Research Proposal PDF
Research Proposal PDF
Submitted by:
Ramraj Sharma
Submitted to:
Table of Contents
PART I: INTRODUCTION
security market for years. Security market is a platform created to facilitate the exchange of
financial securities or assets by bringing together buyers and sellers of securities. It provides
an effective way of procuring long-term funds by issuing shares and debentures or bonds for
corporate enterprises and government and at the same time provide an investment opportunity
for individuals and institutions. When an investor thinks of an investment strategy, most of the
time it turns out to be purchase of some securities. These securities are tradable investment
assets such as stocks, bonds, and all of the assets which have monetary value. Nepal Stock
Exchange (NEPSE) is the only trading floor in Nepal that trades mainly shares and
The Nepalese bond market is not well developed and the investors and borrowers still
prefer bank loans against the bonds. Even within the bond market, the government bond
composes higher proportion than that of corporate sector. The corporate sectors, public
regulatory sector (NRB), brokers and other experts hold different views regarding the lack of
incentive for bond market growth and development. This study attempts to discuss the concept
of effects on debentures on the stock market of issuing company and further aims to analyze
the performance of Nepalese securities market. Similarly, the variables such as trading
turnovers, paid up values, market capitalization and stock price are analyzed for the secondary
market. Since, in Nepal corporate sectors have been issuing debentures as debt instrument and
IMPACT OF CORPORATE BOND ISSUANCE ON STOCK PRICE 4
bond issuance events are found only in case of NRB, debentures have been treated as corporate
bonds based on their availability and treatments by issuing companies in their financial reports.
payments over the maturity period. Inability to make such payments can lead to adverse
impacts on issuing company. Addition of huge debt to a company’s capital structure can cause
higher expected future cash flows (Barclay and Smith, 2005). So, events of debt issuance
signals that the company is well aware that it can pay its debt (coupons) obligations.
By present value models, incase of debt issuance, debt having higher interest (coupons)
payments (viz higher discount rates) , other things being equal, cause stock prices to fall; a fall
in expected discount rates should have the opposite effect on both. Putting the same point in
simpler terms, an increase in expected long-term bond yields would seem to make long-term
bonds a more attractive investment, and so stock prices would have to fall to induce people to
hold stocks. That argument might be right, if certain implicit assumptions about stochastic
properties of relevant variables are valid, but need not be. The problem with the argument is
that the dividend stream that is discounted for stocks is radically different than the stream of
coupons that is discounted for bonds. The implied differences in their stochastic properties can
be relevant for the problem of the relations between the two assets from at least two
perspectives.
First, the dividend stream on stocks is relatively stable in real terms, while the dividend
stream on debentures is in nominal terms. If there is substantial inflation, then these two streams
can be dramatically different in ways that are correlated with the (nominal) discount rates.
then these changes should perhaps have little effect on stock prices. Second, movements in l
interest rates might also be related to information about the future dividend stream on stocks.
results. In the case of announcements of bond issuance, there are no any statistically significant
stock market reaction (Haug, 2017). Besides solely analyzing straight bonds, Eckbo/Masulis
(1995) also look at the issue of convertible bonds and here the authors find negative effects on
stock market prices, which is due to the fact that convertible bonds have debt and equity
components. Eckbo/Masulis (1995) find that the stock market reaction is most negative for
common stock issues, less negative for convertible bonds and zero for straight debt issues
(Eckbo/Masulis 1995, p. 1042). Most studies carried out on the U.S. market find these negative
effects when convertible bonds are issued. Similarly, Machel (2013) conducted a study on the
effects of debt issues on the stock price performance of companies listed at the Nairobi
Securities Exchange and came to a conclusion that bond issues do not have a significantly
Since the findings are conflicting, this study of impact of corporate bond issuance on
stock price has further scope for research as it helps managers to understand how different
capital change decisions, more specifically the decision of debt issuance, affect the company
value.
1.3 Rationale
well as by raising additional funds. The new capital received can be seen as an advance on
future growth as the money can be used for investments that optimally increase the company
IMPACT OF CORPORATE BOND ISSUANCE ON STOCK PRICE 6
value. Firms that need additional funds can draw from a list of many possibilities of how they
want to raise new capital, ranging from equity offerings to different debt instruments.
