Important cases of medical negligence in India

A.
 A.Saibaba Goud (Dr.) v. Mrs. L. Thomas, 2002 (1) CPJ 199 (AP SCDRC)

 SAmbi Reddy v. KKR ENT Hospital and Research Institute & Anr. 1997 (3)CPR 316(TN SCDRC)

 A.H. Rizvi (Dr.) v. Ku. Divya Mittal.2001 (3) CPJ 223 (UP SCDRC)

 A.K. HAzarika v. Straight X-Ray& Clinical Lab, Complaint Petition No. 122of 1992, decided on

9.10.93 (Assam SCDRD) (unreported)

 A.K.Pias v. Karithas Hospital. 1992 (1) CPJ 182 (Ker. SCDRC)

 A.M. Mathew V. Director, Kauna Hospital & Ors. 1998 (1) CPJ 476: 1998 (1) CPR 39 (Ker.

SCDRC)

 A.M Mulla (Dr.) V. Mahaksab Ismailsab Nanawada, 1999 (2) CPR 353(Ker. SCDRC)

 A.P, Joseph & Anr. V. Dr. Kunjannamma Mathai & Anr, 1997 (3) CPJ 382(Ker. SCDRC) 551

 A.S.Chandra (Dr.) V. Union of India. (1992) 1 Andhra Law Times 713

 A.S Mittal & Ors. V. State of Up & Ors. AIR 1989 SC 1570:1989 (3)SCC 223:1989(2) JT 419 (SC)

 A.S. Mohanan v. Dr. Joseph George & Ors. 1998 (2) CPR 116: 1998 (2) CPJ 528(Ker. SCDRC)

 A.V Janaki Amma (Amt.) v. Union of India, 2004 (7) CLD 662 (AP-HC)

 Abdul Kadar Suleman Allana v. SAptarshi Medical & Research Centre Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.,2000 (3)

CPJ 258 (Mah. SCDRC)

 Achutrao HAribhau Khodwa & Ors. V. State of Maharashtra & Ors. JT 1996(2)SC 624: AIR 1996

SC 2377: 1996 (2) SCC 634: 1996(2) Scale 328: 1996 (2) Supreme 751:1996 ACJ 505 (SC)

 Adams v. State, 429 P 2d 109, Wash 1967

 Adarsh BAraria (Amt.) v. Dr. P.S. HArdia, 2000 (2) CPR 188 (MP SCDRC)

 Additional Director, C.G.H.S Pune v. Dr. R.L Butani, 1996 (1) CPJ 255 (NCDRC)

 Administrator, Natal v. Edouard, 1990 (3) SA 581

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 1

 Adoration Convert v. Cicily, 2001 ACJ 1605 (Ker.) (DB)

 Ahmed Rashid Abdul Majid Bhuraveala v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd.,1996 (1) CPJ110(AP

SCDRC)

 Air India v. Suganda Ravi Mashelkar, 1993 (1) CPJ 63 (64) (NCDRC)

 Ajay H.Katharia (Dr.) v. Car Mart Pvt. Ltd. & Anr., 2000 (3) CPJ 502(Mah. SCDRC)

 Ajit Kaur (Dr.) v. State of Punjab, 1986 ACJ 696 (P&H-HC)

 Akerele v. The King,[1943] AC 255: 168 LT 102: [1943] 1 All ER 367

 Akhil Bhartiya Grahak Panchayat and Anr. V. Dr. Jog Hospital, 1993 (2) CPR 252:1993 (3) CPJ

1(Mah. SCDRC)

 Akshay Lal jah v. Dr. Shyam Narain Arya, 2003 (1) CLD 125 (Bih. SCDRC)

 Aleymma Varghese v. Dewan Bahadur Dr. V. Varghese & Ors., 1997 (3)CPJ 165(Ker. SCDRC)

 Allan v. Greater Glasgow Health Board, 1998 SLT 580

 Allen v. Bloomsbury Health Authority, (1993) 1 All ER 651

 Alok Kumar Chakraborty v. Dr. Gautam Biswas & Anr., 1996 (2)CPJ 368 (WB SCDRC)

 Alphic Finance Ltd. V. P. Sadasivam and another , 2001 (3) SCC 513

 Altaf Hussain Farooqui v. Dr. Ashok Mathure & Ors., 1998 (1) CPR 427(Mah. SCDRC)

 Amar Jwala Paper Mills (India) and Anr. V. State Bank of India, 1998 (8) SCC 387

 Amar Singh v. Frances Newton Hospital, 2001(1)CPJ8:2001(1)CPR 379(Punj.SCDRC)

 Amblappa v. Sriman D. Veerbhan Hegade, 1999 (3) CPR 72 (Karn. SCDRC)

 Amir Ali Shakir v. St. John’s Medical College Hospital, Bangalore, 1996(1) CPJ 169 1995 (3) CPR

174 (Karn. SCDRC)

 Anil Nadir (Dr.) v. Dr. Rakesh Dullu, 2003 (3) CPR 308: 2003 (3) CPJ 401(Del. SCDRC)

 Anjana Verma v.Dr.Ashok KumarThakur&Ors., 2003 (2) CPR 475:2003 (6) CLD 583 : 2003 (2)

CPJ 210 (Bih. SCDRC)

 Anjani Kumar v. Madras Medical Mission & Anr., 1998 (2)CPJ 308 (TN SCDEC)

 Annam Vijaya Bhaskar Reddy v. (Dr.) V.S Reddy, 2003 (5) CLD 906 (AP SCDRC)
©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 2
 Anthony Dass A. V. Ex. Engineer, Earth Movers Division, BEM, KGF, 1997 (3) CPJ 224(Karm.

SCDRC)

 Anthony v. Grey, (1936) 1 All ER 540

 Anumalla Satyanarayana (Dr.) v. K. Shankar, 2000 (1) CPJ 288: 1999(3) CPR 316 (AP SCDRC)

 Anup K.Ghose v. Dr. T.K. Biswas, 1997 (3) CPJ 469 (WB SCDRC)

 Anup Kumar Jana v. Dr. Pabitra Chaterjee, 1998 (1) CPR 693, (WB SCDRC)

 Anup Kumar v. S.M. Kanwar, 1993 (1) CPJ 45:1993 (1) CPR 113 (NCDRC)

 Anuradha Kapil (Smt.) v. Dr. Suresh, 2001 (1) CPR 336 (MP SCDRC)

 Aparna Doraisamy v. Dr. Anandan, 1999 (2) CPR 5 (TN SCDRC)

 Aparna Dutta v. Apollo Hospital Enterprises Ltd., 2002 ACJ 954 (Mad, HC)

 Aphraim Jayanand Rathod v. Dr. Shailesh Shah, 1996 (1) CPJ 243: 1996 (1) CPR 547(Guj.

SCDRC)

 Archana (Smt.) & Ors. V. Chaudhari Trust Hospital & Ors. , 1998 (1) CRP 556(Mah. SCDRC)

 Archana Paul and etc. Etc. V. State of Tripura & Ors., AIR 2004 Gau.-HC7

 Arizona v. Maricopa Country Medical Society,475 US 332: 73 L.Ed. (2d) 48

 Arun Balakrishanan Iyer and Anr.V.Soni Hospital and others,AIR2003 Mad.-HC 389

 Arun Kumar Mishra v. Dr. Purshottam Singh, 1998 (3) CPR 284: 1998 (3) CPJ 573(Bih. SCDRC)

 Aruna Ben D.Kothari & Ors. V. Navdeep Clinic & Ors. , 1996 (3) CPJ 605(Guj. SCDRC)

 Aruna Mani Mishra Sanchalika Swati Sewa Sanstha Hospital, S.S.S. Hospital Mahmoodabad,

District Sitapur v. Smt. Bhagwati & Anr., 2003(1) CPR 157:2003(1)CPJ 69 (UP SCDRC)

 Aruna Trikha (Smt.) v. Sehra Medical Centre, 2002 (1) CPJ 75 (NCDRC)

 Arvind K. Hemant Lal Shah v. Bombay Hospital Trust, 1992 (2) CPR 154(Mah. SCDRC)

 Ascher v. Gutirrez, 533 F 2d 1235, DC CA 1976

 Asha Rani v. Dr. Rohit Grover & Ors., 1996 (3) CPJ 259 ( Chd. UTCDRC)

 Asha v. Rohini Hospital , 2003 (1) CLD 537 (Del. SCDRC)

 Ashok Kumar v. Dr. Suresh Sharma, 2001 (1) CPJ 478 (Punj. SCDRC)
©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 3
 Ashok Dhawan (Dr.) v. Surjeet Singh, 1997 (1) CPJ 82: 1997 (1) CPR 169 (NCDRC)

 Ashok Kumar Aneja v. Dr. Harish Kohli,2003 (2) CPJ 290:2003 (2) CPR 471(Uttaranchal-

SCDRC)

 Ashok Kumar Choudhary v. Shashi Bhushan Singh, 2004 (1) CPR 8 (Bih. SCDRC)

 Ashok Kumar Singh v.Mohan Thakur, 2000 (2) CPJ 220:2000 (3) CPR 202(Bih. SCDRC)

 Ashpal Singh v. Sher Singh, 2002 (1) CPJ 73 (Del. SCDRC)

 Avtar Singh Bhatora v. Dr. Swarn Prakash Garg, 2001 (1) CPJ 197: 2001 CPR 44(Punj. SCDRC)

B
 B.Ashok Kumar (Dr.) v. Kamma Narasimha Swamy,2003 (3) CLD 670 : 2004 (1) CPJ 55(AP

SCDRC)

 B.Mahidhar Reddy v. Apollo Hospitals, 2003 (6) CLD 373 (AP SCDRC)

 B.Murali Krishna Reddy v. Smt. Dr. E. Adilaxmi, 2003 (5) CLD 672 (AP SCDRC)

 B. NArasaiah (Dr.) v. Kande Laxmaiah, 1998 (1) CPJ 489 (AP SCDRC)

 B.C. Joshi v. Dr. SAndeep Kumar & Ors., 2002 (2)CPJ 125 (Del. SCDRC)

 B.H Tolani v. Rajasthan Housing Board, 1993 (1) CPJ 524 (Raj. SCDRC)

 B.S. Agarwala v. State of Orissa, 1993 (2) CPJ 1066 (Ori. SCDRC)

 B.S Hegde v. Dr. Sudhanshu Bhattacharya, 1993 (3) CPR 414 (NCDRC)

 Babanrao Yadav v. Lion Tarachand Bappa Hospital, 2003 (1) CPJ 365: 2002 (3) CPR329(Mah.

SCDRC)

 Babita Jha v. State of Bihar & Ors., 2002 (3) CPR 392 (Bih. SCDRC)

 Baby Ramya, represented by her father K. Raji Reddy v. Dr. (Mrs.) Aruna Reddy & Anr.,1996 (1)

CPR 244 (AP SCDRC)

 Badri Parsad Rai v. Dr. M.L. Peshin, 2003 (3) CPR 119 (Uttaranchal-SCDRC)

 Bailey v. Belinfante, 218 SE 2d 289, Ga 1975

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 4

 Balbir Singh Makol v. Chairman, M/S. Sir Ganga ram Hospital and Ors., 2000 (1) CPR

45(NCDRC)

 Baldev Singh & Anr. v. Arya Hospital-cum-Daulat ram Memorial Medical Centre & Ors., 1997 (3)

CPJ 528 (Chd. UTCDRC)

 Baleshwar Prasad & Ors. (Dr.) v. Firtu Das Mahant, 2003 (2) CPR 112:2003 (2) CPJ 457

(Jharkhand SCDRC)

 Balwinder Kumar v. Arya Hoapital, 2001 (2) CPR 394 (Chd.- UTCDRC)

 Bandhua Mukti Morcha v. Union of india, (1984) 3 SCC 161: AIR 1984 SC 802

 Basidhar Panigrahi v. Chief Medical Officer, Ganjam and Ors, 1993(1) CPR 94(Ori. SCDRC)

 Barcia v. Society of the New York Hospital,241 NYS 2d 373, NY 1963

 Barkway v. South Wales Transport Co., (1950) 1 All ER 392

 Barnete v. Chelsea and Kensington Hospital Management Committee, (1968) 1 All ER1068\

 Barnnett v. Bachrach, 34 A 2d 626, Dc 1943

 Barrie in moore v. Lewisham Group, HMC (1959)

 Basant Mahadev Samvatsar v. Dr. Sudhir Mahashabde & Ors., 2000 (3) CPR 349 (MP SCDRC)

 Basant Seth & Anr. v.Regency Hospital Ltd.,OP No.99 of 1994,Decided on22.1.2002(NCDRC)

 Baseo v. State of Pepsu, AIR 1956 SC 448

 Basudev Goswami v. Dr. Bhaskar Das & Anr., 2001 (3) CPJ 262 (WB SCDRC)

 Bee Enn General Hospital v. Sunita Kaloo, 2003 (2) CLD 137 (J&K-HC)

 Beena Gark v. Kailash Nursing Home, 2002 (3) CPR 254: 2002 (3) CPJ 99 (NCDRC)

 Behal Hospital & Medical Research Centre, though Manager, Dr. Vinay B. Behal v. Sh. Sahi Ram

& Ors., 2003 (1) CPR 49-2003 (1) CPJ 14 (Raj SCDRC)

 Benarr v. Kettering Health Authority, (1988) 138 NLJ 179

 Beringer v. Lackner, 73 NE 2d 620, III 1947

 Beti Bai Saxena (Smt.) v. Dr. S.L.Mukherjee & Ors.., 2001 (3) CPJ 251:2001(2) CPR 163(MP

SCDRC)
©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 5
 Bhagbat Saran Agarwala & Ors. V. State of Orissa & Ors., 1993 (2) CPJ 1066 (Ori SCDRC)

 Bhagwan DAss Arora v. Dr. Ashok Singal, 1999 (#) CPJ 345 (Punj SCDRC)

 Bhairu lal v. Rajasthan State Electricity Board, 1992 (3) CPJ 1656 (Raj SCDRC)

 Bhajan Lal Gupta v. Mool Chand Kheraiti Ram Hospital, 2001 (1) CPJ 31 (NCDRC)

