The Use of Bubble CPAP in Premature Infants
The Use of Bubble CPAP in Premature Infants
KM CHAN, HB CHAN
Abstract Bubble continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) was introduced more than 30 years ago for infants
with respiratory distress. With this, there had been reports of decreased incidence of mechanical ventilation
and chronic lung disease among the premature, as well as less failure of extubation. This report described
how this treatment modality was adopted locally and showed it might be associated with less apnoea
among very low birth weight (VLBW) and extremely low birth weight (ELBW) infants post extubation
with improved non-pulmonary outcomes.
Key words Apnoea of prematurity; Bubble CPAP; Chronic lung Disease; ELBW babies; VLBW babies
interface connecting the infant's airway with the circuit without leakage, it results in continuous bubbling and
(Figure 1). As the gas leaves the circuit via the expiratory the pressure oscillates in the circuit. 9 Leakage is not
limb, it bubbles (Figure 2). obvious in ventilator (Infant Star) CPAP. Though the
Oxygen blender connected to wall oxygen and pressure oscillation was once suggested to facilitate gas
compressed air supply is used for supplying appropriate exchange,10 this postulation was not supported in another
concentration of inspired oxygen. Optimal gas flow is recent report.11
maintained with a flow meter to prevent rebreathing of Short binasal prongs are commonly used for the nasal
carbon dioxide, increased work of breathing related to interface between the circuit and the infant's airway as they
insufficient flow available for inspiration and to compensate are found to have the lowest resistance12 and their use has
for leakage in the CPAP system.7,8 Flow rate of 5 to 10 been supported by a meta-analysis as the better device for
liters per minute is optimal for CPAP delivery in the delivery of effective CPAP.13 Choosing the right prong and
neonates.8 keeping it in place not only increase the effectiveness of
Pressure in the bubble CPAP system is created by placing CPAP support but can also prevent nasal trauma. The
the distal expiratory tubing in water. Designated pressure resistance increases proportionately with increasing length
is determined by the length of expiratory limb being of the prongs and exponentially with decreasing radius.
immersed.8 When the pressure is delivered to the baby Shorter and wider binasal prongs that can fit snugly in the
nares without causing blanching of the skin is a good option.
Hudson (The Hudson RCI infant nasal CPAP cannula
system, Teleflex Incorporated, USA) and Inca (Ackrad
Laboratories, Cranford, N.J., USA) prongs are similar in
design. Similar sized prongs (actual measured size, not
nominal size as designated by the manufacturer) of either
type are likely to have similar resistance. Inca prongs are
straight, whereas Hudson prongs are anatomically curved.
Theoretically, the latter might fit the airway better, directing
the flow more appropriately down the airway.
(e.g. Airlife , Allegiance Healthcare Corp., USA) and October, 2000 and end of March, 2002 (Period 1) were
servo-regulated humidification system is necessary for compared with those born between October, 2002 and end
the delivery of warm and humidified inspired gas to the of March, 2004 (Period 2). Babies with major congenital
CPAP supported infant. 18 "Rain-out" (condensation) anomalies such as cranio-facial cleft or requiring transfer
affects the gas flow and resistance. It should be checked to other centres for various reasons were excluded.
and drained regularly. The probe and chamber This study aimed to evaluate the following respiratory
temperature and the positioning of the temperature probe outcomes after the change:
can be manipulated to minimise the "rain-out". 1. duration of mechanical ventilatory support
Consistent bubbling is important to recruit alveoli, 2. number of infants who required mechanical ventilation
maintain functional residual capacity, and reduce airway within 24 hours after extubation (failed extubation)
resistance and work of breathing, especially in the early 3. duration of CPAP support
acute phase of respiratory distress. If the bubbling stops 4. number of days with significant apnoea (cessation of
it means that there is a pressure leak in the system, respiration 15 seconds with SaO2 <50% and associated
usually around the nostrils. It has been reported that the with bradycardia, heart rate <100 beats per minute)
pharyngeal pressure drops markedly when the CPAP during CPAP
supported infant opens his mouth. 19 Recent study 5. duration of oxygen therapy
demonstrated that the prong pressure, though not totally 6. the postmenstrual age (PMA) of the infants when
transmitted to the pharynx, was more effectively oxygen therapy was terminated
transmitted when the mouth was closed.20 The use of chin 7. number of infants requiring FiO2 >30% at PMA of 36
strap or pacifier has been recommended to reduce mouth weeks.
