COUKSLOUTi-INF-

(-iuilfr.,."Jr'"

{s s ista nt .!o Ii.ito. (-1. n. r.,| \'t a rissa pl a ca...ig-f u iI|.'',

2010-2011

ReferenceBook: Regolodo,F.RemedialLow Compendium,Vol. 7

of RemedialLaw
l. GeneralPrinciples -'

A) DifferencebetweenSubstantiveLawand ProcedureLaw
. B e rn a b evs A l e j o ,7 4 SCRA180
B) Objectiveof ProceduralLaw
. K ovs P N B G.R, .N o s.1691,1,- 32,
Januar y20,2006
C) Applicationof ProceduralLaws
. S p s.D e l o sS a n to svs v dade Mangubat, G.R.No.149508,October10,2007
. B o rrevs C A ,1 5 8S C RA 560 ( 1988)
c C A ,G.R .No. L4l- 530,
R e p u b l ivs Mar chL8,2003
. Ma g a l l a n evs
s S u nY at Sen ElementarSchool,
y G.R.No. 160876,Januar y
19,2009

l l . J u r i sd i cti o n

A) Laws:

1) A rt.8 , S e c.1 , 1 9 8 7C onstitution

2) B a ta s P a mb a n saBldg., L29 ( ' An Act Reor ganizinlthe Judic i ar y ,
A p p ro p ri a ti nFgu n d sTher eforand , fr otherpur poses")
3) R A N o . 7 9 0 2(" A nA c t Expanding the Jur isdiction of the Cour tof Appeal s ,
A me n d i n g fo r th e p u rposeSection9 of B.P.129"1
4) R A 7 6 9 1 ('A n A ct Expanding the Jur isdiction of the M etr opolitanT r i al
C o u rts,Mu n i ci p aTl ri alCour tsand MunicipalCir cuitTr ialCour ts,Amen di ng
th e P u rp o se o f B .PL. 29"\
5 ) S C A d m i n i s t r a t i vNeo . 0 9 - 9 4( " G u i d e l i n ei sn t h e l m p l e m e n t a t i oonf R A
769r"\
6) R A 8 6 9 ('A n A ct E s tablishing FamilyCour ts,Gr antingthem Exc l us i v e
O r i g i n a l J u r i s d i c toi o
ven rC h i l da n d F a m i l C
y ases")
7) S e c.5 .2 ,C h a p telrl o R.A.8799( "TheSecur ities Code)
S ) S .CA . .M. N o .0 1 -2 -04- SC ( "lnter imRulesof Pr ocedur es for Intr a- Corpor ate
Controversies")
. R e a dC a l l e j vs a P anday, G.R.No. 168696,Febr uar 28,2006 y
9 ) A .M. N o .0 8 -0 -7R u l esof Pr ocedurfor e SmallClaim s( October0L, 2008)

