Equity Research On FMCG
Equity Research On FMCG
PROJECT REPORT
ON
A Equity research
On
Fast Moving Consumer Goods
SUBMITTED BY:
IMTIYAZ SIDDIQUE
MMS-FINANCE
2008-10
DECLARATION
I Mr. Imtiyaz A. Siddique of Rizvi Institute of Management
hereby declare that I have completed the summer project on A
EQUITY RESEARCH ON FAST MOVING CONSUMER
GOODS in the academic year 2008-10. The information
submitted in the same is true & original of the best of my
knowledge.
Signature
CERTIFICATE
I Mr. Kalim Khan hereby declare that Mr. Imtiyaz A.
Sidddique of Rizvi Institute of Management has completed his
summer project in the academic year 2008-10. The information
submitted in the same is true & original of the best of my
knowledge.
Signature
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
There is joy in work. There is no happiness except in the
realization that we have accomplished something - Henry Ford
The making of any project requires contribution from many
people, right from inception till its completion. In my case also,
there had been a few people who have made this happen. It
was not only learning but also an enriching experience.
I am deeply indebted to Prof. Kalim Khan, Director, Rizvi
Institute of Management Studies for having allowed me to
carry out the project successfully. I specially thank my guide
Prof. Furqan Shaikh for his constant guidance, professional
help and support during the course of the project.
I thank my colleagues and friends for providing constant
encouragement and help. I am indebted to them for their
timely help & the enthusiasm they expressed in helping me
bring this project to the fruitful end. Finally, I am grateful to
my family for their moral support and understanding.
Teachers open the door, but you must enter by yourself
Signature
Executive summary
The Indian FMCG sector is the fourth largest sector in the economy
with a total market size in excess of US$ 13.1 billion. FMCG market is
expected to rise to 33.4 billion US$ till 2015.
This report starts with a brief introduction of FMCG market along with
Industry Overview. It further state that why FMCG sector is Analyzed
and why India. In this report two FMCG company HUL & Dabur
India is analyzed there history their shareholding pattern along with
their product is being discussed.
The company Fundamental & Technical is shown in the report. An
analysts evaluates the stocks based on different parameter like
fundamentals of the company i.e earnings of the company, P/E
dividend yield etc. And technical based on Chart of the company
share price the chart i.e Moving Average Crossover Chart, MACD
chart through which we come to know the future price whether it is
going to come down or go up.
The report also include the distinguish feature of FMCG as compared
to other sector and a well defined conclusion.
As consumer behavior and lifestyles changed, people no longer buy the way
they used to. Simply increasing width' and depth' of coverage no longer
seems to produce the magical results it once used to."
-' Business Line, April 2003.
TABLE OF CONTENT
Sr No TOPICS
1.1
1.2
2.1
2.2
2.3
2.4
2.5
2.6
2.7
3.1
4.1
5.1
5.2
5.3
5.4
5.5
6.1
6.2
6.3
6.4
6.5
7.1
8.1
9.1
10.1
11.1
12.1
PAGE
NO.
Introduction
Indian FMCG market size
Industry Overview
Structural Analysis of FMCG Industry
FMCG Market Review
Why FMCG Sector is Analyzed
FMCG Sector Product and Category
India- a large consumer goods spender
Consumer expenditure on food at international level
FMCG sector product and category
SWOT Analysis
Hindustan Unilever LTD
Product of HUL
Distribution Network
Fundamental Analysis
Technical Analysis
Dabur India
Product of Dabur
Distribution Network
Fundamental Analysis
Technical Analysis
Sectoral opportunities
Policy Issues
Distinguishing Features of Indian FMCG Business
Other Suggestions
Salient Feature
Conclusion
1.1 Introduction
6
The Indian FMCG sector is the fourth largest sector in the economy
with a total market size in excess of US$ 13.1 billion. It has a strong
MNC presence and is characterized by a well established distribution
network, intense competition between the organized and unorganized
segments and low operational cost. Availability of key raw materials,
cheaper labour costs and presence across the entire value chain
gives India a competitive advantage.
The FMCG market is set to treble from US$ 11.6 billion in 2003 to
US$ 33.4 billion in 2015. Penetration level as well as per capita
consumption in most product categories like jams, toothpaste, skin
care, hair wash etc in India is low indicating the untapped market
potential. Burgeoning Indian population, particularly the middle class
and the rural segments, presents an opportunity to makers of
branded products to convert consumers to branded products.