Nepal has witnessed the frequent turn arounds of excess or minimum liquidity in the
financial markets. These turn arounds have stirred the financial institutions to issue bond and
raise capital and ensure a shield against the frequent changes in liquidity. Since, the capital
raised comes from the investors who seek to grab higher returns through high interest rates
offered by the financial institutions, there have been a shift of investors in capital market (stock
exchange) towards investment in bonds with an expectation to make a low risk and sure profit.
Corporate bond issuance can lead to changing patterns of demand and supply of stocks of
companies listed in the exchange and can also signal different expectation regarding company
performance in long run which could create drastic changes in the wealth of investors. Such
changing patterns has made it very essential to deduce the relationship between bond issuance
and the prices of stocks. This paper tries to identify how such debt instrument viz Bond
Issuance changes the prices of stocks listed on the stock market. In brief the research addresses
very practical issue that helps to understand the effect of corporate bond issuance on the stock
index.
The large body of empirical literature on the market reactions to bond issuances
motivated many researchers to develop theories about how the stock market movements can
be explained. Based on these theories, this paper formulates hypotheses that will be tested for
a sample of Nepalese stock market share prices of debenture issuing companies for a period
of 6 years between January 2013 and September 2019. Applying the event study methodology,
this paper aims at contributing to our understanding of why stock index behaves the way we
observe it.
IMPACT OF CORPORATE BOND ISSUANCE ON STOCK PRICE 7
The returns quoted by newly issued bonds can have impact on price of stocks. If the
expected returns of any underlying stock asset is less than the return promised by any newly
issued bond then there are high chances that investors shift their investment preferences to bond
and then sell their current stock holdings. This could lead to higher selling preferences of stocks
leading to decreased stock price. Considering the present value models, an increase in expected
future discount rates (viz bond yields) should, other things being equal, cause both stock prices
to fall and long-term interest rates to rise; a fall in expected discount rates should have the
opposite effect on both. Putting the same point in simpler terms, an increase in expected long-
term bond yields would seem to make long-term bonds a more attractive investment, and so
stock prices would have to fall to induce people to sell stocks. On the other hand, if the newly
issued bond has relatively lower returns than the stocks, it is more likely that the value of the
bond will decrease making the demand of the stocks higher. This argument claims there should
be a simple inverse relation between bond issuance with high returns and stock price.
According to Premchand, (1989), whenever a company issues debentures or bonds , the risk
perception of the equity holders increases, as debenture holders have to be paid interest, before
paying any amounts to the other beneficiaries of the company. So, the company has to increase
the dividend payout ratio, in order to create a balance and retain its existing shareholders and
IMPACT OF CORPORATE BOND ISSUANCE ON STOCK PRICE 8
keep them satisfied, even after the issue of debentures. Similarly, according Richardo Kolodny
and Diane Rizzuto Suhler (1998) debt issuance can signal equity investors about the kind of
investment companies will have through the issued funds and investments with higher potential
in cash flows can lead to expectations of increasing value of firms affecting stock market
positively.
However, though this has been the fundamental explanation on the relation between
bonds yields and stock price, this hasn't always been the case and we can see contradictory
results from different reports on this subject. Studies of stock market reactions to bond
announcements have seen to come with conflicting results. Antweiler and Frank (2006) come
to the result that for their sample of U.S. firms, announcements of straight bond issues do not
affect the stock price of the issuing firm. These results of Antweiler and Frank (2006) are
confirmed by Shyam-Sunder (1991) as well as by Eckbo and Masulis (1995) who also found
neither positive nor negative effects on the stock market when straight bonds were issued.
