Casting Alloys: V.Nivedha
Casting Alloys: V.Nivedha
V.NIVEDHA
HISTORY
INTRODUCTION
PROPERTIES OF CASTING ALLOYS
CLASSIFICATION
ALL METAL RESTORATIONS
TYPES
GOLD ALLOYS
SILVER-PALLADIUM
ALUMINIUM BRONZE
METAL CERAMIC ALLOYS
EVOLUTION
CLASSIFICATION
NOBLE ALLOYS
BASE METALS
TITANIUM
COBALT CHROMIUM
GOLD ALTERNATIVE
1907 – The Lost – Wax Process → Taggart and noble metals were used
Base metal removable partial denture alloys were introduced in the 1930.The
advantages of the base metal alloys are their lighter weight, greater stiffness, other
beneficial mechanical properties, and reduced costs.
In 1932, the dental materials group at the National Bureau of standards surveyed
the alloys being used and classified them as Type I (Soft , VHN between 50 and
90) Type II (Medium VHN between 90 and 120) Type III (Hard VHN between 120
and 150) Type IV (Extra hard, VHN ≥ 150) ANSI/ADA Specification no.5 ISO
standard 15592.
Base metal alloys with nickel as the major element eliminated the exclusive need
for noble metals.
The only nearly pure metal cast for dental applications is commercially pure
titanium
ALLOY: is defined as a metal containing two or more metals ,at least
one of which is a metal and all of which are mutually soluble in a molten state
Biocompatibility: The alloy should not react with the oral fluids and
release any harmful products in oral environment.
Alloys with the lower the solidus temperature is preferred as the lower
shrinkage occurs during cooling.
Hardness: The hardness of an alloy should be sufficient enough to
resist wear by the opposing tooth or restoration.
At the same time, it should not be high enough to cause wear of the opposing
enamel (VHN of enamel is 340 kg/mm²).
Hardness of an alloy should not be less than 125 kg/mm² or greater than 340
kg/mm²
Palladium-silver-tin
Nickel-chromium-molybdenum
Cobalt-chromium-molybdenum
Iron-nickel-chromium
Titanium-aluminum-vanadium
Ternary-three elements
Quaternary (and so forth)-four elements
These alloys were among the earliest alloys available to dentistry.
The early alloys were mostly gold alloys. Since they were intended for all
metallic and later for resin veneered restorations, they just had to meet the
basic requirements. No special requirements are needed for veneering with
resin.
Karat
It refers to the parts of pure gold present
in 24 parts of alloy Eg: 24- karat gold is
22 parts pure gold and 2 parts of other metal
Fineness
Fineness of a gold alloy is the parts per thousand of pure gold. Pure gold is
1000 fine. Thus, if 3/4 of the gold alloy is pure gold, it is said to be 750 fine.
Pure gold is a soft and ductile metal and so is not used for casting dental
restorations and appliances.
Dental casting golds are alloyed commonly with copper, silver, platinum,
nickel and zinc.
Alloying gold with these metals not only improves its physical and
mechanical properties but also reduces its cost.
COPPER:
It is the principal hardener. It reduces the melting point and density of
gold. If present in sufficient quantity, it gives the alloy a reddish color.
It also helps to age harden gold alloys. In greater amounts it reduces
resistance to tarnish and corrosion of the gold alloy. Therefore, the maximum
content should not exceed 16 percent
SILVER:
It whitens the alloy, thus helping to counteract the reddish color of copper.
It increases strength and hardness slightly.
In large amount, however, it reduces tarnish resistance
PLATINUM:
It increases strength and corrosion resistance. It also increases melting
point and has a whitening effect on the alloy. It helps to reduce the grain
size
PALLADIUM:
Similar to platinum in its effect. It hardens and whitens the alloy. It also
raises fusion temperature and provides tarnish resistance. It is less expensive
than platinum, thus,reducing the cost of the alloy
ZINC:
It acts as a scavenger for oxygen. Without zinc, the silver in the alloy
causes absorption of oxygen during melting. Later during solidification,
the oxygen is rejected producing gas porosities in the casting
INDIUM,TIN,IRON:
They help to decrease the grain size. They are added in small quantities
MELTING RANGE:
Ranges between 920 to 960°C. The melting range of an alloy is important. It
indicates the type of investment required and the type of heating source needed to
melt the alloy
DENSITY:
It gives an indication of the number of dental castings that can be made
from a unit weight of the metal. In other words, more number of cast
restorations per unit weight can be made from an alloy having a lower density,
than one having a higher density. Gold alloys are lighter than pure gold
HARDNESS:
The hardness indicates the ease with which these alloys can be cut, ground
or polished.