leak for effective CPAP support. 20 However, it should
not be so tight as to prevent the infant from yawning or The non-respiratory outcomes were also reviewed which
crying but tight enough to prevent leaking at rest. included:
The infant's respiratory status has to be assessed at 1. duration on total parenteral nutrition (TPN)
regular interval to evaluate effectiveness of the treatment 2. postnatal age of the infants when full enteral feeding
and plan for subsequent care. CPAP has to be temporarily was tolerated
interrupted during chest auscultation as the bubbling sound 3. number of infants with necrotising enterocolitis (NEC)
may interfere. However, caution has to be taken as the infant 4. number of infants with grade 3 to 4 intraventricular
may present with apnoea and bradycardia when CPAP hemorrhage (IVH)
support is suspended for just a brief period. 5. body weight at PMA of 36 weeks
Gastric distension is common in the CPAP supported
infant (CPAP Belly Syndrome).21 Frequent decompression During both study periods, there was no major change
of the stomach with an oro-gastric tube is necessary to in technology and medical management of the premature
promote comfort, preventing the distended stomach from infant in the unit. The only difference was the use of bubble
splinting the diaphragm and compromising respiration. CPAP in Period 2 which substituted for the ventilator (Infant
The bubble CPAP system and practice of the Columbia Star, Tyco Healthcare) CPAP support in Period 1. All of
University were introduced to the Neonatal Intensive Care the study population except 6 very low birth weight
Unit of United Christian Hospital, Hong Kong in October, (VLBW) infants, 3 in each period, required intubation. They
2002. A retrospective survey with historic control was were extubated and maintained on CPAP when their
carried out after the change to evaluate the effects of bubble synchronised intermittent ventilator (SIMV) settings were
CPAP on the respiratory and non-respiratory outcomes in <10 breaths per minute, peak inspiratory pressure (PIP) was
premature infants in the unit. <15 cmH2O, positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) was
5 cmH2O, fractional inspired oxygen (FiO2) was <0.3 with
no respiratory acidosis and minimal respiratory distress.
Patients and Methods Apnoea, cessation of respiration for 15 seconds or more
with or without desaturation (SaO2 <90%), and cardio-
The short term outcome of CPAP supported premature respiratory status of the subjects were monitored
infants who were delivered in United Christian Hospital continuously with physiological monitors (Spacelab
with birth weight less than 1499 gram born between Healthcare). During the study periods, caffeine citrate was
Chan and Chan 89
given to infants with repeated apnoea (i.e., more than three groups of premature infants between the two study periods
apnoea episodes per hour) with SaO2 <50% or they required (Table 1). Around 85% of the VLBW infants and all of the
frequent bag and mask ventilation. Reintubation was ELBW infants were initially intubated in both study periods.
considered when infants on CPAP developed marked The infants in Period 2 were extubated to bubble CPAP
retraction, FiO2 requirement >0.6 with PaO2 <50 mmHg, and those in Period 1 were given ventilator (Infant Star)
PaCO2 >65 mmHg with intractable metabolic acidosis, nasal CPAP post extubation.
prolonged apnoea with SaO2 <50% and required bag and In the VLBW group, there was no difference in duration
mask ventilation, frequent apnoea not responsive to drug of mechanical ventilatory support or extubation failure in
therapy or at the discretion of the attending clinician both study periods. Though the duration of CPAP was
depending on the infant's clinical status. Infants without significantly shorter in babies in Period 1, the number of
significant retractions would be weaned off from CPAP days with significant apnoea during bubble CPAP was
when their FiO2 requirement <0.3, free from apnoea for 24 significantly less (Table 2). There was no difference in
hours and tolerated gentle nasal-pharyngeal suctioning duration of oxygen support in both periods and the infants
without increasing FiO2 requirement with CPAP removed. were weaned off oxygen at the mean PMA of 35 weeks.
Two babies, one with cranio-facial cleft in Period 1 and Around 20% of the VLBW infants required oxygen support
one baby required interhospital transfer in Period 2 were greater than 30% at PMA of 36 weeks. However, all of
excluded in the study. A total of 80 infants were analysed them survived and could successfully wean off oxygen
and they were further stratified into the very low birth therapy before PMA of 40 weeks.
weight (VLBW) group with birth weight between 1000 Similar results were obtained in the ELBW group (Table
gram to 1499 gram and the extremely low birth weight 3). There was no significant difference in failed extubation
(ELBW) group with birth weight less than 1000 gram. The and duration for mechanical ventilation. Again, there was a
outcomes of 45 VLBW and 35 ELBW premature infants significantly longer duration of CPAP support in Period 2.
