CRM - Comparison 2006
CRM - Comparison 2006
BizAutomation CRM
+ Business
Question ACT! Management Centric CRM Commence RM Epicor CRM 7.3.6 Epicor CRM 8.4.1
Contact
Name ACT! Sales & Support Carl Zaldivar Michael Harvey Commence Sales Melissa Almquist Melissa Almquist
877-501-4496 (< 5
copies) 866-421-7752
(corporate licensing, 5
Telephone copies+) 408-705-4370 757-627-8977 732-380-9100 952-417-5000 952-417-5000
customerinquiry@act.c carl@bizautomation.co
Email om m mharvey@centriccrm.com malmquist@epicor.com malmquist@epicor.com
www.bizautomation.co
Website www.act.com m http://www.centriccrm.comwww.commence.com www.epicor.com www.epicor.com
(based on ACT!
Licence based Premium)
Average cost per user $400 $399 $400 $495 $1,500 $1,500
Average number of users 12 10 100 10 20 50
Average cost $4,800 $3,990 $40,000 $4,950 $30,000 $75,000
Average Implementation costs /
licence costs 0.50 3.00 0.25 0.50 0.50
Average implementation costs $0 $1,995 $120,000 $1,238 $15,000 $37,500
Total $4,800 $5,985 $160,000 $6,188 $45,000 $112,500
BizAutomation CRM
+ Business
Question ACT! Management Centric CRM Commence RM Epicor CRM 7.3.6 Epicor CRM 8.4.1
Recurring costs
Average annual fee / user $50
Average number of users 10 10
Applications (Yes/No/Partly/Third
party/By next year/Customization)
Contact management Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Sales force automation Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Marketing automation Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Partly
Services management Third party Yes Yes Yes Third party Third party
Call centre Third party Partly Yes Yes Yes Yes
Knowledge management Third party Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Business intelligence Third party Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Financial system Yes Yes Third party No Yes No
Distribution system Third party Yes Third party Yes Yes No
Manufacturing system Third party No Third party Yes Yes No
Profile
Newcastle-Upon-
World head office Thyme, UK Redondo Beach, CA Norfolk, VA, USA New Jersey, USA Irvine, CA Irvine, CA
Canadian head office Mississauga, ON Mississauga, ON Mississauga, ON
BizAutomation CRM
+ Business
Question ACT! Management Centric CRM Commence RM Epicor CRM 7.3.6 Epicor CRM 8.4.1
Target market
1- 10 43%
11 - 100 36%
101 - 1000 14%
Average no. of employees/customer 1,001+ 7% 20 500 100 200
BizAutomation CRM
+ Business
Question ACT! Management Centric CRM Commence RM Epicor CRM 7.3.6 Epicor CRM 8.4.1
Technology
Database (approximate % of
implementations)
Microsoft SQL Server 100% Yes 50% 10% 100% 100%
Oracle 10%
Pervasive SQL
IBM DB2 15%
Sybase
Informix
BizAutomation CRM
+ Business
Question ACT! Management Centric CRM Commence RM Epicor CRM 7.3.6 Epicor CRM 8.4.1
Access
Btrieve
Proprietary 90%
FoxPro
Progress
Other 25%
Total 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Networks supported (approximate % of
implementations)
Microsoft 100% Yes 50% 100% 100% 100%
Linux 50%
Unix
AIX
Novell Netware
IBM AS/400 (OS/400)
Other
Total 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Accounting links to
Peachtree, Simply
Accounting,
BusinessWorks, MAS
Integration with ERP or accounting 90 and Quickbooks Epicor Enterprise,
systems - which? available Yes Vantage and Avante No
% of application available from browser, ACT! by Sage
not including use of Citrix or Terminal Premium for Web 2006
Services available soon 100% 10% 0%
ACT! by Sage
Premium for Web 2006
Expected date for Web-based version available in Q106 Shipping Available as of 5/06 Version 8.4.1 Today
BizAutomation CRM
+ Business
Question ACT! Management Centric CRM Commence RM Epicor CRM 7.3.6 Epicor CRM 8.4.1
Features
Business intelligence Third party Yes Yes Yes No
Analyse performance related to CRM Third party Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
KPIs Third party By next year Yes Yes Yes No
Forecasts of customer behaviour Third party Yes By next year Partly Yes Yes
Contact management Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Multiple criteria used to create list for
