [114 SCRA 725] AND
a. PCL SHIPPING PHILIPPINES VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 153031]
MERCURY DRUG CO., INC. V. DAYAO, [117 SCRA 99, 116] AND
a. ACUA VS CA [G.R. 159832 (2006)]
BISIG MANGGAGAWA SA TRYCO VS. NLRC. [G.R. NO. 151309. OCT. 15, 2008]
PAL VS NLRC [302 SCRA 582 (1999)]
PAN AMERICAN AIRWAYS VS PAN AMERICAN EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION [GR NO

L-16275 (FEB 23, 1961) 1 SCRA 527]

7. SAN JUAN DE DIOS HOSPITAL EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION-AFW/MA VS NLRC
[G.R. NO. 126383 NOVEMBER 28, 1997]
8. BISIG NG MANGGAGAWA NG PHILIPPINE REFINING CO., INC., VS. PHILIPPINE
REFINING CO.
9. PNB VS PEMA [G.R. NO. L-27761 SEPTEMBER 30, 1981; 115 SCRA 507 (1982)]
10.JULIO N. CAGAMPAN vs NLRC [G.R. Nos. 85122-24 March 22, 1991]
B. NIGHT SHIFT DIFFERENTIAL
11.NATIONAL SEMICONDUCTOR (HK) DISTRIBUTION, LTD vs NLRC [G.R. No.
123520 June 26, 1998]
12.NARIC VS NARIC WORKERS' UNION, [105 PHIL., 891 (1959)]
C. HOLIDAY PAY
13.JOSE RIZAL COLLEGE VS NLRC [G.R. NO. L-65482 DECEMBER 1, 1987] AND

Page 20 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

a. ASIAN TRANSMISSION CORPORATION VS CA [G.R. NO. 144664 MARCH

15, 2004]
14.SAN MIGUEL CORPORATION VS CA [G.R. NO. 146775. JANUARY 30, 2002]
15.INSULAR BANK OF ASIA AND AMERICA EMPLOYEES' UNION (IBAAEU) VS
INCIONG [G.R. NO. L-52415 OCTOBER 23, 1984]
16.THE CHARTERED BANK EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION, VS. HON. BLAS F. OPLE
[G.R. NO. L-44717 AUGUST 28, 1985]
17.CEZAR ODANGO VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 147420. JUNE 10, 2004]
18.UNION OF FILIPRO EMPLOYEES (UFE), VS. BENIGNO VIVAR, JR [G.R. NO. 79255
JANUARY 20, 1992]
19.WELLINGTON INVESTMENT

AND

MANUFACTURING

CORPORATION

VS

CRESENCIANO B. TRAJANO [GR NO 114698 JULY 3, 1995] AND

a. ASIAN TRANSMISSION CORPORATION VS CA [G.R. NO. 144664 MARCH
15, 2004]
20.STOLT-NIELSEN MARINE SERVICES (PHILS.) INC VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 109156.
JULY 11, 1996]
D. SERVICE INCENTIVE LEAVE (VACATION LEAVE, SICK LEAVE, ETC.)
21.VERA V. CUEVAS, [90 SCRA 379, MAY 31, 1979]
22.CEBU INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY (CIT), VS. HON. BLAS OPLE [G.R. NO. L58870 DECEMBER 18, 1987]
23.MAKATI HABERDASHERY, INC VS NLRC [G.R. NOS. 83380-81 NOVEMBER 15,
1989]
24.BONIFACIO MURILLO VS SUN VALLEY REALTY, INC [G.R. NO. L-67272 JUNE 30,
1988]
25.DAVAO INTEGRATED PORT STEVEDORING SERVICES, VS. RUBEN V. ABARQUEZ
[G.R. NO. 102132. MARCH 19, 1993]
26.ESTEBAN CUAJAO V. CHUA LO TAN [G.R. NO. L-16298 SEPTEMBER 29, 1962]
27.NICANOR M. BALTAZAR, VS. SAN MIGUEL BREWERY, INC [G.R. NO. L-23076
FEBRUARY 27, 1969]
28.REPUBLIC PLANTERS BANK NOW KNOWN AS PNB-REPUBLIC BANK VS NLRC
[G.R. NO. 117460 JANUARY 6, 1997]
29.LUCIANO ESCOSURA VS SAN MIGUEL BREWERY, INC. [G.R. NOS. L-16696 AND
L-16702, JANUARY 31, 1962]
30.MANSION PRINTING CENTER VS DIOSDADO BITARA, JR. [G.R. NO. 168120 (JANUARY 25, 2012)]
E. OTHER CASES
31.EMIRATE SECURITY AND MAINTENANCE SYSTEMS, INC. AND ROBERTO YAN VS.
GLENDA M. MENESE, [G.R. NO. 182848. OCTOBER 5, 2011] AND
a. CAPITOL WIRELESS, INC. VS NIEVES CONFESSOR [G.R. NO. 117174.
NOVEMBER 13, 1996]
32.SLL INTERNATIONAL CABLES SPECIALIST VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 172161 (MARCH
2, 2011)]
33.LEIDEN FERNANDEZ VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 105892 JANUARY 28, 1998]
34.MAYNILAD WATER SUPERVISORS ASSOCIATION, VS. MAYNILAD [G.R. NO.
198935 NOVEMBER 27, 2013]
35.EASTERN TELECOM PHILIPPINES, INC. VS EASTERN TELECOM EMPLOYEES
UNION [G.R. NO. 185665 - FEBRUARY 8, 2011]
36.SEVILLA TRADING COMPANY VS. A.V.A. TOMAS E. SEMANA AND SEVILLA
TRADING WORKERS UNION [G.R. NO. 152456 APRIL 28, 2004]
37.MANILA ELECTRIC COMPANY, VS. HON. SECRETARY OF LABOR LEONARDO
QUISUMBING [G.R. NO. 127598 FEBRUARY 22, 2000]
38.GLOBE TELECOM INC VS FLORENDO-FLORES [G.R. NO. 150092. SEPTEMBER
27, 2002]