Similarly, Shyam Sunder (1991) studied bond ratings, but could not find statistically significant
effect of ratings on the stock market effects (Shyam-Sunder 1991). Gebhardt et al (2005), in
their study, indicated that bonds and stocks have the similar underlying cash flows and they are
affected by the company fundamentals. Their study shows that over a ninety day period, any
abnormal returns on a company’s share matched by better performance of short term notes with
A more recent investigation by Chin and Abdullah (2013) studies abnormal returns in
response to straight bond issues in Malaysia as well as the company characteristics that
influence that effect. Based on the sample of 100 bond issuers between 2000 and 2007, the
authors report a positive and significant cumulative average abnormal return for the 21 days
IMPACT OF CORPORATE BOND ISSUANCE ON STOCK PRICE 9
that surround the event. In this case, if we consider firm characteristics, we can find an
insignificant relationship of the control variables on the abnormal returns, Max Hung (2016)
In addition to solely analyzing straight bonds, Eckbo and Masulis (1995) also studies
at the issue of convertible bonds and the authors found negative effects on stock market prices,
which is due to the fact that convertible bonds have debt and equity components. Eckbo and
Masulis (1995) find that the stock market reaction is most negative for common stock issues,
less negative for convertible bonds and zero for straight debt issues (Eckbo and Masulis 1995).
The study conducted by Ammann et al. (2006) in the period 1996 – 2003 found results
similar to Eckbo and Masulis (1995). The authors report that the announcement of convertible
bonds leads to significant negative return of -2.43% for the German sub-sample in the two-day
event window (Ammann et al. 2006). Similarly, in another study by Burlacu (2000) 141 issues
of convertible bonds in France between 1981 and 1998 were analyzed. The research showed
that, on average, there is a negative stock market response to convertible bond issues in France
and the reaction is more negative, the higher the equity component in the convertible bond is
(Burlacu 2000`).
In another research by Robert J Shiller and Andrea E Beltratti (1992), the nature of the
this variability, there should indeed be generally a slight negative correlation between changes
in real stock prices and changes in long-term interest rates. Robert J Shiller and Andrea E
Beltratti (1992) found that excess returns in the stock market correlate too much with excess
Given the profound findings of mixed impacts in stock price from corporate bond
issuance the question of impact of bond issuance on stock price serves as a benchmark in terms
IMPACT OF CORPORATE BOND ISSUANCE ON STOCK PRICE 10
of understanding the interrelation of different tools applied in capital market. For this study
theoretical framework has been formulated from the literature review. Here, the independent
variable is bond issuance (event, which is dummy variable) and the dependent variables are
stock price of issuing company and transaction volume of same company. Also
For this research, the NEPSE price for banks and financial institutions will be taken as
the indicator of stock market index. The movement of the prices will be tracked over a 361
estimate period which is 180 days before and 180 days after the bond issuance opening date.
Stock Market
Bond Issuance
Transaction Volume
• Bond: A bond, also known as a fixed-income security, is a debt instrument created for
the purpose of raising capital. They are essentially loan agreements between the
bond issuer and an investor, in which the bond issuer is obligated to pay a specified amount
created for the purpose of raising capital. They are essentially loan agreements between the
bond issuer and an investor, in which the bond issuer is obligated to pay a specified amount
of money at specified future dates. Since, debentures are issued by financially stable and
company.
• Stock market index: A stock market index measures the change in the prices of stocks
• Coupon rates: It is the interest rate that the issuer of the bond promises to pay the
bondholder.
• Convertible bond: It is a fixed-income debt security that yields interest payments, but
can be converted into a predetermined number of common stock or equity shares. The
conversion from the bond to stock can be done at certain times during the bond's life and is
• Discount rates: It refers to either the interest rate that the bank charges for short term
loans or the rate used to discount future cash flows in discounted cash flow analysis.
IMPACT OF CORPORATE BOND ISSUANCE ON STOCK PRICE 12
• Discounted cash flow analysis: It is a valuation method used to estimate the value of
• Dividend payout ratio: It is the ratio of the total amount of dividends paid out to
shareholders relative to the net income of the company. It is the percentage of earnings paid to
shareholders in dividends.
knowing a stock’s intrinsic value, an investor may determine whether the stock is undervalued
• Free cash flows: It is the cash left over after a company pays for its operating
data collection, selection of sample, the research process, including the type of data analysis.
