Policy Continuum of Teacher Education
Policy Continuum of Teacher Education
of Teacher Education
June 2011
Table of Contents
Foreword 4
Glossary 5
Introduction 6
Guiding Principles 10
Induction 16
Conclusion 22
Foreword
In 2007, the Council began the process of drafting its Policy on the Continuum of Teacher Education
covering initial teacher education, induction and early and continuing professional development.
To inform the development of the policy, the Council commissioned two pieces of research. Firstly,
a position paper entitled A Review Paper on Thinking and Policies Relating to Teacher Education in
Ireland was prepared by Dr John Coolahan, Professor Emeritus, NUI Maynooth. This was followed
by a detailed study entitled Learning to Teach: A Nine Country Cross National Study, undertaken by
a team of researchers from University College Cork, led by Dr Paul Conway.
In parallel with the research outlined above, the Council embarked on a comprehensive
consultation process. On 4 February 2008, the Council convened a meeting of the partners in
education to initiate a national debate on the continuum of teacher education. At that meeting,
a wide-ranging discussion took place and all feedback was noted by the Council and informed its
deliberations. In the months which ensued, the Council developed the outline of its policy paper.
In October 2008, as part of a second phase of consultation, a series of 11 sectoral meetings was
convened by the Council at which the outline document was discussed by the partners in education.
In June 2009, the Council established a sub-group of its Education Committee to further develop
the policy. That working group met on 16 occasions over the months from July 2009 to November
2010 where it debated and drafted a number of iterations, culminating in the draft policy which
was published in December 2010. The publication of the draft policy marked the beginning of the
third phase of consultation. There was a high level of engagement with that process and more
than 200 submissions were received from individuals and organisations. Each submission was
read and considered and the policy was finalised and adopted by the Council at its meeting on
13 June 2011.
4 An Chomhairle Mhúinteoireachta
The Teaching Council
Glossary
Competences: Competences are statements of the attributes, skills and knowledge that
teachers as professionals should possess and exemplify. The achievement of competence is
a developmental process that continues throughout a teacher’s career. ‘Competencies’ is
the term used in some countries (e.g. New Zealand) and by some researchers. The term
‘competences’ is used in this paper.
Continuum of teacher education: This describes the formal and informal educational and
developmental activities in which teachers engage, as life-long learners, during their teaching
career. It encompasses initial teacher education, induction, early and continuing professional
development and, indeed, late career support.
HEI: The term HEI or Higher Education Institution is used in this document to denote those
colleges, universities and other third level bodies providing one or more programmes of
teacher education.
Out-of-field teachers: Teachers teaching a subject in respect of which their qualifications do not
meet the subject-specific criteria set down by the Teaching Council for registration purposes.
Professional portfolio: The term professional portfolio refers to an instrument used by the
student teacher to document his or her work, to support the process of reflection on his or her
practice and on the subject content, and to identify areas in which he/she may need support
or guidance. The portfolio also facilitates students to become more conscious of the theories
and assumptions that guide their practice, and provides a basis for collaborative dialogue
about teaching.
Professional studies: Professional studies incorporate studies in the pedagogy of the subjects
of the relevant curriculum or syllabus (i.e., in the case of the primary sector, the entire range of
subjects which is included in the Primary School Curriculum and, in the case of post-primary,
the post-primary syllabus subjects in which the student teacher is specialising). Professional
studies should be directed towards the appropriate age group.
School placement: The term school placement refers to that part of the programme which
takes place in school settings and which is designed to give the student teacher an opportunity
to apply educational theory in a variety of teaching situations and school contexts. It affords
the student teacher opportunities to participate in school life in a way that is structured and
supported. The Council is aware that the term “teaching practice” is the more widely used term
in the Irish teacher education context. However, it considers the term “school placement” more
accurately reflects the nature of the experience as one encompassing a range of teaching and
non-teaching activities.
Ireland has been fortunate in the quality of its teachers and this is due in no small measure
to the supportive role of the State in teacher education. The Council regards education as a
public good and therefore wishes to reiterate that it is the primary responsibility and direct
role of the State, in co-operation with the Council, to support high quality teacher education.