Page1 of 18
B ) B a si cP ri n ci p l e s

of the par ties

n n fe rredby law and not by agr eement
1 ) Ju ri sd i cti oco
. S p o u seAs tu e lvs Spouses Valdez,G.R.No. 139561- , 10,2003
June
. Zamoravs CA,183 SCRA279
2 ) D e te rmi n ebdy th e l aw in for ceat the tim e of com m encem ent
. D e l aC ru zvs Mo ya,10 SCRA 838
3 ) D e t e r m i n ebdy t h e a l l e g a t i oonf t h e c o m p l a i not r o t h e ri n i t i a t o r py l e a d i n g
. C h i n gv s M a l a y a1, 5 3S C R A 412
. T i me ,In c.vs R e yes, 39 SCRA 303 ( 1971)
4 ) Ju ri sd i cti oonve rth e par ties
. Agravante vs Patriarca, 183SCRA113
. N a va l evs C o u rto f Appeals, G.R.No. L09957,Febr uar 20, y L996
5 ) D i ffe re n ce b e tw e e nJur isdiction and Exer cise of Jur isdiction
. Platinum . o .1 3 3 3 6 5S, e p t e m b e1r6 ,2 0 0 3
T o u r sv s P a n l i l i oG, . R N
6 ) D i ffe re n ce b e tw e e nJur isdiction andVenue
. D a va oL i g h ta n d PowerCo.,Inc.vs Cour tof Appeals, 363SCRA 396
. N o cu mvsT a n ,G.R.No. 145022,Septem ber 23,2005
7) Paymentof DocketFees
. ManchesterDev't.Corp. VsCA,19 SCRA562 (May7, L987)
. S u nIn su ra n ce vs Asuncion, L7OSCRA 274 ( 1989)
. B a ra n g aPyi a pvs i Talip,G.R.No. 138248, Septem ber 7,2O05
. P R O T OP Ni l i p i n aCs o r p o r a t i ovns B a n q u eN a t i o n a l eD e P a r i sG , . R .N o .
1,5L242, June15,2005
' S p o u sedse L e o nv s CA,287SCRA 94
. T o ki o Ma ri n e MalayaInsur anceCo., Inc. vs Jor geValdez,G.R . N o.
1 5 0 1 0 8Ja, n u a ry28,2OO8
. L u vs L u ,G.R .N o. 1- 53690/G.R. No. L5738t/G.R. No. t70889,Augus t4,
2009
8) Staggered DocketFee
. S p s.Gre g o ri o Go andJuanaTanGovs Tong,G.R.151942,Novem e b r 27,
2003
. A M N o , 0 4 -2 -0 4- SC, Re:Amendmentof Section21' ( i\,Rule141 o f the
R u l e so f C o u rt[A.M .No.04- 2- 04- SC, AugustL6,2004]by Clar ifyi ng the
Ma n n e ro f P a ymentof the Incr eased Feesfor Cor por ateRehabi l i tati on
P e ti ti o n s,T a ki n gInto Accountthe Cour t' slssuance in Amendmenton
th e C l a ri fi ca ti oon n the LegalFeesto be Collected in Casesof Cor por ate
R e h a b i l i ta ti o[A.M
n . No. 00- 8- ]- Q- SC, Decembert0, 2021,Septem ber
19,2006
9 ) A d h e re n ce to Ju ri sdiction; Jur isdiction cannotbe ousted
Leevs MTCof Legaspi City,1-45SCRA408
. D i o q u i n vos C r u z t, L 6 S C R A 451(1982)
. R a mo svs C e n tralbank,41 SCRA 565

Poge2 of 18
 10 )E ffe ct o f l a cko f Ju ri sdiction
. A b b a i nvs C h u a 22SCRA748
,
. Mu n i ci p a l i ty o f A ntipolovs CA,133SCRA 320
. Estoesta, Sr.vs CA,I79 SCRA203
. S u a re vs z C A ,1 8 6SCRA 339
. T i j a mvs S i b o n g hanoy, et. al.,23 SCRA 29 ( 1968)
L 1 )S u s p e n d eJdu r i s d i c t i o n
. PALvs Kurangking, 389 SCRA588 ..
1-2 )H i e ra rch o fyC o u rts .'
. Ou a n ovs P GT TInter national Investment Cor p.( 384SCRA 589)
. A g a ne a li r T e r m i n a l G
, t . a l .V s P h i l i p p i nIen t e r n a t i o nA s ,. R .N o . l - 5 5 0 0 1 ,
Ma y 5 , 2 0 0 3

s to 6 , R OC
l l l . R u l e1 , S e cti o n 1
. Redefra vs CA,G.R.No. 1,466L1., February06,2007
. V d ad e V i cto ri avs CA,G.R.No. 147550, Januar y06,2007
. H e r n a n d evzs R u r aB 75
l a n k8, 1 S C R A
- . Govs U C P BG.R , .No. LGL87, Novem bert1' ,2004
. P e d e ra n gvs a H o n.Buissan, G.R.No.L- 49475 28,1993
Septem ber
. P h i l i p p i nN
e a ti o nalBankvs Cour tof Appeals, 153SCRA437( 1987)
. Tesorero vs Mathay,185SCRA328
Ma n i l aH o te lvs CA,384SCRA 515

lV. Rule2, Sectionl to 6

' R e b o l l i dvs
o C A ,170SCRA 800 ( 1989)
. D eGu zma nJr vs lAC,192SCRA 507( 1990)
. BaliwaT Incvs.Ople,171-SCRA
g ra n si t, 250 ( 1989)
. B a ch ra ch 68 Phils287
Mo to rsvs lcar angal,
. A g u sti nvs B a ca l an,135SCRA 340 ( 1985)
. 144SCRA
F l ro e svs Ma l l a re- Philipps, 377 ( L986)
' S p s.D e ce n avs S ps.Piquer o, G.R.No. L55736,Mar ch31,2005

