Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology
Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology
To cite this article: R.H.M. de Groot , G. Hornstra , N. Roozendaal & J. Jolles (2003) Memory
Performance, but not Information Processing Speed, may be Reduced During Early Pregnancy,
Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology, 25:4, 482-488
Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information (the
“Content”) contained in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor & Francis,
our agents, and our licensors make no representations or warranties whatsoever as to
the accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the Content. Any opinions
and views expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of the authors,
and are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy of the Content
should not be relied upon and should be independently verified with primary sources
of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for any losses, actions, claims,
proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other liabilities whatsoever
or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with, in relation to or
arising out of the use of the Content.
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any
substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing,
systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden. Terms &
Conditions of access and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-
and-conditions
Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology 1380-3395/03/2504-482$16.00
2003, Vol. 25, No. 4, pp. 482–488 # Swets & Zeitlinger
ABSTRACT
Several studies have investigated aspects of cognitive functioning during late pregnancy or in the period
around delivery. The present paper describes a controlled study of neurocognitive functioning in an early
phase of pregnancy (14 weeks). Seventy-one pregnant women and 57 control subjects matched for age and
education were tested with a cognitive test battery. Intentional learning was tested with the Verbal Learning
Test, retrieval from semantic memory with the Fluency Test, and speed of information processing with the
Concept Shifting Test, the Stroop test, and the Letter Digit Substitution Test. Results show that performance
on tests measuring intentional learning and retrieval from semantic memory were lower in the pregnant
group during early pregnancy as compared to a closely matched nonpregnant group. In contrast, speed of
information processing was not different between the two groups. The differences observed in memory
performance were not large and further research is needed to establish their clinical significance. In addition,
the results should be interpreted with care, because our study has a cross-sectional design, which has
limitations concerning the fact that preexisting performance differences might be possible. Therefore,
longitudinal studies are essential to ascertain clear associations between pregnancy and cognitive
performance.
Address correspondence to: R.H.M. de Groot, Department of Human Biology, Maastricht University, P.O. Box
616, 6200MD Maastricht, The Netherlands. Tel.: þ 31 433881507. Fax: þ 31 433670976. E-mail:
RHM.deGroot@HB.unimaas.nl
Accepted for publication: September 23, 2002.
MEMORY PERFORMANCE 483
possibility that early pregnancy is already char- normal health, that is, not suffering from any metabolic,
acterized by cognitive changes is of importance as cardiovascular, renal, psychiatric, or neurological dis-
there is not yet a profound change in psychosocial orders. Exclusion criteria were diastolic blood pressure
higher than 90 mmHg, multiple pregnancy, consump-
circumstances around the pregnant woman. Pos- tion of dietary supplements rich in polyunsaturated fatty
sible changes in cognitive functioning could acids, and not being of Caucasian origin, in order to
therefore more directly be ascribed to biological limit scatter of the measuring results due to large
changes in the body brought about by hormones or differences in genetic, social, and cultural patterns.
by a redistribution of nutrients essential for brain The nonpregnant women in the control group were
functioning (e.g., long chain highly unsaturated friends or family members of the pregnant women, or
were recruited by advertisements in local newspapers.
essential fatty acids) in favor of the unborn child.
All in- and exclusion criteria were the same as for the
The present study investigated whether cogni-
Downloaded by [Eindhoven Technical University] at 09:02 22 November 2014
Concept Shifting Test (CST) in a random order. On the rest of the page, boxes are
The Concept Shifting Test (CST) was used to measure presented with just letters. Subjects were asked to fill in
visual conceptual and visuomotor tracking (Houx, as many corresponding numbers as possible within
1991; Vink & Jolles, 1985). This test consists of four 1 min. The total number of digits correctly related to a
test sheets. On each test sheet, 16 small circles are letter was used as the dependent variable.