were reviewed. Results were analysed by the independent The number of days with significant apnoea during bubble
sample t-test for normally distributed continuous variables, CPAP was significantly less during Period 2. There was no
Chi Square analysis for dichotomous variables and difference in duration of oxygen support in both periods
Mann-Whitney U-test for non-parametric data at the 5% and the neonates were weaned off oxygen at the mean PMA
significance level. of 39 weeks. Thirty percent of ELBW infants in both study
periods require oxygen therapy greater than 30% at PMA
of 36 weeks. The majority of them could be weaned off
Results oxygen successfully at PMA of 44 weeks. The longest
duration of oxygen therapy in ELBW in Period 1 and 2 were
There was no difference in the characteristics of both PMA of 64 weeks and PMA of 54 weeks respectively.
The non-respiratory outcome of both groups of enteral feeding as measured by gastric residue less than
premature infants was similar (Tables 4 & 5). As soon as half of the feeding volume with no vomiting or gastric
the infants were medically stable, trophic feeding was distention, total enteral feeding was gradually advanced by
instituted. In both study periods, when the infants tolerated 10 ml to 20 ml/kg/day. Both groups of infants who were
on bubble CPAP had shorter duration of TPN support and A recently published retrospective case-control study
they could tolerate full enteral feeding sooner. Most from the Netherlands also suggested that a trial of early
important of all, there was no increase in incidence of IVH. nasal CPAP, using nasopharyngeal tube or the Infant Flow
No baby on bubble CPAP suffered from NEC. These were system, at birth might reduce the incidence of moderate to
consistent with the findings reported in 2001 at New severe CLD and did not seem to be detrimental in very
Zealand.22 preterm infant. Thirty-three percent of the very preterm
No infant had any injury or trauma to the nose. No infants (25-32 weeks) were successfully managed with
significant airleak was encountered in both study periods. CPAP alone.24 Whether bubble CPAP in the delivery room
management of the premature babies will demonstrate
differences in chronic lung disease or death at 36 weeks
Discussion adjusted age may be addressed in multi-centers randomised
trials such as the one by the Vermont Oxford Network.
When bubble CPAP was used after extubation in our With our experience, we conclude that there was no
unit in Period 2, the neonates had significantly less number increase in adverse respiratory outcome in the unit after
of days with significant apnoea, although they were on the change from ventilator CPAP to bubble CPAP. Bubble
CPAP for longer duration. There was no significant CPAP is safe to use and it appeared to be associated with
difference in other respiratory outcomes in the VLBW and less apnoea and more favorable non-respiratory outcome.
ELBW babies in the two time periods. The bubble CPAP However, because of the small sample size, a larger scale
supported premature infants achieved full enteral feeding prospective study is warranted to determine the long term
earlier, thus the duration for TPN was significantly reduced. benefits.
This might be related to the decrease in significant apnoea,
which is a sign of medical instability for which the attending
clinician might be more cautious in increasing the amount References
of enteral feeding. Nevertheless, we are aware that the small
sample size and the retrospective nature of this case-control 1. Gregory GA, Kitterman JA, Phibbs RH, Tooley WH, Hamilton
study impose important limitation. WK. Treatment of the idiopathic respiratory-distress syndrome
with continuous positive airway pressure. N Engl J Med 1971;
In 2000, Van Marter23 observed marked differences in
284:1333-40.
the incidence of CLD at Columbia University (4%) vs that 2. Ho JJ, Subramaniam P, Henderson-Smart DJ, Davis PG.
at two Boston hospitals (22%). With bubble CPAP, Continuous distending pressure for respiratory distress syndrome
newborns at Columbia University were less likely to require in preterm infants. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2002;(2):
mechanical ventilation, and those who did were ventilated CD002271.
3. Davis PG, Henderson-Smart DJ. Nasal continuous positive
for significantly shorter time. There were no differences in airways pressure immediately after extubation for preventing
short-term morbidities such as periventricular leukomalacia morbidity in preterm infants. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2003;
(PVL) and IVH between centres. (2):CD000143.