V. Rule3 - Section1 to 3: Partiesto a CivilAction

. l ro na n dS te e A l u thor ityvs CA,249SCRA 538 ( 1995)
. T ra veWil d eA ssociated Sales,Inc.vs CAL99SCRA 205( 1991)
. R a l avs R a l l a1, 9 9SCRA 495 ( 1991)
. T a mp i n g co vs l A C,207SCRA 652
. H o u sel n te rn a tionalBuildingTenantsAssoc.vs lAC, 151 SCRA703
(1e87)
o P a scu avs l P a scual, G.R.No. 157830,Novembert7,2005
' Go l a n g ovsJo n eB. Fung,G.R.No. 157952, September 8,2009
. . E q u i ta b l eP C IB ank,Inc. ( now known as BancoDe Or o- EPCl,lnc .)v s

Poge3 of 18
 H e i rso f A n to n i oC.Tiu,et. al.,G.R.No. L78529,
Septem ber
04,2009

Vl. Rule3, Sections4 to 6: Partiesto a CivilAction

. Wongvs lAC,200 SCRA792
. B e g o sa
vs C h a i rm an,
PVA,32 SCRA 66 ( 1970)
. Mo b i lP h i l vs. Ar r astr e( 18SCRAIL20)( 1966)
. C ustom s,
. A me ri ca nE xp re ssCo.vs Santiago, 49 SCRA 75 ( 1.973)
. P a n tra n co G.R.No. 14Q746,
vs B u ncan, Mar ch1.6,2005

Vll. Rule3, Sections7 to 12 (Partiesto a Civilnction)

. L o za n o vs B a l l e ser os,
L95SCRA 681 ( 1991)
. D a e lvsT e ve s, 1 3 6SCRA199( 1- 985)
. S e n ovs Ma n g u bat,156SCRA11- 3( 1987)
. L o tteP h i l svs D e laCr uz,G.R.No. 1,663302,
July28,2005
. Qu i o mb o n vs g C our tof Appeals, L89SCRA 325 ( 1990)
. D o mi n g ovs S ch eer421 , SCRA 468
. C h u avsT o rre s, G.R.No. 151900,August30, 2005
- . L i a n a 's
S u p e rmaar ket vs NLRC,G.R.No. 1,LI0L4M ay 3 j- ,1995
. R e p u b l ivs
c C a mpos, G.R.No.84895,May4, t989

Vlll. Rule3, Sections13 to 19: Partiesto a CivilAction

. C h i a n gK a iS h e kSchoolvs CA,G.R.No.58028,Apr il18,1989

. A tty.L a vi n a vs C our tof Appeals, 171SCRA 691( 1989)
. L a w a svs C A ,1 4 6SCRA173( 198)
. Vda.De Salazar vs CA,G.R.No. I2I5L0
. B o n i fa ci oe,t. a l .Vs Hon.Dizon,et. al.,( 1989)
. T h e H e i rso f th e the late Flor entina Nuguidvda de Haber ervs CA ,104
scR As3 4 (1 9 8 1 _)
. Atty.RogelioE.Sarbasa vs Fevda de Te,represented by her Attorney-in-
fa ctF a u sti nC o a stafieda, G.R.No. 175910, July30,2009
. D a g a d avsg T o n gnawa, G.R.No. 161166- 67, Febr uar03, y 2005
' C a r a n d a nvgs H e i r so f Q u i r i n od e G u z m a nG, . R .N o . 1 6 - 3 4 7N
, ovember
29,2006

lX. Rule3, Sections18 to 22: Partiesto a CivilAction

. R u mu a l d evs z T i glao,G.R.No. 51.I5L,July24,I98t
. T h eB o a rdo f L i quidatorvss Heir sof M aximoM . Kalaw20 SCRA19 67
. A g u a svs L l e mo s5, SCRA 595

Page4 of L8
X. Rule4 Venue
. Govs U C P Be, t. al.G.R.No. L56I87,November' 1,L,2004
. S a l u d ovs.a me ri canExr ess, G.R.No. L59507, Apr il16,2006
. H o e ch stP h i l i p pines, 83 SCRA297( 1978)
Inc.petitionervs Tor r es,
. S u ri g a o C e n tu rySawmillvs CA,218SCRA 623
. P h i l i p p i nB
e a n ki ng vsTensuan,
Cor por ation 230SCRA4L3( 1994)
. Ge smu n dvs o JR BRealtyCor por ation,234 SCRA153( 1994)
. P h i l .B a n ko f C o mm er cevs Lim ,G.R.No. 159507, Apr ilL9,2006
. U n i te dOve rse as Bankvs Rosem or M inngand Dev' t,G.R.No. 159669