 Bhal Chandra’s Case, AIR 1968 SC 1319: 1968 Cri. LJ 1501: 1969 ACJ 87 (SC)

 Bhanupal v. Dr. Prakash Padode and Ors., 2000 (2) CPJ 384: 2000 (3) CPR 356 (MP SCDRC)

 Bharat II Gurjar v. Newciti Hospitals, 2003 (1) CLD 1019 (AP SCDRC)

 Bharat Pathology Laboratory v. Mangi Lal Vyas, 2003 (3) CPJ 94 (NCDRC)

 Bhargava Nursing Home v. Mrs.Charan Kamal Kaur,2003(3)CLD 351(Chd.-UTCDRC)

 Bhavchanbhai Manjibhai Lakhani v.Dr.Bhupendra D.SAgar, Complaint No.378 of 1991 Decided

on 26.8.1993 (Guj. SCDRC) (unreported)

 Bhim Singh v. State of J&K, (1985) 4 SCC 677: AIR 1986 SC 494

 Bhiwani Dutta v.P.G.I.Chandigarh,1998(2)CPJ 102: 1998(1)CPR 548(Chd.UTCDRC)

 Bhogi Lal Chimanlal v, Nanavati, AIR 1931 Bom. 409: (1931) 33 Born LR 648

 Bholi Devi v. State of Jammu and Kashmir & Ors., AIR 2002 J&K (HC)65

 Bhupendra Nath Dass v.Maharaj Ram Krishna Mission Seva Pratisthan&Ors.,1998(1) CPJ

377:1998 (2) CPJ (WB SCDRC)

 Biharilal Thavait v. Dr. Prakash Ladikar, 1999 (3) CPJ 535 (MP SCDRC)

 Biju @ Paul Joseph v. Dr. K. Kunhu Mohammed & Ors., 1997 (3) CPJ 316(Ker. SCDRC)

 Birbal Singh & Ors. V. ESI Corporation & Ors., 1993 (2) CPJ 1028

 Birdhi Chand Meena v. Dr. Prabhakar Sethi & Anr., 2003 (1) CPJ 45 (Raj. SCDRC)

 Biswanath Chakraborty(Dr.)v.Mrs.China Sinha&Ors..,2002(2)CPJ 329(WB SCDRC)

 Blyth v. Birmingham Waterworks Co., (1856) II Ex. 781

 Bolam v.Friern Hospital Management Committee,[1957]2All ER 118:1 BMLR 1 (QBD)

 Bolotho administratrix of the Estate of Bolitho v. City and Hackney Health Authority, (1997)4 All

ER 771 Bourgeois v. Davis, 337 So 2d 575, La 1976

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 6
  Bridges v. Directors, etc. Of N.L.RY., (1873-74) LR7 HR.213

 Brij Mohan Kher v.Dr.N.H.Banka and Ors.,1995(1)CPJ 99:1994(3)CPR 140:1994(3)CP 197

(NCDRC)

 Buchan v.Ortho, Pharmaceuticals (Canada) Ltd. Robins, (1986) 25 D.L.R. (4th) 658,669 (Ont; C.A.)

 Bull and another v. Devon AHA, (1993) 4 Med LR 117

 Butler v. Layton, 164 NE 920, Mass 1929

 C. Sivakumar v. Dr. John Arthur & Anr. 1999(1) CPR 367 (TN SCDRC): 1998 (3) CPR 436 (TN

SCDRC)

 C.A Philomina v. Dr. Vijaya Kumar Kodali, 2003(1) CLD 709: 2003 (3) CPJ 403:2003 (3) CPR

485(AP SCDRC)

 C.C. Chaubal (Dr. V. Pankaj Srivastava, 2003 (3) CPR 20: 2003 (5) CLD 871 (NCDRC)

 C.S. Subramanian (Dr.) v. Kumarasamy & Anr. (1994) 1 MLJ 438

 C.V. Mathew (Dr.) V. P. Babu, 2000(1) CPJ 134: 1999 (3) CPR 461 (Ker. SCDRC)

 Calcutta Medical; Research Institute v. Bimlesh Chatterjee & Ors. , 1999 (1) CPR3 (NCDRC)

 Carrigan v. Roman Catholic Bishop, 178 A 2d 502, NH 1962

 Cassel and Co. Ltd. V. Broome, (1962) AC 1027 (HL)

 Cassidy v. Ministry of Health, (1951) 2KB 3641: (1951) 1 All ER 574

 CCI. Chambers Co-op. Housing Society Ltd. V. Development Credit Bank Ltd., AIR 2004 SC 184

 CDR Hospitals v. Smt. Nirmala Manaseh, 2001 (2) CPR 69 (NCDRC)

 CES v. Superlinics (Australia) Pty. Ltd., (1995) 38 NSWLR 47

 Ch. Padma v. Sudha Nursing Home, 2002 (1) CPJ 53 (AP SCDRC)

 Chaman Singh Faujdar & Ors.V.German Remedies Ltd. & Anr. 1992 (2) CPJ 915 1992(1) CPR

603 (Raj. SCDRC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 7

 Champaben Babul al v. C.V. Shah Medical Centre, 1992(1) CPR 667 (Guj. SCDRC)

 Chanchal Ostwal (Smt.) v. SDM Hospital and Dr.Nimish A. Shah, Decided on 28.11.92 by Raj.

SCDRC (Unreported)

 Chandra Sagar D. Rajput v. Dr. Dinesh J. Shah, 1999 (1) CPJ 434 (Mah. SCDRC)

 Chandrikaben v.Shree Vijay Vallabh Sarvajanik Hospital, 2004 (7) CLD 254(Guj. SCDRC)

 Charan Singh v.Healing Touch Hospital & Ors.2003(2) CPR 95:2003 (3) CPJ 62:2003 (6) CLD 46

(NCDRC)

 Charan Singh v. Healing Touch Hospital, 2000 (3) CPJ 1:2000 (#) CPR 1(SC)

 Charanjit Kaur & Ors.v. Manjit Kaur, 1999 (1) CPR 559 (Punj. SCDRC)

 Cheroth Suhara v. Dr. K.K. Subramanian & Anr. 1995 (1) CPR 258 (Ker. SCDRC)

 Chester v. Afshar, (2002) 3 All ER 552

 Chin Keo v. Government of Malaysia, 1967 ACJ 379 (P.C.England)

 Christian Medical Centre v. A. Shahjahan, 1998 (#) CPJ 242 (AP SCDRC)

 Christy v. Saliterman, 179 NW 2d 288, Minn 1970

Clark v. Reading and District HMC, (1963) 107 SJ 115

 Collins v. Hertfordshire Country Council, (1947) 1 All ER 633

 Commander Sohan Singh Sandhu (Retd.) v. Dr. H.K. Bedi, Cardiology Deptt. & Anr. 1999 (1) CPR

550 (Chd-UTCDRC)

 Commercial Officer, Office of the Telecom District Manager, Patna v. Bihar State Warehousing

Corporation, 1993 (1) CPJ 42 (44) (NCDRC)

 Commissioner, Hindu Religious Endowments Madras v. Sir Lakshmindra Thirtha Swamiar of Sri

Shiur Mutt, 1954 SCR 1005

 Common Cause v. Drug Controller of India, 1991 (2) CPJ 698

 Common Case,A Regd.Society v.Union of India & Ors.,(1999)6 SCC 667:JT 1999(5) SC 237: VII

(1999) CLT 76 (SC): AIR 1999 SC 2979

 Commr. Of Inland Revenue v. Maxse, (1919) 1 KB 647 (657)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 8

  Consumer Education Research Society & Anr. V. Dr. Ratilal B.Patel & Ors. 1994(2) CPJ 342 (Guj.

SCDRC)

 Consumer Protection Council & Anr. V. Parul Clinic Maternity Home and Hospital& Ors., 1996 (2)

CPJ 157: 1996 (!) CPR 585(Guj. SCDRC)

 Consumer Education & Research Centre v. Union of India, 1995 (3) SCC 42

 Consumer Protection Council and Ors. V. Dr. S. Sundaram & Anr.1998(2) CPJ 3 1997(@) CPR

162 (NCDRC)

 Consumer Unity and Trust Society v. State of Rajasthan & Ors., 1992 (1) CPR 259 (NCDRC)

 Consumer Unity and Trust Society v. State of Rajasthan & Ors., 1991 (1) CPR 241 (NCDRC)

 Cook v.J.L Kier & Co. Ltd., (1970) 1 WLR 774: (1970) 2 All ER 513

 Cosmopolitan Hospital Pvt. Ltd. And Anr. V. Vasantha P.Nair and Cosmopolitan Hospital Pvt.

Ltd.V. V.P. Shantha and Ors. 1992 (1) CPJ 302: 1992 (1) CPR 820 (NCDRC)

 Coupland v. Arabian Gulf Petroleum Co. (1983) 3 All ER 226 (CA)

 Crawford v. Charing Cross Hospital, (1953) the Times, 23rd April & 8th Dec

 Crits v. Sylvester, (1956) 1 DLR (2d) 502,508

 Crossman v. Stewart, (1977) 82 DLR (3d) 677

 Croichman v. Burke, (1997) 40 BMLR 163

 Crouch v. Most, 432 P 2d 250, NM 1967

 .
D Savitri Devi v. Medwin Hospitals, 2003 (5) CLD 635 (AP SCDRC)

 D.C Bhawani Parasad v. Krishna Nursing Home.1997 (1) CPJ 483(Karn. SCDRC)

 D.D Trikha (Dr.) v. Dr. Devender Mahant & Ors. 2002 (2) CPJ 116 (NCDRC)

 D.H. Kumari v. Director, Nizam’s Institute of Medical Services, 2003 (5) CLD 805 (AP SCDRC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 9

 D.K Basu v. State of West Bengal, AIR 1997 SC 610

 D’Souza v.Pushpapati Nath Sarkar, 1968 Cri LJ 405 (Cal.)

 Dale v. Muthali, (1976) 78 DLR (3d) 588

 Daly v. Mcneil Laboratories, 509 f 2d 617, CCA 6, 1975

 Darshan Kaur v. Dr. J.S Sodhi & Ors. 1999 (1) CPR 522 (Chd.- UTCDRC)

 Darshan Singh Barsa v. Dr. Jasbir Singh & Ors. , 1998 (2) CPJ 45: 1998 (1) CPR 304 (Punj.

SCDRC)

 Darshini Devi v. Rajeshwar Prashad, 1998 (1) CPJ 358 (HAr. SCDRC)

 Dashrathbhai Keshabhai NAi v. Dr. Pravin C. Patel & Anr. 1998 (3) CPJ 30: 1999 (1) CPR 12

(Guj. SCDRC)

 Davidson v. Connaught Laboratories, (1980) 14 C.C.L.T. 251, 276 (Ont. H.C)

 Davis v. Wilmerding, 24 SE 2d 337, NC 1943

 Daya (Smt.) v. Dr. Rohit Goel & Ors. 2000 (1) CPJ 232 (UP SCDRC)

 Deepak Behl v. Dr. Narendra M. rege, 1999 (3) CPR 11 (Mah. SCDRC)

 Deepak Gokaran v. Chairman, Mahant Gurmukh Singh Charitable Hospital Trust & Anr. , 2003 [1]

CPJ 518 [Del. SCDRC]

 Deramma & Ors. v. Superintendent, Area Hospital & Ors. , 1997 [3] CPJ 613 [AP SCDRC]

 Derr v. Bonney , an American case, 231 p 2d 637, Wash, 1951

 Devendra Kantilal Nayak & Ors. V. Dr.Kalyani Ben Dhruv Shah& Anr., 1997 (1) CPJ 103 (Guj.

SCDRC)

 Devendra Kumar Sharma v. Post gradute Institute of Medical Education & Reseach, 2002 (1) CPJ

211(Chd. UTCDRC)

 Devendra Madan (Dr.) v. (Smt.) Shakuntla Devi, 2003 (1) CLD 447: 2003(1) CPJ 57 (NCDRC)

 Devi Rani v. N Prakash rao & Ors., 2002 (3) CPR 258: 2002(3) CPJ 123 (APSCDRC)

 Dharmendra K.Mishra v. Dr. Akhnri S.Sinha, Medico lab, 1996 (2) CPR 192 (Bih. SCDRC)

 Dharngdhara Chemical Works Ltd. V. State of Saurashtra, 1957 SCR 152 at P. 157
©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 10
  Di Filliopo v. Preseton, 173 A 2d 333, Del 1961

 Dig Vijay Sinh A. Zata v. Dr. Narendra T. Vani & Ors. , 1995 (1) CPJ 186 (Guj. SCDRC)

 Dilbagh Hussain v. Harjinder Kaur, 2000(3) CPJ 17: 2000(3) CPR 467 (Punj. SCDRC)

 Dilip Kumar Biswas v. Mothari Medical Centre, 1999 (3) CPJ 609:2000 (1) CPR 502 (WB

SCDRC)

 Dinesh Kaushal v. Dr. K.K.Khurana, 2002 (1) CPJ 414(Chd.-UTCDRC)

 Dipti De SArkar v. SAIL, 1993 (2) CPJ 1209:1993(1) CPR 640 (Ori. SCDRC)

 Director, Mary Queen’s Mission Hospital Allegry Clinic v. M.J.Jose, 1999 (2) CPR 7 (Ker.

