10.1007@978 981 15 4745 4 PDF
10.1007@978 981 15 4745 4 PDF
S. Vijayan
Nachiappan Subramanian
K. Sankaranarayanasamy Editors
Trends in
Manufacturing
and Engineering
Management
Select Proceedings of ICMechD 2019
Lecture Notes in Mechanical Engineering
Series Editors
Francisco Cavas-Martínez, Departamento de Estructuras, Universidad Politécnica
de Cartagena, Cartagena, Murcia, Spain
Fakher Chaari, National School of Engineers, University of Sfax, Sfax, Tunisia
Francesco Gherardini, Dipartimento di Ingegneria, Università di Modena e Reggio
Emilia, Modena, Italy
Mohamed Haddar, National School of Engineers of Sfax (ENIS), Sfax, Tunisia
Vitalii Ivanov, Department of Manufacturing Engineering Machine and Tools,
Sumy State University, Sumy, Ukraine
Young W. Kwon, Department of Manufacturing Engineering and Aerospace
Engineering, Graduate School of Engineering and Applied Science, Monterey,
CA, USA
Justyna Trojanowska, Poznan University of Technology, Poznan, Poland
Lecture Notes in Mechanical Engineering (LNME) publishes the latest develop-
ments in Mechanical Engineering—quickly, informally and with high quality.
Original research reported in proceedings and post-proceedings represents the core
of LNME. Volumes published in LNME embrace all aspects, subfields and new
challenges of mechanical engineering. Topics in the series include:
• Engineering Design
• Machinery and Machine Elements
• Mechanical Structures and Stress Analysis
• Automotive Engineering
• Engine Technology
• Aerospace Technology and Astronautics
• Nanotechnology and Microengineering
• Control, Robotics, Mechatronics
• MEMS
• Theoretical and Applied Mechanics
• Dynamical Systems, Control
• Fluid Mechanics
• Engineering Thermodynamics, Heat and Mass Transfer
• Manufacturing
• Precision Engineering, Instrumentation, Measurement
• Materials Engineering
• Tribology and Surface Technology
To submit a proposal or request further information, please contact the Springer
Editor of your location:
China: Dr. Mengchu Huang at mengchu.huang@springer.com
India: Priya Vyas at priya.vyas@springer.com
Rest of Asia, Australia, New Zealand: Swati Meherishi at
swati.meherishi@springer.com
All other countries: Dr. Leontina Di Cecco at Leontina.dicecco@springer.com
To submit a proposal for a monograph, please check our Springer Tracts in
Mechanical Engineering at http://www.springer.com/series/11693 or contact
Leontina.dicecco@springer.com
Indexed by SCOPUS. The books of the series are submitted for indexing to
Web of Science.
K. Sankaranarayanasamy
Editors
Trends in Manufacturing
and Engineering
Management
Select Proceedings of ICMechD 2019
123
Editors
S. Vijayan Nachiappan Subramanian
Sri Sivasubramaniya Nadar College of University of Sussex
Engineering Brighton, UK
Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India
K. Sankaranarayanasamy
National Institute of Technology Puducherry
Puducherry, India
This Springer imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd.
The registered company address is: 152 Beach Road, #21-01/04 Gateway East, Singapore 189721,
Singapore
Preface
v
Contents
vii
viii Contents
Optimization Techniques
Multi-response Optimization of Inconel 825 Process Parameters
Using LN2 Cooled Zinc-Coated Brass Wire in CNC
Wire-Cut EDM . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 875
Midthur A. Salman Khan, C. Nandakumar, B. Mohan,
and R. Senthil Kumar
Optimization of Process Parameters During EDM on Inconel
Alloy 625 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 897
K. Jayakumar
Optimization of Laser Trepanning Parameters for Mild Steel
by Taguchi Response Surface Methodology
(T-RSM) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 905
A. Gnanavelbabu, V. Arunachalam, K. T. Sunu Surendran, V. Dharaniya,
and K. Rajkumar
Parametric Optimization of Cracked Cantilever Beam
Using Genetic Algorithm . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 915
Mihir Kumar Sutar, Sarojrani Pattnaik, and Pawan Kumar Modi
Study of the Influence of Reinforcement Parameters on Thermal
Conductivity of Magnesium-Based MMCs Through Taguchi’s
Orthogonal Array Approach . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 923
M. R. Shivakumar, N. V. R. Naidu, M. Jai Surya, and D. Indhuja
Finite Element Modelling and Optimisation of Sheet Hydroforming
for Cryo-rolled AA5083 Sheets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 931
Akhil B. Raj, A. Arun, and Ajith Ramesh
Contents xv
Energy Engineering
Experimental Study of an Axial Turbine for Wave Energy
Conversion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 953
Kumud Kumar, Tapas K. Das, R. Srikanth, and Abdus Samad
Investigations into Nonlinear Energy Sinks for a Stochastic
Dynamical Oscillator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 963
Anuroop Parvathaneni, Dhritimaan Sharma, Dhruv Vashishtha,
Pradeep V. Malaji, and J. Venkatramani
A Novel Banana Leaf Waste-Based Activated Carbon
for Automobile Emission Control . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 977
A. John Presin Kumar, S. Sivakumar, R. Balaji, and Mukesh Nadarajan
Analyzing Different Methods to Increase the Natural Period
of a Compact Wave Energy Converter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 991
Vishnu Vijayasankar and Abdus Samad
Comparison of Hydrogen Yield from Ball-Milled and Unmilled
Magnesium Hydride in a Batch System Hydrogen Reactor . . . . . . . . . 1003
J. A. Adeniran, R. S. Fono-Tamo, Esther Titilayo Akinlabi, and T. C. Jen
A Review on the Synthesis of Activated Carbon from Natural
Resources for Mechanical Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1013
A. John Presin Kumar, S. Sivakumar, D. Prasanth, B. Guhanesh,
and A. Ijas Ahamed
Combined Casing Groove and Blade Tip Treatment for Wave
Energy Harvesting Turbine . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1027
P. Madhan Kumar, Paresh Halder, and Abdus Samad
Design and Development of Wind Tunnel to Study
Smoldering Combustion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1041
S. Sanjana, M. Rakshantha, Yeleti Bunny Venkat, and B. T. Kannan
Spatial Location of Renewable Energy Plants: How Good
Is Good Enough? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1055
Paul A. Adedeji, Stephen Akinlabi, Nkosinathi Madushele,
and Obafemi O. Olatunji
Analysis of Pendulum-Based Nonlinear Energy Sink
for Energy Harvesting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1065
Pradeep V. Malaji
xvi Contents
xvii
xviii About the Editors
1 Introduction
The magnesium and its alloys have been established as the best alternative to iron
and aluminum in a wide variety of applications due to high strength-to-weight ratio
and other excellent physical properties [1]. However, machining magnesium alloys
using conventional methods cause a built-up edge and chatter. The most important
precaution needed to bear in mind, while machining magnesium alloy is that the
formation of fine chips and dust is highly flammable [2]. Due to the development of
new difficulties to machine materials (carbide, composite materials, etc.) and com-
plex geometrical shapes of engineering components, the available traditional fin-
ishing processes alone are incapable of producing required surface finish and other
geometrical features. Even if these processes can be used, they require expensive
equipments and large labor, hence making them economically incompetent. Devel-
opments in advanced machining processes in the last few decades have attributed
to the relaxation of limitations of tool hardness requirement or/and restricted pre-
defined relative motion of cutting edges with respect to the workpiece surface. Use
of alternative source of energy like electrical, chemical, mechanical or thermal to
assist or perform machining relaxed the constraint of using cutting tool harder than
the workpiece. Electric discharge machining (EDM), electrochemical machining
(ECM), ultrasonic machining (USM), abrasive jet machining (AJM), laser beam
machining (LBM), etc. are a few instances of such techniques. Being the most ver-
satile of all the non-conventional machining, electric discharge machining (EDM)
process becomes viable for the machining of these magnesium alloys materials [3–
5]. In all applications, geometrical features of machined parts are more important.
This work is carried out to study the effect of process parameters while machining
a hole feature of diameter 10 mm. Existing research works carried out using AZ31
magnesium alloy focus on the measurement of surface roughness [6]. But the present
work focuses on geometrical features of the holes which is essential to make a proper
hole on AZ31 magnesium alloy while machining using EDM.
2 Details of Experiments
In this work, magnesium AZ31 alloy is chosen as a workpiece material. The work-
piece is in the form of a flat plate with length (50 mm), width (30 mm) and thickness
(6 mm). Tool materials such as copper, brass and graphite are chosen as an electrode.
The electrode in the form of a rod with a diameter of 10 mm and a length of 25 mm
is machined and used to carry out experiments. The workpiece material (anode)
used is AZ31 magnesium alloy. The tool (cathode) materials such as copper, brass
and graphite are used. The experimental trials are conducted using ALTRA ZNC
ORB 5530 EDM machine, based on Taguchi’s L16 orthogonal array. Figure 1 shows
the machined workpiece and their corresponding electrode. The process parameters
such as discharge current (I P ), pulse-on time (T ON ), pulse-off time (T OFF ) and tool
Effect of Process Parameters in Electric Discharge … 5
material (M) are selected as control factors, and overcut (OC), tapercut (TC), cir-
cularity (CIR) and cylindricity (CYL) are considered as response variables. Table 1
shows the control factors and their levels. Overcut is equal to half the difference of
the diameter of the hole to the diameter of the tool. The diameter of the hole and
tool is measured using a digital vernier caliper. Tapercut is the difference between
hole diameter of top and bottom surface of the plate. It was measured with the help
of a profile projector. Circularity describes how close an object should be to a true
circle. Cylindricity is used when the hole part features must have good circularity
and straightness. Circularity applies only to cross sections, where the cylindricity
applies simultaneously to the entire surface. Both circularity and cylindricity were
measured using Mitutoyo Coordinate Measuring Machine (CMM).
Two trials are carried out for each combination of process parameters, and the average
of two values is presented in Table 2.
smaller the better characteristic is selected. It is found that pulse-on time shows a
maximum contribution of 48% in the assessment of overcut as shown in Fig. 2. The
increase in pulse-on time resulted in increasing of overcut as shown in Fig. 3, and
this is mainly due to increases in spark energy as pulse-on time increases.
From Fig. 4, it is observed that the discharge current shows a maximum contri-
bution of 28% on tapercut. As discharge current increases, tapercut decreases up to
a certain saturated point as shown in Fig. 5. This phenomenon occurs mainly due to
an increase in spark energy as discharge current increases.
From Fig. 6, it is observed that interaction between discharge current and pulse-
off time shows a maximum contribution of 31% on circularity. Circularity increases
Fig. 2 Contribution of
process parameters on OC
Effect of Process Parameters in Electric Discharge … 7
Figs. 3 and 7. Since brass has less thermal conductivity and greater tool wear rate
which made brass suitable for features that can be machined at a particular plane. In
case of geometrical features when compared with copper and brass, graphite found
to be very less significant.
Regression model for prediction of overcut (OC) is developed using the results
from experiments as shown in Eq. (1). Similar models are developed for prediction
of other response variables. The experimental response variables show significant
correlation with predicted response variables as shown in Figs. 10, 11, 12 and 13.
Effect of Process Parameters in Electric Discharge … 9
4 Conclusion
pulse-off time and tool material on the overcut, tapercut, circularity, and cylindric-
ity of a through-hole made in AZ31 magnesium alloy. Based on the results from
experiments, the following conclusions are made.
• Among the mentioned quantitative EDM process parameters, pulse-on time and
discharge current show the significant effect on geometrical features. It was
observed that pulse-off time shows less significant in case of geometrical features.
12 M. Somasundaram and J. Pradeep Kumar
• In terms of a qualitative EDM process parameter, tool material also shows less sig-
nificance on the accuracy of geometrical features when compared with other pro-
cess parameters considered in this work. Among the electrode materials, graphite
is found to have a less significant effect when compared with copper and brass.
• As the objective of the present study is to minimize OC, TC, CIR and CYL. The
S/N plots are used to decide the optimal set of process to obtain best response.
The optimal machining parameters for OC are I p = 6 amps; T ON = 10 µs; T OFF
= 8 µs; M = Br, for TC are I P = 9 amps; T ON = 40 µs; T OFF = 8 µs; M = Cu,
for CIR are I P = 3 amps; T ON = 20 µs; T OFF = 7 µs; M = Br, for CYL are I =
6 amps; T ON = 20 µs; T OFF = 5 µs; M = Cu.
• The developed regression models are found to be accurate in the prediction
of response variables within the domain of experiments. The predicted results
correlate well with experimental results.
References
1. Lee ES, Won JK, Shin TH, Kim SH (2012) Investigation of machining characteristics for elec-
trochemical micro-deburring of the AZ31 lightweight magnesium alloy. Int J Precis Eng Manuf
13(3):339–345
2. Abdul-Rani AM, Razak MA, Littlefair G, Gibson I, Nanimina AM (2017) Improving EDM
process on AZ31 magnesium alloy towards sustainable biodegradable implant manufacturing.
Procedia Manuf 7:504–509
3. Kumar P, Parkash R (2016) Experimental investigation and optimization of EDM process
parameters for machining of aluminum boron carbide (Al–B4C) composite. Mach Sci Technol
20(2):330–348
Effect of Process Parameters in Electric Discharge … 13
1 Introduction
Metal matrix composites (MMCs) are now replacing metals in various engineering
applications. Specifically, aluminum matrix composites (AMCs) occupy a position of
great significance in industries, because of their good thermo-mechanical properties,
good damage resistance, and wear resistance. Generally, machining of MMCs is a
laborious work owing to the presence of hard and brittle reinforcement particle and
non-homogenous structure [1]. It was also realized that their machining behavior is
unlike any of the other conventional processes observed so far. It can be machined
through some of the conventional methods. But, severe damage to the workpiece and
the cutting tool are observed. Workpiece damages such as particle cracking, particle
pulling out and particle debonding were occurred [2, 3]. Surface roughness was also
observed to be high, and in order to overcome that, self-lubricating particles are added
to the composites. This reduces wear between the tool and workpiece. Otherwise, it
decreases strength, hardness, and low fracture toughness which are undesirable [4].
To counteract unsatisfactory properties, some novel approach has to be followed,
i.e., adding concurrent lubricants and strength improvement particles. Tribological
investigations are evident that the relationship between work material grain size and
reinforcement particle size has a major impact on the wear behavior [5].
In recent times, carbon nanotubes are considered as reinforcement in aluminum
composites. There are major reasons for selection of CNT as reinforcement that
increases stiffness, strength and vibration absorption properties of the composite.
This also makes the machining process as smoother than ever and facilitates easy
chip breaking [6, 7].
Nowadays, machining of MMCs is viable through unconventional processes [8].
The major advantages of these processes are having a good surface finish and easy
disposal of removed material. Also, regardless of the material properties, it can
machine the component with less tool wear. Shubhra paliwal et al. [9] studied the
EDM process by analyzing pulse on and off time on the machining behavior of the
material. Hewidy et al. [10] conducted EDM experiments using a RSM for the Inconel
601 material. They concluded that RSM method has an advantage of describing the
effect between input variables and response parameters.
Tilekar et al. [11] determined that high electrical conductivity and low melting
point of aluminum are directly affecting machining. As an increase in current, more
melting and vaporization of material are observed, thereby increasing MRR. Bobbili
et al. [12] experimented EDM with hot-pressed boron carbide and observed deep
craters and microcracks at high Ton and peak current which deteriorated surface fin-
ish. Moreover, higher input energy significantly affected the wear rate of the wire and
caused breakage of the wire frequently. Udaya Prakash et al. [13] conducted machin-
ability studies on the Al alloy with fly ash and B4 C composite using a wire-cut EDM.
They determined that gap voltage is the more significant parameter than pulse on
time, pulse off time, wire feed rate, and percentage of reinforcement. However, fabri-
cated Al/boron carbide/CNT hybrid composite is heterogeneous in nature. Therefore,
Desirability Approach Machining Study on Aluminum … 17
2 Experimental Procedure
Aluminum (Al 6061) was used as matrix element in the composite. B4 C (40 µm) was
used as one of the reinforcing agents and has exotic properties like high hardness,
low specific gravity, and neutron absorption. CNT (74 nm) was used as another
reinforcing fiber and also solid lubricant.
Fabrication of composite was done using a stir casting apparatus. Aluminum 6061
ingots were melted in the furnace around 800 °C. Flux was used to increase the
wettability between melt matrix and reinforcements and prevents oxidation of melt.
A steel stirrer was used to mix the reinforcements in the melt uniformly and runs at
150 rpm with the help of a motor. Simultaneously, B4 C and CNT were added as the
reinforcements. CNT was functionalized using nitric acid solution before mixing it
with the aluminum melt. The composition of the composite was Al-80 wt% B4 C-
18.5 wt% and CNT-1.5 wt%. After uniform dispersion of the reinforcements in the
aluminum matrix melt, the mixture was poured into a rectangular die of dimension
12 * 100 *10 mm.
The machining parameters that influence the metal removal rate and kerf width were
T on , T off , voltage, wire feed (in machine code values), and its levels are presented
in Table 1. A face-centered composite design (FCD) with total of 30 experimental
runs (six center points) has been selected, and experimentation was conducted on
the 4-axis CNC Eco-cut WEDM. The results were analyzed using Design–Expert
software.
The study focuses on the effects of these inputs on the responses, namely MRR,
kerf width, and surface roughness. A wire-cut EDM machine uses bronze-coated
copper wire of 0.25 mm diameter. 15 straight slit cuts were made on the composite.
During the machining process, a EDM oil dielectric fluid was used. The dielectric
18 K. Rajkumar et al.
fluid flow is perpendicular to the direction of the wire feed. The typical cut job is
shown in Fig. 1.
The kerf width was measured using an optical microscope. The typical cuts on the
workpiece are shown in Fig. 2. Kerf width was measured by using ImageJ software.
Material removal rate was calculated using a mathematical Eq. (1)
MRR = Vc ∗ b ∗ t (1)
where b—kerf width (mm), t—thickness of the workpiece in mm, and surface rough-
ness was calculated in Ra using a tally surf roughness meter with cutoff length
0.25 mm.
The effects of the process parameters on the MRR, surface roughness, and Kerf width
are shown in Table 2.
Hold Values
Ton
128 Toff 55
WS 3
127
126
20 25 30 35 40
voltage
the availability of spark time on the local spot is low, resulting in little erosion of
material. This results in a smoother surface. MRR and surface roughness are inversely
proportional, and hence, as voltage increases, the surface roughness also increases.
In Fig. 8, it can be concluded that similar observation is evident. The combination
of high wire speed and low T on is evident of smoother surface of cut. Moreover, it is
22 K. Rajkumar et al.
observed that Ra with slope is steeper than the T on which indicates that voltage has
more significant effect on surface roughness.
Figure 9 shows the desirability values of optimized multiple responses of wire-cut
EDM on the given composite material. The desirability of the cut is having a high
MRR, a low kerf width, and a low surface roughness, and in order to achieve that,
optimization was done, to identify the best balance between the three requirements.
Desirability Approach Machining Study on Aluminum … 23
The corresponding input parameters were found to be exhibiting the best results; the
desirability of the cut was relatively higher when the combination of input param-
eters was of 39.99 V, 128.94 µs-T on , 50 µs-T off , and 4 mm/s-WS, than any other
combinations.
4 Conclusions
3. It is evident that the smoothness of cut surface is obtained with increasing in wire
speed. The reason is that a fast-moving wire electrode has less time for on a local
spot leading to a reduction of erosion of workpiece material. The combination
of high wire speed and low T on offered smoother surface of cut.
4. The combination of 39.99 V, 128.94 µs-T on , 50 µs-T off, and 4 mm/s-wire speed
provided a relatively more desirable cut than any other combinations of input
parameters.
References
3. Yadav RK, Abhishek K, Mahapatra SS (2015) A simulation approach for estimating flank wear
and material removal rate in turning of Inconel 718. Simul Model Pract Theory 52:1–14
4. Kong L, Zhu S, Bi Q, Qiao Z, Yang J, Liu W (2014) Friction and wear behavior of self-
lubricating ZrO2 (Y2O3)–CaF2–Mo–graphite composite from 20 to 1000 °C. Ceram Int
40(7):10787–10792
5. Vangla P, Gali ML (2016) Effect of particle size of sand and surface asperities of reinforcement
on their interface shear behaviour. Geotext Geomembr 44(3):254–268
6. Banks-Sills L, Shiber DG, Fourman V, Eliasi R, Shlayer A (2016) Experimental determination
of mechanical properties of PMMA reinforced with functionalized CNTs. Compos B Eng
95:335–345
7. Moghadam AD, Omrani E, Menezes PL, Rohatgi PK (2015) Mechanical and tribological
properties of self-lubricating metal matrix nanocomposites reinforced by carbon nanotubes
(CNTs) and graphene–a review. Compos B Eng 77:402–420
8. Rajkumar K, Santosh S, Ibrahim SJS, Gnanavelbabu A (2014) Effect of Electrical dis-
charge machining parameters on microwave heat treated Aluminium-Boron carbide-Graphite
composites. Procedia Eng 97:1543–1550
9. Paliwal S, Solanki P (2014) Parameter optimization of wire electrical discharge machining for
minimum surface roughness and kerf width using taguchi method. In: 4th SARC international
conference
10. Hewidy MS, El-Taweel TA, El-Safty MF (2005) Modelling the machining parameters of wire
electrical discharge machining of Inconel 601 using RSM. J Mater Process Technol 169(2):328–
336
11. Tilekar S, Das SS, Patowari PK (2014) Process parameter optimization of wire EDM on
Aluminum and mild steel by using taguchi method. Procedia Mater Sci 5:2577–2584
12. Bobbili R, Madhu V, Gogia AK (2015) An experimental investigation of wire electrical
discharge machining of hot-pressed boron carbide. Defence Technol 11(4):344–349
13. Prakash JU, Moorthy TV, Peter JM (2013) Experimental investigations on machinability
of aluminium alloy (A413)/Flyash/B4C hybrid composites using wire EDM. Procedia Eng
64:1344–1353
A Comparative Study on Abrasive Water
Jet Machining Characteristics of Entry
and Exit Layers of Glass and Basalt
Woven Polymer Composites
Abstract Abrasive water jet machining (AWJM) induced kerf and kerf tapper angle
variation is much affected by the properties of the entry and exit layer of fiber
reinforced polymer of composite. In this work, experimental investigation on the
machining characteristics of vinyl ester composite fabricated by basalt and glass
fiber as top and bottom layers separately interlayered with flax fiber. Hybridization
of basalt/glass composite was made by the additional layers of flax woven. Two dif-
ferent stacked composites were fabricated by using hand layup process followed by
static compression loading. The mechanical properties such as tensile and flexural
strength were studied. It was found that top and bottom basalt layers interlayered
flax fiber composite exhibited higher tensile and flexural properties. The tensile and
flexural strength improvements were 7.15% and flexural 13.3% over the top and bot-
tom glass layers interlayered flax fiber composite. The fabricated composites were
machined by abrasive water jet machining (AWJM) using constant cutting parame-
ters with pressure, nozzle speed, and standoff distance. Experimental results reveal
that minimum kerf taper and higher cutting surface quality obtained with entry and
exit layers of glass fiber composite.
1 Introduction
Nowadays, FRP composite is losing its merits by environmental concerns and gov-
ernment regulation [1]. Natural fibers most widely accepted have many advantage
properties as reinforcement to composite. Owing to relatively low density and high
strength, the natural fiber is popular now. The natural fibers are extracted from the
plants, nutshells, palm shells, wood flour, and animals [2]. Moreover, they have enor-
mous merits over synthetic fiber such as renewable in nature and less abrasive [3,
4]. However, its mechanical properties are much lower than synthetic fiber [5]. This
limits to use in the semi-structural application.
Natural fiber composite exhibits poor resistance to moisture absorption because
of its hydrophilic behavior. Thus, it makes less attractive but rather using suitable
chemical treatments rectifying hydrophilic problem [6]. The reinforcing of natural
and synthetic fibers in a polymer matrix provides the best properties. The hybridiza-
tion of fibers is remarking superiority and reduces relay on the synthetic fibers. Hybrid
composite is being now enough strength, stiffness, and rigidity to satisfy the needs of
semi-structural applications [7, 8]. Apart from that, composite required machining
process, to shape, size, and tolerance for an application.
Conventional machining processes namely drilling, turning, and milling will tend
to pull out fibers from the composite. Additionally, it leads to delamination and
damage to composite. Almost 60% of the composites are rejected due to damages
like fiber pullout and delamination [9]. In order to improve the machining quality of
composite, these works made an attempt with abrasive water jet machining (AWJM)
process. This process is environmentally safe and free from heat-induced detects.
Researchers are more interested in AWJM of the composite to evaluate kerf ratio,
kerf angle, and surface quality parameters [10, 11].
Moreover, the selection of proper machining parameters is more concern to the
researcher and machinist for quality machining. A few researchers revealed that
standoff distance is the most significant factor to reduce the kerf ratio followed by the
traverse speed. The minimum traverse speed and maximum pressure were smoothly
removed material from the FRP composite and also minimize delamination fracture
[12]. The combination of traverse rate and standoff distance increases kerf ratio
but decreases standoff distance resulting in a smooth surface and lowers the kerf
ratio as a result of the increased kinetic energy of jet. Increase in water pressure
and abrasive flow rate improved surface quality of composite [13, 14]. Selvam et al.
[15] investigated AWJM cutting parameters on the surface and kerf taper by response
surface model (RSM). They concluded that kerf and surface roughness are a function
of traverse speed and abrasive flow rate.
A comparative study on the kerf and surface quality by changing entry and exit
layer of glass and basalt woven fiber polymer composite by AWJM process has been
made in this work.
A Comparative Study on Abrasive Water … 29
2.1 Materials
The interplay hybrid FRP composite was made by woven fabrics of basalt, flax,
E-glass, and vinyl ester resin of grade VBR 4508 was used as matrix. Regular accel-
erator, promotor, and catalyst were used for curing agent. The properties of flax,
basalt, and glass fabric are summarized in Table 1.
The flax fabric was treated in sodium hydroxide (NaOH) solution with the concen-
tration of 5% in one liter of water for the duration of two hours at room temperature.
NaOH-treated fibers were washed by tap water followed with distilled water. FRP
composite was fabricated by a hand layup process with dead weight. The stacking
sequences of FRP composites were G2F7 and B2F7. G2F7 has two layers of E-glass
woven fabric (top and bottom) and seven layers of flax woven fabric. B2F7 has
two layers of basalt woven fabric (top and bottom) and seven layers of flax woven
fabrics. The ratio of reinforcement weight fraction to the matrix weight fraction is
maintained at 40:60. The size of the laminate was a square of 300 × 300 mm. The
stacking sequence of laminates was shown in Fig. 1. The actual thickness of the
laminate was approximately 7.2 mm for both B2F7 and for G2F7.
Universal testing machine (UTM) was used to evaluate the tensile and flexural prop-
erties of the composite. To measure tensile property, the test sample was made in
accordance with ASTM-D 638 and tested at a uniform crosshead speed of 5 mm/min.
Three-point bending tester was performed to the specimen as per ASTM D790 the
standard for the flexural property evaluation. The sample was tested with a strain rate
of 5 mm/min. Typical tensile and flexural fracture specimens are shown in Fig. 2a–d.
30 K. Ramraji et al.
Fig. 2 a–d Tensile and flexural fractured specimens of B2F7 and G2F7 composites
The surface morphology of tensile fractured and machining surface was studied
through Scanning Electron Microscope SEM (JOEL JSM840A). The failure mech-
anisms of the composite were analyzed through fiber and matrix intact by SEM
images.
A Comparative Study on Abrasive Water … 31
A two-axis OMAX-1530(CNC) water jet cutting machine was used for experimen-
tation. AWJM nozzle assembly consists of an orifice of (0.35 mm diameter) with a
sapphire jewel and carbide focusing tube of 0.35 mm internal diameter and length
of 75 mm. The impinging angle of the jet was maintained at 90°. The mixing tube
diameter was 0.762 mm, and the abrasive size was 80 mesh and tool offset of 0.3 mm.
These standard set of AWJM geometry are used widely in most industrial applica-
tions. The photocopy of AWM machining of composite setup is shown in Fig. 3. The
selected parameters and their ranges listed in Table 2.
In this study, surface roughness was measured over the cut by SURFTEST SJ-210.
Three different locations of readings for Ra were measured, and then, the average
value was calculated. The kerf taper was measured using a video measuring system
(VMS), as shown in Fig. 4. Kerf taper was calculated by measuring top, and bottom
of kerf average value of three readings reported in order to minimize the error. The
kerf taper is calculated as given in Eq. (1)
Lt − Lb
Kerf Taper = (1)
2T
Where L t —top kerf width (mm), L b —bottom kerf width (mm), and T —thickness
of the laminate (mm).
Fig. 3 Photocopy of AWJ machining setup and typical machined G2F7 and B2F7 composites
Tensile and flexural strength of B2F7 and G2F7 composites are represented in
Fig. 5a, b. From this figure, it clearly shows that the maximum tensile and flexu-
ral strength were obtained with B2F7 composite. The tensile strength and flexural
strength improvement were 7.15% and 13.3%, respectively, over the G2F7 compos-
ite. This could be a typical reaction between vinyl ester resin and basalt fiber reacting a
good interfacial strength. The basalt surface layers provide the load-bearing strength
to the composite. This is certainly delayed fracture and pullout of basalt fibers. As
in flexural strength, the top and bottom layers are so important to redistribute the
bending stress to next interlayers. The sufficient flexibility provided by the basalt
fibers increases the bending strength of the composite.
The typical SEM images of the tensile fracture surface are shown in Fig. 6a, b.
It is observed that good adhesion was seen between basalt fiber and matrix, as in
the case of B2F7composite. G2F7 composite reveals matrix crack, fiber pullout, and
breakage, as shown in Fig. 6b This is due to that changes in fiber surface morphology
during loading which affecting the fiber/matrix interfacial adhesion strength.
The effect of water pressure on the kerf taper of B2F7 and G2F7 composites is shown
in Fig. 7a. This figure shows that the kerf taper ratio decreases with an increase in
water pressure for both the B2F7 and G2F7 composites. Moreover, G2F7 composite
exhibited minimum kerf taper. The reduction of kerf taper observed to be 14% at a
pressure of 300 MPa. B2F7 composite is rather produced higher taper angle due to
more brittle nature of basalt fiber. The brittle fracture of the top layer of basalt fiber
increases with increase in water jet energy. This results in larger access by the water
jet next layer of flax fabrics loading to higher kerf taper. As water jet moving in a
transverse direction, the energy of water jet gets lowered due to friction with cutting
surface. It reduces the jet ability to the removal of material at bottom layers. The
effect of surface roughness by water pressure for B2F7 and G2F7 composites is shown
in Fig. 7b. It can be seen that surface quality increases when an increase in water
pressure for both the B2F7 and G2F7 composites. Moreover, G2F7 composite shows
34 K. Ramraji et al.
Fig. 7 a, b Kerf taper and surface roughness with water pressure for the B2F2 and G2F2 composites
a minimum surface roughness with 53.05% lower than B2F7 composite. Owing to
uneven machining in B2F7 composite, the surface roughness was higher.
The effect of nozzle traverse speed on the kerf taper of B2F7 and G2F7 composites is
shown in Fig. 8a. This figure clearly reveals that kerf taper increases with increasing
the nozzle traverse speed for both the B2F7 and G2F7 composites. Moreover, G2F7
composite shows a minimum kerf taper with 6.2% at a traverse speed of 125 mm/min,
B2F7 composite. This could be due to the energy unbalance between energy require-
ment for cutting and energy supplied to the point of cutting. This unbalanced cutting
Fig. 8 a, b Kerf taper and surface roughness with nozzle traverse speed for B2F2 and G2F2
composites
A Comparative Study on Abrasive Water … 35
Fig. 9 a, b Kerf taper and surface roughness with standoff distance for B2F7 and G2F7 composites
energy increased with traverse speed left larger kerf taper. The effect of nozzle tra-
verse speed on the surface roughness of B2F7 and G2F7 composites is shown in
Fig. 8b. Surface quality decreases with increasing the nozzle traverse speed for both
the B2F7 and G2F7 composites. This is attributed to the un even cutting with var-
ied water jet energy in the traverse direction. Moreover, G2F7 composite shows a
minimum kerf taper with 45.1% lower than B2F7 composite.
The effect of standoff distance on the kerf taper of B2F7 and G2F7 composites is
shown in Fig. 9a. Kerf taper ratio increases with every step increment of standoff
distance for both B2F7 and G2F7 composites. This could be to water jet flaring with
distance and loss of water jet energy. Moreover, G2F7 composite shows a minimum
kerf taper with a reduction of 5.9% at a standoff distance of 1.5 mm as compared
with B2F7 composite. The effect of standoff distance on the surface roughness of
B2F7 and G2F7 composites is shown in Fig. 9b. The surface quality of the machined
surface decreases with increasing the standoff distance for both B2F7 and G2F7
composites. This is a reduction in localized material erosion by flared water jet which
results in non-uniform cutting over the surface. Interestingly, G2F7 composite reveals
minimum surface roughness by 49.2% at standoff distance 1.5 mm than the B2F7
composite.
36 K. Ramraji et al.
4 Conclusions
The entry and exit of basalt and glass layers with interlayered flax fiber reinforced
polymeric composite were most influencing the mechanical properties and AWJ
machining process. From the results, the following conclusion were made,
1. The maximum tensile and flexural strength were obtained with entry and exit
basalt layer of B2F7 composite. B2F7 composite shows an improved tensile
strength by 7.15 and 13.3% for flexural strength when compared to the entry and
exit glass layers of G2F7 composite. This is a result of a typical reaction between
vinyl ester resin and basalt fiber, improving the good interfacial strength of the
composite.
2. Water jet pressure was considered as the most significant control factor in influ-
encing surface quality (Ra) and kerf taper. Increase in pressure results in a better
machining performance for both B2F7 and G2F7 composites. G2F7 composite
shows a minimum kerf taper by 14% at a pressure of 300 MPa, as compared to
B2F7 composite. As a result of more brittle nature of basalt fiber (B2F7) increases
taper angle. Whilst, G2F7 composite shows a minimum surface roughness with
53.05% at a pressure of 300 MPa compared with G2F7. This could be uneven
machining in B2F7 composite leads to poor surface quality.
3. Interestingly, another machining parameters, traverse rate, and standoff distance
at low level improved the machining performance of both the composites.
4. These experiments confirm that greater kinetic energy and pressure energy
required for abrasive water jet machining of interlayered composites.
References
1. Frollini E, Silva CG, Ramires EC (2013) Advanced fibre-reinforced polymer (FRP) composites
for structural applications: 2. Phenolic resins as a matrix material in advanced fiber-reinforced
polymer (FRP) composites. Elsevier Inc. Chapters
2. Westman MP, Fifield LS, Simmons KL, Laddha S, Kafentzis TA (2010) Natural fiber com-
posites: a review (No. PNNL-19220). Pacific Northwest National Lab (PNNL), Richland, WA
(United States)
3. Monteiro SN, Lopes FPD, Ferreira AS, Nascimento DCO (2009) Natural-fiber polymer-matrix
composites: cheaper, tougher, and environmentally friendly. JOM 61(1):17–22
4. Kalia S, Kaith BS, Kaur I (2009) Pretreatments of natural fibers and their application as
reinforcing material in polymer composites—a review. Polym Eng Sci 49(7):1253–1272
5. Joshi SV, Drzal LT, Mohanty AK, Arora S (2004) Are natural fiber composites environmentally
superior to glass fiber reinforced composites? Compos A Appl Sci Manuf 35(3):371–376
6. Ramraji K, Rajkumar K, Sabarinathan P (2019) Tailoring of tensile and dynamic thermo-
mechanical properties of interleaved chemical-treated fine almond shell particulate flax fiber
stacked vinyl ester polymeric composites. In: Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical
Engineers, Part L: Journal of Materials: Design and Applications, p 1464420719849616
7. Gujjala R, Ojha S, Acharya SK, Pal SK (2014) Mechanical properties of woven jute–glass
hybrid-reinforced epoxy composite. J Compos Mater 48(28):3445–3455
A Comparative Study on Abrasive Water … 37
8. Sanjay MR, Arpitha GR, Yogesha B (2015) Study on mechanical properties of natural-glass
fibre reinforced polymer hybrid composites: a review. Mater Today: Proc 2(4–5):2959–2967
9. Ramkumar J, Malhotra SK, Krishnamurthy R (2004) Effect of workpiece vibration on drilling
of GFRP laminates. J Mater Process Technol 152(3):329–332
10. Wang J, Wong WCK (1999) A study of waterjet cutting of metallic coated sheet steels. Int J
Mach Tools Manuf 39:855–870 (1999)
11. Gnanavelbabu A, Saravanan P, Rajkumar K, Karthikeyan S (2018) Experimental investigations
on multiple responses in abrasive waterjet machining of Ti-6Al-4 V alloy. Mater Today: Proc
5(5):13413–13421
12. Irina Wong MM, Azmi AI, Lee CC, Mansor AF (2018) Kerf taper and delamination dam-
age minimization of FRP hybrid composites under abrasive water-jet machining. Int J Adv
Manufact Technol 94(5–8):1727–1744
13. Azmir MA, Ahsan AK (2009) A study of abrasive water jet machining process on glass/epoxy
composite laminate. J Mater Process Technol 209(20):6168–6173
14. El-Hofy M, Helmy MO, Escobar-Palafox G, Kerrigan KM, Scaife R, El-Hofy H (2018) Abra-
sive water jet machining of multidirectional CFRP laminates. Procedia CIRP 68:535–540
(Elsevier)
15. Selvam R, Karunamoorthy L, Arunkumar N (2017) Investigation on performance of abrasive
water jet in machining hybrid composites. Mater Manuf Processes 32(6):700–706
16. Singha K (2012) A short review on basalt fiber. Int J Text Sci 1(4):19–28
Electrolyte and Machining Parameters
Optimization of Wire Electrochemical
Cutting of Aluminum/Titanium Diboride
Composite
1 Introduction
Aluminum metal matrix composites have opened a new window to various indus-
trial sectors like automobile components—drive shaft, brakes, cylinder liners, engine
locks, and motor casing [1]. Generally, aluminum metal matrix composites are rein-
forced with mono or combination of reinforcements such as oxides, nitride, carbide,
and borides [2] to increase its mechanical properties. The addition of the reinforce-
ment leads to complexity in machining of composite. Normally, the conventional
machining process cannot help in the context of hard materials like a metal matrix
composites and ceramic materials [3]. A selected machining technology requires to
produce good surface integrity for components made from particulate reinforced
composites. The past and present scenarios show an electrochemical machining
that fulfills the industry requirements without much disturbing the materials being
machined. Another variant of an electrochemical process namely wire electrochemi-
cal machining process is a hybrid unconventional metal cutting process for very hard
materials [4]. The reasons for selecting a wire electrochemical machining process,
specifically for metal matrix composites, are produced complex shapes, profiles, and
slits without residual stress.
Normally, material removal rate (MRR), surface roughness, and slit width are the
essential characteristics for the WEDM machining operations [5]. These character-
istic parameters depend on the machining gap, concentration of electrolyte, type of
electrolyte, wire diameter, and current source characteristics. Senthilkumar et al. [6]
obtained higher MRR and lower surface roughness by performing electrochemical
machining of MMC with different process parameters. It is reported that increases
in voltage and feed rate resulting in lower surface roughness and higher MRR. Fur-
thermore, increasing in concentration and flow rate of electrolyte showed the same
result. Taweel et al. [7] were optimized wire electrochemical turning experimental
results using a response surface method. The input parameters such as feed rate, rota-
tional speed, and overlap distance were optimized to obtain higher material removal
rate and lower surface roughness. In case of ECM optimization, Bhattacharyya et al.
[8] developed a mathematical model to correlate machining response to process
parameters.
In the present study, the WEDM on the Al-5 & 15wt% TiB2 composites has
been done. Process parameters like inter-gap voltage, concentration, and flow rate
of electrolyte were optimized in order to obtain better machining responses such as
surface roughness, material removal rate, and slit width.
Composites made from Al6061 matrix reinforced with TiB2 ceramic particles (size
of 10 µm) with two different proportions of (5% and 15wt%) using a stir casting
method. The fabricated composites were heat treated by T-6 heat treatment method.
Figure 1 shows the experimental machine setup of the wire electrochemical machine.
In a wire electrochemical machining process, copper wire of 0.5 mm diame-
ter can be used as a cathode and the Al6061/TiB2 as an anode. Both electrodes
were immersed in a sodium chloride electrolyte solution with wire feed rate of
1 mm/min. experiments were conducted by varying the input parameters such as
Electrolyte and Machining Parameters … 41
DC voltage of (10–14 V), electrolyte concentration (12–18%), and flow rate (2–
8 l/min). The machining output parameters like MRR, slit width, and surface rough-
ness are reported. MRR was calculated using a mass loss method. Slit width was
observed by optical microscope. The surface roughness of machined surface was
measured by using a talysurf meter with cut-off length 0.8 mm. Table 1 shows
complete experimental parameters for WECM.
Material removal rate, surface roughness, and slit width were classified as response
functions to the voltage (A), electrolyte concentration (B), and electrolyte flow rate
(C) and were considered as control variables. The experiments were conducted using
a design of experiment technique with central composite design. The experiments
were run as sequence of L19 orthogonal array. Table 2 shows the process parameters
levels as per the central composite design. Table 3 presents an experimental design
matrix and 5 and 15% reinforced composite experimental results.
42 K. Rajkumar et al.
Table 2 Experimental
Process parameters Levels
parameters and their levels
−1 0 1
Voltage (V) 10 12 14
Electrolyte flow rate (l/min) 2 5 8
Electrolyte concentration (%) 12 15 18
The mathematical model for the material removal rate when considering with various
process parameters for 5 and 15% reinforcement composites is shown in Eqs. 1 and
2,
The mathematical model for the surface roughness of machined surface of 5 and
15% reinforcement composites is shown in Eqs. 3 and 4,
The mathematical model for the obtained slit width while cutting with wire as
considering various process parameters for 5 and 15% reinforcement composites is
shown in Eqs. 5 and 6,
Analyzing experimental work by DOE method and regression model for MRR, and
the effect caused by control variables is given in ANOVA Table 4. Composite 5
and 15% show that the developed MRR model was well-suited for machining of
composite material, as seen that model is highly significance. Likewise, each control
variable was affected material removal rate within confidence limit of 95%, as clearly
shown in Table 4.
Figure 2a, b shows a 3D model graph of MRR of composite machining with
electrolyte flow rate, concentration, and voltage. Electrolyte flow rate and concentra-
tion were directly affected by MRR. When increased electrolyte flow rate hydrogen
bubbles are removed which were generated at cathodic surface, this increases the
ionic strength of electrolyte in the slit cutting zone. Finally, it leads to high material
removal rate at anode surface. Besides, high flow rate of electrolyte can speed up
ionization process between inter-electrode gaps. This results in more anodic disso-
lution of material and easy flushing of formed debris. Further, electrolyte high flow
rate generates a fresh surface over and over again so that fresh un-machined surface
available for further electrochemical machining. This also resulted in increased MRR
with the flow rate. Similarly, the electrical conductivity of the electrolyte between
the wire and composite is increased by electrolyte concentration. Thus, electrolyte
conductivity between electrodes increased which speed up the electrochemical reac-
tion. This makes a process to steadily improve its cutting ability on the composite. It
is also observed that increases in the voltage and produces high machining current
44
Fig. 2 Effect of MRR a electrolyte flow rate and concentration b voltage and electrolyte
concentration
in the inter-electrode gap. It might result in increased current density between the
electrodes that increased material removal rate at anode surface [9].
Table 5 shows an ANOVA table for surface roughness of machined surface of compos-
ites. This table indicates developed surface roughness model which perfectly reflects
the control variables behavior to the experimental results. The control variables were
adequately fit into the developed mathematical model.
Figure 3a, b shows the 3D model graph of surface roughness with the electrolyte
flow rate, concentration, and voltage. It is observed from the plot that surface rough-
ness slightly increases with increase in flow rate. Owing to flow streaks on the surface
increases unsteady rotating eddies on the surface. This results in high turbulence
over the surface. Surface roughness increases with increasing electrolyte concentra-
tion. At low concentration, the ion depletion in electrolyte between inter-electrode
gap results in reduced surface roughness [10]. The current density increases with
increase in electrolyte concentration which leads to pitting on the cutting surface. It
is observed that surface roughness affected with inter-electrode potential difference
increases. When voltage increased the metal, dissolution was also increased. This
leads to an uneven dissolution around the cutting surface resulting in poor surface
finish.
Table 6 shows an ANOVA table for slit width of composites. This table clearly
indicates that developed slit width model with consideration of all control variables
is well-fitted by seeing an evidence of less than 5% P-value. All the control variables
were significantly affected the process
46
Fig. 3 Surface roughness plot a electrolyte flow rate and concentration b voltage and electrolyte
concentration
The slit width of the composites as function of different process variables are
shown in Fig. 4a, b. It is observed that high voltage increased order of MRR. Increase
in metal dissolution increases the slit width. Similarly, at high flow rate the burrs were
removed and enlarge the slit width. Hence, the medium flow rate was optimal for
machining of composites.
Slit width was observed using optical microscopy images. Figure 5a, b shows
the slit profiles of machined composites. 5% reinforcement composite shows a line
straight geometric profile (Fig. 5a). This is the effect of lesser reinforcement particle’s
presence in composite. It is understood that these particles slightly interfere the
machining. The presence of larger amount of nonconductive ceramic particles, in case
of 15% reinforcement composite, leads to inhomogeneous dissolution and uneven
distribution of current intensity resulted in an entry side enlarge of slit (Fig. 5b).
4 Conclusions
Fig. 4 Slit width plot a electrolyte flow rate and concentration b voltage and electrolyte
concentration
References
1. Hemanth J (2009) Quartz (SiO2 p) reinforced chilled metal matrix composite (CMMC) for
automotive applications. Mater Des 30(2):323–329
2. Shorowordi KM, Laoui T, Haseeb ASMA, Celis JP, Froyen L (2003) Microstructure and inter-
face characteristics of B4C, SiC and Al2 O3 reinforced Al matrix composites: a comparative
study. J Mater Process Technol 142(3):738–743
3. McGeough JA (1988) Advanced methods of machining. Springer Science & Business Media
(1988)
4. Sen M, Shan HS (2005) A review of electrochemical macro-to micro-hole drilling processes.
Int J Mach Tools Manuf 45(2):137–152
5. Sankar M, Gnanavelbabu A, Rajkumar K (2014) Effect of reinforcement particles on the abra-
sive assisted electrochemical machining of Aluminium-Boron carbide-Graphite composite.
Procedia Eng 97:381–389
6. Senthilkumar C, Ganesan G, Karthikeyan R (2009) Study of electrochemical machining
characteristics of Al/SiC p composites. Int J Adv Manufact Technol 43(3–4):256–263
7. El-Taweel TA, Gouda SA (2011) Performance analysis of wire electrochemical turning
process—RSM approach. Int J Adv Manufact Technol 53(1–4):181–190
8. Bhattacharyya B, Sorkhel SK (1999) Investigation for controlled electrochemical machining
through response surface methodology-based approach. J Mater Process Technol 86(1–3):200–
207
9. Bhattacharya B, Sorkhel SK (1997) Response surface methodology based analysis for achieving
controlled electrochemical machining. In: Proceedings of the 17th all India machine tool design
and research conference, pp 307–311
10. Sankar M, Gnanavelbabu A, Rajkumar K, Thushal NA (2017) Electrolytic concentration effect
on the abrasive assisted-electrochemical machining of an aluminum–boron carbide composite.
Mater Manuf Processes 32(6):687–692
Modeling and Parametric Optimization
of Process Parameters of Wire Electric
Discharge Machining on EN-31
by Response Surface Methodology
1 Introduction
and desirability approach for the optimization of process factors of EDM on MMC.
The low value of EWR is observed at high value of T off (pulse off time) and SR is
influenced by current and T on (pulse on time). Sharma et al. [9] performed single and
multi-objective optimization of process variables of WEDM using response surface
methodology (RSM). For this research work, they used HSLA (High Strength Low
Alloy) steel used as workpiece material and brass wire as an electrode. The result
of ANOVA shows that (CS), T on , and T off are the most significant parameters and
for (DD), (SV), and (T on ) are the most significant parameters. Singh et al. [10]
investigated surface characteristics after powder mixed electric discharge machining
and compare results of surface roughness and recast layer in between powder mixed
and without powder mixed electric discharge machining. The workpiece material
used for this study is aluminum 6061. Finally, they concluded that surface roughness
and recast layer is reduced in the case of powder electric discharge machining as
compared to normal electric discharge machining. Dubey et al. [11] studied the
material removal rate in powder mixed electric discharge machining on AA7075/B4 C
composite. In this experimentation for improving material removal rate chromium
powder is added in a dielectric fluid. From SEM images of the recast, layer shows
that recast layer thickness is more at high value of process variables as compared to
initial values of process variables.
2 Experimental Setup
parameters and their levels in terms of actual and coded value is shown in Table
2. The zinc (Zn) coated Brass wire of 0.25 mm which is used as an electrode in
wire electric discharge machining. So the weight (Wt.) of the workpiece is measured
with the help of PESCO weight balance machine having least count of 0.001 gm. The
PESCO weight balance machine is shown in Fig. 3. The equation used for calculation
of MRR which is given in Eqs. 1.
Table 2 Process Parameters and their levels in terms of coded and actual value
Factor symbol Parameter Unit Levels
Low (−1) High (+1)
A Pulse on time (T on ) µs 110 (−1) 120 (+1)
B Pulse off time (T off ) µs 45 (−1) 55 (+1)
C Servo Voltage (SV) V 20 (−1) 40 (+1)
D Wire Feed (WF) m/min 2 (−1) 6 (+1)
To find out significant factors from model and to check the lack of fit of model,
analysis of variance is calculated. Result of analysis of variance for MRR is shown
in Table 4.
According to the fit summary linear model is significant for analysis of material
removal rate. The value of R2 is 96.07% and the value of adjusted R2 is 95.44% this
clearly indicates that the regression model gives a good relationship between process
factors and the response variable. The factors havingP-value less than 5% (i.e., 0.05)
56 S. B. Patil et al.
these factors are most significant. The factor A-Pulse on time, B-Pulse off time, C-
servo voltage has a significant effect. Among them, A-pulse on time, C-servo voltage
these parameters are most significant for MRR. The value of lack of fit is also non-
significant this is desirable. Figure 5 shows that the normal probability plot for MRR
is clearly indicated that residuals are present on a straight line, it means that error
follows a normal distribution. Figure 6 shows the plot for predicted versus actual
value it shows that model is fitted well. After backward elimination, i.e., eliminates
non-significant terms equation of MRR in coded terms and actual terms is given in
Eqs. 2 and 3 respectively.
Figure 7 shows the surface plot for MRR in relation to the process parameters of
the pulse on time and servo voltage. From the surface plot, it is clearly observed that
as a pulse on time increases material removal rate increases, and as servo voltage
increases material removal rate decreases. Hence, the maximum value of the material
removal rate is obtained at high value of pulse on time (120 µs) and a low value of
servo voltage (20 V). The minimum value of the material removal rate is obtained
at a low value of pulse on time (110 µs) and a high value of servo voltage (40 V).
From Fig. 8, it is clearly indicated the effect of the pulse on time and pulse off time
on material removal rate. The material removal rate increases as the value of pulse
off time decreases. In this case, the high value of material removal rate is obtained
at high value of pulse on time (120 µs) and low value of pulse off time (45 µs) and
minimum value material removal is obtained at low value of pulse on time (110 µs)
and high value of pulse off time (55 µs).
Modeling and Parametric Optimization of Process Parameters … 59
In case of surface roughness, fit summary states that the quadratic model is significant.
Result of analysis of variance for surface roughness is shown in Table 5.
The value of R2 is 0.9858 and adjusted R2 is 0.9725 shows a good relationship
between process parameters and the response variable. The process parameters A-
pulse on time, C-servo voltage, and interaction effect of process parameter A with
process parameter C have a significant effect. The lack of fit is also non-significant
which is desirable. Figure 9 shows that normal probability plot for SR it clearly
indicated that residuals are present on a straight line it means that error follows a
normal distribution. Figure 10 shows the plot for predicted versus actual value it
shows that model is fitted well. After backward elimination, i.e., (eliminates non-
significant terms) equation of SR in coded terms and actual terms is given in Eqs. 4
and 5 respectively.
The surface plot in Fig. 11 clearly indicates the variation of surface roughness
with respect to process parameters such as pulse on time and servo voltage. The value
of surface roughness increases as the value of pulse on time increases similarly high
value of surface roughness is obtained at a low value of servo voltage. The maximum
value of surface roughness is obtained at high value of pulse on time (120 µs) and
low value of servo voltage (20 V) and a minimum value of surface roughness is
obtained at low value of pulse on time (110 µs) and high value of servo voltage (40
V). The effect of the pulse on time and wire feed on surface roughness is shown in
Fig. 12 with the help of the surface plot. Surface plot in Fig. 12 clearly indicates that
high value of surface roughness is obtained at a high value of pulse on time (120 µs)
and low value of wire feed rate (2 m/min) and low value of surface roughness is get
at low value of pulse on time (110 µs) and high value of feed rate (6 m/min).
The confirmation test table clearly shows that error is very small lies between ±
4%. Result of confirmation test is shown in Table 6. Finally, confirmation test confirms
the good reproducibility of experimentation results.
4 Conclusions
roughness clearly shows that surface roughness increases as the value of pulse on
time increases and the value of servo voltage decreases. The minimum value of sur-
face roughness is obtained at a low value of pulse on time and high value of servo
voltage, i.e., (T on = 110 µs and SV = 40 V). From the confirmation test the error
between actual and predicted values for material removal rate and surface roughness
lies within ± 4% range. This error is very small it confirms the good reproducibility
of experimental results.
References
1. Kansal HK, Singh S, Kumar P (2005) Parametric optimization of powder mixed electrical
discharge machining by response surface methodology. J Mater Proc Technol 169:427–436
2. Kung K-Y, Chiang K-T (2008) Modelling and analysis of machinability evaluation in the wire
electrical discharge machining (WEDM) process of aluminium oxide-based ceramic. Mater
Manufact Proc 23:241–250
3. Patel KM, Pandey PM, Venkateswara Rao P (2009) Determination of an parametric com-
bination using a surface roughness prediction model for EDM of Al2 O3 /SiCw /TiC ceramic
composite. Mater Manufact Proc 24:675–682
4. Patil NG, Brahmankar PK (2010) On the response surface modelling of wire electrical discharge
machining of Al/SiCp metal matrix composites (MMCs). J Mach Form Technol 2(1/2):47–70
5. Ojha K, Garg RK, Singh KK (2011) Experimental investigation and modeling of PMEDM
process with chromium powder suspended dielectric. Int J Appl Sci Eng 2:65–81
6. Shandilya P, Jain PK, Jain NK (2012) Parametric optimization during wire electrical discharge
machining using response surface methodology. Proced Eng 38:2371–2377
7. Khanna R, Singh H (2013) Performance analysis for D-3 material using response surface
methodology on WEDM. Int. J Mach Mach Mater 14(1):45–65
8. Gopalakannan S, Senthilvelan T (2014) Optimization of machining parameters for EDM oper-
ations based on central composite design and desirability approach. J Mechan Sci Technol
28(3):1045–1053
9. Sharma N, Khanna R, Gupta RD, Sharma R (2013) Modeling and multiresponse optimization
on WEDM for HSLA by RSM. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 67:2269–2281
10. Singh B, Kumar J, Kumar S (2014) Experimental investigation on surface characteristics in
powder-mixed electrodischarge machining of AA6061/10%SiC composite. Mater Manufact
Proc 29:287–297
11. Dubey V, Singh B (2018) Study of material removal rate in powder mixed EDM of AA7075/B4C
composite in IMME17. Mater Today: Proc 5:7466–7475
Wire-Cut Electric Discharge Machining
on Nickel–Aluminium–Bronze Using
Brass Wire Electrode
Keywords Brass wire · NAB alloy · Wire-cut EDM · Taguchi’s method · DOE
1 Introduction
2 Experimentation
Table 3 Experimental design—L9 orthogonal array (tool: brass wire, workpiece: NAB alloy)
Experiment A B C D Kerf width (mm) MRR (mm3 /min) SR (µm)
number
1 1 4 2 0.98 0.215 2.95 2.245
2 1 7 3 1.47 0.195 3.29 1.958
3 1 10 5 2.45 0.31 6.82 2.256
4 3 4 3 2.45 0.31 5.67 2.289
5 3 7 5 0.98 0.27 6.59 2.494
6 3 10 2 1.47 0.295 4.98 2.175
7 6 4 5 1.47 0.28 6.83 2.277
8 6 7 2 2.45 0.29 4.54 2.587
9 6 10 3 0.98 0.325 5.40 2.556
The SEM microstructures reveal the surface quality for each sample under different
parameters. A smooth surface is obtained in Fig. 1a for the parameters as pulse-on
time: 1 µs, pulse-off time: 4 µs, current: 2 A, and wire tension: 0.98 N. Figure 1c
shows the formation of a rough surface obtained at higher setting parameters as
pulse-on time: 6 µs, pulse-off time: 10 µs, current: 5 A, and wire tension 2.45 N.
The smoother surface as seen in Fig. 1a may be due to the lower intensity discharges
that took place during machining; thus, there is very small debris that can be observed
in this surface. Figure 1c shows the lumps and globules of debris with some deep
craters and microcracks on the surface which may have caused due to higher values
machining parameters. These deeper craters may be the places where the individual
discharge was able to penetrate far into the workpiece.
The recast layers can be clearly seen thicker in Fig. 1d compared to Fig. 1b, as
Experiment No. 1 (pulse-on time: 1 µs, pulse-off time: 4µs, current: 2A, and wire
tension: 0.98 N) was used to machine the sample shown in Fig. 1b and Experiment No.
9 (pulse-on time: 6 µs, pulse-off time: 10 µs, current: 5 A, and wire tension 2.45 N)
Wire-Cut Electric Discharge Machining … 71
a) b)
c) d)
Fig. 1 SEM micrographs of a sample 1 WEDM surface, b sample 1 cross section, c sample 9
WEDM surface, and d sample 9 cross section
was used to machine the sample shown in Fig. 1d. This difference in the recast layer
thickness is due to the resolidified materials formed on the surface layer after the
spark melts a small portion of workpiece and wire electrode during machining.
The higher the MRR, better the machining. Figure 2 shows the effect of MRR for
the various machining parameters. When the pulse-on time increases the MRR also
increases; it is similar to the peak current and wire tension. High current generates
large number of electrons. These electrons striking the work surface in a single
discharge, which increases the erosion process. Therefore kerf width and MRR also
increased. This can be confirmed by Figs. 3 and 2 respectively. Similarly, the surface
72 E. Beni et al.
roughness also increases when the peak current is high which results in high discharge
frequency, leading to the formation of deeper and larger craters in the surface. Table 4
shows the interaction between various process parameters and their significance
based on the rankings, with percentage contribution for the peak current to be the
highest at 87.2% and the wire tension and the pulse-off time percentage contribution
is the least at 31% and 32.3%, respectively. The pulse-on time is also a significant
factor with percentage contribution of 53.8%.
In all the graphs, the pulse-off time also showed some increase in MRR and kerf
width. This particular phenomenon requires supporting reasons to clarify; thus, the
pulse-off effect is not considered as a major significance causing parameter.
The effect of various parameters like pulse-on time, pulse-off time, peak current,
and the wire tension has been studied through machining of NAB with using brass
electrode wire. The surface roughness was unchanged by using different parameters
as shown in Fig. 3. The SR had been only influenced by the pulse-on time. Wire
tension has the least effect on the surface roughness. This is because the number of
electrons hitting the surface for elapsed time causes more erosion of material, and
thus, surface roughness is increased (Fig. 4).
4 Conclusions
In this study, the effect of machining parameters on the kerf width, MRR, and the
surface roughness of nickel–aluminium–bronze was investigated experimentally by
using brass wire-cut EDM.
1. Peak current and pulse-on time have been found as the most significant factors,
with percentage contribution of 87.2% and 53,8%, respectively. The other two
process parameter interactions were also significant; however, their contribution
in variance is relatively low.
2. The higher values of discharge energy and the elongated period of pulse-on time
increase the machining rate and thus result in large craters and microdamages
that cause the surface to be rough. This problem can be optimized by Taguchi’s
parameter design for WEDM.
3. The effect of various parameters like pulse-on time, pulse-off time, peak current
and the wire tension has been studied through machining of NAB with using
brass electrode wire. The surface roughness was unchanged by using different
parameters. SR had been only influenced by the pulse-on time.
74 E. Beni et al.
4. A linear regression graph is obtained for the MRR, kerf width, and the surface
roughness responses. The result shows that the MRR and kerf width can be highly
influenced by the variation in peak current and the pulse-on time.
5. Based on the results, the untreated brass wire provides good machining perfor-
mance (maximum MRR and better surface roughness) when used for machining
NAB material.
6. In the future, this work can be extended to discuss effect of the cryogenic cooled
electrodes of different materials with NAB and comparison of the same by
discussing the dimensional accuracy and MRR.
References
1. Lia L, Guob YB, Weia XT, Lib W (2013) Surface integrity characteristics in wire-EDM of
inconel 718 at different discharge energy. In: Seventeenth international symposium on electro
machining, Procedia CIRP, vol 6, pp 220–225
2. Amitesh G, Jatinder K (2014) Investigation of surface integrity, material removal rate and wire
wear ratio for WEDM of Nimonic 80A alloy using GRA and Taguchi method. Eng Sci Technol
Int J 17:173–184
3. Kanlayasiri K, Boonmung S (2007) An investigation on effects of wire-EDM machining
parameters on surface roughness of newly developed DC53 die steel. J Mater Process Technol
187–188:26–29
4. Ivan R, Carol P (2016) Guide to nickel aluminium bronze for engineers. Copper Development
Association Publication, No. 22
5. Ho KH, Newman ST (2003) State of the art electrical discharge machining (EDM). Int J Mach
Tools Manufact 43:1287–1300
6. Brajesh KL, Sanjay A (2014) Optimization of machining parameters in WEDM of AISI D3
Steel using Taguchi Technique. In: 6th CIRP international conference on high performance
cutting, HPC
7. Bijaya BN, Siba SM (2016) Optimization of WEDM process parameters using deep cryo-
treated Inconel 718 as work material. Eng Sci Technol Int J 19:161–170
8. Ashish G (2009) Investigation of material removal rate and surface roughness during wire
electrical discharge machining (WEDM) of Inconel 625 super alloy by cryogenic treated tool
electrode. J King Saud Univ Sci 29:528–535
9. Amitesh G, Jatinder K (2017) Trim cut machining and surface integrity analysis of Nimonic
80A alloy using wire cut EDM. Eng Sci Technol Int J 20:175–186
10. Norliana MA, Darius GS, Fuad BMd (2007) A review on current research trends in electrical
discharge machining (EDM). Int J Mach Tools Manuf 47:1214–1228
11. Subrahmanyam M, Nancharaiah T (2019) Optimization of process parameters in wire-cut EDM
of Inconel 625 using Taguchi’s approach. Mater Today: Proc
12. Reolon LW, Henning Laurindo CA, Torres RD, Amorim FL (2019) WEDM performance and
surface integrity of Inconel alloy IN718 with coated and uncoated wires. Int J Adv Manufact
Technol 100:1981–1991
Development and Characterization
of Metal Matrix Composite
Manufacture, Mechanical Properties
and Microstructural Characterization
of Aluminium and Iron Metal Matrix
Composite Manufactured
Abstract The objective of the present work is to investigate the formation of inter-
metallic compounds such as iron aluminides and oxides during the formation of an
alloy by melting commercially pure aluminium (Al) billets and adding iron powder
(Fe) at 750 °C in the molten aluminium. The exothermic reaction during the addition
of ‘Fe’ in the molten ‘Al’ resulted in the formation of more amounts of intermetallic
compounds because of the rise in temperature. The composition of the ‘Al’ and ‘Fe’
powder was varied to obtain various alloys. The optical microscopy examination
revealed the presence of various intermetallic compounds and oxides in the matrix.
The Rockwell hardness survey performed on various samples exhibited a maximum
hardness value of 79 in ‘B’ scale for the alloy composition of 60% Al and 40% Fe. A
maximum shear strength of 288 Mpa was obtained for the samples containing 65%
Al and 35% Fe.
1 Introduction
Aluminium is a chemical element in the boron group with symbol ‘Al’ and atomic
number 13. It is silvery-white, and it is not soluble in water under normal circum-
stances. Pure aluminium possesses low strength and toughness, and its strength can be
increased with the addition of various elements. Aluminium is alloyed with elements
like ‘Cu’, ‘Si’, ‘Mg’, ‘Zn’, ‘Fe’ and other elements. The solubility of aluminium in
iron at 400 °C is 11.5% which is as shown in Fig. 1. Addition of excess ‘Al’ in
‘Fe’ results in the formation of intermetallic compounds such as FeAl, Fe3 Al, FeAl2
and FeAl3 . The presence of intermetallic compounds and oxides reinforces the softer
matrix aluminium and increases the mechanical properties. These intermetallic com-
pounds are formed as a result of the reaction between two or more metals which are
mixed together in certain proportions. These intermetallic compounds exhibit neither
metallic nor ceramic properties. Iron aluminides are compounds formed between
‘Fe’ and ‘Al’. The phase diagram drawn between Al–Fe reveals the formation of
intermetallic compounds like Fe3 Al, FeAl, FeAl2 , Fe2 Al5 and FeAl3 . The proper-
ties of iron aluminide are dependent on number of aluminium atoms present in the
compound. The presence of more aluminium atoms in the intermetallic compounds
such as FeAl2 , Fe2 Al5 and FeAl3 is detrimental to strength properties and induces
brittleness. On the other hand, Fe3 Al and FeAl, which have a high iron composi-
tion, are used as structural materials because of their good wear resistance, corrosion
resistance and specific strength properties.
In pure elements and solid solutions, the atoms are bound together with metallic
bonds. In the case of intermetallic compounds covalent bond is formed which alters
the crystal structure, chemical, mechanical and electrical properties. Intermetallic
compounds such as Fe3 Al and FeAl are among a variety of different intermetallic
compounds that can be used in heterogeneous metal (Al)–intermetallic materials and
Manufacture, Mechanical Properties and Microstructural … 79
intermetallics that can be used for corrosion resistance applications at higher tem-
perature. This alloy system containing Al–intermetallic compounds having nearly
homogeneous composition exhibits properties varying from intermetallics to alu-
minium alloys. The literature revealed that the formation of Fe–Al intermetallic
compounds took place during melting of these elements and during powder com-
pacting and sintering of these powders. Wangyu Hu et al. [1] revealed the formation
of nanocrystalline iron aluminide intermetallic compounds by mechanical alloying,
sintering and high-velocity oxy-fuel (HVOF) thermal spraying from the elemental
powders. The strength, ductility and toughness of the samples were increased by
maintaining grain size to the nanocrystalline level. Jiqiang et al. [2] produced an
ultra-fine grained Fe-40Al intermetallic compound. The X-ray diffraction of the Fe-
40Al intermetallic compound revealed the presence of FeAl phase. The Fe-40Al
intermetallic compound presented ultra-fine grains size in the range of 100–600 nm
because of high nucleation rate and the low growth rate.
The fabrication process of the metal–intermetallic materials is one of the most
important areas of research. Several research works presented the capabilities of the
formation of intermetallic compounds, metal–intermetallic compound and metal–
ceramic combination. These include solidification processing, powder metallurgy
(PM), coating technology and layered manufacturing. Among these methods, PM
is the most commonly used because of its ability to produce a wide range of com-
positions, its phase and property control as well as shape-forming capability. In the
present research work, the Al-FeAl intermetallic compound’s fabrication route con-
sists of melting the solid aluminium billets and keeping ‘Fe’ powder in solid state. In
the first method, ‘Al’ solid billets and ‘Fe’ powder are mixed together and then heated
to 750 °C. At this temperature, the molten aluminium reacted with ‘Fe’ powder to
form Al-FeAl rich phase. Solubility of Fe in Al is 10–12%. Since we are adding 20–
40% Fe, it can be seen from the phase diagram that there is a very good possibility
of formation of intermetallics.
This alloy is then heat-treated for 10 h in a muffle furnace. In the second method,
‘Fe’ powder is added with the molten aluminium followed by annealing the alloy
for 10 h at 600 °C to form Al-FeAl system. During the solidification process, oxides
such as Al2 O3 and FeO2 are formed which may have strengthened the Al-FeAl alloy.
Prichard [3] conducted experiments by adding silicon to Fe-15%A1 alloy which
produced faceting on powder particle surfaces during vacuum sintering above
1200 °C. The faceting planes occurred on the low index planes with high sym-
metry. The faceting was due to a change in the solid–vapour surface energy as a
function of crystallographic orientation. The extrusion of Fe–Al–Si alloys produced
a wire texture, which nearly doubled the yield strength of the material in the extru-
sion direction compared to the transverse direction. Although the extruded alloy
was fully dense, the tensile properties in the extruded direction do not represent the
mechanical properties of a sintered microstructure with randomly oriented grains.
The yield strength of sintered powders was comparable to the extruded powders in
the same heat treatment condition. The yield strength and fracture energy of the fine
grain material with approximately 10% porosity exceeded the yield strength and
fracture energy of coarse grain material with approximately 3% porosity. Therefore,
80 D. Arthur Jebastine Sunderraj et al.
the processing parameters are broad enough to develop desirable mechanical prop-
erties with a wide range of microstructures. The next phase of development would
be to incorporate these processing parameters into an MIM process to address the
interaction of the powder with binder systems. The uniform porosity and fine grain
size of the sintered Fe-15A1-2.8Si alloy, which was heat-treated at 600 °C, developed
the best combination of strength and toughness. This indicates the silicon atoms are
more beneficial in a solid solution rather than in an ordered precipitate.
The objective of this work is to produce Al–Fe alloys possessing optimum mechan-
ical properties. Addition of ‘Fe’ in ‘Al’ to very high level decreases strength because
more amounts of brittle phase is formed in the alloy. Therefore, an optimum level
of ‘Fe’ percentage should be fixed for obtaining maximum strength. In the present
work ‘Fe’ content is varied from 20–40% and ‘Al’ content 60–80% to produce various
alloys. In the molten aluminium, ‘Fe’ powder is added which produces an exothermic
reaction. This reaction generates heat, and this heat partially melts the ‘Fe’ powder
to form intermetallic compounds with ‘Al’.
2 Experimental Procedure
2.1 Material
The iron powder 4–8 µm particle size having purity 99.9% is used in this study.
Wrought aluminium having 99.5% purity with 0.2% Si, 0.1% Fe, 0.04% Mg, 0.1%
Mn and 0.05% O is used. The purchased rod is of 20 mm in diameter which is cut to
billets of 20 mm in length.
The muffle furnace having a heating chamber of 380 mm length and 180 mm width
is used. The heating rate of this furnace can be varied to the required level. The
maximum temperature of the furnace is 1000 °C. Small crucibles made with clay are
used for melting the aluminium metal. The experimental set-up is shown in Fig. 2.
The billets were cleaned mechanically by turning them in a lathe and finally cleaned
with chemicals like HCl and NaOH. The ‘Al’ billets were weighed and placed inside
the crucibles and heated inside the furnace. The crucibles were heated up to 750 °C
and kept inside the furnace for 1 h. In the molten ‘Al’, ‘Fe’ powder is added to initiate
Manufacture, Mechanical Properties and Microstructural … 81
exothermic reaction. Because of this exothermic reaction, the temperature inside the
crucible rises to 1600 °C. Further, this alloy is kept at 750 °C for two hours and given
an annealing heat treatment for 16 h at 550 °C.
The specimens obtained from the furnace were machined in a lathe to obtain
circular discs as shown in Fig. 3a, b. Square and circular specimens of 6 × 6 mm and
4 mm in diameter (for metallography and shear test) were cut using wire-cut electric
discharge machining technique. The WEDM specimens are shown in Fig. 3c. The
metallographic samples were polished using various grades (up to 1200 grade) of
a b
Fig. 3 a and b Al–Fe partial melt turned samples and c wire-cut EDM samples
82 D. Arthur Jebastine Sunderraj et al.
silicon carbide paper to obtain mirror finish. These samples were finished with Al2
O3 slurry to obtain mirror finish without any scratch marks. The polished specimens
were etched with a chemical mixture containing 5 ml HCl + 10 ml HNO3 + 3 ml
HF + 50 ml H2 O for 1 min. The specimens were rinsed in water and dried using a
drier.
The optical micrographs shown in Fig. 4a, b correspond to the sample1 processed
at 750 °C and annealed at 550 °C for 19 h inside the furnace. Figure 4a shows
three different regions marked as region ‘A’, region ‘B’ and region ‘C’. These three
regions are rich with intermetallic compounds such as FeAl2 , Fe2 Al5 and FeAl3
and oxides like Al2 O3 and FeO2 . Further, away from these dark regions a yellowish
region with fine grains of ‘Al’ is noted. This region is rich with pure aluminium.
Adjacent to this region on both sides, fine intermetallic compounds which impart
dispersion strengthening effect to this soft region are seen. The micrograph shown
in Fig. 4b reveals three distinct regions containing recrystallized regions rich with
alternate grains of aluminium and intermetallic compounds. The grain boundaries
are precipitated with ‘Fe’. The recrystallization is because of pinning of these ‘Fe’
atoms along the grain boundaries and migration of ‘Fe’ atoms into ‘Al’ matrix and
subsequent formation of newer grain boundaries. In Fig. 4c, a dark region which
resembles like a large spear at the centre of the micrograph with serrations at the
sides is observed and indicates the formation of intermetallic compounds and its
growth into the ‘Al’ grains because of long annealing time and diffusion of ‘Fe’
atoms into the ‘Al’ matrix.
The micrographs shown in Fig. 4a, b correspond to the sample 2 as given in
Table 1. This sample is rich with 20% ‘Fe’ and annealed for 16 h at 550 °C which is
mechanically agitated to obtain homogeneous alloy. The microstructures show dark
regions, which may possibly be intermetallics.
The optical micrographs shown in Fig. 5a, b correspond to the sample 3 processed
at 750 °C and annealed at 550 °C for 16 h inside the furnace. Figure 5a shows two
different regions marked as region A and region B. These three regions are rich with
intermetallic compounds such as FeAl2 , Fe2 Al5 and FeAl3 and oxides like Al2 O3
and FeO2 . Further, proof of intermetallics formation can be obtained by viewing the
XRD patterns as shown in Figs. 9, 10 and 11. The micrographs shown in Fig. 5d–f
correspond to the sample 4 as given in Table 1. This sample is rich with 35% ‘Fe’ and
annealed for 16 h at 550 °C which is mechanically agitated to obtain homogeneous
alloy.
Because of this, the micrographs shown in Fig. 5a, b reveal the presence of
fragmented intermetallic compounds such as FeAl2 , Fe2 Al5 and FeAl3 .
In Fig. 5d, the thick grain boundaries are visible and adjacent to the grain bound-
aries fingerprint-like intermetallic compound formation is noted which resembles
like laves phase (circle mark A). The lengthy intermetallic compounds rich with ‘Fe’
are observed in the published literature by Chakraborty et al. [4]. The circle marks
containing a sphere are possibly intermetallic compounds. The micrographs shown
84 D. Arthur Jebastine Sunderraj et al.
The Rockwell hardness values measured across the sample at twelve points were
recorded. The graphical plot of the hardness values is shown in Fig. 7. The hardness
values were on the rise as the composition of ‘Fe’ was on the rise. A maximum
Manufacture, Mechanical Properties and Microstructural … 85
hardness of 79 in ‘B’ scale was noted for the sample 6. The hardness value was in
the range of 52–78 for the sample 5. A minimum value of 41 in B scale was recorded
for the sample 1. This is due to less amount of ‘Fe’ present in the alloy.
The average shear strength values are shown in Table 2. The average shear strengths
of the sample 1 processed at 750 °C and annealed for 19 h was 278 MPa. The average
shear strength of the sample 2 was only 265 MPa. The lowest shear strength was
recorded for the sample 3 (Table 2) which was 250 MPa. The shear strength of
the sample 4 was 280 MPa. For the sample 5, the shear strength was 272 MPa. The
sample 6 exhibited a shear strength of 279 MPa. The shear strength of various samples
is presented as a graph in Fig. 8. The variation in shear strength was attributed to
variation in the composition of ‘Fe’ and difference in annealing time and stirring of
the alloy during the formation of alloy.
The XRD report of the sample 2 as given in Table 1 was shown in Fig. 9 and has
indicated the presence of several intermetallic compounds in the FeAl matrix. The
XRD pattern for the sample 2 is shown in Fig. 9. These compounds are hard and
brittle, which increase the shear strength of the annealed samples. The intermetallic
compounds such as Fe2 Al, Fe3 Al, FeAl, FeAl5 and Fe2 Al3 are present in the alloy.
The secondary phase particles like Al2 O3 and FeO2 are present. These intermetallic
compounds and secondary phase particles strengthened the soft aluminium matrix.
The XRD pattern reveals the presence of pure Al and Fe along with other compounds.
This XRD report of the sample 4 as given in Table 1 is shown in Fig. 10. The
intermetallic compounds such as Fe2 Al, Fe3 Al, FeAl, FeAl5 and Fe2 Al3 are present
in the alloy and indicated the presence of several intermetallic compounds in the
FeAl matrix. It increases the shear strength of the annealed samples. The secondary
phase particles like Al2 O3 and FeO2 were present. These intermetallic compounds
and secondary phase particles strengthened the soft aluminium matrix and make the
increase in strength of the original aluminium.
The XRD report reveals the composition of the various intermetallic compounds
that were present in Fig. 11 of sample 6 and has indicated the presence of several
intermetallic compounds in the FeAl matrix; this intermetallic compounds increase
the shear strength of the annealed samples. The various compositions of alloy are
Fe2 Al, Fe3 Al, FeAl, FeAl5 and Fe2 Al3 which are present in the alloy, and also, the
particles like Al2 O3 and FeO2 are present in the secondary phase particle. These inter-
metallic compounds and secondary phase particles strengthened the soft aluminium
matrix and give more strength to the pure aluminium.
4 Conclusions
hardness value of 79 in B scale was recorded for the sample 6. The concentration
of Fe was at maximum level for this sample.
• Maximum shear strength of 280 MPa was observed for the sample 4. The minimum
shear strength was observed for the sample 3.
• The formation of intermetallic compounds such as FeAl2 , Fe2 Al5 , FeAl6 and
FeAl3 was observed in all the samples in varying amounts. The oxides such as
FeO2 and Al2O3 were noted in few samples.
References
1 Introduction
Nowadays industries have focused its attention towards aluminum alloys due to its
improved properties such as lightweight, corrosion resistance, improved thermal
conductivity, recycling properties, etc. and are widely used in aviation, automobile
and structural industries [1, 2]. AA7068 aluminum alloy provides high mechanical
strength among the alloying elements and provides improved mechanical proper-
ties [3]. Graphite is a soft reinforcement and due to its self-lubricating property, it
provides a better wear resistance than conventional aluminum alloys for Al-Gr com-
posites, which prevents metal to metal contact by forming a thin layer of graphite
particle [4]. Graphite serves as a solid lubricating layer and reduces the composite
wear without the need for solid and liquid lubrication [5]. The addition of graphite in
aluminum matrix leads to a reduction in hardness and flexural strength [6]. Graphite
powder acts as a friction-reducing element, helps to get stronger bond with metals
and widely used in power metallurgy [7]. Graphite has extrinsic lubricating prop-
erty and hence reduces friction and wear. Large amount of graphite added to cop-
per reduces the hardness and fracture strength of the composites [8]. Addition of
graphite in Al7075/Al2 O3 /Gr composites exhibited superior wear-resistance proper-
ties. Smaller amount of aluminum graphite composite exhibits superior wear prop-
erties over the base alloys [9]. Gheorghe et al. [10] fabricated Al/Al2 O3 /Gr hybrid
composites through powder metallurgy route and showed that Vickers microhardness
was increased by increasing the duration of mechanical milling and also by increasing
the reinforcement content of hard Al2 O3 particles. The presence of graphite particles
act as a solid lubricant and reduced the wear rate. Kaushik et al. [11] produced Al
6082 alloy-SiC-Gr hybrid composites using stir casting technique and reported that
the hybrid composites showed improved wear resistance compared to single SiC
reinforced composite and base alloy. The presence of graphite forms a graphitic film
which acts as a self-lubricant in the hybrid composites. Akhlaghi and Pelaseyyed
[12] developed A365 alloy- graphite composites using in situ powder metallurgy
technique and showed that wear rate reduced as a result of increased graphite con-
tent due to the homogeneous distribution of graphite particles with reduced porosity
and fine-grained base alloy. Akhlaghi and Zare-Bidaki [13] produced Al 2024/5-20
wt% flake graphite composites by in situ powder metallurgy technique and reported
that the hardness of these composites decreased with increasing graphite content. Up
to 5 wt% graphite addition the composites showed improved the wear resistance and
beyond 10 wt% or more graphite particles addition, the wear rate increased. Riahi
and Alpas [14] fabricated A356 Al–10% SiC–4% Gr and A356 Al–5% Al2 O3 –3%
Gr composites using molten metal mixing technique. He reported that the compos-
ites have undergone severe wear regime and the hardness of the composites has been
reduced. Graphitic composites demonstrated mild to severe wear at various load and
sliding speed combinations, which were higher than A356 base alloy and A356–20%
SiC composites. Babu et al. [15] studied the wear behavior of aluminum/graphite
nanofiber/alumina short fiber hybrid composites with a different volume fraction of
fibers (10, 15, and 20%) under dry sliding conditions. The composites with 10 and
Influence of Graphite Particles on Microhardness … 93
15 vol.% of fiber showed the lowest friction and wear loss, and increased friction and
wear loss for 20 vol.% of fiber. Ted and Tsao [16] fabricated aluminum/SiC/graphite
hybrid composites with different volume percentages (2, 5, 8%) of graphite using a
semi-solid powder densification technique and studied the tribological behavior. As
the amount of graphite content increased, the hardness of the composites decreased.
The wear rate of the composites increased up to 5% graphite addition and then
reduced for 8% graphite addition. Rajaram et al. [17] fabricated Al-SiC/graphite
hybrid composites using stir casting technique and studied the wear behavior. The
wear properties showed that by the addition of graphite particles, the wear resistance
of the composites increased compared to Al–Si base alloy for all load ranges.
The produced AA7068/graphite metal matrix composites were tested and their
results were reported.
2 Experimental Procedure
FESEM image of AA7068 and graphite powders used in this research work was
demonstrated in Fig. 1. AA7068 was used as a matrix material and graphite was
used as the reinforcement material to produce metal matrix composites using pow-
der metallurgy technique. AA7068 (Zn-8%, Mg-3%, Cu-2%, Si-0.12%, Fe-0.15%,
Mn-0.1%, Cr-0.05%, Zr-0.1%, Ti-0.01%, Al-bal) powders reinforced with different
weight percentages of graphite (3, 6, 9%) particles were milled in a ball mill for
40 h separately. The average particle size of AA7068 powders and graphite powders
were 1.785 µm and 2.07 µm respectively. Stearic acid is mixed up to 2% to improve
the bonding strength between the metal powders [18]. The ball-milled powders were
compacted using a Universal Testing Machine (UTM) at a low pressure of 318 MPa
and sintered at a temperature of 560 °C for an hour to produce composites of size
Fig. 3 Vickers
microhardness of
AA7068/Graphite
composites
The graph of wear rate vs sliding distance and volume loss vs. sliding distance for
AA7068/graphite composites were presented in Fig. 4a, b respectively. It was noticed
that the wear rate and the volume loss of all the composites were lower compared
to that of the matrix material. As the graphite content increased, the wear rate and
the volume loss decreased for all the composites. As the sliding distance increased,
wear rate and the volume loss increased for both the base alloy and the composites.
The graphite particles incorporated in the base alloy act as a solid lubricant, thereby
increasing the wear resistance of the composites. The increase in wear resistance was
due to the direct metal contact which was prevented due to the presence of graphite
Fig. 4 a Wear rate vs sliding distance and b volume loss vs sliding distance of AA7068/Graphite
composites
96 K. John Joshua et al.
particles which formed a rich thin tribofilm between sliding surfaces [9]. Composites
reinforced with 9% graphite showed reduced wear rate and volume loss compared
to other composite combinations.
wear mechanisms [9, 22, 23]. Mixture of rough, smooth regions and large cavities
were found. Cracks and cavities were present on the worn surface due to delamination.
Subsurface deformation, nucleation of cracks, propagation of cracks were involved
in delamination. The nucleation of cracks occurs on the surface of the material at
weak points. Figure 5c, d demonstrate the FESEM images of AA7068 with the
addition of 6% graphite and 9% graphite respectively. Shallow, narrow grooves were
present on the worn surfaces along the sliding direction of the pin. Severely damaged
patches and few rough regions were found on the worn surface. Cracks, cavities, and
small pits were visible on the worn surface. Direct metal contact was prevented
due to the presence of graphite particles which form a rich thin tribofilm between
sliding surfaces [9]. Ploughing and exposure of graphite particles were clearly visible.
Ploughing of materials results in hard wear debris entrapped in between the contact
surfaces due to micro-cutting.
4 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The authors thank Mr. J. Devamanoharan of Centre for Research in Metal-
lurgy (CRM) Laboratory of Karunya Institute of Technology and Sciences for his assistance to carry
out this experimental work.
98 K. John Joshua et al.
References
1. Sandar D, Chatterjee R, Bharathi RJ, Sreehari P (2019) Investigation on the microstructure and
mechanical properties of AA6082/TiO2 surface composites produced by friction stir process-
ing. In: Lakshminarayanan AK, Idapalapati S, Vasudevan M (eds) Conference 2018, ICEMMM.
Springer, Singapore, pp 19–28
2. Kaku SMY, Khanra AK (2019) Hot deformation studies of Al–Cu–Mg powder metallurgy
alloy composite. In: Lakshminarayanan AK, Idapalapati S, Vasudevan M (eds) Conference
2018, ICEMMM. Springer, Singapore, pp 75–81
3. Amin A, Ali S, Omid N, Hamid F, Saeid (2015) Optimizing consolidation behavior of Al
7068–TiC nanocomposites using Taguchi statistical analysis. Trans Nonferrous Met Soc China
25:2499–2508
4. Pardeep S, Dinesh K, Satpal S (2016) Dry sliding wear investigation of Al6082/Gr metal matrix
composite by response surface methodology. J Mater Res Technol 5(1):29–36
5. Kenneth KA, Kazeem OS (2015) Microstructural characteristics, mechanical and wear
behaviour of aluminium matrix hybrid composites reinforced with alumina, rice husk ash
and graphite. Eng Sci Tech 18:416–422
6. Baradeswaran A, Vettivel SC, Elaya P, Selvakumar N, Franklin IR (2014) Experimental inves-
tigation on mechanical behaviour, modelling and optimization of wear parameters of B4C and
graphite reinforced aluminium hybrid composites. J Mater Des 63:620–632
7. Gan Y, Yih P, Chen CQ (2011) Electroplating graphite powder with metals and its use in
microwave absorbing composite. Mater Sci Eng Compos Mater 3(2):129–133
8. Jing FL, Lei Z, Jin KX, Ke CZ (2015) Sliding wear behavior of copper-based composites
reinforced with graphenenanosheets and graphite. Trans Nonferrous Met Soc China 25:3354–
3362
9. Baradeswaran A, Elaya PA (2014) Study on mechanical and wear properties of Al
7075/Al2 O3 /graphite hybrid composites. Compos Part B 56:464–471
10. Gheorghe I, Valeriu GG, Mihai B, Traian B, Mircea IP (2015) Studies on wear rate and micro-
hardness of the Al/Al2 O3 /Gr hybrid composites produced via powder metallurgy. Compos Part
B 69:603–611
11. Kaushik NC, Rao RN (2016) The effect of wear parameters and heat treatment on two body
abrasive wear of Al–SiC–Gr hybrid composites. Tribol Intl 96:184–190
12. Akhlaghi F, Pelaseyyed SA (2004) Characterization of aluminum/graphite particulate com-
posites synthesized using a novel method termed in-situ powder metallurgy. Mater Sci Eng, A
385:258–266
13. Akhlaghi F, Zare-Bidaki A (2009) Influence of graphite content on the dry sliding and oil
impregnated sliding wear behavior of Al 2024–graphite composites produced by in situ powder
metallurgy method. Wear 266:37–45
14. Riahi AR, Alpas AT (2001) The role of tribo-layers on the sliding wear behavior of graphitic
aluminum matrix composites. Wear 251:1396–1407
15. Babu JSS, Kang CG, Kim HH (2011) Dry sliding wear behavior of aluminum based hybrid
composites with graphite nanofiber–alumina fiber. Mater Des 32:3920–3925
16. edGuo ML, Tsao CYA (2000) Tribological behavior of self-lubricating aluminium/SiC/graphite
hybrid composites synthesized by the semi-solid powder-densification method. Compos Sci
Technol 60:65–74
17. Rajaram G, Kumaran S, Srinivasa Rao T (2010) Sliding wear behavior of Al-Si/graphite
composite. Tribol Trans 54:1(115–121)
18. Angelo PC, Subramanian R (2008) Powder metallurgy: science, technology and application,
1st edn. Prentice Hall, India
19. John Joshua K, Vijay SJ, Philip Selvaraj D (2018) Effect of nano-TiO2 particles on micro-
hardness and microstructural behavior of AA7068 metal matrix composites. Ceram Int
44:20774–20781
20. Ashok KB, Murugan N, Dinaharan I (2014) Dry sliding wear behavior of stir cast AA6061-
T6/AlNp composite. Trans Nonferrous Met Soc China 24:2785–2795
Influence of Graphite Particles on Microhardness … 99
21. Yan TY, Lan J, Gao FF, Li QC (2015) Wear behavior and mechanism of B4C reinforced
Mg-matrix composites fabricated by metal-assisted pressureless infiltration technique. Trans
Nonferrous Met Soc China 25:2543–2548
22. Baradeswaran A, Elaya PA (2013) Wear and mechanical characteristics of Al 7075/graphite
composites. Compos Part B 56:472–476
23. Maa W, Lua J, Wanga B (2009) Sliding friction and wear of Cu–graphite against 2024, AZ91D
and Ti6Al4V at different speeds. Wear 266:1072–1081
Microhardness and Microstructural
Behavior of AA7068/SiC Metal Matrix
Composites Synthesized by Powder
Metallurgy
Abstract If anybody is missing any arm or leg, a prosthetic limb can be replaced
to take care of their activities by themselves. Manufacturing of prosthetic limbs for
such persons should be lightweight and requires improved hardness. Hence, silicon
carbide (SiC) was incorporated into aluminum alloy (AA7068) to produce compos-
ites by powder metallurgy technique with different weight percentages of SiC (3,
6 and 9%) along with base alloy. A compaction pressure of 318 MPa was applied
and sintered at a temperature of 560 °C for an hour. Vickers microhardness test was
carried out to find out the microhardness values. Wear experiments were conducted
with a velocity of 1.2 m/s over a sliding distance of 2.5 km of load 5 N. Field emission
scanning electron microscopy (FESEM) analysis was carried out to investigate the
worn surface. Experimental results showed that the Vickers microhardness number
has been increased to a maximum of 55 VHN by the addition of 9% SiC particles
which were 66.7% more than the base alloy. Wear experiments exposed an improved
wear resistance by the addition of SiC particles. AA7068-9% SiC composite exhib-
ited maximum wear resistance. FESEM analysis revealed that abrasion and oxidation
were the predominant wear modes for the produced AA7068/SiC composites. The
prosthetic limb produced using such composite combination would be lightweight
with the improved hardness which would serve the persons better to perform their
daily activities.
1 Introduction
Aluminum matrix composites when reinforced with hard ceramic particles replace
monolithic materials and finds a wide range of application in automobile, transporta-
tion, defense and aerospace industries due to its improved properties such as high
strength, improved wear resistance, high corrosion resistance, low density, heat treat-
ment capability, high elastic modulus, high strength-to-weight ratio and high thermal
conductivity [1–4]. Among the 7xxx series aluminum alloys, AA7068 is one of the
most famous one which provides high strength and improved mechanical properties
[5]. Silicon carbide (SiC) is one of the most used ceramic particulates when intro-
duced into aluminum-based matrix that exhibits various improved advantages such
as high corrosion resistance, improved thermal conductivity, high strength and stiff-
ness, improved wear resistance, good machinability and low cost [6–9]. Mohammad
et al. [10] reported that the hardness and wear resistance improved for Al 5252 alloy
reinforced with micro- and nano-sized SiC particles fabricated using in situ pow-
der metallurgy method. Ali et al. [11] stated that the AA6061 reinforced with SiC
synthesized through semi-solid processing exhibits improved hardness and superior
wear resistance compared to the matrix alloy. Ali et al. [12] concluded that A356
alloy reinforced with nano-SiC composites fabricated through stir casting showed the
improved hardness, yield strength and ultimate strength. Devaraju et al. [13] reported
that aluminum alloy 6061-T6 reinforced with (SiC and Al2O3) hybrid composites
fabricated using stir casting showed the improved hardness and wear resistance due
to the presence of hard SiC and Al2 O3 particles. Nidhi et al. [14] stated that Al–
10 wt%SiC composites fabricated using stir casting technique showed reduced wear
rate and coefficient of friction. Dolatkhah et al. [15] concluded that the Al5052/SiC
metal matrix composite fabricated through friction stir processing showed that the
microhardness has been improved up to 55% and wear rate was decreased up to 9.7
times compared with the base matrix. Powder metallurgy is an economical manufac-
turing method to produce components and offers various advantages such as better
dimensional precision, improved surface finish, ability to produce complex shapes
and cost-effectiveness [16].
The mechanical and microstructural properties are characterized for the fabricated
AA7068/SiC composites, and their results are reported.
2 Experimental Procedure
Figure 1 demonstrates the FESEM image of AA7068 and SiC powders used in this
research work. AA7068 was used as a matrix material, and SiC was used as the
reinforcement material to produce metal matrix composites using a powder metal-
lurgy technique. Power metallurgy provides better bonding of matrix and particles,
Microhardness and Microstructural Behavior … 103
better distribution and easier control of matrix structure. AA7068 (Zn-8%, Mg-3%,
Cu-2%, Si-0.12%, Fe-0.15%, Mn-0.1%, Cr-0.05%, Zr-0.1%, Ti-0.01%, Al-bal) pow-
ders reinforced with different weight percentages of SiC (3%, 6%, 9%) particles were
milled in a ball mill for 40 h separately. The average particle size of AA7068 powders
and SiC powders were 1.785 µm and 2.253 µm, respectively. Stearic acid is mixed
up to 2% to improve the bonding strength between the metal powders. The ball-
milled powders were compacted using a Universal Testing Machine (UTM) at a low
pressure of 318 MPa and sintered at a temperature of 560 °C for one hour to produce
composites of size 20 mm diameter and 32 ± 2 mm height. Figure 2 demonstrates
Fig. 3 Vickers
microhardness of
AA7068/SiC composites
Microhardness and Microstructural Behavior … 105
The effect of sliding distance on the wear rate is presented in Fig. 4a. As the SiC
content increases from 0 to 9%, the wear rate decreases for all the composites. As the
sliding distance increases, wear rate increases for both base alloy and composites.
According to Archard’s equation, as hardness increases the wear rate decreases. The
increase in wear resistance is due to an increase in the thermal stability of the base
alloy because of the addition of SiC particles [10]. Composites reinforced with 9%
SiC demonstrate superior wear resistance than other composites. The composites
reinforced with SiC exhibit improved wear resistance compared to that of the base
alloy and also increase with the increase in the SiC content. The wear rate increases
with increasing sliding distance, while as the SiC weight fraction increases, wear
rate decreases.
The effect of sliding distance on the volume loss is presented in Fig. 4b. As the
sliding distance increases, the volume loss also increases for both base alloy and
composites. The volume loss decreases as the SiC content increases from 0 to 9%.
Increase in the SiC content weight percentage improves the hardness which improves
the wear resistance of the composites [18]. Composites reinforced with 9% SiC show
reduced volume loss than other composite combinations. The volume loss of the base
alloy is higher compared to other reinforced composites. The hardness of SiC is more
compared to the base alloy which naturally increases the wear resistance of all the
composites. Hard SiC reinforcement particles provide protection, strength to the
base alloy and also improve the thermal stability and load-bearing capacity to the
composites [19].
Fig. 4 a Wear rate versus sliding distance and b volume loss versus sliding distance of AA7068/SiC
composites
106 K. John Joshua et al.
Fig. 5 FESEM analysis of a AA7068, b AA7068-3% SiC, c AA7068-6% SiC and d AA7068-9%
SiC composites
Microhardness and Microstructural Behavior … 107
the delamination process which improves the wear resistance of the composites.
The incorporation of hard SiC content improves the strength and reduces the plastic
deformation of the composites. During deformation, SiC particles initiate microc-
racks and develop a strong interfacial bonding between the reinforcement and the
base alloy. By high-stress concentration, the local strain and dislocation density reach
the critical values, as the SiC particles nucleate microcracks [6, 8]. It is also observed
that less cracks and scratches compared to the base alloy. Addition of SiC particles
protects the base alloy and hence improves wear resistance, hardness and prevents
severe wear [11, 13]. Reduced grain size, improved hardness and uniform dispersion
of SiC particles exhibit improved wear properties. Abrasion wear is predominant at
lower loads. Addition of SiC particles reduces the grain size which reduces plas-
tic deformation and improves the wear resistance [15]. Spherical shaped pores are
evident from the worn surfaces. Pores present are likely to occur in powder metal-
lurgy compared to the liquid melting route which may be due to reduced compaction
pressure applied or different sintering parameters [20].
Figure 5d demonstrates the FESEM micrograph of AA7068-9% SiC composite.
Mild abrasion and oxidation are the predominant wear modes found in the composite.
Few narrow, shallow microgrooves are noticed paralleling to the sliding direction.
The depth and width of the grooves present are very less and the surface is finer
and smoother compared to other composite combinations. This can be attributed to
the microploughing tendency, which is less in the composite. During the eventual
process, first the crack initiation layer is removed and then hard SiC particles are
involved in further wear reduction process [21]. Delamination is eliminated in the
composites reinforced with SiC due to the incorporation of hard SiC particles which
has a strong interfacial bond between the SiC and base alloy particles [10]. It is
evident from the micrograph that the oxide layer is present in all the samples. The
oxide layer serves as a protection layer, thereby minimizing the wear loss by reducing
the contact area between the sliding surfaces [22].
4 Conclusions
• AA7068/SiC metal matrix composites have been produced successfully using the
powder metallurgy route.
• The microhardness has been increased as SiC content increased. AA7068-9% SiC
composite exhibited a maximum hardness of 55 VHN which was 66.7% more than
the base alloy.
• The wear resistance has been improved by increasing the SiC content. Addi-
tion of 9% SiC exhibited superior wear resistance compared to other composite
combinations.
• The FESEM analysis disclosed that abrasion and oxidation were the predominant
wear modes found in the produced AA7068/SiC composites.
108 K. John Joshua et al.
Acknowledgements The authors thank Mr. J. DevaManoharan, Centre for Research in Metallurgy
Laboratory of Karunya Institute of Technology and Sciences, for his assistance to carry out the
experimental work.
References
1. Shyam Kumar CN, Ranjit B, Devinder Y (2016) Wear properties of 5083Al–W surface
composite fabricated by friction stir processing. Tribol Int 101:284–290
2. Ridvan G, HakanAtapek S, Ahmet K (2017) Influence of preform preheating on dry sliding
wear behavior of 304 stainless steel reinforced A356 aluminum matrix composite produced by
melt infiltration casting. Tribol Int 115:608–618
3. Hayrettin A, Tolga K, Ercan C, Huseyin C (2006) Wear behaviour of Al/(Al2 O3 pCSiCp) hybrid
composites, Tribol Int 39:213–220
4. Ramesh CS, Keshavamurthy R, Channabasappa BH, Pramod S (2010) Friction and wear
behavior of Ni–P coated Si3 N4 reinforced Al6061 composites. Tribol Int 43:623–634
5. Amin A, Ali S, Omid N, Hamid F, Saeid S (2015) Optimizing consolidation behavior of Al
7068 − TiC nanocomposites using Taguchi statistical analysis. Trans Nonferrous Met Soc
China 25:2499–2508
6. Umanath K, Palanikumar K, Selvamani ST (2013) Analysis of dry sliding wear behaviour of
Al6061/SiC/Al2 O3 hybrid metal matrix composites. Compos. Part B 53:159–168
7. Taherzadeh MR, Azari RK, Yazdani S, Brabazon D, Boostani AF (2016) Fabrication of alu-
minum matrix composites reinforced with nano- to micrometer-sized SiC particles. Mat Des
89:58–70
8. Min S, Yue-hui H (2010) Effects of die-pressing pressure and extrusion on the microstructures
and mechanical properties of SiC reinforced pure aluminum composites. Mat Des 31:985–989
9. Uthayakumar MS, Aravindan S, Rajkumar K (2013) Wear performance of Al–SiC–B4 C hybrid
composites under dry sliding conditions. Mater Des 47:456–464
10. Mohammad MG, Farshad A (2016) Wear behaviour of al 5252 alloy reinforced with
micrometric and nanometricSiC particles. Tribol Int 102:28–37
11. Ali M, Mohsen Ostad S (2013) Microstructural and abrasive wear properties of SiC rein-
forced aluminum-based composite produced by compocasting. Trans Nonferrous Met Soc
China 23:1905–1914
12. Ali M, Mohsen Ostad S (2012) Characterization of cast A356 alloy reinforced with nanoSiC
composites. Trans Nonferrous Met Soc China 22:275–280
Microhardness and Microstructural Behavior … 109
Abstract Aluminium hybrid composites due to its tailored properties are being
used in many industrial applications. Machining of metal matrix hybrid composites
with desired quality through conventional methods is a great challenge. As advance-
ment, non-conventional cutting method such as laser cutting is effectively employed
to cut hybrid composites. The present work investigates the cutting quality char-
acteristics of AA6061/B4 C/hBN hybrid composites using pulsed CO2 laser cutting
method. Optimization of machining parameters plays a vital role in improving the
quality characteristics. The parameters involved in this non-contact-type cutting pro-
cess such as laser power (2000–2200 W), gas pressure (12–14 bar), speed of spot
movement (600−1000 mm/s), pulsing frequency (60–100 Hz) and reinforcement
(5–15 Vol.%) were varied according to Taguchi L27 orthogonal array, and the quality
characteristics such as surface roughness, kerf width and edge slope were noted.
Response surface methodology (RSM) was applied to generate quadratic models
and 3D surface plots. Desirability analysis was carried out to obtain the optimal con-
ditions. The optimal parameters obtained are: laser power—2000W, gas pressure—
12.05 bar, speed of spot movement—998.07 mm/s, pulsing frequency—60 Hz and
reinforcement—6.81 Vol.%.
1 Introduction
The needs of structural materials with high specific strength and stiffness have catal-
ysed the emergence of metal matrix composite (MMC). MMCs are intrinsically
smart, high performing and lightweight materials that are being utilized for various
automobile, aircraft and industrial applications [1]. To act as a solution over alu-
minium alloys, the attention shifts to aluminium metal matrix composites (AMMCs)
because of the beneficial properties like lightweight, good castability and machinabil-
ity, durability, good mechanical properties, etc. [2]. Further, properties of AMMCs
can be enhanced by the addition of ceramic (SiC, B4 C, Al2 O3, etc.) and solid lubricant
(CNT, graphite, hBN, etc.) reinforcements [3]. Nowadays, boron carbide (B4 C) is
used as ceramic reinforcement because of its superior properties like high strength,
low density, high hardness and good chemical stability. Hexagonal boron nitride
(hBN) solid lubricant improves the friction and wear resistance of the composite
material, and moreover, it reduces the cutting zone temperature [4–7].
Laser cutting is a technology that uses a laser to cut materials and is typically
used for industrial manufacturing applications. Laser beam machining (LBM) is a
non-traditional subtractive manufacturing machining process, in which a laser is
directed towards the work piece for machining. Chinmaya R. et al. investigated the
experimental evaluation of laser-assisted machining of silicon carbide reinforced
aluminium matrix composites. It is found that laser-assisted machining minimizes
the specific cutting energy, roughness, tool wear and surface damage as compared
to traditional machining process [8]. Adalarasan et al. confirmed the possibility of
obtaining good quality characteristics such as surface roughness, material removal
rate and kerf width using pulsed CO2 laser cutting of Al6061/Al2 O3 composites
[9]. Response surface methodology (RSM) is an easy way to calculate a first-degree
polynomial model, and it uses a fractional factorial design. Adalarasan et al. eluci-
dated that the application of Taguchi-RSM was to optimize the drilling parameters
for Al6061/SiC/Al2 O3 hybrid composite and the experimental trials were designed
using Taguchi’s L18 OA [10].
The literature survey reveals that a less number of research works has been reported
particularly for the optimization of CO2 laser machining parameters on aluminium
metal matrix hybrid composites. Therefore, the main objective of this research work
is to optimize the effects of CO2 laser cutting parameters over surface roughness, kerf
width and edge slope on AA6061-B4 C-hBN hybrid composites using Taguchi-RSM.
AA6061 was chosen as the matrix material as it is the most commonly used
precipitation-hardened aluminium alloy for the development of aluminium compos-
ites due to its favourable properties like good mechanical properties and wettability.
B4 C is a hard ceramic commonly used as particulate reinforcements in aluminium
to improve the wear resistance and strength. Hexagonal boron nitride (hBN) is well
known for its excellent lubricating properties, chemical inertness, high-temperature
stability, etc. hBN in composites improve the machinability by acting as a self-
lubricant and reducing the cutting zone temperature due to its good thermal con-
ductivity. In this experiment, B4 C and hBN particles of size 20 µm and 5 µm,
Optimization of CO2 Laser Cutting Parameters for AA6061/B4 C/hBN … 113
The aluminium metal matrix hybrid composites were successfully fabricated using
stir casting process. The CO2 laser cutting was performed on the composites as per
L27 orthogonal array, and the corresponding responses such as surface roughness
(Ra), kerf width (mm), edge slope (°) are shown in Table 2.
The cutting parameters and their responses were analysed using Design–Expert
software. Polynomial equations of the second order were formed statistically with
the laser cutting parameters and quality characteristics joined with RSM. The math-
ematical model is created with the help of back selection technique and elimination
of higher order to maintain the model hierarchy. This model explains the individ-
ual and interaction of cutting parameters on surface roughness, kerf width and edge
slope. The analysis on the influence of input parameters on responses was carried
out by ANOVA, predicted versus actual graph, response surface plot and quadratic
equation.
The ANOVA for the surface roughness is shown in Table 3. SS denotes Sum of
114 A. Gnanavelbabu et al.
Squares, “D” denotes the Degree of Freedom, M.S. denotes Mean Square and “S”
denotes Significant.
The modelF-value of 269.53 implies the model is significant. Values of “Prob
>F” less than 0.0001 indicates that model terms are significantly contributed. In this
case, A—Laser power, E—Vol.% of reinforcement, AE, E2 are the significant model
terms.
The closeness of the fit determines the actual and predicted values into the sub-
jected desired level. From Fig. 1, it is evident that the actual and predicted values are
Optimization of CO2 Laser Cutting Parameters for AA6061/B4 C/hBN … 115
on the same line without any appreciable spreading. It ensures the closeness of the
fit as well as the validity of the fitted model.
Figure 2 illustrates the 3D response surface plot for surface roughness. X-axis
represents laser power, Y-axis represents Vol.% of reinforcement and Z-axis rep-
resents surface roughness. Increase in reinforcement percentage and laser power
increases the surface roughness of the composite. The best surface roughness 4.0197
is achieved with the combination of the lowest laser power and the lowest reinforce-
ment. Even though the minimal interaction was found between the reinforcement and
laser power, laser power emerged to be a dominant parameter in affecting the surface
roughness by means of its linear as well as interaction conditions. The regression
equation for the surface roughness is given in Eq. 1.
The modelF-value of 3.16 implies the model is significant. Values of “Prob >F”
less than 0.0263 indicates that model terms are significantly contributed. In this case,
B, AE are the significant model terms.
Figure 3 represents the predicted and actual values for kerf width. Higher R2 value
indicates the closeness of all the points to the regression line. The obtained R2 value
78.6 indicates a good fitness for kerf width, and the model is validated.
Figure 4 represents the response surface plot for kerf width. Laser power, rein-
forcement percentage and kerf width are on X, Y, Z axes, respectively. Minimum kerf
width 0.200121 was achieved at minimum laser power and nominal reinforcement
%. Increase in reinforcement percentage and laser power increases the kerf width of
the composite. Equation 2 is the corresponding quadratic equation for kerf width.
The modelF-value of 3.17 implies the model is significant. Values of “Prob >F”
less than 0.0260 indicates that model terms are significantly contributed. In this case,
B, AE, E 2 are significant model terms.
Figure 5 shows the relationship between actual and predicted values of edge slope.
R2 value for edge slope is 78.87. It indicates the closeness of points to the regression
line, and the model is validated.
Figure 6 represents the response surface plot for edge slope. Laser power, rein-
forcement percentage and edge slope are on X, Y, Z axes, respectively. Minimum
edge slope 1.9107 achieved at minimum laser power and nominal reinforcement %.
Increase in reinforcement percentage and laser power increased the edge slope of the
composites. Equation 3 is the quadratic equation for edge slope.
Design of expert software was employed to perform the desirability analysis. The
obtained values for parameters and responses are shown in Fig. 7. The desirability
Optimization of CO2 Laser Cutting Parameters for AA6061/B4 C/hBN … 121
Fig.7 Desirability graph for surface roughness, kerf width and edge slope
4 Conclusions
CO2 laser cutting on AA6061/B4 C/hBN hybrid composites was successfully done
as per the structured L27 orthogonal array. Optimization of process parameters was
carried out by applying RSM, and the following conclusions were drawn.
1. Minimum surface roughness of 4.0197 Ra was obtained by maintaining the laser
power at 2000 W, pressure 12.03 bar, speed 1000 mm/s, frequency 60.01 Hz and
reinforcement 6.65 Vol.%.
2. Minimum kerf width 0.200121 mm was obtained at laser power 2000 W, pressure
12 bar, speed 999.04 mm/s, frequency 60.16 Hz and reinforcement 6.68 Vol.%.
3. At laser power 2000 W, pressure 12 bar, speed 999.04 mm/s, frequency 60.16 Hz
and reinforcement 6.68 Vol.%, a minimum edge slope 1.9107° was achieved.
4. From the desirability analysis of the parameters, a desirability value of 0.990 was
obtained. It showed that the optimal condition for pulsed CO2 laser cutting on
AA6061/B4 C/hBN composite was laser power = 2000 W, pressure = 12.05 bar,
speed of spot movement = 998.07 mm/s and pulsing frequency = 60 Hz and
Vol.% of % reinforcement = 6.81.
Acknowledgement The financial support for consumables in this research work was provided by
“DST PURSE Phase II”.
122 A. Gnanavelbabu et al.
References
1. Bains PS, Sidhu SS, Payal HS (2016) Fabrication and machining of metal matrix composites.
Mater Manufact Proc 31:573
2. Jojith R, Radhika N (2018) Mechanical and tribological properties of LM13/TiO2 /MoS2 hybrid
metal matrix composite synthesized by stir casting. Part Sci Technol 1–13
3. Hung NP, Zhong ZW Zhong CH (1997) Grinding of metal matrix composites reinforced with
silicon-carbide particles. Mater Manufact Proc 12:1075–1091
4. Yao YT, Chen LQ (2016) B4 C/Al Composites Processed by Metal assisted Pressure less
Infiltration Technique and its Characterization. Mater Manufact Proc 31:1286–1291
5. Santhosh S, Rajkumar K, Gnanavelbabu A (2015) Effect of hBN solid lubricant concentration
on machinability of titanium (Ti-6Al-4V) alloy. Mater Sci Forum 830:87–90
6. Gnanavelbabu A, Rajkumar K, Saravanan P (2018) Investigation on the cutting quality charac-
teristics of abrasive water jet machining of AA6061-B4C-hBN hybrid MMC. Mater Manufact
Process 1313–1323
7. Muthazhagan C, Gnanavelbabu A, Bhaskar GB, Rajkumar K (2014) Influence of graphite
reinforcement on mechanical properties of Al-boron carbide composites. Adv Mater Res
845:398–402
8. Dandekar CR, Shin YC (2012) Experimental evaluation of laser-assisted machining of sil-
iconcarbide particle-reinforced aluminium matrix composites. Int J Adv Manufact Technol
66:1603–1610
9. Adalarasan R, Santhanakumar M, Thileepan S (2016) Selection of optimal machining param-
eters in pulsed CO2 lasercutting of Al6061/Al2 O3 composite using Taguchi-based response
surface methodology (T-RSM). Int J Adv Manufact 93:305–317
10. Adalarasan R, Santhanakumar M (2015) Application of taguchi based response surface method
(TRSM) for optimization of multi responses in drilling Al/SiC/Al2 O3 hybrid composites. J Inst
Eng (India) 96:65–71
Analysis of Corrosion Resistance
in Domestic Water Geysers by Coating
Nano-Film Using Thermal Spray Coating
Abstract The lifespan of domestic water geysers drastically reduces over a period of
time of usage due to environmental challenges such as corrosion and scale develop-
ment. The objective to be achieved here is to increase the property of corrosion resis-
tance of internal components of the geyser and overcoming the challenges posed by
such. A steel plate is to be coated with a nano-film of specified thickness using thermal
spray coating consisting of nano-alumina, nano-zinc oxide and nano-molybdenum.
These elements were chosen for their high corrosion resistance and formation of a
superior alloy coating. The coating elements are mixed in three different ratio com-
binations, and each is coated on three stainless steel sample plates. These sample
plates are tested for corrosion and scale development by performing a salt spray test
for a period of time till visual examination shows the development of corrosion. A
comparison of the results of the three samples is analysed with industry standards
to determine the suitable alternative for geyser coatings. The results have convinc-
ingly proved that there is an increase in the life expectancy of the geyser which can
significantly reduce maintenance expenditure.
1 Introduction
12–18 months. Many geysers undergo corrosion at a rate with respect to the hard-
ness of the water and frequency of usage. The high temperature and hardness of
water combined create a favourable environment for the degradation of the tank at
a gradual pace. McAdam et al. [1] performed experiments to determine the rate of
calcium carbonate formation and how its growth can be controlled. Shi et al. [2] did
a study on the impact of nano-aluminium articles in corrosion resistance coatings.
This experiment provided strong backing for the selection of nano-alumina to be
included in the coating. Kourtidou et al. [3] performed experiments on Ni-Al coat-
ings in high temperature and marine environments. This project aims at developing
a better alternative using nano-technology by providing a nano-film coating of com-
mercially available materials that possess high corrosion resistance properties [4].
A study was conducted to analyze the types of geysers available in the commercial
market before coming to a conclusion on material selection [5].The materials that
fit this category were alumina, zinc and molybdenum. These materials were mixed
in three different ratios to determine the most suitable and effective coating mixture
[6–8] that can withstand the corrosion attacks [9, 10] inside the geyser. Salt spray
test would then be performed to determine the most suitable coating.
2 Methodology
The nano-materials selected for the coating are alumina, zinc and molybdenum. The
three elements were mixed in three different specified ratios. The nano-materials
were in powder form and mixed using a ball grinding machine. After ensuring the
thorough mixing of the materials, each sample ratio was coated onto a stainless steel
plate of dimension 75 mm × 75 mm × 1 mm. The plates had to be pre-treated before
applying the coating. The coating method used here is the plasma thermal spray
coating where the materials were coated onto the plate by blowing at a temperature
of 4000 °C. The plate is then cooled to allow the material to be coated well onto the
plate. The three stainless steel plates coated with different ratios of nano-coating are
tested using a salt spray test for a period of 96 h to determine the impact of corrosion
resistance. Visual examination is performed to determine the impact of corrosion
on the three sample plates, and the results are compared to determine the effect of
corrosion (Fig. 1).
3 Experimental Details
Alumina and zinc are commercially feasible and widely used elements. Both elements
possess high corrosion resistance properties. Molybdenum is a rare earth element that
is also used in the steel industry for its ability to impart high corrosion resistance
properties to the alloy it is alloyed to. Hence, they are the reason for the selection of
these nano-materials. The three nano-materials consist of a particle size of 80 nm. The
three nano-materials are mixed in three different ratios. Three test samples are used
here, and the best ratio of material coating is selected from the three. The materials
are weighed as per the ratio required and put into the ball grinding machine. The ball
grinding machine is used to mix the elements thoroughly so as to prevent any large
concentrations of same elements when coated onto the stainless steel plate.
Reference Sample 1
Reference sample 1 is one of the two benchmark samples that are considered among
the industry best standards. The salt spray test results of this reference sample will be
compared with the salt spray test results of test samples. Figure 2 shows an image of
the plate sample used. Stainless steel’s resistance to corrosion and staining make it
an ideal material for many applications where corrosion resistance is required. This
reference sample will be tested by salt spray testing for the duration of 96 h. The
stainless steel plate used is of the grade SAE 304 with a dimension of 75 mm in
length, 75 mm in width and 1 mm thickness.
Reference Sample 2
Reference sample 2 is one of the two benchmark samples that are considered best
according to industry standards whose salt spray test results will be compared with
those of the test samples. The mild steel grade used for this sample is of Indian
Standard 2062 and its dimensions are 75 mm in length, 75 mm in width and a
thickness of 2 mm. The enamel coating is done on top of the steel plate’s surface. It
is a mild steel plate consisting of a coating of enamel coating with a coating thickness
of 125 µm. Figure 3 shows an image of the plate after coating.
The nano-materials after mixing are coated onto the stainless steel plate using thermal
spray coating for a thickness of 125 µm. Initially, the surface of the stainless steel
plate undergoes pre-treatment before coating can be done. The surface is wiped
clean to remove off any dust or foreign particles. The surface undergoes bit blasting
where it is sprayed with aluminium oxide. The surface is then treated with a nickel
chromium bond coating to ensure proper adhesion of the nano-material coating. A
spray gun is used to eject the nano-mixture onto the plate at a speed of 80–90 m/s
with argon gas to prevent external reaction with foreign elements. The amount of
material coated per minute is 30 gm/min and the spray gun is at a distance of 127 mm
from the surface of the stainless steel plate. The details of the three test samples are
described in detail along with an SEM image.
Test Sample 1
Test sample 1 contains nano-alumina, nano-zinc oxide and nano-molybdenum that
are mixed together with the help of ball grinding, and the mixture ratio is as shown in
Table 1. After that process, they are fed to the thermal spray coating machine where
Analysis of Corrosion Resistance in Domestic Water Geysers … 127
they will be coated onto the stainless steel plate. The stainless steel plate used here
is of the grade SAE 304, and its dimensions are 75 mm in length, 75 mm in width
and 1 mm in thickness. The stainless steel undergoes pre-treatment of its surface for
better adhesion of coating of the nano-material mixture. The nano-material mixture
is coated on top of the stainless steel plate with a coating thickness of 125 µm (Fig. 4;
Table 2).
Test Sample 2
Test sample 2 contains nano-alumina, nano-zinc oxide and nano-molybdenum that
are mixed together with the help of ball grinding, and the ratio is as shown in Table 3.
After that process, they are fed to the thermal spray coating machine where they will
be coated onto the stainless steel plate. The stainless steel plate used here is of the
grade SAE 304, and its dimensions are 75 mm in length, 75 mm in width and 1 mm
in thickness. The nano-material mixture is coated on top of the stainless steel plate
with a coating thickness of 125 µm (Fig. 5; Table 4).
Test Sample 3
The three elements are mixed together with the help of ball grinding, and in the
mixture, the ratio is as shown in Table 5. After that, they are fed to the thermal spray
coating machine where they will be coated onto the stainless steel plate. The stainless
steel plate used here is of the grade SAE 304, and its dimensions are 75 mm in length,
The salt spray test is a standardized corrosion test method used to test for corrosion
resistance of materials and surface coatings. It is an accelerated corrosion test that
produces a corrosive attack to coated samples in order to evaluate the suitability of
the coating for use as a protective finish. The apparatus consists of a closed testing
chamber where a saltwater (5% NaCl) solution is atomized by means of spray nozzles
using pressurized air. This produces a corrosive environment of dense saltwater fog
in the chamber so that the test samples are subjected to severely corrosive conditions.
The chamber temperature is maintained at 70.5–71.5 °C with a pH value of 6.65–
6.85. The components are loaded into the chamber at an angle of 30° with air pressure
at 14–18 psi.
Test sample 1 image shows it turned the colour of the mixture into a dark silver.
Thus, the appearance of the coating on the test plate is dark in colour compared
to the other three samples. After 96 h of salt spray testing, test sample showed the
endurance and good resistance to corrosion attack from the salt spray. This can be
due to the possibility of an additional percentage of molybdenum and zinc oxide,
both having high corrosion resistant properties. Visual examinations do show slight
traces of corrosion which could have occurred due to the mixture not containing
optimum ratio (Table 9).
The darkness in the colour of the coating has reduced to a minor extent which can
be justified by the reduction in the percentage of molybdenum added in this mixture.
After 96 h of salt spray testing, the test sample showed good endurance and very
good resistance to corrosion attack from the salt spray. The percentage of alumina
in this sample has been increased by 15% with a reduction of 10% in zinc oxide and
132 K. Sankar et al.
The darkness in colour is the least in test sample 3 among the three test samples. This
can be justified by the very low presence of molybdenum, and a higher percentage
of alumina which is white in colour. Visual examinations showed that the sample
underwent quite extensive corrosion damage but not as severe as the reference test
samples. This can be justified by the increased percentage of alumina and very
few percentages of zinc with traces of molybdenum. Alumina’s corrosion resistance
Analysis of Corrosion Resistance in Domestic Water Geysers … 133
properties are lesser compared to that of zinc and molybdenum and are the reason
why the corrosion damage is greater among the three samples (Table 11).
5 Conclusion
The three test samples and two reference samples were tested by salt spray testing for
a period of 96 h. The salt spray test provided the simulation of a geyser except that the
saltwater is constantly being sprayed without any intervals. This test provided us with
an insight on how the five samples would survive in what is considered an extreme
environment. Test sample 2 proved to be the optimum combination of nano-materials
that can withstand the extreme environment of the geyser without falling victim to
corrosion. Test results showed that it was expected to last well beyond the 96 h of
testing after performing a visual examination of its surface. Test sample 1 ranked
second in its ability to withstand corrosion. This could be due to the almost correct
ratio of elements but apparently not the optimal ratio to withstand for long. Test
sample 3 ranked third due to a large percentage of alumina and reduced percentages
of zinc oxide and molybdenum. Both the reference samples did not last longer than
48 h. Reference sample 2 ranked fourth lasting for 48 h before giving way to attacks
of corrosion. Reference sample 1 ranked fifth and the last among the five samples
not lasting longer than 24 h providing evidence of why many commercially available
geysers in India have a reduced life expectancy and undergo frequent maintenance
activities. Therefore, it can be concluded that test sample 2 consists of the optimum
ratio of nano-materials to resist attacks of corrosion faced in a domestic water geyser.
This is supported by evidence from the salt spray test.
134 K. Sankar et al.
References
1. McAdam J, Parsons SA (2004) Calcium carbonate scale formation and control. Publ Views
Env Sci Technol 3(2)
2. Shi X, Nguyen TA, Suo Z, Liu Y, Avci R (2009) Influence of Nano-Al concentrates on the
corrosion resistance of epoxy coatings. Elsevier-Surface Coat Technol 204(3):237–245
3. Kourtidou D, Chaliampalias D, Tarani E, Pavlidou E (2019) Deposition of Ni-Al coatings
by pack cementation and corrosion resistance in high temperature and marine environments.
Elsevier Corrosion Sci 148:12–23
4. Gal J-Y, Bollinger J-C, Tolosa H, Gache N (1996) Calcium: a reappraisal of scale formation
and inhibition. Published in Talanta 43(9):1497–1509
5. Venus Home Appliances webpage (2019) https://www.venushomeappliances.com/tank-
comparision.html. Last accessed 12 May 2019
6. Khodair ZT, Khadom AA, Jasim HA (20185) Corrosion protection of mild steel in different
aqueous media via epoxy/nanomaterial coating: preparation, characterization and mathematical
views. J Mater Res Technol
7. Liang Y, Liu F-C, Nie M, Zhao S, Lin J, Han E-H (2013) Influence of Nano-Al concentrates
on the corrosion resistance of epoxy coatings. J Mater Sci Technol 29(4):353–358
8. Koutsomichalis A, Vaxevanidis NM, Psyllaki P (2016) Wear and corrosion behaviour of zinc-
alumina electrodeposited coatings on mild steel. Tribological J Bultrib 6(06)
9. Kadhim MJ, Sukkar KA, Abbas AS, Obaeed NH (2017) Investigation of nano coating for
corrosion protection of petroleum pipeline steel type A106 grade B: theoretical and practical
study in Iraqi Petroleum Sector. Eng Technol J 35(Part A, No. 10)
10. Bhakre VS, Nayak DK (2007) Nanotechnology in corrosion prevention. Published at inter-
national conference CORCON 2007 held at Mumbai focusing on cost of corrosion to the
nation
Effect of Multi-walled Carbon Nanotubes
Additions on Its Dispersion
Characteristics in Titanium Oxides
Abstract The transition metal oxides are inorganic nanomaterials with exclusive
properties. However, metal oxides cannot exceptionally accomplish all requirements
to develop new technologies as they are brittle and have low fracture toughness,
which has motivated researchers to adopt novel techniques in enhancing their prop-
erties. Carbon nanotubes (CNTs) have drawn attention in engineering fields due
to their unique structural, electrical and mechanical properties. This work aims to
achieve a homogeneous dispersion of multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs)
by investigating the effect of increased MWCNTs concentration in titanium oxide.
The MWCNTs (0.5, 1, 1.5 wt.%) were dispersed in titanium oxide using high energy
ball milling (HEBM) technique at a lower milling speed of 100 rpm for 6 h. The
composite powders were characterized using scanning electron microscopy (SEM),
transmission electron microscopy (TEM), Raman spectroscopy and X-ray diffraction
(XRD) to understand the uniformity of dispersion, interfacial reaction and structural
integrity of the MWCNTs after dispersion. The results showed that the MWCNTs
detangles at a lower concentration of 0.5 wt%, with an increase in MWCNTs there
is the formation of entanglement. In addition, further analysis on structural integrity
showed minimal structure damage due to lower speed adopted for HEBM technique,
and there were no interfacial reactions favoured.
1 Introduction
The utilization of CNTs for diverse structural and engineering applications have
spurred more research attention in the recent time. This is due to their attractive,
outstanding and superlative properties [1–4]; high Young’s modulus in the tera-pascal
(TPa) range and excellent strength about 100 GPa to synthesize less dense materials
for diverse applications. Additionally, the exclusive properties of CNTs are ascribed
to their unique morphology and the existence of strong sp2 carbon–carbon (C–C)
bonds in their outermost shells. These sp2 C–C bonds form a fastened honeycomb
lattice and high bond strength in the structure of the material [4].
The development of durable, inert and insoluble composites has been of interest in
scientific research communities. This composite materials demand have encouraged
the integration of CNTs into titanium-based materials to enhance their properties for
composites production. However, during the processing of these composites, CNTs
tend to agglomerate into clusters and this is due to their nanostructural dimension,
high aspect ratio and the strong van der Waal forces that exist between their individual
tubes [5–7]. In many cases, the increase in the content of MWCNTs as reinforcements
improves the properties of the matrix material but poses the tendency of agglomera-
tion and deteriorates the dispersion characteristics of the MWCNTs within the matrix
materials [7, 8] which is ascribed to the corresponding of increase in the strong van
der Waal forces among individual nanotubes.
In a bid to improve the properties of the titanium oxides and achieve uniform
dispersion of MWCNTs in the metal oxides, optimized dispersion techniques are
highly desirable to overcome the strong van der Waal forces and achieved optimal
dispersion characteristics of the MWCNTs in titanium oxides [7]. In this study, high
energy ball milling (HEBM) method with regulated milling parameters was adopted
[9] to 1.0 and 1.5 wt.% of MWCNTs in titanium oxide, and various characterization
techniques were used to investigate the effect of an increase in MWCNTs on its
dispersion.
The starting powder materials used for this study were MWCNTs (NX7100-A-Ultra
purified CNT) with an average diameter of 9.5 nm and an average length of 1.5 μm,
supplied by Nanocyl, Belgium. Titanium (IV) oxide anatase powder with percentage
purity (99.6%) and −325 mesh particle size was supplied by industrial analytical in
Johannesburg, South Africa.
Effect of Multi-walled Carbon Nanotubes Additions … 137
High energy ball mill (Retch 400, Germany) was used to 1 and 1.5 wt.% MWCNTs
into titanium oxide and this was conducted by charging the titanium oxide powder in
an alumina vial (250 ml, inner diameter (ID) = 100 mm) with alumina balls of 5 mm
diameter. The milling was carried out using a ball to powder ratio (BPR) was 10:1 at
100 rpm milling time and speed of 6 h and 100 rpm, respectively. A relaxation time
of 10 min was observed during the milling operation to prevent the samples from
overheating. The admixed powders were collected and characterized after milling.
Scanning electron microscopy (FESEM, Carl Zeiss Sigma) equipped with energy-
dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) and transmission electron microscopy (JEOL-
Jem 2100) were used for morphological characterization of the starting and admixed
powders. X-ray diffractometer (XRD, Rigaku D/max-rB) was used for phase identi-
fication using Cu-Kα(λ = 0.154 nm) radiation at a scanning rate of 1°/min over the
angular range of 20–90°. Raman spectroscopy was used to ascertain the structural
integrity of the MWCNTs before and after milling
Fig. 1 SEM images of the as-received powders (a) Titanium oxide, (b) MWCNTs, (c) TEM image
of as-received MWCNTs and (d) HRTEM image showing the walls of MWCNTs
ratio and the strong van der Waal forces that exist between individual MWCNTs [7]
This features of MWCNTs deteriorate the dispersion characteristics in the TiO2 .
The strategies that usually adopted in achieving the detangling of MWCNTs
during the powder processing are to further increase the milling parameter such as
milling time, speed and BPR which could results on defects on the graphitic structure
of the MWCNTs [11] which affect their properties to be attained on TiO2 powder.
Since, it is essential to efficiently transfer these unique properties to TiO2. This can
be achieved by homogeneous dispersion of MWCNTs with good interfacial bonding
without damaging the walls of the nanotubes. Hence, this study adopted the powder
processing using HEBM technique to disperse MWCNTs in TiO2 powder at lower
regulated milling parameters.
Figure 2(a)–(c) shows the SEM images of (0.5, 1.0, 1.5) wt% MWCNTs dispersed
into TiO2 . Figure 2(a) shows the SEM image where 0.5 wt% MWCNTs dispersed in
TiO2 , and it is observed that the MWCNTs are relatively detangled which could be
attributed by less effectiveness of van der Waal forces between individuals. However,
Effect of Multi-walled Carbon Nanotubes Additions … 139
Fig. 2 SEM images of dispersed MWCNTs in titanium oxide (a) 0.5 wt%, (b) 1.0 wt% and (c)
1.5 wt
Fig. 3 TEM images of dispersed MWCNTs in titanium oxide (a) 0.5 wt% (b) 1 wt% and (c)
1.5 wt% and HRTEM for tubular characteristics (d) 0.5 wt% (e) 1 wt% and (f) 1.5 wt%
and it is observed by wrapping of MWCNTs around that TiO2 particles which may
lead to transfer of unique properties of MWCNTs in TiO2 .
Moreover, HRTEM analysis shown in Fig. 3(d)–(f) for dispersion of MWCNTs
in TiO2 powder. Figure 3(d) displays a slightly evolution on the walls compared to
the pristine MWCNTs. However, when the concentration of MWCNTs dispersed in
TiO2 powder increases to 1.0 and 1.5 wt% in Fig. 3(e)–(f), there is obvious crystalline
structure observed and this confirms that MWCNTs were embedded within titanium
oxide and this could be possibility of good interfacial bonding that leads to the
transfer of the unique properties of MWCNTs to titanium oxide [12].
Raman spectroscopy analysis was used to evaluate the structural integrity of MWC-
NTs after dispersion in titanium oxide. This analysis was carried out specifically to
ascertain the D-band which is associated with defects in form of sp3 disorders in the
C–C bonds and the G-band which is related to the plane stretching mode of the C–C
bond to determine the degree of graphitization, orderliness of carbon, metallicity
and crystalline nature of the MWCNTs. Meanwhile, the ID /IG ratio is used to assess
the crystallinity and structural disorder of the MWCNTs during powder processing
[13, 14].
Effect of Multi-walled Carbon Nanotubes Additions … 141
Fig. 4 (a) Raman shift spectrum and (b) XRD patterns Raman shift of dispersed 0.5, 1 and 1.5 wt%
MWCNTs in titanium oxide
Figure 4a shows the Raman spectra of the pristine MWCNTs and the admixed
composite powders. The graphite peaks of the pristine MWCNTs are observed corre-
spondingly, D (1340 cm−1 ) and G (1570 cm−1 ) bands. This was followed by pristine
TiO2 powder which showed anatase structures at B1g (399 cm−1 ), A1g (518 cm−1 )
and Eg (641 cm−1 ), respectively [15]. The dispersion of MWCNTs (0.5, 1.0 and
1.5) wt% shifted the D- and G-band from the pristine of MWCNTs D (1340 cm−1 )
and G (1570 cm−1 ) to (D)1341.3 cm−1 and (G) 1575.6 cm−1 , (D)1345.2 cm−1 and
(G)1575.3 cm−1 and (D)1347.6 cm−1 and (G) 1577.7 cm−1, respectively. This could
have been attributed by the energy extended to the walls of MWCNTs during power
processing. However, there were no interfacial reactions products which are carbide
phases observed on the Raman spectra. Application of lower milling parameters
adopted for MWCNTs dispersion played a role in preserving the walls [16].