Xl. Rule5: UniformProcedurein TrialCourts

L a w :R u l eo n S u mma ryP rocedur(eSCResolution
dateOctober15,1991)

A . M .N o . 0 2 - 1 1 - 0 9 - S C

S e c.L A (2 )o f th e R e vi se d Ruleson Summ ar yPr ocedur es is amendedto r e adas

f o l lo w s:
'(2 ) A l l o th e r c ases,except pr obate pr oceedings, wher e the total
a mo u n to f th e plaintiff' sclam does not exceedon hundr edthous and
p e so s(P 1 0 0 ,0 00.00) or , two hundr edthousandpesos( P200,00 0.00) in
Me tro p o l i ta Manila,
n exclusive of inter estan cost"
T h ea me n d me nto t o k e ffe c ton November25,2002

. y C A ,2 24SCRA
B a yu b avs 557 ( 1993)
. Januar31,
A,M . No.MTJ- 99- 1226,
L u ca svs F a b ro s, y 2000
. B o n g a to
vs Ma l v arG.R.
; No.1,4L614,August1.4,2002
. P a scu avsl Jo ve llanos, 390SCRA 333
. L u n avs Mi ra fu e ne,A.M. No.MTJ- 05- I- 610,
September 26,2005
. vs B P l ,G.R.No.L75490,September
Ma ca l i n o l- 9,2009

X l l . R u l e5 : K i n so f P l e a d i n g s
. C a l ovs A j a x,2 2 SCRA 996 ( 1968)
. R e ye vs s C A ,3 8 SCRA138( 1971)
. C h a nvs C A ,2 3 0SCRA 685
. ICTSIvs CA,214 SCRA456 (1992)
. Me ta l sE n g i n e er ing r esour ces vs CA203SCRA273lt992l
Cor por ation
. C o j u a n g co vs V i l legas,et. al. 184SCRA 374 ( 1990)
. A g a n avs L a g man, G.R.No. 139018,Apr il1,1,,2005
. S i n g a p o re A i rl n esvs CA,243SCRA143( 1995)

Page5 of 18
Xlll. R u l e7 : P a rtso f P l e adings
. Qu i mp ovs D e l aVictor ia, 46 SCRA1,39( L972)
. Buenaventura vs Uy,et., L49SCRA22 (L987)
. S a mme rOve rseas Placem ent
Agency,lnc.vs Mildr edR. Santose, t. al .
G.R.No. 152579,August4,2009
. B u a nvs L o p e z,G.R.No.75349,October13,L986
. S h p si d eIn c.vs C A,G.R.No. t43377,Febr uar 20,2001. y
. L o q u i svs Offi ceof he Om budsm 4pr August
, 2000
. D o e n av s L a p e s u r a , 3 5S5C R A658
. S to .T o ma sU n i ver sity vs Sur la,294SCRA 382 ( 1998)
. C a g a yaV n a l l e yvs Com m issioner of Inter nalRevenue, G.R.No. L5'J .41.3,
F e b ru a ry 1 3 ,2 0 08
. F i d e lO . C h u a a n d F i l i d e nR e a l t ya n d D e v e l o p m e nCt o r p o r a t i o vns
Me tro p o l i ta n B ankand Tr ustCom pany, et. al. G,R.No. 1.8231.L A ugus
, t
19,2009

XlV. R u l e8 : Ma n n e ro f M akingallegations in pleadimngs

Vdade Daffonvs CA,387 SCRA427 (ultimatefact)
. T o ri b i ovs B i d i n ,134SCRA162( 1985)
. B o u g ha n d B o u ghvs Cantiver os, 40 Phil209 ( 1919)
. H i b b e rdvs R h o de,32 Phil476( t9I5\
. Ja b a l d vs
e P N B 7, SCRA79L ( L963\
. CentralSuretyvs CNNHodges,38 SCRAL59(1971)
. C o n so l i d a teBda nkvs Del Monte Motor W or ks,July29,2005,G.R .N o.
1 .4 3 3 3 8
Ju, l y2 9 ,2005
. Me mi tavs Ma songsong, G.R.No. I509I2, May 28,2007
. C a p i toMol to rsvs Yabut,32 SCRA1 ( 1970)
. A n ta mC o n so l i dated, 34 ( 1986)
Inc.et. al.vs CA,et. al. 143SCRA
. Me ri l lL yn chF u tur es, CA,G.R.No.97816,July24,1992
. R e ye vs s R T CB ranch142G.R.No. 165744,August1L,2008