SCDRC)

 District Manager, Telephones, Patna v. Dr. Tarun Bharthuar, 1992 (1) CPJ 47 (49) (NCDRC)

 Divisional Controller, KSRTC v. MAhadeva Shetty, 2003 (7) SCC 197

 Donoghue v, Stevenson, (1932) AC 562 (HL)

 Dudhi Ben Navghanbai v. Dr. Ashok Bhai H. Pathak & Anr. , 1996(2) CPR 69 (Guj. SCDRC)

 Dulieu v. White, (1901) 2 KB 669,P.679

 Edler v. Greenwich & Deptford Hospital, The Times, March 7, 1993

 Elizabeth Rani v. Dr. A.N. HArilal & Ors., 2003 (3) CPJ 149 (TN SCDRC)

 Emeh v. Kensington and Chelsea and Westminster Area Health Authority, (1984) 3 All ER 1044:

(1985) QB 1012

 F. v. R.(1982) 33 SASR 189,201

 Fakhruddin Abbs Bharmal v. Dr. Dasgupta & Ors. , 1998 (3) CPR 365 (Mah. SCDRC)

 Fakir Mohan Bhuyan v. Dr. G.C. Pothal and Ors. , 1999 (1) CPR 140 (Ori. SCDRC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 11

 Feency v. Young, 181 NYS 481, NY 1920

 FORCE v. Dr. M. Ganeswara Rao & Ors., 1998 (3) CPR 251 : 1998(1) CPJ 413 (AP SCDRC)

 Foster v. Englewood Hospital Association,313 NE 2d 255, III 1974

 Fraster v. Vancouver General Hospital, (1951) 3 WWR 337 Affirmed in (1952) 3DLR 785

 Fredette v. Wiebe, (1986) 29 DLR (4th) 534

 Freese v. Lemmon, 210 N.W. 2d 576 (S.C. of lowa) (1973)

 G.Bala Saroj v. C.D.R. Hospital, 2003 (2) CLD 198 (APSCDRC)

 G.Bhart v. Dr. G. Sarangapani (dead) by Lrs, 1997 (1) CPR 466 (AP SCDRC)

 G.Murali (Dr.) v. Moratkal Kalarikkal Janardhanan, 1999 (2) CPR 14 (Ker. SCDRC)

 G.Padmanabhan Nair v. G.M. Kerala State Road Transport Corporation, 1989 ACJ 873(Ker.- HC)

 G.Suresh Kumar v. Director, Nizam Institute of Medical Sciences(NIMS),2003(3) CLD 377 (AP

SCDRC)

 G.D Jiladia (Dr.) v. Minor Dharmistha Chhotubhai Goswami & Anr. , 2003 (2) CPR 490:2003 (2)

CPJ 381: 2004 (8) CLD 87 (Guj. SCDRC)

 G.K.B. Optics & Ors. V. Mrs. Nima Roy, 1996 (2) CPJ 135 (WBSCDRC)

 Gangadharan (Dr.) v. K.A. Abdul Salam, 2003 (3) CLD 40 (Ker. SCDRC)

 Gangapam Ramalinga Reddy v. Appollo Hospital, 2003 (1) CLD 494 (AP SCDRC)

 Ganta Mohana Laxmi v. Dr. C.V. Ratnam, 2003 (6) CLD 360 (NCDRC)

 Gare Devamma & Ors. V. Supdt. Area Hospital & Ors., 1997 (3) CPJ 613 (AP SCDRC)

 Geeta Devi v. Dr. Ketki Gark, 1999 (2) CPR (Punj. SCDRC)

 Geetha Kumari v. Dr. Mrs. Anita Ranjan, 1995 (2) CPR 393 (Ker. SCDRC)

 Ghanshyamdas Bhagwandas v.State of M.P,1997 ACJ 182:1977 Cri LJ 1373(MP-HC)

 Ghisa Ram v. Dr. P.K. Bansal, 2003 (2) CLD 347: 2004 (1) CPR 24 (Del. SCDRC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 12

 Gian Chand Aggarwal (Dr.) v. Darshana Devi, 2002(1) CPJ 351 (Punj. SCDRC)

 Giannarelliv. Wraith, 81 ALR 417

 Giesen, International Medical Malpractice Law (1988), Para 255

 Gill v. Hartfort Accident and Indemnity Co., 337 So 2d 420,Fla 1976

 Gladwell v. Steggall, (1839) 5 Bing NC 733: 8 LJCP 361

 Glare Devamma & Ors. V. Suprintendent, Area Hospital& Anr., 1997 (3) CPJ 613 (APSCDRC)

 Gloning v. Miller, (1954) IDLR 372

 Golia v. Health Insurance Plan of Greater New York, 166 NYS 2d 889, NY,1957

 Goorkani v. Tayside Health Board, [1991] 3 Med LR 33

 Gordon v. Wilson, [1992] 3 Med LR 401

 Governor-General in Council v. M.T. SAliman, (1948) ILR 27 Pat. 207

 Govind Bilumal Sindhi v. Dr. Kiran M. Doshi, 1999 (3) CPR 123 (Mah. SCDRC)

 Govind Ram Aggarwal v. Dr. V.P. Gupta & Anr., 2003 (2) CPJ 110: 2003 (3) CPR

360(Uttarancahal SCDRC)

 Graham v. Sisco, 449 SW 2d 663, Pa 1966

 Gujrat State Road Transport Corparation v. Kamlaben Valjibhai Vora, 2002 (3)TAC 465: 2002

ACJ 780 (Guj.) (DB)

 Gunturu Ajaya Kumar v. Dr. K. Rama Rao, 2003 (6) CLD 785 (AP SCDRC)

 Gurmit Mahal v. Chauhan Nursing Home Pvt. Ltd. & Anr., 1998 (3) CPR405 (Chd.-UT CDRC)

 Gurpreet Kaur v. Dr. R.K. Bhutani, 1993 (3) CPJ 355:1993 (3) CPR 409 (NCDRC)

 Gursewak Kaur v. Dr. Jaskaran Singh, 1996 (3) CPJ 300 (Punj. SCDRC)

 Guru Teg Bahadur Sahib (Charitable) Hospital v. D.K. Nayyar, 2002 (1) CPR 442 (Punj. SCDRC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 13

H

 Hv. Royal Alexandra Hospital forChildren [1990] 1 Med. L.R. 297 (N.S.W.S.C.)

 HAase v. Garfinkel, 418 SW 2d 108, Mo 1967

 Hans Raj v. Dr. K.S. Chugh, 2000(1) CPR 310 (Chd.-UTCDRC)

 Hanuman Dass v. Usha Rani, 1978 ACJ 310

 HArbhajan Singh v. Dayanand Medical College and Hospital & Anr., 1996 (3) CPJ 263: 1994(1)

CPR 518 (Punj. SCDRC)

 Harbhajan v. State of Punjab, AIR 1966 SC 97

 Hardeep Kaur v. (Dr.) (Smt.) Satinder Saluja, 2003 (5) CLD 793: 2003 (2) CPR 415 (MP SCDRC)

 Hari Bhai Leghar Bhai Solanki v. Dr. Suresh Parikh, 1994 (1) CPJ 373 (Guj. SCDRC)

 Hari Kishan v. Sukhbir Singh, (1988) 4 SCC 561 : AIR 1988 SC 2187

 Hari Mohan & Co. V. Kailashpati Pandey, 1994 (1) CPJ 344 (Bih. SCDRC)

 Hari Shanker Singh v. Sukhbir Singh, (1988) 4 SCC 561

 HAri bhai Lagharbhai Salon v. Dr. Suresh Parikh, 1994 (1) CPJ 373 (Guj. SCDRC)

 HAripada Saha v. State of Tripura, 2002 ACJ 1877 (Gau.)

 HArjeet Kaur v. Santokba Durlabhji Memorial Trust, 2003 (5) CLD 1066 (Raj. SCDRC)

 HArjiwanbhai Khoda Bhai Gohil v. Dr. Yogendra D. Shah, 1997 (3) CPR 517 (Guj. SCDRC)

 HArjot Ahluwalia (minor) though his parents v. Spring Meadows Hospital and Ors. 1997 (2) CPJ

98: 1997 (3) CPR 1 (NCDRC)

 Harkanwaljit Singh Saini (Dr.) v. Gurbax Singh , 2003 (1) CLD 611: 2003 (1) CPJ 153 (NCDRC)

 HArris v. Harris, (1973) 1 Lloyds Rep. 445

 Harvinder Kaur v. Dr. (Mrs.) Sushma Chawla & Anr. , 2001(3) CPJ 143 (Punj. SCDRC)

 Hatcher v. Black, Times July 2, 1954

 Hay v. University of Alberta Hospital, [1991] 2 Med LR 204

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 14

 Heaps v. Peerite Ltd., (1937) 2 All ER 60:81 Sol Jo 236

 Health v. Burkshire Health Authority, [1991] 8 BMLR 98 QBD

 Hedley Byrne & Co. Ltd. V. Heller & Partner Ltd., 1964 AC 465: (1963) 2 All ER 575

 Heirs and LR’s of the Deceased Arvind Kumar Himmatlal Shah v. Bombay Hospital Trust,

Complaint No. 20 of 1992 Decided on 10.6.1992 (Mah. SCDRC)

 Helen C. Rebello and Ors. V. Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation, AIR 1998 SC 3191

 Hemant Bahadur Singh Parihar v. Dr. Mrs. Maya Pathak, 2000 (1) CPR 191 (MP SCDRC)

 Hemant Kumar v. Dr. Sanjay Sharma & Anr., 2003 (2) CPR 418 (MP SCDRC)

 Hemina Hitesh Kotak & Ors. V. Dr. Ashok Nathawani & Ors., 2003 (1) CPJ 252 (NCDRC)

 Hepworth v. Kerr, (1995) 6 Med LR 139, p. 139

 Heramerlal v. Dr. Ajoy Paul & Ors., 2002 (2) CPJ 248 (WB SCDRC)

 Herxheimer and Young, (1990) 140 New I.J. 859

 High Commissioner for India v. I.M. Lall, (1948) LR 75 IA 225

 Hilarious Institute & Clinical Laboratories v. Mohan Das, Appeal No. 497/95 Decided on 20.4.1995

by the Ker. SCDRC (Unreported)

 Hindustan Paper Corporation Ltd. V. Dhir Copy House, 1992 (2) CPR 753 1992 (2) CPJ 558

(NCDRC)

 Hogan v. Almand, 205 SE 2d 440, Ga 1974

 Hogmann v. Blackmon, 241 So 2d 752. Fla 1970

 Hollis v. Dow Coming Corpn., (1993) 103 DLF (4th) 520

 Holmes v. Ashford, [1950] 2All E.R. 76

 Hotchkiss v. National City Bank, (1911) 200 Fed. 287

 Hundley v. St. Frances Hospital, 327 P 2d 131, Cal 1958

 Hunter v. Hamlay, (1955) SLT 213

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 15

I

 .
I Ahmed (Dr.) v. Sumitra Biswas, 2002 (2) CPJ 275 (WB SCDRC)

 I.K Raju (Dr.) v. Masaqrapu Ramalakshmi, 2003 (6) CLD 502 (AP SCDRC)

 Idu Beg’s case, (1881) 3 All 776

 Incollingo v. Ewing, 282 A 2d 206, Pa 1971

 Inderjeet Singh v. Dr. P.K. Bhatia & Anr. , 1998 (3) CPJ 289 (HAR. SCDRC)

 Indian Medical Association & Ors. V. V.P. Shantha & Ors. JT 1995 (8) SC 119: AIR 1996 SC 550:

1995 (6) SCC 651: 1995 (3) CPJ 1 (SC): 1995 (3) CPR 412 (SC)

 Ishwar Das Lakhraj Ramchandani v. Dr. P.J. Bunch & Anr. , 1995 (3) CPJ 549 (Guj. SCDRC)

 J.Gopal v. Nagarjuna Blood Bank, 2003 (2) CPJ 434: 2003 (2) CLD 714 (AP SCDRC)

 J.J Merchant v. Dr. Shrinath Chaturvedi, 2002 (5) Supreme 337: 2002 CTJ 757 JT 2002 (6) SC 1

 J.N. Shrivastav (Dr.) v. Rambiharilal and Ors., AIR 1982 MP 132

 J.P Goel (Dr.) v. Smt. Pushpa Verma, 2002 (1) CPJ 28: 2002 (1) CPR 467 (Del. SCDRC)

 Jackson v. Mountain Sanitarium, 67 SE 2d 57, NC 1951

 Jacob George (Dr.) v. State of Kerala, (1994) 3 SCC 430: JT 1994 (3) SC 225

 JAgan Nath v. Jinadl Dental and Orthopedic Clinic of Kaithal & Anr., 1994 (1) CpJ 119 (Har.

SCDRC)

 Jagat Narayan Chaube v. Dr. Achal Sepaha, 2003 (6) CLD 606: 2004 (1) CPJ 435 (MP SCDRC)

 Jagdeep Mohanlal Kakadia v. Ophthalmics and Drugs India & Ors. , 1997 (3) CPR 229 (Guj.

SCDRC)

 Jai Prakash Saini v. Director , Rajiv Gandhi Cancer Institute and Research

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 16

 Centre & Ors. 2003 (1) CPJ 305: 2003 (2) CPR 202 (Del. SCDRC)

 Jaiwati (Smt.) v. Parivar Seva Sanstha, 1999 (3) CPJ 167 (Del. SCDRC)

 Jan Sangharsh Morcha v. State of Gujrat, 2001 (1) AJR 397 (Guj.)

 Janak Kanimathi Nathan (Dr.) v. Murlidhar Exnath Masane, First Appeal No. 740 of 1994 Decided

on 17.4.2002 (NCDRC)

 Janak Kumari v. Dr. Balwinder Kaur “Nagpal & Anr. , 2003 (2) CPJ 28 (NCDRC)

 Janaki S. Kumar & Anr. (Dr.) v. Mrs. Sarafunnisa, 2000 (1) CPJ 66:1999 (3) CPR 472(Ker.

SCDRC)

 Jasmine Patel (Dr.) (Miss) v. Dr. R.J. Manekshaw & Ors.., 1997 (3) CPJ 14:1997(2) CPR 223

(NCDRC)

 Jasmine Patel (Dr.) (Ms.) v. Dr. R.J. Maneksa and Ors., 2000 (1) CPR 421(Mah SCDRC)

 Jaswinder Singh v. J.S. SAini, 2000 (2) CPJ 262 (Chd.-UTCDRC)

 Jay Laxmi Salt Works (P) Ltd. V. State of Gujrat, (12994) 4 SCC 1:JT (1994) 3 SC 492

 Jayantilal Govindlal Parmar v. Managing Trustee. & Ors. , 1997 (1) CPJ 295: 1997(2) CPR 9 (Guj.