The ID /IG ratio of the pristine MWCNTs was calculated to be 0.800, after the dis-
persion of MWCNTs at (0.5, 1.0 and 1.5 wt%) in titanium oxide. There was increase
in ID /IG ratio form 0.800 to 0.914, 0.937 and 1.023, respectively. This characteristic
is an indication of radical shift that broadens the intensity peaks of the D-band and
G-band which is ascribed to higher stress on the walls of MWCNTs during milling.
The stress on the nanotubes may lead to the formation of weak sp3 C–C amorphous
phase from broken sp2 bonds due to harsh milling conditions which favours forma-
tion of carbides [9, 12]. Carbide phases are usually formed when there are severe
damages to the walls of the nanotubes during dispersion.
142 S. S. Lephuthing et al.
The destruction in the walls of the nanotubes usually occurs when high milling
speed, long milling time and extremely high ball to powder ratios are adopted during
milling operation which may further affect the unique properties of the nanotubes
that are transferrable to augment the properties of titanium oxides. From past studies,
HEBM technique is still adjudged as the most effective route for dispersing MWCNTs
in TiO2 [9, 11] especially when regulated milling parameters are adopted to minimize
the destruction to the walls of the MWCNTs during milling operation.
X-ray diffraction technique was conducted to analyse the different phases, struc-
tural changes and the evolution of the crystalline phases in the as-received and
admixed composite powders. The XRD results are shown in Fig. 4b where prominent
peaks are observed at 25.6 and 43.3 which corresponds to (002) and (100) planes of
the MWCNTs. While, in the admixed composite powders, the following planes were
identified (101), (004), (200), (105), (211), (204), (215) and (303) which ascertain the
anatase type of titanium oxide powder. In addition, the XRD results further revealed
that the MWCNT (002) plane was overlaps by the anatase-type titanium oxide (101)
plane in the MWCNTs/titanium oxide composite. Moreover, it was also observed
that with increase in MWCNT concentration, there was a decrease in peak intensity
on corresponding plane (101) of MWCNTs this may be ascribed to the interlock of
the MWCNTs in the titanium oxide.
4 Conclusion
It has been successfully demonstrated that MWCNTs can be dispersed using high
energy ball milling HEBM technique. Though, this dispersion technique has draw-
backs of destruction the MWCNTs wall due to harsh milling conditions during pow-
der processing which poses a challenge on losing their ability to improve TiO2 .
However, milling conditions were controlled to minimize the destruction as shown
in this study. Therefore, the following was drawn from this study.
• The SEM results showed that the lower concentration of 0.5 wt% MWCNTs was
relatively de-agglomeration of MWCNTs. However, when further increases in the
MWCNTs the prominent agglomerated MWCNTs were shown.
• The TEM results confirmed the SEM results, however, at HRTEM analysis. It
was observed that there was good bonding which showed by crystal structures
and this my attribute to good interfacial bonding the leads to transfer of the their
unique properties.
• The structural integrity of MWCNTs showed that indeed, there was good inter-
facial bonding achieved during powder processing. Though, the D- and G-band
were stretched which could defeat of MWCNTs and there was an increase in the
ID /IG ratio that affects the crystallinity. The destruction was minimal as there were
no interfacial reactions observed of the Raman spectra.
Effect of Multi-walled Carbon Nanotubes Additions … 143
References
1 Introduction
Mechanical properties have a correlation with other properties like corrosion, opti-
cal properties and surface morphology. Mechanical properties can be improved via
different manufacturing techniques such as composite, heat treatment and surface
modification [1–3]. RF magnetron sputtering is a useful tool technique for improv-
ing these properties by coating the surface with materials of superior qualities. A
detailed analysis of thin-film coating by these processes can be found in Reference
[4–7]. Although studies have been done on the applications of sputtering for sur-
face modification [8–10], further understanding of the contribution of each process
parameters of RF magnetron sputtering on the response properties still needs more
research study. Understanding the influence of RF power, sputtering and tempera-
ture on the mechanical properties is important for both industrial application and
research advancement. In this study, Taguchi was used to developing the experi-
mental matrix. The control factors considered are RF power, sputtering time and
temperature. An orthogonal three levels and three factors method (l9 33 ) were used.
The percentage contribution and influence of the independent process parameters’
factors on the hardness and Young’s modulus were analyzed using ANOVA analysis
and signal-to-noise ratio.
2 Experimental Method
TiC thin films were deposited in an RF magnetron sputtering coater which was
specifically designed for the deposition process. The substrate (CpTi) was ground
using silica carbide paper and then polished to remove any surface impurities. The
surface of the substrate was further cleaned in acetone and stored in a desiccator
to prevent contamination and surface oxidation. The purity of the TiC target used
is 99.99% pure TiC. The target–substrate distance was kept fixed throughout the
experiments. Evacuation of the sputtering chamber to a base pressure of 1.13 × 10−5
m bar was done for all the coating process before sputtering takes place. The reason
for the low pressure is to provide a long mean free path for a collision between the
target and substrate and allows for the control and minimization of contaminants.
After the evacuation, the system is refilled with argon to a partial pressure of 2.5 ×
10−3 m bar. Argon flow rate of 12 sccm was used, and constant working pressure
was maintained. Maintaining constant pressure helps to place many argon atoms in
the path of the ions and ejected coatings. After the plasma formation, the sputtering
of the target is triggered, and the shutter is removed. Pre-sputtering was done for
all the samples for 5 min before the main sputtering deposition. The substrate was
located directly above the target on a rotating disk to ensure uniform distribution and
condensation of the target on the surface of the substrate. The target material was
cleaned up after each cycle to prevent build up charge, thereby reducing the arcing
effect.
Evaluation of Process Parameters Influence on the Mechanical … 147
2.3 Nanoindentation
2.4 Microscratch
The peeling behavior of the coatings was evaluated using a linear displacement
microscratch tester (Anton Paar Micro Combo Tester, Austria). A Rockwell diamond
ball with a radius of 100 µm was used for the nanoscratch test to determine the film
adhesion toughness and failure mode. For each measurement, the applied load was
progressive from 50 mN to 2 N at a sliding speed of 2 mm/min and sliding length of
1 mm. All these experiments were carried out in an ambient atmospheric condition.
2.5 Wear
The tribological properties which represent the macroscratch of the thin-film coat-
ings were achieved on a Rtec Universal ball-on-disk tribometer at ambient condi-
tion. (temperature, pressure and humidity). An E521000 alloy steel grade 25 ball
(6.350 mm in diameter) was used as the counter body while the surface of the thin-
film coating serves as the disk. The movement of the motion is translational with
maximum sliding displacement of 1 mm. The sliding velocity was kept constant at
1 mm/s for 2 min at normal load of 10 N for all the experiments. The friction coef-
ficient was monitored throughout the experiment by a linear variable displacement
transducer and recorded on a data acquisition computer attached to the tribometer.
After completion of the wear, the wear tracks were examined on the microscope for
further analysis of the surface deformation and failure. All process parameters were
repeated three times and the average values were reported.
Evaluation of Process Parameters Influence on the Mechanical … 149
Young’s modulus and hardness of the thin-film coating were characterized using
an experimental approach and the optimization of measured response was analyzed
using signal-to-noise ratio. The signal-to-noise (S/N) ratio is a loss function used for
determining the deviation between the experimental values and desired. S/N ratio
is divided into three distinctive quality characteristics for analysis namely lower the
better, nominal the better and higher the better. The S/N ratio result of the hardness
and young modulus is shown in Table 3. The higher the better equation was used for
the S/N ratio of the hardness. Higher hardness value is a sign of improvement in the
surface quality and improves the resistance to wear and corrosion, thereby reducing
the loss of material due to contact with other surfaces and enhance the overall quality.
Evaluation of young modulus gives in-depth behavior of specific properties of the
coating such as flexibility, bond strength, fatigue life, wear, fracture toughness and
residual stress [16, 17]. Low Young’s modulus yields a more flexible coating behavior
and improves its thermal stress resistance [17]. Higher Young’s modulus results in
high wear rate and short fatigue life. For this reason, the lower the better equation
was used for the Young modulus S/N ratio. The average values of the hardness and
Young’s modulus were calculated after the sputtering deposition and were found
to be 4.54 GPa and 121.32 GPa, respectively. Similar calculation was done for the
S/N ratio of the hardness and Young’s modulus and found to be 12.404 dB and
Table 4 Response table for signal-to-noise ratios for hardness and Young’s modulus
Levels Control factors
Hardness (H) Young’s modulus (E)
A B C A B C
Level 1 14.380 12.675 10.873 −42.88 −42.11 −41.17
Level 2 7.742 11.471 12.314 −39.29 −40.93 −41.72
Level 3 15.090 13.066 14.025 −42.39 −41.51 −41.66
Delta 7.349 1.595 3.152 3.59 1.18 0.54
The bold values are the output response with optimal performance
−41.52bB, respectively. The response table for the signal-to-noise ratio and level
values of the input or control factor is illustrated in Table 4. The significant effect of
the input or control factors (RF power, sputtering time, temperature) on the coating
hardness and Young’s modulus obtained from Taguchi analysis was presented. The
optimal sputtering process parameter levels that yield high hardness and low Young’s
modulus values can be easily obtained from the table. The highest S/N ratio of the
control factor at different levels was utilized to determine the optimal setting. From
Table 4, the levels and S/N ratios for the factors yielding optimal hardness values
are factor A (level 3, S/N = 15.090), factor B (level 3, S/N = 13.060) and factor C
(level 3, S/N = 14.025). On the other hand, the levels and S/N ratios for the factors
yielding optimal young modulus values are factor A (level 2, S/N = −39.29), factor
B (level 2, S/N = −40.93) and factor C (level 1, S/N = −41.17), respectively. This
implies that an optimum value for hardness was obtained at RF power of 250 W,
sputtering time 3 h and temperature 1000 C which is graphically illustrated in Fig. 2.
The optimum value for the young modulus was obtained at RF power of 200 W,
sputtering time of 2.5 h and temperature of 800 C graphically presented in Fig. 3.
15
14
Mean of SN ratios
13
12
11
10
7
150 200 250 2.0 2.5 3.0 80 90 100
-40
Mean of SN ratios
-41
-42
-43
150 200 250 2.0 2.5 3.0 80 90 100
factor B and C contribute 9.5% and 1.9%, respectively, to the output response. The
percentage of errors for both ANOVA for hardness and Young’s modulus is 3.2%
and 4.2%, respectively.
4 Tribology
The coefficients of friction (COF) for the microscratch and wear are presented in
Table 6. The range for the friction coefficient of scratch is between 0.031 and 0.075,
while the coefficient of friction range for the wear test is between 0.447 and 0.496.
It is noticeable that there was a substantial improvement in the COF for both wear
and scratch with respect to the process parameters.
Figure 4 shows some selection of the wear scar for the microscratch result micro-
graph obtained. No obvious crack and delamination of the film were noticed around
the crack region. These micrographs revealed good bonding between the film and
the substrate.
5 Conclusion
From the Taguchi analysis of the results using signal-to-noise analysis and ANOVA,
it can be concluded that the RF power is the most effective control factor on both the
Table 6 Friction coefficient for wear and scratch tests
Experimental no L1 L2 L3 L4 L5 L6 L7 L8 L9
Coefficient of friction Scratch 0.031 0.040 0.048 0.071 0.048 0.075 0.036 0.047 0.069
Wear 0.447 0.462 0.484 0.471 0.465 0.496 0.469 0.480 0.462
Evaluation of Process Parameters Influence on the Mechanical …
153
154 O. O. Abegunde et al.
Fig. 4 Macrograph of some selected scratch surface for sample L1, L4 and L7
hardness and Young’s modulus. The coefficients of friction for both microscratch
and wear show considerable improvement, and the process parameters prove to be
major determinant factors in the response outcome.
Acknowledgements The authors will like to acknowledge the Council for Scientific and Industrial
Research (CSIR) for bursary awarded to the first Author.
References
1. Halling J (1986) The tribology of surface coatings, particularly ceramics. Proc Inst Mech Eng
Part C 200(1):31–40
2. Holmberg K, Mathews A (1994) Coatings tribology: a concept, critical aspects and future
directions. Thin Solid Films 253(1–2):173–178
3. Abegunde OO et al (2019) Overview of thin film deposition techniques. AIMS Mater Sci (-
2):174
4. Martin P (2010) Deposition technologies: an overview. In: Handbook of deposition technolo-
gies for films and coatings, 3rd Edn. Elsevier, Oxford
5. Martin PM (2009) Handbook of deposition technologies for films and coatings: science,
applications and technology, William Andrew
6. Wasa K, Hayakawa S (1992) Handbook of sputter deposition technology
7. Seshan K (2012) Handbook of thin film deposition. William Andrew
8. Alexeeva OK, Fateev VN (2016) Application of the magnetron sputtering for nanostructured
electrocatalysts synthesis. Int J Hydrogen Energy, 41(5):3373–3386, 2016
9. Pethe SA et al (2012) Effect of sputtering process parameters on film properties of molybdenum
back contact. Solar Energy Mater Solar Cells 100:1–5
10. Dibyendu R, Shampa A (2013) Effect of sputtering process parameters on the magnetron
sputtered Ni-Ti-Cu thin films. Int J Curr Res 5(01):075–079
11. Oliver WC, Pharr GM (1992) An improved technique for determining hardness and elastic
modulus using load and displacement sensing indentation experiments. J Mater Res 7(6):1564–
1583
12. Oliver WC, Pharr GM (2004) Measurement of hardness and elastic modulus by instrumented
indentation: advances in understanding and refinements to methodology. J Mater Res 19(1):3–
20
13. Fang T, Jian S, Chuu D (2004) Nanomechanical properties of TiC, TiN and TiCN thin films
using scanning probe microscopy and nanoindentation. Appl Surf Sci 228(1–4):365–372
Evaluation of Process Parameters Influence on the Mechanical … 155
14. Bec S et al (1996) Improvements in the indentation method with a surface force apparatus.
Philos Mag A 74(5):1061–1072
15. Mani A et al (2005) Effects of residual stress on the mechanical and structural properties of
TiC thin films grown by RF sputtering. Surf Coat Technol 194(2–3):190–195
16. Janos B, Lugscheider E, Remer P (1999) Effect of thermal aging on the erosion resistance of
air plasma sprayed zirconia thermal barrier coating. Surf Coat Technol 113(3):278–285
17. Karthikeyan S, Balasubramanian V, Rajendran R (2014) Developing empirical relationships to
estimate porosity and microhardness of plasma-sprayed YSZ coatings. Ceram Int 40(2):3171–
3183
Effect of Compaction Loads
in Machining of Short Carbon
Fiber-Reinforced Aluminum Composite
1 Introduction
2 Experimental Procedure
2.1 Materials
Ball milling is one of the techniques used to homogeneously blend the reinforcement
particles in the matrix phase [11]. Pure aluminum powder and short carbon fiber
(SCF) of 2 weight percentage were mixed using ball milling for an hour. The Al
matrix powder and SCF mixer are then compacted in the mild steel die, and it is
cold pressed with 250, 300 and 350 kN compressive loads using universal testing
machine. After cold pressing, sintering was carried out in an electric muffle furnace
with an inert atmosphere. The cold-pressed Al/SCF sample is kept inside the furnace
at 580 °C for 30 min and allowed to cool in the furnace. The sintered samples were
of 50 mm in diameter and 25 mm in height.
Machining was carried out in a water jet machine at SBB Water Jet (STREAMLINE
SL-V E50V2), Coimbatore, with a 1.1 mm orifice. Experiments were performed at a
constant pressure of 3500 bar and constant mass flow rate of 700 g/min using abrasive
garnet (silicon sand of 100 mesh). The two-process parameters used to perform
the machining are standoff distance and transverse speed. They were considered
in abrasive water jet machining of SCF/Al composite specimens. The machining
process parameters and the compacting load variation are shown in Table 1.
Wear is the process of friction between two interacting surfaces in a confined envi-
ronment. Wear test was conducted in pin-on-disk test apparatus as per the ASTM
standard G99. The specimens were machined to a size of 10 mm×10 mm×25 mm.
The wear rate was calculated directly as the volume loss of the specimen for the
distance traveled. During the conduct of wear test, the specimen was forced against
the rotating hardened steel disk by applying the load. The test was carried out at
room temperature with the process parameters shown in Table 2.
The 9-run machining was carried out in abrasive water jet machine as per combination
of factors based on the DOE, and the composite’s surface roughness, hardness and
wear rate are measured as in Table 4.
The powder mixer was compacted and sintered, and then, it was kept in the furnace
to maintain the temperature. The sintered composites with various compacting load
have shown an increase in hardness (Fig. 1). The hardness value for the specimen
compacted with 300 kN and specimen compacted with 350 kN are almost similar.
Hence, it may be concluded that increasing the compacting load over 300 kN is
insignificant with respect to the hardness values.
Surface morphology of the sintered composite for various compacting loads is
shown in Fig. 2. The microstructure for the specimen with 250 kN is found to be more
porous than 300 and 350 kN. Hence, the specimen compacted with 250 kN is not as
dense as the other specimens. As the compacting loads are gradually applied to the
powdered mixer, the same leads to the densification of the specimen which reduces
the porosity and increases its hardness. The surface of the specimen compacted with
300 kN (Fig. 2b) and 350 kN (Fig. 2c) is found to have a similar textured surface.
Hence for the higher loads, the change in hardness value is negligible.
Wear tests were conducted with a load of 2 N, by rubbing the sintered composite
specimens. Sliding velocity was kept as constant of 2 m/sec. Wear test results show
the effect of the compacting load on the wear rate. The specimen compacted for the
load of 250 kN displayed a higher wear rate than 300 and 350 kN are shown in Fig. 3.
It shows that the increase in compacting load reduces the wear rate.
The hardness of the composites influenced the resistance to friction and erosion.
Cavities are formed along the composites’ surface due to carbon fiber particles pulling
out from the composites, which in turn increases the surface roughness. The surface
roughness value of the composite increases with an increase in transverse speed from
180 mm/min to 200 mm/min as shown in Fig. 4.
It is observed that material erodes at a higher rate as the transverse speed increases
are shown in Fig. 5. Surface roughness of composite specimens for various standoff
distances. At a load of 300 kN, as the standoff distance increases there is a gradual
reduction in the surface roughness value owing to the porosity of the specimen. Since
the compaction id good at a load of 350 kN the surface roughness value varies linearly
as the specimen is less porous.
Fig. 2 Surface morphology of sintered composite (a) 250 kN compacting load, (b) 300 kN
compacting load and (c) 350 kN compacting load
4 Conclusion
The Al/SCF powder and fiber mixer were compacted for different loads and sintered
at 580 °C. The sintered specimens were machined in abrasive water jet machine for
164 S. Mohanasundaram et al.
the various transverse speeds and standoff distances. The following conclusions were
made.
• The sintered composites with various compacting load increased the hardness of
the specimen. For the higher compacting loads, the change in hardness value is
very minimum. As the compacting loads increased, the specimen became denser.
It is found that higher compacting loads play a significant role in enhancing
hardness.
• The wear rate is high for the lower compacting loads and vice versa. Increase in
hardness results in the reduction of wear rate.
• The surface roughness value of the composite increases with an increase in trans-
verse speed. Along the surface, cavities are formed due to pull out of carbon fiber
particles from the composites due to which the surface roughness is increased.
Effect of Compaction Loads in Machining of Short Carbon Fiber … 165
References
Abstract Composite materials are the combinations of two or more materials which
are different in form and chemical composition. These composite are gradually gain-
ing more importance as a structural material in the present engineering design and
development activities because they offer very attractive mechanical properties such
as high strength-to-weight ratio higher thermal and corrosive resistance. A wide
range of metals and their alloys such as aluminium, titanium and magnesium are
extensively used in combination with different reinforcements such as SiC, Al2 O3 ,
TiC, TiO2 , TiB, ZrO2 and ZrB. Aluminium and its alloys are widely used to develop
lightweight material for construction, transportation, aerospace industries, marine,
automobile and similar engineering applications. In the present study, attempts are
made to synthesize Al 7072-Al2 O3 MMCs using stir casting process by varying the
weight percentage of reinforcement to investigate the mechanical behaviour as per
ASTM standards. EDX and XRD results confirm the presence of Al2 O3 particles in
the composite, and it is observed from the SEM images that alumina particles are
homogeneously distributed in the matrix. Further, results reveal that the mechanical
properties of Al 7072-Al2 O3 were enhanced with the addition of the reinforcement.
1 Introduction
Ravi et al. [12] developed aluminium matrix composites using boron carbide
using centrifugal casting technique by varying the wt% of the reinforcement to study
the mechanical properties. It is evident from the results that tensile strength was
enhanced from 117 to 145 MPa, and hardness value increased from 62 to 68 HV.
Zhao et al. [13] developed AA 6061-B4 C composites using a friction stir pro-
cess to study the microstructure and mechanical properties. Results revealed that
with an increasing number of FSP passes, the dispersion of B4 C particles becomes
more uniform, further by way of four FSP passes, the expected AA6061/B4 C sur-
face composite layer is successfully fabricated with homogeneously distributed B4 C
particles.
Vijaya Ramnath et al. [14] proposed that Al6061 B4 C-SiC composite was pro-
duced with stir cast route for different particle size (viz. 37, 44, 63, 105, 250 µ)
by maintaining melt temperature at 800 °C during the process preheated B4 C par-
ticles and degassing agents C2 Cl6 were added into the vortex with a stirring speed
of 300 rpm. It was observed from the XRD analysis the B4 C particles are homoge-
neously dispersed in the matrix. Further, it is noticed that hardness of the composite
was maximum at 250 µ at 12 wt% and an increment in tensile strength at 105 µ for
8 wt% of B4 C.
From the available literature, it is absorbed that many researches are worked
towards the development of lightweight materials for engineering applications using
different reinforcements and found that the addition of the reinforcement enhances
the mechanical and tribological properties. Further noticed that limited work has
been done to study the mechanical characteristics of Al 7072-Al2 O3 AMCs. Hence
in this research work, attempts are made to develop Al 7072-Al2 O3 MMCs to study
the mechanical properties.
Al 7072 alloy is an extensively used aluminium alloy which offers a range of good
properties [15]. Al 7072 (Fig. 1) based composites are high strength, good machin-
ability, low thermal and electrical resistivity and easily extractable in nature. Being
stiff and strong material, it finds many applications in different engineering fields
[16, 17].
Among various reinforcements, Al2 O3 (Fig. 2) is selected because of its stag-
gering properties like chemical and thermal stability, availability, relatively good
strength, high hardness strength, high electrical insulation, good corrosion resistance
and biocompatibility.
170 G. Mallesh et al.
Stir casting process is an extensively used method to fabricate MMCs in liquid state
in which molten metal is mixed in the furnace by means of mechanical stirring [19].
It is noticed that almost all the composites were manufactured by this process using
up to 30% volume fraction of reinforcement [20, 21]. It is evident from the literature
that use of stir casting process enables better mixing of matrix and reinforcement in
the MMCs. Different components of stir casting process are shown in Figs. 3 and 4.
Al 7072 rods and 3, 6, 9 and 12 wt% of Al2 O3 are weighed as per the wt% of the
reinforcement and fed into the graphite crucible and heated using an electrical furnace
up to 850 °C and coating was applied inside the crucible to avoid contamination.
ing of different wt% of Al2 O3 composites using wire cut EDM, CNC turning and
milling was carried out as per different ASTM standards to conduct mechanical tests.
EDS is an analytical tool used to know the presence of different elements in the
specimen using X-ray spectrum. To stimulate the emission characteristic of X-rays
from a specimen, a high-energy beam of electrons or protons or a beam of X-rays
was focused on the sample being studied.
In the present research, EDS analyses of Al 7072-Al2 O3 composites by varying the
wt% of Al2 O3 were conducted to know the presence of elements in the composites.
The EDS patterns of Al 7072-Al2 O3 with different wt% of Al2 O3 are shown in
Fig. 8(a–e). It is evident from the plots that aluminium exhibits high intensity peaks
which indicate that aluminium is predominant because it is chosen as base alloy.
Further, it is found that low intensity peaks of oxygen were identified which shows
the presence of Al2 O3 reinforcement [22].
The X-ray diffraction patterns (XRD) of Al 7072-Al2 O3 composites were obtained
using Panalytical X-ray diffractometer having 0.15–0.40 nm inter-atomic distances
with photon energies between 3 and 8 keV. Peak values were collected over the 2θ
range of 10–800 with a step size of 0.0170° and step time of 20.3142 s. The crystalline
size measurements were carried out using Debye–Scherrer equation D hkl = β0.98λ cos θ
[23]. It is observed from the XRD patterns (Fig. 9a–e) that all the composites
developed confirm the formation of Al2 O3 particles.
The SEM micrographs of Al 7072-Al2 O3 composites are presented in Fig. 10a–e.
It is noticed from the micrographs that all the castings are free from defects such
as porosity, shrinkages and slag inclusions which highlights the quality of castings
and Al2 O3 particles are distributed homogeneously in the composites which is an
essential requirement to achieve better mechanical properties.
174 G. Mallesh et al.
(e) 12 % Al2O3
Tensile strength is the ability or capacity of the material to expand prior to failure.
The tensile tests were conducted on computerized universal testing machine model
TUE400(C) as per ASTM E8M-13a standard shown in Fig. 11.
Synthesis and Characterization of Al 7072-Al2O3 Metal Matrix … 175
(a) Unreinforced
(b) 3 % Al2o3
(c) 6 % Al2o3
(d) 9 % Al2o3
(e) 12 % Al2o3
(e) 12 % Al2O3
Ability of the material to resist a sudden/shock loads is known as impact strength. Izod
or Charpy impact tests are used to measure the impact energy required to fracture
the specimen. In this study, ASTM E23 standard is used to determine the impact
resistance of Al 7072 reinforced with different wt% of Al2 O3 composite system.
The standard size of impact test specimen is as shown in Fig. 12.
Synthesis and Characterization of Al 7072-Al2O3 Metal Matrix … 177
3.3 Hardness
Tensile strength of the composites was tested using universal testing machine, and
it is evident from Fig. 14 that an increase in the wt% of the reinforcement increases
the tensile strength of the specimen. Unreinforced alloy possesses tensile strength
of 51.28 MPa and addition of 3 wt% Al2 O3 tensile strength improved by 10%, i.e.
56.64 MPa. Further increase in the 12 wt% of Al2 O3 , tensile strength reaches its peak
35
29
30 26
22
Energy, Joules
25
19
20 17
15
10
5
0
Al 7072 3% 6% 9% 12%
Wt. % of Al2O3
value of 79.28 MPa, which is approx. 70% improvement [14]. Reason for this expo-
nential improvement in tensile strength is because of grain boundary strengthening
where alumina acts as a grain refiner and decreases the size of the alloy, uniform
distribution of the particle in the matrix, reduction in grain size leads to enhance the
tensile strength of Al 7072-Al2 O3 composite.
It is also evident that increase in the wt% of the reinforcement there was noticeable
decrease in the percentage of elongation due to the addition of hard particles alumina
which leads to the formation of brittle phase in the composite in turn enhances the
load carrying capacity.
Izod impact tests were conducted as per ASTM standard to know the impact strength
of the composites. It is observed from the results that a gradual improvement in
the impact strength of the composite as percentage of reinforcement increases. The
improvement in the impact strength is due to the resistance in flowing energy of the
reinforcing particles at the molecule level. It is observed from Fig. 15 that impact
strength of the composite developed is enhanced by 41% compared to base alloy.
4.3 Hardness
Vickers hardness tests were conducted as per ASTM standard to know the hardness
number of Al 7072-Al2 O3 composites. Figure 16 represents hardness number of
3,6,9 and 12 wt% of Al2 O3 reinforcement. It is observed from the results that the
addition of alumina enhances the hardness of the composite. Presence of Al2 O3
particles in the composite helps to resist the movement of dislocation within the
180 G. Mallesh et al.
matrix, minimization of inter-atomic distance and better bonding between the matrix
and the reinforcement.
5 Conclusions
• Al 7072 reinforced with different wt% of Al2 O3 AMC’s were synthesized using
stir casting process.
• EDX and XRD results reveals the presence of the reinforcement in the composite
developed and SEM images shows the clear and uniform distribution of Al2 O3 in
the matrix alloy.
• Mechanical tests on Al 7072-Al2 O3 AMC’s were carried out using different
ASTM standards to evaluate mechanical behaviour.
• Mechanical properties such as tensile strength, impact strength and hardness of
Al 7072-Al2 O3 composites were enhanced with the addition of reinforcement.
References
1. Miller WS, Zhuang L, Bottema J, Wittebrood AJ, De Smet P, Haszler A, Vieregge A (2000)
Recent development in aluminium alloys for the automotive industry. Mater Sci Eng A
280(1):37–49
2. Heinz A, Haszler A, Keidel C, Moldenhauer S, Benedictus R, Miller WS (2000) Recent
development in aluminium alloys for aerospace applications. Mater Sci Eng A 280(1):102–107
3. Vijaya RB, Elanchezhian C, Annamalai RM, Aravind S, Sri Ananda Atreya T, Vignesh V,
Subramanian C (2014) Aluminium metal matrix composites-a review. Rev Adv Mater Sci
38(2014):55–60
4. Shirvani MK, Abdizadehb H, Baharvandic HR. Mechanical and structural behavior of alu-
minium matrix composite reinforced by B4 C under different processing temperature and
volume fraction of reinforcement
Synthesis and Characterization of Al 7072-Al2O3 Metal Matrix … 181
5. Bindumadhavan PN, Chia TK, Chandrasekaran M, Wah HK, Loh NL, Prabhakar O (2001)
Effect of particle-porosity clusters on tribological behavior of cast aluminium alloy A356-SiCp
metal matrix composites. Mater Sci Eng A 315(1–2):217–226
6. Hong SJ, Kim HM, Chun BS (2003) Effect of clustering on the mechanical properties of
SiC particulate-reinforced aluminium alloy 2024 metal matrix composites. Mater Sci Eng A
347(1–2):198–204
7. Auradi V, Rajesh GL, Kori SA (2014) Processing of B 4 C particulate reinforced 6061 aluminum
matrix composites by melt stirring involving two-step addition. Procedia Mater Sci 6:1068–
1076
8. Stalin B, Murugan C (2016) Evaluation of mechanical behavior of aluminium alloy boron
carbide MMC. In: International conference on emerging engineering trends and science
(ICEETS–2016), pp 2348–8360
9. Kumar GBV, Rao CSP, Selvaraj N, Bhagyashekar MS (2010) Studies on Al6061-SiC and
Al7075-Al2O3 metal matrix composites. J Miner Mater Charact Eng 9(01):43
10. Kalaiselvan K, Dinaharan I, Murugan N (2014) Characterization of friction stir welded boron
carbide particulate reinforced AA6061 aluminum alloy stir cast composite. Mater Des 55:176–
182
11. Gopal Krishna UB, Sreenivas Rao KV, Vasudeva B (2013) Effect of boron carbide rein-
forcement on aluminium matrix composites. Int J Metall Mater Sci Eng (IJMMSE):41–48.
ISSN
12. Ravi B, Balu Naik B, Udaya Prakash J (2015) Characterization of aluminium matrix composites
(AA6061/B4C) fabricated by stir casting technique. Mater Today: Proc 2(4–5): 2984–2990
13. Zhao Y, Huang X, Li Q, Huang J, Yan K (2015) Effect of friction stir processing with B 4 C
particles on the microstructure and mechanical properties of 6061 aluminum alloy. Int J Adv
Manufact Technol 78(9–12):1437–1443
14. Subramanya RP, Kesavan R, Vijaya Ramnath B (2018) Investigation of mechanical properties of
aluminium 6061-silicon carbide, boron carbide metal matrix composite. Silicon 10(2):495–502
15. Eliasson J, Sandström R (1995) Applications of aluminium matrix composites. In: Key
engineering materials. vol. 104, Trans Tech Publications, pp 3–36
16. Viala JC, Bouix J, Gonzalez G, Esnouf C (1997) Chemical reactivity of aluminium with boron
carbide. J Mater Sci 32(17):4559–4573
17. Shorowordi KM, Laoui T, Haseeb ASMA, Celis JP, Froyen L (2003) Microstructure and inter-
face characteristics of B4C, SiC and Al2 O3 reinforced Al matrix composites: a comparative
study. J Mater Process Technol 142(3):738–743
18. Kok M (2005) Production and mechanical properties of Al2 O3 particle-reinforced 2024
aluminium alloy composites. J Mater Process Technol 161(3):381–387
19. Gopalakrishnan S, Murugan N (2012) Production and wear characterisation of AA 6061 matrix
titanium carbide particulate reinforced composite by enhanced stir casting method. Compos B
Eng 43(2):302–308
20. Balasivanandha PS, Karunamoorthy L, Kathiresan S, Mohan B (2006) Influence of stirring
speed and stirring time on distribution of particles in cast metal matrix composite. J Mater
Process Technol 171(2):268–273
21. Reddy AC (2009) Mechanical properties and fracture behavior of 6061/SiCp metal matrix
composites fabricated by low pressure die casting process. J Manufact Technol Res 1(3/4):273–
286
22. Suresh S, Shenbaga Vinayaga Moorthi N, Vettivel SC, Selvakumar N (2014) Mechanical behav-
ior and wear prediction of stir cast Al–TiB2 composites using response surface methodology.
Mater Des 59:383–396
23. Kaviyarasu K, Anand P (2012) One pot synthesis and characterization of caesium doped Sn O2
Nano crystals via a hydrothermal process. J Mater Sci Technol 28:15–20
Erosion-wear Behaviour of 304 Stainless
Steel Reinforced with TiN at Elevated
Temperatures
1 Introduction
Austenitic stainless steels (ASSs) are extensively used in nuclear reactors, biomed-
ical implants, as well as in components for chemical and food industries. They are
the most popular corrosion-resistant materials used in various applications due to
their excellent corrosion resistance and good mechanical properties [1]. Apart from
applications in corrosive environment, high impact velocity of particles is frequently
encountered in components used in these industries. Examples are coal-fired boilers
used in the power generation industries [2]. Although austenitic stainless steels are
well known for their good corrosion properties, they are famous for poor mechanical
properties such as friction and wear. According to Sun and Bell [3], when ASSs are
in contact with each other or other materials, they experience severe metallic wear as
a result of adhesion junction and severe plastic deformation occurring between the
surfaces of the materials in contact with each other. Furthermore, ASS fails mainly
because of wear rather than corrosion-related material loss problems.
Wear can be defined as the loss of materials due to the mechanical action occurring
between two or more bodies in contact with each other [4]. Wear phenomena include
several mechanisms such as abrasive, adhesive, corrosive and erosion wear. Erosion-
wear mechanism plays an important role in determining the life span of components
used in several applications such as in mining, solids transportation in pipelines,
power generation and marine [5]. Erosion wear is a material deterioration process
due to impacting particles on solid surfaces.
Although there are literatures available on 304 steel reinforcement with ceramics
and nitrides, there is still a need to study the effect of these reinforcements at elevated
temperatures. This is important as there are very few literatures available on erosion-
wear or erosion-corrosion performance of spark plasma-sintered 304 stainless steel
composites at high temperatures. Therefore, this study focuses on the erosion-wear
behaviour of sintered 304 steel under high temperature conditions.
2 Experimental Procedures
Spark plasma-sintered compacts of 304 austenitic stainless steel (ASS) without and
with 2, 4 and 6% TiN were supplied by Centre for Nanoengineering and Tribo-
corrosion. The samples were sintered under high vacuum conditions using graphite
die and punch at an applied pressure of 50 MPa, sintering temperature of 1000 °C,
heating rate of 100 °C/min and holding time of 10 min. After sintering, the sam-
ples were sand-blasted to remove any excess graphite material on them. Thereafter,
the substrates were machined using the robofil 240-SL electrical discharge machine
(EDM) wire cut. The sintered samples were ground and polished to 3 µm diamond
finish. The samples were further polished with fumed silica using a polishing sus-
pension of 0.2 µm to achieve mirror-like surface. The morphology of the sintered
specimen before and after erosion-wear test was investigated using scanning elec-
tron microscope model TESCAN Vega 3 which is equipped with energy-dispersive
spectroscope. The Rigaku Ultima IV X-ray diffractometer XRD equipped with a
graphite-monochromatic Cu Kα radiation source at 40 kV and 30 mA was used to
perform the XRD analysis. Collection of diffractograms took place in the 2θ range
between 3° and 90° with a step size of 0.01 [6].
Erosion-wear Behaviour of 304 Stainless Steel Reinforced … 185
Table 1 Chemical
Erosion conditions
compositions of admixed
powders Erodent material Alumina particles
Particle size (µm) 45
Particle velocity (m/s) 18
Impact angle (°) 90
Sample temperature (°C) 25, 400, 600
Duration of impact (mins) 10
Erosion-wear testing was carried out using a high temperature erosion tester. The
erosion test rig used in the study was designed at the Universidad Nacional Del Sur
(UNS), Argentina. The equipment works similar with that of the ASTM G76-04
standards. Prior to erosion tests, specimens were cut into approximately 35 mm ×
1.5 mm × 1.5 mm dimension, ground and polished using sand papers 180, 220, 400
and 600 and cleaned in acetone for 2 min in an ultrasonic cleaner. The erosion tester
consists of particle feed inlet, air compressor and furnace. The alumina particles were
used as erodent material and were accelerated through the feed inlet by compressed
air at a constant speed of 18 m/s and this cause the abrasive particles to impact on the
sample. Erosion-wear tests were carried out at room temperature, 400 and 600 °C,
and the specimens were eroded for 10 min. Table 1 shows the operating solid particle
erosion-wear parameters used in the study.
The effects of temperatures (25, 400 and 600 °C) on the rate of erosion of 304
austenitic stainless steel without and with TiN additions at an impact angle of 90°
and an impact velocity of 18 m/s are presented in Fig. 1.
From the graphs, it could be observed that the erosion-wear behaviour of these
materials shows a similar behaviour. The graphs show that material mass loss
increases with increasing temperature and as a result, higher material loss is expe-
rienced at 600 °C while the least material loss is observed at room temperature.
Material loss increases as the temperature increases. This is observed up to a max-
imum temperature where a point of maximum material loss is achieved. The total
material loss between room temperature and 400 °C in all the samples is small in
the same order (in the range of 10–15 mg) while the total material loss between 400
and 600 °C in all the samples rises sharply (in the range of 90–40 mg). In this case,
not only erosion-wear occurs but also the combined effect of erosion and oxidation
takes place at elevated temperatures [7].
The combined effect of temperatures on material loss as the amount of TiN hard
phase is increased in the substrate is presented in Fig. 2. From the graph, it could
be observed that at 25 °C, the materials show almost similar weight loss between
28.9 and 31.4 mg. As the temperature increases, more material loss is experienced
186 R. M. Mafafo et al.
Fig. 1 Temperature versus weight loss of a 304 ASS b 304/2TiN c 304/4TiN and d 304/6TiN
85
304 ASS 2TiN 4TiN 6TiN
75
65
Weight loss (mg)
55
45
35
25
Temperature (oC)
on 304/6TiN. This could be due to the formation of debris that could contain TiN
hard phase which can act as a third body. Since there is a high content of TiN in
304/6TiN, it could translate to higher TiN content as a third body. Therefore, this
may promote higher weight loss. On the other hand, there could be particle loosening
along the grain boundaries at high temperature and as a result, an increase in wear
phenomena on the eroded surface. At 600 °C, it could be observed that 304 ASS
Erosion-wear Behaviour of 304 Stainless Steel Reinforced … 187
with TiN additions display similar trend and closely related weight loss between 50
and 55.15 mg. However, for 304 ASS without TiN at 600 °C, it was observed that
weight loss was the highest (76 mg) compared to 304 ASS with TiN. This could be
due to sintered 304 ASS ductility behaviour as the temperature increase, thereby a
loss in hardness properties [7, 8].
Figure 3 further compares the effect of temperature on the hardness of the sin-
tered composites under erosion-wear test. Higher microhardness values are recorded
at room temperature. At higher temperatures (400 and 600 °C), all the samples
recorded a significant drop in microhardness values. According to studies reported
by Huttunen-Saarivirta et al. [7], when a material is subjected to high temperature
effect, it becomes soft and loses its hardness properties. These findings are in full
agreement with the results indicated in Fig. 3.
Figure 4 compares the effect of temperature (25, 400 and 600 °C) on the erosion-
wear behaviour of the composites. The rate of erosion wear indicates that there is
a proportional relationship between drop in microhardness values (shown in Fig. 3)
and the weight loss, as the percentage of TiN in the material increases.
This indicates that at low temperature, the sintered composites are less prone
erosion-wear. On the other hand, an increase in temperature raises the materials loss.
However, addition of TiN to 304 matrix reduced material loss at 600 °C from 76 mg
(for 304 ASS without TiN) to 55 mg. This shows a correlation between TiN content
in the metal matrix hardness values and weight loss.
Visual aid image of sintered composite surfaces before and after erosion-wear are
presented in Fig. 5. Figure 5a shows the material prior to erosion-wear tests while
Fig. 5b–d shows the materials after being subjected to erosion-wear at 25, 400 and
600 °C, respectively. In every case, erosion-wear region shows a circular shape at
the centre and spread towards the edge of the samples. Furthermore, three layers
could be identified: the first layer is at the centre, where most of the material is
removed; second layer where less material is removed and lastly, the third layer,
Fig. 3 Microhardness values of eroded 304 SS without and with TiN addition at different
temperatures
188 R. M. Mafafo et al.
Fig. 4 Comparison of material loss in spark plasma-sintered 304 stainless steel without and with
TiN
where very small amount of material has been removed. This could be clearly seen
in Fig. 5d. This behaviour is also reported by Kumar and Kanwar [9] and Patel et al.
[10]. Similarly, Kumar and Kanwar [9] found that an erosion study carried out at an
impact angle of 90° results in circular shape on the region where erosion has taken
Erosion-wear Behaviour of 304 Stainless Steel Reinforced … 189
place while at an impact angle of 30°, an elliptical shape is observable on the surface
where erosion has occurred.
SEM micrographs of the eroded composites are displayed in Fig. 6 at 600 °C con-
dition. The SEM of eroded samples provides useful information about the mechanism
of erosion. According to Javaheri et al. [11], the mechanism at which erosion occurs
by solid particle is broadly divided into two mechanisms, namely “cutting” and “de-
formation”. On the damaged surfaces, pitting action is clearly observed. Materials
were predominantly damaged by brittle fracture and plastic deformation. Large frag-
ments of wear debris could be observed in all the samples and plastic deformation
in the form of ploughing, misplaced material, micro-cut and ploughing is present.
The results found in this study are in line with those conducted by Laguna-Camacho
et al. [12] and Qin et al. [13]. Sintered 304 (Fig. 6a) shows an unconventional wear
mechanism which was characterized by large fragments on the surface of the eroded
surface, and this is an indication that the removal mechanism is through brittle frac-
ture. Also, pitting behaviour was observed. Elsewhere, Bahri et al. [14] revealed that
materials from eroded surface of 304 L SS had been removed due to ploughing and
pitting. Patel et al. [10] observed that in a steady-state condition, a simultaneous
action of three phases occurs on the surface of 304 steel at different locations.
During the initial phase, a crater is formed by the impacting particles and the mate-
rial is displaced from the specimen. The second phase involves the material being
displaced due to subsequent impact and this result in lateral material displacement
Fig. 6 SEM micrographs of a 304 ASS b 304 ASS/2TiN c 304 ASS/4TiN and d 304 ASS/6TiN
at 600 °C
190 R. M. Mafafo et al.
accompanied by fracture. The third stage is experienced after few impacts where the
materials become strained and therefore removed from the surface by fracture. Qin
et al. [13] conducted a study on the erosion-wear and intergranular corrosion resis-
tance properties of AISI 304 L austenitic stainless steel after low-temperature plasma
nitriding. It was reported that the most erosion damage taking place on the surface of
the materials includes ploughing action, embedded particles, cutting grooves, large
fragments, pitting action and wear debris on the surface of the sample that was nitride
at 673 K.
4 Conclusion
Acknowledgements The authors are grateful to Tribology Group, Universidad Nacional del Sur,
Bahía Blanca, Argentina for the use of equipment and facilities. The Institute of Nano Engineer-
ing Research (INER), Tshwane University of Technology, Pretoria, for the use of sintering and
characterization facilities.
References
6. Dada OR (2015) Characterization and beneficiation of foundry greensand waste from ferrous
foundries. University of Johannesburg
7. Huttunen-Saarivirta E, Antonov M, Veinthal R, Tuiremo J, Mäkelä K, Siitonen P (2011) Influ-
ence of particle impact conditions and temperature on erosion–oxidation of steels at elevated
temperatures. Wear 272:159–175
8. dos Santos JF, Garzón CM, Tschiptschin AP (2004) Improvement of the cavitation erosion
resistance of an AISI 304 L austenitic stainless steel by high temperature gas nitriding. Mater
Sci Eng A 382:378–386
9. Kumar N, Kanwar R (2012) To study erosion behavior of Cr2 O3 Coating on SS-304 boiler
steel tubes in simulated coal fired boiler conditions
10. Patel M, Patel D, Sekar S, Tailor P, Ramana P (2016) Study of solid particle erosion behaviour
of SS 304 at room temperature. Procedia Technol 23:288–295
11. Javaheri V, Porter D, Kuokkala V-T (2018) Slurry erosion of steel–review of tests, mechanisms
and materials. Wear 408:248–273
12. Laguna-Camacho JR, Vite-Torres M, Gallardo-Hernández E, Vera-Cárdenas E (2013) Solid
particle erosion on different metallic materials. Tribology in Engineering. InTech
13. Qin X, Guo X, Lu J, Chen L, Qin J, Lu W (2017) Erosion-wear and intergranular corrosion
resistance properties of AISI 304 L austenitic stainless steel after low-temperature plasma
nitriding. J Alloy Compd 698:1094–1101
14. Bahri A, Guermazi N, Elleuch K, Ürgen M (2016) On the erosive wear of 304 L stainless steel
caused by olive seed particles impact: Modeling and experiments. Tribol Int 102:608–619
A Concise Review of Nano-enhanced
Phase Change Materials for Passive
Cooling Applications in Buildings
Abstract Building energy consumption has been on a steady rise over the past
decade. This is due to the ever-growing human population and the effect of climate
change. Space conditioning accounts for over 40% of the final global energy pro-
duction. Thermal energy storage (TES) systems have shown to be quite effective in
reducing buildings energy demand while maintaining the desired comfort. It finds
a useful application in solar thermal systems as and heat recovery systems. Phase
change materials are used in building components for storing excess heat energy
for use when the need arises. The ability of PCMs to store great quantity of heat
in comparatively small volume makes them suitable for this application. Some of
the set backs encountered by using PCMs is its poor thermal conductivity and sub-
cooling characteristics. Nanoparticles have been found very useful in ameliorating
the thermal conductivity of PCMs thereby improving its general performance. This
review work brings to bear recent developments on the use of nanoenhanced PCMs
for passive cooling applications in buildings, and there are very little articles in lit-
erature that emphasizes the application of nanoPCMs in passive cooling systems.
We further discussed the physics of operation and phase transition behaviours with
mathematical representations. Some gaps currently encountered in the research of
nanoPCMs was also highlighted for further research purposes.
1 Introduction
Space conditioning in buildings have been identified as the major consumer of the
final global energy production with respect to buildings. This pattern is the same
for both residential and commercial buildings. This figure was reported to be about
40% of annual global energy production by the international energy agency [1].
A greater majority of the global energy resource is fossil-based and comes with
increased CO2 production. The rapidly growing population of the world and the
effect of climate change account for the rise in energy demand. Some of the adverse
effects of global warmingas listed by the IPCC include but not restricted to the
following: a continuous rise in temperature, increased hurricane, more draught, and
heat waves etc. [2]. It is due to this cause that scientists have sought to reduce global
CO2 emission while maintaining reasonable thermal comfort. Over the past decades,
researches have studied various novel renewable approaches to meet the energy
requirements of residential or commercial buildings while keeping the environment
safe. Thermal energy storage (TES) is one way, that many researchers have proposed,
that can sufficiently reduce building’s energy demand. It finds a useful application in
solar thermal systems as well as heat recovery systems [3]. Thermal energy storage
(TES) mediums are green systems which results in zero-emission of carbon into
the atmosphere. Thermal energy storage (TES) systems absorbs heat, stores it and
releases it when required for use; this helps in load shedding in buildings. TES is
further classified based on their mode of operation as: chemical heat storage (CHTES)
sensible heat storage (SHTES) or latent heat storage (LHTES) [4].
Phase change materials change their physical form upon absorption or release of
energy. This energy could be in the form of heat of fusion or heat of vaporization;
their ability to store substantial amounts of thermal energy in proportionately small
volume makes them fit for a broad range of applications. When the PCM absorbs
energy from the ambient, the chemical bonds of the PCM breaks up and this leads
to a change of phase. The process of the phase change is an endothermic process;
therefore, heat is absorbed from the ambient causing a drop in the bulk temperature
of the surrounding. When there is a drop in the ambient temperature, the PCM
gives up its energy and returns to the solid state, thereby increasing the ambient
temperature of the room [5]. PCMs are generally classified by considering their
chemical composition as organic, inorganic or eutectic compounds [6]. Summarized
below are some advantages and disadvantages of different classes of PCMs also some
desired properties of PCMs (Table 1).
Some examples of the three classes PCMs applicable to buildings are outlined in
the Table 2.
A Concise Review of Nano-enhanced Phase Change Materials … 195
The foregoing discussions have revealed how phase change materials play a very
crucial role in latent heat energy storage and dispensing systems. There exist various
solar-deriventhermal technologies that employ the use of PCMs in both active and
passive capacities. Enhancing the heat storage and dispensing capabilities of PCMs
can be achieved by doping pure PCM with nanoparticles [8]. Metals, metallic oxides
196 C. K. Oluah et al.
and carbonic nanoparticles have all been introduced in various quantities to boost the
heat conduction abilities of PCMs]. Babapoor et al. further established that nanopar-
ticles improved the heat transfer abilities of PCMs, and there seem to be a dilemma
in the discourse of the outcome of nanoparticles on the heat of fusion of phase
change materials, while a few authors presented results of positive improvement on
the latent heat of their materials, and some others had shown a gradual decline of
the latent heat value of the nanoPCM with increased quantities of nanoparticles. The
duration of phase change, density and the viscosity have also been improved with
nanoparticles. [9].
Nanomaterials are broadly classified as organic, inorganic and hybrids just like phase
change materials [8]. Further sub-classifications are identified in the chart below
(Fig. 1).
There are two general methods scientists use for the preparation of nanoenhanced
phase change materials; these methods are the one-step method and the two-step
method. The first method being the one-step method entails the concurrent produc-
tion of the nanoparticles into the base PCM while in the two-step approach, the
nanomaterials are first produced before introduction into the base material [10].
The essence of doping phase change materials with nanoparticles is to improve its
properties leading to a better performance upon application. Below are some desirable
characteristics of nanoPCMs.
The two-dimensional energy balance equation of heat flow in the PCM containing
nanoparticles is given below
2
∂T ∂T ∂T ∂ T ∂2T
ρc p + ρc p u +v =k + (1)
∂t ∂x ∂y ∂x2 ∂ y2
like density (ρ), heat capacity (ρC p ) and thermal conductivity (k) due to change in
phase presented in Eqs. (2)–(4) below.
⎧
⎨ ρns T < Tm
ρns +ρnl
ρ= T ≤ T ≤ Tm + Tm (2)
⎩ 2
ρnl T ≥ Tm + Tm
⎧
⎨ kns T < Tm
kns +knl
k= Tm ≤ T ≤ Tm + Tm (3)
⎩ 2
knl T ≥ Tm + Tm
⎧
⎨ (ρC p )ns
⎪
T < Tm
(ρC p )ns +(ρC p )nl ρns +ρnl L h f,n
ρC p = + Tm
T ≤ T ≤ Tm + Tm (4)
⎪
⎩
2 2
(ρC p )n f T ≥ Tm + Tm
Subscripts “ns” and “nl” refers to the state properties of the nanoPCM in solid
and liquid forms. L h f,n in Eq. (4) above represents the latent heat of fusion of the
nanoPCM and expressed mathematically as L h f,n = (1 − ϕ)h s f and ϕ is the weight
percentage of nanoparticles contained in the base materials [14].
The use of nanoparticles have greatly improved the thermal conductivity of PCMs,
however, some researchers reported a decline in latent heat as the concentration
of nanodopant increased while some others reported a linear relationship with the
increased concentration of nanomaterials; it is therefore important that a valida-
tion study is carried out. A research on optimum particle loading for best thermal
performance of nanoPCMs should also be investigated. Health risks involved in inte-
gration on nanoparticles in building envelopes should be studied and safety measures
are advised accordingly.
Table 4 Summary of recent studies on nanoenhanced PCM for passive cooling applications
200
Expanded graphite Capric-lauric acid (CA-LA) CTES in buildings A 114.2% improvement in thermal [25]
conductivity upon addition of
10 wt% of EG
201
202 C. K. Oluah et al.
5 Conclusion
References
15. Carneiro JO, Vasconcelos G, Azevedo S, Jesus C, Palha C, Gomes N, Teixeira V (2014) Energy
Build 81:1–8
16. Wang J, Xie H, Guo Z, Guan L, Li Y (2014) Appl Thermal Eng 73(2):1541–1547
17. Constantinescu M, Dumitrache L, Constantinescu D, Anghel E, Popa V, Stoica A, Olteanu M
(2010) Latent heat nano composite building materials. Eur Polym J 46(12):2247–2254
18. Kalaiselvam S, Parameshwaran R, Harikrishnan S (2012) Analytical andexperimental investi-
gations of nanoparticles embedded phase change materials for coolingapplication in modern
buildings. Renew Energy 39(1):375–387
19. Sayyar M, Weerasiri RR, Soroushian P, Lu J (2014) Experimental and numericalstudy of shape-
stable phase-change nanocomposite toward energy-efficient buildingconstructions. Energy
Build 75:249–255
20. Parameshwaran R, Deepak K, Saravanan R, Kalaiselvam S. Preparation
21. Parameshwaran R, Kalaiselvam S (2014) Energy conservative air conditioning system using
silver nano-based PCM thermal storage for modern buildings. Energy Energy Storage. Appl
Energy 115:320–330. Build 69:202–212
22. Sarı A, Alkan C, Özcan AN (2015) Synthesis and characterization of micro/nano capsules
of PMMA/capric–stearic acid eutectic mixture for low temperature-thermal energy storage in
buildings. Energy Build 90:106–113
23. Amin M, Putra N, Kosasih EA, Prawiro E, Luanto RA, Mahlia T (2017) Thermal properties
of beeswax/graphene phase change material as energy storage for buildingapplications. Appl
Therm Eng 112:273–280
24. Luo Z, Zhang H, Gao X, Xu T, Fang Y, Zhang Z (2017) Fabrication andcharacterization of
form-stable capric-palmitic-stearic acid ternary eutectic mixture/nano-SiO2 composite phase
change material. Energy Build
25. Hussain SI, Dinesh R, Roseline AA, Dhivya S, Kalaiselvam S (2017) Enhancedthermal per-
formance and study the influence of sub cooling on activated carbon dispersedeutectic PCM
for cold storage applications. Energy Build 143:17–24
Effect of Silicon Carbide
in Yttria-stabilized Zirconia for Thermal
Protective Structural Materials
1 Introduction
Zirconia-based thermal protective coatings are widely used for the thermal, oxidation,
and hot corrosion protection of high temperature components in gas turbine engines.
These coatings provide insulation to metallic structures in the hot section of turbine
engines and offer increased operating temperature of the engine-enhanced efficiency,
extended durability, and extended life of metallic components subjected to high
S. Subha (B) · P. Surendra · Ch. Gowtham Chowdary · V. Naga Venkata Sai Ram · P. Srikanth
School of Aeronautical Sciences, Hindustan Institute of Technology and Sciences, Chennai, India
e-mail: subhasvkmr@gmail.com
temperatures [1–3]. Several impurities common in fuels have been identified and
associated with corrosion in the coatings. These impurities include sodium, sulfur,
phosphorous, and especially vanadium. These impurities react with convectional
YSZ turbine blade coating, severely limit the coating lifetime. Therefore, it is of
great interest to develop alternative materials that increase the operating lifetime of
the coating [4].
New zirconia-based ceramic compositions have been under investigation for TBC
applications since many years. Previous work focuses on studying stabilizers such
as Y2 O3 and MgO were susceptible to chemical attacks. Indium-stabilized zirconia
shows relative inertness in vandia containing atmosphere but it volatilizes at a lower
temperature than zirconia [5]. Graphene-based materials are single- or few-layer
platelets that can be produced in bulk quantities by chemical methods. Thermal and
barrier properties of these composites are dependent upon the intrinsic properties
of graphene-based materials and their state of dispersion in the matrix [6]. Nanos-
tructurally stabilized zirconium oxide (NSZ) hard transparent films were produced
without chemical stabilizers by the ion beam-assisted deposition technique (IBAD).
These NSZ films have better thermal stability, probably because of the absence of
porosity due to the nature of the IBAD process [7]. In another study, sol–gel method
has been used to coat multiwalled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs) with zirconia at
room temperature and the coated tubes were sintered at high temperature. Sinter-
ing has improved the adhesion of the coating with CNTs and thereby improved its
high temperature resistance. It is also observed that the selecting proper sintering
temperature is the key to ensure a uniform coating layer on the CNTs [8].
The aim of this study is to synthesis the yttria-stabilized zirconia with silicon
nanocarbide material through wet chemical method. The morphology and thermal
properties of the prepared hybrid ceramic coating particles were studied by using
scanning electron microscope (SEM) and thermogravimetric analysis (TGA), respec-
tively. The ablation performances of the hybrid coating samples were tested using
oxyacetylene flame test.
2 Experimental
2.1 Materials
SiC of average particle size 50 nm used for composite preparation was obtained
from Sisco Research Chemicals Co. Ltd. Yttria-stabilized zirconia (YSZ) of average
particle size 3 µm was procured from Sigma Aldrich Co Ltd.
Effect of Silicon Carbide in Yttria-stabilized Zirconia for Thermal … 207
The SiC was coated on yttria-stabilized zirconia (YSZ) using sol–gel method.
The solution of YSZ is mixed with distilled water and ethanol in the molar ratio
0.1:3.17:1.75 [9]. The solution was magnetically stirred for 30 min to ensure the
homogenous distribution of particles. Thereafter, the SiC has added to the YSZ solu-
tion and the mixture was pre-reacted for 15 min with ultrasonicator. Finally, the
mixture was dried at room temperature for 24 h. The same process was repeated for
other samples with SiC content (0.1, 0.25 wt%). To improve the interfacial adhesion
of SiC on YSZ, the YSZ/SiC powder was sintered at 1000 °C for 1 h under nitrogen
atmosphere. The pre-determined amount of yttria-stabilized zirconia (YSZ) powder
was added to 150 ml of deionized water in a beaker maintain stirring at 600 rpm.
To ensure the better solid suspension, the mixture was stirred for 5 h. The resultant
mixture was dried in an muffle furnace at 200 °C for 2 h and dried solid mixture was
grinded to form fine powders and poured into a metallic mold (30 mm in diameter
and 10 mm thickness), Then the powder was dry-pressed into a disk-shaped pellet,
under a pressure of 70 MPa [10]. The sintering temperature was set at 1400 °C for
2 h with the heating rate of 1 °C/min as shown in Fig. 1.
The thermal stability of the prepared samples was investigated using TGA instrument
(SEIKO model TG/DTA 6200). The 5 mg sample was placed in an alumina crucible
and temperature was raised to 900 °C at a heating rate of 10 °C/min.
d (di − d f )
LR = = (1)
ta ta
M (m i − m f )
MR = = (2)
ta ta
where MR is mass ablation rate; m is a total change in mass of specimen before and
after ablation; mi and mf are initial and final mass of the composite sample before
and after ablation test.
Figure 2a shows the surface morphology that YSZ grains blend and become incred-
ibly quick at 1400 °C and the break is about all trans granular because of the grain
development it was seen in Fig. 2b that the microstructure turns out to be progressively
heterogeneous dispersion. The state of micron pores is increased by using higher slur-
ries [11]. When the silicon nanocarbide is added to yttria-stabilized zirconia surface,
strong stacking was diminshed (Fig. 2c) . The heterogeneous dispersion of silicon
nanocarbide was scribed to various sedimentation speeds as shown in Fig. 2d. The
Effect of Silicon Carbide in Yttria-stabilized Zirconia for Thermal … 209
Fig. 2 High magnification of a Surface morphology of YSZ b YSZ with 0.25% silicon nanocarbide
c Surface morphology of YSZ d YSZ with 0.25% silicon nanocarbide
The effect of fillers on thermal stability of YSZ-SiC hybrid coating was studied using
TGA and DTA techniques. Figure 3 shows the weight loss of samples at the low-
temperature stage, below 150 °C, corresponds to the evolution of organic solvents or
gases trapped during the process of synthesizing. This small amount of weight loss
(2–4%) includes formaldehyde, water, cross-linked molecules, methanol and phenol
[12]. However, the evolution of these products was less evident for the YSZ1 and
YSZ2 hybrid coatings. The major weight mass loss was observed around 604 °C for
pure YSZ and in the range of 650 °C for hybrid coating cured composites [13]. The
210 S. Subha et al.
Fig. 5 Images of prepared samples: a before ablation test b after ablation test
Fig. 6 Mass ablation performance of prepared sample after oxyacetylene flame test
212 S. Subha et al.
after adding the 0.25 wt% of SiC hybrid filler. The porosity increases as the YSZ-to-
SiC ratio increases, and because the permeability of the material, it directly increases
the thermal properties. The ablative properties of prepared samples are presented in
Table 1.
4 Conclusion
In this work, the effect of silicon nano-carbide coated into yttria-stabilized zirconia
was studied. Thermal studies results show that the YSZ2 sample attained higher ther-
mal stability compared to all other samples. The major weight mass loss was observed
around 604 °C for pure YSZ and in the range of 650 °C for hybrid coating cured
composites. Ablation performance of tested samples linearly reduced as % wt of SiC
nanofillers increased in the composite. The YSZ2 sample showed that the linear and
mass ablation rates were significantly decreased by 43% and 18.4%, respectively.
The surface morphology of hybrid-coated sample revealed the homogeneous disper-
sion and porus structure formed certainly contributed to a compressibility of the
coating material.
Effect of Silicon Carbide in Yttria-stabilized Zirconia for Thermal … 213
References
1 Introduction
from the recycled or recovered spent materials. Recycling of spent materials from
various sectors like agricultural [3], industrial [4], and electrical [5] are explored as
reinforcement substitute to the polymer composites. Addition of this kind of recycled
materials shows good improvement in mechanical properties.
Abrasive water jet machining (AWJM) is one of the unconventional machining
processes and is most suitable to machining of versatile materials [6]. This process
is not evolving with thermal heat leading to no heat-affected zone, and more flex-
ible to cut in all direction [7]. Besides, AWJM process bestows, as exact, required
dimensions with limited tolerance with complex profile.
Conventional machining like drilling of fiber-reinforced polymer composite
exhibited various damages such as fiber pull out, fiber scrolling, and delamination.
These are due effect of variation in cutting forces during drilling operation. AWJM
process produces a minor damage like side wall damage but it is controllable by judi-
cious selection of process parameters. The various process parameters controllable
in AWJM process are pressure, standoff distance, abrasive flow rate and size, and
traverse rate [8]. Cut surface quality was mostly influenced by the above-mentioned
machining parameters. Besides economy of the cut, environment consciousness is
most important issue for cutting operation.
Machining of polymer composite is entirely different form homogenous material
cutting because of discontinuous phases of constituent materials. Azmir et al., have
studied the surface roughness and kerf taper ratio on the glass fiber/epoxy composite
with varying process parameters. Machining quality in terms of surface roughness
was low at higher pressure of 275 MPa, lower standoff distance of 1.5 mm, and lower
traverse rate of 1.5 mm/s [9]. Unde et al., have investigated the abrasive water jet
machining process on carbon fiber-reinforced polymer composite [10]. The results
report that standoff distance and abrasive flow rate were influencing material removal
rate and delamination of fiber. Likewise, hydraulic pressure has majorly influenced
the cut quality. Researchers have studied the machinability studies of with and without
filler-added polymer composites. The results show that the filler added composite
produces a good surface quality. Moreover, the traverse rate and jet pressure were
influential parameters for the machining process [11, 12].
The present work deals influence of cutting quality on recovered blue-fired
alumina-reinforced GFRP composite using an abrasive water jet machining pro-
cess. Various process parameters such as abrasive flow rate, pressure, and standoff
distance were used. Analysis on the response parameters such as kerf taper angle
and surface roughness was done to determine the optimal and influential parameters
on the surface cut quality.
Optimization of Process Parameter in Abrasive Water Jet … 219
Vitrified grinding wheel reject of blue-fired alumina with various percentages (5, 15
and 25%) was used as secondary reinforcement for polymer composite production.
Composites were produced using hand layup technique. Epoxy LY556 and hardener
HY951 were raw materials for the matrix. Blue-fired alumina of 120 grit particles
was mixed with resin using magnetic stirring. Mixed resin and glass mat with vari-
ous weight proportions were placed inside wooden mold with cross-section of 310 ×
310 × 5 mm. Five layers of resin in-between four layers of fiber was stacked con-
secutively. Composite samples were cured at room temperature for 24 h. After 24 h,
the samples were taken out from mold and used for machining operations. Figure 1
shows the fabricated composites. These composites filler loading of 5, 15, and 25%
are referred as RBA1, RBA2, and RBA3, respectively. The hardness of fabricated
composites was measured using ASTM-D2240 by D-Shore hardness tester.
Typical layout of the abrasive water jet machining process is shown in Fig. 2. Two-axis
abrasive water jet CNC machine (OMAX Corporation, Model: 1530) was used for
the machining process. The equipment which is designed to have a nozzle diameter
of 0.762 mm, abrasive mesh size of 80 grit, tool offset of 0.3 mm, and impinging
angle of 90° is maintained constant throughout the experiment.
The machine is capable to work with various process parameters such as pressure,
standoff distance, abrasive flow rate, abrasive mesh size, and traverse rate. From that
effective parameters of water jet pressure (MPa), standoff distance and traverse rate
were chosen. The machining parameters for abrasive water jet cutting were referred
from the literature [13]. Table 1 shows various process parameters and its level used
for the machining process.
Kerf width was measured using profile projector (Make: Metzer) with a coordinate
measuring table size of 200 × 200 mm with micrometer. Typical kerf width and taper
angle measurement are depicted Fig. 3. Measurement was done at bottom and top
kerf, and the kerf taper angle was calculated using an Eq. (1),
(K t − K b )
Kerf taper angle ∅ = tan−1 (1)
2t
where t is the thickness of the polymer sample and K t is kerf top width and K b is
kerf bottom width.
Optimization of Process Parameter in Abrasive Water Jet … 221
Surface roughness of the machined surface was analyzed using a Mitutoyo Surf
test SJ-301 stylus-type profilometer. The average surface roughness (Ra) was mea-
sured for all the three composites at different locations. Optical images of the
machined zone were taken using a Leica S6 D stereo microscope.
Abrasive water jet machining process was carried by varying the selected process
parameter on the RBA1, RBA2, and RBA3 samples which are shown in Fig. 5.
width. On the other hand, there is only slight energy loss during cutting at bottom,
resulting in reduction of bottom kerf taper, as shown in Fig. 6a. The higher percent-
age of reinforcement (blue-fired alumina) shows the highest kerf taper angle. This
is due to high pressure garnet particle striking on the composite with higher energy
at entrance. Further jet energy absorbed by reinforcement particles causes them to
dislocate or dislodge from its own sites. This reduces jet energy at exit side. Due
to the interaction of garnet with high pressure, the reinforcement particles in matrix
could be dislodged [15]. As a result, a higher top kerf width is produced.
Optimization of Process Parameter in Abrasive Water Jet … 223
Fig. 6 Effect of water jet pressure on machined surfaces a kerf taper angle b surface roughness
Fig. 8 Effect of standoff distance on machined surfaces a kerf taper angle b surface roughness
the standoff distance (1, 3 and 5 mm). Maximum kerf taper angle was observed
at higher standoff distance and also for the 25% filler composite. An increase in
standoff distance causes an expansion of water jet leading to more interaction with
atmospheric air. It leads to loss in the jet energy, ultimately, increasing kerf taper
angle.
Standoff distance increases dragging of water jet in atmospheric air and impairs
the cutting ability of jet at top and is worst in bottom portion. Owing to uneven
erosion of matrix, the reinforcement particles were protruded from the matrix surface,
increasing the surface roughness. In the case of 25% filler loaded composite, reduced
water jet energy at high standoff distance results in poor interaction of jet with
reinforcement particle. This may lead to deflection of water jet at reinforcement
sites, reducing the machining rate and uneven machining. This adversely affects
surface roughness at the cutting zone.
Fig. 9 Effect of abrasive flow rate on machined surfaces a kerf taper angle b surface roughness
4 Conclusion
From the present research work, the following conclusions are arrived.
1. The addition of blue-fired alumina abrasive grain in the epoxy matrix shows a
linear increase in the hardness.
2. Machining on different percentages of (5, 15 and 25%) blue-fired alumina-
reinforced polymer composite was experimentally done and uniform machining
was observed at 5% composite whereas uneven machining was observed for the
25% composite.
3. Better quality cutting of polymer composites was achieved at high water pressure,
low standoff distance, and high abrasive flow rate.
4. Jet pressure has direct co-relation with kerf taper and surface roughness. At higher
pressure, the reinforcement is uniform and deeper machining is observed. At low
pressure, jet capability was reduced to low level, increasing surface roughness
and kerf taper angle.
226 P. Sabarinathan et al.
5. With increase in standoff distance, there is an expansion in the jet size, due to
interaction of jet with the atmospheric air and there is a loss in jet energy. This
results in increase of kerf taper angle.
6. Optical image of machined surface shows that uniform machining has occurred
at minimum filler loaded composite. Maximum filler loaded composite resulted
in increased surface roughness of cut surface.
References
1. Singh N, Hui D, Singh R, Ahuja IPS, Feo L, Fraternali F (2017) Recycling of plastic solid
waste: A state of art review and future applications. Compos B Eng 115:409–422
2. Gnanavelbabu A, Saravanan P, Rajkumar K, Sabarinathan P, Karthikeyan S (2018) Mechan-
ical strengthening effect by various forms and orientation of glass fibre reinforced isopthalic
polyester polymer composite. Mater Today Proc 5(13):26850–26859
3. Sabarinathan P, Rajkumar K, Gnanavelbabu A (2016) Mechanical properties of almond shell-
sugarcane leaves hybrid epoxy polymer composite. Appl Mech Mater 852:43–48
4. Sabarinathan P, Annamalai VE, Kumar SS, Kennedy AX (2019) A study on recovery of alumina
grains from spent vitrified grinding wheel. J Mater Cycles Waste Manag 21(1):156–165
5. Senophiyah-Mary J, Loganath R, Meenambal T (2018) A novel method for the removal of
epoxy coating from waste printed circuit board. Waste Manag Res 36(7):645–652
6. Wang J (1999) Abrasive waterjet machining of polymer matrix composites–cutting perfor-
mance, erosive process and predictive models. Int J Adv Manufact Technol 15(10):757–768
7. Hutyrova Z, Scucka J, Hloch S, Hlavacek P, Zelenak M (2016) Turning of wood plastic
composites by water jet and abrasive water jet. Int J Adv Manufact Technol 84(5–8):1615–1623
8. Gnanavelbabu A, Rajkumar K, Saravanan P (2018) Investigation on the cutting quality charac-
teristics of abrasive water jet machining of AA6061-B4C-hBN hybrid metal matrix composites.
Mater Manuf Processes 33(12):1313–1323
9. Azmir MA, Ahsan AK (2008) Investigation on glass/epoxy composite surfaces machined by
abrasive water jet machining. J Mater Process Technol 198(1–3):122–128
10. Unde PD, Gayakwad MD, Patil NG, Pawade RS, Thakur DG, Brahmankar PK (2015) Exper-
imental investigations into abrasive waterjet machining of carbon fiber reinforced plastic. J
Compos
11. Ramesha N, Akhtar S (2016) Abrasive water jet machining and mechanical behavior of banyan
tree saw dust powder loaded polypropylene green composites. Polym Compos 37(6):1754–
1764
12. Jani SP, Kumar AS, Khan MA, Kumar MU (2016) Machinablity of hybrid natural fiber
composite with and without filler as reinforcement. Mater Manuf Processes 31(10):1393–1399
13. Dhanawade A, Kumar S (2017) Experimental study of delamination and kerf geometry of
carbon epoxy composite machined by abrasive water jet. J Compos Mater 51(24):3373–3390
14. Rajesh S, VijayaRamnath B, Elanchezhian C, Aravind N, Rahul VV, Sathish S (2014) Analysis
of mechanical behavior of glass fibre/Al2 O3 –SiC reinforced polymer composites. Procedia Eng
97:598–606
15. Doreswamy D, Shivamurthy B, Anjaiah D, Sharma NY (2015) An investigation of abrasive
water jet machining on graphite/glass/epoxy composite. Int J Manufact Eng
16. MM IW, Azmi AI, Lee CC, Mansor AF (2018) Kerf taper and delamination damage mini-
mization of FRP hybrid composites under abrasive water-jet machining. Int J Adv Manufact
Technol 94(5–8):1727–1744
Mechanical Behavior of Raavi
and Pineapple Fiber-reinforced Hybrid
Polyester Composites
1 Introduction
No the global consumer sectors accounts for major part of the plastic materials, but
commonly these materials are degradable due to a resistance to microbial decay. The
natural fiber-based composite material can be produced by partly replacing polyester
resin with some natural fibers of different compositions with different percentage,
owing to use some conventional resources in our day today life. Van Vuure et al. [1]
have made comparative analysis on three different natural fiber composites based on
bamboo, flax, and coir fiber and he observed the percentage of variations of tensile
properties of natural fibers. Chegdani et al. [2] performed investigation on multiscale
tribological behavior when drilling natural fiber composites and hence the cause by
which the tribo mechanical behavior of drilling operation is affected was studied.
Vitale et al. [3] studied on natural and synthetic fiber-reinforced composite sandwich
panels for attaining a report on failure mode in sandwich panels of the composite.
Torres et al. [4] performed statistical study on comprehensive set of long natural fiber
composite systems to check the variability’s in long natural fiber laminate properties.
Corona et al. [5] observed on natural fiber composite selection without causing an
impact over the environment. Song et al. [6] studied the dynamic tensile properties for
recycled office paper fiber and old corrugated cardboard fiber at different proportions.
Fan et al. [7] determined the thermal decomposition of natural fiber composites and
the behavior and damage profile of natural fiber composite at microscopic and macro-
scopic levels. Pornwannachai et al. [8] determined the flammability and mechani-
cal performance of each fiber about the fire resistance on natural fiber-reinforced
composites. Mejri et al. [9] prepared birch fiber and high density polyethylene com-
posite for replacing nylon which is used in spur gear manufacturing in industries.
Chegdani et al. [10] studied on machinability of natural fiber-reinforced composite
material by investigating the mechanics of chip formation and the multiscale cut
surface by orthogonal cutting experiment. Vignesh G et al. [11] prepared hybrid
composite materials with kenaf, human hair as reinforcements, and epoxy resin
as matrix for investigating its mechanical properties such tensile strength, flexural
strength, and impact strength. Choudhry et al. [12] conducted experimental investi-
gation on polypropylene-based composite material with human hair as reinforcement
by varying the reinforcement and matrix percentage. From the results, they found
the mechanical properties of composite material are good with lower percentage of
reinforcements then the higher. Pothana et al. [13] analyzed the dynamic mechanical
properties of banana fiber-reinforced polyester composites with the effect of fiber
loading, frequency, and temperature. Rana et al. [14] fabricated natural fibers such
sisal, kenaf, hemp, jute, and coir-reinforced polypropylene composites processed by
compression molding using a film stacking method and analyzed the mechanical
properties of composites. Idicula et al. [15] fabricated randomly oriented intimately
mixed short banana and sisal hybrid fiber-reinforced polyester composites and ana-
lyzed the dynamic and static mechanical properties. The major objective of this work
is to bring new classes of fibers under process and to develop an alternative method
toward the use of unconventional and recycling products. In this work, we are going
Mechanical Behaviour of Raavi and Pineapple Fibre-reinforced … 229
2.1 Materials
In this study, two natural fibers, namely Raavi fiber (ficusreligiosa) is extracted from
the sticks of the branches of peepal tree or bodhi tree by pealing the outer layer of
the sticks by mechanical means and Pineapple fiber (ananascomosus) is extracted
from the leaves of the Pineapple plant by mechanical means and polyester GP51
matrix was used to fabricate natural fiber-reinforced composites to evaluate the fiber
performance under different percentages of composition. The selected fibers are
from different region and they exhibit variability in their physical and mechanical
properties.
The natural fiber composite with 15% Raavi [Ficusreligiosa], 15% Pineapple
[Ananas Comosus], 69.5% polyester GP51 resin, 0.25% of MERP catalyst, and
0.25% of octane solution is kept as composition 1 and the natural fiber composite with
10% Pineapple [Ananas Comosus], 20% Raavi [Ficusreligiosa], 65.5% polyester
GP51 resin, 0.25% of MERP catalyst, 0.25% of octane solution is kept as composition
2 (Fig. 1).
Fig. 1 Pineapple 15%, Raavi 15% as composition 1 and Pineappl e10%, Raavi 20% as composition
2
230 J. Varun Siddharth et al.
Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy was used to determine the functional groups
in a molecule. The functional group exhibits its vibration by bending, stretching, and
waging at different frequencies.
FTIR Test with Raavi Fiber The functional groups present in the molecules of
Raavi fiber are observed by passing light at different frequencies through the speci-
men. By observing the graph, it is found that the transmittance of IR light is less in
functional group region then in finger print region. The stretching vibration with the
Mechanical Behaviour of Raavi and Pineapple Fibre-reinforced … 231
transmittance of 88% is obtained for the wave number of 2917.90; the obtained wave
number shows presence of strong alkane (C–H) group. The stretching vibration with
the transmittance of 65% is obtained for the wave number of 3285.88, the obtained
wave number shows the presence of strong and broad alcohol (O–H) group. The
values from 0 to 1800 are neglected since they come under finger print region. It is
observed that Raavi fiber has formaldehyde as its chemical compound. The results
are shown as graphical representation (Fig. 3).
FTIR Test with Pineapple Fiber The results are obtained by observing the graph;
it is found that the transmittance of IR light is less in functional group region then in
finger print region. The stretching vibration with the transmittance of 88% is obtained
for the wave number of 2915.33, and the obtained wave number shows presence of
strong alkane (C–H) group. The stretching vibration with the transmittance of 65%
is obtained for the wave number of 3299.17, and the obtained wave number shows
the presence of strong and broad alcohol (O–H) group. The values from 0 to 1800
are neglected since they come under finger print region. It is observed that Raavi
fiber has formaldehyde as its chemical compound.
The fabrication work was executed with the help of compression molding machine
by setting up the composite lamina. The compression molding machine is set up with
5–15 amps as current with the upper and lower die temperatures as 348 K and the
pressure of the hydraulic actuation system is maintained at 2 bar. The lamina plate is
set up with the dimensional specification of 3 mm as its thickness and the 300 mm
as its length and width is taken as a boundary parameter for the experiment, whose
total gross weight is said to be 450 g.
The prepared composite laminas are introduced to various test method in order to
attain the property and characteristics of the above said compositions. The properties
232 J. Varun Siddharth et al.
and the characteristics of the above said two compositions are compared with each
other in order to observe the changes in the composite behaviour, characteristics,
and properties with respect to change in composition, which is having similar pair
of materials with varying proportion of percentage for each and every material.
The tensile test is performed with the help of universal testing machine where the
alternate ends of the testing specimen are held to unidirectional moving supports. The
UTM with the composite specimen is integrated with the computer in order to attain
the results which are obtained through the universal testing machine. The specimen
for the tensile test is grooved using wood grooving machine from the lamina based
on the dimensional specification which is suggested as per ASTM D638 standard.
composite specimen is brittle in nature. Based on the visual observation of the graph,
we can note that the ultimate stress is attained at 20.1 MPa whose corresponding
strain percentage is 0.67 (Fig. 5).
Based on the visual observation of force to length graph, the composite specimen
has elongated up to the length of 0.68 mm. Since the composite specimen is brittle
in nature, the reduction of size along its cross-section is too small. The specimen
attains a maximum force of 753 N at a length of 0.68 mm and the specimen breaks
at 0.70 mm with a small drop in force of 725 N for the corresponding thickness of
3 mm.
The above given bar graph and table are obtained by conducting tensile test
between two different compositions. The results obtained through comparative anal-
ysis show that the strength and withstanding ability of the composite composition 1
are greater than that of composition 2 (Fig. 6; Table 2).
Fig. 6 Stress strain graph for flexural test in composition 1 and composition 2
The flexural test was conducted with the help universal testing machine by using
three-point bending method by replacing the default setting for tensile test.
Flexural Test Characterization of Composition 1 The results converged through
stress–strain graph show that the maximum force required to break the specimen is
31.67 N and the flexural strength attained by the specimen is 42.22 MPa, respectively.
The stress and strain at which the specimen breaks is 33 MPa and 2.80%, respectively.
Flexural Test Characterization of Composition 2 The results obtained through
stress-strain graph show that the maximum force required to break the specimen is
32.67 N and the flexural strength attained by the specimen is 43.56 MPa, respec-
tively. The stress and strain at which the specimen breaks is 34.95 MPa and 1.85%,
respectively.
Comparative Analysis of Flexural Test Characteristics The table which is repre-
sented below is obtained by conducting flexural test between two different compo-
sitions. The results obtained through comparative analysis show that the maximum
force, flexural strength, and breaking stress are greater in composition 1 and the
breaking strain is greater in composition 2.
The impact test is done with the help of impact testing machine as per the ASTM
standard D256. The stress–strain curve of the composite specimen pointed that the
specimen is exhibiting an brittle nature.
Mechanical Behaviour of Raavi and Pineapple Fibre-reinforced … 235
The fractured surface of the Raavi and Pineapple fiber-reinforced composite was
analyzed using scanning electron micro graphs. Observed SEM images show the
fiber and resin compatibility in natural fiber polymer composites. The SEM image of
tensile fractured specimen showed uniform crack propagation due to better mixing
of the fiber and matrix. The fiber segregation was found to be good in the fractured
region due to the improvement in compatibility between the fiber and resin matrix.
4 Conclusion
References
1. Van Vuure AW, Baets J, Wouters K, Hendrickx K (2015) Compressive properties of natural
fibre composites. Mater Lett 149:138–140
2. Chegdani F, El Mansori M (2018) Friction scale effect in drilling natural fiber composites.
Tribol Int 119:622–630
3. Vitale JP, Francucci G, Xiong J, Stocchi A (2017) Failure mode maps of natural and synthetic
fiber reinforced composite sandwich panels. Compos A Appl Sci Manuf 94:217–225
4. Torres JP, Vandi LJ, Veidt M, Heitzmann MT (2017) The mechanical properties of natural fibre
composite laminates: a statistical study. Compos A Appl Sci Manuf 98:99–104
5. Corona A, Madsen B, Hauschild MZ, Birkved M (2016) Natural fibre selection for composite
eco-design. CIRP Ann Manuf Technol 65(1):13–16
6. Song Z, Li S, Lei J, Noble RL, Wang Z (2018) Dynamic tensile properties of ROP/OCC natural
hybrid fibers reinforced composites. Compos Struct 185:600–606
7. Fan M, Naughton A (2016) Mechanisms of thermal decomposition of natural fibre composites.
Compos B Eng 88:1–10
8. Pornwannachai W, Ebdon JR, Kandola BK (2018) Fire-resistant natural fibre-reinforced
composites from flame retarded textiles. Polym Degradation Stab
9. Mejri M, Toubal L, Cuillière JC, François V (2018) Hygrothermal aging effects on mechanical
and fatigue behaviors of a short-natural-fiber-reinforced composite. Int J Fatigue 108:96–108
10. Chegdani F, El Mansori M (2018) Mechanics of material removal when cutting natural fiber
reinforced thermoplastic composites. Polym Testing 67:275–283
11. Vignesh G. Mechanical characterization of kenaf-hair reinforced hybrid composite
12. Choudhry S, Pandey B (2012) Mechanical behaviour of polypropylene and human hair fibres
and polypropylene reinforced polymeric composites. Int J Mech Ind Eng 2(1):118–121
13. Pothan LA, Oommen Z, Thomas S (2003) Dynamic mechanical analysis of banana fiber
reinforced polyester composites. Compos Sci Technol 63(2):283–293
14. Rana AK, Mandal A, Bandyopadhyay S (2003) Short jute fiber reinforced polypropylene
composites: effect of compatibiliser, impact modifier and fiber loading. Compos Sci Technol
63(6):801–806
15. Idicula M, Malhotra SK, Joseph K, Thomas S (2005) Dynamic mechanical analysis of randomly
oriented intimately mixed short banana/sisal hybrid fibre reinforced polyester composites.
Compos Sci Technol 65(7–8):1077–1087
Carbon Fiber Surface Treatment
for Enhanced Interfacial Properties:
A Review
Abstract Pristine carbon fibers are intrinsically brittle, fuzzy, non-polar and possess
graphite-based planes which are highly crystallized. These characteristics are limit-
ing to effective interfacial bonding between fiber and matrix. Therefore, the ability to
modify the surface of carbon fibers present an avenue for enhancing surface function-
alities and increasing surface energy which results in improved interfacial properties
(wettability) and mechanical properties. In this paper, the current novel techniques
for carbon fiber surface treatment are presented. The current direction of the field
is reviewed, and emerging technologies are discussed. The comparative study con-
ducted provides insight for optimal selection of treatment approaches depending on
the requirement.
1 Introduction
Carbon fiber (CF) reinforced composites (CFRPs) are known to be very reliable and
find applications in varying multidisciplinary fields such as the aerospace, automo-
tive and sports equipment manufacturing industries as a result of the excellent and
superior mechanical strength and physical (lightweight) properties [1]. Unmodified
or virgin carbon fiber, however, has some limitations which include a very moderately
active specific surface area, non-polar properties and chemically inert characteristic,
low lipophobic surface, low energy surface and the inherently low weak interfacial
adhesion characteristic of the fibers which limits the efficient transfer of stresses
from the resin to the carbon fiber that consequently affects the mechanical integrity
of the fabricated composite [2]. Pristine carbon fibers are intrinsically brittle, fuzzy,
non-polar and possess graphite-based planes which are highly crystallized. These
characteristics are limiting to effective interfacial bonding between fiber and matrix
[3]. As a result, many CFRPs tend to demonstrate a propensity for failure within
the fiber-matrix interface due to the relatively weak bonding and eventually results
in the pullout effect which exposes the fiber from the matrix (pullout effect). This
phenomenon compromises the mechanical integrity of the composite material like
the interlaminar shear stress (ILSS).
Over a couple of decades, several techniques for modifying the surface of carbon
fibers to improve the interfacial properties of fabricated composites, include plasma
treatment [4], sizing [1], oxidation treatment [5], graphene oxide modification [6]
coating [7], high energy irradiation [8], chemical grafting [9], electrophoretic depo-
sition (EPD) [10], etc. All the above-stated methods have their own inherent insuffi-
ciencies. An optimal approach to fiber surface treatment is very critical to ensuring
that the right amount of fiber-matrix interface bonding is obtained to prevent issues of
extreme bonding which can result in brittleness [11]. Therefore, a carefully controlled
interface is vital to ensuring that the requisite amount is transferred from the matrix
to fiber reinforcements which ameliorate the induced internal stress concentrations
and also enhance the mechanical properties [12].
The ability to modify the surface characteristics of carbon fiber provides a pow-
erful optimization tool for enhancing the fiber-matrix adhesion properties of carbon
fiber reinforced polymer composites. Therefore, in this study, a thorough review of
the approach currently adopted for the modification of carbon fiber surface is pre-
sented. Comparison of the different methods is discussed, and the advantages and
disadvantages also reported.
between carbon fiber reinforcement and the matrix is a primary focus for manufac-
turers [15]. Therefore, sizing agents are designed to promote increased fiber-matrix
interlocking, enhanced wettability and improve the density of oxygen-containing
functional groups on the surface of the fiber. To enhance the interfacial adhesion
properties of fiber and matrix, nanoparticle inclusions in sizing agents have been the
most preferred approach; the nanoparticles explored include carbon nanotubes [16],
titanium oxide [17], graphene oxide [18] and zirconium dioxide [15].
Polyurethanes (PU) have also emerged as highly suitable sizing agents because
of advantages such as excellent mechanical properties (strength and toughness), low
viscosity, excellent abrasion resistance, outstanding interlocking adhesion with sev-
eral matrices, cost-efficient and environmentally sustainable [19, 20]. The application
of PUs for sizing has not been thoroughly explored as only a few publications are
available.
The most industrially preferred approach for surface modification is sizing treat-
ment methods and the reasons include simplicity and ease of process operation,
moderate environmental impact, flexibility in tunability and controllability process
is continuous and seamlessly incorporates into the overall manufacture of carbon
fibers [21].
1.3 Electro-grafting/polymerization
1.4 Grafting
Laser radiation treatment has also been successfully adapted for enhancing the fiber-
matrix bond while additionally improving the mechanical properties of the matrix.
In a study by Fischera et al. [40], CO2 and UV lasers were tested for carbon fiber
surface treatment which showed that both lasers equally improved the interfacial
bond strength between the reinforcement and matrix.
1.6 Coating
Most of the carbon fiber surface modification techniques for the inclusion of
nanoscale materials are not environmentally friendly or green as toxic chemicals
and catalysts are required [45]. In contrast, the layer-by-layer (LbL) self-assembly
technique is generally considered a green approach because it is environmentally
friendly, high flexibility for optimization and tuning, moderate processing condi-
tions and excellent repeatability [45]. This approach basically operates on a cycli-
cally based concept where alternating film deposition of materials that are oppositely
charged takes place.
The two main limitations of untreated carbon fiber are the reduced interfacial adhe-
sion of fiber and matrix and relatively high conductivity which is possibly detrimental
to electric machines. Most of the available treatment methods for surface modifica-
tion can resolve the interfacial adhesion issue; however, covalent functionalization
is one of the few methods capable of decreasing carbon fiber conductivity as pre-
sented in the study by [46]. They achieved CF surface modification via covalent
functionalization involving electrochemical reduction of phenyl-diazo species.
Microwave irradiation is another emerging tool for modifying the surface of carbon
fiber made possible by carbon fiber’s outstanding microwave absorbability. Wang
et al. [47] developed a microwave irradiation method that was carried out in air
atmosphere, however, some drawbacks reported included some level of burnout and
degradation. A study by [48], avoided the limitations by conducting the irradiation
via immersion of the carbon fiber. The microwave etching process resulted in large
formation oxygen-containing groups on the surface of the carbon fibers.
of 48% and 83% for the ILSS and and surface energy, improved
IFSS, respectively fiber-matrix interlocking and
interface chemical bonding
(continued)
245
Table 1 (continued)
246
3 Conclusion
An exhaustive review of the current methods for carbon fiber surface treatment has
been conducted. A comparison of the techniques is carried out and tabulated. The
advantages and disadvantages of the methods are also presented. All the methods
still require further research and tuning to achieve optimal conditions. The chemical
approaches are efficient but are mostly not environmentally friendly. It is envis-
aged that as technology advances more environmentally sensitive approaches will
be developed.
References
7. Li F, Liu Y, Qu C-B, Xiao H-M, Hua Y, Sui GX, Fu S-Y (2015) Enhanced mechanical properties
of short carbon fiber reinforced polyethersulfone composites by graphene oxide coating. Polym
(Guildf) 59:155–165. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.POLYMER.2014.12.067
8. Tiwari S, Bijwe J (2014) Surface treatment of carbon fibers—a review. Procedia Technol
14:505–512. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.protcy.2014.08.064
9. Gao B, Zhang R, He M, Sun L, Wang C, Liu L, Zhao L, Cui H, Cao A (2016) Effect of a mul-
tiscale reinforcement by carbon fiber surface treatment with graphene oxide/carbon nanotubes
on the mechanical properties of reinforced carbon/carbon composites. Compos Part A Appl
Sci Manuf 90:433–440. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesa.2016.08.012
10. Sui X, Shi J, Yao H, Xu Z, Chen L, Li X, Ma M, Kuang L, Fu H, Deng H (2017) Interfacial and
fatigue-resistant synergetic enhancement of carbon fiber/epoxy hierarchical composites via an
electrophoresis deposited carbon nanotube-toughened transition layer. Compos Part A Appl
Sci Manuf 92:134–144. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.COMPOSITESA.2016.11.004
11. Morgan P (2005) Carbon fibers and their composites. Taylor & Francis. https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.tube.2011.07.006
12. Paul R, Dai L (2018) Interfacial aspects of carbon composites. https://www.tandfonline.com/
doi/full/10.1080/09276440.2018.1439632. https://doi.org/10.1080/09276440.2018.1439632
13. Sharma M, Gao S Mäder E, Sharma H, Wei LY, Bijwe J (2014) Carbon fiber surfaces and com-
posite interphases. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0266353814002358.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compscitech.2014.07.005
14. Drzal LT, Rich MJ, Koenig MF, Lloyd PF (1983) Adhesion of graphite fibers to epoxy matrices:
II. The effect of fiber finish. J Adhes 16:3–152. https://doi.org/10.1080/00218468308074911
15. Wu Q, Zhao R, Ma Q, Zhu J (2018) Effects of degree of chemical interaction between carbon
fibers and surface sizing on interfacial properties of epoxy composites. Compos Sci Technol
163:34–40. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compscitech.2018.05.013
16. Kamae T, Drzal LT (2012) Carbon fiber/epoxy composite property enhancement through incor-
poration of carbon nanotubes at the fiber-matrix interphase—Part I: The development of carbon
nanotube coated carbon fibers and the evaluation of their adhesion. Compos Part A Appl Sci
Manuf 43:1569–1577. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesa.2012.02.016
17. Qian J, Wu J, Liu X, Zhuang Q, Han Z (2013) Improvement of interfacial shear strengths
of polybenzobisoxazole fiber/epoxy resin composite by n-TiO2 coating. J Appl Polym Sci
127:2990–2995. https://doi.org/10.1002/app.37970
18. Qin W, Vautard F, Drzal LT, Yu J (2015) Mechanical and electrical properties of carbon fiber
composites with incorporation of graphene nanoplatelets at the fiber-matrix interphase. Compos
Part B Eng 69:335–341. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesb.2014.10.014
19. Loos MR, Yang J, Feke DL, Manas-Zloczower I, Unal S, Younes U (2013) Enhancement
of fatigue life of polyurethane composites containing carbon nanotubes. Compos Part B Eng
44:740–744. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.COMPOSITESB.2012.01.038
20. Pokharel P, Lee DS (2014) High performance polyurethane nanocomposite films prepared from
a masterbatch of graphene oxide in polyether polyol. Chem Eng J 253:356–365. https://doi.
org/10.1016/J.CEJ.2014.05.046
21. Wang Z, Huang X, Xian G, Li H (2016) Effects of surface treatment of carbon fiber: Tensile
property, surface characteristics, and bonding to epoxy. Polym Compos 37:2921–2932. https://
doi.org/10.1002/pc.23489
22. Baghery Borooj M, Mousavi Shoushtari A, Nosratian Sabet E, Haji A (2016) Influence of
oxygen plasma treatment parameters on the properties of carbon fiber. J Adhes Sci Technol
30:2372–2382. https://doi.org/10.1080/01694243.2016.1182833
23. Moosburger-Will J, Jäger J, Strauch J, Bauer M, Strobl S, Linscheid FF, Horn S (2017) Inter-
phase formation and fiber matrix adhesion in carbon fiber reinforced epoxy resin: influence
of carbon fiber surface chemistry. Compos Interfaces 24:691–710. https://doi.org/10.1080/
09276440.2017.1267513
24. Baghery Borooj M, Mousavi Shoushtari A, Haji A, Nosratian Sabet E (2016) Optimization of
plasma treatment variables for the improvement of carbon fibres/epoxy composite performance
by response surface methodology. Compos Sci Technol 128:215–221. https://doi.org/10.1016/
j.compscitech.2016.03.020
250 K. Anane-Fenin et al.
25. Chang T (1999) Plasma surface treatment in composites manufacturing. J Ind Technol 15:1–7
26. Farrow GJ, Jones C (1994) The effect of low power nitrogen plasma treatment of carbon fibres
on the interfacial shear strength of carbon fibre/epoxy composites. J Adhes 45:29–42. https://
doi.org/10.1080/00218469408026627
27. Corujeira Gallo S, Charitidis C, Dong H (2017) Surface functionalization of carbon fibers with
active screen plasma. J Vac Sci Technol A Vac Surf Film 35:021404. https://doi.org/10.1116/
1.4974913
28. Jones C, Sammann E (1990) The effect of low power plasmas on carbon fibre surfaces. Carbon
N Y 28:509–514. https://doi.org/10.1016/0008-6223(90)90046-2
29. Jang BZ (1992) Control of interfacial adhesion in continuous carbon and kevlar fiber rein-
forced polymer composites. Compos Sci Technol 44:333–349. https://doi.org/10.1016/0266-
3538(92)90070-J
30. Moosburger-Will J, Lachner E, Löffler M, Kunzmann C, Greisel M, Ruhland K, Horn S (2018)
Adhesion of carbon fibers to amine hardened epoxy resin: influence of ammonia plasma func-
tionalization of carbon fibers. Appl Surf Sci 453:141–152. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apsusc.
2018.05.057
31. Bousquet A, Awada H, Hiorns RC, Dagron-Lartigau C, Billon L (2014) Conjugated-polymer
grafting on inorganic and organic substrates: a new trend in organic electronic mate-
rials. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0079670014000380. https://doi.org/
10.1016/j.progpolymsci.2014.03.003
32. Subramanian RV, Jakubowski JJ (1978) Electropolymerization on graphite fibers. Polym Eng
Sci 18:590–600. https://doi.org/10.1002/pen.760180708
33. Harris B, Braddell OG, Almond DP, Lefebvre C, Verbist J (1993) Study of carbon fibre surface
treatments by dynamic mechanical analysis. J Mater Sci 28:3353–3366. https://doi.org/10.
1007/BF00354259
34. Kainourgios P, Kartsonakis IA, Dragatogiannis DA, Koumoulos EP, Goulis P, Charitidis CA
(2017) Electrochemical surface functionalization of carbon fibers for chemical affinity improve-
ment with epoxy resins. Appl Surf Sci 416:593–604. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apsusc.2017.
04.214
35. Semitekolos D, Kainourgios P, Jones C, Rana A, Koumoulos EP, Charitidis CA (2018)
Advanced carbon fibre composites via poly methacrylic acid surface treatment; surface analy-
sis and mechanical properties investigation. Compos Part B Eng 155:237–243. https://doi.org/
10.1016/j.compositesb.2018.08.027
36. Luo W, Zhang B, Zou H, Liang M, Chen Y (2017) Enhanced interfacial adhesion between
polypropylene and carbon fiber by graphene oxide/polyethyleneimine coating. J Ind Eng Chem
51:129–139. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jiec.2017.02.024
37. Zhang RL, Gao B, Ma QH, Zhang J, Cui HZ, Liu L (2016) Directly grafting graphene oxide
onto carbon fiber and the effect on the mechanical properties of carbon fiber composites. Mater
Des 93:364–369. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2016.01.003
38. Steurer P, Wissert R, Thomann R, Mülhaupt R (2009) Functionalized graphenes and ther-
moplastic nanocomposites based upon expanded graphite oxide. Macromol Rapid Commun
30:316–327. https://doi.org/10.1002/marc.200800754
39. Wu Y, Lin X, Shen X, Sun X, Liu X, Wang Z, Kim JK (2015) Exceptional dielectric properties
of chlorine-doped graphene oxide/poly (vinylidene fluoride) nanocomposites. Carbon N Y
89:102–112. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2015.02.074
40. Fischer F, Kreling S, Jäschke P, Frauenhofer M, Kracht D, Dilger K (2012) Laser surface pre-
treatment of CFRP for adhesive bonding in consideration of the absorption behaviour. J Adhes
88:350–363. https://doi.org/10.1080/00218464.2012.660042
41. Ran B, Jing C, Yang C, Li X, Li Y (2018) Synthesis of efficient bacterial adhesion-resistant
coatings by one-step polydopamine-assisted deposition of branched polyethylenimine-g-
poly(sulfobetaine methacrylate) copolymers. Appl Surf Sci 450:77–84. https://doi.org/10.
1016/J.APSUSC.2018.04.184
42. Xiong S, Wang Y, Zhu J, Yu J, Hu Z (2016) Poly(ε-caprolactone)-grafted polydopamine par-
ticles for biocomposites with near-infrared light triggered self-healing ability. Polym (Guildf).
84:328–335. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.POLYMER.2016.01.005
Carbon Fiber Surface Treatment for Enhanced Interfacial … 251
43. Kim HJ, Song JH (2019) Improvement in the mechanical properties of carbon and aramid
composites by fiber surface modification using polydopamine. Compos Part B Eng 160:31–36.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesb.2018.10.027
44. Merenda A, Ligneris E des, Sears K, Chaffraix T, Magniez K, Cornu D, Schütz JA, Dumée
LF (2016) Assessing the temporal stability of surface functional groups introduced by plasma
treatments on the outer shells of carbon nanotubes. Sci Rep 6:31565. https://doi.org/10.1038/
srep31565
45. Fu J, Zhang M, Jin L, Liu L, Li N, Shang L, Li M, Xiao L, Ao Y (2019) Enhancing interfacial
properties of carbon fibers reinforced epoxy composites via Layer-by-Layer self assembly
GO/SiO2 multilayers films on carbon fibers surface. Appl Surf Sci 470:543–554. https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.apsusc.2018.11.168
46. Beggs KM, Randall JD, Servinis L, Krajewski A, Denning R, Henderson LC (2018) Increasing
the resistivity and IFSS of unsized carbon fibre by covalent surface modification. React Funct
Polym 129:123–128. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.reactfunctpolym.2017.06.016
47. Wang B, Duan Y, Zhang J, Zhao X (2016) Microwave radiation effects on carbon fibres interfa-
cial performance. Compos Part B Eng 99:398–406. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.COMPOSITESB.
2016.06.032
48. Yuan JM, Fan ZF, Yang QC, Li W, Wu ZJ (2018) Surface modification of carbon fibers by
microwave etching for epoxy resin composite. Compos Sci Technol 164:222–228. https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.compscitech.2018.05.043
49. Lee ES, Lee CH, Chun YS, Han CJ, Lim DS (2017) Effect of hydrogen plasma-mediated surface
modification of carbon fibers on the mechanical properties of carbon-fiber-reinforced polyether-
imide composites. Compos Part B Eng 116:451–458. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesb.
2016.10.088
50. Montes-Morán MA, Martínez-Alonso A, Tascón JMD, Paiva MC, Bernardo CA (2001) Effects
of plasma oxidation on the surface and interfacial properties of carbon fibres/polycarbonate
composites. Carbon N Y 39:1057–1068. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0008-6223(00)00220-7
51. Fu YF, Xu K, Li J, Sun ZY, Zhang FQ, Chen DM (2012) The influence of plasma surface
treatment of carbon fibers on the interfacial adhesion properties of UHMWPE composite.
Polym Plast Technol Eng 51:273–276. https://doi.org/10.1080/03602559.2011.617406
52. Reitz V, Meinhard D, Ruck S, Riegel H, Knoblauch V (2017) A comparison of IR- and UV-laser
pretreatment to increase the bonding strength of adhesively joined aluminum/CFRP compo-
nents. Compos Part A Appl Sci Manuf 96:18–27. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.COMPOSITESA.
2017.02.014
53. Encinas N, Oakley BR, Belcher MA, Blohowiak KY, Dillingham RG, Abenojar J, Martínez
MA (2014) Surface modification of aircraft used composites for adhesive bonding. Int J Adhes
Adhes 50:157–163. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.IJADHADH.2014.01.004
54. Wetzel M, Holtmannspötter J, Gudladt H-J, Czarnecki JV (2013) Sensitivity of double can-
tilever beam test to surface contamination and surface pretreatment. Int J Adhes Adhes
46:114–121. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.IJADHADH.2013.06.002
55. Gude MR, Prolongo SG, Ureña A (2012) Adhesive bonding of carbon fibre/epoxy laminates:
correlation between surface and mechanical properties. Surf Coatings Technol 207:602–607.
https://doi.org/10.1016/J.SURFCOAT.2012.07.085
56. Hui C, Qingyu C, Jing W, Xiaohong X, Hongbo L, Zhanjun L (2018) Interfacial enhancement
of carbon fiber/nylon 12 composites by grafting nylon 6 to the surface of carbon fiber. Appl
Surf Sci 441:538–545. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apsusc.2018.01.158
Preparation and Mechanical Property
Analysis of Polymer Matrix Composite
Containing Rice Husk and Saw Dust
Keywords Polymer matrix composite · Saw dust · Rice husk · Hardness · Tensile
strength
1 Introduction
biodegradable and contain no toxic products. Thus, they are frequently inserted in
polymer matrix to form fiber-reinforced PMCs. Till date, commonly used natural
fibers employed in PMCs are flax fiber, jute, date palm leaf fiber, hemp, sisal, coir,
cotton, saw dust, rice husk, etc [2].
Yang et al. [3] used rice husk (RH) flour as filler material in preparing thermo-
plastic composite. The authors did four levels of filler loading and tested the mor-
phology and mechanical properties of the developed composites. It was found that
with increase of filler loading, tensile strengths of the composite decreased, whereas
tensile modulus increased. Chen et al. [4] prepared high loading of RH containing
recycled thermoplastic green composites. The authors found that the fire-retardancy
and mechanical properties of the composites were greatly increased with the usage
of rice husk at higher loadings. However, it adversely affected the dimensional sta-
bility of the composite. Monteiro et al. [5] studied the effects of RH ash and graphite
as fillers separately in polypropylene (PP)-based composites. A good bonding of
aforementioned fillers in the polymeric matrix was found.
Xu et al. [6] prepared perforated high-density polyethylene-based composites
made from recycled rubber and fiber-board sawdust (SD) with different loadings
(18, 40 and 42%) for sound performance testing. It was found that the acoustic prop-
erties of the prepared composite depended on hole-size, cavity depth and perforation
ratio. Suarez et al. [7] studied the tensile properties plus the fracture phenomenon of
sawdust containing polypropylene (PP) or PP together with maleated PP composites.
The tensile strength of the composites containing increased amount of MAPP to the
PP matrix was found to be enhanced and also, they exhibited improved bonding of
sawdust to the PP matrix.
From the above literature survey, it can be seen that the natural fibers, namely rice
husk or saw dust have been proved as a good source of filler materials in preparing
polymer matrix composites. However, till date, the combination of both aforemen-
tioned natural products has not been utilized in preparing a composite material.
Thus, the present work focuses on using both RH and SD as reinforcing materials
for developing epoxy resin base composites.
The rice husk obtained from the winnowing process was sieved in order to remove
the impurities from it. Saw dust was obtained from the carpentry shop. The epoxy
resin used in the present study was HSC-9221 and the hardener used was EH-411.
Silica powder was also used along with resin and hardener to act as support material
at high temperatures. The composites were made using a compression mold and
made up of mild steel.
First, the volume fraction of fibers (RH & SD) and resin was calculated. The
volume fraction of fibers was equally divided for RH & SD. Then, the epoxy and
Preparation and Mechanical Property Analysis of Polymer Matrix … 255
hardener were mixed in 2:1 ratio and the silica powder was added in such a manner
that it would be 33% of epoxy resin. Composites containing 30, 35, 40 and 45% fiber
volume fractions were made, as shown in Fig. 1 and they were coded as Type 1, 2,
3 and 4, respectively.
Then, the specimens were prepared for conducting tensile tests from each of the
composite types as shown in Fig. 2. The tensile test was performed on panel controlled
digital universal testing machine (UTM) with hydraulic open type grip (Fig. 3). The
sample hardness was measured at different positions using a digital microhardness
tester. The surface roughness of the composites was measured using Taylor Hobson
Talysurf surface roughness tester (shown in Fig. 4). Several readings were taken by
moving the stylus tip on the surface of the workpiece, and finally, the average of the
surface roughness readings of each of the composite types were computed for the
sake of comparison.
Fig. 1 Composites containing variable volume fractions of fibers a 30%, b 35%, c 40% and d 45%
The tensile strengths of the composites of Types I, II, III and IV are shown in Fig. 5
and were found to be 51.7, 52.4, 57.7 and 53.7 MPa, respectively. Figure 5 depicts
the tensile test results of each type of composites. It is seen that the tensile strengths
of the composites increase with increase in filler content from 30 to 40 wt%, and
thereafter, it decreases. The average microhardness test results of all composite types
are depicted in Table 1. It is very obvious from the table that there is an increasing
trend of hardness values with increase in filler percent from 30 to 45 wt%, and Type
IV composite containing 45% filler material possessed maximum Vicker’s hardness
of 9.1 HV (Fig. 6), whereas average hardness value is 8.86 HV.
From the above results obtained for tensile strength and hardness tests, it is evi-
dent that up to 40 wt% of fillers loading, both the tensile strength and hardness of
the composites increased. The Type III composite containing 40% fibers exhibited
maximum tensile strength among all composite types because of highest interfacial
adhesion between the fiber and the matrix which led to efficient load transfer between
them. With rise in fiber content, the reinforcement in the matrix increases causing
increase in hardness of the composites.
It is found that at 45 wt% filler content, the tensile strength of the composite
decreased, whereas its microhardness is increased. The reason behind decline in
tensile strength may be due to the weak chemical reaction at the interface to shift
Preparation and Mechanical Property Analysis of Polymer Matrix … 257
Fig. 5 Tensile test results of a Type I, b Type II, c Type III, d Type IV composite specimen
the tensile stress amid the matrix and the particulates. Also, there is a possibility of
non-uniform distribution of reinforcing fillers in the matrix due to their increased
wt. percent and these fillers would have somewhere agglomerated leading to delam-
ination. Hardness test is done by pressing the filler particles and the epoxy matrix
together so that both have a tight grip which facilitates easy transfer of pressure,
causing increase in hardness of the composite.
The results of surface texture of all the prepared composites are depicted in Table 2.
258 S. Pattnaik et al.
It is seen that Type II composite containing 35% filler material showed maximum
surface finish as regards to others, due to uniform distribution of fillers in the matrix.
During the manufacture of the composites, few defects were detected. Few cavities
were seen on the surface of the composite because of the sliding of the upper plate
at the time of loading. Overflow of polymer also took place due to its high percent
in the composition. A line was formed on one side of the composite due to slipping
of the Mylar sheet.
4 Conclusions
From all the different types of tests performed on the fiber-reinforced epoxy compos-
ites containing saw dust and rice husk, final results are accomplished. The following
observations are concluded from the present investigation:
• A good dispersibility of both sawdust and rice husk in the epoxy matrix had
enhanced the tensile strength, hardness and surface texture of the composites.
Preparation and Mechanical Property Analysis of Polymer Matrix … 259
• 40% of reinforcing fillers in the epoxy matrix gave the overall best results among
all the prepared and tested composites.
• A very high surface finish of the composite can be obtained by careful handling
of the specimen during the process.
References
1. Agarwal BD, Broutman LJ (1980) Analysis and performance of fiber composites. Wiley, New
York, pp 3–12
2. Balakrishnan P, John MJ, Pothen L, Sreekala MS, Thomas S (2016) Natural fiber and polymer
matrix composites and their applications in aerospace engineering. Adv Compos Mater Aerosp
Eng. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-100037-3.00012-2
3. Yang HS, Kim HJ, Son J, Park HJ, Lee BJ, Hwang TS (2004) Rice-husk flour filled polypropylene
composites: mechanical and morphological study. Compos Struct 63:305–3012
4. Chen RS, Ahmad S, Gan S, Tarawneh MA (2019) High loading rice husk green composites:
dimensional stability, tensile behavior and prediction, and combustion properties. J Thermoplast
Compos Mater. https://doi.org/10.1177/0892705718815536
5. Monteiro AS, Barreira DAS, Bartolomei SS, Rene R. Oliveira and Esperidiana Augusta Barreto
de Moura, Comparative Study of the Use of Rice
6. Xu X, Wang H, Sun Y, Han J, Huang R, Zhan X (2018) Sound absorbing properties of perforated
composite panels of recycled rubber, fiberboard sawdust, and high density polyethylene. J Clean
Prod. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2018.03.174
7. Suarez JCM, Coutinho FMB, Sydenstricker TH (2003) SEM studies of tensile fracture surfaces
of polypropylene-sawdust composites. Polym Test 22:819–824
Investigation of the Mechanical
Properties of Polyamide 6 Hybrid
Nanocomposites with MWCNT
and Copper Nanoparticles
1 Introduction
The developments in the field of engineering and technology majorly depend on the
advancement of materials. Increasing demand for lightweight, strong and stiff struc-
ture has paved the way for the development of new materials. Composite materials
have played a vital role in the process of optimization in materials from the beginning
of the 1960s. Composite materials provide flexible designs and tailor-made materials
for an optimum design.
2 Experimental
2.1 Materials
The PA6 (commercial grade) material has been used in the present work. The multi-
walled carbon nanotube is purchased from Applied Sciences Innovations private
limited, Pune. The particle size of MWCNT is 25 nm and it is surface modified with
COOH. Carbon coated copper nanoparticles of size 20 nm were purchased from
Nanoshell Corporation, USA. A silane coupling agent γ -aminopropyltriethoxysilane
has been used to create bonding between the matrix material and reinforcements.
Investigation of the Mechanical Properties of Polyamide … 263
Fig. 1 Specimens for tensile, flexural and impact tests as per ASTM standards
The materials are kept in an oven at a temperature of 80 °C for four hours to remove
the moisture content present in them. The reinforcement materials are added to PA6
in weight percentage. The surface modified multi-walled carbon nanotube taken is
0.25 wt% and the carbon coated copper nanoparticles taken are 0.2, 0.4 and 0.6 wt%
with PA6. The materials are blended in a co-rotating twin-screw extruder with a
screw diameter of 25 mm and the rotating speed of the screw is kept at 180 rpm.
The operating temperature is 250 °C. The blended material for each composition is
pelletized in a pelletizer.
The blended composite mixture is then injection moulded using the MACI-
FOLD injection moulding machine. The barrel temperature of the injection moulding
machine is 290 °C and 10 MPa pressure. The specimens for the tensile, flexural and
impact tests were prepared as per ASTM standards. Figure 1 shows the specimens
prepared for the testing.
The operating temperature has been selected based on the melting point of the
matrix material, whereas the screw diameter is kept constant. The rotating speed of
the screw and operating pressure has been selected with reference to the machine
catalogue depends on the matrix material. These parameters ensure proper blending
of reinforcements with the matrix material [10].
An XRD analysis [11] was employed to identify the dispersion of MWCNT and
copper nanoparticles present in the matrix material PA6. X-ray diffraction analyses
were performed on the prepared specimens using a Philips X-ray diffraction instru-
264 T. Anand and T. Senthilvelan
ment with a radiation source of Cu-k-β using 30 kV and 100 mA. A step size of 0.02
degree, scan rate of 2 degree per minute and continuous scan mode are the parameters
used for the analysis.
An atomic force microscope has been widely used for viewing the surface topology
of the polymer composites. It is also applied to study the dispersion of the nano-
reinforcements in the matrix material. AFM images were taken using the NTMDT
atomic force microscope, Ireland. The frequency range is 5 MHz and the resolution
of the atomic force microscope is 0.01 nm.
The tensile test has been conducted in the specimen made as per ASTM D638(Type 1)
with size 165 × 13 × 3 using the INSTRAN 3382, 100 KN universal testing machine
with available load cells 100 N, 1 KN and 10 KN. The flexural test is conducted in
the specimens made as per ASTM D 790 with size 127 × 12.7 × 6.4 mm using the
AUTOGRAPH AG-IS 50 KN universal testing machine with the available range of
loads 0.5,1,2.5,5,10,25 and 50 KN. The impact test is conducted in the specimen
made as per ASTM D256 with size 63.5 × 12.7 × 6.4 mm using the izod impact
testing machine [12]. A notch was provided on the impact test specimen with a depth
of 2, 450 and 0.25 mm end radius. Five similar samples were used for each test
and the average values are considered for the analysis. Figure 1 shows the prepared
specimens for the tensile, flexural and impact tests as per ASTM standards.
74
Hardness (Shore-D)
PA6 + 0.25
72 %MWCNT + 0.2% PA6 +0.25 %
nano Cu PA6 +0.25 %
70 MWCNT + 0.6%
MWCNT + 0.4%
nano Cu
nano Cu
68
PA6
66
64
0 0.2 0.4 0.6
% of Nano Cu Reinforcement
The stress-strain behaviour [13] of PA6 and PA6 composites with 0.25 wt%
MWCNT and 0.2, 0.4 and 0.6 wt% of copper nanoparticles are shown in Fig. 3.
The stress value increases linearly within the elastic limit, beyond which the
strain increases rapidly for a small stress value. The stress-strain behaviour of PA6
nanocomposites was more or less similar to that of virgin PA6.
Figure 4 shows the tensile modulus of PA6 and its composites. The tensile modulus
of PA6 was increased for various proportions of reinforcements. The nanofillers
dispersed evenly in the matrix material and created a strong interaction between the
matrix material and reinforcements [14].
266 T. Anand and T. Senthilvelan
PA 6
60
PA6,0.25% MWCNT,0.2
50 %nano Cu
Stress (Mpa)
PA6,0.25% MWCNT,
40 0.4% nano Cu
PA6,0.25%
30 MWCNT,0.6% nano Cu
20
10
0
30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300 330 360
Strain (%)
600
Tensile Modulus, MPa
500
400
300
200
100
0
PA 6 PA6 + 0.25 PA6 + 0.25 PA6 + 0.25
%MWCNT +0.2 %MWCNT +0.4 %MWCNT +0.6
% nano Cu % nano Cu % nano Cu
The tensile, flexural and impact strength and percentage of elongation at break
for PA6, PA6 with MWCNT and PA6 with MWCNT and various proportions of
copper nanoparticles (0.2, 0.4 and 0.6%) are depicted in Fig. 5a–d. The addition
of MWCNT and copper nanoparticles with PA6 increased the tensile, flexural and
impact strengths. PA6 with 0.25 wt% MWCNT and 0.6 wt% copper nanoparticles
showed better mechanical properties than the other proportions. The deformability
of PA6 nanocomposites decreases due to the reinforcement materials thus reducing
the elongation at break [15].
Figure 6 shows the X-ray diffraction pattern of PA6 nanocomposites with various
proportions of nano-reinforcements (PA6, 0.25 wt% MWCNT and 0.2 wt% Nano-
Cu, PA6, 0.25 wt% MWCNT and 0.4 wt% Nano-Cu, PA6, 0.25 wt% MWCNT and
0.6 wt% Nano-Cu). The d-spacing was calculated by analysing the peaks of the XRD
patterns using Bragg’s law nλ = 2dsinθ , where θ is the scattering angle, n is a positive
integer and λ is the wavelength of the incident wave and d is the interplanar distance
[16]. An X-ray with a wave length of 1.54 A is used. The XRD pattern shows that
PA6, MWCNT and nano-copper composites have diffraction peaks at 2θ = 21.680
and 43.40 corresponding to a d-spacing of 4.09 and 2.08 A.
The dispersion of nano-copper and multi-walled carbon nanotubes reinforced in
different proportions with PA6 is studied by viewing the structure of PA6 nanohybrid
Investigation of the Mechanical Properties of Polyamide … 267
40
20
0
PA 6 PA6 + 0.25 PA6 + 0.25 PA6 + 0.25
%MWCNT +0.2 %MWCNT +0.4 %MWCNT +0.6
% nano Cu % nano Cu % nano Cu
(a)
Flexural Strength, MPa
50
40
30
20
10
0
PA 6 PA6 + 0.25 PA6 + 0.25 PA6 + 0.25
%MWCNT +0.2 % %MWCNT +0.4 % %MWCNT +0.6 %
nano Cu nano Cu nano Cu
(b)
Impact Strength, J/m
15000
10000
5000
0
PA 6 PA6 + 0.25 PA6 + 0.25 PA6 + 0.25
%MWCNT +0.2 %MWCNT +0.4 %MWCNT +0.6
% nano Cu % nano Cu % nano Cu
(c)
Elongation at break, %
400
300
200
100
0
PA6 PA6 + PA6 + PA6 +
0.25 % MWCNT + 0.25 % MWCNT +0.25 % MWCNT +
0.2 % nano Cu 0.4 % nano Cu 0.6 % nano Cu
(d)
Fig. 5 a Tensile, b flexural, c impact strengths, d elongation at break of PA6 and its composites
containing MWCNT and nano-copper
composites using AFM [17]. The height and phase images of the PA6 nanocomposites
with different proportions of reinforcement are shown in Fig. 7.
The copper nanoparticles and multi-walled carbon nanotubes are evenly dispersed
in the PA6 matrix with an average size of 61.49 nm. The microscopy images show,
Fig. 7a PA6 with 0.25% MWCNT and 0.2% nano-Cu consists of an average particle
size of 59.66 nm, Fig. 7b PA6 with 0.25% MWCNT and 0.4% nano-Cu consists of
an average particle size of 61.293 nm, Fig. 7c PA6 with 0.25% MWCNT and 0.6%
nano-Cu consists of an average particle size of 61.48 nm.
268 T. Anand and T. Senthilvelan
6000
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
0 10 20 30 40 50
2θ ( Degrees)
Fig. 6 X-Ray diffraction pattern of PA6 nano-hybrid composites with various proportions of nano-
Cu and MWCNT
To study the fracture behaviour, fractographs of PA6 and PA6 with MWCNT and
copper nanoparticles were taken using the scanning electron microscope. Figures 8
and 9 show the fracture surface of PA6 and PA6 composites after the tensile and
impact tests. The microstructure of the fractured surface of PA6 appeared rough in
Fig. 8a and PA6 with 0.25 wt% of MWCNT and 0.2 wt% of copper nanoparticles
show small spherical dimples in Fig. 8b indicates a ductile fracture. Figure 8c, d
shows smooth surface and some crazes were seen, indicating that the fracture was
brittle in nature [18].
Figure 9a shows the fractured surface of PA6 after the impact test. The rough
surface observed absorbs energy and that causes ductile fracture [19]. The nanopar-
ticles, MWCNT and copper nanoparticles are found uniformly dispersed in the PA6
matrix material as shown in Fig. 9b, c. The addition of MWCNT and copper nanopar-
ticles made the fractured surface of the composites smooth and brittle fracture was
observed shown in Fig. 9d.
The incorporation of surface modified MWCNTs and carbon coated nano-
copper particles into the PA6 matrix creates good interaction between the nano-
reinforcements and polymeric chains [20–22]. The strong interaction between the
nano reinforcements and PA6 matrix greatly enhanced the dispersion as well as
interfacial adhesion. Hence, the mechanical properties of the composites could be
improved.
Investigation of the Mechanical Properties of Polyamide … 269
(a). Height images of PA6 with 0.25% MWCNT and 0.2% nano Cu
(b) . Height images of PA6 with 0.25% MWCNT and 0.4 % nano Cu
(c) . Height images of PA6 with 0.25% MWCNT and 0.6 % nano Cu
Fig. 7 a. Height images of PA6 with 0.25% MWCNT and 0.2% nano-Cu. b. Height images of PA6
with 0.25% MWCNT and 0.4% nano-Cu. c. Height images of PA6 with 0.25% MWCNT and 0.6%
nano-Cu
270 T. Anand and T. Senthilvelan
Fig. 8 Scanning electron microscopic images of the fractured surface after tensile test a PA6 b PA6,
0.25% MWCNT, 0.2% nano-Cu c PA6, 0.25% MWCNT, 0.4% nano-Cu d PA6, 0.25% MWCNT,
0.6% nano-Cu
4 Conclusion
PA6 nanocomposites reinforced with MWCNT and copper nanoparticles were suc-
cessfully manufactured using twin-screw extrusion and injection moulding pro-
cesses. Tensile, flexural and impact tests were conducted successfully on different
compositions of PA6, PA6 + 0.25% MWCNT + 0.2% nano-Cu, PA6 + 0.25%
MWCNT + 0.4% nano-Cu, PA6 + 0.25% MWCNT + 0.6% nano-Cu. The experi-
ments showed that the tensile, flexural and impact strength values were improved by
26.6%, 39.47% and 139.46% in the composition of PA6 + 0.25% MWCNT + 0.6%
nano-Cu compared to that of virgin PA6.
Investigation of the Mechanical Properties of Polyamide … 271
Fig. 9 Scanning electron microscopic images of the fractured surface after impact test a PA6 b PA6,
0.25% MWCNT, 0.2% nano-Cu c PA6, 0.25% MWCNT, 0.4% nano-Cu d PA6, 0.25% MWCNT,
0.6% nano-Cu
References
1. Rusu G, Rusu E (2012) Anionic Nylon 6/TiO2 composite materials: effects of filler on the
thermal and mechanical behaviour of the composites. Polym Compos 13:1557–1569
2. Rangari V, Mohammad GM (2012) Synthesis of hybrid ZnO/CNTs nano particles and their
reinforcement in Nylon 6 polymer fibers. J Appl Polym Sci 129(1)
3. Liu Q, de. Wijjin JR, Van Blitterswijk CA (1977) Nano—Apatite/Polymer composites:
mechanical and physiochemical characteristics. Biomaterials 18:1263–1270
4. Kransov AP, Aderikha VN, Afonicheva OV, Mit VA, Tikhonov NN, Yu A (2010) Vasil’kov:
categorization system of nanofillers to polymer composites. J Friction Wear 31:68–80
5. Chiu FC, Kao GF (2012) Polyamide 46/multi walled carbon nanotube nano composites with
enhanced thermal, electrical and mechanical properties. Compos Part A 43:208–218
6. Shen Z, Bateman S, Wu DY, McMohan P (2009) The effects of carbon nanotube on mechanical
and thermal properties of woven glass fiber reinforced Polyamide 6 nano composites. Compos
Sci Technol 69:239–244
7. Mohanty S, Nayak SK (2007) Mechanical, thermal and viscoelastic behaviour of Nylon 6/Clay
nano composites with Cotreated Montmorillonites. Poly Plast Technol Eng 46:367–376
8. Liu TX, Liu ZH, Ma KX, Shen L, Zeng KY, He CB (2003) Morphology, thermal and mechanical
behavior of Polyamide 6/layered—silicate nano composites. Compos Sci Technol 63:331–337
272 T. Anand and T. Senthilvelan
9. Luyt AS, Molefi JA, Krump H (2006) Thermal, mechanical and electrical properties of copper
powder filled low-density and linear low-density polyethylene composites. Polym Degrad Stab
91(7):1629–1636
10. So HH, Cho JW, Sahoo NG (2007) Effect of carbon nanotubes on mechanical and electrical
properties of polyimide/carbon nanotubes nano composites. Eur Polym J 43:3750–3756
11. Lee MW, Hu X (2003) Effect of fillers on the structure and mechanical properties of
LCP/PP/SiO2 in-situ hybrid nano composites. Compos Sci Technol 63(3):333–346
12. Chen GX, Kim HS, Park BH, Yoon JS (2006) Multi walled carbon nanotubes reinforced nylon
6 composites. Polymer 27:4760–4767
13. Amrishraj D, Senthilvelan T (2017) Acrylonitrile butadiene styrene composites reinforced with
nano zirconia and PTFE. Polym Compos
14. Sahoo NG, Cheng HKF, Cai J, Li L, Chan SH, Zhao J, Yu S (2009) Improvement of mechanical
and thermal properties of carbon nanotube composites through nanotube functionalization and
processing methods. Mater Chem Phys 117 (2009) 313 – 320
15. Coleman JN, Khan U, Werner J, Blau Yurii K. Gun’ko (2006) Small but strong: a review of
the mechanical properties of carbon nanotube—polymer composites. Carbon 44:1624–1652
16. Berti G, Angelo LD’, Gatto A, Iuliano L. Mechanical characterization of PA—Al2 O3
composites obtained by selective laser sintering. Rapid Prototyping. 16:124–129
17. Pollanen M, Pirinen S, Suvanto M, Pakkanen TT (2011) Influence of carbon nanotube—poly-
meric compatiblizer master batches on morphological, thermal, mechanical and tribologigal
properties of polyethylene. Compos Sci Technol 71:1353–1360
18. Fu SY, Qiao Feng XI , Lauke B, Wing Mai Y (2008) Effects of particle size, particle/matrix
interface adhesion and particle loading on mechanical properties of particulate—polymer
composites. Composites: Part B 39:933–961
19. Saeed MB, Zhan MS. Adhesive strength of nano size particles filled thermoplastic polyimides.
Int J Adhe Adhes 27(4):319–329
20. Kulkarni MV, Elangovan K, Reddy H, Prakash JN (2011) Investigations on the influence of
filler on the impact properties of Polyamides and its composites. I-Managers J Mech Eng 1(4)
21. Yun Zheng L, Tak Lau K, Xin Zhao L (2009) mechanical and thermal properties of nano
Al2O3/Nylon 6 composites. Chem Eng Commun 197:343–351
22. Chitte HK, Bhat NV, Karmakar NS, Kothari DC, Shinde GN (2012) Synthesis and character-
ization of polymeric composites embedded with silver nanoparticles. World J Nano Sci Eng
2:19–24
Preparation, Characterization, Image
Segmentation and Particle Size Analysis
of Cow Bone Powder for Composite
Applications
Abstract Cow bone is a bio-waste material that has caused environmental unfriend-
liness to the people living around the place of production and deposition. In recent
time, researchers have exploited various means of utilizing this bio-waste material
and make it environmentally friendly and economically utilizable, especially in the
area of applications, such as activated carbon, water purification, reinforcement in
composites, filler and additives, and its efficacy has been traced to whether is in
the form of macro-, micro- and nanoparticles. In this study, cow bone head (skull)
was collected, washed and cleaned from meats, processed, sun-dried for six weeks,
and it was then washed again with distilled water to remove impurities and con-
taminants, then placed inside the oven set at 50 °C to dry for 5 h to remove any
trace of moisture content and to ensure absolute dryness. It was then milled into
nanoparticle powder using vibratory disk milling machine and the milling times
were 0 min which was taken to be 150 µm size, 20, 40 and 60 min. The morpho-
logical and physiological characterizations were carried out using scanning electron
microscopy (SEM), energy dispersive X-ray (EDX) as well as X-ray fluorescence
(XRF). MATLAB (R2015a) was employed for image processing into bimodal with
foreground and background pixels using thresholding segmentation method. SEM
images were taken at 1.00 ×, 2.00 × and 5.00 × which resulted to 50 µm, 20 µm
and 10 µm, respectively. The image segmentation was employed to determine the
foreground from a background of cow bone powder (CBP) and to enhance high
resolutions, visual perception as well as to achieve better quality of the final output.
1 Introduction
Cow bone as organic bio-waste materials have been developed into different particles
sizes from macro, micro as well as to nanoparticles. The development of micropar-
ticles from cow bones was carried out by first carbonized the cow bones at 750 °C
using heat treatable furnace in the absence of oxygen and sieved using different mesh
sizes of 150, 300 and 600 µm and these were then applied to polymer as reinforce-
ment to form polymatrix composites [1] and it has also been used as reinforcement
nanoparticle during friction stir welding of metal composites [2], in this study, cow
bone was milling for 1 h and then carbonized at a temperature of 500 °C inside
muffle furnace for 2 h and allowed for thermal stability inside the furnace to room
temperature. It is a known fact that cow bones are waste products and making the
environment unconducive to live in with the unbearable pollutants. Notwithstand-
ing, researchers are making every effort to convert this agro-wastes to more useful
engineering applications, especially for reinforcement purposes. Cow bone being
natural animal fiber is expected to have good surface compatibility in addition to the
structural compatibility requirements as biomaterials [3, 4].
It is essential to determine the particle size distribution as they affect the pow-
ders dissolution, dispersion and the flow properties. In the recent times, there have
been tremendous works on the techniques to improve and address the dichotomy
between the image backgrounds and foreground, especially when the object in a case
is brighter with much variance [5, 6]. The image segmentation technique requires
knowledge about difference intensity and object size for successful thresholding. To
complement other studies, this study uses a sequence of an algorithm written in MAT-
LAB to estimate the particle size at varying milling time. This is seen as a means of
automating the process, such that particle size can be determined in real time during
milling by using optimal imagery of samples. Thresholding becomes a potent tool
for image segmentation when the variance of the object differs significantly from
that of the background. This is often the case in SEM images and change monitoring
applications [7]. The ideal threshold for segmentation is the intersection point of the
image and its background. This is such that the intersection is far from the class with
large variance [8].
The skulls of the cow (cow head bone) were collected from the abattoir in the city of
Johannesburg, South Africa as shown in Fig. 1a. It was then washed with de-ionized
water, cleaned from meat and then sun-dried for about six weeks to allow for absolute
dryness as shown in Fig. 1b. After 6 weeks in the sun, it was then washed again with
Preparation, Characterization, Image Segmentation and Particle … 275
Fig. 1 a Fresh cow skull bone obtained, b dried cow bone and c cow bone powder (CBP) in a
150 µm ASTM standard sieve
de-ionized water to remove any impurities and contaminations that may be present.
In order to ensure total dryness before crushing, it was dried again inside the electric
oven set 50 °C to dry for 5 h for 7 days to ensure absolute dryness of moisture
contents, this was further cleaned with acetone before crushing and pulverizing and
sieved into 150 µm size using ASTM meshes standard range by employed KingTest
Sieve, after which it was further milled with digital vibratory disk milling machine
(VDMM) for 60 min before utilization as shown in Fig. 1c. The flowchart of the
study is presented in Fig. 1.
The following characterizations were carried out on the cow bone powder scanning
electron micoscopic (SEM), eergy dispersive X-ray (EDX) and X-ray fluorescence
(XRF) to determine the elemental and chemical compositions as well as morphology
of the powder (Fig. 2).