Page 21 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

39.HONDA PHILS., INC., VS. SAMAHAN NG MALAYANG MANGGAGAWA SA HONDA

[G.R. NO. 145561 JUNE 15, 2005] AND
a. RFM CORPORATION-FLOUR DIVISION AND SFI FEEDS DIVISION VS
KASAPIAN NG MANGGA-GAWANG PINAGKAISA-RFM (KAMPI-NAFLU-KMU)
AND SANDIGAN AT UGNAYAN NG MANGGAGAWANG PINAGKAISA-SFI
(SUMAPI-NAFLU-KMU) [G.R. NO. 162324 - (FEBRUARY 4, 2009)]

CASE LIST H:
MINORS

BENEFITS FOR WOMEN AND

A.

WOMEN
1. GUALBERTO,
ET

AL.

VS.

MARINDUQUE MINING & INDUSTRIAL CORPORATION [CA-G.R. NO. 52753-R,

JUNE 28, 1978]
2. CLAUDINE DE CASTRO ZIALCITA VS PAL [CASE NO R04 3-398-76, (20 FEB
1977) [DECIDED BY THE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT]]
3. PHILIPPINE TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE COMPANY VS NLRC [G.R. NO.
118978 MAY 23, 1997]
B. SEXUAL HARASSMENT AND OTHER RELATED CASES
4. DELFIN G. VILLARAMA VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 106341 SEPTEMBER 2, 1994]
5. RAMON B. FORMANTES, VS DUNCAN PHARMACEUTICALS, PHILS.INC. [G.R.
NO. 170661 DECEMBER 4, 2009]
6. PHILIPPINE AEOLUS AUTOMOTIVE UNITED CORPORATION VS NLRC [G.R.
NO. 124617. APRIL 28, 2000]
7. TERESITA G. NARVASA VS BENJAMIN A. SANCHEZ, JR [G.R. NO. 169449 MARCH 26, 2010]
8. DIGITEL TELECOMMUNICATIONS PHILIPPINES, INC VS MARIQUIT SORIANO
[G.R. NO. 166039 - JUNE 26, 2006]
9. STANFORD MICROSYSTEMS, INC. VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 74187 JANUARY 28,
1988]
10.CASIANO A. NAVARRO III VS HON. ISRAEL D. DAMASCO [G.R. NO. 101875
JULY 14, 1995]
11.JOSE S SANTOS V NLRC, [G.R. NO. 115795 MARCH 6, 1998]
12.CARLOS G. LIBRES VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 123737. MAY 28, 1999]
13.DIVINE WORD HIGH SCHOOL VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 72207 AUGUST 6, 1986]
14.EVELYN CHUA-QUA VS. HON. JACOBO C. CLAVE [G.R. NO. 49549 AUGUST
30, 1990]
15.BANK OF THE PHILIPPINE ISLANDS EMPLOYEES UNION AND ZENAIDA UY VS
BANK OF THE PHILIPPINE ISLANDS [G.R. NO. 137863. MARCH 31, 2005]
16.DR. RICO S. JACUTIN, VS. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES [G.R. NO. 140604
MARCH 6, 2002]
17.ROLINDA B. PONO VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 118860. JULY 17, 1997]
18.CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION VS PETER NIERRAS [G.R. NO. 165121

FEBRUARY 14, 2008]

19.MA. LOURDES T. DOMINGO VS ROGELIO I. RAYALA [G.R. NO. 155831
FEBRUARY 18, 2008]
20.EASTERN TELECOMMUNICATIONS PHILIPPINES, INC VS ATTY. VIRGILIO R.
GARCIA [G.R. NOS. 173163-64 - APRIL 16, 2009]
21.ROMULO G. MADREDIJO ET AL VS JUDGE LEANDRO T. LOYAO JR [A.M. NO.
RTJ-98-1424. OCTOBER 13, 1999]

Page 22 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

CASE LIST I:
CASES ON JOB CONTRACTING,
LABOR ONLY CONTRACTING AND
STATUS OF EMPLOYMENT

A.