SCDRC)

 Jayendra Maganlal Pandey v. Dr. Lalit P.Trivedi & Ors. , 1997 (1) CPJ 11 (Guj. SCDRC)

 Jitendra Nath v. Dr. (Mrs.) Manju Geeta Mishra & Ors. , 1995 (2) CPJ 96 (Bih. SCDRC)

 John Andrade v. P.D. Hinduja National Hospital and Medical Research Centre & Ors., 1998 (1)

CPR 579, (Mah. SCDRC)

 Joint Director of Health Service v. Sahai, AIR 2000 Mad. 305

 Jolly v. Chief Secretary Hospitals of Cleveland, (19689) 540 NE 2d 1370 (Ohio)

 Jones v. Livox Quarries Ltd., [1952] QB 608

 Joseph Alias Animon & Anr. V. Dr. Elizabeth Zachariah & Ors. , 1997 (1) CPJ 96 (Ker. SCDRC)

 Joseph Ollapally & Ors. V. New India Assurance Co. Ltd. & Ors. , 1996 (3) CPJ 528 (Karn.

SCDRC)

 Joslin Chrysostom (Dr.) v. S. Lourdu, 2001 (3) CPJ 126: (2002) 1 CPR 150 (TN SCDRC)
©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 17
  Jot Maternity and Children Hospital & Anr. V. SAnjogita, 2003 (3) CPJ 136: 2003 (1) CPR 171

(Punj. SCDRC)

 Jugbir Singh v. Dr. Manoj Sharma & Anr., 2003 (2) CPJ 467 (Del. SCDRC)

 Jaggan Khan v. State of M.P., AIR 1965 SC 831: (1965) 1 Cri. LJ 763 (SC)

 Jyothi Vivek & Ors. (Dr.) v. Pradeep & Ors., 1998 (1) CPJ 191: 1997 (3) CPR 220 (Ker. SCDRC)

 K. Jayaram v. Poona Hospital and Research Centre & Ors., 1993 (3) CPJ 70: 1994 (1) CPJ

23: 1994 CCJ 311 (NCDRC)

 K.Kuttapan v. Benigar Hospital & Ors. , 1996 (1) CPR 462 (Ker. SCDRC)

 K.MAhabala Bhat (Dr.) v. K. Krishna, 2001 (3) CPR 137:2002 (2) 127 (NCDRC)

 K.Mahendran v. Dr. O. Satyanarayana, 2003 (5) CLD 645 (AP SCDRC)

 K. Sridhar (Dr. )v. Budda Lakshmikantham, 2003 (3) CLD 207 (AP SCDRC)

 K.Ummaer v. Jubilee Mission Hospital, Trichur & Anr. , 1997 (3) CPJ 432 (Ker. SCDRC)

 K. VAsantha v. Teja Hospital , 1993 (1) CPR 20 (TN SCDRC)

 K.C. Nasa (Dr.) v. Sahib Cjhand Sharma, 2003 (6) CLD 26: 2003 (3) CPR 509: 2003 (3) CPJ

622 (Del. SCDRC)

 K.E. Rajesh v. President, District Co-operative Hoapital & Anr. , 2000 (3) CPJ 354: 2000 (1)

CPR 144 (Ker. SCDRC)

 K.G. Krishanan (Dr.) v. Praveen Kumar (Minor), 2003 (3) CLD 705: 2003 (2)CPR 38: 2003

(2) CPJ 125 (NCDR C)

 K.K Radha (Mrs.) v. Dr. G.U Su\hekhar & Anr.., 1994 (3) CPJ 376 (Ker. SCDRC)

 K.K. Radha v. P.P. Isnail, 1994 (3) CPJ 376 (Ker SCDRC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 18

  K.M. BalaKrishanan @ Premnath v. Padma Ayurveda Vaidyasala and Research Centre &

Ors.., 2003 (3) CPJ 645 (TN SCDRC)

 K.N.Lal v. Dr. R.K. Akhaury, 1997 (3) CPJ 112 (Bih. SCDRC)

 K.S. Bhatia v. Jeevan Hospital, 2003 (6) CLD 382 (NCDRC)

 K.V . Narayani v. Dr. P. Gopinathan, 2001 (3) CPJ 498 (Karn. SCDRC)

 Kailash Chandra, 2000 (1) Crimes 359 (MP)

 Kailash Kumar Sharma v. Dr. Hari Charan Mathur, 1997 (3) CPJ 41: 1997 (2) CPR 126

(NCDRC)

 Kalavati (Smt.) v. State of Himachal Pradesh, AIR 1956 SC 5

 Kalawati v. State of Himachal Pradesh, 1988 ACJ 780 (HP-HC)

 Kamlesh Gupta & Ors. v. Dr. OM Prakash Sadana & Anr., OP No. 96 of 1994, Decided on

28.2.2000 (NCDRC)(unreported)

 Kamlesh Gupta & Ors. v. Dr. Abhijit Roy Chaudhary & Ors., 2000 (3) CPR 498 (WB

SCDRC)

 Kamta Prasad Singh (Dr.) V. Nagina Prasad, 2000 (3) CPJ 283 (Bih. SCDRC)

 Kaniya Prasad G. Mishra & Ors. V. Dr. SAtyanarayana Vishwakarma ans Anr. , 1997 (1) CPJ

322 (Guj. SCDRC)

 Kanhaiya Kumar Singh v. Park Medicare & research Centre, 1999 (3) CPJ 9(NCDRC)

 Kanhaiya Singh v. Secretary/Administrative Officer Vevekanand Polyclinic & Ors., 2003 (3)

CPJ 263 (UP SCDRC)

 Kashi Ram Bhim Rao Kamble v. Dr. Udaya A. Patil & Anr. , 1998 (3) CPJ 614(Mah.

SCDRC)

 Kashi Ram Bhim Rao Kamble v. Dr. Udaya A. Paul, 2001(3) CPR 117 (NCSCDRC)

 Kasturilal Ralia Ram Jain v. State of U.P, AIR 1965 SC 1039: (1965) 2 Cri. 144: (1965) 1

SCWR 955

 Katakam Sujatha v. Hira Hospital,2003 (5) CLD 718 (AP SCDRC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 19

  Katra Satyanarayana v. Lakshmi Nursing Home, 2003 (3) CLD 535: 2003 (2) CPR 219: 2003

(2) CPJ 262 (AP SCDRC)

 Kedar Nath v. State, AIR 1965 All. 233

 Kennedy v. Parrott, 90 SE 2d 75, NC 1956

 Kent v. Griffits, (2000) 2 All ER 474

 KLhairati Lal v. Dr. Kewal Krishan, 1998 (!) CPJ 181 (Punj. SCDRC)

 Katri (II) v. State of Bihar, 1981 (1) SCC 627

 Khushaldas v. State of M.P., AIR 1960 MP 50: 1960 Cri LJ 234

 King v. Carney, 204 Pac 270, Okla 1922

 King v. King (1987, C.A.; (unreported))

 Kiran Bala Rout v. Christian Medical College & Hospital & Ors., 2003 (1) CPR 238

(NCDRC)

 Kiran Sharma (Smt.) v. Dr. Kavata Saluja, 2003 (2) CLD 256 (MP SCDRC)

 Kiranjeet v. Dr. Nirlep Kaur , 1999 (3) CPJ 208 (Chd. UTSCDRC)

 Kirtilal Gelchand SAnghvi v. Medical Suprintendent, Chaturbhuj Hospital & Anr. , 1998 (3)

CPJ 45: 1997 (3) CPR 506 (Guj. SCDRC)

 Kishan garh Marbles ()P)Ltd. V. Gujrat State Financial Corp., 1991 (1) CPJ 103 (NCDRC)

 Klaus Mitterbachert v. The East India Hotels Ltd., AIR 1997 Del. 201

 Kody Elcot Ltd. V. Dr. C.P. Gupta, 1996 (1) CPJ 7 (NCDRC)

 Krishna HAzra (Smt.) v. Dr. S.K. Bindai, 2001 (2) CPR 491 (WB SCDRC

 Krishna Kant De v. Dr. T. Roy & Ors. , 1996 (!) CPR 364 (WB SCDRC)

 Krishna Kumari Gupta v. Gurbax Sheesh Singh, AIR 1985 All 85: 1985 ACJ 457 (ALL-HC)

 Krishna Mini Tewari v. Dr. (Mrs.) Gouri BAndyopadhyay & Ors., 2003 (1) CPJ 286 (WB

SCDRC)

 Krishna Prasad (Dr.) v. State of Karnatka, 1989 ACJ 393 (Karn.- HC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 20

  Krishnan v. State, 2003 (7) SCC 56: 2003 SCC (Cri.) 1577 : AIR 2003 SC 2978: 2003 Cri LJ

3705 (SC)

 Kumbach v. Hollands. [1973] 3 All ER 907

 Kuhn v. Banker, 13 NE 2d 242, Ohio 1938

 Kuljit Kaur v. B.R.S. Heart Institiute and Research Centre, 2003 (6) CLD 317 (Chd.-

UTCDRC)

 Kulvinder Kaur v. Dr. Kiranpreet Kaur Makkar & Ors. , 1997 (2) CPJ 355 (Punj. SCDRC)

 Kunhikrishnan Nambiar P.V. & Ors. V. Sreechitra Tirumal Institute for Medical Science and

Technology 2001 (3) CPJ 86 (Ker. SCDRC)

 Kusum Bakshi Ahlawat (Dr.) (Mrs.) v. G.P. Singh, Mahnager, Administration & Ors., 1993

(3) CPJ 1135 (Har. SCDRC)

 Kusum Sharma & Ors. (Smt.) v. Batra Hospital and Medical Research Centre & Ors., 2000

(3) CPJ 18 (NCDRC)

 L.v.M., (1978) 2 NZLR 519

 L.D. Bajaj (Fauji Doctor) (Cancer Hospital) (Dr.) v. Hari Chand, 20003 (1) CPR 328: 2003 (3) CPJ

49 (Punj. SCDRC)

 Lakhan Singh v. Mst. Geetwa Devi, 2003 (1) CPR 504: 2003 (6) CLD 941 (Jharkhand SCDRC)

 Lakshmanan Prakash (dr.) v. State, 2001 ACJ 1204 (Mad.- HC)

 Lakshmi Rajan v. Malar Hospital Ltd. & Anr., 1997 (3) CPJ 242: 1998 (3) CPJ 586: 1997 (3) CPR

90 (TN SCDRC )

 Lalluram Meena v. Dr. S. Mathur & Anr. , 2001 (3) CPJ 200(Raj. SCDRC)

 Laxman Balkrishana Joshi (Dr.) v. Dr. Trimbak Bapu Godbole, 1968 ACJ 183 (SC):AIR 1969 SC

128: 1969 (1) SCR 206

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 21

 Laxman Singh v. Gurmit Kaur, AIR 1979 P& H-HC 50 (FB)

 Laxman Thamappa Kotgiri v. Union of India & Ors., 1998 (1) CPR 665 (Mah. SCDRC)

 Laxmi Agarwal v. Dr. K.K. Gupta, 2003 (2) CLD 381 (MP SCDRC)

 Laxmi Engg. Works v. P.S.G. Industrial Institute, (1995) 3 SCC 582

 Laxmi Joy Prasad v. Dr. Cameroon & Ors., 1998 (1) CPJ 336: 1998 (2)CPR 450 (WB SCDRC)

 Laxmi narain v. Esitha Nursing Home And Amish X-Ray & Anr., 2001 (3)CPJ 394 (UP SCDRC)

 Laxmi Narain v. Eshita Nursing Home and Amish X-Ray & Anr., 2001 (3) CPJ 394 (UP SCDRC)

 Laxmi Narain v. Eshitha Nursing Home and Amish X-Ray *\& Anr., 2001 (3) CPJ 394 (UP

SCDRC)

 Leela bai v. Sebastian & Ors., 2002 (2) CPJ 363 (Ker.-HC) (DB)

 Leena Bhattarcharjee v. Nightangle Diagnostic and Eye Care Research Centre

 (P) Ltd., 2003 (6) CLD 706: 2004 (1) CPR 130 (WB SCDRC)

 Lekhraj v. Bharaj Nursing Home & Anr., 1998 (2) CPJ 335 (Punj. SCDRC)

 LIC of India v. SAnjeev Mahendra Lal Shah, 1996 (1) CPR 129 (NCDRC)

 Lindsay v. Mid. Western Health Board, (1991) Irish Law Times Reports

 Lovelace Medical Center v. Mendez, (1991) 805 P 2d 603

 Lucknow Development Authority v.M.K.Gupta,1994(1)SCC 243:1994(1)CPR 56: IAIR 1994 SC

787: 1993 (3) CPJ 7 (SC)

 M.ArunachalaVaidivel and Ors. V. Dr. N. Gopalkrishan, 1992 (2) CO\PJ 764(TN SCDRC)

 M.Dravidamani (Dr.) v. Dr. S.P. Paramasivam, 2001 (1) CPJ 68 (TN SCDRC)

 M.Jeeva v. R. Lalitha, 1994 (2) CPJ 73: 1994 (2) CPR 517 (NCDRC)

 M.Parimanan v. Dr. C.P. Jaganathan & Ors., 1998 (1) CPR 273 (TN SCDRC)

 M.Ramesh Reddy v. State of Andhra Pardesh, 2003 (1) CLD 81 (AP SCDRC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 22

  M.Sriniwas v. Dr. (Smt.) Rama Thulasi, 2003 (1) CLD 214: 2003 (1) CPJ 449:2003 (2) CPR

242 (AP SCDRC)

 M.Subramani & Ors. V. Christu Jothi Hospital & Anr., 1998 (3) CPR 428 (NCDRC)

 M.Vijaya (Smt.) v. Chairman & Managing Director of Singareni Colliery Co. Ltd., AIR 2001

AP 502 : 2002 ACJ 32 (AP- HC) (FB)

 M.C Mehta v. Union Of India, (1987) 1 SCC 395: AIR 1987 SC 965

 M.C Mehta v. Union Of India, air 1987sc 1086: (1987) 1 Com LJ 89: (1987) 1 ACC 157:

(1987) 1 SCC 395: (1987) 1 Supreme 65: 1987 SCC (Lab) 37: (1987) 4 LJ Rep. 104

 M.J. Joseph v. Dr. P.J.John, 2001 (!) CPJ 409: 2001 (1) CPR 5 (Ker. SCDRC)

 M.K. Gourikutty & etc. (Dr.) v. M.K. Madhwan &Ors.,AIR 2001 Ker.- HC 398:2002 ACJ

1356 (Ker.) (DB)

 M.P. Agarwal v. Dr. M.R. Jain, Complaint No. 125 of 1993 Decided on 9.1.1996 by Raj.