X-Ray fluorescence (XRF) spectroscopic analysis of cow bone powder (CBP) was
carried out using PHILIP PW1404 XRF wavelength disperse spectrometer and it
was revealed that CBP contains the following chemical composition 45.06% (CaO),
34.60% (P2 O5 ), 0.065% (MgO), 0.25% (Fe2 O3 ), 0.17% (Na2 O), 0.16% (Al2 O3 ),
0.08% (Al2 O3 ), 0.12% (K2 O), 0.06% (TiO2 ), 0.02 (ZnO), 0.01% (MnO) and 16.28%
(LOI).
276 O. M. Ikumapayi et al.
SEM images at varying magnifications and milling time with respect to SEM image
segmentation are shown in Fig. 3 while the elemental compositions are showed in
Table 1.
Fig. 3 SEM images and their segmentations for cow bone powder at varying magnification of 1.00,
2.00 and 5.00 kx at different milling time of 0, 20, 40 and 60 min
278 O. M. Ikumapayi et al.
Fig. 3 (continued)
3 Methodology
Calcination process is simply mean the method of heating a substance with a con-
trolled temperature and controlled environment [11], i.e., thermal treatment process
of material in the absence or limited supply of air in order to induce thermal stability,
phase transition, thermal decomposition as well as removal of a volatile fraction from
the material before using [12]. This is done to improve the strength, texture, thermal
stability, etc. The milled cow powder cannot be applied directly as reinforcement to
the workpiece that will be processed. If applied without any carbonization process,
it will react with the metal and form slag within the processed metal as a result of a
Preparation, Characterization, Image Segmentation and Particle … 279
thermal generation that could lead to combustion of the particles, thereby leading to
internal and surface defects. On this note, the processed powder was first undergone
calcination process to ensure thermal stability. The calcination of the powder was car-
ried out by putting each of CBP in pure graphite crucible and then put them carefully
inside the muffle furnace set at 500 °C for two (2) hours, after the 2 h, the furnace
was put off and the carbonaceous powder was allowed to cool to room temperature
inside the furnace before it was then brought out for use, and then further grinded was
performed on cow bone powder to ensure smoothness of the carbonaceous powder
before use.
Distinguishing foreground pixels from the background pixels has been used to
enhance visual perception of images [13–15]. One of the common techniques used
to identify morphological maps [16] and image color intensity and is the threshold
segmentation. The technique offers a simplicity in calculation and speed in operation
[17]. Threshold segmentation recognizes image patterns aiming toward enhancing
final image quality and resolutions [18]. This method does not perform well in cases
where there is overlap in the grayscale value of the image [19, 20]. In this study, the
SEM images, which are grayscale, were converted into binary images thus reducing
data complexity.
Otsu’s method [21], a nonparametric and an unsupervised thresholding technique,
was used for image thresholding. The technique selects optimum thresholds by max-
imizing the intraclass variance of binary images. In this study, we assume that the
SEM images are bimodal with foreground and background pixels.
Selecting from a set of local thresholds t1 , t2 , t3 , . . . tn , the thresholds subdivide
the images into n + 1 classes of C1 , C2 , C3 , . . . Cn . This is achieved by maximizing
the objective function of a sum of all threshold variances [6];
where
t1 −1
t1 −1
i pi
σ02 = ω0 (μ0 − μT ) , ω0 =
2
pi , μ0 = . (2)
i=0 i=0
ω0
t2 −1
t2 −1
i pi
σ12 = ω1 (μ1 − μT )2 , ω1 = pi , μ1 = . (3)
i=t1 i=t1
ω1
t3 −1
t3 −1
i pi
σ22 = ω2 (μ2 − μT )2 , ω2 = pi , μ2 = (4)
i=t2 i=t2
ω2
280 O. M. Ikumapayi et al.
t4 −1
t4 −1
i pi
σ32 = ω3 (μ3 − μT )2 , ω3 = pi , μ3 = (5)
i=t3 i=t3
ω3
tn+1 −1 tn+1 −1
i pi
σn2 = ωn (μn − μT )2 , ωn = pi , μn = (6)
i=tn i=t
ωn
n
and σ02 , σ12 , σ22 , σ32 , . . . σn2 . are the class variances, ω0 , ω1 , ω2 , ω3 , . . . ωn represents
the class probabilities, μ0 , μ1 , μ2 , μ3 , . . . μn represents the mean values of the
segmented classes. The intensity of the whole image is
μT ⊆ μT = ω0 μ0 + ω1 μ1 + ω2 μ2 + ω3 μ3 + . . . + ωm μm ω0
+ ω1 + ω2 + ω3 + ωn = 1.
The segmentation process was performed at different milling times and at different
magnifications. A script for this was computed using MATLAB (R2015a) installed
on a desktop computer workstation with configuration 64 bits, 32 GB RAM Intel (R)
Core (TM) i7 5960X. The mean particle sizes were obtained at different milling time
and different magnifications. A two-way analysis of variance was performed on the
result to determine whether there is a statistically significant difference between the
mean particle sizes across varying milling time and the across the magnifications.
Table 1 and Fig. 4 showed the variability in elemental compositions of cow bone
powder as analyzed by EDXS. It was revealed that the following elements are present,
calcium (Ca), carbon (c), phosphorous (P), oxygen (O) and little traces of magnesium
(Mg). It can be observed that there is variation in composition of the elements as the
milling progresses. The elemental composition varied along with the milling time
from 0–60 min and this was also in agreement with the work carried out Omah et al.
[1].
The mean particle sizes at each milling time and each magnification are as pre-
sented in Table 2. It is expedient to statistically establish whether the difference
between the mean particle sizes at each milling time and magnification are sta-
tistically significant. To establish this, an analysis of variance was performed and
presented in Table 3.
From Table 3, at a confidence interval of 0.05, the difference between the mean
particle sizes obtained at different milling times is statistically significant. Similarly,
the mean particle sizes obtained at different magnifications are statistically signif-
icant. However, the degree of significance in milling time is not as obvious as that
from varying magnifications.
Preparation, Characterization, Image Segmentation and Particle … 281
Table 2 Mean particle size of segmented SEM images at different magnifications and milling times
Magnification
Milling time ×1000 ×2000 ×5000
0 2.70E+03 1.06E+03 507.996
20 2.98E+03 1.87E+03 526.284
40 3.54E+03 1.89E+03 727.674
60 4.03E+03 2.13E+03 781.975
Table 3 Statistical analysis of variance between mean particle sizes at varying milling time and
different magnifications
Source of variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
Milling time 1,215,747 3 405,248.9 4.464 0.057 4.757
Magnification 14,487,754 2 7,243,877 79.799 4.76E−05 5.143
Error 544,659.7 6 90,776.62
Total 16,248,160 11
282 O. M. Ikumapayi et al.
It can be inferred that the increasing the milling time of cow bone depending on
the use, significantly affect its particle size. Particle sizes at different magnification
are bound to vary due to change in image resolution.
4 Conclusion
The method used in this work permitted the manipulations of micrographs in order
to have a true representation of the powder distribution and at the same time dis-
tinguishing foreground from background. Image processing analysis was investi-
gated in this research through thresholding segmentation at varying milling times
(t = 0, 20, 40, 60 min). It was revealed in the study that progressive milling leads
to increase in particle size distributions and decrease in the area of particle size as
noted in Table 2. It was revealed by EDX analysis that the main constituents of cow
bone powder are calcium, oxygen, magnesium, carbon and phosphorous.
References
1. Omah AD, Okorie BA, Omah EC, Ezema IC, Aigbodion VS (2017) Measurement of dielectric
properties of polymer matrix composites developed from cow bone powder. Int J Adv Manuf
Technol 88:325–335. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-016-8759-1
2. Ikumapayi OM, Akinlabi ET (2019) Experimental data on surface roughness and force feed-
back analysis in friction stir processed AA7075-T651 aluminium metal composites. Data Br
23:103710. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dib.2019.103710
3. Ahmad M, Lee SS, Lim JE, Lee SE, Cho JS, Moon DH et al (2014) Speciation and phy-
toavailability of lead and antimony in a small arms range soil amended with mussel shell, cow
bone and biochar: EXAFS spectroscopy and chemical extractions. Chemosphere 95:433–441.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2013.09.077
4. Aramide FO, Ibitoye SA, Oladele IO, Borode JO (2010) Pack carburization of mild steel,
using pulverized bone as carburizer: Optimizing process parameters. Leonardo Electron J
Pract Technol 9:1–12
5. Elbayoumi Harb SM, Isa NAM, Salamah SA (2015) Improved image magnification algo-
rithm based on Otsu thresholding. Comput Electr Eng 46:338–355. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
compeleceng.2015.03.025
6. Khairuzzaman AKM, Chaudhury S (2017) Multilevel thresholding using grey wolf opti-
mizer for image segmentation. Expert Syst Appl 86:64–76. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eswa.
2017.04.029
7. Hu QM, Hou ZJ, Wieslaw LN (2006) Supervised range-constrained thresholding. IEEE Trans
Image Process 15:228–240
8. Xu X, Xu S, Jin L, Song E (2011) Characteristic analysis of Otsu threshold and its applications.
Pattern Recognit Lett 32:956–961. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.patrec.2011.01.021
9. Abdulrahman A, Latiff AAA, Daud Z, Ridzuan MB, Jagaba AH (2016) Preparation and char-
acterization of activated cow bone powder for the adsorption of cadmium from palm oil mill
effluent. IOP Conf Ser Mater Sci Eng 136:1–11. https://doi.org/10.1088/1757-899X/136/1/
012045
10. Adewole T (2015) Effect of cow bone ash particle size distribution on the mechanical properties
of cow bone ash-reinforced polyester composites. Chem Mater Res 7:40–47
Preparation, Characterization, Image Segmentation and Particle … 283
11. Mohammed A, Aboje AA, Auta M, Jibril M (2012) A comparative analysis and characterization
of animal bones as adsorbent. Pelagia Res Libr Adv Appl Sci Res 3:3089–3096
12. Ihom PA (2013) Case hardening of mild steel using cowbone as Energiser. Afr J Eng Res
1:97–101
13. Zhu S, Xia X, Zhang Q, Belloulata K (2007) An image segmentation algorithm in image
processing based on threshold segmentation. Third Int IEEE Conf Signal-Image Technol
Internet-Based Syst 2007:673–678. https://doi.org/10.1109/SITIS.2007.116
14. Kuruvilla J, Sukumaran D, Sankar A, Joy SP (2016) A review on image processing and
image segmentation. Int Conf Data Min Adv Comput 2016:198–203. https://doi.org/10.1109/
SAPIENCE.2016.7684170
15. Ikumapayi OM, Akinlabi ET (2019) Image processing and particle size analysis of coconut
shell. Int J Civ Eng Technol 10:2475–2482
16. Rohilla L, Garg V, Mallick SS, Setia G (2018) An experimental investigation on the effect of
particle size into the flowability of fly ash. Powder Technol 330:164–173. https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.powtec.2018.02.013
17. Zaitoun NM, Aqel MJ (2015) Survey on image segmentation techniques. Procedia Comput Sci
65:797–806. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.procs.2015.09.027
18. Aly A, Deris S, Zaki N (2011) Research review for digital image Segmentation techniques. Int
J Comput Sci 3:99–106. https://doi.org/10.5121/ijcsit.2011.3509
19. Kaur D, Kaur Y (2014) Various image segmentation techniques: a review. Int J Comput Sci
Mob Comput 3:809–814
20. Kaur A (2012) A review paper on image segmentation and its various techniques in image
processing. Int J Sci Res 3:2319–7064 ISSN (Online Impact Factor)
21. Otsu N (1979) A threshold selection method from gray-level histograms. IEEE Trans Syst Man
Cybern 9:62–66. https://doi.org/10.1109/TSMC.1979.4310076
Investigation of Mechanical
and Chemical Properties of the Coir
Fiber and Wood Powder Reinforced
Hybrid Polymer Composite
Abstract In many engineering applications, natural fibers are used because of high
strength, low weight, and easy availability. In many composite studies reveals among
the various natural fibers, the coir fiber is used as a reinforcing agent in polymer
composites. In this paper, the mechanical and chemical properties of the hybrid
polymer composites reinforced with coconut coir fiber and wood powder at different
fractions were studied. The hand layup technique is used for sample preparation
as per ASTM D638-03 standards. The mechanical and chemical properties such as
tensile strength, flexural strength, and impact strength and water absorption capacity
of the hybrid polymer composite were tested for different specimens prepared as per
ASTM D638-03 standards. The results of the above tests prove that the coir fiber and
wood powder have a significant influence on the mechanical properties of the hybrid
polymer composite.
Keywords Hybrid polymer composite · Coir fiber · Wood powder · Hand layup
technique
1 Introduction
properties of hybrid composite materials. Balaji et al. [4] used coir fiber and cot-
ton fiber-reinforced unsaturated polyester composites for packaging applications.
Kattimani et al. [5] conducted experimental investigation on coconut coir reinforced
composite polymer. Prathapsingh et al. [6] investigate the tensile properties of alkali-
treated pantandanus odoratissimus fiber-reinforced with polymer matrix composite.
The main objective of this work is the preparation of coconut coir fiber and wood
powder reinforced polymer composite with different weight fractions and compares
the mechanical and chemical properties of the polymer composite.
Coir fiber is one of the naturally available fibers extracted from the coconut husk.
The coir fiber is prepared from coconut husk available from rural areas of all over the
southern states of India. The collected coir material is washed with normal water and
dried in sunlight for several days. Hammering is done on dried coconut husk to extract
coir fiber then it will be cut into the small pieces of 10 mm length approximately.
Figure 1 shows the extracted coir fiber from coconut.
The wood powder is collected from the local saw mill. The wood powder used in
this work is extracted from the mango tree. The powder is sieved into the same size
and dried in sunlight for several days. Figure 2 shows the processed wood powder.
The hybrid composite specimen was prepared by hand layup technique which one
of the common methodologies used for the preparation of composite materials. The
coir fiber and wood powder act as the reinforcing material, whereas the epoxy resin
acts as the base material. The hand layup technique may be divided into four stages
such as mold preparation, gel coating, layup, and finishing. Molds were made of
wood with a dimension of 30 × 30 × 0.5 cm. Gel coating is applied to the surface of
the mold to separate the composite easily after curing. In layup stage, the required
amount of coir and wood powder are measured along with resin and hardener with
the ratio 10:1. Initially, the resin is mixed with coir fiber and wood powder and
stirred for a few minutes to ensure uniform distribution of reinforcement material
with the resin. After that the hardener is mixed with the resin and again stirred well.
Then, the mixture is poured into the mold cavity and allowed to solidify for one day.
After curing, the composite was taken away from the mold and dried is normal room
temperature for a few hours. Table 1 shows the samples and the weight fractions of
coir fiber and wood powder.
The tensile test was carried out to determine the tensile strength of the prepared
hybrid composite material specimens. The specimen was prepared as per ASTM
standard for tensile test. The prepared tensile test specimens were inspected under
loading in the universal testing machine. The tensile strength of all the samples is
tabulated in Table 2.
From Fig. 3, it was found that the composite with wood powder reinforcement
shows lower tensile strength than the composite with coir reinforcement. The com-
posites having the mixture of 15% of coir and 15% of wood powder reinforcement
shows greater tensile strength than the individual reinforcement composites. This
shows that the combination of coir and wood powder increased the tensile strength
of the composites. Therefore, the increase in the coir percentage gives good tensile
strength than the increase in wood powder percentage.
Table 2 Tensile strength of coir and wood powder reinforced polymer composites
Sample Length (mm) Width (mm) Thickness mm) Area (mm2 ) Load (kN) Tensile
strength (Mpa)
A 175 13.50 4.40 59.40 0.59 9.96
B 175 11.60 4.10 47.56 0.67 14.07
C 190 12.40 4.20 52.08 0.76 14.59
D 175 12.90 5.20 67.08 0.77 11.41
E 185 13.60 4.80 65.28 0.92 14.11
The flexural test is carried out to determine the flexural properties of the composite
material. The sample was prepared as per ASTM standard. The sample is kept on
bending fixture and the compressive load is given and the curve generated till the
failure of the sample takes place. Table 3 shows the flexural strength of all the samples.
From Fig. 4, it was found that the composite with wood powder reinforcement
shows lower flexural strength, whereas the coir reinforced composite has greater
flexural strength. Therefore, the increase in the coir percentage gives good flexural
strength than the increase in wood powder percentage.
Table 3 Flexural strength of coir and wood powder reinforced polymer composite
Sample Length Width Thickness Area Load (kN) Flexural
(mm) (mm) (mm) (mm2 ) strength
(N/mm2 )
A 100 14.50 4.10 59.45 0.06 36.92
B 100 14.50 4.60 66.70 0.08 39.11
C 100 14.10 4.60 64.86 0.07 35.56
D 100 15.50 4.30 66.65 0.09 47.10
E 100 15.50 4.30 66.65 0.10 52.34
Table 4 Impact strength of coir and wood powder reinforced polymer composites
Sample Length of span Width (mm) Thickness (mm) Area (mm2 ) Impact strength
(mm) (J)
A 80 15 5 75 2
B 80 15 5 75 4
C 80 15 5 75 2
D 80 15 5 75 2
E 80 15 5 75 2
The impact test is the study of the ability of the material to withstand the sudden
shock loads. This impact test was conducted in the impact testing machine. Table 4
shows the impact strength of all the samples.
From Fig. 5, it was found that the impact test result shows that there is a consid-
erable increase in the impact strength for coir reinforced composite and there is no
considerable change in impact strength of other specimens. It shows that the impact
strength was improved by increasing the coir percentage.
Water absorption test is used to determine the amount of water absorbed under room
temperature conditions. Initially, the weights of the samples are measured using the
weighing machine and then the samples were immersed in the normal water for 48 h.
Then, the weights of the samples were measured again. The change in the weight of
Investigation of Mechanical and Chemical Properties of the Coir … 291
the sample shows the water absorption capabilities of the composite. Table 5 shows
the water absorption capacity of all the samples.
From Fig. 6, it was found that the composite absorbs a very minimum percentage
of water. So, it is used in application such as storage tank and container fabrication.
4 Conclusions
The mechanical and chemical properties such as tensile strength, flexural strength,
and impact strength, and water absorption capacity have been carried out on hybrid
polymer composite samples. The results obtained from the above test conducted are
concluded that the flexural strength of the composites increases with an increase in the
percentage of coir than increases the percentage of wood powder. The coir reinforced
composite has good impact strength than the wood powder reinforced composite.
The water absorption capacity decreases when increasing amount of wood powder
and a decreasing amount of coir fiber.
292 T. Prabhuram et al.
References
1. Rajesh M, Jeyaraj P (2017) Mechanical characterization of natural fiber intra-ply fabric polymer
composites. Influence of chemical modifications. J Reinf Plast Compos 36(22):1651–1664
2. Omrani E, Menezes PL, Rohatgi PK (2016) State of the art on tribological behavior of polymer
matrix composites reinforced with natural fibers in the green materials world. Eng Sci Technol
Int J 19(2):717–736
3. Prabhuram T, Somurajan V, Prabhakaran S (2010) Hybrid composite materials. In: Frontiers in
automobile and mechanical engineering (FAME), pp 27–31
4. Balaji V, Senthil Vadivu KP (2017) Mechanical characterization of coir fiber and cotton fiber
reinforced unsaturated polyester composites for packaging applications. J Appl Packag Res
9(2):12–19
5. Kattimani P, Raikar N, Patil AN, Nandi P (2016) Experimental investigation on coconut coir
reinforced composite polymer. Int J Engineering Trends Technol 41(3):128–133
6. Prathapsingh D, Elilraja D, Prabhuram T, Immanuel Durairaj J (2018) Investigation of ten-
sile properties of Alkali treated pandanus odoratissimus fiber reinforced with polymer matrix
composite. Int J Mech Prod Eng Res Dev 8(8):403–407
An Experimental Study on Hemp/Sisal
Fiber Embedded Hybrid Polymer
Composites
Abstract Environmental concerns encourage the use of artless fibers since bio-
fiber embedded polymer composite crumble easily in nature and cheaper compare
to petroleum-based fibers. Cellulosic fibers are gradually more gaining attention as
their uses are diversified into structural and automobile parts for vehicle where low
weight is necessary. The low density of cellulosic fibers is very beneficial in the
structural and automobile industry. Cellulosic fibers offer many ecological and tech-
nical benefits for its use in incorporating composites. Current research paper inves-
tigates the mechanical strength (tensile, flexural, compression strength and shore-
D hardness) and water absorption performance of different weight percentage of
hemp/sisal fiber embedded polymer resin (epoxy resin) hybrid composites. Hemp
and sisal fiber surfaces were subjected to 10 weight percentage of alkaline (NaOH)
solution to improve the bonding characteristic between hydrophilic cellulosic fibers
and hydrophobic polymer resin. Hybrid composite specimens were prepared by sim-
ple cold pressing technique. A 40 weight percentage of hemp/sisal fiber embedded
hybrid composite sample discloses maximum tensile strength, flexural strength and
compression strength. Shore-D hardness value and absorption of moisture of hybrid
composite samples increases with increase in fiber loading. Morphological analy-
ses are carried out to analyze the fractured surface of hybrid composite samples by
using scanning electron microscope (SEM) and reported. The investigational result
also discloses that the hemp and sisal fibers are promising reinforcements for use in
cheaper bio-composites which have high strength to weight ratio.
1 Introduction
Cellulosic fibers are increasingly gaining attention as their uses are diversified into
structural and automobile parts for vehicles where low weight is required. The low
density of cellulosic fibers is very helpful in the structural and automobile industry.
Cellulosic fibers offer many ecological and technical benefits for its use in incorpo-
rating composites. Number of types of cellulosic fibers have been investigated for use
in polymers, including bamboo, sisal, hemp, coir, flax, jute, banana leaf extracted,
pineapple leaf extracted fiber etc., and the polymer matrix used for incorporating
the fibers are classified as thermoplastics and thermosetting plastics. Cellulosic fiber
incorporated composites are also claimed to offer ecological reward such as min-
imized dependence on non-renewable material/energy sources, lower green house
gas emission, lower pollutant emissions, enhanced energy recovery and end of life
biodegradability of components. Cellulosic fibers are renewable, discloses high spe-
cific properties, abundantly available with low density as well as they decompose in
soil and less abrasive to costly molds and mixing tools [1]. Due to their poor resistance
to moisture, incompatibility with hydrophobic polymer resin and their tendency to
form aggregate during processing has reduced their potential use as reinforcement
in polymer matrix composites.
The mechanical strength of cellulosic fiber reinforced polymer composites are
lower compare to synthetic-based fibers [2]. To produce rough surface and reactive
hydroxyl groups on cellulosic fiber surface for better bonding with polymeric resin,
cellulosic fibers have to undergo chemical or/and physical treatment to modify the
structure and surface. The hydrophobic epoxy resin—hydrophilic sisal and hemp
fiber interfacial bond was improved by an alkaline treatment.
Hemp fiber and sisal fiber are most suitable cellulosic fibers for use in polymer
composites, due to its greater specific strength and decompose in nature after use.
Due to the more lignin content sisal and hemp fiber is long durable compared to other
cellulosic fibers. With increasing emphasis on fuel efficiency, cellulosic fibers such
as sisal and hemp fiber incorporated composite samples enjoying wider applications
in structural, domestic and automobiles applications. Many aspects of the use of
sisal and hemp fibers as incorporation in polymer resin composites are discussed in
literature. Rout et al. [3] studied the mechanical properties of untreated and treated
hemp fibers, discloses clear signs of the presence of poor bonding, long pulled out
fibers without any polymer resin adhered to the fibers and poor mechanical strength
were obtained compare to treated fiber embedded composites. Alkaline treatment
to cellulosic fibers increases hydrophobic behavior with improving the resistance to
fungi attack and also increases mechanical strength of polymer composites [4, 5].
According to author [5] 45 wt% of fiber loading is considerable reinforcing effect
when the composite specimens are tested for tension. The utilization of cellulosic
fiber alone, in a polymer resin is not enough in satisfactory tackling all the technical
needs of a fiber embedded polymer composite. In an attempt to develop a better but
inexpensive composite, a cellulosic fiber can be combining with another natural fiber
in the same matrix so as to take the best favorable results of both natural fibers. The
An Experimental Study on Hemp/Sisal Fiber Embedded … 295
aim of this research work is to investigate the mechanical properties and moisture
absorption behavior of sodium hydroxide treated hemp and sisal embedded epoxy
resin polymer composites.
2 Experiments
2.1 Materials
Chopped hemp and sisal fibers were used as incorporation materials. These cellulosic
fibers were procured from local dealers. Epoxy resin and corresponding hardener
with brand name AW106 and HV953, respectively, were used as matrix phase to
manufacture hybrid composites. Epoxy resin (AW 106) and hardener (HV953) at a
ratio of 10:1 was mixed to prepare matrix material.
Simple cold pressing method was used to manufacture hybrid composite specimens
in 250 * 250 * 6 mm metallic (cast iron) mold at high pressure. Hydraulic pressing
machine was used to manufacture hemp/sisal fiber embedded epoxy resin hybrid
composites. Thin layers of polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) were coated to both male and
female molds to ensure that the sheet will not stick on to the metallic mold. Epoxy
resin (Araldite AW 106) and hardener (HV 953) were mixed in a ratio of 10:1
in a bowl to prepare polymer matrix material. The quantity of fiber (hemp/sisal
fiber) was varied from 10 to 50 wt% in steps of 10 wt%. A well-mixed mixture
296 Akash et al.
of reinforcement and matrix material was poured into PVA coated female mold die
cavity. A PVA coated male die was positioned on the female die and pressure applied
on male die up to 410.4 kg/cm2 from hydraulic pressing machine for three hours.
After drying, fabricated sample was cut to specimen to carry out tensile test, flexural
test and compression test and water absorption behavior according to ASTM standard
dimensions.
Tensile test, compression test, flexural test and hardness test were conducted accord-
ing to ASTM D-3039, ASTM D-695, ASTM 790-03 and ASTM D-2240, respec-
tively. Three specimens were tested for individual test and average values are tab-
ulated. Tensile, flexural and compression strength and shore-D hardness values of
hybrid composite samples are shown in Figs. 1, 2, 3 and 4 respectively. The tensile
strength of hemp/sisal fiber incorporated hybrid composites increases with increase
in fiber loading up to 40 wt%, after that decreases is shown in Fig. 1. This indicates
an effective and uniform stress transfer within composite after the incorporation of
48
47
46
45
44
43
42
41
40
39
38
10 20 30 40 50
Fiber percentage
80
75
70
65
60
55
10 20 30 40 50
Fiber percentage
An Experimental Study on Hemp/Sisal Fiber Embedded … 297
Fig. 3 Compression
cellulosic fibers in polymer matrix. At higher % of fiber loading, it is difficult for the
polymer to penetrate the reducing spaces between fibers, leading to poor wetting, and
hence, a reduction in the stress transfers efficiency through the fiber-matrix interface.
Drop in tensile strength is attributed to the poor matrix/fiber interfacial bonding. The
results highlight that the fiber weight fraction is the most dominant parameter that
will affect the tensile strength [8].
Flexural strength of the fabricated hybrid composite specimens increases with
increasing fiber loading up to 40 weight percentage, this enhancement in fiber/matrix
strength is due to the ability of cellulose fiber to resist the bonding force. The lower
flexural strength at lower cellulosic fiber content may be attributed to the lower loads
transferred from the matrix to the fibers, thus resulting in lower load carried by fibers
[9]. Significant increases in flexural strength at higher fiber content is because of
the increase in stress transferred to the fibers as a result of increased adhesion at the
fiber-matrix interface.
Compression strength of the fabricated hybrid composite specimens increases
with increasing fiber loading up to 40 weight percentage this is due to the bonding
at the crossing point between hydrophobic matrix and hydrophilic cellulosic fiber is
too strong to transfer strength [10]. Higher cellulosic fiber concentration demands
higher stress for the same deformation; therefore, the reinforcement of hemp fiber
and sisal fiber into resin resulted in increases the compression strength. Further
addition of hemp fiber and sisal fiber, i.e., 50 weight percentage lead to decrease
298 Akash et al.
the compression strength of composite. When the quantity of cellulosic fibers is not
sufficient to restrain the epoxy resin, large stresses will be developed at low strains
and distribution of these stresses will not be uniform [10, 11].
Shore-D hardness of polymer composite refers to its resistance to shape change
after load/force applied on it. For fiber reinforced polymer composites, hardness value
depends on the distribution of fibers in polymer resin. The shore-D hardness value
was taken at four different spots for every sample and average result was considered
as the hardness value of specimen. Figure 4 shows the variation of hardness value
of different wt% of hemp/sisal fiber embedded hybrid composite. Figure 4 discloses
that the hardness value of composites increases with increasing in fiber loading. The
inclusion of hemp fiber and sisal fiber in epoxy resin has decreased the mobility of
polymer chain in the rigid polymer composite [12].
10
10 wt.% fiber
9
20 wt.% fiber
8
water absorption in %
30 wt.% fiber
7
40 wt.% fiber
6
50 wt.% fiber
5
4
3
2
1
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Time duration in days
Fiber pullout
Fiber
Fiber
breakage
debonding
Hemp fiber
Sisal fiber
Fig. 6 SEM images of the hemp/sisal fiber reinforced hybrid composite samples
300 Akash et al.
4 Conclusions
The study on mechanical, water absorption and fractured surface of hemp/sisal fiber
incorporated epoxy resin hybrid composite led to the following conclusions.
• Tensile strength, flexural strength and compression strength of hemp/sisal fiber
embedded hybrid composites increases with increasing fiber weight percentage
in composite specimens up to 40 weight percentage, and then it decreases due to
further loading the percentage of hemp/sisal fibers is incompatible with polymer
resin and has tendency to form aggregates.
• Shore-D hardness value of hybrid composite increases with increasing in weight
parentage of fiber due to addition of hemp/sisal fiber in polymer resin has
decreased the mobility of polymer chain in the rigid composites.
• SEM images reveal that the hydrophilic cellulosic fibers (hemp fiber and sisal
fiber) homogeneously mixed with hydrophobic polymer resin (epoxy resin).
• Absorption of water content increases with increase in the weight percentage of
fibers of manufactured hybrid composite specimens.
References
11. Venkatesha Gupta NS, Akash, Sreenivasa Rao KV, Arun Kumar DS (2016) Fabrication and
evaluation of mechanical properties of alkaline treated sisal/hemp fiber reinforced hybrid
composite. IOP Conf Ser Mater Sci Eng 149:1–7
12. Mir SS, Nafsin N, Hasan M, Hasan N, Hassan A (2013) Improvement of physico-mechanical
properties of coir-polypropylene biocomposites by fiber chemical treatment. Mater Des
52:251–257
13. Akash, Girisha KG, Venkatesha Gupta NS, Sreenivas Rao KV (2017) A study on flammability
and moisture absorption behavior of sisal/coir fiber reinforced hybrid composites. IOP Conf
Ser Mater Sci Eng 2:1–6
14. Singh NP, Aggarwal L, Gupta VK (2015) Tensile behavior of sisal/hemp reinforced high density
polyethylene hybrid composite. Mater Today Proc 2:3140–3148
Investigation on Chemical Isolation
and Characterization of Cellulose
from Delonix regia Fruit Fibers
Abstract Lignocellulosic fibers have gained popularity among the research frater-
nity in recent years due to its abundance in nature, biodegradability, high specific
strength, etc. Cellulose can be extracted from biomasses by various chemical and
mechanical methods. In this paper, Delonix regia fruit fibers are presented as a new
source of cellulose, and chemical methods are used for extraction of cellulose from
it. Chemically treated and untreated fibers were characterized by X-ray diffraction
(XRD) and thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) to understand the effect of chemical
treatment and properties of the cellulose yield. The results obtained demonstrated
that a high yield of cellulose is obtained by chemical extraction methods followed
and validated the suitability of Delonix regia fruit fibers for various applications
including biocomposites and bionanocomposites.
1 Introduction
2.1 Materials
Delonix regia fruits were collected from the local fields of Raipur, Chhattisgarh, India.
Chemicals used were: toluene, ethanol, sodium hydroxide, sodium hypochlorite,
hydrogen peroxide and sulfuric acid. Various chemicals used were of analytical
grades and obtained from Kasliwal Brothers, Raipur, Laxmi Scientific Works, Raipur
and Lab Chemicals, Chennai.
Green fruits of D. regia were cut from the D. regia tree, and seeds of fruit were
removed. Delonix regia fruits were washed several times with deionized water and
chopped into small pieces (approx. 2 cm × 2 cm) by chopper. Chopped fibers were
dried in a convective oven at 80 °C for 24 h and grounded in a mill and sieved
to attend uniform size in powder form and then washed and filtered to remove the
dirt or waxing substances and improving swelling tendency as per NREL standard
procedures [9]. Dirt-free and screened samples were stored in a polyethylene bags
and kept in a desiccator for further use. Figure 1 shows the D. regia fruits biomass
before and after size reduction.
Moisture Content
Screened sample (8 g) was subjected to convection oven drying at 105 °C for 24 h
and weighed in balance and stored in a desiccator to avoid the moisture absorption.
Total solid in the biomass is obtained by weight difference before and after oven
drying and subtracting it from 100 gives moisture content of the biomass [9–11].
Extractive Content
Dry sample (5 g) was taken in a tared extraction thimble, and Soxhlet apparatus was
assembled, and thimble was inserted in Soxhlet tube. Ethanol (190 ml) was added
as solvent for extraction in the receiving flask and placed on Soxhlet apparatus.
Temperature of the heating plate was kept at 80 °C, and distillation flask was kept in
306 K. P. Kaurase and D. Singh
Fig. 1 Raw biomass (Delonix regia fruit) before and after size reduction; a Delonix regia tree,
b Delonix regia fruits (on tree), c Delonix regia fruits (Cut), d removed seeds, e dried and chopped
fruits, f fruits after size reduction and screening
a water bath for the reflux time of 16 h. After complete extraction, sample was kept in
Buchner funnel with cellulose filter paper and air dried at room temperature [9–11].
Weight difference before and after extraction process gives the extractive content.
Hemicellulose Content
Distilled water and NaOH (150 ml) were added to dry extracted sample (3 g) in
Erlenmeyer flask and boiled for 4 h. Mixture was air cooled, vacuum filtered and
washed to reach neutral pH after completion of boiling time. Residual content was
dried in oven at 105 °C, and weight difference before and after treatment gives
hemicellulose content [9–11].
Ash Content
Dried extracted sample (2 g) was placed in a tared crucible and ashed in a muffle
furnace at 575 °C for 24 h. Crucible was removed and placed in a desiccator (to
avoid moisture absorption) for initial cooling before weighing after complete ashing.
Weight difference before and after complete ashing gives the ash content of the
biomass [9–11].
Lignin Content
72% H2 SO4 (3 ml) was added to dry extracted sample (1 g) and kept at room tem-
perature for 2 h with continuous mixing by magnetic stirrer. After initial hydrolysis,
distilled water (84 ml) was added and kept in autoclave for 1 h at 120 °C to complete
hydrolysis. Then, mixture was air cooled at room temperature and vacuum filtered.
Investigation on Chemical Isolation and Characterization … 307
Acid insoluble lignin was calculated by drying residue at 105 °C and accounting for
ash content. Acid soluble lignin was determined by acid digestion 320 nm. Lignin
content of biomass was obtained by summing acid insoluble and acid soluble lignin
content [11].
Cellulose Content
Cellulose content was estimated by considering that biomass contains moisture, ash,
lignin, hemicellulose, extractives and cellulose and subtracting moisture, ash, lignin,
hemicellulose, extractive percentage from 100%.
The following techniques were utilized for extracting cellulose from D. regia fruit
fibers: Size-reduced and screened D. regia fruit fiber samples (20 g) were first
subjected to extractive removal procedure by using Soxhlet apparatus. 2:1 (v/v)
toluene/ethanol mixture was added to the round flask and placed on heating mantle,
and Soxhlet apparatus was assembled for the total reaction time of 6 h at 90 °C, fol-
lowed by washing with ethanol and drying [12]. Fibers were pulped chemically with
17.5% (w/w) NaOH and kept at room temperature overnight to improve swelling
tendency of the fiber and partial removal of lignin and hemicellulose, successive
cleaning with tap water, and filtration was carried out afterward. Fibers were deligni-
fied with 72% (v/v) sulfuric acid (H2 SO4 ) at 70 °C for 1 h followed by washing with
distilled water and centrifuged several times to reach neutral pH, and supernatant was
collected [13]. Fibers were subjected to alkaline treatment with 2% (w/w) NaOH at
90 °C for 2 h in a water bath to remove hemicellulose. Fibers were bleached 5 times
with 5% (v/v) sodium hypochlorite at 75 °C for 2 h followed by repetitive rinsing and
filtration. Fibers were further bleached with 10% (v/v) hydrogen peroxide (H2 O2 ) at
80 °C for 1 h, and filtrate was oven dried at 40 °C for 5 h to obtain highly purified
yield of cellulose [14] (Fig. 2).
Material characterization was conducted for raw D. regia fruit fiber samples and
cellulose extracted by chemical treatments and termed as sample 1 and sample 2,
respectively. Characterization was carried out using three techniques: X-ray diffrac-
tion (XRD), thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) and differential scanning calorimetry
(DSC).
where I002 is the intensity of the peak at 2θ angle between 26° and 27° representing
crystalline region, Iam is the intensity of the peak at 2θ angle between 21° and 22°
representing amorphous region [15, 16].
70 ml/min was used for both the samples. Difference in the amount of heat required
to raise the temperature of the sample was recorded, and DSC curve was obtained
by Stare SW 13.00 software by DSC 1/700/2861 module [18].
For analyzing the crystallinity index and crystallite size of the extracted cellulose
with raw D. regia Fruit fiber sample, X-ray diffractometry was conducted. Figure 3
shows diffraction pattern of the extracted cellulose with raw D. regia Fruit fiber
4000
2000
20 40 60 80 100
Angle (2*theta) (deg.)
310 K. P. Kaurase and D. Singh
sample. Two peaks were observed for sample 1 at 2θ values of 22.6855° and 186
34.8198° and most of the portion of curve is flat with the absence of sharp peaks which
shows that the major the amorphous nature of the untreated material. For chemically
treated sample, total 24 peaks were observed having narrow and sharp regions which
represent crystalline nature of chemically treated material. Major peak for sample 2
was seen at 2θ value of 29.567°. Crystallinity index (CrI) was found to be 52.24% for
raw D. regia fruit fiber sample (sample 1) and 73.41% for chemically treated sample
(sample 2). Improvement in crystallinity index by chemical treatment is observed
which clearly indicates that all the amorphous material such as hemicellulose, lignin
and wax has been successfully removed leaving behind crystalline material, i.e.,
cellulose [19, 20].
Fig. 4 TGA and DTG plots for raw (untreated) Delonix regia fruit fiber sample (sample 1)
Investigation on Chemical Isolation and Characterization … 311
Fig. 5 TGA and DTG plots for chemically treated, i.e., extracted cellulose sample (sample 2)
45% reduction in total mass which represents the degradation of cellulose and lignin
in sample 1 and degradation of cellulose in sample 2. This degradation continues
further up to 600 °C till the ashing point after which degradation becomes negligible.
The results indicate that weight loss at first degradation is less in untreated sample as
compared to chemically treated sample due to fact that moisture absorption is less in
untreated sample which is due to the presence of wax and other extractive content.
Weight loss at the second degradation is more in untreated sample as compared to
chemically treated sample because of the presence of lignin in untreated sample
[21–23].
Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) was used to determine the thermal behav-
ior of untreated sample (sample 1) and chemically treated sample, i.e., cellulose
extracted (sample 2). From the results, we can observe that endothermic peak starts
20–130 °C which represents the energy consumed in evaporating the moisture con-
tent; low energy consumption is seen for untreated sample as compared to chemically
treated sample because of the presence of wax and other extractive content. Fur-
ther, endothermic peak was observed between 260 and 370 °C in untreated sample,
due to energy consumption for degradation of lignin, hemicellulose and cellulose,
whereas almost uniform rise in energy consumption 260–400 °C without any peak
was observed in chemically treated sample which represents the presence of pure
crystalline cellulose [24] (Figs. 6 and 7).
312 K. P. Kaurase and D. Singh
Fig. 6 DSC plot for raw (untreated) Delonix regia fruit fiber sample (sample 1)
Fig. 7 DSC plot for chemically treated, i.e., extracted cellulose sample (sample 2)
Acknowledgements I would like to thank Bombay Textile Research Association (BTRA), Mum-
bai (India), for providing necessary support and scientific help in compositional analysis. Also, I
would like to thank National Institute of Technology, Raipur and Department of Physics, School of
Sciences, Pt. Ravishankar Shukla University, Raipur for assisting in characterization.
References
1. Krasznai DJ, Champagne Hartley R, Roy HM, Champagne P, Cunningham MF (2018) Com-
positional analysis of lignocellulosic biomass: conventional methodologies and future outlook.
Crit Rev Biotechnol 38(2):199–217
2. Han JS (1997) Chemical composition of fibers, Chapter 5
3. Watkins D, Nuruddin M, Hosur M, Tcherbi-Narteh A, Jeelani S (2015) Extraction and
characterization of lignin from different biomass resources. J Mater Res Technol 4(1):26–32
4. Mohanty AK, Misra M, Hinrichsen G (2000) Biofibres, biodegradable polymers and biocom-
posites: an overview summary of contents 1. Introduction 2. Reinforcing biofibres 2.1 Chem-
ical constituents and structural aspects 2.2 Properties of biofibres 2.3 Degradation properties
of biofibres 2.4 Cost asp
5. Möller J (2014) Comparing methods for fibre determination in food and feed
6. Welker CM, Balasubramanian VK, Petti C, Rai KM, De Bolt S, Mendu V (2015) Engineering
plant biomass lignin content and composition for biofuels and bioproducts. Energies 8(8):7654–
7676
7. Ayeni A, Adeeyo O, Oresegun O, Oladimeji T (2015) Compositional analysis of lignocellulosic
materials: Evaluation of an economically viable method suitable for woody and non-woody
biomass. Am J Eng Res 4(4):14–19
8. Senthilkumar N, Murugesan S, Sumathi R, Babu DS (2015) Tree species in India, vol 6, no 2,
pp 25–28
9. Templeton DW, Scarlata CJ, Sluiter JB, Wolfrum EJ (2010) Compositional analysis of
lignocellulosic feedstocks. 2. Method uncertainties. J Agric Food Chem 58(16):9054–9062
10. Sluiter A et al (2011) Determination of structural carbohydrates and lignin in biomass
determination of structural carbohydrates and lignin in biomass. Natl Renew Energy Lab
2011(July)
11. Giger-Reverdin S (1995) Review of the main methods of cell wall estimation: interest and
limits for ruminants. Anim Feed Sci Technol 55(3–4):295–334
12. Sun RC, Fang JM, Mott L, Bolton J (1999) Extraction and characterization of hemicellu-
loses and cellulose from oil palm trunk and empty fruit bunch fibres. J Wood Chem Technol
19(1):167–185
13. Martins MA, Teixeira EM, Corrêa AC, Ferreira M, Mattoso LHC (2011) Extraction and charac-
terization of cellulose whiskers from commercial cotton fibers. J Mater Sci 46(24):7858–7864
14. Sun JX, Sun XF, Zhao H, Sun RC (2004) Isolation and characterization of cellulose from
sugarcane bagasse. Polym Degrad Stab 84(2):331–339
15. Ibrahim MM, Agblevor FA, El-Zawawy WK (2010) solation and characterization of cellulose
and lignin from steam-exploded lignocellulosic biomass. Biol Syst Eng 5:397–418
16. Singh S et al (2015) Comparison of different biomass pretreatment techniques and their impact
on chemistry and structure. Front Energy Res 2(February):1–12
314 K. P. Kaurase and D. Singh
17. Suryanto H, Marsyahyo E, Irawan YS (2013) Morphology, structure, and mechanical properties
of natural cellulose fiber from Mendong grass (Fimbristylis globulosa). J Nat Fibers (November
2014):37–41
18. Morán JI, Alvarez VA, Cyras VP, Vázquez A (2008) Extraction of cellulose and preparation of
nanocellulose from sisal fibers. Cellulose 15(1):149–159
19. Maheswari CU, Reddy KO, Muzenda E, Guduri BR, Rajulu AV (2012) Extraction and char-
acterization of cellulose microfibrils from agricultural residue e Cocos nucifera L. Biomass
Bioenerg 46:555–563
20. Reddy KO et al (2018) Extraction and characterization of cellulose single fibers from native
african napier grass. Carbohydr Polym 188:85–91
21. Kalita RD, Nath Y, Ochubiojo ME, Buragohain AK (2013) Extraction and characterization
of microcrystalline cellulose from fodder grass; Setaria glauca (L) P. Beauv, and its potential
as a drug delivery vehicle for isoniazid, a first line antituberculosis drug. Colloids Surf B
Biointerfaces 108:85–89
22. Jahan MS, Saeed A, He Z, Ni Y (2011) Jute as raw material for the preparation of
microcrystalline cellulose. Cellulose 18(2):451–459
23. Nuruddin M et al (2011) Extraction and characterization of cellulose microfibrils from
agricultural wastes in an integrated biorefinery initiative. Cellul Chem Technol 45(5–6):5–6
24. Ohwoavworhua F, Adelakun T, Okhamafe A (2009) Processing pharmaceutical grade micro-
crystalline cellulose from groundnut husk: extraction methods and characterization. Int J Green
Pharm 3(2):97
Experimental Study and Analysis
of Defragmented Carbon Nanotubes
in Polyacrylonitrile Matrix
Abstract The aim of this research is to elucidate the change in electrical properties
of polyacrylonitrile (PAN) polymer when reinforced with defragmented multiwall
carbon nanotubes. In conventional chopped fiber-reinforced polymer composites,
uniform distributions of fibers throughout the matrix are critical for producing mate-
rials with superior physical and electrical properties. The previous methods have
dispersed carbon nanotubes by aggressive chemical modification of the nanotubes
or by the use of a surfactant prior to dispersion. Here, ultrasonic energy was used to
uniformly disperse and defragment the multiwall nanotubes (MWNTs) in solutions
and to incorporate them into composites without chemical pretreatment. A common
solvent dimethylformamide (DMF) is used for the dissolution process. The film is
formed by solvent casting method which involves evaporation of the homogeneous
solution of CNT and polymer. Electrical characteristic studies were done on the film
samples. The electrical properties such as conductivity and resistivities were found
and compared to the original polymer matrix.
1 Introduction
Recent theoretical and experimental studies suggest that carbon nanotubes have
remarkable mechanical and electrical properties [1–4]. In this article, the electrical
properties of carbon nanotubes [5] are applied to enhance the conducting property
of a poor conductor [6]. The previous study indicated that most polymers are poor
conductors [7]. Our broad objectives were to explore the development of advanced
composites in which carbon nanotubes serve as the reinforcing element in a poly-
mer matrix. Although several studies have focused on producing polymer nanotube
composites, many practical challenges remain before their potential can be fully real-
ized. Dispersing the nanotubes individually and uniformly into the matrix seems to
be fundamental in producing composites with reproducible and optimal properties
[8, 9]. The article focuses on dispersing defragmented MWNTs into the polymer
matrix using solvent casting process [10, 11] and analyzing the change in the elec-
trical properties of the nanocomposite material. Polyacrylonitrile (PAN) was chosen
as the matrix material because its properties are well known; it is soluble in a broad
range of solvents; and its clarity allows dispersion of MWNTs to be observed at the
micron scale [12]. DMF (dimethylformamide) was chosen as a common solvent.
MWNTs were prepared without any aggressive chemical pretreatment, purification,
or modification using CVD method [13]. MWNTs and the polymer (PAN) solutions
were dispersed and defragmented using a probe sonication process. The solution
samples were evaporated to form a film using solvent casting process [14] which
was later characterized by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) to determine disper-
sion and orientation of MWNTs within the PAN matrix. Composite samples were
tested for its electrical properties such as conductivity and resistivity, and the results
were plotted and tabulated.
2 Experimental
See Fig. 1.
2.2 Process
The catalyst employed was a 1:1 mixture of misch metal-based alloy (MmNi3 ) and
graphene oxide (GO). Hydrogen decrepitation was employed for powdering the ingot
of MmNi3 , and a modified Hummer’s method [15] was used for preparing GO as
described by the authors [16, 17]. The catalysts were grinded together in a mortar for
a few minutes and then loaded into the center of a horizontal quartz tubular reactor,
and hydrogen was allowed to enter at 240 °C for 30 min. Hydrogen reduction of GO
to graphene has been observed under these conditions. The sample was heated further
at 700 °C, before introducing a burst of acetylene (C2 H2 ) as the carbon containing
precursor, in addition to the argon (Ar) flow. The as grown samples were purified
by refluxing in conc. HNO3 at 60 °C for 6 h where the end hemispherical distorted
Experimental Study and Analysis of Defragmented Carbon … 317
carbon layers were removed. Acid-treated samples were washed with deionized water
until pH 7, filtered using a 0.2 micron polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) membrane,
and dried at 60 °C in a vacuum. The graphene-wrapped CNT samples grown at
240 °C and 500 °C of H2 flow were labeled as graphene–CNT-240 and graphene–
CNT-500, respectively. The growth mechanism of the graphene-wrapped CNT is
now considered. At 500 °C, GO exfoliated into graphene sheets in the presence of
hydrogen gas. The reaction was further carried out by allowing acetylene at 700 °C.
When the catalyst particle (MmNi3 ) is saturated with carbon, carbon leaves the
particle in another form. Saturated carbon atoms nucleate into six membered rings
and finally lead to CNT formation which is described in Fig. 1. The magnified
images using FESEM and TEM are described in Fig. 2. This is the well-reported
vapor liquid solid (VLS) mechanism for the growth of carbon nanotubes by chemical
vapor deposition. The graphene nanosheets located at a distance of ≥0.35 nm from
a nanotube get affixed to the surface of the nanotube by van der Waals interaction.
The catalyst (MmNi3 ) must be crushed into very fine powder. The growth of the
carbon nanotubes takes place on the surface of the catalyst. Hence, finer the particles
of the catalyst more surface area is formed for nanotube growth. The tubular structure
of CNTs depends upon the insertion of gases at optimal temperature. Hydrogen is
passed at 2400 °C to reduce the graphene oxide into graphene. The oxide group
reacts with hydrogen and leaves as water vapor from the furnace. Graphene is the
main source of carbon to form the carbon nanotubes. Acetylene is passed at 7000 °C
to separate the carbon nanotubes from the misch metal catalyst.
318 N. Arunkumar et al.
The CNTs formed by CVD method were checked for morphology using field elec-
tron scanning electron microscope (FESEM) and transmission electron microscope
(TEM) at different magnifications. The tubular structures are the carbon nanotubes
indicated in Fig. 2.
micro-carbon coil, and hexagonal crystal lattice may be created and form film. Put
silicon, quartz, porcelain, oxide, and other carriers in the external import device with
catalyzer precursor which is prepared at advance, catalyst and carbon nanotube will
be created at the same time, without the necessity to prepare catalyzer separately.
The device can easily prepare highly dispersed CNT compound with CNT lamella
structure/core structure of compound material. The catalyst is placed in the center
of the furnace to ensure that there is uniform heating and uniform chemical vapor
deposition. The gases and other chemicals are passed as mentioned earlier, and
various formation processes of the carbon nanotubes take place at their respective
temperatures.
The polymer used in this research was purchased from Sigma-Aldrich. The polymer
has 99% purity and a molecular weight ranging from 1,50,000 to 2,00,000 mol.
Preparation method adopted to prepare this polymer is described by the authors of
[18] in Fig. 3.
Polyacrylonitrile (PAN) powder was first weighed and placed in the beaker described
in Fig. 4. It is then dissolved in DMF using a probe sonicator which produces ultra-
sonic waves to form a homogeneous polymer solution described in Fig. 5. The time
used for obtaining a complete homogeneous solution of PAN is about 12 min having
an OFF and ON cycle of 5 s and with a pulse of 50 Hz.
Fig. 4 Polyacrylonitrile
polymer (PAN) weighed in a
beaker before preparation of
PAN solution
The multiwall carbon nanotubes were weighed using the electronic weighing balance.
Solutions were created with wt% varying from 1 to 10. The solvent used in this
application is the same dimethylformamide (DMF). 60 ml of the solvent was taken
in 100 ml beaker, and the carbon nanotubes were added. The amount of carbon
nanotubes added for every sample preparation varies from 10 to 100 mg, respectively.
A total of 10 samples were created with weight percentage 1–10 %wt. The probe
sonicator was used to disperse and defragment the carbon nanotubes in DMF. The
complete dispersion takes place in 20 min and having an ON cycle of 15 s and
OFF cycle of 5 s and with a pulse of 50 Hz. The final homogeneous solution of
defragmented CNT and DMF is shown in Fig. 6.
It was ensured that the solvent chosen (DMF) would be a common solvent for both
PAN and CNTs, thereby assuring no chemical reactivity between solvents. The two
solutions formed in 2.7 and 2.8 were mixed using a probe sonicator for about 30 min
with a pulse of 50 Hz and an ON and OFF cycle of 5 s. A homogeneous solution of
defragmented CNT and PAN was formed which is described in Fig. 7. Evaporation
process is carried out by pouring the solution in a 4-inch petri dish and placing it on
a hotplate as shown in Fig. 8. The hot plate is maintained at a constant temperature
of 90 °C. A vacuum furnace can also be used for evaporation purpose.
The evaporation process takes place till all the solvent has evaporated and a thin
film (50 µm thick) of composite material is formed in the petri dish as depicted
in Fig. 9. The film was then peeled from the petri dish carefully without tearing
as shown in Fig. 10. This method adopted for preparing a thin film by evaporating
322 N. Arunkumar et al.
Fig. 7 Prepared
homogeneous solution of
CNT and PAN by probe
sonication process
Fig. 8 Homogeneous
composite solution placed on
a hot plate for evaporation
process
the common solvent is known as solvent casting process explained in detail with an
example by the authors of [19, 20]. The concentration of the nanotubes was varied
with respect to the polymer concentration. The same process was repeated for all the
samples and was checked for its morphology using a scanning electron microscope.
SEM observations at low resolution were used to assess the degree of dispersion of
the defragmented carbon nanotubes in the polymer matrix.
The tubular structure of carbon nanotubes has been distorted into flake-like struc-
tures during probe sonication. According to references [1–4], carbon nanotubes have
excellent electrical conducting properties. Our discussion focused on using this prop-
erty of CNTs to enhance the electrical conductivity of insulators, namely polymers by
incorporating CNTs into them. Polymers have two major drawbacks which restrict
its usage. One being its mechanical strength and other its electrical and thermal
properties. By overcoming its drawbacks and with addition to its advantages (light
in weight, high corrosion resistant, etc.), it would have a huge impact in replacing
conventional materials in structural and electrical domains.
The samples were observed under a scanning electron microscope, and images of
the morphology were obtained. The following are the SEM images for a few samples
of the nanocomposite film. It is evident that the carbon nanotubes are completely
defragmented into carbon layers or strands of carbon. This carbon is represented by
the dark shaded area in the image. The lighter strands represent the polymer polyacry-
lonitrile strands which are spread throughout the matrix. Fig. 11 is the SEM image
of 4 %wt CNT (which is 40 mg of CNT in 960 mg of polymer). The magnifica-
tion was taken to 1 µm, and the analysis was conducted. While the defragmentation
process using the probe sonicator, it is noticed that complete defragmentation into
324 N. Arunkumar et al.
Fig. 11 Low-resolution
SEM images of composite
films prepared using the
probe sonicator
pure carbon will occur only during extensive use of the device. Figure 11, 12, and
13 indicate a lesser level of defragmentation of the CNTs which can be noticed by
the flake-like structure indicating the graphene distorted rings merged with polymer.
Hence, longer the sonication process, more the defragmentation of CNTs occurs.
The flake-like structure indicated in Fig. 12 has graphene layers fused with the poly-
mer which was the result of defragmenting the CNTs during solvent casting it with
the polymer. The magnification was taken at 500 nm. Partial flakes and dispersion
of PAN and defragmented CNTs are noticed in Fig. 13. The sample consisted of
8 %wt CNT and was magnified at 1 µm. The broad flake-like structure represents
the carbon/graphene structure merged with the polymer which is similar to Figs. 11
and 12 (Fig. 14 and Table 1).
Table 2 indicates the values which have been measured using a multimeter. This
multimeter has a very high sensitivity of measuring resistivity of sample. The resis-
tance and conductivity have been calculated using basic formula of electrical resis-
tance and resistivity formula. The graph shows the variation of various electric prop-
erties of the nanocomposite with the variation of carbon nanotube weight percentage.
Table 1 Concentration of
S. No. Percentage of Weight of CNT Weight of
various samples
CNT (%) added (mg) polyacrylonitile
(mg)
1 2 20 980
2 3 30 970
3 4 40 960
4 5 50 950
5 6 60 940
6 7 70 930
7 8 80 920
8 9 90 910
The electrical resistivity of the material decreases gradually with increase in concen-
tration of CNT as shown in Fig. 15. Similarly, resistance decreases by a large extent
with increase in CNT as shown in the graph. Conductance increases drastically with
the increase in CNT as shown in the graph. Resistivity is measured in m (ohm
Fig. 15 Resistivity,
resistance, and conductivity
versus CNT concentration
Experimental Study and Analysis of Defragmented Carbon … 327
meter). Weight of the CNT in the composite is measured in mg. Figure 16 shows that
with the increase in carbon nanotubes in the polymer matrix, the resistivity decreases.
This happens because the free electrons travel through a defined path along the carbon
nanotubes. Therefore, there is less opposition to the flow of electrons. Hence, there
is decrease in resistivity with more number of CNTs added in the polymer matrix.
Resistance is measured in ohms (). Concentration of the CNT is measured in mg.
Resistance is defined as the opposition to the flow of electric current. This opposi-
tion involves protons which oppose the flow of electric current by creating a barrier.
When CNTs are added to the polymer matrix, the potential barrier space is reduced
drastically and the concentration of current along the carbon nanotubes increases;
hence, the opposition is less. Therefore, there is a decrease in resistance with more
number of CNTs added in the polymer matrix as shown in Fig. 17. Conductivity is
measured in siemens/meter. The concentration of the CNTs is measured in mg. Con-
ductivity is defined as the flow of electrons through a material for a specified area of
cross section and length. The conductivity of the material increases drastically with
the increase in CNT concentration as depicted in Fig. 18. Hence, conductance also
increases. The flow of electrons is aligned along the carbon nanotube walls and acts
as a carrier of current which is present all through the polymer matrix.
4 Conclusion
It has been experimentally proved that by inserting the carbon nanotubes into the
polymer matrix, the electric properties of the polymer are improved drastically. The
original resistance of the polymer was found to be in the range of 1016 . After
adding carbon nanotubes into the matrix, it was found to be in the range of 10 to 103
. This proves that a significant increase in the electrical properties of a polymer
can be improved by addition of carbon nanotubes. With further doping of carbon
nanotubes, the conductance can be compared with the present materials which are
used for electrical purposes such as copper and silver. The PAN nanocomposite is
a unique material which consists of good electrical properties, high tensile strength
which is inherited from the carbon nanotubes and also good corrosion resistant which
is inherited from the polymer polyacrylonitrile.
References
1. Bhushan B (2010) Introduction of carbon nano tubes. In: Springer handbook of nanotechnology,
Part A, pp 47–118
2. Perie T, Brosse A-C, Tence-Girault S (2012) Mechanical and electrical properties of multi
walled carbon nanotubes/ABC block terpolymer composites. Carbon 50(8):2918–2928
3. Bai J, Huang Y (2010) Fabrication and electrical properties of graphene nanoribbons. Mater
Sci Eng: R: Rep 70(3–6):341–353
4. Shokrieh MM, Rafiee R (2010) Mechanics of composite materials. Chem Mater Sci 46(2):155–
172
5. Marinho B, Ghislandi M, Tkalya E, Koning CE, de With G (2012) Electrical conductivity
of compacts of graphene, multi-wall carbon nanotubes, carbon black, and graphite powder.
Powder Technol 221:351–358
Experimental Study and Analysis of Defragmented Carbon … 329
6. Inam F, Reece MJ, Peijs T (2012) Shortened carbon nanotubes and their influence on the
electrical properties of polymer nanocomposites. J Compos Mater 46(11):1313–1322
7. Zhang Y, Rutledge GC (2012) Electrical conductivity of electrospun polyaniline and
polyaniline-blend fibers and Mats. Macromolecules 45(10):4238–4246
8. Hou H, Reneker DH (2004) Carbon nanotubes on carbon nanofibers: a novel structure based
on electrospun polymer nanofibers. Adv Mater 16:69–73
9. Rzepka M, Bauer E, Reichenauer G, Schliermann T, Bernhardt B, Bohmhammel K (2005)
Hydrogen storage capacity of catalytically grown carbon nanofibers. J Phys Chem B
109:14979–14989
10. Greiner A, Wendorff JH (2007) Electrospinning: a fascinating method for the preparation of
ultrathin fibers. Angew Chem Int Ed 46:5670–5673
11. Aravind SS, Eswaraiah V, Ramaprabhu S (2011) Facile synthesis of one dimensional graphene
wrapped carbon nanotube composites by chemical vapor deposition. J Mater Chem 21:15179
12. Jeong JM, Choi MY, Ahn YT (2006) Morphology and properties of polyacrylonitrile
nanocomposite prepared viain-situ polymeriszation with macroazoinitiator. Macromol Res
14(3):312–317
13. Lu C, Liu J (2006) controlling the diameter of carbon nanotubes in chemical vapor deposition
Method by carbon feeding. J Phys Chem 110(41):20254–20257
14. Cantoro M, Hofmann S, Pisana S, Scardaci V, Parvez A, Ducati C, Ferrari AC, Blackburn
AM, Wang K-Y, Robertson J (2006) Catalytic chemical vapor deposition of single-wall carbon
Nanotubes at lowtemperatures. Nano Letters 6(6):1107–1112
15. Marcano DC, Kosynkin DV, Berlin JM, Sinitskii A, Sun Z, Slesarev A, Alemany LB, Lu W,
Tour JM (2010) Improved synthesis of graphene oxide. ACS Nano 4(8):4806–4814
16. Arai T, Yamazaki H, Tsujimoto T (2006) Solvent casting process. US Patent No. 7,132,074
17. Eswaraiah V, Sankaranarayanan V, Ramaprabhu S (2011) Inorganic nanotubes reinforced
polyvinylidene fluoride composites as low-cost electromagnetic interference shielding materi-
als. Nanoscale Res Lett 6(1):137
18. Kim JH, Ganapathya HS, Hong S-S, Gal Y-S, Lim KT (2008) Preparation of polyacrylonitrile
nanofibers as a precursor of carbon nanofibers by supercritical fluid process. J Supercrit Fluids
47:103–107
19. Safadi B, Andrews R, Grulke EA (2002) Multiwalled carbon nanotube polymer composites:
synthesis and characterization of thin films. J Appl Polym Sci 84(14):2660–2669
20. Moniruzzaman M, Winey KI (2006) Polymer nanocomposites containing carbon nanotubes.
Macromolecules 39(16):5194–5205
Design and Fabrication of Car Door
Panel Using Natural Fiber-Reinforced
Polymer Composites
Abstract For a lot of years, extensive research was carried on the use of natu-
ral fibers in automotive sector to meet the environmental regulations as well as to
increase the profit margins of company. Natural fibers being of low cost, recyclable
and lightweight provide industry with the best alternative for traditional materials
such as steel, aluminum and synthetic fiber. Applications such as car door panels,
sun visors, seat covers and rearview mirrors have provided excellent scope for usage
of natural fiber-reinforced polymer composites. Various car manufacturers have suc-
cessfully implemented natural fiber-reinforced polymers in some of their car models
in recent years and have yielded desirable results in terms of lightness, cost saving
and reduction of environmental pollution. Various factors such as combinations of
fibers, layer sequence, fiber-to-matrix ratio and manufacturing method influence the
properties of the composite specimens. The natural fibers used are flax, hemp and
kenaf. Epoxy is selected as a matrix material. Hand layup method was used to fab-
ricate the specimens as well the car door panel. The mechanical testing was carried
out to determine the tensile strength, flexural strength, hardness and impact strength
according to ASTM standards. The composite with most desirable mechanical prop-
erties is chosen to fabricate the final car door panel. This paper also discusses about
the optimization of influencing parameters for drilling the natural fiber-reinforced
epoxy plate using Taguchi method. Spindle speed, feed rate and drill bit diameter
are selected as input parameters. These parameters which influence the thrust force
are measured by using drill tool dynamometer.
1 Introduction
Recently, the growing need of alternative materials in the field of aerospace, marines
and construction, etc., had led to in-depth research in natural fiber-reinforced polymer
composites [1, 2]. Natural fiber-reinforced polymer composites consist of polymer
matrix reinforced with natural fibers such as flax, kenaf, sisal, hemp and jute. These
fibers possess high specific strength and high modulus and are used in various appli-
cations [3]. Natural fibers offer advantages over synthetic fibers such as high specific
strength, renewable, recyclable, less damage to processing equipment and easily
available. Srinivas et al. [4] investigated the properties of various natural fiber com-
posites such as jute, sisal, banana, bamboo, flax, kenaf, coir, hemp, curaua, cotton,
abaca and Ramie and compared it with synthetic fibers such as glass, carbon and
Kevlar. Hemp, flax, kenaf, abaca, etc., were found to have comparable properties
of tensile strength and Young’s modulus to those of synthetic fibers. Natural fibers
were seen as potential replacements due to their lower cost and recyclable in nature.
Various studies have been carried out on comparison of using hand layup method
and vacuum infusion method for preparation of composites [5]. In the present study,
hand layup method is selected based on various factors such as flexibility of design,
low volume of production and good surface finish. It is also an easier method for
production of heavy components.
Mechanical testing of natural fiber-reinforced polymer composites is quite essen-
tial to determine its tensile strength, flexural strength, impact strength, hardness and
water absorption property. Numerous studies have been carried out on mechanical
testing on natural fiber-reinforced polymer composites [6–12]. Mechanical proper-
ties of natural fiber-reinforced polymer composites depend on various factors such
as type of fiber, fiber-to-matrix ratio, stacking sequence of fiber, fiber orientation,
manufacturing method and number of layers. Elanchezhian et al. [13] evaluated the
mechanical properties of kenaf, name and banana hybrid composites. The ratio of
resin to hardener was found in the ratio of 10:1 to provide adequate interfacial bond-
ing between fibers. It was found that kenaf fiber possessed the highest tensile strength
and hardness among all the combinations and can be used for automotive compo-
nents using car hood and mudguard. The ratio of hardener to resin should be 1:10
to provide suitable interfacial strength, and the critical ratio of fiber to matrix was
found to be 40:60 for best mechanical properties. Girisha et al. [14] studied the prop-
erties of sisal, coconut fiber and ridge guard fiber. The mold was prepared by using
hand layup method. The specimens of the three fibers with epoxy are made with
varying the ratio of fiber to matrix. Increase in strength was observed with increase
in fiber volume fraction. However, natural fibers are hydrophilic in nature because
of cellulose content present in them. Hydrophilic fibers offer insufficient adhesion
with hydrophobic polymer matrices. This may lead to improper adhesion and bond
breakage between matrix and fibers. Various types of chemical treatment methods
such as alkali treatment and saline treatments are available to remove the moisture
from the natural fibers [15]. Alkali treatments such as treatment with 10% NaOH
for 24 h improve the fiber–matrix adhesion due to removal of moisture. This along
Design and Fabrication of Car Door Panel Using Natural … 333
with increased surface roughness, increased aspect ratio and reduction in moisture
absorption properties of fibers results in increased mechanical properties.
The applications of NFRCs in automobile industry include door panels, floor
panels, sun visor, door cladding, mudguards and in aerospace applications such as
aircrafts nose, doors, struts, outboard and indoor flaps and stabilizers [16]. Holbery
et al. [17] studied the process of making thermoplastic polypropylene with natural
fibers like compounding process, extrusion, kneading, injection molding, compres-
sion molding and sheet molding compound. The applications for these composites in
automotive sector include door cladding, seatback lining, cushions, floor panel, floor
body panels, head restraints and sound proofing. The improvement of these compos-
ites from plastic composites is increased stability, enhanced mechanical properties,
excellent electrical properties, good impact strength. dos Santos et al. [18] postu-
lated that the traditional materials used in automotive application can be replaced by
natural reinforced composites. Experimentation was carried on modification of nat-
ural fiber to improve their properties like stretching, calendaring, electric discharge
method, alkaline treatment and copolymerization. The fiber used for this study is
curaua. The application of this natural fiber is sun visor, sun visor hinge pin and
car interiors. The major problems which occur in drilling of natural fibers are fiber
pullouts from matrix and delamination of composite. So, various parameters have to
be optimized during drilling of natural fibers for higher surface finish and low thrust
force [19]. Various experimental analyses were carried out to determine the torque
and thrust force during drilling operation of NFRCs [20].
2 Methodology
Flax, hemp and kenaf fiber mats were selected as reinforcements for epoxy (LY556)
matrix. Hy951 Hardener was used. Hand Layup was used for fabricating the compos-
ite specimens. Totally six different composite plates with layers each were fabricated.
All the natural fibers were chemically treated with 10% NaOH solution to remove the
moisture content present in the fibers. Flax fiber-reinforced epoxy composite plate
with layers of flax fiber is fabricated with size 350 * 350 mm as shown in Fig. 1a.
Similarly, with the same size, kenaf and hemp are fabricated as shown in Fig. 1b, c,
respectively. Three hybrid plates are fabricated using three different combinations of
fiber mats such as kenaf + hemp, flax + hemp and flax + kenaf as shown in Figs. 1d,
e, f, respectively.
334 S. V. N. B. Prasad et al.
a b c
d e f
Fig. 1 a Flax [F6 ], b Kenaf [K6 ], c Hemp [H6 ], d Kenaf + hemp [(K/H)3 ], e Flax + hemp [(F/H)3 ],
f Flax + kenaf [(F/K)3 ]
3 Experimental Testing
Tensile test is carried out on all the six specimens as per ASTM D-3039 standard. In
this test, the specimen is subjected to a constant tensile force until it fails. The stress–
strain plot for various combinations of composite plates is shown in Fig. 2. Properties
that can be determined by a tensile test are ultimate tensile strength, breaking strength,
maximum elongation and area reduction.
Flexural test is carried out as per ASTM D-790 standard. The three-point flexural or
bending test is used to determine the modulus of elasticity, flexural stress and flexural
strain. The main advantage of a three-point bending test is the ease of the specimen
preparation and its testing. The main disadvantage of this method is that the results
are sensitive to specimen, the loading geometry and the strain rate of the specimen
under the load. The load versus displacement graph is shown in Fig. 3.
Impact test is carried out as per ASTM D-256 standard that was used for testing. The
energy absorbed by the specimens is calculated from the height from which the arm
swings to after hitting the specimen which is shown in Fig. 4.
ASTM D-2583 standard was followed to carry out this testing. The Barcol hard-
ness test studies the indentation hardness of materials by measuring the depth of
penetration made by an indenter, loaded on a material sample and compared to the
penetration in a reference material. The values of hardness are shown in Fig. 5.
336 S. V. N. B. Prasad et al.
Mechanical testing was carried out on all the specimens; the results are shown
in Table 1. The composite made up of all six flax fibers showed better mechanical
properties over others. So, this combination of six flax fibers is chosen for fabrica-
tion of car door panel. It is observed that individual fibers possess higher mechanical
properties than the hybrid combinations. This unusual trend is attributed to the pres-
ence of a large number of voids on the surface of hemp and kenaf fiber, which leads
to poor interfacial bonding and hence poor mechanical properties among the hybrid
fibers.
Flax fiber-reinforced epoxy composite is selected among the five combinations. The
properties of ABS plastic and the flax fiber-reinforced composite plate are compared
as shown in Table 2.
Design and Fabrication of Car Door Panel Using Natural … 337
On comparing flexural strength of the flax fiber and ABS plastic, flax has more
flexural strength. But impact strength is almost same for both flax and ABS plastic.
So, flax can be used as alternative material for ABS plastic while fabricating the car
door panel.
4 Machining
CNC machining center is used for drilling the natural fiber-reinforced epoxy com-
posites using HSS twist drill tool. Drill tool dynamometer is connected to CNC
machining center which is used to measure the thrust force as shown in Fig. 6.
Thrust force values are measured for flax specimen. L9 orthogonal array is used in
Taguchi analysis. Three influencing parameters are chosen in three levels (3 * 3). The
three influential parameters are drill bit size, spindle speed and feed rate. The main
objective function is to reduce the thrust force. So smaller is better is chosen while
undergoing Taguchi analysis using Minitab software. Residual plots for thrust force
338 S. V. N. B. Prasad et al.
are obtained after Taguchi as shown in Fig. 8 by selecting four in one. All the param-
eters are taken with three levels as shown in Table 3. Thrust force is the response
variable recorded for all nine runs. General linear model was performed in analysis
of variance using Minitab software to obtain the % of contribution of parameters on
thrust force. Spindle speed plays a major role in varying the thrust force from the %
of contribution in Table 5. Spindle speed, drill bit size and feed rate are contributing
13.33, 53.08 and 30.86, respectively. The signal-to-noise ratio shows the optimized
parameters from the given parameters. The highest signal-to-noise ratio value will
be the optimized value. At 5 mm drill bit size, 50 mm/min feed rate and 3000 rpm
spindle speed are shown in Fig. 7. Response table for means is obtained as shown in
Table 4.
-34
Mean of SN ratios
-35
-36
-37
-38
5 6 7 50 100 150 1000 2000 3000
Signal-to-noise: Smaller is better
2
50
0
10
-2
1
-8 -4 0 4 8 40 60 80
Residual Fitted Value
4.5
2
Residual
3.0
0
1.5
-2
0.0
-2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Residual Observation Order
Conformability test is performed for the optimized parameters of 5 mm drill bit size,
50 mm/min feed rate and 3000 rpm spindle speed. Least thrust force of 33.82 N is
obtained.
Design and Fabrication of Car Door Panel Using Natural … 341
Original door panel was purchased from the automobile spare parts vendor. To fab-
ricate the mold using hand layup, firstly, applied wax on the specimen to clean the
surface and then applied the PVA on the specimen for easy removal of mold after
curing. Resin, catalyst and chalk powder are mixed and applied over the PVA. The
glass fiber mat is placed, and resin mixture is transferred on to it. Repeated this pro-
cedure for three layers and cured it for 48 h. Mold is removed from the original door
panel. The final mold obtained from hand layup is as shown in Fig. 9. Flax fiber is
used to fabricate the final door panel. The same technique was employed to fabricate
the door panel using hand layup method as shown in Fig. 10.
6 Conclusion
References
1. Haydar Zaman U, Mubarak Khan A, Ruhul Khan A, Arifur Rahman M, Lily Das R, Al-Mamun
MD (2010) Role of potassium permanganate and urea on the Improvement of the mechanical
properties of jute polypropylene composites. Fibers Polym 11(3):455–463
2. Ratna Prasad AV, Mohana Rao K, Gupta AVSSKS, Reddy BV (2011) A study on flexural
Properties of Wild cane grass Fiber-reinforced polyester composites. J Mater Sci 46:2627–2634
3. Yang Yuqiu, Ota Tomoko, Morii T, Hamada H (2011) Mechanical property and hydrothermal
aging of injection molded jute/polypropylene composites. J Mater Sci 46:2678–2684
4. Srinivas K, Lakshumu Naidu A, Raju Bahubalendruni MVA (2017) A review on chemical
and Mechanical properties of natural fiber reinforced polymer composites. Int J Perform Eng
13(2):189–200
5. MohdYuhazri Y, Phongsakorn PT, Sihombing H (2010) A Comparison process between vacuum
infusion and Hand lay-up method toward kenaf/polyester composites. Int J Basic Appl Sci
IJBAS-IJENS 10(3)
6. Jamrichova Z, Akova E (2013) Mechnical testing of natural fiber composites for automotive
industry. Univ Rev 7(3):20–25
7. Dan-mallam Y, Abdullah MZ, MegatYusoff PSM (2012) Predicting the tensile properties of
woven kenaf/polyethylene terephthalate (PET) fiber reinforced polyoymethylene (POM) hybrid
laminate composite. J Mech Civil Eng (IOSRJMCE)
8. Muthukumar V, Venkatasamy R, Sureshbabu A, Arunkumar D (2011) A study on mechanical
properties of natural fiber reinforced Laminates of Epoxy (Ly 556) polymer matrix composites.
Int J Prod Technol Manag Res 2(2)
9. Barile C, Casavola C, De Cillis F (2019) Mechanical comparision of new composite materials
for aerospace applications. Elsevier J Compos Part B 162:122–128
10. Alagarraja K, Dhamodharan A, Gopinathan K Mathan Raj R, Ram Kumar K (2014) Fabrication
and testing of fiber reinforced polymer composites material. IOSR J Mech Civil Eng (IOSR-
JMCE)
11. Arun Kumar, Abishek T, Jegatheesh Raja S, Gokul Krishnan A (2016) A review on mechanical
properties of natural fiber Reinforced hybrid polymer composites. Int J Adv Sci Tech Res 6
Design and Fabrication of Car Door Panel Using Natural … 343
12. Rihayat T, Suryani S, Fauzi T, Agusnar H, Wirjosentono B, Alam PN, Sami M (2017) Mechan-
ical properties evaluation of single and hybrid composites polyester reinforced bamboo, PALF
and coir fiber. IOP Conf Ser Mater Sci Eng 334(2018):012081
13. Elanchezhian C, VijayaRamnath B, Kaosik R, Nellaiappan TK, Santhosh Kumar K, Kavirajan
P, Sughan MU (2017) Evaluation of mechanical properties of kenaf based hybrid composite
for automotive components replacement. ARPN J Eng Appl Sci 10(13)
14. Girisha C, Sanjeevamurthy, Rangasrinivas G (2012) Tensile properties of natural fiber
reinforced epoxy hybrid composites. Int J Mod Eng Res (IJMER)
15. Suardana NPG, Piao Y, Lim JK (2011) Mechanical properties of hemp fibers and hemp/PP
composites: effects of chemical surface treatment. Mater Phys Mech 11:1–8
16. Leao AL, Rowell R, Tavares N (1998) Application of natural fibers in automotive industry. Sci
Technol Polym Adv Mater
17. Holbery J, Houston D (2006) Natural-fiber-reinforced polymer composites in automotive
applications. J Mater
18. dos Santos PA, Giriolli JC, Amarasekera J, Moraes G, Natural fibers plastic composites for
automotive applications. SABIC Innovative Plastics
19. Palani Kumar K (2011) Experimental investigation and optimization in drilling of GFRP
composites. Measurement 44:2138–2148
20. Chandramohan D, Marimuthu K (2011) Drilling of natural fiber particle reinforced polymer
composite material. Int J Adv Eng Res Stud 1(1):134–145
Investigation of Physical–Chemical
Properties and Evaluation of Optimal
Blend Ratio of Rice Bran Biodiesel:
A Mathematical Regression Analysis
Approach
1 Introduction
The fossil fuel is a great power source, but it has many drawbacks. It is the main
contributor to the increase of global warming due to its emission which leads cli-
matic changes and environmental effects like acid rain, depletion of the ozone layer,
increase in greenhouse phenomena and formation of smog. This is a renewable source
of energy, but the formation of fossil fuel takes over a million of years to renew when
compared to other sources like solar and wind energy, so it is considered to be a
non-renewable form of energy. Biodiesel be able to be extracted from a variety of
raw materials similar to vegetable oil, animal fat, used cooking oil, etc. Biodiesel is
said to be a good alternative because it is biodegradable, less toxic in nature, superior
lubricity and the abundant availability of various raw materials around us. Biodiesel
enhances the efficiency of diesel engines because it has high oxygen content, and it
also has high carbon content which increases the combustion rate. Along with the
efficiency, the emission characteristics of biodiesel are found to be better than diesel.
It emits a relatively less amount of carbon monoxide, hydrocarbons, particulate mat-
ter than diesel. However, biodiesel tends to increase the emission of nitrogen oxide
(NOx ), and also, utilization of biodiesel (B100%) within diesel engine will result in
reduced power, torque and fuel economy. Many researchers have reported that vari-
ous blends of diesel and biofuel could increase the power, torque and fuel economy
of the vehicle.
In the recent environmental research scenario regarding biofuel, the investigation
rice bran oil is considered for production of biodiesel due to the vast availability, and
India produces of about 8 lakhs tonnes rice bran oil from rice husk (which contains
nearly 10–23% of oil). Rice bran oil is removed from rice husk with help of huller
and sheller mills. Such extracted rice bran oil consists of several compositions of
fatty acids like 1.297% stearic, 14.883% palmitic, 42.013% oleic, 38.561% linoleic,
1.396% linolenic, 0.122% myristic. Production of biodiesel starts with transesteri-
fication process which involves to get fatty acid methyl ester through rice bran oil.
Fatty acids from the oil are removed so as to minimize oil viscosity for meeting the
standard value of mineral diesel.
Lin et al. (2009) produced biodiesel using transesterification process and optimum
reaction conditions to analyze the fatty acid composition. The fuel properties obtained
are well suited with the standards of ASTM D6751-02 and DIN V51606 [1]. Dennis
et al. (2010) created biodiesel by means of catalyzed process of transesterification at
atmospheric temperature and pressure which avoids the necessity of high temperature
and pressure for animal fats, and waste cooking oils increase the molar ratio of
triglycerides to alcohol of 6:1 [2]. Atabani et al. (2013) suggested Sterculia foetida
oil biodiesel blend to increase the effectiveness of properties of maximum kinematic
viscosity of 75.826 mm2 /s at 40 °C [3]. Evangelos (2013) found that the cold flow
properties have higher impact on the biodiesel than that of conventional diesel [4].
Ashrafu et al. (2014) stated that the fatty acid composition plays a major role in
the fuel properties such as viscosity, calorific value and cetane number. They also
established that monosaturated fatty acid present in the biodiesel blend at minimum
temperature increases the ignition quality and also increases the fuel properties [5].
Subhash et al. (2015) indicated that the biodiesel blend of B15 does not lead to
the wall impingement, whereas the B20 has better boundary of wall impingement
(within uncertainty ±1.3%). [6]. Bhaskor et al. (2016) carried out the three diverse
compression ratios of 18, 17.5 and 17, at injection timing 23 °C at various loading
conditions. In maximum load, the most extreme brake thermal efficiencies (BTEs)
with respect to double fuel mode (DFM) are observed to be 20.27%, 19.97% and
18.39% for CRs of 18, 17.5 and 17 [7]. Mayank et al. (2016) found that the fatty
acid content in crude rice bran oil is elevated with respect to oil quality since of over
fatty content. The two-step transesterification process is followed which includes
acid-catalyzed transesterification and base-catalyzed transesterification [8]. Baharak
et al. (2016) found that the edible oil has various drawbacks like deforestation,
Investigation of Physical–Chemical Properties and Evaluation … 347
increased vegetable oil price, to overcome which extraction can be done with non-
edible oils(rice bran oil, rubber seed, mahua seed, silk cotton, babassu tree) [9].
Mohamed Shameer et al. [10] used the B20 blend because of its low emission and
increased engine performance. Also, they used advanced injection timing as well as
injection pressure for reducing emission [10].
Maria et al. (2017) found that rice bran is the by-product of rice which is under-
utilized and could be used in biodiesel production and also rich in protein. They
also stated that the rice bran oil is more captivating for its more nutraceutical char-
acteristics and balanced fatty acid content [11]. Ertan et al. (2017) stated that the
oxygenated fuel blends reduce NOx emission but increase CO2, CO [12]. Evangelos
et al. (2018) analyzed the properties of fuel with respect to the fatty acid composition
of the biodiesel. They also analyzed the properties such as the cetane number, den-
sity, kinematic viscosity with respect to the fatty acid content present in the biodiesel.
[13]. Ertan et al. (2019) stated that the fuel properties play a major role in the per-
formance, combustion and injection characteristics of the diesel engine. They also
stated that the combustion and performance of methyl and ethyl ester show better
values when compared with diesel at various engine conditions such as engine speed
and at different load conditions (BMEP 3.3, 5.0, 6.6, 8.3 bar) [14]. Jeyaprakash
et al. (2019) investigated rice bran biodiesel in a four-stroke, single-cylinder, direct-
injection engine which runs at 1500 rpm is made in which the biodiesel blend of
20%(B20) has greater values when compared with other blending ratio. Their results
show that the rice husk contains about 16–20% of crude rice bran oil, and it has high
in-cylinder pressure of about 72.1 bar and heat release rate of about 70.826 J/CA
[15].
In our research work, consider rice bran oil for production of biodiesel due to
the vast availability. Rice bran oil is removed from rice husk with help of huller and
sheller mills. Such extracted rice bran oil consists of several compositions of fatty
acids like stearic, palmitic, oleic, linoleic, linolenic, myristic. Production of biodiesel
starts with transesterification process involves to get fatty acid methyl ester (FAME)
from rice bran oil.
Rice bran oil is edible oil which is used for cooking purpose. Rice husk is a main
source of rice bran oil. India produces about 80 million tonnes of paddy from which 5
million tons of rice bran and to the extent of 8 lakh tonnes of rice bran oil are obtained.
2 lakh tonnes is currently produced and about 10–12% percentage is of edible grade.
Around 5–10 kg of rice bran is produced from 100 kg of paddy. About 10–23%
of rice bran oil is produced from rice bran. Rice bran is a mixture of substances
which contains protein, fat, ash and crude fiber. 70% of the paddy is processed by
huller mills, and about 30% is produced by sheller mills. Rice bran oil production
comes under three production phases. The first and foremost is the primary phase
which includes needing, feeding, separating of fogging material (killing insects that
348 M. Selvam et al.
involves using fine pesticide spray). The separated material is fed into the cooker for
steam processing, and then, the cooked material is fed into the palletizer to make
material into pallets. Now, the pallets are allowed to cool down; then they are sent
to the conveyor for the extraction. The second phase is started by pouring pallets
into hexanoate in order to remove the hexane. Then, the final stage is the distillation
process; the product from the distillation process is fed into the missile tank for
storage, and now, the stored product is sent to the heater to evaporate the hexane in
order to produce crude rice bran oil. The crude rice bran oil consists of dissolved
gum which is removed by degumming process. Further, it is sent to bleaching section
to refine the crude oil; following the bleaching section, it is sent to the de-waxing
section where the wax is removed from the oil. At last, deodorizing process is carried
out at high vacuum and temperature to remove the fatty acids. Thus, the required
edible rice bran oil is obtained.
The raw rice bran oil was extracted from conventional process. The oil was then
filtered to remove minuscule residues. The raw rice bran oil was transformed to
biodiesel by transesterification technique. Initially, the oil was heated to a temperature
of about 55–60 °C. By the side, methanol (10%) and potassium hydroxide (KOH)
were titrated and added to the oil. Then, the concoction is stirred thoroughly at
600 rpm for about an hour. The mixture is kept nearly for 24 h for the glycerol to
settle down. At the end of the process, glycerol is settled down, and after its removal,
fatty acid methyl ester is obtained. Warm water was added to the methyl ester and
kept for 24 h in order to take away suspended impurities. The above said process is
clearly shown in Fig. 1.
The properties like kinematic viscosity, density, flash point, fire point, cetane
number, cloud point, pour point were tested using standard apparatus and examined
for both raw rice bran oil and biodiesel.
Rice bran oil as well as rice bran biodiesel is composed of 17.892% and 18.849%
of saturated fats and 82.102% and 81.152% of unsaturated fats, respectively. The
level of free fatty acid of rice bran oil as well as rice bran biodiesel is evaluated by
means of gas chromatography (GC) test. Gas chromatography (GC) is a typical kind
of chromatography utilized for isolating and breaking down composites that can be
vaporized without disintegration. The free fatty acid compositions are described in
Investigation of Physical–Chemical Properties and Evaluation … 349
terms of C:D ratio, where C represents the number of carbon atoms and D represents
the number of double carbon atom chains. The succeeding acids have the major part
in rice bran oil and rice bran biodiesel. Rice bran oil and rice bran biodiesel consist
of 42.013% and 41.414% of oleic acid C18:1 which is also used as an emulsifying
agent as it withstands the structure of chemical compounds. The linoleic acid C18:2
has volumes of 38.236% and 38.032% in rice bran oil and biodiesel. The palmitic
acid C16:0 serves as release agent and also used to increase the volatility. It is present
about 14.883% and 15.897% in rice bran oil and biodiesel, respectively.
The vibrational motion of the functional group is determined by the Fourier trans-
formation infrared spectroscopy of the diesel sample and biodiesel blends of B30 as
shown in Fig. 2 and B100 as shown in Fig. 3. In the infrared region, the light rays pass
through the interferometer and the beam splitter to generate absorption frequencies.
350 M. Selvam et al.
The peaks in the spectrum band are the absorbent of the vibration molecule and the
concentration of the mixture. MIR (Mid-range) valDB; ues for this apparatus are in
range of 400–4000 cm−1 and as a resolution of about 1 cm−1 . The highest peak is
found for blend of B30. The double bond stretching vibration related to C–H alkyl
methylene group which frame olefin and to extend fluctuation and reduce at methyl
group and the second peak clearly at 1745 cm−1 C=O carbonyl group it frames esters
the C–H group’s tendency in –CH3 and CH2 assignment and as same as the B100
Investigation of Physical–Chemical Properties and Evaluation … 351
sample as shown in Fig. 3. In between 3007 and 2926 cm−1 stretch combined with
2855 cm−1 and yield stretch has shown –CH2 and the C–H alkyl group is present at
another peak got at 1743 cm−1 carbonyl C=O aldehyde are identified both sample
bending has approximately at 723 cm−1 . The sample of diesel shown in Fig. 4 has
similar functional groups at the approximate region of wave number in the spectro-
metric image, and the appropriate values were given as well as the functional group
families and type of vibration motion.
Blending the biofuel with mineral diesel is mostly preferred in many countries
because the use of 100% of biodiesel in the engine may have some drawbacks like less
availability, poor cold flow properties and comparatively reduced calorific value. For
this purpose, a detailed investigation was done to analyze the deviation, and required
information is gained in the physical and chemical properties of diesel and biodiesel
blend. Rice bran oil is blended with mineral diesel at different blending ratios from
10 to 90% to determine the properties like kinematic viscosity, density, calorific
value, fire point, flash point, cloud point, pour point. The above said properties are
measured using the instruments compared with different bending ratios, and graphs
are generated to determine the deviation of properties for each blending ratio for the
same. The mathematical regression equations are determined from which values of
properties for different blending ratios are established. This considerably reduces the
time and cost.
Graphs for different properties of rice bran biodiesel blends are established. Mathe-
matical regression equation is developed for these properties using analysis software
know as sigma plot software, which is mainly used to predict the values for the dif-
ferent properties of various blending ratios. Here, in the mathematical equation, ‘x’
represents the blending ratio which is defined as the mixture of mineral diesel and
biofuel.
Equation:
Y = ax + b (1)
‘a’ coefficient
‘b’ coefficient
Coefficient of determination
R 2 = r x2y (5)
In our research work, rice bran oil properties have been evaluated and compared
with various standards like American Standard (ASTM), European Standard (EN)
and Bharat Standard (BIS).
4.1 Density
Density can be defined as ratio of mass per volume which is mostly communicated
as kilogram per meter cubic. Density plays a major role in the engine output and
performance since the change in density has a direct influence on the mass of the fuel,
which has an effect on the fuel injection in the engine. Also, density has greater effect
on emission like particulate matter (PM) and NOx . When the density is increased by
10%, it leads to loss of combustion heat by 4%. Thus, in order to increase the heat
of combustion, the density of rice bran is reduced. The main reason to reduce the
density of biofuel is to reduce the viscosity which has influences on the fuel injection
characteristics. The density of mineral diesel is in the range of about 820 kg/m3 .
It is clearly detected that the density values increase in a linear manner in which
the density increases with the increase in blending ratio because of the increase in
the biofuel ratio in the biodiesel mixture. Thus, the density range for B30 is almost
nearer to the density value and is also in range mentioned in the EN-590 (reference
paper no). The density value reaches up to a range of 874 kg/m3 for the B90 blends.
These values are shown in Table 1.
354
Fig. 5 Density vs Biodiesel blending ratio and kinematic viscosity vs Biodiesel blending ratio
Viscosity is the oil’s resistance to flow and shear. Thus, the kinematic viscosity was
determined using Redwood Viscometer. This kinematic viscosity has an important
influence in the fuel flow and fuel injection. Kinematic viscosity should be in the
range of 2–5 mm2 /s which will affect the fluidity of the fuel at low temperature.
When the kinematic viscosity increases, it will affect the combustion rate since the
atomization of the fuel will be delayed. Spray cone angle and spray penetration are
reduced with increase in viscosity and results in bigger droplets. High viscosity can
reduce fuel flow rates which results in inadequate fueling of engine. On the other
hand, low viscosity results in fuel leakage and loss of fuel system calibration. As in
the density, the viscosity value also has a linear increase in value with the increase
in the volumetric ratio of the rice bran biofuel with the mineral diesel as shown in
Fig. 5. In this, the viscosity range for raw biodiesel (B100) is about 30.26 mm2 /s
whereas the value for B30 blend is almost nearer at 3 mm2 /s which satisfies the
engine specification and also helps to increase the combustion rate.
The amount of heat liberated during the combustion at steady pressure and tempera-
ture is known as calorific value. It is one of the major factors that has an effect in the
combustion rate and also affects the output power of the engine. The calorific value
is measured using the bomb calorimeter, which is measured by the heat produced by
combustion of a little quantity of oil. This is usually expressed in kilojoules’ per kilo-
gram. Figure 6 shows the variation of calorific value with the various blending ratios
of rice bran biodiesel. In contrast to density and kinematic viscosity, the calorific
value shows a decrease in value with increasing blending ratio. The calorific value
for raw rice bran oil is almost around 36,283 kJ/kg which is less when compared to
356 M. Selvam et al.
Fig. 6 Calorific value vs Biodiesel blending ratio and Flash point vs Biodiesel blending ratio
mineral diesel. But the biodiesel blends of B20 and B30 have a calorific value nearer
to diesel.
The minimal temperature at which the fuel starts to vaporize and forms as an ignitable
mixture in the presence of atmospheric air around the fuel surface is termed as flash
point. Ignition source temperature does not have effect on flash and fire point, but
its value is far higher than that of flash point and fire point. However, lower the flash
point easier to ignite the fuel mixture. The flash point of diesel is 55, and flash point
of biofuel is 165. In order to reduce the flash point value, the biofuel is blended
with mineral diesel. The fuel is termed as flammable if the flash point value is less
than 37.8 °C, and if value is greater than 37.8 °C, then the fuel is called combustible.
Thus, crude rice bran oil and biodiesel come under combustible fuel. Figure 7 clearly
shows that value of flash point gradually increases from B0 to B100.
Fig. 7 Fire point vs Biodiesel blending ratio and Cetane number vs Biodiesel blending ratio
Investigation of Physical–Chemical Properties and Evaluation … 357
Fig. 8 Cloud point vs Biodiesel blending ratio and Pour point vs Biodiesel blending ratio
Fire point can be defined as the minimal temperature at which the fuel vapor starts
to burn for a specified time after it is ignited. In general, the fire point will be 10 °C
more than the flash point. In Fig. 8, same as that of the density and flash point, the
fire point also has a linear increase in values for increasing values of blending ratio.
It is observed that the raw rice bran oil has a fire point of about 242 °C. The blending
ratio B30 and B20 has optimal fire point when compared to the mineral diesel.
Cetane number is a marker or indicator which gives the info about the ignition
delay and also indicates the ignition quality of the fuel. For the increasing value of
cetane number, the ignition delay period reduces subsequently the rate of combustion
increases and vice versa. As per the ASTM standards, the cetane number should have
a minimal value of 40 to a maximum value of 60. If the value of cetane number falls
below 40, it leads to smoke emission and fails to obey the emission laws. The cetane
number value of biodiesel lies in the acceptable range, and it also enhances the
combustion rate and reduces the ignition delay period alternatively. In the same way
as before, it also shows a linear increase in value with increase in volumetric ratio of
rice bran biofuel with the mineral diesel.
Cloud point can be referred to as the temperature at which the wax crystal is created
in the fuel which has a direct impact at the low condition application. Pour point is
also an important property for the low temperature application. It is defined as the
358 M. Selvam et al.
temperature at which the fuel losses its fluidity and flow characteristics. The cloud
point also shows constant increase with increase in blending ratio where the cloud
point of mineral diesel is around 1 °C. It is recommended that the cloud point and
the pour should be low as possible. In the same way, as that of the cloud point, the
pour point also shows an increase in readings. The pour point for the raw rice bran
biodiesel is around +5 °C whereas for mineral diesel is about −9 °C.
5 Conclusion
In this investigation, the physical and chemical properties of rice bran oil are evaluated
and compared with the mineral diesel as per ASTM-D-6751, EN-14214 and IS-
15607 standards. From this investigation, it is clearly known that different properties
of rice bran biodiesel are nearer to that of mineral diesel at lower blending ratios,
and the deviation increases as the blending ratio increases. Mathematical regression
calculation is used to determine the properties for different blending ratios. Sigma
plot software is used to draw the graph using the values determined by regression
values. From the graph, it is evaluated that B30 is optimum blending ratio. At this
blending ratio, it is found that viscosity of oil is higher than that of mineral diesel,
and other properties like density, cetane number, calorific value, flash point and fire
point are closer to that of mineral diesel. Cold flow properties like cloud point and
pour point do not show major deviation to the value of mineral diesel.
References
1. Lin L, Ying D, Chaitep S, Vittayapadung S (2009) Biodiesel production from crude rice bran
oil and properties as fuel. Appl Energy 86:681–688
2. Dennis Leung YC, Xuan W, Leung MKH (2010) A review on biodiesel production using
catalysed transesterification. Appl Energy 87:1083–1095
3. Atabani AE, Mahlia TMI, Masjuki HH, Badruddin IA, Yussof HW, Chong WZ, Lee KT (2013)
A comparative evaluation of physical and chemical properties of biodiesel synthesized from
edible and non-edible oils and study on the effect of biodiesel blending. Energy 58:296–304
4. Evangelos Giakoumis G (2013) A statistical investigation of biodiesel physical and chemical
properties and their correlation with the degree of unsaturation. Renew Energy 50:858–878
5. Ashraful AM, Masjuki HH, Kalam MA, Rizwanul Fattah IM, Imtenan S, Shahir SA, Mobarak
HM (2014) Production and comparison of fuel properties engine performance emission charac-
teristics of biodiesel from various non-edible vegetable oils A review. Energy Convers Manag
80:202–228
6. Lahane S, Subramanian KA (2015) Effect of different percentages of biodiesel–diesel blends
on injection spray combustion performance and emission characteristics of a diesel engine.
Fuel 139:537–545
7. Bhaskor Bora J, UjjwalSaha K (2016) Experimental evaluation of a rice bran biodiesel e biogas
run dual fuel diesel engine at varying compression ratios. Renew Energy 87:782–790
8. Chhabra M, Sharma A, Dwivedi G (2016) Performance evaluation of diesel engine using rice
bran biodiesel. Egypt J Petrol 26(2):511–518
Investigation of Physical–Chemical Properties and Evaluation … 359
Abstract There is a growing demand for the development of new polymer matrix
composite materials that exhibits high strength, high wear resistance, good rigidity
and less weight. In this work, an attempt has been made to develop a novel car-
bon fibre reinforcement polymer (CFRP) composite with stainless steel (SS 316)
wire mesh and to investigate its tribological characteristics with the objective of
improving the wear resistance. The pin-on-disc experiment was performed on the
fabricated CFRP-SS316 fibre metal laminate by using EN31 steel (high carbon alloy)
pins. Wear rate and coefficient of friction have been examined by conducting four
experiments on CFRP-SS316 laminate. The process parameters used for this inves-
tigation includes applied load, sliding velocity, sliding distance and speed. Experi-
mental results showed that the wear rate increases on a CFRP-SS316 disc laminate
when the load increases gradually from 10 N to 40 N. The minimum wear rate of
16.34 mm3 /N was obtained for 10 N applied load.
Keywords Carbon fibre reinforced polymer · Stainless steel 316 wire mesh · Wear
rate · Coefficient of friction
A. H. Ansari
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Saveetha School of Engineering, Saveetha Institute of
Medical and Technical Sciences, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India
V. Jayakumar (B)
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Amrita School of Engineering, Chennai, Amrita Vishwa
Vidyapeetham, Tamil Nadu, India
e-mail: v_jayakumar@ch.amrita.edu
S. Madhu
Department of Automobile Engineering, Saveetha School of Engineering, Saveetha Institute of
Medical and Technical Sciences, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India
1 Introduction
The objective of this current research is to fabricate the stainless steel wire mesh
(SS316) reinforced carbon fabric epoxy composite using hand layup process, and the
tribological properties such as wear rate, frictional force and coefficient of friction
were investigated on CFRP-SS316 composite sample under different applied load,
sliding velocity, sliding distance and speed.
The pin-on-disc wear test is carried out to predict the wear performance of the
fabricated carbon fibre reinforced SS polymer composite. A pin-on-disc wear tester
is used to find the wear rate and coefficient of friction of the samples. A pin is located
against a flat rotating disc specimen such that a circular wear path is described by the
machine. The machine is used to evaluate wear and friction properties of materials
under pure sliding conditions. The disc can serve as specimen, while the other as
counter face. Pin with various geometry is used. Figure 2a shows the two-dimensional
model of pin and disc. Figure 2b shows the CAD model of wear mechanism.
The disc placed above the flat rotating surface and a pin is just above the disc
with sliding diameter as shown in Fig. 2a. The wear track formed depending upon
the load applied on the material through pin as shown in Fig. 2b. This also shows the
metal removal rate and wears depth of cut of material.
364 A. H. Ansari et al.
Fig. 1 a Fabricated CFRP samples. b Wear test specimen. c SEM image of the fabricated CFRP-SS
polymer composite
The wear test parameters used for this investigation is applying load (N), sliding
velocity (m/s), sliding distance (m) and speed (rpm). The above three parameter
values are considered depending upon the material properties. Table 1 shows the
wear parameters used for this investigation, and Fig. 3a, b shows the pin-on-disc
apparatus and sample.
The specific wear rate is calculated as loss in volume loss (V ) divided by applied
load (P) and sliding distance (L) as shown in the following Eq. 1
k = m/P · L (1)
where ‘m’ is mass loss, ‘P’ is the applied load and ‘L’ is the sliding distance.
The wear tests have been done on CFRP-SS316 material specimen, and its average
values are given in Table 2. With the help of software and arrangement made in the
wear equipment, it was possible to record reading on every 1 s, and for the 16.664 min
test duration, 998 readings were recorded for the wear rate and coefficient of friction.
Table 2 shows the average values of wear rate and coefficient of friction.
700
700
600
600
Wear rate (mm3/N-m)
Wear rate (mm3/N-m)
500
500
400 400
300 300
200 200
100 100
0 0
0 10 20 30 40 50 0 1 2 3
Load (N) Sliding velocity (m/s)
(a) Effect of applied load on wear rate (b) Effect of sliding velocity on wear rate
700 700
600 600
Wear rate (mm3/N-m)
Wear rate (mm3/N-m)
500 500
400 400
300 300
200 200
100 100
0 0
700 1200 1700 2200 2700 500 700 900 1100 1300 1500
Sliding distance (m) Speed (rpm)
(c) Effect of sliding distance on wear rate (d) Effect of speed on wear rate
the applied load increases. The minimum wear rate obtained from this experiment
is 16.34 mm3 /N-m (10 N) and 633.9 mm3 /N-m was obtained for 40 N applied load
as shown in Fig. 4a. Also, the minimum wear rate is obtained for sliding velocity of
1 m/s and sliding distance of 1000 m. The minimum speed is 623 rpm for less wear
rate and for maximum speed 1274 rpm, the wear rate is high as shown in Fig. 4d.
The applying load has a significant influence on wear rate. When the load increases,
the friction between the pin and the work surfaces increases which in turn increase
the wear rate of the fabricated composite [19].
The reason behind high wear loss of a material is that due to the applied load
which is high on the material, there was no possibility of the fibre detachment due
to deep embedding of fibres in the epoxy resin. The need of stainless steel 316 mesh
inside the material is the wear rate that decreases due to less friction. The sliding
velocity is a circumferential speed of the rotating face. When the sliding velocity
increases on the material, the contact pressure between the pin on material increases
and affects the unidirectional fibres for more material loss. The high speed also is
one of the reasons, why the removal rate of material is high.
The effect of wear parameters on COF for the fabricated CFRP-SS316 composite
material is shown in Fig. 5. The effect of COF increases on CFRP-SS316 material
when load increases. The minimum COF is 0.1008 for 10 N applied load and maxi-
mum 0.269 for 40 N applied load as shown in Fig. 5a. In the same way, the minimum
COF is 0.1008 for sliding velocity and sliding distance (i.e., 1 m/s and 1000 m) and
maximum 0.269 for 2.5 m/s and 2500 m as shown in Figs. 5b, c. For minimum speed,
623 rpm less COF was obtained, and for maximum speed 1274 rpm, COF is high
as shown in Fig. 5d. The effect of coefficient of friction increases, because at low
speed, the friction is high, whereas at high speed the friction is less.
4 Conclusions
0.3 0.3
0.25 0.25
0.2 0.2
COF
COF
0.15 0.15
0.1 0.1
0.05 0.05
10 20 30 40 50 0.75 1.25 1.75 2.25 2.75
Load (N) Sliding Velocity (m/s)
(a) Effect of applied load on COF (b) Effect of sliding velocity on COF
0.3
0.3
0.25
0.25
0.2
0.2
COF
COF
0.15
0.15
0.1
0.1 0.05
0.05 0
500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 0 500 1000 1500
Sliding distance (m) Speed (rpm)
(c) Effect of sliding distance on COF (d) Effect of speed on COF
References
12. Sahinand Y, De Baets P (2017) Tribological behaviour of unidirectional carbon fibre reinforced
epoxy composites. Mater Sci Eng, 174
13. Odabas D (2018) Effects of load and speed on wear rate of abrasive wear for 2014 Al alloy.
Mater Sci Eng, 295
14. Suresha B, Chandramohan G, Renukappa NM, Siddaramaiah (2007) Mechanical and tribolog-
ical properties of glass-epoxy composites with and without graphite particulate filler. J Appl
Polym Sci 103:2472–2480
15. Khalladi A, Elleuch K (2017) Tribological behavior of wheel rail contact under different
contaminants using pin-on disk methodology. J Tribol 139:011102–011108
16. Rudas JS, Gomez LM, Toro A, Gutiérrez JM, Corz A (2016) Wear rate and entropy generation
sources in a Ti6Al4V—WC/10Co sliding pair
17. Uvaraja VC, Natarajan N, Rajendran I, Sivakumar K (2013) Tribological behavior of novel
hybrid composite materials using Taguchi technique. J Tribol 135:021101–021109
18. Shibo W, Niu C, Teng B (2017) Tribological behavior of polytetrafluoroethylene: effect of
sliding motion. J Tribol 139:011301–011306
19. Xu S, Liu T, Tangpong XW, Zhong W-H (2012) Wear and friction of carbon nanofiber-
reinforced HDPE composites. J Tribol 134:041602–041606
Tribological Properties of PEEK
Reinforced with Synthetic Diamond
Composite
1 Introduction
material. It has greater elastic modulus, mechanical strength, wear resistance and
inert to chemical reactivity. It is easy processable characteristics.
Recently, the usage of PEEK in the engineering and medical fields is increasing to
multifold. It has good resistance against biological actions [3, 4]. It is a material for
high temperature-bearing application since it has high creep property up to 250 °C
[2]. Various researches have been done to test the tribo behaviour of PEEK and its
composites. Various carbon allotropes are being reinforced with thermoplastics due
to their high mechanical properties and low manufacturing cost. Some of such mate-
rials are graphite, diamond and graphitize carbon (long, short) fibre. Carbon fibre
as a reinforcement in PEEK brings in good effect in its strength and tribo nature
[5, 6]. PEEK composites are being used in many areas like electrical, automobile,
biomedical and aerospace. Advantageous properties like lightness, self-lubrication
and easy maintenance can be achieved by using this polymer during the application.
Tribological performance of PEEK and PTFE has been researched. The results stated
that PEEK is used for the production of précise-machined custom bearings which
are suitable for market needs. PEEK’s properties such as self-lubrication, high cor-
rosion resistance and high melting temperature (340 °C) make it to be considered
as one of the high-performance materials among polymers [7]. The stable opera-
tion of the polymer and polymer composites were influenced by the frictional wear
[9]. Thermal conductivity of the composite was increased by the addition of the
nano-particle [10]. Dispersion of zirconia fillers in the polymer matrix increases the
mechanical property, thermal stability and certain combinations of their physical and
mechanical properties. The amount of nano-filler affects the thermal stability of the
polymer composite [11]. Diamonds exhibit properties like high thermal conductivity,
high corrosion resistance, high wear resistance, low coefficient of thermal expansion
and high hardness. Due to higher thermal conductivity and higher modulus of syn-
thetic diamond, it is used as reinforcement in high temperature polymer [12]. By the
addition of nano-sized TiO2 , the wear rate of the PEEK can be reduced [13]. Wear
rate of the polymer matrix can be reduced in large sum by the addition of diamond
as reinforcement. These literatures were reporting tribological properties of PEEK
composite reinforced with ceramic and carbon nano-materials. Synthetic diamond
is another form of high-strength crystalline carbon reinforcement which enhances
wear resistance of polymer materials.
In this work, pure peek with different weight percentages of synthetic diamond
were added in PEEK matrix, and its tribological properties were studied. Wear loss
and friction coefficient of synthetic diamond reinforced PEEK were reported as
function of sliding velocities.
Tribological Properties of PEEK Reinforced with Synthetic … 373
2 Experimental Procedure
2.1 Materials
The received poly ether ether ketone of grade 2000FP powder form properties is
shown in Table 1. In this, PEEK makes the matrix phase, and synthetic diamonds
(SD) are the reinforcing material. The size of PEEK and synthetic diamond were
20 µm and 5 µm, respectively. Poly vinyl alcohol (PVA) was used as a binder agent.
Powder metallurgy process was used to fabricate the polymer composite. The syn-
thetic diamond was varied from 10 to 30 volume % to reinforce PMC. To get a
homogeneous mixture, pure PEEK powder and different composition of synthetic
diamond were mixed in ball milling technique. This mixture was mixed for three
hours. The composites were prepared by pressing the powder hydraulically and sin-
tering it. The powder was pressed at 100 MPa to get a cylindrical shape of diameter
10 mm and height 10 mm. During sintering process, temperature ramp of 100 °C
was maintained. The polymer composites were sintered at 3250 °C and soaked for
two hours. P/M process produces high potential homogeneous composite materials,
it involves lesser time, and it is cost efficient. Cylindrical specimens were fabricated
in the form of pellets, as shown in Fig. 1.
To confirm the structure of diamond, XRD was carried out for the synthetic diamond
powder. From the fabricated samples, particle distribution in the composite was
evaluated by optical microscope. SEM with 15 kV of accelerating voltage is applied
for image observation. Before SEM analysis, the specimen was cleaned with alcohol
and then gold sputtered over the specimen to make it surface conductive.
374 K. Rajkumar et al.
2.4 Density
The density of the polymer matrix composite (PMC) was measured by Archimedes’
principle. The fabricated composite was submerged in water, and its equivalent
weight is calculated. Weight of the PMC was also calculated in the air. From these
values, the density of the PMC was obtained.
2.5 Hardness
Pin-on-disc wear testing is a method of characterizing the wear rate and coefficient
of friction, and frictional force between two sliding materials. The tests have been
conducted under normal atmospheric condition in PIN ON DISC FRICTION &
WEAR TEST RIG–TE-165-SPOD. The PMC pin specimen was normally loaded
over the steel disc. Test was conducted on a flat surface of cylindrical pin of diameter
10 mm and height of 10 mm. Tribo test was conducted for a constant normal load
of 100 N using different sliding velocities of 0.6, 1.2, 1.8, 2.4 m/s. Each test was
conducted for a period of 30 min which ensures a steady-state coefficient of friction
for all the tested samples. An average of three trials was done for each sample. All
the tribological sliding tests were conducted at 20 °C in a dry-sliding condition.
Figure 2 shows the XRD profile of synthetic diamond. From the figure, peeks at 430
and 750 show the presence of carbon which confirms that the compound is diamond.
The crystal structure was found to be cubic in nature.
Figure 3 shows the typical optical image of the fabricated composite. The image
clearly shows the synthetic diamond particles that were fairly dispersed. However, the
presence of agglomerates is obvious. No micro-cracks are seen from the fabricated
sample.
3.2 FTIR
The sample of PEEK/synthetic diamond composite was analysed using the FTIR
technique. A typical spectrum of PEEK/synthetic diamond composite can be seen
in Fig. 4. The spectrum is trace distinctive of amorphous PEEK/synthetic diamond
composite. The finger-print region of the spectrum (1432–1024 cm−1 ) exhibits the
distinctive spectral features typical to an IR-recorded spectrum of PEEK.
3.3 Density
The effect of synthetic diamond on the density of peek is shown in Fig. 5. Due to
the high density of diamond, the density of the composite material increased as the
reinforcement increased.
Tribological Properties of PEEK Reinforced with Synthetic … 377
As per the ASTM E92 standard, Vickers hardness test was conducted for the polymer
composite. The hardness of peek and synthetic diamond is shown in Fig. 6. Hardness
of the peek is improved when reinforcement is added, due to the high strength of
synthetic diamond. Although there was an agglomeration of diamond particle beyond
10%, the hardness of peek composite was observed to increase slightly. This is
because of the termination and pinning mechanism.
As seen from the previous section, the 30% SD reinforced composite shows a high
mechanical property. Therefore, the tribological studies are limited to this composi-
tion only when compared to pure PEEK. In this section, tribo behaviour of 30% SD
reinforced composite was done with different sliding speed at constant normal load.
The wear performance is influenced by sliding velocities according to the volume
fractions and environment. Figure 7 shows the wear rate of virgin PEEK and PEEK
composite. This figure shows that wear rate of fabricated composite and pure PEEK
is decreasing with sliding velocity. This is because the contact region of the pin
and the counterpart gets minimized [7]. PEEK composite shows a lower wear rate
as compared to pure PEEK. SD in PEEK makes this composite stronger to sliding
wear loss. As a result, the load-bearing constituent of SD provides a direct contact
to counter surface. Greatest hardness of SD also shares the contact load and reduces
tearing of PEEK [6]. It can be seen from SEM image Fig. 8a that PEEK surface was
torn out along with some micro-cutting grooves. However, PEEK composite was
observed to be the only counter surface with hard asperities scoring marks over the
surface, as shown in Fig. 8b.
Under normal loading, there is a decrease in coefficient of friction at room temper-
ature with sliding velocity increasing, as seen from Fig. 9. The graph clearly shows
the reduction of coefficient of friction from 0.047 for the pure PEEK to 0.035 for
the PEEK reinforced with synthetic diamond composite. The reduction of COF is
around 50%. This is because of the addition of the SD which renders the rolling or
mending effect of smaller-sized SD particles between the sliding surfaces [8].
Fig. 8 Worn surface SEM images (a) pure PEEK (b) 30%SD-PEEK
4 Conclusions
1. The effects of several volume fractions of fillers in a PEEK polymer matrix were
studied. The mechanical and wear rate of PEEK and different composition of
synthetic diamond powder have been studied in this paper.
2. It was observed that the dispersion of synthetic diamond particles in PEEK matrix
is fair at low volume of fraction.
3. Density of PEEK composite increased due to the addition of synthetic diamond
powder, due to the higher density of diamond.
4. The hardness of the PEEK polymer composite is higher with increase in the
reinforcement when compared with pure PEEK.
5. Under constant loading condition of 100 N, tribological tests were performed at
different sliding velocities of 0.6 m/s, 1.2 m/s and 1.8 m/s. Friction coefficients
and wear rates were evaluated, and from scanning electron microscopy, worn
surfaces were examined.
380 K. Rajkumar et al.
6. As the amount of the synthetic diamond powder increased in the polymer matrix,
the wear rate of the composite decreased.
7. With the increase in reinforcement, coefficient of friction decreases. The
coefficient of friction of PEEK-based composites was reduced by nano- and
micro-particle which becomes more significant at higher contact pressure.
References
Abstract The utilization of natural fibres has become extensive instead of conven-
tional synthetic fibres because of the issues with the greenhouse effect and conscious-
ness towards the environment. Exploring natural fibres has several advantages such as
economically viable, availability in fibrous form readily and ease of extraction from
the plant leaves. In this study, an attempt has been made to investigate the mechanical
properties such as tensile, impact and flexural strength of the composites made by
reinforcing American agave fibre into a polypropylene resin. In addition to that, the
mechanical properties of hybrid composites that are fabricated by reinforcing Amer-
ican agave and glass fibre as 1:1 proportion into a polypropylene resin are studied.
The proportion of fibre content is varied from 10 to 30% by volume percentage, and
the behaviour in the mechanical properties in each case is examined. It is observed
that the American agave and glass fibre reinforced polypropylene hybrid compos-
ite has exhibited better mechanical properties than American agave fibre reinforced
polypropylene composite.
1 Introduction
Over the years, natural fibres are serving mankind and find their application in vari-
ous fields. Eventually, natural fibres are contending with the man-made fibres, espe-
cially, as far as sustainability, quality and economy of production are concerned [1].
Because of their biodegradable nature, the utilization of natural fibres has become
expensive. Alongside, they often have low densities, beneath processing costs and
sustainable than the synthetic materials [2]. Conventionally, natural fibres have been
used as reinforcements in polypropylene composites due to their recyclability nature
[3]. The alkali and acrylic acid treatment of the banana fibres could enhance the
water resistance property and improves the mechanical properties of the composites.
However, the addition of compatibilizer will further intensify the above-mentioned
properties. It was reported that the addition of compatibilizer improves the impact
and flexural strength which further yields to alleviate the water absorption capac-
ity [4]. Zaman et al. [5] considered irradiated banana fibres and treated them with
monometer in MeOH solution blended with 2% benzyl peroxide. The authors have
used thermal curing method and observed a significant enhancement in the mechan-
ical properties because of the monometer treatment. Rana et al. [6] examined the
influence of compatibilizer on jute fibre reinforced polypropylene composites. The
authors observed that there is a reduction in the water absorption capacity and a sud-
den increase in the mechanical properties. This can be attributed to the fact that the
addition of compatibilizer developed a linkage between the hydroxyl groups of jute
and the carboxyl groups of the compatibilizer [6]. On the other hand, the properties
such as modulus of composites and tensile strength are affected by fibre composition,
liquid of immersion and number of immersion cycles. In the case of kenaf fibre rein-
forced polypropylene composites, there is a depression in the tensile strength values
because of the number of immersion cycles and conditioning. However, continuous
and cyclic immersion in bleach resulted to alter the tensile strength of the composites
significantly. However, there is a minimal variation in the values of tensile modulus
after a number of immersion cycles [7].
Oksman et al. [8] examined the effect of fibre morphology on the mechanical prop-
erties of natural fibres and on the fibre breakage of the composites due to the extru-
sion process. It was observed that the sisal composites had displayed the favourable
impact properties and the longest fibres after the extrusion among the considered
natural fibres. In general, the flexural stiffness of the composites increases with fibre
content, being highest for flax-type composites. Perhaps, the addition of fibres has no
effect on the flexural strength property because of the low compatibility [8]. Based on
the exhaustive literature review, it has been found that the mechanical properties of
American agave, polypropylene composites have not explored. The main objective
of this study is to prepare the composite by incorporating the American agave and
glass fibres at various volume percentages into a polypropylene resin matrix. Finally,
the composites are examined and characterized to evaluate the tensile, impact and
flexural properties.
2 Experimental Procedures
The following section elaborates the experimental procedure carried out, and the
steps involved are:
Experimental Investigation on the Mechanical Properties … 383
1. Materials
2. Extraction of fibres
3. Fabrication of composites
4. Investigating the mechanical properties of composites.
2.1 Materials
American agave fibre is extracted directly from the American agave plant. Initially,
teen-aged American agave plants are taken, and then, the leaves are plucked. Later,
the edges of the leaves are trimmed, and then, these edge-trimmed American agave
plant leaves are allowed to soak in water for about 10–15 days. After soaking for
sufficient time, the residual from leaves gets deposited in the water. Remaining leaf
is taken into hand and rubbed, and final fibre is obtained (these fibres appear like
threads) and then dried in sunlight. For removing additional organic waste from the
fibre, we go for alkali treatment. In alkali treatment, we soak the fibre in 1% NaOH
solution for sufficient time, and later, the fibres are again dried in sunlight to obtain
the agave fibre. The American agave plant is shown in Fig. 1.
Polymer matrix composites are made using polypropylene resin matrix to evaluate
the reinforcing ability of American agave fibres. The accelerator (1.5% by volume)
and catalyst (1.5% by volume) are supplemented to the resin for curing at room tem-
perature. The appropriate mixture of polypropylene resin and American agave fibres
is filled up in the prepared mould and fed to injection moulding machine. In order
to ensure good quality fibre reinforced composites, the deformation and movement
of the fibre should be minimized. Hence, a compressive pressure of 0.05 MPa is
enforced on to the mould, and the composite specimens are allowed to cure for 24 h.
In addition to the curing at room temperature, post-curing at 70 °C for about two
384 M. Indra Reddy et al.
hours is carried out onto the specimens. The fabricated samples are represented in
Fig. 2. Five composite samples are prepared with five different volume percentages
of American agave Fibres.
In order to investigate the tensile properties of the American agave and glass fibre
reinforced polypropylene composites, the specimens are prepared according to the
ASTM D 638M standards (Standard, 2010). The composite specimens are prepared
with a length of 165 mm, width of 12.7 mm and thickness of 3 mm. Three identical
specimens are tested for each percentage volume fraction of fibre. These composite
specimens are tested using a tensile testing machine operating with a cross-head
speed of 2.5 mm/min.
In order to examine the flexural properties of the specimens, three-point bend tests
are carried out in accordance with ASTM D 790M (Standard, 2010) test standards.
Three-point bend test is chosen, as it provides the flexibility in determining the centre
point deflections with the equipment. In addition to that, it operates with the less
amount of material for each test cycle. The specimens are made with 125 mm length,
12.7 mm width and 3 mm thickness. During the test, the outer rollers are kept 64 mm
apart, and the specimens are examined under the strain rate of 0.2 mm/min. For each
composition, three identical specimens are tested using tensile testing machine, and
all the experiments are carried out at a cross-head speed of 2.5 mm/min. Flexural
Experimental Investigation on the Mechanical Properties … 385
σ = 3Pl/2bt 2
E f = l3m/bt 3
where
σ Bending strength (N/mm2 )
P Maximum load (N)
L Distance between the supports (mm)
B Width of the specimen
T Thickness of the specimen
M Slope of the initial straight portion of the load-deflection curve.
386 M. Indra Reddy et al.
The test specimens for carrying the impact test are prepared according to the standards
of ASTM D256. These specimens are having a length of 55 mm, width of 10 mm
and thickness of 10 mm. To achieve the notch onto the specimen, a sharp file having
an included angle of 45° is drawn across the cut at an angle of 90° to the sample axis.
These specimens are fractured in a plastic Izod impact testing machine (capacity—
21.68 J). For each composition, three specimens are tested, and the value of the
absorbed energy is noted. Finally, the impact strength for a specimen is calculated
by dividing the measured absorbed energy value with the cross-sectional area.
The variation of mean tensile strength and tensile modulus of composite with vary-
ing fibre content is illustrated in Figs. 3 and 4. It can be observed that, the tensile
strength is increasing with the increase in the fibre content of the polypropylene
matrix. This can be attributed to the fact that as the polypropylene resin dissem-
inates, it dispenses the applied stress to the American agave fibres which further
resulted to higher strength value. The tensile strength of the composite with maxi-
mum fibre content (30% volume of the fibre) is found to be 27.03 MPa. The tensile
strength and the tensile modulus of American glass fibre reinforced polypropylene
composite considered in this study are far better than that of American agave fibre
reinforced polypropylene composites. From the tensile test, we obtained load versus
displacement graphs at 30% volume of fibre, which are shown in Fig. 5. The tensile
tested samples are represented in Fig. 6.
Figures 7 and 8 describe the flexural behaviour of American agave fibre reinforced
composites and American agave–glass fibre reinforced composites. The trend is
similar to the trend observed for the case of tensile properties with the same above-
mentioned conviction. The flexural strength value of the composite with maximum
fibre (30% volume of the fibre) content is about 84 MPa. The American agave–glass
fibre reinforced composite considered in this study has shown improved flexural
strength value than that of American agave fibre reinforced composites. The flexural
tested samples are represented in Fig. 9.
Figure 10 describes the results of Izod impact test. From below figure, it is evident
that as the percentage of volume increases, the impact strength value increases. It
can be noted that the impact strength value of the composite with maximum fibre
(30% volume of the fibre) content is found to be 5.8 J. The impact strength of
390 M. Indra Reddy et al.
American agave–glass fibre composite is better than American agave fibre reinforced
composites. The impact tested samples are represented in Fig. 11.
4 Conclusions
In this study, American agave fibre reinforced polypropylene composite and Ameri-
can agave–glass fibre reinforced polypropylene hybrid composites are fabricated with
different volume of fibres, and the mechanical properties, namely tensile, impact and
flexural properties, are examined. After evaluating the obtained experimental results,
the following conclusions are made:
• The tensile strength and tensile modulus of the American agave and agave–glass
fibre reinforced polypropylene composite increases with the increase in volume
of fibre.
• The flexural strength and flexural modulus of the American agave and agave–glass
fibre reinforced polypropylene composites increases with the increase in volume
of fibre.
• The impact strength of the American agave and agave–glass fibre reinforced
polypropylene composites increases with the increase in volume of fibre.
• American agave and glass reinforced polypropylene composites show bet-
ter mechanical properties than American agave fibre reinforced polypropylene
composites.
References
1. Kozłowski RM (ed) Handbook of natural fibres: types, properties and factors affecting breeding
and cultivation. Elsevier
2. Heng JY, Pearse DF, Thielmann F, Lampke T, Bismarck A (2007) Methods to determine surface
energies of natural fibres: a review. Compos Interfaces 14(7–9):581–604
3. Joshi SV, Drzal LT, Mohanty AK, Arora S (2004) Are natural fiber composites environmentally
superior to glass fiber reinforced composites? Compos A Appl Sci Manuf 35(3):371–376
4. Prasad N, Agarwal VK, Sinha S (2016) Banana fiber reinforced low-density polyethy-
lene composites: effect of chemical treatment and compatibilizer addition. Iran Polym J
25(3):229–241
5. Zaman HU, Khan MA, Khan RA (2013) Banana fiber-reinforced polypropylene composites: s
study of the physico-mechanical properties. Fibers Polym 14(1):121–126
6. Rana AK, Mandal A, Mitra BC, Jacobson R, Rowell R, Banerjee AN (1998) Short jute fiber-
reinforced polypropylene composites: effect of compatibilizer. J Appl Polym Sci 69(2):329–338
7. Haniffah WH, Sapuan SM, Abdan K, Khalid M, Hasan M, Hoque ME (2015) Kenaf fibre
reinforced polypropylene composites: effect of cyclic immersion on tensile properties. Int J
Polym Sci
8. Oksman K, Mathew AP, Långström R, Nyström B, Joseph K (2009) The influence of
fibre microstructure on fibre breakage and mechanical properties of natural fibre reinforced
polypropylene. Compos Sci Technol 69(11–12):1847–1853
Influence of Magnesium Hydroxide
Fillers on Acoustic, Thermal, and Flame
Retardant Properties of Pu Foam
Abstract Polyurethane foam is a versatile material for many applications like acous-
tic, thermal insulation, as well as for energy absorption. The main aim of this paper is
to improve acoustic properties by adding weight percentage of 2, 4, and 6 of magne-
sium hydroxide (Mg(OH)2 ) micro-particles in polyurethane (Pu) foam. To investigate
the influence of micro-particles on acoustic properties, the samples are tested in an
impedance tube to measure sound absorption coefficient. The experimental results
are compared to finite element results predicted from Johnson–Champoux–Allard
model. For thermal properties, the samples are experimented in thermal conductivity
and fire retardant test. The results indicate that the significant improvement in the
acoustic and thermal properties due to the addition of magnesium hydroxide.
1 Introduction
The noise produced by vehicles not only affects the quality of the automobile but
also decreases the comfort of driving. Eliminating automotive interior noise has
become an important and predominant topic in noise control engineering. This noise
reduction depends on the coefficient of sound absorption. It is necessary to identify the
coefficient of sound absorption of polyurethane at different frequency ranges. These
porous materials such as polyurethane foam have been widely used in various fields
like acoustic absorption thermal insulation, aeronautics, and building construction.
Cao et al. [1] have discussed Delany–Bazley model for sound absorption of porous
material. Ekici et al. [2] improved coefficient of sound absorption of polyurethane
foam by the addition of tea leaf and luffa-cylindrical. Tao et al. [3] explained the
effect of rice straw and wheat straw fiber in polyurethane foam on sound absorption
property. Chen et al. [4] added bamboo chips and bamboo stem in polyurethane
foam in order to enhance the coefficient of sound absorption and also carried out
airflow resistivity test. Tiuc et al. [5] have discussed the addition of textile waste in
polyurethane foam with detailed microstructure studies they noticed improvement
in the acoustic properties of developed hybrid foams. Benkreira et al. [6] investigated
porosity, airflow resistivity, and sound absorption of porous material. Verdejo et al.
[7] have discussed the effect of the addition of carbon nanotube in polyurethane
foam on the acoustic property as well as on Young’s modulus. Orfali et al. [8] added
silicon oxide and carbon nanotubes in polyurethane foam to enhance the coefficient of
sound absorption. Rasheed et al. [9] have explained compressive strength, thermal
conductivity, and moisture absorption test of polyurethane foam with glass wool.
Chen et al. [10] have discussed the effect of variation of reactants like percentage of
blowing agent of polyurethane foam on sound-absorbing capacity.
Sripathy and Sharma [11] described the flammability and moisture absorption
test of polyurethane foam. Mazraeh-shahi et al. [12] explained method to calibrate
thermal diffusivity and thermal conductivity of porous material. Moretti et al. [13]
explained the influence of granule size of aerogels on acoustic and thermal proper-
ties and also explained transmission loss. Xu et al. [14] discussed thermal stability
and flame retardancy property of pure polyurethane and the addition of organoclay
nano-composites. Nedkov et al. [15] and Ahmadinejad et al. [16] explained finite
element modeling of the impedance tube and calibration of the coefficient of sound
absorption. Wang et al. [17] have enhanced the coefficient of sound absorption by
using rice hull in polyurethane foam. Matyka et al. [18] have described the con-
cept of tortuosity, porosity, and the relationship between these factors of porous
material. Lim et al. [19] discussed the sound-absorbing property of knife fibers and
also discussed the effect of thickness of the sample and air gap behind sample on
the coefficient of sound absorption. Othmani et al. [20] and Santoni et al. [21] pre-
sented different mathematical models for porous absorption. The explained concept
of porosity, touristy, flow resistivity calibrated coefficient of sound absorption for
recycled sugarcane wastes.
Putra et al. [22] explained the effect of air gap on sound-absorbing property of
porous material by using pineapple-leaf fibers. Gle et al. [23] explained the acoustic
properties of hemp concrete as a green building material. Piegay et al. [24] discussed
sound absorption and transmission loss of flax wool and hemp wool samples, and
carried out validation with Delany–Bazley and Tarnow perpendicular random model.
Curtu et al. [25] used wood fiber, jute, and wood chips to prepare biodegradable com-
posite samples and evaluated the acoustic properties of these samples. Hurrell et al.
[26] explained mathematical models of airflow resistivity for non-woven materials.
Berardi et al. [27] explained the comparative study of sound absorption of various
fibers like coconut, straw, cane, sheep wool, cork, hemp, and kenaf. Kuranska et al.
[28] explained microstructure details of pure and composite polyurethane foams and
investigated their compressive strength performance. Or et al. [29] explained oil
palm empty fruit bunch fibers as the sustainable acoustic absorber and carried out
an experiment of sound absorption to explain the effect of air gap behind the sample
Influence of Magnesium Hydroxide Fillers on Acoustic … 395
and also explained the effect of density and thickness of sample on sound absorption
property of porous material.
Fouladi et al. [30] explained the Biot–Allard model for sound absorption of coir
fiber and projected comparative results of the impedance tube, Delany–Bazley model,
and Biot–Allard model. Koruk et al. [31] experimented with pure luffa fiber, luffa
fiber with perforated lines, and luffa composite with epoxy with varying volume
fraction in order to evaluate the coefficient of sound absorption and transmission
loss. Martellottaa et al. [32] explained the acoustic-absorbing property of samples
made from olive pruning wastes and also projected the effect of air gap and the effect
of thickness of samples.
In this study, the different weight percentage of magnesium hydroxide is added to
Pu foam. The acoustic capabilities of the foam samples measured in impedance tube
test, and other physical parameters are tested in the individual experimental setup.
These physical parameters are given as input to the FEA analysis to predict the
numerical sound absorption. For thermal properties, the sample is tested in thermal
conductivity and flame retardant test.
2 Sample Preparation
The flexible foams are a simple mixture of isocyanides and polyol in the ratio of
100:65. First of all, pure foam with no additives is prepared by adding the two
compounds in a circular mold with one face open and letting the reaction take place.
The reaction is exothermic, and carbon dioxide gas is released during the blowing
process. The mixture is allowed to expand and is then removed from the mold and
is prepared according to the required dimensions. Now, three different samples were
prepared with different weight percentages of magnesium hydroxide, i.e., 2%, 4%,
6% with average particle size, 6.8 (µm), reactants, and their weight percentage are
mentioned in Table 1. Composition of magnesium hydroxide filled hybrid foam is
mentioned in Table 2. Samples are shown in Fig. 1
The airflow resistivity is major parameter for governing acoustic behavior of porous
material. The airflow resistivity depends on the direction of airflow through the
material. The flow resistance (Rf ) is the ratio of the pressure difference between
two sides of the sample to the air velocity, which is stably passed through a porous
medium. The flow resistivity (σ ) flows resistance per unit thickness of the sample.
