Intermetallics: A. Gali, E.P. George
Intermetallics: A. Gali, E.P. George
Intermetallics
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/intermet
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Equiatomic, face-centered-cubic, high- and medium-entropy alloys were arc melted, hot-rolled to pro-
Received 11 March 2013 duce recrystallized sheets, and tensile tested. The alloys having the compositions CrMnFeCoNi and
Accepted 25 March 2013 CrFeCoNi exhibited a strong temperature-dependent decrease in strength with increasing temperature
Available online 18 April 2013
from 196 C to 1000 C, and a relatively weak strain-rate dependence (at 103 and 101 s1). Ductility
did not vary inversely with yield strength; rather, when strength doubled as the test temperature was
Keywords:
decreased from room temperature to 196 C, elongation to fracture increased by a factor of 1.5 to >60%.
B. Yield stress
A high degree of work hardening, possibly due to deformation-induced nanotwinning, postpones the
B. Solid-solution hardening
B. Brittleness and ductility
onset of necking and may be the reason for the ductility increase.
B. Work-hardening 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
D. Microstructure
F. Mechanical testing
1. Introduction While the above concepts can, in principle, explain why some multi-
element alloys are single-phase solid solutions [2,13,14,16,17,19,20],
Recently, there has been considerable interest in multi-element, most of the so-called high-entropy alloys reported in the literature
equiatomic alloys and their derivatives e.g.[1e20], that are often contain multiple phases [e.g.,4-12,15]. The reason for this is that
referred to in the literature as high-entropy alloys. In ideal solid congurational entropy cannot usually overcome the other driving
solutions, the congurational entropy, DSconf RSniln(ni), where forces of phase stability, such as enthalpy and non-congurational
ni is the atomic fraction of the ith element and R is the gas constant, entropy, which often have stronger inuences [19]. Additionally, in
increases with the number of alloying elements. It has been hy- alloys consisting of multiple phases, the congurational entropy is
pothesized that, when the number of alloying elements increases actually lower than that implied by the equation above for a single-
beyond ve, the contribution of congurational entropy to the total phase ideal solid solution [19]. Therefore, to study the mechanical
free energy becomes signicant enough that it can overcome the properties of high-entropy alloys, it is important that truly single-phase
enthalpies of compound formation and phase separation, thereby solid solution alloys be investigated.
stabilizing the solid solution state relative to multi-phase micro- Here we investigate the equiatomic, FCC-structured quinary alloy
structures [1]. Based on this logic, a high-entropy alloy was dened (CrMnFeCoNi), rst reported by Cantor et al. [2] and later conrmed to
as one with at least ve major elements whose individual atomic consist of a single solid-solution phase [19,20]. For comparison with
concentrations are between 5 and 35% [1,7]. Alloys based on one this high-entropy alloy, we investigated a medium-entropy quater-
principal metallic element were classied as low-entropy alloys nary alloy (CrFeCoNi) that is comprised of the same elements as the
and those comprised of two to four principal elements as medium- Cantor alloy minus the Mn; this quaternary alloy is also single-phase
entropy alloys [7]. In all such multi-element alloys, the congura- FCC [17]. The tensile properties of neither of these alloys have so far
tional entropy is obviously maximized when the alloying elements been published. We report here our initial ndings on the micro-
are present in equal atomic concentrations [1]; consequently, much structure and tensile behavior of these alloys, which were produced
of the high-entropy alloy research has tended to focus on alloys by arc melting, drop casting and hot rolling, as described below.
consisting of multiple principal elements in roughly equal
proportions. 2. Materials and methods
0966-9795/$ e see front matter 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.intermet.2013.03.018
A. Gali, E.P. George / Intermetallics 39 (2013) 74e78 75
melting under argon atmosphere. The arc-melted buttons were patterns in a Scintag diffractometer and (b) determine their melting
ipped and remelted ve times to promote thorough mixing and to points in a NETZSCH 404 C differential scanning calorimeter.