SCDRC (unreported)

 M.Ramesh Reddy v. State of Andhra Pradesh, 2003 (1) CLD 81 (APSCDRC)

 M.S. Bahatambre (Dr.) v. Babu K.Kople, 2000 (3) CPJ 366 (Mah. SCDRC)

 Machineni Rama Rao (Dr.) v. D. Padmavathi @ Padma Sree, 2002 (1) CPJ 380 (AP SCDRC)

 Madan Mohan v. Dr. Ashwani Sood, 1996 (2) CPJ 204 (Har. SCDRC)

 Madhu Rana (Dr.) (Mrs.) v. Smt. Bimla Gupta, 1999 (3) CPJ 224 (Del. SCDRC)

 Madhu v. Narendra Kumar, 1990 ACJ 159 (MP-HC)

 Madhya Pardesh State Road Transport Corporation v. Sudhakar, AIR 1977 SC 1189

 Madhyamgram Consumers Welfare Society v. Dr. Kalyan Kumar Chaatterjee & Ors., 2002

(@) CPJ 381 (WB SCDRC)

 Mharaj Prasad Agarwal v. Dr. M.R. Jain Complaint No. 125 of 1993 decided on 9.1.1996 by

Rajasthan SCDRC (unreported)

 Mahesan v. Malaysia Govt. Officers Co-operative Housing Society Ltd., (1978) 2 All ER 405

(411) (PC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 23

  Mohan v. Osborne, (1939) 1 All ER 534, 548-91939) 2 KB 14: 160 LT 39: 83 Sol. Jo. 134

 Makhan Singh v. Dr. Prem Singh, 2002 (3) CPR 320 (Punj. SCDRC)

 Malkhan Singh v. Modern X-ray Sonography & Photo Centre, 2000 (2) CPJ 441:2000 (3)

CPR 60 (MP SCDRC)

 Mallet v. Pirkey, 466 P 2d 466, Colo 1970

 Manager, Martin Medical Centre & Ors. V. E. V. Thomas, 1999 (1) CPR 466 (Ker. SCDRC)

 Managing Director, Rohini Hospital v. L. Sunil Reddy, 2004 (1) CPJ 299 (AP SCDRC)

 Mangi Lal v. State of M.P., JT 2004 (1) SC 81

 Manilal Natha Bhai & Ors. V. Dr. Tushar N. Shah, 1997 (1) CPJ 560: 1997 (2) CPR 15(Guj.

SCDRC)

 Manish Agarwal v. Administrator, Kamla Nehru Memorial Hospital, 2001 (1) CPJ 42(UP

SCDRC)

 Manjit Singh Sadhu (Dr.) v. Uday Kant Thakur, 2002 (3) CPR 42 (Jharkhand SCDRC)

 Manju Kumar Chaudhary & Anr. v. S.K. Ghosh, 1997 (3) CPJ 246 (WB SCDRC)

 Mappooyan v. Dr. Premavathy Elango, 1991 (2) CPR460 (TN SCDRC)

 Master Asok Kumar v. Agadi Nursing Home & Anr., 1995 (3) CPJ 142: 1995 (1) CPR 517

(Karn. SCDRC)

 Master Mritunjay v. Virender Arya, 1996 (3) CPJ 429 (Chd. UT CDRC)

 Master P.M Ashwin & Ors. v. MAnipal Hospital Banglore & Ors., 1997 (1) CPJ 238: 1997

(1) CPR 393 (Karn. SCDRC)

 Mathurea Matho (Mistry) v. Dr. Bindeshwar Jha “Bindu”, 2003 (1) CPJ 535: 2003 (2) CPR

274 (Bih. SCDRC)

 Maya Bagchi v. Dr. SAmir Sen Gupta & Anr., 1996 (2) CPR 180 (WB SCDRC)

 Mayanard v. West Midlands Regional Health Authority, (1985) 1 All ER 635 (HL)

 Mayo Hospital v. Sunil Tiwari, 1997 (3) CPJ 387: 1997 (3) CCPR 574 (<|MP SCDRC)

 Mayo v. Mcclung, 64 SE 2d 330, Ga 1951

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 24
  McQuary v. Eastwood, (1886) 12 O.R. 402

 Md. Aslam v. Ideal Nursing Home, 1997 (3) CPJ 81 (NCDRC)

 Medical Superintendent, Geetha Maternity & Nursing Home v. Shaikh Mahaboob Saheb,

2003 (6) CLD 736 (AP SCDRC)

 Meena Vyas v. City Nursing Home and Hospital and Another, 2002 CCJ 1537 (Punj.

SCDRC)

 Meenakshi (Mrs.) v. Dr. Surekha SAchar Hospital & Maternity Home (Regd.) & Anr. , 1999

(1) CPR 616 (Punj. SCDRC)

 Meghdut Gordhanbhai Thakkar v. Dr. Anupama Vidhyut Bhai Desai & Anr. , 1997 (1) CPJ

5.3: 1997 (2) CPR 9 (Guj. SCDRC)

 Mehboob Alam (Dr.) v. State of U.P., AIR 2001 All 374 (DB)

 Midland Silicones Ltd. V. Scruttons Ltd., (1960) 2 All ER 737: (1961) 1 QB 106: (1960) 3

WLR 372: 104 SJ 603, confirmed in (1962) 1 All ER 1

 Mitchel v. Dicksen, (1954) AP PD 519

 Mohammed Aynuddin v. State of A.P., AIR 2000 SC 2511: 2000 Cri LJ 3508 (SC): 2000 (7)

SCC 72: 2000 SCC (Cri) 1281

 Mohan Mahindroo v. New India Assurance Company & Anr. 1997 (1) CPJ 585 (HP SCDRC)

 Mohd. Azzimuddin v. Dr.Nagabhushnam, 2003 (5) CLD 653 (AP SCDRC

 Mohd. Ishfaq v. Dr. Martin D.’Souza, 2003 (1) CPJ 116 (NCDRC)

 Mohd. Ubain Siddiqui v. Dr. Ramesh Kumar Upadhyaya, 2000 (1) CPR 77 (UP SCDRC)

 Mohr. V. Williams, 104 NW 12, Minn 1905

 Moore v. Tremelling, 78 F 2d 821, CCA 9, 1935

 Morgan Stanley Mutual Fund v. Kartick Dass and Ors., 1994 (2) CPJ 7 (SC)

 Morrison v. Forsyth, [1995] 6 Med LR 6

 Moti Bai Dalvi Hospital v. M.L. Govilkar, 1991 (1) CPR 334: 1991 (2) CPJ 684 (MAh.

SCDRC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 25

  Muktiar Chand & Ors. (Dr.) v. State of Punjab & Ors., (1998) 7 SCC 579: 1998 (5) SCALE

501

 Mumbai Grahak Panchayat v. (Dr.) (Mrs.) Rashmi B. Fadnavis & Ors. , 1996 (1) CPR 137:

1996 NCJ 226: 1998(1) CPJ 49 (NCDRC)

 Municipal Corpn. Of Greater Bombay v. Laxman Iyer, 2003 (8) SCC 731

 Murari lal Maurya v. Rallis India Ltd., 1993 (3) CPR 396 (MP SCDRC)

 Murlidhar Eknath Masane v. Sushrusha Citizen Co-op. Hospital Ltd. & Anr. , Complaint No.

203/92, decided on 29.1031994 by Mah. SCDRC (unreported)

 N.C SArin v. Moolchand Khairatiram Hospital & Ors., 1996 (2) CPJ 418 (Del. SCDRC)

 N.Lalitha Krishna (Dr.) v. Mrs. Deepa Nair, 2000 (1) CJ 340: 2000 (2) CPR 469: 2001 CCJ 1286

(AP SCDRC)

 N. Nagendra Rao & Co. v. State of A.P., JT 1994 (5) SC 572: 1996 ACJ 505:AIR 1994 SC 2663:

(1994) 6 scc 205

 N. Nirmala v. (Dr.) Nageswar Reddy, 2003 (5) CLD 812 (AP SCDRC)

 N. Paduranga Rao v. State of A.P., 1975 (2) AP LJ 277

 N. Sandhya Rani (Dr.) v. M.K. Kalpana, 1999 (3) CPJ 6 (AP SCDRC)

 N. Saravanan Bhavanantham v. Diabetes Research Centre & M.V. Hospital forDiabetes & Ors.,

1999 (1) 605 (TN SCDRC)

 N.D. Srivastava v. S.K. Srivastava, 2003 (6) CLD 482 (UP SCDRC)

 N.K. Kohli v. Bajaj Nursing Home, 2003 (6) CLD 308: 1999 (2) CPR 79 (MP SCDRC)

 N.S. Sajpta v. New Ruby Hospital, 2000 (2) CPJ 345: 1999 (3) CPR 29 (Punj. SCDRC)

 N.T. Subramanyam (Dr.) v. B. Krishna Rao & Willingdon Nursing Home,1993 (3) CPJ 1557 (TN

SCDRC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 26

 N.T. Subramanyam (Dr.) v. B. Krishna Rao, 1996 (2) CPJ 233: 1996 (2) CPR 247(NCDRC)

 Nachhatar Singh v. Malkeet Singh, 2001 (2) CPJ 237 (Punj. SCDRC)

 Nadiya v. Proprietor Fathima Hospital, 2001 (3) CPJ 572 (Ker. SCDRC) 582Nagaraj Murthy v. Dr.

Rajendran, 2003 (1) CLD 508 (Karn. SCDRC)

 Nagarmal Modi Sewa Sadan v. Anita Devi, 2002 (3) CPR 163 (Jharkhand SCDRC)

 Nand Kishore Prasad v. Sister Grace, Kurji Holi Family Hospital, 2003 (1) CLD 722:2003 (3) CPJ

331l 2003 (3) CPR 503 (Bih. SCDRC)

 Narayan Chaudhary & Anr. (Dr.) v. Dr. (Mrs.) Rita Podder & Ors., 1997 (3)CPJ 557: 1998 (3) CPJ

66 (WB SCDRC)

 Narcinva V. Kamat v. Alfredo Antonio Doe Martins, 1985 ACJ 397

 Narendra Singh Rastogi v. Shaskiya Gyara Panch Trust & Anr., 2002 (2) CPJ 3 (MP SCDRC)

 Naresh Kumar v. Sunil Blood Bank Ltd., 1991 (1) CPJ 645 (Del. SCDRC)

 Nathu Lal v. State of M.P., AIR 1966 SC 43

 Nationakl Hospital & Anr. V. Muhammed Najeeb, 2003 (1) CPR 653 (Ker. SCDRC)

 National Justice Compania Naviera SA v. Prudential Assurance Co. Ltd.,“The Ikarian Reefer”,

[1993] 2 Lloyd’s Rep. 68, 81 – 82, Q.B.D.

 Naved Ahmed v. Dr. Rakesh Kacker, 2000 (1) CPJ 201 (UP SCDRC)

 Neena Gupta v. Dr. Kanwarjit Kochhar, Cmplaint case No. 489 of 1993, decided on5.1.1996 by

Chd. –UT CDRC (unreported)

 Neha Kumari & Anr. V. Apollo Hospital & Ors., 2003 (1) CPJ 145 (NCDRC)

 Nettleship V. Weston , [1971] 2 QB 691

 New India Assurance Co. Ltd. & Anr. v. P.P. Khanna, 1997 (2) CPJ 1 (NCDRC)

 New India Assurance Co. Ltd. V. Rajendra Singh Bajaj, 2003 (3) CPR 87 (MP SCDRC)

 Newman v. Anderson, 217 NW 306, Wise 1928

 Newman v. Hounslow & Spelthorne Health Authority (1985, Q.B.D. unreported)

 Mga Myat Thin, (1898) PJ LB 426

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 27
  Nihal Kaur & Ors. v. Director, P.G.I. Chandigarh, 1996 (3) CPJ 112 (Chd. –UT CDRC)

 Nilabati Behara v. State of Orissa, 1993 (2) SCC 746

 Nirmala R. Pranab & Anr. V. Dr. Kalpana Desai & Ors., 1998 (3) CPJ 66: 1998 (3) CPJ527 (Mah.

SCDRC)

 Nirmalendu Paul v. Dr. P.K. Bakshi, 2001 (1) CPJ 466 (WB SCDRC)

 Nita Singh & Ors. V. Dr. Karnail Singh, 1998 (3) CPJ 39 (Punj. SCDRC)

 Nuruddin Kutubuddin Bulati v. Dr. L.N. Vohra & Anr. , 1995 (1) CPJ 455:1995 (2) CPR 424 (Mah.

