The Strength Analysis of Steel Sunk Screw Connections in The Rocket
The Strength Analysis of Steel Sunk Screw Connections in The Rocket
net/publication/316520765
CITATIONS READS
3 227
2 authors, including:
Xiaotian Zhang
Beihang University (BUAA)
20 PUBLICATIONS 60 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Xiaotian Zhang on 21 August 2019.
Acta Astronautica
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/actaastro
The strength analysis of steel sunk screw connections in the rocket MARK
⁎
Xiaogang Li, Xiaotian Zhang
School of Astronautics, Beihang University, Beijing 100191 PR China
A R T I C L E I N F O A BS T RAC T
Keywords: A finite element model is established to investigate the strength and slip characteristic of sunk screw
Sunk screw connections in the rocket. A typical configuration is used as the basic model of parametric study to analyze
Strength analysis the influence of pretension, friction coefficient and the angle of sunk head. It is found that with the rise of
Slip characteristic pretension force, the maximum von Mises of sunk screw connection decreases before the optimal pretension
Pretension
force and then increases, and the optimal pretension force can be predicted by finite element method. The
Friction coefficient
Angle of sunk head
friction coefficient has positive influence on structural behavior. With the rise of angle of sunk head, the
maximum Von Mises increases and then decreases, and the position of stress concentration transfer from the
middle of sunk screw to the lower edge of sunk head.
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: zhangxiaotian@buaa.edu.cn (X. Zhang).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.actaastro.2017.04.032
Received 8 August 2016; Accepted 8 April 2017
Available online 27 April 2017
0094-5765/ © 2017 IAA. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
X. Li, X. Zhang Acta Astronautica 137 (2017) 345–352
F 4M
J= + 2.1. Geometry of sunk screw connections
n nD (1)
The single sunk screw connection is simplified as a double shear
where n=24 is the amount of the sunk screws, D=0.324 m is the
connection to investigate the behavior of the sunk screw under shear
diameter of bearing circle. The result of the calculation is J=4919.2 N.
force. Fig. 4 shows the sectional dimension of sunk screw connection.
There is no engineering algorithm for sunk screw connections to
The width of the specimens is 44 mm. The left ends of top plate and the
examine the strength. Because of the particularity of sunk screw, its
bottom plate are fixed and the shear force is applied to the right ends of
structural performance under shear force is between ordinary bolted
middle plate. Fig. 5 shows the dimension of sunk screw.
connections and fitting bolted connections which both have the
The values of parameters in Figs. 4 and 5 are defined as:
universal engineering checking algorithm. But the performance of that
two kinds of connections is too wide-range to make an accurate
R1 = 8.2 mm
judgment of whether the sunk screw connections are strong enough. R2 = 8 mm
Because of the structure symmetry of sunk screw connections R3 = 4.2 mm
between two cabins along the circumference, the most dangerous R = 4 mm
single sunk screw connection which bearing the maximum load is H = 4 mm
chosen to be the research object. This paper will present a parametric h = 6 mm
study of sunk screw connections about the pretension force, friction θ = 90°
coefficient and the angle of sunk head using the commercial finite
element modeling software ANSYS.
Fig. 1. The bending moment distribution along the rocket body. Fig. 5. The dimension of sunk screw.
346
X. Li, X. Zhang Acta Astronautica 137 (2017) 345–352
347
X. Li, X. Zhang Acta Astronautica 137 (2017) 345–352
Fig. 11. The data in path1. (a)SX, SZ, SXZ and SEQV, (b) UX, UZ and USUM.
Fig. 12. The data in path2. (a)SX, SZ, SXZ and SEQV, (b) UX, UZ and USUM.
obtained from the paths are the coordinate values(XG,YG,ZG), the von
Mises stress(SEQV), the stress along the X axis(SX), the stress along
the Y axis(SY), the stress along the Z axis(SZ), the shear stress in plane
X-Z(SXZ), the deformation along the X axis(UX), the deformation
along the Y axis(UY) the deformation along the Z axis(UZ) and the total
deformation(USUM). Figs. 11 and 12 show the SX, SZ, SEQV, SXZ,
UX, UZ and USUM in two paths.