Gold alloys are generally more user friendly than the base metal alloys
which are extremely hard
ELONGATION:
It indicates the ductility of the alloy. A reasonable amount is required
especially if the alloy is to be deformed during clinical use, e.g. clasp
adjustment for removable partial dentures, margin adjustment and
burnishing of crowns and inlays.
Modulus of Elasticity: This indicates the stiffness/flexibility of the metal.
Gold alloys are more flexible than base metal alloys
Indications
It is indicated for appliances that are to be ground, shaped or otherwise
cold worked in or outside the mouth
Indications
For strengthening metallic
dentures, saddles, bridges,
and other similar structures
before use in the mouth.
It is not employed for smaller
structures such as inlays
It is done by "soaking" or ageing the casting at a specific temperature for
a definite time, usually 15 to 30 minutes. It is then water quenched or cooled
slowly. The ageing temperature depends on the alloy composition but is
generally between 200C and 450°C.
In India, because of their relatively low cost many of the laboratories use
these alloys along with resin facings. These metals are very strong and
hard. Because of this they are generally difficult to work with (cutting,
grinding, polishing, etc)
Though these metals can be used for all-metal and metal ceramic
restorations, as well as partial dentures.
Bronze is an alloy known to man since ancient times. Traditional bronze is
copper alloyed with tin.
The composition is as follows
Copper (81 to 88%) ,
Aluminum (8 to 10%
Nickel ( 2 to 4%)
Iron ( 1 to 4%)
Being relatively new, the information on these alloys is relatively scanty
Metal ceramic alloys are those alloys that are compatible with porcelain and
capable of bonding to it.
A layer of porcelain is fused to the alloy to give it a natural tooth- like
appearance. Porcelain being a brittle material fractures easily, so these alloys
are used to reinforce the porcelain
Several types of alloys are used to cast sub- structures for porcelain fused to
metal crowns and bridges.
They may be noble metal alloys or base metal alloys . All have coefficient
of thermal expansion (CTE) values which match that of porcelain. Note CTE
has a reciprocal relationship with melting point, i.e. the higher the melting
point of a metal, lower is its CTE
The metal-ceramic alloys evolved from resin-veneered crown and bridge alloys.
Resin facing faced the problem of gradual wear and had to be replaced over time.
Besides resin could not be used on the occlusal surface. To retain a resin veneered
restoration undercuts had to be provided.
The early metal-ceramic alloys were high gold alloys (88% gold). They were
not strong enough for use in bridges. In those early days before porcelain-metal
bonding was clearly understood, porcelain had to be retained by mechanical
means with the help of undercuts.
Later, it was discovered that adding 1% of base metals like iron, tin, indium,
etc. induced chemical bonding by the formation of an oxide layer. This
significantly improved the bond strength between the porcelain and the metal
It's melting temperature should be higher than the porcelain firing
temperature
Density
ranges from 13.5 to 18.3 gm/cm- (depending on the gold content). Because of
the high gold and noble metal content, these alloys have a high density. The
density reduces as more palladium is added
Castability: the high density of these alloys make them easy to cast.
If done well one can expect most of the fine features to be accurately
duplicated
Yield strength ranges from 450 to 572 MPa.
Hardness and workability ranges from 182 to 220 VHN. These
alloys are relatively softer when compared to the base metal alloys and so
are extremely easy to work with. They are easy to cut, grind and polish
Percent elongation ranges from 5 to 20%. This gives an indication of the
ductility of the alloy. The higher the value the more ductile it is
Porcelain bonding
the presence of an oxide layer on the surface of metal ceramic alloys assists in
chemical bonding of porcelain to the alloy. Pure noble metal alloys rarely
form an oxide layer. To induce the formation of an oxide layer, 1% of base
metals like tin, indium, iron, etc. are added to the alloy. This significantly
improved the bond strength between the porcelain and the metal
Sag resistance
during porcelain firing, the metal frame has to withstand temperatures of as high
as 950°C. At these high temperatures there is a danger of the metal substructure
sagging under its own weight, thereby deforming. The longer the span the greater
is the danger of sagging. The ability of a metal to resist sag is known as sag
resistance. Compared to base metal alloys, gold alloys are less sag resistant
high noble alloys have had a good and safe track record. They are not known
to cause any problems in the mouth
Soldering
Melting range
a typical melting range is 1155 to 1304°C. The melting range of these alloys like
the gold ceramic alloys are high. This is desirable to ensure that these alloys don't
melt during porcelain firing
Yield strength
ranges from 462 to 685 MPa.