SCDRC)

 O.Aisha Bi v. J.R. Danilal, 2003 (5) CLD 915: 2003 (3) CPJ 178: 2003 (3) CPR 100 (NCDRC)

 O.A. Varadadesigan v. Chief Medical Officer (Ortho.) Govt. General Hospital, 1992 (2) CPR 71

(TN SCDRC)

 Om prakash Sekri v. Pritam Singh, 1984 ACJ 435 (P&H-HC)

 Ophthalmics and Drugs India v. Dr. Jagdip Mohanlal Kakadia & Ors., 2003 (3) CPJ 21 (NCDRC)

 Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. V. Miss Amisha Jain, 1996 (2) CPJ 183 (Del. SCDRC)

 Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. V. SAtyavarapu Satyanarayana, 2003 (5) CLD 957 (AP SCDRC)

 Owens v. Sykes, (1936) 1KB 192

 P. Madanmohan Rao (Dr.) v. Khaja Moizuddin, 2004 (7) CLD 313 (AP SCDRC)

 P.Mani v. Sri Ramachandra Medical College 2000 (3) CPJ 190 (TN SCDRC)

 P. Narasimha Rao (Dr.) v. Gundarapu Jaya Prakash, AIR 1990 AP 207: 1990 ACJ 3350 (AP

HC)

 P. Raveendram v. Fort Hospital, 2001 CCJ 1251 (Ker. SCDRC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 28

  P. Sudhakar v. Gowri Gopal Hospital, 2004 (1) CPJ 329 (AP SCDRC)

 P.Venkata Lakshmi (Smt.) v. Dr. Y. SAvitri Devi & Ors., 2001 (3) CPJ 402 (AP SCDRC)

 P.Venkata Lakshmi v. Dr. Y. Savitha Devi, 2003 (5) CLD 207: 2003 (3) CPR 52 (NCDRC)

 P.B. Thailramani (Dr.) v. R.M. Joshi, RP No. 339 of 1993 Decided by the National

Commission on 3.2.1994 (Unreported)

 P.C. Dwivedi (Dr.) v. Smt. Kamaklabai Pandey, 2003 (2) CLD 916: 23003 (3) CPJ 170 (MP

SCDRC)

 P.G.I., Chandigarh v. Jaspal Singh & Ors., 2000 (3) CPJ 32 (NCDRC)

 P.N. Bhaskaran & Anr. (Dr.) v. Mrs. Molly Robinson & Anr. , 2000(1) CPJ 81: 1999 (3) CPR

442 (Ker. SCDRC)

 P.N.De Souza v. Emperor, AIR 1920 All 32 : (1920) 42 All 272

 P.N. Sudhankar Gupta v. Anugraha Vittala Nursing Home, 1997 (1) CPJ 266 (KArn.

SCDRC)

 P.P. Ismail v. K.K. Radha, 1998 (1) CPJ 16: 1998 (1) CPR 171 (NCDRC)

 P.P. Ismail v. Kerala State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission & Ors. 1994 (2) CPJ

449

 P.R. Sumangi v. Kairali Medical Centre & Anr., 1997 (3) CPR 418: 1998 (1) CPJ 208 (Ker.

SCDRC)

 P.S. Govindarajan v. General Manager, Integral Coach Factory & Ors. 1993 CPJ 1211 (TN

SCDRC)

 Padmabai v. M.P. State Road Transport Corporation, II (1999) ACC 281 (DB)

 Pallattu George & Anr. V. Dr. Thamkamma Punnoose & Anr. , 1997 (3) CPJ 341: 1997 (3)

CPR 167 (Ker. SCDRC)

 Pankajbhai Nagjibhai Patel v. State of Gujrat, AIR 2001 SC 567

 Paramjeet Kaur & Ors. V. Doaba Hospital & Anr. , 1998 (2) CPJ 265: 1998 (2) CPR 93

(Punj. SCDRC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 29

  Pardeep Seth & Ors. V. Dr. Ashok Sarwal & Anr. , 1998 (1) CPJ 612 (HAr. SCDRC)

 Parmanand Katara v. Union of India, 1989 (4) SCC 286: AIR 1989 SC 2039: 1989 ACJ 1000

: 1989 (4) SCC 286

 Paschim BAnga Khet Mazdoor Samity & Ors. V. State of West Bengal & Anr. 1996 (4)

Supreme 260: AIR 1996 SC 2426: 1996 (4) SCC 37: JT 1996 (6) 43 (SC)

 Patel v. Adhya, (1985) CA 168

 Payne v. St. Heliera Group of Hospitals 1952 CLY 2442

 Perry v. Hodgson, 148 SE 659, Ga 1929

 Peters v. Fulhar, BMJ dt. 27.3 1954, p. 767

 Philips India Ltd. V. Kunju Punnu, 1975 ACJ 311 (Bom,- HC)

 Pinnamaneni Narasimha AR (Dr.) v. Gundavarapu Jayaprakash, AIR 1990 AP-HC 207

 Piyush verma (Dr.) v. Jabar Singh, 2002 (1) CPR 391 (UP SCDRC)

 Plydell v. Aubyn, (1993) (unreported)

 Poona Medical Foundation Ruby Hall Clinic v. Maruti Rao L. Titkare, 1995 (1) CPJ 232:

1995 (1) CPR 661 (NCDRC)

 Poonam Verma v. Ashwin Patel & Ors. , JT 1996 (3) CPR 205 (SC): AIR 1996 SC 2111 :

1996 (4) SCC 332: 1996 (2) CPJ 1 (SC)

 Poonam Verma v. Dr. Ashwin Patel & Anr. , 1995 (1) CPJ 11: 1995 (1) CPR 661

 Prabha Chaoudhry & Anr. (Dr.) (Smt.) v. Shantilal Jain, 2004 (1) CPJ 307 (MP-SCDRC)

 Pradeep Kumar H. Trivedi v. Dr. Mahesh V. Shah, 1995 (3) CPR 533 (Guj. SCDRC)

 Prafulla K. SAhoo v. Dr. B.B PaTHNAIK, cd Case no. 185 of 1991 decided on 20.5.1993 by

Ori. SCDRC (unreported)

 Prafulla Kumar Das v. Apollo Hospital & Ors., 20002 (2) CPJ 106 (NCDRC)

 Prashanta Kumar Chakarborty v. Dr. JAhar Dabnath, 2000 (3) CPJ 91 (WB SCDRC)

 Pratibha Rani v. Suraj Kumar , (1985) 2 SCC 370

 Prem NAth Hospital v. Poonam Mangla & Anr. , 1998 (2) CPJ 205 (HAr. SCDRC)
©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 30
  Prendergast v. Sam & Dee, (1989) 1 Med LR 36: (1988) Independent, 17 March (QBD) : This

decision affirmend on appeal: (1989) Times, 14 March, CA

 Public Health Trust v. Brown, (1980) 388 So 2d 1084

 Public Prosecutor v. E.O. Christian, 1971 ACJ 20 (AP- HC)

 PUDR v. Union of India , (1982) 3 SCC 235

 Pulfinbarger v. Day, 24 Cal Rptr 533, Cal. 1962

 Punjab National BANk v. K.B. Shetty, 1991 (2) CPR 633: 1991 (2) CPJ 639 (NCDRC)

 Punjab State v. Surinder Kaur, 2001 ACJ 1266 (P&H-HC)

 Punjab Nursing Home v. Kailash Marodia, 2003 (2) CLD 852 (MP SCDRC)

 Pushpa Thakur v. Union of India, 1984 ACJ 559 (SC)

 Pyare Lal Verma v. Dr. A.K Gupta & Ors. , 1993 (3) CPR 144 (HAr. SCDRC)

 Queen, NRI Hospital v. B. Rama Krishna Rao, 2004 (8) CLD 51 (AP SCDRC)

 Quintal v. Laurel Grover Hospital, 397 P2d 161, Cal 1964

 R.Shanmuga Chandra Vadivu v. Sir Ivan Stedford Hospital, 200(3) CPJ 299 (TN SCDRC).

 R.B.Kapoor (Dr.)v. Phool Dev Prasad, 1996(3)CPJ 477 (Har.SCDRC)

 R.C.Sharma(Dr.)v.Jage Ram, 2003(1) CPJ 248 (NCDRC)

 R.C.Singhal (Dr.)v. Smt.Urmila mathur, Appeal No.1334/Cs of 1992, decided On 11.11.1994

( UP SCDRC) (unreported)

 R.D. Hattangadi v. Pest Control (India) Ltd. (1995) 1 SCC 551: 1995 SCC (Cri.) AIR 1995

SC 755

 R.K.Agarwal v. Dr. B. Mukhopadhya, 1995 (1) CPJ 260: 1994 (3) CPR 574 (Bih. SCDRC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 31

  R.K.Jain (Dr.)v. Sunil, 1999(3) CPJ 546 (MP SCDRC)

 R.L.Sethi v. Dr.Somnath Chakraborti,2001 (2) CPR 379 (WB SCDRC)

 R.M.Joshi v. Dr.P.B.Tahilramani, 1993 (3) CPJ 12 (Mah. SCDRC)

 R.P.Dahiya v. Dr. Pradeep Aggarwal and another ,2002 CCJ 649 (Har.SCDRC)

 R.P. Sharma v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 2002 (Raj.-HC-Jpr.-Bench)104

 R.V. Rao (Dr.) v. Dr. Y.R. Krishna, 2003 (1) CPJ 210 (MP SCDRC)

 Rabinarayan Sahoo v. Dr. B. Jayaram Patra & Ors. 2004 (1) CPJ 3 (NCDRC)

 Rahul Sinha & Ors. V. Dr. Alok Mitra & Ors., 1995 (2) CPJ 227: 1995 (1) CPR 835

(NCDRC)

 Raj Kumar Agarwal v. Dr. B. Mukhopadhyaya, 1995 (1) CPJ 260: 1994(3) CPR 574(Bih.

SCDRC)

 Raj Kumar v. Ajay Gupta, 2001 (1) CPJ 495 (UP SCDRC)

 Rajani (Mst.) v. Nihal Singh, 2001 (1) TAC 708

 Rajani Shukla v. Rajendra Kumar Agarwal, 2003 (1) CLD 347: 2003 (1) CPJ 551:2003 (2)

CPR 238 (MP SCDRC)

 Rajeev Kumar v. Dr. V.K. Biswas & Ors. , 1998 (2) CPJ 494: 1998 (2) CPR 149(Bih.

SCDRC)

 Rajinder Lal v. Dr. Rulda Singh, 1996 (2) CPR 364 (Chd-UT SCDRC)

 Rajinder Singh v. Batra Hospital & Medical Research Centre & Anr., 2003 (3) CPJ558 (Del.

SCDRC)

 Rajkuwarbai & Anr. (Smt.) v. Dr. R.R. Dhoot, 1993 (3) CPR 2 (Mah. SCDRC)

 Rajmal v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1996 Raj. –HC 80

 Rajni Bansal v. D.C. Mittal & Ors. , 1997 (3) CPJ 511 (Har. SCDRC)

 Rakesh Goyal (Smt.) v. Senior Divisional Manager, Life Insurance Corporation of India,

1997 (1) CCC 66 (HP SCDRC)

 Rakesh Jain (Dr.) v. Rakesh Kumar Khare & Ors., 2003 (1) CPJ 27 (MP SCDRC)
©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 32
  Rakesh Nath Mehrotra (Dr.) v. Atul Pradhan & Ors., 2000 (1) CPR 405(UP SCDRC)

 Rakesh Ranjan Gupta v. State of UP & Anr.,1999 ACJ 807 (SC)

 Ram Babu v. Dr. Anjani Kishore Prasad, 1997 (3) CPJ 112:1998 (2) CPR 224:1998 (2) CPJ

684 (Bih. SCDRC)

 Ram Biharilal v. Dr. J.N. Shrivastav, AIR 1985 MP –HC 150 (DB)

 Ram Kali v. State of Haryana and others, 2003 ACJ 752 (P& H -HC)

 Ram Kissen Das Dhanuka v. Satya Charan Law, (1949) LR 77 LA. 128

 Ram Rattan Sharma v. Government of Medical College & Hospital, 2003 (2) CLD903: 2003

(3) CPR 215 (Chd. –UTCDRC)

 Ram Singh A. Parmar v. Sampat Raj C Shah, 1993 (2) CPR 496 (Guj. SCDRC)

 Ramesh Bhai P. Prajapati & Anr. V. Dr. P.N. Nagpal, 1997 (1) CPJ 471 (Guj. SCDRC)

 Ramesh Chandra v. Randhir Singh, AIR 1997 All 330

 Rameshwar Pd. Agrawal (Dr.) v. Mohd. Abas Ansari, 2000 (1) CPJ 433:1999 (2) CPR 386

(Bih. SCDRC)

 Ramji Lal v. Sarvodaya Medical, 1995 (1) CPR 833:1995 (2) CPJ 234 (NCDRC)

 Ranjit Kumar Das v. Medical Officer, E.S.I. Hospital & Ors., 1997 (3) CPJ 336:1998 (1) CPR

165 (WB SCDRC)

 Ranjit Singh Buttar (Dr.) v. Sewa Singh, 2000 (2) CPJ 180 (Punj. SCDRC)

 Rashmi B. Fadnavis & Anr. (Dr.) (Mrs.) v. Mumbai Grahak Panchayat & Ors., 1996 (1) CPR

137: 1998 (3) v. CPR 34 (NCDRC)

 Ravinder Gupta & Ors. (Dr.) v. Ganga Devi, 1993 (3) CPR 255 (Har. SCDRC)

 Ravindra Kulkarni (Dr.) v. Balasaheb Gangaram Gavade, 1999 (3) CPR 219(Mah.SCDRC)

 Rees v. Sinclair, (1974) 1 NZLR 180

 Rekha Gupta (Smt.) v. Bombay Hospital Trust & Anr., 2003 (2) CPJ 160(NCDRC)

 Rekha V. Kamble v. Dr. N.M. Agrawal, 1999 (3) CPJ 75: 1999 (3) CPR 1 (Mah. SCDRC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 33

  Renu Jain v. Escorts Heart & Research Institute, 1992 (2) CPJ 391 (NCDRC)

 Revathy & Anr. v. Dr. Chandra & Anr., 2001 (1) CPR 600 (TN SCDSRC)

 Rich v. Pierpont, 1862, 3 F & F 36

 Riggs v. Christier, 173 NE 2d 610, Mass 1961

 Rina Prakash (Smt.) v. Dechi Ganpati & Ors., 1994 (3) CPJ 358 (Karn. SCDRC)

 Robinsons v. Salford Health Authority, (1992) 3 Med LR 270

 Roe v. Ministry of Health, (1954) 2 All ER 131: (1954) 2 Q.B. 66 (1954) 1 W.L.R. 128:98

Sol. Jo 319

 Rogers v. Whitaker, (1992) Aust. Torts Rep. 81: 1993 (109) ALR 625

 Rohini Devi (Ms.) v. Dr. H.S. Chudavat, 2001 (3) CPR 172 (NCDRC)

 Rohini Devi v. Dr. H.S. Chudavat & Anr., 1995 (1) CPJ 334: 1994 (3) CPR 621(Raj.SCDRC)

 Rohini Pritam Kabadi (Smt.) v. R.T. Kulkarni, 1996 (3) CPJ 441:1998 (1) CPR 142(Karn.