allow the regions in contact with the water-cooled copper hearth to From the rolled sheets, dog-bone shaped specimens with gage
become fully incorporated in the melt. After the fth remelt, the sections of 10 mm 2.5 mm 0.63 mm were cut by EDM with their
arc-melted buttons were drop cast into a rectangular copper mold long axes parallel to the rolling direction. They were subsequently
measuring 127 mm 25.4 mm 12.7 mm. Weight losses after ground through 1200 grit SiC paper, and stress relieved at 900 C
melting and casting were w1% and <0.1% for the HE-1 and HE-4 for 1 h in vacuum. Tensile tests were performed on a screw-driven
alloys, respectively. Since there was negligible weight loss in the Instron machine at engineering strain rates of approximately 103
alloy without Mn, it was assumed that the entire weight loss in HE- and 101 s1 at temperatures from 196 C to 1000 C. The cryo-
1 was due to evaporation of Mn (consistent with its much higher genic tests were performed with the specimens completely
vapor pressure). To compensate for this weight loss, we added an immersed in liquid nitrogen; tests at room temperature and higher
extra gram of Mn per 100 g of raw materials. were performed in vacuum. Prior to testing, seven, roughly equally
The drop-cast bars exhibited dendritic segregation; therefore, spaced Vickers indents were made on the gage sections using a
they were rst annealed at 1000 C for 24 h in vacuum to ho- micro-hardness tester and a 300-g load. The distance between
mogenize their compositions. After homogenization, the alloys adjacent indents was measured before and after the tensile tests
were clad with stainless steel sheet and hot rolled to break down and averaged for each specimen to get the uniform elongation to
their cast structures and obtain a recrystallized microstructure. The fracture (the two indents on either side of the fracture plane were
purpose of the cladding was to minimize heat loss to the unheated excluded from the measurements). Occasionally, all the indents
rolls during the rolling operation. Before the rst rolling pass, the could not be located after testing; in those cases, the total change in
clad bars were pre-heated at 1000 C for 1 h; between all subse- specimen length divided by the gage length was used as a measure
quent passes, reheating to 1000 C was done for w15 min. For the of ductility (implicitly assuming that all the deformation occurred
rst ve rolling passes, a 10% reduction in thickness per pass was in the gage section). Fracture surfaces of the tensile tested speci-
used; after that, a 20% reduction in thickness per pass was used for mens were examined either in an XL30 or Hitachi S4800 FEG
all subsequent passes until a nal sheet thickness of w1 mm was scanning electron microscope.
reached. Therefore, starting from the initial thickness of the drop-
cast bar (12.7 mm), the total reduction in thickness after rolling 3. Results and discussion
was w92%.
To evaluate the microstructures of the alloys, transverse sections Backscattered electron images of the cast and homogenized
were cut by electric discharge machining (EDM) from the homog- microstructures are shown in Fig. 1 (a) and (b). Both alloys are
enized bars and hot-rolled sheets. The sections were mounted in essentially single-phase; however, HE-1 contains isolated dark
epoxy, ground through 600 grit SiC paper, and polished using particles that are not present in the HE-4 alloy. Energy dispersive X-
Vibromet machines, rst with 0.3 mm Al2O3 and then in a suspen- ray spectroscopy was performed on these particles. Oxygen, chro-
sion of colloidal silica having a particle size of 60 nm. The polished mium and manganese peaks were detected, which leads to the
samples were examined in an XL30 FEG scanning electron micro- conclusion that the particles are oxides. Since they were absent in
scope (SEM) in the backscattered electron mode. Specimens from the Mn-free HE-4 alloy, the oxygen contamination is likely associ-
the homogenized bars were also used to (a) obtain x-ray diffraction ated with the Mn, but whether it was introduced through the raw
Fig. 1. Backscattered electron images of (a) CrMnFeCoNi (HE-1), (b) CrFeCoNi (HE-4) after casting and homogenization, and (c) CrMnFeCoNi (HE-1), (d) CrFeCoNi (HE-4) after hot
rolling.
76 A. Gali, E.P. George / Intermetallics 39 (2013) 74e78
materials or during one of the subsequent processing steps is not similar behavior over the ranges investigated: strong temperature
known. Regardless, because of their tiny volume fraction, they did dependence and weak strain-rate dependence. The temperature
not signicantly inuence mechanical properties as shown below. dependence is strongest at low and high temperatures with a
X-ray diffraction patterns were obtained from the two alloys in smaller slope in between. Both alloys exhibit somewhat higher
the homogenized condition. All the peaks could be indexed as FCC. strengths at the higher strain rate, especially at temperatures below
There were no peaks corresponding to the oxide particles in HE-1, w600 C. At intermediate temperatures, the slope is less steep at
consistent with their low volume fraction. The melting point the slower strain rate, but in neither case does yielding appear to be
ranges, as determined by differential scanning calorimetry, were truly athermal, although additional experiments at intermediate
determined to be 1280e1349 C and 1422e1462 C, for the HE-1 temperatures are warranted to obtain better statistics. The larger
and HE-4 alloys, respectively, indicating that the addition of Mn grain size of HE-1 relative to HE-4 (35 vs. 14 mm) appears not to
to the quaternary depresses the melting point and increases the have a signicant effect.