In path 1, as shown in Fig. 11(a), the maximum stress points in all
configurations in this paper, appear around the lower edge of the sunk
screw where ZG=4.2 mm or the middle of the shank where
ZG=7.65 mm. The performance of the sunk screw depends on the
stress value of these two points. As shown in Fig. 12(a), the dangerous
part in path 2 is the middle of screw, where ZG range from 6 mm to
12 mm. Comparing the stress in path 1 and path 2, the SEQV in path 2
is less than that in path 1, so caring the data in path 1 is enough for
consideration of the strengh of sunk screw. The deformation curves in
Fig. 11(b) and Fig. 12(b) present the phenomenon of screw bending.
The deformation along Z axis is caused by asymmetry. Fig. 13. The MXSEQV of sunk screw in different pretension force.
3. Parametric study
is obtained from the data of a node which always located in path1 and
3.1. Pretension force the coordinate ranging from ZG=7.65 mm to ZG=8.6357 mm with the
rise of pretension.
Analyzing the effects of pretension force on sunk crew connections As shown in Fig. 13, the MXSEQV of sunk screw decreased first and
by changing the pretension force from P=0 N to P=3000 N while the then increased with the increase of pretension force, and the minimum
external force and friction coefficient is the same as the typical of MXSEQV appears when P=2250 N. As shown in Fig. 14, because of
configuration. The max von-Mises stress of sunk screw(MXSEQV), the increase of friction force that leading by the increase pretension
the max contact sliding(MXSLID) and the max force, the MXSLID and the MXUSUM decreases almost by linear,
deformation(MXUSUM) are shown in Figs. 13 and 14. The MXSEQV which indicate that the stiffness increased.
348
X. Li, X. Zhang Acta Astronautica 137 (2017) 345–352
Table 1
The stress state of middle plate in different pretension force.
349
X. Li, X. Zhang Acta Astronautica 137 (2017) 345–352
Table 2
The stress state of middle plate in different friction coefficient.
0 0 0 4993.2 – 0
0.05 85.0 71.2 4837.1 1.194 3.23
0.10 152.3 128.0 4713.0 1.190 5.95
0.15 204.8 174.6 4614.0 1.173 8.22
0.20 247.1 210.6 4535.6 1.173 10.09
0.25 283.1 236.3 4474.0 1.198 11.61
0.30 308.6 260.7 4424.0 1.184 12.87
where also the max von Mises point. On the other hand, when a great
angle of sunk head, the sunk screw can also be simplified to a simply
supported beam. But the details of sunk head is highly significant.
Because of the rapid change of dimension and force that top plate to
sunk head along Z axis, the stress concentration at the lower edge of
sunk head is extremely serious. Fig. 17. The MXSEQV in different θ.
The MXSLID increase with the rise of the angle of sunk head. That
because with the rise of θ , the supporting effect by the conical surface of
sunk hole to sunk head decreases. The slip between sunk head and As shown in Table 5, the MXSLID and MXUSUM increase with the
sunk hole is easily produced, relevantly, the sliding between plates is rise of θ, while the MXSEQV increases and then decreases. The max
greater. von Mises point locates around the lower edge of sunk head in Path 1
As shown in Table 4, with the rise of θ, the friction force increase. where ZG=4.69. As shown in Table 6, the friction force increases and
The greater angle of sunk head leads to the asymmetry of connection then decreases with the rise of θ. The reason for strength weaken while
which cause an intense extrusion between plates and finally results in friction force increase is explained as Chapter 3.3.1. When θ is great
an increase in friction force. Accordingly, the force that middle plate enough, the extrusion between plates diminish and result in a decrease
acts on sunk screw decreases. in friction force. Although the shear force that middle plate acts on
sunk screw augment, the strength of sunk screw connection is
enhanced because of the decrease of extrusion force between sunk
3.3.2. Change the edge height ‘m’ of sunk head
head and sunk hole.