mail merge Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Mass update noting all clients that
were updated Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Multiple addresses per contact Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Identify potential duplicates for new
contact Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Duplicate merge process Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes
Audit trail Yes Partly Yes Yes Yes
Date and person making change Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Full audit trail with what was
changed Yes By next year Yes Partly Yes Yes
Unlimited follow-ups with contact Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Unlimited notes per contact with
date/time stamp Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Search for embedded text in notes Yes Yes Yes Partly Yes Yes
Two steps to delete contact Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Contact hierarchy Yes Yes Yes Yes
BizAutomation CRM
+ Business
Question ACT! Management Centric CRM Commence RM Epicor CRM 7.3.6 Epicor CRM 8.4.1
No - Using Exchange
SMTP Services for
email blasts is
considered a bad
practice both by
Microsoft and
BizAutomation and
Use Microsoft Exchange Server for e- can damage the
mail blasts Yes Exchange server By next year Yes Yes Yes
Use an SMTP Server for e-mail blasts Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
BizAutomation CRM
+ Business
Question ACT! Management Centric CRM Commence RM Epicor CRM 7.3.6 Epicor CRM 8.4.1
Multiple relationships for each contact Yes Partly Yes Yes Yes Yes
Primary relationship Yes Yes Yes Yes Third party Yes
Four secondary relationships Yes No Yes Yes Third party Yes
Ten secondary relationships Yes Yes Yes Yes Third party Yes
Each relationship is a contact (set up
once) Yes Yes Yes Yes Third party No
Online
Can forward/re-assign support calls Yes Partly Yes Yes Yes Yes
BizAutomation CRM
+ Business
Question ACT! Management Centric CRM Commence RM Epicor CRM 7.3.6 Epicor CRM 8.4.1
Ability to set priorities and severities Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Dispatching Yes Yes Yes No Third party No
Synchronization
Palm Pilot Yes By next year Yes No No
Windows CE Yes By next year Yes No Yes
BlackBerry Third party Yes Yes No Yes
Microsoft Outlook Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Lotus Notes Yes By next year No Yes Yes
BizAutomation CRM
+ Business
Question ACT! Management Centric CRM Commence RM Epicor CRM 7.3.6 Epicor CRM 8.4.1
Change field captions and headings Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Add new sub-form and push buttons Yes Customization By next year Customization Yes Yes
Apply to all or selected users Yes By next year Yes Yes Yes
Work flow Yes Yes Yes Yes
Alerts - e.g., if date for follow-up is
missed Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Electronic routings if approval
required Yes Partly Yes Yes Yes Yes
All-in-one capability -
Seamless online/offline BizAutomation is a total Action plans: Easily Email marketing and
capabilities when used e-business suite, build "best practices" advanced surveys
with ACT! for Web; containing an end-to- into a standardized, .NET architecture with
sync with Palm, Pocket end pre-integrated graphical workflow for Support for Integrated with Epicor opt-in and opt-out, click
Unique/important feature no. 1 PC, BlackBerry feature set. any user disconnected client ERP solutions tracking.
BizAutomation CRM
+ Business
Question ACT! Management Centric CRM Commence RM Epicor CRM 7.3.6 Epicor CRM 8.4.1
Fusion (deep
integration) with Open Source: Easy to Email marketing and
One-click export to Microsoft Exchange, deploy & maintain; low advanced surveys Smart client, therefore
Microsoft Excel for Microsoft Outlook, and cost of ownership; .NET architecture with feature rich
easy data analysis and Outlook Web Access flexible; enhanced Complete opt-in and opt-out, click presentation while
Unique/important feature no. 2 reporting (OWA) control customization tracking. Web-based operation.