gap between the solidus and liquidus. The above temperature dependence of yield strength is not
Fig. 1 (c) and (d) show the microstructures of the two alloys after usually observed in pure FCC metals; however, it is known to occur
hot rolling. The microstructures are fully recrystallized indicating in binary solid-solution alloys [22e29]. In pure FCC metals, the
that dynamic recrystallization occurred during the hot rolling. athermal portion of the yield stress versus temperature curve is
Grain sizes of the roughly equiaxed grains were measured using the large compared to the thermal part, unlike in BCC metals where the
linear intercept method on a plane perpendicular to the rolling opposite is the case. Since the athermal region is where thermal
direction in the through-thickness (short-transverse) direction and activation can overcome barriers to dislocation motion, these bar-
found to be approximately 32 mm and 11 mm for the HE-1 and HE-4 riers are believed to be weak in pure FCC metals and easily over-
alloys, respectively. The larger grain size of the HE-1 alloy may be at come by thermal uctuations even at cryogenic temperatures.
least partly due to the higher homologous temperature (w0.81 Tm) Solute atoms can increase signicantly the thermal part of the yield
at which it was hot rolled compared to the HE-4 alloy (w0.75 Tm). stress, as seen in Fig. 2 for the quinary and quaternary alloys, and
Grain sizes were also measured after the rolled sheets were reported earlier for binary FCC alloys. Thus, solute atoms introduce
annealed for 1 h at temperatures of 600e1000 C. No change in obstacles to dislocation motion that are not as easily overcome by
grain size was observed up to 800 C; only at temperatures of thermal activation. However, the nature and strength of these ob-
900 C and higher was grain growth observed. These results are stacles may be different in relatively dilute binaries compared to
consistent with the notion that the alloys recrystallized during the the equiatomic quinary/quaternary alloys investigated here. In bi-
hot rolling operation. To relieve any residual stresses in the rolled nary FCC alloys, the transition between the thermal and athermal
sheets, they were annealed for 1 h at 900 C prior to tensile testing. regions often occurs at relatively low temperatures, e.g., at around
The grain sizes after this stress-relief heat treatment were room temperature in CueZn binaries [23], which implies barrier
approximately 35 and 14 mm for the HE-1 and HE-4 alloys, strengths on the order of kT at room temperature, namely, 0.025 eV.
respectively (slightly larger than in the as-rolled state, 32 and By contrast, the thermal regions in Fig. 2 extend to signicantly
11 mm). higher temperatures, implying the presence of relatively strong
Numerous annealing twins are visible in both alloys after obstacles in our HE-1 and HE-4 alloys. Some of this difference may
recrystallization [Fig. 1 (c) and (d)]. Since annealing twins are be due to the shorter distance between atoms of different kinds in
commonly found in recrystallized FCC metals and solid solution multi-element equiatomic alloys compared to more dilute solid
alloys with relatively low stacking fault energies [21], it is reason- solutions. That is, as dislocations move in the HE-1 and HE-4 alloys,
able to conclude that our HE-1 and HE-4 alloys have low stacking they encounter obstacles over lengths scales that are fractions of a
fault energies. unit cell in dimension (as opposed to distances of a few unit cells in
Fig. 2 (a) and (b) show the temperature dependencies of the 0.2% more dilute alloys). In addition, the disparate alloying elements in
offset yield strengths of HE-1 and HE-4 tensile tested at strain rates HE-1 and HE-4, although they are substitutional in nature, could
of 103 and 101 s1, respectively. The two alloys show broadly possibly introduce tetragonal distortions that offer more resistance
Fig. 2. Temperature dependencies of the 0.2% offset yield strengths of the CrMnFeCoNi (HE-1) and CrFeCoNi (HE-4) alloys tensile tested at engineering strain rates of 103 s1 (a),
and 101 s1 (b).