In order to fulfil this responsibility, the State should guarantee, through its Higher Education
Institutions (HEIs), an adequate supply of highly qualified teachers, as has been the tradition
for many decades. In this context, the State and the profession share a responsibility for the
continuing professional development of teachers. The State should consider the negative impact
of the casualisation of the profession where many teachers remain in part-time or short-term
employment for extended periods. The State also needs to recognise that the quality of teaching
is compromised by the deployment of out-of-field teachers.
The Council believes that the time is now right for a fresh and thorough look at teacher education
to ensure that tomorrow’s teachers are competent to meet the challenges that they face and
are life-long learners, continually adapting over the course of their careers to enable them to
support their students’ learning.
This paper is underpinned by an extensive programme of research and consultation and it sets
out the Council’s policy on the continuum of teacher education including initial teacher education,
induction, early and continuing professional development. The policy, and a suite of ancillary
documents which helped inform it, are available for download from the Council’s website,
www.teachingcouncil.ie
In setting out its policy, the Council is cognisant of the value of education in society, of the
unique role which teachers play within the education system in providing for the holistic
development of students, and of the complex and intricate nature of teaching as it is elaborated
in the Code of Professional Conduct for Teachers. The Council reiterates the critical objectives
of promoting quality teaching and learning, as well as the centrality of the core values and
professional commitments of the teaching profession as set out in the Code.
The Council is also mindful of the evolving and dynamic context for teaching whereby new
understandings and insights have emerged in a range of areas including pedagogy, curriculum,
assessment, human learning, early childhood education and teacher education. In parallel,
teachers have found themselves facing a range of new challenges and opportunities in the
classroom in recent years. The inclusion of children with disabilities and/or special
educational needs into mainstream schools, the increase in the numbers of students from
different ethnic and cultural backgrounds, the changes in an increasingly diverse society,
changing family structures and the emergence of new societal and economic problems are
contributing to the complexity of teaching in 21st century Ireland. This complexity is intensified
by the fact that teaching in the primary, post-primary and further education sectors takes place
6 An Chomhairle Mhúinteoireachta
The Teaching Council
in a multiplicity of contexts, thereby resulting in a diverse range of needs within and across the
different sectors.
The pace of change in the education system since the 1990s, including significant changes to,
and reform of curriculum, pedagogy and assessment at both primary and post-primary levels,
together with the pace of legislative change in the education sector, is having a significant impact
on teaching. The introduction of Aistear1, a new framework for early childhood education,
brings into focus the work of teachers in the junior classes of primary school. The Government’s
20-Year Strategy for the Irish Language (Straitéis 20 Bliain don Ghaeilge 2010-2030) highlights the
challenges and requirements that arise in preparing teachers to teach Irish throughout their
careers. Its Draft National Plan to Improve Literacy and Numeracy in Schools highlights the
challenges which arise in relation to literacy and numeracy and the developments that are
needed to enhance the skills of teachers in teaching literacy and numeracy. The emergence of
new technologies and social media play a central role in the way young people communicate
and learn and this is having an impact across all education provision. Regard for social inclusion,
the early identification of children with learning difficulties, multiculturalism, partnership with
parents and ICT are increasingly significant issues. There is a heightened expectation in relation
to the role of teachers and a major cultural shift whereby teaching now requires a much greater
degree of interaction with students, colleagues, parents and co-professionals.
In summary, the emergence of new knowledge, understandings and insights into curriculum,
pedagogy, assessment and teacher learning, together with the accelerating pace of societal,
legislative and educational reform and the increasingly complex role of teachers, provide an
important context for this policy.
1 Aistear: the Early Childhood Curriculum Framework was developed by the National Council for Curriculum and Assessment (NCCA)
in partnership with the early childhood sector. It was published in October 2009.
The continuum of teacher education has traditionally been referred to internationally as the
“three ‘I’s” of initial teacher education, induction and in-career development. The Council is
adopting another set of “three ‘I’s”, namely, innovation, integration and improvement which
should underpin all stages of the continuum.
Innovation
The Council believes that innovation is essential at all stages of the continuum if teacher
education is to be effective in meeting the changing needs identified in the introduction.
The Council sees the concept of innovation as encompassing those processes whereby fresh
thinking is applied to teacher education with the aim of renewing and improving it. Initial teacher
education must be reconceptualised so that it is fit-for-purpose in preparing 21st century
teachers and interfaces appropriately with the induction stage. Innovative, multi-faceted
programmes of induction must be developed and made available to all teachers to ensure a
seamless transition from being a student on a programme of initial teacher education to being
a practising teacher in the classroom. Equally, at early and continuing professional development
stages, new models of provision need to be developed to assist teachers to develop and broaden
the professional knowledge, skill and competences appropriate to their teaching.