SCDRC)

 Rookes v. Barnard, (1964) AC 1129 (1221) (HL)

 Rose v. Friddell, 423 SW 2d 658, Tex, 1967

 Ross v. Counters, (1979) 3 All ER 580; Junior Books Ltd.v. Veitchi Co. Ltd., (1982) 3 All ER

201 (HL)

 Rourke v. Bouton, The Times, 23rd June 1982

 Rudick v. Prineville Memorial Hospital, 319 F 2d 764, CCA 9, 1963

 Rudal Shah v. State of Bihar, 1983 (3) SCR 508: AIR 1983 SC 1036

 Rukmani v. State of Tamil Nadu, AIR 2003 Mad.-HC 352

 Rylands v. Fletcher, (1868) LR 3 HL 330

 S. Gurunathan (Dead) (Dr.) v. Vijaya Health centre, 2003 (1) CPR 222 (NCDRC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 34

  S. Iqbal Khan v. Child Trust Hospital, Madras, 1994 (3) CPR 233 (TN SCDRC)

 S. Kantamma v. Medicity Hospital, Madras, 1994 (3) CPR 233 (TN SCDRC)

 S. Krishan Rao & Ors. V. Sudha Nursing Home & Ors., 2001 (3) CPJ 478 (AP SCDRC)

 S. Rama Rao v. Bantwal Sulochana Madhava Shenoy Trust (Regd.) & Ors. , 1997 (1) CPJ

301 (Karn. SCDRC)

 S. Ramanujam v. Dr. C.P. Sreekumar, 1999 (1) CPR 4914 (TN SCDRC)

 S. Suresh Kumar v.Anand Hospital & Anr., 1996 (3) CPJ 534 (TN SCDRC)

 S. Tharani v. Southern Railway Headquarters Hospital, 1999 (3) CPR 336 (TN SCDRC)

 S.A. Quershi v. PadodeMemorial Hospital and Research Centre, 2002 CCJ 98 (MP SCDRC)

 S.B Dutt (Dr.) v. University of Delhi, 1959 SCR 1236

 S.B Jain (Dr.) v. Moon Devi & Anr., 1998 (2) CPJ 239 (Har. SCDRC)

 S.B Kadkol v. Dr. N. Chandershekhara & Ors., 2000 (1) CPR 131 (Karn, SCDRC)

 S.B. Nayyar (Dr.) v. Bhupinderpal singh, 2003 (3) CLD 52 (Punj. SCDRC)

 S.B Tiwari v. Dr. D. Panavadhyani, 1996 (1) CPJ 301 (NCDRC)

 SB. Venkatappa v. Dr. Kasthuri S. Shallikeri & Anr. , 1995 (2) CPR 80 (Karn. SCDRC)

 S.K Iyengar v. Bombay Hospital and Medical Research Centre & Ors., 2001 (1) CPJ 23

(NCDRC)

 S.K. Sharma v. Dr. P.B. Desai, 2000 (3) CPJ 407: 2001 (1) CPR 68 (Mah. SCDRC)

 S.K Sharma v. Dr. Praful B. Desai, 2003 (2) CPJ 90 (NCDRC)

 S,K, Sukur v. State of Orissa, 1991 (2) CPJ 202 (NCDRC)

 S.L Dhawan (Dentist) (Dr.) v. Post Graduate Medical Institute & Research Centre and Six

Ors., 1998 (2) CPR 425: 1998 (3) CPJ 128 (Chd.-UT CDRC)

 S.N Namboodiri (Dr.) v. Haneefa, 1998 (1) CPJ 389 (Ker. SCDRC)

 S.P. Gupta v. Union of India, (1981) Supp. SCC 87: AIR 1982 SC 149

 S.V. Panchori & Ors. V. Dr. Kaushal Pandey & Ors. 1999 (1) CPR 385 (Mah. SCDRC)

 SA’d v. Robinson and Ors., [1989] 4 BMLR 13 QBD

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 35
  Sachin Aggarwal @ Vicky (through guardian) v. Dr. Ashok Arora, 1993 (1) CPJ 113 (Har.

SCDRC)

 Sai Medical Stores v. R.D Gupta, 1992 (2) CPJ 515 (MP SCDRC)

 SAif Ali v. Sidney Mitchell & Co. (1980) 1 AC 198

 SAlgaocar Medical Research Centre v. R.B. Raikar, 1996 (2) CPJ 209: 1996 (2) CPR 50

(NCDRC)

 SAlinder @ Surender v. Dr. Vijay Gupta & Ors. , 1998 (3) CPJ 352 (Har. SCDRC)

 Samar Nath Mukherjee v. Dr. SAroj Ghosh, 2000 (#) CPJ 216: 2000 (3) CPR 332 (WB

SCDRC)

 Sambhu Singh v. Kamrun Nissa, 1992 (2) AJR 339: 1992 (2) TAC 354: 1992 (2) ACC 494:

1992 ACJ 516 (Orissa)

 SAntosh Bhardwaj (Smt.) v. Post Graduate Institute of Medical Science, 2002 (1) CPR 375

(Chd.-UT-CDRC)

 Santosh Kaur Sodhi v. Dr. Vijay Mujoo, 2003 (2) CLD 751: 2003 (2) CPJ 344 (Chd.-

UTCDRC)

 SAntosh Sharma v. State bank of india, 1991 (2) CPJ 262: 1991 (1) CPR 103 (NCDRC)

 SAnzari v. Rosefeld, 167 A 2d 625, NJ 1961

 SAraswati (Mrs.) v. M/s Vimla Hospital (P) Ltd., 2000 (1) CPJ 115 (TN SCDRC)

 Saraswati Parakhoi v. Grid Corporation of Orissa, 2001 ACJ 874 (Ori.) (DB)

 SArwan Singh v.State of Punjab, AIR 1978 SC 1525

 SAtish Bnasal v. Rajeev Gandhi Cancer Institute, 2002 (1) CLD 5 (NCDRC)

 Satish Chandra Shukla v. Union of India , 1987 ACJ 628 (MP-HC)

 SAtish Goswami v. Dr. Kammela Sreedhar, 2003 (2) CLD 323 (AP SCDRC)

 SAtwant Kaur (Mrs.) v. Dr. Kanwaljit Kaur, 1998 (2) CPR 458: 1998 (1) CPJ 298 (Punj.

SCDRC)

 SAtya Arti (Dr.) (Mrs.) v. Smt. Shashi Sharma, 2003 (1) CLD 149: 2003 (3)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 36

  CPR 17: 2003 (1) CPJ 612 (J&K-HC)(DB)

 SAu Madhuri v. Dr. Rajendra & Ors., 1996 (3) CPJ 75 (NCDRC)

 Saunders. V. Leeds Western H.A., (1993) CPJ 75 (NCDRC)

 SAvita v. State of A.P., 1999 ACJ 454 (A.P.) (DB)

 SAvita Y. Chaudhari v. Dr. Ghanshyam G. Kochure, Complaint No. 672/92 Decided on

8.2.1994 (Mah. SCDRC)(Unreported)

 SAvitri Devi v. Union of India, 2003 (1) CPR 240 (Punj. SCDRC)

 SAvitri Singh v. Dr. Ranbir Pd. Singh, 2003 (3) CLD 383: 2004 (1) CPJ 25 (Bih. SCDRC)

 Scott v. London and St. Katherine’ Docks, (1865)2 H&C 596

 Scott v. Salem Country Memorial Hospital, 280 A 2d 843, NJ 1971

 Selfe v. IIford and District Hospital Management Committee, 1970 Times, 26 November

 Sethu Raman Subramanian Iyer v. Triveni Nursing Home & Anr., 1998 (1) CPJ 110

(NCDRC)

 Sewa Ram v. Dr. Vitual K. Gupta, 1999 (2) CPR 68 (Punj. SCDRC)

 Shahjahan Siddiquie & Anr. V. Ruby General ?Hospital & Anr., 2003 (2) CPJ 182 (WB

SCDRC)

 Shahul Hameed & Anr. V. Apollo Hospital Enterprises & Ors., 2002 (2)CPJ 189 2002

(3)CPR 1 (TN SCDRC)

 Shailesh Shah (Dr.) v. Aphraim Jayanand Rathod, First Appeal No. 597/95, Decided on

8.5.2003 (NCDRC)

 Shakuntla Sharma v. State of U.P., 2001 ACJ 620 (All-HC) (DB)

 Sham Lal & Ors. (Dr.) v. Mrs. Saroj Rani & Ors., 2003 (1) CPJ 47 (NCDRC)

 Shanta (Mrs.) v. State of A.P. and Ors., 1997 (3) CPJ 481 (AP-HC) (DB)

 Shanti & Anr. V. Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education & Research, 1998 (1) CPJ 609

(Chd.-UT CDRC)

 Shanti Devi v. Dr. C.K Mittal & Anr., 1998 (3) CPJ 7 (Har. SCDRC)
©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 37
  Sharad Vaidya (Dr.) v. Paulo Joel Vales (deceased by LRs) and ors., 1994 ACJ 835 (Bom.-

HC, Panaji Bench)

 Shashikala & anr. V. Command Hospital (Air Force) & Ors. , 2003 (2) CPJ 84 (Karn.

SCDRC)

 Shashikumar v. Dr. Suresh Harve, 2003 (2) CLD 236 (Kar. SCDRC)

 Shefali Bhargava v. Indraprastha Apollo Hospital, 2003 (1) CLD 910 : 2003 (1) CPJ 216:

2003 (3) CPR 58 (NCDRC)

 Sheikhupua TransportCo. Ltd. V. Northern India Transporters Insurance Co. Ltd.,AIR 1971

SC 164

 Shibu v. St. Joseph Hospital & Ors., 1995 (3) CPR 177 (Ker.SCDRC)

 Shikha v. Dr. Ashok Jindal, 2003 (1) CPJ (NCDRC)

 Shiv Gopal v. Dr. (Smt.) Sudha Gupta & Anr., 2000 (1) CPR 243 (UP SCDRC)

 Shivaji Gedeo Chavan v. Chief Director Wanless Hospital & Anr., 1995 (#) CPJ 43

 (Mah. SCDRC)

 Shivkumar Gautam (Dr.) v. Alima B. & Ors., 1999 (1) CPR 592 (MP SCDRC)

 Shobha v. Government, NCT of Delhi, AIR 2003 Del.-HC 399

 Shri Ganesh Trading Co., Saugar v. State of Madhya Pradesh, 1972 MPLJ 864 (FB)

 Shubh Lata v. Christian Medical College, 1995 (1) CPJ 365 (Punj. SCDRC)

 Shushrusha Citizens Co-op. Hospital & Anr. V. Murlidhar Eknath Masane, 2003 (2) CPJ 127

(NCDRC)

 Shyam Kumar (Dr.) v. Rameshbhai Harmanbhai Kachhiya, 2002 (1) CPR 320 (Guj. SCDRC)

 Shyam Sunder Tantia & Anr. (Dr.) v. Deepika & Ors., 2002 (1) CPJ 411 (Raj. SCDRC)

 Shyam Sunder v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1974 SC 890: (1974) 1 SCC 690: 1974 ACJ 296

 Sidway v. Bathlem Royal Hospital, (1985) 1 All ER 643 (HL): (1985) 2 WLR 480 (HL) :

1985 AC 871

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 38

  Sidharth Batta v. Dr. Maj. Gen.M.L.Magotra, 2003 (2) CLD 266L: AIR 2003 NOC 477

(J&K-HC)

 Simmon v. Health Laundry Co., (1910) 1 KB 543

 Sir Gangaram Hospital v. D.P. Bhandari and Ors., 1992 (2) CPJ 397 (NCDRC)

 Siva Ram v. Stat, AIR 1965 Alll 196

 Slater v. Baker, (1767) 2 Wils. 359

 Smita Ashok Bangal (Mrs.) v. Noorjehan Israr Ahmed Ansari & anr. , 2000 (3) CPJ 132

(Mah. SCDRC)

 Smith v. Barking, Havering and Brentwood HA, (1994) 5 Med LR 285

 SMN Consumer Protection Council & Anr. V. Ganga Hospital & Anr., 1994 (3) CPJ 237 (TN

SCDRC)

 Soni Kumari (Minor) v. Dr. Nagendra Narain Bhagat, 2003 (1) CPJ 196: 2003 (1) CPR 321:

2004 (7) CLD 388 (Bih. SCDRC)

 Sourindra Mohan Ghosh v. D. V. Pahwa, 2001 (1) CPR 200: 2002 (2) CPJ 243 (WB SCDRC)

 Special Machines v. Punjab National Bank, 1991 (1) CPJ 78: 1991 (1) CPR 52 (NCDRC)\

 Spring Meadows Hospital & Anr. V. Harjot Ahluwalia (through K.S. Ahluwalia) & Anr.,

1998 (3) CPR 1 (SC): 1998 (1) CPJ 1: JT 1998 (2) SC 620

 Sr. Louie & Ors. (Dr.) v. Smt. Kannolol Pathumma & Anr., 1993 (1) CPR 422 (NCDRC)

 Srikrishan Nursing Home v. Smt. P. Yasoda & Ors., 1997 (3) CPJ 532 (AP SCDRC)

 Stacey v. Chiddy, [1993] 4 Med LR 216 affirmed in [1993] 4 Med LR 345

 State Government v. Vijay Singh, 2003 (3) CPJ 382 (Uttaranchal SCDRC)

 State of Gujrat v. Dr. Maltiben Valji Bhai Shah, 1994 ACJ 375 (Guj HC)

 State of Gujrat v. Laxmiben Jayantilal Sikligar, AIR 2000 Guj. 180 (DB)

 State of Haryana & Ors. V. Smt. Santra, (2000) 5 SCC 182: AIR 2000 SC 1888: 2000(1) CPJ

53 (SC)

 State of M.P & Ors. V. Ashram, 1997 ACJ 1224

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 39
  State of M.P v. Sundari Bai and Anr., AIR 2003 MP-HC 284