JOB

CONTRACTING
1. GARDEN OF
MEMORIES
PARK AND LIFE PLAN, INC. AND PAULINA T. ROQUIO VS. NLRC, ET. AL.,
[G.R. NO. 160278, FEB. 8, 2012]
2. D.M. CONSUNJI, INC. AND/OR DAVID M. CONSUNJI VS. ESTELITO, [G.R. NO.
192514, APRIL 18, 2012]
3. NORKIS TRADING CORPORATION VS. JOAQUIN BUENAVISTA, ET AL. [G.R.
NO. 182018 OCTOBER 10, 2012]
4. SUPERIOR PACKAGING CORPORATION VS ARNEL BALAGSAY ET AL [G.R.
NO. 178909. OCTOBER 10, 2012]
5. JOEB M. ALIVIADO, ET AL. VS. PROCTER AND GAMBLE PHILS. INC., ET AL.,
[G.R. NO. 160506, JUNE 6, 2011]
6. DIGITEL TELECOMMUNICATION PHIL VS DIGITEL EMPLOYEES UNION [G.R.
NOS. 184903-04. OCTOBER 10, 2012]
7. EMMANUEL BABAS ET. AL. V LORENZO SHIPPING CORPORATION [G.R. NO.
186091]
8. PEOPLE'S BROADCASTING VS SECRETARY OF DOLE [G.R. 179652 (2009)]
9. CATHOLIC VICARIATE, BAGUIO CITY VS HON. PATRICIA A. STO. TOMAS [G.R.
NO. 167334]
10.SAN MIGUEL CORPORATION VS. SEMILLANO [G.R. NO. 164257. JULY 5,
2010]
11.MANILA WATER COMPANY, INC VS JOSE J. DALUMPINES ET AL [G.R. NO.
175501 - OCTOBER 4, 2010]
B. STATUS OF EMPLOYMENT
12.GMA NETWORK, INC., VS. CARLOS P. PABRIGA [G.R. NO. 176419
NOVEMBER 27, 2013]
13.ROY D. P ASOS, VS. PHILIPPINE NATIONAL CONSTRUCTION CORPORATION
[G.R. NO. 192394 JULY 3, 2013]
14.LEYTE GEOTHERMAL POWER PROGRESSIVE EMPLOYEES UNION - ALU
TUCP VS PHILIPPINE NATIONAL OIL COMPANY - ENERGY DEVELOPMENT
CORPORATION [G.R. NO. 170351 MARCH 30, 2011]
15.MARTICIO SEMBLANTE AND DUBRICK PILAR VS CA [G.R. NO. 196426.
AUGUST 15, 2011]
16.MILLENIUM ERECTORS CORP. V. VIRGILIO MAGALLANES, [G.R. NO. 184362,
NOVEMBER 15, 2010]
17.PANGANIBAN V. TARA TRADING SHIPMANAGEMENT, INC., [G.R. NO.
187032, OCTOBER 18, 2010, 633 SCRA 353, 365]

Page 23 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

18.DACUITAL V. L.M. CAMUS ENGINEERING CORPORATION, [G.R. NO. 176748,

1 SEPTEMBER 2010, 629 SCRA 702]
19.D.M. CONSUNJI, INC VS ANTONIO GOBRES ET AL. [G.R. NO. 169170 AUGUST 8, 2010]
20.AVELINO S. ALILIN ET AL VS PETRON [G.R. NO. 177592, JUNE 09, 2014]
21.SOUTH DAVAO DEVELCPMENT COMPANY, INC. AND/OR PACQUIAO V.
GAMO, [605 PHIL. 604, 613]
22.BPI EMPLOYEES UNION-DAVAO CITY-FUBU (BPIEU-DAVAO CITY-FUBU) V.
BANK OF THE PHILIPPINE ISLANDS (BPI), ET AL., [G.R. NO. 174912, JULY 24,
2013]
23.TIMOTEO H. SARONA VS. NLRC, ET. AL., [G.R. NO. 185280, JAN. 18, 2012]
24.DEALCO FARMS, INC. VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 153192 JANUARY 30, 2009]
25.ZAMUDIO VS. NLRC [GR NO. 76723. MARCH 25, 1990]
C. OTHER CASES
26.PHILIPPINE SCHOOL OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION (PSBA)-MANILA VS
NLRC [G.R. NO. 114143. AUGUST 28, 1996]
27.LEOPOLDO GUARIN VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 86010 OCTOBER 3, 1989]
28.WILLIAM L. TIU VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 95845. FEBRUARY 21, 1996]
29.FRANKLIN BAGUIO VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 79004-08 OCTOBER 4, 1991]
30.ABOITIZ SHIPPING EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION VS. NLRC, ET AL., [186 SCRA
825 JUNE 27, 1990]
31.SARRA VS AGARRADO, [166 SCRA 625 [1988]]
32.BROADWAY MOTORS, INC. V. NLRC, [G.R. NO. 78382, 14 DECEMBER 1987,
156 SCRA 522, 530]
33.TABAS VS. CALIFORNIA MANUFACTURING CO., INC. [169 SCRA 497]
34.KIMBERLY INDEPENDENT LABOR UNION FOR SOLIDARITY, ACTIVISM AND
NATIONALISM-OLALIA V. DRILON, [185 SCRA 190 [1990]]
35.RHONE-POULENC AGROCHEMICALS PHIL., INC. VS NLRC [G.R. NOS.
102633-35]
36.VIRGINIA G. NERI AND JOSE CABELIN VS NLRC [G.R. NOS. 97008-09 JULY
23, 1993]
37.PCI AUTOMATION CENTER, INC. VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 115920. JANUARY 29,
1996]
38.ISAGANI ECAL, ET AL VS NLRC [G.R. NOS. 92777-78]
39.PHILIPPINE BANK OF COMMUNICATIONS VS NLRC [G.R. NO. L-66598
DECEMBER 19, 1986]
40.COCA-COLA BOTTLERS PHILS, INC. V. ALAN M. AGITO [G.R. NO. 179546]
41.AFP MUTUAL BENEFIT ASSOCIATION, INC. VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 102199
JANUARY 28, 1997]
42.INSULAR LIFE ASSURANCE CO., LTD VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 84484 NOVEMBER
15, 1989]
43.SINGER SEWING MACHINE COMPANY, VS. HON. FRANKLIN M. DRILON [G.R.
NO. 91307 JANUARY 24, 1991]
44.RAQUEL P. CONSULTA VS CA [G.R. NO. 145443. MARCH 18, 2005]
45.ALEXANDER VINOYA VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 126586 FEBRUARY 2, 2000]
46.ALEJANDRO MARAGUINOT, JR VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 120969 JANUARY 22,
1998]
47.MANILA WATER COMPANY, INC., VS. HERMINIO D. PENA [G.R. NO. 158255
JULY 8, 2004]
48.SAN MIGUEL CORPORATION, VS. PROSPERO A. ABALLA [G.R. NO. 149011
JUNE 28, 2005]
49.DOLE PHILS. VS. ESTEVA, [G.R. NO. 161115, NOVEMBER 30, 2006]
50.REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES V. ASIAPRO COOPERATIVE [GR 172101
NOVEMBER 23, 2007]