Vendor Exact Software FrontRange Solutions Infor Microsoft NetSuite, Inc. Sage Software
Version 363 Corporate Edition 7.0 "3.0" 11 v7
Release date (mmm-yy) Jul-06 Jan-06 April 2006 - June 2006 Dec-05 Spring 2006 Sep-06
Contact
Name Sales Kevin Smith Patric Timmermans Frank Falcone Tracy Matsumoto Sales & Support
Includes workflow,
document mgmt, HRM,
Licence based project management
Average cost per user $1,500 $700 $1,000 $795
Average number of users 20 15 40 30
Average cost $30,000 $10,500 $40,000 $23,850
Average Implementation costs /
licence costs 0.75 0.75 1.00
Average implementation costs $22,500 $7,875 $40,000 $0
Total $52,500 $18,375 $80,000 $23,850
Applications (Yes/No/Partly/Third
party/By next year/Customization)
Contact management Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Sales force automation Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Marketing automation Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Services management Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Third party
Call centre Yes Yes Yes Third party Yes Yes
Knowledge management Yes By next year Yes Yes Yes Yes
Business intelligence Yes Third party Yes Yes Yes Yes
Financial system Yes Third party Yes Yes Yes Yes
Distribution system Yes No Yes Yes Yes Third party
Manufacturing system Yes No Yes Yes Third party Third party
Profile
Newcastle-Upon-
World head office Delft, The Netherlands Dublin, CA Atlanta, GA Redmond, WA, USA San Mateo, CA Thyme, UK
Canadian head office Cambridge, Ontario Toronto, ON Toronto, ON Mississauga, ON Toronto, ON Mississauga, ON
Target market
Technology
Database (approximate % of
implementations)
Microsoft SQL Server 100% 70% Yes 100% 90%
Oracle Yes 100% 10%
Pervasive SQL Yes
IBM DB2 Yes
Sybase No
Informix No
Access No
Btrieve
Proprietary
FoxPro
Progress
Other 30%
Total 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Networks supported (approximate % of
implementations)
Microsoft 100% 80% Yes 100% 100%
Linux Yes 100%
Unix Yes
AIX Yes
Novell Netware 15%
IBM AS/400 (OS/400) Yes
Other 5%
Total 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Microsoft Dynamics
Exact Globe products and other Sage MAS ERP, Sage
Enterprise, Exact EPR integrations Accpac ERP, Great
Integration with ERP or accounting Macola ERP, Exact supplied with third- Plains, see Website for
systems - which? MAX, Great Plains Intuit Various Infor ERP party integrations NetSuite full listing
% of application available from browser,
not including use of Citrix or Terminal All customer centric,
Services 100% 100% most end-user 100% 100% 95%
Expected date for Web-based version Released N/A Available Available today 100% Web-based Web client available
Limited,
SageCRM.com is
Sage's main hosted
Approx. no. of implementations 100's CRM application
Features
Business intelligence Yes Third party Yes Yes Yes Yes
Analyse performance related to CRM Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
KPIs Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Forecasts of customer behaviour Partly Yes Yes Yes No Third party
Contact management Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Multiple criteria used to create list for
mail merge Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Mass update noting all clients that
were updated Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Multiple addresses per contact Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Identify potential duplicates for new
contact Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Duplicate merge process Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Audit trail Yes Yes Yes Third party Yes Yes
Date and person making change Yes Yes Third party Yes Yes
Full audit trail with what was
changed Yes Yes Third party Yes Yes
Unlimited follow-ups with contact Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Unlimited notes per contact with
date/time stamp Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Search for embedded text in notes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Two steps to delete contact Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Contact hierarchy Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Use an SMTP Server for e-mail blasts Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Multiple relationships for each contact Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Primary relationship Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Four secondary relationships Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ten secondary relationships Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Each relationship is a contact (set up
once) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Online
E-commerce - orders, check status… Yes No Yes Third party Yes Third party
Self-serve - access product support
information… Yes No Yes Third party Yes Yes
Prospects respond online Yes No Yes Third party Yes Yes
Register for seminars Yes No Third party Customization Third party
Order processing Yes Third party Yes Yes Yes Yes
Quotes Yes Third party Yes Yes Yes Yes
Orders Yes Third party Yes Yes Yes Yes
Invoices Yes Third party Yes Yes Yes Yes
Sales force automation Yes Third party Yes Yes Yes Yes
Track status of opportunity Yes Third party Yes Yes Yes Yes
Proposal generation Partly Third party Yes Yes Yes Yes
Security Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
By employee Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
By role Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Services management Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Maintain contract Yes Yes Yes Yes Customization Yes
Can forward/re-assign support calls Yes By next year Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ability to set priorities and severities Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Dispatching Partly Yes Yes Yes Customization Yes
Synchronization
Palm Pilot Third party By next year Partly Yes Yes
Windows CE Yes By next year Yes Customization Yes
BlackBerry Third party Yes Third party Yes
Microsoft Outlook Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Lotus Notes No No Yes Third party Customization Yes
Change field captions and headings Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Add new sub-form and push buttons Customization Yes Yes Yes Yes
Apply to all or selected users Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Work flow Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Alerts - e.g., if date for follow-up is
missed Yes Yes Yes No Yes
Electronic routings if approval
required Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Contact
Licence based
Average cost per user $545 $2,380
Average number of users 21 10
Average cost $11,445 $23,800
Average Implementation costs /
licence costs 0.75 1.00
Average implementation costs $8,584 $23,800
Total $20,029 $47,600
Recurring costs
Average annual fee / user $828 $528
Average number of users 11 23
Applications (Yes/No/Partly/Third
party/By next year/Customization)
Contact management Yes Yes Yes Yes
Sales force automation Yes Yes Yes Yes
Marketing automation Yes Yes Yes Yes
Services management Yes Yes Yes Yes
Call centre Yes Yes Yes Third party
Knowledge management Yes Yes Yes Yes
Business intelligence Third party Yes Yes Yes
Financial system Yes Yes Third party Yes
Distribution system Third party Yes Yes Yes
Manufacturing system Third party Yes No Yes
Profile
Newcastle-Upon-
World head office Thyme, UK Halifax, NS, Canada San Francisco, CA Waldorf, Germany
Canadian head office Mississauga, ON Halifax, NS, Canada Toronto, ON Toronto, ON
Target market
$5 million to $100
Average revenue/customer (CAD) $5M - $250M $8M million annual revenue
Technology
Database (approximate % of
implementations)
Microsoft SQL Server 90% Yes 100%
Oracle 6% Yes
Pervasive SQL Yes
IBM DB2 3% Yes
Sybase 1% Yes
Informix No
Access Yes
Btrieve Yes
Proprietary No
FoxPro No
Progress Yes
Other Yes - PostgreSQL
Total 100% 100%
Networks supported (approximate % of
implementations)
Microsoft Yes Yes 100%
Linux No Yes
Unix No Yes
AIX No Yes
Novell Netware No Yes
IBM AS/400 (OS/400) No Yes
Other No
Total 100%
Features
Business intelligence Third party Customization Yes Yes
Add new sub-form and push buttons Customization Yes Yes Partly
Apply to all or selected users Yes Yes Yes Partly
Work flow Yes Yes Yes
Alerts - e.g., if date for follow-up is
missed Yes Yes Yes Yes
Electronic routings if approval
required Yes Yes Yes Yes
Integrated sales,
marketing and Integrated CRM for
customer care; easy AJAX enabled user customer service, Business alerts &
Unique/important feature no. 2 customization interface sales, marketing notifications