Experimental setup is shown in Fig. 3. By using this method, we can measure airflow
resistivity of porous material ranging from 100 to 10,000 Ns/m4 , and air velocity can
vary up to 50 mm/s. The pressure differential across samples range from 0.1 to 250 Pa.
P
Rf = (1)
V
Rf P
σ = ,σ = (2)
d V ×d
The test samples with 100 mm diameter and 40 mm thickness are held between
the holder and mounting plate. Compressed air with 50 mm/s is supplied to one side
of the sample, and pressure difference (P) is measured by a digital pressure gauge.
In this setup, confined acrylic tube with different diameter based on cut-off frequency
is used to find the sound absorption coefficient as per ASTM E-1050. The test setup is
Influence of Magnesium Hydroxide Fillers on Acoustic … 399
equipped with two microphones, loudspeaker, and DAQ system. A loudspeaker that
excites the sound in quantified frequency and microphone senses the sound pressure
at position one and two. The two-channel DAQ systems were used to record the time
domain data for post-processing. The MATLAB® software is used to estimate the
transfer function across two microphone data. Based on the transfer function, normal
incidence sound reflection and absorption obtain following Eqs. (4) and (5)
P1
H= (3)
P2
H − e− jks j2k(l+s)
R= e (4)
e jks − H
α = 1 − |R|2 (5)
S is the distance between two microphones, and l is the distance between the
speaker and first microphone (Fig. 5).
The acoustic body of impedance tube is presented with parameters like the speed
of sound in air and volume density. For meshing 3D brick, acoustic fluid element
is selected. The Johnson–Champoux–Allard model is selected for FEA analysis.
Harmonic mass source (loudspeaker) is inserted at one end of the tube, and another
400 L. Yuvaraj et al.
end sample is placed. Source of sound generates plane waves which incident normally
on the sample to be tested. The frequency range is selected up to 5000 Hz. Mesh
sensitivity was carried, and the maximum element length must satisfy the following
equation (Fig. 6).
C
L= (7)
8f
where L is the maximum element length, C is the speed of sound in air, and f is the
maximum frequency of the model. Parameters used for FEA modeling of impedance
tube are listed below.
1. Impedance tube length = 600 mm
2. Impedance tube diameter = 33 mm
3. Speed of sound in air = 343 m/s
4. Density of air = 1.2 kg/m3 .
Other than above for FEA analysis, other parameters are also required like flow
resistivity, touristy, and porosity which is listed in the result section.
Thermal conductivity depends on density, porosity, shape, and size of pores. The addi-
tion of fillers should not increase the thermal conductivity, or at least, the material
should maintain the existing value. So, it is essential to ensure the thermal conduc-
tivity of polyurethane filled with magnesium hydroxide. The principle used in heat
flow meter method is represented by the schematic diagram in Fig. 7. This method is
based on Fourier’s law of heat flow. The sample is placed between two plates. One
plate is heated, and the other is kept cool. The temperature gradient across sample
and heat flux calibrated by the sensor and thermal conductivity is calculated by the
equation of Fourier’s law. Thickness of all sample is maintained as 30 mm.
Influence of Magnesium Hydroxide Fillers on Acoustic … 401
T
Q = KA (7)
d
4 Results
The experimental test results of porosity, flow resistivity, and tortuosity are listed in
Table 3. The results prove that the physical parameters are interconnected to each
other. Addition of magnesium hydroxides increases the porous nature of Pu foam
which means the number of pores is increased. The increasing number of pores leads
to more number of cell walls, which makes the porous path as resistive and complex.
One can notice that as the percentage of magnesium hydroxide increased, the values
of porosity, flow resistivity, and tortuosity is also increased.
402 L. Yuvaraj et al.
Fig. 9 Comparison of the coefficient of sound absorption of pure and hybrid polyurethane foam
to non ideal condition of experimental setup such as air leakage, loose fit of sample
and so on.
Fig. 10 Comparison of experimental and FEA result of the coefficient of sound absorption of
different foams
Influence of Magnesium Hydroxide Fillers on Acoustic … 405
Fig. 10 (continued)
5 Conclusion
It is concluded that this study investigated the acoustic and thermal properties dif-
ferent weight percentage addition of magnesium hydroxide as filler in Pu foam. The
filler enhances the physical parameters of foam samples as well as thermal properties.
The measured sound absorption results compared with numerical FEA showing fairly
good agreement to each other. The insulating properties of foam samples remain con-
stant, which is noticed in the result of a thermal conductivity test. Non-flammable
nature of magnesium hydroxide improves fire retardant property of polyurethane
foam.
406 L. Yuvaraj et al.
Acknowledgements We would like to thank the Department of Science and Technology (DST-
SERB; File no: ECR/2015/000111) for providing us the necessary facilities and funds for conducting
this study.
References
4. Chen S, Jiang Y (2018) The acoustic property study of polyurethane foam with addition of
bamboo leaves particles. Polym Compos 39(4):1370–1381
5. Tiuc AE, Vermeşan H, Gabor T, Vasile O (2016) Improved sound absorption properties of
polyurethane foam mixed with textile waste. Energy Procedia 85:559–565
6. Benkreira H, Khan A, Horoshenkov KV (2011) Sustainable acoustic and thermal insulation
materials from elastomeric waste residues. Chem Eng Sci 66(18):4157–4171
7. Verdejo R, Stämpfli R, Alvarez-Lainez M, Mourad S, Rodriguez-Perez MA, Brühwiler PA,
Shaffer M (2009) Enhanced acoustic damping in flexible polyurethane foams filled with carbon
nanotubes. Compos Sci Technol 69(10):1564–1569
8. Orfali WA (2015) Acoustic properties of polyurethane composition reinforced with carbon
nanotubes and silicon oxide nano-powder. Phys Procedia 70:699–702
9. Rasheed AK, Marhoon II (2015) Mechanical and physical properties of glass wool-rigid
polyurethane foam composites. Alnahrain J Eng Sci 18(1):41–49
10. Chen S, Jiang Y, Chen J, Wang D (2015) The effects of various additive components on the
sound absorption performances of polyurethane foams. Adv Mater Sci Eng
11. Sripathy M, Sharma KV (2013) Flammability and Moisture absorption test of rigid
polyurethane foam. Int J Sci Eng Res 4(2)
12. Mazraeh-shahi ZT, Shoushtari AM, Bahramian AR (2015) A new method for measuring the
thermal insulation properties of fibrous silica aerogel composite. Procedia Mater Sci 11:583–
587
13. Moretti E, Merli F, Cuce E, Buratti C (2017) Thermal and acoustic properties of aerogels:
preliminary investigation of the influence of granule size. Energy Procedia 111:472–480
14. Xu Z, Tang X, Zheng J (2008) Thermal stability and flame retardancy of rigid polyurethane
foams/organoclay nanocomposites. Polym-Plast Technol Eng 47(11):1136–1141
15. Nedkov T, Pleshkova-Bekjarska S (2015) Modeling of 3D impedance tube with a complex
termination impedance using finite element method. International Scientific Conference on
Information, Communication and Energy Systems and Technologies, 2015 june, pp 170–173,
Sofia, bulgaria
16. Ahmadinejad P, Monazzam MR (2018) 3D simulation of impedance tube: effect of mesh size
on sound absorption characteristic. Int J Comput Sci Netw Secur 18(1):179–182
17. Wang Y, Zhang C, Ren L, Ichchou M, Galland MA, Bareille O (2013) Influences of rice hull in
polyurethane foam on its sound absorption characteristics. Polym Compos 34(11):1847–1855
18. Matyka M, Khalili A, Koza Z (2008) Tortuosity-porosity relation in porous media flow. Phys
Rev E 78(2):026306
19. Lim ZY, Putra A, Nor MJ, Yaakob MY (2018) Sound absorption performance of natural kenaf
fibres. Appl Acoust 15(130):107–114
20. Othmani C, Taktak M, Zain A, Hantati T, Dauchez N, Elnady T, Fakhfakh T, Haddar M (2017)
Acoustic characterization of a porous absorber based on recycled sugarcane wastes. Appl
Acoust 120:90–97
21. Santoni A, Bonfiglio P, Fausti P, Marescotti C, Mazzanti V, Mollica F, Pompoli F (2019) Improv-
ing the sound absorption performance of sustainable thermal insulation materials: natural hemp
fibres. Appl Acoust 150:279–289
22. Putra A, Or KH, Selamat MZ, Nor MJ, Hassan MH, Prasetiyo I (2018) Sound absorption of
extracted pineapple-leaf fibres. Appl Acoust 136:9–15
23. Glé P, Gourdon E, Arnaud L (2011) Acoustical properties of materials made of vegetable
particles with several scales of porosity. Appl Acoust 72(5):249–259
24. Piégay C, Glé P, Gourdon E, Gourlay E, Marceau S (2018) Acoustical model of vegetal wools
including two types of fibers. Appl Acoust 129:36–46
25. Curtu I, Stanciu MD, Cosereanu C, Vasile O (2012) Assessment of acoustic properties of
biodegradable composite materials with textile inserts. Materialeplastice 49:68–72
26. Hurrell AI, Horoshenkov KV, Pelegrinis MT (2018) The accuracy of some models for the
airflow resistivity of nonwoven materials. Appl Acoust 15(130):230–237
27. Berardi U, Iannace G (2017) Predicting the sound absorption of natural materials: best-fit
inverse laws for the acoustic impedance and the propagation constant. Appl Acoust 115:131–
138
408 L. Yuvaraj et al.
28. Kuranska M, Prociak A (2012) Porous polyurethane composites with natural fibres. Compos
Sci Technol 72(2):299–304
29. Or KH, Putra A, Selamat MZ (2017) Oil palm empty fruit bunch fibres as sustainable acoustic
absorber. Appl Acoust 119:9–16
30. Fouladi MH, Ayub M, Nor MJ (2011) Analysis of coir fiber acoustical characteristics. Appl
Acoust 72(1):35–42
31. Koruk H, Genc G (2015) Investigation of the acoustic properties of bio luffa fiber and composite
materials. Mater Lett 15(157):166–168
32. Martellotta F, Cannavale A, De Matteis V, Ayr U (2018) Sustainable sound absorbers obtained
from olive pruning wastes and chitosan binder. Appl Acoust 141:71–78
33. Salissou Y, Panneton R (2007) Pressure/mass method to measure open porosity of porous
solids. J Appl Phys 101:124913
Development and Analysis of GFRP
Conical Springs
1 Introduction
Generally, automobile parts are made up of steel and its alloys. Steel is an alloy con-
sisting mainly of iron with carbon content of 0.2–2.1% by weight. Steel has many
physical properties such as density, elasticity, strength and hardness. Among these
properties, the strength property is very important, which can be achieved by the addi-
tion of more materials like manganese, niobium and vanadium. But, steel has some
limitations like having more weight, and its corrosion resistance is low. By using FRP
components, fuel efficiency and endurance of various components in machines can
be achieved. FRP is slowly replacing steel, especially in the automobile sector. FRP is
a composite material made up of polymer matrix reinforced with fibres [6]. The fiber
is usually glass (fiber glass), carbon (in carbon-fiber-reinforced polymer), aramid
or basalt. The polymer is usually an epoxy, vinyl ester or polyester thermosetting
plastic, though phenol formaldehyde resins are still in use. FRP composite material
has excellent mechanical properties such as impact resistance, strength, stiffness and
flexibility. Main advantages of this FRP are corrosion resistance, low weight and
high formability [7, 8]. FRP materials are anisotropic and can be tailor made to suit
any requirement to counter stresses in any desired direction and location. The com-
ponents made of FRP are thermally and dimensionally stable and well suited to work
at high temperatures. FRP is widely used in many industries like automobile suspen-
sion system, railway wagons, electrical applications, aerospace and marine, etc [8].
The conical springs are cone shaped springs to provide near constant spring rates
with lower solid height than traditional compression springs. The improved solid
height is achieved by nesting active springs within each other during compression.
It can also achieve the objective of reducing the weight of the engine component,
thus increasing shock absorption, reducing spring weight and improving strength of
springs [9].
2 Literature Review
Conical compression springs designed by Krishna et al. [3] is having the character-
istics of a cylindrical spring of much greater free length.
The spring is characterised by wire whose diameter diminishes from base to apex
end and by coils whose pitch diminishes from base to apex end such that the ratio
of mean coil diameter to wire diameter is constant from coil to coil. Further, each
coil diameter is preferably dimensioned to fit within the next larger coil permitting
a spring to be designed which exhibits a small solid compressed height [5].
Kudapane [4] invented a conical spring wherein the diameters of the coils vary
progressively and the spaces separating adjacent coils vary in relation to the dimen-
sions of the coils to provide pre-determined force displacement spring characteristics.
A conical spring is provided wherein the diameters of the coils thereof vary progres-
sively, and the spaces separating adjacent coils vary in relation to the dimensions
of the coils to provide pre-determined force displacement spring characteristics has
been referred.
Optimisation of steel helical spring by composite spring was presented by Mehdi
Bakhshesh, and Majid Bakhshesh [2] proposed springs that can reserve high level
of potential energy and have undeniable role in industries. Helical spring is the most
common element that has been used in car suspension system. In their research, steel
helical spring related to light vehicle suspension system under the effect of a uniform
loading has been studied.
Arularasan and Sabapathy [1] fabricated GFRP helical spring with E-glass and
epoxy resin using semi-mechanised pultrusion process, and braiding process has
Development and Analysis of GFRP Conical Springs 411
3 Experimentation
The equipments required for GFRP fabrication process consists of fibre rolls, tray,
clamps, steel tube, PVC hose pipe and wooden mould. By using marker pen, the pitch
is marked in the periphery of the wooden mould and hammered with number of nails
in a marked area in order to mention the pitch gap. The E-glass fibres are made with
different loops. Now, the resin and hardener are poured into a tray and thoroughly
mixed until it attains heat reaction. This process is called exothermic reaction.
After, the fibres are dipped and completely submerged with resin and hardener
solution. A steel tube is rigidly fixed by holding with clamps. A PVC hose tube is
inserted over one side of steel tube and another side is kept open.
Steel wire is inserted into hose tube through steel tube. Now, steel wire is tied
with fibres having more number of loops, and other side of steel wire ending is used
for pulling. Slowly, the steel wire is pulled through steel tube.
The fibre with solution is doped into a hose tube. Finally, the hose tube containing
solution and fibres are rolled on the mould with preferred pitch of 20 mm. After
a period of 40–48 h, the hose tube is removed by hammering on mould. Cut the
hose tube periphery, and FRP conical spring is manufactured. By using this data, the
analytical solving is done by using software called ANSYS.
The procedure for analysing GFRP conical spring for different loads is explained
in following, open the ANSYS software. Click and drag the static structural module.
Select the engineering data and upload the composite material as epoxy E-glass
with having unidirectional. Update the constant properties values like density (2000
kgm−3 ), Young’s modulus (x-direction = 4500 Mpa, y-direction = 10,000 Mpa and
z-direction = 10,000 Mpa), shear modulus (xy = 5000 Mpa, yz = 3846.2 Mpa and xz
= 5000 Mpa). Import the geometry from Creo 3.0 software in which it is converted
into IGES file format. Generate the model in ANSYS Workbench software. Now,
fix the one end of spring and other end as different loads (i.e., 20 N, 30 N, 60 N,
80 N) through setup option. Update and generate a solution which provides the total
deformation, equal elastic strain and equivalent stress using von-Misses formulation.
Finally, result is obtained and noted down the maximum values of total deformation,
equal elastic strain and equivalent stress for plotting the graphs.
3.1 3D Modelling
Figure 1 describes how to create a tapered spring in Creo 3.0. The helical sweep
option is used to create a tapered spring, define internal helix profile, select suitable
axis and make profile for axis of revolution. Now, draw a cross line with preferred
412 D. Vivek et al.
Fig. 1 Schematic line diagrams for creating tapered spring using Creo 3.0
dimensions, and after clicking ok, edit the profile to draw a wire diameter circle at
lowest point and apply the pitch required in millimetre. Finally, the conical spring
is generated and converted it into initial graphic exchange format (IGES) file. The
generated 3D model is shown below in Fig. 2.
Fig. 2 3D model
representations in Creo 3.0
Development and Analysis of GFRP Conical Springs 413
Figure 7 shows the graphical representation between equivalent stress and equivalent
Development and Analysis of GFRP Conical Springs 415
elastic strain. In this graph, equivalent stress is noted in x-axis, and equivalent elastic
strain is noted in y-axis. The maximum stress and strain values mentioned in the
result are used in x-axis and y-axis. After jointing the points, the curve is gradually
increased as shown in Fig. 7.
Figure 8 is a graphical representation between load and strain energy. The curve
clearly shows that increasing in load causes gradual increase in strain energy.
Figure 9a shows the wooden mould which is hammered with nails in a pre-determined
dimensions before winding the hose tube. The pre-determined dimensions are also
said to be pitch of spring. Figure 9b shows the final product after completely cut and
removed hose tube.
416 D. Vivek et al.
0.003
0.002
0.001
0
0 10 20 30 40 50
Equivalent stress(MPa)
Development and Analysis of GFRP Conical Springs 417
Strain Energy(MJ)
6
0
0 20 40 60 80 100
Load(N)
5 Conclusion
In the present paper, conical springs or tapered springs using GFRP composites as
epoxy resin and glass fibre were developed experimentally by the application of the
manual pultrusion technique that can be used effectively to improve weight saving.
In general, this study considered that the composite open coil springs can be used
for light commercial vehicle, together with saving of weight of the component.
In case of automobiles, the weight reduction is one of the important factors and
may not cause any technological impact. By using the geometric data, the conical
springs are investigated by the aid of analysis software called ANSYS.
The result shows that for such loads (20 N, 40 N, 60 N and 80 N), total defor-
mation decreases gradually, but elastic strain and stress are increased by applying
compressive force. It is found that maximum values for each load are obtained.
418 D. Vivek et al.
References
1. Arularasan R, Sabapathy YK (2014) Fabrication and testing of FRP open coil springs. Appl Mech
Mater 592–594:1065–1069. https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/amm.592-594.1065
2. Bakhshesh M, Bakhshesh M (2012) Optimization of steel helical spring by composite spring.
Int J Multidiscip Sci Eng 3:47–51
3. Krishna J, Manoj M, Reddy P, Kumar S (2014) Design and optimization of leaf spring using
composites. IJMCA 2:163–168
4. Kudapane SA (2017) Modeling and finite element analysis of hybrid FRP leaf spring, pp 551–556
5. Mahanthi DL, Murali CVS (2017) Design and analysis of composite leaf spring for light weight
vehicle. Int J Adv Eng Res Sci 4:147–152. https://doi.org/10.22161/ijaers.4.3.23
6. Pozhilarasu V, Parameshwaran Pillai T (2013) Comparison of performance of glass fibre
reinforced plastic leaf spring with steel leaf spring. Int J Chem Tech Res 5:1339–1345
7. Sun W, Guan Z, Li Z (2017) Compressive failure analysis of unidirectional carbon/epoxy com-
posite based on micro-mechanical models. Chinese J Aeronaut 30:1907–1918. https://doi.org/
10.1016/j.cja.2017.10.002
8. Zarif Karimi N, Heidary H, Fotouhi M, Minak G (2017) Experimental analysis of GFRP lam-
inates subjected to compression after drilling. Compos Struct 169:144–152. https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.compstruct.2017.01.017
9. Zhou L, Zhao L, Liu F, Zhang J (2018) A micromechanical model for longitudinal compressive
failure in unidirectional fiber reinforced composite. Results Phys 10:841–848. https://doi.org/
10.1016/j.rinp.2018.08.003
Effect of Nano and Microfillers
in Basalt/Epoxy Composites
1 Introduction
Recent research has its focus in energy conservation and environmental issues
for green living. Booming polymeric composite materials attracts the inventors in
research vicinity. Basalt fibre possesses high tensile strength when compared to glass
fibre and better fracture strain than do carbon fibre. Abundant availability of basalt
rock and its simple fabrication process makes the fibre a desired research component.
Exceptional behaviour of basalt fibre in chemical, weather and heat resistance made
itself a promising fibre [1]. Surface modification of basalt fibre improves interfacial
interaction [2].
Current research results indicate that composites with micro and nano-sized mate-
rials reinforced in polymer matrix perform better mechanical properties than do con-
ventional fibre reinforced composites [3–6]. The fillers are added to polymer in order
to reduce the cost and also to improve physical or chemical properties of polymer.
Addition of inorganic particulate fillers such as nano/microglass, CNT, Al2 O3 ,
CaCO3 , silicates into polymers improves stiffness and strength of polymer matrix,
thus expanding their applications in diverse field. Particulate fillers also modify the
physical and mechanical properties of polymer composites in many ways.
In the present work, basalt fibres were treated by alkaline agent, sodium hydroxide
solution before fabrication of the composite. Effects of surface-treated basalt fabric
with the addition of nano and microfillers on mechanical behaviour were studied
by suitable tests. The commercially available nanoparticles are generally incorpo-
rated into polymers such as epoxy, polypropylene and polystyrene to form a matrix.
Introduction of nano fillers like carbon nanotubes, graphene into micrometal matrix
enhances mechanical properties and reduction in weight. High specific surface area
and 2-D structure of graphene increase tensile strength of the composite [3, 4]. These
nanoparticles enhance the mechanical, thermal and electrical properties of composite
matrix [5, 6].
Nano graphene platelets (GnPs) are similar to carbon nanotubes but possess excel-
lent performance characteristics when compared to other nano materials. Graphene
nanoplatelets are two dimensional (2-D) thin sheets made up of tiny stacks of
graphene, which replaces carbon nanotubes, carbon fibre, nanoclays in various com-
posite applications. Carbon atoms of graphene nanoplatelets are arranged in a honey-
comb structure with sp2 hybridization. Thickness of graphene nanoplatelet is of a sin-
gle carbon [7]. Two-dimensional platelets have capability of sliding over one another,
allowing higher loading and lower viscosities. GnPs are widely used as an ideal filler
in industry owing to its excellent mechanical and physical properties, including
exceptional conductivity and high specific strength. Incorporation of GnPs in very
small quantity enhances the performance of composite [8]. Addition of graphene also
has a considerable effect on flammability properties of the composites [9]. Outstand-
ing performance of graphene nanoplatelets is due to stability of sp2 bonds that form
a hexagonal lattice [10]. Surface modified CNT enhanced the performance of tensile
strength and Young’s modulus compared to plain CNT/basalt/epoxy composites [11,
12]. Silane modified CNT increases fracture toughness of basalt/CNT/epoxy by 40%
than acid modified CNT composites [13]. Addition of graphene platelets nanopowder
enhances thermo-mechanical and flame-retardant properties of polymer composite.
Flame retarders are substances that are added into polymer molecule or blended
physically into the polymers. Non-halogen additives are used with polymers for its
flame-retardant property. The most commonly used non-halogen additives are metal
hydroxides, like aluminium trihydroxide (ATH) due to their low cost and toxicity,
ease of handling and minimal corrosion effects. Alumina trihydrate (ATH), the most
extensively used flame retardant, is in usage for decades [14]. Fire retardant property
of alumina trihydrate flags an important role in epoxy resin. Alumina trihydrate itself
has the potential to retard flame inevitably. Synergistic effect of alumina trihydrate
could endure the flammable property of multicomponent epoxy nano composite [15].
Effect of Nano and Microfillers in Basalt/Epoxy Composites 421
Metal borates gained significant interest and extensive usage in industrial appli-
cation due to their excellent structural chemistry [16]. Zinc borates are being used
as a polymer additive for more than decades. Addition of zinc borate significantly
improves the flame-retardant property. Synergistic effect of zinc borates in addition
to polymer/metal hydroxide provides feasible properties [17].
Incorporation of aluminium trihydroxide and zinc borate in epoxy asphalt binders
increases flame retardancy of neat cold-mix epoxy asphalt binders. Synergistic effect
of aluminium trihydroxide and zinc borate in epoxy asphalt binders enhances glass
transition temperature of the composite. Halogen-free flame retardants disperse uni-
formly and increase the tensile strength [18]. Metal fillers in polymers enhance
mechanical performance of composite such as hardness. It also acts as a reinforce-
ment and increases the interfacial bond between fillers and polymers [19]. Mechan-
ical properties of metal matrix fabricated into epoxy depend mainly on size of parti-
cle. Tensile modulus of composite laminate fabricated with metal matrix reinforce-
ment increases with increase in filler [20]. The size of particles added as fillers in
epoxy concludes hardness value of fabricated composite. Aluminium particles when
added to epoxy resin increases the hardness of composite with decrease in particle
size [21]. Tensile modulus and density of metal matrix filled epoxy depend on rule
of mixtures [22]. Interfacial strength between fibre and composite is improved by
incorporation of titanium dioxide [23–25]. The interfacial shear strength is more for
graphene–titanium than that of graphene–aluminium [25].
Several studies have been conducted to explore the application of basalt fibre
as a reinforcing substance in various composites. However, performance analysis
of graphene nano platelets with microfillers and graphene nano platelets with nano
titanium dioxide on basalt/epoxy composite has not been studied elsewhere till date
to the maximum knowledge of author.
2.1 Materials
varied alumina trihydrate (ATH) and constant zinc borate. Titanium dioxide (TiO2 –
rutile), an ultrapure white nanopowder with an average particle size 250 nm, was
used with basalt/epoxy matrix and graphene platelet nanopowder.
Basalt fabrics were sprayed with 1 (N) NaOH solution and dried at room temperature.
Surface-treated basalt fabrics were then cleaned with deionized water to maintain
neutrality [25]. Finally, basalt fibres were made to dry in open air for 24 h at a
room temperature of 30 °C. The nano filler, graphene platelet nanopowder of 0.2%,
0.4% and 0.6% by weight were added to resin and stirred using a magnetic stirrer
of 600 rpm. ATH and zinc borate of 3% and 1%, respectively, by weight were then
added to resin as microfillers followed by magnetic stirring. Epoxy resin with fillers
was then mixed with hardener in the weight ratio of 10:1 and was mixed thoroughly
using a mechanical stirrer continuously. Vacuum bagging procedure was adapted for
fabrication of basalt fibre reinforced composite. Basalt fibre reinforced composite
excluding nanofiller was considered as control specimen. The composite laminates
were fabricated to the dimensions of 300 mm × 300 mm × 3 mm.
Similar procedure was repeated for graphene platelet nanopowder and titanium
dioxide nanopowder reinforced basalt epoxy composite laminate. The schematic
representation of fabrication process is illustrated in Fig. 1.
Various combinations of composite specimens are enlisted in Table 1.
Basalt/epoxy composite laminates with nano and microfillers were fabricated with
varying weight percentages of ATH as 0, 1%, 3% and 5% with a constant 1 wt% of
zinc borate as microfillers. GnP nano fillers were also included by 0, 0.2%, 0.4% and
0.6%, respectively. Another set of basalt/epoxy composite laminates were fabricated
with different nano fillers. Based on the previous work, 0.5 wt% of nano titanium
dioxide was kept constant and varying graphene platelet nanopowder as 0, 0.2, 0.4
and 0.6 wt%, respectively.
The morphology and surface textures of basalt fibre reinforced with nano graphene
platelet powder, titanium dioxide, alumina trihydrate and zinc borate were investi-
gated by scanning electron microscope (SEM). However, long cylindrical smooth
surface is the common morphological characteristics of fibres after treatment. Fail-
ure mechanisms related with dispersion of nano and microfillers in epoxy resin were
also detailed using SEM images.
Effect of Nano and Microfillers in Basalt/Epoxy Composites 423
Tensile test samples were prepared according to ASTM D 3039, the international
standard. Specimens were tested using universal testing machine, Shimadzu AG–X,
of load capacity 50 kN. The cross head speed for tensile tests was maintained at
2 mm/min.
Flexural test for composite specimen was performed with a cross head speed of
2 mm/min. Samples with and without GnPs were prepared according to ASTM
D 790 specifications and subjected to three-point bending load. The load cell was
equipped with 50kN.
Impact of composite specimens was tested using Charpy impact testing machine,
AIT 300-N. Specimens for impact test were prepared for ASTM D 256 standard.
The Charpy impact test machine was equipped with a 300 J hammer.
Basalt fibre reinforced composite specimens with multiscale fillers were subjected to
standard tensile test. Variations in tensile properties of composites based on addition
of nano and microfillers in matrix are discussed here. Incorporation of varied per-
centages of GnPs triggered the mechanical characterization of composites to certain
extent.
Stress–strain values of varying weight % of GnPs in multiscale composite explain
the deviation of strength after a sudden drop in load at 0.4 wt%. Tensile modulus of
composite specimen fabricated with varying wt% of GnPs, ATH and constant zinc
borate is shown in Fig. 2. It is clearly observed from Fig. 2 that tensile modulus of
composite specimen with wt% of 0.4 GnPs with a combination of 3 wt% (ATH) and
1 wt% (Zinc borate) named as A3Z1 marks highest value, whilst A0Z1 without GnPs
possesses the lowest as 18.97 MPa and 10.65 GPa, respectively. Incorporation of nano
Effect of Nano and Microfillers in Basalt/Epoxy Composites 425
10
0
0 % GnP 0.2% GnPs 0.4% GnPs 0.6% GnPs
Wt of nano fillers (%)
Table 2 Tensile test results of composite specimen with micro and nano fillers (A3Z1)
GnPs content (%wt) Tensile strength Tensile modulus Tensile strain (mm)
(MPa) (GPa)
Epoxy/Basalt 212 12.53 0.023
Epoxy/Basalt/ATH/ZB 216 14.12 0.027
0.2 234 15.76 0.029
0.4 244 18.97 0.030
0.6 219 16.81 0.028
filler along with microfillers enhances the tensile property of composite specimen.
Nano fillers being able to slide over one another in its structural arrangement create
a good interfacial bond with the matrix. Presence of microfillers in matrix grooves
the surface and widens gap between fibre and matrix.
Table 2 shows the obtained result in terms of tensile properties for A3Z1 alone
(i.e. 3% ATH with 1% zinc borate and varying GnPs as 0, 0.2%, 0.4%, 0.6% by
weight). Tensile strength and modulus of control specimen were 216 MPa and 14.12
GPa, respectively. An enhancement in tensile strength and modulus was observed for
0.4 wt% GnPs with an increment of 14.03% and 40.89%, respectively, than that of
control sample. It may be noted that tensile strength and modulus of hybrid multiscale
composites with GnPs were observed to have higher values than composites without
GnPs.
Weak Vander walls force lowers homogeneity of material due to the presence
of multiscale fillers. Elongation at break decreased dramatically with almost linear
tensile behaviour after 0.4% GnP. Tensile strength of multiscale composite specimen
increases with increase of nano graphene platelets up to a certain percentage and then
decreases with increase of it. Inclusion of GnPs up to 0.4 wt% exhibited a yielding
behaviour which shows typical plastic, and the sudden fall for 0.6 wt% of GnPs
exhibited a brittle behaviour. A decline in elastic modulus was observed, thereby
indicating softening of material with an increase in nano filler of the composites.
It was stated from previous study that the addition of GnPs at 0.1% by weight
reaches critical value [26]. Addition of graphene enhances toughness of epoxy with
an enhancement of 65% in fracture toughness [27, 28]. A decreasing trend for tensile
426 M. M. Metro and M. Selvaraj
strength was noticed after 0.4% of nano filler. This enhancement in tensile strength
may be due to the inclusion of multiscale fillers into the polymers. Stiffness of
composite specimen increases with 0.4 wt% of GnPs and decreases for 0.6 wt% of
GnPs. Elasticity decreases from the addition of 0.6 wt% of GnPs to the polymer.
However, there is a decrease in tensile strength and tensile strain values at break,
by 10% and 6.67%, respectively, for same loading of GnPs. SEM images of tensile
specimen of A3Z1 with 0.4 wt% of GnP are illustrated in Fig. 3.
From SEM image shown in Fig. 3, it is observed clearly that incorporation of nano
fillers has made interfacial bond between fibre and matrix closer, thus reducing the
gap. The surface roughness (Fig. 3a) is due to protrusion of microparticles on matrix.
Presence of microfillers may result in stress concentrations around its surface creat-
ing weak bondage in matrix and hence makes the matrix to crack. Agglomeration of
nanoparticles is also seen on the surface of composite laminates. These agglomera-
tions might have caused interfaces to weaken and in turn to fracture. Fibres visualized
without matrix coat in Fig. 3b is seen and may be due to error in fabrication. This
space created by improper fill of matrix leads the composite specimen to fail.
Table 3 enlists tensile strength and modulus of composite specimen fabricated with
0.5 wt% of nano titanium dioxide and varied wt% of (0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6%) graphene
platelet nanopowder. It is observed that composite specimen with 0.4 wt% of GnPs
marked maximum tensile strength and modulus, whilst e minimum is with exclu-
sion of GnPs. Addition of 0.5 wt% of nano titanium dioxide has increased tensile
strength and modulus of composite by 21.85% and 41.09%, respectively, than that
of epoxy/basalt plain composite. Increase of 13.77% and 21.89% on tensile strength
and modulus with 0.2 wt% of GnPs than 0.4 wt% of GnPs has an increase in strain
rate with softening of composite. Strain at 0.4 wt% reaches ultimate and had sudden
decline for 0.6 wt% making the composite brittle.
Ease of mobility of nano fillers into matrix makes the interaction better than that of
multiscale fillers. Interfacial interaction of nano fillers with polymer forms a strong
bondage and hence strong matrix. Mobility of polymer-coated nano fillers interlocks
Table 3 Tensile test results of specimen with nano TiO2 and GnPs
%wt of fillers Tensile strength Tensile modulus Tensile strain (mm)
(MPa) (GPa)
Epoxy/Basalt 212 12.53 0.023
Epoxy/Basalt/0.5 225 13.26 0.026
(TiO2 )
0.5 (TiO2 ) & 0.2 230 15.26 0.031
(GnPs)
0.5 (TiO2 ) & 0.4 264 19.01 0.035
(GnPs)
0.5 (TiO2 ) & 0.6 240 14.15 0.029
(GnPs)
Flexural test specimens were subjected to three-point bending tests. The flexural
performance of multiscale composite specimen fabricated by varying wt% of GnPs,
ATH with constant zinc borate was evaluated. Discrepancies in flexural modulus of
composite specimen are depicted in Fig. 4. An enhancement in flexural performance
of composite laminates was observed with an inclusion of 0.2 wt% nano filler with
microfiller filled resin than that of epoxy/basalt composite. Multiscale composite
with 3 wt% of ATH and 1 wt% of zinc borate in addition to 0.4 wt% of GnPs has
14
12 A0ZB1
Flexural modulus (GPa)
A1ZB1
10 A3ZB1
A5ZB1
8
0
0 % Gn P 0 . 2 % Gn P s 0 . 4 % Gn P s 0 . 6 % Gn P s
Fig. 4 Flexural values of composite specimen with micro and nano fillers
428 M. M. Metro and M. Selvaraj
Table 4 Flexural values of composite specimen with micro and nano fillers (A3Z1)
% weight of GnPs Flexural strength Flexural modulus Flexural strain (mm)
(MPa) (GPa)
Epoxy/Basalt 208.92 4.03 0.022
Epoxy/Basalt/ATH/ZB 243.24 7.05 0.028
0.2 329.73 9.93 0.026
0.4 395.45 12.45 0.027
0.6 295.54 10.61 0.024
SEM images of flexural specimen of nano graphene platelets and TiO2 are illus-
trated in Fig. 6. The matrix that bounds fibre itself demonstrates clear and smooth
matrix formed with inclusion of different nanoparticles. Presence of nanofillers
grounds smooth matrix.
Flexural test results of composite specimen fabricated with 0.5 wt% of TiO2 with
varying wt% of GnPs are tabulated in Table 5. It is evident that specimen with 0.4
wt% has marked maximum, whilst epoxy/basalt scored the minimum. Increase in
strain rate from plain specimen (epoxy/basalt) till composite specimen with 0.4 wt%
GnPs measures higher tensile and flexure properties. Composite has proved its yield
capacity till 0.4 wt% of GnPs with a limit. The specimen bounds its stiffness to
0.4 wt% of GnPs into 0.5 wt% of TiO2 filled epoxy/basalt.
Fig. 6 SEM images of flexural test specimen fabricated with nano GnPs and TiO2
430 M. M. Metro and M. Selvaraj
Table 5 Flexural test results for composite specimen with TiO2 and GnPs
% weight of GnPs Flexural strength Flexural modulus Flexural strain (mm)
(MPa) (GPa)
Epoxy/Basalt 208.92 4.03 0.022
Epoxy/Basalt/0.5 236.66 7.98 0.025
(TiO2 )
0.5 (TiO2 ) & 0.2 335.23 11.87 0.026
(GnPs)
0. 5(TiO2 ) & 0. 400.64 14.41 0.028
4(GnPs)
0.5 (TiO2 ) & 0.6 358.75 12.69 0.025
(GnPs)
Energy absorbed and lost by specimen during Charpy impact test gives impact resis-
tance and impact strength of the specimen. The striking velocity of pendulum is
2.45 m/s. Impact strength of specimen subjected to impact energy of 300 J at room
temperature is shown in Fig. 7. It is evident from Fig. 7 that incorporation of 0.4 wt%
GnPs increased the impact strength of specimen with a reduction on further addition
of GnPs. Addition of 0.6 wt% of GnPs declined in its impact strength. Impact strength
of composite specimen fabricated with nano fillers is higher than composite with nano
and microfillers. This might have been effected from interfacial interaction of fillers
which enhances interfacial bonding between fibre and matrix. Impact strength of
composite falls from 1517 to 1505 kJ/m2 after the addition of 0.6 wt% GnPs into
nano TiO2 matrix. The composite fabricated with multiscale fillers recorded a value
of 1507 kJ/m2 for 0.4 wt% of GnPs from 1435 kJ/m2 for plain epoxy/basalt compos-
ite. Though the impact strength values are similar, further addition of GnPs lowers
impact strength and thus leads to delamination.
1510 TiO2-GnP
1500
1490
1480
1470
1460
0 % GnP 0.2% GnPs 0.4% GnPs 0.6% GnPs
wt % of GnP
Effect of Nano and Microfillers in Basalt/Epoxy Composites 431
4 Conclusion
References
1. Dhand V, Mittal G, Rhee KY (2015) A short review on basalt fiber reinforced polymer
composites. Compos Part B Eng 73:166–180. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesb.2014.
12.011
2. Espano (2013) Investigation of the effect of different silane coupling agents on mechanical
performance of basalt fiber composite laminates with biobased epoxy matrices. Polym Compos
34
3. Dasari BL, Morshed M, Nouri JM (2018) Mechanical properties of graphene oxide reinforced
aluminium matrix composites, pp 136–144
4. Muhammad R, Fusheng P, Aitao T (2014) Effect of graphene nanoplatelets addition on
mechanical properties of pure aluminum using a semi-powder method, pp 101–108
5. Park JH, Jana SC (2003) The relationship between nano- and micro-structures and mechanical
properties in PMMA-epoxy-nanoclay composites. Polymer (Guildf) 44:2091–2100. https://
doi.org/10.1016/S0032-3861(03)00075-2
6. Koricho EG, Khomenko A, Haq M (2015) Effect of hybrid (micro- and nano-) fillers on
impact response of GFRP composite. Compos Struct 134:789–798. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
compstruct.2015.08.106
7. Sengupta R, Bhattacharya M, Bandyopadhyay S, Bhowmick AK (2011) A review on the
mechanical and electrical properties of graphite and modified graphite reinforced polymer
composites. Prog Polym Sci 36:638–670. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.progpolymsci.2010.11.003
8. Weihua K, Yuuki H, Lei Hua YI (2008) Thermal and mechanical properties of a poly(« -
caprolactone)/graphite oxide composite. J Appl Polym Sci 107:1395–1400
9. Huang G, Gao J, Wang X (2012) How can graphene reduce the flammability of polymer
nanocomposites? Mater Lett 66:187–189. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matlet.2011.08.063
10. Papageorgiou DG, Kinloch IA, Young RJ (2017) Mechanical properties of graphene and
graphene-based nanocomposites. Prog Mater Sci 90:75–127. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pmatsci.
2017.07.004
11. Lee JH, Rhee KY, Park SJ (2010) The tensile and thermal properties of modified CNT-reinforced
basalt/epoxy composites. Mater Sci Eng, A 527:6838–6843. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.
2010.07.080
12. Liang M, Wong KL (2017) Study of mechanical and thermal performances of epoxy resin filled
with micro particles and nanoparticles. Energy Procedia 110:156–161 https://doi.org/10.1016/
j.egypro.2017.03.121
432 M. M. Metro and M. Selvaraj
13. Kim MT, Rhee KY, Park SJ, Hui D (2012) Effects of silane-modified carbon nanotubes on
flexural and fracture behaviors of carbon nanotube-modified epoxy/basalt composites. Compos
Part B 43:2298–2302. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesb.2011.12.007
14. Lynch TJ, Chen T, Riley D (2003) Advances in ATH benefit Aluminium hydroxide is a widely
used flame retardant for reinforced plastics. Materials E, 44–46
15. Elbasuney S (2017) Novel multi-component flame retardant system based on nanoscopic.
Powder Technol 305:538–545. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.powtec.2016.10.038
16. Schubert DM, Alam F, Visi MZ, Knobler CB (2003) Structural characterization and chemistry
of the industrially important zinc borate, Zn [B3 O4 (OH)3 ]. Chem Mater 4:866–871
17. Bourbigot S, le Bras M (2003) European meeting on fire retardancy and protection OF
Materials, pp 327–335
18. Chen R, Gong J, Jiang Y (2018) Halogen-free flame retarded cold-mix epoxy asphalt binders:
rheological, thermal and mechanical characterization. Constr Build Mater 186:863–870. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2018.08.018
19. Tanwyn M, Khushairi M, Sharif S (2015) Evaluation of mechanical properties of filled epoxy
composite for improving mould performance—a review. Appl Mech Mater 735:13–18. https://
doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/AMM.735.13
20. Bhagyashekar MS (2014) J Reinf Plast Compos, 28–42. https://doi.org/10.1177/
0731684408095034
21. Chung S, Im Y, Kim H, Jeong H (2005) Evaluation for micro scale structures fabricated using
epoxy-aluminum particle composite and its application
22. Tilbrook MT, Moon RJ, Hoffman M (2005) Study on the mechanical properties of alumina—
epoxy composites with an interpenetrating network structure. Mater Sci Eng A 393:170–178.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2004.10.004
23. Ma L, Zhu Y, Li X (2018) The architecture of carbon fiber-TiO2 nanorods hybrid structure in
supercritical water for reinforcing interfacial and impact properties of CF/epoxy composites.
Polym Test 66:213–220. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polymertesting.2018.01.021
24. Yi C, Bagchi S, Dmuchowski CM (2018) Direct nanomechanical characterization of carbon
nanotube—Titanium interfaces. Carbon N Y. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2018.02.069
25. Lipatov YV, Gutnikov SI, Manylov MS (2015) High alkali-resistant basalt fiber for reinforcing
concrete. J Mater 73:60–66. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2015.02.022
26. Bulut M (2017) Mechanical characterization of Basalt/epoxy composite laminates containing
graphene nanopellets. Compos Part B 122:71–78. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesb.2017.
04.013
27. Silva F, Njuguna J, Sachse S (2013) The influence of multiscale fillers reinforcement into impact
resistance and energy absorption properties of polyamide 6 and polypropylene nanocomposite
structures. Mater Des 50:244–252. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2013.02.041
28. Prasad V, Joseph MA, Sekar K (2018) Investigation of mechanical, thermal and water absorption
properties of flax fibre reinforced epoxy composite with nano TiO2 addition. Compos Part A
115:360–370. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesa.2018.09.031
29. Mahesha CR, Mohan N, Rajesh M (2017) Role of nanofillers on mechanical and dry sliding
wear behavior of basalt-epoxy nanocomposites. Mater Today Proc 4:8192–8199. https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.matpr.2017.07.161
30. Thotsaphon T, Katsuyoshi K, Hisashi I (2019) Titanium matrix composite reinforced with
in-situ formed TiC using carbon black nano particles via a wet process. Trans JWRI 38:13–17
A Feasibility Study on Microwave
Joining of GFRP Composite Pipes
with Interlayer Coupling Agents
Abstract This paper investigates the feasibility of energy, economic, and envi-
ronment way to joining the GFRP pipes. These GFRP pipes are used to transport
chemicals, fuel, oil, and natural gases. Microwave joining is economic and energy-
efficient method for bonding thermoset composite with suitable intercoupling layers.
Microwave joining was carried out in 2.45 GHz furnace with suitable susceptor and
various coupling agents such as molten polypropylene and polyethylene, epoxy resin
liquid, and sodium silicate. These interlayered GFRP pipes were tested to evaluate
their lap shear strength and bond strength. Among the various coupling agents used,
polyethylene interlayered coupling agent joints exhibited a good shear strength. The
abstract should summarize the contents of the paper in short terms, i.e., 150–250
words.
1 Introduction
GFRP pipes were made using the resin composition of isophthalic (50%) and
vinylester (50%). The volume fraction of the materials is 65:35 (resin/glass). The
hand lay-up technique was used to manufacture the GFRP pipe with the dimensions
of 30 mm and 55 mm of inner and outer diameters, respectively. The glass fiber
orientation angle in matrix was 90°.
The term “joining” refers to a zone bounded by the GFRP substrates, in which
the entanglement of polymer chains has progressed beyond simple, mechanical,
and chain entanglement. The process comprises generating sufficient heat energy at
interface of an assembly of thermosets substrates to bond them together using an
“interface strip,” referred to as a “coupling agent.” Prior to joining, the surfaces of
the pipes were cleaned, and surface contaminations were removed by fine SiC paper.
The different coupling agents used were liquid sodium silicate, epoxy resin, molten
polypropylene, and polyethylene. Pipe to be joined was placed in multimode cavity
of industrial microwave furnace (2.45 GHz and 3.2 kW). Normally, GFRP thermoset
substrates are transparent to the microwave radiation, and the only part that can be
heated up is the coupling agent implanted at the joint. The microwave power and
heating rate were 320 W and 10 °C/min, respectively. The temperature range fixed
was based on the glass transition temperature T g of the coupling agent. The lap shear
strength of the processed joints was evaluated. Effect of microwave exposure was
assessed through buckling strength testing of the GFRP pipes.
Initially, liquid sodium silicate was used as the coupling agent which was applied
between the surfaces to be joined. The microwave power was adjusted to 320 W.
The holding time, also referred to as “exposure time at maximum temperature,”
was varied between 5 and 10 min. Table 1 shows the results of microwave joining
of GFRP pipe with different coupling agents. The samples prepared using sodium
silicate as coupling agents gave a successful weld at 150 °C. When the temperature
was increased to 200 °C, the weld exhibited bad strength, but joints have been made.
But once the temperature was increased to 250 °C, both the pieces separated out on
the application of slightest additional force and hence the joint failed at 250 °C. The
A Feasibility Study on Microwave Joining of GFRP Composite … 435
variation in the holding time also had not affected the failure at 250 °C. Epoxy resin
could not provide the joint since there was no bonding at all. Polypropylene paste
was applied between the joints to be made. The samples failed to produce joint at
any of the temperatures tested. Although there was some bonding between the two
surfaces of joint but with a slight rotation, the joints separated away. Polyethylene
thin film was then tested as a coupling agent. The polyethylene was cut in the shape
of rings, and a double film was placed at the junction of two thermoset pipes.
The temperature was varied from 250 to 350 °C with 2–10 min holding time.
The samples at 250 and 350 °C failed on application of slight force. Same samples
processed at 300 °C and exhibited good strength. Figure 1 shows the successful
joint made by using polyethylene as a coupling agent. Heat generated along the
bond interface, i.e., coupling agent is transferred from inside to the outer surface. At
the softening temperature, the coupling agent softens and joins together. When the
temperature of coupling agent increases, it absorbs/couples with microwave energy.
When amount of microwave energy is absorbed, heat generation also is increased.
This cumulative effect leads to burnouts as noticed on samples. Samples prepared
with sodium silicate at 250 °C suffered due to burnouts at the outer layer of the
436 K. Rajkumar et al.
substrates. Samples prepared with polyethylene at 350 °C suffered due to the burnouts
on the whole of the outer surface of the substrate. Figure 2 shows the burnout sample
of joint with polyethylene. From Table 1, it is understood that higher temperature
and longer duration of microwave heating degrade the material properties. A very
narrow weldability window is available, for joining these thermoset pipes.
Figure 3a shows the SEM image of the joint made using liquid sodium silicate was
a coupling agent (150 °C and 10 min). The SEM image shows well-defined bound-
ary between the two pipes. The amorphous glass phase (sodium silicate) absorbs
microwaves, and thus, a selective heating was observed [4]. Sodium silicate is con-
verted into solid films or bonds between the two GFRP pipes by evaporation of water
(dehydration). During microwave exposure, the viscosity of the glass drops down to
A Feasibility Study on Microwave Joining of GFRP Composite … 437
a b
Pipe 1
Coupling agent
10 µm
10 µm
c
Coupling agent
Pipe 2
20 µm
Fig. 3 SEM image of successful microwave joint with coupling agent a liquid sodium silicate,
b polyethylene, c magnified image of polyethylene
the lower order and spreading of this material over the interface. Microwave exposure
makes it easier to inter-diffusion of coupling agent over the GFRP pipes. Further-
more, attainment of crystalline state at the processing temperature can also facilitate
effective bond. Sodium silicate films are having an affinity to moisture pickup, and
then, degradation of joints is also possible. However, microwave heating can com-
pletely remove the water particles from the sodium silicate which is helpful to form
good bond.
In the case of polyethylene coupling agent, the interface is observed very narrow
as seen in Fig. 3b. To understand more clearly, the interface of the joint is magnified,
and the corresponding image is shown in Fig. 3c. It is interesting to observe that there
is no presence of voids or discontinuities at the interface. The role of the coupling
agent is to absorb the microwave energy, generate local heat at the interface at the butt
faces of thermoset material. The dielectric property of polymers to external electric
field depends mainly on its polarity. Moreover, in unpolar polymers (polyethylene),
only induced (electron or ion) polarizations play a role when interact with electro-
magnetic wave [7], whereas in polar polymer orientation, dipole polarization can
contribute for heating. During microwave heating, due to localized interdiffusion
occurred [8] between the coupling agent to adjacent substrate materials the bond
formation occurred.
438 K. Rajkumar et al.
After the elimination of the failed samples, successful joints were tested for their joint
strength. The mechanical strength of the joint was tested through shear strength.
The successful joint was held in position with the help of the designed fixture.
From Table 1, it can be understood that sodium silicate and polyethylene are typical
coupling agents for bonding. Successful joints made from coupling agent such as
sodium silicate with 150 °C and 5 min and 150 °C and 10 min exhibited same shear
strength of 40.8 MPa. Polyethylene coupling agent with 300 °C and 2 min exhibited
strength of 122.4 MPa. Polyethylene produced better joint at 300 °C, and the shear
strength was quite high when compared with that of sodium silicate. In fact, the
shear strength of the former was almost triple than that of the latter. At an exposure
time of 10 min and higher temperature 350 °C, the substrate material was weakened,
and when it was subjected to a shear strength test, failure occurred at the substrate
material. The surface skin also been affected during the microwave exposure when
exceeding the optimal parameters. The buckling test was carried out on microwave
exposed at 150 °C and 10 min and unexposed samples. For carrying out the buckling
test, the sample was placed in the compressive testing machine, and the load was
steadily applied. Both the samples showed the same load of failure (2 kN). It is
understood from this compressive strength data that the microwave exposure had not
induced any detrimental effect on the GFRP pipe.
4 Conclusions
References
1. Ku HS, Siores E, Ball JAR, Horsfield B (1999) Microwave processing and permittivity
measurement of thermoplastic composite at elevated temperature. J Mater Process Technol
89:419–424
2. Siores E (1994) Microwave technology for welding and joining. Mater World 2(10):526
3. Liu F, Turner I, Siores E, Groombridge P (1996) A numerical and experimental investigation
of the microwave heating of polymer materials inside a ridge waveguide. J Microwave Power
Electromagn Energy 31:71–82
A Feasibility Study on Microwave Joining of GFRP Composite … 439
Abstract Synthetic fiber polymer laminates are becoming competitive material for
engineering and structural applications. In this work, an attempt is made to syn-
thesize a laminate with natural as well as synthetic fibers to get the advantage of
cost-effective natural fibers. Coir is a natural fiber available in significant amount
in south India. The present work aims at manufacturing a strong, cost effective,
light and low impact on environment hybrid material. Both GFRP laminates and
hybrid (GFRP + coconut Coir) laminates were fabricated by hand layup method and
compression molding. Physical and mechanical properties of this laminates such as
tensile strength, impact strength and density were evaluated. Microscopy images of
this laminates were arrived at through scanning electron microscope. Even though
the performance of hybrid (GFRP + coconut Coir) laminates is relatively lesser than
GFRP laminates, these hybrid laminates may be adopted in the industries where cost
is an important design factor.
1 Introduction
Biocomposites are an attractive new age alternative for synthetic composites [1]. The
increase in fiber reduces ductility but when treated with epoxy resin produces inho-
mogeneity however hardness increases [2]. Energy absorption and failure modes
were significantly affected by strain rate [3]. Coir fibers obtained from disregarded
coconut shells were used for reinforcement up to 80%. Up to 50% strength increased
further addition resulted in agglomeration [4]. Highest tensile strength of 30.7 MPa
was reported for cotton unsaturated polymer composite and tensile strength increased
linearly [5]. It was found that 30 volume percentage of coir reinforcement displayed
ballistic performance as good as Kevlar [6]. The coir reinforced epoxy matrix treated
with alkali showed 15% increase in impact strength when compared with untreated
samples [7]. Coconut shell powder as filler with fiber reinforcement in epoxy exhib-
ited reduction in wear rate due to the filler powder [8]. Epoxy resin was reinforced
with untreated coconut fiber leading to increase in tensile strength and higher impact
strength which was influenced by the high aspect ratio of the fibers [9]. The inclu-
sion of cow dung and corn starch fibers increases the friction coefficient. Overall, 6%
weight cow dung showed superior wear properties and thus proved that cow dung
fiber is efficient in improving the friction properties of composites. [10] There was
improved mechanical properties in treated fiber compared with raw fibers [11]. There
was 25% and 28% increase in flexural and tensile strength, respectively, after the coir
was treated in sodium carbonate for 96 h. Coir polyester achieved superior mechan-
ical properties compared to coir epoxy derivatives composites. The solution also
led to increase in the superfluous fiber roughness attributing to increased mechan-
ical properties [12]. Coconut fibers pre-treated with alkali solution such as NaOH
exhibited superior mechanical properties. And the length of the fibers subsequently
affected the tensile properties of the composites [13]. The hygroscopic swelling and
absorption effect on the mechanical properties of biocomposites revealed that the
direction of the fiber played a major role in the improved mechanical properties
[14]. Surface modification of fibers resulted in improved mechanical properties [15].
The flexural strength and tensile properties improved with longer coir [16]. The
effect of immersion of coir in water leads to a drastic decrease was preceded with
modulus stabilization [17]. The interaction effect between the curing time and coir
reinforced volume decided the tensile strength properties of coir fiber reinforced
epoxy composites [18].
the part. This technique is used to rapidly cure large quantities fiberglass-reinforced
polymer parts. Matched metal dies are placed in large molding press. The materials
to be molded are placed between the hot dies and pressed. Fiber arrangement and
volume percentage are similar to the hand layup GFRP. Only difference is that the
fiber and resin are compressed in between hot dies at 200 °C. Fiber arrangement and
volume percentage are similar to the hand layup hybrid. Only difference is that the
fiber and resin are compressed in between hot dies at 200 °C. The size of the specimen
for the impact test was as per ASTM A370. Brinell hardness test was carried out on
a specimen with measurements 50 * 50 * 10 mm.
3.1 Density
From Fig. 1, it can be seen that the density of GFRP and hybrid produced using
compression molding method is less dense when compared to hand layup method.
It may be due to the removal of excess epoxy through vaporization or through side
leaks when pressure is applied. It can therefore be inferred that GFRP and hybrid
composite fabricated using compression molding method are suitable for production
of low weight structural models and components (Fig. 2).
Fig. 2 Tensile samples according to ASTM D3039 after the test. a Hand layup GFRP. b Hand
layup hybrid. c Compression molding hybrid. d Compression molding GFRP
The tensile test of the composites was performed as per the ASTM D3039
(200 * 15 * 6) standards. The test was done using a universal testing machine.
The above figure shows tensile stress samples after the test.
From Fig. 3, it is evident that the tensile strength of compressed GFRP is higher
than that of hand layup method, this is because during compression the gap between
different layers is reduced due to the high pressure applied as well as the heat treatment
given, and this is also true when we look in hybrid composite. The hybrid composite
possesses less tensile strength due to that the GFRP slab contains more glass fibers
when compared to hybrid composite, and from the experiment, it is provident that the
tensile strength increases with increased glass fiber content as glass fiber is stronger
than natural fiber (coir). Therefore, we could conclude that the composite materials
fabricated by compression molding method possess more tensile strength than those
fabricated with usual hand layup method.
Comparative Evaluation of Mechanical Properties of GFRP … 445
Fig. 3 Effect of GFRP and hybrid on the ultimate tensile strength (MPa)
The typical test uses a 10 mm (0.39 in) diameter steel ball as an indenter with a
1000 kgf force. For softer materials, a smaller force is used; for harder materials, a
tungsten carbide ball is substituted for the steel ball (Fig. 4).
From Fig. 5, it is evident that the indentation of compressed GFRP is lower
than that of hand layup method, this is because during compression the gap between
different layers is reduced due to the high pressure applied as well as the heat treatment
given, and this is also true when we look in hybrid composite. Therefore, we could
conclude that the composite materials fabricated by compression molding method
possess more hardness than those fabricated with simple hand layup method.
The specimens were cut as per ASTM A370 standard. A V-notch is provided at
28 mm, i.e., at half the length of the specimen. The depth of the notch was around
2 mm, and 10 * 10 was its width and thickness, respectively.
From Fig. 6, it can be noticed that the impact strength of compression molding
is found to be way higher than that of the hand layup method, and this is due to
better adhesiveness of different layers in composite slabs. The compression molding
uses pressure as well as temperature to give better compression of the material,
446 R. Raja et al.
Fig. 4 Experimental values of Brinell hardness test obtained in this study are plotted in graph
Fig. 5 Charpy impact test specimens a Hand layup GFRP. b Hand layup hybrid. c Compression
hybrid. d Compression GFRP
and as a result, the bonding between various atom particles increases on comparing
with hand layup method. Among compression molded composite, the glass fiber
composite provides better impact strength than hybrid composite because the fiber
content in GFRP composite is found to be higher as well as the strength of glass fiber
Comparative Evaluation of Mechanical Properties of GFRP … 447
Fig. 6 Effect of fabrication technique and GFRP and hybrid polymer on the impact strength
strand is better when compared with a single coir fiber strand. Therefore, we can
conclude that the compressed glass fiber composite possesses more impact strength
when compared with other three samples.
Failures in composites are mainly due to voids, improper fiber bonding, poor
adhesiveness between the fiber and matrix, etc. The SEM images of the four samples
were taken at a magnification of 300× without any gold sputtering. The size of the
image measured 50 microns. The surface topography of each sample was studied,
and the conclusion obtained is as follows. In Fig. 7a and Fig. 7b, lots of voids are
visible. Weak interface between the fiber and matrix due void leads to premature
failure. These weak points lead to stress concentrations which cause de-bonding of
fiber. Cracks propagate from voids to voids which eventually lead to matrix failure,
fiber failure and ultimate failure of composites. Unlike the hand layup samples, the
compression molding processed samples as shown in Fig. 7c, d have higher interfacial
bonding between fire and matrix which will improve the ability of composite material
to undergo loading. The matrix clings to individual strands of fibers which suggest
that the fiber and matrix interfacial strength are exceptionally high. Thus, it can be
concluded that compression molded composites have higher bond strength and can
withstand higher loads without failing when compared to hand layup method.
448 R. Raja et al.
a b
c
d
Fig. 7 SEM images of different samples. a SEM image of hand layup GFRP 1-Fiber breakage.
b SEM image of hand layup hybrid. c SEM image of compression GFRP, 1-Fiber breakage. d SEM
image of compressed hybrid 2-voids
4 Conclusion
In the present investigation, a glass fiber coir hybrid composite was fabricated using
hand layup and compression molding method, and its mechanical properties were
tested. It was observed that compression molding showed enhanced mechanical prop-
erties when compared to hand layup. The effect of the addition of coconut fibers has
been studied, and the following conclusions have been drawn:
The tensile strength of hybrid is 44% of GFRP. Tensile strength of compression
molded composite is slightly higher than hand layup. Hybrid is 87% as hard as
GFRP, and when fabricated using compression molding, it showed slight increase in
hardness. Compression molded hybrid was 92% as tough as the compression molded
GFRP according to the impact test results.
Compression molding had also significantly raised the toughness of the compos-
ites. It was observed from the SEM images that the compression molded composites
had better interfacial bonding between matrix and fibers.
Comparative Evaluation of Mechanical Properties of GFRP … 449
The mechanical properties of hybrid are obviously lower than GFRP. But the
addition of coconut fibers leads to cost and weight reduction of the regular glass fiber
reinforced composites. Cost and strength of materials should always be maintained
at an optimum level. In this case, hybrid materials are able to provide reasonable
strength compared to purely synthetic materials at a lower cost, reduced weight and
also efficient usage of natural eco-friendly resource.
References
1. Khan A, Ahmad MA, Joshi S (2015) A systematic study for electrical properties of chemically
treated coir fiber reinforced epoxy composites with ANN model. Int J Sci Res 4:410–414
2. Deshpande S, Rangaswamy T, Engg M (2014) Effect of fillers on E-glass/jute fiber reinforced
epoxy composites. Int J Eng Res Appl 4:118–123
3. Fazita MRN, Khalil HPSA, Izzati ANA, Rizal S (2019) 3 - Effects of strain rate
on failure mechanisms and energy absorption in polymer composites. Elsevier Ltd.
https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-102293-1.00003-6
4. Monteiro SN, Terrones LAH, Almeida JRMD (2008) Mechanical performance of coir
fiber/polyester composites. Polym Test 27:591–595. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polymertesting.
2008.03.003
5. Balaji V, Senthil Vadivu K (2017) Mechanical characterization of coir fiber and cotton fiber
reinforced unsaturated polyester composites for packaging applications. J Appl Packag Res
9(2), Article 2. https://scholarworks.rit.edu/japr/vol9/iss2/2
6. Santos F, Neves S, Sousa E, Pereira É, Júnior L (2017) Ballistic application of coir fiber
reinforced epoxy composite in multilayered armor. Mater Res 20:23–28
7. Karthikeyan A, Balamurugan K (2012) Effect of alkali treatment and fiber length on impact
behavior of coir fiber reinforced epoxy composites. JSIR 71(09):627–631. http://nopr.niscair.
res.in/handle/123456789/14634
8. Kumar TV, Chandrasekaran M, Santhanam V (2017) Characteristics analysis of coconut shell
husk. J Eng Appl Sci 12:2401–2406
9. Biswas S, Kindo S, Patnaik A (2011) Effect of fiber length on mechanical behavior of coir
fiber reinforced epoxy composites. Fibers Polym 12:73–78. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12221-
011-0073-9
10. Ma Y, Wu S, Zhuang J, Tong J, Qi H (2019) Tribological and physio-mechanical characteri-
zation of cow dung fibers reinforced friction composites: an effective utilization of cow dung
waste. Tribiol Int 131:200–211. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.triboint.2018.10.026
11. Hasan M, Mir SS (2015) Manufacturing of coir fiber-reinforced polymer composites by hot,
Chapter 15. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-07944-8
12. Cesar J, Luiz R, Machado L, Vieira G, Teixeira R, Freire S, Mano V, Hallak T (2018) Effects
of sodium carbonate on the performance of epoxy and polyester coir-reinforced composites.
Polym Test 67:533–544. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polymertesting.2018.03.043
13. Nazeer A (2014) To Study the mechanical properties of coconut coir fiber reinforced with
epoxy resin AW 106 & HV 953 IN. Int J Mod Eng Res 4:38–47
14. Péron M, Célino A, Castro M, Jacquemin F, Le Duigou A (2019) Study of hygroscopic stresses
in asymmetric biocomposite laminates. Compos Sci Technol 169:7–15. https://doi.org/10.1016/
j.compscitech.2018.10.027
15. Cunha G, Filho DO, Carlos R, Mota DS, Claudia A, Antunes M, Olimpio O, Filho DA (2019)
Effects of hybridization on the mechanical properties of composites reinforced by piassava
fibers tissue. Compos Part B 162:73–79. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesb.2018.10.050
16. Obada DO, Kuburi LS, Dauda M, Umaru S, Dodoo-arhin D, Balogun MB, Iliyasu I, Iorpenda
MJ (2018) Effect of variation in frequencies on the viscoelastic properties of coir and coconut
450 R. Raja et al.
husk powder reinforced polymer composites. J King Saud Univ Eng Sci. https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.jksues.2018.10.001
17. Habibi M, Laperrière L, Mahi H (2019) Effect of moisture absorption and temperature on quasi-
static and fatigue behavior of nonwoven flax epoxy composite. Compos Part B 166:31–40.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesb.2018.11.131
18. Romli FI, Nizam A, Shakrine A, Rafie M, Laila D, Abdul A (2012) Factorial study on the tensile
strength of a coir fiber-reinforced epoxy composite. Procedia Soc Behav Sci 3:242–247. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.aasri.2012.11.040
Study of Hexagonal Boron Nitride
Particulate as Vibration Behaviour
Modifier of Alternate Stacked
Glass–Natural Fibre Polymer Composite
Laminate
1 Introduction
In recent years, it is a known fact that the environment is completely messed up. As
a result, the researchers are probing a solution to fix it using naturally acquired mate-
rials. There comes the natural fibre as an alternate for synthetic fibre. The studies, till
the date, have undoubtedly proved that the natural polymeric substances are substi-
tuted for synthetic polymers. In order to achieve the desired properties of the current
applications, the evolution of composites with various natural fibres as reinforcement
and fillers do meet the requirements. Various studies have reported a better result on
the hybridization of natural fibres along with synthetic fibres reinforced with ther-
mosetting polymers [1–3]. Woven fibres with particulates improve the properties of
the composites. Glass fibres are hybridized with natural fibres like kenaf, sisal, jute,
coir, banana, flax, date palm wood, basalt.
Researchers are attracted to the fibres acquired from nature to utilize in poly-
mer composites due to their eco-friendly nature and sustainability [1]. The lignin,
hemicellulose, cellulose-based composites are suitable for the electrical, mechani-
cal, thermal and biodegradation applications [1, 3]. The elastic modulus of fibres
and the interface properties of the matrix have a large effect on the stress and strain
to failure initiation [2]. The thermal property of individual low conductivity kenaf
fibres proves that a reduction in 16% of the effective thermal conductivity of the
composite [3]. The addition of kenaf fibres reduces the degree of crystallinity of the
recycled polypropylene/polyethylene sourced from rejected–unused diapers whose
plastic and absorbent gel were separated [4]. The tensile strength and flexural strength
of kenaf fibre were improved considerably when reinforced with vinyl ester, epoxy
and polyurethane matrixes [5]. The double-layered kenaf fibres increase the thermal
property and the tensile strength of the composite than single-layered kenaf fibre
[6]. The thermal and dynamic mechanical properties of silane-treated pineapple leaf
fibre and kenaf fibre have better than that of untreated fibres [7]. Kenaf fibres absorb
sound and thus used for acoustic purpose. The sound absorption of kenaf fibres is
similar to that of synthetic rock wool [8].
The dynamic flexural modulus has no significant effect on the radial configuration
of the kenaf yarns, whilst the glass fibres have on damping factor. The bilateral
configuration of glass yarns has considerable effects on the static flexural modulus,
strength and the strain at break [9].
The addition of microsize calcium carbonate with kenaf fibres reinforced vinyl
ester increases the tensile and flexural properties of the composite [10]. The
flax/basalt hybrid reinforced with vinyl ester laminates enhances the durability and
water repellence behaviour [11]. The inclusion of kenaf fibre with hexagonal boron
nitride (hBN) and epoxy increases the thermal conductivity of the composite than
with hBN and epoxy alone [12].
Hexagonal boron nitride also termed as white graphite is chemically stable and
possesses good lubrication properties, resistant to oxides, high thermal conduc-
tivity and excellent electrical insulation [13]. Recently, the application of boron
nitride nanomaterials (nanoparticles, nanotubes, nanosheets, etc.) in medical areas
is increasing rapidly because of its unique properties and suitable to the other
applications [14] also.
A study on the damping behaviour of composite is necessary since it reduces
the vibration by dissipating energy. Various types of transducers have been used to
measure the response of the vibrations of composite. An impact hammer attached
with a force transducer is used as an exciter and a mini accelerometer to obtain the
Study of Hexagonal Boron Nitride Particulate … 453
response of the simply supported specimen [15]. Flat coils were attached to the ends
of a beam within the fields of permanent magnets. An alternating current through
one coil was used as vibrators whilst the motion of the other coil as transducer. The
composite specimen with high flexural modulus lowers specific damping capacity
[16].
From the above review, it is concluded that the work presented in this paper has not
been done anywhere in the past. This paper provides an overview of the characteristics
of treated and untreated fabrics of kenaf and glass reinforced vinyl ester with boron
nitride particle. The contribution of the boron nitride with the thermosetting polymer
has a significant role on the mechanical and vibration properties of polymer laminates.
2.1 Materials
The E glass woven was chosen for its low cost and high performance in strength,
stiffness, heat and chemical resistance. Kenaf being one of the lignocellulosic fibres
was selected due to its low cost, low density, high specific strength and sustainability.
Woven kenaf fibres were soaked in 6% (wt) of NaOH solution at 25 °C for 24 h
maintaining a water solution ratio of 15:1. They were then washed well with distilled
water and after neutralizing with dilute acetic acid. The kenaf fabrics were dried for
48 h. The boron nitride particle of size 5 µm is used due to its lamellar structure and
high thermal conductivity. The vinyl ester resin of grade HPR 8711 with catalyst
(1% MEKP), promoter (Benzyl peroxide) and accelerator (0.5% Cobalt Napthanate)
to form a matrix was used. Table 1 refers the physical and mechanical properties of
the thermoset polymer used.
The hybrid composite laminates were fabricated at room temperature by hand layup
technique. The treated and untreated fabrics of kenaf along with glass fibres of size
30 × 30 cm2 were placed in the thermoset resin mixed with hexagonal boron nitride
454 K. Rajkumar and M. Selvaraj
of various proportions. It was then cured with the promoter, catalyst and accelerator.
Five sets of hybrid composites were prepared by placing the fabrics of treated kenaf
and glass alternately for 0, 2 and 4% of hBN. Similarly, the untreated kenaf fibres
were arranged alternately with glass fibres for 2% and 4% hBN mixed with resin,
respectively.
The five samples prepared for each formulation were cut according to ASTM D-3039
(1995) with a size of 250*25*4 mm to carry out the tensile test in an universal testing
machine (Instron 4206) at a feed rate of 0.1 mm/min. Figure 1 shows the test samples.
During the tension test, the grips were moved apart at a constant rate to stretch the
specimen. The results were averaged for the five specimen of each formulation for
calculation purpose. Scanning electron microscope (SEM) was used to evaluate the
fracture surface of the polymer matrix and to illustrate the fibrillose morphology of
the kenaf fibres.
A multirecorder frequency processing unit was used to determine the vibration of the
hybrid composite laminates. Vibration induced on the specimen by electro-dynamic
shaker. The phase analyser (FFT analyser) has four input channels and was used
as a data acquisition system. The accelerometer measures the acceleration of the
vibrations. The impact hammer was used for impacts of varying amplitude. The
real-time frequency analysis software, DEWESOFT, was used for the data analysis
and verification. The one end of the specimen was hold by gripper, and another
end was free, as cantilever mode. The specimens were excited at the free end by
impact hammer, and the corresponding responses were recorded. This vibration test
determines the natural frequency and damping ratio.
Figure 2 shows a comparative analysis of tensile strength for the composite laminates
fabricated with treated and untreated kenaf/glass fabrics reinforced with 0, 2 and 4%
of hBN. The fabricated specimen with treated kenaf fabric hybridized with glass
fibres for the addition of 2% hexagonal boron nitride (hBN) mixed with vinyl ester
resin has the highest tensile strength. The tensile strength gradually increases for the
samples fabricated with the treated kenaf fibres hybridized with glass fibres matrix
with 0–2% addition of hBN and decreases for 4% of hBN.
The tensile strength obtained for the untreated kenaf fibre with the addition of
2% hBN gives the maximum value, whilst the addition of 4% hBN gives the mini-
mum value. The notable improvement in tensile strength of the treated kenaf fibres
hybridized with glass fibres can be due to strong interface adhesion. The proper addi-
tion of hBN, that is, 2% resulted a very good adhesion property for the fibres with
the matrix than 4%. The fall of tensile strength value for 4% addition of hBN does
not attribute high bond between fibre and matrix. Figure 3 shows fracture surface of
untreated and treated kenaf fibre hybrid composites.
The untreated fibre composite shows an inefficient transfer of resin along the fibre
direction leading to poor intact between fibre-matrix interfaces. The used NaOH
treatment has removed impurities from the external surface of kenaf fibres, so their
surface appears clean, and it gives good adhesion to the polymer matrix.
The flexural strength of the laminated hybrid composite samples is shown in Fig. 4.
It is clearly noted that the flexural strength of the sample fabricated with untreated
kenaf fabric hybridized with glass fabric reinforced in 2% hBN mixed with vinyl
ester resin gives the maximum, whilst the minimal value is seen for 4% hBN. The
composite laminates fabricated with treated fabrics of kenaf and glass reinforced in
thermoset resin gradually increase from 0 to 2% hBN and a fall in value for 4% hBN.
Study of Hexagonal Boron Nitride Particulate … 457
The two modal frequencies of each sample are enlisted in Table 2. The damping
ratio was obtained using the DEWESOFT software. In higher modal frequency,
treated fibre laminate shows the higher damping than that of untreated kenaf fibre
laminate. The strong adhesion of matrix and fibre mostly relaxes the vibration energy.
The hBN particles inclusion in the treated kenaf laminate increases the damping ratio
by dissipating by more vibration energy, as shown in Fig. 6. This is a synergizing
effect by the strong adhesion between fibre-matrix and local relaxing behaviour of
secondary hBN particles. The weak interface was observed from the untreated fibre
reinforced composite, despite being the presence of hBN particle, leading to lower
damping ratio. This is due that lower dissipation of vibration energy by the kenaf
fibres.
The damping ratio of composite without hBN particle exhibited a minimum value.
The four times of increasing particle content in matrix observed to be increased the
two times of damping ratio.
0.03
Untreated fiber
0.02 Treated fiber
0.01
0 2 4
hBN %
Study of Hexagonal Boron Nitride Particulate … 459
4 Conclusions
Vinyl ester hybrid composites were fabricated with kenaf fibre mat, glass fibre mat
and different wt. fraction of hBN particles. The composite with treated fibre-2%
hBN showed a higher tensile strength, but 4% hBN addition shows a lower value.
Fracture surface of untreated fibre composite shows an incomplete resin transfer
to fibre leading poor intact between fibre-matrix interfaces. The NaOH treatment
has removed impurities from the surface of kenaf fibres paved the way for good
adhesion property. It is clearly showed that the flexural strength of the treated kenaf
fabric hybridized with glass-2% hBN exhibited a maximum, whilst the minimal value
observed for 4% hBN content composite.
It is clearly seen that natural frequency of laminates decreases with increasing
particulate content. Fibre treatment increases the natural frequency of laminates due
to undisturbed continuous phase of matrix. The hBN particles inclusion in the treated
kenaf laminate increases the damping ratio by dissipating by more vibration energy.
This is a synergizing effect of strong adhesion between fibre-matrix and local relaxing
behaviour of secondary hBN particles. The damping ratio of composite without hBN
particle exhibited a minimum value. The four times increasing hBN particle content
in the matrix increases the two times of damping ratio.
References
1. Mohammed L, Ansari MNM, Pua G, Jawaid M, Saiful Islam V (2015) A review on natural
fiber reinforced polymer composite and its applications. Int J Polym Sci. Article ID 243947,
15 pages http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2015/243947
2. Asp LE, Berglund LA, Talreja R (1996) Effects of fiber and interphase on matrix Initiated
Transverse failure in polymer composites. Compos Sci Technol 56:657–665
3. Guillou J, Lavadiya DN, Munro T, Fronk T, Ban H (2018) From lignocelluloses to biocomposite:
multi-level modeling and experimental investigation of the thermal properties of kenaf fiber
reinforced composites based on constituent materials. Appl Thermal Eng 128:1372–1381
4. Taufiq MJ, Mansor MR, Mustafa Z (2018) Characterization of wood plastic composite
manufactured from kenaf fibre reinforced recycled-unused plastic blend. Compos Struct
189:510–515
5. Sharba MJ, Salman SD, Leman Z, Sultan MTH, Ishakand Mohamad MR, AzmahHanim A
(2016) Effects of processing method, moisture content and resin system on physical and
mechanical properties of woven kenaf plant fiber composites. BioResources 11(1):1466–1476
6. Islam MR, Beg MDH (2016) Effects of reinforcing arrangement of kenaf fibers into unsaturated
polyester for improved properties. J Mech Eng Sci 10(2):2020–2030
7. Asima M, Paridah MT, Saba N, Jawaid M, Alothman OY, Nasir M, Almutrai Z (2018) Thermal,
physical properties and flammability of silane treated kenaf/pineapple leaf fibers phenolic
hybrid composites. Compos Struct 202:1330–13338
8. Lim ZY, Putra A, Nor MJM, Yaakob MY (2018) Sound absorption performance of natural
kenaf fibers. Appl Acoustics 130:107–114
9. Hashemi F, Brancheriau L, Thahir PM (2018) Hybridization and yarns configuration effects
on flexural dynamic and static properties of pultruded hybrid kenaf/glass fibre composites.
Compos Part A 112:415–422
460 K. Rajkumar and M. Selvaraj
10. Fairuz AM, Sapuan SM, Zainidin ES, Jaafar CNA (2016) Effect of filler loading on mechan-
ical properties of pultruded kenaf fiber reinforced vinyl ester composites. J Mech Eng Sci
10(1):1931–1942
11. Ramraji K, Rajkumar K, Sabarinathan P (2019) Tailoring of tensile and dynamic thermo-
mechanical properties of interleaved chemical-treated fine almond shell particulate flax fiber
stacked vinyl ester polymeric composites. In: Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical
Engineers, Part L: Journal of Materials: Design and Applications, p 1464420719849616
12. Xia C, Garcia AC, Shi SQ, Warner N, Wu Y, Cai L, Rizvi HR, D’Souza NA, Nie X (2016)
Hybrid boron nitride—natural fiber composites for enhanced thermal conductivity. Sci Rep
6:34726. https://doi.org/10.1038/srep34726
13. Kivnc M, Barutca B, Koparal AT, Goncu Y, Bostanci SH, Ay N (2018) Effects of hexagonal
boron nitride nanoparticles on antimicrobial and antibiofilm activities, cell viability. Mater Sci
Eng C. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msec.2018.05.028
14. Gnanavelbabu A, Rajkumar K, Saravanan P (2018) Investigation on the cutting quality charac-
teristics of abrasive water jet machining of AA6061-B4C-hBN hybrid metal matrix composites.
Mater Manuf Process 33(12):1313–1323
15. Rao MD, Crocker MJ (2009) Vibrations of bonded beams with a single lap adhesive joint. J
Sound Vibration 92(2):299–309
16. Kadioglu F (2009) Measurement of dynamic properties of composites in vibration by means
of a non-contact mechanism. J Reinforced Plast Compos 28, No. 12/2009 https://doi.org/10.
1177/0731684408089514
Study of Statistical Distribution
and Morphology of Particles in a Polymer
Matrix by Foldscope Imaging Technique
Abstract Design and material engineers are focusing on strengthening and tough-
ening of the polymer matrix by introducing secondary particles. However, particle
distribution is a control parameter to ensure the properties of polymer materials. Fur-
ther, the agglomeration of the fine particle affects polymer composite performance.
The chosen process may affect the statistical distribution and aggregation of sec-
ondary particles in the polymer composite. There is a lack of simple and affordable
technique to evaluate the particle distribution, morphology and degree of agglomera-
tion of particles in the polymer matrix. In this paper, the origami crafted microscope
called foldscope is used to find out the particle distribution in the polymer matrix. Ini-
tially, the fillers/particles are mixed in the epoxy matrix through an ultra-sonication
technique. The experiments are conducted by varying the size of filler (30, 80 and
120 grit) with sonication parameters such as power rate (70, 80 and 100%) and pro-
cessing time T on (45, 90 and 135 s) with constant 3% filler in weight. With the above
parameters, Taguchi L17 array was constructed, and the process parameters were
optimized to the high degree of uniform distribution. From the particulate polymer
composite, the images captured by foldscope were further analyzed by ImageJ tech-
nique for determination of the statistical distribution of particles. The processing
parameters of 80% power, T on 135 s for 120 grit size exhibited excellent particle
distribution and higher tensile strength.
1 Introduction
In this work, dry almond shells were reinforced to obtain the polymer composite.
Initially, the impurities from almond shells were removed. Then, it is crushed by
using Willy’s mechanical mill. The crushed particles were sieved to 30, 80 and 120
grit size by laboratory shaker and used as a filler material for the polymer matrix.
Araldite HY550 epoxy resin and hardener HY951 were used as polymer matrix to
fabricate the polymer composite. A constant filler weight of 3% is used to fabricate
the composite laminate.
Study of Statistical Distribution and Morphology … 463
2.3 Fabrication
The hand layup method was used for the fabrication of polymer composite because
of its low cost, maximum effectiveness and simplicity. The particulate laminate has
dimensions of 300 mm × 300 mm × 4 mm, which is divided into three segments
along its length. Each segment has a size of 300 mm × 100 mm × 4 mm. The almond
shell powder of different grits was mixed with resin by ultra-sonication process. For
the particle dispersion study, Taguchi experimental design was constructed, and the
464 P. Kaythry et al.
range and level of the selected input parameters are given in Table 1. Table 2 shows
the formation of L17 array by using a Box–Behnken method of experimentation.
The fabricated almond particle dispersed in polymer composites is shown in Fig. 2.
The tensile test was carried out to evaluate the tensile strength by universal testing
machine (Instron 4206) at a feed rate of 0.2 mm/min. A standard dimension of
250 mm × 25 mm × 4 mm was prepared according to American Society for Testing
and Materials (ASTM) D638 standard. Abrasive water jet machine (AWJM) was used
to make the standard specimen. The prepared specimens and tested tensile samples
are shown in Figs. 3 and 4, respectively.
Study of Statistical Distribution and Morphology … 465
Table 3 represents the processing parameters and results for particle distribution and
tensile strength. As the grit size increases, the mean particle size decreases. From the
experiment number 2, 4 and 12, it is observed that smaller particle size shows a higher
particle distribution with very less mean free path between the particles. Since the
surface area to the volume of the particle is higher for smaller particles, the number of
particles present in the fixed area is high. On the other hand, the experiment numbers
7, 10 and 13 with larger particle size reveal particle distribution with low surface area
to the volume of the particle. As results, the number of particles in the fixed area was
low. Thereby mean free path between the particles is also high. The foldscope images
of polymer composites are given by a column–row matrix in Fig. 7. The grit size of
120, 80 and 30 is mentioned for each column. It also evidences that the strength of
the composites partly depends on the degree of the particle distribution.
The statistical analysis of the experimental results is performed using Design
Expert statistical software. A separate analysis of variance (ANOVA) is carried out
for the particle distribution and tensile strength. The optimum level of variables for the
uniform distribution is obtained using the Design Expert program. For a significant
model, the P value should be < 0.05. From ANOVA for particle distribution in Table 4,
the Model P value of 0.0098 implies the model is significant. There is an only chance
of 0.98% error in Model F value occurs due to noise in experimentation. Power (B),
Particle size × T on (AC) were significant model terms.
Increasing the power of the sonication process increases the intensity of the sonic
waves, which is shown in Fig. 8. There is no effect on the particle distribution when
Fig. 8 Contour plot showing the effect of particle size and power on particle distribution
the threshold level of power is above 93%. Moreover, 120 grit particle size requires
less energy to disperse the particle with high distribution percentage due to the mass–
acceleration relationship. If the power is below 93%, then the maximum distribution
of particles occurs for all range of particle size. For 30 grit particle size, it requires
a higher power level of 85% for the dispersion of particulates to cover a maximum
of 47.85% distribution area.
The 120 grit particle size with medium power (85%) gives the higher tensile
strength. The higher particle size with all range of power reduces the strength of the
composites due to mass–acceleration relationship as shown in Fig. 9.
Study of Statistical Distribution and Morphology … 471
The ANOVA for tensile strength is given in Table 5. In this Model, P value of
0.0224 implies the model is significant. So, there is only a 2.24% chance that a model
deviates, which could be due to the noise in the experimentation. Particle size (A),
Particle size × T on (AC), Power × T on (BC) are significant model terms.
Figure 10 shows the relationship between tensile strength, particle size and power.
The particle size affects the mechanical strength of the polymer matrix composites.
In a smaller particle (120 grit), the lower mean free path of particles increases the
cross-linking of polymer chain. Hence it results in higher tensile stress of particulates
in polymer composite. The degree of cross-linking is low for large particle size (30
grit), which leads to lower tensile strength.
Figure 11 shows the relationship between tensile strength, power and T on . The
tensile strength of composites increases with the T on due to the higher degree of
particulate disperse with all the range of particle size. It is directly derived that
power of the sonication process increases the tensile strength of composite. This is
because of higher degree particle distribution with all the range of particle size.
Figure 12 depicts the average tensile strength to the ratio of distribution and particle
size. In zone-I, when the ratio of distributions to particle size is low, there is a steep
rise in tensile strength due to the higher order of cross-linking. Zone-II is called as
a transition zone, where the tensile strength begins to decrease. In zone-III, there is
no improvement in the tensile strength due to the saturation in cross-linking.
4 Conclusions
References
1 Introduction
chemical treatment method has reducing hydrophilic behavior of the natural fiber.
Flax fiber woven was treated with 5% NaOH solution providing better mechanical
properties [7]. However, its low degradation temperature (∼200 °C) makes them
incompatible to the thermoset polymer composite. This also restricts the selection
of manufacturing method for natural fiber composite processing [8].
Epoxy (EP) resin is one of the most important matrixes for the polymer compos-
ites include surface coatings, insulating materials, and structural adhesives. But its
high cross-linking network during curing produces undesirable brittle characteristic.
This leads to poor resistance to crack growth, low toughness, and low impact strength
[9, 10]. In order to change its brittle nature by blending with compatible polymers
such as an elastomer or rubbery, thermoplastic is required. These are providing addi-
tional interpenetrating polymer networks (IPNs) with an epoxy cross-link network.
Polyurethane and the epoxy resins are NCO (nitrogen, carbon, and oxygen) and OH
group. Epoxy blending with polyurethane makes it strong and flexible. Also, it gives
a stable epoxy structure by polyurethane IPNs [11, 12]. The properties of the blends
are the same as those synthesized by batch polymerization. Moreover, it requires the
least time and energy input for the polymerization process [13]. Polyurethanes (PUs)
are a unique family of polymers that possess some of the properties of plastics and
rubbers. PU/EP IPNs show excellent thermal and mechanical properties as derived
from the advantage characteristic of both the PU and EP [14, 15]. During the past
decades, the great deals of efforts have been made on the evaluation of mechanical
properties, and morphology of PU/EP IPNs and optimal ratio of PU IPNs in EP [16].
Viscoelastic polymeric materials are used as a medium of attenuating sound and
damping the vibration. Those capabilities of the polymer are determined by how
much dissipating sound or the vibrational mechanical energy into heat. This is indi-
cated by intensity and broadness of the loss modulus or tan δ peaks at a particular
range of temperatures. As temperature or testing frequency increases, the loss mod-
ulus (E ) and loss tangent (tan δ) show an intensity peak when damping reaches
a maximum value [17]. The storage modulus (E ) or dynamic modulus is typically
related to Young’s modulus of a material. It depends on the stiffness of a material
and determines the sample whether it is stiff or flimsy. E is a material property that
having an ability to store energy applied to it. The changes in strength and stiffness
of epoxy thermoset are evident by blending with polyurethane resin. The damp-
ing characteristics of epoxy polymer composites can be tailored by optimization of
polyurethane composition [18, 19].
This research work reports the optimum composition of polyurethane blend and its
effect on the dynamic mechanical properties of flax fiber-reinforced epoxy polymer
composite.
Dynamic Mechanical Analysis of Flax … 477
2.1 Materials
Flax fiber was purchased from the Go Green Fiber Ltd., Chennai. The properties
of flax fiber are follows, fiber strength (88–1500 MPa), density (1.4 g/cm3 ), specific
modulus (60–80 GPa), and elongation at failure 1.2–1.6% [20]. The used epoxy resin
grade was LY556 and of density 1.25 (g/cm3 ), Young’s modulus (3.5 GPa), tensile
strength (50 MPa), and fracture toughness (0.5 MPa) [21]. Polyurethane properties
are followed as density (1.2 g/cm3 ), Young’s modulus (0.01 GPa), tensile strength
(20 MPa), and fracture toughness (0.1 MPa) [15]. Diethylenetriamine (DETA) was a
curing agent of C4H13N3 purchased from the Vasavibala Chemical, Chennai. Methyl
ethyl ketone (MEK), a grade of C2 H5 ·CO·CH3 as a compatizer was purchased from
the Chen chem chemical, Chennai, India.
The composite laminates were made by hand layup technique that followed a grav-
ity compression loading. Flax woven was treated with 5% NaOH solution for three
hours and then washed by running tap water. Treated woven fibers were dried under
direct sunlight to remove moisture. The releasing agent (Mansion Wax) was properly
spread inside of mold for easy separation. Polymer blend laminate has a dimension
of 300*300*5 mm3 and is fabricated. To prepare epoxy-polyurethane blend compos-
ite, epoxy resin and polyurethane were dissolved separately in methyl ethyl ketone
(MEK). The polyurethane pre-polymer was acting as a slender and its concentra-
tions (5, 10, 15, and 20%) in the epoxy resin as shown in Table 1. The polymer blend
resin mixture was prepared by mixing epoxy-polyurethane resins at room temper-
ature. The ultrasonic stirring process was employed to mix the polyurethane resin
in the epoxy resin. The chosen ratio of 10% of diethylenetriamine (DETA) and 2%
of methylethylketone (MEK) has been added. Then, a woven flax layer was an ini-
tial layer, above which flax layer by layer were stacked. Finally, blend mixture was
applied between the flax layers for effective binding. The composite laminates were
Table 1 Polyurethane
Blend composites % of polyurethane blend (by weight)
content of composite samples
BC0 0
BC5 5
BC10 10
BC15 15
BC20 20
478 K. Rajkumar et al.
cured under dead weight loading for 24 h. The typical blend laminate is shown in
Fig. 1.
The mechanical and dynamic mechanical properties were evaluated for the fabricated
blend composites as given below.
Tensile and Flexural Strength
The specimens were cut by abrasive water jet machine for both tensile and flexural
tests. The tensile property was recorded from the universal testing machine (UTM).
The tensile specimen was confirming the ASTM-D638 standard and is shown in
Fig. 2a. Loading on the sample was continued until the specimen breaks. The flex-
ural property was recorded using the universal testing machine with a facility of
three-point bending. The flexural specimen was prepared according to ASTM-D790
standard, as shown in Fig. 2b. Five specimens of tensile and flexural strength were
tested for each blend compositions.
Dynamic mechanical analysis
DMA measurements were carried out in Du Pont 983 analyzer. Dynamic mechanical
properties were measured in tensile mode at a fixed frequency of 1 Hz under nitrogen
gas purging. The specimen was heated from 34 to 185 °C with a heating rate of
5 °C/min. The quantities of the storage modulus (E ), loss modulus (E ), loss factor
(tan δ), and temperature were recorded in the data logger. These data were further
used to construct the damping characteristics curve.
Dynamic Mechanical Analysis of Flax … 479
The tensile strength and modulus of blend composites are shown in Fig. 3a, b. This
figure shows that tensile strength and modulus of blend composites increased with
increase in polyurethane composition. An addition of polyurethane blend provides
significant changes in the network structure. It reduces the tensile strength when
polyurethane composition was exceeding 10%. Increases in polyurethane resin con-
tent above the 15 and 20% (BC15 and BC20) the failure of composite occurs under
lower tensile stress. It can be seen that composite BC10 blend composition shows a
higher tensile strength. The improvement of tensile strength was 25.5% which is more
than that of base composite (BC0). This is due to saturation of polyurethane inter-
penetrating network with epoxy rings [16]. Similarly, BC10 blend composite shows
a maximum tensile modulus. It was almost 44.4% greater than BC0 blend composite.
While, BC5 and BC15 blend composites observed higher tensile modulus by 22.2
and 31.1% than the BC0 blend composite.
The flexural strength and modulus of blend composites are shown in Fig. 4a, b.
Figure 4a shows a flexural strength which increases with increasing polyurethane
blend composition. This could be an addition of polyurethane blend which signifi-
cantly increases interlinking networks of the epoxy matrix. IPNs are improving the
strength and flexi of the composite. Additionally, flax fiber resisting bending stress
induced upon it. Higher flexural strength was obtained from the BC10 blend com-
posite. It is observed that BC10 was 40.4% higher than the BC0 blend composite.
Moreover, BC5, BC15, and BC20 blend composites are showing 12.3, 25.8, and
9% higher than BC0 blend composite. Similarly, BC10 blend composite reaches a
maximum flexural modulus and of 21.5% more than the BC0 blend composite.
The high value of E , specifically BC10, indicates a good adhesion between polymer
blend composites. This fact shows that blend composite BC10 has a better interface
bonding as compared to other blend composites. This figure also shows a shifting
of glass transition temperature toward the left side as increasing in polyurethane
composition in the matrix.
Loss modulus (E )
The variation of loss modulus of blend composites as a function of temperature at 1 Hz
frequency is shown in Fig. 6. Similar to storage modulus, the value of loss modulus
of blend composite was also found to be increasing with increase in polyurethane
composition up to 10%. It can be observed that the value of E increases up to the
glass transition temperature (T g ) and then decreasing with temperature. In glassy
region, the maximum values of loss modulus of blend composites BC0, BC5, BC10,
BC15, and BC20 are found as 5.05E+7 Pa, 5.96E+7 Pa, 7.38E+7 Pa, 6.4E+8 Pa, and
1.87E+7 Pa, respectively. The peak height (maximum value) of loss modulus curve
shows the T g of corresponding composites. The blend composite BC10 shows the
highest value of T g (93 °C) which indicates better thermal stability than the other
blend composites.
Loss factor (tan δ)
The variation of loss factor of blend composite as a function of temperature is shown
in Fig. 7. The temperature corresponding to the tan δ peak is known as the glass
transition temperature of the composite. The order of maximum value of tan δ for
blend composites of BC10, BC5, BC0, BC15, and BC20 is found that 0.452, 0.448,
0.428, 0.417, and 0.378, respectively. The highest peak of tan δ value was found for
BC10 composite which means that better damping property reached as compared
482 K. Rajkumar et al.
to other blend composites [19]. The lower value of tan δ is found for the blend
composite BC20. Damping properties of different blend composite are shown in
Table 2. The capability of damping was improving up to BC10 and begins to decrease
as polyurethane composition increases. This clearly observed from Table 2. The
similar trend is observed for the T g of composites. It can be noted that the temperature
Dynamic Mechanical Analysis of Flax … 483
4 Conclusions
Dynamic mechanical properties of polymer blend reinforced with flax fiber compos-
ite were studied and the following conclusions are drawn.
1. The tensile strength and modulus of BC10 composition reaches a maximum
value and then decreases with further increase in blend composition. The tensile
strength and its modulus improvement were 25.5 and 40.4% higher than that of
base composite (BC0). This is attributed to the interpenetrating networks (IPNs)
of polyurethane with epoxy cross-link networks.
2. The higher flexural strength and flexural modulus were obtained for the BC10
blend composite. The flexural strength and modulus were increased by 40.4 and
21.5% when compared to the BC0 composite.
3. It is found that the value of storage modulus increases with increase in
polyurethane composition up to 10% in the matrix and then decreases with further
increase in polyurethane composition. Due to the reduction in stiffness of matrix
and flexi or rubbery nature, the loss modulus (E ) of blend composite BC10 shows
the highest value of T g (93 °C) which shows better thermal stability. The blend
composite BC10 reveals a higher value of tan δ, which is indicative of higher
dampness. Among the dynamic mechanical tested composites, the dampness of
BC10 exists for a longer temperature range.
References
1. Ali M, Liu A, Sou H, Chouw N (2012) Mechanical and dynamic properties of coconut fiber
reinforced concrete. Constr Build Mater 30:814–825
2. Yan LB, Chouw N, Yuan XW (2012) Improving the mechanical properties of natural fiber fabric
reinforced epoxy composites by alkali treatment. J Reinforced Plastics Compos 31(6):425–437
484 K. Rajkumar et al.
3. Liang S, Gning PB, Guillaumat L (2012) A comparative study of fatigue behaviour of flax/epoxy
and glass/epoxy composites. Compos Sci Technol 72(5):535–543
4. Ku H, Wang H, Pattarachaiyakoop N, Trada M (2011) A review on the tensile properties of
natural fiber reinforced polymer composites. Compos Part B: Eng 42(4):856–873
5. Sgriccia N, Hawley MC, Misra M (2008) Characterization of natural fiber surfaces and natural
fiber composites. Compos Part A: Appl Sci Manuf 39(10):1632–1637
6. Genc G, El Hafidi A, Gning PB (2012) Comparison of the mechanical properties of flax and
glass fiber composite materials. J VibroEng 14(2):783
7. Ramraji K, Rajkumar K, Sabarinathan P (2019) Tailoring of tensile and dynamic thermo-
mechanical properties of interleaved chemical-treated fine almond shell particulate flax fiber
stacked vinyl ester polymeric composites. In: Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical
Engineers, Part L: Journal of Materials: Design and Applications, p 1464420719849616
8. Li X, Tabil LG, Panigrahi S (2007) Chemical treatments of natural fiber for use in natural
fiber-reinforced composites: a review. J Polym Environ 15(1):25–33
9. May CA (1998) Epoxy resins. Marcel Dekker, New York
10. Lee L, Nevile K (1986) Handbooks of epoxy resins. McGraw-Hill, New York
11. Maxwell D, Young RJ, Kinloch AJ (1984) Hybrid particulate-filled epoxy-polymers. J Mater
Sci Lett 3(1):9–12
12. Kinloch AJ, Shaw SJ, Hunston DL (1983) Deformation and fracture behaviour of a rubber-
toughened epoxy: 2. Failure criteria. Polymer 24(10):1355–1363
13. Chen S, Tian Y, Chen L, Hu T (2006) Epoxy resin/polyurethane hybrid networks synthesized
by frontal polymerization. Chem Mater 18(8):2159–2163
14. Kostrzewa M, Hausnerová B, Bakar M, Dalka M (2011) Property evaluation and structure
analysis of polyurethane/epoxy graft interpenetrating polymer networks. J Appl Polym Sci
122(3):1722–1730
15. Chen CH, Chen MH (2006) Synthesis, thermal properties, and morphology of blocked
polyurethane/epoxy full-interpenetrating polymer network. J Appl Polym Sci 100(1):323–328
16. Jin H, Zhang Y, Wang C, Sun Y, Yuan Z, Pan Y, Xie H, Cheng R (2014) Thermal, mechanical,
and morphological properties of soybean oil-based polyurethane/epoxy resin interpenetrating
polymer networks (IPNs). J Thermal Anal Calorimetry 117(2):773–781
17. Chern YC, Tseng SM, Hsieh KH (1999) Damping properties of interpenetrating polymer
networks of polyurethane-modified epoxy and polyurethanes. J Appl Polym Sci 74(2):328–335
18. Jawaid M, Khalil HA, Hassan A, Dungani R, Hadiyane A (2013) Effect of jute fiber loading
on tensile and dynamic mechanical properties of oil palm epoxy composites. Compos Part B:
Eng 45(1):619–624
19. Wang C, Jia J (2014) Damping and mechanical properties of polyol cross-linked
polyurethane/epoxy interpenetrating polymer networks. High Perform Polym 26(2):240–244
20. Mohammed L, Ansari MN, Pua G, Jawaid M, Islam MS (2015) A review on natural fiber
reinforced polymer composite and its applications. Int J Polym Sci
21. Chawla KK (2012) Composite materials: science and engineering. Springer Science & Business
Media
Material Processing Technology
Comparative Study of Ball Nose and Flat
End Milling on A356 Alloy/SiCp Metal
Matrix Composite
K. Jayakumar
Abstract The end milling process is mainly used to quickly remove large amounts
of material during heavier machining operations. It is most suitable for making slots,
profiles and plunge cutting. The ball nose end milling is used to produce complex
3D sculptured surfaces for making moulds and dies. But, a variation of cutting force
and surface roughness in both end milling processes is not well understood due
to the constant change in cutting tool–workpiece engagement during these milling
processes.
Aluminium alloy–SiC particle-reinforced metal matrix composites (MMCs) are
used in many industries in different shapes through different machining processes.
Therefore, the present study focuses on the comparative performance study of ball
end and flat end milling on A356/SiC MMC.
Composite was prepared from A356 alloy powders (avg. size-50 µm) and SiC
powders (avg. size-1 µm). MMC with 90 vol.% A356 alloy powder and 10
vol.% SiC powders were synthesized using vacuum hot pressing (VHP) process
at 600 °C temperature with 25 MPa pressure. VHP is mainly used to achieve high
densification with uniform distribution of reinforcement.
Both ball and flat end mill machining experiments were conducted as per Taguchi
L9 array. Experiments were carried out by varying cutting speed (100, 150 and
200 m/min), feed (0.1, 0.2 and 0.3 mm/rev) and depth of cut (0.4, 0.7 and 1 mm)
for both machining processes. From the experimental results, it is observed that
the flat end mill gave more material removal rate (MRR) in cm3 /min with low
surface roughness (Ra) value than ball nose milling.
Keywords A356/SiCp MMC · Vacuum hot pressing technique · Flat end milling ·
Ball nose end milling · Material removal rate · Surface roughness
K. Jayakumar (B)
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Sri Sivasubramaniya Nadar College of Engineering,
Kalavakkam, Chennai 603110, India
e-mail: kjayakumar@ssn.edu.in
1 Introduction
Metal matrix composites (MMCs) are materials which combine metallic matrix
and hard ceramic reinforcement to manufacture composite materials with supe-
rior properties to conventional metallic alloys. Among modern composite materi-
als, particulate-reinforced metal matrix composites (PMMCs) are finding increased
applications due to their favourable properties, including high mechanical properties
and good wear and corrosion resistance. Silicon carbide particle (SiC)-reinforced
aluminium-based MMCs are among the most common MMCs and commercially
available due to their economic production. Increasing quantities of metal–matrix
composites are being used to substitute conventional materials in many applica-
tions, particularly in the automobile, aerospace, electronics, armour and recreational
industries, owing to increasing performance requirements [8]. In the modern manu-
facturing process, the objective is to produce low-cost, high-quality products in tiny
time. Automated and flexible manufacturing systems are working for that purpose
along with CNC machines that are capable of achieving high accuracy with low
processing time. End milling is the second most common process (after turning)
for metal cutting and especially for the finishing of machined flat parts, in many
applications. Also, ball nose end milling is widely used for generating 3D sculptured
surfaces for making moulds and dies.
Although SiC particle-reinforced aluminium matrix composites are regarded as
one of the new engineering materials that have many applications, the abrasive parti-
cles reinforcement used in these materials makes them difficult to machine especially
if the reinforcement is more than 10 vol. % of base matrix and also brittleness started
increasing. If there is no solution to the machining problem, it is most likely that such
composites would not find wide application. Many works have been carried about
the machining of this material with turning, drilling, grinding and electric discharge
grinding, etc. Kuram et al. [1] studied the effect of spindle speed, feed and depth of cut
on tool wear, cutting force and surface roughness during microball nose end milling
of Al 7075 material. They found the optimum process parameter for achieving higher
machinability of the selected alloy. End milling study was carried out on Al 2124
alloy with 20% B4 C MMC to analyse the effect of machining parameter on surface
roughness [2]. Conclusions were medium cutting speed, high feed and low depth
of cut are suitable for machining the composite with low surface roughness value.
Al 2014-T6 alloy was machined using high-speed ball nose end milling process by
Dikshit et al. [3]. They identified surface roughness value which was influenced by
cutting speed and axial depth of cut then the radial depth of cut and feed. Jayakumar
[4] did an experimental investigation on ball nose end milling study on A356-based
MMC and identified the best machining parameter for getting low cutting force and
surface roughness value. Liu et al. [5] investigated microslot milling of 45% SiCp/Al
composite using a single-edge PCD end mill of ∅ 1 mm. They got optimum condition
to get minimum Ra of 0.4 µm.
Optimization of parameters in the end milling of Al Al5059/SiC/MoS2 aluminium
hybrid metal matrix composites was carried out by Daniel et al. [6]. Major findings
Comparative Study of Ball Nose and Flat … 489
from the study increased in particle size of the composites tend to decrease in surface
roughness, temperature, cutting forces and increased the MRR. Recently, ball nose
end milling on Inconel 718 was conducted to study the effect of radial and axial depth
of cut, feed and cutting speed on surface finish using minimum quantity lubrication
[7]. It was identified that feed effects on the quality of surface finish whilst the radial
depth of cut controls Ra variation.
From the available literature, it was found that ball nose end milling studies of
A356 Al-based MMCs are in the initial stage and it needs further detailed analysis.
Hence, the present study focuses on ball nose end milling of A356 alloy with 10
vol.% SiC MMC and its comparison with flat end milling machining process using
the same process parameter. The output performance measures considered for both
processes are surface roughness and MRR.
2 Experimental Details
A356 alloy powder (average size of 50 µm) and SiC particles (average size of 1 µm)
of 10 vol. % were used as raw materials for processing of MMC. The major challenge
in synthesizing the particulate MMCs is uniform mixing of finer reinforcement in the
matrix. Vacuum hot pressing (VHP) shared with powder metallurgy (P/M) process
was used in the present study to consolidate and process the composite with good
densification (relative density—nearly 95%) and more isotropic in nature. Hence,
the P/M process was used rather than stir casting of this alloy. The vacuum hot press
used in this work is available at VSSC, Trivandrum, Kerala.
In sintering or VHP, at first, mixed powders were cold compacted at a pressure
of 15 MPa. Then, the hot compaction was carried out at 600 °C temperature with
25 MPa pressure in a vacuum (10−5 mbar) to avoid oxidation of A356 alloy. The load
and temperature were maintained to a dwell time of 30 min for effective densification
of the powder compacts. The above-mentioned pressure and temperature were taken
from the literature [4]. The hot pressed blank is shown in Fig. 1 which has nearly
125 mm in diameter and 20 mm thickness. Figure 2 shows the microstructure images
of the composite taken from scanning electron microscope (SEM) at 1000 × . From
the image, it was observed that the SiC particles are fairly well distributed on the
matrix.
Fig. 2 Microstructure of
MMC with 10% SiC
the composite material were carried in dry condition. HSS ball nose cutter of Ø
16 mm with two uncoated carbide inserts (R 390-11 T3 04E-NL H13A) and HSS
end mill cutter of Ø 16 mm with two uncoated cemented carbide inserts (WIDIA
XDHT 09 03 08) were used in this experimentation. The factors contributing to
surface roughness and MRR during end milling of MMCs are work material (vol. %
of reinforcement, particle size, type of ceramic particle and the base alloy chemical
composition, etc.), machining parameters (up and down milling, cutting speed, feed
and depth of cut), tool material and geometry, etc. Among these, cutting speed (100,
150, 200 m/min), feed (0.1, 0.2, 0.3 mm/rev) and axial depth of cut (0.4, 0.7, 1 mm)
were considered as the process parameter for the present work.
Comparative Study of Ball Nose and Flat … 491
Fig. 3 a Ball nose end milling b machined workpiece after ball nose milling c machined workpiece
after flat end milling
A good experimental design can decrease the number of experiments at the same
time the error of the model does not change intensely. In the present work, Taguchi’s
L9 orthogonal array was used for three-level experiments with nine different condi-
tions for flat end milling and ball nose end milling process for designing the exper-
iments and is given in Table 1. During the experiments, inserts were indexed and
changed at the end of five experiments to reduce the wear in the inserts. Slots were
made for 16 mm width during both milling processes for each experiment.
The roughness (Ra) of the machined samples was measured using roughness tester
(Model: Form Talysurf 50 Infra). Measurements were taken using the cut-off length
(λc ) of 0.8 mm and no. of samples of 5 using stylus with diamond tip of Ø 2 µm and
an average of 3 readings taken at different locations in each slot was reported.
The weight of the workpieces before and after the experiments has been measured
using a digital weighing balance (accuracy 1 mg). From the weight loss, actual density
and machining time, MRR was calculated.
492 K. Jayakumar
Material removal rate (MRR) is crucial in manufacturing industries for higher pro-
duction and it can be attained by selecting proper machining parameters like cutting
speed, feed and depth of cut. From Fig. 4, it was found that the MRR is increased
with an increase in cutting speed, feed and depth of cut for both ball nose end milling
and flat end milling processes. Increase in cutting speed caused the material to be
soft due to the increase in temperature at the shear zone which reduced the strength
of the composite workpiece that caused the effortless removal of chips. Increase in
feed and depth of cut (DOC) increased the normal pressure, size of chip cut per tooth
and chip load which improved the MRR. MRR is low for ball nose milling than flat
end milling. The reason is that more compressive force is given to workpiece during
ball nose end milling than flat end milling due to inadequate space available for the
chip flow.
From Fig. 5a, it was found that surface roughness increased initially and then later
it decreased for both milling processes. The reason is the development of built-up
edge (BUE) whilst machining Al-based MMCs at lower cutting speed. BUE is break
off when it becomes large at medium cutting speed. When this happens, broken
Comparative Study of Ball Nose and Flat … 493
10 (a) 10
(b)
MRR (cm3/min)
MRR (cm3/min)
5 5
0 0
100 150 200 0.1 0.2 0.3
Cutting speed (m/min) feed (mm/rev)
Ball nose Flat end mill Ball nose Flat end mill
10
(c)
MRR (cm3/min)
0
0.4 0.7 1
depth of cut (mm)
Ball nose Flat end mill
Fig. 4 a Cutting speed versus MRR (cm3 /min) b Feed versus MRR (cm3 /min) c Depth of cut
versus MRR (cm3 /min)
BUE may pass off the underside of the chip and it randomly scratches the already
machined surface and causes saw-toothed surface which finally makes the work
surface as rough. As the cutting speed increases, the BUE vanishes, chip fracture
decreases, thus the surface finish is improved. From Fig. 5b, the surface roughness of
the composite is increased with a rise in feed for both milling cutters. The explanation
is that, the feed rate has increased the distance between the two successive tool paths,
which leads to increase in Ra value. As the depth of cut increased, the cutting process
vibrations increases [8] and the development of high normal pressure on the rake
faces of the tool resulted in the formation of BUE that worsened the surface finish
(Fig. 5c). Surface roughness value was low for flat end mill cutting process than
ball nose end milling process. Compared with the flat end mill profile, the surface
produced by ball end mill is complex and a new cut is overlapped which generated a
new surface roughness by removing the earlier cut thus the non-uniform feed marks
being formed on the machined surface which increased surface roughness value.
Using design expert software’s optimization option, cutting speed of 186 m/min,
feed 0.29 mm/rev and 0.9 mm depth of cut were recommended as an optimum
condition for ball nose end milling process to get high MRR and low surface value.
Similarly, cutting speed of 200 m/min, feed 0.3 mm/rev and 0.83 mm depth of cut
was recommended as an optimum condition for flat end milling process.
494 K. Jayakumar
(a) (b) 2
2.5
2 1.5
1.5
1
1
0.5 0.5
0
0
100
150 0.1
200 0.2
0.3
Cutting speed (m/min) feed (mm/rev)
Ball nose Flat end mill Ball nose Flat end mill
(c)
2
Surface roughness (μm)
1.5
0.5
0
0.4
0.7
1
depth of cut (mm)
Ball nose Flat end mill
Fig. 5 a Cutting speed versus surface roughness (µm) b Feed versus surface roughness (µm)
c Depth of cut versus surface roughness (µm)
4 Conclusions
In the present work, fairly homogeneous MMC of A356-10% SiC powders was
synthesized using vacuum hot pressing technique.
The effects of cutting speed, feed and depth of cut on MRR and surface roughness
during flat end milling and ball nose milling of Al-based MMC were investigated
using Taguchi’s L9 experimental design method.
Flat end milling process gave better responses than ball nose mill in terms of high
MRR with low surface roughness value.
The optimum machining parameter was found to improve the machinability of
the MMC for both milling processes.
Comparative Study of Ball Nose and Flat … 495
References
1. Kuram E, Ozcelik B (2013) Multi-objective optimization using Taguchi based grey relational
analysis for micro-milling of Al7075 material with ball nose end mill. Measurement 46(6):1849–
1864
2. Boswell B, Islam MN, Davies IJ, Pramanik A (2017) Effect of machining parameters on the
surface finish of a metal matrix composite under dry cutting conditions. Proc Inst Mech Eng
Part B: J Eng Manuf 231(6):913–923
3. Dikshit MK, Puri AB, Maity A (2017) Optimization of surface roughness in ball-end milling
using teaching-learning-based optimization and response surface methodology. Proc Inst Mech
Eng Part B: J Eng Manuf 231(14):2596–2607
4. Jayakumar K (2018) Study of cutting force and surface roughness in Ball nose end milling of
vacuum hot pressed A356 alloy/SiCp metal matrix composite. Mater Today: Proc 5(2):6526–
6533
5. Liu J, Cheng K, Ding H, Chen S, Zhao L (2018) An investigation of the influence of phases’
removal ways on surface quality in micro milling SiCp/Al composites. Proc CIRP 71:59–64
6. Ajith Arul Daniel S, Pugazhenthi R, Kumar R, Vijayananth S (2019) Multi objective predic-
tion and optimization of control parameters in the milling of aluminium hybrid metal matrix
composites using ANN and Taguchi-grey relational analysis. In: Defence technology
7. Kasima MS, Hafiza MSA, Ghanib JA, Haronb CHC, Izamshah R, Sundic SA, Mohamed SB,
Othman IS (2019) Investigation of surface topology in ball nose end milling process of Inconel
718. Wear 426:1318–1326
8. Niu Z, Cheng K (2019) An experimental investigation on surface generation in ultraprecision
machining of particle reinforced metal matrix composites. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 103:1–9
Numerical Modeling of Orthogonal
Machining Process Using Smoothed
Particle Hydrodynamics—A Parametric
Study
1 Introduction
Numerical modeling normally gives close to accurate results for problems including
nonlinear ones which analytical methods find difficult to handle. They are neither
costly nor time-consuming as compared to experimental analysis. Machining is a
controlled material removal process in which a raw material is converted into desired
shape and size. Orthogonal machining is a machining process in which the cutting
edge of the tool is perpendicular to the direction of motion of the cutting tool. AISI
1045 steel used in this study is a medium carbon steel that has good machinability,
good weldability, and high strength and impact properties both for hot rolled and
normalized conditions. It is widely used in gears, shafts, connecting rods, crankshafts,
hydraulic clamps, etc.
Orthogonal machining uses a wedge-shaped tool in which the cutting edge is
perpendicular to the cutting direction. The chip is formed from the shear deforma-
tion along the shear plane. The important tool geometry angles are rake angle and
clearance angle. The direction of chip flow is determined by the rake angle, whereas
clearance between tool and workpiece is endowed by the clearance angle. This paper
presents numerical modeling of orthogonal machining using SPH. Numerical mod-
eling has many advantages over experimental and analytical methods. Numerical
methods can give close to accurate results for problems even when analytical methods
fail to solve the problem. It is cheaper compared to experimental analysis.
Smoothed particle hydrodynamics, abbreviated as SPH, is one among the most
popular particle methods available. The SPH particles move in space following the
conservation laws of continuum fluid dynamics. It has been proved stable to solve
engineering problems. Hence, commercial FE packages like Abaqus/Explicit and LS-
Dyna incorporated this method in their codes. In this research work, Abaqus/Explicit
package is used for modeling.
In the literature, there are many researchers who have done research in the field
of numerical modeling, orthogonal machining, smoothed particle hydrodynamics
(SPH) and combination of these fields. Given below are details of some of the previous
research work related to the machining area.
Niu et al. [1] introduced an improved SPH method and used it for modeling
orthogonal cutting and predicted the cutting force and chip morphology under dif-
ferent cutting conditions. This modification is achieved by approximating density
and kernel gradient. Olleak and El-Hofy [2] used SPH method in the modeling
of high-speed machining. The paper also predicted the chip morphology and cut-
ting forces during high-speed orthogonal machining of Ti6Al4V. Ramesh et al. [3]
predicted the deformation and machining characteristics for high-speed orthogonal
machining of Ti6Al4V using a detailed FE model. The influence of feed rate, spindle
speed, and rake angle on output parameters such as cutting force and surface finish
are studied. The paper also tackled the issue of self-contact using a unique model.
Avachat and Cherukuri [4] studied the SPH control parameters in detail in modeling
orthogonal machining. The paper evaluated the effects of various parameters like
smoothing length, type of SPH formulation, and particle density. The influence of
the above-mentioned parameters on stress distribution as well as chip morphology
of orthogonal machining of AISI 1045 steel is also studied. Bagci et al. [5] presented
the simulation and analysis of 3D machining using SPH. AISI H13 Steel was used in
the model. The model accurately predicted the cutting forces. M.B. Liu and G.R. Liu
[6] were the people who wrote the first book on SPH. In the year 2010, the authors
Numerical Modeling of Orthogonal Machining … 499
published a paper discussing the SPH method and its latest development. This paper
gives a very good background on SPH.
Kershah et al. [7] estimated cutting coefficients of AISI 1045 steel using finite ele-
ment modeling. The paper also contains a parametric study which correlates cutting
parameters to cutting coefficients. Madaja and Píškaa [8] presented a comparison of
SPH results with experimental results and FE model result for orthogonal cutting
simulation of Al 2024-T351. The study found that as particle spacing reduces, the
particles tend to form segmented chips. Sumesh and Ramesh [9] studied the effect of
process parameters like depth of cut, cutting speed, and feed rate on surface integrity
of turned Al 6061–T6 alloys using RSM. Zetterberg [10] discussed the important
parameters and different possibilities to form a chip in metal cutting simulation in
Abaqus/Explicit. It emphasizes on how the flank wear and hardening implemented in
the material model affects the formation of the chip. Villumsen et al. [11] predicted
the cutting forces of orthogonal machining using the SPH method and compared with
the existing literature to validate the model. The authors also carried out a sensitivity
analysis of machining parameters. Haddag et al. [12] analyzed the effect of orthog-
onal machining parameters on chip segmentation of Al2024-T351 alloy. The paper
also considered the effect of feed and rake angle on chip morphology and cutting
force.
Barge et al. [13] developed a numerical model and studied the physical and pro-
cess parameters dependence using finite element modeling. The paper discusses the
numerical modeling of orthogonal machining. Zhang et al. [14] used digital image
correlation technique to obtain the deformation field containing elastic as well as
plastic parts. A new methodology has been proposed to obtain the cutting stress
field. Limido et al. [15] evaluated SPH method for high-speed cutting modeling. The
developed approach in the paper is used for finding the cutting forces in ball end
milling. The paper used both a 2D model and a 3D model using the software LS-
Dyna. Chen et al. [16] developed FE model for high-speed machining of Ti6Al4V
alloy. Cleary et al. [17] used SPH for modeling thin-walled high-pressure die casting
using SPH. The paper compared the results with the experimental data and found that
the results were accurate. The study also performed flow analysis using the validated
model. Hu et al. [18] used SPH for modeling high-pressure die casting. The paper
compared SPH results with the finite element method and found that they are com-
parable and thus validated the model. The paper showed that the method is able to
capture the fine details of the free surface motion, including plume shape, frequency,
and phase of oscillation.
The above-mentioned research works have helped extensively in the presented
research. In this paper, the influence of the important factors such as type of SPH
formulation, particle density, smoothing length, mass scaling, and artificial bulk
viscosity has been studied. The challenges involved in accurately modeling this
highly nonlinear problem is handled using the Abaqus/Explicit integration scheme
along with the Johnson–Cook material model.
500 S. B. T. Surendran et al.
2.1 History
where
< > —the approximation
w(y − y ,h)—the kernel function
h—the smoothing length
y —the particle within the smoothing length
As h tends to zero, the kernel function becomes the Dirac delta function,
i.e., limh→0 w(y − y , h) = δ(y − y , h)
Thus, limh→0 <f (y) > = f (y)
So, for N discretized points, the function approximation becomes:
N
mj
< f (y ) >=
i
f (y j )w(y i − y j , h) (3)
j=1
j
where
mj
j
—Volume of the particle j with mass m j
where
y − y
r=
h
D = the number of spatial dimensions and C = scale factor
C = 2/3 for D = 1,
C = 10/7π for D = 2,
C = 1/π for D = 3.
The numerical model uses a tungsten carbide rigid tool. It has a rake angle of 8°
and a clearance angle of 10°. The workpiece material used is AISI 1045 steel with
dimensions 3.6 mm × 0.3 mm. The out-of-plane thickness is 0.04 mm. The material
properties of workpiece are displayed in Table 1. Equation of state is used along with
the material properties with US-UP formulation. The remaining parameters used in
the model are as follows [4]:
(a) Speed of sound in the workpiece
(b) c = 6.35 × 106 mm/s
502
ε
T − Tr
σ = A + Bεn 1 + C ln 1− (5)
ε0 Tm − Tr
where
εn —equivalent plastic strain
Following numerical controls were used for SPH modeling of the machining pro-
cess. The influence of each parameter on the optimal modeling of the problem is
investigated.
504 S. B. T. Surendran et al.
Mass scaling is a numerical technique that is used to increase the time step by scaling
up the density in specific elements. Initially, a mass scaling factor of 10,000 was used
in the study. Initial results indicated the absence of any material removal, although
the tool had contact with the workpiece (see Fig. 1). Hence, a reduced mass scaling
factor of 100 was used and was found to initiate the material removal. However,
the computational time increased to a significantly large value. Therefore, no mass
scaling was used in this study for better results. It has been understood that an
increased mass scaling can lead to high inertial effects that can corrupt the results.
In this work, initially, only the bottom and left faces of the workpiece were encastered.
However, the results indicated that boundary conditions were not transferred to the
SPH particles. Figure 2 shows the end results of the above-mentioned condition. This
problem was resolved by using smoothed particle hydrodynamics instead of finite
element conversion to SPH particles [21]. In the SPH analyses, a node set had to be
Fig. 2 Encastered
workpiece moving along
with the tool
Numerical Modeling of Orthogonal Machining … 505
created and inertia mass had to be assigned to the nodes to create mass elements in
the .inp file. Later, these mass elements had to be replaced with continuum particle
elements (PC3D).
Another major problem that was encountered was the inability to use general contact
algorithm. The reason being due to the extensive nodal penetration of tool nodes
to the workpiece surface. This was tackled by using the traditional master–slave,
surface-to-surface contact algorithm.
The initial simulation results indicated the movement of SPH particles in the Z-
direction instead of flowing over the tool rake (see Fig. 3). This issue was resolved by
assigning encaster boundary conditions to the bottom most and left most nodes, and
a displacement/rotation boundary condition to the rest of the nodes of the workpiece
where the displacement along the Z-direction and rotations about Y and X axes were
constrained.
Smoothing length is the radius of the sphere of influence within which any parti-
cle may affect the neighboring particle. Initially a value of 0.005 was assumed for
smoothing length based on the calculation of half of the characteristic length [4].
This, however, leads to non-physical results (see Fig. 4). Then, a higher value of
0.02 was assumed which resulted in the termination of the simulation with an error.
506 S. B. T. Surendran et al.
The error indicated that the smoothing length was too large as the number of parti-
cles exceeded the maximum specified. Between these two extreme values, a suitable
trade-off value was reached as 0.01, which was used as a constant smoothing length.
Figure 5 shows the results of constant smoothing length that lead to breaking up of
workpiece or flow of chips over the tool. This issue was resolved by using a variable
smoothing length option in the .inp file. Maximum number of particles within the
smoothing length was maintained at a default value of 140, since the computational
memory required to run the simulation was too high even for a slight increase from
the default value.
Influence of Artificial Bulk Viscosity and SPH formulation
The von Mises stress contour plot was found to be uniformly distributed for Q1
= 0.5 than the default value of Q1 = 0.06. Another important parameter was the
type of SPH formulation. The default SPH formulation was found to be inadequate
and inconsistent for modeling the process, and it leads to non-physical results (See
Fig. 6). Thus, NSPH and XSPH were used simultaneously instead of default SPH
formulation.
5 Validation
Although the numerical model was developed, the initial results were not found to
match with the literature since the simulation had many issues which are mentioned
in the previous section. After making necessary modifications based on the trial-and-
error simulations, the model was finally developed successfully. This work was able
Numerical Modeling of Orthogonal Machining … 507
to reproduce the results obtained from the literature, Chinmay et al. [4] and Kershah
et al. [7]. The average stress in the shear zone was found to be matching with the
literature. The von Mises stress contours of the validated model are shown in Fig. 7.
6 Conclusions
This paper discusses the development of a numerical model for simulating orthogonal
turning of AISI 1045 steel using SPH method. The FE package Abaqus/Explicit was
used. The results obtained are found to be in good agreement with the results found
in the literature.
By varying SPH control parameters and boundary conditions, parametric studies
were performed. All the simulations were conducted by modifying the .inp file,
except for FE conversion to SPH results.
508 S. B. T. Surendran et al.
Influence of mass scaling factor was studied and as expected computational time
decreased with increasing the factor. However, for better modeling of orthogonal
machining, it was found that mass scaling need not be used as it changes the whole
dynamics.
Initially, the encaster boundary conditions given to the workpiece were not trans-
ferred during the conversion of elements to SPH particles. This issue was solved
using the direct SPH method instead of FE conversion to SPH method.
The significance of using variable smoothing length was also investigated. When
low smoothing length was used, the particles were found to fly out of the domain,
since there were a less number of particles in the sphere of influence. On the other
hand, the maximum number of particles in the sphere of influence was maintained
at a default value of 140. Even a slight increase from the default value was found to
increase the computational memory required to run the simulation.
It was found that when the correct SPH parameters were used, the computational
results obtained were in good agreement with the results from conventional FEM.
It was also found that SPH can naturally handle self-contact, mesh distortion, and
material separation. However, the SPH method has some limitations. The values of
some SPH parameters used in the model are obtained by trial-and-error methods.
Also, computational time was found to increase significantly due to particle sorting
and neighbor search.
References
1. Niu W, Mo R, Liu GR, Sun H, Dong X, Wang G (2017) Modeling of orthogonal cutting process
of A2024-T351 with an improved Sph method. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 95:905–919
2. Olleak AA, El-Hofy HA (2015) Prediction of cutting forces in high speed machining of
Ti6Al4 V using Sph method. In: Proceedings of the ASME 2015 International Manufacturing
Science And Engineering Conference MSEC 2015 June 812, 2015, Charlotte, North Carolina,
USA
3. Ramesh A, Sumesh CS, Abhilash PM, Rakesh S (2015) Finite element modelling of orthogonal
machining of hard to machine materials. Int J Mach Machinability Mater 17(6):543–568
4. Avachat CS, Cherukuri HP (2015) A parametric study of the modeling of orthogonal machining
using the smoothed particle hydrodynamics method. In: Proceedings of the ASME 2015 Inter-
national Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition IMECE 2015, 13–19 Nov 2015,
Houston, Texas
5. Bagci E (2011) 3-D Numerical analysis of orthogonal cutting process via Meshfree method.
Int J Phys Sci 6(6):1267–1282
6. Liu MB, Liu GR (2010) Smoothed particle hydrodynamics (Sph): an overview and recent
developments. Arch Comput Methods Eng 17:25–76
7. Kershah T (2000) Prediction of cutting coefficients during orthogonal metal cutting process
using FEA approach
8. Madaja M, Píškaa M (2013) On the Sph orthogonal cutting simulation of A2024-T351 alloy.
In: 14th CIRP Conference on Modeling of Machining Operations, Procedia Cirp, vol 8, pp
152–157
9. Sumesh CS, Ramesh A (2018) Numerical modelling and optimization of dry orthogonal turning
of Al 6061 T6 alloy. Periodica Polytechnica Mech Eng 62(3):196–202
Numerical Modeling of Orthogonal Machining … 509
10. Zetterberg M (2014) A critical overview of machining simulations in Abaqus. Degree Project.
In: Solid mechanics, Second Level Stockholm, Sweden
11. Villumsen MF, Fauerholdt TG (2008) Simulation of metal cutting using smooth particle
hydrodynamics. Ls-Dyna Anwenderforum, Bamberg
12. Haddag B, Atlati S, Nouari M, Barlier C, Zenasni M (2012) Analysis of the cutting parameters
influence during machining Aluminium alloy A2024-T351 with uncoated carbide inserts. Eng
Trans 60(1):31–39
13. Barge M, Rech J, Hamdi H, Bergheau J-M (2005) Numerical modelling of orthogonal
cutting numerical, physical and process parameters dependence. In: Proceedings of the
2nd International Conference on Manufacturing Engineering (ICMEN), 5–7 Oct 2005,
Kallithea-Chalkidiki, Greece
14. Zhang D, Zhang X-M, Xu W-J, Ding H (2016) Stress field analysis in orthogonal cutting process
using digital image correlation technique. J Manuf Sci Eng 139:031001-1 (March 2017)
15. Limido J, Espinosa C, Salaun M, Mabru C, Chieragatti R, Lacome JL (2011) Metal cutting
modelling Sph approach. Int J Mach Machinability Mater 9(¾)
16. Chen G, Ren C, Yang X, Jin X, Guo T (2011) Finite element simulation of high-speed machin-
ing of Titanium alloy (Ti-6Al-4V) based on ductile failure model. Int J Adv Manuf Technol
56:1027–1038
17. Cleary PW, Savage G, Ha J, Prakash M (2014) Flow analysis and validation of numerical
modelling for a thin walled high pressure die casting using Sph. Comp Part Mech. https://doi.
org/10.1007/s40962-017-0144-9
18. Hu MY, Cai JJ, Li N, Yu HL, Zhang Y, Sun B, Sun WL (2017) Flow modeling in high-pressure
die casting processes using Sph model. Am Foundry Soc. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40962-017-
0144-9
19. Liu GR, Liu MB (2003) Smoothed particle hydrodynamics: a Meshfree particle method. World
Scientic, Singapore
20. Dassault Systmes Simulia Corporation. ABAQUS Analysis user’s guide (2013)
21. Dassault Systmes Simulia Corporation. ABAQUS Analysis user’s guide (2016), Section 15.2.2
Acoustic Emission-Based Grinding
Wheel Sharpness Monitoring Using
Machine Learning Classifier
1 Introduction
Grinding is an abrasive machining process carried out using grinding wheel. The
grinding wheel is embedded with randomly distributed abrasive particles like alu-
minium oxide, silicon carbide, diamond or cubic boron nitride. Abrasive particles of
different grit sizes are used in the machining process based on metal removal rate
and surface quality requirements. The grinding process starts with sharp abrasive
particles, and the abrasive particles will become dull and lose its cutting ability due
to wear. This phenomenon is called as the glazed condition of the grinding wheel.
The wear is attributed due to attritious wear or progressive wear [1]. Also, during
grinding of soft materials, workpiece chip will clog into the grinding wheel and
deteriorates the cutting ability of the abrasive wheel and called as clogging of the
grinding wheel. Once the grinding wheel becomes glazed or clogged, it is necessary
to subject the grinding wheel for dressing operation. The dressing is a grinding wheel
conditioning operation, which will expose the abrasive grits and make the grinding
wheel free from glazing and clogging. Truing operation is performed for new grind-
ing wheels especially for a precision grinding process for ensuring concentricity of
grinding wheel with the work surface. Dressing and truing operations are integrated
as a single process for the conventional grinding wheels.
The sharpness of the abrasive particles in a grinding wheel plays a prominent role in
determining the capacity of the abrasive wheel to remove the material and achieving
the required finish in the work surface. The sharpness of the wheel face is also directly
related to heat generation and grinding forces developed during grinding. Nakayama
et al. [2] proposed a procedure for evaluating the abrasive wheel sharpness. Alexandre
et al. [3] proposed a test bench for measuring the sharpness of the abrasive wheel to
study the dresser condition. In this study, the methodology proposed in [1, 3] is used
to design and fabricate the sharpness measurement device which is used to establish
the conditions of the grinding wheel.
et al. [9]. ANN models were developed by Moia et al. [10] for monitoring dress-
ing operation using AE signals. Dias et al. [11] identified a range of frequency for
the occurrence of roundness, cylindricity and surface roughness. In a cylindrical
grinding process, Arun et al. [12] predicted grinding wheel conditions in a cylin-
drical grinding process using classifiers such as SVM, decision trees and artificial
neural network (ANN). Off late, decision tree, Naive Bayes, SVM and artificial neu-
ral network models are used to predict the tool conditions in high-speed precision
machining process [13–15]. In a surface grinding process, dresser conditions of alu-
minium oxide (Al2 O3 ) grinding wheel was studied by Alexandre et al. [3] with AE
and fuzzy methods.