Page 24 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

51.COCA-COLA BOTTLERS, PHILS. INC., PETITIONER, VS. DELFIN HINGPIT [G.R.

NO. 127238 AUGUST 25, 1998]
52.PHILIPPINE FUJI XEROX CORPORATION VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 111501 MARCH
5, 1996]
53.ASSOCIATED

LABOR

UNIONS-TUCP

V.

NATIONAL

LABOR

RELATIONS

COMMISSION [G.R. NO. 101784, 21 OCTOBER 1991]

54.ESCARIO, ET. AL. VS. NLRC [G.R. NO. 124055. JUNE 8, 2000]
55.SHOPPERS GAIN SUPERMART VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 110731. JULY 26, 1996]
56.ASSOCIATED ANGLO-AMERICAN TOBACCO CORPORATION, VS. HON.
JACOBO C. CLAVE [G.R. NO. 50915 AUGUST 30, 1990]
57.RUBEN SERRANO VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 117040 MAY 4, 2000]
58.WACK WACK GOLF & COUNTRY CLUB VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 149793. APRIL 15,
2005]
59.GENERAL SANTOS COCA-COLA PLANT FREE WORKERS UNION-TUPAS VS
COCA-COLA BOTTLERS PHILS., INC. (GENERAL SANTOS CITY), THE COURT
OF APPEALS AND THE NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION [G.R.
NO. 178647 - FEBRUARY 13, 2009]
60.LOPEZ SUGAR CORPORATION, VS. LEONITO G. FRANCO [G.R. NO. 148195.
MAY 16, 2005]
61.BONIFACIO ASUFRIN, JR., VS. SAN MIGUEL CORPORATION [G.R. NO. 156658
MARCH 10, 2004]
62.DOLE PHILIPPINES, INC VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 120009 SEPTEMBER 13, 2001]
63.ISMAEL V. SANTOS, ALFREDO G. ARCE AND HILARIO M. PASTRANA, VS.
COURT OF APPEALS AND PEPSI COLA [G.R. NO. 141947 JULY 5, 2001]
64.SMART COMMUNICATIONS, INC. V. REGINA ASTORGA [G.R. NO. 148132]
65.PURE FOODS CORPORATON VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 122653. DECEMBER 12,
1997]
66.ARTEMIO J. ROMARES VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 122327 AUGUST 19, 1998]
67.PHILIPS SEMICONDUCTORS (PHILS.), INC., VS. ELOISA FADRIQUELA [G.R.
NO. 141717. APRIL 14, 2004]
68.LAPANDAY AGRICULTURAL DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION VS CA [G.R. NO.
112139 JANUARY 31, 2000]
69.ROSEWOOD PROCESSING, INC VS NLRC [G.R. NOS. 116476-84. MAY 21,
1998]
70.EAGLE SECURITY AGENCY, INC VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 81314 MAY 18, 1989]
71.NATIONAL FOOD AUTHORITY (NFA) VS MACEDA SECURITY AGENCY [G.R.
NO. 163448. MARCH 08, 2005]
72.CAILO/EDDIE NORICO VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 82718 FEBRUARY 27, 1991]
73.MCARTHUR MALICDEM VS MARULAS INDUSTRIAL CORPORATION [GR NO
204406 -FEB 26, 2014]

CASE LIST J:
CASES ON 13TH MONTH PAY,
BONUSES, ALLOWANCES,
COMMISSIONS, ETC.