A. Gali, E.P. George / Intermetallics 39 (2013) 74e78 77
Fig. 4. (a) Temperature dependence of the tensile ductilities of CrMnFeCoNi (HE-1) and CrFeCoNi (HE-4) tested at an engineering strain rate of 103 s1. Also shown are fractographs
of specimens tested at 196 C (b, c) and 400 C (d, e). The dashed outlines of the fracture surfaces show that there is less thickness reduction (necking) at 196 C (b) than at
400 C (e).
78 A. Gali, E.P. George / Intermetallics 39 (2013) 74e78
4. Summary and conclusions [6] Tong CJ, Chen MR, Chen SK, Yeh JW, Shun TT, Tsau CH, et al. Mechanical
performance of the AlxCoCrCuFeNi high-entropy alloy system with multi-
principal elements. Metall Mater Trans A 2005;36:1263e71.
Two equiatomic, multi-element alloys were produced by arc [7] Yeh JW, Chen YL, Lin SJ, Chen SK. High-entropy alloys e a new era of
melting and hot rolling. The rst was a high-entropy quinary alloy, exploitation. Mater Sci Forum 2007;560:1e9.
CrMnFeCoNi, and the second a medium-entropy quaternary alloy, [8] Zhou YJ, Zhang Y, Wang YL, Chen GL. Solid solution alloys of AlCoCrFeNiTix
with excellent room-temperature mechanical properties. Appl Phys Lett
CrFeCoNi. Both alloys had FCC crystal structures and were essen- 2007;90:181904.
tially single-phase with fully recrystallized microstructures and [9] Wang XF, Zhang Y, Qiao Y, Chen GL. Novel microstructure and properties of
equiaxed grains containing numerous annealing twins suggestive multicomponent CoCrCuFeNiTix alloys. Intermetallics 2007;15:357e62.
[10] Wang FJ, Zhang Y. Effect of Co addition on crystal structure and mechanical
of low stacking fault energies. Their tensile behavior was studied properties of Ti0.5CrFeNiAlCo high entropy alloy. Mater Sci Eng A 2008;496:
at temperatures in the range 196 C to 1000 C and at strain rates 214e6.
of 103 and 101 s1. Both alloys exhibited a strong temperature [11] Shun TT, Hung CH, Lee CF. Formation of ordered/disordered nanoparticles in
FCC high entropy alloys. J Alloys Compd 2010;493:105e9.
dependence of strength and weak strain-rate dependence. Tem- [12] Zhu JM, Fu HM, Zhang HF, Wang AM, Li H, Hu ZQ. Synthesis and properties of
perature dependent strength is not usually seen in pure FCC multiprincipal component AlCoCrFeNiSix alloys. Mater Sci Eng A 2010;527:
metals but has been observed in several binary FCC solid solution 7210e4.
[13] Senkov ON, Wilks GB, Scott JM, Miracle DB. Mechanical properties of
alloys. What appears to be different in the present FCC high- Nb25Mo25Ta25W25 and V20Nb20Mo20Ta20W20 refractory high entropy alloys.
entropy alloys is that the thermal part of the yield stress versus Intermetallics 2011;19:698e706.
temperature curves extends to relatively high temperatures [14] Senkov ON, Scott JM, Senkova SV, Miracle DB, Woodward CF. Microstructure
and room temperature properties of a high-entropy TaNbHfZrTi alloy. J Alloys
whereas, in FCC binaries, the transition from thermal to athermal
Compd 2011;509:6043e8.
behavior usually occurs at relatively low temperatures. These re- [15] Singh S, Wanderka N, Murty BS, Glatzel U, Banhart J. Decomposition in multi-
sults imply that there may be stronger obstacles to dislocation component AlCoCrCuFeNi high-entropy alloy. Acta Mater 2011;59:182e90.
motion in high-entropy alloys. However, further investigations are [16] Lucas MS, Mauger L, Munoz JA, Xiao Y, Sheets AO, Semiatin SL, et al. Magnetic
and vibrational properties of high-entropy alloys. J Appl Phys 2011;109:
needed to understand the precise nature and distribution of these 07E307.
obstacles in the various alloys. The ductilities of both HE-1 and [17] Lucas MS, Wilks GB, Mauger L, Munoz JA, Senkov ON, Michel E, et al. Absence
HE-4, instead of showing the typical inverse dependence on of long-range chemical ordering in equimolar FeCoCrNi. Appl Phys Lett
2012;100:251907.
strength, increased in tandem with strength as the test tempera- [18] Ng C, Guo S, Luan J, Shi S, Liu CT. Entropy-driven phase stability and slow
ture decreased from room temperature down to liquid nitrogen diffusion kinetics in an Al0.5CoCrCuFeNi high entropy alloy. Intermetallics
temperature: as the yield strengths doubled the elongations to 2012;31:165e72.