The trend of issuing debentures by banks and financial institutions has seen livelier in
recent years. While we see increasing trend of issuing debenture to cope up with the present
problem of liquidity, now investors have more options to choose among investment sectors,
some corporate bonds providing them with abnormally high interest rates. This research aims
to deduce the impacts of bond issuance to the stock market index of Nepal, with the help of
literature and empirical evidences from past researches, while understanding the impacts in
other nations. This study aspires to seek the link between bond issuance and the price
This study has employed the event study methodology to determine the effect of
debenture issuance on stock prices. This methodology has been used with an understanding
IMPACT OF CORPORATE BOND ISSUANCE ON STOCK PRICE 13
that stock prices represent the discounted value of issuing firms’ future stream of profits. The
changes in equity value of firms that have been affected by their event (issuance of corporate
bond or debenture ) can be taken as a measure of discounted (or additional) value of stocks
The study analyses the correlation between issuance of bonds and their impacts on the
stock market index. The returns offered by debentures can be related to the investors preference
of buying bonds to investing in stocks. Further, past results show that there is a negative
correlation between the change in actual real log stock prices and the change in actual long-
term interest rates (Shiller and Beltrati, 1992). So, considering these factors correlation
This research is aimed to understand the real relationship between debenture issuance
and stock market prices, which clearly makes it to have real time data and real market
participants in stock and capital market. So, considering these facts, the non-contrived study
setting will be applied, where the phenomenon will be analyzed while they occur naturally.
The relationship between the stock market and the bond issuance will not be tampered with in
any way by any exogenous factors so in that regards the study setting will be that of a non-
contrived one.
The study has been conducted within the time frame of 6 years (January 2013 to Februry
2020) which includes both bull and bear cycle in Nepse. The study critically analyses all the
debenture issuances and debenture issue announcements during this period and the changes in
the stock prices at the same time period. Hence, longitudinal time frame has been used.
IMPACT OF CORPORATE BOND ISSUANCE ON STOCK PRICE 14
The Data Collection in this research will all be done which is a much greater time frame
than what this study seeks to evaluate hence making the data collection aspect simpler.
Due to the fact that this research evaluates the effect of bond issuance on stock market,
the primary data collection methods like questionnaire and interview are not necessary. The
data for the bond issuance will be collected through the Nepal Rastra Bank (NRB) website and
its publication along with websites www.sharesansar.com. Because our study deals with the
impact of Bond Issuance on the Stock Market prices, the stock market index data is available
in Nepal Stock Exchange and data have been extracted from the same. Nepal has only one
stock market and the data for 125 days of past index is available in it’s website. However,
because this study seeks to evaluate the effect of bond issuance on the stock price for a period
of six years, the software Share Sansar Pro (SSPRO) has been referred which will enable us to
Numerous amounts of bonds and Debentures have been issued in Nepal from
government bonds to corporate bonds since the first bond was issued in 1964 (Shrestha, 2038).
Most of these government as well as corporate bonds are listed in the securities market NEPSE.
The study population includes the companies that have issued debentures in the security market
and the stock market (NEPSE) in the given time frame. However, any company issuing
The ideal scenario for any research would be the study of the entire population. And in
most of the cases it is unfeasible to conduct due to which certain sample is taken. Sample is a
part of the population, that generally is representative of the entire population (Mugo Fridah
W., 2002).
IMPACT OF CORPORATE BOND ISSUANCE ON STOCK PRICE 15
sampling technique, is selected. Purposive sampling technique relies on the judgement of the
researcher on selecting the units to be studied and they can provide researchers with the
justification to make generalizations from the sample that is being studied, whether such
generalizations are theoretical, analytic and logical in nature (Gaganpreet Sharma, 2017).