A. 13TH MONTH PAY

1. MARCOPPER
MINING

CORPORATION, VS. THE HONORABLE BLAS OPLE [G.R. NO. L-51254 JUNE
11, 1981]
2. NATIONAL FEDERATION OF SUGAR WORKERS (NFSW) VS ETHELWOLDO R.
OVEJERA [G.R. NO. L-59743 MAY 31 1982]

Page 25 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

3. DOLE PHILIPPINES, INC. VS. THE HON. VICENTE LEOGARDO JR [G.R. NO. L60018 OCTOBER 23, 1982]
4. BROKENSHIRE MEMORIAL HOSPITAL, INC VS NLRC [G.R. NO. L-69741
AUGUST 19, 1986]
5. UNITED CMC TEXTILE WORKERS UNION, VS. THE HONORABLE LABOR
ARBITER, RAYMUNDO VALENZUELA [G.R. NO. 70763 APRIL 30, 1987]
6. UNIVERSAL CORN PRODUCTS (A DIVISION OF UNIVERSAL ROBINA
CORPORATION) VS NLRC [G.R. NO. L-60337 AUGUST 21, 1987]
7. FAR EASTERN UNIVERSITY EMPLOYEES LABOR UNION, VS. FAR EASTERN
UNIVERSITY [G.R. NOS. L-69224-5 APRIL 15, 1988]
8. FRAMANLIS FARMS, INC. VS MINISTER OF LABOR [G.R. NO. 72616-17
MARCH 8, 1989]
9. UST FACULTY UNION VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 90445 OCTOBER 2, 1990]
10.VICTORIAS MILLING CO. INC. V. NLRC, [233 SCRA 403 (1994)]
11.OLAYBAR V. NLRC, [G.R. NO. 108713, 28 OCTOBER 1994, 237 SCRA 819]
12.SMI FISH INDUSTRIES, INC. VS. NLRC, [213 SCRA 444]
13.PHILIPPINE AGRICULTURAL COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL WORKERS
UNION (PACIWU)-TUCP VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 107994 AUGUST 14, 1995]
14.PHILIPPINE DUPLICATORS, INC VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 110068 FEBRUARY 15,
1995]
B. BONUS
15.EASTERN

TELECOMMUNICATIONS

PHILIPPINES,

INC.

VS.

EASTERN

TELECOMS EMPLOYEES UNION, [G.R. NO. 185665 FEB 8, 2012]

16.PHILIPPINE EDUCATION CO., INC. VS. COURT OF INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS,
[92 SCRA 381 [1979]]
17.H. E. HEACOCK VS. NATIONAL LABOR UNION, ET AL., [95 PHIL., 553; 50
OFF. GAZ., 4253]
18.LIBERATION STEAMSHIP CO., INC. VS. CIR [23 SCRA 1105]
19.NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT COMPANY VS. UNLICENSED CREW MEMBERS OF
THREE DONS VESSELS [23 SCRA 1106]
20.LOURDES G. MARCOS VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 111744 SEPTEMBER 8, 1995]
21.TRADERS ROYAL BANK VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 88168 AUGUST 30, 1990]
22.KAMAYA POINT HOTEL VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 75289 AUGUST 31, 1989]
23.THE MANILA BANKING CORPORATION VS NLRC [G.R. NOS. 107487 &
107902 SEPTEMBER 29, 1997]
C. COMMISSIONS
24.PHILIPPINE AGRICULTURAL COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL WORKERS
UNION (PACIWU)-TUCP VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 107994 AUGUST 14, 1995]
25.JOSE SONGCO ET AL VS NLRC [G.R. NOS. 50999-51000 MARCH 23, 1990]

D. FACILITIES
26.STATES MARINE CORPORATION AND ROYAL LINE, INC., VS. CEBU SEAMEN'S
ASSOCIATION, INC [G.R. NO. L-12444 FEBRUARY 28, 1963]
27.ATOK-BIG WEDGE MINING CO., INC. V. ATOK-BIG WEDGE MUTUAL BENEFIT
ASS'N. [G.R. NO. L-5276 MARCH 3, 1953 - 92 PHIL 754]
28.CEBU AUTOBUS COMPANY V. UNITED CEBU AUTOBUS EMPLOYEES ASSN.,
[GR NO L-9742, OCT. 27, 1955]

Page 26 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

E. GRATUITY AND ALLOWANCES

29.PLASTIC TOWN CENTER CORPORATION VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 81176 APRIL 19,
1989]
30.NORMA MABEZA VS NLRC [G.R. NO. 118506 APRIL 18, 1997]
31.CEBU INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY (CIT), VS. HON. BLAS OPLE [G. R. NO. L58870 APRIL 15, 1988]

CASE LIST K:
CASES ON BENEFITS ARISING
FROM DEATH DUE TO DISEASE

1. EMILIA VDA.
DE
INGUILLO,
VS.
EMPLOYEES'

COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO. L-51543 JUNE 6, 1989]