The method by changing the value of R1 to change the angle of sunk
When m=0.5, 1.5 and 2.5 mm, change the value of pretension force
head is improper when θ is oversize that will make the sunk screw
and the results of MXSEQV is shown in Fig. 20.
abnormal. Another method is applied to change θ by changing the edge
As shown in Fig. 20, with the rise of pretension force, the MXSEQV
height of sunk head.
increases and then decreases when m=0, 0.5, and 1.5 mm. In fact,
Fig. 19 presents the dimension of blunt-edged sunk screw. Keep the
when m=2.5 mm and pretension force F=3500 N, the
height of sunk head H=4 mm. By changing the value of m, the angle of
MXSEQV=353.07 MPa, which is larger than that when F=3000 N. It
sunk head change from 90° to 180°. Make sure R1=8.2 mm, and other
is interesting to note that the turning points are pushed back with the
dimension of sunk hole fit the sunk head.
increase of θ. The optimal pretension force is exist in every angle of
Table 5 presents the angle of sunk head, MXSEQV, MXSLID and
sunk head.
MXUSUM in different edge height.
Table 3
The dimension value of different angle of sunk head.
350
X. Li, X. Zhang Acta Astronautica 137 (2017) 345–352
Table 4 Table 6
The stress state of middle platE in different angle of sunk head. The stress state of middle plate in different θ.
θ/° F1/N F2/N N1/N F1/F2 (F1+F2)/N1 (%) θ/° F1/N F2/N N1/N F1/F2 (F1+F2)/N1 (%)
59.8 167.2 154.6 4671.5 1.082 6.89 97.6 269.2 228.6 4495 1.178 11.07
70.0 194.1 173.9 4625.3 1.116 7.96 101.0 276.6 231.5 4485.1 1.195 11.33
79.0 219.3 191.8 4582.3 1.143 8.97 104.4 283.8 235.4 4474.1 1.206 11.60
87.1 240.2 206.1 4547.1 1.165 9.81 106.3 286.6 237.7 4469.0 1.206 11.73
90.0 247.1 210.6 4535.6 1.173 10.09 116.0 303.7 244.2 4445.4 1.244 12.33
94.1 255.8 215.5 4522.0 1.187 10.42 126.9 317.6 243.9 4431.8 1.302 12.67
100.4 275.5 219.0 4499.0 1.258 10.99 138.9 325.4 227.5 4440.4 1.430 12.45
105.9 284.5 227.6 4481.2 1.250 11.43 151.9 315.0 191.4 4487.0 1.648 11.29
110.8 293.6 232.8 4467.0 1.261 11.78 165.8 278.0 131.2 4584.1 2.119 8.93
171.4 253.3 109.1 4630.9 2.322 7.83
A finite element model is established to investigate the structural point which is named the optimal pretension force can be calculated
behavior of sunk screw connection and draw the following conclusions: by finite element methods.
2. The friction coefficient has positive influence on structural behavior.
1. Pretension force have effect on the behavior of sunk screw connec- In actual engineering, some strategies can be used to improve
tion. With the rise of pretension force, the maximum von Mises of friction coefficient such as increasing the surface roughness of plates
sunk screw connection decreases and then increases. The turning or surface treatment.
3. The angle of sunk head influence the structural behavior. With the
Table 5
The angle of sunk head and analysis data in different m.
m/mm 0.5 0.7 0.9 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 3.7
θ/° 97.6 101.0 104.4 106.3 116.0 126.9 138.9 151.9 165.8 171.4
SEQV/MPa 283.3 287.8 293.3 297.0 336.5 378.3 389.4 392.5 381.3 351.4
SLID/μm 30.1 31.6 32.6 33.2 36.3 40.4 45.8 53.1 62.0 65.7
USUM/mm 0.228 0.239 0.250 0.256 0.289 0.332 0.388 0.460 0.542 0.573
351
X. Li, X. Zhang Acta Astronautica 137 (2017) 345–352
rise of θ, the maximum von mises increases and then decreases, and [8] E. Shamoto, et al., Analytical prediction of contact stiffness and friction damping in
bolted connection, CIRP Ann.-Manuf. Technol. 63 (1) (2014) 353–356.
the position of stress concentration transfer from the middle of sunk [9] Cheng Yu, M.X. Panyanouvong, Bearing strength of cold-formed steel bolted
screw to the lower edge of sunk head. In summary, the angle of sunk connections with a gap, Thin-Walled Struct. 67 (2013) 110–115.
head is better to be small. [10] Yancheng Cai, Ben Young, Behavior of cold-formed stainless steel single shear
bolted connections at elevated temperatures, Thin-Walled Struct. 75 (2014) 63–75.