grouped in a larger circle. On the first sheet, numbers
appear in a fixed random order, on the second sheet Statistics
letters, and on the third sheet both. Subjects were One pregnant subject did not have reliable test results,
requested to cross out the items in the right order (1-2- because the conditions under which she performed the
3-4 (Subtask I), A-B-C-D (Subtask II), 1A-2B-3C cognitive tests were unacceptable. Data for this person
(Subtask III), respectively); the time required to do this were excluded from the analyses. Individual data were
was measured with a stopwatch. A fourth sheet with screened for extreme values based on normative data
Downloaded by [Eindhoven Technical University] at 09:02 22 November 2014
empty circles (Subtask IV), which had to be crossed out from the Maastricht Aging Study (van Boxtel et al.,
as fast as possible, was used to correct for motor speed. 1998); Five datapoints were considered outliers, with
Mean speed for Subtasks I and II, corrected for motor values outside the range of þ / 3*SD, and were
speed (Subtask IV), was used as a measure of general excluded from the analyses.
information processing speed. Subtask III, also cor- Subject characteristics were examined for statistical
rected for motor speed, was used as a measure of differences between the two groups by unpaired t tests.
concept shifting ability. The Mann–Whitney U-test analyzed the differences
in education and number of pregnancies. The group
Fluency (FLU) differences for the dependent variables were analyzed
The subjects completed a fluency task (Lezak, 1995) as by ANOVA with education and total number of
a measure of retrieval from long-term semantic pregnancies as covariates. In the analysis of the WLT
memory. Subjects had to name as many animals as a correction for test version was applied too. The CST
possible within 1 min. Fluency is a measure of the was also analyzed by a two-way ANOVA for group
adequate, strategy-driven retrieval of information from repeated measures (two variables), to find out whether
semantic memory. The number of animals named was there was a differential effect for concept shifting (CST
used as dependent variable. III) or general speed (mean CST I/II). The same was
done for the Stroop test. A p level of < .05 was con-
Stroop Color-Word Interference Test sidered statistically significant.
The Stroop Color-Word Interference Test was used to
test selective attention (Klein, Ponds, Houx, & Jolles,
1997; Stroop, 1935). The test involves three cards RESULTS
displaying 40 stimuli each: color names printed in black
(Subtask I), colored patches (Subtask II), and color
names printed in one of the other colors (Subtask III). Subject Characteristics
For Subtask I subjects had to read aloud the printed Table 1 shows the subject characteristics. With an
items, for Subtask II they had to name to color of the unpaired t test no statistically significant differ-
patches and for Subtask III they had to name the ink ences were found between the two groups for age,
color the words were printed in. The amount of extra height, and weight. The control subjects tended to
time needed to discard irrelevant but very salient have attained a higher level of education
information (reading) in favor of a less obvious aspect
(p ¼ 0.0628). We therefore decided to use a sta-
(color naming) was recorded. Mean speed for Subtasks
I and II was used as a measure of general information tistical design in which education was controlled
processing speed. Subtask III was used as a measure of for. The average total number of pregnancies was
color word interference susceptibility. statistically different between the two groups
(p ¼ .0014). Therefore, we corrected for both
Letter-Digit-Substitution-Test (LDST) education and total number of pregnancies.
The Letter-Digit-Substitution-Test (LDST) is related to
the Symbol-Digit Modalities Test developed by Smith
Intentional Learning Task and Retrieval
(Smith, 1968), which originates from the Digit Symbol
Test developed by Wechsler (Wechsler, 1958). The from Semantic Memory
LDST was used to measure the efficiency of operations The control group had a significantly higher score
in working memory. At the top of the test sheet, a box is on the WLTtot (mean SD 11.77 1.34, n ¼ 57)
presented with nine numbers coupled with nine letters than the pregnant group (11.07 1.35, n ¼ 70,
MEMORY PERFORMANCE 485
0 0 (0) 17 (29.8)
Downloaded by [Eindhoven Technical University] at 09:02 22 November 2014
1 25 (35.2) 11 (19.3)
2 31 (43.7) 17 (29.8)
3 9 (12.7) 8 (14.0)
>3 6 (8.4) 4 (7.1)
Note. 1The age range is 21–39 years.
2
Education was measured on an 8-point scale.
Significant.