2. CAROLINA CLEMENTE, VS. GOVERNMENT SERVICE INSURANCE SYSTEM
[G.R. NO. L-47521 JULY 31, 1987]
3. AMALIA NARAZO V. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO.
80157 FEBRUARY 6, 1990]
4. HILARIA DABATIAN, VS. GOVERNMENT SERVICE INSURANCE SYSTEM [G.R.
NO. L-47294 APRIL 8, 1987]
5. JOSE B. SARMIENTO, VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R.
NO. L-65680 MAY 11, 1989]
6. GLICERIA C. CASUMPANG, VS. EMPLOYEES COMPENSATION COMMISSION
[G.R. NO. 48664 MAY 20, 1987]
7. NICETAS C. RODRIGUEZ, VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION
[G.R. NO. L-46454 SEPTEMBER 28, 1989]
8. ROSALINA G. NAVALTA, VS GOVERNMENT SERVICE INSURANCE SYSTEM
[G.R. NO. L-46684 APRIL 27, 1988]
9. JUAN BONIFACIO VS GOVERNMENT SERVICE INSURANCE SYSTEM [G.R. NO.
L-62207 DECEMBER 15, 1986]
10.TELEFAST COMMUNICATIONS/PHILIPPINE WIRELESS, INC VS CASTRO [G.R.
NO. 73867 FEBRUARY 29, 1988]
11.NAPOLEON O. CARIN VS EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION AND
GOVERNMENT SERVICE INSURANCE SYSTEM [G.R. NO. L-46556 MAY 28,
1988]
12.JESUS DE JESUS, VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO.
L-56191 MAY 27, 1986]
13.LUPO S. CARBAJAL VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R.
NO. L-46654 AUGUST 9, 1988]
14.CALVERO V. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION ET AL., [117 SCRA
461 [1982]]
15.PARAGES VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION, [JANUARY 17,
1985, 134 SCRA 73, 78]
16.FLERIDA OVENSON VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R.
NO. L-65216 - DEC 1, 1987]
17.AMELIA DELEGENTE, V. EMPLOYEES COMPENSATION COMMISSION AND
GOVERNMENT

SERVICE

NOVEMBER 2, 1982]

INSURANCE

SYSTEM

[G.R.

NO.

L-47460.

Page 27 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

18.FLORENCIA

B.

SAN

VALENTIN,

VS

EMPLOYEES'

COMPENSATION

COMMISSION AND GOVERNMENT SERVICEINSURANCE SYSTEM [G.R. NO. L56909 NOVEMBER 2, 1982]
19.SARMIENTO VS EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION, [SEPT. 24,
1986, 144 SCRA 421]
20.JOSE B. SARMIENTO, VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R.
NO. L-65680 MAY 11, 1989]
21.FELIXBERTO VILLONES, VS. EMPLOYEES COMPENSATION COMMISSION
[G.R. NO. L-46200 JULY 30, 1979]
22.FLAVIANO NEMARIA, VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R.
NO. L-57889 OCTOBER 28, 1987]
23.EULALIO MORA JR VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO.
L-62157 DECEMBER 1, 1987]
24.ZAIDA G. RARO, VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO.
L-58445 APRIL 27, 1989]
25.APOLINARIO KIRIT, SR., ET AL. VS GOVERNMENT SERVICE INSURANCE
SYSTEM, ET AL [G.R. NO. 48580 JULY 6, 1990]
26.EDUARDO LAGINLIN, VS. WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R.
NO. L-45785 MARCH 21, 1988]
27.BENJAMIN SEGOVIA, VS. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES [G.R. NO. L-46102.
APRIL 15, 1988]
28.CEPEDA VS. BACOLOD MURCIA MILLING CO., INC., [135 SCRA 505]
29.ANGELITA TAEDO VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R.
NO. L-62300 SEPTEMBER 25, 1987]
30.ROSALINDA GODIZANO, VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION
[G.R. NO. L-62354 MAY 9, 1985]
31.JESUS DE JESUS, VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO.
L-56191 MAY 27, 1986]
32.ZARAGOSA VS. WORKMENS COMPENSATION COMMISSION, [203 SCRA
302, G.R. NO. 32982, NOV. 5, 1991]
33.ANGELO L. LOYOLA, VS. GOVERNMENT SERVICE INSURANCE SYSTEM [G.R.
NO. 89097 AUGUST 24, 1990]
34.MALLI A. HATTA HATAIE VS EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION
[G.R. NO. 92803 MARCH 22, 1991]
35.ALBERTO C. CEREZO VS EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R.
NO. L-50295 OCTOBER 23, 1979]
36.PERFECTO JARILLO, VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R.
NO. L-52058 FEBRUARY 25, 1982]
37.MAURO G. MERIS VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO.
59872 AUGUST 24, 1990]
38.ROQUE V. ZOZOBRADO VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION
[G.R. NO. L-65856 JANUARY 17, 1986]
39.VDA, DE PANGAN VS WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION COMMISSION [136
SCRA 572]
40.PEDRO ESGUERRA, VS. WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R.
NO. L-43082 APRIL 9, 1985]
41.SAN VALENTIN VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION, [118 SCRA
160 [1982]]
42.VDA. DE TUMOLVA VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION, [141
SCRA 78]
43.NAVAL V. EMPLOYEES COMPENSATION COMMISSION, [G.R. NO. 83568, JULY
18, 1991, 199 SCRA 388]
44.MILLORA V. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION, ET AL. [G.R. NO.
69572, 28 JULY 1986, 143 SCRA 151]

Page 28 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

45.DE GUIA V. EMPLOYEES COMPENSATION COMMISSION, [G.R. NO. 95595,

JULY 8, 1991, 198 SCRA 834]
46.RUTH JIMENEZ VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO.
58176 MARCH 23, 1984]
47.RODOLFO YOSORES VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R.
NO. 97346 MARCH 23, 1992]
48.ERESE V. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION, [138 SCRA 192]
49.JOSE A. BEJERANO, VS. EMPLOYEES COMPENSATION COMMISSION [GR NO.
84777 JANUARY 30, 1992]
50.ANGELES BRAVO VS. EMPLOYEES COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO.
L-66174 JULY 22, 1986]