Integration
The theme of integration is threaded throughout this document. For many years in Ireland,
there has been a recognition of teacher education as a continuum and this is evidenced in the
Report on the National Education Convention (1993) the Government White Paper, Charting Our
Education Future (1995) and the OECD Report, Teachers Matter: Attracting, Developing and Retaining
Effective Teachers (2005). Further details are available in the Council’s background report,
Teacher Education in Ireland and Internationally, which accompanies this document.
This view of teacher education as a continuum was reflected in the mid 1990s in the
establishment of the In-Career Development Unit (ICDU), now the Teacher Education Section
(TES), by the Department of Education and Skills. The rationale for the administrative change
from the ICDU to the TES was to ensure cohesion in teacher education policy and practice across
all phases of the teaching career.
Despite research, reports and restructuring of sections within the Department of Education and
Skills, the problem of fragmentation of teacher education has remained significant in Ireland
with insufficient linkages being made between the stages of the continuum. Furthermore,
8 An Chomhairle Mhúinteoireachta
The Teaching Council
there is an overreliance on initial teacher education in a context where, until very recently, a
formal induction programme has not been in place for the majority of newly qualified teachers
(NQTs). It has long been recognised that there is a need to bring greater coherence to provision
at all stages of the continuum and the Council believes that this issue must be addressed as a
matter of priority.
Improvement
The Council recognises that there is much excellent work being done by providers at the initial
teacher education stage. However, it has identified many opportunities for improvement in key
areas, e.g., many current programmes are overloaded and are based on somewhat outdated
models of provision where there is much emphasis on contact hours and assessment. This
leaves insufficient time and space for the meaningful initiation of the development of teachers
as reflective, enquiry-oriented, life-long learners. This development is essential to prepare
teachers to continually self-evaluate, collaborate and adapt throughout their careers to reflect
the changing realities of the classrooms in which they will teach.
The Council welcomes the recent introduction of the National Induction Programme for
Teachers, which is accessible to all newly qualified teachers, but it believes that this is just a
starting point, and there remains considerable scope for growth and improvement.
Equally, while the Council acknowledges the range of continuing professional development
programmes available for teachers, it believes that there is a need for much improvement in this
area to ensure the long-term capacity-building that is now needed in the system.
The Council is conscious of the need for strategies which will enable coherence and cohesion
throughout the continuum and ensure the achievement of appropriate standards.
The Council is also mindful of the Government’s 20-Year Strategy for the Irish Language (Straitéis
20 Bliain don Ghaeilge 2010-2030) which sets out areas for Government action under various
headings including education. In line with that strategy, the Council recognises the need for high
standards of Irish among both primary and post-primary teachers in regard to teaching Irish
as a subject, using it as a means of communication and as a medium of instruction. The Council
expects that this need can be factored in at each phase of the continuum. It is confident that
existing reserves of expertise and capacity may be harnessed effectively by teacher education
providers and other agencies to meet the challenges and requirements that arise in this context.
—— be directed towards the learner, who is at the centre of all educational endeavour;
—— be informed by the core values and professional commitments which are central to
teaching, as set out in the Teaching Council’s Code of Professional Conduct for Teachers
—— be informed by the best available research and evidence;
—— recognise teachers as life-long learners and teacher education as a continuum;
—— develop those competences which facilitate quality learning, cater for educational priorities
and are central to teachers’ professional practice and personal growth;
—— promote a love of learning and a sense of wonder and enquiry;
—— foster reflective, critical and research-based learning;
—— be based on a broad understanding of the practice of teaching as one involving complex
relationships and requiring different types of professional knowledge1, attitudes and
dispositions;
—— be supported by appropriate structures designed to achieve coherence across all stages of
the continuum;
—— be designed and provided using a partnership model involving teachers, schools and
teacher educators;
—— be adequately resourced to meet teacher, school and system needs;
—— recognise that teachers, as professionals and as public servants, are accountable for the
quality of the service that they provide;
—— be subject to periodic review and ongoing evaluation of needs and priorities.