Table 2. Cognitive Test Performance in the Pregnant Group Versus the Control Group (Mean SD).
p ¼ .015). The same was found for WLT delayed Speed of Information Processing
recall task: 12.75 1.83 for the control group General speed of processing and concept shifting
(n ¼ 57) versus 11.69 2.06 for the pregnant in the concept shifting test were not different
group (n ¼ 70, p ¼ .006) (see Table 2). between the two groups (see also Table 2). Two
With respect to retrieval from long-term scores on this test were analyzed; the mean of
semantic memory, the pregnant group had a Version I and II as the general speed of informa-
significantly lower score for the fluency test than tion processing (p ¼ .421) and the score of Ver-
did the control group (24.80 5.46, n ¼ 70 vs. sion III as a measure of concept shifting ability
27.84 5.79, n ¼ 57; p ¼ .006 after correction for ( p ¼ .303). By two-way repeated measures
education and number of pregnancies). ANOVA no differential effect was found for
Analyses without correction for number of concept shifting.
pregnancies revealed comparable results (WLTtot Likewise, there were no significant group
p ¼ .013, WLTdr p ¼ .004, FLU p ¼ .020). differences in scores on the Stroop test (p ¼ .872
486 R.H.M. DE GROOT ET AL.
for the group differences concerning the mean of (Keenan et al., 1998; Sharp et al., 1993). In our
Stroop Version I and II and p ¼ .491 for Ver- study, explicit memory (as measured by WLTtot
sion III). Also, two-way ANOVA for repeated and WLTdr) was significantly impaired in the
measures did not show any statistically significant pregnant group compared to the control group.
differences. Finally, scores on the Letter Digit These results are consistent with those of Keenan
Substitution Test were not statistically different et al. (1998), who, however, only found statisti-
between the pregnant and the control groups cally significant differences in explicit memory in
(p ¼ .624). the third trimester of pregnancy. Their group
sizes, however, were small (10 pregnant women
and 10 women in the control group). Sharp et al.
DISCUSSION (1993) detected deficits in explicit memory in all
Downloaded by [Eindhoven Technical University] at 09:02 22 November 2014
Keenan et al. (1998) found that although pregnant factors, and hormones. A change in LC-PUFA
women scored higher on both depression and availability could, therefore, explain our findings.
anxiety scales, the pregnancy-related decline in During pregnancy, accretion of maternal, placen-
memory was not attributable to these factors. It is tal and fetal tissue occurs and, consequently, the
not likely that our findings were influenced by LC-PUFA requirements of pregnant women and
mood changes or depression, because our study their developing fetuses are high (Clandinin et al.,
was performed in early pregnancy, when mood 1980). To obtain these LC-PUFA, the fetus mainly
changes are minor, if present, in contrast to late depends on placental transfer and thus on the EFA
pregnancy, close to delivery, when a substantial status and/or supply of the mother (Innis, 1991).
proportion of pregnant women experience some- The overall biochemical LC-PUFA status of
times profound psychological changes. However, women declines during pregnancy (Al, van
Downloaded by [Eindhoven Technical University] at 09:02 22 November 2014
preexisting mood differences between our two Houwelingen, & Hornstra, 2000) which may have
groups cannot be completely ruled out, as this is functional consequences on maternal cognition.
one of the limitations of a cross-sectional study In summary this cross-sectional study demon-
design as has been stated before. strated less adequate memory performance in an
Several biological factors may underlie the early pregnancy group as compared to a matched
cognitive decline during pregnancy. One factor group of nonpregnant women. A longitudinal
may be hormonal, because the levels of estrogen, study will be needed to establish clear association
progesterone, testosterone, and dehydroepiandos- with pregnancy, especially any causal relation,
terone change considerably during pregnancy. and to find out whether the observed differences
Buckwalter et al. (1999) tried to find a relation in early pregnancy disappear at some point after
between impaired memory and the above-men- delivery. Currently, such a study is in progress in
tioned hormones. They confirmed that cognitive our laboratory and results will become available
functioning decreased during pregnancy, especially later this year.