Hardness
ranges from 189 to 270 VHN. They tend to
be slightly harder than the high noble
metalceramic alloys
Percent elongation
Ranges from 10 to 34%. This gives an indication of the ductility of the alloy.
The higher the value the more ductile it is
Porcelain bonding
Like the gold alloys, base metals like tin, indium, etc are added to assist porcelain
bonding
Biological considerations
These alloys are very safe and biocompatible.
These alloys were introduced in the 1970's as an alternative to gold and
base metal alloys.
Their popularity has declined a little because of the greening problem
COMPOSITION:
%Palladium 53 to 60 wt
%Silver 28 to 40 wt
%(Palladium (74 to 80 wt
%(Copper (5 to 10 wt
%(Gallium (4 to 9 wt
%(Gold (1 to 2 wt
%( Base metal (around 1 wt
Esthetics
Copper does cause a slight discoloration of the porcelain, but is not a major
problem. During the oxidation firing the metal acquires a dark brown almost
black oxide layer. Care should be taken to mask this completely with
opaquer. Also of concern is the dark line which develops at the margins
Castability
These alloys are more technique sensitive. Slight errors can lead to faulty
castings
COMPOSITION:
%Palladium 78 to 88 wt
%Cobalt 4 to 10 wt
%Gallium up to 9wt
%Base metals around 1 wt
Esthetics Cobalt can cause some insignificant discoloration.
However, more care should be given for masking the dark oxide layer
with opaque
Sag resistance They are the most sag resistant of all the noble alloys
There are two groups-the palladium-gallium-silver and the
palladium-gallium- silver-gold
Composition
%Palladium 75 wt
%Gallium 6 wt
%Silver 5 to 8 wt
%Gold 6 wt
In countries like the USA, western Europe and some middle eastern states,
there is a preference for noble and high noble ceramic alloys.
:Basic elements
%Nickel 61 to 81 wt
%Chrome 11 to 27 wt
%Molybdenum 2 to 9 wt
Cost they are the cheapest of the casting alloys
Density ranges from 7.8 to 8.4 gm/cm-'. They have just half the density of
the gold alloys making them much lighter. One can get more castings per
gram compared to the gold alloys
Castability they are extremely technique sensitive. One reason may be their
lower density compared to the gold alloys
They tend to be much harder than the high noble metal ceramic alloys. Unlike
the gold alloys these alloys are extremely difficult to work with.
Their high hardness makes them very difficult to cut (sprue cutting), grind
and polish. In the mouth more chair time may be needed to adjust the occlusion.
Cutting and removing a defective crown can be quite demanding. The high
hardness results in rapid wear of carbide and diamond burs.
Yield strength ranges from 310 to 828 MPa. These alloys are stronger than
the gold and palladium based alloys
Modulus of elasticity ranges from 150 to 210 MPa This property denotes
the stiffness of the alloy.
Base metal alloys are twice as stiff as the gold ceramic alloys. Practically,
this means that we can make thinner, lighter castings or use it in long span
bridges where other metals are likely to fail because of flexing. Gold alloys
require a minimum thickness of at least 0.3 to 0.5 mm, whereas base metal
alloys copings can be reduced to 0.3 mm some even claim 0.1 mm
Percent elongation ranges from 10 to 28%. This gives an indication of
the ductility of the alloy.
Though they may appear to be ductile these alloys however, are not easily
burnishable. This may be related to additional factors like the high hardness
and yield strength
Porcelain bonding These alloys form an adequate oxide layer which is essential for
successful porcelain bonding. However, occasionally the porcelain may delaminate
from the underlying metal. This has been blamed on a poorly adherent oxide layer
which occurs under certain circumstances which have not been fully understood
Sag resistance These materials are far more stable at porcelain firing
temperatures than the gold based alloys. They have a higher sag resistance
Esthetics A dark oxide layer may be seen at the porcelain metal junction
Tarnish and corrosion resistance These alloys are highly resistant to tarnish
and corrosion. This is due to the property known as passivation. Passivation is the
property by which a resistant oxide layer forms on the surface of chrome
containing alloys. This oxide layer protects the alloy from further oxidation and
corrosion. These alloys can maintain their polish for years. Other self passivating
alloys are titanium and aluminum
Soldering
Soldering is necessary to join bridge parts. Long span bridges are often
cast in two parts to improve the fit and accuracy. The parts
are assembled correctly in the mouth and an index made. The parts are then
reassembled in the laboratory and joined together using solder.