[19] Otto F, Yang Y, Bei H, George EP. Relative effects of enthalpy and entropy on
fracture increased by a factor of 1.5 to values in excess of 60%. the phase stability of equiatomic high-entropy alloys. Acta Mater 2013;61:
There was a high degree of work hardening evident at low tem- 2628e38.
peratures, possibly due to deformation-induced nanoscale twin- [20] Liu WH, Wu Y, He JY, Nieh TG, Lu ZP. Grain growth and Hall-Petch relationship
in a high-entropy FeCrNiCoMn alloy. Scripta Mater 2013;68:526e9.
ning. This likely postponed the onset of necking to higher strains [21] Carpenter HCH, Tamura S. Proc Roy Soc A 1926;113:161.
and enhanced the ductility. [22] Koppenaal TJ, Fine ME. Solid solution strengthening in alpha Cu-Al single
crystals. Trans Metall Soc AIME 1962;224:347e53.
[23] Mitchell TE. Dislocations and plasticity in single crystals of face centered cubic
Acknowledgments metals and alloys. In: Stanford EG, et al., editors. Progress in applied materials
research, vol. 6. London: Heywood and Co.; 1964. p. 119.
This research was supported by the U. S. Department of Energy, [24] Wigley DA. Mechanical properties of materials at low temperatures. New
York: Plenum Press; 1971.
Ofce of Basic Energy Sciences, Materials Sciences and Engineering [25] Basinski ZS, Foxall RA, Pascual R. Stress equivalence of solution hardening.
Division. Scripta Mater 1972;6:807.
[26] Butt MZ, Feltham P. Solid-solution hardening. Acta Metall 1978;26:167e73.
[27] Traub H, Neuhuser H. Ch. Schwink, Investigations of yield region of
References concentrated CueGe and CueZn single crystals. 1. Critical resolved shear-
stress, slip line formation and true strain rate. Acta Metall 1977;25:437e46.
[1] Yeh JW, Chen SK, Lin SJ, Gan JY, Chin TS, Shun TT, et al. Nanostructured high- [28] Wille Th, Schwink Ch. Precision measurements of critical resolved shear-
entropy alloys with multiple principal elements: novel alloy design concepts stress in CuMn alloys. Acta Metall 1986;34:1059e69.
and outcomes. Adv Eng Mater 2004;6:299e303. [29] Wille Th, Gieseke W, Schwink Ch. Quantitative analysis of solution hardening
[2] Cantor B, Chang ITH, Knight P, Vincent AJB. Microstructural development in in selected copper alloys. Acta Metall 1987;35:2679e93.
equiatomic multicomponent alloys. Mater Sci Eng A 2004;375-377:213e8. [30] Fleischer RL, Hibbard WR. Solution hardening, in the relation between
[3] Yeh JW, Chen SK, Gan JY, Lin SJ, Chin TS, Shun TT, et al. Formation of simple structure and mechanical properties of metals. In: Proc. Conf. Held at the
crystal structures in CueCoeNieCreAleFeeTieV allaoys with multiprincipal national physical laboratory, vol. 1. Middlesex: Teddington; 7e9 January
metallic elements. Metall Mater Trans A 2004;35:2533e6. 1963. p. 261.
[4] Huang PK, Yeh JW, Shun TT, Chen SK. Multi-principal-element alloys with [31] Otto F, Dlouhy A, Somsen Ch, Bei H, Eggeler G, George EP. Unpublished results.
improved oxidation and wear resistance for thermal spray coating. Adv Eng 2013.
Mater 2004;6:74e8. [32] Thornton PR, Mitchell TE. Deformation twinning in alloys at low tempera-
[5] Tong CJ, Chen YL, Chen SK, Yeh JW, Shun TT, Tsau CH, et al. Microstructure tures. Philos Mag 1962;7:361.
characterization of AlxCoCrCuFeNi high-entropy alloy system with multi- [33] Venables JA. Reed-Hill RE, Hirth JA, Rogers HC, editors. Deformation twinning.
principal elements. Metall Mater Trans A 2005;36:881e93. New York: Gordon Breach; 1963.