XV.Rule
9
. e r i t i s hC o . ,I n c . ,e t . a l . v s D e l o sA n g e l e s6, 3 S C R A5 0
T h e P h i l i p p i nB
(1s7sl
. D u l o svs C A ,1 -8 8SCRA 413 ( 1990)
. Go ch a n g coe,t. al. vs CFINegr osOccidental, et. al. ( G.R.No. L- 49396,
J a n u a r 1y 5 ,1 9 8 8 )
. In d i a n aA e ro sp ace of HigherEducation,
Univ.vs.Comm ission 356 SC R A
367(2oorl
. Mo n zo nvs L7, 2008
G.R.No. t7L827, Septem ber
, S p s.Relova,

Page6 of 18
XV l . R u l e1 0 :A me n d e da nd supplemental Pleadings
. L e o b re ra vs C A ,G.R.No.8000L,Febr uar27,1989y
. T h eP a sa C y i tyGover nment vs CFl,132SCRA156( 1984)
. Torresvs CA,131SCRA24 (t984\
. V e rso za vs C A ,2 99SCRA100
. Ma g a sp e et. al.,115SCRA1- 93( 1982)
i , t. a l .vs Ram olete,
. MWS Svs C Aa n dthe Cityof Dagupan, 143SCRA 623 ( 1986)
. N o rth e rnC e me ntCor por ation vs..lACand ShipsideIncor por ated
, [G.R .
y 19881
N o .L -6 8 6 3 6F, e br uar 29, .,
. V a l e n zu e vs l a C A,G.R.No. 131175,August28,2001,63SCRA 779
. S p s.L a mb i n ovs Hon. Pr esiding Judge,G.R.No. L69551,Janua r y24,
2007
. P h i l i p p i n eP o r t s A u t h o r i t yv s W i l l i a m G o t h o n g ,G . R . N o . 1 5 8 4 0 1 - ,
Ja n u a ry2 8 ,2 0 0 8

XVll. R u l e1 1 :Wh e nto fi l e r esponsive

Pleadings
. D e lB ro svs l A C ,159SCRA 533
. S p o u seB s a rra zavs Cam pos, L20SCRA 8881( 1983)

XVlll. R u l e1 2 :B i l lo f P a rticular
. S a l i tavs Ma g to l is,233 SCRA100( 1994)
. A g ca n avs s Me rc ado,7 SCRA 688( 1963)
. Santosvs Liwag,101SCRA327 (19801

XlX. R u l e1 : F i l i n g
. B a rra me dvs a C astillo, 78 SCRA ( 1977)
. P N Bvs C F Io f R i zal,209SCRA ( 19921
. H e rn a n d e z, e t. a l. vs The Honor ablePer dr oC. Navar r o,et. al.,48 SC R A
4s (19721
. Qu e l n a nvs V H FG.R. , No. L38500,September 16,2005
. Ga rru ch o vs C A ,G.R>No. L43791- Januar
, y1,4,2007
. SolaT r e a mE n te r tainment vs Ricafor te,203SCRA 661( 1998)
. A me nvs C A ,G.R.No. L43424, August- ,200L
' P e fro so vs D o n a G.R.
, No. 154018,Apr il3,207
. H e i rso f E u g e n i oLopezvs Hon.Enr iquez, G.R.No.146262, Janu ar 21,,
y
2007
. Ga rvi d a Jr .,G.R.No.124893,
vs S a l e s, Apr il18,1997

X X . R u l e1 4 :S u mmo n sS e cs.1 to 14
. P a ra mo u nltn su r anceCor por ation
vs Maximo M. Japzon,et al ., 2L1-
- scRA87e(19921
. , c.vs C astr o,175SCRA1- 71( 1989)
S yj u coIn
. v C h u ,L48SCRA
B o ti ca n o 541 ( 1987)
.