Base metal alloys are much more difficult to solder than gold alloys.
Casting shrinkage
These alloys have a higher casting shrinkage than the gold alloys. Greater mould
expansion is needed to compensate for this. Inadequate compensation for casting
shrinkage can lead to a poorly fitting casting
Etching
Biological considerations
It is also used for NITI files, removable partial denture alloy frames and of
course commercial implants, It has been adapted in dentistry because of its
excellent biocompatibility, light weight, good strength and ability to passivate
Color it is a white color metal
Modulus of elasticity its MOE is 110 Gpa which makes it only half as
rigid as base metal alloys. However this appears to be sufficient for most
dental uses
Melting point its melting point is quite high (1668°C). Special equipment is
needed for casting titanium
Tarnish and corrosion Titanium has the ability to self- passivate. It forms a
thin protective oxide layer which protects the metal from further oxidation
Cobalt-chromium alloys have been available since the 1920's.
These alloys are also known as 'stellite' because of their shiny, star-like
appearance. They have bright lustrous, hard, strong, and non-tarnishing
qualities
COMPOSITION:
Cobalt 35 to 65%
%Chromium 23 to 30
%Nickel 0 to 20
%Molybdenum 0 to 7
%Iron 0 to 5
%Carbon up to 0.4
Cobalt
Imparts hardness, strength and rigidity to the alloy. It has a high melting point
Chromium
Its passivating effect ensures corrosion resistance. The chromium content
is directly proportional to tarnish and corrosion resistance. It reduces the
melting point. Along with other elements, it also acts in solid solution
hardening.
30% chromium is considered the upper limit for attaining maximum
mechanical properties
Nickel Cobalt and nickel are interchangeable. It decreases strength,
hardness, MOE and fusion temperature. It increases ductility
Molybdenum or Tungsten They are effective hardeners. Molybdenum
is preferred as it reduces ductility to a lesser extent than tungsten.
Molybdenum refines grain structure
Iron, Copper, Beryllium They are hardeners. In addition, beryllium
reduces fusion temperature and refines grain structure
Manganese and Silicon Primarily oxide scavengers to prevent oxidation of
other elements during melting. They are also hardeners
Boron Deoxidizer and hardener, but reduces ductility
Modulus of Elasticity They are twice as stiff as gold alloys (225 x 10"
MPa). Thus, casting can be made thinner
Hardness These alloys are 50% harder than gold alloys (432 VHN). Thus,
cutting, grinding and finishing is difficult. It wears off the cutting instrument.
Special hard, high speed finishing tools are needed
Casting Shrinkage The casting shrinkage is much greater (2.3%) than that
of gold alloys. The high shrinkage is due to their high fusion temperature
NPG and NPG+2 are unique alloys; formally the only formulations of their type to
be Accepted by the American Dental Association’s Council on Dental Materials, in
1989 and 1998 respectively.
Benifited by smooth and accurate NPG castings, providing reliable quality and fit.
NPG is simple to finish, and soldering is trouble-free with specially formulated
Aalba Gold Solder and Aalba Flux.
The bio-compatibility of NPG has been established through extensive in-vitro
corrosion and biological studies. With over 25 years of clinical service, NPG has
been proven to offer patients reliability, durability, comfort
APPLICATIONS
Non-ceramic fixed appliances, full cast crowns (FMC), single units, onlays, short-span
multiple unit bridgework, metal sub-structure for veneer crowns using polymer resins
(acrylic & composites), posts and cores.
Properties:
Tensile Strength psi (MPa)
81,200 (560)
Yield Strength psi (MPa)
38,425 (265)
Elongation Percent %
15
Vickers Hardness HV1
140
Density g/cm3
7.8
Color
Yellow-Gold
Melting Range °F (°C)
1,850-1,950 (1,012-1,068)
Composition
Cu 80.7% Al 7.8% Ni 4.3% Fe, Zn, Mn
• Since the elastic modulus of Ni-Cr is higher than NPG, it was rigid when the force
was applied and did not longer follow the elastic deformation, which resulted in
localized stresses within the root canal, leading to root fracture
• Since the elastic modulus of Ni-Cr is higher than NPG, it was rigid when the force was
applied and did not longer follow the elastic deformation, which resulted in localized
stresses within the root canal, leading to root fracture
CRAIG RESTORATIVE DENTISTRY
ANUSAVICE