3.8 Sampling
For the purpose of this study under the purposive sampling technique typical case
sampling has been selected. Typical case sampling helps us to identify the ongoing
phenomenon, have an in-depth understanding and relate it to the research objective. Typical
case sampling also allows the researcher to select a sample where the study subject is more
frequent (Palys, 2008). This complements our study since, our study aims to illustrate the effect
The corporate bonds that have been issued since Jan, 2013 to Dec, 2018 will be
analyzed. This sample has been selected on the basis that complete amount of data is available
in the market and the consequences of selecting the greater sample would be gap in the research
due to lack of accurate and reliable data (Robinson, K.A., Saldanha, I.J., & Mckoy, 2011). And
this sample should be sufficient enough to get insight of the phenomenon of the stock index
Firstly, expected return was calculated by taking 180 days prior and 180 days after
issuance. Similarly, window period of 60 days prior and 60 days after was calculated to
calculate abnormal return which is the difference of expected and actual price. The calculated
indicators will then be used for panel regression, and the resulting analysis will be the
Dependent Variables:
• Abnormal return
Independent Variables:
• Transaction Volume
The paper employs the market-adjusted model, also called the beta-one model. This
market model calculates the returns of each stock based on the firm’s historical stock return
and the historical market return. Here the paper also clarifies whether the market model or the
where,
i= entity (firm)
t= time
IMPACT OF CORPORATE BOND ISSUANCE ON STOCK PRICE 17
Akerlof, G. A. (1970). The market for "lemons": Quality uncertainty and the market
Ammann, M., Fehr, M., & Seiz, R. (2006). New evidence on the announcement effect
Antweiler, W., & Frank, M. (2006). Do U.S. Stock markets typically overreact to
Asquith, P., & Mullins, D. W. (1986). Equity issues and offering dilution. Journal of
Bessler, W., & Thies, S. (2006). Initial public offerings, subsequent seasoned equity
Billet, M. T., Flannery, M. J., & Garfinkel, J. A. (1995). The effect of lender identity on
2), 699-718.
Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2011). Principles of corporate finance. New
York: McGraw-Hill.
Brennan, M. J., & Schwartz, E. S. (1978). Corporate income taxes, valuation, and the
problem of optimal capital structure. The Journal of Business , Vol. 51 (No. 1),
103-114.
Brown, S. J., & Warner, J. B. (1985). Using daily stock returns: The case of event
Burlacu, R. (2000). New evidence on the pecking order hypothesis: The case of French
439-459.
Issuance and its determinants. Contemporary Economics , Vol. 7 (No. 1), 5-18.
Cooper, M., Gulen, H., & Schill, M. (2005). What best explains the cross-section of
stock returns? Exploring the asset growth effect. Working Paper Purdue
University , 1-52.
De Roon, F., & Veld, C. (1998). Announcement effects of convertible bond loans and
Do, Q.-N. (2009). Leverage, growth opportunities and stock price response to new
35-49.
Fama, E. F. (1970). Efficient capital markets: A review of theory and empirical work.
Fama, E. F., & French, K. R. (1992). The cross-section of expected stock returns. The
Fama, E. F., & MacBeth, J. D. (1973). Risk, return, and equilibrium:Empirical tests.
Frank, M., & Goyal, V. K. (2007). Trade-off and pecking order theories of debt.
Gajewski, J.-F., & Ginglinger, E. (2002). Seasoned Equity Issues in a Closely Held
Market: Evidence from France. European Finance Review , Vol. 6 (No. 3).
Gaud, P., Jani, E., Hoesli, M., & Bender, A. (2005). The capital structure of Swiss
Ginglinger, E., & L'her, J.-F. (2011). Ownership structure and open market stock
repurchasees in France. The European Journal of Finance , Vol. 12 (No. 1), 77-
94.
Godlewski, C. J. (2014). Bank loans and borrower value during the global financial
Godlewski, C. J., Fungácová, Z., & Weill, L. (2010). Stock market reaction to debt
Huang, W., Schwienbacher, A., & Zhao, S. (2012). When bank loans are bad news:
Ikenberry, D., Lakonishok, J., & Vermaelen, T. (1995). Market underreaction to open
James, C. (1987). Some evidence on the uniqueness of bank loans. Journal of Financial
Jensen, M. C. (1986). Agency costs of free cash flow, corporate finance, and takeovers.
Jensen, M. C., & Meckling, W. H. (1976). Theory of the firm: Managerial behavior,
305-359.
Kang, J.-K., & Liu, W.-L. (2008). Bank incentives and suboptimal lending decisions:
Evidence from the valuation effect of bank loan announcement in Japan. Journal
Kapoor, A. K., & Pope, R. A. (1997). The relationship between corporate debit issuance
Max Haug (2016). How do markets react on stock and bond issuance and on loan origination?