1 Knowledge – for practice, knowledge – in practice and knowledge – of practice, as explicated in Cochran-Smith, M., & Lytle,
S. L. (1999). ‘Relationships of knowledge and practice: teacher learning in communities’, Review of Research in Education
10 An Chomhairle Mhúinteoireachta
The Teaching Council
Initial Teacher Education
Initial Teacher Education (ITE) refers to the foundation stage of learning to be a teacher
when student teachers are engaged in a recognised teacher education programme provided
by a Higher Education Institution. Further information on the provision of initial teacher
education in Ireland and internationally is available in the Council’s background document,
Teacher Education in Ireland and Internationally.
The Council’s policy is based on the generic principles of good teacher education which are
outlined on page 10, bearing in mind its drive for innovation, integration and improvement.
In addition, the following principles, which are specific to initial teacher education,
are significant.
Programmes
—— The foundation studies, professional studies and the school placement should be
carefully planned in the light of changing understandings of the nature of learning and
the theory-practice relationship, so that there is an appropriate balance between them
and their inter-relationship is made explicit.
12 An Chomhairle Mhúinteoireachta
The Teaching Council
—— Professional studies such as subject pedagogies (methodologies) and curriculum studies
should be designed to advance the communicative skills of student teachers. They should
also promote pedagogical content knowledge and cultivate the understanding and acumen
that transform a fluency in one or more teaching subjects into an assured pedagogical
capability. In such studies, teaching itself is understood and practised as a form of
self-critical learning by student teachers, with ample opportunities for teamwork and
enquiry-based initiatives with colleagues.
—— Where academic elective subjects form part of the programme, they should incorporate
material appropriate to the teaching of the subject in the relevant sector. While such
subjects may aim to contribute to students’ personal and cultural development, they should
also be related to their future work as teachers and the development of subject leaders.
The range and focus of such subjects should be reviewed to reflect these aims.
Assessment
—— Rigorous systems should be in place to assess the development of the competences
expected of graduating teachers. Such systems should ensure that the graduating teacher
will be capable of sustained classroom practice.
14 An Chomhairle Mhúinteoireachta
The Teaching Council
Resourcing Issues
—— Among the resourcing issues to be considered are the following:
—— Lecturers and other staff responsible for student teachers’ professional and personal
development should be suitably qualified and experienced;
—— Staffing levels in provider institutions should be such that a student-centred experience
can be provided, in particular, through active tutorial workshops;
—— HEI facilities appropriate to the programme concerned should be available to support
teaching, learning and research.
The Council welcomes the communication from the Minister for Education and Skills in
August 2010 that it is intended to commence section 7(2)(f) of the Teaching Council Act, 2001,
in relation to the induction of teachers into the teaching profession, in September 2012.
The Council is now preparing for its role in that area and is working towards the establishment
of induction procedures for newly qualified teachers from that date. As part of that work, the
Council is considering how such procedures might dovetail with the probationary process.
Policy on Induction
The Teaching Council’s policy on induction is based on an appreciation that teaching is an
instance, par excellence, of life-long learning and that initial teacher education cannot furnish
‘finished products’. It also recognises the important part induction plays in enriching schools
themselves as learning environments, including the significant changes in work practices that
innovative induction programmes both require and promote. Therefore, the implementation
of comprehensive induction programmes for all newly qualified teachers will be a major step
forward in building the continuum of teacher education in Ireland.
The Council’s policy on induction is based on the three pillars of innovation, integration and
improvement as well as the generic principles of good teacher education which are outlined on
page 10. In addition, the following principles, which are specific to induction, are significant.
16 An Chomhairle Mhúinteoireachta
The Teaching Council
Induction and the Continuum
—— Induction, a primarily formative process, is distinct from probation, a primarily
evaluative process.
—— Induction programmes should be integrally related to, and build on, programmes of
initial teacher education and be based on a co-operative approach involving partnership
between HEIs, the education centres network, support services and schools.
—— Induction and continuing professional development should be based on the enquiry-oriented
stance initiated in initial teacher education. Structural links and interfaces should be
explicitly addressed in any national induction programme.
—— Induction programmes should shape NQTs’ professional engagement in life-long learning
and help them continue their development as competent, effective teachers.
—— Induction should attend to the professional learning needs of NQTs and their induction into
learning communities for life-long learning as professionals.