In this paper, the grinding wheel sharpness measurement device has been designed
and fabricated. This device is used to identify the conditions of the grinding wheel. A
grinding wear plot was established for the complete grinding cycle starting from sharp
wheel condition to the wornout condition. Grinding experiments were carried out
using an Al2 O3 grinding wheel and a correlation is established between the features
extracted from AE and grinding wheel sharpness condition. A statistical prediction
model is established using feed-forward back-propagation neural network.
the sharpness of the grinding wheel face. A relationship between ‘displacement’ and
‘time’ is established to arrive at the sharpness of the grinding wheel. The sharpness
of the grinding wheel is estimated using Eq. (1).
Abrasive grinding wheel sharpness,
√
2b 8r 2/3
K = a (1)
3F N
where ‘b’ is the width of the disc, ‘r’ is the radius of the disc, ‘FN ’ is the normal force
applied to the disc over the grinding wheel, ‘a’ is the gradient of the characteristic
curve of grinding wheel, i.e. regression line obtained from the plot of ‘displacement’
versus ‘t(2/3) ’. A device used for measuring the grinding wheel sharpness has been
designed and fabricated based on the principle of sharpness measurement as shown
in Fig. 1. The photograph of the device is shown in Fig. 2. The specification of the
device is as shown in Table 1. The grinding wheel grade used in this study is ‘AA60-
K5-V8’. The details of the grinding wheel are shown in Table 2. The sharpness
measurement device is fixed over the surface grinding machine table using a fixture.
Grinding tests were conducted in a surface grinding machine by fixing the sharp-
ness measurement device over the grinding table. The grinding wheel sharpness is
evaluated for all the states of the abrasive wheel using the sharpness measurement
device fabricated in this study. The grinding wheel sharpness is quantified for sharp
and dull-wornout conditions separately. Time–displacement plots are drawn, and the
gradient of the regression lines are computed. Time–displacement plots are shown
in Figs. 3 and 4. Figure 3 shows the regression plot of the sharp condition, and Fig. 4
shows the dull-wornout condition. Sharpness parameters of grinding wheel of three
different conditions are shown in Table 3.
Grinding experiments were repeated to validate the sharpness of the grinding
wheel. From the results, it is observed that the sharpness is lower in the dull or
wornout condition due to clogging or natural wear of the abrasive particles in the
grinding wheel. Lower sharpness value indicates that the grinding wheel has to be
dressed for improving its cutting ability. Sharpness values of the grinding wheel are
indicated in Table 3 for sharp and dull conditions of the grinding wheel.
Grinding wheel wear plot is drawn as a function of metal removal rates of the grind-
ing wheel and work material. Experiments were conducted starting with a dressed
grinding wheel with sharp abrasive edges. Experiments were continued until the
wheel became a dull and glazed condition. During the grinding process at differ-
ent intervals of time, the metal removal rates in workpiece and grinding wheels are
recorded and grinding wheel wear plot is established and shown in Fig. 5. Three
The main objective of AE monitoring of the grinding process is to predict the grinding
wheel condition based on the sharpness parameter using the features extracted from
the AE signature. The experimental set-up used in this study is shown in Fig. 6. The
experimental set-up for AE measurement consists of (a) surface grinding machine,
(b) AE sensor, (c) AE sensor attachment, (d) AE sensor data acquisition system, (e)
AE win software, (d) machine learning classifier and (e) signal processing hardware.
AE sensor used in this study is supplied by M/s Physical Acoustic Corporation,
USA. Micro 30 D sensor used in this study is capable of capturing AE signature in
the frequency range 100–350 kHz. An AE attachment is used to hold the AE sen-
sor to capture the acoustic emissions from the grinding wheel. AE sensor output is
connected to a pre-amplifier and to the data acquisition system. The signal is con-
verted into digital form and stored in the computer memory for further processing.
AE features are extracted using AE-Win software supplied by M/s Mitras Corpora-
tion, USA. After extracting the features, those having wealthy information about the
grinding wheel conditions are selected. The selected features are used for developing
a statistical model using artificial neural network (ANN) classifier for predicting the
grinding wheel condition.
Grinding experiments were carried out from the sharp-initial condition to the dull-
wornout condition. AE signatures were acquired for the complete grinding cycle. AE
signals were captured at a sampling rate of 1 MSPS with a threshold of 40 dB. AE fea-
tures, viz. Count, RMS, amplitude, rise time, energy and duration are extracted from
the raw signal. The features having useful information about the grinding wheel con-
ditions are selected by plotting the feature value versus grinding time. It is observed
that the AE features RMS and Count have a strong correlation with the grinding wheel
conditions as shown in Fig. 7. RMS and Count feature data are used to train the feed-
forward back-propagation neural network classifier for predicting the grinding wheel
condition using a sharpness parameter.
Neural networks or multi-layer perceptrons have the ability to extract useful infor-
mation from the AE sensor feature data and have the capability to extract patterns and
detect the conditions of the grinding wheel. RMS and Count data extracted from the
AE signature are provided as an input to neural network with the known condition
of the surface grinding wheel. Training of the neural network is carried out using
back-propagation algorithms. After training, the neural network model is tested with
AE signal feature data for which the condition of the grinding wheel is not known.
Training and testing procedure of neural network classifiers is shown in Fig. 8.
Multi-layer perceptron used in this study consists of three layers namely (a) input
layer, (b) hidden layer and (c) output layer. A supervised learning technique, back-
propagation algorithm, is used for training the network. Input layer consisting of
neurons is based on the input data. In this case, 1363 AE data (RMS and Count) are
used for training and testing the network. Among 1363 AE data, 320 are belonging
to the sharp-initial state of the abrasive wheel. 636 samples are belonging to the
sharp-intermediate state of the abrasive wheel. The balance 407 samples belong
to the dull-wornout state of the abrasive wheel. The samples were extracted by
conducting the experiment in appropriate grinding wheel conditions established in
this study. Experiments were conducted to optimize the number of hidden layers. It
is found that the no. of hidden layers as ‘3’ that yields good results. The sigmoidal
transfer function is used. Learning rate and momentum are taken to be 0.3 and 0.2,
respectively. A ‘10’ fold cross-validation is used for training and testing of the neural
network classifiers. In a ‘10’-fold cross-validation process, the data sets are divided
into ‘10’ groups and perform the training on nine groups and validate the results using
the remaining group. To reduce the variability, 10 times of validation experiments
are performed using different groups of training data leaving out the validation (test)
data. The results are averaged over 10 times of validation. Neural network classifier
is implemented using the Weka platform [16]. Performance of the classifier is studied
using classification accuracy, misclassification rate, Kappa and ROC statistics.
where ‘po ’ is the observed accuracy and ‘pe ’ is the expected accuracy.
AE features RMS and Count were given as an input to ANN classifiers for training.
Training and testing data are acquired from the grinding wheel conditions arrived
using the grinding wheel sharpness data. The confusion matrix obtained after train-
ing and testing the AE features and the ANN classifier performance is shown in
Table 4. The ANN classifier is able to predict the grinding wheel conditions with
an overall accuracy of 90.201%. Among 1363 instances, 1230 instances were clas-
sified correctly according to its conditions. Misclassifications of AE features are
more in the features which were acquired in the boundary regions of ‘sharp-initial’
and ‘sharp-intermediate’. ANN is unable to differentiate the very minute variations
in the sharpness of the abrasive particles in the boundary regions. There are 21
instances of ‘sharp-initial’ misclassified as ‘sharp-intermediate’ and 50 instances of
‘dull-wornout’ are misclassified as ‘sharp-intermediate’ condition.
Kappa statistics value of 0.8468 justifies the good performance of the ANN classi-
fiers. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve statistics provided by the ANN
classifiers also demonstrate the diagnostic ability of the classifier and show that the
ANN is able to distinguish the grinding wheel conditions with good accuracy. ROC
statistics were arrived by using the true positive rate and false positive rates of the
classifier. It is observed that ANN is able to classify the grinding wheel condition
with good accuracy. The time taken for building the ANN model for grinding wheel
6 Conclusions
A grinding wheel sharpness measurement device has been designed and fabricated
in this study. This device will be useful in automated manufacturing environments
for detecting the grinding wheel conditions. AE sensor is used for capturing the
signals of the grinding process and grinding wheel conditions are established using
the grinding wheel wear plot. Time domain AE features such as RMS and Count were
found to have a good association with the abrasive wheel conditions. A statistical
model using ANN is developed for estimating the grinding wheel condition. AE
sensor with ANN-based machine learning classifiers is able to predict the grinding
wheel conditions with an accuracy of 90.2%. Kappa and ROC statistics are also
justifying the effectiveness of ANN classifier in predicting the conditions of the
grinding wheel. Further studies can be taken up to develop an AE-based real-time
grinding wheel condition monitoring system using the data and knowledge generated
in this study.
References
1. Jackson MJ, Davim JP (2011) Machining with abrasives. Springer, New York, pp 4–5
2. Nakayama K, Takagi JI, Irie E, Okuno K (1980) Sharpness evaluation of grinding wheel face
by the grinding of steel ball. CIRP Ann 29(1):227–231
3. Alexandre FA, Lopes WN, Dotto FRL, Ferreira FI, Aguiar PR, Bianchi EC, Lopes JC (2018)
Tool condition monitoring of Aluminum oxide grinding wheel using AE and fuzzy model. Int
J Adv Manuf Technol 96(1–4):67–79
4. Lezanski P (2001) An intelligent system for grinding wheel condition monitoring. J Mater
Process Technol 109(3):258–263
5. Liao TW, Ting CF, Qu J, Blau PJ (2007) A wavelet-based methodology for grinding wheel
condition monitoring. Int J Mach Tools Manuf 47(3):580–592
6. Liao TW (2010) Feature extraction and selection from acoustic emission signals with an
application in grinding wheel condition monitoring. Eng Appl Artif Intell 23(1):74–84
7. Subrahmanya N, Shin YC (2008) Automated sensor selection and fusion for monitoring and
diagnostics of plunge grinding. J Manuf Sci Eng 130(3):031014
8. Yang Z, Yu Z (2012) Grinding wheel wear monitoring based on wavelet analysis and support
vector machine. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 62(1–4):107–121
9. Roth JT, Djurdjanovic D, Yang X, Mears L, Kurfess T (2010) Quality and inspection of
machining operations: tool condition monitoring. J Manuf Sci Eng 132(4):041015
522 J. Revant et al.
10. Moia DFG, Thomazella IH, Aguiar PR, Bianchi EC, Martins CHR, Marchi M (2015) Tool
condition monitoring of aluminum oxide grinding wheel in dressing operation using acoustic
emission and neural networks. J Brazilian Soc Mech Sci Eng 37(2):627–640
11. Dias EA, Pereira FB, Ribeiro Filho SLM, Brandão LC (2016) Monitoring of through-feed
centerless grinding processes with acoustic emission signals. Measurement 94:71–79
12. Arun A, Rameshkumar K, Unnikrishnan D, Sumesh A (2018) Tool condition monitoring of
cylindrical grinding process using acoustic emission sensor. Mater Today: Proc 5(5):11888–
11899
13. Krishnakumar P, Rameshkumar K, Ramachandran KI (2018) Acoustic emission-based tool
condition classification in a precision high-speed machining of titanium alloy: a machine
learning approach. Int J Comput Intell Appl 17(03):1850017
14. Krishnakumar P, Rameshkumar K, Ramachandran KI (2018) Feature level fusion of vibration
and acoustic emission signals in tool condition monitoring using machine learning classifiers.
Int J Progn Health Manag 9:1–15
15. Krishnakumar P, Rameshkumar K, Ramachandran KI (2018) Machine learning based tool
condition monitoring using acoustic and vibration data in high speed milling. Int J Intell Decis
Technol 1:1–18
16. https://www.cs.waikato.ac.nz/~ml/weka/
17. Landis JR, Koch GG (1977) The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data.
Biometrics 159–174
Turning Process Characteristics
of Aluminium Matrix Hybrid Composite
Using Grey Relational Surface
Methodology
1 Introduction
Metal matrix composite (MMC) has been considered as an important class of mate-
rial, as it progressively replaces conventional materials utilized in structural engineer-
ing, aeronautics, mechanical engineering and in many other sectors [1]. MMCs are
considered for engineering applications where high specific strength, stiffness and
lightweight are important. Common matrix metals include aluminium, magnesium,
copper and titanium in its pure or alloy forms. Aluminium metal matrix composites
(AMMCs) are suitable material for aerospace, defence and automotive applications.
Generally, aluminium (6 series) alloys have been considered broadly because of its
merits such as strength, castability, formability, corrosion resistance and low cost
comparing to other aluminium alloys.
Ceramic reinforcements such as silicon carbide (SiC), boron carbide (B4 C) and
titanium carbide (TiC) are common reinforcements in AMMC [2, 3]. Incorporation of
such reinforcements improved the specific properties of the metal matrix phase [4, 5].
In addition, graphite, graphene, carbon nanotube (CNT) and hexagonal boron nitride
(hBN) are commonly used solid lubricants in developing AMMCs. A. Gnanavelbabu
et al. investigated the cutting quality characteristics of AA6061-B4 C-hBN hybrid
composites by abrasive water jet machining and reported favourable results [6]. C.
Muthazhagan et al. found a positive influence of solid lubricant on the mechanical
properties of aluminium-B4 C composites. Also, they found that the addition of B4 C
conversely increased the hardness of the composites [7].
Design of experiment (DOE) plays a vital role in reducing the number, time
and cost of the experiments. Optimizations of process parameters are important for
improving the quality characteristics of the responses. W.H. Yang et al. optimized
the cutting parameters for turning operations for steel using Taguchi’s orthogonal
array, S/N ratio ANOVA [8]. A. J. Makadia et al. investigated the influence of tool
geometry (nose radius) and cutting parameters (cutting speed, feed and depth of cut)
on the surface finish obtained in turning of mild steel by applying Taguchi-response
surface methodology (T-RSM) [9]. R. Adalarasan et al. investigated the quality char-
acteristics of laser cutting parameters using grey-response surface methodology (G-
RSM) and found the optimum level of cutting parameters by applying grey relational
analysis and G-RSM [10]. A. Dey et al. predicted the optimal combination of pro-
cessing parameters by hybrid approach of grey-based response surface methodology
(G-RSM) and found the significant model using grey-based approach [11].
It is observed from the literature that optimization of multiple responses based on
orthogonal array with GRA tends to take advantage of both the Taguchi method and
the GRA. Hence, an approach named GRSM which combines with GRA is presented
to find out the optimal parameter setting. This paper presents a detailed experimental
analysis on the turning process of AA6061-B4 C-hBN hybrid composites by applying
G-RSM for optimizing the machining quality characteristics such as tangential force,
cutting power and tool wear.
Aluminium alloy 6061 is the most commonly used alloy which has a better combina-
tion of mechanical properties and it was chosen as the matrix material.B4 C and hBN
were the reinforcement particulates of size 10–25 µm and 5 µm, respectively. The
composition of the fabricated hybrid composites is shown in Table 1. Aluminium
hybrid composites were fabricated using two-stage stir casting process.
Turning Process Characteristics of Aluminium … 525
The fabricated composites comp A, comp B and comp C were cut into required
dimensions for performing turning operation. Taguchi’s L27 orthogonal array was
used to collect the experimental data and to analyse the characteristics of turning
parameters of AMMC. Turning parameters namely speed, feed, depth of cut and solid
lubricant are chosen for controlling the responses and each parameter is designed
with three levels, denoted by, low, medium and high as shown in Table 2.
CNC turning centre with 360–480 V and 40/60 Hz was used to perform the
experiments. Polycrystalline diamond (PCD) was used as the cutting tool. PCD tools
are preferred instead of polycrystalline cubic boron nitride (PCBN) tools as they
exhibit high fracture resistance and low adhesion property. Also, it improves the
machining productivity and tool life characteristics. Each experiment was carried
out using a new cutting edge every time to obtain accurate response values which
are tangential force, cutting power and tool wear. The values of tangential force (F z )
and tool wear (T w ) are obtained directly from CNC turning machine, and the cutting
power (Pc ) is calculated using Eq. 1.
D ∗ F ∗ S ∗ Kc
Pc = (1)
60 ∗ 103 ∗ η
into a decimal sequence between 0.00 and 1.00 is known as pre-processing raw data.
The pre-processing starts with calculating signal-to-noise ratio (S/N). S/N ratio was
calculated to reduce the variability in the process. The objective of this study is to
minimize the tangential force, cutting power and tool wear for better characteristic
performance. Hence, the S/N ratio was calculated by considering “smaller the bet-
ter” condition for all three responses. The obtained sequence normalized with the
“smaller is better” condition.
Further, GRC was calculated to express the relationship between the best and
actualized S/N ratio. Finally, the average of grey relational coefficients was taken to
get grey relational grade (GRG). Further, response surface methodology (RSM) was
Turning Process Characteristics of Aluminium … 527
applied to optimize and generate ANOVA and regression equations. Surface plots and
contour plots were generated using G-RSM. Statistical analysis of the experimental
data was performed using design expert software.
The coefficient of the regression equation is determined and contour and surface
plots are plotted for the p values lower than the significance level (α) equals to
0.05. The results of response surface regression and analysis of variance for the grey
relational grades are shown in Table 5.
Based on the results from ANOVA, the response surfaced models generated are
significant as shown in Table 6.
Referring to the ANOVA table, the regression model p value showed 0.0001, which
indicated that the model was more significant. Thus, the model is more suitable to
predict the values. The significance of the regression fitted model is determined by
incorporating the coefficient correlation. The obtained R-sq. and R-sq. (adj) for the
model are 94.24 and 88.48, respectively. Thus, the statistical measure of value shows
that the model is fitted closely. Response surface optimizer in design is used to find
the parameters which provide the best results. The goal is to maximize the GRG
528 A. Gnanavelbabu et al.
values so that the response values can be optimized. The optimal parameter settings
are shown in Table 7 at which our objective function can be satisfied.
Figure 1 illustrates the plot of actual versus predicted values of responses and it
is observed that all the points of the experimental runs are spotted randomly inside
the reliable range of residuals.
Surface plots and contour plots for GRGs are given in the Figs. 2 and 3, respec-
tively. The response surface plots are drawn based on the generated regression equa-
tion associating the dependent variable GRGs with the independent variables such
as tangential force, cutting power and tool wear. Increased level of speed and feed
Turning Process Characteristics of Aluminium … 529
improved the GRG values and responses as shown in Fig. 2. It is observed that speed
and feed are directly proportional to the responses, while the volume percentage of
hBN is inversely proportional to the responses. From the surface plot, the maximum
value of GRG is obtained for Comp B with high cutting speed, high feed and medium
depth of cut.
The contour plots (Fig. 3) shows the graph of GRG and process parameters,
where the dark green colour indicates higher the GRG value and light green colour
indicates lower the GRG value. They hold values in the contour plots which are
120 rpm, 0.1 mm/rev, 0.4 mm and 10% for speed, feed and depth of cut and volume
percentage of hBN, respectively. Lower the cutting speed lead to striations and cause
rough surface finish while higher the cutting speed caused thermal damage to the
material. Hence, a moderate level (120 rpm) of cutting speed is desired for turning
operation.
4 Conclusion
The G-RSM optimization tool was applied for the optimization of CNC turning
process parameters on AA6061-B4C-hBN hybrid composites and the following
conclusions were drawn.
1. The derived second-order polynomial equation has shown good correlation
between the predicted and experimental values.
530 A. Gnanavelbabu et al.
2. Experiment no. 26 has the highest GRG value (0.9611) and it is the optimal
process parameters setting to obtain the best multiperformance characteristics.
3. Effect of speed is much more prominent than the effects of feed rate and depth
of cut, on the tangential force, cutting force and tool wear.
532 A. Gnanavelbabu et al.
4. The optimal process parameters from the grey relational analysis for turning pro-
cess were speed—180, feed—0.15, depth of cut—0.3374 and %B4 C—8.6364.
Acknowledgements The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial support from “DST-PURSE
Phase II” for research consumables.
References
1. Nicholas JC, Boswell B, Davies J, Islam MN (2017) Review of machining metal matrix
composites. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 90:2429–2440
2. Rai RN (2006) A study on the machinability behavior of Al-TiC composite prepared by in situ
technique. Mater Sci Eng 428:34–40
3. Torralba JM, Da Costa CE, Velasco F (2003) P/M aluminum matrix composites: an overview.
J Mater Process Technol 133:203–206
4. Chawla N, Chawla KK (2013) Metal matrix composites, 2nd edn. Springer, New York
5. Lin JT, Bhattacharyya D, Ferguson B (1998) Chip formation in the machining of SiC-particle-
reinforced aluminium-matrix composites. Compos Sci Technol 58(2):285–291
6. Gnanavelbabu A, Rajkumar K, Saravanan P (2018) Investigation on the cutting quality char-
acteristics of abrasive water jet machining of AA6061-B4C-Hbn hybrid MMC. Mater Manuf
Process (45):1313–1323
7. Muthazhagan C, Gnanavelbabu A, Bhaskar GB, Rajkumar K (2014) Influence of graphite
reinforcement on mechanical properties of Al-boron carbide composites. Adv Mater Res
495:398–402
8. Makadia AJ, Nanavati JI (2013) Optimization of tool geometry and cutting parameters for
turning operations based on response surface methodology. In: Proceedings of AMPC, Chennai,
pp 6–8
9. Yang WH, Tarng YS (1998) Design optimization of cutting parameters for turning operations
based on the Taguchi method. J Mater Process Technol 84:122–129
Turning Process Characteristics of Aluminium … 533
1 Introduction
Aluminium alloy 8015, among other aluminium alloys, is equally known for its
excellent corrosion resistant property owing to the very thin oxide film layer formed
on the metallic surface. Hot rolled aluminium alloy 8015 is distinctly based on the
fact that it has undergone mechanical hot rolling process achieved with heat. The hot
rolled aluminium alloy 8015 product has the best applications where dimensional
tolerances are not as important as the overall material strength and likewise, surface
finish is not a major concern [1].
Corrosion of aluminium alloys has significant records by various scholars [2–12].
The presence of intermetallic particles in aluminium alloys, usually on the surface,
causes a weak thin oxide film layer [13]. Research shows that these intermetallic
particles act as a cathodic role to the aluminium matrix in corrosive environments
containing chloride ions [14]. These intermetallic alloying element particles have
a varying degree of solid solubility in the aluminium matrix. Polmear et al. [15]
reveal the solid solubility of individual alloying elements in aluminium. Findings
show that zinc, silver, magnesium and copper have high solid solubility compared
to iron, nickel, manganese and silicon, thereby suggesting that intermetallic alloying
elements of the latter are the main causes of localized corrosion in aluminium alloys.
Electrochemical corrosion studies of aluminium alloys in natural seawater have
been reported in the literature [16–18], and all reveal the mode of corrosion by pitting.
Information on electrochemical corrosion of hot rolled aluminium alloy 8015 is yet
to be reported in the literature.
This present work was motivated to investigate the corrosion behaviour of hot
rolled aluminium alloy 8015 in natural seawater at 1.37 µm surface roughness aver-
age. Electrochemical corrosion test using Ivium potentiostat was used to analyse
the open-circuit potential (OCP), polarization measurement and corrosion rate of
the aluminium alloy 8015. The aluminium alloy 8015 specimen samples, before and
after electrochemical corrosion, were analysed with TESCAN VEGA scanning elec-
tron microscope having energy dispersive spectrometry to observe the microstructure
and morphologies of the corroded surface. The details of the corrosion behaviour are
discussed in the present study.
2 Methods
Aluminium Rolling Mill Nigeria Plc, Sango-Ota, Nigeria. The elemental composition
as determined by Bruker Elemental Optical Emission Spectrometry is shown in
Table 1.
Prior to the hot rolling process, the aluminium alloy 8015 slab formed by solidifi-
cation of metallic solution of pure aluminium and the alloying elements were fed into
the furnace and heated to above recrystallization temperature up to 55 °C. The molten
alloy was continuously casted and solidified using roll casters into a continuous strip
of approximately 20 mm thickness. Further mechanical deformation process in a hot
rolling mill in tandem reduced the thickness to 7 mm plate.
The hot rolled aluminium alloy 8015 specimen samples having thickness of 7 mm
were prepared for electrochemical corrosion testing according to the ASTM stan-
dard G1-03 [19]. The specimen samples were square-cut into dimensions 10 mm
by 10 mm. Insulated copper wire with SANS 60227-5 specification, cut into short
lengths, was adhered to the cut specimen samples using epoxy glue for connec-
tivity. Subsequent cold mounting was achieved and further grinding with 320-grit
SiC paper was done. Surface roughness measurement using HOMMEL-ETAMIC
TURBO WAVE V7.53 roughness and contour metrology before and after sample
preparation reads 2.50 µm and 1.37 µm, respectively.
The progression of the open-circuit potential (OCP) as a function of time for the
hot rolled aluminium alloy 8015 samples (at 1.37 µm surface roughness) exposed to
natural seawater electrolyte solution is presented in Fig. 1.
Fig. 1 Display of
open-circuit potential (OCP)
versus time for hot rolled
aluminium alloy 8015 (Ra ≈
1.37 µm) in natural seawater
540 O. Olaogun and E. T. Akinlabi
Figure 1 illustrates that the OCP variation for the three hot rolled aluminium alloy
8015 samples with 1.37 µm surface roughness slightly shifted to the lower negative
values. This observation shows that the inert thin-film oxide layers of the samples
exhibit similar resistance to seawater electrolyte attack. The recorded OCP values
for samples 1, 2 and 3 against Ag/AgCl are −0.693 V, −0.696 V and −0.714 V,
respectively.
The polarization curves generated from the potentiodynamic experiments are
illustrated in Fig. 2. The polarization curves show the anodic scan (progresses in
the positive direction) and cathodic scan (progresses in the negative direction). Point
O denotes the open circuit or rest potential. At this point, the measured current is
relatively zero, confirming that the sum of the anodic and cathodic reaction rates on
the hot rolled AA8015 electrode is zero. In the anodic scan, the potential increases
up to region B. At region A, the steeply rise of the anodic current confirms dominant
metal oxidation reaction taking place. Likewise, in the cathodic scan, a fast reduc-
tion reaction is observed. Rapid decrease in the applied potential in region C shows
evidence of no change in the reaction rate.
Corrosion rate of the hot rolled aluminium alloy 8015 at 1.37 µm was analysed from
the polarization curve using Tafel analysis. The Tafel analysis for the three samples
is given in Fig. 3. The straight lines that best fit the data at high potentials were
achieved at selected potential range markers on both the anodic and cathodic curves.
The straight lines were extrapolated until it intersects. Table 1 shows the computed
corrosion potential (E corr ), corrosion current density (I corr ) polarization resistance
(Rp ) and corrosion rate (Table 2).
Corrosion Behaviour of Hot Rolled AA8015 … 541
(a) (b)
Black
spots
showing
localised
Fig. 4 Macrographs showing photographic observation for hot rolled aluminium alloy 8015 sample
at 1.37 µm surface roughness. a Image before corrosion of hot rolled sample; b images after
corrosion for hot rolled sample
Figure 4 shows the visual camera images of the prepared hot rolled alloy surface
before and after electrochemical corrosion. A larger surface area of the aluminium
alloy surface is attacked in the form of localized corrosion with the existence of black
spots observed on the surface of the alloy. Further microstructural observation using
TESCAN VEGA scanning electron microscope revealed pitting corrosion, as shown
in Fig. 5.
4 Conclusions
Fig. 5 SEM images of corroded hot rolled aluminium alloy 8015 at 1.37 µm surface rough-
ness. a Image before corrosion at 271- × magnification; b–d images after corrosion at amplified
magnifications
• The potentiodynamic polarization curves for the three samples are similar, show-
ing an actively corroding region. This confirms precision of the experimental
investigation.
• Mean corrosion rate of the hot rolled aluminium alloy 8015 is at 1.37 µm, and
surface roughness under natural seawater condition at room temperature of 20 ±
2 is given as 0.029385 mm per year.
• Microstructural analysis of the hot rolled aluminium alloy 8015 surface after
electrochemical corrosion reveals localized corrosion in the form of pitting.
Acknowledgements The Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR), South Africa, is
acknowledged for provision of financial support.
544 O. Olaogun and E. T. Akinlabi
References
1. Dieter GE, Kuhn HA, Semiatin SL (2003) Handbook of workability and process design. ASM
International, USA
2. Gundersen JTB, Aytaç A, Ono S, Nordlien JH, Nişancıoğlu K (2004) Effect of trace elements on
electrochemical properties and corrosion of aluminium alloy AA3102. Corros Sci 46(2):265–
283
3. Laferrere A, Parson N, Zhou X, Thompson G (2013) Effect of microstructure on the corrosion
behaviour of extruded heat exchanger aluminium alloys. Surf Interface Anal 45(10):1597–1603
4. Shahidi M, Gholamhosseinzadeh MR (2015) Electrochemical evaluation of AA6061 aluminum
alloy corrosion in citric acid solution without and with chloride ions. J Electroanal Chem
757:8–17
5. Krüger L, Schwarz F, Mandel M, Hockauf M (2015) Electrochemical corrosion studies of
ultrafine-grained aluminium alloy EN AW-6063. Mater Corros 66(3):226–232
6. Dai X, Wang H, Ju L, Cheng G, Cong H, Newby BZ (2016) Corrosion of aluminium alloy
2024 caused by Aspergillus Niger. Int Biodeterior Biodegrad 115:1–10
7. Aribo S, Fakorede A, Ige O, Olubambi P (2017) Erosion-corrosion behaviour of aluminum
alloy 6063 hybrid composite. Wear 376–377:608–614
8. Tian G, Jin G, Zhang W, Huang Z, Yang Z (2017) Investigation on electrochemical corrosion
characteristic of 2a14 aluminum alloy in nitric acid. Surf Rev Lett 24(Supp 01):1850016
9. Deepa P, Padmalatha R (2017) Corrosion behaviour of 6063 aluminium alloy in acidic and in
alkaline media. Arab J Chem 10:S2244
10. Donatus U, Thompson GE, Omotoyinbo JA, Alaneme KK, Aribo S, Agbabiaka OG (2017)
Corrosion pathways in aluminium alloys. Trans Nonferrous Metals Soc China 27(1):55–62
11. Zhang X, Zhou X, Hashimoto T, Liu B (2017) Localized corrosion in AA2024-T351 alu-
minium alloy: transition from intergranular corrosion to crystallographic pitting. Mater Charact
130:230–236
12. Liu B, Zhang X, Zhou X, Hashimoto T, Wang J (2017) The corrosion behaviour of machined
AA7150-T651 aluminium alloy. Corros Sci 126:265–271
13. Seri O (1994) The effect of NaCl concentration on the corrosion behavior of aluminum
containing iron. Corros Sci 36(10):1789–1803
14. Verma AS, Sumankant S, Yashpal NM (2015) Corrosion behavior of aluminum base particulate
metal matrix composites: a review. Mater Today: Proc 2(4–5):2840–2851
15. Polmear I, John D, Nie J-F, Qian M (2017) 2-physical metallurgy of aluminium alloys. Light
alloys. Elsevier Ltd, pp 31–107
16. Al-Moubaraki AH, Al-Rushud HH (2018) The red sea as a corrosive environment: corrosion
rates and corrosion mechanism of aluminum alloys 7075, 2024, and 6061. Int J Corrosion
2018:1–15
17. Lameche-Djeghaba S, Benchettara A, Kellou F, Ji V (2014) Electrochemical behaviour of pure
aluminium and Al–5%Zn alloy in 3% NaCl solution. Arab J Sci Eng 39(1):113–122
18. Kim S, Jang S, Han M, Park J, Jeong J, Chong S (2013) Mechanical and electrochemical
characteristics in sea water of 5052-O aluminum alloy for ship. Trans Nonferrous Metals Soc
China 23(3):636–641
19. ASTM International. (a). ASTM G1-03 standard practice for preparing, cleaning, and
evaluating corrosion test specimens. ASM International
20. ASTM G5-14 Standard Reference test method for making potentiodynamic anodic polarization
measurements. ASTM G5-14 Standard Reference test method for making potentiodynamic
anodic polarization measurements
21. ASTM International. (c). ASTM G69-97 (2009) Standard test method for measurement of
corrosion potentials of aluminum alloys. ASM International
Influence of Tool Profiles on Heat
Transfer Analysis in Al-6061 Alloy Using
Friction Stir Welding
Abstract The following paper describes the thermal analysis on friction stir welded
aluminum alloy AA 6061. The tool for this investigation is made up of high-speed
steel material. We considered tool profile as tapered and the pin is with threaded
and without threaded and also discusses the process parameters and their effects
of thermal analysis of similar welded aluminum alloys. The joint is fabricated at a
tool rotational speed of 825 rpm, feed rate of 32 mm/min and angle of 3 degree for
the joining process. There is no surface-level cracks in a welded region by using
liquid penetrant testing (NDT) method. The heat transfer model and evolution of
temperature during the process of FSW are calculated theoretically, and the values
of heat rate and peak temps are evaluated. These are compared with practical analysis
values based on ANSYS values.
1 Introduction
Friction stir welding (FSW) is a process of joining of metals in solid state. This
process is efficient in energy, eco-friendly and comfortable to do. It is considered
that the most significant development in the metal joining process in the twenty-first
decade. 6061 Aluminum alloys are widely used for structural and marine applica-
tions. They have the advantage of being lightweight at the same time exhibiting
good tensile strength. Non-consumable tool is used to join two faces of workpieces
without melting the workpiece material. In Friction stir welding (FSW) major role
play the tool material, tool profile, rotational speed, axial force and also temperature
distribution perpendicular to the tool moment. Heat is generated by friction between
the rotating tool and the workpiece and plastic deformation of workpiece, which
leads to a softened region near the FSW tool. While the tool is traversed along the
joint line, it mechanically intermixes the two pieces of metal, and forges the hot and
softened metal by the mechanical pressure, which is applied by the tool, much like
joining clay. Thus, a joint is produced in solid state. It is primarily used on wrought
or extrude and particularly for structures which need very high weld strength.
2 Literature Review
A Daneji et al. [1] studied about “ Influence of tool profile and processing parameters
on welding defects and mechanical properties of friction welding of AA 6061.”
In this study, he took rotational speed, welding speed, pin height and pin thread
pitch as input parameters. However, the weld quality-related defects and mechanical
properties were treated as output parameters. A cylindrical tool of external thread
is taken as tool geometry, rotational speed of 1750 rpm and weld speeds of 6, 9,
12 mm/min. From the experimental results, he concludes that welding speed plays
a key role toward the heat generation and lead to the generation of wormhole in
the welding nugget in case of wrong selection. The thread pitch has a controlling
influence on the stirring action and it can contribute toward the material accumulation
toward the retrieving side of the welding.
M.S. Srinivasa Rao et al. [2] studied about “Study of weld characteristics during
friction stir welding of aluminum alloy 6061.” They selected AA6061 of dimensions
200*60*6 mm and two types of tools such as taper threaded tool and half grooved
tool. They used 900 rpm, feed 16 mm/min, and 2 degrees of tilt angle as process
parameters for the welding process. They observed that there is no influence on tool
profile on hardness value. Hardness is mainly influenced by rotational speeds. The
maximum Brinell’s hardness numbered 69 BHN occurred at 900 rpm welded using
the half grooved tool.
Ch Mohana Rao et al. [3] studied on “Friction Stir Welding of Aluminium Alloys
6061-To-6061 Similar Metals.” Friction stir welding is performed to join 4 mm thick
plates of 6061 aluminum to aluminum with varied parameters (like tool rotation
speed (rpm), welding speed (mm/min), and the joining conditions are characterized.
All welds were defect-free. Microstructure of weld and microhardness were shown
at center of the weld. Tensile strength was good. As tensile strength increases from
710 to 1120 rpm, hardness decreases from 710 to 1120 rpm.
Abdul Arif et al. [4] studied on “Temperature Validation for Friction Stir Welding
of Dissimilar Aluminum Alloys.” The results of thermal analysis which are simulated
using ANSYS® are used to evaluate the temperature distribution in the workpiece
geometry. From ANSYS software, evaluated temperature distribution in dissimilar
plates and compared actual models. Values of temperatures received by the finite
element method are close to the real temperature distribution in the welded construc-
tion. % of error between experimental and simulation results do not exceed 5%. The
analysis results are closely matched with experimental results.
CM Chen et al. [5] studied the FEM of friction stir welding—thermal and
thermo-chemical analysis. They took the AA6061-T6 as base metal of dimensions
Influence of Tool Profiles on Heat Transfer … 547
Evolution During Frication Welding Of 6061-T6 Aluminum Alloy.” they were con-
sidered AA 6061 as a base metal of thickness 2.1 mm, three types tools of shoulder
diameters 12 mm, 15 mm, 18 mm and pin with equal probe lengths are used for entire
process. They used thermocouples to measure the temperature distribution. They con-
ducted the experimental work taking rotational speed of 1300, 1400, 1500 rpm and
weld speeds of 90,100,120 mm/min and tool tilt angle of 2.5°. They concluded that
increase in shoulder diameter and rotations speeds increase the temperature.
Summary of Literature Survey: Work done has been done on FSW of Al6061
plates of different thickness, different researches concluded that tool rotational speed,
welding speed, axial force, pin profile, pin diameter, shoulder profile, shoulder diam-
eter, tool tilt angle are the important process parameters which determine the quality
of weld. Before the start of the experiment this values has to be chosen carefully.
Improperly selection this process parameters leads to weaker joints containing several
defects like tunnel defect voids, cracks etc.
3 Experimental Procedure
Aluminum plates of 6 mm thick, Al 6061 alloy base metal were cut to the required
size (150 m × 50 mm) by power hacksaw cutting and milling. Square butt joint
configuration (300 mm × 300 mm) was prepared, and single-pass welding proce-
dure was followed to fabricate the joints. The chemical composition and mechanical
properties of base metals are presented in Tables 1 and 2. The non-consumable tool
is made of high-speed steel (HSS) material. The shoulder and pin of the tool are
designed and machined by using the CNC machine. The shoulder diameter profile
of the tool (20 mm) is flat and pin length (5.6 mm) is tapered with thread, and the
other one is tapered without thread. Then, both tools are made by using heat treat-
ment process. Machining process is done by the universal milling machine and the
plates are tightened by clamping force of 2 kN by varying process parameters that
are tool rotational speed, feed rate, and tilt angle. The process parameters are shown
in Table 3. The plates were successfully welded using friction stir welding tech-
nique. The welded samples were first visually inspected to element any defective
workpieces. All the samples passed this test. Next, the samples were subjected to
non-destructive tests. Only one sample (Al6061 and Al6061 without threaded tool)
was found, and all others were non-defective. In the present work, 6 mm thick com-
mercial grade aluminum plates have been welded by using different types of tool
(tapered and tapered with thread). From the numerical analysis, it is observed that
the tool with tapered threaded pin profile generates less temperature than the tool
with tapered pin profile because for the same base diameter the cylindrical pin has
more contact area with the workpiece than the contact area of pin with conical pin
profile (Table 4).
A 3D finite element transient thermal model was developed in the present work to
analyze the heat transfer and temperature distribution in the FSW process. The actual
conditions were accommodated as far as possible in the present thermal model. The
following assumptions were made in developing the thermal model of a FSW process
(Figs. 3 and 4).
The temperature calculation is based on Fourlier’s equation:
dT
ρc = div(k · gradT ) + qin Ω (1)
dt
where q is the power generated by friction between the tool and the top of the
workpiece and by the plastic deformation work of the central weld zone, T is the
temperature, n is the conductivity, r is the material density, and c is the heat capacity.
The main heat source in FSW is generally considered to be the friction between the
rotating tool and the welded plates, and the “cold work” in the plastic deformation
of material in the vicinity of the tool. Considering an element at the contact surface
between the tool shoulder and the top surface of workpiece, the rate of heat generation
derived from the friction in the element at radius r is:
The rate of heat generation (caused by the friction) over the entire interface of the
contact will be:
R0
2
q̇ = 2π ω.r 2 μ(T ) p(T )dr = π ωμ(T ) p(T ) R03 − r03 (3)
3
r0
The rate of heat generation at the interface between the shoulder and the top of
the workpiece surface is a function of the coefficient of friction m, angular velocity
w, and radius r. As the m (T ) and p (T ) are dependent on the local temperature and
the radius r, Eq. (3) is difficult to evaluate. As the temperature increases, the friction
coefficient is expected to decrease, and the work of the plastic formation increases.
In this model, the p is from the experimental measurement. A constant value of the
friction coefficient is used to approximate the comprehensive effect of both factors
of thermal and plastic effects during FSW, and the predicted temperature history is
verified by the measured ones. The heat generation in the vicinity of the probe is
considered the same as that at the shoulder periphery with a radius equal to that of
the probe.
dT
ρc = div(k · gradT ) + qinΩ
dt
2
q= π ωμ(T ) p(T ) R03 − r03
3
We assume that
Shoulder diameter R0 = 20 mm
Probe diameter r 0 = 7 mm
We taken μ = 0.5
2π N
ω=
60
At 700 rpm,
2 2π 700 5000
q= π 0.5 2 (T ) p(T ) 0.01 − 0.0035
3 3
3 60 π 3.5∗10−3
= 5185.7 W
= 5.18 kW
552 M. Bala Chennaiah et al.
Tthe = 385.65 ◦ C
4 Conclusions
In this experiment, the two process parameters of FSW, i.e., feed rate and tool rota-
tional speed are varied to find the effect on the thermal properties of friction stir
welded Al 6061 alloy plates of 6.0 mm thickness of those parameters. A combina-
tion of tool rotational speeds and welding speeds were employed in this experiment.
As a result, two joints were fabricated. The following are the results that are derived
from these experimentations.
• We chosen two types of tools profiles: one of them is tapered with thread and
another type is tapered without thread tool.
• Then, the highest temperature is generated at taper with thread tool, the amount
of increase temperature in %, i.e., 6.05%
References
1. Daneji A, Ali M, Pervaiz A (2018) Influence of tool geometry and processing parameters on
welding defects and mechanical properties for friction stir welding of 6061 alloy. Mater Sci Eng
346
2. Srinivasa Rao MS, Ravi Kumar BVR, Manzoor Hussain M. Experimental study of weld char-
acteristics during friction stir welding (FSW) of Aluminum Alloy (Aa6061-T6). Int J Res Eng
Technol. ISSN: 2319-1163
3. Mohana Rao C, Mallikarjuna Rao K (2017) Friction stir welding of Aluminium Alloys 6061-
To- 6061 similar metals. Int J Mech Eng Technol (IJMET) 8(1):264–269
4. Arif A et al (2013) Temperature validation for friction stir welding of dissimilar Aluminum
Alloys. In: International Conference on Advances in Mechanical Engineering, ICAME-2013
5. Chen CM, Kovacevic R (2003) Finite element modeling of friction stir welding thermal and
thermo mechanical analysis, by Received 12 May 2003; Accepted 10 June 2003
Influence of Tool Profiles on Heat Transfer … 553
6. Tang W, Guo X, Mcclure J. Heat input and temperature distribution in friction stri welding.
University of Texas at El pasa
7. Ramulu PJ, Ganesh Narayana R (2014) Experimental study on temperature evolution during
frication welding of 6061-T6 Aluminum Alloy. (AIMTDR 2014) 12th–14th Dec 2014
Tensile, Hardness, and Impact Properties
of Amorphous Al–Si–Mg Cast Alloys
Abstract This research work focused on tensile, hardness, and influence properties
of amorphous Al–Si-Mg cast alloys. Enhancement of aluminum alloy with Mg and
Si was performed after which heat treatments were carried out on the produced
samples. The result showed the percentage of Mg as 0.14, 4.14, 0.14, 0.32, and
0.20%, for as-cast aluminum, annealed, age-hardened, hardened, and glassy-phase
samples, respectively. The percentages of Si were 2.01%, range of 1.94–4.10% and
3.37% for as-cast, heat-treated, and glassy-phase aluminum alloys, respectively. The
impact tests showed an increase in impact value from 5.423 J of as-cast sample to
8.135 J of age-hardened sample. Hardened sample has the lowest impact value of
2.712 J while glassy-phase sample has the highest impact value of 10.847 J. The
ultimate tensile strength of annealed sample is higher compared to as-cast while
glassy-phase has the highest value. The SEM of the annealed alloy sample contains
bright and dark regions indicating α and β phases, respectively.
1 Introduction
aluminum are applicable in joining the roof of automobile, engine, and side panels to
the underbody, [3]. Steel or iron was previously used for automobile; but discovery
has tested alloys of aluminum proven to result into lighter part which might occur to
be complicated most times [4]. As a result of the increase in part design or a material
property, it is most likely to generate a specific part that will perform the activities
of other parts, thereby making it easy to minimize the parts to be produced [5].
The particular combination of metals and another element type leading to Al–
7Si–0.4 Mg is normally utilized in automobile part, aircraft; as a result of the Mg
in the combination, deterioration of materials is opposed [6]. Cast Al–Si–Mg alloys
are applicable in automobile and aviation industry as a result of their excellent char-
acteristics and the ratio of its capacity to weight [7]. Mechanical properties required
for the aforementioned application are excellent opposition to weakening of mate-
rials, high proof strength, and high resistant to fracture [8]. Heat treatment of cast
Al–Si–Mg alloys is normally examined in the aspect of homogeneous solid solution,
undesirable low-temperature changes been hindered, and accelerated changes occur-
ring in the properties [9], and this method for strengthening materials is utilized in
other to achieve a preferred combination of its mechanical properties [10, 11]. This
research work therefore aimed to produce amorphous Al–Si–Mg cast alloys with an
improved mechanical property.
The material, tools, and equipment required for the production of the aluminum alloys
and heat treatments included aluminum ingot, silicon ingot, magnesium ingot, alloy
additives, heating furnace, vernier calipers, and hacksaw.
The aluminum (Al), magnesium (Mg), and silicon (Si) ingots were properly dried
with acetone. In other to easily detach the mold from the casting, graphite coatings
are made available within the mold. The casting of aluminum alloy was carried out
at research center in the country. The molds were prepared toward a particular high
temperature. Electric induction furnace was used for the melting of metal, and the
alloy was inverted twice and was allowed to cool in sand. The alloys produced were
categorized into as-cast sample and heat-treated samples. The cast samples were
analyzed to determine the percentage of elemental composition in the alloys.
Tensile, Hardness, and Impact Properties … 557
In other to enhance the mechanical properties of cast alloy, heat treatment process
was done on mechanical test samples. Heat treatment process comprises mainly of
age-hardening, annealing, hardening, and glassy phase which were carried out at the
research center.
Percentage weight elemental composition of the alloys produced was carried out
in a local aluminum rolling mill. The equipment used for the analysis was optical
emission spectrometer. The test was carried out following the procedure below:
The samples were prepared by forming into the shape accommodated by the
machine. This involved cutting and filling to shape, and prepared samples as described
above were then sparked using argon gas after which the sample was inserted into
metal analyzer for proper analysis.
Various mechanical tests were carried out on the samples; hardness and impact
tests were carried out at the university laboratory. Tensile test was carried out in
another university. The equipment used included meter rule, testing equipment appa-
ratus, hardness testing equipment, tensile strength testing equipment, and inspection
equipment apparatus.
Hardness Impact and Tensile Tests. Rockwell hardness testing machine was
used for Brinell hardness test using heat-treated samples and control samples. The
surface was prepared by grinding and polishing. 20 mm length of no specific diameter
was sectioned out from the sample and fixed on the machine using a dwell time of
15 s.
The SEM is majorly applicable in the evaluation of samples that are thick by putting
together electrons which are emitted from the sample under experiment so as to
obtain secondary electrons. In addition, other signals including electron beam were
also collected. This was done using Phenom ProX scanning electron microscope,
model number-800-07334.
558 O. R. Adetunji et al.
The casting produced was grouped into two for the purpose of comparison on the test
to be carried out: The first group is as-cast (i.e., non-heat-treated samples), and the
second is heat-treated sample. Both groups of samples were subjected to chemical
analysis to determine the percentage weight composition of elements in the aluminum
alloy produced (Fig. 1).
The scanning process as earlier explained was followed by the EDX analysis with
the acquired microstructure using the Phenom identification software. The scanning
electron micrograph in Fig. 2 shows the microstructure of annealed alloy sample.
The bright region indicates the primary solid solution, and the dark region shows the
non-equilibrium eutectic solid solution between the grains. The energy dispersive
X-ray as shown in Fig. 3 reveals the chemical composition. Figure 4 shows the SEM
of age-hardening test carried out on the alloy samples. The emergence of a scattered
solid form from a solution in combining two or more metals is the aim of the solid-
hardening process. The fine solid in the combination of the two or more metals as
seen in the micrograph prevents abnormality separation in mobility by forcing the
abnormality to pass through the solid particles or encompasses round it. Preventing
abnormality in mobility makes combination of two or more metals to be strengthened
(Figs. 5 and 6).
Tensile, Hardness, and Impact Properties … 559
Mechanical tests carried out on the samples were impact test, hardness test, and
tensile test, and the results are as given below. These results are given in Tables 2
and 3.
560
Fig. 2 a SEM image of the As-cast sample b Energy dispersive spectrometer (EDS)
The results show the percentage weight of elements in the as-cast, heat-treated, and
glassy-phase aluminum alloys. The as-cast aluminum alloy shows a percentage of
Mg 0.14%, heat-treated samples show annealed sample to be 4.14%, age-hardened
sample 0.14%, hardened sample 0.32%, and glassy phase shows 0.20%. The per-
centage of Si in the as-cast Al alloy is 2.01 by wt% as the range is between 1.94%
and 4.10% in the heat-treated aluminum alloy while glassy phase is 3.37%.
The impact value of as-cast sample is 5.423 J just as it is in annealed sample; age-
hardened sample experiences an increase in the impact value to 8.135 J, and hardened
sample has aÀ reduced impact value of 2.712 J. Glassy phase has the highest impact
value of 10.847 J.
Comparatively, the results of hardness (HRB) value of as-cast sample is 68, and
this value remained in hardened sample and increased to 70 in the annealed sample
while the value reduced to 66 in age-hardened sample. Glassy phase only shows the
lowest rate of reduction to 62. This result conformed to those of other researchers
like Adeyemi et al. [10].
562 O. R. Adetunji et al.
The tensile yield strength of as-cast is 82 MPa, and the ultimate tensile strength
is 94.22 MPa while the percentage elongation is 3.62. The test also shows tensile
yield strength in annealed sample to be 98 MPa, ultimate tensile strength increased
to 108.24 MPa, and the percentage elongation is 2.81. In age-hardened sample shows
tensile yield strength increased to 114 MPa, ultimate tensile strength is 91.81 MPa,
and percentage elongation reduced to 1.60. The results show the tensile strength to be
116 MPa, ultimate tensile strength as 87.98 MPa, and percentage elongation is 1.62.
Glassy-phase sample shows tensile yield strength to be 116 MPa, ultimate tensile
strength to be 115.87 MPa, and percentage elongation to be 2.68.
The bright region in the SEM of the annealed alloy sample indicates the primary
solid solution which accounted for solid solution hardness got in the result, and the
dark region shows the non-equilibrium eutectic solid solution between the grains
which accounted for the higher tensile and impact toughness values. This is in line
with the findings of Chen et al. [11, 12]. The energy dispersive X-ray reveals the
Tensile, Hardness, and Impact Properties … 563
4 Conclusions
The results of analysis show that the produced Al–Si–Mg alloys exhibit excellent
casting characteristics evident from the results of microstructural test. Mechanical
properties including impact toughness, hardness, and tensile were of good values.
Glassy-phase alloy had the best impact toughness value followed by age-hardened
one. The best hardness value was obtained for hardened alloy and followed by as-cast,
age-hardened, and lastly glassy phase. The best yield and ultimate tensile strength
564 O. R. Adetunji et al.
References
1. Adetunji OR, Olukuade ML, Simka W, Sowa M, Adesusi OM, Okediran IK (2017) Production
and characterization of amorphous Aluminium-Copper alloy for aerospace applications. Eur J
Eng Res Sci 2(2):1–5
2. Afolalu SA, Abioye AA, Dirisu JO, Okokpujie IP, Ajayi OO, Adetunji OR (2018) Investigation
of wear land and rate of locally made HSS cutting tool. In: AIP conference proceedings, vol
1957, no 1. AIP Publishing, p 050002
3. Afolalu SA, Abioye OP, Salawu EY, Okokpujie IP, Abioye AA, Omotosho OA, Ajayi OO
(2018) Impact of heat treatment on HSS cutting tool (ASTM A600) and its behavior during
machining of mild steel (ASTM A36). In: AIP conference proceedings, vol 1957, no 1. AIP
Publishing, p 050003
4. Afolalu SA, Okokpujie IP, Salawu EY, Abioye AA, Abioye OP, Ikumapayi OM (2018) Study
of the performances of nano-case treatment cutting tools on carbon steel work material during
turning operation. In: AIP conference proceedings, vol 1957, no 1. AIP Publishing, p 050001
566 O. R. Adetunji et al.
5. Al-Khazraji KK, Hanna WA, Muhammed OS (2011) Study the effect of polymeric quenching of
wear resistance of eutetic modified Aluminum-Silicon alloy. J Minerals Mater Characterization
Eng 10(10):941–958
6. Abioye A, Abioye OP, Ajayi OO, Afolalu SA, Fajobi MA, Atanda PO (2018) Mechanical and
microstructural characterization of ductile iron produced from fuel- fired rotary furnace. Int J
Mech Eng Technol 9(1):694–704
7. Raj KS, Amit T, Das S (2016) Microstructure and mechanical properties of Al-Si alloy in
As-cast and heat-treated condition. Am J Eng Res (AJER) 5(8):133–137
8. Abdulwahab M, Madugu IA, Asuke F, Fayomi OSI, Ayeni FA (2013) Effect of thermal ageing
treatment on the mechanical properties of antimony-modified A356.0-type Al-Si-Mg alloy. J
Mater Environ Sci 4(1):87–92
9. Umaru OB, Abdulwahab M, Hafsat NM, Maidawa H, Murtada AO, Suleiman TM (2016)
Influence of a low temperature ageing on the properties of Al-6.5%Si-0.35%Mg alloy. Nigerian
J Technol (NIJOTECH) 35(3):550–554
10. Adeyemi DI, Bolaji A, Mosobalaje OA, Oluyemi JO, Moshood DS (2013) Effect of heat
treatment on some mechanical properties of 7075 Aluminum alloy. Int J Mater Res 16(1):190–
194
11. Chen R, Wang L, Apelian D (2000) fludized bed reactor heat treatment of A356 alloy:
microstructure analysis and mechanical properties. Trans Am Foundry Soc 2(4):289–304
Experimental Investigation
on the Influence of Tool Geometry
in Minimum Chip Thickness
of Microendmilling Using Cutting Force
Analysis
1 Introduction
Recently, with more demand for accurate and precise micro-components, the impor-
tance of tool-based micromachining processes has been increased in the num-
ber of fields, such as medical, aerospace and automobile [1]. Among the tool-
based micromachining processes, microendmilling is used for manufacturing the
micro-components like microsurgical equipment, micro-impellor and micro-nozzle.
Microendmilling uses microendmills with diameter in the sub-millimetre range. The
edge radius of a typical microendmill is in the order of a few microns, and also,
the uncut chip thickness (t) is usually lesser than the edge radius. Due to the size
of the microendmill, it is very difficult to achieve the quality in the finished com-
ponents. Previous investigations have indicated that the tool life in the tool-based
micromachining is unpredictable, and also it fails prematurely [2–4].
Microendmilling distinguished from macro-regime machining in terms of size
effect and t [5]. The t is greatly influenced by the chip formation process in the
microendmilling. If the t is less than the minimum uncut chip thickness (t m ) (i.e. 0.33
of nose radius (r e )), ploughing is found to be dominating than that of the shearing [4],
which resulted in the increase of cutting forces. New by et al. [5] made an attempt
to calculate the uncut chip thickness (t) based on the feed per flute and cutting edge
radius, which is shown in Eqs. 1 and 2.
n 2 1 2
Uncut chip thickness (t) = tx sin α − tx sin α cos α + t cos2 α (1)
2πr e 2re x
where
F × 1000
tx = (2)
S×n
where t—uncut chip thickness (µm), t x —feed per flute (µm), F—feed rate
(mm/min), S—rotational speed (rpm), n—number of flute, α—tool rotational angle,
r e —tool nose radius.
Generally, in tool-based micromachining processes the quality of the machined
surface is mostly affected by the characteristics of cutting forces, which are mostly
affected by the tool geometry [6]. Therefore, there is a need for more investigation on
the effect of cutting forces generated during microendmilling. However, few attempts
were made by researchers to study the effect of cutting forces in conventional/macro-
regime endmilling [6–11].
Literature review related to the studies on the effect of tool geometry on the
cutting forces is briefly presented here. Fang et al. [6] carried out the experimental
investigations to study the effect of different tool geometries such as two flutes,
triangle type and semicircular type and its failure modes using cutting force signals
in the microendmilling of brass material. They have observed that the tool rigidity
is much higher with the triangular-based microendmill, than that of the two flutes
Experimental Investigation on the Influence … 569
2 Experimental Set-up
axial force is not considered for further analysis. The resultant force is also calculated
by considering transverse and feed force using Eq. 3, which is given as
Resultant force (Fr ) = Fx2 + Fy2 (3)
Experimental Investigation on the Influence … 573
The effect of two different microendmill geometries such as two flutes and four flutes
during microendmilling on the surface roughness (Ra ), the uncut chip thickness (t),
and cutting forces (F x and F y ) is analysed. They are briefly presented below.
Experiments are carried out by varying the rotational speed and feed rate with constant
depth of cut of 50 µm. The effect of two different tool geometries such as two flutes
and four flutes of the microendmill at various cutting parameters on the Ra is shown
in Fig. 5. Typical surface topography of the machined surface with two flutes and
four flutes of microendmill is shown in Fig. 6. From Figs. 5 and 6, it is observed that
Ra values are found to be lower in the four flutes microendmill than that of two flutes
microendmill. This may be due to the formation of continuous chips with four flutes
than that of the two flutes (Fig. 7). This may also be due to the formation of closer tool
path (i.e. due to the increase in number of flutes in the four flutes microendmill) for
subsequent passing of microendmill in the feed direction as illustrated by Bao et al.
[16]. In the case of microendmilling with two flutes, higher Ra is observed due to
interrupted chip formation (Fig. 7). It is also observed that Ra is found to be decreased
with the increase in the rotational speeds up to the feed rate of 12 mm/min both with
the two flutes and four flutes microendmill. However, Ra is found to be increased
as the feed rate increases beyond 12 mm/min. There is no significant variation in
Ra at the higher rotational speed above 1400 rpm with increase in feed rate beyond
12 mm/min. Therefore, in order to achieve a better Ra , four flutes microendmill
0.25 0.25
700 rpm
700 rpm
0.20 0.20
Surface roughness [Ra] (µm)
Surface roughness [Ra] (µm)
1400 rpm
0.15 0.15
2100 rpm 1400 rpm
2400 rpm
0.10 2100 rpm
0.10
2400 rpm
0.05 0.05
0.00 0.00
5 10 15 20 25 5 10 15 20 25
Feed (mm/min) Feed (mm/min)
(a) (b)
Fig. 5 Tool geometry effect on surface roughness in microendmilling. a Two flutes microendmill.
b Four flutes microendmill
574 M. Prakash et al.
(a) (b)
Fig. 6 Typical surface topography of the machined surface in microendmilling. a Two flutes
microendmill. b Four flutes microendmill
100µm 1 0 0 µm
(a) (b)
Fig. 7 Typical chips obtained in microendmilling. a Two flutes microendmill. b Four flutes
microendmill
with higher rotational speed along with moderate feed rate are found to be highly
desirable.
The behaviour of the uncut chip thickness (t) is analysed during the half rotation
for both two flutes and four flutes microendmill by varying the rotational speed.
Figure 8 indicates the two regions of material removal mechanism in microendmill
based on the uncut chip thickness (t) such as ploughing (regions A to B and D to E)
Experimental Investigation on the Influence … 575
15 15
Feed - 10 mm/min A - B: Ploughing Feed - 10 mm/min A - B: Ploughing
DOC - 50 µm B - C: Upmilling
DOC - 50 µm B - C: Upmilling
10 C - D: Downmilling C - D: Downmilling
10
700 rpm D - E: Ploughing
Shearing
C D - E: Ploughing
Shearing
1400 rpm 700 rpm
Ploughing
-5
Ploughing
-10 -10
A
E -15
-15 0 30 60 90 120 150 180
0 30 60 90 120 150 180
Tool rotational angle ( [degree] Tool rotational angle ( [degree]
(a) (b)
Fig. 8 Behaviour of uncut chip thickness of different tool geometry with varying speed in
microendmilling. a Two flutes microendmill. b Four flutes microendmill
Shearing
20 mm/min
Shearing
Uncut chip thickness (t) [ m]
Ploughing
Ploughing
-2 A E -2
A E
-4 -4
Fig. 9 Behaviour of uncut chip thickness of different tool geometry with varying feed in
microendmilling. a Two flutes microendmill. b Four flutes microendmill
lesser than that of with the two flutes microendmill. This may be due to the closer
trochoidal tool path generation of the four flutes microendmill than that of two flutes
microendmill, which is also similarly observed by Newby et al. [5]. These results
indicate that the tool path generation in microendmilling significantly depends on
the number of flutes and the feed rate, which is also similarly observed by Tansel
et al. and Bao et al. [14, 16]. Higher feed rate with more number of flutes results
in continuous chip formation, which is also similarly observed in the conventional
endmilling [11–13].
Figures 10 and 11 show the typical cutting forces in the transverse and feed directions,
2
Speed - 2800 rpm
Un chip Chip Un chip Chip
Transverse force [Fx] (N)
O
B D O
A
0
E A B D E O - A : Un chip forming zone
Un chip Un chip Chip
Chip A - E : Chip forming zone
forming forming forming Two flute microendmill
forming
zone zone zone A - B: Ploughing
-1 zone
B - C: Upmilling
C - D: Downmilling
Two flute microendmill Four flute microendmill D - E: Ploughing
-2
0 180 360 540 720 900 1080 1260 1440 1620 1800
Tool rotational angle (degree)
respectively, for two flutes and four flutes microendmill. From Figs. 10 and 11, it
is observed that the signature of the transverse force and feed force signals for both
two flutes and four flutes microendmill is found to be in increasing and decreasing
trend both in positive and negative directions with respect to the tool rotational angle.
However, from Figs. 10 to 11, it is observed that, at the earlier stages with four flutes
microendmill there is the significant angular shift in cutting forces at the region of
unchip forming zone (O to A), where no chips are formed, than that of with the two
flutes microendmill. This may be due to the closer trochoidal tool path of the four
flutes microendmill than that of two flutes microendmill. This is well agreed with the
result of Bao et al. [16]. It is also observed from Figs. 10 and 11, that the signature
of the cutting force signal during unchip forming zone (O to A) and chip forming
zone (A to E) is found to be different from the four flutes microendmill than that
of two flutes microendmill, due to the change in frequency of contact of two flutes
microendmill than that of four flutes microendmill.
From Fig. 10, it is observed that the direction changes in the transverse force
from upmilling (B to C) to downmilling (C to D) with both two flutes and four flutes
microendmill as shown in Fig. 4. However, the magnitude of the transverse force
during the upmilling is lower in the case of four flutes microendmill. But in the case
of downmilling, there is no significant variation is observed. Transverse force due
to ploughing (regions A to B and D to E) is more dominant in the case of two flutes
microendmill. From the above, it is observed that, the microendmilling with two
flutes is mostly affected by ploughing than that of shearing.
From Fig. 11, it is observed that increasing and decreasing trends of feed force
from upmilling (B to C) and downmilling (C to D) in both microendmills as shown
in Fig. 4. However, the magnitude of feed force during upmilling is lesser in the case
of four flutes microendmill than that of two flutes microendmill.
Figure 12a, b shows the cutting forces behaviour with respect to the uncut chip
thickness (t) and tool geometry. Feed force is found to be the maximum when the
uncut chip thickness (t) reaches the maximum limit. From Fig. 12, it is also observed
that transverse force approaches nearly zero, when the uncut chip thickness (t) is
578 M. Prakash et al.
4 4 4 4
Speed - 2800 rpm A - B: Ploughing Speed - 2800 rpm A - B: Ploughing
3 Feed rate - 10 mm/min B - C: Upmilling
3 Feed rate - 10 mm/min
3 B - C: Upmilling 3
DOC - 50 µm C - D: Downmilling
DOC - 50 µm C - D: Downmilling
D - E: Ploughing
2 C 2 2 2
Feed force (Fy)
1 1 C
Fig. 12 Typical behaviour of cutting forces with the uncut chip thickness of different tool geometry
in microendmilling. a Two flutes microendmill. b Four flutes microendmill
found to be the maximum level. The transverse force is found to change the direction
from positive direction to negative direction during downmilling (regions C to D)
while using two flutes and four flutes microendmill (Fig. 12a, b). By comparing
Fig. 12a, b, it is observed that, shearing mode of material removal mechanism is
dominant with four flutes than the two flutes microendmill. This may be due to the
increase in contact area between the tool and workpiece. Figure 12 also indicates that
the transverse force and feed force are found to be lesser in the case of four flutes
microendmill due to the reduced uncut chip thickness (t).
Figure 13 shows the tool geometry effect on the resultant forces (F r ) with various
rotational speed and feed rate with the constant depth of cut (50 µm). It is observed
that, the rotational speed and feed rate are compounded irrespective of the tool
geometry at the lowest speed of 700 rpm, as similar to the conventional endmilling.
The same trend is observed by Lai et al. [9]. In conventional endmilling, increased
rotational speed and feed rate resulted in the increasing trend of the cutting force
4 4
700 rpm
3 3 700 rpm
Resultant force (N)
2 2
0 0
5 10 15 20 5 10 15 20
Feed (mm/min) Feed (mm/min)
(a) (b)
Fig. 13 Tool geometry effect on cutting forces in microendmilling. a Two flutes microendmill.
b Four flutes microendmill
Experimental Investigation on the Influence … 579
values [11]. At lower speed of 700 rpm along with increased feed rate, higher cutting
forces are observed due to the dominance of rubbing and ploughing. However, when
the rotational speed increases above 2100 rpm the resultant forces tends to decrease.
In the case of two flutes microendmill, the cutting forces are found to be higher
than that of four flutes microendmill due to the effect of ploughing than that of the
shearing [28].
4 Conclusions
This work presented the investigations on the effect of tool geometries of microend-
mill with two flutes and four flutes during microendmilling of copper alloy (BSS
249) on the surface roughness (Ra ), the uncut chip thickness (t) and cutting forces
(feed and transverse forces). The following conclusions are drawn from the present
investigations.
• Four flutes microendmill resulted in lesser Ra than that of the two flutes microend-
mill, due to the closer tool path generation of the flutes in the microendmill in
the feed direction and also due to the formation of continuous chip. Therefore,
to achieve the better Ra during microendmilling, four flutes microendmill with
higher speed and with moderate feed rate is recommended.
• Based on the behaviour of uncut chip thickness (t), it is found that both plough-
ing and shearing are observed during the half tool rotation of the microendmill,
irrespective of the rotational speed and feed rate, in both two flutes and four flutes
microendmills. However, the size of uncut chip thickness (t) and the ploughing
effect is found to be lesser while using four flutes. Shearing is found to be domi-
nant during microendmilling with four flutes microendmill due to the increase in
contact area of tool–workpiece interface.
• From the cutting forces analyses, it is found that the signature of the cutting force
signals for both two flutes and four flutes microendmill are similar with respect
to the tool rotational angle. However, significant angular shift is observed in the
case of four flutes microendmill due to the closer trochoidal tool path generation
of successive passing of microendmill. Transverse and feed forces are found to be
low in the case of four flutes microendmill due to the reduced uncut chip thickness
(t) in the same parametric level of microendmilling. Cutting forces are found to
be higher with two flutes microendmill due to the dominance of ploughing than
that of the shearing.
580 M. Prakash et al.
References
25. Cuba Ramos A, Autenrieth H, Straub T, Deuchert M, Hoffmeister J, Schulze V (2012) Charac-
terization of transition from ploughing to cutting in micromachining and evaluation of minimum
chip thickness of cut. J Mater Process Technol 212:594–600
26. Afazov SM, Zdebski D, Ratchev SM, Segal J, Liu S (2013) Effect of micro-milling conditions
on the cutting forces and process stability. J Mater Process Technol 213:671–684
27. Prakash M, Kanthababu M (2013) In-process tool condition monitoring using acoustic emission
sensor in microendmilling. Int J Mach Sci Technol 17(2):209–227
28. Chen W, Teng X, Huo D, Wang Q (2017) An improved cutting force model for micro milling
considering machining dynamics. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 93(9–12):3005–3016
29. Sahoo P, Patra K (2019) Mechanistic modeling of cutting forces in micro-end-milling consid-
ering tool run out, minimum chip thickness and tooth overlapping effects. Mach Sci Technol
4;23(3):407–430
30. Chen W, Huo D, Teng X, Sun Y (2017) Surface generation modelling for micro end milling
considering the minimum chip thickness and tool runout. Proc CIRP 1(58):364–369
Temperature and RF Power Effect
on the Morphology and Structural
Properties of TiC Thin Film Grown
by RF Magnetron Sputtering
Abstract In this research study, the effect of temperature and radio frequency (RF)
power on the surface morphology and structural properties of titanium carbide (TiC)
thin film was studied. TiC thin film was deposited on the surface of commercially
pure titanium (CpTi) alloys to enhance its surface properties. During the deposition
process, the sputtering temperature and RF power were varied while other sputtering
parameters were kept constant. Field emission scanning electron microscope was
used to analyze the surface profiling of the film, and atomic force microscope was
used to study the surface roughness. Raman spectroscopy was used to determine the
film composition, and grazing incidence X-ray diffractometer was used to analyze
the phase composition. Nanoindentation was carried out to understand the hardness
and Young’s modulus properties of the coating. The results reveal the dependency
of the thin film properties on the independent process parameters.
1 Introduction
TiC coatings are extensively applied for modifying and enhancing the surface prop-
erties of materials. This is due to the superior quality of their properties such as high
hardness, low coefficient of friction, low wear rate, good electrical conductivity,
excellent thermal resistance and stability, high modulus, excellent biocompatibility
adhesion and chemical inertness [1–6].
2 Experimental Setup
TiC thin films were grown on commercially pure titanium (CpTi) using HHV TF500
versatile RF magnetron sputtering coater. Before deposition of the film, the substrate
(CpTi) was ground using silica carbide paper and then polished to remove any surface
impurities. Further, cleansing of the surface was done by using acetone to remove
any form of lubricant or contaminant on the surface. The purity of the TiC target used
is 99.99%. During the sputtering process, the RF power and temperature were varied
while other sputtering parameters were kept constant. Three runs of experiments
were conducted, and the experimental matrix is shown in Table 1. The sputtering
apparatus was first evacuated to a base pressure of 1.13 × 10−5 mbar. The reason for
the low pressure is to provide a long mean free path for a collision between the target
and substrate and allows for the control and minimization of contaminants. After
evacuation, the system is refilled with argon to a partial pressure of 2.5 × 10−3 mbar.
Temperature and RF Power Effect … 585
Table 1 Experimental matrix of the process parameters for thin film deposition
S/N RF Power (W) Temperature (°C)
A 150 80
B 200 90
C 250 100
The flow rate of argon was kept constant at 12 sccm while the sputtering time was
maintained at 2.5 h. The working pressure was constant throughout the experiments.
Maintaining constant pressure helps to place many argon atoms in the path of the
ions and ejected coatings.
A veeco Di2100 atomic force microscope was used to evaluate the surface topogra-
phies of the samples. Image scan size at 5 × 5 µm2 was obtained in tapping mode.
All analysis was performed in ambient temperature. Nanoscope software was used
for capturing and analyzing the images from the surface of the samples. Field emis-
sion scanning electron microscope (ZEISS Gemini*2, Germany) (FESEM) capable
of capturing nanoscale images effortlessly at very high magnification was used to
observe the surface morphology evolution. The FESEM can take images at very
high magnification and images were taken at 50,000× magnification. Raman anal-
yses were performed on TiC thin films using an alpha300R (WITec) confocal laser
Raman microscopy coupled with frequency-doubled Nd-YAG laser of 532 nm wave-
length. A magnification of ×50 on Nikon objective lens was used in capturing the
Raman spectra intensity. A laser power of 2 mW at room temperature was used to
prevent the burning of the film surface. Before the acquisition of the Raman spectra,
beam centering and Raman spectra calibration were done using standard Si(111)
samples. The Raman spectrum of the substrate was obtained and used to compare
with the TiC thin films deposited. Grazing incidence X-ray diffractometer (PAN-
alyticals’s Xpert Pro with Cu K-alpha and wavelength 1.540598 A) at a very low
angle of incidence that allows penetration into the thin film was used to study the
structural properties of the thin film. Young’s modulus and hardness thin film of the
nanomechanical properties were obtained using Hysitron TI 950 Triboindenter. The
control mode used was load controlled, and the load pattern was modeled to follow a
trapezoidal geometry of loading dwelling and unloading profile with dwelling time
of 15 s at peak load.
Berkovich tip was used as the diamond indenter with a tip radius of curvature
of 100 nm. From the analyzed load-displacement curves, Oliver and Pharr analysis
method was used to calculate Young’s modulus of the thin film [21–23]. The depth of
penetration for all the samples was limited to 10% of the coating thickness to eliminate
the effect of the substrate on the thin film properties [24, 25]. The hardness and
586 O. O. Abegunde et al.
Figure 1 depicts the microstructural evolution of the surface morphology of the coat-
ing at three different process parameters. Three different distinct features and growth
modes are noticeable at each process parameter. For sample A, the microstructural
growth pattern is similar to island growth which shows an early stage of film growth
and nucleation on the surface and the adherence bond between the adatoms is stronger
than the bonding between the adatoms and substrate. The coatings are sparingly dis-
tributed on the surface with granular grain shape. The coating becomes dense and
homogenous distributed as the power and temperature increased. This might be asso-
ciated with the fact that at sufficient temperature and power, the rate of nucleation
and growth of the film is rapid. In sample B, the images reveal a columnar structure
as expected. It is of no doubt that these columnar structures usually associated with
ceramic coating Amina et al. [2]. For sample C, two layers of coating are noticeable.
The topmost layer is coarse with high porosity while the latter layer coating is evenly
distributed. This implies that further increased in RF power and temperature leads to
thicker coating surface and formation of a new layer with the nucleation mechanism
pattern of the Stranski–Krastanov mechanism.
The 3D morphology of the surface roughness is shown in Fig. 2, and the statistical
Fig. 2 3D images from the AFM surface profiling at scan size of 5 × 5 µm2
Temperature and RF Power Effect … 587
details are summarized in Table 2. The 3D AFM structure for sample 1 exhibits
extended columnar grain growth which agrees with the result of the FESEM images.
The AFM morphology of samples 2 shows evenly distributed coating, and for sample
3, the surface becomes uneven.
The surface roughness reduced from 39.68 nm for sample A to 20.48 nm in sample
B. This phenomenon might due to the homogenous morphology of sample B. The
roughness increases for sample C which has the highest roughness and most uneven
surface due to incomplete formed multilayer surface. The hardness and Young’s
modulus are presented in Table 3. Similarly, the graph is shown in Fig. 3. The highest
hardness value is associated with sample B that exhibits uniform coating of the film.
Sample C has the least hardness value. Although for thin film, the hardness is not
enough to conclude the resistance of the surface to deformation or failure, the wear
resistance which is the ratio of H3 /E2 and plasticity index (H/E) is used to study the
film resistance. The wear resistance and plasticity index were highest at B. The wear
resistance and plasticity increase with an increase in RF power and temperature and
then decrease as the RF power and temperature were raised from 200 W and 90 °C
to 250 W and 100 °C, respectively.
The crystallographic structures from the XRD are shown in Fig. 4. The patterns
of the TiC peaks obtained exhibit a preferential orientation of 110, and other planes
found are 200, 220, and 311. TiC films have a rock salt-type (NaCl type) face-centered
cubic (FCC) with diffraction peaks intensity at 110, 200, 220, and 311 plane reflection
[26]. This agrees with the result, and different peak intensities were noticed due to
the RF power and temperature of the coating. The highest peak intensity was found
at 110 for all the samples. 110 spectra are known to result in high hardness value [2].
Sample A produces the highest peak value at 110 dues to the geometrical factor on
the slip system [14].
Raman spectroscopy is responsible for determining the crystal structure quality,
and the response graph is shown in Fig. 5. Both the D and G bands for TiC are
noticeable on the spectra graph. The D band for TiC was found around 500–700
(1/cm). Sample B tends to have smaller Raman intensity peaks compared to A and C.
Raman peaks are caused by lattice mismatch, chemical composition, defects, short-
range order, crystalline structure, and internal stresses. Since sample B possesses
better homogenous and uniformly distributed coating, it can be concluded that the
lattice is better matched compared to A and C with less defect.
Temperature and RF Power Effect … 589
4 Conclusion
The observation from the characterization shows how RF power and temperature
contribute to the properties of TiC thin film coating. Three distinct growth types
were noticed depending on the process parameters, and the lowest surface roughness
was noticed at the film with the dense and uniformly distributed coating. The XRD
revealed the preferential plane of 111 has the highest peak, and the hardness properties
show substantial dependence on the process parameters.
Acknowledgements The authors will like to acknowledge CSIR South African and the University
of Johannesburg for funding this project.
References
1. Kulkarni M et al (2014) Biomaterial surface modification of titanium and titanium alloys for
medical applications. Nanomedicine 111:111
2. Djafer ZA et al (2014) Deposition and characterization of titanium carbide thin films by
magnetron sputtering using Ti and TiC targets. Appl Surf Sci 312:57–62
3. Longo G et al (2010) Effect of titanium carbide coating by ion plating plasma-assisted depo-
sition on osteoblast response: a chemical, morphological and gene expression investigation.
Surf Coat Technol 204(16–17):2605–2612
4. Brama M et al (2007) Effect of titanium carbide coating on the osseointegration response
in vitro and in vivo. Biomaterials 28(4):595–608
5. Galevsky G et al (2015) Titanium carbide: nanotechnology, properties, application. In: IOP
conference series: materials science and engineering, p 012017
6. Bugaev SP et al (2003) Amorphous hydrogenated carbon films deposited by a closed-drift ion
source. Laser Part Beams 21(2):285–289
7. Abegunde OO et al (2019) Overview of thin film deposition techniques. AIMS Mater Sci
(2):174
590 O. O. Abegunde et al.
Abstract Thin porous coating was found to be vital for boiling heat transfer
enhancement in various heat transfer devices that use a phase change mechanism.
However, the formation of a stable thin porous surface is a challenging process. It is
known that the aluminium tubes were used to fabricate different kinds of heat pipes
which are used in space applications. Therefore, developing nanoporous coating in
an aluminium tube is essential to improve the performance of heat pipes. Anodiza-
tion is an electrochemical process that applied mostly for aluminium materials to
protect the surface from corrosion. This anodized aluminium surface can also be
utilized for heat transfer applications by controlling the morphology of the surface
through adjusting the process parameters of the anodization. One of the most critical
parameter that controls the morphology of coating surface is the temperature of the
anodizing cell. Therefore, in this study, the effect of cell temperature on the coating
thickness, pore size and contact angle is analysed while maintaining the electrolyte
concentration, cell voltage, electrolyte flow rate and anodizing time as constant. An
aluminium tube of the outer and inner diameter of 19 mm and 16.8 mm, respectively,
with a length of 350 mm was used for anodization. The anodized aluminium tubes
were characterized by analysing the surface morphology, coating thickness, pore size
and contact angle. It was found that the formation of micro/nanoporous structure in
the inner layer of aluminium tube with the pore size ranging from 2.05 µm to 3.6 µm
and contact angle less than 10° between the temperature range of 20–35 °C when
10% H2 SO4 solution is used as the electrolyte.
1 Introduction
The capillary rise is a critical parameter for an efficient operation of heat transfer
device such as heat pipe. To enhance the capillary rise, anodization (electrochemical
process) was performed on the inner surface of the aluminium tube. The anodization
process prevents corrosion and also increases the number of nucleation sites by
forming micro/nanopores [1, 2]. By controlling the anodizing parameters, surface
morphology can be modified for efficient heat transfer applications [3, 4]. Singh
et al. [5] studied the thermal performance of anodized flat thermosyphon with a heat
input range of 50–300 W, various fill ratio (40%, 60% and 100%) and different
inclination angles (0°, 45°, 90°). It was found that the thermal resistance was reduced
by more than 20% in the anodized surface when compared to the non-anodized
surface. Also, it was noticed that the pore density was increased up to 90% compared
to the non-anodized surface due to the anodization. Solomon et al. [6] investigated
the thermal performance of anodized two-phase thermosyphon by varying the heat
input in the range of 50–300 W with the combination of R600a and R290 as working
fluid. It was found that the reduction in thermal resistance of 17% to 23% while
varying the inclination angle from 0° to 90°. Further, the heat transfer coefficient
was increased up to 33% for anodized thermosyphon. Solomon et al. [7] studied
the thermal performance of anodized grooved heat pipe with various parameters
such as heat input in the range of 25–250 W, fill ratio of 10–70% and inclination
angle of 0°–90° using R600a as working fluid. It was found that the formation of
micro/nanostructures enhances the heat transfer performance by 39% while reducing
the thermal resistance of 30% compared to the non-anodized surface. Due to the
anodization process, the generation of nucleation site is more; thus, it makes the
surface more wettable and leads to capillary rise and heat transfer. Weng et al. [8]
studied the transfer performance of the anodized heat pipe by developing anodic
aluminium oxide nanotubes in the inner surface of the heat pipe. It was found that heat
transfer was enhanced by 4.12% and the reduction in thermal resistance was 58.68%
by anodization. From the above literature studies, it is evident that the anodized
coating formed in the inner surface of the heat pipe enhances the thermal performance
of the heat pipe. This paper aimed at modifying the surface morphology such as
pore size, coating thickness and surface wettability, which are key for heat transfer
enhancement. Also, the effect of temperature on the pore size, coating thickness and
contact angle of anodized surface is studied and discussed.
2 Experimental Analysis
The anodizing facility consists of three systems, namely the electrolyte flow system,
chilling unit and DC power supply. The aluminium tube of OD 19 mm, ID 16.8 mm
Effect of Temperature on the Surface … 593
Variations of anodizing current with respect to the anodizing time at different tem-
peratures while using H2 SO4 as electrolyte solution during the anodization process is
shown in Fig. 2. During the voltage increment, a thick anodized layer is formed, and
when the voltage is maintained at 15 V, the pore formation starts. After the pore
formation started, the current consumption increases slightly, as shown in Fig. 2.
Therefore, as the temperature is maintained, the increase in current leads to more
prominent pore formation. Also it is noticed that the pore size is increasing with the
increase in temperature of the anodizing cell. Therefore, it was decided to decrease
the temperature further to minimize the pore size. Moreover, the literature suggest-
ing that adding oxalic acid reduces the pore size formation. Therefore, oxalic acid
of 3% is combined with the 7% H2 SO4 solution is considered while decreasing the
temperature. The variation of current at different temperature with respect to the
anodizing time using 7% H2 SO4 + 3% oxalic acid as electrolyte solution is shown
in Fig. 3. It was observed that the current increases with the increase in time for all
anodizing temperatures as similar to H2 SO4 as an electrolyte solution. The thick-
ness of the coating for this combination of electrolyte is skinny, and it is around 3
to 5 µm. Though the thickness of the anodized layer is thin, there were no pores
found on the anodized surface. From these experiments, we can conclude that using
H2 SO4 solution as an electrolyte at an anodizing temperature of 20 °C, the pore size
(2.053 µm) and coating thickness (6.446 µm) are found to be less which is suitable
for enhanced heat transfer applications.
9
8
7
Current (Amps)
6
5 Temp at 35°C
4 Temp at 29°C
3 Temp at 25°C
2 Temp at 20°C
1
0
0 20 40 60 80
Time (Min)
Fig. 2 Variation of current with respect to the anodizing time at different temperatures using H2 SO4
as an electrolyte
Effect of Temperature on the Surface … 595
2.5
Current (Amps)
2
Temp at 10°C
1.5 Temp at 15°C
Temp at 20°C
1
Temp at 25°C
0.5 Temp at 29°C
0
0 20 40 60 80
Time (Min)
Fig. 3 Variation of current with respect to anodizing time at different temperature using 3% oxalic
acid + 7% H2 SO4 as electrolyte
In our previous study [4, 7], anodization results for the electrolyte flow rate of
380 ml/min, the anodizing voltage of 1 to 15 V and the concentration of 10 vol%
of H2 SO4 were discussed. In the present study, the surface morphology of anodized
aluminium tube using H2 SO4 as electrolyte solution with an increase in temperature
is shown in Fig. 4a–d and Table 1. It was found that the pore size is increasing with
the increase in anodizing temperature. The pore size is found to increase suddenly
from 2 to 3.6 µm when the temperature is increased from 29 to 35 °C. The maxi-
mum experimental temperature was limited at 35 °C due to the formation of larger
pore size, which is against our requirement of smaller pore size. To find the thick-
ness of coating formed at the surface of the inner layer, SEM photograph for 10%
of H2 SO4 as electrolyte solution is shown in Fig. 4 (e, f, g and h). A sponge-like
substance was formed in the inner layer of the aluminium tube, which represents the
coating thickness. This sudden decrease in coating thickness may happen due to the
dissolution of the aluminium oxide layer in the inner layer of the tube. A similar
dissolution pattern is common in anodization practices [9]. This dissolution occurs
with consuming more current of 9 A while forming coating at the inner side of the
aluminium tube and if it is continuing the dissolution may take place. With these
above discussions, anodization concerning increasing in temperature may result in
more dissolution. The anodizing temperature of 20 °C with a minimum pore size
of 2.053 µm and minimum coating thickness of 6.44 µm is found to be optimum,
which will be suitable for enhanced heat transfer applications.
Surface morphology of anodized aluminium tube while using 7% H2 SO4 + 3%
oxalic acid as electrolyte solution is given in Fig. 5a–e. It was observed that the
596 A. L. Sriram Sudhan and A. Brusly Solomon
pore size is 4.54 nm for the anodizing temperature of 29 °C. When the anodization
temperature decreases from 29 to 10 °C, there was no pore size noticed. This combi-
nation of 7% H2 SO4 + 3% oxalic acid electrolyte consumes less current (about two
amps) for anodizing compared to 10% H2 SO4 electrolyte. Due to less consumption
of current, the coating layer formed on the inner surface of the aluminium tube is
found to be very thin with cracks and breaks. Though the coating layer is very thin,
it is necessary to estimate the coating thickness from the SEM photographs, and it is
shown in Fig. 5 f–j. With the decrease in anodizing temperature, the coating thickness
also decreases up to a temperature of 15 °C and then starts increasing for 10 °C and
it is around 4.7 µm. As a result, this combination of 7% H2 SO4 + 3% oxalic acid of
electrolyte will not be suitable for anodization since there was no pore formation.
To find the wettability of the anodized surface, the contact angle of the surface was
measured using Drop Shape Analyzer (DSA 25, Kruss GmBH) with a needle diam-
eter of 0.652 mm. The contact angle for the tube anodized using 7% H2 SO4 + 3%
oxalic acid as electrolyte solution is given in Fig. 6a–e. With the increase in tem-
perature, the contact angle was found to be decreasing, and it is in the range of
98.4–135.6°. Further, it was found that the minimum contact angle obtained at a
Table 1 Anodization conditions
Experiment Electrolyte Electrolyte Anodizing Final cell Acid Anodizing Average Average Average
number flow rate Solution Temperature voltage concentration time coating pore size contact
(ml min−1 ) (°C) (Vfinal ) (V/V %) (minutes) thickness (µm) angle (θ)
(µm)
Uncoated – – – – – – – – 110
1 380 H2 SO4 20 15 10 60 6.446 2.053 <10
2 380 H2 SO4 25 15 10 60 7.465 2.167 <10
3 380 H2 SO4 29 15 10 60 10.97 2.333 <10
Effect of Temperature on the Surface …
higher temperature is 29 °C. The minimum contact angle implies that the anodized
surface is hydrophilic, where the solid–liquid interaction is more, which leads the
surface to produce capillary rise. The contact angle for the inner surface of aluminium
tube coated using 10% of H2 SO4 as an electrolyte solution is much less than 10°,
which cannot be measured as the liquid drop is spreading quickly.
Effect of Temperature on the Surface … 599
4 Conclusion
The effects of anodization on the aluminium tube with varying temperature for two
different electrolytes were analysed and discussed. From this study, the following
conclusions arrived.
• The pore size and coating thickness were found to be increasing with an increase
in temperature for anodization using 10% of H2 SO4 as an electrolyte solution
• When the cell temperature was varied from 10 to 30 °C, there were no pores found
in the anodization process with 7% H2 SO4 + 3% oxalic acid as an electrolyte
solution
• H2 SO4 of 10% electrolyte solution with an anodizing temperature of 20 °C is found
to be the optimum conditions due to the minimum the pore size and minimum
coating thickness.
It was noticed that the anodized surface with the above conditions seems to be
more hydrophilic, which will be suitable for enhanced heat transfer applications.
600 A. L. Sriram Sudhan and A. Brusly Solomon
References
Abstract The cutting temperatures during milling operation are high owing to the
hardness of work specimens and due to friction at the tool–work and tool–chip inter-
faces. This elevated temperature results in the deformation of the cutting edges during
dry milling. The most common method employed to reduce the heat that is generated
is the application of cutting fluids in the cutting zone. The tool life during milling is
prominently enhanced by providing a higher quantity of cutting fluid at the cutting
zone. Though the cutting fluid effectively removes heat from the tool, its sudden
application causes thermal shocks in the tool. This thermal shock makes the tool
brittle specifically at the cutting edges resulting in tool wear. Also, coolant appli-
cation has a negative impact on the environment as well as the machine operator’s
health. Moreover, tool cost is higher than the cost of safekeeping and clearing of cut-
ting fluids. Machining with heat pipe is a newly established technique to lower the
problem involved with cutting fluid. Thus, in this experiment, a customized milling
tool is fabricated such that it can house a ring-shaped heat pipe. The experiments
were conducted in conditions of dry milling with no coolant and heat pipe-assisted
cooling. The results obtained in the experiments confirm that milling with heat pipe-
assisted cooling exhibited reduced cutting force and cutting temperature than dry
machining. Thus, heat pipe-assisted cooling can be suggested as an alternative for
conventional methods.
1 Introduction
Milling is the most commonly employed metal removal process in the industry. The
main advantage of the process is that it can create a wide variety of features on
the component by removing the material from the component. In milling, a large
amount of heat is produced at cutting zone due to the shearing of the workpiece by
the milling cutter. In dry machining, the elevated temperature results in high tool wear
and surface finish of the workpiece being poor. Thus, to remove the heat generated,
a large amount of cutting fluid is employed in the cutting zone. Though cutting fluid
aids in better surface finish and increased tool life, it adds up to the indirect cost of
the product. Also, cutting fluid makes the work floor unclean and hazardous to the
operator. Thus, it is suggested to implement heat pipe in the process for the effective
transfer of heat from the tool.
The main objective of the experimental work is to study dry machining and heat
pipe-assisted cooling in the milling process. The parameters considered for the com-
parison are temperature, cutting force and surface roughness. For a proper investi-
gation, a nine-level experimental run was designed with variation in metal cutting
parameters such as spindle speed, feed and depth of cut. The preset values of the
nine-level experimental are given in Table 1.
For the experimental purpose, a new tool was designed and fabricated. The material
used for the fabrication of the tool is HSS. To embed the ring-shaped heat pipe, a
housing position is made using EDM. The metal removal process using EDM was
Cavity for
Heat pipe
carried out in a way that does not weaken the tool as well as enabling the heat
pipe to reach the maximum possible distance near to the cutting zone. A pre-shaped
electrode in the shape of the required cavity is used in the process. The fabricated
tool is shown in Fig. 1.
The heat pipe was made using thin copper plates of 0.5 mm thickness. Special
care was taken in order to maintain the ring shape since any deformation in the
shape would lead to mismatch with the housing slot on the tool. Distilled water is
the working fluid used in the heat pipe. The heat pipe filling is done using a vacuum
pump and is sealed properly. The dimensions of the heat pipe are given in Table 2.
The fabricated heat pipe shown in Fig. 2 is fitted in the housing cavity made on
the tool. The fit was made in such a way that the heat pipe does not come off the tool.
The assembly of milling tool with the heat pipe is shown in Fig. 3.
AISI 1040 steel workpiece was used to carry out experiments with heat pipe-assisted
cooling method. The parameters measured during the experiments were temperature,
surface roughness and cutting force. The cutting force during milling was measured
using a Kistler 9257B dynamometer. Mahr TR100 surface roughness tester of type
Mahr Surf GD 25 was used in measuring the surface roughness of the workpiece.
Experimental Investigation on Heat Pipe-Assisted Cooling … 605
Among the various parameters measured using the surface roughness tester, rough-
ness average (Ra) is considered in the study. The temperature during the milling
operation is measured using Amprobe IR-750 an infrared thermometer.
The fabricated heat pipe is housed on the custom-made milling tool. A heat pipe is
a tool that transfers heat using the ideas of phase transition and thermal conductivity
to transfer heat efficiently. A heat pipe is always fabricated using a high thermally
conductive material like copper. The part of the heat pipe which is exposed to the
higher temperature is the hot interface and part that is exposed to the atmosphere is
the cold interface. At hot interfaces, the liquid which is in contact with the highly
conductive material is converted to vapour. This vapour reaches the cold interface of
the heat pipe where the temperature is low. The vapour at the cold interface due to the
low temperature condenses to become liquid again giving away the latent heat to the
atmosphere. This condensed liquid is then returned to the hot interface by capillary
action, centrifugal force, or gravity and the cycle restarts.
606 I. Kantharaj et al.
Infrared thermometer
Milling Cutter
Work Piece
Vice connected to
Dynamometer
The effect of the milling process was studied under the conditions of dry machining
and heat pipe-assisted machining. The cooling performance of the heat pipe-assisted
cooling in milling is analysed by comparing the values of surface roughness, cutting
temperature and cutting forces.
It is clear from Table 3 that irrespective of speed of spindle, depth of cut and feed
values of surface roughness, cutting force and cutting temperature obtained during
milling with heat pipe cooling has an improvised result in comparison with that of
dry machining. The cutting temperature of dry machining is so high since there is no
external agent such as coolant for heat removal. Due to an increase in temperature and
cutting forces, dry machining results in the improper surface finish of the component.
This elevated temperature of the tool leaves burnt marks on the machined surface of
the component.
Figure 5 shows a comparison of cutting temperatures obtained during each run,
from the graph it is clear that in heat pipe-assisted milling machining happens at a
lower temperature. The heat pipe housed on the milling cutter effectively removes
heat from the cutting zone due to its thermal conductivity and phase transition prop-
erties. This reduced temperature during the milling process aids in the production of
Experimental Investigation on Heat Pipe-Assisted Cooling … 607
good quality of surface finish on the component along with a considerable reduction
in cutting force which is shown in Fig. 6. The surface finish of the obtained compo-
nent is measured for each run of the experiment, and a comparison is made between
dry and heat pipe-assisted milling plotted in the form of a graph as shown in Fig. 7.
Since there is no usage of cutting fluid in the heat pipe-assisted milling process, it
causes no hazard to the environment as well as the operator.
608 I. Kantharaj et al.
4 Conclusion
For the milling process under study, for each experimental run, parameters such as
surface roughness, cutting force and temperature are considered and a comparison
is made between both dry machining and heat pipe-assisted machining. From the
results obtained, it is observed that the heat pipe-assisted milling process exhibited
improved surface finish in comparison with dry machining, due to the lower cutting
temperature observed during the machining process. Also, there is a considerable
reduction in cutting force, thus conserving energy. Since heat pipe-assisted cooling
does not use cutting fluid, it eliminates the process of safekeeping and disposal of
cutting fluid, thereby reducing the cost of the final product. Thus, heat pipe-assisted
milling will serve as a better alternative for conventional dry milling process. This
Experimental Investigation on Heat Pipe-Assisted Cooling … 609
References
1. Shokoohi Y, Paiva JM, Fox-Rabinovich G, Bork CAS, Veldhuis SC (2019) Evaluation of the
superabsorbent coolant as a new approach to semi-dry machining. Int J Adv Manuf Technol
101:2037–2050
2. Kalpakjian S (2001) Manufacturing engineering and technology. Pearson Education India
3. Liew PJ, Shaaroni A, Sidik NAC, Yan J (2017) An overview of current status of cutting fluids
and cooling techniques of turning hard steel. Int J Heat Mass Transf 114:380–394
4. Sharma VS, Dogra M, Suri N (2009) Cooling techniques for improved productivity in turning.
Int J Mach Tools Manuf 49:435–453
5. Chan C, Lee W, Wang H (2013) Enhancement of surface finish using water-miscible nano-
cutting fluid in ultra-precision turning. Int J Mach Tools Manuf 73:62–70
6. Arulraj GA, Wins KLD, Raj A (2014) Artificial neural network assisted sensor fusion model
for predicting surface roughness during hard turning of H13 steel with minimal cutting fluid
application. Proc Mater Sci 5:2338–2346
7. Liang L, Liu X, Li X-Q, Li Y-Y (2015) Wear mechanisms of WC–10Ni3Al carbide tool in dry
turning of Ti6Al4V. Int J Refract Metal Hard Mater 48:272–285
8. Adler D, Hii W-S, Michalek D, Sutherland J (2006) Examining the role of cutting fluids in
machining and efforts to address associated environmental/health concerns. Mach Sci Technol
10:23–58
9. Brinksmeier E, Meyer D, Huesmann-Cordes AG, Herrmann C (2015) Metalworking fluids—
mechanisms and performance. CIRP Ann 64(2):605–628
10. Anton S, Andreas S, Friedrich B (2015) Heat dissipation in turning operations by means of
internal cooling. Proc Eng 100:1116–1123
11. Das SR, Dhupal D, Kumar A (2015) Experimental investigation into machinability of hardened
AISI 4140 steel using TiN coated ceramic tool. Measurement 62:108–126
12. Debnath S, Reddy MM, Yi QS (2016) Influence of cutting fluid conditions and cutting parame-
ters on surface roughness and tool wear in turning process using Taguchi method. Measurement
78:111–119
13. Shokrani A, Dhokia V, Newman ST (2012) Environmentally conscious machining of difficult-
to-machine materials with regard to cutting fluids. Int J Mach Tools Manuf 57:83–101
14. Ghosh S, Rao PV (2015) Application of sustainable techniques in metal cutting for enhanced
machinability: a review. J Clean Prod 100:17–34
15. Robinson Gnanadurai R, Varadarajan AS (2016) Investigation on the effect of cooling of the
tool using heat pipe during hard turning with minimal fluid application. Eng Sci Technol Int J
19(3):1190–1198
16. Stephenson DA, Agapio JS (2016) Metal cutting theory and practice, 3rd edn. CRC Press, Boca
Raton
Development of a Modified Magnetic
Moulding Set up for Improved Heat
Transfer
1 Introduction
Metal casting is one of the widely used primary manufacturing processes. Currently,
there is a greater need for manufacturing processes that can reduce lead time, cost of
manufacturing without compromising on the quality of products. Also, many efforts
are made towards production strategies/processes that reduce damage to the envi-
ronment. Magnetic mould casting is an innovative process having a great potential
to replace conventional casting methods due to various advantages associated with
it. In magnetic moulding steel balls are used instead of moulding sand and an elec-
tromagnetic field, surrounding the moulding flask acts as a binding agent [1]. This
process is similar to the lost foam process because the pattern used is an expend-
able polystyrene pattern. Once the cast metal is solidified the electromagnetic field is
interrupted so that the steel balls would collapse by itself; the part is recovered and the
steel balls could be reused in the subsequent castings [2]. Compared to the moulding
sand (mixture of sand, clay and water) used in sand casting, this mould has no mois-
ture content to generate steam and vapour, which generally results in casting defects
like blow holes and pores when they are trapped in the mould itself [3]. Therefore,
replacing the sand with alternate materials with better thermal conductivity, like steel
balls improves the heat transfer rate and reduces the solidification time of casting.
This paper deals with the development of a modified magnetic moulding set up to
overcome the heat transfer limitations in the conventional magnetic moulding set up.
The type of process employed for casting has an effect over properties like surface
finish, microstructure, hardness, toughness, etc. of the resultant product. Magnetic
mould casting is an application of electromagnetism to the process of casting. Steel
shots constitute the mould that is formed by application of magnetic field on them.
The application of magnetic field induces temporary magnetic force between steel
shots giving strength to mould [4]. This reduces the time elapsed in the ramming
process. Also, breaking of mould becomes easier by using magnetic field, as it is
required to switch off the supply to turn down the magnetic field and mould breaks.
The conventional magnetic moulding set up (Fig. 1) consists of a mild steel con-
tainer inside which the steel balls are filled with the pattern at the center. The pattern
is made using Expendable Polystyrene pattern (EPS) and it is cut according to the
cast product size and shape required. Polystyrene is in solid-state (glassy) at room
Fig. 1 Schematic diagram of the conventional magnetic moulding setup. 1. Steel shots. 2.
Expendable polystyrene pattern (EPS). 3. Container. 4. Copper coil
Development of a Modified Magnetic Moulding … 613
temperature, but when heated above 100 °C it evaporates. Copper coils of 22 gauge
were wound surrounding the mild steel container. The number of turns of the copper
wire was 500 with 8 A DC power supply given.
When the molten metal is poured over the polystyrene pattern, the molten metal
evaporates the polystyrene, and the molten metal takes the shape of the pattern, trans-
fers the heat to the surrounding steel balls, which act as mould wall. This contributes
to nucleation and thereby encourages directional solidification of the mould mate-
rial. In the conventional magnetic moulding set up, the heat that is dissipated from
the molten metal moves towards the steel balls by conduction and then to the mild
steel container wall. Simultaneously, certain amount of heat is generated due to Joule
heating/Ohmic heating, from the current-carrying copper coils that are wound around
the container. This can lead to stagnation of heat in the steel balls and hence lead to
reduction in solidification time for the cast material. To overcome this stagnation of
heat, a modified magnetic moulding set up was developed with a water jacket in the
container wall.
The water jacket was developed such that room temperature water enters inlet
port available at the bottom, the heat is transferred to the water during circulation
and the hot water exits through the top port. The schematic diagram of the modified
magnetic moulding set up is shown in Fig. 2.
3 Calculations
Diameter = 30 mm = 0.03 m
Radius = 15 mm = 0.015 m
614 B. Anand Ronald et al.
Volume of Mould = πr 2 h
= π × (0.015)2 × (0.06)
= 4.24 × 10−5 m3
Mass of Aluminium = Volume × Density
= 4.24 × 10−5 × 2700
= 0.11448 kg
Temperature Difference T = 700 ◦ C − 30 ◦ C
Required = 670 ◦ C
μI
Magnetic Induction B = T
2πr
To find Magnetic Permeability (μ),
Magnetic Permeability for materials
Current I = 3A
μI 2.52117 × 10−6 × 3
Magnetic Induction B = =
2πr 2 × π × 0.001
= 1.20377 × 10−3 T
Actual Magnetic Induction B = N × B
= 500 × 1.20377 × 10−3
= 0.60188 T
Two concentric cylinders are used so that there can be a passage of fluid in between
the walls of the closed cylinder. A cylindrical mild steel pipe is chosen for this
purpose. As per the design calculation, we require a 2 mm thick-walled cylinder so
that magnetic field can penetrate. From the determined flow rate for proper removal
of heat the diameters of the cylinders are selected as 80 and 140 mm (outer diameter).
So in order to achieve the required dimensions 88 and 148 mm mild steel pipe (Outer
diameter) of thickness 4 mm is purchased and is turned using four jaw lathe to 80
and 140 mm diameter with 2 mm thickness (Fig. 3).
5 Conclusions
A Modified Magnetic Mould casting setup was successfully fabricated. Since the
modified set up has a water jacket, it is expected that the modified set up will give bet-
ter heat transfer, which can be ascertained by evaluating (at the outlet port) the amount
of heat carried away. Also after solidification, the mechanical (tensile strength) and
Development of a Modified Magnetic Moulding … 617
metallurgical properties (fine grain size) of the cast material will give insight into the
improvement due to modification of the existing magnetic moulding set up.
References
1. Wittmoser A (1975) The new third generation of molding processes. AFS Trans 63–72
2. Suganth Kumar KJ, Senthilkumaran S, Rajendra Boopathy S, Ramesh A (2008) Theoretical and
experimental investigation of mold strength in magnetic molding compacts. J Mater Process
Technol 205:235–242
3. Rajkolhe R, Khan JG, Gajanan SS (2014) Defects, causes and their remedies in casting process:
a review. Int J Res Advent Technol 2(3). E-ISSN: 2321-9637
4. Anand Ronald B, Arun Prakash C, Suba Karthik M (2016) Influence of steel shots size on tensile
properties of magnetic moulded MMC. Appl Mech Mater 852:118–122
Quality Assessment Studies on AA7075
Plate in Hot Rolling Process
K. Jayakumar
1 Introduction
AA7075 alloy is mainly used in Aircraft fittings, Gears and shafts, Fuse parts, Missile
parts, Worm gears, keys, aircraft, aerospace and defence applications, bike frames,
all-terrain vehicle (ATV) sprockets, etc. It has lower resistance to corrosion than
K. Jayakumar (B)
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Sri Sivasubramaniya Nadar College of Engineering,
Kalavakkam,
Chennai 603110, India
e-mail: kjayakumar@ssn.edu.in
many other aluminum alloys but has significantly better corrosion resistance than
the 2000 series aluminum alloys. Its relatively high cost limits its use. Rolling is the
most important material-forming process by which properties of the materials can be
improved further by grain refinement. In hot rolling, the workpiece is heated nearer to
its recrystallization temperature and hence the compressive force required for defor-
mation is comparatively less and porosity of the rolled metal can be minimized. Also,
the smaller capacity rolling stand can be used for rolling operation. Much research
work has been conducted on the rolling of different aluminum alloys. Panigrahi et al.
[1] did rolling studies on AA7075 alloy at cryogenic and room temperature and they
compared its mechanical properties from tensile tests and hardness testes results.
The conclusion from the study was rolling with cryogenic temperature is good. The
effects of rolling parameters on the mechanical behavior of AA6061 alloy was carried
out by Rajabi et al. [2]. They concluded that higher rolling temperature and strain rate
were improved the tensile strength of the material. Guo et al. [3] suggested that the
true stress-strain curves at 300–500 °C temperature and strain rates of 0.01–10 s−1
were obtained through isothermal compression tests, providing a data basis for the
hot processing map of AA7075 alloy. From 2015 onwards, the accumulative roll
bonding process (ARB) came to replace the conventional rolling to further improve
the properties of the AA alloys. Alvandi et al. [4] studied the mechanical proper-
ties of fine structured AA7075 alloy by ARB process at room temperature. Results
showed that the tensile and hardness of the sample were improved by ARB compared
with alloy with a coarse grain sample. Guo et al. [5] evaluated the microstructure of
hot-rolled AA7075 alloy through Friction Stir Processing (FSP). Major conclusions
were the maximum superplastic elongation of 776.4% was achieved at 500 °C and
strain rate 10−3 s−1 for the hot-rolled AA7075 subjected to one pass FSP. Microstruc-
ture and deformation behavior of Al–Fe–Mn alloys with different Fe contents during
Cold Rolling was tried by Pan et al. [6].
From the available literature, it was found that different researchers have tried to
improve the mechanical properties of the AA7075 alloy by different rolling processes.
But, they evaluated the improvement in properties by destructive testing. However,
the present work focused on the improvement of mechanical properties of AA7075
by hot rolling process and assessment of the mechanical properties by destructive
and nondestructive testing through dye penetrant testing.
2 Experimental Details
Roller
AA7075 sample
using digital vernier caliper and Rockwell hardness tester with B scale respectively.
Initial hardness value obtained as 42.6 HRB and thickness as 6.62 mm.
The hot rolling mill (Maximum Temperature = 1200 °C) facility which is available
in the Department of Metallurgical and Materials Engineering at IIT Madras was
used in the present work. Figure 1 shows the experimental setup with the rolling
of aluminum plate. The hot rolling study was conducted by varying roller rotational
speed, the number of passes and preheating temperature of the workpiece. The rolling
parameter was selected based on trial and error as well as machine constraints. Rolling
pressure or load was kept as constant with 0.5 ton. Eight experiments were conducted
as per three factors with two level-full factor experimental designs due to facility
constrain.
After rolling, the hardness test was conducted for all eight pieces to check the
improvement of hardness. Rockwell B scale hardness test conditions are Load-
100 kg, Indenter-1/16 in. or 1.6 mm diameter ball indenter. Hardness was measured
in each plate at three different locations and the average is considered. Dwell time
of 10–15 s was maintained during the hardness test to allow for elastic recovery.
Thickness variation of the rolled samples was also measured and Table 1 lists the
experimental design with results. During thickness measurement, thickness variation
was observed in all samples from middle to edges. Average of thickness variation
from all samples is 0.03 mm.
Figure 2 shows the samples after the rolling process in which the first sample
which is present in the right end is a not rolled one and the remaining eight pieces
are rolled one as per eight experimental conditions.
To check the internal defect of the rolled samples, Dye penetrant (DP) based
nondestructive testing (NDT) was carried. DP test is sensitive to small surface dis-
continuities/defects, gives real-world results and affordable one than other NDTs.
There are three types of liquids that were used in the DP test and they are cleaner,
penetrant, and developer.
622 K. Jayakumar
The cleaner is used to remove the dust particles on the workpiece surface and the
penetrant is used to fill the surface cracks. Dwell time of 15 min was maintained after
applying penetrant and Fig. 3 shows the rolled plate after applying the developer.
A developer is a nonaqueous wet type one and they are acetone, isopropyl alcohol,
or a propellant that is a combination of these two.
8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Base material
From the DP test after applying developer, sample number 3 and 4 are shown in
Fig. 6 has more surface-level microcracks. The reason is that the rolling process was
carried out with more number of passes (20 numbers), low temperature (350 °C)
with high speed (850 rpm) in those experiments. Due to these effects, the material is
not able to deform and got slightly torn on the edges which caused microcracks.
Overall, from these rolling studies, it was observed that the experiment number 7
and 8 can be recommended for getting good mechanical properties of the AA7075
strip.
4 Conclusions
References
Abstract The manufacturing sector in the modern era is striving hard to reduce the
cost of production by employing innovative techniques. One such technique is hard
turning where the workpiece is heat treated to the requisite hardness, and the final
size and shape of the component are obtained directly through hard turning process.
Hard turning is generally carried out with a huge amount of cutting fluid to enhance
the output performance. Since petroleum-based emulsions are easily available in
the market at reasonable price, they are widely used in industries. Petroleum-based
cutting fluids create a number of environmental and health issues. In this perspective,
pure dry turning is a logical substitute as it does not possess the harmful effects
connected with the cutting fluids. The feasible tool life and surface quality are often
disturbed while carrying out the machining operation under pure dry condition. Under
such circumstances, the concept called minimal cutting fluid application (MCFA)
performs itself as a possible solution. This paper investigates the effect of applying
cutting fluid using MCFA technique at the critical contact zones while hard turning of
H13 steel. An artificial neural network (ANN) model was developed for the prediction
of the main cutting force, and its ability to predict cutting force (F z ) was analyzed.
An effort is made to optimize the cutting parameters to accomplish minimum cutting
force using genetic algorithm.
1 Introduction
and viable [11]. Özel and Karpat used ANN model for predicting flank wear and
surface finish during hard turning [12]. An ANN model was developed by Leo et al.
for predicting surface finish based on ANN during surface milling of AISI 4340 steel
of hardness 43 HRC with minimal fluid application [13].
Genetic algorithm with the basic principle of genetics and evolution is one of the
optimization methods. It mimics biological evolution for solving search and opti-
mization problems [14]. Computer programs based on genetic algorithm approach
helps to produce optimal solutions [15].
The literatures review revealed that, lot of research works have been reported on
the optimization of surface finish and cutting force during hard turning of different
steels but no work is reported on the prediction of cutting force using ANN during
hard turning of H13 steel with minimal cutting fluid application. In this research,
hard turning process was assisted with minimal cutting fluid application technique,
which reduced the usage of cutting fluid to a minimum amount of 8 ml/min. Based on
the earlier researches in the optimization while machining of hardened steels [16], an
attempt was also made to achieve minimum cutting force by optimizing the cutting
parameters using genetic algorithm. The prediction model derived out of GA was
found to be highly accurate with more than 99% accuracy.
H13 tool steel of 45 HRC was used as the workpiece material in this research. It
is one of the toughest tool steels. It has high toughness and red hardness. Its good
hardenability makes it useful in making extrusion tools and dies.
Accordingly, a cylindrical rod of 65 mm diameter with 355 mm length was used
for the experimentation. Table 1 shows the percentage composition of elements in
the workpiece material. The tool used for hard turning was SNMG120408 (MT TT
5100) hard metal inserts and tool holder used was PSBNR2525M12.
3 Experimental Setup
It has been proved by many researchers that the artificial neural network (ANN)
model has better accuracy and yields more admissible results when compared with
the simple tools such as Taguchi method and regression analysis. Artificial neural
network seems to be the most preferable algorithm for developing a predictive model
for complex nature of the hard turning of H13 steel. Artificial neural network was
developed and trained using quickprop (QP) algorithm, and cutting force values
were predicted. The neural network contains one input layer and an output layer.
The hidden layer was changed into single and multi-layer types with the changes in
number of neurons, and cutting force was predicted with the help of best configuration
which gave better coefficient of determination with least MSE error through trial-
and-error method [18]. “Tansig” was considered as the transfer function. Equation (1)
shows the sigmoid function used in this experimentation.
1
F(x) = (1)
1 + e−x
632 K. Leo Dev Wins et al.
In order to get the best possible network structure, ANN model was trained with
80 different network configurations. Some of the network configurations which gave
lower values of RMSEs are presented in Fig. 2. Based on the results, 3-4-1 network
structure was selected with multilayer normal feedforward algorithm.
This ANN model consists of one input layer with three neurons corresponding to
cutting speed, feed rate, and depth of cut, one hidden layer with four neurons, and
an output layer corresponding to cutting force as shown in Fig. 3.
The regression coefficient (R) value of 0.99996 was obtained for the 3-4-1 network
configuration, which is very close to unity, and it shows a close relationship between
observed and predicted data. Table 4 shows the comparison between test patterns with
experimental results for validating the ANN model. The comparison results revealed
Table 5 Optimum
Machining parameter Optimum value
machining parameters using
hybrid ANN-GA approach Cutting speed (m/min) 77.00109
Feed rate (mm/rev) 0.0600000325
Depth of cut (mm) 0.610000123
the good concurrence between the predicted values and experimental results. No
significant interaction effect between the variables was found.
In this present investigation, an effort is made to find the optimum values of cutting
parameters that will lead to minimum cutting force. To solve the optimization problem
for this study, a hybrid ANN-GA approach was used. Predictive model was trained
and developed [19]. The developed artificial neural network (ANN) was used as the
fitness function for genetic algorithm (GA).
The machining parameters leading to minimum cutting force are the optimization
problem in this case. The constraints in this case are cutting speed (77–115 m/min),
feed (0.05–0.1 mm/rev), and depth of cut (0.5–1 mm). The GA parameters used were
population size of 30, mutation rate of 0.1, crossover rate of 0.8, and of uniform
crossover type. The optimum machining parameters which led to minimum cutting
force using hybrid ANN-GA approach are given in Table 5. The optimum cutting
force value obtained was 195.4946 N.
Confirmatory tests were conducted to check the adequacy of the optimum param-
eter combinations, and the experimental results showed good agreement with the
predictions. The confirmatory test results are shown in Table 6.
6 Conclusions
• The developed ANN model can be very much helpful in setting up the machining
parameters to reduce the force needed to achieve the best results.
• The new scheme is well suitable for the industry as it can be directly practiced in
the shop floor with no modifications in the existing setup.
634 K. Leo Dev Wins et al.
References
18. Zhang G, Patuwo BE, Hu MY (1998) Forecasting with artificial neural network; The state of
the art. Int J Forecast 14:35–62
19. Mia M, Dhar NR (2017) Prediction and optimization by using SVR, RSM and GA in hard
turning of tempered AISI 1060 steel under effective cooling condition. Neural Comput Appl
1–22
Experimental Study of the Effect
of TiN–Zn Coated High-Speed Steel
Cutting Tool on Surface Morphology
of AL1060 Alloy During Machining
Operation
1 Introduction
Coating and its application in cutting tool used for metal to metal machining are
very significant, as the coatings help to improve the wear rate of the cutting tool life,
prevent the cutting tool from corrosion attack, increases the electrical, thermal, and
mechanical characteristic of the cutting tool material, which enables the cutting tool
to withstand high temperature at the cutting zone and vibration during machining
operations [1–3]. Machining operations are greatly affected by the cutting tools.
The continuous failures of cutting tools during machining operations can give rise
to high cost of production of mechanical parts [4, 5]. Coating is the application of
additives on the surface of working materials for improved mechanical properties.
The state-of-the-art technology during the machining process is the use of coated
cutting tool. Improvements in covering hardware and procedures currently empower
us to deliver a wide scope of various hard nitride and oxidic films and to store them
on different apparatus substrates as monolayer, multilayer, or composite coatings [4,
6–13]. Ghani et al. [14] examined the wear rate of carbide cutting tool coated with
titanium nitride (TiN) and the uncoated carbide cutting tool, using different values
of machining speed, feed rate, and depth of cut. From the result, the authors confirm
that the uncoated cutting tool, crack with little or no time and the wear rate with
the machining parameters were very high, when compared with the carbide cutting
tool coated with TiN. Huang [15] also carried out tool evaluation in associations of
tool life centered on flank wear at standard machining conditions, such as machining
speed, depth of cut, and feed rate. They discovered that machining speed plays a
great role in analyzing the tool life evaluation, due to the fact that the increase of the
cutting speed led to gradual reduction of the tool wear, followed by depth of cut and
feed rate.
According to Schulz et al. [16] who worked on the chemical vapor deposition
(CVD) and physical vapor deposition (PVD) of TiN, TiC, and TiAl on cutting tool,
the result shows that the cutting tool life was improved significantly when compared
with the uncoated cutting tool. Fahad [17] confirmed that the application TiN coating
on the cutting tool leads to a great reduction of heat from getting to the cutting tool,
the heat rate was analyzed and the coated cutting decrease the heat by 17% for
traditional cutting speed and 60% for high-speed machining region.
The comparison of different coatings on cutting tools and uncoated cutting tools
were also studied by Astrand et al. [18] on heat distribution in the cutting tool.
This proves that coating has great influence in tool flank face and racks on the tool
wear. Grzesik [19] and Corduan et al. [20] also confirm that the multilayer coatings on
cutting tool done by physical vapor deposition performed better when compared with
the chemical vapor deposition method. Bayraktar et al. [21] produced a permanent
Al-35Zn alloy using mold casting method and carried out cutting evaluations on
Experimental Study of the Effect of TiN–Zn Coated … 639
titanium aluminum nitride (TiAlN) coated carbide tool with ordinary carbide tool
without coatings on A-35Zn alloy during end milling operation. The study employs
CNC vertical milling machining center, using a constant feed rate, depth of cut and
machining speed. From their result it is clearly seen that the TiAlN increases the
cutting force and the surface roughness when compared with the uncoated cutting
tool during the machining operation, the authors clamped that the coatings applied
reduce the contact area between the cutting tool and the working material, which also
reduces the sharpness of the cutting teeth. Quadrini [22], Qin [23] and Heaney [24]
contradict this study, saying surface roughness and cutting force can be optimized
with the application of coated cutting tool with smaller grain size.
According to Tamerabet et al. [25] the elimination of the lubrication process
from machining operation, which is dry machining process, gives a clear picture to
study and know all the factors that can lead to cutting tool damages. To optimize
the cutting condition, there is need to know the wear pattern, contact angles, and the
factors in the operating environment, this idea is to select the important or the most
influential factor values that can help to eliminate the wear behavior. The work of
the authors focusses on the application of multilayer coating on the cutting tool and
the optimization of the cutting parameters on tool wear and temperature at the tool-
chip cutting region for two different cutting tools of KC810 and KC910 during dry
turning of SAE 1030 carbon steel. The study is to achieve the optimized cutting tool
conditions using Taguchi techniques. The result shows that machining speed is the
most significant parameter on the wear rate study and the temperature distribution.
From the observations of the authors, the KC810 applied to perform better during the
turning of carbon steel with a longer lifetime of 228 min during operation. Cutting
tool also has a great impact on surface roughness of the mechanical component if not
properly optimized and controlled. From the study carried out from [26–32] shows
that vibration and surface roughness can also be affected by coated cutting tool and
non-coated cutting tool. Therefore, the need to study cutting tool performance on
surface roughness is very significant.
However, this experimental study is aimed at analyzing the performance of coated
TiN–Zn HSS cutting tool on surface morphology during the machining operation of
Aluminum 1060 alloy.
The material used for this research work are coated HSS cutting tool, non-coated
HSS and AL1060 alloy rectangular bar size of length of 2000 mm, width of 50 mm
and thickness of 5 mm. The machining experiment was carried out using WARCO
X6323A vertical milling machine, Vernier caliper, Steel rule, Mitutoyo surface
roughness tester. After each experiment, the surface morphology is studied by mea-
suring the surface with the Mitutoyo surface roughness tester, in order to determine
the effects of the coated cutting tool on the surface morphology of AL1060 alloy.
Tables 1 and 2 shows the chemical composition, mechanical, thermal and physical
properties of AL1060 alloy.
640
Table 2 Physical,
Properties Units
mechanical, and thermal
properties of AL1060 alloy Density 2700 kg/m3
Melting start (solidus) 649 °C
Tensile strength 130 MPa
Yield strength 94 MPa
Elastic modulus 80 GPa
Poisson’s ratio 0.33
Thermal expansion 23.6 (10−6 /°C)
Thermal conductivity 234 (mK)
Table 3, present the parameters employed for the machining analysis, of different
axial depth of cut, while the cutting speed and feed rate were kept constant. Figure 1,
shows the experimental set up of the SIEG 3/10/0016 milling machine employed
for this research work. After each machining process, the surface morphology is
measured with the surface roughness tester and the machining process was carried
out between 15 and 500 s, under the dry machining conditions.
4.06
3.96
SURFACE MORPHOLOGY μM
3.45
3.35
3.06
2.96
1.875
2.01
1.775
1.91
1.84
1.76
1.74
1.66
1.66
1.56
1.355
1.255
1.31
1.21
1.06
0.96
Fig. 1 Surface morphology variation versus cutting time with depth of cut of 1 mm, machining
speed 1250 rpm and feed rate 10 mm/rev for TiN–Zn coated HSS and non-coated HSS
4.79
4.7
SURFACE MORPHOLOGY (μM)
3.68
3.59
3.26
3.17
2.082
1.992
1.972
1.882
1.86
1.79
1.77
1.73
1.64
1.372
1.7
1.318
1.282
1.228
1.083
0.993
Fig. 2 Surface morphology variation versus cutting time with depth of cut of 1.5 mm, machining
speed 1250 rpm and feed rate 10 mm/rev for TiN–Zn coated HSS and non-coated HSS
Experimental Study of the Effect of TiN–Zn Coated … 643
4.81
DOC = 2 mm (HSS) DOC = 2 mm (TiN-Zn HSS)
4.73
SURFACE MORPHOLOGY (μM)
4.01
3.93
3.56
3.48
2.66
2.58
2.04
1.96
1.91
1.85
1.83
1.77
1.76
1.68
1.485
1.405
1.36
1.28
1.092
1.012
Fig. 3 Surface morphology variation versus cutting time with depth of cut of 2 mm, machining
speed 1250 rpm and feed rate 10 mm/rev for TiN–Zn coated HSS and uncoated HSS
4.86
DOC= 2.5 mm (HSS) DOC = 2.5 mm (TiN-Zn HSS)
4.9
4.35
4.29
SURFACE MORPHOLOGY (μM)
3.76
3.7
3.06
3
2.06
1.94
1.88
1.86
1.81
1.75
1.555
1.495
1.8
2
1.43
1.37
1.101
1.041
Fig. 4 Surface morphology variation versus cutting time with depth of cut of 2.5 mm, machining
speed 1250 rpm and feed rate 10 mm/rev for TiN–Zn coated HSS and non-coated HSS
644 I. P. Okokpujie et al.
4.98
4.87
4.66
4.59
SURFACE MORPHOLOGY (μM)
4.06
3.99
3.43
3.36
2.26
2.19
1.96
1.91
1.89
1.85
1.84
1.78
1.558
1.488
1.472
1.402
1.115
1.045
Fig. 5 Surface morphology variation versus cutting time with depth of cut of 3 mm, machining
speed 1250 rpm and feed rate 10 mm/rev for TiN–Zn coated HSS and non-coated HSS
were significant reductions in the surface roughness across the various depths of cut
applied in this study, from Figs. 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5. This result is in line with Fahad [16]
but it contradicted the study done by Bayraktar et al. [20] applying TiAlN coatings on
carbide cutting tool during machining Al-35Zn alloy. From the study it was observed
during the development of the said coatings, there was no critical consideration of
the coating thickness put in place so when it was deposited on the cutting tool it
caused the coated cutting tool to have a blunt surface, which definitely increases the
cutting force and the surface roughness during operations.
4 Conclusion
The study of TiN–Zn coated HSS cutting tool on surface morphology of aluminum
1060 alloys during machining operation has been done experimentally. From the
study, it has been confirmed that TiN–Zn coated HSS cutting tool when compared
with the uncoated HSS cutting tool during machining operations has significant
effects on the surface morphology of the aluminum 1060 alloy during the machining
operation. The following finding was observed
Experimental Study of the Effect of TiN–Zn Coated … 645
• The experimental result proves that cutting time has a great effect on surface
morphology, as the cutting time and the depth of cut increases there was continuous
increase in the surface morphology (roughness).
• The minimum surface morphology of 0.96 and 1.06 µm was achieved for the
TiN–Zn coated and uncoated HSS cutting tool at a cutting time of 15 s at 1 mm
depth of cut.
• From the observation, during the machining operation, the TiN–Zn coated HSS
cutting tool was able to perform at high temperature at the cutting zone without
loosening its hardness.
Acknowledgements The author wishes to appreciate the covenant university management for their
sponsorship.
References
1. Ucun İ, Aslantas K, Bedir F (2013) An experimental investigation of the effect of coating
material on tool wear in micro milling of Inconel 718 super alloy. Wear 300(1–2):8–19
2. Okokpujie IP, Ohunakin OS, Bolu CA, Okokpujie KO (2018) Experimental data-set for pre-
diction of tool wear during turning of Al-1061 alloy by high speed steel cutting tools. Data
Brief 1(18):1196–1203
3. Ezugwu CA, Okonkwo UC, Sinebe JE, Okokpujie IP (2016) Stability analysis of model regen-
erative chatter of milling process using first order least square full discretization method. Int J
Mech Appl 6(3):49–62
4. Nwoke ON, Okonkwo UC, Okafor CE, Okokpujie IP (2017) Evaluation of chatter vibration
frequency in CNC turning of 4340 alloy steel material. Int J Sci Eng Res 8(2):487–495
5. Afolalu SA, Salawu EY, Okokpujie IP, Abioye AA, Abioye OP, Udo M, Adetunji OR, Ikuma-
payi OM (2017) Experimental analysis of the wear properties of carburized HSS (ASTM A600)
cutting tool. Int J Appl Eng Res 12(19):8995–9003
6. Ogundimu O, Lawal SA, Okokpujie IP (2018) Experimental study and analysis of variance of
material removal rate in high speed turning of AISI 304L alloy steel. In: IOP conference series:
materials science and engineering, vol 413, no 1, p 012030. IOP Publishing, UK
7. Afolalu SA, Okokpujie IP, Salawu EY, Abioye AA, Abioye OP, Ikumapayi OM (2018) Study
of the performances of nano-case treatment cutting tools on carbon steel work material during
turning operation. In: AIP conference proceedings, vol 1957, no 1, p 050001. AIP Publishing,
New York
8. Afolalu SA, Abioye AA, Idirisu J, Okokpujie IP, Ikumapayi OM (2018) Abrasion wear of
cutting tool developed from recycled steel using palm kernel shell as carbon additive. Prog Ind
Ecol Int J 12(1/2):206–218
9. Okokpujie IP, Ikumapayi OM, Okonkwo UC, Salawu EY, Afolalu SA, Dirisu JO, Nwoke ON,
Ajayi OO (2017) Experimental and mathematical modeling for prediction of tool wear on the
machining of aluminium 6061 alloy by high speed steel tools. Open Eng 7(1):461–469
10. Okokpujie IP, Salawu EY, Nwoke ON, Okonkwo UC, Ohijeagbon IO, Okokpujie KO (2018)
Effects of process parameters on vibration frequency in turning operations of perspex material,
pp 700–707
11. Afolalu SA, Abioye OP, Salawu EY, Okokpujie IP, Abioye AA, Omotosho OA, Ajayi OO
(2018) Impact of heat treatment on HSS cutting tool (ASTM A600) and its behaviour during
machining of mild steel (ASTM A36). In: AIP conference proceedings, vol 1957, no 1, p
050003. AIP Publishing, New York
646 I. P. Okokpujie et al.
12. Afolalu SA, Abioye AA, Dirisu JO, Okokpujie IP, Ajayi OO, Adetunji OR (2018) Investigation
of wear land and rate of locally made HSS cutting tool. In: AIP conference proceedings, vol
1957, no 1, p 050002. AIP Publishing, New York
13. Afolalu SA, Oluwaseyifunmi O, Ongbali SO, Abioye AA, Okokpujie IP, Oloyede OR (2018)
The study of the impact of nano carbon additives on ASTM A53 mild steel during machining.
In: IOP conference series: materials science and engineering, vol 413, no 1, p 012028. IOP
Publishing, UK
14. Ghani JA, Choudhury IA, Masjuki HH (2004) Wear mechanism of TiN coated carbide
and uncoated cermets tools at high cutting speed applications. J Mater Process Technol
10(153):1067–1073
15. Huang Y, Liang SY (2005) Effect of cutting conditions on tool performance in CBN hard
turning. J Manuf Process 7(1):10–16
16. Schulz U, Peters M, Bach FW, Tegeder G (2003) Graded coatings for thermal, wear and
corrosion barriers. Mater Sci Eng A 362(1–2):61–80
17. Fahad M, Mativenga PT, Sheikh MA (2012) A comparative study of multilayer and functionally
graded coated tools in high-speed machining. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 62(1–4):43–57
18. Åstrand M, Selinder TI, Fietzke F, Klostermann H (2004) PVD-Al2 O3 -coated cemented carbide
cutting tools. Surf Coat Technol 188:186–192
19. Grzesik W, Van Luttervelt CA (2005) Analytical models based on composite layer for com-
putation of tool-chip interface temperatures in machining steels with multilayer coated cutting
tools. CIRP Ann 54(1):91–94
20. Corduan N, Himbart T, Poulachon G, Dessoly M, Lambertin M, Vigneau J, Payoux B (2003)
Wear mechanisms of new tool materials for Ti-6AI-4V high performance machining. CIRP
Ann 52(1):73–76
21. Bayraktar S, Hekimoglu AP, Turgut Y, Haciosmanoglu M (2018) A performance comparison
study of uncoated and TiAlN coated carbide end mill on machining of the Al-35Zn alloy.
In: IOP conference series: materials science and engineering, vol 295, no 1, p 012013. IOP
Publishing, UK
22. Quadrini F, Tagliaferri V, Polini R (2008) Effect of coating roughness on performance of small
CVD diamond coated tools. Mach Sci Technol 12(3):390–404
23. Qin F, Chou YK, Nolen D, Thompson RG (2009) Coating thickness effects on diamond coated
cutting tools. Surf Coat Technol 204(6–7):1056–1060
24. Heaney PJ, Sumant AV, Torres CD, Carpick RW, Pfefferkorn FE (2008) Diamond coatings
for micro end mills: enabling the dry machining of aluminum at the micro-scale. Diam Relat
Mater 17(3):223–233
25. Tamerabet Y, Brioua M, Tamerabet M, Khoualdi S (2018) Experimental investigation on tool
wear behavior and cutting temperature during dry machining of carbon steel SAE 1030 using
KC810 and KC910 coated inserts. Tribol Ind 40(1)
26. Okonkwo UC, Okokpujie IP, Sinebe JE, Ezugwu CA (2015) Comparative analysis of alu-
minium surface roughness in end-milling under dry and minimum quantity lubrication (MQL)
conditions. Manuf Rev 2(30):1–11
27. Okokpujie IP, Okonkwo UC (2015) Effects of cutting parameters on surface roughness during
end milling of aluminium under minimum quantity lubrication (MQL). Int J Sci Res 4(5):2937–
2942
28. Nwoke ON, Okokpujie IP, Ekenyem SC (2017) Investigation of creep responses of selected
engineering materials. J Sci Eng Dev Environ Technol (JOSEDET) 7(1):1–5
29. Okokpujie IP, Ajayi OO, Afolalu SA, Abioye AA, Salawu EY, Udo M (2018) Modeling and
optimization of surface roughness in end milling of aluminium using least square approximation
method and response surface methodology. Int J Mech Eng Technol (IJMET) 9(1):587–600
30. Dunmade I, Udo M, Akintayo T, Oyedepo S, Okokpujie IP (2018) Lifecycle impact assessment
of an engineering project management process—a SLCA approach. In: IOP conference series:
materials science and engineering, vol 413, no 1, p 012061. IOP Publishing, UK
31. Okokpujie I, Okonkwo U, Okwudibe C (2015) Cutting parameters effects on surface roughness
during end milling of aluminium 6061 alloy under dry machining operation. Int J Sci Res
4(7):2030–2036
Experimental Study of the Effect of TiN–Zn Coated … 647
32. Chuan SP, Ghani JA, Tomadi SH, Hassan CH (2012) Analysis of Ti-base hard coating
performance in machining process: a review. J Appl Sci (Faisalabad) 12(18):1882–1890
Experimental Investigation of Surface
Roughness in End Milling of AA6061
Alloy with Flooded Cooling
and Minimum Quantity Lubrication
(MQL) Technique
1 Introduction
Nowadays, modern industries are looking for ways to reduce the use of lubricants in
metal cutting operations due to ecological and economical limitations. Lubrication
in the machining process becomes one of the most important challenges. Almost
conventional flooded lubrication with water-based lubricants in high-speed machin-
ing has a negative effect on tool life [1]. Although various lubricants are used in the
industries, unfortunately, these cutting fluids have many negative characteristics like
costly; need more quantity; they need a periodical replacement; and, lead to health
and environmental issues [2, 3]. Minimum Quantity Lubrication otherwise called
“micro lubrication” is the latest technique used for delivering coolant at the tool–
workpiece interface. In order to improve the effectiveness of high-speed machining,
D. Nathan (B)
Dr. Mahalingam College of Engineering and Technology, Pollachi, India
e-mail: nathan14576@gmail.com
D. Elilraja · T. Prabhuram · S. Prathap Singh
St. Joseph’s Institute of Technology, Chennai, India
© Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd. 2021 649
S. Vijayan et al. (eds.), Trends in Manufacturing and Engineering Management,
Lecture Notes in Mechanical Engineering,
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-15-4745-4_58
650 D. Nathan et al.
MQL came into existence because it assists in lowering temperature in chip tool inter-
face as well as tool–workpiece interface and maintains the sharpness of the cutting
edges. Vegetable oil or synthetic easter oil are used instead of mineral oil which can
improve lubrication properties in MQL [4]. The exposure to flooded metal cutting
fluid may lead to adverse health effects and safety issues, including toxicity, cancer,
dermatitis, and respiratory disorders [5]. Comparative experiments were performed
to investigate machining of titanium alloy (Ti–6Al–4V) and difficult-to-cut alloys
under different lubrication conditions such as dry, MQL, and high-pressure air [6].