Growth is also likely to come from consumer 'upgrading' in the
matured product categories. With 200 million people expected to shift
to processed and packaged food by 2010, India needs around US$
28 billion of investment in the food-processing industry.
Automatic investment approval (including foreign technology
agreements within specified norms), up to 100 per cent foreign equity
or 100 per cent for NRI and Overseas Corporate Bodies (OCBs)
investment, is allowed for most of the food processing sector.
At the macro level, Indian economy is poised to remained buoyant
and grow at more than 7%. The economic growth would impact large
proportions of the population thus leading to more money in the
hands of the consumer. Changes in demographic composition of the
population and thus the market would also continue to impact the
FMCG industry.
2.
3.
4.
5.
12
15
16
17
Category
Product
Food and
Beverages
Personal Care
Household Care
Strengths
Well established distribution networks extending to the rural areas
Backed by strong brands
Low cost operations
Presence of established distribution networks in both urban and
rural areas
Presence of well-known brands in FMCG sector
Weakness
Low export levels
Small scale sector reservations limit ability to invest in technology
and achieve economies of scale
Several Me-Too products
Opportunities
Large domestic market
Export potential
Increasing income levels will result in faster revenue growth
High consumer goods spending
Threats
Tax & Regulatory Structures
Slowdown in Rural Demands
Removal of import restriction resulting in replacing of domestic
brands
Management Structure
20
Board
Chairman
Harish Manwani
Nitin Paranjpe
Vice Chairman
D Sundaram
Director
D S Parekh
C K Prahalad
A Narayan
S Ramadorai
R A Mashelkar
Executive Director
Dhaval Buch
Executive Director
Gopal Vittal
21
16%
15%
3%
Foreign
Institutions
51%
Non Promoter
Promoters
Public & Others
Stock Code
500696
HINDUNILVR
Laundry
Surf Excel
Rin
Wheel
Ala bleech
Hair-Care
Sunsilk naturals
Clinic
Dove
Beauty Products
Pepsodent
Close-up
Foods
Ice-cream
Kwality Wall's
Foods
Annapurna(Aata and
salt)
Kissan(Jam,Ketchup,Squ
ashes)
Knorr Soups
Coffee
Brooke bond
Bru
Tea
Brooke bond
Lipton
24
FACTORY
REDISTRIBUTION STOCKIST
CONSUMER
The products that are manufactured are first brought to the JIT (Just
In Time) Depot from the factory. Then these products are delivered to
the Redistribution Stockiest according to the order placed by them,
this is done through Permanent Dispatch Plan. Then this stock is
send to either retailers or wholesalers, according to the channel
followed by them. From there it reaches to the consumers.
At the supermarkets
25
Distribution Network
26
FACTORY
CONSUMER
March
09
0.92
0.51
0.20
118.70
Dec 07
Dec 06
Dec 05
0.68
0.25
0.06
83.09
0.73
0.34
0.03
171.62
0.70
0.33
0.02
83.27
Current Ratio of HUL has been less than 1 for all the 4 years taken
for analysis. As the standard of current ratio is 1:1 for FMCG industry.
This implies that working capital of HUL is always negative. This is
generally considered an aggressive strategy i.e. to financing its long
term asset by short term sources that increases profitability because
current liabilities are non interest bearing items. There is significant
difference between CR and LR which indicates that the current asset
of HUL consists of good amount of inventory. Value of sundry debtors
is quite low. The liquidity ratios have increase from previous year
which shows that HUL has increase its liquidity further.
The loans taken by HUL is high in 2009 which is indicated by high
debt to total source ratio and this is why its ICR ratio gone up as
compared to previous year (as compared to ICR in 2007). It has
increased its loan as it currently operating the business through loan
money. Debt to equity ratio was between 0.02 to 0.06 for previous 3
year as taken to comparision but all of sudden in current year it has
increase to almost 3 times as compared to 0.06 in the year 2007 this
means that the company has taken huge amount of loan to finance it
business. Interest Coverage Ratio show that how Leverage the
company is the higher the ratio the less leverage.