CASE LIST L:
CASES ON BENEFITS ARISING
FROM DEATH DUE TO ACCIDENT/
CRIME

1. BELARMINO
V.
EMPLOYEES

COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO. 90104, MAY 11, 1990, 185 SCRA
304]
2. CIRIACO HINOGUIN V. EMPLOYEES COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO.
84307 APRIL 17, 1989]
3. GOVERNMENT SERVICE INSURANCE SYSTEM (GSIS), VS. THE HONORABLE
COURT OF APPEALS [G.R. NO. 128524. APRIL 20, 1999]
4. CELERINO VALERIANO, VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION
[G.R. NO. 136200 JUNE 8, 2000]
5. ILOILO DOCK & ENGINEERING CO., , VS. WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION
COMMISSION [G.R. NO. L-26341 NOVEMBER 27, 1968]
6. GENEROSO ALANO, VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R.
NO. L-48594 MARCH 16, 1988]
7. CRISPINA VANO, VS. GOVERNMENT SERVICE INSURANCE SYSTEM [G.R. NO.
81327 DECEMBER 4, 1989]
8. SALVADOR LAZO, VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO.
78617 JUNE 18, 1990]
9. BELLOSILLO VS CITY OF MANILA [GR NO 34522 NOV 9, 1991]
10.CONRADO PAEZ, VS. WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO.
L-18438 MARCH 30, 1963]
11.ENAO V. EMPLOYEES COMPENSATION COMMISSION, [135 SCRA 660
[1985]]
12.GALICIA VS. DY PAC [G.R. NO. 7402, MARCH 25, 1941]
13.BOHOL LAND TRANSPORTATION CO., VS. FERMINA VIUDA DE MADANGUIT
[G.R. NO. L-47360 NOVEMBER 28, 1940]
14.PAMPANGA SUGAR DEVELOPMENT CO., INC. V. QUIROZ, [16 SCRA 784
[1966]]
15.ESTANDARTE V. PHIL. MOTOR ALCOHOL CORP., [G. R. NO. 39733, NOV.
1933]
16.BALAJADIA VS. PROVINCE OF ILOILO, [G. R. NO. 41979 OCTOBER 1934]
17.LUZON STEVEDORING CO., INC., VS. WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION
COMMISSION [G.R. NO. L-19742 JANUARY 31, 1964]
18.VERGOZA VS. ARNAZ VDA. DE CRUZ, [GR NO L-7305, DECEMBER 15,
1953]

Page 29 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

19.VISAYAN

STEVEDORE-TRANSPORTATION

CO.

VS.

WORKMEN'S

COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO. L-22135 - DECEMBER 27, 1963]

20.CHUA YENG VS. MICHAELA ROMA [G.R. NO. L-14827 OCTOBER 31, 1960.]
21.ENAO V. EMPLOYEES COMPENSATION COMMISSION, [135 SCRA 660
[1985]]
22.DIOPENES VS. GSIS, [205 SCRA 331 (1992)]
23.CRISPINA VANO, VS. GOVERNMENT SERVICE INSURANCE SYSTEM [G.R. NO.
81327 DECEMBER 4, 1989]
24.EXALTACION VDA. DE TORBELA,

VS.

EMPLOYEES

COMPENSATION

COMMISSION [G.R. NO. L-42627 FEBRUARY 21, 1980]

25.GENEROSO ALANO, VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R.
NO. L-48594 MARCH 16, 1988]
26.SALVADOR LAZO, VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO.
78617 JUNE 18, 1990]
27.PEDRO BALDEBRIN, VS. WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R.
NO. L-43792 OCTOBER 12, 1984]
28.LUZON STEVEDORING CORPORATION,

PETITIONER,

VS.

WORKMEN'S

COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO. L-27588 APRIL 28, 1969]

29.ROSA
LENTEJAS,
PETITIONER,
VS.
EMPLOYEES'
COMPENSATION
COMMISSION [G.R. NO. 89168 MAY 14, 1991]
30.NITURA V. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION, [201 SCRA 278
(1991)]
31.TALISAY-SILAY

MILLING

CO.,

INC

VS.

WORKMEN'S

COMPENSATION

COMMISSION [G.R. NO. L-22096 - SEPTEMBER 29, 1967]

32.REPUBLIC V. AMIL, [GR NO L-20137, MARCH 31, 1964, 10 SCRA 669]
33.PERLITA LOPEZ VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO.
90267 DECEMBER 21, 1993]
34.DE LA REA VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [141 SCRA 128]
35.CONCEPCION MURILLO VS ALFREDO MENDOZA [G.R. NO. L-46020
DECEMBER 8, 1938]
36.ENCARNACION VDA. DE YOHANON V. JOSE BALENA, ET AL [G.R. NO. L43641 AUGUST 26, 1977]
37.SANTIAGO RAMOS VS PEDRO POBLETE AND JACOBA JARIN [G.R. NO. L47829 OCTOBER 8, 1941]
38.CONRADO PAEZ VS WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO. L18438 MARCH 30, 1963]
39.BENIGNA CAUNAN VS COMPAIA GENERAL DE TABACOS DE FILIPINAS
[G.R. NO. L-34194 - FEBRUARY 20, 1932]

CASE LIST M:
CASES OF PERMANENT TOTAL
DISABILITY AND OTHER
DISABILITIES

1. GLORIA

D.