Although dry machining without using any cutting fluids may result in tremendous
environmental and economic benefits, it suffers a rise in temperature at workpiece tool
interface and hence reduced tool life. The goal of MQL is to use the minimum amount
of cutting fluids during machining, typically of a flow rate of 50–500 ml/h. Out of
total machining costs, 7–17% of the cost is spent for cutting fluids while 15–20%
of total machining cost is used for coolants compared to the tool cost which ranges
from 2 to 4% [7–9]. Thus minimum use of lubricants in machining can be a prime
indicator of sustainable manufacturing. End milling is one of the most widely used
machining operations in the industry because of its high MRR and good surface qual-
ity [10]. Usually, in the end milling process, abundant amounts of liquid coolant are
applied. Since liquid coolant provides intermittent cooling in end milling causes an
increase in temperature variations at the tool–workpiece interface and hence buildup
edge [11]. MQL has been effectively applied in increasing tool life while machining
components [12]. Also, the MQL technique possesses many advantages over dry,
air and flooded lubrication besides requiring some accessories and attachment like
chip removal system in machine tool [13]. MQL parameters such as lubricant flow
rate, nozzle angle, and distance between the nozzle tip and the tool cutting edge have
remarkable effects on the machining performance also in their work optimal condi-
tion of nozzle distance, MQL flow rate and nozzle angle using Taguchi Method [14].
The influence of dry, flood and minimum quantity lubrication on diameter error and
circularity was studied in aluminium, mild steel 1030 and alloy steel 4340 and found
that circularity has a significant effect [15]. Significant parameters for end milling of
AA6061T6 alloy end milling using an HSS tool under flood cooling were studied in
the statistical method and Genetic Algorithm [16]. Due to high adhesive properties
and smearing effects on the cutting tool edges, effective lubrication is required for
aluminium alloys [17]. However, very few investigations found employing MQL
into the end milling of aluminium alloys [18]. Although most of the researches have
been concerned mainly with the turning, drilling and grinding processes involved
with MQL. The role of MQL is still to be explored in end milling [19]. This leads to
further exploration of the effect of MQL in end milling of aluminium alloys. Hence
in this study, end milling of aluminium alloy is investigated by comparing the surface
roughness of the components machined under flooded cooling and MQL cooling.
Experimental Investigation of Surface Roughness in End Milling … 651
2.1 Materials
A custom-designed MQL set up was fabricated for this study. Compressed air at 2 bar
pressure is passed through the FRL unit. Then at the mixing chamber, compressed
air is mixed with coolant at 6.588 l/h. A nozzle of diameter 2 mm sprayed out the
coolant air mixture at the tool–workpiece zone as shown in Fig. 1. Figure 2 describes
the arrangement of MQL setup.
652
Table 2 Properties of
Properties Value
AA6061 aluminium alloy
Density (ρ) 2.70 g/cm3
Young’s modulus (E) 68.9 GPa
Tensile strength (σ t ) 124–290 MPa
Elongation (ε) at break 12–25%
Poisson’s ratio (v) 0.33
Melting temperature (T m ) 585 °C
Thermal conductivity (K) 151–202 W/m-K
Specific heat capacity (c) 897 J/kg-K
Table 3 Machining
Exp. No. Speed (rpm) Feed (mm/min) Depth of cut
parameters
(mm)
1 700 200 0.4
2 700 200 0.8
3 700 200 1.0
4 700 500 0.4
5 700 500 0.8
6 700 500 1.0
7 700 1000 0.4
8 700 1000 0.8
9 700 1000 1.0
10 1500 200 0.4
11 1500 200 0.8
12 1500 200 1.0
13 1500 500 0.4
14 1500 500 0.8
15 1500 500 1.0
16 1500 1000 0.4
17 1500 1000 0.8
18 1500 1000 1.0
19 2000 200 0.4
20 2000 200 0.8
21 2000 200 1.0
22 2000 500 0.4
23 2000 500 0.8
24 2000 500 1.0
25 2000 1000 0.4
26 2000 1000 0.8
27 2000 1000 1.0
654 D. Nathan et al.
Mixing Nozzle
Chamber
Figure 3 describes that, at 700 rpm, the highest surface roughness values were
observed at 1000 mm/min feed with flood cooling. Lowest surface roughness val-
ues were given by 200 mm/min with flood cooling. Comparing the various depth
Experimental Investigation of Surface Roughness in End Milling … 655
Fig. 3 Influence of depth of cut and feed with surface roughness at 700 rpm
of cut, the lowest depth of cut of 0.4 mm produces low surface roughness. Irre-
spective of depth of cut, almost minimum variation in surface roughness observed
in 500 mm/min feed with flood cooling. Even under flood cooling higher feed rate
results in lesser heat dissipation at the workpiece and cutting edge interface subse-
quently increases the surface roughness values. At higher feed rate with MQL, it is
evident that heat dissipation is still lower as the depth cut increases which results in
a higher gradient of surface roughness. Hence, the strong influence of flood cooling
at this speed, feed, and depth of cut combinations were observed.
Figure 4 reveals that, at 1500 rpm, lower feed of 200 mm/min MQL end milling
operation produces lowest surface roughness because of sufficient heat dissipation
with MQL was achieved at the tool chip interface. On the other hand, the higher
feed rate of 1000 mm/min with MQL gives the highest surface roughness by sticking
phenomena of aluminium chips due to insufficient exposure of lubricant at the tool–
workpiece interface. At lower feed rate, irrespective of the depth of cut it is evident
that flood cooling produces almost constant surface roughness values as the heat
dissipation and consequently low friction at tool chip interface.
From Fig. 5, at highest cutter speed and feed rate, as the temperature at the tool–
workpiece interface became high, it is evident that MQL produces the highest surface
656 D. Nathan et al.
Fig. 4 Influence of depth of cut and feed with surface roughness at 1500 rpm
Fig. 5 Graph showing influence of depth of cut and feed with surface roughness at 2000 rpm
contribution of each parameter under the MQL condition. From Table 4 it is evident
that feed rate is the most significant parameter with 55.09% contribution and followed
by the speed with 40.7% contribution of the total effect. The linear model expresses
that 89.25% variability in surface roughness.
Table 5 describes the result of ANOVA under flood cooling for surface roughness
with linear model prediction. From Table 5 it is observed that speed gives a major
contribution of 53.41% followed by 46.3% of contribution by feed rate in minimizing
surface roughness. The model has 72.87% variability in surface roughness.
Figure 6 describes the comparison of surface roughness values of the end milled
specimens both under minimum quantity lubrication and flood cooling for various
experiments. From the comparison graph, it is found that a considerable amount of
deviation in the surface roughness values has been noted. The trend line deviates
much in MQL cutting conditions compared with flood cooling conditions.
From literature, MQL increases tool life and reduces surface roughness in machin-
ing, but this work gives contradictory results. However, other researchers claimed
that MQL application has given poor tool life compared to flood cooling conditions
in some work tool material combinations. Many researchers argued that cooling
method or machining performance depends on workpiece tool material. This study
supports the argument and hence AA6061 aluminium alloy and carbide coated tool
worsen surface roughness in end milling operation.
658 D. Nathan et al.
Fig. 6 Comparison of surface roughness values between MQL cooling and flood cooling
4 Conclusions
End milling of AA6061 aluminium alloy with a carbide-coated end mill tool under
MQL and flooded cooling conditions were performed successfully by varying cut-
ter speed, feed, and depth of cut. Within the limitations of current research, it was
concluded that the application of MQL does not give favorable results in reduc-
ing surface roughness compared with the flooded cooling condition. The surface
roughness of AA6061 machined with MQL was higher than that obtained with flood
cooling method irrespective of the other cutting conditions. ANOVA was employed
to investigate the significant parameters for surface roughness under both MQL and
flood cooling conditions. As future work, other MQL settings such as distance from
the nozzle tip to the tool–workpiece interface, angle of impinging spray, coolant flow
rate and compressed air pressure are to be optimized.
References
1. Dhar NR, Islam S, Kamruzzaman M (2007) Effect of minimum quantity lubrication (MQL)
on tool wear, surface roughness and dimensional deviation in turning AISI-4340 steel. G.U. J
Sci 20(2):23–32
2. Rozzi JZ, Sanders JK, Chen W (2010) The experimental and theoretical evaluation of an indirect
cooling system for machining. J Heat Transf 133(3):1–10
Experimental Investigation of Surface Roughness in End Milling … 659
Abstract An attempt is made in this research work to study the influence of filler
wire materials on the dissimilar alloys between SS321 and SS347 are made using
Robotic MIG welding process Preliminary experimental welding trials are conducted
by varying the MIG welding process parameters like current, welding speed and stick
out the distance. The prepared metal coupons of two different stabilized stainless
steels are welded using ER321 as well as ER347 filler wires. The performance of
the joint is studied by mechanical testing and microstructural characterization. The
results of mechanical testing showed that the welded joint with ER347 filler wire
exhibited improved tensile strength and hardness value than the joint made by ER321
filler wire.
1 Introduction
The highest demand for enhanced material performance in both military and civilian
sectors is the main driving force for advances in new alloys and technologies for
newer designs. In this work type 321 stainless steel, an austenitic alloy is stabilized
with titanium, making it resistant to intergranular attack caused by chromium car-
bide precipitation is joined using gas metal arc welding with dissimilar 347 which
resembles the same chemical composition using two different filler wires ER321 and
ER347 the specimens are prepared and welded in specific conditions and tested for
mechanical properties along with microstructure.
It is identified that stabilized austenitic stainless steel such as 347 and 321 are
widely used in components designed for high-temperature applications like nuclear
reactors, boilers, superheaters and chemical reactors [1]. This material can be selected
for high temperatures services due to its high creep and intergranular corrosion
resistance. However, for services into the sensitization range of temperatures (450–
850 °C) [2]. Austenitic stainless steel type AISI 321, has an incredible resistance to
corrosion and oxidation [3].
2 Experimental Procedure
The grade SS347 is chosen as one of the dissimilar parent alloys which are stabilized
austenitic stainless steel with the addition of niobium. The intermittent temperature
is about 800–1650 °F (427–897 °C). It is nonmagnetic. The grade SS321 is another
alloy to be welded with 347 which is a stabilized austenitic stainless steel which is
similar to SS304 but with a titanium addition of at least five times the carbon content.
The intermittent temperature is about 800–1500 °F (427–816 °C). It is normally
magnetic. This grade is equivalent to SS304 in the annealed condition and stronger
if weldments in these grades have not subjected to annealing or if this grade is put
into general service in the 420–900 °C range. Table 1 gives the material composition
of the alloys.
This alloy has been extensively used in Expansion joints Spiral Welded tube for burner
pipes and flues, Bellows, Woven or welded screens for high-temperature mineral
processing Furnace parts, Heating element tubing, Heat Exchangers. Due to the
above-said reasons, their weld characteristics have been studied. Stabilized austenitic
stainless steel (SS) such as type 347 and 321 are widely used in components designed
for high-temperature applications like nuclear reactors, boilers, superheaters and
chemical reactors [1].
2.2.1 Experiment
The experiment is carried out in robotic gas metal arc welding machine shown in
Figs. 1 and 2. The specifications of the GMA welding setup is DM 350 MIG power
source of OTC Daihen. GMA welding torch was attached with a 6 axis OTC Daihen
robot. The experimental study denotes that MIG weld process provides higher quality
Table 1 Composition of 321/347 grades
Grade C Mn Si P S Cr Mo Ni N Other
321 Min – 2.00 0.75 0.045 0.030 17.0 – 9.0 0.10 T=5(C+N)
Max 0.08 – – – – 19.0 – 12.0 – 0.70
347 Min 0.08 2.00 0.75 0.045 0.030 17.0 – 9.0 0.10 Nb=10(C+N)
Performance Study of Dissimilar Alloy Joints of SS321 …
welds in a wide variety of metal and alloys. Therefore, it is most commonly used to
join stainless steel and other metals. The helium and argon are shielding gases that
are used to protect the welding zone from the atmosphere [4].
The specimen preparation is carried out to get sound welding joints.
The specimen size is 100 × 50 × 6 mm (two pieces). The butt weld joint is
preferred. The specimen is set to resist the degrees of freedom in a welding fixture
available. The welding is carried out with parameters arrived from the previous
literature. The welding current is chosen as 140 A for welding. The filler wire of two
types one is ER321 and ER347 is taken. The specimens were welded using ER321
and ER347 separately and subject to mechanical test.
The tensile tests were carried out at room temperature, specifically, the methods of
determination of yield strength, ultimate tensile strength, elongation, and reduction
of area. The specimens were prepared according to ASTM E8. The tests were carried
out in x-direction and with Tinius Olsen H50KL tensile testing machine. The Fig. 3
shows the specimen size as per the standards.
Some of the literature findings reveal that the tensile test sample fractures occurred
at the base metal of SS321 austenitic stainless steel, which shows that the strength
of the welded joint was better than that of base metal [5].
The tensile test provides data on the strength and ductility of materials under
uniaxial tensile stresses. The results of the tensile test, which was conducted for
dissimilar welds of low alloy steel to austenitic stainless steel, showed that fracture
happened in the HAZ of low alloy steel [6].
In this work, it is studied that the tensile strength of the base metals SS321 and
347 is about 515 MPa. After welding the dissimilar combination, the specimens were
subjected to tensile test. The results of the tensile tests were shown in Table 2. The
comparison is to find the best suitable filler wire for the dissimilar alloy combinations
having high tensile strength. It is found that the weld specimen of the combination
of filler wire 347 and welding current 160 A has high tensile strength.
The stress–strain curve is shown in Fig. 4 for the weld specimen welded with filler
ER347. The ultimate tensile strength is obtained at 18% strain and the upper yield
point occurs at 13% of strain. The specimen before testing and after testing is shown
in Fig. 5.
The hardness measurements were performed to determine the strength along with
hardness. Vickers hardness provides medium indentations. The specimen is subjected
Performance Study of Dissimilar Alloy Joints of SS321 … 669
to Vickers hardness test. Hardness is lower in the HAZ region compared to the weld
metal and base metal regions from welding technique [7].
Figure 6 shows the values obtained in the hardness test. Vickers scale is considered.
The specimen welded with ER347 has hardness value of 289 HV and the specimen
welded with ER321 has 257 HV in the welded region. The base metal always gave
the highest hardness value for all the welding parameters [8].
The microstructure properties were studied using SEM analysis. The Fig. 7 shows a
Weld zone
uniform flow of filler material and good weld joint. The scanning electron microscopy
was used for the examination of weld microstructure. In the interdendritic region
where the small white precipitates which were sometimes segregated clearly from
the field were observed [9].
4 Conclusion
References
Abstract Efficient joints can be accomplished through the friction stir welding
(FSW) process with the selection of appropriate tool profile, tool material and D/d
ratio. This experiment to weld Aluminium 6061 with 10% silicon carbide reinforce-
ment was carried out in a CNC FSW machining set-up, the tool materials being H13
and OHNS, the tool profiles plain pentagon, plain taper and threaded cylinder and the
D/d ratio, a common 2. The different welding parameters chosen were 1000 rpm tool
rotation speed and 25 mm/min travel speed with an axial load varying between 3.8
and 4.3 kN. The joint produced with the threaded cylinder tool, compared with the
rest of the tools, exhibited the maximum tensile strength of 150 MPa and hardness
of 41 HRC and was found to be defect-free with a uniform grain size distribution.
1 Introduction
Friction stir welding was first developed in December 1991 by “the Welding Institute”
(TWI). Friction stir welding procedure is a process of solid-state connection without
any external filler. This entire process is carried out in the CNC machine setup.
Large alloys, like highly alloyed 2xxx and 7xxx series, are not weldable because
their microstructure and porosity in the area of melting are poorly solidified. This
entire process is carried out in the CNC machining setup [1]. When there are high
P. Jayaseelan · S. J. Vijay
Department of Mechanical Engineering, School of Engineering and Technology, Karunya
Institute of Technology and Sciences, Coimbatore, India
e-mail: jeevaglory@gmail.com
S. J. Vijay
e-mail: vijayjoseph.2001@gmail.com
T. V. Christy (B)
Professor of Mechanical Engineering, PRIST, Vallam, India
e-mail: drchristytv@gmail.com
levels of thermal stress and solidification of shrinkage during the welding process,
Aluminium is susceptible to Solidification cracking or hot cracking can be found
out. FSW has several benefits in the welding process which can be listed: FSW
does not need a joint preparation for plates, the result is high-quality welding with
increased tensile strength, expectation fatigue and corrosion resistance [2]. In order to
improve material mechanical properties, combining with various alloying elements
shows high performance, and heat treatable alloys. In this experimental process, we
used Aluminium Silicon Carbide alloy as a weldment. The four major parameters
determine the quality and strength of joint are mainly classified into (i) Speed of the
Rotation, (ii) Traverse speed, (iii) Plunging depth, (iv) Tilt angle. Then, the selection
of appropriate tool profile, tool material, tool geometry is risky and challenging one
[3]. By determining the proper ratio for the shoulder and pin, the tool was selected
[4]. Palin pentagon, Plain Tapering and Threaded cylinder with various instruments
are the tool profiles used in this experimental work. After the welding process once
completed, the scans of the weldment are important to check the different zones and
its welded quality. The areas discussed here are (i) Base Material (BM) or Parent
Zone (PZ) (ii) Heat affected zone (HAZ) (iii) Thermo-Mechanically affected zone
(TMAZ) (iv) Weld zone (WZ) or Nugget Zone (NZ). In this experimental work, we
finally discussed the various Tensile strength and hardness for the welded specimen
in different tool profiles and the values are tabulated, and the micrographs for the
weldment zones are shown.
2 Experimental Procedure
The experiment was initially started by selecting the proper tool profiles which
namely Plain Pentagon, Plain tapered, threaded cylinder tool pin and the material
used for the tools are H13, OHNS are selected for use. Hence the D/d ratios for the
tool profiles are listed in Table 1. Hence, the listed tool profiles are allowed to weld
in the Al–SiC weldment are measured the tensile strength and hardness values are
compared. The tools used in this experiment are shown in Fig. 1. The experiment was
therefore performed with a composite aluminium metal matrix. Al-10% SiC with the
dimensions 100 mm × 50 mm × 6 mm is produced under the in situ casting process
with the composition of the metal plates. As we discussed before, the composition
of the Aluminium alloy with other alloys possess greater mechanical strength [5]. If
the material composition is balanced, then the defect-free weld can be obtained [6].
The Al-10% SiC MMC microstructure is displayed in Fig. 2.
Then, the proper selection of the tool material is important that the tool should
withstand such mechanical properties [7]. The selection of the material is important
so that the good quality of the weld can be achieved.
H13 and OHNS with proper tool geometry are the tools used in this experiment
which have a strong temperature resistance to thermal fatigue and resistance to wear.
The parameters used in this experiment are (1) 1000 rpm tool rotation speed; (2)
25 mm/min traversing speed; (3) 3.8–4.3 kN axial load. The parameters are fixed after
we did some trial experiments which yielded defect-free weld [8]. The parameter used
676 P. Jayaseelan et al.
in this experiment is tabulated as shown in Table 2. Then the experiment was followed
with this fixed parameter for all the tool profiles, then the results are discussed. The
connection between the number of revolutions and the speed of soldering directly
affects the toughness of the fracture and the energy needed to initiate and propagate
the crack [9].
Specimens are welded with above-mentioned parameters and it was prepared for
testing the hardness and tensile strength. The test was conducted as per ASTM E08
standard. Table 3 shows the tensile strength of the welded Aluminium Silicon car-
bide (Al–SiC) is welded with different tool profiles (Plain Pentagon, Plain Tapered,
Threaded Cylindrical). And it was shown that Tool number 3 (Threaded Cylinder—
H13) yields high tensile strength than the other tool profiles. And it is clearly stated
that it yields 150 MPa, 118 MPa, 127 MPa with respect to Threaded cylinder—H13,
Plain Tapered—OHNS, Plain Pentagon—H13 respectively. As we know that it yields
high tensile strength only if the grains are evenly distributed (uniformly). That the
condition is satisfied in the case of Threaded Cylinder—H13 and its microstructure
are given in Fig. 3. The welding temperature and welding speed are mainly deter-
mined for the UTS of the friction stir welds in EN AW-2219-T87 [10]. Other than the
H13, Threaded cylinder, tools profile, and materials made like H13—plain pentagon
and OHNS—plain tapered couldn’t even uniformly distribute than the H13 Threaded
cylinder profile. So, the other two tools yield slightly lower than the H13—Threaded
Cylinder profile. The optimal combination of process parameters for the high-speed
steel (HSS) tool [11].
After the test, the maximum hardness for the welding specimens (Al–SiC) was
determined by a hardness test. The hardness value for the welded specimen is shown
in Table 4. It is clearly stated that again H13—Threaded Cylinder shows the maxi-
mum hardness value of 41 HRC compared to OHNS—Plain tapered and H13—Plain
a) BM b) HAZ c) TMAZ
Considerable d) WNZ
grain
refinement
with the
precipitates 10μm
e) TMAZ f) HAZ g) BM
Fig. 3 Composite FSW micrographs using the threaded cylinders tool H13
Table 4 Hardness of
Tool No. Tool profile Tool material Hardness (in
weldments
HRC)
1 Plain pentagon H13 40
2 Plain tapered OHNS 26
3 Threaded H13 41
cylinder
micrographs are shown in Fig. 3. The grain structure of the HAZ is well known to be
almost the same as base metal (BM). Since, when compared to Thermo-Mechanically
Affected zone (TMAZ) grain size are smaller than the other grains due to its plastic
deformation near the weld zone (WZ). The heat is allowed to pass through the TMAZ.
The welding zone with a maximum heat generation is thus smaller than TMAZ and
BM in grain size. In different areas of the welded joint, the asymmetry of the sold
joints and the changes in metallurgical transformations that occur around the pine
and below the tool during their joint movement affect the effect strength value [14].
Also, the macrostructure of the Welded zone of Al–SiC is shown along with the
Tensile Strength (in MPa) as shown in Table 5. As we see that, weldment made
using the Tool No 3 has exhibits defect-free joint and yield high tensile strength with
desired hardness.
4 Conclusion
Significant difficulties in achieving high-quality welds are the right choice for the
FSW tool. As already stated, the material, pin profile and ratio of D/d affect soldering
quality significantly and therefore require a thorough investigation. Detailed investi-
gations were carried out using tools of various profiles, such as friction stir welding
aluminium metal matrix composites (Al–SiC). Simple flap, cylinders, materials such
as simple tapering and threading. FSW, OHNS and H13 and D/d ratio 2 are allowed
on commercial CNCs. The results show that Al-MMC joints can produce superior
Effect of Friction Stir Welding Tool on Al–SiC Composites … 679
tensile strength and durability in a threaded cylinders H13 tool with a ratio of D/d
2. The ongoing work in the production of quality welds using the FSW process is
considered an important contribution.
References
1. Barath VR, Vignesh RV, Padmanaban R (2018) Analysing the strength of friction stir welded
dissimilar aluminium alloys using Sugeno fuzzy model. IOP Publishing, Coimbatore
2. Bosneag A, Constantin MA, Nitu E, Iordache M (2018) Friction stir welding of three dissimilar
aluminium alloy: AA2024, AA6061 and AA7075. IOP Publishing, Romania
3. Palani K, Elanchezhian C, Avinash K, Karthik C, Chaitanya K, Sivanur K, Reddy KY (2018)
Influence of friction stir processing parameters on tensile properties and microstructure of dis-
similar AA8011-H24 and AA6061-T6 aluminium alloy joints n nugget zone. IOP Publishing,
Kanchipuram
4. Jayaseelan P, Christy TV (2019) Behaviour of threaded cylinder tool in the friction stir welding
of Al-ZrB2 and Al-SiC composite. Int J Mech Eng Technol 10(1):1751–1761
5. Daneji A, Ali M, Pervaiz S (2018) Influence of tool geometry and processing parameters on
welding defects and mechanical properties for friction stir welding of 6061 aluminium alloy.
IOP Publishing, Dubai
6. Chand S, Vineetha S, Madhusudhan D, Krishna CS, Devi GK, Hemarao K, Naidu GG (2018)
Effect of FSW welding speed on microstructure and microhardness of Al-0.84Mg-0.69Si-
0.76Fe alloy at moderate rotational tool velocity. IOP Publishing, Andhra Pradesh
7. Jayaseelan P, Christy TV, Rubesh, Prabhu G, Srinivasan R (2019) Behaviour of threaded
cylinder tool in the friction stir welding of Al–ZrB2 composite. J Comput Theor Nanosci
16(2):719–724
8. Vijayan D, Abhishek P (2018) Multi objective process parameter optimization of friction stir
welding using NSGA-II. IOP Publishing, Kanchipuram
9. Jayaseelan P, Christy TV (2019) Behavior of threaded cylinder tool in the friction stir welding
of Al-SiC composite. In Materials today: Proceedings (Vol. 16)
10. Zhang H, Zhao C, Cui B, Yan X, Dou C, Shao T, Pan R (2018) The corrosion behaviour of cold
spray coating on 2219 aluminium alloy joints prepared by friction stir welding. IOP Publishing,
Beijing
11. Milcic M, Vuherer T, Radisavljevic I, Milcic D, Kramberger J, Andjelkovic B (2018)
Mechanical behavior of Al 2024 alloy welded by friction stir welding. IOP Publishing, Beograd
12. Chernykh IK, Vasil’ev EV, Matuzko EN, Krivonos EV (2018) Upgrading weld quality of a
friction stir welded aluminium alloys AMG6. IOP Publishing, Omsk
13. Constantin MA, Bosneag A, Nitu E, Iordache M (2018) Orientation of process parameter values
of TIG assisted FSW of copper to obtain improved mechanical properties. IOP Publishing,
Romania
14. Jayaseelan P, Christy TV, Vijay SJ, Nelson R (2019) Effect of tool material, profile and D/d ratio
in friction stir welding of aluminium metal matrix composites. Materials Research Express,
IOP Science Publishing
Fabrication of AISI 304 Austenitic
Stainless Steels with TiN Addition Using
Spark Plasma Sintering Method
Abstract The spark plasma sintering (SPS) is a type of electric discharge sintering
technique used to consolidate metallic/ceramic powders. In this study, spark plasma
sintering was used to fabricate 304 stainless steel with TiN addition. The best param-
eters that influence the sintering process such as sintering temperature, heating time
and pressure were investigated. Results show that by varying the amount of TiN,
the sintered properties of the composites could be significantly affected. The relative
density decreased with the increment of TiN. Microhardness values vary from 270
to 350 HV0.1.
1 Introduction
urban water, chemical, aircraft gas turbine engines and food industries [2]. Apart from
corrosive environment application, high impact velocity of particles is frequently
encountered in components used in these industries. Examples are coal-fired boilers
used in the power generation industries [3]. Although austenitic stainless steels are
well known for their good corrosion properties, they are famous for poor mechanical
properties such as friction and wear. According to Sun and Bell [4], when ASSs are
in contact with each other or other materials, they experience severe metallic wear
which results from the adhesion junction and severe plastic deformation occurring
between the surfaces of the materials in contact with each other. Furthermore, ASS
fails mainly because of wear rather than corrosion-related material loss problems.
According to More et al. [5], 50% or more investigators focuses on steel as their
target material because steel is used in many industrial applications, however, it
has been noticed that steel material can be effectively replaced or alloyed with some
other materials such as titanium. Mainly because titanium is the second-largest target
material and they have good wear properties. Titanium nitride (TiN), which has
relatively good wear properties, is intentionally alloyed to 304 ASS to improve the
hardness and wear properties of the resulting material.
There are several methods that can be used to consolidate 304L ASS with TiN.
Such methods include hot isostatic pressing (HIP), hot pressing (HP), microwave
sintering and spark plasma sintering (SPS) [6, 7]. This study focuses on ASS grade
304 reinforced with TiN under high-temperature conditions.
2 Experimental Procedures
Commercial as-received 304-austenitic stainless steel and TiN were chosen as the
starting powders. The two feedstock powders were characterized for particle size
distribution (PSD) using Microtrac S3500 analyzer. It uses the three red laser diodes
(tri-laser) that provides accurate and repeatable particles sizes [8]. Powders were
weighed according to the proportions as shown in Table 1. The weighed powders
were then mixed (under dry environments) using Turbula Shaker Mixer T2F for 8 h at
a speed of 72 rpm. The function of mixing is to achieve uniformly blended particles
without altering the properties required for the next steps [9]. Admixed powders
were then characterized using SEM-EDX and the phases formed were analyzed
using XRD. The admixed powders were also characterized by PSD.
Table 1 Chemical
Number Powder Weight ratio
compositions of admixed
powders 1 304-ASS 100
2 304-ASS/2TiN 98:02
3 304-ASS/4TiN 96:04
4 304-ASS/6TiN 94:06
Fabrication of AISI 304 Austenitic Stainless Steels … 683
The admixed powders were then consolidated using spark plasma sintering tech-
nique in which specimens with dimensions of 35 mm × 1.5 mm were produced.
The substrates were machined using the robofil 240-SL electrical discharge machine
(EDM) wire cut. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM, Tescan Vega 3) which has the
energy-dispersive X-ray spectrometer (EDS) attached to it was used to analyze the
morphology of the feedstock and admixed powders to confirm the element present
in the powders. Phase identification of the powders was also analyzed with X-ray
diffraction (XRD Rigaku Ultima IV). Admixed powders were sintered using spark
plasma sintering technology (H-HPD25-FCT Systeme GmbH Germany) in a 40 mm
graphite die and the thickness between the graphite foil (used to separate the graphite
die and the punches) and the powder was 6.5 mm. The densification process took
place at varying operating parameters under a heating rate of 100 °C/min from room
temperature up to the desired temperature (1100 °C) and holding time of 10 min. The
temperature was monitored using the optical pyrometer throughout the SPS process.
A constant vacuum pressure of 50 MPa was applied in each test. The sintering param-
eters used are presented in Table 2. After sintering, the samples were sand-blasted
to remove any excess graphite material on them. Furthermore, the densities of the
sintered samples were accurately weighed using the Archimedes for five times using
Mittler electronic balance and the average densities were recorded.
The sintered samples were ground and polished to 3 μm diamond finish. The sam-
ples were further polished with fumed silica using a polishing suspension of 0.2 μm to
achieve a mirror-like surface. The morphology of the sintered specimen was investi-
gated using scanning electron microscope model TESCAN Vega 3 which is equipped
with Energy-dispersive spectroscope. The Rigaku Ultima IV X-ray diffractometer
XRD equipped with a graphite-monochromatic Cu Kα radiation source at 40 kV and
30 mA was used to perform the XRD analysis. Collection of diffractograms took
place in the 2θ range between 3° and 90° with a step size of 0.01 [8]. The purpose
of the XRD analysis is to identify the phases present/formed in the composites. The
effect of adding TiN on the hardness of the resulting composite was carried using
the INNOVATEST Falcon 500 Vickers microhardness tester. The specimens were
indented under a load of 100 g and dwell time of 10 s on 10 different positions. The
average values were calculated and recorded.
684 B. A. Obadele et al.
The SEM morphologies and EDS analysis of the starting 304 ASS and TiN powders
used in this study are given in Fig. 1. From Fig. 1a, it could be seen that 304 ASS
particles are spherical in shape, smooth and non-porous with a few satellites. This
is typical for powders that were produced by gas atomization [10]. From Fig. 1b, it
could be seen that the TiN powder show an irregular shape and it is porous. The TiN
powder could have been produced by the sol-gel method. This method is used to
produce metal-oxides or metal chlorides (usually known as precursors), especially
that of silicon and titanium. The morphology of particles produced by this technique
is porous. EDS reveals Fe, Cr and Ni in the 304 ASS powder as the major elements
and Ti and N as the main elements in the TiN starting powder.
The XRD spectra of as-received 304 ASS and TiN powders are given in Fig. 2. In
Fig. 2a, the XRD pattern shows the phases present in the starting 304 ASS powder.
The phases that have emerged contain elements such as Cr, Ni, and Fe. Similarly, in
Fig. 2b, the diffractometer reveals that there is only TiN present in the powder. The
XRD results of the starting powders obtained in this study are in line with the EDS
analysis.
The particle size distribution curves are presented in Fig. 3. The PSD graph repre-
sents the amount of materials in percentage passing through a specific screen size in
microns. From the graph, it could be observed that for pure 304 SS, 304 SS/2TiN, 304
a b
Fig. 1 SEM morphologies of a as-received 304 ASS and b TiN particles with EDS analyses
Fabrication of AISI 304 Austenitic Stainless Steels … 685
Fig. 2 XRD pattern of the feedstock a 304 ASS and b TiN powders
100
90
80
70 304 ASS
TiN
% Passing
SS/4TiN and 304 SS/6TiN, 50% (D50) of the particles pass through approximately
15 μm sieves. In the case of TiN, 50% (D50) of the particles pass through 5.5 μm.
From SEM analysis of the powders (see Fig. 1), TiN particles were identified by
smaller particle size whereas 304 ASS particles were classified by larger particles.
The PSD curves confirm that the particles sizes of TiN powder to be smaller than
that of 304 ASS powder.
Relative densities for the SPS composites used in the study are shown in Fig. 4.
From the graph, it could be observed that the densities of the composites decrease
with an increasing amount of TiN reinforcing material in the steel matrix. The reason
for this trend may be due to the lower density of TiN (5.43 g/cm3 ) than that of 304 SS
(8.03 g/cm3 ). Relative densities of the composites were 97.65%, 96.64%, 96.56% and
96.23% for compositions without and with TiN (0 wt%, 2 wt%, 4 wt% and 6 wt%)
respectively. Sulima et al. [11] reported that the apparent densities of the composites
decrease with increasing content of the reinforcing material in the matrix. This is
so because of the lower densities the reinforcing material usually possess. On their
studies on the effect of SPS parameters on densification and properties of steel matrix
composites, they indicated that the apparent densities of the steel matrix decrease as
the content of TiB2 reinforcing material increases in the steel matrix. On the other
hand, a decrease in relative density could result from the formation of pores around
the TiN phase as shown in Fig. 5.
Figure 5 presents the SEM micrographs of spark plasma sintered composites of
different content of TiN. It could be observed that most of the TiN are distributed
within the grain boundaries of the matrix material. As the amount of TiN increases
from 5 to 6%, more of TiN (white phase) segregate along the grain boundaries. SEM
images (Fig. 5a–d) reveal the presence of micropores within the grain and along
Fig. 5 SEM micrograph of SPS 304 ASS without and with 2%, 4% and 6% TiN
Fabrication of AISI 304 Austenitic Stainless Steels … 687
♣
♣
304ASS-6TiN ♥ ♥
304 ASS-4TiN
304 ASS-2TiN
304 ASS
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
2-theta (deg)
grain boundaries of 304 ASS. The decrease in sintered relative density (see Fig. 4)
correlates with SEM images presented in Fig. 5.
The XRD analysis of the SPS stainless steel composites with various amount
of reinforcement (TiN) in wt% sintered at a sintering temperature (1100 °C), heat-
ing rate (100 °C/min) and holding time (10 min) is given in Fig. 6. The peaks were
scanned at room temperature under argon atmosphere. The XRD reveals the presence
of the following phases; TiN with a chemical formula TiN0.90, phases containing
iron, chromium and nickel such as FeCr0.29Ni0.16C0.06, austenite. The main ele-
ments of 304 ASS which are Fe, Ni and Cr, are revealed, these elements lie close to
each other on the periodic table. Therefore, they possess similar properties and lattice
parameters. In situations like this, it is practically impossible to accurately determine
the phase composition of the spark plasma sintered 304 ASS composites because
the XRD analysis of these composites can only prove the solid solution of iron [11,
12]. There has been no peak shift during sintering. However, there has been a slight
change in peak intensities. The change in peak intensities could result from the sin-
tering temperature, time and heating rate. The XRD patterns before and after spark
plasma sintering process are very similar. There has been no significant transforma-
tion or phase change during spark plasma sintering. However, cubic nitride (chemical
formula, FeN0.0939) has been detected in the major peak of ASS 304 with 2, 4 and
6 wt% TiN at peak position 2θ = 43.884°. This finding could be due to the intense
phenomena that take place during the SPS process, which include surface activation,
diffusion, surface melting as well as necking between sintered powder particles and
plastic flow. An increase in mass transportation is obtained during sintering and this
improves the bonding between powder particles. The iron nitride that has emerged in
the studied material after sintering is formed as a result of iron and nitrogen diffusing
in the grain boundary of the steel matrix. It is very crucial to mention that the SPS
process involves a stage where the material undergoes non-equilibrium conditions
688 B. A. Obadele et al.
Fig. 7 Microhardness of
304 SS composites before
erosion studies
and this has a great impact on the reactions as well as the diffusions which take place
during SPS [12].
Microhardness profiles of ASS 304 without and with TiN additions are given in
Fig. 7. As expected, the microhardness values increase as the amount of TiN in the
specimen increases. This could be due to the hard phase TiN presence in the matrix
material. ASS 304 with 6% TiN shows the highest microhardness value of about 350
HV0.1 while ASS 304 without and with 2% and 4% TiN microhardness values of
275, 330, 338 HV0.1 respectively.
4 Conclusion
In this study, the effect of TiN on the microstructure and hardness behaviour of
304 austenitic stainless steel has been evaluated. Based on the results obtained, the
following conclusion could be drawn; SPS results given in terms of relative densities
show a decrease in relative density with increasing content of TiN. Also, an increase
in TiN value in the matrix increased the hardness values.
Acknowledgements The authors are grateful to Tribology Group, Universidad Nacional del Sur,
Bahía Blanca, Argentina for the use of equipment and facilities and The Institute of Nanoengi-
neering Research (INER), Tshwane University of Technology, Pretoria for the use of sintering and
characterization facilities.
References
2. Bregliozzi G, Di Schino A, Ahmed S-U, Kenny J, Haefke H (2005) Cavitation wear behaviour
of austenitic stainless steels with different grain sizes. Wear 258:503–510
3. Samandi M, Shedden B, Smith D, Collins G, Hutchings R, Tendys J (1993) Microstructure,
corrosion and tribological behaviour of plasma immersion ion-implanted austenitic stainless
steel. Surf Coat Technol 59:261–266
4. Sun Y, Bell T (2002) Dry sliding wear resistance of low temperature plasma carburised
austenitic stainless steel. Wear 253:689–693
5. More SR, Bhatt DV, Menghani JV (2017) Recent research status on erosion wear—an overview.
Mater Today Proc 4:257–266
6. Smuk O (2004) Microstructure and properties of modern P/M super duplex stainless steels
(Doctoral dissertation, Materialvetenskap).
7. Brytan Z, Dobrzański L, Grande MA, Rosso M (2009) Characteristics of vacuum sintered
stainless steels. J Achievements Mater Manuf Eng 33:126–134
8. Dada OR (2015) Characterization and beneficiation of foundry greensand waste from ferrous
foundries. University of Johannesburg
9. Obadele BA, Masuku ZH, Olubambi PA (2012) Turbula mixing characteristics of carbide
powders and its influence on laser processing of stainless steel composite coatings. Powder
Technol 230:169–182
10. Obadele BA, Ige OO, Olubambi PA (2017) Fabrication and characterization of titanium-nickel-
zirconia matrix composites prepared by spark plasma sintering. J Alloy Compd 710:825–830
11. Sulima I, Putyra P, Hyjek P, Tokarski T (2015) Effect of SPS parameters on densification and
properties of steel matrix composites. Adv Powder Technol 26:1152–1161
12. Oke SR, Ige OO, Falodun OE, Obadele BA., Shongwe MB, Olubambi, PA (2018) Optimization
of process parameters for spark plasma sintering of nano structured SAF 2205 composite.
Journal of materials research and technology, 7(2), 126–134.
Effect of Process Parameters on Bead
Width of 202 Grade Stainless Steel Gas
Tungsten Arc Welded Plates Using
Response Surface Methodology
1 Introduction
ton of work has been completed to foresee weld bead width for gas metal arc weld-
ing, GTAW, Friction stir welding process for various evaluations of stainless steels
yet no work has been accounted for anticipating bead width for 202-grade stainless
steel which can be utilized as a substitute for 304-grade stainless steel in many appli-
cations like food processing equipment, kitchen hardware, sink and apparatus and
medicinal instruments and so on. Increasingly over the collaboration impacts of pro-
cedure parameters on bead width are not intricately talked about. Thus an endeavor
has been made to connect GTAW process parameters, for example, welding current
(I), welding speed (V ), gas flow rate (Q) and welding gun angle (θ ) with bead width.
A factually planned examination dependent on central composite rotatable design
was utilized for the improvement of numerical model [9]. The direct and intuitive
impacts of procedure parameters on bead width were examined. The created model
was helpful to decide quantitatively bead width of 202 stainless steel GTAW plates.
2 Experimental Procedure
The trials were structured and dependent on four-factor five-level central composite
rotatable plans with full replication method [10]. These trials were directed according
to the design matrix utilizing Lincoln V 350 PRO electric computerized welding
machine. A servo motor driven controller was utilized to keep up uniform welding
speed. The fundamental trial set up utilized comprised of a travelling carriage with a
table for supporting the specimens. A power source was kept prepared. A welding gun
was held stationary in an edge over the table and was given a connection for setting
the expected nozzle to plate distance and welding gun angle individually. The nozzle
to plate distance was kept consistent at 2.5 mm all through the experimentation
procedure. A high recurrence connection was utilized to produce the arc at this
separation. Test plates of size (100 mm × 30 mm × 5 mm) were cut from 202
stainless steel plates and one surface was cleaned to evacuate oxide scale and earth
before welding. The concoction synthesis of AISI stainless steel plate is given in
Table 1.
Argon gas with flow rates between 5 and 25 l/min was utilized for protecting the
weld bead. The reason for utilizing the protecting gas was to shield the weld region
from climatic gases, for example, oxygen, nitrogen, carbon dioxide and water vapor.
The welding machine and controller utilized for leading the trials is shown in Figs. 1
and 2.
694
3 Plan of Investigation
The working extents of each picked factor were settled by coordinating fundamental
runs. This was finished by contrasting one of the components while keeping whatever
is left of them as relentless characteristics. The working extent of every method
parameter was constrained by exploring the dot for a smooth appearance with no
conspicuous distortions, for instance, surface porosity, undercut, etc. The maximum
furthest reaches of a given factor were coded as (+2) and lower limit was coded as
(−2). The coded qualities for centre qualities were resolved using the Eq. (1) [11]
The plan framework picked to lead the investigations was a five-level, four-factor
central composite rotatable design comprising of 31 sets of coded conditions and
involving a half replication 24 = 16 factorial structure in addition to eight star focuses
and seven centre focuses. All welding factors at the middle level (0) comprise the
inside focuses while the mix of each welding factors at either its lower level (−2)
or its more elevated amount (+2) with the other two factors at the moderate level
establish the star focuses. Subsequently, the 31 test runs permit the estimation of
straight, quadratic and two way intuitive impacts of the procedure factors on bead
width [12]. Examinations were led at random to maintain a strategic distance from
schematic errors crawling into the exploratory methodology.
Effect of Process Parameters on Bead Width … 697
To measure the bead width the following processes were carried out on the specimens
(1) Segmenting, (2) Granulating, (3) Polishing, (4) Etching and (5) Profile tracing.
Segmenting: The transverse areas of each weld were cut utilizing band saw and
care was taken to keep away from twisting of the delicate austenitic stainless steel.
Granulating: It was performed so as to expel the cold work from cutting. The
granulating was done at rates of roughly 300 RPM.
Polishing: The specimens were then harsh cleaned by hand. So as to acquire
better edge evenness, the specimens were polished utilizing silicon carbide grating
papers of evaluations 100, 220, 400, 600 and 800 individually. The specimens were
then cleaned utilizing a rough—slurry of alumina (Al2 O3 ) and water (H2 O) on a
polishing machine.
Etching: After cleaning, etching was done on the specimens. Etching was impor-
tant for analyzing the microstructure of the weld bead. The etchant utilized was
Marble’s reagent which is a blend of HCl (50 ml), CuSO4 and H2 O (50 ml). The
polished countenances of every specimen were swabbed utilizing the etchant for
around 50–60 s to uncover the weld bead.
Profile Tracing: The bead profiles of the specimens were followed utilizing a
reflective type optical profile projector.
The followed bead profiles were examined so as to decide the bead width. The
bead width was estimated with the assistance of AUTOCAD. The followed bead
profile is shown in Fig. 3. The welded specimens are shown in Fig. 4.
The design matrix and measured value of bead width are shown in Table 3.
The welding conditions continue as before for trial keeps running from 25 to
31 yet the reaction shifts marginally. This is because of the impact of obscure and
eccentric factors called noise factors that creep into the tests. To represent the effect
of these obscure factors on the reaction rehashed runs were incorporated into the
design.
The development of a numerical model was done dependent on the regression tech-
nique to foresee the bead width. The response surface capacity speaking to bead
width can be communicated as α = f (I, V, Q, θ ) and the relationship chose is a
698 R. Sudhakaran et al.
second request reaction surface for k factors is given by Eq. (2) [9]
k
k
k
Y = b0 + bi X i + bi j X i X j + bii X i2 (2)
i=1 i, j=1 i=1
i= j
Factual programming bundle (Minitab Release 14) [11] was utilized to figure
the estimations of these coefficients. An underlying numerical model was created
utilizing the coefficients got from the above conditions.
The estimation of the regression coefficients gives a thought about what degree the
control parameters influence the response quantitatively. The less critical coefficients
are dispensed with alongside the responses with which they are related without giving
up a significant part of the exactness. This is finished by utilizing a student’s t-test
[13]. As per this test, when the determined value of ‘t’ comparing to the coefficient
surpasses the standard classified an incentive for the likelihood rule kept at 0.75, the
coefficient ends up noteworthy. The final numerical model was created utilizing just
the noteworthy coefficients. The final scientific model as controlled by the above
examination is given by Eq. (3).
The square numerous estimations of ‘R’ of the full model and the diminished
model are exhibited in Table 4. It is apparent from the table that the full model has
the higher estimation of balanced square multiple ‘R’ than the diminished model and
Effect of Process Parameters on Bead Width … 699
Table 4 Comparison of square multiple ‘R’ values and standard error of estimate for full and
reduced models
Response Adjusted square multiple R Standard error estimate
Full model Reduced model Full model Reduced model
Bead width 0.950 0.959 0.140 0.126
700 R. Sudhakaran et al.
the diminished model has lesser estimations of the standard error of estimate than
that of the individual full model. Thus the diminished model is superior to the full
model.
The adequacy of the model was tried utilizing the Analysis of Variance Technique
(ANOVA). According to this procedure [14], the determined estimation of the F—
the proportion of the model created ought not to surpass the standard estimation of
F-proportion for an ideal dimension of certainty, i.e., 95% and the determined esti-
mation of R-proportion of the model created ought to surpass the standard organized
estimation of the R-proportion for a similar certainty level. In the event that these
conditions are satisfied, the model is viewed as sufficient. The aftereffects of ANOVA
are exhibited in Table 5. It is obvious from the table that the model is sufficient.
The scientific model created can be utilized to foresee bead width by substituting
the estimations of the individual procedure parameters. The impact of the procedure
parameters on the bead width was concentrated utilizing the created model. The direct
impact of procedure parameters was contemplated utilizing the created model. The
direct impact was concentrated by keeping all the procedure parameters at the mid-
dle level with the exception of the parameter whose direct impact was examined.
The interaction of the parameters is considered by keeping every one of the param-
eters at the middle level aside from the parameters whose interaction impacts are
contemplated. The direct impact of the considerable number of parameters and the
interaction impacts of welding process parameters which have solid interaction on
bead width are examined underneath.
bead width. Figure 6 demonstrates the direct impact of welding speed on bead width.
Welding speed is one of the primary factors that control heat info and bead width.
Bead width and measurements of the warmth influenced zone diminish with the
expansion in welding speed. This is because of the way that heat input is contrarily
corresponding to welding speed. Henceforth, there is an abatement in bead width as
the welding speed increments.
Figure 7 demonstrates the direct impact of shielding gas flow rate on bead width.
At the point when the gas flow rate is changed from lower level to more elevated
amount there is a peripheral increment in bead width up to (−1) level and afterward
Effect of Process Parameters on Bead Width … 703
there is a diminishing pattern up to (+2) level. This is because of the way that at
higher gas flow rates more warmth is diverted by the gas. These outcomes in less
bead width and diminishing in measurements of the warmth influenced zone. Thus
there is an abatement in bead width for comparing increment in shielding gas flow
rate. Figure 8 demonstrates the direct impact of welding gun angle on bead width.
From the figure, bead width increments as the welding gun angle increments. This is
because of the way that at higher gun angles the preheating of the base metal is high
and the base metal gets more introduction to the arc. Thus there is an expansion in
bead width for comparing increment in gun angle.
Figure 9 speaks to the contour diagram for interactive effect of welding speed and
welding current on bead width. From the contour plot, when the welding speed is
at its lower limit for example (−2) level, bead width is in the scope of 3–3.5 mm
for increment in welding current from (−2) to (0) level. It increments and is in the
scope of 3.5–4 mm for the welding current from (0) to (+2) level. At the point when
the welding speed is at (−1) level, bead width is in the scope of 2.5–3 mm for the
welding current up to (−1) level. It increments and is in the scope of 3–3.5 mm for the
welding current up to (+1) level. It is in the scope of 3.5–4 mm for the welding current
at (+2) level. For the following dimension of welding speed for example (0) level,
bead width is in the scope of 2–2.5 mm for the welding current up to (0) level. It is in
the scope of 3–3.5 mm for the welding current at (+1) level and increments to 4 mm
for the welding current at (+2) level. At the point when the welding speed is at (+1)
level, bead width is under 2 mm for the welding current at (−2) level. The bead width
builds like (0) level for different dimensions of welding current. A similar pattern is
watched for welding speed at (+2) level. The expansion in bead width for increment
in welding current for all dimensions of welding speed is because of the beneficial
outcome of welding current which is more noteworthy than the negative impact of
welding speed. Figure 10 demonstrates the contour plot for interactive of welding
speed and welding gun angle on bead width. From the contour plot, when the welding
gun angle is at (−2) level, bead width is in the scope of 4–4.5 mm for all dimensions
of welding speed. At the point when the welding gun angle is at (−1) level, bead
width is in the scope of 3.5–4 mm for the welding speed up to (−1) level. It at that
point diminishes and is in the scope of 3–3.5 mm for the welding speed at (0) level.
It further reduces and is in the scope of 2.5–3 mm for the welding speed at (+1) level.
It tumbles to under 2.5 mm for the welding speed at (+2) level. At the point when
the welding gun angle is at (0) level, a similar pattern is watched for bead width for
all dimensions of welding speed. For the following dimension of welding gun angle
for example (+1) level, bead width is in the scope of 4–4.5 mm for all dimensions of
welding speed. At the point when the welding gun angle is at its maximum farthest
point for example (+2) level, bead width is in the scope of 4–4.5 mm for the welding
speed up to (0) level. It at that point insignificantly increments to 4.5 mm for the
other two dimensions of welding speed. From the above investigation, it tends to
be derived that bead width increments for increment in welding gun angle for all
dimensions of welding speed. This is because of the beneficial outcome of welding
gun angle which is more critical than the negative effect of welding speed.
Figure 11 speaks to the shape outline for the interactive effect of welding current and
shielding gas flow rate on bead width. From the contour plot, when the shielding gas
flow rate is at (−2) level and welding current is differed from (−2) to (+2) level bead
width increments from 1.5 to 5 mm. At the point when the shielding gas flow rate is at
(−1) level, bead width increments from 2 to 5 mm for increment in welding current
from (−2) to (+2) level. A similar pattern is watched for gas flow rate at (0) and (+1)
level. At the point when the shielding gas flow rate is expanded to its furthest restrict
for example (+2) level, bead width is in the scope of 2–3 mm for increment in welding
current from (−2) to (+2) level. From the above investigations, it may be surmised
that bead width increments when the welding current increments for all dimensions
of gas flow rate. This is because of the way that the beneficial outcome of welding
current is more critical than the negative effect of shielding gas flow rate on bead
width. Figure 12 demonstrates the contour plot for interactive effect of shielding gas
flow rate and welding speed on bead width. As appeared in the contour plot, when
the shielding gas flow rate is at (−2) level bead width is in the scope of 2–2.5 mm for
706 R. Sudhakaran et al.
increment in welding speed from (−2) to (+2) level. At the point when the shielding
gas flow rate is at (−1) level, bead width is in the scope of 3.5–4 mm for increment
in welding speed from (−2) to (+2) level. At the point when the shielding gas flow
rate is at (0) level bead width is more noteworthy than 4 mm for welding speed at
(−2) level. It at that point diminishes and is in the scope of 3.5–4 mm for different
dimensions of welding speed. For the following dimension of shielding gas flow rate
for example (+1) level, bead width is in the scope of 3.5–4 mm for the welding speed
up to (+1) level. It at that point diminishes and is in the scope of 3–3.5 mm for the
welding speed up to (0) level. It further declines and is in the scope of 2.5–3 mm for
the welding speed up to (+1) level. It is in the scope of 2–2.5 mm for the welding
speed at (+2) level. At the point when the shielding gas flow rate is at its maximum
breaking point for example (+2) level, bead width is in the scope of 3–3.5 mm for
the welding speed at (−2) level. It is in the scope of 2.5–3 mm for the welding speed
at (−1) level. It further declines and is in the scope of 2–2.5 mm for the welding
Effect of Process Parameters on Bead Width … 707
speed at (0) and (+1) levels. It goes underneath 2 mm for the welding speed at (+2)
level. From the above investigation, it very well may be induced that bead width
diminishes when the welding speed increments for all dimensions of gas flow rate.
This is because of the way that both welding speed and shielding gas flow rate have
a negative effect on bead width.
5 Conclusions
The accompanying ends were touched base at from the present examination.
1. The regression display created in this work from the experimental information
can be utilized to control the procedure so as to accomplish the ideal weld quality
in butt-welded plates.
2. The percentage of error got for profundity of entrance among predicted and
experimental esteem falls inside the breaking point of 95% certainty level. Sub-
sequently, the created regression display is fit for making the forecast of bead
width with sensible exactness.
3. Central composite design can be advantageously used to examine the immediate
and intuitive impacts of various blends of procedure parameters inside the scope
of the examination.
4. Out of four procedure parameters chose for examination, welding current and
welding gun angle has constructive outcome on bead width where as welding
speed and shielding gas flow rate has negative impact on bead width.
5. Out of the distinctive blends of procedure parameters the following combinations,
i.e., welding current and welding speed, welding current and shielding gas flow
rate, welding speed and shielding gas flow rate and welding speed and welding
gun angle have solid interactions on bead width.
6. The greatest bead width acquired from experimental investigations was 4.78 mm
when the procedure parameters, for example, welding current, welding speed,
and welding gun angle were at 100 A, 200 mm/min and 80° individually and
shielding gas flow rate was at 10 l/min.
7. The least bead width acquired from experimental investigations was 2.06 mm
when welding current and welding gun angle were at 80 A and 60° separately
whereas welding speed and shielding gas flow rate were at 200 mm/min and
20 l/min individually.
References
1. Giridharan PK, Murugan N (2009) Optimization of pulsed GTA welding process parameters
for the welding of AISI 304L stainless steel sheets. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 40(5–6):478–489
2. EL Rayes M, Walz C, Sepold G (2004) The influence of various hybrid welding parameters on
bead geometry. Weld J 147–153
708 R. Sudhakaran et al.
Abstract The aim of this paper is to study the feasibility of welding dissimilar
aluminum alloys AA6063 and AA7075 using destructive and nondestructive testing.
Dissimilar Aluminum alloys AA6063 and AA7075 plates were butt-jointed using the
tungsten inert gas (TIG) welding method. The feasibility of welding of dissimilar
aluminum alloy can be confirmed by both strength calculations as well as identifica-
tion of welding defects. The feasibility of welding of dissimilar aluminum alloy joint
was studied through visual appearance, microstructures, tensile strength, hardness,
liquid penetrant test and ultrasound test. Microstructures at different zones of dis-
similar TIG joints were identified. The average tensile strength and hardness values
were calculated. Using the liquid penetrant test and ultrasound test, welding defects
were identified. It can be concluded that TIG welding of a dissimilar aluminum alloy
is feasible.
1 Introduction
D. Nathan (B)
Dr. Mahalingam College of Engineering and Technology, Pollachi, India
e-mail: nathan14576@gmail.com
S. Ashwin Kannan · P. Krishna Kumar
St. Joseph’s Institute of Technology, Chennai 600119, India
© Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd. 2021 709
S. Vijayan et al. (eds.), Trends in Manufacturing and Engineering Management,
Lecture Notes in Mechanical Engineering,
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-15-4745-4_63
710 D. Nathan et al.
weld structural members such as truck and marine frames, pipelines and railroad cars.
Besides, the 7xxx series alloys are also heat treatable with the highest strength of
all aluminum alloys. AA7075 is also wide applications in aircraft as well as in auto-
motive industries [1]. The joining of dissimilar alloys becomes a prime demand in
the automotive and aircraft industries for products with improved quality in terms of
strength and ductility but light in weight. In order to produce vehicles with economical
fuel consumption and manage pollution, many parts are manufactured by combin-
ing alloys that have lightweight and good corrosion resistance such as aluminum
alloys [2].
Tungsten Inert Gas (TIG), also known as Gas Tungsten Arc Welding (GTAW) is
the preferred welding process of alloys because of the comparatively easier applica-
bility and superior economy [3]. The TIG welding process is also suitable to weld
thin plates, resulting in high-quality and defect-free welded joints [4]. The arc is
established between the tip of a non-consumable tungsten electrode and the work
piece with a shielding gas applied to protect oxidation of the weld pool area [5].
In the TIG welding, problems may occur during the welding process where the
welds may fail in the soft and over age heat-affected zone [6]. The limitations exist
to join dissimilar aluminum alloys that are mainly related to the presence of an oxide
layer. This oxide layer weakens the grain boundary cohesion and consequently the
weld becomes prone to inter-granular cracking experienced during welding-pool
solidification. Also, thermal conductivity and composition with alloying elements are
one of the major causes these materials are difficult to join [7, 8]. Hence, feasibility of
welding dissimilar alloys needs to be studied deeply before applied to the fabrication
of engineering products.
In this study, the weldability of dissimilar aluminum alloys 6061 and 7075
was studied using both destructive and nondestructive testing. Visual inspec-
tions, microstructure identification, tension test and hardness test are conducted to
investigate the effect of the welding process.
2.1 Materials
fixed. The other parameters such as welding current welding voltage and gas flow
rate are varied. The various welding parameters and its level are tabulated in Table 1
(Table 3).
2.2 Experimentation
Tungsten Inert Gas Welding is a multi-factor metal joining technique. The various
process parameters include welding current, welding voltage, gas flow rate, elec-
trode diameter, nozzle gap, etc. influence on weld bead geometry, weldment quality
and also mechanical-metallurgical properties of the weldment. A limited number
of experimental runs have been done in this study to use three levels of welding
process parameters namely welding current, welding voltage, gas flow rate. Single
side 60° V groove has been made before welding. Experiments have been carried
out to create a single pass butt joint of dissimilar aluminum plates by varying the
process parameters in the TIG welding. The tensile test specimens were prepared as
per ASTM standards.
Feasibility Study of TIG Welding of AA6063-AA7075 Alloys 713
Table 4 Experimentation
Exp. No. Welding Welding Gas flow rate
matrix
current (A) voltage (V) (L/min)
1 150 18 5
2 150 20 7
3 150 22 9
4 175 18 7
5 175 20 9
6 175 22 5
7 200 18 9
8 200 20 5
9 200 22 7
Taguchi’s orthogonal arrays are standard experimental design tables in order to per-
form only a small number of experimental trials to find the influence of the main
factors on the response. The minimum number of experiments to be conducted is
calculated from the formula given below
N = 1 + V (L − 1) (1)
In this study,
V = 3 and L = 3, Hence
N = 1 + 4(3 − 1) = 9.
Taguchi experimental design of experiments suggests L9 orthogonal array, where
nine experiments are sufficient to optimize the parameters. Hence at least nine exper-
iments are to be conducted. Based on this L9 orthogonal array (OA) is to be selected
which has at least nine rows, i.e., nine experimental runs (Table 4).
Destructive testing was done on three specimens (specimen 2, specimen 4 and spec-
imen 9). The results are as shown in Fig. 1. The result shows the specimen 2, welded
714 D. Nathan et al.
at low welding current, low welding voltage and medium gas flow rate has a low
tensile strength.
The result of the testing done on specimen 4 which is welded under medium
welding current, medium welding voltage and low gas flow rate gives out high tensile
strength. The result depicts the specimen nine welded low welding current, low
welding voltage and medium gas flow rate brings very low tensile strength (Table 5).
The Vickers Hardness test was done on all specimens under 10 kgf load with a dwell
time of 10 s. Before doing hardness test the specimens were prepared by polishing
with help of different grades of emery paper in order to get clear indentation marks.
Hardness measurement was carried from either side of base metal towards the center
of the weld. The results of specimens 2, 4, and 9 were plotted in a graph as shown in
Fig. 2. The result shows the specimen 2, welded at low pulsed current, low pulsed
voltage and medium gas flow rate has a high hardness structure in HV.
The result of the testing done on specimen 4, which is welded under medium
pulsed current, medium pulsed voltage and low gas flow rate gives out medium
Hardness structure in HV. The result depicts the specimen 9, welded high pulsed
current, high pulsed voltage and high gas flow rate bring very low Hardness structure
in HV.
Distribution of microhardness values was analyzed and depicted in Fig. 3. The
graph shows that hardness value decreases at HAZ on both sides of welding due to
the coarsening of grain structure. Hardness value has an increasing trend near the
Feasibility Study of TIG Welding of AA6063-AA7075 Alloys 715
center of the weld bead on both sides of the welded region. It is found to be AA 7075
side has higher hardness distribution compared to the AA 6063 side.
test specimen, 2 grain distortion was found clearly. A small amount of intermetallic
phases in the form of fine precipitates is present in the grains and grain structure
found to be coarse (Fig. 4).
Liquid penetrant test results are depicted in Fig. 6. A maximum flaw length of 10 mm
was found in the test number 1 is an unacceptable value. Test number 3, 4, 5, 6, 7
and 8 have an average flaw length of 2.91 mm. Test number 2 and 9 have no defects
(Fig. 5).
Feasibility Study of TIG Welding of AA6063-AA7075 Alloys 717
The calibrated ultrasound flaw detector can calculate the depth of the discontinuity
and the thickness of the component accurately. Figure 7 shows the ultrasonic testing
on TIG-welded specimen.
From Fig. 8, it is evident that the maximum flaw length of 3.8 mm occurs in test
number 5 at the gas flow rate of 9 L/min and welding of 175 A. Test numbers 2, 8,
and 9 show minimum flaw length of 3.4 mm. Average flaw length of 3.5 mm found
in test 3 and 7. Hence, it is evident that all the test specimens have flaws in the weld.
From literature, gas flow rate in the TIG welding process of Aluminum alloy has
a significant effect on weld quality. Shielding gas has a greater influence on weld
strength, porosity, ductility, impact strength and resistance to corrosion. Argon is used
as shielding gas in this work. Welding defects such as porosity, lack of penetration and
fusion are taken care of by suitable shielding gas at a certain flow rate. Hence the gas
flow rate is considered as one of the welding parameters in this study. Observations
show a significant variation in tensile strength with respect to gas flow rate.
4 Conclusion
This investigation found the feasibility of various TIG welding by estimating mechan-
ical properties and microscopic study of the weld. Taguchi’s L9 Orthogonal Array
has been implemented in the experimentation. Tensile testing, hardness testing and
microscopic examinations have been done. Liquid penetrant test and ultrasonic
inspection were successfully conducted on welds produced at various parameter
combinations. It can be concluded that based on the various parameters of welding
Feasibility Study of TIG Welding of AA6063-AA7075 Alloys 719
the liquid penetrant testing and ultrasonic technique successfully detected the defects
present in the welds and can be said to be appropriate in this regard. This study shows
the idea to choose suitable welding parameters for the better welding of dissimilar
alloy.
References
1. Fukuda T (2012) Weldability of 7000 series alloy materials. Weld Int 26:256–269
2. Hayat F (2012) Effect of aging treatment on the microstructure and mechanical properties of
the similar and dissimilar 6061-T6/7075-T651 RSW joints. Mater Sci Eng A 556:834–843
3. Kumar TS, Balasubramanian V, Sanavullah MY (2007) Influences of pulsed current tungsten
inert gas welding parameters on the tensile properties of AA 6061 alloy. Mater Des 28:2080–2092
4. Nascimento MP, Voorwald HJC, PayãoFilho JDC (2011) Fatigue strength of tungsten inert
gas-repaired weld joints in airplane critical structures. J Mater Process Technol 211:1126–1135
5. American welding. Society 261–269 (2012)
6. Mutombo K, Du Toit M (2011) Corrosion fatigue behaviour of alloy 6061-T651 welded using
fully automatic gas metal arc welding and ER5183 filler alloy. Int J Fatigue 33:1539–1547
7. Lakshminarayanan AK, Balasubramanian V, Elangovan K (2007) Effect of welding processes
on tensile properties of AA6061 alloy joints. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 40:286–296
8. Song JL, Lin SB, Yang CL, Ma GC, Liu H (2009) Spreading behavior and microstructure
characteristics of dissimilar metals TIG welding–brazing of aluminum alloy to stainless steel.
Mater Sci Eng A 509:31–40
Effects of Processing Parameters
on Temperature Distributions, Tensile
Behaviour and Microstructure
of Friction Stir Welding of Dissimilar
Aluminium Alloys
Abstract Research has shown that there is a correlation between process parameters,
temperature variations, tensile strength, microstructures and the durability of the
welds obtained in friction stir welding (FSW). The need to institute this correlation
is crucial in order to achieve a weld free of defects and having sound mechanical
behaviours for industrial applications. This work examines process parameters effects
on variations of weld temperature, tensile strength and microstructures in dissimilar
FSW of 6101-T6 and 7075-T651 aluminium alloys with a plate thickness of 6 mm.
The welding was done with rotational speeds of 1250, 1550 and 1850 rpm and
traverse speeds of 50 and 110 mm/min. The results obtained indicate that processing
parameters significantly affect the temperature distributions in the weld. Increase in
rotational speed increases the temperature but cause a decrease in tensile strength.
While the increase in travel speed cause a reduction in temperature which results to
increase in the tensile strength. Highest tensile strength of 143 MPa was obtained
at 1250 rpm and 50 mm/min but better mixing of both materials was achieved at
1550 rpm and 50 mm/min.
1 Introduction
One of the metals that are broadly used in many engineering applications is alu-
minium. The extensive use of this alloy emanates from its properties. One of which
is its high strength to weight ratio. FSW is a technology that has been in use for
joining both similar and dissimilar aluminium alloys. The unique advantages of this
Dissimilar aluminium alloys 6101-T6 and 7075-T651 were used for the experiment.
The elemental constituents of the two materials are indicated in Table 1 while Table 2
shows the mechanical properties.
Three tool rotational speeds and two feed rates were engaged in this study as presented
in Table 3.
The tool for the experiment was fabricated using high carbon steel H13. It has shoul-
der diameter of 22 mm with a tapered pin profile of big diameter 7.3 mm, small
diameter 5.5 mm and pin length of 5.6 mm as illustrated in Fig. 1. The two alloy
plates of 7075-T651 and AA6101-T6 were cleaned and arranged in butt configura-
tion with AA6101-T6 on the advancing side and 7075-T651 on the retreating side
as illustrated in Fig. 2. The FSW was performed along the rolling direction of the
two alloy samples with the tilt angle at 20 . Two thermocouple wires were embedded
in the workpiece 2 mm away from the welding zone on both sides of the plates
and are placed 40 mm apart. The thermocouples were connected to a temperature
data capturing machine for in-process temperature measurements. The thermocouple
arrangement is shown in Fig. 3. Four different experiments were carried out using
the parameters shown in Table 3. Three tensile samples cut according to ASTM E8
standard were tested for each weld and the average for each weld taken for evalua-
tion. The microstuctural analysis was done on the nugget zone of each weld using
an optical microscope.
724
Fig. 3 Schematic diagram of the thermocouple arrangements T0, T1, T2, T3 on the alloy plates
The weld joints were carefully observed after the welding and were found to be
externally free form defects although little flashes are noticed in some of the welds
as shown in the photograph in Fig. 4.
Effects of Processing Parameters on Temperature Distributions … 727
400
300
T1 1250/50
T2 1550/50
200
T3 1850/50
T4 1850/110
100
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
Time (Min)
Heat is produced as a consequence of the friction between the workpiece and the
rotating tool. This generated heat influenced the thermo-mechanical welding process
and impact on the mechanical behaviours of the joints. The highest heat takes place
at the workpiece and rotating tool interface. The temperature profile of the welding
process with time is presented in Fig. 5. The temperatures recorded at the 6101-T6
side of the weld which is the advancing side were lower than those at the 7075-T651
side which is the retreating side. This is as a result of different thermal conductivity
influence of the welded plates. The 6101-T6 alloy on the advancing side of the welds
has a higher thermal conductivity than 7075-T651 placed on the retrieving side.
This implies that the rate of heat transfer and heat losses is higher in 6101-T6 than in
7075-T651, hence the aluminium alloy 7075-T651 on the retreating side retains more
heat than 6101-T6 and therefore gave higher temperature values than the 6101-T6
alloys during the welding. The temperature profile also indicates that the temperature
728 O. P. Abolusoro and E. T. Akinlabi
generally increases as the welding progresses and get to the peak in the middle of
the weld.
Varying the travel speed also influenced the temperature distributions. At 1850 rpm
and 50 mm/min, the highest temperature recorded was 560 °C while at 110 mm/min
travel speed with the same rotational speed of 1850 rpm, the highest temperature
was 480 °C. The lower temperature recorded at the higher travel speed could be as
a result of less heat generated own to less dwelling time of the rotating tool as it
moves faster on the workpiece. While the higher temperature obtained at the lower
travel speed was due to more dwelling time of the rotating tool as it moves slower
on the workpiece. Also, the ratio of the rotational speed to the welding speed of
the tool decreases from 37 to 17 rpm min/mm as the speed rises from 50 mm/min
to 110 mm/min. This decrease in the ratio leads to a reduction in heat input and
consequently lowers the temperature of the weld.
100
80
60
40
20
0
1200 1400 1600 1800 2000
Rotational Speed (rpm)
At a steady rotational speed of 1850 rpm, the rising of feed rate from 50 to
110 mm/min causes the ultimate tensile strength to increase by 4 MPa. The increase
follows a drop in the temperature as shown in Fig. 5. This implies that there was
an improvement in grain bonding as the temperature drops and consequently an
improvement in the ultimate tensile strength of the joint. This is shown in Fig. 7.
140
Ultimate Tensile Strength (MPa)
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
50 100
Travel Speed (mm/min)
Fig. 8 Macrographs of the welded zone. a 1250 rpm/50 mm/min, b 1550 rpm/50 mm/min,
c 1850 rpm/50 mm/min, d 1850 rpm/110 mm/min
The macrographs of all the welds (Fig. 8a–d) show that there was sufficient heat for
plasticization for all the welds. The welds exhibited onion ring structures at all the
rotational speed. Lamellae structure pattern of material flow was observed in all the
parameters. Larger material movement is observed at the 1850 rpm and 110 mm/min.
However, full penetration of the alloys into one another occurred more at 1550 rpm
and 50 mm/min rotational speed and feed rate respectively.
The microstructure varies across the length and the breath of the weld and can
be divided into unmixed, mechanically mixed and mixed regions as reported by
some authors [27–29]. The unmixed region is observed close to the tool shoulder
areas. Fine-grain structure is observed here as shown in Figs. 9a, 10a, 11a and 12a
as a result of dynamic recrystallization during the welding. The mechanically mixed
region (Figs. 9b, 10b, 11b and 12b) is the interface region of both alloys at the fusion
zone. It contains the microstructures of both alloys. Weck’s reagent etchant used
revealed 7075-T651 as a lighter colour and the 6101-T6 as brown colour. At the
mixed region, the tool pin stirring mechanism moved plastically deformed materials
in alternate layers of 7075-T651 and 6101-T6 to form lamellae structural pattern
(Figs. 9c, 10c, 11c and 12c.
Material penetration of the aluminium alloy into each other was highest at
1550 rpm and 50 mm/min rotational speed and travel speed, respectively.
Effects of Processing Parameters on Temperature Distributions … 731
Fig. 9 Microstructures of weld nugget zone at 100× for 1250 rpm/50 mm/min, a unmixed,
b mechanically mixed, c mixed regions
Fig. 10 Microstructures of weld nugget zone at 100× for 1550 rpm/50 mm/min, a unmixed,
b mechanically mixed, c mixed regions
Fig. 11 Microstructures of weld nugget zone at 100× for 1850 rpm/50 mm/min, a unmixed,
b mechanically mixed, c mixed regions
Fig. 12 Microstructures of weld nugget zone at 100× for 1850 rpm/110 mm/min, a unmixed,
b mechanically mixed, c mixed regions
732 O. P. Abolusoro and E. T. Akinlabi
4 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The authors appreciate the head and all the scholars of the Friction stir lab-
oratory of the India Institute of Technology Kharagpur where this experiment was carried out and
to the University of Johannesburg South Africa for sponsorship.
References
1. Padhy GK, Wu CS, Gao S (2017) Friction stir based welding and processing technologies -
processes, parameters, microstructures, and applications: a review. J Mater Sci Technol 34:1–38
2. Sidhu MS, Chatha SS (2012) Friction stir welding—process and its variables: a review. Int J
Emerg Technol Adv Eng 2(12):275–279
3. Abolusoro OP, Akinlabi ET (2019) Wear and corrosion behaviour of friction stir welded
aluminium alloys—an overview. Int J Mech Prod Eng Res Dev 9(3):967–982
4. Mishra RS, Mahoney MW, Sato Y, Hovanski Y (2016) Friction stir welding and processing
VIII
5. Silva ACF, De Backer J, Bolmsjö G (2017) Temperature measurements during friction stir
welding. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 88(9–12):2899–2908
6. Khandkar MZH, Khan JA, Reynolds AP (2003) Prediction of temperature distribution and
thermal history during friction stir welding: input torque based model. Sci Technol Weld Join
8(3):165–174
7. Yan F, Zhang Y, Fu X, Li Q, Gao J (2019) A new calculating method of frictional heat and its
application during friction stir welding. Appl Therm Eng 153(January):250–263
8. Givi MKB, Asadi P (2014) Advances in friction-stir welding and processing
9. Lombard H, Hattingh DG, Steuwer A, James MN (2008) Optimising FSW process parameters
to minimize defects and maximize fatigue life in 5083-H321 aluminium alloy. Eng Fract Mech
75(3–4):341–354
10. Prabha KA, Putha PK, Prasad BS (2018) Effect of tool rotational speed on mechanical properties
of aluminium alloy 5083 weldments in friction stir welding. Mater Today Proc 5(9):18535–
18543
11. Aydin H, Bayram A, Esme U, Kazancoglu Y, Guven O (2010) Application of grey relation
analysis (Gra) and Taguchi method for the parametric optimization of friction stir welding
(FSW) process. Appl Grey Relat Anal 44(4):205–211
Effects of Processing Parameters on Temperature Distributions … 733
12. Abd Elnabi MM, Elshalakany AB, Abdel-Mottaleb MM, Osman TA, El Mokadem AA (2019)
Influence of friction stir welding parameters on metallurgical and mechanical properties of
dissimilar AA5454-AA7075 aluminum alloys. J Mater Res Technol 8(2):1684–1693
13. Rajakumar S, Balasubramanian V (2012) Establishing relationships between mechanical prop-
erties of aluminium alloys and optimized friction stir welding process parameters. Mater Des
40:17–35
14. Kumar SR, Rao VS, Pranesh RV (2014) Effect of welding parameters on macro and microstruc-
ture of friction stir welded dissimilar butt joints between AA7075-T651 and AA6061-T651
alloys. Procedia Mater Sci 5:1726–1735
15. Das U, Toppo V (2018) Effect of tool rotational speed on temperature and impact strength of
friction stir welded joint of two dissimilar aluminum alloys. Mater Today: Proc 5:6170–6175
16. Takayama Y, Akutsu Y, Choshiro N, Kato H, Watanabe H (2010) Temperature measurement
during friction stir welding of dissimilar aluminum alloys, pp 0–5
17. Kandasamy J, Sairam J, Hussain MM (2018) ScienceDirect ICMPC_2018 comparative analysis
of temperature variation in friction stir welding. Mater Today Proc 5:18798–18804
18. Sun YF, Fujii H, Sato Y, Morisada Y (2019) Friction stir spot welding of SPCC low carbon
steel plates at extremely low welding temperature. J Mater Sci Technol 35:733–741
19. Silva-Magalhães A, De Backer J, Martin J, Bolmsjö G (2019) In-situ temperature measurement
in friction stir welding of thick section aluminium alloys. J Manuf Process 39:12–17
20. Hamilton C, Dymek S, Sommers A (2010) Characteristic temperature curves for aluminum
alloys during friction stir. Weld J
21. Covington JL, Robison W, Webb BW (2006) Experimental characterization of tool heating
during friction stir welding. Mech Eng 179–184
22. Buffa G, Donati L, Fratini L, Tomesani L (2006) Solid state bonding in extrusion and FSW:
Process mechanics and analogies. J Mater Process Technol 177(1–3):344–347
23. Feng Z et al (2007) In situ neutron diffraction measurements of temperature and stresses during
friction stir welding of 6061-T6 aluminium alloy. Sci Technol Weld Join 12(4):298–303
24. Fehrenbacher A, Duffie NA, Ferrier NJ, Pfefferkorn FE, Zinn MR (2014) Effects of
tool-workpiece interface temperature on weld quality and quality improvements through
temperature control in friction stir welding. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 71(1–4):165–179
25. Upadhyay P, Reynolds AP (2010) Effects of thermal boundary conditions in friction stir welded
AA7050-T7 sheets. Mater Sci Eng A 527(6):1537–1543
26. Miles M, Karki U, Hovanski Y (2014) Temperature and material flow prediction in friction-stir
spot welding of advanced high-strength steel. JOM 66(10):2130–2136
27. Palanivel R, Koshy Mathews P, Murugan N, Dinaharan I (2012) Effect of tool rotational speed
and pin profile on microstructure and tensile strength of dissimilar friction stir welded AA5083-
H111 and AA6351-T6 aluminum alloys. Mater Des 40:7–16
28. Ouyang JH, Kovacevic R (2002) Material flow and microstructure in the friction stir butt welds
of the same and dissimilar aluminum alloys. J Mater Eng Perform
29. Shigematsu I, Kwon YJ, Suzuki K, Imai T, Saito N (2003) Joining of 5083 and 6061 aluminum
alloys by friction stir welding. J Mater Sci Lett
Optimizing the Parameters for Friction
Stir Welding of an Aluminium Alloy
M. Selvaraj
Abstract A novel slip factor accounted for thermal model is being used to predict the
temperature with time and the effect of welding and rotations on heat input for weld
length peak-temperature of the friction stir welding process. Material used in this
study is aluminium alloy of AA6061 grade which is used in aerospace applications.
For various rotations and weld velocities, friction stir welding experiments were
conducted on aluminium alloy plates. The plates were fixed with thermocouples
at different locations from weld centerline to measure the temperatures during the
welding process. The temperature with time and locations predicted by the model
along the transverse direction are closely matching with the experimental results.
The heat input for unit length of weld and peak-temperature increases as rotation
increases and decreases as weld velocity increases. The energy required for welding
for length is minimum at the combination of lower rotation and higher weld velocity
in the defect-free zone.
1 Introduction
Heat flow modeling during the FSW process was done by Rajamanickam et al. [1]
and Riahi and Nazari [2] using a heat flow model to obtain the thermal history.
Song and Kovacevic [3] presented the isotherms and temperature with time of FSW
process by simulating the welding process. Woo et al. [4] and Chao and Tang [5]
developed a heat flow model for the FSW process, numerically predicted tempera-
ture with time. Prasanna et al. [6] modeled the FSW process of steel, predicted the
temperature with time. Nandan et al. [7] presented a 3D thermal and material flow
model and predicted the thermal history, velocity and strain rate during the FSW
process. Hamilton et al. [8, 9] done simulation of FS welding of aluminium alloy
M. Selvaraj (B)
Sri Sivasubramaniya Nadar College of Engineering, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India
e-mail: selvarajm71@gmail.com
to predict the thermal cycle. 3-dimensional model for FSW considering energy due
to friction and plastic deformation is developed by Emam and Domiaty [10] and
predicted change of peak normalized temperature with the effective energy. Selvaraj
et al. [11, 12] proposed a thermal model for FS welding of steels assuming slip factor
as a function of temperature to predict the temperature with time and energy required
per unit weld length during the welding process.
The literature survey indicates that most of the thermal studies concentrate on
predicting temperature distribution and temperature with time during FSW process.
Most of the researchers have not predicted the energy required for different com-
binations of weld velocity and rotation. In some combinations of weld, parameters
require to weld with minimum energy. It will save a lot of energy. In this paper, atten-
tion has been given to predicting the energy-efficient rotational and weld velocity in
the FS welding process using a mechanics-based heat flow model.
2 Experiment Work
This study uses AA6061 aluminium alloy which is used in applications like aerospace
and marine. The material was cut into a plate of 150 × 75 × 6 mm size. Two plates are
aligned and fixed by clamps. Aligned plates were welded using an M2 steel tool as
shown in Fig. 1. The tool and welding parameters are given in Table 1. The welding
experiments were done by an FSW machine with 12 kW motor as shown in Fig. 2.
3 Thermal Model
Shoulder heat
Friction heat at shoulder
2π
Q sh−fr = μ pn ω (rs3 − r13 ) (1)
3
738 M. Selvaraj
Fn
pn = (2)
πrs2
2π N
ω= (3)
60
The friction coefficient (μ) is linearly varying from 0.5 to 0.4 between the room
and solidus temperature [13].
Shear deformation heat at shoulder
2π
Psh−pl = τ ω(rs3 − r13 ) (4)
3
Shear stress,
σy
τ=√ (5)
3
Total heat
Calculated pin heat at side Q ps and bottom Q pb are
Pin heat,
Q pin = Q ps + Q pb (7)
Q T = Q sh + Q ps + Q pb (8)
QT
Ql = × 60 (9)
V
Table 2 Properties of 6061-T6 aluminium alloy [2]
Temperature (°C) 26 38 93 147 205 260 316 372 425
Yield strength (MPa) 276 275 265 249 219 159 66 34 17
Density (kg/m3 ) 2700 2686 2686 2666 2656 2656 2631 2621 2601
Optimizing the Parameters for Friction Stir Welding …
Thermal con. (W/m °C) 167 171 178 185 191 202 205 215 225
Heat capacity (J/kg °C) 896 921 979 1005 1029 1051 1079 1105 1134
739
740 M. Selvaraj
ht = 15 W/m2 oC
ht= 15 W/m2 oC
Weld center
line
Area heat flux
ht = 15 W/m2 oC Plate
ht = 300 W/m2 oC
3Q shr
qsh = 0.9 × for rp ≤ r ≤ rs (10)
2π(rs3 − rp3 )
Heat around the pin is taken as volume heat flux in the shape of hollow cylinder
based on the shear layer thickness of 2 mm as stated by Chen et al. [15].
Q pin
qpin = 0.9 × (11)
π [(rp + 2)2 − rp2 ]h
See Fig. 3.
(a) Weld velocity 300 mm/min & rotation 300 rpm. (b) Weld velocity 300 mm/min & rotation 1200
rpm.
(c) Weld velocity 300 mm/min & rotation 2000 rpm. (d) Weld velocity 900 mm/min & rotation 300 rpm.
(e) Weld velocity 900 mm/min & rotation 1200 rpm. (f) Weld velocity 900 mm/min & rotation 2000
rpm.
Fig. 4 Temperature with time at various locations from the weld centerline for different Weld
velocity and rotations
742 M. Selvaraj
(g) Weld velocity 1800 mm/min & rotation 300 rpm. (h) Weld velocity 1800 mm/min & rotation 1200 rpm
.
Fig. 4 (continued)
Analyzing the temperature with time of 300 mm/min weld velocity and different
rotations, the temperature increases and drops sharply for 300 rpm than 1200 rpm.
It also shows that the peak-temperature is high and wider cycle is obtained for 1200
as compared to 300 rpm. But the variation of temperature with time and peak-
temperature between 1200 and 2000 rpm is not significant. For a constant weld
velocity (300 mm/min), when speed is increased from 300 to 1200 rpm, heat gen-
eration increases and leads to variation in temperature with time. The variation in
temperature with time between 1200 and 2000 rpm is not significant because vari-
ation in heat generation is not significant. The same kind of pattern is visible in the
other weld velocities also.
Analyzing the effect of various weld velocity for a constant rotation (300 rpm), the
rise and dip in temperature are very sharp and peak-temperature decreases as weld
velocity increases. As weld velocity increases, the heat source quickly approaches
and passes away the measuring location and it leads to a sharp rise and drops in
temperature.
Optimizing the Parameters for Friction Stir Welding … 743
The energy required for length of weld and peak-temperature for various weld veloc-
ity and rotations are illustrated in Figs. 5 and 6. It is noted that the heat input for
length of weld and peak-temperature increases as rotation increases but decreases as
weld velocity increases. It is also noted that at lower rotations slope of the curve is
more and it reduces as rotation increases. This is due to reduction in heat generation
rate as rotation increases. The heat input for length of weld is inversely propor-
tional to the weld velocity. The heat input for length of weld and peak-temperature
Fig. 6 Simulated
peak-temperature for various
weld velocity and rotations
744 M. Selvaraj
600
400
200
0
2000
1500 2000
1000 1500
1000
500 500
Translational velocity in mm/min 0 0
Rotational speed in rpm
Fig. 7 Energy required for length of weld for various weld velocity and rotations
follow the same trend. It is clear that heat input for length of weld influences the
peak-temperature (Fig. 7).
In the defect-free zone, the energy required per unit weld length is 188.2 J/mm
at the combination of lower rotation (1200 rpm) and higher weld velocity
(1800 mm/min). The energy required per unit weld length is 549.6 at the combi-
nation of higher rotation (1200 rpm) and lower weld velocity (300 mm/min). The
energy required at the combination of higher rotation and lower weld velocity is 2.9
times higher as compared with the energy required per unit weld length the combi-
nation of lower rotation and higher weld velocity. It shows that the energy required
for welding for length is minimum at the combination of lower rotation and higher
weld velocity in the defect-free weld zone. Hence it is vital to see the combination
of lower rotation and higher weld velocity in order to weld with minimum energy.
This will save a lot of energy required for welding.
5 Conclusions
1. The predicted temperature with time and location in transverse direction has
closely merged with that of experimental values.
2. The energy required per weld length is minimum at the combination of lower
rotation and higher weld velocity.
Optimizing the Parameters for Friction Stir Welding … 745
References
Abstract This study explains the effects of process parameters of Wire Electrical
Discharge Machining (WEDM) on the machinability and surface characteristics of
Magnesium ZE41 alloy. ZE41 alloy has a plethora of applications in the structural
industry, aerospace industry, military equipment, video cameras, and vibration test-
ing equipment. In this study, Pulse on time (Ton), Pulse off time (Toff), Current
(I) and Wire Tension (WT) were considered as the input parameters to conduct the
experiments for the performance measures Material removal rate (MRR) and Sur-
face roughness (Ra). Experimentation works were conducted by using Taguchi’s L9
orthogonal array. Analysis of variance (ANOVA) was performed to identify the sig-
nificant parameters. XRD test was carried out to identify the phase constituents of
the material. Further, Surface morphology of the machined surface is analyzed using
SEM micrographs.
1 Introduction
The demand for alloy materials is rising abound in recent years due to its appealing
properties like high strength to weight ratio, ductility, formability, and high resistance
to chemical attack. Alloying is an effective technique to enhance the mechanical prop-
erties of the materials by combining the beneficial properties of two or more metals
[1]. It is the most predominantly used material in all engineering applications since
pure metals have limitations in its properties. Magnesium is the 6th widely available
lightweight material in the earthly resources [2]. Magnesium alloys have renowned
properties like good castability, formability, high sound dampening capacity, and
low density [3]. Among aluminum, steels, and copper-base alloys, magnesium alloy
is the supreme material for structural applications due to its high strength to weight
ratio. However, it has poor hardness, wear, and corrosion resistance. Pure magne-
sium is highly susceptible to corrosion and weakens the material behavior which
can be enhanced by adding alloying elements [3]. Magnesium and its alloys have a
plethora of applications in biomedical engineering like screws and plates for bone
fixation, tissue engineering scaffolds, as well as on cardiovascular stents [4], automo-
bile, aerospace, electronics, and structural industries [5]. Machining of magnesium
alloy at the required shape with the superior surface finish is necessary to perform its
intended functions. So, it is indeed crucial to machine the material with minimal sur-
face roughness and higher material removal rate. It is identified that nontraditional
machining is the best way out to cut intricate shapes with a better surface finish.
Amongst all other nontraditional machining processes, WEDM is the apt machining
process to process magnesium alloys. The material removal mechanism for WEDM
is the melting and vaporization of the material due to the electrical discharges. It has
the potential to cut any intricate shapes with great accuracy of electrically conduc-
tive material [6]. A material with high electrical and thermal conductivity would be
preferred as wire electrodes. Brass wire and zinc-coated brass wire are commonly
used wire electrodes in the recent era due to its utmost performance [7].
Janardhan and Samuel [8] developed a pulse discrimination algorithm to study the
effect of machining parameters at spark gap and revealed that the surface roughness
(Ra) and roundness error are majorly affected by the occurrence of arc regions, width
of arc and average ignition delay time. Weingartner et al. [9] investigated the shape
and size of craters produced during single discharge experiments and developed
an electro-thermal model. Further, the experimental results are then compared with
the simulation results. Mohammadi et al. [10] discussed the effects of machining
parameters for roundness error and surface quality of a cylindrical component and
further presented the mathematical model equation for predicting the roughness using
regression analysis.
Few researchers have attempted on processing ZE41 magnesium alloy in WEDM
but there is a gap in investigating the surface integrity and morphology of the
machined surface. The objective of the present work is to study the effect of process
parameters of WEDM on machining of ZE41 alloy for the responses MRR and sur-
face roughness. Surface morphology of the machined surface was examined through
SEM micrographs. Besides, the phase constituents of the alloy were investigated
using XRD pattern.
spectrum. Copper is used as target material, generator voltage and tube current were
set as 45 kV and 40 mA, respectively. In Fig. 1, from the obtained XRD peaks, it
is evident that magnesium occupies the dominant phases and few traces of zinc are
also detected when compared with JCPDS data.
Zinc-coated brass wire is used as wire material with the diameter 250 µm and
deionized water is used as dielectric medium. Taguchi’s L9 orthogonal array was
employed to conduct the experiments. The controllable factors considered for this
experiment were based on previous literature and trial experiments. Table 2 dis-
cusses the controllable parameters and their levels considered for conducting the
experiments. The constant parameters used for these experiments were wire feed:
3 m/min, Gap voltage:30 V, Water Pressure: 9 bar.
MRR is calculated by the following expression:
MRR (mm3 /min) = cutting speed (mm/min) × kerf width (mm) × thickness (mm)
(1)
From Fig. 2 and Table 4, it is revealed that the pulse on time is the most predominant
factor which majorly influences the MRR. Next to pulse on time, current plays a
major role in deciding MRR. The rest of the factors have minor influences over
MRR. The increase in pulse on time and current increases the material removal rate,
this is due to the fact that the amount of discharge energy rises up drastically which
in turn melt and vaporize large lump of material and produces huge crater. Therefore,
an increasing trend is observed in Fig. 3 for both pulse on time and current.
Machining of ZE41 Magnesium Alloy in WEDM Using Taguchi Approach 751
From Fig. 3 and Table 4, it is revealed that the pulse on time plays the major role
followed by the current on determining the surface roughness of the machined sur-
face. The amount of discharge energy applied is directly proportional to the longevity
of the pulse and the magnitude of discharge energy per pulse decides the crater size.
An increase in pulse on time increases the discharge energy which tends to produce
large craters and creates an uneven surface. Hence, increase in pulse on time and
current diminish the surface quality of the material [11].
Figure 4 explains the surface morphology of the machined surface. In WEDM,
material removal takes place in the form of craters. The size of the crater depends on
the intensity of the electrical discharge. As the discharge energy increases, the more
will be the crater size. It is observed from the SEM images that the machined surface
752 G. Selvakumar et al.
Fig. 4 a Microcracks on the machined surface, b presence of molten globules, c crater and
microcrack formation of the machined surface
4 Conclusion
In this work, WEDM machining of ZE41 alloy was performed and the effect of
process parameters was studied for the responses MRR and Ra. The XRD analysis
has been conducted to identify the phase constituents of the material. Pulse on time
and current were identified as the prime factors which influence the material removal
rate and surface roughness. The surface morphology of the machined surface has
been studied with the SEM micrographs. Molten globules, microcracks, pockmarks,
and microvoids were observed in the machined region.
References
1. Chen J, Tan L, Yu X, Etim IP, Ibrahim M, Yang K (2018) Mechanical properties of magnesium
alloys for medical application: a review. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater 87:68–79
2. Singh K, Singh G, Singh H (2018) Review on friction stir welding of magnesium alloys. J
Magn Alloys 6:399–416
3. Dinodi N, Nityananda Shetty A (2013) Electrochemical investigations on the corrosion
behaviour of magnesium alloy ZE41 in a combined medium of chloride and sulphate. J Magn
Alloys 1:201–209
4. Hohna S, Virtanena S, Boccaccini AR (2019) Protein adsorption on magnesium and its alloys:
a review. Appl Surf Sci 464:212–219
5. Luo AA (2013) Magnesium casting technology for structural applications. J Magn Alloys
1:2–22
6. Selvakumar G, Thiruppathi Kuttalingam KG, Ram Prakash S (2018) Investigation on machining
and surface characteristics of AA5083 for cryogenic applications by adopting trim cut in
WEDM. J Braz Soc Mech Sci Eng 40:267
7. Gnanavelbabu A, Saravanan P, Rajkumar K, Karthikeyan S, Baskaran R (2018) Optimization
of WEDM process parameters on multiple responses in cutting of Ti-6Al-4V. Mater Today:
Proc 5:27072–27080
8. Janardhan V, Samuel GL (2010) Pulse train data analysis to investigate the effect of machining
parameters on the performance of wire electro discharge turning (WEDT) process. Int J Mach
Tools Manuf 50:775–788
9. Weingartner E, Wegener K, Kuster F (2012) Wire electrical discharge machining applied to
high-speed rotating workpieces. J Mater Proc Technol 212:1298–1304
10. Mohammadi A, Tehrani AF, Emanian E, Karimi D (2008) A new approach to surface roughness
and roundness improvement in wire electrical discharge turning based on statistical analyses.
Int J Adv Manuf Technol 39:64–73
11. Selvakumar G, Sarkar S, Mitra S (2013) An experimental analysis of single pass cutting of
aluminium 5083 alloy in different corner angles through WEDM. Int J Mach Machinabil Mater
13(2/3)
Comparative Study of Friction Stir
Welding and Underwater Friction Stir
Welding on Magnesium ZE41 Alloy
Abstract 5-mm-thick ZE41 magnesium alloy plates were subjected to normal fric-
tion stir welding (in air) and under water friction stir welding (UWFSW). A compar-
ative study was made to investigate the process parameter and resultant properties of
microstructure and tensile behaviour. The friction stir welding (FSW) was carried out
at two different speeds 660 and 1220 rpm in order to obtain the influence of rotation
speed on the performance of underwater joints. And the tool transverse speed and
the tool tilt angle were fixed at 40 mm/min and 2.5°, respectively. From this investi-
gation, it can be found that the UWFSW joint made using the higher tool rotational
speed of 1220 rpm exhibited good tensile properties when compared to FSW joints
without any defects like tunnel-type defects or hot cracking. The higher cooling rate
in the UWFSW caused reduced thermomechanically affected zone (TMAZ) in the
weld. The joint welded at UWFSW made the grain size fine when compared to the
grain size of joints at the air weld condition. It is also noted that the hardness was
increased in the UWFSW specimen due to the fine grains present in the stir zone.
For air weld, the fracture occurred in the weld region and for UWFSW the fracture
moved away from the stir zone.
1 Introduction
Magnesium alloys have brought more and more attention lately in response to the
rising eco-awareness. Due to the fact that magnesium possesses the lowest density
among all structural metals (such as Al, Mg and Ti), the purpose of magnesium alloys
will reduce the energy consumption and has very high vibration damping capacity.
2 Experimental Procedure
of vertical friction stir welding machine with the 5HP capability shown as in Fig. 5.
The machine has 360 cm of table width and 1370 cm of table length (Fig. 5), and
the chamber for underwater welding was designed and fabricated with dimensions
of 400 mm × 280 mm × 75 mm length, width and height, respectively. This set-up
is designed to hold the material to be welded and capable of carrying the water to
make the material immersed condition (Figs. 1, 2, 3 and Table 2).
Figure 4 shows that the non-consumable tool was made up of high carbon steel
with dimension of shoulder diameter (D) 15 mm, insert pin diameter (d) 5 mm and
pin length (L) of 4 mm, respectively. Two plates were welded at rotational speed of
1220 rpm and travel speed of 40 mm/min. The tool’s tilt angle used is 2.5° to get
effective material flow during tool transverse. Various parameters used in this study
were indicated in Table 3.
After the FSW process at both conditions, the samples were cut perpendicular to
the direction of welding using electrical discharge machine. The cross section was
observed by the optical microscopy (OM). Afterwards, the prepared samples were
mounted and polished using SiC papers with different grit sizes. Polished surfaces
were swabbed with the etching solution (picric acid, ethanol, acetic acid and water of
4.2 g, 70 ml, 40 ml and 10 ml, respectively) until the macrostructure was revealed. The
etched samples were cleaned with ethanol for few seconds. Microstructure images
were obtained by the optical microscope (Figs. 6, 8, 9 and 10).
Comparative Study of Friction Stir Welding and Underwater … 759
Figure 6 shows the optical micrograph of ZE41 base alloy. The α-Mg matrix has
T-Phase: Mg7 Zn3 -RE precipitates which are distributed over the matrix eutectically.
There are some more finely distributed particles in the matrix; they are Zr4 Zn3 or
Zn2 Zr3 zirconium-rich particles. These zirconium-rich particles have grain size of
760 S. Cyril Joseph Daniel and A. K. Lakshminarayanan
T - Phase
Intermetallic particles
α - Mg
around 4 μm [8, 9]. From the Mg–Zr phase diagram, below 653 °C, the α-Zr particles
and α–Mg particles are present in the magnesium matrix and they are not dissolved
in the base material [10, 11]. The brighter contrast of the grain boundaries shows
that the presence of higher atomic number of the secondary-phase particles in the
grain boundary. The T-phases in the Mg matrix show a white- and light-coloured
zone in the SEM micrograph of ZE41 alloy, and similar observations are reported
by Neil et al. [12].
Figure 7 shows the FSW joint of ZE41. It also showed no defects on surface when
the rotational speed of tool was 1220 rpm and transverse speed was 40 mm/min. And
the spiral formation on upper surface of the joints can be seen. It shows that material
flow during the welding process and the spiral obtained due to the relation between
tool rotation and the substrate movement. Figures 8 and 9 represent the macrograph
and its microfeatures of underwater FSW and FSW, respectively. The boundary
between stir zone (SZ) and the thermomechanically affected zone (TMAZ) is called
delineation. From Fig. 8, it can be seen that the delineation in the advancing side is
sharper and the delineation in the retreating side is gradually changed. It evidences
the state of plastic flow during welding process. In the stir zone, the friction effect is
produced by the welding tool and the material on the advancing side is squeezed to
the back of the pin [6].
Heat dissipation rate was high on the underwater friction stir welding since water
at room was in contact with magnesium plate; thus, the thermal gradient developed
during welding was dissipated from plate. So the frictional heat between tool and
the specimen was absorbed by the surrounding water. So that there was no enough
time given for growth of recrystallized grains than the air weld. On the other side,
the heat dissipation rate in the normal air atmosphere was low where sufficient time
was given for grain refinement than the underwater condition. So it had enough time
762 S. Cyril Joseph Daniel and A. K. Lakshminarayanan
Fig. 8 Micrograph and macrograph of underwater welded sample: a advancing side, b retreating
side, c SZ and base interface, d stir zone and e macroimage
for grain growth near the interface. So the geometry of stir zone in the air weld
condition was quite higher than the underwater condition.
The macrostructure of friction stir welded ZE41 alloy is shown in the figure in
which grain refinement occurred heavily in stir zone. The FSW weld joint reveals
the bathtub-like curve which denoted the stir zone, a narrow region of interface like
structure that divides the stir zone from HAZ in TMAZ (Figs. 8 and 9). This TMAZ
appeared as a resultant of mechanical stirring effect occurring between tool and
workpiece. The retreating and advancing side of the weld metal can be identified by
grain refinement pattern. The sudden grain refinement was observed in advancing
side due to the initial area of contact was at advancing side during the welding. Then
the plasticized material was wiped towards the rotating direction of the tool. It is
called as retreating side where the grain growth took place eventually.
Figure 8d shows that the stir zone of the underwater welding has smaller cross
section when compared to the stir zone of the air weld FSW, because the higher heat
dissipation in underwater limited the grain growth at the interface region.
Comparative Study of Friction Stir Welding and Underwater … 763
Fig. 9 Micrograph and macrograph of air welded sample: a advancing side, b retreating side, c SZ
and base interface, d stir zone and e macroimage
Figures 10a and b show that the average grain size measured for underwater
welded specimen is 25 μm and for the air welded specimen is 40 μm. This is due to
the cooling rate was higher in the underwater FSW when compared to air FSW.
Table 4 Micro- and macrograph of tensile samples: (a) air welded conditions and (b) underwater
welded conditions
S. Macrograph Micrograph Observation
No.
1. Failure
occurs in
the TMAZ
2. Failure
occurs in
the base
The tensile strength of underwater friction stir welded ZE41 alloys is up to 189 MPa
and for air weld condition is 168 MPa. Maximum elongation of air welded sample
is 20% and for underwater weld is 8%. The normal elongation for magnesium ZE41
is 4%. In air weld condition, the heat input at the stir zone is higher and it causes
excessive grain growth. Therefore, the sample exhibits lower tensile strength when
compared to the weld done at underwater condition.
From Table 4, we can see that the failure occurs in the stir zone for air weld speci-
men and the fracture is located at the base metal for underwater welded specimen. It
denotes that the weld strength of the underwater specimen is higher than the strength
of air weld specimen. The fracture location of friction stir weld underwater has less
elongation than the air weld FSW. This is because of the formation of precipitation
on the welding region decelerates the elongation of grains in interface.
4 Conclusions
In this study, the investigation of UWFSW and FSW on MgZE41 alloy was
experimentally conducted in which the process parameter, resultant properties,
microstructure and tensile behaviour were studied.
Comparative Study of Friction Stir Welding and Underwater … 765
• Heat dissipation rate was high on the underwater friction stir welding since water
at room was in contact with magnesium plate; thus, thermal gradient developed
during welding was dissipated from plate. So the frictional heat between tool and
the specimen was absorbed by the surrounding water. So that there was no enough
time given for the growth of recrystallized grains than the air weld.
• On the other side, the heat dissipation rate in the normal air atmosphere was low.
And so sufficient time was given for grain refinement than the underwater condi-
tion. So it had enough time for grain growth near the interface. So the stir zone in
the air weld condition was quite higher than the underwater condition.
• The tensile strength of underwater friction stir welded ZE41 alloys was up to
189 MPa and for air weld condition was 168 MPa. Maximum elongation of air
welded sample was 20%, and for under water weld was 8%. The normal elongation
for magnesium ZE41 is 4%.
• The failure occured in the stir zone for air weld specimen, and it was located at
the base metal in underwater welded specimen.
• The heat input at the stir zone was higher, and it caused excessive grain growth.
Therefore, the sample exhibited lower tensile strength when compared to the weld
done at underwater condition.
References
11. Neil WC, Forsyth M, Howlett PC, Hucthinson CR, Hinton BRW (2009) Corrosion of
magnesium alloy ZE41—the role of microstructural features. Corros Sci 51:387–394
12. Genghua C, Datong Z, Wen Z, Cheng Q (2015) Microstructure evolution and mechanical
properties of Mg–Nd–Y alloy in different friction stir processing conditions. J Alloy Compd
636:12–19
Characterizing the Tensile Deformation
Behavior of Friction Stir Welded
Dissimilar Joints Using Acoustic
Emission Technique
Abstract In the present investigation, P91 and 316LN dissimilar weld joints were
fabricated at the tool speeds of 600 and 900 rpm with 0.5 and 1 mm offset condi-
tions. For all mentioned welding conditions, the tensile testing was carried out at the
constant strain rate of 3.3 × 10−4 S−1 . A non-destructive acoustic emission (AE)
technique was used to analyze the tensile deformation behavior at elastic and plastic
deformation stages. The AE signals were recorded until the crack initiation and the
deformation behavior is compared with base metals. The obtained results were useful
to identify the deformation characteristics and joint integrity in different tool speed
and offset conditions.
1 Introduction
The dissimilar weld joints of P91 steel and low carbon and nitrogen enhanced stain-
less steel 316LN were widely used in pressure vessels, piping materials, and steam
generator applications in fast-breeder nuclear reactors [1, 2]. During sudden start-ups
and shutdowns of the nuclear reactor, high cyclic thermal stresses were generated due
to the mismatches in thermal expansion coefficients of the dissimilar weld metals.
This cyclic stresses are superimposed on the residual welding stresses and leads to
service failure/premature failure during long time service of the welded structure [3].
Therefore, by online monitoring, the material behavior through a wide range of non-
destructive testing techniques, the real-time information on material integrity can be
predicted and the failures of the welded structures can be controlled in advance.
Acoustic emission technique (AE) is a non-destructive technique that used to
monitor the structural integrity, dislocation kinetics, crack initiation and inclusions
in various types of materials [4]. Due to its simplicity in testing, the deformation
characteristics have been analyzed in different kinds of materials such as brass [5],
copper [6], aluminum [7], and magnesium [8]. But only a few researchers [9–15]
have shown interest in characterizing the tensile behavior in a wide variety of steels
and stainless steels. During tensile deformation, the variation in AE signals will
depend on the physical, chemical, and the structural properties of the base materials.
The acoustic signals will generate high activity due to high precipitate content, low
dislocation densities, different grain sizes, and variation in carbon content in different
weld thermal cycles [9]. Khamedi et al. [10] investigated the acoustic behavior of
DP steel under tensile loading. The rate of deformation and modes of failure were
comparatively correlated with the use of AE frequency signals and the counts. Barat
et al. [11] studied the tensile deformation behavior of AISI-type 304LN SS in low
temperature, it is depicted that the AE counts were gradually increased due to the
evolution of martensite during low-temperature deformation. Han et al. [12] studied
tensile deformation behavior of Q345 steel weld and base metals. It is reported that
the crack initiation in weld was comparably higher than the base metal. It is due to
the presence of oxide inclusions and coarse grain structures in the weld samples.
Raj et al. [13] studied the systematic variation and a high source of AE signals
that generated during the prior stage of deformation in austenitic stainless steels;
it is due to the material dislocations and multiplication of existing dislocation, i.e.,
Frank-Read grain boundary during the tensile straining. Venkataraman et al. [14]
monitored the AE activity of 316 austenitic stainless steel, and the AE count rate
is varied with respect to different strain rates during tensile testing. In maximum
straining condition, the generated AE counts and signal frequency were high due
to high deformation rate and the source activation of acoustic signals. Haneef et al.
[15] investigated the tensile behavior of grade 316 austenitic stainless steel. The
AE parameters such as RMS voltage and dominant frequency were monitored in
different strain rates from 1.4 × 10−3 S−1 to 1.4 × 10−2 S−1 . The RMS voltage was
increased with the increase in the strain rate. The dominant frequency was decreased
during necking, but it is increased due to the increased dislocation velocity at high
strain rates.
From the above literature, it is identified that by using AE technique, the tensile
deformation behavior was characterized in various kinds of metallic and non-metallic
materials. But only a few studies were available on characterizing the weld defor-
mation behavior using the AE technique. Moreover, no work has been carried out on
monitoring the tensile deformation behavior of ferritic–martensitic–austenitic dis-
similar weld joints using a friction stir welding process. In this present study, an
attempt was made to study the acoustic emission characteristics during the tensile
deformation of P91-316LN dissimilar joints. The weld integrity in different tool
speed and offset conditions was characterized, and the differences in AE parameters
were compared with base metal studies.
Characterizing the Tensile Deformation Behavior of Friction … 769
2 Experimental Details
The materials used in the present study were P91, a nuclear grade ferritic/martensitic
steel, and 316LN, a corrosion-resistant austenitic stainless steel. The physi-
cal properties of the base metals and its chemical compositions were listed
in Tables 1 and 2.
The normalized and tempered condition of P91 steel and solution annealed 316LN
was received in the form of 10-mm-thick plates. With the use of an electrical discharge
machine (EDM), the plates were sliced to the thickness of 3 mm. The sliced plates
were fabricated to the length of 125 mm and a breadth of 60 mm. Before conducting
the FSW trials, the machined plates were cleaned with methyl alcohol (CH3 OH)
solution, and the centerline of the weld plates was tightly clamped to each other.
The P91 steel plate was arranged in the retreating side, and the 316LN SS plate
was arranged in the advancing side. By using tungsten lanthanum oxide tool, FSW
process was carried out. The weld trials were carried out at the rotational speeds (ω)
of 600 and 900 rpm with 0.5 and 1 mm offset towards the P91 side. For all FSW trials,
constant welding speed (v) of 50 mm/min was maintained. The process parameters
used for the FSW process were shown in Table 3. The representation of the FSW
tool and its schematic view of the FSW process were shown in Fig. 1.
The weld joints and the base metals were machined according to ASTM E8M-09
standards for testing the tensile properties of the weld joint. The graphical represen-
tation of the tensile sample is shown in Fig. 2a. The tensile deformation behavior was
characterized by using 100 kN hydraulic tensile testing machine (Make: INSTRON,
Model: 8801), and the testing was accomplished at the constant strain rate of 3.3 ×
10−4 S−1 .
Two piezoelectric AE sensors (Make: Physical Acoustics, Model: micro 30) with
a frequency range of 150–400 kHz was fixed at the shoulder regions of the tensile
samples. A very small quantity of silicon grease gel was used as a sensor cou-
plant in gauge transition regions. To obtain proper signals without any disturbances,
770
petroleum-based lubricant gel was applied between the sensor interface and around
the specimen surface. During tensile loading, the AE sensor starts sensing the defor-
mation levels and generates the acoustic signals in the shoulder region. These signals
were captured and processed by pre-amplifier and 100–300 kHz range bandpass fil-
ter. An average threshold frequency was set to eliminate the external noises that
occurred during tensile testing. The AE signals produced during tensile deformation
were simultaneously recorded and processed by using an AE workstation (Make:
Physical electronics), and the tensile deformation results were evaluated by using
AEwin disp software v2.19. Finally, the fractured surfaces of the deformed tensile
samples were studied by using scanning electron microscopy (Make: Hitachi, Model:
3400 N). The graphical and pictorial views of the AE experimental setup were shown
in Fig. 2b.
772 A. Venkatakrishna et al.
Fig. 2 Schematic of tensile sample and AE experimental setup with block diagram
The tensile properties of the base metals were illustrated along with the acoustic
emission characteristics as shown in Fig. 3. The tensile and yield strength of P91 steel
were high around 36 and 150 Mpa. But the rate of elongation was low around 32%
as compared to 316LN SS. In P91 steel (Fig. 3a), high tensile strength was observed
due to co-precipitation of MX and M23 C6 precipitates in ferrite and coarse martensite
grain boundaries [16]. In 316LN (Fig. 3d), the elongation percentage was increased
due to the effect of work hardening. Dissimilar joints between these two materials
exhibited different tensile properties in different tool speed and offset conditions
as shown in Figs. 4 and 5. In both 600 and 900 rpm weld conditions, the tool was
offset toward the P91 side. The tensile strength of 600 rpm 0.5 condition (Fig. 4a)
was reduced due to inadequate heat input and insufficient mixing of 316LN material
toward the P91 area. Therefore, the tensile strength of 600 rpm and 0.5 mm weld
condition was reduced around 110 Mpa than the base metal. Similarly, by increasing
the offset up to 1 mm toward P91 side (Fig. 4d), the weld region was not softened
Characterizing the Tensile Deformation Behavior of Friction … 773
properly. So, the defects such as micropores and tunnel defect were developed around
the 316LN HAZ side. Therefore, the tensile strength was drastically decreased around
315 Mpa. Moreover, in both offset conditions, the fracture was observed in the weld
region.
In 900 rpm weld with 0.5 offset condition (Fig. 5a), material mixing proportions
were good due to increased heat input. The obtained tensile strength was almost
equal to 316LN base metal properties. When compared to both base materials, a
slight drop in strength around 25 Mpa was noticed. It is due to the coarsening effect
774 A. Venkatakrishna et al.
Fig. 5 Tensile properties of the 900 rpm joints and its AE characteristics
of grains during welding. The yield strength was increased up to 66% than 316LN,
and the elongation percentage was increased up to 21% than the P91 base metal.
But in 1 mm offset condition (Fig. 5d), the mixing ratio of 316LN was reduced;
therefore, the tensile properties are comparatively reduced than 0.5 offset condition.
Moreover, in both offset conditions, ductile mode of fracture was observed in P91
HAZ region. The variation in tensile properties for both base metals and weld joints
was illustrated in Table 4.
Table 4 Tensile test results of the base metals and the weld joints
Strain rate 3.3 × 10−4 S−1
P91 316LN 600 rpm and 600 rpm and 900 rpm and 900 rpm and
0.5 mm 1 mm offset 0.5 mm 1 mm offset
offset offset
Tensile 618 582 479 303 569 554
strength
(Mpa)
Elongation 54 82 31 12 75 60
(%)
Yield 431 290 262 212 356 304
strength
(Mpa)
Characterizing the Tensile Deformation Behavior of Friction … 775
AE behavior during tensile testing was characterized in four regions; they are: (1) 0–
3% elastic deformation region, (2) 3–10% yield region, (3) UTS and necking region,
and (4) final fracture after UTS [15]. During tensile testing, the transient elastic AE
waves were generated from the shoulder region of the tensile sample and the rate of
deformation is identified in the form of counts. The emission characteristics during
AE analysis differ in three stages—they are (1) crack initiation, (2) crack propagation,
and (3) the final stage of failure. In the crack initiation stage, the emission character-
istics will be low, but in crack propagation stage, the emission characteristics will be
increased, and during the fracture stage, the AE signal and emission characteristics
will be in maximum peak level [17]. Similar to these emission characteristics, the
variation of AE counts with respect to time was identified in P91 and 316LN base
metals and its weldments.
In P91 base metal (Fig. 3b), the AE counts have been increased at the beginning
stage of plastic deformation, but sudden rise and fall of signals were observed till
the yield region; it is due to the movement of dislocations during straining. In crack
initiation region, the dislocation densities were increased and necking formation
was observed, and the amplitude signals were slightly increased with respect to the
acoustic signals. But at the stage of crack propagation, the dislocation motion and its
velocity were increased and the rise in AE signals was observed. With the increase of
AE counts at maximum straining condition, the duration of acoustic signals (Fig. 3c)
has increased to 70,000 μS. Generally, the AE signals generated during deformation
were mainly depended upon the microstructure of the metal, strain rate, and presence
of any inclusions [18]. Due to single-phase austenite microstructure in 316LN base
metal, AE signals are observed at the constant strain levels corresponding to the
phenomenon of macroyielding (Fig. 3e). But compared to P91 steel, the AE counts
were less during crack initiation. In the crack propagation region, AE signals were
generated due to the effect of dislocation motion and twinning. At the final stage of
fracture, the burst AE signals were observed due to the increase in source activation
signals at the constant strain rate. Therefore, the duration of acoustic with respect to
amplitude (Fig. 3f) was increased up to 140,000 μS.
In 600 rpm weld joint with 0.5 offset condition (Fig. 4b), the AE counts were
slightly increased until the homogenous plastic deformation stage. But at the begin-
ning stage of crack propagation, the AE counts were gradually increased until the
end of the tensile test. Due to high dislocation movements in the weld region, the
stress concentration was increased and the material was failed in an earlier stage as
compared to base metals. Therefore, the amplitude of AE signals was increased up
to 100 dB and the AE burst signals were increased until the minimum duration of
25,000 μS (Fig. 4c).
In 1 mm offset condition (Fig. 4d), the AE counts were increased at the beginning
stage of plastic deformation. Sudden rise and fall of AE peaks were continuously
monitored in the crack initiation region. But at the crack propagation region, the AE
776 A. Venkatakrishna et al.
counts have increased again till the occurrence of a failure in the tensile specimen.
The sample was failed without necking, so it is concluded that the sample is failed due
to the presence of increased dislocations in the weld region. Therefore, the material
was failed in an earlier stage as compared to 600 rpm 0.5 offset weld condition.
Similarly, the AE signals were constantly increased up to 100 dB, and the AE burst
signals were increased until the minimum duration of 25,000 μS (Fig. 4e).
In 900 rpm weld joint with 0.5 offset condition (Fig. 5b), the AE counts were very
low until the final stage of elastic deformation, but a sudden increase of AE signals
was noticed due to the decohesion of inclusions during crack initiation. The recorded
AE counts were too weak for a long time up to 800 s of testing time (i.e., up to neck-
ing), because the rate of deformation of this weld joint was high as compared to other
welds. Due to improved tensile properties, AE counts was increased upto 160,000 μs
during crack propagation stage of the tensile sample. Similarly, in 1 mm offset con-
dition (Fig. 5f), a peak of AE emission was noticed due to the presence of coarse
grains in the plastic deformation region. But other than the obtained AE signals,
the counts were almost the same as the 0.5 mm offset condition. But the amplitude
frequency signals were reduced up to 40 dB than the 0.5 mm offset condition; this
change is attributed with the effect of moving dislocations associated with the tensile
deformation.
4 Conclusion
Using the AE technique, tensile deformation behavior has been successfully moni-
tored for P91-316LN FSW joints that welded at the tool speed of 600 and 900 rpm
with 0.5 and 1 mm offset conditions. From the experimental investigations, some
important results were observed and it is listed below as follows:
1. In 600 rpm welds, AE signals were generated in yielding stage of deformation—
it is mainly associated due to the increased fraction of dislocation density in the
weld region.
2. Due to the improper coalescence of dissimilar materials in 600 rpm weld con-
dition, the ductility of the joint has been comparably reduced in 1 mm offset
condition. Hence, AE counts and signal duration were found to be increased at
the beginning stage of plastic deformation.
3. In 600 rpm weld joints, crack initiated in weld region, and for 900 rpm joints,
the fracture occurred in P91-HAZ region for both offset conditions. The 900 rpm
joints exhibited good tensile properties as compared to 600 rpm joints. But com-
pared to base metals, the strength of 900 rpm joints was reduced due to the
presence of inclusions and coarse grains in the weld joints.
4. During necking, frequencies and amplitude signals were found to be increased
in 900 rpm weldments; it is attributed to the increase of the material dislocations
during deformation at the constant strain level.
Characterizing the Tensile Deformation Behavior of Friction … 777
5. The amplitude signals and AE waves generated during tensile deformation were
varied in both 600 and 900 rpm weld joints. In 600 rpm condition, the peaks
were totally varied due to the presence of defects in 1 mm offset condition. But
in 900 rpm, slight changes in AE counts and amplitude were observed during
deformation in both offset conditions.
Therefore, it is concluded that by increasing the tool speed with a low offset value,
the defect formation in dissimilar metals has been reduced and the joint integrity
has been improved. Moreover, by using the AE technique, overall material life can
be predicted in earlier stages of deformation; therefore, the joint failures can be
controlled in advance.
Acknowledgements Authors are thankful to Mr.T Haneef, Scientific Officer D, and Dr. C.K
Mukhopadhyay Head, NDTD/MMG, IGCAR, Kalpakkam, India, for providing the acoustic emis-
sion test facility in their laboratory. The authors are thankful to Mr. Thirukumaran, Research fellow,
NDTD/MMG, IGCAR, for providing constant encouragement and support during the experimental
analysis.
References
14. Venkataraman B, Mukhopadhyay CK, Raj B (2004) Effect of variation of strain rate on thermal
and acoustic emission during tensile deformation of nuclear grade AISI type 316 stainless steel.
Mater Sci Technol 20:1310–1316
15. Haneef T, Lahiri BB, Bagavathiappan S, Mukhopadhyay CK, Philip J, Rao BPC, Jayakumar
T (2015) Study of the tensile behavior of AISI type 316 stainless steel using acoustic emission
and infrared thermography techniques. J Mater Res Technol 4(3):241–253
16. Zhang S, Melfi T, Narayanan BK (2016) Effects of precipitates on mechanical properties of
P91 submerged arc welds. Sci Technol Weld Joining 21(2):147–156
17. Yu J, Ziehl P, Zárate B, Caicedo J (2011) Prediction of fatigue crack growth in steel bridge
components using acoustic emission. J Constr Steel Res 67(8):1254–1260
18. Ono K (2005) Current understanding of mechanisms of acoustic emission. J Strain Anal Eng
Design 40(1):1–15
Study of Infrared Thermography
on Tensile Behavior of Laser Beam
Welded 316LN Austenitic Stainless Steel
R. Rajasekaran, A. K. Lakshminarayanan, A. Venkatakrishna,
and K. Radhika
Abstract In this investigation, the tensile behavior of laser beam welded 316LN
austenitic stainless steel was studied by infrared thermography (IRT) and compared
with the base metal tensile behavior. Initially, microstructural characterization of
base metal and weld bead was carried out by optical microscopy (OM). Base metal
comprises an average grain size of 60 μm and LBW exhibited refined grains at
the fusion zone. Very narrow HAZ around 15 μm was recorded at LBW interface.
Tensile samples were prepared as per ASTM standard E8, and the test was conducted
at room temperature of 26.5 °C. A strain rate of 4.4 × 10−4 s−1 was used during
the tensile test of the base metal and LBW samples. Temperature variations of the
base metal and weld bead were recorded by an infrared camera at different stages
of deformation. Compared to LBW sample base metal sample deformed more and
displayed the percentage of elongation as 64.14%, whereas LBW sample displayed
less percentage of elongation around 53.2% due to lesser deformation as compared
to the base metal. This is attributed to grain refinement during rapid solidification
of LBW process at fusion zone. High temperatures were recorded on the base metal
(39.2 °C) and center of the LBW fusion zone (30.8 °C) before just the time of fracture.
This high temperature of the base metal over LBW sample indicates that the base
metal deformed more compared to laser beam welded sample.
1 Introduction
Austenitic stainless steels are used widely in nuclear power plants for their excellent
mechanical and corrosion resistance properties. Many structural components, except
the nuclear core structures, are built by 316LN grade austenitic stainless steel for
its superior mechanical and corrosion resistance property at high temperatures [1].
During the structural component fabrication process the joining of 316LN together is
done using conventional GTAW process. Many research works are going on joining
of 316LN using high energy density and solid-state welding techniques [2, 3]. Joining
of 316LN using the LBW process could improve mechanical properties in the fusion
zone. Improvement in toughness property by LBW process on 409 M ferritic stainless
steel was reported in earlier research work [4]. During the service, 316LN joints
may experience different types of load/stress conditions. This phenomenon leads
to deformation in that particular material as well as joints. Hence, the study of the
deformation behavior of 316LN base and its joints is essentially one.
Infrared thermography is a contactless nondestructive technique used in many
engineering applications due to the accurate monitoring of temperature variations in
fast inspection rates [5]. Assessment of material deformation is successfully carried
out on metals, polymers, and composite materials using infrared thermography tech-
nique [6–8]. This is followed by the concept of infrared radiations from a deforming
object detected by IR camera, and the radiations are converted in terms of temper-
ature patterns. These temperature patterns are stored and analyzed using computer
workstations. Deformation distribution in the material and its severity is evaluated by
the intensity of the temperature patterns. In this experimental investigation, IRT has
been used for studying tensile deformation of laser beam welded 316LN austenitic
stainless steel.
2 Experiment
2.1 Material
Austenitic stainless steel 316LN was taken to study about IR thermography during
the tensile test. The details of the chemical composition of 316LN austenitic stainless
steel are given in Table 1. Plate form of the base material with a length of 300 mm,
the width of 75 mm, and a thickness of 3 mm was prepared to make weld joint.
Edge preparation was made by square butt configuration. Argon with a purity level
of 99.995% was used as a purging gas during the welding process. The following
process parameters were used for fabricating LBW joint: (i) laser power: 2.5 KW
and (ii) welding speed: 1500 mm/min.
Metallographic samples of base metal and weld joints (transverse side) were polished
up to 2500 girt emery sheet. Further samples were polished by using 0.5-μm diamond
paste to eliminate micro-sized impurities. After polishing, etching process was done
Table 1 Chemical composition of 316LN austenitic stainless steel
Weight % of elements
C Cr Ni Mo Mn Si S P N Fe
316LN 0.026 17.8 11.7 2.4 1.6 0.45 0.009 0.026 0.095 Balance
Study of Infrared Thermography on Tensile Behavior of Laser …
781
782 R. Rajasekaran et al.
by a solution which contains 1:3 ratios of HNO3 to HCl as per ASTM standard
designation E407. Microstructures of base metal and the LBW fusion zone were
captured by olymphus BX 51 M optical microscope.
Figure 1 depicts experimental setup of IRT during the tensile test. Figure 2 depicts
samples of base metal and LBW after the tensile test. Tensile test of the base metal
and LBW samples were performed by Dartec, UK, 100KN hydraulic servo motor
computer-controlled universal testing machine (UTM). 2 mm/min crosshead speed
was maintained during the tensile test. Thermographic images were recorded by the
IR camera model: CEDIP silver 420 with 25 m/C temp sensitivity.
Figure 3 depicts the microstructural morphologies of 316LN base metal and LBW
joint. The base metal consists complete austenite phase with grain size around 60 μm.
Annealing twins were clearly observed in the base metal microstructure. LBW fusion
zone exhibited the primary austenite mode of solidification. Following morphologies
were recorded at the fusion zone of the LBW process viz: (i) epitaxial grain growth,
(ii) equiaxed dendrite, and (iii) columnar structure. Higher welding speed of LBW
process resulted in the formation of very narrow weld bead and HAZ around 15 μm
[9].
Thermographic images of the base metal at different stages during tensile deformation
are shown in Fig. 4a. The highest temperature around 39 °C was recorded at stage
III (before fracture) in the base metal. Temperature curve and its different stages are
explained in Sect. 3.3. Temperature evolution curves along the axial length of the
base metal sample at different stages are shown in Fig. 4b. Necking was observed
almost center of the gauge portion in the base metal. This is clearly correlated with
the peak point of the temperature evolution curve.
Thermographic images of the LBW sample at different stages during tensile defor-
mation are shown in Fig. 5a. The highest temperature around 32 °C was recorded
784 R. Rajasekaran et al.
Fig. 4 a Thermographic images during tensile deformation of base metal and b evolution of
temperatures in axial length of the base metal
Fig. 5 a Thermographic images during tensile deformation of LBW joint and b evolution of
temperatures in axial length of LBW sample
at stage III (before fracture) in LBW sample. Temperature evolution curves along
the axial length of the LBW sample (Fig. 5b) revealed that the position of the peak
temperature is away from the center of the gauge portion (LBW fusion zone).
Transverse tensile properties of the base metal and the LBW joint are given in Table 2.
Base metal showed more percentage of elongation as compared to the LBW tensile
sample. This phenomenon is mainly attributed to the grain refinement at the fusion
zone during the solidification process. Failure of LBW sample occurred at the base
metal side around 8 mm from the fusion zone. This failure location indicating that the
LBW joint contains more tensile strength compared to the base metal. Further micro-
tensile samples [10] were extracted from LBW fusion zone along weld direction to
asses UTS of LBW joint. From UTS evaluation, it was seen that the LBW joint
exhibited 11.7% more strength (688 MPa) compared to the base metal UTS value.
Study of Infrared Thermography on Tensile Behavior of Laser … 785
Evolution of peak temperature with the stress plot of the base metal and the LBW
samples is shown in Figs. 6 and 7, respectively. This temperature curve is divided into
four main stages based on the deformation behavior of the material. They are (i) linear
temperature drop stage, (ii) temperature rise stage, (iii) rapid temperature rise stage,
and (iv) final temperature decline stage [11, 12]. The considerable temperature drop
Fig. 6 a Evolution of peak temperature of the base metal during deformation with respect to time
and b stress versus strain curve of base metal
Fig. 7 a Evolution of peak temperature in LBW sample during deformation with respect to time
and b stress versus strain curve for LBW sample
786 R. Rajasekaran et al.
was observed in stage I due to the thermoelastic effect of the material. This effect
occurred up to yield point of the base metal and LBW sample. When the plastic
deformation started, the continuous rise in temperature was noticed on both base
metal and LBW sample. This is attributed to the generation of heat due to plastic
deformation effect [13]. Sudden rise in temperature occurred during the necking and
cracking stage of the samples. This is attributed to the local plastic deformation of
the initiated crack tip during necking. On stage III, the base metal sample exhibited
39.2 °C, whereas the LBW sample exhibited a peak temperature of 32.4 °C. But the
fusion zone of the LBW sample experienced peak temperature of 30.8 °C before
fracture (stage III). Lesser deformation in the gauge portion of the LBW sample
compared to the base metal sample is the reason for this temperature difference.
4 Conclusions
• Higher welding speed and solidification behavior of LBW process influenced the
formation of refined grains at fusion zone compared to the base metal grains. This
grain refinement increased strength in the fusion zone of the LBW process over
the base metal.
• During tensile deformation study, peak temperatures were recorded just before to
the time of fracture for both LBW and base metal samples. This phenomenon is
attributed to the increase of temperature with respect to increasing deformation in
metals. Moreover, failure locations were revealed in terms of temperature patterns
in advance before the occurrence of fracture during the tensile test on different
samples.
• From IR thermography images, peak temperatures of 39.2 and 30.8 °C were
observed at base metal and LBW fusion zone, respectively. This increased tem-
perature at the base metal indicates that the base metal has undergone more
deformation compared to LBW sample.
References
1. Mannan SL, Chetal S et al (2003) Selection of materials for prototype fast breeder reactor.
Trans Indian Inst Met 56(2):155–178
2. Vignesh A, Vijay Prakaash VG, Lakshminarayanan AK (2015) Improving wear resistance of
AISI 316LN austenitic stainless steel using friction stir processing. Appl Mech Mater 787:421–
425
3. Rajasekaran R, Lakshminarayanan AK, Vasudevan M, Vasantharaja P, Role of welding pro-
cesses on microstructure and mechanical properties of nuclear-grade stainless steel joints. J
Mater: Design Appl. In: Proceedings of the institution of mechanical engineers, part L. SAGE.
https://doi.org/10.1177/1464420719849448
4. Lakshminarayanan AK, Balasubramanian V (2012) Characteristics of laser beam and friction
stir welded AISI 409M ferritic stainless steel joints. J Mater Eng Perform 21:530–539
Study of Infrared Thermography on Tensile Behavior of Laser … 787
Abstract Ever since the origin of the evolution of human being either named as
ape or man, striving to survive with safety, by becoming wise on live hazards, he
has been innovating as many ways and means for the safe living/working. To this
day, the struggle for safety is existing but in a sophisticated manner, as he grew from
being wise to being an intellectual. This paper discusses the ergonomics issues in an
automobile industry handling the hard substance, among the engineering industries,
as the manual scrap handling system is one of the most critical safety concern aspects
which includes more manual effort, due to its impact on the manpower expenses,
medical expenses, personal protective equipment expenses, and time consumption.
Ergonomic assessment, as a tool and method for analyzing human activities and
their interactions with the surrounding environment, is thus crucial for designing
operations and workplaces that achieve high safety. In the engineering industry, how-
ever, the constant repetitive work environment and laborious tasks cause traditional
approaches to ergonomic analysis, such as manual observations and measurements
to require substantial time and effort to yield reliable results. This study mainly con-
centrates on scrap handling because of its repetitive actions with heavy loads and
also explores the adaptation and integration of various existing methods for data
collection, analysis, and output representation potentially available for comprehen-
sive ergonomic analysis. The proposed framework integrates the 3DSSP’s (Static
Strength Prediction) localized fatigue report for the inputs such as measurement
of body angles using goniometer and NIOSH (National Institute of Occupational
Safety and Health) weight lifting equation. The proposed framework is demonstrated
through a case study using data from on-site scrap handling system through 3DSSP
software.