aspects of verbal memory, and that negative mood
states were reported more often during pregnancy
than after delivery. However, no consistent correla- REFERENCES
tion was found between impaired memory and
negative mood state or steroid hormone concentra- Al, M.D., van Houwelingen, A.C., & Hornstra, G.
tions. Oxytocin has been mentioned as a possible (2000). Long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids,
pregnancy, and pregnancy outcome. The American
factor, influencing cognitive function, but a corre-
Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 71, 285S–291S.
lation between oxytocin concentration and cogni- Baildam, E. (1991). Doctor as mum. BMJ, 303, 424.
tive function during pregnancy has not been found Bie, S.E.D. (1987). Standaardvragen 1987: Voorstellen
(Silber et al., 1990). Moreover, because the voor uniformering van vraagstellingen naar achter-
oxytocin concentration does not change in early grondkenmerken en interviews [Standard questions
pregnancy, this factor cannot explain the compro- 1987: Proposal for uniformisation of questions
mised intentional learning and retrieval from regarding background variables and interviews]
(2nd ed.). Leiden, The Netherlands: Leiden
semantic memory found in our study.
University Press.
Another biological factor, which may be caus- Brand, N., & Jolles, J. (1985). Learning and retrieval
ally implicated in the cognitive changes during rate of words presented auditorily and visually. The
pregnancy, is nutrition. This particular applies to Journal of General Psychology, 112, 201–210.
longer-chain, highly-unsaturated derivatives of Brett, M., & Baxendale, S. (2001). Motherhood and
essential fatty acids, the so-called LC-PUFA. memory: A review. Psychoneuroendocrinology, 26,
The latter compounds are very important struc- 339–362.
Brindle, P.M., Brown, M.W., Brown, J., Griffith, H.B.,
tural components in brain tissue, where they
& Turner, G.M. (1991). Objective and subjective
perform an array of membrane-associated func- memory impairment in pregnancy. Psychological
tions (Sastry, 1985). For instance, they can Medicine, 21, 647–653.
influence membrane fluidity and thus affect the Buckwalter, J.G., Stanczyk, F.Z., McCleary, C.A.,
activities of neurotransmitters, peptides, releasing Bluestein, B.W., Buckwalter, D.K., Rankin, K.P.,
488 R.H.M. DE GROOT ET AL.
Chang, L., & Goodwin, T.M. (1999). Pregnancy, the Lezak, M.D. (1995). Neuropsychological assessment
postpartum, and steroid hormones: Effects on (3rd ed.). New York: Oxford University Press.
cognition and mood [published erratum appears in McDowall, J., & Moriarty, R. (2000). Implicit and
Psychoneuroendocrinology 1999 July; 24, 581]. explicit memory in pregnant women: An analysis of
Psychoneuroendocrinology, 24, 69–84. data-driven and conceptually driven processes. The
Casey, P., Huntsdale, C., Angus, G., & Janes, C. (1999). Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 53,
Memory in pregnancy. II: Implicit, incidental, 729–740.
explicit, semantic, short-term, working and pro- Morris, N., Toms, M., Easthope, Y., & Biddulph, J.
spective memory in primigravid, multigravid and (1998). Mood and cognition in pregnant workers
postpartum women. Journal of Psychosomatic [see comments]. Applied Ergonomics, 29, 377–381.
Obstetrics and Gynaecology, 20, 158–164. Parsons, C., & Redman, S. (1991). Self-reported
Christensen, H., Poyser, C., Pollitt, P., & Cubis, J. cognitive change during pregnancy. Australian
Downloaded by [Eindhoven Technical University] at 09:02 22 November 2014
(1999). Pregnancy may confer a selective cognitive Journal of Advanced Nursing, 9, 20–29.
advantage. Journal of Reproductive and Infant Poser, C.M., Kassirer, M.R., & Peyser, J.M. (1986).