MENEZ, VS.
EMPLOYEES'

COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO. L-48488 APRIL 25, 1980]

2. EMILIA VDA. DE INGUILLO, VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION
[G.R. NO. L-51543 JUNE 6, 1989]
3. EULALIO GALANIDA, VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R.
NO. 70660 SEPTEMBER 24, 1987]
4. RUBEN T. LIMBO VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R. NO.
146891 JULY 30, 2002]

Page 30 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

5. ELIGIO P. MIRASOL VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R.

NO. L-45910 APRIL 28, 1980]
6. NONATO ROSALES VS. EMPLOYEES' COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R.
NO. L-46443 JUNE 28, 1988]
7. ZOSIMO CAPACIO, VS. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES [G.R. NO. L-45484
APRIL 8, 1988]
8. EDUARDO LAGINLIN, VS. WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION COMMISSION [G.R.
NO. L-45785 MARCH 21, 1988]
9. NORMA ORATE, VS. COURT OF APPEALS [G.R. NO. 132761.

MARCH 26,

2003]

CASE LIST N:
CASES INVOLVING
SEAFARERS DISABILITY, DISEASE,
AND DEATH

1. MR.
REGINALDO
A.

OBEN,.

BANDILA
SHIPPING,
INC VS MARCOS C. ABALOS [G.R. NO. 177100 - FEBRUARY 22, 2010]
2. QUIZORA V. DENHOLM CREW MANAGEMENT PHILS. INC., [G.R. NO. 185412
NOV 16, 2011]
3. NFD INTERNATIONAL

MANNING

AGENTS,

INC.

BARBER

SHIP

MANAGEMENT, LTD. VS. ESMERALDO ILLESCAS; [G.R. NO. 183054;

SEPTEMBER 29, 2010]
4. NAESS SHIPPING PHILIPPINES, INC VS. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS
COMMISSION [G.R. NO. 73441 SEPTEMBER 4, 1987]
5. MABUHAY SHIPPING SERVICES, INC. AND SKIPPERS MARITIME CO., LTD. VS
NLRC [G.R. NO. 94167 JANUARY 21, 1991]
6. SEA POWER SHIPPING ENTERPRISES INC V NENITA P SALAZAR, [GR
188595, AUGUST 28 2013]
7. PRUDENTIAL SHIPPING AND MANAGEMENT CORPORATION V. STA. RITA,
[544 PHIL. 94]
8. LEONIS NAVIGATION CO., INC. V. VILLAMATER [G.R. NO. 179169, MARCH 3,
2010, 614 SCRA 182]
9. KLAVENESS MARITIME AGENCY, INC. V. BENEFICIARIES OF ALLAS, [566
PHIL. 579 (2008)]
10.HERMOGENES V. OSCO SHIPPING SERVICES, INC., [504 PHIL. 564, 570
(2005)]
11.KESTREL SHIPPING CO., INC/CAPT. AMADOR P. SERVILLON AND ATLANTIC
MANNING LTD. VS. FRANCISCO D. MUNAR [G.R. NO. 198501. JANUARY 30,
2013]
12.SUSANA SY V PHILIPPINE TRANSMARINE CARRIERS INC, [GR 191740,
FEBRUARY 11 2013]
13.PANGANIBAN V. TARA TRADING SHIPMANAGEMENT, INC., [G.R. NO.
187032, OCTOBER 18, 2010, 633 SCRA 353]
14.ALPHA SHIP MANAGEMENT CORPORATION VS ELEOSIS V. CALO [G.R. NO.
192034 JANUARY 13, 2014]
15.JESUS VERGARA V. HAMMONIA MARITIME SERVICES [G.R. NO. 172933]
16.MAERSK FILIPINAS CREWING INC VS NELSON E. MESINA [G.R. NO. 200837
JUNE 5, 2013]
17.CARMELITO VALENZONA VS. FAIR SHIPPING CORPORATION AND/OR SEJIN
LINES COMPANY LIMITED, [G.R. NO. 176884, OCTOBER 19, 2011]

Page 31 of 31
USEC JBJs COURSE SYLLABUS IN PHILIPPINE LABOR STANDARDS

18.RIZALDY M. QUITORIANO VS JEBSENS MARITIME, INC. [G.R. NO. 179868

JANUARY 21, 2010]
19.CRYSTAL SHIPPING, INC. V. NATIVIDAD, [510 PHIL. 332, 339 (2005)]
20.INC. SHIPMANAGEMENT, INC VS ALEXANDER L. MORADAS [G.R. NO.
178564 JANUARY 15, 2014]
21.COASTAL SAFEWAY MARINE SERVICES, INC VS LEONISA M. DELGADO [G.R.
NO. 168210 - JUNE 17, 2008]
22.COOTAUCO V. MMS PHIL. MARITIME SERVICES, INC., [G.R. NO. 184722,
MARCH 15, 2010, 615 SCRA 529]
23.CAREER PHILIPPINES SHIPMANAGEMENT, INC., ET AL. VS. SALVADORS T.
SERNA [G.R. NO. 172086 - DECEMBER 3, 2012]
24.FIL-PRIDE SIDPPING COMPANY, INC VS EDGAR A. BALASTA [G.R. NO.
193047 MARCH 3, 2014]