Evaluation
—— Any induction procedures which may be put in place should be subject to periodic review
and ongoing evaluation of needs and priorities.
18 An Chomhairle Mhúinteoireachta
The Teaching Council
Continuing Professional Development
Continuing professional development (CPD) refers to life-long teacher learning and comprises
the full range of educational experiences designed to enrich teachers’ professional knowledge,
understanding and capabilities throughout their careers. Further information on the provision of
continuing professional development in Ireland and internationally is available in the Council’s
background document, Teacher Education in Ireland and Internationally.
The Council intends to work towards a position, following the adoption of a coherent national
framework for CPD as outlined above, where renewal of registration with the Teaching Council
will be subject to the receipt of satisfactory evidence in relation to engagement in CPD.
Teacher Formation
—— CPD should promote knowledge-for, knowledge-in and knowledge–of practice in a context
where there is adequate time for feedback and follow-up support.
—— Effective CPD, which is participative in nature, should encourage teachers to evaluate their
pedagogical beliefs and practices, to critically reflect on their professional practice and
working environments and to engage in professional collaboration.
—— Individual teachers should actively shape their own professional development, in the context
of a professional development portfolio commenced during initial teacher education and
retained throughout the teaching career.
—— CPD should facilitate teachers’ critical engagement with curriculum, pedagogy and
assessment to maximise students’ learning.
Design of CPD
—— Approaches to professional development should be designed having regard to the settings
in which teachers work and the plurality of roles played by teachers in the holistic
development of students.
—— Approaches to professional development should recognise the importance of an attractive
career structure for teachers. In that regard, the Council believes that a national framework
should facilitate teachers wishing to avail of leave of absence to pursue professional
development opportunities.
—— Effective CPD should be constructivist in nature, involving both formal and informal ways
of learning where emphasis is placed on reflection, joint problem solving, networking and
systematic sharing of expertise and experience.
—— As professional learning communities, schools, or clusters of schools working together
through structures such as HEIs, the education centres and subject associations, have a
central role to play in prioritising professional development needs.
20 An Chomhairle Mhúinteoireachta
The Teaching Council
—— CPD should be linked to school development and improvement and should empower
teachers as professionals working within a coherent school programme rather than
focussing solely on skills training.
—— School-based collaborative enquiry carried out by teachers in teams or groups and
supported by teacher education departments, is a valuable model for CPD.
—— In exercising their role as professional learning communities, schools should prepare a
professional development plan covering a three to five year period, taking into account
teachers’ individual needs, the needs of the school and the needs of the system.
Accreditation of CPD
—— The National Framework of Qualifications should be utilised to facilitate recognition of
the role of additional qualifications in teachers’ career structures.
—— Flexible modes of recognition and administration of CPD need to be continually developed
and reviewed.
—— Programmes of CPD should be accredited by the Teaching Council having regard to its
statutory powers under Section 39 of the Teaching Council Act, 2001. Such accreditation
should be based on criteria to be developed by the Teaching Council as part of a
framework for CPD.
Priority Areas
—— CPD should foster the development of competences to facilitate quality learning and
cater for educational priorities. At present, key national priority areas include: literacy;
numeracy; ICT; inclusion.
—— The Council will actively engage with teacher education providers in relation to the
development of programmes of professional development aimed at up-skilling practising
teachers in their subject content knowledge.
In this policy paper, the Council has set out its vision for teacher education under the banner
of a new “three I’s”: innovation, integration and improvement. Guiding principles have been
identified which will facilitate cohesion and coherence in teacher education across the teaching
career. Within each stage of the continuum, these generic principles have been elaborated into
more detailed policy positions, following a process of research, consultation and deliberation.
This policy will guide the Council in the years ahead, as it works to develop criteria and
guidelines for reconceptualised programmes of initial teacher education, induction and
continuing professional development. As such, it is key to ensuring that tomorrow’s teachers
will be competent to meet the challenges that they face and will be life-long learners, continually
adapting over the course of their careers to enable them to support their students’ learning.
This document will be subject to ongoing review and revision as appropriate. It is available for
download from the Teacher Education page of www.teachingcouncil.ie
22 An Chomhairle Mhúinteoireachta
The Teaching Council
An Chomhairle Mhúinteoireachta
The Teaching Council
www.teachingcouncil.ie