 State of Maharashtra v. Kanchanmala Vijaysingh Shirke & Ors., JT 1995 (6) SC 155

 State of Rajasthan v. Vidyawati, AIR 1962 SC 933: (1963) SCJ 307: (1962) 2 SCA 362

 State of U.P. v. Hindustan Lever Ltd., AIR 1972 All 486: 1972 all LJ 501

 State of U.P. v. Krishna Gopal, JT 1988 (3) SC 544: AIR 1988 SC 2154

 State of U.P. v. Tulsi Ram, AIR 1971 All. 162: 1970 All Cri R 429: 1970 all WR (HC) 160

 State v. Devaki Amma, 1971 ACJ 45 (Ker.- HC)

 Study Circle Society v. Choithram Hospital & Research Centre, 2000 (2) CPJ 436: 2000(3)

CPR 321 (MP SCDRC)

 Subhashsis Dhar v. Smt. Sanjukta Sengupta, 1999 (3) CPJ 29 (NCDRC)

 Subhasis Bakshi v. West Bengal Medical Council, (2003) 2 ACE 403 (SC)

 Subhlata v. Christian Medical College, 1995 (1) CPJ 365 (Punj. SCDRC)

 Subraia Kumar Ghost v. Dr. Adit Dey & Ors., 2002 (1) CPJ 431 (WB SCDRC)

 Sudhanshu Bhattacharya (Dr.) v. B.S. Hedge, 1993 (3) CPR 414 (NCDRC)

 Sudheendra Medical Mission Hospital & Ors. V. V.R. Kennen, 2003 (2) CPJ 146: 2003 (5)

CLD 211 (NCDRC)

 Sukhchain Singh v. Chandigarh Administration Though Secretary Health & Anr., 2003 (5)

CLD 211 (NCDRC)

 Sukhwarsha Rani v. General Hospital, through Secretary Health & Ors., 2000 (1) CPR 337

(Chd.-UTCDRC)

 Suman Bai v. State of M.P., AIR 1982 MP 62

 Suman Jain & Ors. V. Insol Tertiary Care Hospital, though Sh. Daljeet singh Gujral, its

Managing Director & Ors., 2003 (1) CPR 131 (Punj. SCDRC)

 Sunakar Bhol v. Amar Drug House, 1992 (2) CPJ 938 (Ori. SCDRC)

 Sunil Rungta (Dr.) v. Dr. Chandreshekhar agarwal, 2002 (3) CPR 30:2002 (3) CPJ

266(Jharkhand SCDRC)
©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 40
  Sunita Vasant Heganawar & Ors. V. Miraj Medical Centre 1994 (2) CPJ 544: 1994 (3) CPR

214 (Mah. SCDRC)

 Supriti Modak (Smt.) v. Dr. Gokul Ch. Modak, 2001 (2) CPJ 219 (WB SCDRC)

 Suraj Singh v. Dr. Manoj Kankaney, 2000 (2) CPJ 293 (UP SCDRC)

 Surinder Kumar (Laddi) & Anr. V. Dr. SAntosh Menon & Ors., 2000 (1) CPR 23 (Punj.

SCDRC)

 Surjit Kaur v. Dr. Deepak Kaura, 2003 (2) CLD 764:2003 (1) cpj 622 (Chd. UTCDRC)

 Sutton v. Population Service Family Planning Programme Ltd. , The Times, 7.11.1981

 Suvarna Baljekar v. Rohit Bhatt \, 1996 (2) CPJ 75: 1996 (2) CPR 13 (NCDRC)

 Suyash Hospital (P) Ltd. V. Prassanna Kumar Ojha, 2003 (2) CLD 451: 2003 (2) CPJ 150

(NCDRC)

 Swanson v. Wilson, (1953) 3 D.L.R. 171

 Syad Akbar v. State of Karnataka, AIR 1979 SC 1848 : 1979 Cri. LJ 1374 (SC): 1980 SCC

(Cri) 59: 1980 (1) SCC 30

 Syed Zahid Ali v. Dr. Jaya Prakash Pliwal, 2000 (1) CPJ 129 (MP SCDRC )

 Szekeres v. Robinson, (1986) 715 P 2d 1076

 T. Hareendran Nair v. Dr. P. Ashokan, 1995 (1) CPJ 220 (Ker. SCDRC)

 T. Padmabhan v. Hindustan Maternity Home, Decided by the Kerala State Commission

Hindustan Times, Delhi, 9.11.98

 T. Rama Rao v. Vijaya Hospital & Anr., 1997 (3) CPJ 59 : 1997 (3) CPR 477 (TN SCDRC)

 T.T. Thomas (Dr.) v. Smt. Elisa, AIR 1987 Ker – HC 52: 1986 Ker. LT 1026:1987 ACJ 192

(Ker-HC) (DB)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 41

  T. Vani Devi (Dr.) (Smt.) v.Tugutla Lakshmi Narasaiah Alias Narasa Reddy, 2003 (1) CLD

860 : 2003 (1) CPJ 180:2003 (1) CPR 325 (NCDRC)

 T.M.T. Panjali v. S Jamuna Lokanathan, 1999 (2) CPR 408 (TN SCDRC)

 T.V. Krishna (Dr.) v. S.K. Afsar, 2003 (6) CLD 958 (AP SCDRC)

 Tankship (U.K.) Ltd. v. Morts Dock & Engineering Co., (1961) 1 All ER 404 (PC)

 Tapan Kumar Nayak & Ors. v. State of Orrisa & Ors., 1997 (2) CPJ 14:1997 (2) CPR 104

(NCDRC)

 Tapas Das Gupta v. Dr. Kalyan Mukerjee, 2002 (2) CPJ 73 (WB SCDRC)

 Tarachand Jain v. Ganga Ram Hospital, 1999 (3) CPJ 53 (NCDRC)

 Tarasoff v. Regents of the University of California, 551 P(2d) 334 (1976)

 Tarun Kumar Pramanik v. Dr. Kunal Chakraborty & Ors., 1995 (2) CPR

 Tarun Thakore v. Dr. Noshir M. Shroff, 2003 (1) CLD 62 (NCDRC)

 Thake v. Maurice, (1986) QB 644: (1986) 1 All ER 479

 Thomarina Marcel D’Cruz v. Management of St. Joseph’s Boys Higher Secondary School &

Ors., 1998 (1) CPJ 340 (TN SCDRC)

 Thumu Padma v. Dr. Hemlatha, 2003 (6) CLD 108 (AP SCDRC)

 TMT. Chandra v. Mahesh & Ors., 2000 (1) CPJ 361: 2000 (2) CPR 129:2001 CCJ 1362 (TN

SCDRC) Treasury Officer & Member Secretary, Pensioner Medical Fund & Ors. v.

G.K. Joshi, 1996 (1) CPJ 22 (Raj SCDRC)

 Trilochan Pradhan (Dr.) v. R.P. Acharya, 1999 (1) CPR 247 (Ori.-SCDRC)

 U.K. Kinni & Anr. (Dr.) v. K. Vasudeva Pai & Ors. 2001 ACJ 2141 (Karn. -HC) (DB)

 Udale v. Bloomsbury Area Health Authority, (1983) 2 All ER 522

 Uday Kant Jha v. Moolchand Khairaiti Ram Hospital, 2003 (4) CLD 922 (Del. SCDRC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 42

  Uday Shankar Bhagat v. Santosh Kumar Sah, 2004 (1) CPR 64 (Bih. SCDRC)

 Ujjain Charitable Trust Hospital v. Ramesh Chandra & Ors., 2003 (3) CPJ 181 (MP

SCDRC)

 Uma Pinglay v. Dr. N.P. Mookherjee & Ors. , 1997 (2) CPR 160 (Karn. SCDRC)

 Uma v. Dr. Nishu Kharbanda & Anr. , 1997 (2) CPJ 580 (Har. SCDRC)

 United State Shipping Co. v. Ship St. Abbans, AIR 1931 PC 189

 Urmila Upadhyay Gynaecologist Surgeon (Dr.) v. Anjani Kumar Panday, 2002 (3) CPR 240

(MP SCDRC)

 Usha Mehrotra (Mrs.) v. Apollo Hospitals Enterprises Ltd., 1999 (2) CPR 453(SCDRC)

 Usha Rajput v. Sir Ganga Ram Hospital, 2003 (1) CLD 352 (Del. SCDRC)

 Usha v. G.B. Namboodiri, 1986 ACJ 141 (Ker -HC)

 Uttaranchal Forest Hospital Trust v. Smt. Raisan, 2004 (1) CPJ 257 (Uttaranchal -SCDRC)

 V. Chandra Sekar v. Malar Hospital Ltd., 2001 (1) CPJ 137: 2001 (1) CPR 628 (TN SCDRC)

 V. Chandrasekhar v Apollo Hospitals Enterprises Ltd., 1994 I.L.W. 68 (Mad-HC) (DB)

 V. Chitralekha v. Director & Superintendent, I.O.G. & Ors., 1998 (1) CPJ 124(TN SCDRC)

 V.Vassanda Coumarry v. DR. T. Ramachandrudu, 1998 (3) CPR 277 (Pondi SCDRC)

 V.P. Chopra v. Dr. S.P. Kumar, 2003 (2) CLD 567 (Del. SCDRC)

 V.P. Shantha & Ors. V. Cosmopolitan Hospitals Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. , 1997 (1) CPR 377(Ker.

SCDRC)

 Vadlamudi Nageswara Rao v Dr. Koneru Gangadhara Rao M.D.D.G.O., 2004 (8) C; D (1)

(AP-SCDRC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 43

  Vaghri Gopal Bhai v. Parmar Navalben Balabhai & Anr. , 1993(1) CPR 526 1993 (2) CPJ

1038 (Guj. SCDRC)

 Valdez v. Percy, 217 P 2d 422, Cal 1950

 Vaqar Mohd. Khan& Anr. v. Dr. S.K. Tondon, 2002 (2) CPJ 169 (MP SCDRC)

 Varanasi Subrahmanyam v. Dr. G. Ravi Kumar, 2003 (3) CLD 593 : 2004 (1) CPJ 125 (AP

SCDRC)

 Ved Khuller (Dr.) v. State, 1988 ACJ 328 (J&K-HC)

 Venkappa v. Devamma, (1956) Mad. 1381

 Venkatesh Iyer v. Bombay Hospital Trust, 1998 (2) TAC 820 (Bom.)

 Venkatesh v. Tamil Nadu, AIR 1993 SC 1230

 Vijay H. Mankar v. Dr.(Mrs.) Mangla Bansod & Ors., 2000 (1) CPJ 37 (NCDRC)

 Vijaya Raghavan v. Dr. Dheg, 2000 (3) CPJ 251 (TN SCDRC)

 Vijayamma (Mrs.) v. Apollo Diagnostic Centre & Ors., 2002 (1) CPJ 230 (AP SCDRC)

 Vimlesh Dixit v. Dr. R.K. Singhal, 2004 (1) CPJ 123 (Uttaranchal SCDRC)

 Vinitha Ashok (Smt.) v. Lakshmi Hospital, AIR 2001 SC 3914: 2001 (8) JT 142: 2001 (6)

Scale 476: (2001) 8 SCC 731 : 2001 (4) Supreme 225 : 2001 (6) SLT 735: 2001 (3) KLT 606:

2002 (1) CPJ 4 (SC) Vinitha Ashok v. Lakshmi Hospital & Ors., 1992 (2) CPJ 372

(NCDRC)

 Vinod Kumari Srivastav v. Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd., 2003 (1) CPJ 246 (UP SCDRC)

 Vinubahi Parshottamdas Patel v. Vijay K. Ajmera, 1997 (1) CPR 348 (Guj. SCDRC)

 Vivek Sahay (Dr.) v. Ajay Prasad @ Ajay Prasad Gupta, 2003 (3) CLD 101: 2002 (3) CPR

303 (Jharkhand SCDRC)

 Voluntary Organization in Interest of Consumer Education (VOICE) v. Registrar Tamil Nadu

State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, 2003 (1) CLD 1045: 2003 (2) CPJ 33

(NCDRC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 44

W

 Wahid Khan v. Dr. Mohd. Abdul, 1999 (3) CPJ 304 (UP SCDRC)

 Walker v. Semple, (1993) CA 573

 Warren v. Greig and White, The Lancet, 1935, Vol. LP 330

 Weld Blundell v. Stephens, 1920 AC 956-86 (HL)

 West v. Shephard, 1964 AC 326: (1963) 2 All ER 625 : (1963) 2 WLR 1359 (HL)

 White v. Board of Governors of Westminster Hospital, The Time 26th October 1961

 White House v. Jordan, (1980) All ER 650: (1979) 3 WLR 150

 White House v. Jordan, (1981) 1 All ER 267 HL:

 Whiteford v. Hunter, (1950) 94 Sol. Jo 758: (1950) WN 553

 Whiteford V. Wittaker Memorial Hospital, 169 SE 2d 563, Va 1969

 Wilsher v. Essex Area Health Authority, (19860 3 All ER 801 (CA)

 Wise v. Kaye, (1962) 1 QB 638

 Wood v. Thurston, 1953 -1-C.L.C. 687

 Woronka v. Sewall, 69 NE 2d 581, Mass 1946

 Wright v. Wellock, 1971 RTR 228

 Xv. Hospital Z & Anr., 1998 (6) SCALE 230: 1998 (7) JT 626: 1998 (8) SCC 296

 X v. Hospital Z, 2003 (1) CLD 1:2003 (1) SCC 500:2003 (1) CPJ 14:2003 (1) CPR 298 (SC)

 X v. Hospital Z, AIR 2003 SC 644

 Y.K. Ramamurthy v. Dr. L.P. Nagarajaiah. 1997 (1) CPJ 525: 1997 (2) CPR59 (Karn. SCDRC)

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 45

  Yoginder Beri v. Grover Eye and E.N.T. Hospital & Ors., 2001 (3) CPJ 106(Chd. UTCDRC)

 Younghusband v. Luftung, (1949) 2 KB 354

 Zirker v. Robertson, (1897) 30 NSR 61

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 46