Dec 07
Dec 06
Dec 05
09
9.26
41.83
7.81
7.20
31.41
5.64
8.02
25.42
5.35
8.57
22.12
5.11
Profitability Ratios
29
March
09
14.46
13.50
12.05
121.34
121.06
Dec 07
Dec 06
Dec 05
14.95
15.86
12.58
122.97
138.72
14.74
15.80
14.94
68.14
65.89
14.14
15.03
12.42
61.09
67.66
11.47
7.50
13.35
8.12
9.00
13.78
8.41
6.00
13.50
6.40
5.00
12.87
Dec 07
Dec 06
Dec 05
09
29.26
2.40
25.21
29.67
3.16
32.36
28.61
3.67
17.55
34.79
3.63
18.84
PE ratio for HUL is not so good with values over 30. In the year 2009,
2007 and 2006 and somewhat better with value around 30. It means
an investor will get return around 1/30 times on his actual investment.
If you multiply EPS & PER of 2009 you get Rs 336 and the current
market share of Hul is Rs 272 this means that the company is
undervalued. Market capitalization of HUL has increased after 2005,
but there is a small decrease in the year 2007, and now it is 2.40 in
current financial year it has decreased over here management should
play a vital role to increase market capitalization.
- Price Line
- 50 days moving average
- 20 days moving average
From the above Moving Average Crossover Chart we can see that in
the month of January HUL stock was very volatile we cannot predict
what is going to happen because price line is not able to cut 20 days
moving average nor it is able to cut 50 days moving average from
down or from up as it can be see from the chart that at the end of
January price line has cut 20 days moving average from down so
price has raise little bit but in march 20 days moving average has cut
50 days moving average from up this is the clear indication that price
is going to fall and this is the time to sell the stock and we can see
that in march price has gone down to the low as compared from
January to june and for 3 month (march, april, may) price line and 20
days moving average was below 50 days moving average so price
was low for that period but in the start of june price line and 20 days
moving average has cut 50 days moving average from down so this
is clear indication that price is going to go up and this is the right time
to buy the stock.
MACD Chart
32
- Price Line
- 9 days signal line
- MACD line
Moving Average Convergence Divergence chart means that when as
MACD falls below the signal line, it is a bearish signal.
When the MACD rises above the signal line, the indicator gives a bullish
signal.
From the above MACD chart we can make out that in the month of
January MACD was above the signal line that means the price will also go
up and till end of February the stock price that was indicated in the chart is
more or less up. At the start of march MACD line has touch signal line and
then it has gone down this is a signal to come out if you have a stock
because the price is going to go down and till the end of march MACD was
below the signal line in April it has try to cut signal line but it was not able
to cut it so it is advice not to enter in this market we need to wait. As seen
from the chart that at the start of June MACD line has cut signal line and
gone up so stock price has also gone up and till now it is showing upward
trend this is a good time to enter in the market.
Recommended to Hold
33
As FMCG sector was struggling with the slow growth in the Indian
economy, Dabur decided to take numerous strategic initiatives,
reorganize operations and improve on its brand architecture
beginning 2002. It decided to concentrate its marketing efforts on
35
Management Structure
Dabur India's Fast Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG) Company. It is
present in Home & Personal Care & Food categories.
36
Board
Chairman
Anand Burman
Vice Chairman
Amit Burman
Executive Director
Pradip Burman
Additional Director
Mohit Burman
Director
P D Narang
Sunil Duggal
R C Bhargava
P N Vijay
S Narayan
Albert Wiseman Paterson
Analjit Singh
Company Secretary
37
9%
14%
1%
Foreign
Institutions
Non Promoter
Promoters
Public & other
70%
Stock Code
500096
DABUR
38
Skin Care
Vatika fairness
Gulabari
Olive oil
Dabur lal tel
Shampoo
Vatika heena
conditioning
Anmol-natural shine
silky
Oral Care
Babool
Meswak
promise
Binaca
Home Care
Odomos
Odonil
Sanifresh
Odopic
Foods
Digestive
Hajmola range
Hingoli
Pudin hara
Health Supplements
Chyawanprash
Dabur Honey
Glucose
39
The initiative
An in-house developed, easy-to-use, Intranet based data-warehouse
displays as-of-yesterday sales, stock, receivables, banking, and other
MIS. Over 5,000 ASP pages meet almost all reporting requirements
and make this a single source of MIS for all levels of decision makers.