Poge7 of 18
 . P a nA si a ti cT ra vel, Cor p.vs CA,G.R.No.L- 6278t,August1- 9,1988
. Mapavs CA,et. al.,214 SCRA4I7 (1,992)
. S a n d o vavs l H re t,G.R.No. 149380, July3, 2000
. Oa mi n avs l C a stillo, G.R.No.1.52776, October8, 2003
. Masonvs CA,G.R.No.144662, OctoberL3,2003
. Josevs Boyon,G.R.No. L47369,October23,2003
. D o ma g avs s Je n sen, G.R.No. 158407, Januar yt7,2005
. B i a covs P h i l .C o untr yRur al,Bankr .G.R. No.161417,Febr uar8,20 y 07
. B a n ko f t h e P h i l i p p i nles l a n d vs s - S a n t i a gGo.,R .N o . L 6 9 1 1 6M , a r c h2 8 , '
2007
. T h e P h i l i p p i nAe m e r i c a nL i f e& G e n e r aIl n s u r a n cC e o m p a n yv s H o n .
A u g u stoV . B re va,G.R.No. 1.47937, NovemberL1,,2004
. S a n to svs P N OCExplor ation Cor por ation, G.R.No. 170943,Septem ber
23,2008
. A l e xa n d eTr a m Wong vs Cather ineFactor - KoyomG.R. a, No. 1- 83802,
S e p te mb et7 r ,2 009
. S a n s i oP h i l i p p i n e Isn, c .v s S p s .A l i c i aL e o d e g a r iM
o o g o l ,J r . ,G . R .N o .
L77007,july L4,2009
. B D L o n gS p a nB u i l d e r sl,n c . v s R . S .A m e p l o q u i oR e a l t yD e v ' t . ,G . R .
N o .1 6 9 9 1 9S,e p tem ber LL,2009

XXl. Rule14,Secs.15 to 20
. C a ri a gvsa Ma l a ya,143SCRA 441 ( 1986)
. L i ca rovs s L i ca ros,G.R,No. 150656,Apr il29,2003
, . D e Mi d g e l yvs F er andos, 64 SCRA 23 ( 1975\
. Busuegovs CA,151SCRA376 (1987)
. P i n l a cvs C A ,Ja n uar yL9,200L
. Go n za l evs Januar y25,200t
Cor p.G.R.No. 1,49765,
s S ta tePr oper ties

XXll. R u l e1 5 :Mo ti o n sS ecs.1to 10

. D e l aP e n avs D e laPena,258SCRA 298
' Manacopvs CA,215SCRA773 (L992)
. Yapvs CA,115SCRA105
. Azajarvs CA,145SCRA333
. S a rmi e n to vs Z a ralan, Febr uar 5,2007
G.R.No.16747L, y
. AnecoRealtyDev'tvs Landex,G.R.No. 165952,July28, 2008

Xx l l l . R u l e1 5 :Mo ti o nto Dismiss

. V i ta n g co lvs N ew Vista Pr oper ties,Inc. et. al., G.R. No. L7 6014,
S e p te mb e1r 7 ,2 009
. Barraza vs Campos,Jr.I20 SCRA881 (1983)
' . Panganiba l o r p3
v sn P i l i p i n aSsh e C 624
. 9 5S C R A
. . BAFinancevs Pineda,119SCRA493(1982)

Page8 of 18
 . o f B iffanLaguna
Mu n i ci p a l i ty vs CA,219SCRA69
. Guerrerovs RTCof llocos,229 SCRA274
. R a mo svs P e ra l ta, 203SCRA 412
. C h u a vs A n g , G.R. No. I56t64, Septem ber4, 2009 ( excepti onto
e xh a u sti oonf a d ministr ative r emedies)
. A n to n i oN a va rrovs Metr opolitanBankand Tr ustCom pany/Cl ar i P.
ta
N a va rro vs Me tr opolitan Bank and Tr ust Com pany,G.R, N o.
1.65697/G.R. No. 1.56481, August4,2009
. BancoDe Oro-EPCl, G.R.No. 1'81235,July22,
Inc. vs John.-iansipek,
2009

XXIV. Rule17: Dismissal of Actions

. D a e vsl S p s.B e l tr an, G.R.No. 156470,Apr il30,2008
' Go vs Cruz,I72 SCRA247
. Ja o vevs r Y to ri a ga, October28, L977
et. al.,G.R.No.L- 35989,
' V a l l a n g ca
e ,t. a l .vs CA,et. al.,G.R.No.55336,M ay4, 1989
. Mo n te j ovs U ro ti a,40 SCRA 41

XXV. Rule18: Pre-trial

A .M. N o .0 3 -1 -0 9 -S "Rule
C, to be Obser ved
on Guidelines by the Tr ialC our t
and Useof
s n dC l e rkso f Cour tin the conductof Pr e- tr ial
Ju d g e a
D e p o si ti o ni-d measu
sco ve ry r e.