Psychology, 17, 7–25. Benign encephalopathy of pregnancy. Preliminary
Clandinin, M.T., Chappell, J.E., Leong, S., Heim, T., clinical observations. Acta Neurologica Scandina-
Swyer, P.R., & Chance, G.W. (1980). Intrauterine vica, 73, 39–43.
fatty acid accretion rates in human brain: Implica- Rey, A. (1964). L’examen psychologique dans les cas
tions for fatty acid requirements. Early Human d’encephalopathie traumatique [Psychological
Development, 4, 121–129. assessment in cases of traumatic brain injury].
Condon, J.T. (1987). Altered cognitive functioning in Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.
pregnant women: A shift towards primary process Sastry, P.S. (1985). Lipids of nervous tissue: Composi-
thinking. The British Journal of Medical Psychol- tion and metabolism. Progress in Lipid Research,
ogy, 60, 329–334. 24, 69–176.
Eidelman, A.I., Hoffmann, N.W., & Kaitz, M. (1993). Schneider, Z. (1989). Cognitive performance in preg-
Cognitive deficits in women after childbirth. nancy. Australian Journal of Advanced Nursing, 6,
Obstetrics and Gynecology, 81, 764–767. 40–47.
Engelberts, N.H., Klein, M., van der Ploeg, H.M., Sharp, K., Brindle, P.M., Brown, M.W., & Turner, G.M.
Heimans, J.J., Ader, H.J., van Boxtel, M.P., Jolles, (1993). Memory loss during pregnancy [see com-
J., & Kasteleijn-Nolst Trenite, D.G. (2002). Cogni- ments]. British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynae-
tion and health-related quality of life in a well- cology, 100, 209–215.
defined subgroup of patients with partial epilepsy. Silber, M., Almkvist, O., Larsson, B., & Uvnas-
Journal of Neurology, 249, 294–299. Moberg, K. (1990). Temporary peripartal impair-
Harris, N.D., Deary, I.J., Harris, M.B., Lees, M.M., & ment in memory and attention and its possible
Wilson, J.A. (1996). Peripartal cognitive impair- relation to oxytocin concentration. Life Sciences,
ment: Secondary to depression? The British Journal 47, 57–65.
of Health Psychology, 1, 127–136. Smith, A. (1968). The Symbol Digit Modalities Test: A
Houx, P. (1991). Cognitive aging and health-related neuropsychologic test for economic screening of
factors. Limburg, Maastricht: Rijksuniversiteit learning and other cerebral disorders. Learning
Innis, S.M. (1991). Essential fatty acids in growth and Disorders, 3, 83–91.
development. Progress in Lipid Research, 30, 39–103. Stroop, J. (1935). Studies of interference in serial verbal
Jolles, J., Houx, P., Boxtel van, M., & Ponds, R. (1995). reaction. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 18,
Maastricht aging study: Determinants of cognitive 643–662.
aging. Maastricht: Neuropsych Publishers. van Boxtel, M.P., Buntinx, F., Houx, P.J., Metsemakers,
Kane, F.J., Jr., Harman, W.J., Jr., Keeler, M.H., & J.F., Knottnerus, A., & Jolles, J. (1998). The relation
Ewing, J.A. (1968). Emotional and cognitive between morbidity and cognitive performance in a
disturbance in the early puerperium. The British normal aging population. The Journals of Gerontol-
Journal of Psychiatry, 114, 99–102. ogy. Series A, Biological Sciences and Social
Keenan, P.A., Yaldoo, D.T., Stress, M.E., Fuerst, D.R., Sciences, 53, M147–M154.
& Ginsburg, K.A. (1998). Explicit memory in Vink, M., & Jolles, J. (1985). A new version of the Trail
pregnant women. American Journal of Obstetrics Making Test as an information processing task.
and Gynecology, 179, 731–737. Journal of Clinical Neuropsychology, 7, 162.
Klein, M., Ponds, R.W., Houx, P.J., & Jolles, J. (1997). Wechsler, D. (1958). The measurement and appraisal
Effect of test duration on age-related differences in of adult intelligence. Baltimore: Williams &
Stroop interference. Journal of Clinical and Experi- Wilkins.
mental Neuropsychology, 19, 77–82. Welch, J. (1991). Labouring brains. BMJ, 303, 253.