This success paved the ground for the company's supply chain
initiative. Fifty-five Ku Band TDMA VSATs were used to link primary
distributors to the system. Factories were hooked up using PAMA
(Permanent Assigned Multiple Access) VSATs. At some locations
VPNs had to be used because it was not possible to set up a dish.
The zonal offices in Mumbai were hooked up in a similar manner.
The hardware is mostly owned by the primary CFA (Carry and
Forward Agent) except for the networking equipment, which is owned
by Dabur. In the case of the secondary systems, stockists wholly own
the hardware.
The primary rollout began in April 2001 and took 16 months. The first
six months were used to create a business model common to all
divisions (family products, healthcare, ayurvedic products, and
pharmaceuticals), and testing and piloting the same.
40
The Innovation
The integrated primary and secondary system has a number of
unique features. The features like tight integration of schemes,
stockists credit limit control, automated banking of cheques, and
online cheque reconciliation have obvious advantages in the primary
distribution. These are basically extensions to the MFG/PRO ERP
system and not core customizations.
Dabur's stockists supply to 1.5 million retailers. Seventy percent of
the sales are accounted for by the top 500 stockists. The
incorporation of these top stockists into its supply chain is a first for
any FMCG company in India. The average sale of each stockist and
the current stock are the two parameters.
A 'My Page' allows the stockist to see the 'as-of-yesterday' details
pertaining to the in-transit shipments, transporter details, back-orders,
account statement, cheque status, credit notes, and claim
settlements.
Details are collected from stockists on a weekly basis. In case of
primary distribution points, an incremental backup is sent to the
central location when the CFA closes operations for the day. These
are computed at night in a process called cubing. And when
managers come into office in the morning the information is ready for
them.
The integrated system allows each Area Manager to plan for the
month's sales forecasts, stockists performance, and sales officers'
performance. The integration allows better control on pipelines in
primaries and secondaries, brings down inventories, and offers better
control on production and sales against a confirmed forecast.
The company has added an SMS interface that lets authorized
phones query the system for aspects like stock status, credit limits,
current outstanding and division-wide sales. An control list of mobile
phone numbers is used to restrict access to the system. Salespeople
can get responses to their queries in a minute with this system," said
Gopal Shukla, Chief Information Officer, Dabur India Limited.
41
Current Ratio
Quick ratio
Total Debt/Equity
Interest Coverage
March
09
1.19
0.99
0.19
38.34
March
08
0.91
0.58
0.03
46.79
March
07
0.97
0.63
0.05
140.69
March
06
0.82
0.52
0.05
70.12
Current Ratio of dabur for last 3 year is near to 1 and for this financial
year it is more then 1 this indicate that the company is in good
position as Current Ratio standard for FMCG industry is 1:1.There is
less difference between CR and LR which indicates that the current
asset of Dabur consists of less amount of inventory. Value of sundry
debtors is quite high. The liquidity ratios have increase from previous
year which shows that dabur has increase its liquidity further.
Debt/Equity ratio means the ratio of finance coming from Debts
compared to shareholders. A ratio exceeding 1 may be cause for
concern. As it can be seen that the Debt/Equity ratio is near to 0.03 &
0.05 for the last three year this means that company operate the
business mainly through owner funds but this financial year
Debt/Equity ratio has increased from 0.03 to 0.19 this indicate that
company has taken loan from market to finance the business with
Debt/Equity ratio we can say that in this financial year 2009 company
is investing Rs 1 from there pocket and 19 paisa from out side. As
they have taken loan from market then there Interest coverage ratio
has decreased. Interest Coverage Ratio show that how Leverage the
company is the higher the ratio the less leverage
Inventory turnover
Debtor turnover
Asset turnover
March
09
10.94
22.63
4.84
March
08
12.52
25.94
4.67
March
07
11.11
39.70
4.50
March
06
11.65
35.30
4.24
Profitability Ratios
43
March
09
18.33
17.19
15.44
51.20
47.98
March
08
18.60
17.37
15.06
61.58
67.51
March
07
17.45
17.49
14.41
62.52
66.07
March
06
17.90
17.74
14.04
42.22
46.69
4.32
1.75
17.11
3.67
1.50
17.29
2.92
1.75
16.16
3.30
2.50
16.47
March
09
24.55
3.52
11.57
March
08
32.23
4.48
17.99
March
07
34.91
5.00
20.33
March
06
40.64
5.19
15.87
PER ratio for Dabur is not so good with values over 30 In the year
2006, 2007 and 2008. But for this financial year it is 24.55 that means
it is decreasing the PER should be as low as possible. This means
that the market is valuing the company 24.55 times then its EPS if
you multiply EPS & PER for 2009 you get Rs 106 and the current
market share of Dabur is Rs 124 this means that the company is
overvalued. Market capitalization of Dabur is decreasing from 2006
which was 5.19 and for 2009 it is 3.52 every year it is decreasing
Management need to look forward to increased their market
capitalization.