. P h i l i p p i nPe o r t sA u t h o r i t yv s C i t yo f l l o i l o ,G . R .N o . 1 0 9 7 9 I ,J u l y 1 4 ,
2003
. S a r m i e n tvosJ u a n G , . RN . o .L - 5 5 6 0 5J;a n u a r2y 8 ,L 9 8 3
. Alarconvs CA,323 SCRA7L6 (2OO\
. T i uvs Mi d d l e to n,310SCRA 581-
. D u l o svs C A ,1 8 8SCRA 413 ( 1990)
. T ro p i caH l o me sInc.vs Villar uz,et. al., G.R.No. L- 4O628, Febr ua r y24,
1989
. F o u n t a i n h e aI dn t e r n a t i o n aPl h i l i p p i n e sI n, c . v s C A , G . R .N o . 8 6 5 0 5 ,
F e b ru a ry 1 ,1 ,,1 991,
. Saguid vs C A ,G.R.No. 150611, June10,2003
. S o nvs S o n ,G.R .No.73077,December 29,1995
. C o rp u zvs C i ti b ank,N.A, et. al./Citibank, NA vs SpousesAzucenaB.
C o r p u za n d R e n a t oS . C o r p u zG , . R .N o . 1 7 5 6 7 7G , . R 'N o . 1 7 7 1 3 3J, u l y
31.,2009

Poge9 of 18
XXVI. Rule19, Intervention
. P a g ta l u n avs G.R.No. 5428t,Mar ch19,1990
n T am ayo,
. Ma g ysa ysa y-Labr ador vs CA,G.R.No.58168,Decem ber L9,L989
. Ord o n e zvs Gu stilo,192SCRA 469
. Me tro p o l i ta n judge,RTCMani l a,
B ankand Tr ustCom panyvs Pr esiding
1_89 SCRA821

XXVIl. Rule20: Calendarof Cases

. A n gK e kC h e nvs Bello,G.R.No. t- JOZqq- q6,
June30, 1988

X X V l l l . R u l e2 1
. U n i ve rsaRl u b b erPr oducts,
Inc.vs CA,130SCRA104( 1984)
. P e o p l evs Mo n tejo,21-SCRA 722 ( 1967)
. Ge n o rg vsa Qu i ntain,78 SCRA 94 ( 1.977)

XXIX. Rule22
. N a cto rvs l A C ,1 -58SCRA
635 ( 1988)
Ma yo rvs l A C ,1 6 1SCRA 63 ( 1988)
. L u zvs N a ti o n aAmnesty
l G.R.No. 159708,September
Com m ission, 24,
2004
. Neypesvs CA,G.R.No. 141,524, September14,2005

XXX. Rule23: DepositionPendingAction

, A . M .N o .0 3 - 1 - 0 9 - S"CR,u l eo n G u i d e l i n et os b e O b s e r v ebdy t h e T r i a C
l ourt
s n dC l e rkso f Cour tin the Conductof Pr e- Tr ial
Ju d g e a and Useof
D e p o si ti o n -d i sco vm ereasu
y r es.

. Kohvs lAC,L44SCRA259 (1986)

. R e p u b l ivs
c S a n diganbayan, 204SCRA 212 ( L991' )
. C a g u i avs 30 SCRA106( 1969)
t T o rre s,
. o a n dD ev' tCor p.vs CA,G.R.No. t03922,July9, 1996
S a n ti a g L
. V d ad e Ma n g u e rrvs Risos, G.R,No. 152643, August28,2008

XXXI. Rule24-28(other modesof discovery)

. a C A ,G.R .No. 1,02390,
L a fra dvs Febr uar I,2002
y
. M ar ch1' 1' ,2002
; No. 1- 51310,
B a n kC o rp .vs DelAlcazarG.R.
S e cu ri ty
. R o se tevs L i m,G.R .No. 13605,June8, 2006

X X X |l . R u l e2 9
. L o p e zvs Ma ce re n9, 5 SCRA753
F o rtu n eC o rp .vs C A,355 SCRA

Page10 of L8