De Klerk AM and de Klerk RK published another 4. Halamek LP, Morley C. Continuous positive airway pressure
during neonatal resuscitation. Clin Perinatol 2006;33:83-98, vii.
retrospective study in 2001 suggesting that the use of a 5. Avery ME, Tooley WH, Keller JB, et al. Is chronic lung disease
CPAP based approach to respiratory support of the preterm in low birth weight infants preventable? A survey of eight centers.
infant resulted in a shorter and less invasive respiratory Pediatrics 1987;79:26-30.
course, less chronic lung disease at 28 days and no increase 6. Aly HZ. Nasal prongs continuous positive airway pressure:
a simple yet powerful tool. Pediatrics 2001;108:759-61.
in non-respiratory morbidities, such as the NEC, grade 3-4 7. De Paoli AG, Morley C, Davis PG. Nasal CPAP for neonates:
IVH, PVL and stage 3 or worse retinopathy of prematurity what do we know in 2003? Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed
(ROP) in infants of 1000-1499 g birthweight.22 2003;88:F168-72.
More than 85% of our VLBW and 100% of our ELBW 8. Polin RA, Sahni R. Newer experience with CPAP. Semin
Neonatol 2002;7:379-89.
babies were intubated early whereas Columbia University
9. Morley C. Continuous distending pressure. Arch Dis Child Fetal
places all spontaneously breathing infants on bubble CPAP Neonatal Ed 1999;81:F152-6.
as the first mode of respiratory support. The early initiation 10. Lee KS, Dunn MS, Fenwick M, Shennan AT. A comparison of
of bubble CPAP, in combination with a tolerance to higher underwater bubble continuous positive airway pressure with
ventilator-derived continuous positive airway pressure in
PCO2 level might be associated with a lower incidence of
premature neonates ready for extubation. Biol Neonate 1998;
CLD to <5% in babies <1500 g there.8 73:69-75.
92 Use of Bubble CPAP in Premature Infants
11. Morley CJ, Lau R, De Paoli A, Davis PG. Nasal continuous 18. AARC (American Association for Respiratory Care). Application
positive airway pressure: does bubbling improve gas exchange? of continuous positive airway pressure to neonates via nasal
Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed 2005;90:F343-4. prongs or nasopharyngeal tube. Respir Care 1994;39:817-23.
12. De Paoli AG, Morley CJ, Davis PG, Lau R, Hingeley E. In vitro 19. Chilton HW, Brooks JG. Pharyngeal pressures in nasal CPAP.
comparison of nasal continuous positive airway pressure devices J Pediatr 1979;94:808-10.
for neonates. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed 2002;87:F42-5. 20. De Paoli AG, Lau R, Davis PG, Morley CJ. Pharyngeal pressure
13. De Paoli AG, Davis PG, Faber B, Morley CJ. Devices and in preterm infants receiving nasal continuous positive airway
pressure sources for administration of nasal continuous positive pressure. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed 2005;90:F79-81.
airway pressure (NCPAP) in preterm neonates. Cochrane 21. Jaile JC, Levin T, Wung JT, Abramson SJ, Ruzal-Shapiro C,
Database Syst Rev 2002;(4):CD002977. Berdon WE. Benign gaseous distension of the bowel in
14. Rego MA, Martinez FE. Comparison of two nasal prongs for premature infants treated with nasal continuous airway
application of continuous positive airway pressure in neonates. pressure: a study of contributing factors. AJR Am J
Pediatr Crit Care Med 2002;3:239-43. Roentgenol 1992;158:125-7.
15. Loftus BC, Ahn J, Haddad J Jr. Neonatal nasal deformities 22. De Klerk AM, De Klerk RK. Nasal continuous positive airway
secondary to nasal continuous positive airway pressure. pressure and outcomes of preterm infants. J Paediatr Child Health
Laryngoscope 1994;104(8 Pt 1):1019-22. 2001;37:161-7.
16. Robertson NJ, McCarthy LS, Hamilton PA, Moss AL. Nasal 23. Van Marter LJ, Allred EN, Pagano M, et al. Do clinical markers
deformities resulting from flow driver continuous positive of barotrauma and oxygen toxicity explain interhospital variation
airway pressure. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed 1996;75: in rates of chronic lung disease? The Neonatology Committee
F209-12. for the Developmental Network. Pediatrics 2000;105:1194-
17. Yong SC, Chen SJ, Boo NY. Incidence of nasal trauma associated 201.
with nasal prong versus nasal mask during continuous positive 24. Te Pas AB, Lopriore E, Engbers MJ, Walther FJ. Early respiratory
airway pressure treatment in very low birthweight infants: a management of respiratory distress syndrome in very preterm
randomised control study. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed infants and bronchopulmonary dysplasia: a case-control study.
2005;90:F480-3. PLoS ONE 2007;2:e192.