MACD Chart
46
- Price Line
- 50 days moving average
- 20 days moving average
Moving Average Convergence Divergence chart means that when as
MACD falls below the signal line, it is a bearish signal.
When the MACD rises above the signal line, the indicator gives a
bullish signal.
When the security price diverge from the MACD. It signals the end of
the current trend.
From the above MACD chart we can make out that from January to June
MACD was above the signal line that means the price will also go up and
the price line has gone up if you see the price line chart In the start of
March MACD was almost equal to signal line at this point we cant predict
any think because it may go up or also it can come down but as in the mid
of march MACD goes on increasing and gone above the signal line the
price goes on increasing and the price is showing the upward trend.
Recommended to Hold
47
packs are also likely to drive potential up trading. In the personal care
segment, according to forecasts made by the Centre for Industrial
and Economic Research (CIER), detergent demand is likely to rise to
4,180, 000 metric tonnes by 2011-12 with an annual growth rate of 7
per cent between 2006 and 2012. The demand for toilet soap is
expected to grow at an annual rate of 4 per cent between 2006-12 to
870,000 metric tones by 2011-12. Rapid
urbanization is expected to propel the demand for cosmetics to
100,000 metric tonnes by 2011-12, with an annual growth rate of 10
per cent.
Beverages: The US$ 2 billion Indian tea market has been growing
at 1.5 to 2 per cent annually and is likely to see a further rise as
Indian consumers convert from loose tea to branded tea products. In
the aerated drinks segment, the per capita consumption of soft drinks
in India is 6 bottles compared to Pakistan's 17 bottles, Sri Lanka's 21,
Thailand's 73, the Philippines 173 and Mexico's 605. The demand for
soft drink in India is expected to grow at an annual rate of 10 per cent
per annum between 2006-12 with demand at 805 million cases by
2011-12. Per capita coffee consumption in India is being promoted by
the coffee chains and by the emergence of instant cold coffee.
According to CIER, demand for coffee is expected to rise to 535,000
metric tonnes by 2012, with an annual growth rate of 5 per cent
between 2006-12.
Edible oil: The demand for edible oil in India, according to CIER, is
expected to rise to 21 million tonnes by 2011-12 with an annual
growth rate of 7 per cent
per annum.
Confectionary: The explosion of the young age population in India
will trigger a spurt in confectionary products. In the long run the
industry is slated to grow at 8 to 10 per cent annually to 870,000
metric tonnes by 2011-12.
The cascading effect of sales tax and local levies on inputs used in
domestic manufacture should be eliminated by providing either
MODVAT credit or by introducing notional VAT covering both central
and state taxes on an urgent basis.
51
FDI Policy
Automatic investment approval (including foreign technology
agreements within specified norms), up to 100 per cent foreign equity
or 100 per cent for NRI and Overseas Corporate Bodies (OCBs)
investment, is allowed for most of the food processing sector except
malted food, alcoholic beverages and those reserved for small scale
industries (SSI). 24 per cent foreign equity is permitted in the smallscale sector. Temporary approvals for imports for test marketing can
also be obtained from the Director General of Foreign Trade. The
evolution of a more liberal FDI policy environment in India is clearly
supported by the successful operation of some of the global majors
like PepsiCo in India.
12.1 Conclusion
The FMCG sector has traditionally grown at a very fast rate and has
generally out performed the rest of the industry. Over the last one
year, however the rate of growth has slowed down and the sector has
recorded sales growth of just five per cent in the last four quarters.
The outlook in the short term does not appear to be very positive for
the sector. Rural demand is on the decline and the Centre for
Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE) has already downscaled its
projection for agriculture growth in the current fiscal. Poor monsoon in
some states, too, is unlikely to help matters. Moreover, the general
57
58