1 Introduction
The engineering industry is labor- and machine-intensive, and worker activities can
significantly affect the success of the engineering industry and scrap handling opera-
tions. Labor is one of the most crucial resources and has the highest direct impact on
the outcomes in the industry, including time and cost. Furthermore, labor operations
in scrap handling involve physically demanding motions and tasks that frequently
expose workers to risk in their working environments, leading to a rate of injuries
and chronic injuries that are among the highest of any engineering industry’s scrap
handling system.
The risk involved in the repetitive manual scrap handling system gets its peak with
respect to the duration of the work, work atmosphere, distance between the loading
and unloading region, and loading to unloading pathway of the scrap movement.
The repetitive manual scrap handling system leads to the considerable effects on the
expenses such as personal protective equipment (PPE) and medical expenses.
Golabchi et al. [1] state that the constantly changing work environments and
laborious tasks subject traditional approaches to ergonomic analysis such as man-
ual observations and measurements and his proposed framework used sensing for
data collection, action recognition, and simulation modeling, by using different tech-
niques that could facilitate the assessment of manual operations and could enhance
the implementation of ergonomic practices during the work by reducing time, com-
plexity and effort required, improvement achieved by proposing automated, simple
and reliable analysis of manual operation.
Munck-Ulfsfält et al. [2] inferred that the ergonomics work is not a separate
entity, but it is based on a strategy and much easier to get the management and other
employees to realize, accept, and understand the risk involved in ergonomics work.
Training on the load ergonomics concerned will be the key to success.
Dul et al. [3] argued that by contributing the shared goals of business performance,
ergonomists would also be better able to reach their traditional health and safety
objectives and also discussed the organizational strategies and business goals to
which ergonomics contribute.
Leung et al. [4] studied the impact of many organizational stressors and stress on
construction work safety behaviors and injury incidents. To achieve this, they studied
a number of workers, also by using factor analysis, identified the major organizational
stressors (inappropriate safety equipment, unfair reward and treatment, lack of goal
setting and poor physical treatment, lack of provision of training), two types of
stressors (physical and emotional), and safety behaviors and concluded that setting
personal, long-term, and specific work goals with the workers would reduce the
injury incident rate directly.
Evaluation of Ergonomics Issues in Repetitive Scrap Handling … 793
Golabchi et al. [5] discussed the approach that enabled modeling of manual activ-
ities at human motion level in order to provide standard task durations in addition to
initial insight into the level of ergonomic risks associated with a planned production
scenario.
Golabchi et al. [6] proposed the concept by making the approach with motion
data from the 3D model of the jobsite to evaluate the risk factors that probably could
produce more physical loads on the human body through biomechanical analysis.
The framework was proposed after analyzing the jobsite ergonomic safety.
Tran et al. [7] introduced the metric-based learning approach for human activity
identification, with the abilities to reject invisible actions, and discussed the vital
role of invisible actions when applying human activity recognition to real-world
applications.
Wei et al. [8] stated that their proposed model could generate physically realistic
animations that react to external forces or changes in physical quantities of human
bodies and interaction environments and evaluated their system by comparing against
ground-truth motion data and alternative methods.
Case et al. [9] discussed the digital human modeling practices for the last four
decades which is the first usable tool and still existing for the designing of the
ergonomics-related issues.
This current study deals with the procedure of analyzing and evaluating the issues
in the ergonomics in the automobile industry, analyzing the number of machines,
plant layout, and the frequency of the scrap produced from different operations,
gathering the anthropometric details through personal interview, video recording the
manual scrap handling process for analyzing AS-IS model through MOST method,
measuring the body angles using goniometer as input to the 3DSSP software for
analyzing the load on the body parts and their ability of bearing the load, evaluating
the RWL (Recommended Weight Limit) and LI (Lifting Index) for safe lifting weight,
and giving the remedial action according to the NIOSH evaluation technique.
The main activities carried out to complete the task include picking up s45c grade
steel scrap from the trolley and throw it into the scrap dump yard. As the first step, the
work was video graphed to extract time lapses and types of activities and then angles
of the worker’s body joints were measured during his bending, picking, twisting, and
throwing work postures. By using goniometer, the body angles were measured.
Fig. 1 Number of machinery and frequency of scrap with respect to the operation
Table 3 gives the details about the time lapse used for the MOST method of analysis,
which represents the duration in seconds taken for the single exertion to get completed
Evaluation of Ergonomics Issues in Repetitive Scrap Handling … 795
Table 1 Different types of scrap from different operations for manual scrap handling
S. No. Operation Scrap sample
1 Facing
2 Turning
4 VMC-multi-angle cut
5 Boring
in the sequence, the actions for the scrap handling being identical for the all scraps
produced from different operations.
AS-IS Model
The AS-IS model of the plant layout gives the detailed description of the unloading
work pathway from its source to destination, besides the details like distance. As per
the above plant layout, the sources of the unloading trolley are not the same, but the
796 A. B. Dasari and D. Balasubramanian
Fig. 3 AS-IS model representation of the factory layout, for scrap collection
destination of unloading the trolley is the same. The pathway is drawn connecting
the individual source to the destination.
Table 3 Details of the action sequence and duration of the manual scrap lifting operation
S. No. Activity sequence Duration
1 @00 h:00 m:01 s
Bend
2 @00 h:00 m:04 s
Hold
3 @00 h:00 m:05 s
Pickup
4 @00 h:00 m:06 s
Throw
45–50 expensive gloves are used on an average for the work of scrap unloading. The
average life span of the gloves used is hardly 2 days.
Figure 5 gives the monthly medical expenses in a year for 3 scrap unloading
workers; the inference from the graph is that on an average the monthly medical
Fig. 4 Number of gloves used by the scrap handling worker during a month
798 A. B. Dasari and D. Balasubramanian
expenses which is been referred from the monthly medical expenses bill of the
particular workers are approximately 1500 Indian rupees.
Figure 6 gives the information about the average of different types of medical
expenses incurred in a month; the inference from the pie chart is that the medical
expenses are major for the hip and torso pains.
Fig. 6 Pie chart for the different types of medical expenses for a month
Evaluation of Ergonomics Issues in Repetitive Scrap Handling … 799
3 Methodology
This study proposes and tests an integrated framework that couples data acquisition
and 3D static simulation program with an analysis of manual operations to enable
effective evaluation of those manual operations for a comprehensive ergonomic anal-
ysis. The three objectives are (1) exploring the data associated with the different
angles of the body, (2) examining possibility and applicability of sharing data among
those different methods, and (3) testing, feasibility, and effectiveness of integrat-
ing the various methods. The framework is composed of the following modules:
simulation, as-is modeling, and safety assessment. This analysis was held by gath-
ering information about the conditions in the work environment through manual
measurement.
The workers’ normal activities at the work site were video graphed, and then
extracts were obtained of the type of work, the sequence of operation, and duration
of tasks and were used to build a simulation and get analysis report of the particu-
lar operation. The simulation made through 3DSSP software served to evaluate the
static strength of the operation and gave the information about the strength or pressure
applied on the particular parts of the body because of the particular operation and
helped to evaluate the duty cycle based on the number of and duration of exertions.
This 3DSSP 7.0 simulation program has the advantage of built-in range manipula-
tor for duty cycle limit, exertion limits, etc., according to American Conference of
Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) 2016 (Fig. 7).
To carry out a thorough ergonomic analysis, information about the effects of physical
activities on a worker’s body needs to be available. Main contributors to those effects
are the type, duration, and sequence of manual tasks. A complete ergonomic analysis
involves evaluating the motions and postures of working people and the physical
attributes of job site to assess present work conditions and propose the new designs
for manual operations (safe conditions) and working spot (work spot dimensions).
To carry out assessments, the ergonomists need to go through the three stages: (i)
data collection, (ii) data analysis, and (iii) interpretation and presentation of results.
Ahead of data collection, the ergonomist has to plan the analysis process and
define the strategy based on certain conditions of work being analyzed. The required
inputs for each relevant data are collected, traditionally by observing the subjects
(posture, anthropometry), their motions during work (leaning, bending), and the
work environment particulars (workbench, tools, equipment).
After the completion of data collection, the ergonomist uses the gathered data to
conduct an ergonomic evaluation using tools such as ergonomics assessment check-
list (RULA, ROSA) and time and motion studies (MTM, MOST), giving the details
800 A. B. Dasari and D. Balasubramanian
Sensing
• Video Camera • Visual Checking
• Direct Interview • Goniometer measurement
Fig. 7 Methodology for the evaluation and analysis of ergonomics in the automobile industry
like worker’s posture (body angles/joint angles) along with the frequency and dura-
tion of exposure allowing posture-based tools to report on the level of ergonomic
risk associated with the task.
This work involves three stages of the ergonomics analysis. They are (i) data acqui-
sition, (ii) analysis (simulation modeling), and (iii) representation (result/corrective
action).
Evaluation of Ergonomics Issues in Repetitive Scrap Handling … 801
Methods Time Measurement (MTM) is the motion time system that is primarily used
in industrial settings to analyze the methods to perform any manual task or operation
and as a product of analysis, set the standard time that a worker should complete that
particular task.
MOST systems are designed to provide the optimal combination of speed, detail,
and accuracy of the work/operation. It was designed to be much faster than the
conventional work measurement techniques such as time study [10].
Simulation Model
To create a simulation model of manual operation and analyze its operational activ-
ities, either human observation or sensing methods have to be used to gather the
required inputs. Human observation typically requires time, effort, and expertise,
but adding the human observation along with simulation software enables more
facts regarding the ergonomics issues of the particular work.
The developed simulation model using 3DSSP software represents the current
status of an ongoing operation which is also used to serve as a base model to evaluate
other scenarios for operation in terms of safety to find the most reliable.
RWL = LC(51) × HM × VM × DM × AM × FM × CM
802 A. B. Dasari and D. Balasubramanian
Table 4 gives the details regarding the anthropometry details of the worker performing
manual scrap handling taken prior to the starting of the 3DSSP analysis (Fig. 9).
The simulation of the images is done using the 3DSSP software from the input
parameters taken through goniometer.
Table 5 gives the details regarding the input parameters for the 3DSSP software
being taken manually using the goniometer, though it is a time-consuming process
but the most effective and accurate process of taking the body angles of the worker
during the working posture (Fig. 10).
The simulation of the images is done using the 3DSSP software from the input
parameters taken through goniometer (Table 6).
Evaluation of Ergonomics Issues in Repetitive Scrap Handling … 803
Fig. 8 Details of weight & number of Exertions for unloading different operations
By using the proposed body angles measuring algorithm on the human body with
a goniometer, recognized scrap handling procedure which is induced from different
operations is obtained.
Inference from the Analysis Summary Report for the 3D Low Back Compression
Figure 11 gives details obtained from the analysis summary report which discusses
the 3D low back compression (Newton) with respect to the scrap produced from
different operations.
Figure 12 gives the details of the low back compression for the different steps
followed in handling (unloading) the scrap produced from #05 operation.
Inference of the Analysis Summary Report for the Percent of the Population
Capable
Figure 13 gives details in percentage about the capability of the population to execute
the particular operation; the analysis summary gives the report for the following
body parts such as wrist, elbow, shoulder, torso, hip, knee, and ankle. The inference
804 A. B. Dasari and D. Balasubramanian
Fig. 9 The above figures are the steps an unloading person follows from pick to drop
that can be derived from the analysis summary report obtained from the 3DSSP
software is that while manually handling this type of scrap nearly 96.5% of people
can effectively and capably handle the wrist load, almost 100% of people can capably
handle the elbow load, on an average 98.5% population can capably handle the
shoulder load, around 93.75% of the population can manage the torso load, only
90.25% of population can capably manage the hip load, on an average 95.5% of
population can handle the knee loads, and 96.25% of population can capably handle
the ankle load while handling the scrap. As a result, the load on the hips while
handling (unloading) the scrap is comparatively more than other body parts loads.
Table 7 gives information about the percent of the population capable of bearing
the loads on the individual body part. The inference from the table is that only 90.25
and 93.75% of the population are capable of handling the load on the hip region and
the torso region, respectively.
The results of the localized fatigue analysis report from 3DSSP software are used
to give awareness about the work duration limits and also threshold duty cycle limits
of the particular unloading work.
Evaluation of Ergonomics Issues in Repetitive Scrap Handling … 805
Table 5 Input parameters for the steps involved in the manual scrap handling of the facing operation
scrap
Parameters Step-1 Step-2
Left Right Left Right
Horizontal Vertical Horizontal Vertical Horizontal Vertical Horizontal Vertical
Hand (°) 106 −55 106 −55 106 −53 106 −56
Fore arm 106 −55 106 −55 106 −53 106 −56
(°)
Lifting 0 0
weight (N)
Trunk Flexion Axial Lateral bending Flexion Axial Lateral bending
angles rotation rotation
Head 44 0 0 12 0 −1
Angles 45 0 0 12 0 0
Parameters Step-3 Step-4
Left Right Left Right
Horizontal Vertical Horizontal Vertical Horizontal Vertical Horizontal Vertical
Hand (°) 110 −53 110 −54 106 −52 110 −50
Fore arm 110 −53 110 −54 106 −52 110 −50
(°)
Lifting 0 27.5
weight (N)
Trunk Flexion Axial Lateral bending Flexion Axial Lateral bending
angles rotation rotation
Head 12 1 −1 6 −1 −1
Angles 12 0 0 7 0 0
Parameters Step-5 Step-6
Left Right Left Right
Horizontal Vertical Horizontal Vertical Horizontal Vertical Horizontal Vertical
Hand (°) 106 −52 110 −50 118 −66 120 −41
Fore arm 106 −52 110 −50 118 −66 120 −41
(°)
Lifting 27.5 27.5
weight (N)
Trunk Flexion Axial Lateral bending Flexion Axial Lateral bending
angles rotation rotation
Head 50 0 0 43 25 −4
Angles 33 0 0 26 0 0
Parameters Step-7
Left Right
Horizontal Vertical Horizontal Vertical
Hand (°) 43 −12 162 13
(continued)
806 A. B. Dasari and D. Balasubramanian
Table 5 (continued)
Parameters Step-7
Left Right
Horizontal Vertical Horizontal Vertical
Fore arm (°) 43 −12 162 13
Lifting weight (N) 0
Trunk angles Flexion Axial rotation Lateral bending
Head 60 40 −6
Angles 75 10 −4
#10 scrap Handling #20 Scrap Handling #50 Scrap Handling #60 Scrap Handling
Fig. 10 The figures are the unloading postures of the scrap produced from #10, #20, #50, #60
operations
Table 8 gives the total information regarding the maximum and minimum weights
that the scrap unloading worker handles for different scrap operations; minimum
average load and maximum average load of the handling material are used for the
calculation of the NIOSH weight lifting equation (Fig. 14).
From Table 9, it is clear that the Lifting Index (LI) of this scrap unloading work
is in the highest risk factor, it badly needs the corrective remedial action to reduce
the Lifting Index value for the safe lifting work, and it should be less than 1.0.
5 Results
Table 10 gives the details about the center of gravity of the particular position of the
scrap unloading work for each step; this is obtained based on the weight of the load
that the scrap handling person picks and the position of the torso; in the above figures,
Evaluation of Ergonomics Issues in Repetitive Scrap Handling … 807
Table 6 Input parameters for the steps involved in the manual scrap handling of the other operation
scrap
Parameters Turning Turning and ID Boring
Left Right Left Right
Horizontal Vertical Horizontal Vertical Horizontal Vertical Horizontal Vertical
Hand (°) 117 −54 115 −51 115 −51 109 −48
Fore arm 117 −54 115 −51 115 −51 109 −48
(°)
Lifting 46.1 46.1
weight (N)
Trunk Flexion Axial Lateral bending Flexion Axial Lateral bending
angles rotation rotation
Head 19 0 0 18 −1 1
Angles 18 0 0 16 0 0
Parameters Multi-angle cut Boring
Left Right Left Right
Horizontal Vertical Horizontal Vertical Horizontal Vertical Horizontal Vertical
Hand (°) 115 −51 109 −48 115 −51 109 −48
Fore arm 115 −51 109 −48 115 −51 109 −48
(°)
Lifting 52 54.9
weight (N)
Trunk Flexion Axial Lateral bending Flexion Axial Lateral bending
angles rotation rotation
Head 18 −1 0 18 −1 3
Angles 16 0 0 16 0 0
the red dot represents the center of gravity; if the red dot is out of the green region,
the particular position is not acceptable to work and that at any time the worker may
fall down or cause to himself heavy strain to the hip and the torso region.
Table 11 gives the details about the center of gravity for the other scrap handling
operations; this kind of analysis is made according to the ACGIH 2016 standards of
the ergonomic analysis.
Table 7 Percent of
S. No. Load on body parts for Percent of population
population capable of
different operation capable (%)
handling the scrap with
respect to body parts 1 Wrist 96.5
2 Elbow 100
3 Shoulder 98.5
4 Torso 93.75
5 Hip 90.25
6 Knee 95.5
7 Ankle 96.25
Fig. 14 a Represents NIOSH weight lifting equation details, b represents the dimensions of the
trolley, c, d represent the real-time action with NIOSH weight lifting standards
6 Conclusions
This evaluation and analysis study on the ergonomics in manual scrap handling
system of a particular automobile industry has enabled to draw the following
conclusions
• Confirms that the load is heavy on the hip and torso of the scrap handling person.
• The unacceptable level of the center of gravity of the scrap handling person even-
tually leads to fall of person and strongly supports the heavy load on the hip and
torso region of the worker.
• The NIOSH weight lifting equation indicates that the Lifting Index (LI) is above
the acceptable value of 1, i.e., (1.11). So the scrap handling operation critically
needs the engineering and administrative controls as corrective action.
Evaluation of Ergonomics Issues in Repetitive Scrap Handling … 811
MOST Method
• The MOST method of analysis for the scrap lifting operation produced from all
the operations has the quick and shorter time duration of handling the scrap from
its origin to the destination.
• It also serves the same to the plant layout; the traveling distance of unloading
trolley to bring from origin to destination is the shortest and quickest as per the
time duration and the plant layout.
812
Table 10 Details on the center of gravity for the steps involved in facing operation scrap unloading
S. No. Step posture Center of gravity %MVC (maximum voluntary %DC (maximum exertion
contraction) duty cycle)
1 Critical Are within the limits Neck Flexion and torso
flexion are out of limits
Acceptable
2 Are within the limits Wrist flexion and Ulnar/radius, elbow flexion, shoulder
rotation backward, frontward, neck flexion, torso flexion
are out of limits
Acceptable
3 Are within the limits Wrist flexion and ulnar/radius, elbow flexion, shoulder
rotation backward, frontward, neck flexion, torso flexion
are out of limits
Evaluation of Ergonomics Issues in Repetitive Scrap Handling …
Acceptable
(continued)
813
Table 11 (continued)
814
Acceptable
A. B. Dasari and D. Balasubramanian
Evaluation of Ergonomics Issues in Repetitive Scrap Handling … 815
Fig. 16 Indication for the percentage of population considered for the analysis
References
Abbreviations
1 Introduction
In this study, effective lean tool such as Kaizen has been adopted for process improve-
ment in a wire harness manufacturing company and Kaizen is used for betterment
of cost-effectiveness at the shop floor in the company through teamwork. The study
deals with various aspects of Kaizen as a lean manufacturing tool and how improve-
ments can be made by adopting practices of Kaizen in wire harness manufacturing
companies. OEE method was applied to reduce the cost by using Kaizen technique to
a semiconductor industry which results in cost reduction of 7% annually for the use of
gases and chemicals [1]. Kaizen was adopted to reduce operational cost and improve
efficiency [2]. Kaizen-based case study was performed in Romania for improvement
through PDCA cycle which results in reduction in service interventions, labor costs,
and cost of replaced parts [3]. Kaizen signifies small improvements that have been
made in the quality as a result of continuing efforts. Kaizen method concerned to
work out the part mismatch problems in automobile assembly production line [4].
Step-by-step Kaizen procedure has been attempted to solve the problem by data col-
lection, root cause analysis, selection of the best solution method, corrective actions,
and documentation. Identifying the problems, analyzing them, signifying solutions,
implementing them, and getting feedback are all sequential procedures that help to
resolve work-related problems properly and efficiently. The sequential method of
Kaizen is followed to solve work-related problems. The study is carried out over a
period of three months, during which team of Kaizen worked together to identify
the major problem and found a suitable solution at the shop floor of the company.
This study was performed on the basis of different Kaizen tools and problem-solving
techniques for collecting and analyzing the data. The sequential procedure that we
followed is shown by a flowchart in Fig. 1.
3 Case Study
The ABC Company is a professionally managed company known for its quality and
attitude toward perfection in the field of auto-electrical and electronic components.
Appreciating the continually evolving needs of the automotive industry, the company
has constantly developed new products for its customers and has endeavored to
remain at par with the leading technology available worldwide. The selected com-
pany is among the largest manufactures of wiring harnesses in India. A well-equipped
Reduction of Terminal Rejections and Failure Cost through … 819
Identification of Problem
1. ABC Analysis
Selection of Problem 2. Ranking Method
3. Pareto Analysis
Theme selection
Define Problem
Regular imple-
Data Collection
mentation status
Team members identified problems by visiting the shop floor of production depart-
ment of the company, and after discussion with shop floor workers, 52 problems
(shown in Table 1) have been recognized in crimping section of WIP area of the
company.
820 P. Kumar and J. Bhamu
Table 1 (continued)
S. No. Problem
37 Improper display of work instruction at shop floor
38 Improper storage of master sample
39 Time loss in changeover of terminal
40 Terminal damage during taping
41 Break down of 2.8 m terminal
42 Time loss in opening the tape
43 Tape wastage during taping
44 Tongue revert back
45 Contact gap in terminal
46 Improper knurling in terminal
47 Terminal face damaged
48 Leg height variation in terminal
49 Improper identification system of sleeves
50 Terminal blackout
51 Excess machine setup time of continuity tester
52 Conveyor hanger broken
It is required to select the problem which affects the most and due to which more
rejections are occurring. So to identify this problem in this study, three basic methods
are followed, i.e., ABC analysis, Pareto analysis and rating method.
ABC Analysis
After ABC analysis, it is observed that out of 52 problems, 43(shown serial no. 1–43
in Table 1) problems are in category of A, which have minimum involvement of other
department and only 5 problems (serial no. 44–48 in Table 1) are under B category in
which involvement of other department is necessary and 4 problems (serial no. 49–
52 in Table 1) are signified in C category which is needed management support for
implementing solutions. The problems which have minimum involvement of other
department are considered in ‘A’ category and which have involvement of other
department is necessary are in ‘B’ category. In ‘C’ category problems management
support may be needed in implementing solutions.
Pareto Analysis
Pareto analysis is basically a statistical technique used for selection of the problem
which has significant overall affect on operations. Pareto analysis not only shows
you the most important problem to solve, also gives you a score showing how severe
the problem is. Out of 52 problems, it is decided to select a major problem that
is responsible for increasing rejection level of terminal. After discussion and deep
822 P. Kumar and J. Bhamu
inspection, the team members decided to take one problem out of 5 problems from B
category problems. With the help all members’ opinion, all these five problems are
assigned score of severity of rejections. After plotting the score on chart, it is found
that highest rejections terminal are occurring due to improper gap between leg of
terminal so this problem is first selected to solve. Pareto chart is shown in Fig. 2.
Rating Method
Rating method is also an important technique which is also utilized for selection of
the major problem for responsible for most of rejections of terminal. In this method,
rating from 1 to 5 is decided based on three factors, i.e., occurrence, detection and
extent of impact. 1 rating is for LOW, and 5 is for HIGH. Problem selected on the
100.00
88.61
74.68
100 100
55.69
Mark Obtained
80 80
35.44
60 60
Cum %
40 28 40
16 15
20 11 9 20
0 0
CONTACT TERM. IMPROPER LEG TONGUE
GAP FACE KNURLING HEIGHT REVERT
DAMAGE VARIATION BACK
PROBLEMS
The problem that creates major rejections is found the improper contact gap or height
in 1.6F female type of terminal designed to slip inside a socket contact. The gap should
be as per standards decided by the company, but at most of working station, this was
not found as per the standards. As per the quality standards, this gap should not be
greater than 2 mm (shown in Photo 2), but after measuring this gap, it was found
5–6 mm or up to 7 mm (shown in Photo 1). Due to this improper gap, the rejections
levels were very high. As per data collected for 6 days in month of April 2018, the
rejection was 66% because of this improper contact gap.
The problem that was occurring before the improvement affected so many things in
the company, i.e., increase in-house rejections, decrease in vendor rating, decrease
in customer satisfaction, loss in productivity, increase in rework cost, and operator
fatigue.
4.2 Objectives
The objectives of our team are to ensure 100% customer satisfaction, increase vendor
rating, reduce in-house rejections, increase productivity, increase confidence level of
operator, and reduce the cost of failure. As per (Table 4) rating method, the priority
number of ‘contact gap in terminal’ is high so it is decided to solve this problem on
priority basis.
5 Process Flow
The flow process of wire harness manufacturing section of the company is shown
in Fig. 3. The raw material is received at raw material store and then goes through
BOP; after that, the material is transferred to main store of the company. After issuing
from main store, it reaches to wire assembly section and then transfers to coupler
assembly. In coupler assembly, coupler is fixed to wires and this semi-finished product
is transferred for board tapping process, and after that, this is electrically tested and
cover connector is inserted. After complete assembly, the harness is sent to final
inspection stage, and after inspection, it is ready for dispatch (Table 3).
826 P. Kumar and J. Bhamu
Problem
2 Area
1. Receiving store
2. BOP
Problem 3. Main Store
3 10 Area 4. Wire Assembly
5. Coupler Assem-
bly
Problem 6. Board Tapping
9 Area
4 7. Electrical Testing
8. Cover connector
insert
5 8 9. Final Inspection
10. DOL
Problem
6 7 Area
Leg Height
Variation Tongue revert
6% back
Improper 6%
Knurling 8%
Contact Gap
66%
Terminal face
damage
14%
6 Data Collection
For analysis of the impact of the five B category problems, data are collected for
non-conforming pieces of terminal. After the analysis of six-day observations, it was
found that 10 pieces are non-conforming due to leg height variation, 13 are due to
improper knurling, 22 are due to face damaged, 9 are due to tongue revert back, and
highest non-conforming pieces are due to improper contact gap of the terminal. This
analysis is also shown in pie chart; according to that, 66% pieces of terminal are
non-conforming due to contact gap problem. Total rejection level at different stages
of production process is shown in Fig. 5. Out of total received quantity 1,120,000,
Reduction of Terminal Rejections and Failure Cost through … 827
1120000
. Rej.Qty
72500
8000 2000 150
90000 82650
80000
70000
60000
50000
Rejection from
40000 35000
Dec17 to April18
30000
20000
20000
10000 1500
2000
0
Dec Jan Feb March April
72,500 pieces are rejected at BOI, 8000 pieces are rejected during process stage,
2000 at DOL, and 150 are rejected at customer end. Five month rejections status is
shown in Fig. 6. It is observed that the rejection is continuously increasing due to the
present problem as in the month of April 2018 this is found 82,650 pieces (Fig. 4).
Why-Why analysis method is used to move past symptoms and understand the true
root cause of a problem. It is said that only by asking ‘Why?’ Successively, it can
investigate into a problem deeply enough to understand the ultimate root cause. With
the help of this technique, it is observed that first tool setup rolled is due to insufficient
828 P. Kumar and J. Bhamu
training given to operator, latch/lever stopper wear problem is due to not analyzing
tool life properly, the problem of improper setting of lever stroke length occurs due
to inadequate tool design, and gap induced during rework of wire interchange is the
problem which is due to inadequate rework method (Tables 4 and 5).
8 Data Analysis
After the root analysis of causes of failure, it is found that major causes are there due
to which rejections level is high that are shown in Table 7. Observations are taken 15
times, and out of that, 9 times failure occurred due to tool setup problem and 5 times
due to wear out lever stopper, only 2 failure are because of improper setting of lever
stroke length and 1 time due to gap induced during rework of wire interchange. So
it is observed from data that 53% failures are due to tool setup problem (Table 6).
9 Developing Solution
Theme that got maximum percentage in ABC analysis, rating method, and Pareto
analysis is directly related to company’s esteemed customer and fit/function at cus-
tomer end, internal customer harassment, overall quality rating, time loss in pro-
ductivity and rejection increase/rejection cost increase, so it is must to eliminate
the root causes of this problem that are identified during root cause finding stage.
Training is provided to the operator about the impact of first set pieces, and customer
complaints were displayed at the notice board. Fresh pieces were used while rework-
ing the wire interchange, and training is provided to operator for change of rework
method that concludes to adequate method of reworking. Tool life is analyzed again
and displayed, and fixed punch is used at the place of lever/latch. To implement the
improvements, following are the resistances that are responsible for further step to
overcome the causes of failures.
Before the implementation of the counter measures, the rejection level found
82,650 pieces at the end of April 2018, it is observed that after implementation of
countermeasure 1, rejection level reduced to 55,600 pieces, after countermeasure 2,
it reduced to 45,600 pieces, after countermeasure 3, it is found 40,000 pieces and
after implementation of countermeasure 4, the rejections level found at zero level.
This is great achievement of our objectives (Table 8).
830 P. Kumar and J. Bhamu
82650
90000 55600
80000
70000 45600
40000
60000
50000
40000
30000 0
20000
10000
0
Before CM's After CM1 After CM2 After CM3 AFTER
CM4
11 Conclusion
The theme of this was to reduce material cost and failure cost by solving the contact
gap problem of the terminal in WIP area by adopting Kaizen lean tool. In this regard,
total 52 problems are identified, out of those 43 in A, 5 in B, and 4 in C category.
This problem affects that total 82,650 pieces were rejected maximum in month of
April 2018. In this case, to remove the contact gap, a modified mechanism with fixed
punch installed in place of existing mechanism. After improvement in mechanism,
the rejection level reduced to zero and the total cost saved Rs. 227,124/year. At the
closing stages of this work, it concludes that Kaizen technique is very effective to
solve the work-related problems in the organizations. This way of improving the
production processes and getting cost-effectiveness is very precious for building far
above the ground productivity of the company (Fig. 7).
References
1. Kikuchi K, Kikuchi T, Takai T (2007) Method of overall consumable effectiveness. In: IEEE
international symposium on semiconductor manufacturing, Santa Clara, USA, pp 1–4
2. Modarress B et al (2005) Kaizen costing for lean manufacturing: a case study. Int J Prod Res
43(9):1751–60
832 P. Kumar and J. Bhamu
3. Veres C, Marian L, Moica S (2017) Case study concerning effects of Japanese Management
Model. Procedia Eng 181:1013–1020
4. Chandrasekaran M, Kannan S, Pandiaraj P (2008) Quality improvement in automobile assembly
production line by using kaizen. Manuf Technol Today 7(3):33–38
Solving the Flexible Job Shop Scheduling
Problem Using a Hybrid Artificial Bee
Colony Algorithm
Abstract In this work, a hybrid artificial bee colony algorithm is proposed for solv-
ing the flexible job shop scheduling problem (FJSP) which is a classification of
the classical job shop scheduling problem (JSP) considered to NP-hard in nature.
In FJSP, an operation can be processed on a set of capable machines with different
processing times, thereby dealing with a routing and sequencing problem. The objec-
tive considered is to minimize the makespan. The basic artificial bee colony (ABC)
algorithm stresses on the balance between global exploration and local exploitation.
However, the drawback of the basic ABC algorithm is that it converges prematurely
and may get trapped in the local optima. Hence to improve its exploration capability
in local space, it is hybridized using a Tabu search (TS) algorithm. At first, initial
solutions are generated with certain quality and diversity as food sources using mul-
tiple strategies in combination. Crossover and mutation operations are carried out for
machine assignment and operation sequencing separately generating new neighbor-
ing solutions. Lastly, a local search strategy based on TS is proposed to enhance the
local search capability. Kacem’s and Brandimarte’s benchmark instances are used to
compare the performance of the proposed approach to five other well-known algo-
rithms in the literature. Experimental results revealed the superiority of the proposed
approach in solving FJSP.
Keywords Flexible job shop scheduling · Artificial bee colony algorithm · Tabu
search · Makespan
1 Introduction
exploitation. A local search strategy based on critical path theory was proposed to
enhance the local intensification capability of the onlooker bees.
A hybrid ABC for solving the FJSP proposed by Li et al. [8] considered the total
flow time criterion, where TS heuristic is introduced to perform a local search for
employee, onlooker, and scout bee phases. A best-so-far ABC proposed by Banharn-
sakun et al. [9] biases the solution direction toward the best-so-far solution rather
than a neighboring solution as proposed in original ABC method and also uses the
set theory to describe a mapping of their proposed method to the problem in the
combinatorial optimization domain. Among different approaches, ABC algorithm
proposed by Karaboga and Gorkemli [10] is a widely employed swarm intelligence
algorithm for scheduling FJSP problems. ABC algorithm was first proposed to solve
the multi-variable and multi-modal continuous functions. Localization and multi-
objective evolutionary optimization for FJSP proposed by Kacem et al. [11] present
two new approaches to jointly solve routing and scheduling by localization and then
by evolutionary approach. Mehrabad and Fattahi [12] proposed a TS algorithm to
solve the FJSP to minimize makespan. Hurink et al. [13] performed TS for solving
the FJSP.
In this work, we propose a hybrid ABC with TS to improve the exploration
capability in local space (exploitation). The proposed algorithm consists of the basic
ABC phases, initialization, employee bee phase, and the scout bee phase. Here, solu-
tions are initialized as two separate chromosomes to facilitate individual crossover.
The two chromosomes are machine assignment and operation sequencing. Machine
assignment follows the random rule, maximum time remaining rule, and most num-
ber of remaining operations rule, whereas operation sequencing follows the random
rule, global minimum processing time rule, and work-time considered rule. These
rules are adopted so that the population generated is diverse and feasible.
Employee bee phase initiates with the modified precedence operation crossover
operator (MPOX) for crossover in operation sequencing. A uniform crossover is
used for machine assignment. For half of the population chosen at random maximum
workload reduction, mutation operator is used for modifying machine assignment.
The mutation operator is used to enhance the exploration capability of the algorithm.
The solution obtained is now introduced into a TS local search. This search performs
an iterative search on the entire population to get new and better solutions in each
step. TS is chosen as it prevents the local search from converging on a solution
prematurely, thereby improving the local exploration capability of the algorithm.
When the solution does not improve, a random solution is generated on behalf of the
scout bee phase which is compared with the TS solution. A new better population is
obtained from both of these solutions and taken for the next ABC iteration until the
termination criteria are satisfied.
836 R. Caldeira et al.
2 Problem Definition
The problem is solved hierarchically, and thus, solutions are represented as separate
vectors each for operation sequencing and machine assignment which is termed as
the two-vector solution representation (see Fig. 1). To guarantee an initial population
with a certain quality, different heuristics are adopted to generate a population.
Solving the Flexible Job Shop Scheduling Problem Using … 837
In this phase, the two vectors are modified separately by crossover and mutation
operators. Machine assignment vector undergoes a uniform crossover (see Fig. 3),
where the new vector unew is derived from the initial vector ui and the vector with
the best solution u’ by generating a binary vector and then a maximum workload
reduction mutation operator is used to reduce the assignment of the machine with
maximum workload.
Operation sequencing vector undergoes a modified precedence operation
crossover (MPOX) operation (see Fig. 2), where a random subset of half the jobs is
generated, and they are given priority from one vector, whereas the other jobs are
assigned from another vector from left to right. Then, a maximum workload reduc-
tion operator is applied which identifies the machine with the maximum workload
and re-assigns possible operations to other machines with lesser workloads. This acts
as the mutation operator which is performed on only half of the population (Fig. 3).
The parameters for the algorithm like population size, number of iterations, and bee
colony size are set. The initial population solution representation is done by using
two-vector notations employing population initialization rules.
In the employee bee phase, the machine assignment vector undergoes uniform
crossover and a maximum workload reduction mutation operation where the muta-
tion is performed on only half of the population, whereas the operation sequencing
vector undergoes a modified operation crossover operation. Then, for the whole mod-
ified population, a TS local search is performed which provides the best solution in
every iteration without converging predominantly, thus improving the exploration
capability of the ABC algorithm in local search space. The flowchart of the proposed
hybrid ABC is illustrated (see Fig. 4).
4 Experimental Results
This paper considers the NP-hard FJSP with the makespan criteria, and the same
is solved by a proposed hybrid algorithm where a TS is incorporated in the ABC
algorithm. The effectiveness of using TS as a local search is highlighted by the
improved exploration and convergence capability of the ABC algorithm in the local
search space. The proposed hybrid ABC algorithm showed superior performance in
comparison with other well-known meta-heuristics on Kacem’s and Brandimarte’s
instances.
This work can be extended to solve other scheduling problems with constraints.
842 R. Caldeira et al.
References
1. Brandimarte P (1993) Routing and scheduling in a flexible job shop by tabu search. Ann Oper
Res 41(3):157–183
2. Sharma N, Sharma H, Sharma A (2018) Beer froth artificial bee colony algorithm for job-shop
scheduling problem. Appl Soft Comput 68:507–524
3. Xiang W et al (2018) A novel artificial bee colony algorithm based on the cosine similarity.
Comput Ind Eng 115:54–68
Solving the Flexible Job Shop Scheduling Problem Using … 843
4. Sharma H, Bansal JC, Arya KV, Yang XS (2016) Lévy flight artificial bee colony algorithm.
Int J Syst Sci 47(11):2652–2670
5. Thammano A, Phu-ang A (2013) A hybrid artificial bee colony algorithm with local search for
flexible job-shop scheduling problem. Procedia Comput Sci 20:96–101
6. Zhang R, Shiji S, Cheng W (2013) A hybrid artificial bee colony algorithm for the job shop
scheduling problem. Int J Prod Econ 141(1):167–178
7. Wang L, Zhou G, Xu Y, Wang S, Liu M (2012) An effective artificial bee colony algorithm for
the flexible job-shop scheduling problem. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 60(1–4):303–315
8. Li JQ, Xie SX, Pan QK, Wang S (2011) A hybrid artificial bee colony algorithm for flexible
job shop scheduling problems. Int J Comput Commun Control 6(2):286–296
9. Banharnsakun A, Sirinaovakul B, Achalakul T (2012) Job shop scheduling with the best-so-far
ABC. Eng Appl Artif Intell 25(3):583–593
10. Karaboga D, Gorkemli B (2012) A quick artificial bee colony-qABC-algorithm for optimization
problems. In: International symposium on innovations in intelligent systems and applications.
IEEE, pp 1–5
11. Kacem I, Hammadi S, Borne P (2002) Approach by localization and multiobjective evolutionary
optimization for flexible job-shop scheduling problems. IEEE Trans Syst Man Cybern Part C
(Appl Rev) 32(1):1–13
12. Saidi M, Fattahi P (2007) Flexible job shop scheduling with tabu search algorithms. Int J Adv
Manuf Technol 32(5–6):563–570
13. Hurink J, Jurisch B, Thole M (1994) Tabu search for the job-shop scheduling problem with
multi-purpose machines. Oper Res Spektrum 15(4):205–215
14. Xing LN, Chen YW, Yang KW (2009) An efficient search method for multi-objective flexible
job shop scheduling problems. J Intell Manuf 20(3):283–293
15. Buddala R, Mahapatra SS (2018) An integrated approach for scheduling flexible job-shop using
teaching–learning-based optimization method. J Ind Eng Int 1–12
16. Bagheri A, Zandieh M, Mahdavi I, Yazdani M (2010) An artificial immune algorithm for the
flexible job-shop scheduling problem. Futur Gener Comput Syst 26(4):533–541
17. Li JQ, Pan QK, Liang YC (2010) An effective hybrid tabu search algorithm for multi-objective
flexible job-shop scheduling problems. Comput Ind Eng 59(4):647–662
18. Rahmati SHA, Zandieh M (2012) A new biogeography-based optimization (BBO) algorithm
for the flexible job shop scheduling problem. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 58(9–12):1115–1129
Linear Programming in Market
Management Using Artificial Intelligence
1 Introduction
Artificial intelligence is widely used in decision making and prediction using math-
ematical algorithms. Artificial neural network (ANN)-based system works similar
2 Methodology
The formulation of a linear programming problem considers only few variables and
can be solved manually, but on real time applications, the variables considered are to
be many. The main focus is not to solve a linear programming problem, but utilizing
the linear programming system by a computer-embedded program that can solve the
figures of large variables and generate the best suitable answer based on the past data
and also configures the future prediction of the product chosen by the people.
In this system, input is taken from the end user like minimum investment, maxi-
mum investment, area, etc., and these inputs are fed to the system with ‘n’ variable,
and from the past records, it gives the output how the amount should be invested in
each format of marketing. So, data in the system enables the customer to decide on
the investment and thus helps to make a smart business.
Decision Variables The decision variables are those which will decide the output of
a problem statement. Decision variables need to be identified to solve any problem.
For the defined problem, decision variables are “add input constraint names the ones
that are visible” investment, type of business, city, time (in months), and assets.
Objective Function It is the prime function which is to be worked upon depending
upon the problem. In this problem, the company wishes to know the better option
in investing money in advertisement (“out of 4 options, add name of output nodes
here”) digital marketing, newspapers, pamphlets, and banners.
Following is the algorithm can be considered for obtaining the desired output:
The model comes under multiple class neural network classification that involves
building neural networks that map the input to the network and output containing
more than two classes. In this case, dependency on the input and output is not known.
Therefore, three hidden layers are used with reLu as activation function for hidden
layer and Softmax for output layer (Fig. 1).
Supervised Learning During the training of ANN under supervised learning, the
input vector is presented to the network, which will give an output vector. The
obtained result vector is compared with the desired result vector. An objection signal
is generated if there is a difference between the actual result and the desired result
vector.
The weights are adjusted (added or subtracted with value) until the actual output
is matched with the desired output. It is a non-recurrent network that has processing
units or nodes in layers, and all the nodes in a layer are connected to the nodes
of the previous layer and also to node of next layer. The connection has different
weights upon them (chosen randomly before training). These weights change as per
848 S. V. Uday et al.
Fig. 2 Graphical
representation of input
output of reLu
Linear Programming in Market Management … 849
eβz j
σ (z) = K (1)
βz k
k=1 e
Training Algorithm For training, use reLu activation function for hidden layers and
Softmax for the output layer. The training of neural network will have the following
four phases.
Step 1: Feed-forward phase:
• Initialize to start the training with following inputs
– Weights (choose random weights)
– Learning rate α (should be small)
• Calculate activation function (a) of unit i in layer j using below relation
n
j
j
ai =g xi Hi (2)
i=1
m
1 (i)
J (θ ) = − t log(yθ (xi ))k + (1 − tk ) log(1 − yθ (xi ))k
i
(3)
m i=1
where m is total number of nodes in a layer, t is desired output, and (yθ )i is ith output.
Step 3: Back propagation:
Intuition: δ ij = error of node j in layers i.
Intuition for output layer is:
δ (m−1)
j = y (m)
j − t (m)
j
where δ (2)
j is intuition of the output layer
**In most cases, back propagation is calculated by the backend library itself**
Step 4: Update the weights in the network until dataset classified correctly or stopping
criterion satisfied.
∂J
H d+1 = H d − ∝ (4)
∂h
where ∝ = learning rate (should be low), d is number of iterations, and J is loss
function
850 S. V. Uday et al.
Testing Stage Simulate the network with new dataset. By using various test cases,
neural network will be trained and that network will be used to solve real cases by
linear programming problem.
Outcome Data is captured to get the best possible way of advertising, calculated by
the neural network
Considering the marketing issues and availability, it is difficult to obtain the solutions
considering all the variables. Hence, by using a formulated mathematical model, it
is easier to obtain the probability of variables. Hence, the objectives can be met and
profits can be maximized in real-life applications.
As marketing strategy is being one of the most important criteria of a product, it is
appreciated if it reaches the end user with necessary requirements in short duration.
The above model will help the marketing team to meet these demands by training
the algorithm. The probability of each variable will be obtained, and with the help of
these values, suitable constraints and variables can be identified. This model helps
the user decide on expenditures and types of marketing.
To demonstrate the working of the trained neural network model, the input is
taken as [200,000, ‘non-profit’, ‘Mumbai’, 15, 3,500,000].
Passing the above as input, the probability obtained is as follows (Table 1).
The above output obtained will help marketing team on understanding the types
of marketing and the priority.
4 Conclusion
This paper gives a complete set of algorithms for the system to train and learn the
marketing environment and predict the most accurate outputs using the system of
linear programming. As the time passes, large datasets will be collected and the
system would have more variables to match and work upon; this will keep system
improving.
In the future, the scope of obtaining the feedback in the system can be incorporated
which will help the system constantly to update and develop. The developed system
Linear Programming in Market Management … 851
will help both the marketing firms to develop individually and also reach to the
customers based on their preferences. Each of the products marketed varies from
each other, based on the type of advertisement which varies from the demographical
area. Based on place, people, and economy, a customized marketing plan can be
formulated considering all possible variables.
Manually, only few variables can be formulated, as the complexity increases, and
when the real-life solutions are needed to meet the customer satisfaction, ANN would
give the best solutions to the problem within least time which gives a better impact
on the marketing firm.
References
1. Kennedy MP, Chua LO (1988) Neural networks for nonlinear programming. IEEE Trans Circuits
Syst CAS 35:554–562
2. Ghasabi-Oskoei H, Mahdavi-Amiri N (2006) An efficient simplified neural network for solving
linear and quadratic programming problems. Appl Math Comput J 452–464
3. Wen U-P, Lan K-M, Shi H-S (2009) A review of Hopfield neural networks for solving
mathematical programming problems. Eur J Oper Res 675–687
4. Gao X, Liao L-Z (2010) A new one-layer, neural network for linear quadratic programming.
IEEE Trans Neural Netw 21(6)
Queueing Theory an Index Factor
for Production Inventory Control
in Automotive Industry—A Review
Abstract In this paper, various approaches to inventory control within the automo-
tive industry were reviewed using queueing theory. Different models used in past
literature were stated and the model considered to be most effective in this review
is dock management modeling. This model was used to analyze inventory control
and how effectively automotive industries can minimize inventory by getting the
component needed in the assembly line just in time, this helps to reduce additional
costs for warehouse maintenance and capital tied down in form of excess inventory.
Analytical and simulation models are the mathematical models that are considered
in this review as they are used in several papers by different authors.
1 Introduction
The resultant effect of a queue could be a result of server factors of which the inability
of servers not to meet up with the demand of the customers is one of them, this
increases waiting time and length of the queue [1]. Other factors that affect a queueing
system are service time, arrival pattern, number of servers, etc. Queues can be found in
various settings which could either be in the manufacturing or service organization;
in this case, the major concern in the manufacturing sector taking the automotive
industry as a case study. In recent times, there has been an increase in variety of
products and mix models in order for the manufacturers to effectively compete in
the global market. For manufacturers to stay relevant, flexibility in manufacturing
is an important concept that must be embraced [2]. However, flexibility has its own
cons which are high initial investment which requires large inventory and this is a
non-negligible cost [3].
Manufacturing car, parts are stamped from steel rolls and the entire body is then
welded to produce a shell, and then each composition is finally welded in the body
on the moving assembly line [4]. It was observed in the automotive industry that
inventory management is a key factor in maximizing productivity and minimizing
waste [5]. Inventory can be in different forms like raw material, work in progress,
finished products, and goods in the warehouse between customers and suppliers. It
is important for all industries to manage inventory properly as it is determinant on
how productive and profitable the business can be one of the most successful models
used to tackle inventory problems in this industry is just-in-time manufacturing that
makes use of the supermarket rule of taking exactly what is needed in the assembly
line from the warehouse [6].
The efficiency of the production system can be determined using the batch size
and throughput. The batch size and the throughput must be aligned to optimize the
system in order to make sure that the system is efficient [7]. Queueing network
was used in this paper to study how throughput and batch size affects the optimal
utilization of resources, especially machine resources in manufacturing systems. This
study is focused on plants in the manufacturing industry that carry out assembly
operations. The result of this study shows that utilization is a function of batch size
and throughput, which means an increase or decrease in batch size or throughput
directly affects the increase and decrease in utilization. If the demand requirement
is higher than the capacity bottlenecks will definitely occur. For the manufacturing
industry to remain relevant, sustainable, and compete strongly they must always
find a way of improving efficiency in the production process. The production line
where production is carried out is divided into three parts, namely single, batch,
and mixed-model line [8]. The machines in the production lines have a cycle time
in which they operate. In a manufacturing system, the efficiency of the production
operation is based on how the machines utilize the resource in particular cycle time.
Some operations did not make full use of the resources, this resulted in increased
cycle time which also affects the throughput rate at which a product enters and
leaves the production line. However, the ideal batch size and throughput for a given
production can be defined with the help of the queueing theory in order to optimally
use resources. In the manufacturing system, modeling can be done by using either an
analytical model or a simulation model. Queueing network is one of the analytical
models used in evaluating manufacturing system [9].
2 Reviewed Literature
In the automotive assembly, the techniques and emerging technologies used in vehicle
assembly plants are discussed in this paper. Assembly processes such as handling,
joining, etc., that involves the use of technology, as well as supporting systems were
considered in this paper. A summary of existing technologies is provided. Mass
customization requirements have been a challenge for the assembly systems as they
are unable to keep up, this means that upgrading technology is necessary to achieve
Queueing Theory an Index Factor for Production Inventory … 855
high flexibility. For operation and system, design flexibility is a key factor that should
be integrated into future assembly plants [10].
The automotive industry faces great challenges such as advancement in technol-
ogy, new competitors, and industry restructuring, and sourcing globally. The quick
change from mass production to mass customization is dependent on the fact that
customers wants certain features incorporated into their products and manufactur-
ers have to provide many variants using fewer resources in a relatively short period
[11]. The ability of the manufacturer to provide several variants per model and bring
onboard new models at a fast rate is restricted by the current equipment used in mass
production and also current technologies that are not capable of supporting product
variability. In automotive assembly increased complexity requires an encompass-
ing view of the main attributes of manufacturing that should be considered when
manufacturing decisions relating to cost, quality, flexibility, and time are taken [12].
In the automotive industry, the typical framework of a plant comprises four phases
- stamping, body shop, painting, and final assembly. Assembly is carried out mainly
in the body shop or final assembly. The assembly of the body in white (BIW) uses high
level of automation, while the final assembly stage introduces a combination of hybrid
human/machine systems. Four approaches can thus be identified when designing the
assembly system; (1) flexible assembly (2) manual assembly, (3) semi-automated
assembly, (4) fixed assembly.
Generally, different vehicles in an automotive assembly make use of the same
assembly line known as mixed-model assembly line (MMAL). The MMAL are
distinguished because of their ability not to hold large inventory when assembling
different models of a given product [13]. Demand for more secured and faster ramp-
up processes which are cost-intensive is one of the major problems modern assembly
system has to tackle. Steady increase in number of products demanded underpins
the goal, which is a result of improved innovation and increased market launches
of product variant and new product. Groover [9] further expounded that the present
trend that Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs) in automotive industry follow
is incorporating equipment, product and process standardization.
One of the probabilistic models used for predicting and making a decision under
uncertainty are Bayesian networks. The inventory, production quantity and deliver
quantity of any manufacturing organization such as the automotive industry varies
according to the several unexpected events [14]. Thus, predicting inventory in pro-
duction is sacrosanct in order to cope with the variations in the market. This paper
considers the way to adjust production for the car parts process through the use of
a dynamic Bayesian network. Material in a production system (known as factory
automation) is delivered to clients and stored in inventory for subsequent shipment
through each manufacturing, sub-assembly and final product process [15].
To utilize a system like factory automation, attributes of production such as pro-
duction rate of the company varies because of the irregular changes found generally
in the operating capabilities and also the strength of the labor force. There are random
changes to product order which means managers of each process have to decide on
the output of products by using their know-how and experience to tackle this issue
[16]. Taking a look at the inventory in a Kanban way, the inventory is considered
856 S. A. Afolalu et al.
this paper for automotive shredders in order to make a short-term strategic decision
with regards to the level at which materials should be processed and reprocessed
through multiple passes. A model known as mixed-integer linear programming is
used to determine whether to separate or combine materials for shipment [26].
3 The Problem
Generally, in supply chain materials move through the distribution center from the
supplier and finally arrive at the moor of the assembly plant. The arriving components
or materials are then taken immediately to the assembly line or the inventory. Prompt
arrival of the components determines the correct feeding of the assembly line because
of any mistake in leaving a part out result to heavy cost for production re-scheduling
[27].
There are two ways of addressing any of the delays from the supplier, through means
of transport or dock, they discussed as follows: Transport management: this is taking
into consideration when the supplier doesn’t deliver on time or problems arise while
transporting the goods. In this type of scenario is an alternative which is to take
advantage of faster means of transportation in order to reduce the lead time of goods
arriving at the plant. It should be noted that change to a faster means of transportation
will lead to additional cost for faster delivery [28].
Dock management takes care of any form of disruptive event that can occur during
delivery of goods.
4 Solution
Askin et al. [28] stated that incoming disruptive events managed by this model led
to a reduction in the total cost of updating the dock work, which helps to identify the
most appropriate dock management solution. The main objective here is to remember
the actual production time that displays the time when the assembly line requires an
incoming order. Based on this time, calculating when the order at the dock should be
ready is possible at maximum. The time difference between production time and time
858 S. A. Afolalu et al.
required to transfer orders for the assembly line from the warehouse is known as due
time [29]. This transfer can be managed in two ways, which are the Standard method
and strategies that are faster which include advantageous transport and an increase in
price which is used to make up for the delay experienced that arrives after due time.
Two moments name acceptable due time_S1 and _S2 are defined by the two strategies
mentioned above, these are calculated as the difference between respective transfer
time and actual production time. Any delayed order arriving after these moments are
transferred for production re-scheduling [30]. Also, the time between the specific
window time when the production re-scheduling is required and due time is known
as buffer time. Arrivals after the buffer time are placed within the re-scheduling time.
Orders that takes place after the estimated arrival time is due to disruption during
order delivery [31].
A specific amount of time known as the unloading duration is used to unload and
transfer goods to the warehouse after the order arrives at the dock. After unloading,
the order is then placed on the assembly line. If the estimated readiness time is before
the due time, then there is no additional cost. If the time of readiness after the due
date is estimated, then the buffer time or cost of re-scheduling will be additional as
a matter of time [32].
5 Conclusions
A number of manufacturing industries like the automotive industry took the use of
queueing theory in inventory management, leading to reductions in lead times to
maximize profit, mathematical models that include analytical models and simulation
models were evaluated in various literature, meanwhile in this paper, the model
considered to be effective is dock management, the use of the model result in proper
inventory keeping of materials necessary for the assembly line in order to avoid
stoppage during production [33–35].
References
4. Bruniaux R, Pierreval H, Caux C (1999) Simulating supply chains with system dynamics. In:
Proceedings of the ESS’99 European simulation symposium, Nuremberg, Germany, 26–28
Oct, pp 209–213
5. Bruniaux R (2000) Simulation continue de réseaux de sites industriels: application aux chaines
logistiques dans le secteur automobile. Ph.D. Dissertation, in French, Université Blaise Pascal,
Clermont-Ferrand, France
6. Bruniaux R, Caux C (2007) A continuous simulation approach for supply chains in the
automotive industry. Simul Model Pract Theory 15(2):185–198
7. Boysen N, Emde S, Hoeck M, Kauderer M (2015) Part logistics in the automotive industry:
decision problems, literature review and research agenda. Eur J Oper Res 242(1):107–120
8. Dalmijn WL (1990) Practical applications of eddy current separators in the scrap recy-
cling industry. In: van Linden JHI, Stewart DL Jr, Sahai Y (eds) Proceedings of the second
international symposium on recycling of metals and engineered materials, pp 303–314
9. Groover MP (1987) Automation, production systems, and computer integrated manufacturing.
Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, pp 36–40, 404–407
10. Ho C (1989) Evaluating the impact of operating environments on MRP system nervousness.
Int J Prod Res 27:1115–1135
11. Michalos G, Makris S, Papakostas N, Mourtzis D, Chryssolouris G (2010) Automotive assem-
bly technologies review: challenges and outlook for a flexible and adaptive approach. CIRP J
Manufact Sci Technol 2(2):81–91
12. Hu SJ, Zhu X, Wang H, Koren Y (2008) Product variety and manufacturing complexity in
assembly systems and supply chains. CIRP Ann Manuf Technol 57(1):45–48
13. Lang S, Reggelin T, Wunder T (2017) Mesoscopic simulation models for logistics planning
tasks in the automotive industry. Procedia Eng 178:298–307
14. Marsudi M, Shafeek H (2013) Production line performance by using queuing model. IFAC
Proc Vol 46(9):1152–1157
15. Marsudi M, Dzuraidah AW, Che Hassan CH (2009) Application of spreadsheet and queuing
network model to capacity optimization in product development. World Acad Sci Eng Technol
34:1068–1071
16. Salawu EY, Okokpujie IP, Afolalu SA, Ajayi OO, Azeta J (2018) Investigation of production
output for improvement. Int J Mech Prod Eng Res Dev 8(1):915–922
17. Afolalu AS, Enesi YS, Kehinde O, Samuel UA, Ikechi VI, Remilekun RE (2018) Failure mode
and effect analysis a tool for reliability evaluation. Eur J Eng Res Sci 3(4):65–68
18. Salawu EY, Ajayi OO, Inegbenebor AO, Afolalu SA, Ongbali SO (2018) Pareto analysis of
product quality failures and cost effects in bottling machines—a lean thinking solution for
alcohol industry. Int J Mech Eng Technol 9(11):2380–2388
19. Afolalu SA, Ayuba SU, Ihebom IV, Elewa RR, Oluyemi K (2018) Role of reliability man-
agement tools and documentations—a review. Glob J Eng Sci Res Manage 5(3):39. ISSN
2349-4506
20. Meyer A, Sejdovic S, Glock K, Bender M, Kleiner N, Riemer D (2017) A disruption man-
agement system for automotive inbound networks: concepts and challenges. EURO J Transp
Logist 1–32
21. Mula J, Poler R, García-Sabater JP, Lario FC (2006) Models for production planning under
uncertainty: a review. Int J Prod Econ 103(1):271–285
22. Pearl J (1986) Fusion, propagation and structuring in belief networks. Artif Intell 29(3):241–288
23. Lee YH, Cho MK, Kim SJ, Kim YB (2002) Supply chain simulation with discrete continuous
combined modeling. Comput Ind Eng 43(1–2):375–392
24. Rabelo L, Magdy H, Lertpattarapong C (2004) Analysis of supply chains using system dynam-
ics, neural networks and eigenvalues. In: Proceedings of the 2004 winter simulation conference,
Dec, Washington, DC, USA
25. Abioye AA, Atanda PO, Abioye OP, Akinlabi SA, Akinlabi ET, Bolu CA, Afolalu SA, Ajayi
OO, Ohijeagbon IO (2018). A review on automotive industries and foundries in Nigeria. In:
IOP conference series: materials science and engineering, vol 413, no 1. IOP Publishing, p
012003
860 S. A. Afolalu et al.
26. Ramírez-Granados M, Hernàndez JE, Lyons AC (2014) A discrete-event simulation model for
supporting the first-tier supplier decision-making in a UK’s automotive industry. J Appl Res
Technol 12(5):860–870
27. Remiel FM, Cauvin A, Ferrarini A (2014) Conceptual design and simulation of an automotive
body shop assembly line. IFAC Proc Vol 47(3):760–765
28. Askin RG, Mitwasi MG, Goldberg JB (1993) Determining the number of kanbans in multi-item
just-in- time systems. IIE Trans 25(1):89–98
29. Sethi SP, Yan H, Zang Q (2002) Optimal and hierarchical controls in dynamic stochastic
manufacturing systems: A survey. Manuf Serv Oper Manage 4:133–170
30. Shin J, Kim S, Lee JM (2015) Production and inventory control of auto parts based on predicted
probabilistic distribution of inventory. Dig Commun Netw 1(4):292–301
31. Shiina T, Birge JR (2003) Multistage stochastic programming model for electric power capacity
expansion problem. Jpn J Ind Appl Math 20:379–397
32. Spengler T, Ploog M, Schroter M (2003) Integrated planning of acquisition, disassembly and
bulk recycling: a case study on electronic scrap recovery. OR Spectrum 25:413–442
33. Ajayi OO, Agarana MC, Akinwumi II, Okokpujie PI, Salawu EY, Abioye AA, Afolalu AS,
Leramo RO (2019) Modelling rate of traffic-induced building vibrations in Sango-Ota, Nigeria:
an assumption based analysis. WIT Trans Built Environ 182:303–313
34. Weiss EN, Tucker C (2018) Queue management: elimination, expectation, and enhancement.
Bus Horiz 61(5):671–678
35. Williams JAS, Wongweragiat S, Qu X, McGlinch JB, Bonawi-tan W, Choi JK, Schiff J (2007)
An automotive bulk recycling planning model. Eur J Oper Res 177(2):969–981
Design and Analysis of ASRS Using AGV
for Rapid Inventory Storage System
Abstract Non-competitive market pricing is easy to use and maintain but it is a major
issue in automated guided vehicles (AGVs) that are available in the current market.
Space is a very valuable commodity in urban areas. The current AGV available in
the market needs optimization and is specifically designed for one particular form of
storage system. In order to reduce the complexity of the system, hard locating method
approach is used. Hard locating is a process that assists the operator in avoiding
mistakes. In this work, an AGV for rapid inventory storage system is proposed. The
AGV consists of a 5-degrees of freedom (DOF) robotic arm with a two-fingered
gripper is used for picking and placing the boxes. The gripper is equipped with
a piezoelectric sensor to sense the size of the object. By using this approach, the
existing rack can be used without much alteration. This system has the capability to
increase the utilization of the warehouse. This paper presents an optimized automated
storage and retrieval system (ASRS) with the help of AGV with reduced cost and
complexity.
1 Introduction
The design and implementation of a 7-channel line sensor for line following robot
were having advanced functionalities such as software-based automatic sensor cal-
ibration and individual threshold per sensor channel. The system was implemented
using light-emitting diodes, phototransistor and an on-board microcontroller Arduino
which communicates with any navigation control system using serial communication
[1]. The optimization problem of AGV in smart warehouse dispatching mechanism
is studied with genetic algorithm [2]. The AGV logistics and distribution compo-
nents which are used for AGV in discrete manufacturing process are explained [3].
AGV is a kind of simple mobile robot, which integrates light, sound, electricity
and computer, and it is applied in the fields of manufacturing industry and logis-
tics, such as automobile industries [4]. An AGV with low-cost camera was used to
capture images to figure out the surrounded conditions and decide the next move.
Region-based convolutional neural network-based deep learning algorithm was used
to analyse the images [5]. In smart factory, as one of key features for our industry, it
requires automation within a manufacturing plant such as a shop floor. Automated
guided vehicle (AGV) systems may be the best idea, whose accuracy depends on
some factors. An AGV with radio frequency identification (RFID)-enabled position-
ing system is used in for smart factory [6]. The robotic gripper was designed and
fabricated taking into account the economics, simplicity and reliability. Suitable-end
effectors can be installed for particular application [7]. The portable robotic arm with
4-degrees of freedom working model was able to imitate the movement of a human
arm with imperceptible delay and had a payload capacity of 150 gm that is achieved
[8]. The ASVS/RS rack design is focused on avoiding collision and deadlock in the
highroad traffic network, by restricting the layout and traffic regulations of trunk
rails, storage rails, lifters, etc. [9]. The ASRS is basically used to store or retrieve the
loads in the warehouse or out of it. The computer will calculate wherein the storage
area the item can be retrieved from and does the retrieval operation. The components
are stored into or retrieved from the racks, and the computer updates the inventory
system [10].
Automated storage and retrieval systems have many potential applications. The
most common ASRS application is the storage and retrieval of inventory component,
but other ASRS applications can greatly increase the efficiency of an operation as
well [11]. An automated guided vehicle (AGV) is a robot that follows marker (wires)
on the floor, magnets or lasers for navigation. With the rise of online shopping, the
requirement of large warehouses has increased exponentially. To manage these large
warehouses, an army of workers is needed, which is not very economical. A better
option would be to implement an automated storage and retrieval system by using
automated guided vehicle which will greatly help the institution in economic terms
and increase the storage density of the warehouse. The objective of the proposed
system is to find the perfect balance between the two systems such that the overall
efficiency of the warehouse storage can be optimized. Implementing human work-
force, wherein large ever-growing demand for storage places, human efficiency may
not update with the technology. Hence to increase the efficiency and storage den-
sity of the packages, implementation of ASRS becomes vital. The ASRS reduces
the probability of human-caused errors, and the AGV increases the efficiency and
the work duration. This is cheaper to handle, and very less maintenance is required.
The integration and optimization of these two complex systems are presented and
detailed in this proposed work.
Design and Analysis of ASRS Using AGV for Rapid Inventory … 863
2 Proposed System
Figure 1 shows the warehouse layout. In front of each box levels, a line or a junction
is created to position the bot in front of the box. The boxes will be kept in the rack
using locating strips so that the position of the box will be known and fixed; hence,
the arm could be hardcoded to reach the designated position of the boxes. Based
on the proposed fixing position of the boxes, the complexity, both mechanically
and electrically, is reduced. Base of the AGV is kept as three-fourth of the track
width (distance between two columns) and not too short of the wheelbase that will
misbalance the centre of gravity of the bot while handling the load. The standby
dimensions of the bot are 800 * 630 * 900. These two package sizes (12.5 × 9.75
× 3.25 and 18 21.5 × 5.25 ) are the most common size used in the shipping
industry. The rack is a simple 3-level rack and used to store objects of various sizes
in inventory systems. The rack system is designed to help with the hardcoded gripper
mechanism and ensure zero error and arrangement of boxes. The arena is designed
such that the bot will have to go through minimum number of iterations. It will
receive a set of location addresses via Bluetooth, using the location instructions; it
will take the necessary turns, will grab the package with the help of gripper and get
back to its original position.
The 5-DOF manipulator is mounted on the chassis which is having four wheels
driven by DC motors. The end effector is driven by a DC motor for open and close
operation of the jaw, and it is designed to have a piezoelectric sensor to adapt to the
size of the object. The line following guidance system is designed for free movement
of the bot without any interference. The precise measurement of the centre of the
bot to the corner of the columns is kept in mind while marking the path. The gripper
is flexible with its gripping length; i.e. it can lift packages of various dimensions.
864 P. S. Nair et al.
Linear ball screw is used for moving the movable arm of the gripper. Figures 2 and
3 show the standby and fully extended position of the arm, respectively. The robotic
arm consists of 5 DOF, which is controlled using electric linear actuators and high
torque DC motors. The arm along with gripper has a lifting capacity of 100 kgs; i.e.
it can lift package weighing up to 100 kg. The AGV components details are tabulated
with specifications in Table 1.
The electric linear actuator proposed in this work is a simple gear and screw
mechanism. The electric motor rotates the main gear connected to the motor shaft
which is connected to the gear which is in turn connected to the screw. The screw
moves up or down depending on the direction of motion of the motor. The robotic
arm consists of three links as shown in Figs. 4 and 5. Link 2 slides over link 1 in order
to extend the overall length of primary link from 500 to 750 mm. Because of this
extendable link, the arm is able to lift objects placed at a height of 1.7 m. The sliding
motion is controlled by a square gear DC motor of torque 30 kgcm and 500 RPM.
The inclination of all the links is controlled by linear actuators of sizes 4 and 8 in.
4 Simulation
Structural analysis of the chassis of the bot is done to ensure that it can handle
the stress while handling maximum load and has enough lifetime before service is
needed. Kinematics is the field of focus while designing the arm. The load acting on
the joints, torque acting on the juncture and the material required to suit the conditions
Design and Analysis of ASRS Using AGV for Rapid Inventory … 865
are calculated. The gripper force directly depends upon the power of the motor used
to move the jaws; keeping this in considerations, the gripper is designed. In order to
check the safety of the components, the components are simulated in the ANSYS
16.0 and the displacements of base and the links are calculated and tabulated in Table
2.
Figure 6 shows the total deformation of base chassis for the payload of 2500 N; the
deformation is found to be 0.000511 m; and it is found to have FOS of 4.8927. Figure 7
shows the total deformation of Link 1 for the payload of 2500 N; the deformation is
found to be 0.000144 m; and it is found to have FOS of 1.9249. Figure 8 shows
866 P. S. Nair et al.
the total deformation of Link 2 for the payload of 2500 N; the deformation is found
to be 0.000144 m; and it is found to have FOS of 4.3403. Figure 9 shows the total
deformation of Link 3 for the payload of 1000 N; the deformation is found to be
0.00028158 m; and it is found to have FOS of 1.9169.
Design and Analysis of ASRS Using AGV for Rapid Inventory … 867
Figure 10 shows the line following sensors implemented in the AGV. The basic
manoeuvrability is found to be perfect, and further, it is preceded with the line
following mechanism. Two IR sensor arrays are placed one behind the other to
follow a straight line. Black tapes are used to mark the line. The operator will be
using a Bluetooth transmitter to send the coordinates to the Bluetooth receiving
868 P. S. Nair et al.
module situated on the AGV. The code will be received by the master Arduino.
The code consists of the coordinates of the rack where the package is placed or
is to be placed. The master Arduino will in turn control 2 other slave Arduinos
which controls both arm and base, respectively. The base controller Arduino will
manage the motor RPM, and the line following mechanism is to guide the bot to
the designated position according to the coordinates received from the operator. The
arm controller Arduino will be hardcoded to reach the hardcoded position of the
package. In Fig. 11, the control system of the AGV is shown. The Bluetooth module
will receive the command from the user which will in turn send the received command
to the master Arduino. According to the system layout, the master Arduino will give
commands to the slave Arduino 1 and slave Arduino 2 which controls the arm and
base of the AGV, respectively. The command received by the slave Arduino 1 will
Design and Analysis of ASRS Using AGV for Rapid Inventory … 869
make the arm position itself in the desired position. The slave Arduino 2 will make
the base of the bot manoeuvre and position itself using the line following algorithm.
The code sent by operator consists of three basic parts. This helps in keeping the
code simple and prevents data skipping by Arduino due to excessive data values. An
example of the code that will be sent to the master Arduino situated on the bot by
the means of Bluetooth is given in Table 3.
The Bluetooth receiver is embedded on the Arduino which is connected to the
transmitter which is in turn controlled by the operator. The code is kept small so
as to prevent data skipping which might occur due to large data values. The master
Arduino is connected to two other slave Arduino which controls the arm and the
1A 3B 2C
870 P. S. Nair et al.
base, respectively. The first two parts of the code are sent to the base slave Arduino.
The part A of the code is used to identify the rack location. The bot understands
the location of the rack, and the motors start to spin following the line. There are
two-line following sensors placed in line. The first sensor is used to implement the
line following mechanism. The second sensor acts as the counter which counts the
junctions. The value of A is being 1, the bot turns in alley 1 and so on. The part B is
used to identify the location of the rack column. This is used in similar method of line
following and counter like in part A to reach the designated location. After reaching
the location, the arm slave Arduino comes into play. The part C is used to identify
the height where the package is placed in the column. The arm will position itself
according to the location of the package. Because the position of the package is placed
according to the strips, the arm could be hardcoded. This enables swift movement
and less complexity. The arms of the gripper are fitted with a piezoelectric sensor
which helps in identifying whether the package is firmly gripped by the gripper or
not. The bot undergoes minimum number of iterations, simplifying the process. The
bot receives the code, goes to the junction, takes a left turn facing the rack, positions
its gripper in accordance with the height and picks up the package. After the package
is firmly gripped, the arm will retrieve back to its original position and the bot returns
back to the retrieval and distribution centre.
Figure 12 depicts the control layout of the Arduinos (4, 5, 6 from left) and motor
drivers (1, 2, 3, 7 from left) and Bluetooth module connected to the master Arduino
(4 from left).
6 Summary
An AGV for rapid inventory storage system is fabricated and tested for industrial
application. Based on the design, structural analysis and experimental results the
following points are summarized,
• The line following sensors (line following) that make the AGV follow a single
path which makes the movement of the AGV much faster than the existing AGVs.
• This AGV can perform pick/place operations up to a height of 6 ft from the ground
using the robotic arm without taking out the whole rack for a single object.
• The AGV is very cost-effective. In general, the market value of an AGV is
approximately 5–10 lakhs. But the total cost of this AGV is around 0.30–0.35
lakh.
• Piezoelectric sensor allows AGV to avoid using visual sensor in assisting bot to
pick up the package, which in turn helps us in reducing the cost.
• As the system is hardcoded, the system follows the written code command and
any decision-making cannot be made by the AGV.
References
10. Farah Hanani MK, Zulkhairi MY, Mohamad Zaihirain MR, MohdAswadi A, Ismail A (2016)
Development of automated storage and retrieval system for flexible manufacturing system. J
Eng Technol 4(1):43–50
11. Cheonga H-W, Leeb H (2018) Requirements of AGV (automated guided vehicle) for SMEs
(small and medium-sized enterprises). Procedia Comput Sci 139:91–94
Optimization Techniques
Multi-response Optimization of Inconel
825 Process Parameters Using LN2
Cooled Zinc-Coated Brass Wire in CNC
Wire-Cut EDM
Midthur A. Salman Khan, C. Nandakumar, B. Mohan,
and R. Senthil Kumar
1 Introduction
response measures along with the orthogonal array design of experiment, to find
the best combination of parameters. Kumari et al. [10], have investigated the extent
of machinability in purview of process performance surface integrity on of Inconel
825 Superalloy by using different tool material and flushing conditions. Moreover,
effects of peak discharge current on EDM responses were also discussed. Aspinwall
et al. [11], have employed Roughing and finishing (multiple trim cut) strategies on
two high specification machines with pulse generators designed to provide minimum
workpiece integrity damage. Results include productivity; 3D topographic maps of
workpiece surfaces, microstructural and microhardness depth profile data. Average
recast thickness was less than 11 µm were achieved. Yildiz and Nalbant [12] have
reviewed the application of coolant in a cutting process which can increase tool life,
dimensional accuracy and decrease cutting temperatures, surface roughness, amount
of power consumed in a metal cutting process using nitrogen, as a cryogenic coolant.
Molinari et al. [13], have studied the effect of deep cryogenic treatment (−196 °C)
on the properties of some tool steels by means of both field tests on real tools and
laboratory tests and concluded that the deep cryogenic treatment on quenched and
tempered high-speed steel tools increases hardness and reduces tool consumption.
Neeraj Sharma et al. [14], have used cryogenic treated high carbon high chromium
tool steel (D-2 tool steel) and investigated the effect of parameters on surface rough-
ness for WEDM. They employed Mathematical modelling of the process is carried
with the help of Response surface methodology (RSM) and the central composite
rotatable design (CCRD) for planning the experiments.
2 Research Methodology
MRR = . . . (1)
For calculating the perimeter of the Spur gear few assumptions are made to make
the calculation simpler and the Fig. 2 shows the gear profile and Fig. 3 shows
the Dedendum triangle reference, Figs. 4 and 5 gives details about the Dedendum
Multi-response Optimization of Inconel 825 Process Parameters … 879
triangle.
Pd = Cd −(L twd × N )
Pd =22.21 mm.
where C d = Dedendum Circumference (π × 20.1).
L twd = Arc length from TWD length.
N = No. of tooth.
TTSL = STSL × N × S
STSL = 3.8118 mm
where h = Gear Tooth Height (3.685 mm)
TSBL = Tooth Side Bottom Length (0.97 mm).
L twd = π d
L twd = 3.411636 mm
Multi-response Optimization of Inconel 825 Process Parameters … 881
The effect of input parameters on the responses is studied by analyzing Taguchi design
in Minitab software. The optimum solutions of the controlled factors were provided
by Signal to noise (S/N) ratios. The highest value of MRR and lowest value of Surface
Roughness are required. The S/N ratios graphs for MRR and Surface Roughness are
shown in Figs. 7 and 8 which show the optimal machining parameters for obtaining
smaller surface roughness and large MRR.
The parameters best level is one which is having the highest value in S/N response
table. The optimal value of MRR is obtained at Wire feed 9 mm/min, Wire tension
1300 g, Pulse on time 9 µs, Pulse off time 7 µs and Servo voltage 6 V. Similarly for
best surface roughness is obtained Wire feed 9 mm/min, Wire tension 1300 g, Pulse
on time 7 µs, Pulse off time 7 µs and Servo voltage 4 V.
Modelling of variables is the relation between input parameters and the responses
are obtained using regression equations. The linear regression equation of the Mate-
rial Removal Rate and Surface Roughness are obtained in Eqs. 2 and 3 which gives the
linear relation between input parameters with its responses. The response obtained
by Eqs. 2 and 3 will give the liner variation of response with inputs. The R2 value
for the linear regression equation of MRR is found to be 98.9% and that of Surface
roughness is found to be 99.2%
The Changes which are obtained because of the input responses in the Material
removal rate are studied.
The effect of Wire tension and Wire feed on MRR is shown as a surface plot in
Fig. 9. It is clearly observed from surface plots that there is an increase in MRR
with an increase in Wire tension and Wire feed. As wire tension of LN2 cooled Zinc-
coated brass wire increases, there is an increase in the stiffness of the wire and wire
becomes hardened due to cryogenic liquid which causes removal of more material.
When Wire feed increases the wire moves faster which leads to less time for the
breakdown between the wire and material hence material removal rate decreases.
3.1.2 Surface Plot of Wire Feed and Pulse On Time Versus MRR
The effect of Wire feed and Pulse on time are shown on surface plot in Fig. 10, in
which it is observed that when pulse on time through the cryogenic cooled zinc-
coated brass wire was increased, the duration of time increases that leads to evenly
distribution of energy over the wire and removes more amount of material from the
surface. This leads to increase in the amount of energy through the wire. Hence, the
MRR increases.
3.1.3 Surface Plot of Wire Feed and Pulse Off Time Versus MRR
Surface Plot of MRR against Wire feed and Pulse off time is shown in Fig. 11.
The figure clearly depicts that the wire feed is prominent than pulse off time. With
increase in Pulse off time, there is an increase in duration for cooling the wire and
the energy passed through the wire will be reduced. This leads to a decrease in MRR.
3.1.4 Surface Plot of Wire Feed and Servo Voltage Versus MRR
The variation in MRR with Wire Feed and Serve voltage is shown in Fig. 12. If Servo
voltage is increased the dielectric will breakdown easily which in turn causes large
energy between the electrodes, i.e. wire and the material, thus MRR increases.
3.1.5 Surface Plot of Wire Tension and Pulse On Time Versus MRR
The variations in MRR with the Wire tension and Pulse on time are shown on surface
plot in Fig. 13. It is observed that MRR increases with the increase of pulse on time
and Wire tension. Highest MRR is observed when Pulse on time is low and Wire
tension is high which indicates that wire tension is more significant compare to Pulse
on time.
3.1.6 Surface Plot of Wire Tension and Pulse Off Time Versus MRR
The variation in MRR with Wire tension and Pulse off time is shown in Fig. 14, which
clearly depicts that the MRR increases with increase in Wire tension and decreases
with an increase in Pulse off time. As wire tension increases the vibrations of the wire
between the upper and lower guide decreases which causes the energy to distribute
evenly, thus MRR increases. When pulse off time increases more delay will be there
in the production of breakdown hence MRR decreases.
3.1.7 Surface Plot of Wire Tension and Servo Voltage Versus MRR
The variation in MRR with wire tension and Servo voltage is shown on surface plot
Fig. 15. It is observed that MRR increases with increase in both wire tension and
Servo voltage. The MRR is highest in Fig. when both servo voltage and wire tension
are highest.
3.1.8 Surface Plot of Pulse On Time and Pulse Off Time Versus MRR
The variation in MRR with Pulse on time and pulse off time is shown in Fig. 16
which clearly depicts that the MRR is high when Pulse on time is Medium and Pulse
off time is less. When Pulse on time increases beyond a certain limit the wire will
break because of short circuit. When Pulse off time is less, the sparks are generated
within short duration of time, and hence MRR is more when Pulse off time is less.
888 M. A. Salman Khan et al.
3.1.9 Surface Plot of Pulse On Time and Servo Voltage Versus MRR
MRR variations with Pulse on time and Pulse off time are shown in surface plot
Fig. 17. The figure clears depicts that the MRR increases with an increase in both
Pulse on time and servo voltage. The variation in MRR with Pulse on time and Servo
voltage is linear. Highest MRR is observed when both Pulse on time and Servo
Voltage are high.
3.1.10 Surface Plot of Pulse Off Time and Servo Voltage Versus MRR
The Surface plot of Pulse off time and Servo voltage on MRR is shown in Fig. 18.
The variation in figure clearly depicts that the highest MRR is obtained when Pulse
Multi-response Optimization of Inconel 825 Process Parameters … 889
off time is less and Servo voltage is more because the delay in time for the generation
of sparks will be less and breakdown occurs faster.
3.2.1 Surface Plot for Ra Against Wire Tension and Wire Feed
The effect of wire tension and Wire feed on surface roughness is shown on surface
plot in Fig. 19. It is observed from the figure that Surface roughness is least when both
wire tension and wire feed are high. When wire tension of cryogenic cooled brass
wire is increased the stiffness of wire increases and vibrations are reduced which
leads to even spark generation from the wire and material is removed evenly from
the surface. When this Stiff wire is fed continuous, i.e. wire feed increases the newer
wire comes in the spark generation are which further helps to remove the material
evenly. Hence, Surface roughness decreases when both Wire tension and Wire feed
are high.
3.2.2 Surface Plot for Ra with Wire Feed and Pulse On Time
The variation in surface roughness against Wire feed and Pulse on time is shown
in Fig. 20. The figure depicts that Surface roughness increases with increase of
both Wire feed and Pulse on time. As Pulse on time increases, the duration for which
energy distortion between wire and workpiece increases which leads to more amount
of material removal from the same surface hence surface roughness increases. When
Wire Feed is increased the break down between newer wire and work piece takes
place continuously, which leads to more amount of energy gets distorted at once.
Thus there is an increase in surface roughness.
3.2.3 Surface Plot for Ra with Wire Tension and Pulse On Time
A surface variation for Ra with Wire tension and Pulse on time is shown in Fig. 21.
It is observed that Surface roughness increases with increase in pulse on time and
decreases with increase in wire tension. When Pulse on time increases, there is
Multi-response Optimization of Inconel 825 Process Parameters … 891
increase in time of spark generation which causes more amount of material getting
eroded from the surface of the work piece. Thus Surface roughness increases with
increase in Pulse on time. When Wire tension is increased there is reduction in
vibrations of the wire which further leads to even distribution of energy between
work piece and the wire, hence surface roughness decreases. It is clearly observed
from the figure the surface roughness is least when Pulse on time is less and wires
tension is high.
3.2.4 Surface Plot for Ra with Wire Tension and Pulse Off Time
The changes in Surface plot for surface roughness with Wire tension and Pulse
off time are shown in Fig. 22. It is observed from the figure that Surface roughness
decreases with increase both Pulse off time and Wire tension, the least surface rough-
ness is obtained when both wire tension and pulse off time are high. When Pulse off
892 M. A. Salman Khan et al.
time is high the duration for wire to get cool increases and increase in the delay in
formation of spark. Thus Surface roughness will decrease.
3.2.5 Surface Plot for Ra with Wire Tension and Servo Voltage
The effects of Wire tension and Servo voltage on Surface Roughness are shown
in Fig. 23. The surface roughness increases with an increase in Servo voltage and
decreases with increase in Wire tension. As Servo voltage increases the amount of
voltage between the wire and work piece increases the breakdown increases which
leads to an increase in energy transfer between the electrodes, which leads to increase
in surface roughness. The least value of surface roughness is observed in the figure
when wire tension is high and servo voltage is less.
3.2.6 Surface Plot of Ra with Pulse On Time and Pulse Off Time
The variations in surface plot of Ra with Pulse on time and Pulse off time is shown
in Fig. 24. The figure depicts that surface roughness decreases with increase in Pulse
off time and increases with increase in Pulse on time. The least surface roughness in
the figure is obtained when Pulse off time is high and Pulse on time is low.
The Surface plot of surface roughness with pulse on time and servo voltage is shown
in Fig. 25. The figures clearly indicate the surface roughness increases with increase
in both servo voltage and pulse on time. The highest value of the surface plot is
obtained when both servo voltage and pulse on time are high.
3.2.8 Surface Plot of Ra with Pulse Off Time and Servo Voltage
The variation in the surface roughness with Pulse off time and Servo voltage is
shown in Fig. 26. When Servo voltage increases there will be an increase in Surface
roughness and when Pulse off time increases the surface roughness will be decreased.
The least value in surface plot is obtained when servo voltage is less and Pulse off
time is high.
4 Surface Analysis
To study the surface Scanning Electron Microscopic images are taken for the highest
MRR and the lowest Surface roughness experimental specimens.
From Fig. 27 it is observed that for high MRR the surface has damaged more.
There are few cracks, debris and globules are observed. The debris is formed when
molten material of the work piece is not flushed properly and gets re-solidifies on the
surface of the workpiece. In Fig. 27, it is observed that more debris is formed because
the molten material during machining gets re-solidifies quickly due to decreases in the
temperature of dielectric as it is in contact with cryogenic cooled wire. Globules are
formed when the material which gets evaporated from the surface of the workpiece
falls back on to the surface during flushing. Due to the difference in the impact of
pulse discharge energy the craters are formed on the work piece.
Multi-response Optimization of Inconel 825 Process Parameters … 895
From Fig. 28, it is observed that better surface is observed. There are less amount
globules and craters are observed. Surface roughness is improved as the as less energy
is discharged during this experiment which causes less material to discharge and less
molten material gets accumulated and fewer globules are formed.
5 Conclusions
• Least Surface Roughness of 2.15 µm is observed when input parameters are Wire
Feed (WF)–8 mm/min, Wire Tension (WT)–1300 g, Pulse on time (T on )–7 µs,
Pulse off time (T off )–7 µs and Servo Voltage (S v )–4 v.
• Wire Tension, Pulse on time and Servo voltage are the most significant factors for
MRR.
• Wire tension, Pulse off time and Wire Feed are the most significant factors for
surface roughness.
• The Mathematical modelling for both MRR and Surface Roughness is found to
be in good agreement with the experimental values.
References
1. Singh T, Misra JP, Singh B (2017) Empirical modelling of wear ratio during WEDM of nimonic
263. Mater Today 5(11):23612–23618
2. Majumder H, Maity K (2018) Prediction and optimization of surface roughness and micro-
hardness using grnn and MOORA-fuzzy-a MCDM approach for nitinol in WEDM. Measure-
ment 118(1):1–13
3. Ajay BT, Mayur Vitthal P, Rajyalakshmi G (2017) WEDM machining on aerospace Materials
for improving material properties. Mater Today: Proc 4(8):9107–9116
4. Singh A, Kumar S (2015) Surface roughness and microhardness evaluation for EDM with
Cu–Mn powder metallurgy tool. Mater Manuf Process 31(4):514–521
5. Dilip Jerold B, Pradeep Kumar M (2013) The Influence of cryogenic coolants in machining of
Ti–6Al–4V. J Manuf Sci Eng 135(3):1–8
6. Singh N, Kumar P, Goyal K (2013) Effect of two different cryogenic treated wires in wire
electrical discharge machining of AISI D3 DIE steel. J Mech Eng 43(2):54–60
7. Kumar P, Bhushan B, Gupta RK (2013) Response of wire electrical discharge machining for
H13 using Taguchi L 9 array. Int J Eng Res Appl 3(5):907–912
8. Patil NG, Brahmankar PK (2009) Some studies into wire electro-discharge machining
of alumina particulate-reinforced aluminum matrix composites. Int J Adv Manuf Technol
48(5–8):537–555
9. Rajyalakshmi G, Venkata Ramaiah P (2013) Multiple process parameter optimization of wire
electrical discharge machining on Inconel 825 using Taguchi grey relational analysis. Int J Adv
Manuf Technol 69(5–8):1249–1262
10. Kumari S, Datta S, Masanta M, Nandi G, Pal PK (2018) Electro-discharge machining of Inconel
825 super alloy: effects of tool material and dielectric flushing. Silicon 10(5):2079–2099
11. Aspinwall DK, Soo SL, Berrisford AE, Walder G (2008) Workpiece surface roughness and
integrity after WEDM of Ti–6Al–4V and Inconel 718 using minimum damage generator
technology. CIRP Ann—Manuf Technol 57(1):187–190
12. Yildiz Y, Nalbant M (2008) A review of cryogenic cooling in machining processes. Int J Mach
Tools Manuf 48(9):947–964
13. Molinari A, Pellizzari M, Gialanella S, Straffelini G, Stiasny KH (2001) Effect of deep
cryogenic treatment on the mechanical properties of tool steels. J Mater Process Technol
118(1–3):350–355
14. Sharma N, Singh A, Sharma R, Deepak (2014) Modelling the WEDM process parameters for
cryogenic treated D-2 tool steel by integrated RSM and GA. Procedia Eng 97(1):1609–1617
Optimization of Process Parameters
During EDM on Inconel Alloy 625
K. Jayakumar
Keywords Inconel alloy 625 · EDM studies · Material removal rate · Surface
roughness
K. Jayakumar (B)
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Sri Sivasubramaniya Nadar College of Engineering,
Kalavakkam, Chennai 603110, India
e-mail: kjayakumar@ssn.edu.in
1 Introduction
Inconel 625 is a nickel-based superalloy that has high strength and resistance to ele-
vated temperatures, corrosion and oxidation. Its capability to survive high stress and
a wide range of temperatures, both in and out of the water, makes it a fitting best for
nuclear and marine uses. Originally Inconel 625 was developed in the 1960s for the
use of making material for steam-line piping. Later, some modifications were made
to be for more creep-resistant and weldable. Because of this, the uses of Inconel
625 has expanded into the chemical processing industry, marine, and nuclear appli-
cations. However, the same properties pose a great challenge during their machin-
ing by conventional machining [1]. Non-conventional machining methods with no
direct contact between tool and workpiece would be a better option to machine such
materials. Electric discharge machining (EDM) is one of the most frequently used
non-conventional machining techniques to machine almost any electrically conduc-
tive material into complex and intrinsic shapes. EDM is an electrothermal process
where material removal takes place through the controlled spark erosion. EDM is the
most widely used machining route for Inconel superalloys because of its less setup
cost and excellent accuracy of the machining performance in terms of quality of the
end product. EDM drilling is most widely performed to machine superalloys in the
aerospace industry, gas turbine, and rocket engine [2].
Due to the technological development, researchers have also worked on EDM
of Inconel alloys (Inconel 625). Dhanabalan et al. [3] conducted EDM studies on
Inconel 625 to analyze the effect of input parameters namely peak current, pulse on
time (T on ), and pulse off time (T off ) on the form tolerances and MRR with circular,
square and hexagonal shaped electrodes.
Torres et al. [4] analyzed the effect of EDM parameters on surface roughness
(Ra), MRR and electrode wear (EW) of an Inconel 600 alloy by varying current,
duty cycle, pulse duration and polarity. They found that +ve positive polarity leads
to higher MRR whereas −ve polarity leads to lower Ra values. The same authors [5]
continued the machining of Inconel 600 alloy using copper infiltrated graphite (C–
Cu). They suggested that the use of negative polarity leads to a higher MRR, higher
EW and higher Ra value. Moreover, they found the optimal condition to obtain a
maximum MRR (Material Removal Rate) of 30.49 mm3 /min was: 8 A, 100 µs and
0.6, respectively, for the current intensity, pulse time and duty cycle. Dikshit et al. [6]
recently used EDM for machining rectangular shape in Inconel 625. Experiments
were conducted by varying peak current, pulse on time and pulse off time as per
central composite design. They found optimum process parameter conditions for
maximizing MRR and minimizing Ra value.
From literature, it was found that the effect of EDM process parameter on different
machinability of Inconel alloys was studied but the effect of electrode bottom profile
on the machinability of Inconel 625 is missing and it needs a detailed study. The
present work focused on the effect of EDM process parameter and electrode bottom
profile on Inconel 625 in terms of MRR and surface roughness.
Optimization of Process Parameters During EDM … 899
2 Experimental Details
workpiece in a different orientation and the average of three readings was considered.
Figure 3 shows the arrangement for surface roughness measurement and results of
Ra is listed in Table 1.
Optimization of Process Parameters During EDM … 901
Figure 4 shows the main effect plots of MRR. With an increase of current, voltage
and Ton time, the MRR is increased. As current and voltage increased, the power and
0.12
0.10
15 20 25 50 65 80
Ton (µs) Electrode
0.20
0.18
0.16
0.14
0.12
0.10
20 30 40 Chamfer Fillet Flat
number of sparks produced were increased this improved the MRR. When the Ton
increased, MRR increased at the start but later decreased with further raise in Ton.
It is the result of an additional reduction on the gap between the work and electrode
developing an electrical short circuit instead of spark which reduced the MRR.
MRR obtained from the study for an electrode with chamfer and the flat electrode is
low compared with the fillet profile of the electrode. The reason is that the fillet profile
has more front curvature surface area than the other two profiles which increased
the spark discharges per unit area of the electrode and hence improved the MRR.
Also, for the same EDM process parameters, the density of the electric discharges is
high; faster separation of the metal from the workpiece and effective flushing of the
molten metal happened with fillet profile than chamfer and flat profile [7].
11
10
9
Surface roughness (µm)
8
7
6
15 20 25 50 65 80
Ton (µs) Electrode
11
10
9
8
7
6
over a longer period, leading to larger and deeper craters which increased the surface
roughness value [8, 9].
Amount of spark discharged from the electrode bottom is decreased from chamfer
to fillet and flat profile, i.e. amount of spark discharged from fillet bottom profile is
more than chamfer and flat profile, which created the melting boundary as deeper and
wider cavities and increased the roughness from 5.471 to maximum of 11.910 µm.
From the experimental runs, experiment number 8 with fillet bottom profile can be
considered as the optimum condition for better MRR and lower surface roughness.
Design Expert software’s optimization module was used for finding optimum
parameter combination. From that, it was found that the process parameter combina-
tion of current-15 A, voltage-55 V, Ton 40 µs with flat bottom profile electrode was
found as the overall optimum parameter for getting maximum MRR of 0.21 g/min
and minimum surface roughness value of 6.34 µm with the highest desirability of
0.93.
4 Conclusions
In this present study, the influence of EDM parameters on Inconel alloy 625 has been
carried out with a copper electrode using three different bottom profiles. The results
showed that, for MRR and surface roughness, Ton and current were identified as the
most influencing factor.
For getting low surface roughness value, an electrode with a flat profile is recom-
mended than the other two profiles and for high MRR; electrode with fillet profile is
suggested.
Application of Design Expert software has determined the optimal setting of
process parameters for concurrently attaining multi-response features (high MRR
and low Ra value) in relation to the overall EDM performance.
References
5. Salcedo AT, Arbizu IP, Pérez CJL (2017) Analytical modelling of energy density and
optimization of the EDM machining parameters of Inconel 600. Metals 166(7):1–21
6. Dikshit MK, Anand J, Narayan D, Jindal S (2019) Machining characteristics and optimization
of process parameters in die-sinking EDM of Inconel 625. J Braz Soc Mech Sci Eng 302:1–14
7. Manohar M, Selvaraj T, Sivakumar D, Gopinath S, George KM (2014) Experimental study
to assess the effect of Electrode bottom profiles while machining Inconel 718 through EDM
process. Procedia Mater Sci 6:92–104
8. S Ahmad, M A Lajis (2013) Electrical discharge machining (EDM) of Inconel 718 by using
copper electrode at higher peak current and pulse duration. IOP Conf Ser: Mater Sci Eng 50:1–7
9. Goyal A, Pandey A, Sharma P (2017) Machinability of Inconel 625 aerospace material using
cryogenically treated WEDM. Solid State Phenom 266:38–42
Optimization of Laser Trepanning
Parameters for Mild Steel by Taguchi
Response Surface Methodology (T-RSM)
Abstract Laser trepanning plays a vital role in the machining of holes as it needs
to eliminate material only from a thin annular region, not the entire circle. The key
benefits of trepanning are material saving and less energy consumption. In this study,
responses from laser trepanning on mild steel were taken for optimization. Responses
like hole-top circularity (HTC), hole-bottom circularity (HBC) and hole taper (HT)
were recorded according to the variations made in the parameters such as laser power,
gas pressure, speed of spot movement and pulsing frequency as per Taguchi’s L 27
orthogonal array. To optimize the operating parameters, Taguchi–response surface
methodology (T-RSM) was applied. Three-dimensional response surface graphs and
ramp function graph for desirability were plotted for the obtained results. Optimal
level of parameters obtained was laser power-2716.83 W, gas pressure-7 bar, speed of
spot movement-1200 mm/s, pulsing frequency-2000 Hz and trepanning hole-20 mm.
1 Introduction
Laser-induced material removal is getting wide attention for precision hole drilling
on difficult to cut superior alloys [1]. The laser drilling is categorized into two types:
trepan drilling and percussion drilling. Laser trepan drilling is more popular than
percussion drilling, and it involves trimming around the boundary of the hole to be
generated [2]. Laser trepanning provides better dimensional accuracy [3]. The major
advantage of laser trepan drilling is its less energy consumption for producing hole
with least material wastage [4].
The statistical relationship between the factors and responses in an experiment can
be determined using various optimization tools. The Taguchi DOE is a reliable and
effective method for evaluating several design parameters by reducing the number
of experiments [5]. Avanish Kumar Dubey et al. made robust design using Taguchi
Orthogonal array and performed multi-objective optimization of laser beam cutting
parameters on aluminium alloy sheet using ANOVA [6]. Response surface methodol-
ogy (RSM) is an emerging optimization tool to characterize the process performance.
Murthy B. R. N. et al. integrated Taguchi and response surface methodology to set
optimum combination of process parameters for drilling of GFRP [7]. Sivaraos et al.
by applying Taguchi and RSM methods compared the CO2 laser machining on PVC
foam by considering the parameters such as cutting speed, laser power, frequency,
duty cycle, gas pressure on kerf width. They concluded that both the techniques
predicted near values of average errors and RSM produced promising results over
Taguchi method [8]. R. Adalarasan et al. studied the effect of CO2 laser cutting
parameters on surface roughness and kerf width of AA 6061/Al2 O3 composite using
L 27 orthogonal array. Desirability analysis was generated by RSM and to obtain opti-
mum setting of laser cutting parameters [9]. Rupesh Goyal et al. applied RSM to find
the optimum parameters setting of laser trepan drilling (LTD) to improve the hole
circularity and hole taper on superalloy sheets. They considered pulse width, pulse
frequency, gas pressure and trepanning speed as the input parameters, more circular
hole due to increased peak power for better penetration and higher pulse width and
lower gas pressure reduced the hole taper [10].
From the literature review, not much work has been reported on the optimiza-
tion of laser trepanning parameters on mild steel using Taguchi–response surface
methodology (T-RSM) method. Therefore, in the present work, optimization of
laser trepanning parameters for optimizing the responses such as hole-top circularity,
hole-bottom circularity and hole taper on mild steel is carried out by T-RSM.
Mild steel is soft, and hence, it can be machined easily. In this work, a mild steel
plate thickens 10 mm was used for laser trepanning. The non-uniformity in melting of
work material, incomplete ejection melt, improper penetration, etc., affect the laser
trepan hole quality characteristics. Hole quality characteristics of laser trepanning
depend on hole circularity on top/bottom and hole taper. The uneven surface in hole
diameter at top and bottom is known as hole taper. The responses such as hole top
circularity (HTC) and hole bottom circularity (HBC) and hole taper (HT) can be
calculated by Eqs. (1–3).
Taguchi DOE as a robust statistical design is used for the optimization of process
parameters. Laser trepanning on mild steel was performed as per the structured
Taguchi’s L 27 orthogonal array with 5 factors and 3 levels as shown in Table 1.
The S/N ratio and ANOVA are applied to study the contribution of input param-
eters in various processes. Taguchi transforms the objective function rate into S/N
ratio of mean standard deviation. It is essential to minimize the responses such as
HBC, HTC, HT always. Therefore, “smaller is better” (Eq. 4) for S/N ratio was con-
sidered for this experiment. P-values of individual input process parameters were
obtained by ANOVA using design expert software.
S/N = −10 ∗ log (Y 2 )/n (4)
Laser trepanning on mild steel was performed successfully at the defined level of
parameters, and the corresponding responses obtained are shown in Table 2.
908 A. Gnanavelbabu et al.
The ANOVA for hole top circularity is given in Table 3. The model F-value 6.93
implies the model which is significant (S). P-values less than 0.050 indicate signifi-
cant models at 95% of confidence level. In this case, B, D, E, AC, BE are significant
model terms. The obtained values for the HTC from ANOVA were S.D = 0.001715,
mean = 0.993322, R2 = 0.890, Adj. R2 = 0.762, pred. R2 = 0.459.
The ANOVA for hole bottom circularity is given in Table 4. The model F-value
3.354 implies that the model is significant at 95% of confidence level. In this case, E,
Optimization of Laser Trepanning Parameters for Mild Steel … 909
BC, A2 are significant model terms. The obtained values for the HBC from ANOVA
were S.D = 0.002996, Mean = 0.987989, R2 = 0.796, Adj. R2 = 0.559, pred. R2 =
−0.062.
The ANOVA for hole taper is given in Table 5. The model F-value of 55.57
implies that the model is significant and significant model terms are A, B, C, D, E,
AB, AE, BE. The corresponding values were S.D = 0.001248, Mean = 0.257444,
R2 = 0.984809, Adj. R2 = 0.967087, pred. R2 = 0.905739.
a b
a b
a b
Figure 1a shows laser power (X-axis), gas pressure (Y-axis), and HTC (Z-axis).
It inferred from the graph that higher the laser power and higher the gas pressure,
minimizes the HTC value (0.9781). When laser power is maximum and gas pressure
is minimum, and HTC is maximum. Figure 1b shows laser power, speed of spot
movement and HTC are on X-, Y-, Z-axes, respectively. At higher speed on spot
movement and higher laser power, a minimal optimal value 0.9781 is achieved.
Hence, higher the laser power and higher speed on spot movement and minimized
the HTC.
Figure 2a represents laser power, gas pressure and HBC on X-, Y-, Z-axes, respec-
tively. The minimum HBC value 0.9772 was obtained at higher gas pressure and
nominal laser power. The maximum HBC values are obtained at the lower level of
gas pressure and laser power. Figure 2b represents gas pressure at X-axis, speed of
spot movement at Y-axis and HBC at Z-axis. An increase in speed of spot movement
and increase in gas pressure resulted in a minimum HBC.
Figure 3a represents X-axis laser power, Y-axis gas pressure and Z-axis hole taper.
At higher laser power and higher gas pressure, the hole taper was minimum. Maxi-
mum HT obtained at higher laser power and lower gas pressure. Figure 3b represents
gas pressure, trepanning hole and taper hole at X-, Y-, Z-axes, respectively. Hole
taper was reduced significantly at high gas pressure and low trepanning hole. Lower
trepanning value minimizes the hole taper.
Ramp function graph for desirability is shown in Fig. 4. The desirability value
obtained is 0.992. It proves a higher closeness interval between the target data and
the responses.
4 Conclusion
• Laser trepanning on mild steel plate was successfully carried out as per Taguchi’s
L 27 orthogonal array, and the parameters were optimized using response surface
methodology.
• Optimal combination of parameters obtained through RSM was laser power-
2716.83 W, gas pressure-7 bar, speed of spot movement-1200 mm/s, pulsing
frequency-2000 Hz and trepanning hole 20 mm.
• The ramp graph indicates a desirability value of 0.992 proving a higher degree of
closeness between the target data and the responses.
References
Abstract This paper presents a smart crack detection system using genetic algorithm
(GA) for a cantilever beam. The accuracy of prediction is optimized by performing
parametric optimization of the first three natural frequencies. The three modes of
natural frequencies are obtained from the experimental procedures and are optimized
to reduce the percentage of error in predicting the relative crack position and crack
depth from a fixed position. Comparison of analytical method is in agreement with
the experimental values as the error percent between the experimental and predicted
values is below 10%.
1 Introduction
Cracks generated in structural and engineering parts lead to their failure, and these
cracks influence the vibration characteristics of the machines. The occurrence of
crack in a machine accounts for decline in natural frequencies, and crack length rises
as the amplitude of vibration increases. This concerned issue has been addressed by
many researchers around the globe, and many methodologies have been suggested
by them.
Mahfouz and Banerjee [1] introduced cracks of diverse lengths at three different
sites along a cantilever steel beam, which was exposed to various amplitudes and
frequencies by the usage of an electromagnetic shaker. The crack length and crack
propagation data have been linked with statistical moments, frequency spectra, and
wavelet coefficient data. Khatir et al. [2] used experimentally determined natural
frequencies along with the particle swarm optimization (PSO) technique to detect
an open crack on a cantilever beam made up of steel. Genetic algorithm (GA) is
an optimization method which is bio-inspired, and it supports the ideas of natural
genetics and selection theories as proposed by Charles Darwin. It was developed at
the University of Michigan by John Holland and his co-workers. It provides robust
search in complex spaces [3]. GA is widely used in the field of engineering and
manufacturing. Pathan et al. [4] successfully built up a real-coded constrained GA
along with finite element (FE) method for optimizing the damping action of a unidi-
rectional composite laminate. Pajand and Tavakoli [5] pioneered a proficient process
for detecting cracks in concrete gravity dams using GA and finite element modeling
(FEM). It was found that this hybrid method could predict accurately and quickly
the displacement values in concrete gravity dam analysis.
Pawar and Ganguli [6] used genetic fuzzy approach to determine the location
of damage in cantilever beam and helicopter rotor pads. They used FEM to find
out the variation in beam frequencies due to structural damage. A fuzzy model was
developed and its rule-base, as well as membership functions, was optimized by GA
so that there was an automatic rule generation. The adopted method proved effective
in identifying the structural damage in both the beam and pads. Wang and Chen [7]
applied GA to choose optimal support location of beams with three different boundary
conditions. They considered both elastic and rigid supports, and it was found that
GA’s performance was better as compared to other optimization tools. Cho [8] used
GA to optimize the design of a composite cylindrical shell which is most prone to
buckling and failure on application of axial load, torsional load, or both. It was found
that the GA optimized shell design possessed better mechanical properties as regards
to conventional ones. Lin and Lee [9] applied GA along with regression analysis to
optimize the stacking sequence of laminated composite structures. Khatir et al. [10]
proposed a methodology using GA and firefly algorithm (FA) to identify the location
of damage in simple and continuous beams and two-dimensional frame structure.
The current analysis includes an experimental investigation of obtaining the three
modes of natural frequencies, e.g. first natural frequency (fnf ), second natural fre-
quency (snf ), and third natural frequency (tnf ), at different relative crack length
(RCL) and relative crack depth (RCD) values. These experimental data are used
further to develop a GA controller that can be used to predict the RCL and RCD.
Comparison between the experimental and predicted values indicates a minimal
percentage of error, and thus, the controller is acceptable. This will be helpful to pre-
dict the defects present in beam in the form of crack, without any experimentation,
thus minimizing the cost of experiment. The current analysis focuses on the health
monitoring of beam structural element for their safe functioning.
Parametric Optimization of Cracked Cantilever Beam Using … 917
2 Experimental Procedure
A cantilever beam with single crack was used for the experimentation. The relative
crack positions from the fixed end were varied at an interval of every 100 mm, and
the three modal frequencies were recorded. The results obtained in the experimen-
tation were further used as the input training data for the GA controller. The GA
controller was able to predict the RCL and RCD from the input of the three modal
frequencies. Number of experimental tests has been carried out on an 800 mm long
aluminium cantilever beam having a cross section of 50 mm width and 6 mm thick-
ness. Complete experimental setup is shown in Fig. 1. The three modes of natural
frequencies recorded during the experimentation for different RCL and RCD are
enlisted in Table 1.
3 Genetic Algorithm
Table 1 Three relative natural frequencies at different RCL and RCD from experimentation
Sl. No. Inputs Outputs
Relative 1st Relative 2nd Relative 3rd Relative crack Relative crack
natural natural natural length (RCL) depth (RCD)
frequency Frequency Frequency
“fnf” (A) “snf” (B) “tnf” (C)
1 0.9848 0.9958 0.9974 0.205 0.073
2 0.9673 0.9874 0.9942 0.43 0.084
3 0.9624 0.9948 0.9982 0.568 0.158
4 0.9689 0.9921 0.9948 0.4317 0.2774
5 0.9755 0.9976 0.9972 0.391 0.188
6 0.9655 0.9837 0.9961 0.3952 0.279
7 0.9785 0.9993 0.9987 0.387 0.189
8 0.9732 0.9916 0.9963 0.3772 0.1486
9 0.9852 0.9984 0.9967 0.23 0.24
10 0.9859 0.9989 0.9974 0.236 0.248
11 0.9724 0.9961 0.9817 0.545 0.287
12 0.9755 0.9869 0.9936 0.4827 0.2585
13 0.9824 0.9872 0.9917 0.447 0.406
14 0.981 0.9809 0.9932 0.495 0.424
15 0.9842 0.9926 0.9948 0.2345 0.2017
16 0.9834 0.9685 0.9974 0.535 0.534
17 0.9689 0.9921 0.9948 0.4317 0.2774
The regression equations for the selected responses, as given by Eqs. (2–3), are
further used as fitness function for process optimization using GA.
where y1 and y2 are responses RCL and RCD; x 1 , x 2, and x 3 are input parameters A,
B, and C, respectively. The flowchart of the GA process is shown in Fig. 2.
Parametric Optimization of Cracked Cantilever Beam Using … 919
4 Confirmatory Experiments
where E t and Pt are the experimental and predicted values. In Table 2, a comparison
has been made between the experimental and the predicted responses of the cracked
cantilever beam. It is seen that the percentage of error is found to be less than 10% in
all the cases, which shows that GA can be successfully used to forecast the responses
of the cracked cantilever beam.
From the confirmatory experimentation, it was observed that the GA predictions
are well within a limit of 10%, and the model is able to predict the relative crack
length and relative crack depth properly.
5 Conclusions
A genetic algorithm approach for predicting the relative crack position and its depth
is presented in the current analysis. The following conclusions are drawn from the
analysis:
• An aluminium cantilever beam of 800 mm length, 50 mm width, and 6 mm
thickness is taken for the current analysis.
920
Table 2 Assessment of the experimental and predicted responses of the cracked cantilever beam by GA
S. No. Relative 1st natural Relative 2nd natural Relative 3rd natural Experimental Predicted % error
frequency “fnf” frequency “snf” frequency “tnf” values values
A B C RCL RCD RCL RCD RCL RCD
1 0.9850 0.9993 0.9987 0.2532 0.184 0.238 0.180 5.64 2.43
2 0.9757 0.9992 0.9986 0.2971 0.142 0.313 0.147 −5.38 −4.01
3 0.9834 0.9991 0.9986 0.2752 0.075 0.254 0.072 7.66 3.06
4 0.9828 0.9992 0.9986 0.247 0.169 0.257 0.164 −4.29 3.00
5 0.9640 0.9991 0.9986 0.3894 0.112 0.405 0.107 −4.18 4.44
6 0.9852 0.9993 0.9987 0.2447 0.115 0.237 0.119 2.86 −2.93
7 0.9697 0.9993 0.9986 0.3716 0.075 0.360 0.072 3.06 3.44
8 0.9735 0.9992 0.9986 0.3512 0.106 0.330 0.112 5.80 −5.54
9 0.9821 0.9993 0.9987 0.2791 0.163 0.262 0.170 6.12 −4.28
10 0.9786 0.9992 0.9987 0.2773 0.135 0.289 0.130 −4.47 3.91
11 0.9678 0.9992 0.9986 0.3867 0.117 0.375 0.115 2.81 1.69
12 0.9724 0.9992 0.9986 0.3276 0.118 0.339 0.125 −3.63 −5.47
13 0.9774 0.9992 0.9986 0.2885 0.181 0.300 0.176 −4.05 2.97
14 0.9707 0.9992 0.9986 0.3411 0.142 0.353 0.137 −3.48 3.57
15 0.9662 0.9992 0.9986 0.3672 0.151 0.388 0.158 −5.74 −4.61
16 0.9750 0.9993 0.9985 0.3408 0.167 0.319 0.173 6.30 −3.82
17 0.9640 0.9991 0.9986 0.3899 0.104 0.405 0.100 −4.05 3.45
Average % of error 5.86 7.82
M. K. Sutar et al.
Parametric Optimization of Cracked Cantilever Beam Using … 921
• Relative crack locations are intentionally provided in the beam with a variation
of crack depth to obtain the first three relative natural frequencies.
• The data obtained from the experimental procedure is then used as training data
to prepare the GA model to predict the structural health of the cantilever beam by
giving input of the three relative natural frequencies.
• Prediction of the GA model is found to be satisfactory within a limit of 10%.
• The average prediction error for RCL is found to be 5.86%.
• The average prediction error for RCD is found to be 7.82%.
References
1. Mahfouz IA, Banerjee A (2017) Crack detection and identification using vibration signals and
fuzzy clustering. Procedia Comput Sci 114:266–274
2. Khatir S, Dekemele K, Loccufier M, Khatir T, Wahab MA (2018) Crack identification method
in beam-like structures using changes in experimentally measured frequencies and particle
swarm optimization. CR Mec 346(2):110–120
3. Griesbach JD, Etter DM Fitness-based exponential probabilities for genetic algorithms applied
to adaptive IIR filtering, IEEE transactions. In: Thirty-second Asilomar conference on signals,
systems and computers, 1–4 Nov, 1998
4. Pathan MV, Patsias S, Tagariellia VL (2018) A real-coded genetic algorithm for optimizing the
damping response of composite laminates. Comput Struct 198:51–60
5. Pajand MR, Tavakoli FH (2015) Crack detection in concrete gravity dams using a genetic
algorithm. Proc Inst Civ Eng—Struct Build 168(3):192–209
6. Pawar PM, Ganguli R (2003) Genetic fuzzy system for damage detection in beams and
helicopter rotor blades. Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng 192:2031–2057
7. Wang BP, Chen JL (1996) Application of genetic algorithm for the support location optimization
of beams. Comput Struct 58(4):797–800
8. Cho HK (2018) Optimization of laminated composite cylindrical shells to maximize resistance
to buckling and failure when subjected to axial and torsional loads. Int J Precis Eng Manuf
19(1):85–95
9. Lin CC, Lee YJ (2004) Stacking sequence optimization of laminated composite structures
using genetic algorithm with local improvement. Compos Struct 63(1):339–345
10. Khatir A, Tehami M, Khatir S, Abdel WM (2018) Multiple damage detection and localization
in beam-like and complex structures using co-ordinate modal assurance criterion combined
with firefly and genetic algorithms. J Vibro Eng 20(1):832–842
Study of the Influence of Reinforcement
Parameters on Thermal Conductivity
of Magnesium-Based MMCs Through
Taguchi’s Orthogonal Array Approach
1 Introduction
Magnesium and its alloys have found certain specific uses in many industries. The
density of pure magnesium (1.70 g/cm3 ) is just 70% of the density of pure alu-
minum, and this aspect enhances its strength-to-weight ratio. The immediate need
for fuel economy and cost-savings in aerospace and automobile sectors has mandated
increasing uses of magnesium components [1]. Although the mechanical properties
(such as UTS and yield strength) of magnesium alloys are somewhat near to those of
aluminum alloys, their thermal properties (specific heat and thermal conductivity) are
much lower than most other non-ferrous and ferrous alloys. The mechanical proper-
ties of magnesium alloys can be enhanced by incorporating ceramic reinforcements
(to result in MMCs) [2, 3]. But, such reinforcements are likely to lead to adverse
effects on the thermal properties. There is an immediate need to analyze such neg-
ative effects in order to make the Mg alloy MMCs more appropriate for specific
end-users.
The following are the different processing routes that are suitable for processing
Mg alloy-based composites [3]:
1. Stir casting,
2. Squeeze casting, and
3. Powder metallurgy methods.
Of the above, the stir casting method appears to be very popular due to its
simplicity, economy of operation, and applicability even to small casting units [4, 5].
The effect of reinforcement on the properties of composites can be analyzed by
varying the reinforcement parameter levels. Optimum parameter levels can be deter-
mined by adopting statistical methods. Design of experiments (DOE) is a method
for scientifically applying statistics in conducting experimental runs. The analysis
involving experimental trials coupled with a methodically planned design procedure
is helpful to lessen the research effort, financial resources, and facilities. Taguchi
simplified the DOE approach with orthogonal array (OA) that significantly lowers
the number of experimental trials needed. Taguchi’s approach to DOE is easy to
adopt, apply, and analyze. Taguchi’s signal-to-noise ratio (S/N ratio) is invariably
used to analyze and optimize the responses [6]. Analysis of variance (ANOVA) is a
tool used to identify the significance of input parameters and to determine the effect
of each input parameter on the properties of the composites [7].
Magnesium and its alloys exhibit good castability, machinability, formability, and
weldability. In view of this and in the light of the ever-increasing applications of
magnesium components in various industries, an experimental investigation on Mg-
based MMCs was planned, with magnesium as the base material (matrix material)
and soda–lime glass powder as the reinforcement (soda–lime glass powder is an
easily available, inexpensive ceramic material) [8].
Magnesium ingots (of German origin) of purity more than 99.50% were procured
from a standard metal supplier. The certified composition (Table 1) is provided by
the manufacturer along with the supply.
The chemical composition of soda–lime glass is given in Table 2. It is noted that
the composition is cited in the literature (8).
Table 2 Composition of
Elements SiO2 Na2 O CaO
soda–lime glass
Percentage by weight 70–73 12–16 10–15
Magnesium ingots were charged into a graphite crucible covered with Magrex-60
flux and melted in an electric resistance furnace. When the melt reached 700 °C,
which is well above the melting temperature of magnesium, dross was skimmed off
from the surface of the melt after treating with degassing tablet hexachloroethene. The
melt was stirred (using the custom made mechanical stirrer) at a fixed stirring speed
of 400 RPM to form a sufficiently large vortex. Preheated soda–lime glass powder
(varying weight percentages, varying particle sizes and varying preheat temperatures)
was added into the vortex. After adding the particles, the stirring impeller was driven
for some more time till the temperature of the melt dropped to 640 °C. Soon after
this, the melt mixture was poured into the preheated die.
The three levels considered for each reinforcement parameter in the experiments
are shown in Table 3.
For the purpose of experimentation, based on the degrees of freedom for the factor
levels, the minimum number of trials needed (as per total degrees of freedom) is 9.
Taguchi’s L 9 OA was selected suitably. As per the design layout of experimentation,
nine castings were produced.
The principle of comparative cut bar method (ASTM E1225 test method) was adopted
in the thermal conductivity measurement; this is perhaps the most widely used method
for axial thermal conductivity assessment. Cylindrical test specimen of size 8 mm
diameter and 50 mm length was sandwiched between two reference specimens as
shown in Fig. 1. As the test set-up is heated to predetermined temperatures, the
temperatures at different marked spots on the test specimen were measured accu-
rately using the temperature sensors located between the reference specimens and
the test specimen. These were then used to compute the thermal conductivity K of
the specimen under test.
If K R is the thermal conductivity of the reference specimens, the thermal
conductivity of the unknown sample (K S ) can be derived from the following equation:
926 M. R. Shivakumar et al.
Ls (T1 − T2 ) + (T3 + T4 )
Ks = K R × × (1)
LR 2(T2 + T3 )
where “n” is the number of observations and “y” is the observed data.
Thermal conductivity test results and S/N ratios with design layout of experimen-
tation are shown in Table 4. The S/N ratio response values and the range for each
parameter are shown in Table 5.
The plot of the main effect for S/N ratios is shown in Fig. 2.
This plot indicates that among all the factors, weight % (Delta = 1.63) is the most
significant factor affecting the thermal conductivity. The optimal parameter levels
were identified from the main effect plot. The optimum parameter levels are:
Study of the Influence of Reinforcement Parameters on Thermal … 927
A B
43.5
43.0
42.5
Mean of SN ratios
42.0
41.5
1.5 3.0 4.5 75 125 210
C
43.5
43.0
42.5
42.0
41.5
260 380 500
Weight %—1.5%
Particle size—75 µm
Preheat temperature—260 °C.
Confirmation tests were conducted corresponding to the optimum parameter lev-
els, and the results are shown in Table 6. From the results, it is seen that mean thermal
conductivity was maximum at the optimum parameter levels.
5 Conclusions
Acknowledgements The authors wish to thank Prof. S. Seshan, Indian Institute of Science Banga-
lore, for his involvement in this work. Financial support received from Visvesvaraya Technological
University, Belagavi, is gratefully acknowledged.
References
1. Watarai H (2006) Trend of research and development for magnesium alloy. Sci Technol Trends
Q Rev 8
2. Luo A (1995) Processing microstructure, and mechanical behavior of cast magnesium metal
matrix composites. Metall Mater Trans A 26A:2445–2455
3. Koti V, George R, Shakiba A, Shivananda Murthy KV (2018) Mechanical properties of copper
nanotubes reinforced with uncoated and nickel coated carbon nanotubes. FME Trans 46:623–630
4. Shivakumar MR, Naidu NVR (2019) Characterization of mechanical and thermal properties in
soda–lime glass particulate reinforced LM6 alloy composites ICEMMM 2018. In: Advances in
materials and metallurgy. Springer, pp 149–157
5. Madhoo G, Shilpa M (2017) Optimization of process parameters of stir casting technique using
orthogonal arrays. Int J Adv Res Methodol Eng Technol 1(2)
6. Jayalakshmi, S. Kailas V, Seshan S, Fleury E (2006) Tensile strength and fracture toughness of
two magnesium metal matrix composites. J Ceram Process Res 7(3)
7. Taguchi G, Chowdhury S, Wu Y (2003) Taguchi’s quality engineering handbook. Wiley,
Hoboken, NJ
8. Hasanuzzaman M, Rafferty A, Sajjia M, Olabi AG (2016) Reference module in materials science
and materials. Published by Elsevier
Finite Element Modelling
and Optimisation of Sheet Hydroforming
for Cryo-rolled AA5083 Sheets
Keywords Sheet hydroforming · Blank holding force (BHF) · Die corner radius ·
Finite element modelling · RSM
1 Introduction
Forming is one of the most critical manufacturing processes where the material is
deformed and takes the desired shape with improved material strength. Hence, a lot
of research is carried out in this field to improve the process. Deep drawing is one
such forming processes, which uses a die and a punch for forming. The problem with
this kind of conventional forming process is that it deteriorates the surface quality
of the material. Also, the material thickness is non-uniform throughout the formed
surface. To improve this, the punch used in conventional processes is replaced with
hydrostatic fluid pressure. This kind of process is generally known as hydroforming
processes.
Hydroforming can be broadly classified into three: i. shell hydroforming pro-
cesses, ii. tube hydroforming process and iii. sheet hydroforming process [6]. The
current research work focuses on the effect of multiple parameters on a punchless
sheet hydroforming process.
Figure 1 shows a punchless sheet hydroforming set-up. As shown in zone A
(portion under the blank holder) due to tangential compression and radial tensions,
the sheet deforms in deep drawing mode [8]. In zone B, which indicates the die corner
radius, the state of stress is three-dimensional. This is because of the superimposing
of deep drawing and stretch bending components. The central portion of the blank,
i.e. the pole region (zone D), is subjected to uniform hydrostatic pressure due to
which it deforms in stretching mode, which leads to thinning of the blank. Initially,
the region between the die corner radius and the central portion (zone C) is slightly
deformed. During the corner formation, it undergoes additional stretching once the
draw-in is completed.
Blank holding force (BHF) is one of the most critical parameters in the sheet
hydroforming process. A varying BHF can yield better formability in terms of mini-
mum corner radius and lower thinning compared to a constant BHF [8]. Many other
parameters are also studied to improve formability. Varying blank annealing temper-
atures of around 300 °C have given better results for modern lightweight alloys [7,
9, 13]. The annealing temperature is highly dependent on the blank material used for
the process. Other vital parameters that have significant effects on formability are
friction and lubrication between the die and the blank surface. Teflon-coated die has
found to be producing less material thinning during the sheet hydroforming process
[3].
In recent years, there has been a tremendous demand for the need for lightweight
and high-strength alloys in the automotive and aerospace industries. Aluminium has
been found as one of the best solutions for this. However, aluminium’s low strength
and formability when compared to carbon steels have restricted its usage. Hence,
cryo-rolled Al alloy sheets that display relatively higher strength due to its ultra-
fine grain structure have occupied the space [4]. Annealing is found to enhance the
formability of cryo-rolled sheets. Cryo-rolling followed by hydroforming has a very
high potential to produce parts having complex shapes with lighter weight and high
strength [9, 11].
In the present work, the experimental results obtained in the literature by Modi
and Ravi Kumar [8] are first replicated using finite element modelling (FEM). The
research is further extended by replacing the current blank material AA5182 using
cryo-rolled AA5083. The effect of varying BHF, at varying annealing temperatures
along with a variable frictional coefficient, is also studied. This work also investigates
the optimisation of the process using a well-established design of experiments (DOE)
technique—response surface methodology (RSM) [14, 15].
2 Methodology
150 to 300 °C is considered, and their effects on output parameters like thickness
reduction and corner radius are investigated [13].
The first part of this work is focused on validating the developed model. The influence
of input process parameters like fluid pressure, BHF, friction at the bottom portion
of blank and die, etc., on output parameters like corner radius and material thickness
is investigated. Table 3 shows the comparison of output parameters obtained under
two conditions, i.e. constant BHF and varying BHF. Comparing experimental (from
journal paper) and simulation results, the percentage of difference in the case of
constant BHF for maximum thickness reduction is 3.7 and for variable BHF is 5.95.
For a minimum corner radius, the difference is 4.24 and 0.6 for constant BHF and
varying BHF, respectively.
Table 3 Comparison of experimental (from the literature) and FEM results for sheet hydroforming
for AA5182
Pressure BHF load Max. thickness reduction (mm) Min. corner radius (mm)
path in Experimental [8] FE simulation Experimental [8] FE simulation
hydroforming
Constant 0.8 0.77 37.7 36.1
Variable 0.84 0.79 33.4 33.2
938 A. B. Raj et al.
Fig. 9 Von Mises stress measured immediately after deformation in case of varying BHF
Figure 8 shows the forming diagram. Von Mises stress distribution in the material
after the hydroforming process is analysed, and it is found that higher stress con-
centration is at the bottom corners and along with the diagonally opposite faces of
the blank. The instantaneous stress distribution for the blank when the fluid pressure
and BHF (variable and constant BHF) are applied is shown in Fig. 9. Spring-back
behaviour of the deformed blank is analysed, and percentage relaxation in case of
hydroforming using constant BHF technique is 38.3% and that in case of variable
BHF technique is 32.52%. Thus, the spring-back effect is less in case of hydroform-
ing using variable BHF technique. Hence, better results are achieved with variable
BHF technique when compared to the constant blank holding force (BHF) technique.
The deformed shape obtained from the model is almost in agreement with the journal
paper.
Further, the work is extended by replacing the blank material with cryo-rolled
AA5083. Simulations are carried out with varying coefficient friction and varying
blank annealing temperature. Optimisation of output parameters is carried out using
response surface methodology (RSM), and ANOVA table is generated. Figure 10
shows the main effect plot for maximum thickness reduction, and Fig. 11 shows
the main effect plot for a minimum corner radius. In both cases, the coefficient
Finite Element Modeling and Optimization of Sheet Hydroforming … 939
of friction and annealing temperature are reflected. The trend displays that, as the
coefficient of friction increases from 0.04 to 0.25, the maximum thickness reduction
is decreasing and the minimum corner radius is increasing until 0.145. Similarly,
annealing temperature increases from 150 to 300 °C, maximum thickness reduction
is falling, and the minimum corner radius is rising.
Three-dimensional surface plot for minimum corner radius versus annealing tem-
perature and coefficient of friction is shown in Fig. 12. Minimum corner radius is
achieved with an increase in the coefficient of friction and with a rise in anneal-
ing temperature. Surface plot for maximum thickness reduction versus annealing
temperature and coefficient of friction is displayed in Fig. 13.
The trend indicates that maximum thickness reduction is obtained by an increase
in both the coefficient of friction and annealing temperature. The optimal value for
the coefficient of friction is 0.25 and for blank annealing temperature is 155 °C.
Simulations are carried out using the optimum value, which is illustrated in Table 4.
The percentage of difference is around 3.5% only.
4 Conclusion
A detailed finite element model for the punchless hydroforming process is devel-
oped and is validated with the available literature. The work is further extended by
changing the blank material from AA5182 to cryo-rolled AA5083 considering the
extent of applications. Cryo-rolling followed by hydroforming has better potential to
provide complex sheet metal parts using lightweight, high-strength aluminium alloy
sheets. The effect of input parameters like the coefficient of friction and annealing
temperatures for blank is studied, with varying BHF, on output parameters like min-
imum corner radius and maximum thickness reduction. It has been observed that
minimum corner radius and lower thinning are achieved in the case of variable BHF
technique than in the case of constant BHF. It indicates that the variable BHF tech-
nique is superior in forming complex sheet metal parts in sheet hydroforming. The
optimisation studies show an optimum value of 0.25 for the coefficient of friction
and annealing temperature; it is 155 °C.
References
8. Modi B, Ravi Kumar D (2013) Development of a hydroforming setup for deep drawing of square
cups with variable blank holding force technique. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 66:1159–1169
9. Raja Satish D, Feyissa FT et al (2018) Formability of cryorolled aluminum alloy sheets in
warm forming. Int J Mater, Mech Manuf, 6(2):123–126
10. Ramesh A, Sumesh CS, Abhilash PM, Rakesh S (2015) Finite element modeling of orthogonal
machining of hard to machine materials. Int J Mach Machinability Mater 17:543–568
11. Rao PN, Singh D, Jayaganthan R (2013) Effect of annealing on microstructure and mechanical
properties of Al 6061 alloy processed by cryorolling. Mater Sci Technol 29(1):76–82
12. Sumesh CS, Ramesh A (2018) Numerical modelling and optimization of dry orthogonal turning
of Al6061 T6 alloy. Period Polytech Mech Eng 62(3):196–202
13. Taye F, Das P, Ravi Kumar D, Ravi Sankar B (2014) Characterization of mechanical properties
and formability of cryorolled aluminium alloy sheets. In: 5th International and 26th All India
manufacturing technology, design and research conference (AIMTDR), pp 511.6–511.11
14. Wang L, Chan LC, Lee TC (2007) Process modelling of controlled forming with time variant
blank holder force using RSM method. Int J Mach Tools Manuf 47:1929–1940
15. Zhu X, Liu D, Yang Y, Hu Y, Zheng Y (2016) Optimization on cooperative feed strategy
for radial-axial ring rolling process of Inco718 alloy by RSM and FEM. Chin Soc Aeronaut
Astronaut Beihang Univ 29(3):831–842
Selection of Parameterization Method
for Fitting of Freeform Curves Using
Uniformly Spaced Data
G. Rajamohan
1 Introduction
Reverse engineering is carried out to transform the engineering objects, for which the
original part drawings are not available, into computer-aided design (CAD) models
in order to improve their design, manufacture and analysis. In reverse engineering,
the data points from the desired engineering objects are acquired using appropriate
measuring devices, such as 3D scanners. The data points are acquired in Cartesian
space, whereas the CAD models are created in parametric space. The mapping of
data points from Cartesian space to parametric space is known as parameterization.
The accuracy of fitted CAD model depends on adequate parameterization.
G. Rajamohan (B)
National Institute of Foundry and Forge Technology, Ranchi 834003, India
e-mail: grajamohan.nifft@gov.in
2 Literature Review
The problem of fitting of freeform curves (and surfaces) to measured point clouds has
been the subject of research for many years. The existing parameterization methods
can be broadly categorized into conventional (single-step) methods, and evolutionary
and nature-inspired algorithms (optimization-based).
The literature reveals various conventional parameterization methods, such as
uniform, chord length, centripetal, etc. A summary of pros and cons of different
parameterization methods can be found in [1]. These parameterization methods work
fairly well with uniformly spaced data points. The literature also reveals that no
single parameterization method is capable of handling all types of data points (e.g.,
collinear data points). While most of the reported research is focused on open curves
and surfaces, few works based on closed curves and surfaces have been reported [2].
The conventional parameterization methods may not lead to optimal allocation
of parameters for data points with nonuniform spacing. This has led the researchers
to focus on developing algorithms based on some soft-computing techniques, such
as the evolutionary and nature-inspired algorithms. The algorithms reported in this
direction are based on artificial neural networks [3–7], genetic algorithms [8–14],
swarm intelligence [15–18], etc.
The chord length and centripetal parameterization methods are generally adequate
for most practical purposes [19]. The objective of this work is to develop and vali-
date an approach to choose between chord length and centripetal parameterization
methods in order to fit more accurate freeform curves for the given set of measured
data points. The B-splines have been used to represent the freeform curves.
The chord length parameterization method uses the chordal approximation for curves.
Let d be the total chord length, computed using Eq. (1).
N
d= |Q i − Q i−1 | (1)
i=1
|Q i − Q i−1 |
ū 0 = 0; ū N = 1; ū i = ū i−1 + , i = 1, . . . , (N − 1) (2)
d
where, Qi (i = 0,...,N) are the data points. This parameterization method is widely
used and is generally considered adequate.
N
d= |Q i − Q i−1 | (3)
i=1
4 Proposed Approach
The chord lengths and discrete curvatures are used in the proposed approach to
select between the chord length and centripetal parameterization methods. The chord
length is the distance between two adjacent measured points and is computed using
the distance formulae. The discrete curvatures are calculated at all measured points
using the algorithm described in the subsection below. The calculated chord lengths
946 G. Rajamohan
and discrete curvatures are normalized in the range [0, 1], and standard deviations are
calculated. The attribute, i.e., the chord length or discrete curvature, having higher
standard deviation is used to select the most suitable parameterization method. In
case of chord length, the chord length parameterization is selected, and in case of
discrete curvature, the centripetal parameterization method is selected.