[11] F. Esmaeili, et al., Experimental and numerical study of the fatigue strength of
Funding double lap bolted joints and the effect of torque tightening on the fatigue life of
jointed plates, Trans. Indian Inst. Met. 67 (4) (2014) 581–588.
[12] S. Ganeshmurthy, S.A. Nassar, Finite Element Simulation of process control for
This research was supported by the National Natural Science bolt tightening in joints with nonparallel contact, J. Manuf. Sci. Eng. 136 (2) (2014)
Foundation of China (11502010) and the Fundamental Research (p.021018).
Funds for the Central Universities of China (YWF-14-YHXY-022). [13] P. Dusicka, G. lewis, High strength steel bolted connections with filler plates, J.
Constr. Steel Res. 66 (1) (2010) 75–84.
[14] P. Moze, D. Beg, High strength steel tension splices with one or two bolts, J. Constr.
References Steel Res. 66 (8–9) (2010) 1000–1010.
[15] P. Moze, D. Beg, Investigation of high strength steel connections with several bolts
[1] P. Moze, D. Beg, A complete study of bearing stress in single bolt connections, J. in double shear, J. Constr. Steel Res. 67 (3) (2011) 333–347.
Constr. Steel Res. 95 (2014) 126–140. [16] T. Kim, Y. Cho, Investigation on ultimate strength and failure mechanism of bolted
[2] E.L. Salih, L. Gardner, D.A. Nethercot, Bearing failure in stainless steel bolted joints in two different aluminum alloys, Mater. Des. 58 (2014) 74–88.
connections, Eng. Struct. 33 (2) (2011) 549–562. [17] A. Talja, M. Torkar, Lap shear tests of bolted and screwed ferritic stainless steel
[3] H.E.M. Sallam, et al., Effect of clamping force and friction coefficient on stress connections, Thin-Walled Struct. 83Pp (2014) 157–168.
intensity factor of cracked lapped joints, Eng. Fail. Anal. 18 (6) (2011) 1550–1558. [18] T. Dang Hoang, et al., Numerical modeling for prediction of ductile fracture of
[4] H. Draganic, T. Doksanovic, D. Markulak, Investigation of bearing failure in steel bolted structure under tension shear loading, Finite Elem. Anal. Des. 67 (2013)
single bolt lap connections, J. Constr. Steel Res. 98 (2014) 59–72. p56–65.
[5] Y.C. He, Y.C. Wang, Load-deflection behaviour of thin-walled plates with a single [19] Y. Cai, B. Young, Structural behavior of cold-formed stainless steel bolted
bolt in shearing, Thin-Walled Struct. 49 (10) (2011) 1261–1276. connections, Thin-Walled Strut. 83 (2014) 147–156.
[6] Y.C. He, Y.C. Wang, Load-deflection behaviour of thin-walled plates with multiple [20] G. Yang, et al., Three-dimensional finite element analysis of the mechanical
bolts in shearing, Thin-Walled Struct. 55 (10) (2012) 51–63. properties of helical thread connection, Chin. J. Mech. Eng. 26 (3) (2013) 564–572.
[7] J. Fernandez, et al., Prediction models for calculating bolted connections using data [21] T. Kim, J. Lim, Ultimate strength of single shear two-bolted connections with
mining techniques and the finite element method, Eng. Struct. 32 (10) (2010) austenitic stainless steel, Int. J. Steel Struct. 13 (1) (2013) 117–128.
3018–3027.
352