Qi αi
Li Li+1
O
R
2π-2αi Qi+1
Si
Qi-1
(a)
QN+
Q1
Q0 Q2
QN-1 QN
QN-2
-
Q0
(b)
Fig. 1 Estimation of discrete curvature; a curvature of a polygon; b additional point supplement
for two end points
Selection of Parameterization Method for Fitting of Freeform … 947
The accuracy of freeform curves (and surfaces) fitted using the measured data points
depends mainly on parameterization. Among the available conventional parameter-
ization methods, the chord length and centripetal methods are mostly used owing
to their simplicity and ease of implementation. The present work is an attempt to
select between these two methods to fit better freeform curves for given measured
data points and to validate the selection approach. The selection is based on the stan-
dard deviation of discrete curvatures and chord lengths, computed using the given
measured data points. The B-splines representation has been used to represent the
freeform curves. The programs were written in C++ language.
In order to make a comparison between the centripetal and chord length parameter-
ization methods, the measured data points have been selected from known freeform
curves. The curves are first discretized in parametric space with fine spacing of 0.005,
giving 201 points in the range assumed, i.e., [0, 1]. Measured data points have been
taken with uniform spacing between them, as the measuring machines typically gen-
erate such data easily. Three runs have been made with the numbers of measured data
points as 11, 21 and 51. The discrete curvature and chord lengths have been computed
using these data points, and standard deviations of the respective measures have been
computed. The chord length parameterization method is chosen when the standard
deviation of chord length is higher and vice versa.
Both the centripetal and the chord length parameterizations have been imple-
mented in order to validate the selection by using the proposed approach. The mea-
sured data points and the respective parameters were used to fit the freeform curves
of degree 3 using interpolation technique [19]. The normal deviations between the
fitted freeform curves and the corresponding point on the known freeform curves
are then calculated. The maximum normal deviation has been used to compare the
948 G. Rajamohan
Table 2 Normal deviations (mm) for sparse measurement data points size of 21
Example No. Selected method Centripetal parameterization Chord length
parameterization
#1 Chord length 0.000122 0.000087
#2 Centripetal 0.003633 0.008180
#3 Centripetal 0.000687 0.002746
#4 Centripetal 0.039825 0.154892
#5 Centripetal 0.002091 0.003382
#6 Centripetal 0.054421 0.084704
Table 3 Normal deviations (mm) for dense measurement data points size of 51
Example No. Selected method Centripetal parameterization Chord length
parameterization
#1 Chord length 0.000024 0.000022
#2 Centripetal 0.000146 0.000210
#3 Centripetal 0.000033 0.000069
#4 Centripetal 0.000561 0.002775
#5 Centripetal 0.000112 0.000112
#6 Centripetal 0.000587 0.000774
Selection of Parameterization Method for Fitting of Freeform … 949
results with dense points. The examples curves #2, #5 and #6 particularly have
higher curvature variations, while the remaining curves have moderate curvature
variations. Considering this aspect, it appears that the curvature calculation algorithm
yields better values even with smaller numbers of measured points if the variation
in curvature is not severe. With dense measured data points (Tables 2 and 3), the
proposed approach has been able to accurately estimate the suitable parameterization
method in all cases considered. The fitting accuracy also improves significantly. In
most cases, the centripetal method is being suggested as the most suitable method.
This may be because the freeform curves typically have more curvature variations
along their length.
6 Conclusions
References
1. Haron H, Rehman A, Adi DIS, Lim SP, Saba T (2012) Parameterization method on B-spline
curve. Math Prob Eng. https://doi.org/10.1155/2012/640472
2. Park H (2001) Choosing nodes and knots in closed B-spline curve interpolation to point data.
Comput Aided Des 33(13):967–974
3. Bishop CM, Roach CM (1992) Fast curve fitting using neural networks. Rev Sci Instrum
63:4450–4456
950 G. Rajamohan
4. Gu P, Yan X (1995) Neural network approach to the reconstruction of freeform surfaces for
reverse engineering. Comput Aided Des 27(1):59–64
5. Hoffmann M, Varady L (1998) Freeform surfaces for scattered data by neural networks. J Geom
Graph 2:1–6
6. Echevarria G, Iglesias A, Galvez A (2002) Extending neural networks for B-spline surface
reconstruction. Lect Notes Comput Sci 2330:305–314
7. Krause FL, Fischer A, Gross N, Barhak J (2003) Reconstruction of freeform objects with
arbitrary topology using neural networks and subdivision techniques. Ann CIRP 52(1):125–128
8. Sarfraz M, Raza SA (2001) Capturing outline of fonts using genetic algorithm and splines. In:
Proceedings of the international conference on information visualization. ISBN: 0-7695-1195-3
9. Renner G, Ekart A (2003) Genetic algorithms in computer aided design. Comput Aided Des
35:709–726
10. Yoshimoto F, Harada T, Yoshimoto Y (2003) Data fitting with a spline using a real coded
genetic algorithm. Comput Aided Des 35:59–64
11. Kumar GS, Kalra PK, Dhande SG (2003) Parameter optimization for B-Spline curve fitting
using genetic algorithms. Proc Congr Evoluti Comput (CEC’03) 3:1871–1878
12. Sun YH, Xiang WJ, Xia DS (2010) Parameter optimization for B-Spline curve fitting based on
adaptive genetic algorithm. J Comput Appl 30:1878–1882
13. Zhao L, Jiang J, Song C, Bao L, Gao J (2013) Parameter optimization for Bezier curve fitting
based on genetic algorithm. Adv Swarm Intell 7928:451–458
14. Hasegawa AY, Tormena C, Parpinelli RS (2014) Bezier curve parameterization using a multi-
objective evolutionary algorithm. Int J Comput Sci Appl 11(2):1–18
15. Galvez A, Cobo A, Pey JP, Iglesias A (2008) Particle swarm optimization for Bezier surface
reconstruction. In: Proceedings of the 8th international conference on computational science
(part II)
16. Galvez A, Iglesias A (2011) Efficient particle swarm optimization approach for data fitting
with free knot B-Splines. Comput Aided Des 43:1683–1692
17. Galvez A, Iglesias A (2012) Particle swarm optimization for non-uniform rational B-Splines
surface reconstruction from clouds of 3D points. Inf Sci 192:174–192
18. Galvez A, Iglesias A (2013) Firefly algorithm for Bezier curve approximation. In: Proceedings
of the 12th international conference on computational science and its applications, pp 81–88
19. Piegl L, Tiller W (1997) The NURBS book. Springer, Berlin
20. Liu GH, Wong YS, Zhang YF, Loh HT (2002) Adaptive fairing of digitized point data with
discrete curvature. Comput Aided Des 34:309–320
Energy Engineering
Experimental Study of an Axial Turbine
for Wave Energy Conversion
Abstract With the growing menace of increase in population and pollution, renew-
able sources of energy are being preferred over the fast depleting fossil fuels. Ocean
wave energy is one such form of renewable source with a huge potential all around the
globe. Wave energy conversion (WEC) devices are used to harness the energy from
ocean waves. An oscillating water column (OWC) is a WEC device, which uses an
axial turbine to convert wave energy into useful electrical energy. The experimental
setup designed and assembled at Wave Energy and Fluids Engineering Laboratory,
IIT Madras tested the turbine subjected to bidirectional airflow. The objective of the
preliminary experiment is to measure the rotational speed and pressure drop across
the turbine. The variable parameters are stroke length and time period of the oscil-
lating piston, which simulates different ocean wave conditions. A comparative study
of the parameters is carried out and reported in this article.
Nomenclature
Abbreviation
1 Introduction
measured performance parameters are rotational speed and the pressure difference
across the turbine. The stroke length and the time period of the oscillating piston
are varied to create different bidirectional airflow profiles similar to different wave
conditions.
Oscillating water columns utilize Wells turbine for converting wave energy to elec-
trical energy. Wells turbine is an axial flow bidirectional turbine especially used in
OWC type wave energy converters. The turbine is made up of symmetrical aerofoil
type blades fixed around the hub (Fig. 2). The aerofoil blades are positioned around
the hub with the chord planes perpendicular to the axis of rotation. The turbine
transmits wave energy to the coupled electric generator through rotation.
The Wells turbine working principle is explained in [11]. When the flow is incident
on the turbine blade at an angle of attack (α), a lift force is generated normal to
the direction of relative velocity. Simultaneously a drag force is experienced in the
direction of the relative velocity. Resolving these lift and drag forces (Fig. 2) gives
components of forces in the plane of rotation (tangential force) and normal to the
plane of rotation (axial force), Ftan and Fax , respectively.
Whatever may be the direction of incoming flow, the tangential force always acts
in the same direction. Therefore, the turbine rotation always remains in the same
direction regardless of flow direction. This turbine performs optimally up to a value
Rotor
Bi-Directional
airflow L
D
Symmetrical
aerofoil
Outer
casing α
V
(a) (b)
Fig. 2 a CAD model of Wells turbine with shroud, b forces acting on the blade
Experimental Study of an Axial Turbine for Wave Energy Conversion 957
of angle of attack (α), further increase in its value results in flow separation around the
blades. This angle at which flow separation occurs is called as stall angle. Beyond this
angle, the magnitude of lift and drag forces reduces; as a result, efficiency decreases.
One main drawback of Wells turbine is that it is difficult to achieve its operational
speed due to its poor starting characteristics [12].
The aerodynamic performance of the Wells turbine depends upon various parameters.
These parameters with optimum values are discussed in this section. All the param-
eters are inter-related. Based on the analytical studies, turbine geometric parameters
are given in [11]. All such important parameters are enlisted in Table 1. One of
the most important parameters is solidity, which measures the mutual interaction
between the blades. With the increase in solidity, turbine blades tend to come closer,
thereby hindering flow passage and as a result efficiency of turbine reduces. Previous
experiments show that with an increase in the hub-to-tip ratio beyond certain value
results in loss of efficiency [11]. The aspect ratio and tip clearance play an important
role in turbine performance. The Wells turbine shows high sensitiveness towards tip
clearance.
A Monoplane Wells turbine was modeled and then fabricated for testing in the
laboratory. The 3D CAD model and the actual turbine is shown in Fig. 3. The turbine
is modeled on the recommended values of various design parameters. It is fabricated
by rapid prototyping, and the material used is ABS Plastic (Acrylonitrile Butadiene
Styrene). The turbine geometrical dimensions are listed in Table 2.
Table 1 Recommended
Parameter Analytical Remarks
parameters
description
Solidity (σ ) Nb c/π Rt Efficiency reduces
for σ > 0.5
Aspect ratio (AR) b/c AR ~0.5 is
recommended
Hub-to-tip ratio Rh /Rt Recommended
(h) value h ~0.6
Tip clearance (tc ) % of c ≤2% of c is
recommended
958 K. Kumar et al.
The experiment is carried out at a laboratory facility in IIT Madras. This experimental
setup consists of a piston-cylinder arrangement which is driven by a motor and
gearbox. Motor rotations are controlled by a variable frequency drive (VFD). The
measured parameters include differential pressure drop across the turbine rotor and
the rotational speed. Table 3 lists the instruments used for measuring the parameters.
The signals from the instrument are recorded by a data acquisition system (DAQ).
The input signals are processed and stored as data in a readable format using LAB
VIEW software.
The VFD runs the motor to generate the required cycle time (CT) of the piston,
which relates to ocean wave time period. The power from the motor shaft is trans-
ferred to the piston rod through worm wheel gearbox (gear ratio 1:40). Ocean wave
height is replicated by piston stroke length (SL). The frequencies corresponding to
different CT of the piston are: 22.5 Hz relates to CT = 4 s and 18.5 Hz to CT =
Fig. 4 a CAD model of the turbine assembly, b actual turbine assembly, c the piston-cylinder
system, d complete setup
5 s. The oscillating motion of the piston creates the bidirectional air flow through the
duct. Once the piston starts reciprocating, data is recorded after some time until the
flow is fully developed. The sampling rate of data taken is 100 ms, and it is recorded
for three minutes. The complete experimental setup is shown in Fig. 4.
All the experiment tests data is recorded by DAQ system, and the comparative results
are plotted as the function of time. Although each data is collected for three minutes
duration, the present result is shown for only one full cycle for the ease of under-
standing. Figure 5 shows the variation of pressure drop and rotational speed of the
960 K. Kumar et al.
2 800
SL=0.4m SL=0.4m
SL=0.5m SL=0.5m
1 600
ΔP (kPa)
N (rpm)
0 400
-1 200
-2 0
0.0 2.5 5.0 0.0 2.5 5.0
T(sec) T (sec)
(a) (b)
Fig. 5 Variation of a pressure drop and b rotational speed for different stroke length at same time
period T = 5 s
turbine for two different stroke lengths (0.4 and 0.5 m) for a fixed time period of 5 s.
In Fig. 5a, the first half cycle shows differential pressure during compression of the
piston and the other half cycle is for suction of the piston. Theoretically, it should be
similar to a sinusoidal curve; however, due to the presence of the supports inside the
duct, the flow faces blockage during the suction stage. As a result, the compression
peak pressure drop is slightly higher than the suction side pressure drop. The turbine
experiences more air flow rate when the stroke length is longer. This is visible in
Fig. 5(b) for the rotational speed. The rotational speed for SL = 0.5 m is much higher
compared to smaller stroke length. For SL = 0.4 m, the turbine rotational speed is
almost zero during the transition from compression to the suction stage. This situ-
ation interrupts the continuous power production from the generator. However, for
SL = 0.5 m, the turbine rotates continuously during both suction and compression
stage of the piston motion.
Figure 6 shows the variation of pressure drop and rotational speed of the turbine
for two different time periods (4 and 5 s) when the stroke length is fixed at 0.4 m.
Higher time period means the piston moves slowly; the rate of air flow is less. So,
the pressure drop is also less when the time period is higher. The same is visible in
Fig. 6a. The variation of rotational speed is shown in Fig. 6b. When the time period is
T=4sec 1200
T = 4sec
2 T=5sec 1000 T = 5sec
N (rpm)
800
ΔP (kPa)
600
0
400
200
-2 0
0.0 2.5 5.0 0.0 2.5 5.0
T (sec) T (sec)
(a) (b)
Fig. 6 Variation of a pressure drop and b rotational speed for different time period at same stroke
length SL = 0.4 m
Experimental Study of an Axial Turbine for Wave Energy Conversion 961
N (rpm)
ΔP (kPa)
150
0.0
100
-0.8 50
0
0.0 2.5 5.0 0.0 2.5 5.0
T (sec) T (sec)
(a) (b)
Fig. 7 Variation of a Pressure drop and b rotational speed for unidirectional and bidirectional
condition at SL = 0.4 m, T = 5 s
less, the piston moves faster, and the transition from compression to suction happens
very fast. So, the turbine speed does not fall to zero and oscillates between 600
and 1000 rpm approximately. However, this rotational speed is less compared to the
design speed of the Wells turbine of similar dimension. This is due to the generator
support, which does not allow uninterrupted airflow to the turbine. For T = 5 s, the
turbine almost stops at the transition from compression to the suction stage.
Figure 7 shows the comparison between unidirectional and bidirectional flow at SL
= 0.4 m and T = 5 s. The piston-cylinder arrangement can be made unidirectional by
opening a valve. In this configuration, the air flows through the turbine only during the
compression stage; whereas, during suction, the air flows through the valve. During
the compression stage, the values for pressure drop and rotational speed are almost
the same for both unidirectional and bidirectional flow. However, for unidirectional
flow, the turbine does not rotate during the suction stage, and the values of pressure
drop and rotational speed remain zero throughout this stage.
6 Conclusion
Acknowledgements The authors thank the Department of Ocean Engineering, IIT Madras for
providing financial support to carry out the experiment.
References
1. Sannasiraj SA, Sundar V (2016) Assessment of wave energy potential and its harvesting
approach along the Indian coast. Renew Energy 99:398–409
2. Falcao AFDO, Henriques JCC (2016) Oscillating-water-column wave energy converters and
air turbines: a review. Renew Energy 85:1391–1424
3. Raghunathan S, Setoguchi T, Kaneko K (1994) Aerodynamics of monoplane Wells turbine—a
review. Int J Offshore Polar Eng 4(1):68–75
4. Shehata AS, Xiao Q, Saqr KM, Alexander D (2017) Wells turbine for wave energy conversion:
a review. Int J Energy Res 41(1):6–38
5. Gato LMC, Curran R (1996) Performance of the biplane Wells turbine. Trans ASME 118:210–
215
6. Curran R, Gato LMC (1997) The energy conversion performance of several types of Wells
turbine designs. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part A J Power Energy 211(2):133–145
7. Takasaki K, Takao M, Setoguchi T (2014) Effect of blade shape on the performance of Wells
turbine for wave energy conversion. Int J Mech Aerospace, Ind Mechatronics Eng 8(12):2080–
2083
8. Paderi M, Puddu P (2013) Experimental investigation in a Wells turbine under bi-directional
flow. Renew Energy 57:570–576
9. Gato LMC, Webster M (2001) An experimental investigation into the effect of rotor blade
sweep on the performance of the variable-pitch Wells turbine. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part A J
Power Energy, 215(5):611–622
10. George A et al (2018) Experimental analysis of turbine-chamber coupling for wave energy
conversion. Int J Energy Res 42(15):4770–4782
11. Raghunathan S (1995) The Wells air turbine for wave energy conversion. Prog Aerosp Sci
31(4):335–386
12. Inoue M, Kaneko K, Setoguchi T, Raghunathan S (1986) Simulation of starting characteristics
of the Wells turbine. In: 4th fluid Mechanics, plasma dynamics and laser conference, 1986
Investigations into Nonlinear Energy
Sinks for a Stochastic Dynamical
Oscillator
Abstract The paper deals with Nonlinear Energy Sinks (NES), utilizing piezoelec-
tric transduction mechanism, focusing on the degree of effect the auxiliary nonlinear
stiffness has on the performance of the NES and the performance of NES with the
primary system subjected to random excitation. Hence, a parametric sweep of the
auxiliary nonlinear stiffness over a broad range of values has been done and the
variations in primary vibration suppression and voltage generation by the NES have
been observed for its corresponding values. It has been conducted with the NES
attached to a linear primary system and then an essentially nonlinear one. Compari-
son of results and validation of the performance of NES for both the cases have been
performed. Following that, performance of the NES has been investigated when a
linear primary system is subjected to random excitation. Two separate cases have
been utilized to randomize the excitation. Results regarding vibration control and
voltage generated have been derived for both and compared to those obtained for
deterministic excitation. By and large, it is found that NES is successful in protect-
ing a primary system and broadening the operation bandwidth, while satisfyingly
generating voltage, irrespective of the type of excitation on the primary system.
1 Introduction
while harvesting energy on a broad frequency scale [9]. It can also be said that it
occupies lesser space while providing better power density [5]. Another area lacking
in investigation has been the performance of an NES for random excitations. Most of
the studies done to date have concentrated on harmonic excitation upon the primary
system which severely limits an NES’s potential to operate satisfyingly on frequency
varying environments while in the meantime, also fails to emulate real-life scenarios
to maximum accuracy. Random vibration has indeed started replacing its harmonic
counterpart when realistic scenarios are concerned and as it is much more capable
of accurately emulating them. Hence, a study is required to understand if an NES
can indeed perform satisfyingly when subjected to random vibrations as only then,
practical application of an NES can be considered on a larger scale.
This work proposes the effect of cubic coefficient of the nonlinear stiffness of the
NES spring on voltage generated by a NES and the structural response of the NES and
the primary spring-mass system. It also investigates NES behaviour for a nonlinear
primary system. The work further investigates into the behaviour of the NES when
the primary system is acted upon by random excitations and analyses the difference
between the voltage generated and structural response of the NES and primary sys-
tem when acted upon by random excitations and when acted upon by deterministic
harmonic excitations. The present study utilizes numerical simulations with the help
of MATLABODE45 function to address these issues. The values of the parameters
used in the study are taken from previous literature [9]. A parametric sweep of the
value of the cubic nonlinear spring stiffness is performed for four different initial
conditions [9]. The interplay and relation between the cubic hardening nonlinear
spring stiffness of the NES and the newly introduced nonlinear spring stiffness of
the primary system are evaluated. The modelling of random vibrations is done by
introducing a deterministic harmonic (sinusoidal) excitation, which depending on
the random variable, was split into two cases to introduce the random vibration,
forcing magnitude or the frequency of forcing. The RMS voltages generated in both
the cases are evaluated and compared with the deterministic harmonic excitation as
well as with the results validated from literature [9]. The time response plots and
time voltage plots hence obtained are presented in this paper.
The paper has been divided into three sections. Section 2 presents the mathematical
model used in this study, followed by results and discussions in Sect. 3. The salient
findings from this study are summarized in Sect. 4.
2 Mathematical Modelling
See Fig. 1.
To study the performance of the piezoelectric vibrational energy harvester (PVEH)
based on the NES, a model is developed consisting of two parts: a primary system
and a PVEH attached to a NES. The governing equations of the linear primary system
with free vibration are given as
966 A. Parvathaneni et al.
y + xp + z y + xp + z
a) b)
ca ca
Piezoelectric k3 Piezoelectric
k3
transducer transducer
k1 R y + xp k1 y + xp
R
cp y cp y
kp kp
Fig. 1 a NES attached to a linear primary system; b NES attached to a nonlinear primary system
m p ẍ p + c p ẋ p + k p x p − ca ż + k1 z + k3 z 3 + θ V = 0 (1)
m a z̈ + (1 + μ) ca ż + (k1 z + k3 z 3 + θ V ]−μ[c p ẋ p + k p x p ] = 0 (2)
V
+ C S V̇ − θ ż = 0 (3)
R
The governing equations of the nonlinear primary system with free vibration are
given as
m p ẍ p + c p ẋ p + k p x 3p − ca ż + k1 z + k3 z 3 + θ V = 0 (4)
m a z̈ + (1 + μ) ca ż + (k1 z + k3 z 3 + θ V ]−μ[c p ẋ p + k p x p ] = 0 (5)
V
+ C S V̇ − θ ż = 0 (6)
R
For forced vibration, Eqs. (1) changes to Eq. (7) while Eqs. (2) and (3) are also
utilized
m p ẍ p + c p ẋ p + k p x p − ca ż + k1 z + k3 z 3 + θ V = F sin(ωt) (7)
In the governing equations, xa (t) and x p (t) represents the displacement of NES
and the primary mass, respectively. z refers to the relative displacement between the
NES and primary system and is represented as z = xa − x p . m a and m p represent
the mass of the NES and the primary system respectively. ca and c p represent the
damping coefficient of the NES and primary system. k1 and k3 represent the linear
and nonlinear stiffness of the NES spring while k p represents the stiffness of the
primary mass. Mass ratio is denoted by μ = m a /m p . The capacitance and the
Investigations into Nonlinear Energy Sinks for a Stochastic … 967
3 Results
The focus of this study was to investigate the steady-state performance in addition
to the transient performance of the 2DOF mass-spring system. First, the results of
previous literature were validated [9] which showed that NES can indeed increase
frequency robustness while also decreasing the primary vibrations with the primary
system being subjected to harmonic excitation. It also displayed satisfying results
regarding voltage generation, irrespective of the initial displacement utilized. Hence
the NES was capable of solving the drawbacks present in linear techniques.
Following that, parametric sweep of the auxiliary nonlinear stiffness has been
done for linear and nonlinear primary systems. Logical inferences have been drawn
from the two sets of results and have been compared to understand the difference in
behaviour of NES as per the nature of the primary system. Following that, perfor-
mance of the NES, when the primary system is subjected to random excitation, has
been investigated. Two cases have been used to randomize the excitation. Results for
both voltage generation and primary vibration suppression have been considered. To
understand if NES remains effective for such a case, the results hence obtained have
been compared to the behaviour of the NES when attached to primary system with
deterministic excitation.
In this section, Eqs. (1)–(3) have been used. A parametric sweep of k 3 has been
performed as the focus is on understanding if auxiliary nonlinear stiffness plays any
role in voltage generation and primary vibration suppression for a linear primary
system. It can be observed that the value of voltage generated is directly proportional
to the value of displacement of auxiliary mass. Initial displacement (X) or k 3 doesn’t
affect the relation between the two in any way as can be seen in Fig. 2.
968 A. Parvathaneni et al.
Fig. 2 a V versus t plot for X = 0.52 mm; b x versus t plot for X = 0.52 mm; c V versus t plot for
X = 1.42 mm; d x versus t plot for X = 1.42 mm
For X = 0.52 mm, the maximum value of voltage can be obtained for a k 3 value
of 2 × 108 and the maximum displacement of auxiliary mass is also obtained for the
same k 3 value.
For X = 1.42 mm, however, the maximum value of voltage and x a are obtained
at k 3 value of 2 × 107 with a similar observation relation being observed for the two
other initial displacement values 2.65 and 4.45 mm as well. Hence, k 3 doesn’t affect
the interrelation between auxiliary mass displacement and voltage generated in any
way.
For constant k 3 value, greater initial displacements showed higher voltage values
as is observable in Fig. 3. Similar increment in magnitude can be observed for the
other two higher initial displacement values as well.
Also, irrespective of the value of initial displacement, negligible change is
observed in the pattern of voltage generated (with respect to time) when k 3 lies
between 2 × 10 and 2 × 104 . There is a negligible change in magnitude as well.
Variations occur only when k 3 values higher than 2 × 105 are considered. It can be
observed in Fig. 4 where X = 0.52 mm has been considered with similar observations
being made for the other initial displacement values as well.
Investigations into Nonlinear Energy Sinks for a Stochastic … 969
Fig. 3 a V versus t plot for X = 1.42 mm with k 3 = 2 × 106 ; b V versus t plot for X = 0.52 mm
with k 3 = 2 × 106
Fig. 4 a V versus t plot with k 3 = 2 × 107 ; b V versus t plot with k 3 = 2 × 1010 ; c V versus t plot
with k 3 = 2 × 10; d V versus t plot with k 3 = 2 × 104
970 A. Parvathaneni et al.
Fig. 5 a V versus t plot with X = 0.52 mm and k 3 = 2 × 108 ; b V versus t plot with X = 1.42 mm
and k 3 = 2 × 107 ; c V versus t plot with X = 2.65 mm and k 3 = 2 × 106 ; d V versus t plot with X
= 4.45 mm and k 3 = 2 × 106
In this section, Eqs. (4)–(6) have been used. Two cases have been considered with the
value of k 3 being varied while keeping a constant value of k p and vice versa. Its effect
on voltage generation and primary vibration suppression have been investigated.
Here, k p refers to the nonlinear stiffness of the primary system. The primary system
considered is essentially nonlinear in nature as no primary linear stiffness has been
considered.
As can be observed in Fig. 6, for a nonlinear primary system too, primary vibration
has been reduced for both the aforementioned cases. Irrespective of the value of k p
or k 3 considered, with respect to the constant value chosen, primary vibration can be
seen to be dying down.
Investigations into Nonlinear Energy Sinks for a Stochastic … 971
Fig. 6 a x versus t plot with k 3 = 2 × 10 and k p = 4 × 10; b x versus t plot with k 3 = 2 × 10 and
k p = 4 × 1010 ; c x versus t plot with k 3 = 2 × 1010 and k p = 4 × 10; d x versus t plot with k 3 =
2 × 1010 and k p = 4 × 1010
Fig. 7 a V versus t plot for k 3 = 2 × 10 for k p = 4 × 10; b V versus t plot for k 3 = 2 × 1010 for
k p = 4 × 10
Fig. 8 a V versus t plot for k 3 = 2 × 10 for k p = 4 × 104 ; b V versus t plot for k 3 = 2 × 10 for
k p = 4 × 1010
Fig. 9 Simulation results of voltage generated in case 1 from PVEH with random and deterministic
excitation for F mean = 1, ω = 5 and X = 0.52 mm: a for σ = 0.1; b for σ = 0.5; c for σ = 0.7 and
d for σ = 0.9
the voltage generated by both the deterministic harmonic excitation and the random
excitation in both the cases for different σ values is presented in Figs. 9 and 10. In
case 1, random F, the difference in magnitude between the random and deterministic
voltage generated increases with an increase in σ as shown in Fig. 9. In case 2,
random ω, the voltage generated dies down faster with increase in σ as shown in
Fig. 10. The RMS voltages generated in both the cases are evaluated and compared
with the deterministic harmonic excitation as well as with the results validated from
literature [9]. This is represented in Tables 1 and 2. The RMS voltage generated
increases with increase in σ in case 1 while it decreases with increase in σ in case 2
as shown in Tables 1 and 2.
The structural response of the system is shown in Figs. 11 and 12. It can be
observed in Figs. 11 and 12, that NES displacement is more than the displacement
of the primary mass, and even at higher values of σ the NES protects the primary
system from excessive vibrations in both the random cases as shown in Figs. 11 and
12.
974 A. Parvathaneni et al.
Fig. 10 Simulation results of voltage generated in case 2 from PVEH with random and deterministic
excitation for F mean = 1, ω = 5 and X = 0.52 mm: a for σ = 0.1; b for σ = 0.5; c for σ = 0.7 and
d for σ = 0.9
Table 1 Comparison of
σ value RMS voltage RMS voltage RMS voltage
RMS voltage generated in
(validated) (deterministic) (random)
case 1: random F
σ = 0.1 0.2077 1.0093 1.0414
σ = 0.3 0.2077 1.0093 1.0896
σ = 0.5 0.2077 1.0093 1.1470
σ = 0.7 0.2077 1.0093 1.1945
σ = 0.9 0.2077 1.0093 1.2582
Table 2 Comparison of
σ value RMS voltage RMS voltage RMS voltage
RMS voltage generated in
(validated) (deterministic) (random)
case 2: random ω
σ = 0.1 0.2077 1.0093 0.8883
σ = 0.3 0.2077 1.0093 0.5858
σ = 0.5 0.2077 1.0093 0.4919
σ = 0.7 0.2077 1.0093 0.4221
σ = 0.9 0.2077 1.0093 0.3953
Investigations into Nonlinear Energy Sinks for a Stochastic … 975
Fig. 11 Simulation results of the structural response of the system for case 1 with random and
deterministic excitation for Fmean = 1, ω = 5 and X = 0.52 mm: a for σ = 0.7 and b for σ = 0.9
Fig. 12 Simulation results of the structural response of the system for case 2 with random and
deterministic excitation for F = 1, ωmean = 5 and X = 0.52 mm: a for σ = 0.7 and b for σ = 0.9
4 Conclusion
Based on the NES principle, a piezoelectric harvesting device has been modelled.
Validation of previous literature [9] was done. The transient response and the steady-
state response of the system, regarding energy harvesting and vibration suppression,
were analyzed using numerical simulations. Investigations into effect of auxiliary
nonlinearity when connected to a primary system with deterministic harmonic exci-
tation were made. All in all, the NES successfully suppressed primary vibration and
continued to generate voltage over a wider operational bandwidth, regardless of the
primary system being linear or nonlinear. The degree of effect auxiliary nonlinearity
has on the variation in voltage generation, voltage pattern and its magnitude have
been understood. Random excitation to the system is also modelled and the struc-
tural response as well as the voltage generated have been presented. It was observed
that NES continues to suppress primary vibration just as in deterministic forcing but
976 A. Parvathaneni et al.
sustained voltage generation has been observed, in contrast to that for determinis-
tic model which showed decreasing voltage. Investigations into the effect of noise
intensity (σ ) showed that it is directly proportional to the rms voltage generated for
random F and indirectly proportional to random ω.
References
Abstract Recycling of plant and vegetable wastes is very much needed for improv-
ing the economy and minimizing wastages of materials. This can be a very beneficial
act toward the progress of society overall. Environmental pollution issues especially
from automobiles are also much decreased by this. Activated carbon is better known
for its characteristics and applications in the areas of gas absorption, water purifica-
tion and as composite reinforcement fillers. In this current research work, an attempt
is made to economically synthesize activated carbon from dried banana leaf waste
taken from a local vegetable market. This is characterized by measuring moisture
content, ash content, bulk density, yield of charcoal, fixed carbon and hardness. Gas
adsorption test is conducted using Atlon gas analyzer for various engine speeds. Its
effect on being porous is analyzed by means of comparing its performance with the
solid ones. Recycled banana leaves are used as the natural resource, and heat activa-
tion is used for converting the so-produced carbon into activated carbon. Potassium
hydroxide is used for synthesizing porous activated carbon. Comparison is made
between solid and porous activated carbons for better adsorbing capabilities for
automobiles. Scanning electron microscopy was done to analyze the morphology of
particles.
1 Introduction
The literature survey indicates that activated carbons can be prepared from a
variety of raw materials such as coconut shell, rice husk, walnut shell, banana stem
and animal bones [3–5]. The aim of this paper is to synthesize activated carbons
from dried banana leaves by heat and chemical activation and to investigate their
important characteristics, especially as an efficient gas adsorbing agent. Two forms of
activated carbon were compared for characterization like solid and porous structures.
Porous structure was achieved by using potassium hydroxide KOH during chemical
activation. Figure 4 shows the overall main steps involved in this current work.
980 A. John Presin Kumar et al.
Figure 1 shows the steps involved in the methodology clearly. The dried banana
leaf samples were collected from a local banana and vegetable market in Chrompet,
Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India. These were crushed into small pieces of about 2- to
3-mm diameter for providing large surface area. Then, these particles are sieved to
get rid of dust particles and other impurities. These crushed pieces were put in an
oven, and the temperature was maintained at 105 °C and soaked for 24 h. The dried
samples were taken in airtight plastic bags to avoid re-absorption of moisture from
the atmospheric air. About 103 g of samples was taken in a crucible with tightly
closed tightened lid for ensuring airtight environment. The crucible is placed in the
furnace carefully. The furnace was switched on, heated to a temperature of 460 °C
and held constant for 30 min. The charcoal obtained from pyrolysis process was kept
in an airtight bag in the activation unit, and the furnace was heated to a temperature
of 750 °C. Steam was allowed to flow to it for 30 min by keeping the temperature
constant. Activated carbon thus obtained has very less porosity which is ignorable
and thus considered solid activated carbon particles.
In order to produce porous structured activated carbon [2], chemical activation
was performed using KOH at various concentrations like 0.0, 0.3, 0.5 and 0.7 M
preferably at 0.5 M. All samples were carbonized at a temperature of 600 °C using
a furnace followed by physical activation using CO2 gas at a temperature of 850 °C
which produces porous activated carbon. Thus, both solid and porous activated carbon
particles are obtained. These different forms of activated carbon were compared later
for gas adsorption performances.
A Novel Banana Leaf Waste-Based Activated Carbon for Automobile … 981
The activated carbon produced was characterized for its moisture content, ash con-
tent, bulk density, yield of charcoal, fixed carbon, hardness and gas adsorption
capability.
Dried sample of activated carbon was weighed and recorded as W d . These were
placed in a crucible, and the total weight of crucible plus dry sample was noted and
recorded as W s . Finally, it was placed in a furnace at 500 °C for a time period of 6 h
[1]. It was removed and its content reweighed and recorded W f . These steps were
repeated twice for all the activated carbon samples, and the estimated value of the
ash content was calculated as: ((Ws − Wf ∗ 100))/(Wd ).
For calculating this, the activated carbon sample was transferred into a cylinder of
10 ml capacity and the weight of the sample along with cylinder was recorded as
W s [2]. The estimated value of the bulk density was calculated as: weight of sample
(W s )/weight of equal volume of water (W w ).
The yield of charcoal [1] that is available in the activated carbon was estimated as:
WS − AC + MC ∗ 100/WS
982 A. John Presin Kumar et al.
where WS is the original weight of dry sample, AC is the ash content and MC is the
moisture content.
The fixed carbon content in each activated carbon sample was estimated [1] using:
YC − AC − MC ∗ 100/YC
where YC is the yield of charcoal, AC is the ash content and MC is the moisture
content.
This involves the following steps. First, 2 g of activated carbon sample was measured
in a standard sieve of size 40. The sieve was made to shake along with particles for a
time period of 1 h using mechanical shaker at 160 rpm with four steel balls of 6.00-
mm diameter inside the sieve [1]. Finally, the quantity of activated carbon retained
inside the sieve after 1 h was expressed in percentage as hardness.
Q = (CO − CT) ∗ V /W
The surface morphology was obtained using scanning electron microscopy (SEM).
A Novel Banana Leaf Waste-Based Activated Carbon for Automobile … 983
This current research work was conducted in our institute Hindustan Institute of
Technology and Science, Chennai. Figure 5 shows single cylinder water cooled
naturally aspirated compression ignition engine having maximum horse power (hp)
of 10 hp. The output shaft is connected to an electrical dynamometer which has
maximum capacity of 24 amps. The engine used a mechanical injector, and it is a
constant engine which is designed to run at 1500 rpm [6, 7].
The engine specification is given in Table 1.
Atlon 5 gas analyzer shown in Fig. 6 was used to measure the emission parameter
of the exhaust gas. This gas analyzer is capable of measuring 5 parameters: carbon
monoxide (CO), carbon dioxide (CO2 ), hydrocarbon (HC), oxides of nitrogen (NOx )
and oxygen (O2 ) whose specification is given in Table 2.
The technical analyses of 5 samples are shown in Fig. 3. It should be noted that
all the samples were representative of activated carbon particles produced under
similar conditions [5, 8–11], namely AC1–AC5. These samples were categorized
based on the different combinational values of temperature and soaking duration.
Temperatures were taken like 105, 110, 115, 120 and 125 °C, and soaking times
were taken like 30, 24, 20, 15 and 10 h. The properties were found to be showing
A Novel Banana Leaf Waste-Based Activated Carbon for Automobile … 985
similar values in all the samples indicating isotropic nature [12, 13]. These are shown
in Tables 1 and 2 for comparing the solid and porous samples, respectively.
Table 3 clearly shows various characteristics of activated carbon without porosity
inside them. Being solid particles, these activated carbon particles may have lesser
surface area compared to the porous ones.
From Table 4 values for solid activated carbon, it was clear that the sample AC3
showed promising results indicating the better preparation temperature of 115 °C
and an optimum soaking time of 20 h for all properties other than moisture and ash
removal.
By comparing the two tables, the values of hardness, bulk density and amount
of carbon were slightly better than that of solid activated carbon. Similarly, from
Table 4 values for porous activated carbon, it was clear that the sample AC3 showed
promising results indicating the better preparation temperature of 115 °C and an
optimum soaking time of 20 h for all properties other than moisture and ash removal.
The adsorption of total unburnt gases was first analyzed using the Atlon gas ana-
lyzer, and comparison is made among various performance curves drawn for vary-
ing engine speeds against activated carbon samples prepared at different activation
temperatures. This performance curve is illustrated in Fig. 7. It was found that the
performance was better for full speed of the engine (1500 rpm) and also at a higher
activation temperature of 810 °C. The temperature for 15 different samples chosen
was varying at 30 °C from its predecessor.
The adsorption capacity toward NOx , CO2 and HC was analyzed for various acti-
vated carbon samples. These samples indicate the different temperature and soaking
time durations in oven. The sample showing better gas adsorption indicated clearly
the appropriate temperature and soaking time duration which were optimum for
preparing activated carbon.
The following graph in Figs. 8 and 9 for solid and porous activated carbon, respec-
tively, showed the performance characteristic of activated carbon samples from AC1
to AC5 in observing the harmful gases. For each sample, the average values of 5
trials were plotted. The sample AC3 showed promising characteristic in adsorbing
all three types of gases (Table 5).
The effect of higher to lower loading on the gas adsorption performance is shown
as various trials in Fig. 10. Porous activated carbon gave better results in all trials
compared to the solid ones having the values of 68%, 55% and 48%, respectively,
whereas the solid ones were having 65%, 53% and 42%, respectively, for trial 1, trial
2 and trial 3, respectively. The effect of chemical and heat activation on the surface
morphology of activated carbon particles from banana true stems is clearly shown
in Fig. 11. SEM micrographs show that the samples prepared have more pores. The
5 Conclusion
• The effectiveness of dried banana leaves in providing activated carbon was ana-
lyzed in this work by means of comparing the performance among two of its forms
such as solid and porous ones. It was found initially in an overall performance
observation made for different activated carbon samples prepared at different acti-
vation temperatures that the gas adsorption was better for full speed of the engine
(1500 rpm) and also at a higher activation temperature of 810 °C. The temperature
for 15 different samples chosen was varying at 30 °C from its predecessor.
• In the case of solid ones, the sample AC3 had removal efficiency of gases
greater than 66% upon the completion of five consecutive adsorption cycles
corresponding to the oven temperature of 115 °C and 20 h of soaking time.
• The same sample showed promising performance in other properties like hardness,
fixed carbon and bulk density also whereas the moisture removal and ash removal
had been better for the other sample AC4 corresponding to the oven temperature
of 120 °C and 15 h of soaking time duration.
• In the case of porous ones, the sample AC3 had removal efficiency of gases
greater than 70% upon the completion of five consecutive adsorption cycles
corresponding to the oven temperature of 115 °C and 20 h of soaking time.
• The same sample showed promising performance in other properties like hardness,
fixed carbon, bulk density.
• Here also, the moisture removal and ash removal have been better for the other
sample AC4 corresponding to the oven temperature of 120 °C and 15 h of soaking
time duration.
A Novel Banana Leaf Waste-Based Activated Carbon for Automobile … 989
• Dried banana leaves had shown good ability to be a better resource for activated
carbon synthesis. The porosity providing effect of potassium hydroxide solution
was also very clear from the results.
Acknowledgements We would like to express our sincere gratitude and thanks to Dr. A. Velayud-
ham, Scientist ‘G’, Ministry of Defence, CVRDE, Avadi, Chennai, India, and Dr. Ashish Selokar,
Accendere, CL Educate Ltd., New Delhi, India, for their valuable suggestions. We express our
sincere gratitude and thanks for their helps in the whole duration of executing this research work.
References
1. Sunday NJ, Okechukwu NS, Elom N, Anthony O, Michael PT (2018) Quantitative charac-
terization of activated carbon from cow, donkey, chicken and horse bones from Ezzangbo in
Ebonyi State, Nigeria. Amer J Appl Chem Sci Publ Group 6(5):169–174
2. Taer E, Taslim R, Mustika WS, Kurniasih B, Agustino, Afrianda, Apriwandi A (2018) Int J
Electrochem Sci 13:8428–8439
3. Lebedeva MV, Ayupov AB, Yeletsky PM, Parmon VN (2018) Rice husk derived activated
carbon/polyaniline composites as active materials for supercapacitors. Int J Electrochem Sci
13:3674–3690
4. Haji Azaman SA, Afandi A, Hameed BH, Mohd Din AT (2018) J Appl Sci Eng 21(3):317–330
5. Subramani T, Revathi PK (2015) Production of activated carbon from agricultural raw waste.
IOSR JEng (IOSRJEN) 05(05):54–63
6. Udhaya Kumar V, Bharath P, John Presin Kumar A (2017) Experimental Investigation of per-
formance and emission characteristics of ethanol blended diesel with zinc oxide nanoparticles.
Int J Eng Tech 9(3):1524–1531
7. John Presin Kumar A, Bharath V, Balakumar S, Godwin John J (2014) A study on the effect
of the dual fuel mixture of diesel and LPG, CNG gases on diesel engines. Int J Ind Prod Eng
Tech 4(1):11–13
8. Aziz NAA, Mohamed NAA, Mohamad M, Amini MHM, Abdul Aziz MS, Yusoff H, Ismael
Rizman Z (2015) ARPN J. Eng Appl Sci 10(1):376–386
9. Chandramohan D, John Presin Kumar A (2017) Experimental data on the properties of natural
fiber particle reinforced polymer composite material. Elsevier, Data Brief 13:460–468
10. Chandramohan D, John Presin Kumar A (2017) Data-enabled discover. Appl, Cross Mark,
Springer Inter Publ 1–9
11. Tsyntsarski B, Marinov S, Budinova T, FerhatYardim M, Petrov N (2013) Synthesis and
characterization of activated carbon from natural asphaltites. Fuel Processing Tech. Elsevier,
116:346–349
12. Abdul Khalil HPS, Noriman NZ, Ahmad MN, Ratnam MM, NikFuaad NA (2007) J Reinf Plast
Comp 26(3):305–320
13. Flores A, Cagiao ME, Ezquerra TA, BaltaCalleja FJ (2001) J. Appl. Pol. Sci. 79:90–95
14. SubhashreePradhan, Project report, B. Tech-Chem Engineering, Department of Chemical
Engineering, NIT, Rourkela, pp 1–9 (2010)
15. Abubakar M, Alechenu AA, Manase A, Mohammed J (2012) Adv Appl Sci Res 3(5):3089–3096
16. Cobb A, Warms M, Maurer EP, Chies S (2012) IntJ Serv Learn Eng 7(1):93–104
17. Aziz NAA, Mohamed M, Mohamad M, Amini MHM, Aziz MA, Yusoff H, Rizman ZI (2015)
ARPN J Eng Appl Sci 10(1):376–386
Analyzing Different Methods to Increase
the Natural Period of a Compact Wave
Energy Converter
1 Introduction
Traditional wave energy converter (WEC) systems like oscillating water columns
(OWC) use a turbine rotating at a high speed to generate electricity [1–3]. However,
since the frequency of oscillations imparted by ocean waves are particularly low, the
complex processes involved in compressing the fluid to attain such a high velocity
proves to be extremely inefficient and less feasible especially if the power requirement
is less or moderate, as in the case of a self-powered navigational or data buoy. A
substitute for these systems would be direct drive systems [4]. The mode of power
conversion in a direct drive system can be mechanical based (using gears) or electrical
based (using linear generators). Even though in the case of a linear generator, there
are only fewer moving parts, the complexity involved in handling a voltage which
varies both in amplitude and frequency makes it difficult to implement.
In the paper, we consider a mechanical-based direct drive wave energy converter
that uses a power take-off (PTO) similar to the design proposed by Ai et al. [5]. The
aforementioned PTO is coupled to a heaving buoy so that together they will perform
like a point absorber WEC. These types of WECs are capable of extracting energy
from a wave of crest length greater than its width [6]. A typical point absorber com-
prises a buoy whose width is less compared to the incident wavelength. In the present
work, the main focus is to improve the performance of such a point absorber WEC
in long period waves without increasing its size or the cost of manufacturing. This
study uses the Boundary Element Method (BEM) code Ansys AQWA to determine
the hydrodynamic coefficient for different test cases which subsequently is fed to an
open-source MATLAB based code that is tailor-made for simulating wave energy
converters (WEC-Sim) [7] to analyze their response in simulated wave conditions.
2 Hydrodynamics of Buoys
In the case of a point absorber, it is convenient to assume the motion of the buoy is
in the heave direction only [8]. Let us consider the buoy makes a displacement z in
the heave direction then, its equation of motion can be written as [9]:
where m is the structural mass of the system, F e is the excitation force imparted to
the buoy by the incoming wave, F r is the wave radiation force, F rs is the hydrostatic
restoring force and F damp is the hydrodynamic damping force.
The excitation force is composed of two different force components, the diffrac-
tion force (F d ) and the Froude–Krylov force (F fk ) [10]. The radiation force consists
of radiation damping and added mass terms.
Fr = − −ω2 A(ω) + jωbd (ω) z(ω) (2)
where, ω is the angular frequency, A(ω) is the frequency-dependent added mass and
bd (ω) is the frequency-dependent radiation damping coefficient. The normalized
value of added mass and radiation damping can be obtained as:
A
A (ω) = (3)
ρ
Analyzing Different Methods to Increase the Natural Period … 993
bd
B (ω) = (4)
ρω
Resonance occurs when a system is forced to oscillate at a frequency near to its natural
frequency. It is desirable for a wave energy converter to operate near resonance in
order to extract more power [11]. The resonance of a floating buoy occurs for an
angular frequency;
ρgπrb2 + k
ωn = (5)
a+m
2π
Tn = (6)
T
where rb the radius of the buoy, and m is the mass of the buoy.
In many coastal areas like Chennai, the periods of the most percentage of the
waves lies in the range of 4–9 s. So, for any point absorber to work efficiently in those
conditions, their natural period should lie somewhere near the same range. However,
small-sized bodies usually possess a natural period lower than that. From Eqs. (5) and
(6), it is evident that the natural period varies with the structural mass, added mass,
and the buoy radius. Since the added mass varies as the cube of diameter [12], the
natural period can be increased by increasing the diameter of the buoy. However, this
idea contradicts the main objective of this work, i.e. to propose a compact low-cost
design to increase the natural period of the buoy. This leaves us with two options,
either to increase the structural mass of the buoy or to increase the added mass of the
buoy by some other means.
Newman [12] quoted that an approximate value of the added mass formed by a
semi-infinite cylinder with radius r can be found by the formula a = 2.064 ρr 3 .
In 1966, Sarpkaya [13] observed that the added mass formed by a circular plate is
approximately equal to the mass of water in an imaginary sphere enclosing the plate.
Based on these two observations, the following equations were derived to find the
added mass of the system of a floating cylindrical buoy with and without a heave
plate.
994 V. Vijayasankar and A. Samad
Added mass
Heave plate
whereRb is the radius of the buoy, r p is the radius of the heave plate and r 0 and R0
are the radii of holes in the buoy and heave plate respectively (Fig. 1).
Wave power is the power content of the incoming ocean wave per crest lest length
of the wave. Wave power depends on the wave height and wave period and can be
mathematically represented as:
ρg 2 T H 2
Pwave = (9)
32π
where g is the acceleration due to gravity (9.81 m/s2 ), T is the wave period and H is
the wave height (Fig. 2).
Analyzing Different Methods to Increase the Natural Period … 995
3 Methodology
The surface model generated by the design modeler is analyzed by the AQWA solver
to determine the hydrodynamic coefficients. During the initial phase of analysis, the
mass properties of the geometry, the range of required wave frequencies and wave
directions are to be specified. For the present work, 99 different wave frequencies
with directions ranging from −180° to + 180° were chosen.
996 V. Vijayasankar and A. Samad
The response of the buoy for various wave conditions be studied using the WEC-Sim
code. WEC-Sim requires four types of inputs from the user
1. Hydrodynamic data generated by the AQWA.
2. Geometry files of the body.
3. Wave conditions like regular/irregular, wave height, wave period, etc.
4. A Simulink model of the hydrodynamic system.
The Response Amplitude Operator of a body in any direction is the ratio of its motion
amplitude in that direction to the incoming wave amplitude. A floating body can have
RAOs for heave, pitch, and roll motions. In the process of designing a point absorber,
the RAO in heave direction plays a significant role to optimize the power absorption.
RAO for heave motion can be expressed as:
ζa
RAO = (10)
ηa
where, ζa is the heave amplitude of the buoy and ηa is the incoming wave amplitude.
In the present work, the buoy is subjected to two main test cases; the first one in
which the experiments are done for different masses of the buoy and the second
one in which the experiments are done for the buoy attached with heave plates of
different diameters. Variation in mass refers to increasing or reducing the mass of
buoy without changing its dimension. For testing the effect of mass on the resonance,
three masses (30, 40 and 50 kg) were chosen and for testing the effect of heave plate
diameter, three different diameters (30, 60, and 90 cm) were used. One important
point to be noted is that the AQWA solves the potential flow theory and therefore
does not take into account the drag forces. So, in order to get the exact results, one
has to find the damping coefficients due to drag experimentally and manually include
it in the AQWA code. However, experimentation is out of the scope of the present
work.
Analyzing Different Methods to Increase the Natural Period … 997
The results of all the test cases developed for the buoy are discussed in this section.
As mentioned in the previous sections, the numerical experiments are first carried
out for different buoy masses without the heave plate and then by connecting heave
plates of different diameters to the buoy after fixing the buoy mass.
Mesh dependency study is done to find an optimum mesh resolution required to get
an accurate numerical solution at a moderate computational cost. Three different
mesh resolutions; fine, medium, and coarse were considered for this purpose. The
specifications of the different meshes are shown in Table 2.
In the present work, since the added mass plays a vital role in approaching the
conclusions; the values of added mass obtained for different mesh sizes were com-
pared to find an appropriate mesh. As seen in Fig. 3, the added mass values obtained
for the medium quality mesh were the nearest to the theoretically calculated value
of added mass (Sect. 2.3) and it required less computational time compared to the
fine mesh. Hence, the medium-sized mesh was used for all further analyses.
0.13
Normalized added mass
Fine Medium
Coarse Theorotical
0.12
0.11
0.10
1.6 2.4 3.2 4.0
ω (rad/s)
2.3
RAO (m/m)
1.5
0.8
0.0
0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50
Period (s)
The same buoy design is tested for three different masses: 30, 40, and 50 kg. The
value of natural frequencies obtained for different buoy masses is listed in Table 3.
It can be noted that the natural period of the buoy keeps on increasing with an
increase in buoy mass. However, since the dimensions of the buoy are kept constant,
the maximum buoyancy that this particular buoy can provide is also constant. This
limits the maximum mass possible to around 55 kg. Figure 4 shows the variation of
RAO with wave periods for different buoy masses. The peaks are obtained near the
resonant period of corresponding buoy configurations.
As discussed in Sect. 2, added mass is independent on the structural mass of the
buoy. It simply represents the added inertia that develops during motion. Therefore,
added mass remains more or less constant for all the three buoy masses.
In the second test case, the buoy mass is conveniently fixed as 30 kg (excluding the
weight of heave plate) and the analysis is done on the buoy fitted with heave plates
of three different diameters, 30, 60, and 90 cm.
It can be seen that the maximum percentage increase in the natural period for the
second test case (89.10%) is much higher than the same in the first test case (13.72%).
Table 4 shows the natural periods for the buoy connected with three different heave
plates. Table 4 also shows an enhancement in the peak power absorbed as the size of
Analyzing Different Methods to Increase the Natural Period … 999
0.28 0.016
0.21 0.012
0.14 0.008
0.07 0.004
0 0.000
0 2 4 6 8 0 2 4 6 8
ω (rad/s) ω (rad/s)
(a) (b)
Fig. 5 a Normalized added mass versus angular frequency. b Normalized radiation damping versus
angular frequency
the heave plate increases. Even though this estimate does not include the power lost
due to drag, it shows the dependence of the power absorbed on the diameter of the
heave plate.
Added mass
As shown in Fig. 1, the added mass is heavily dependent on the size of the heave plate
connected at the bottom of the buoy. As the diameter of the heave plate increases,
the added mass increases significantly (See Fig. 5a) since the added mass varies as
the cube of the diameter of the plate.
Radiation damping
Figure 5b indicates that the radiation damping tends to decrease as the heave plate
diameter increases. Since the radiation damping accounts for only 20–30% of the
total damping [14], this doesn’t necessarily mean that the total damping of the system
decreases with an increase in heave plate diameter.
Excitation force
It is evident from Fig. 6a that the excitation force acting on the buoy drops as the size
of the heave plate is increased. This is occurring due to the dependence of excitation
on added mass.
As explained earlier, the heave excitation force is composed of two counteracting
components, the diffraction force (F diff ) and the Froude–Krylov force (F fk ). The
1000 V. Vijayasankar and A. Samad
RAO (m/m)
0.21
4
0.14
2
0.07
0 0
0 2 4 6 8 0.50 1.00 1.50 2.00 2.50
ω (rad/s) Period (s)
(a) (b)
Fig. 6 a Normalized excitation force versus angular frequency. b RAO for different heave plate
diameters
diffraction component increases with an increase in added mass, while at the same
time the more decisive Froude–Krylov component remains more or less constant.
Thus, the net excitation force drops for higher diameters of the heave plate.
5 Conclusion
The following conclusions were drawn from the numerical analyses carried out for
the two aforementioned test cases:
1. The resonant period of the buoy increased for both the test cases, but the
percentage of increase is different in the two cases.
2. Increasing the mass of the buoy has little effect on its resonant period when
compared to the addition of a heave plate.
3. In the first test case, an increase in mass has virtually no effect on the added mass
and radiation damping of the buoy.
4. In the second test case, an increase in the heave plate significantly increased
the natural period of the buoy as much as by 89.10%. Also, the excitation force
decreased as the heave plate diameter is increased.
Summing up, the present work was able to successfully fulfil the objective of
improving the performance of the point absorber in longer wavelengths, without
increasing its size.
Analyzing Different Methods to Increase the Natural Period … 1001
References
1. Falcão AFdO (2010) Wave energy utilization: a review of the technologies. Renew Sustain
Energy Rev 14(3):899–918
2. Clément A et al. (2002) Wave energy in Europe: current status and perspectives. Renew Sustain
Energy Rev 6(5):405–431
3. Cruz J (2008) Ocean wave energy current status and future prepectives. Springer, Berlin
4. Baker NJ, Mueller MA (2001) Direct drive wave energy converters. Rev des Energies
Renouvelables 1–7
5. Ai J, Zuo L, Lee H, Liang C (2015) Design, fabrication, simulation and testing of a novel
ocean wave energy converter. In: ASME international manufacturing science and engineering
conference, pp 1–7
6. Budar K, Falnes J (1975) A resonant point absorber of ocean-wave power. Nature
256(5517):478–479
7. WEC-Sim | Open Energy Information. (Online). Available: https://openei.org/wiki/WEC-Sim.
Last accessed 06 Dec 2018
8. Chakrabarti SK (1987) Hydrodynamics of offshore structures. Computational Mechanics
Publications, Southampton
9. Falnes J (2002) Ocean waves and oscillating systems: linear interaction including wave energy
extraction. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK
10. Haslum HA (2000) Simplified methods applied to nonlinear motion of spar platforms.
Nowergian University of Science and Technology, Ph.D
11. Arthur Pecher JPK (ed) (2017) Handbook of ocean wave energy, vol 7. Springer, Aalborg,
Denmark
12. Newman JN (2017) Marine hydrodynamics, 40th Anniversary. The MIT Press, Cambridge
13. Sarpkaya T (2010) Wave forces on offstructure structures, First Edit. Cambridge University
Press, USA
14. Vugts JH (1968) The hydrodynamic coefficients for swaying, heaving and rolling cylinders.
Int Shipbuild Prog 15(167):251–275
Comparison of Hydrogen Yield
from Ball-Milled and Unmilled
Magnesium Hydride in a Batch System
Hydrogen Reactor
1 Introduction
Energy remains a pivot for the economic development and sustenance of nations
of the world. With the importance of energy also comes challenges such as high
cost and environmental pollution from some of the conventional energy generation
technologies. It is widely believed that energy technologies of the future are those
with sustainability attributes, that is minimal environmental harm, readily accessible
materials, relatively cheap and safe handling.
Hydrogen is one of the veritable renewable energy techniques with increasing
interests from researchers and policymakers in recent years. Among the different
hydrogen generation/storage methods, solid-state hydrogen storage and generation
especially from metal hydrides have attracted renewed interests. The development is
due to the attributes such as high gravimetric and volumetric hydrogen potentials of
most of these categories of materials [1]. Other alluring qualities of metal hydrides
include less harmful environmental reaction by-products, relatively cheaper cost
of experiments, comparative safe handling of the substrates. Magnesium hydride is
among the metal hydrides with increased interests from the experts for hydrogen stor-
age and generation especially for onboard vehicular application. Magnesium hydride
is readily available due to the abundant nature of its main component (magnesium)
regarded as the fourth most abundant element on earth [2]. Similarly, magnesium
hydride has high volumetric hydrogen storage estimated to be about 7.6 wt% [3,
4], the reaction products are considered to be of less harmful effect on the envi-
ronment and the cost of the material is comparatively affordable [5]. However, the
two major challenges facing the use of MgH2 like most metal hydrides are sluggish
reaction kinetics and thermodynamic limitations [6]. Researchers have explored dif-
ferent interventions towards ameliorating the limitations of slow reaction kinetics
and thermodynamics. Among such interventions the applications of catalysts such
noble metals, organic and inorganic acids have been reported to enhance hydrogen
yield [7–10]. Ball milling of metal hydrides for hydrogen generation results in reduc-
tion of crystallite size of the powder, ensures increase in reaction surface area of the
materials [11]. Similarly, the fracturing of the crystals leads to creation of defects
in the crystals thus enhancing nucleation reaction. The increase in nucleation thus
enhances hydrogen generation. In this study, the effect of ball milling on hydro-
gen yield was investigated by comparing hydrogen generation from unmilled and
ball-milled MgH2 via hydrolysis technique.
three-neck flask while the tube conveying the generated hydrogen from the reaction
vessel is connected to the second outer neck. The line carrying hydrogen from the
reaction vessel was joined to the bubbler for condensation of the gas. The second
opening on the bubbler had another connected to it, through which the condensed
hydrogen gas flows into the flow regulator. It is essential that only hydrogen gas
gets to the flowmeter thus two major components (flow regulator and filter/chemical
separator) were installed on the reactor. The water/moisture in the hydrogen gas is
trapped in the regulator while the gas flows into the filter/chemical separator. The
moisture-absorbent in the design trapped the moisture in hydrogen thus ensuring the
only hydrogen is recorded by the flowmeter. The hydrogen generation was recorded
using the datalogger connected to the flowmeter [13, 14].
The experiment was accelerated with the aid of acetic acid (99.8%, Labchem, SA
(South Africa). The reason acetic acid was chosen as the reaction accelerator is that in
reaction mixture the hydrolysis of the reaction is favour by the large excess of water
employed in the reaction, here water is also serving as the solvent rather than the
acid. This will drive the acetic metal hydrides equilibrium toward the acetic acid, thus
favouring the product formation. The equilibrium will favour the thermodynamically
more stable side and acetic acid is playing the role effectively couple with its pka value
which makes it weaker than other carboxylic acids that could be used for the same
reaction. Furthermore, acetic acid is environmentally friendly as well as the products
of its reaction with MgH2 for hydrogen generation through hydrolysis. Two sets
of substrates were utilized in the study: commercial magnesium hydride powder
99.8% purity (Rockwood Lithium, Germany) without further processing (unmilled)
hereafter referred to as as-received magnesium hydride (AR MgH2 ) and one-hour
ball-milled magnesium hydride (1 h BM MgH2 ). The manufacturer reported average
particle size of 50 µm for the AR MgH2 . Ball milling of the magnesium hydride
1006 J. A. Adeniran et al.
powder was done using Fritsch F6 Planetary mill using tungsten carbide vial and
balls with ball to powder ratio of 30:1. The sample was loaded into the vial inside
glove box operated with argon gas and the sample was ball-milled under argon. The
rotational speed of the ball mill was 300 rpm.
The equation for reaction of magnesium hydride acetic acid-accelerated hydrol-
ysis is represented in Eq. (1):
The X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis was accomplished with the aid of the Bruker
AXS D8 Advance instrument (USA). Using Cu-Kα, λ1 = 1.5406 Å, λ2 = 1.5444
Å, 2θ = 10–90o with a step size of 0.035°. Furthermore, α-Al2 O3 was employed as
the standard sample for establishing the impact of the equipment on the peak profile
of parameters. Thereafter, the Rietveld full profile analysis of the data was achieved
using the General Structure Analysis System (GSAS) software [15, 16].
To ascertain the effect of crystalline size on hydrogen yield, the AR MgH2 and 1 h BM
MgH2 were evaluated for hydrogen generation through three sample weights namely:
0.2 g, 0.4 g and 0.6 g, respectively. Figure 2 shows the result of the comparison
of hydrogen yield from the two materials in three different weight compositions.
Comparison of Hydrogen Yield from Ball Milled and Un-Milled … 1007
Hydrogen generation from the BM samples was higher than AR samples in all the
categories. The development is due to the improvement in the kinetics of the 1 h BM
MgH2 samples due to the increase in surface area relative to the AR MgH2 .
Figure 3 and Table 1 show the combined results of hydrogen yield from the six
substrates used: 0.2 g (AR and 1 h BM MgH2 ), 0.4 g (AR and 1 h BM MgH2 ),
and 0.6 g (AR and 1 h BM MgH2 ), 0.4 g (AR and 1 h BM MgH2 ). From the two
forms of result presentations (Fig. 3 and Table 1), the weight of substrates influenced
hydrogen yield with hydrogen generation proportional to weight of the substrates for
each of the two categories of the six samples (i.e. AR MgH2 and 1 h BM MgH2 ). The
observation agrees with some of the previously reported studies from our research
team [13, 14]. In these sets of experiments, the highest hydrogen yield was 0.0194 L
from 0.6 g 1 h BM MgH2 , however, 0.4 g AR MgH2 produced the lowest hydrogen
yield (0.0096 L) compared to approximately 0.0101 L from 0.2 g AR MgH2 . The
reason for the development is not known now. Similarly, after observing the same
trend of result from the sample when the experiment was repeated and for the fact
that it is the only departure among the six samples, it may be considered an outlier.
1008 J. A. Adeniran et al.
Table 1 Hydrogen
Material Maximum Duration of Ranking of
generation at 30 °C 40 wt%
(Mg H2 ) H2 yield (L) experiment H2 yield
Acetic concentration
(min)
0.6 g 1 h BM 0.0194 60 1
0.6 g AR 0.0131 60 4
0.4 g 1 h BM 0.0176 60 2
0.4 g AR 0.0010 60 6
0.2 g 1 h BM 0.0158 60 3
0.2 g AR 0.0101 60 5
Having observed that 0.6 g 1 h BM MgH2 was the optimum sample for hydrogen
generation, it was selected for optimization of acetic acid concentration on hydrogen
yield. Figure 4 shows the hydrogen yield from the substrate at five different catalyst
concentrations (30, 40, 50, 60 and 70 wt%). The 30 and 40 wt% recorded the best
performance for maximum hydrogen yield at 60 min (approximately 0.0194 L).
However, 30 wt% experiment recorded better hydrogen yield compared to 40 wt%
within 10 min of study suggesting faster kinetics at that point. Moreover, 70 wt%
recorded the fastest kinetics in the first 10 min of experimental observation.
Comparison of Hydrogen Yield from Ball Milled and Un-Milled … 1009
In this section, the results from the XRD analyses of the two samples will be
discussed.
X-ray diffraction (XRD) analyses
XRD characterization of the materials is important to provide useful information on
their crystalline structures and phase information. Figure 5 shows the XRD plots
of AR MgH2 and 1 h BM MgH2 stacked for easy comparison. From the plots, two
major phases were observed namely: Mg and αMgH2 . The αMgH2 is commonly
observed in unmilled MgH2 or samples that have been ball-milled for a short period of
time [17]. Moreover, the crystallite size obtained using GSAS software for Rietveld
analysis reported approximately 52.4 µm for the αMgH2 (MgH2 ) phase, a result
that is close to the 50 reported by the manufacturer. After a 1 h ball milling, the
crystallite size reduces to 92.25 nm. From the structural perspective, the XRD plots
show broadening of peaks in 1 h BM sample and shifting of the peaks to the right
compared to the AR MgH2 an indication of reduction of crystallinity of the materials
[18]. The impact of the crystalline size reduction on hydrogen yield was evident by
the consistent higher hydrogen yield in the 1 h BM samples compared to the AR
samples. The increased hydrogen yield was caused by fracturing of the crystals by
ball milling leading to increased nucleation phenomenon which enhanced reaction
kinetics.
1010 J. A. Adeniran et al.
4 Conclusion
Ball milling of MgH2 for 1 h reduced the crystallite size of the material 52.4 µm to
92.25 nm and improved hydrogen yield in the study. The result further underscores
the importance of crystalline size reduction to improve the reaction kinetics and
hydrogen generation through hydrolysis. The catalysis of the experiment with acetic
acid being an environmentally friendly acid will also enhance the scale-up potential
of the technology.
Acknowledgements Special thanks to the National Research Foundation (NRF) South Africa for
funding the study of the first author. Authors also thank Dr. M Lototskyy for availing the ball milling
facilities at the South African Institute for Advanced Materials Chemistry, University of the Western
Cape, for this study and for assisting with the XRD and GSAS analyses of the MgH2 powders. The
support of Dr. SN Nyamsi during the ball milling process is also gratefully acknowledged. This
project was funded by the TIA grant of the University of Johannesburg.
References
3. Chao CH, Jen TC (2013) Maximized on-demand hydrogen generator design. Adv Mater Res.
Trans Tech Publications
4. Sakintuna B, Lamrdi-Darkim F, Hirscher M (2007) Metal hydride materials for solid hydrogen
storage: a review. Int J Hydrogen Energy 32(9):1121–1140
5. Huot J, Liang G, Schulz R (2003) Magnesium-based nanocomposites chemical hydrides. J
Alloy Compd 353(1):L12–L15
6. Kojima Y, Kawai Y, Haga T (2006) Magnesium-based nano-composite materials for hydrogen
storage. J Alloy Compd 424(1):294–298
7. Uan JY et al (2009) Evolution of hydrogen from magnesium alloy scraps in citric acid-added
seawater without catalyst. Int J Hydrogen Energy 34(15):6137–6142
8. Akdim O, Demirci UB, Miele P (2009) Acetic acid, a relatively green single-use catalyst for
hydrogen generation from sodium borohydride. Int J Hydrogen Energy 34(17):7231–7238
9. Akdim O, Demirci UB, Miele P (2009) Highly efficient acid-treated cobalt catalyst for hydrogen
generation from NaBH4 hydrolysis. Int J Hydrogen Energy 34(11):4780–4787
10. Gervasio D, Tasic S, Zenhausern F (2005) Room temperature micro-hydrogen-generator. J
Power Sources 149:15–21
11. Webb CJ (2015) A review of catalyst-enhanced magnesium hydride as a hydrogen storage
material. J Phys Chem Solids 84:96–106
12. Adeniran JA et al (2019) Temperature optimized hydrolysis of Acetic acid catalyzed mag-
nesium Hydride for Hydrogen generation in a batch sytem Hydrogen reactor. In: Prabha D
(ed)Transactions on engineering technologies, Springer Nature Singapore Pte: Singapore
13. Jen TC et al (2016) Hydrogen generation from Acetic acid catalyzed magnesium Hydride
using an on-demand Hydrogen reactor. In: International mechanical engineering congress and
exposition. Phoenix, Arizona, USA: American Society of Mechanical Engineers
14. Adeniran JA, et al (2017) Organic Acid-Catalyzed Hydrolysis of Magnesium Hydride for
Generation of Hydrogen in a batch system Hydrogen reactor. In: Proceedings of the world
congress on engineering and computer science
15. Larson AC, Von Dreele RB (1994) Gsas. Report lAUR, pp 86–748
16. Nyamsi SN, Yartysb V, Lototskyya M (2017) Synthesis of Mg 2 FeH 6 assisted by heat treatment
of starting materials. In: 1st Africa energy materials conference. Pretoria: Elsevier
17. Huot J et al (1999) Structural study and hydrogen sorption kinetics of ball-milled magnesium
hydride. J Alloy Compd 293:495–500
18. Grosjean MH et al (2006) Hydrogen production via hydrolysis reaction from ball-milled Mg-
based materials. Int J Hydrogen Energy 31(1):109–119
A Review on the Synthesis of Activated
Carbon from Natural Resources
for Mechanical Applications
Abstract Activated carbon is a material which can be produced from various waste
materials such as plant waste, animal waste and industrial waste resulting in reduc-
tion of material wastage, better utilization of natural materials and environmental
friendliness. Activated carbon plays an important role in many applications in vari-
ous forms like gas absorbent, composite fillers, etc. Activated carbon particles have
many promising applications in various industries like water treatment, dye and sugar
refining, degasification and composite fabrication as fillers. In composites, activated
carbon can play a vital role as effective reinforcement materials for improving prop-
erties. During the last ten years, there had been a good work done in this field with
regard to exploring the possibilities of activated carbon in both production and appli-
cation. This work discusses contribution of several authors in the area of activated
carbon in both synthesis and characterization toward various applications related to
mechanical engineering.
1 Activated Carbon
popularly used in many countries as drug to treat diseases like diarrhea, indiges-
tion and flatulence. The adsorption property of carbon or activated carbon is a much
required property as it makes carbon an important material in the areas where adsorp-
tion is needed. For example, it finds an environment-friendly application of reducing
pollution as mentioned in the following points. Activated carbon has numerous appli-
cations in removing pollutants from air or water streams in the field and in industrial
processes such as: spill water cleanup, groundwater remediation, drinking water fil-
tration, air purification, volatile organic compound capture from painting and other
processes. Activated carbon is a readily allowed substance used by agricultural peo-
ple and organic farmers in both livestock production and wine-making. In livestock
production, it is normally used as a pesticide, animal feed additive, processing aid,
nonagricultural ingredient and disinfectant. Filters along with activated carbon in the
form of coatings are usually used in compressed air and gas purification to remove
oil vapors, odor and other hydrocarbons from the air.
2 Review Summary
chicken and pony bones upon corrosive and warmth enactment, was in expanding
request as appeared in Table 1. Among the bone examples, chicken bone has the
least fiery remains content for corrosive, heat and non-actuated examples separately.
The distinction in mass densities of corrosive-initiated and warmth-enacted carbons
is minuscule.
The heat activated carbons show higher percentage of hardness than the acid acti-
vated and non-activated carbons. This study indicated that activated carbons from
the animal residues were effective as adsorbents with those obtained from chicken
having better features of adsorbents. Plant matters such as banana stem can also be
a possible resource for producing activated carbon [2]. In this, the author performed
the production of activated carbon electrodes from a banana stem for supercapacitor
cell applications. The increase in pore properties was conducted using a potassium
hydroxide KOH chemical activation agent at low concentrations, whereas physical
activation was performed using CO2 gas at a particular temperature and time period.
The activated carbon electrode was fabricated without the addition of adhesive mate-
rials as can be noticeable in many works [1, 3, 4]. The density, degree of crystallinity,
surface morphology, elemental content and surface area of the electrodes were ana-
lyzed. The study of electrochemical properties focused on the analysis of the specific
capacitance of the supercapacitor cell using cyclic voltammeter. The physical prop-
erties of the activated carbon electrodes were correlated to generate the optimum
conditions for the specific capacitance of the supercapacitor cells.
The ideal explicit capacitance got at a specific grouping of KOH achieved best
an incentive with a particular surface territory. Initiated carbon can be a decent
material for creation of composites for good quality and firmness. Lebedeva et al.
[5] integrated composite materials, carbon/polyaniline, utilizing permeable actuated
carbon delivered from carbonized rice husk [6]. This has a particular surface zone
(Fig. 4). The arrangement of the composite materials was combined by oxidative
aniline polymerization technique within the sight of the actuated carbon in acidic
medium; polyaniline content was changed. Electrochemical properties of the com-
posite materials were researched by cyclic voltammetry, galvano static charge/release
and soundness tests. Results show that properties of the composites are administered
by proportion of the parts: A type of cyclic bends and area of polyaniline crest
esteems emphatically rely upon the polyaniline sum. Gravimetric capacitance devel-
ops with polymer content in the material and achieves greatest incentive, for example,
with particular polyaniline content. In any case, toughness tests demonstrate that the
steadiest is the example with the least polyaniline amount (Fig. 2).
A Review on the Synthesis of Activated Carbon from Natural … 1017
Coconut shells are often the promising natural material for many applications.
The use of coconut shell (Fig. 5) activated carbon was investigated for a potential
adsorbent for malachite green dye from aqueous solution as done by Haji Azaman
et al. [7]. Abechi et al. studied the effect of various factors, such as initial dye
concentration, contact time, pH and solution temperature [8]. The interaction between
dye molecule and coconut shell activated carbon absorbent was strongly influenced
by the pH of the solution [9]. Maximum adsorption of malachite green dye was
obtained at particular pH, while the point of zero charge was obtained at another value
of pH. The maximum monolayer adsorption capacity was increased with increment
in temperature. The kinetics of adsorption followed a pseudo-second-order kinetic
model. The intra-particle diffusion model was evaluated to determine the mechanism
of the adsorption process (Vijayan et al. [10]). Based on the Boyd plots, the adsorption
of malachite green dye on the coconut shell activated green absorbent was mainly
governed by film diffusion (Fig. 3).
Thermodynamic parameters were determined, and it was found that MG dye
adsorption on coconut shell activated carbon was spontaneous and endothermic in
nature. The conducted reusability test disclosed the decreasing coconut shell activated
carbon performance from higher value of malachite dye removal down to a lower
value of the same after few adsorption/desorption cycles. Activated carbon has wide
variety of applications have done a study in activated carbon [11]. Activated carbon
is used in gas purification, decaffeination, gold purification, metal extraction, water
1018 A. John Presin Kumar et al.
purification, medicine, sewage treatment, air filters in gas masks and respirators,
filters in compressed air and many other applications. Due to its high degree of
microporosity, just one gram of activated carbon has a particular surface area, as
determined by gas adsorption. An activation level sufficient for useful application
may be attained solely from high surface area; however, further chemical treatment
often enhances adsorption properties.
One noteworthy mechanical application includes utilization of activated carbon
in the metal finishing field. It is broadly utilized for refinement of electroplating
arrangements. For instance, it is a fundamental sanitization system for expelling nat-
ural contaminations from brilliant nickel plating arrangements. Anticipating on the
accessible crude materials, it is built up that modern interest for actuated carbon can
be met locally. The portrayal of two sorts of manufacturing plant squanders demon-
strated that paper squander was a superior choice over rice husk. The enacted carbon
delivered from pyrolysis of paper factory squander was synthetically actuated with
different initiating specialists like zinc chloride, potassium hydroxide and potassium
chloride. A precise examination of the impact of impregnation proportion, actuation
temperature and enactment time on the properties of the initiated carbon was fin-
ished. The ideal planning conditions together with the affected of these conditions
on the yield and effectiveness of delivered actuated carbon have been examined. The
artificially initiated carbons were described by estimating iodine and yield rate. The
enacted carbon arranged from paper plant squander in this investigation had most
extreme iodine with zinc chloride as the actuating operator.
A composite material is characterized as a blend of at least two materials that
outcomes in preferable properties over the individual segments are utilized alone.
The job of filler material in composites is essential as it advances improvement in
A Review on the Synthesis of Activated Carbon from Natural … 1019
3 Inferences
Activated carbon has wide utilization. On the one hand, it tends to be degasified;
then again, it can likewise be filler for composites. Numerous creators have done
work on enacted carbon under various objectives. Exploration and usage of plant
and creature source have been done broadly by numerous creators. Figure 4 portrays
roughly picture scatters of different waste asset usages over the most recent ten years
by different creators in the field of enacted carbon amalgamation. This is just a rough
picture showing a comparative analysis through review of selective works.
Various studies indicated that materials made of activated carbon are performing
well compared to conventional materials. The adsorptive efficiency of each of the
carbons can be enhanced through controlled and well-monitored activation. The study
utilizing animal bones [1] indicated that activated carbons from various animals are
effective as adsorbents with regard to their evaluated properties of moisture content,
ash content, bulk density, fixed carbon, hardness and percentage yield. Activated
carbon gotten from chicken having low ash content is a good indication of a better
adsorbent. Plant materials are also good sources for activated carbon such as banana,
rice and coconut. The preparation method for activated carbon electrodes from banana
1020 A. John Presin Kumar et al.
Fig. 4 Comparative
utilization of various wastes
stems used herein is a very feasible method for the production of supercapacitor cells
as in [2] which gave optimum results.
Figure 5 depicts the observed commonality in the procedural steps of synthesiz-
ing activated carbon from naturally available resources. The steps involved and the
corresponding hardware requirements are also mentioned below. Different authors
on different applications had synthesized activated carbon using activation processes
involving pyrolysis. This is normally grouped as heat activation and chemical activa-
tion method. For most of the applications, activated carbon can be prepared econom-
ically and easily using the following seven-step procedure. The following diagram
depicts this clearly followed by an explanation of what are the exact steps involved
and the corresponding hardware requirements.
Fig. 5 Generalized steps for activated carbon synthesis from natural materials
A Review on the Synthesis of Activated Carbon from Natural … 1021
Steps
Rice husk was also a promisingly utilized plant material like banana stem, which
when used for activated carbon has provided many opportunities for making compos-
ite using polymerization [5]. It was shown that the specific capacitance of composite
materials rises with the increase of the polymer amount, and in all cases, its value
exceeds a simple sum of the capacitances of the individual components. Thus, the
combination of the activated carbon material and the conductive polymer provides
the synergistic effect leading to improved capacitive and operational characteris-
tics and allows consideration of such composite materials as promising for the use
as active component of supercapacitor electrodes. Rice husk has been successfully
used by many authors as in [12–14] for polymer bio-composites in addition to other
natural elements like walnut shell and coconut shell, whereas the same authors have
used glass fibers in another work [15] for polymer composites for artificial limp
applications [16, 17].
The coconut shell activated carbon has demonstrated good reusability properties,
with the ability to sustain the removal efficiency of greater values of malachite green
upon the completion of five consecutive adsorption/desorption cycles [7]. In addition
to animal and plant materials, paper wastes are also possible materials for activated
carbons [12] in which the results of the study showed that it is feasible to prepare
activated carbons with relatively high surface areas and pore volumes from paper
waste by direct chemical activation. Activation with zinc chloride produced activated
carbons with better developed porosities than with potassium hydroxide. The iodine
value of the activated carbon product increased with concentration of zinc chloride
solution. As the impregnation time increased, the iodine value rose steeply, reaching a
maximum value. The iodine value also increased with higher activation temperature,
beyond which it gradually decreased, presumably due to excessive carbonization.
1022 A. John Presin Kumar et al.
The porosity of the product was comparable with that of commercially achieved
carbon. The waste-based activated carbon had proper mean pore diameters, pore
volume and micro-details indicating its microporous and mesoporous characters.
Table 2 shows a comparative data of the natural resources used with respect to
different application areas by many authors. Activated carbon not only is capable
of improving strength but also has the ability to relieve stresses [18, 19]; it was
shown that the stress value was increased with the increasing forces applied to the
samples of activated carbon. Other than that, the stress value of plywood without
activated carbon as filler was higher than the one without activated carbon filler. But,
due to the addition of different thicknesses of activated carbon, the stress value of
plywood became lower. This showed activated carbon limiting the energy inside the
plywood sample [20] and thus lowering the stress value of the sample. SolidWorks
simulation determined the sample that has high average displacement and average
stress which indicate good performance of mechanical properties. The addition of
activated carbon as filler increased the average displacement [6, 21, 22] and average
stress which is higher than plywood. Thus, both the methods which were experimental
and simulation showed that the mechanical properties were higher compared to
plywood with the addition of activated filler. It was also proved that SolidWorks
simulation was a suitable tool used to measure strength to get accurate result.
Activated carbon finds better applications as reinforcement fillers for compos-
ites [23–26]. Composites are materials nowadays getting more and more impor-
tance, especially for applications requiring less weight considerations. For instance,
mechanical properties of carbon coir composites depend on many parameters mainly
factors like stress–strain behavior of carbon and matrix phases, the phase volume
fractions, the carbon concentration, the distribution and orientation of the carbon or
reinforcement fillers relative to each other. In many works, it was found that the ten-
sile strength of filler-based composites is higher compared to the other composites
[27–31]. It could be easily predictable that there is always a trend toward carbon
concentration in increasing order. At lower concentration of filler material, the com-
posite specimens exhibit slightly linear behavior before or prior to a sharp failure.
This clearly means that the specimen deformed plastically immediately after elastic
deformation. Normally, the impact performance of the fiber-reinforced composites
depends on many factors including the nature of the individual constituents, interface
between carbon and matrix, the construction and geometry of the composite material
and the surrounding conditions of test. In addition, the impact strength of the com-
posites depends and gets influenced by many factors like toughness properties of the
fillers, the very nature of the interfacial region and frictional component [32–36].
Overall, the mechanical properties of composites filled with activated carbon parti-
cles as reinforcement fillers are influenced by many parameters as discussed. And in
addition to that, the size and morphology of the activated carbon particles are having
very much importance on the resulting mechanical properties of the composites. It is
generally surprising to note that the size of a reinforcement particle is influencing the
overall behavior of the composites [37–41]. Activated carbon particles should gen-
erally be of uniform shape and size as far as concerned in order to achieve betterness
in properties and strength. Surface topography and morphology of activated carbon
particles can be better studied by means of scanning electron microscopy. Recently,
activated carbon particles are getting more importance and influence toward many
environmental applications also like pollution control, agriculture field, etc., through
latest developments in its synthesis procedures and conditions in achieving nano-size
levels [42–46]. Nano-size of the particles can be better promising in achieving even
better surface areas and thereby providing the possibilities of better gas adsorption
and better mechanical properties.
4 Conclusions
• Thus, it was very evident from the work of several authors in the area of activated
carbons that these materials can be better produced through proper selection and
utilization of natural materials for various useful purposes such as natural materials
like coconut shell, rice husk, walnut shell, banana stem and animal bones at an
economical level suitable for our growing country like India.
• The application areas of activated carbon are vast, and especially like gas adsorp-
tion and in composites, the activated carbon plays an enhancing role of improving
the performance characteristics.
• The effective utilization of waste materials which has plant or animal origin creates
lots of benefits not only to the desired application but also to the society as a whole.
• Thus, it promises to be a good future material whose very nature and properties
can be further explored for various better applications and the needs of the society.
• More mechanical properties were discussed with regard to the behavior of
composites made of activated carbon particles in the form of reinforcement fillers.
• The main influencing factors were discussed for composites in relation to the
filled activated carbon fillers.
1024 A. John Presin Kumar et al.
Acknowledgements We would like to express our sincere gratitude and thanks to Dr. Velayudham,
Scientist ‘G’, Ministry of Defence, CVRDE, Avadi, Chennai, India; Dr. Ashish Selokar, Accendere,
CL Educate Ltd., New Delhi, India, for their valuable suggestions; and R. Balaji, mechanical second-
year student of Hindustan Institute of Technology and Science. We express our sincere gratitude
and thanks for their helps in the whole duration of executing this research work.
References
1. Sunday NJ, Okechukwu NS, Elom N, Anthony O, Michael PT (2018) Quantitative character-
ization of activated Carbon from Cow, Donkey, Chicken and Horse Bones from Ezzangbo in
Ebonyi State, Nigeria. Am J Appl Chem 6(5):169–174
2. Taer E, Taslim R, Mustika WS, Kurniasih B, Agustino A (2018) Afrianda and Apriwandi. Int
J Electrochem Sci 13:8428–8439
3. Renugadevi N, Anisha G, Lalith P (2010) Adv App Sci Res 1(2):102
4. Mane PC, Bhosle AB, Deshmukh PD, Janagam CM (2010) Adv App Sci Res 1(3):212
5. Lebedeva MV, Ayupov AB, Yeletsky PM, Parmon VN (2018) Rice husk derived activated
carbon/polyaniline composites as active materials for supercapacitors. Int J Electrochem Sci
13:3674–3690
6. Aloko DF, Adebayo GA (2007) J Eng Appl Sci 2(2):440–444
7. Haji Azaman SA, Afandi A, Hameed BH, Mohd Din AT (2018) J Appl Sci Eng 21(3):317–330
8. Abechi SE, Gimba CE, Uzairu A, Dallatu YA (2013) Res J Chem Sci 3(7):54–61
9. Cobb A, Warms M, Maurer Chiesa EPS (2012) Int J Ser Lear Eng 7(1):93–104
10. Nsi EW, Akpakpan AE, Ukpong EJ, Akpabio UD (2016) Int J Eng Sci 5(9):38–41
11. Subramani T, Revathi PK (2015) Production of activated Carbon from agricultural raw waste.
IOSR J Eng 5(3):54–63
12. Chandramohan D, Kumar AJP (2017) Experimental data on the properties of natural fiber
particle reinforced polymer composite material. Data in brief, vol 13, pp 460–468
13. Yusuf MI, Ariahu CC, Igbabul BD (2012) Afr J Pure Appl Chem 6(9):123–131
14. Darmawan S, Sofyan K, Pari G, Sugiyant K (2010) J Res 7(2):100–111
15. Chandramohan D, Presin Kumar AJ (2017) Data-enabled Discover. Appl CrossMark. Springer
International Publication, pp 1–9
16. Irle M, Barbu MC (2010) Wood-based panel tech. In: Brunei University Press, London pp 190
17. Lam MK, Zakaria R (2008) (Icenv).Inter Conf Envir pp 1–12
18. Aziz NA, Mazlan M, Marinah M, Mohamad Amini MH, Abdul Aziz MS, Yusoff H, Ismael
Rizman Z (2015) ARPN J Eng Appl Sci 10(1):376–386
A Review on the Synthesis of Activated Carbon from Natural … 1025
Abstract The Wells turbine is a self-rectifying air turbine, used in oscillating water
column (OWC) to harvest wave energy. It produces unidirectional torque as the flow
oscillates inside the OWC chamber. It has inherent disadvantage of narrow operating
range due to stall at high airflow rate. Whereas, a wider operating range is essential
to improve the turbine power output. A casing groove modifies the tip leakage flow
pattern and improves the operating range. In addition, a radiused tip can alter the
tip leakage flow and delay the stall. To enhance the performance further, this paper
investigates the combined effect of tip groove and radiused tip (CG&RT) design
modification. The flow was simulated by solving steady, incompressible Reynolds
averaged Navier–Stokes equations in Ansys CFX 15.0. As expected, the CG&RT
blade enhanced the relative operating range and the turbine power output by 44.4%
and 23.8%, respectively.
Keywords Wells turbine · Casing groove · Radiused blade · Wave energy · OWC
1 Introduction
Wells turbine combined with oscillating water column (OWC) is used to extract power
from ocean wave (Fig. 1). It comprises of symmetrical blades aligned perpendicular
to the flow direction. It suffers narrow operating range due to flow separation at a
Hub
Symmetrical blades
low
airf
lic
Cyc
higher flow rate. The airflow inside the OWC is cyclic, and it varies from minimum
velocity to maximum and vice versa. Hence, it is necessary to have a wider operating
range to improve the energy harvest of the turbine.
Many researchers actively pursued different design modifications to enhance the
operating range of Wells turbine. Raghunathan and Tan [1] introduced a biplane Wells
turbine to improve the stall characteristics. The kinetic energy losses at downstream
of Wells turbine can be reduced by implementing guide vanes. The Wells turbine
with guide vanes also showed improved starting characteristics [2]. The blades with
increased thickness improved starting characteristics [3]. Raghunathan and Beattie
[4] used contra-rotating Wells turbine as an alternative to biplane configuration. They
concluded that contra-rotating is superior to biplane turbine regarding operating
range and efficiency. Webster and Gato [5] optimized blade profile to improve the
stall characteristics. Gato and Webster [6] studied Wells turbine with blade sweep
and guide vanes. They reported an enhanced operating range with reduced efficiency.
The blade with variable chord with guide vanes showed better starting character-
istics [7]. The turbine performance can be improved by modifying blade setting angle
[8]. Takao et al. [9] implemented end plates to improve the performance. Mohamed
et al. [10] performed multi-objective optimization to improve efficiency and tangen-
tial force coefficient. The tangential force and efficiency improved by 8.8% and 1%,
respectively. Shaaban and Hafiz [11] studied the Wells turbine with duct geometry.
The optimized duct geometry enhanced the turbine power and efficiency by 14%
and 9%, respectively. The downstream duct suppressed the interaction of tip leakage
flow (TLF) and the suction side (SS). The nature of the interaction between TLF and
primary flow affects the stall characteristic of Wells turbine. Halder et al. [12, 13]
Combined Casing Groove and Blade Tip Treatment for Wave Energy… 1029
introduced a casing groove treatment to modify the TLF behaviour, thereby delay-
ing stall phenomenon. It improved the turbine power output by 26%. Nazeryan and
Lakzian [14] used a variable thickness blade to weaken the interaction between TLF
and blade SS. The variable thickness blade enhanced torque and operating range.
Kumar et al. [15] used a radiused edge blade tip (REBT) to enhance the stall margin
of Wells turbine. REBT showed weak TLF and primary flow (PF) interaction and
delayed stall.
As explained above, various design modifications are proposed to alter the char-
acteristics of the interaction between TLF and PF. In this study, a combined casing
groove and blade tip (CG&RT) blade are investigated to study their effect on Wells
turbine performance. The performance of the CG&RT blade is computed by solv-
ing steady, and incompressible Reynolds averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) equations
using commercial CFD solver ANSYS CFX 15.0. The performance parameters of
the CG&RT blade are compared with the reference blade. Moreover, the flowfield
analyses has been explained using the post-processed figures.
2 Reference Geometry
The reference geometry was taken from Torresi et al. [16]. Figure 1 shows the Wells
turbine with eight blades. It has a unidirectional rotation for the cyclic airflow because
of the symmetrical blades. Table 1 provides the details of the reference blade.
The reference geometry was CG&RT using CAD software to implement the casing
groove and RETB (Fig. 2). The geometrical parameters for the casing groove were
taken from the study of Halder et al. [12]. The width and depth of the casing groove
were chosen as 40%C and 2%C, respectively. The tip diameter was maintained
1030 P. Madhan Kumar et al.
Shroud 40%C
2%C
1%C
Blade
Fig. 2 Reference (left) and CG&RT (right) geometry
constant for both geometries, and the casing diameter was increased to accommodate
the groove. Additionally, the radius of fillet used in blade is taken as 1%C as suggested
in the work of Kumar et al. [15].
4 Numerical Methodology
Inlet
Shroud
Blade
Hub
Periodic
C
4C interface
Outlet
6C
were created around the blade. The initial cell height was fixed as 1E-5 m to retain
the y + < 1.
The boundary conditions were imposed in ANSYS CFX-Pre. Table 2 provides
the applied boundary conditions, and the simulations were run in ANSYS CFX 15.0.
High-resolution advection scheme with second-order accuracy is used for spatial
discretization. The k-w SST model was chosen as the turbulence model. It employs
k-w model closer to wall and k-ε model far from the wall [17]. Double precision was
enabled for all simulations to minimize the round-off error.
The grid convergence index (GCI) was used to estimate discretization error and
grid convergence. The methodology suggested by Celik et al. [18] is followed to
determine GCI. The GCI can be expressed as
1.25ea21
GCI = p (1)
r21 − 1
The present numerical results were validation against the experimental [19] and
numerical results [20, 16] available in open literature. The non-dimensional flow
Combined Casing Groove and Blade Tip Treatment for Wave Energy… 1033
η, Δp*, T*
η
0.5
0.25 T*
0
0 0.1 0.2 0.3
U*
coefficient U ∗ = UUtipA , torque T ∗ = ρωT2 R 5 , pressure p ∗ = ρω2 Rp 2 and effi-
tip tip
Tω
ciency η = Q p
were chosen as the parameters to describe Wells turbine perfor-
mance. The notation U A is inlet axial velocity (m/s), U tip is tip velocity (m/s), T is
turbine torque (Nm), Q is the volumetric discharge (m3 /s), and p is static pressure
drop (N/m2 ). Figure 4 shows the validation of present numerical results with the
existing results. It can be seen that the present CFD result matches well with the
existing literature.
Figure 5 displays the performance parameters of the reference and the CG&RT blade.
At low U * , the reference blade shows higher torque compared to the CG&RT blade.
However, the reference blade experiences stall at U * = 0.225. On the contrary, the
CG&RT blade stalls at U * = 0.325 and produces higher torque than reference blade at
U * > 0.225. The reduced pressure drop in the CG&RT blade explains the decreased
torque output. Similarly, the reference blade exhibits higher efficiency compared
to CG&RT blade up to U * = 0.225, and later it reduces due to stall condition.
Furthermore, the CG&RT blade enhanced the relative stall margin and peak torque
by 44.4% and 23.8%, respectively.
Figure 6 shows the pressure coefficient (Cp) distribution at blade midspan for dif-
ferent flow coefficients (U * ). The area enclosed by the Cp curve provides the lift
force. At low U * = 0.075, area of the Cp curve is small, which indicates lesser
1034
0.25
Reference Reference
0.2 CG&RT 0.9 CG&RT
0.15
0.6
T*
Δp*
0.1
0.3
0.05
0 0
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4
U* U*
0.6 Reference
CG&RT
0.4
η
0.2
0.0
0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4
U*
0.0
Cp
-1.0 Reference
CG&RT
-2.0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
X/C
U*=0.07
2.5
-0.5
Cp
-3.5
-6.5 Reference
Reduced blade loading CG&RT
-9.5
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
X/C
U*=0.22
2.5
-0.5
-3.5
Cp
Stall
-6.5 Reference
CG&RT
-9.5
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
X/C
U*=0.2
torque. As the U * increases, the area enclosed by Cp curves increases which signi-
fies lift increase. As revealed in Fig. 6, the reference blade shows higher pressure
variation at blade leading edge (LE) compared to the CG&RT blade. The reduced
suction at the CG&RT blade explains the decreased torque shown in Fig. 5. At U *
= 0.225, the suction pressure at LE increases for both blades. However, the CG&RT
blade shows reduced blade loading near the LE and trailing edge (TE). To generate
1036 P. Madhan Kumar et al.
maximum torque, the enclosed Cp curve area should be higher, and the CG&RT
blade shows reduced area and consequently reduced torque compared to reference
blade. At increased U * (0.275), for the reference blade, the suction peak vanishes
and the pressure distribution is almost same along the chord. It implies stall condi-
tion because of the flow separation. In contrast, the CG&RT blade shows increased
suction pressure and higher torque.
Figure 7 displays the Cp contour at blade midspan for different U * . At U * =
0.075, a maximum pressure region is visible near the blade LE for both blades. The
CG&RT blade exhibits reduced pressure at blade LE compared to the reference blade.
It can be noticed that the high pressure region at blade LE shifts towards the TE with
increase in U * . At U * = 0.225, the pressure difference at blade LE is higher for the
reference blade compared to the CG&RT blade, and it corroborates the results shown
in Fig. 6. At U * = 0.275, for reference blade, a low-pressure region engulfs the blade
SS, and it signifies flow separation due to adverse pressure gradient. In contrast, in
CG&RT blade the low-pressure region is confined near the blade LE and produces
higher torque compared to reference blade.
Figure 8 illustrates the axial velocity distribution along the normalized span at
blade LE location. At U * = 0.075, the CG&RT blade shows reduced axial velocity at
hub and tip in contrast to the reference blade. The decreased axial velocity reduces the
U*=0.075
U*=0.275
Cp [-]
Combined Casing Groove and Blade Tip Treatment for Wave Energy… 1037
Normalized span
0.75
0.5
0.25
Reference
CG&RT Hub
0
0 5 10 15 20
Axial velocity [m/s]
U*=0.075
1
0.75
Normalized span
0.5
0.25
Reference
CG&RT
0
0 10 20 30 40 50
Axial velocity [m/s]
U*=0.225
1
Normalized span
0.75
0.5
0.25 Reference
CG&RT
0
0 10 20 30 40 50
Axial velocity [m/s]
U*=0.275
relative velocity and angle of attack which reduces the torque generated as shown in
Fig. 5. The casing groove modification is the reason behind the reduced axial velocity
near tip in the CG&RT blade. Moreover, the axial velocity increases with an increase
in U * . At U * = 0.225, the axial velocity increases for both blades and the CG&RT
blade shows reduced axial velocity compared to the reference case. Furthermore, at
1038 P. Madhan Kumar et al.
U * = 0.275, the reference blade shows increased axial velocity near the tip, and it
indicates stall. Higher axial velocity produces a high angle of attack which signifies
flow separation. In contrast, the CG&RT blade shows reduced axial velocity, and it
is responsible for the delayed stall.
Figure 9 displays the tip leakage vortex at the blade mid-chord section for various
U * . The TLF occurs owing to the pressure variation between the pressure side (PS)
and SS of the tip. Consequently, it rolls into a vortex on the blade SS known as
PS SS
Hub
Tip leakage vortex Tip leakage vortex
U*=0.075
tip leakage vortex. At U * = 0.075, a clockwise tip leakage vortex is visible on the
SS of blade tip for both blades. As revealed in figure, the strength of tip leakage
vortex increases with U * . The behavior of tip leakage vortex in the CG&RT blade
is altered due to the casing groove and radiused edge tip. At U * = 0.275, the tip
leakage vortex breakdowns in reference blade and the increases the blockage causing
stall. The presence of severe adverse pressure gradient causes the tip leakage vortex
breakdown. In contrast, the tip leakage vortex is stable in the CG&RT blade. It is
confined near the blade tip and offers less blockage to the primary flow. Moreover,
the casing groove increases TLF, and it explains the reduced efficiency (Fig. 5) as
the fluid passing through the tip clearance will not contribute to energy extraction.
Furthermore, coupled with the casing groove and the radiused edge tip can be done
to alleviate the decrement in efficiency.
6 Conclusion
The numerical investigation of Wells turbine with casing groove and radius edge
tip was presented in this study. The problem was solved in ANSYS CFX 15.0,
and the performance parameters obtained were compared with the reference blade.
Moreover, the pressure coefficient, axial velocity distribution and tip leakage vortex
were analysed. The prominent conclusions drawn were listed below.
• The blade with casing groove and radiused edge tip showed a wider operating
range and enhance power output.
• The relative peak torque and stall margin were enhanced by 44.4% and 23.8%,
respectively.
• The CG&RT blade displayed reduced axial velocity at the tip which decreased
the relative velocity and angle of attack, thereby delaying stall.
• Moreover, optimization of the combined casing groove and radiused edge tip
parameters should be performed for further performance enhancement.
References
6. Gato LMC, Webster M (2001) An experimental investigation into the effect of rotor blade
sweep on the performance of the variable-pitch Wells turbine. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part A J
Power Energy 215(5):611–622
7. Govardhan M, Chauhan VS (2007) Numerical studies on performance improvement of self-
rectifying air turbine for wave energy conversion. Eng Appl Comput Fluid Mech 1(1):57–70
8. Kaneko K, Setoguchi T, Santhakumar S, Takao M, Kim TH (2003) A modified Wells turbine
for wave energy conversion. Renew Energy 28(1):79–91
9. Takao M, Setoguchi T, Kinoue Y, Kaneko K (2007) Wells turbine with end plates for wave
energy conversion. Ocean Eng 34(11–12):1790–1795
10. Mohamed MH, Janiga G, Pap E, Thevenin D (2011) Multi-objective optimization of the airfoil
shape of Wells turbine used for wave energy conversion. Energy 36(1):438–446
11. Shaaban S, Hafiz AA (2012) Effect of duct geometry on Wells turbine performance. Energy
Convers Manag 61:51–58
12. Halder P, Samad A, Kim JH, Choi YS (2015) High performance ocean energy harvesting
turbine design—a new casing treatment scheme. Energy 86:219–231
13. Halder P, Samad A (2015) Casing treatment of a wave energy extracting turbine. Aquatic
Procedia 4:516–521
14. Nazeryan M, Lakzian E (2018) Detailed entropy generation analysis of a Wells turbine using
the variation of the blade thickness. Energy 143:385–405
15. Kumar PM, Halder P, Samad A (2018) Performance analysis of Wells turbine with radiused
blade tip. In: ASME 2018 37th international conference on ocean, offshore and arctic
engineering. OMAE2018, pp 1–10
16. Torresi M, Camporeale SM, Strippoli PD, Pascazio G (2008) Accurate numerical simulation
of a high solidity Wells turbine. Renew Energy 33(4):735–747
17. Menter FR (1994) Two-equation eddy-viscosity turbulence models for engineering applica-
tions. AIAA J 32(8):1598–1605
18. Celik IB, Ghia U, Roache PJ, Freitas CJ, Coleman H, Raad PE (2008) Procedure for estimation
and reporting of uncertainty due to discretization in CFD applications. J Fluids Eng 130(7)
19. Curran R, Gato LMC (1997) The energy conversion performance of several types of Wells
turbine designs. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part A J Power Energy 211(2):133–145
20. Torresi BFM, Camporeale SM, Pascazio G (2004) Fluid dynamic analysis low solidity Wells
turbine, 59 Congresso ATI, Genvo, Italy, pp 277–288
Design and Development of Wind Tunnel
to Study Smoldering Combustion
1 Introduction
smoldering. The reduction in the smoldering rate in the recirculation zone is due
to the reduction of mass of the oxidizer. Bar-Ilan [5] did an experiment on small
polyurethane foam to study the transition phenomenon of forward smoldering to
flaming. The experiment was carried out on the polyurethane foam in order to find
the velocity flow effect, oxygen concentration and the radiation flux on the transition
at microgravity and low gravity environment. The samples of small size are selected
because the smoldering combustion can self-propagate as the heat is lost to the
environment. The experiments are carried out in a wind tunnel where the fuel is
placed vertically. The lateral sides of the three samples were maintained at some
peak temperature whereas the other three sides were maintained to the upward flow
and radiation flux. From these experiments, it was found that there is a delay in
the transition of smoldering to flaming by decreasing the flow velocity, and also by
increasing the concentration of oxygen and radiation flux. They concluded that the
transition can occur in the char region that was left behind by the smoldering reaction
with the appropriate external conditions.
Buoyancy, Turbulence, and Combustion in Fire Field Modeling were discussed
by Gao et al. [6]. The main purpose of this study was to known the effect of buoyancy,
turbulence and combustion on the fire field model, for example, a test section in the
form of the compartment with a window in the side and door in front. Simulations
were carried out using Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD). Two cases were stud-
ied under different operating conditions. Case A simulations were carried out with
fire at the center of the room. Case B simulations were carried out at the corner of
the room. Both cases were compared. The flame height is determined by knowing
whether the fuel is burnt or not. The results from case B showed that because of the
closed surface area the flame is height is more thereby increasing the upper ceiling
temperature. In Case A, the flame height is less and doesn’t reach the ceiling as the
combustion propagates uniformly in all directions. They concluded that this is the
reason for the combustion reactions to take place at the ceiling where the heat release
rates are higher.
Schult et al. [7] did a study on porous material to know the propagation and
extinction of smoldering waves caused by the opposed flow that was artificially
generated. The main reason to use porous material is to allow the mixture of gas
(oxygen and nitrogen) to flow through the pores which are present in the porous
material. The cylindrical samples are considered where the gases are allowed to flow
through one end. In the other end, smolder wave is initiated and it flows in the opposite
direction to the flow of the oxidizer. In this paper, they have used graphical methods
to learn about uniform propagation and smolder wave solutions. These results were
compared with the experimental results which were taken by the same author in
his other paper. The analytical results in this paper showed that the propagation
velocity increases with an increase in mass flow rate which perfectly fits with the
experimental results. Stocker et al. [8] did smoldering combustion experiments on
flexible polyurethane foam in microgravity. The experiments were carried out in both
microgravity and normal gravity and the results were compared. Four cases were
conducted by varying the shapes and the environment both for micro and normal
gravity. In this experiment temperature was measured along with the fuel sample at
1044 S. Sanjana et al.
different locations, the video recording was done and post analyses were done on
the char and gas composition. They found that heat loss was less in microgravity
due to no natural convection in microgravity. This resulted in an increase in ignition
temperature in the microgravity. They concluded that the burning of polyurethane
foam gave rise to combustion products like carbon monoxide which is hazardous in
space.
Hadden [9] did a study on the initiation of smoldering combustion and its spread
in peat. The experimental study was done on the vertical samples of peatlands. The
top surface of the sample was ignited by the radiation so that the smoldering com-
bustion propagates downward in the direction opposite to the flow of oxidizer. The
experiments were carried by varying the ignition conditions and the oxygen con-
centrations. The pyrolysis reaction and the oxidation reactions are the parameters
focused in this paper. The char is formed in the pyrolysis oxidation and the char is
converted into ash in the oxidation reactions. It was found that the smoldering front
thickness depends mainly on the low mass flow rate and the mass of the leftover
residues. The wider smoldering front is required to sustain the smoldering combus-
tion. They concluded that the decreased oxygen concentration environment with less
mass flow rate is required to avoid fire accidents. Sato et al. [10] conducted an experi-
ment on cellulosic powder material to study the smoldering spread. The experimental
set up involved a high bulk density cellulosic powder bed over which a stream of air
was supplied in order to study the smolder spread in a horizontal layer. The results
involved the 2D structure of a spread zone, spread rate, cross-sectional views of the
burning region and temperature distributions. From this experiment, it was observed
that the forward smoldering increases the velocity of the air and also increases the
spread rate of the fuel. But above a certain value of the airstream velocity, the spread
rate becomes independent and the smolder zone disappears. From experimental data,
it is found that the balance of heat between the oxidation zone and unburnt part of
the fuel bed is important to the behavior of smoldering spread. They also concluded
that the aerodynamic effects and heat transfer control the behavior of spread rate
over the smolder zone. The design and construction of wind tunnel were made to
understand the combustion better and the behavior of smolder under the influence
of forced flow effect by taking different parameters, i.e., shaped of fuel, different
airspeeds, different sample holders and also the introduction of flow visualization to
study the aerodynamic behavior of the different shapes under smoldering.
The tabletop wind tunnel was initially designed using CATIA V5. The detailed design
was carried out in order to give a clear picture of the fabrication process. The finalized
CAD design of the tabletop wind tunnel is seen in the Figs. 1, 2 and 3.
Design and Development of Wind Tunnel to Study Smoldering… 1045
The whole length of the wind tunnel is 129 cm and the maximum width is about
29 cm for the inlet to fix the axial fan and 20 cm uniform length for other sections.
Inlet, contraction cone, flow conditioning unit, test section, and outlet are the different
sections of the wind tunnel. Special attention was given on the turbulence intensity,
uniformity, and flow control.
1046 S. Sanjana et al.
The axial fan is fixed with the speed regulator of 5 speeds that allow the airflow to
flow in an axial direction. The fan draws the air from the environment and blows
into the wind tunnel. The speed reaches up to 4.7 m/s. The fan rotates to produce
a pressure difference across it as the flow is axial in both entry and exit. The axial
flow fan used in the present work helps in producing the flow inside the wind tunnel
(Fig. 4).
This facilitates in studying the effect of both the laminar and turbulent flow on
the smoldering combustion. The static rise is produced in order to compensate for
the total pressure in the wind tunnel.
The contraction cone is the second part of the tabletop wind tunnel used to study the
smoldering combustion. The contraction cone is used to accelerate the flow and allow
the flow to pass into the test section. This section effectively reduces the velocity
variation and helps in maintaining the flow uniformity across the length of the wind
tunnel. The decrease in the area along the length of the contraction cone helps in
increasing and decreasing velocity and pressure respectively.
Design and Development of Wind Tunnel to Study Smoldering… 1047
Flow conditioning unit is used to straighten the air that was drawn from the surround-
ing environment and it is also used to channel the ambient air into the test section.
It comprises of mesh and honeycomb structures. The flow conditioning unit reduces
the turbulence of the air. The main purpose of the mesh is to avoid unnecessary
items to enter the tunnel. There are different types of honeycomb structures used
in the low-speed wind tunnel. For example, honeycomb structures with a circular
cross-section, rectangular cross-section and hexagonal cross-section. The type of
honeycomb structure used in the present work is of the circular cross-section. The
cells are aligned in such a manner that it is in the streamwise direction. The honey-
comb structures reduce the transverse velocity of the flow by reducing the pressure
loss (Figs. 5 and 6).
The test section is the basic and most important component of the wind tunnel. The
incense materials of different shapes are placed inside the test section of the wind
tunnel to study the effect of flow over them. The test section of the rectangular cross-
section is used in this paper. The test section is provided with necessary facilities
1048 S. Sanjana et al.
Fig. 6 Mesh
like glass for visual ability, laser light for flow illumination, sample holder, digital
microscope as a camera, LED light and a black screen to capture clear images (Fig. 7).
The fabrication of the tabletop wind tunnel was done using wood of thickness
180 mm, nuts, bolts, nails, glass in the test section, mesh and straws for honey-
comb structures. Woodcutter, tape measures, hammer, chisel, nail gun, and clamps
are some of the tools used in the fabrication process. The fan is the basic component
with respect to which the design and fabrication were done. The contraction cone
was the difficult part to fabricate and it was fabricated so that the fan is installed in
such a manner that no vibration takes place. Similarly, the flow conditioning unit and
the outlet were fabricated. Intense care was taken in fabricating the test section of
the tabletop wind tunnel as it was fabricated using glass. The parts were fabricated in
such a way that the parts can be dismantled for easier transportation, to upgrade the
modification of tunnel for various experiments and installed for the experimentation
(Fig. 8).
The schematic diagram (see Fig. 9) gives a clear picture of experimental set up used
to visualize the effect of flow on the smoldering combustion. The laser light of green
color helps in flow visualization inside the wind tunnel test section. The camera used
is a digital microscope that is connected to the computer to record the video.
A sudden impact of the flow on the solid object, when placed in 90°, may not withstand
the flow and can create a disturbance. In order to avoid such circumstances, the ramp
(see Fig. 10) was placed inside the test section of the wind tunnel to develop a smooth
1050 S. Sanjana et al.
boundary layer. The different types of sample holders were used for different sample
shapes. Three possible cases were employed inside the test section to carry out the
experimentations. They were along with the flow, transverse to the flow and against
the flow. The angle can be varied by using the string as shown in (see Fig. 13). The
velocity inside the test section was measured using the vent anemometer. The width
of the test section was used, and the Reynolds number had been calculated for the
test section (Figs. 11, 12, 13 and 14) (Table 1).
The tabletop wind tunnel was initially designed using CATIA and then fabricated
using different materials and tools. Axial fan, contraction cone, flow conditioning
unit, test section, and outlet are the components of the wind tunnel used. The com-
ponents of the tabletop wind tunnel were fabricated separately and then assembled
to perform experiments. The incense materials with different shapes were used for
the study. Sample holders based on different orientations and shapes were used. The
experimentations were carried under normal gravity conditions (21% oxygen). The
fabricated tabletop wind tunnel was used to study the effect of laminar and turbulent
flow on the smoldering combustion using incense material. Five different fan speeds
were employed over a burning incense material that was placed along with the flow,
transverse to the flow and against the flow. The material is marked at regular intervals
Design and Development of Wind Tunnel to Study Smoldering… 1051
of fixed distance each along the whole length. The regression rates were calculated.
The results obtained from the forced flow smoldering combustion experiments were
compared with the results of natural smoldering combustion experiments. The nat-
ural smoldering combustion results were taken for three different orientations. They
were vertical (90°), horizontal (180°), and inverted (270°). In conclusion, the tabletop
wind tunnel was successfully designed and developed to study the effects of forced
flow on the smoldering combustion. The burn rates of the fuel calculated were used
to predict how smoldering combustion is more harmful than normal combustion. In
addition, the tabletop wind tunnel can be used to conduct furthermore experiments
1052 S. Sanjana et al.
Fig. 14 Sample holders with burning incense materials inside the test section
to analyze and avoid the causes of residential fires, industrial fires, forest fires, rocket
fires, and building fires.
Acknowledgements The authors acknowledge the usage of Flow Visualization Laboratory present
in the Department of Aerospace Engineering, SRM Institute of Science and Technology (SRMIST)
for the experiments performed towards the present research work.
1054 S. Sanjana et al.
References
Abstract Land suitability analysis for renewable energy (RE) plants is gradually
becoming multidisciplinary. The integration of Geographical Information System
(GIS) with Multi-Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) tools has proven effective in
such studies. From the trend in the literature, both experts in GIS and non-experts use
these tools. There exist several factors that determine the suitability of a site for an
intended purpose. In this study, factors specific to the reliability and accuracy of the
results of GIS-MCDM approach to siting RE plants are reviewed. The reliability of
the results from this integrated tool is hinged on the accuracy of principal milestones
in the analysis. Four of these were identified in this article: data integrity, sensitivity
analysis, correct use of tools, criteria weight assignment. It was concluded that apart
from the identified dots in achieving high reliability and accuracy of the suitability
analysis, ground verification is highly essential as this helps to verify the reality of
the seemingly virtual analysis.
1 Introduction
Spatial location of renewable energy (RE) plants largely depends on the availability
of sources, which is a geospatial variant and as such vary from one geographical
location to another. Asides climatic factors, RE facility location problem depends on
other criteria, like economic, technological, social, and physiological factors [1–3].
judgement, weighting factors used, inherent variability in the model used [39, 40].
However, in reality, criteria for suitability analysis of a RE plant are inexhaustible.
Attempts are often made by modellers to cover critical factors, that largely influence
RE facility location.
1058 P. A. Adedeji et al.
Data integrity emphasizes data accuracy and consistency in quality and recency.
The recency of the geospatial data either raster or vector plays a significant role in
the reliability of the suitable sites obtained for RE plant. The advent of GIS as a
potent tool for spatial analysis has led to the proliferation of geographic databases
globally. Individual data creator also makes efforts in populating these databases
with digital maps of physical features and attributes; an example is raster files for
road networks, places, locations, etc. The accuracy of these data, the expertise and
integrity of the data creator is highly significant to the reliability of the study which
uses the data. Government organizations also populate databases for public use. They
often update these data with recent developments about the geospatial location of
features. The analysis which makes use of data from trusted database (e.g. national
database) however, without recency may likely falsify the results of land suitability
analysis of RE plants. For example, protected areas in the database of a year may
not be completely accurate for a study in the next year. Certain areas may have been
considered as non-protected areas due to political or anthropogenic activities. The
recency of the data reveals the present status of surfaces or features.
Data quality, on the other hand, depends on several factors among which is data
projection. Incorrect projection of the data presents the wrong spatial location of the
site. Geospatial data used for spatial analysis are obtained from metadata, which is
either in the form of raster or vector [41]. These metadata contain information that
describes the data like the projection (either spherical or projected coordinate system).
The quality of the input data into a model determines the quality and reliability of
its output [39].
Spatial Location of Renewable Energy Plants: How Good Is Good … 1059
Aside tractability and feasibility, a good model is expected to be robust, which sensi-
tivity analysis constitutes one of the tools in achieving this. As part of good modelling
practice, it is expected that a modeller gives a level of confidence to which the model
efficiently represents the system [39]. Sensitivity analysis helps to account for inac-
curacy, ambiguity, and imprecision of GIS-multi-criteria evaluation process [42] and
also enhances understanding of land suitability results for informed decision making
[43]. It is a related practice to uncertainty analysis, and it is aimed at identifying
principal inputs significantly responsible for output variations [44]. Many empirical
facility location models follow this trend. However, few GIS integrated models, espe-
cially in RE plant consider this. Sensitivity analysis in spatial models differs from
that of analytical and other empirical models due to the nature of the data. There
are several methods, which have been developed over the years for performing sen-
sitivity analysis on spatial models. Some of these are extensively discussed in [39,
45, 46]. However, in RE farm site suitability problems, a pixel by pixel validation
to ensure satisfactory results is sometimes used. Here, a cadastral plot is selected at
random and exported as a single layer, where a similar process of adding factors to its
attribute table is performed [18]. The result is compared with the main analysis for
consistency. The simple weighted model aggregate scoring method of essential fac-
tors of influence is also commonly used in RE plant suitability analysis. This method
is efficient in RE plant land suitability analysis because sometimes, the suitability of
a site for RE farm may be due to an aggregate of trivial factors rather than crucial
and technical factors [47]. Sensitivity analysis in RE farm location also enables the
modeller to identify principal factors, which aggregates to the ranking score. This
analysis is highly essential before actual ground verification.
GIS software like the ArcMap is multi-functional and so contains many tools, which
can be harnessed for geospatially related problems in many fields. The choice of
an appropriate tool for each analysis determines the validity and reliability of the
results. For example, in determining land suitability for a RE plant using GIS-MCDM
approach, several criteria are considered to ensure that the proposed site for the plant
does not interfere with physical or environmental features. To ensure this, exclusion
rules are developed with specific distances from physical features of significance
to the study [7, 14]. Exclusion criteria use inequalities, which require it been care-
fully specified using appropriate tools. A commonly used distance function is the
Euclidean distance. This calculates a straight-line distance from one point to another
as a crow would fly. It has found usefulness in the RE land suitability analysis in
the specification of distance from criteria like waterways, roads, seismic, volcanic
1060 P. A. Adedeji et al.
faults [2, 18, 48], etc. The Euclidean distance tool contains several fields like max-
imum distance. The maximum distance displays raster files with subclasses to the
maximum distance specified. Further exclusion criteria with distances greater than
the already specified distance do become irresponsive to such criteria. Incorrect use
of tools as such may lead to misleading results and wrong location for RE plant.
3 Conclusions
It is observed in the recent decade that studies on suitability analysis for RE plants
using GIS-MCDM as a tool is gradually becoming multidisciplinary. This study,
therefore, focused on specific milestones in the analysis, which contributes to the
reliability and credibility of results obtained. The study discussed the relevance of
data integrity with a focus on obtaining recent data from credible sources. We also
established the importance of sensitivity analysis and the use of appropriate tools
in ensuring the reliability of the result. Effort is being made to reduce subjectivity
in transforming qualitative variables to quantitative equivalence based on experts’
knowledge. The study identified Eigen matrix method with singularity of the trace
elements as a method of ensuring consistency in subjective to the objective transfor-
mation process. Asides these identified dots in achieving high reliability and accuracy
of the results, ground verification is highly essential as this helps to verify the reality
of the seemingly virtual analysis.
References
1. Janke JR (2010) Multicriteria GIS modeling of wind and solar farms in Colorado. Renew
Energy 35:2228–2234. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.renene.2010.03.014
2. Villacreses G, Gaona G, Martínez-Gómez J, Jijón DJ (2017) Wind farms suitability loca-
tion using geographical information system (GIS), based on multi-criteria decision making
(MCDM) methods: the case of continental Ecuador. Renew Energy 109:275–286. https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.renene.2017.03.041
3. Palmer D, Gottschalg R, Betts T (2018) The future scope of large-scale solar in the UK :
site suitability and target analysis. Renew Energy 2018:1–11. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.renene.
2018.08.109
4. Bonham-Carter GF (1994) Geographical information systems for geoscientists: modeling with
GIS. Comput methods Geosci vol 13, New York: Pergamon
5. Noorollahi Y, Itoi R (2007) Geothermal power plant site selection with environmental
consideration in Namafjall area, North Iceland. Trans Geotherm Resour Counc 31:193–198
6. Moghaddam MK, Meentemeyer RK, Samadzadegan F, Sharifi MA, Itoi R (2013) Spatial data
analysis for exploration of regional scale geothermal resources. J Volcanol Geotherm Res 266
7. Noorollahi Y, Yousefi H, Mohammadi M (2016) Multi-criteria decision support system for
wind farm site selection using GIS. Sustain Energy Technol Assess 13:38–50. https://doi.org/
10.1016/j.seta.2015.11.007
8. Iyengar JV (1998) Application of geographical information systems. J Int Inf Manag 7
9. Case C, Hawthorne TL (2013) Served or unserved? A site suitability analysis of social services
in Atlanta, Georgia using geographic information systems. Appl Geogr 38:96–106. https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.apgeog.2012.11.012
10. Calvert K, Mabee W (2015) More solar farms or more bioenergy crops? Mapping and assessing
potential land-use conflicts among renewable energy technologies in eastern Ontario, Canada.
Appl Geogr 56:209–221. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apgeog.2014.11.028
11. Castro-santos L, Prado G, Sim T (2019) Planning of the installation of offshore renewable
energies : a GIS approach of the Portuguese roadmap. 132:1251–1262. https://doi.org/10.1016/
j.renene.2018.09.031
1062 P. A. Adedeji et al.
12. Tien Bui D, Pradhan B, Lofman O, Revhaug I, Dick OB (2012) Landslide susceptibility map-
ping at Hoa Binh province (Vietnam) using an adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system and GIS.
Comput Geosci 45:199–211. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cageo.2011.10.031
13. Boulos MNK (2004) Towards evidence-based, GIS-driven national spatial health Kingdom vol
50, pp 1–50
14. Atici KB, Simsek AB, Ulucan A, Tosun MU (2015) A GIS-based multiple criteria decision
analysis approach for wind power plant site selection. Util Policy 37:86–96. https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.jup.2015.06.001
15. Al-Yahyai S, Charabi Y, Gastli A, Al-Badi A (2012) Wind farm land suitability indexing using
multi-criteria analysis. Renew Energy 44:80–87. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.renene.2012.01.004
16. Ali S, Taweekun J, Techato K, Waewsak J, Gyawali S (2019) GIS based site suitability assess-
ment for wind and solar farms in Songkhla, Thailand. Renew Energy 132:1360–1372. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.renene.2018.09.035
17. Bili A, Vagiona DG (2018) Use of multicriteria analysis and GIS for selecting sites or onshore
wind farms: the case of Andros Island (Greece). Eur J Environ Sci 8:5–13
18. Sánchez-Lozano JM, Teruel-Solano J, Soto-Elvira PL, Socorro García-Cascales M (2013)
Geographical information systems (GIS) and multi-criteria decision making (MCDM) methods
for the evaluation of solar farms locations: case study in south–eastern Spain. Renew Sustain
Energy Rev 24:544–556. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2013.03.019
19. Kiavarz M, Jelokhani-Niaraki M (2017) Geothermal prospectivity mapping using GIS-based
ordered weighted averaging approach: a case study in Japan’s Akita and Iwate provinces.
Geothermics 70:295–304. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geothermics.2017.06.015
20. Kiavarz M, Samadzadegan F, Noorollahi Y (2014) Geothermics Spatial analysis and multi-
criteria decision making for regional-scale geothermal favorability map. Geothermics 50:189–
201. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geothermics.2013.09.004
21. Alsuhaibani Z, Hepbasli A (2013) Environmental effects future aspects of geothermal energy
in Saudi Arabia. Energy Sources Part A Recover Util Environ Eff 7036. https://doi.org/10.
1080/15567036.2010.497805
22. Watts MD (1987) Geothermal exploration of Roccamonfina volcano, Italy. Geothermics
16:517–528
23. Yalcin M, Kilic GF (2017) A GIS-based multi criteria decision analysis approach for exploring
geothermal resources: Akarcay basin (Afyonkarahisar). Geothermics 67:18–28. https://doi.org/
10.1016/j.geothermics.2017.01.002
24. Ahmadi H, Shamsai A, Storage P, Selection S (2009) Preliminary site selection of pumped
storage hydropower plants—a GIS-based approach. AUT J Model Simul 2009:25–32
25. Perpiña C, Martínez-Llario JC, Pérez-Navarro Á (2013) Multicriteria assessment in GIS envi-
ronments for siting biomass plants. Land Use Policy 31:326–335. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
landusepol.2012.07.014
26. Sahoo K, Mani S, Das L, Bettinger P (2018) GIS-based assessment of sustainable crop residues
for optimal siting of biogas plants. Biomass Bioenerg 110:63–74. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
biombioe.2018.01.006
27. Thompson E, Wang Q, Li M (2013) Anaerobic digester systems (ADS) for multiple dairy
farms: a GIS analysis for optimal site selection. Energy Policy 61:114–124. https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.enpol.2013.06.035
28. Brahma A, Saikia K, Hiloidhari M, Baruah DC (2016) GIS based planning of a biomethanation
power plant in Assam, India. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 62:596–608. https://doi.org/10.1016/
j.rser.2016.05.009
29. Uyan M (2013) GIS-based solar farms site selection using analytic hierarchy process (AHP)
in Karapinar region Konya/Turkey. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 28:11–17. https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.rser.2013.07.042
30. Asakereh A, Soleymani M, Sheikhdavoodi MJ (2017) A GIS-based Fuzzy-AHP method for
the evaluation of solar farms locations: case study in Khuzestan province, Iran. Sol Energy
155:342–353. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.solener.2017.05.075
Spatial Location of Renewable Energy Plants: How Good Is Good … 1063
31. Bhandari B, Lee KT, Lee CS, Song CK, Maskey RK, Ahn SH (2014) A novel off-grid hybrid
power system comprised of solar photovoltaic, wind, and hydro energy sources. Appl Energy
133:236–242. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2014.07.033
32. Cebi S, Ilbahar E, Atasoy A (2016) A fuzzy information axiom based method to determine the
optimal location for a biomass power plant: a case study in Aegean region of Turkey. Energy
116:894–907. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2016.10.024
33. Kabu IK (2016) Wind farm site selection assessment in the greater Accra, Volta and Eastern
Regions of Ghana : a GIS spatial multi-criteria assessment 2016
34. Chen CR, Huang CC, Tsuei HJ (2014) A hybrid MCDM model for improving GIS-based solar
farms site selection. Int J Photoenergy 2014. https://doi.org/10.1155/2014/925370
35. Franco C, Bojesen M, Hougaard JL, Nielsen K (2015) A fuzzy approach to a multiple criteria
and geographical information system for decision support on suitable locations for biogas
plants. Appl Energy 140:304–315. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2014.11.060
36. Höhn J, Lehtonen E, Rasi S, Rintala J (2014) A geographical information system (GIS) based
methodology for determination of potential biomasses and sites for biogas plants in southern
Finland. Appl Energy 113:1–10. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2013.07.005
37. Noorollahi Y, Itoi R, Fujii H, Tanaka T (2008) GIS integration model for geothermal exploration
and well siting. Geothermics 37:107–131. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geothermics.2007.12.001
38. Setiawan D (2015) Potential sites screening for mini hydro power plant development in Kapuas
Hulu, West Kalimantan: a GIS approach. Energy Procedia 65:76–82. https://doi.org/10.1016/
j.egypro.2015.01.034
39. Crosetto M, Tarantola S, Saltelli A (2000) Sensitivity and uncertainty analysis in spatial
modelling based on GIS. Agric Ecosyst Environ 81:71–79. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0167-
8809(00)00169-9
40. Crosetto M, Tarantola S (2001) Uncertainty and sensitivity analysis: tools for GIS-based model
implementation. Int J Geogr Inf Sci 15:415–437. https://doi.org/10.1080/13658810110053125
41. Gigović L, Pamučar D, Božanić D, Ljubojević S (2017) Application of the GIS-DANP-MABAC
multi-criteria model for selecting the location of wind farms: a case study of Vojvodina. Serbia
Renew Energy 103:501–521. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.renene.2016.11.057
42. Malczewski J (2004) GIS-based land-use suitability analysis: a critical overview. Prog Plann
62:3–65. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.progress.2003.09.002
43. Xu E, Zhang H (2013) Spatially-explicit sensitivity analysis for land suitability evaluation.
Appl Geogr 45:1–9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apgeog.2013.08.005
44. Mavromatidis G, Orehounig K, Carmeliet J (2018) A review of uncertainty characterisation
approaches for the optimal design of distributed energy systems. Renew Sustain Energy Rev
88:258–277. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2018.02.021
45. Bonin O (2006) Sensitivity analysis and uncertainty analysis for vector geographical applica-
tions. 7th Int Symp Spat Accuracy Assess Nat Resour Environ Sci 319–328
46. Feizizadeh B, Blaschke T (2014) An uncertainty and sensitivity analysis approach for GIS-
based multicriteria landslide susceptibility mapping. Int J Geogr Inf Sci 28:610–638. https://
doi.org/10.1080/13658816.2013.869821
47. Cevallos-Sierra J, Ramos-Martin J (2018) Spatial assessment of the potential of renewable
energy: the case of ecuador. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 81:1154–1165. https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.rser.2017.08.015
48. Al Garni HZ, Awasthi A (2017) Solar PV power plant site selection using a GIS-AHP based
approach with application in Saudi Arabia. Appl Energy 206:1225–1240. https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.apenergy.2017.10.024
49. Sule D (2001) Logistics of facility location and allocation. vol 20010505. https://doi.org/10.
1201/9780203910405
50. Feizizadeh B, Blaschke T (2013) GIS-multicriteria decision analysis for landslide susceptibility
mapping: comparing three methods for the Urmia lake basin. Iran Nat Hazards 65:2105–2128
1064 P. A. Adedeji et al.
51. Miller A, Li R (2014) A geospatial approach for prioritizing wind farm development in North-
east Nebraska, USA. ISPRS Int J Geo-Inf 3:968–979. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijgi3030968
52. Kazak J, van Hoof J, Szewranski S (2017) Challenges in the wind turbines location process
in Central Europe—the use of spatial decision support systems. Renew Sustain Energy Rev
76:425–433. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2017.03.039
Analysis of Pendulum-Based Nonlinear
Energy Sink for Energy Harvesting
Pradeep V. Malaji
Abstract Passive method is one of the best-suited methods for vibration reduction
of the primary structure. Energy harvesting converts vibration energy into useful
electrical energy which can be used to power up sensors used for monitoring. Non-
linear energy sinks (NES) are analyzed to passively reduce vibration of the structure
as well as energy harvesting simultaneously in this article. Current work considers
the applicability of common pendulum as the NES for mitigation linear primary
structure and electromagnetic energy conversion. It is observed that the pendulum
NES can overcome one of the main limitations of conventional tuned mass damper
(TMD) designs, as it has the capability to mitigate primary structure excitation and
harvest electrical energy over a wide range. This is because the pendulum has the
capability to operate both in linear and nonlinear zones that can be utilized into a
resonance of the primary oscillator. For small input excitation, the pendulum acts as
a conventional tuned mass damper. However, for larger energy input, the pendulum
acts in the nonlinear zone as NES to reduce primary mass vibration. Thus, a pen-
dulum can dissipate energies in a relatively broad spectrum. This article presents a
numerical analysis of pendulum NES for control and energy harvesting.
1 Introduction
P. V. Malaji (B)
BLDEA’s V P Dr. P G Halakatti College of Engineering and Technology, Vijayapur, Karnataka
586103, India
e-mail: pradeepmalaji@gmail.com
This paper has been divided into four sections. Section 2 describes the NES
harvester model with mathematical equations used for the simulations. Section 3
deals with the results and discussion followed by summarizing and providing the
relevant and observed conclusions in Sect. 4.
2 System Model
The system model is shown in Fig. 1. The primary system has mass M, damping c1
and linear stiffness k. The pendulum is mounted on the primary mass with provision
for electromagnetic conversion due to pendulum oscillation when primary system is
subjected to support excitation x g . It has mass m, mechanical and electrical damping
c2m and c2e, respectively, and length l.
Lagrangian of the system in terms of potential and kinetic energy is written as,
1
L = (M + m) ẋ g2 + ẋ 2 + M ẋ g ẋ − kx 2 − mgl(1 − cos θ )
2
1 2 2
+ m l θ̇ + 2 ẋ g ẋ + 2 ẋl θ̇ cos θ + 2 ẋ g l θ̇ cos θ (1)
2
Damping as through Rayleigh’s dissipation function is taken as,
1
D= C1 x 2 + (C2m + C2e )θ 2 (2)
2
From the Lagrangian equation of motion with the voltage generated is written as:
where B is magnetic flux density, L is coil inductance and d is a gap between coil
and magnet.
v = B Ld θ̇
v = θ̇
In order to study the effect of the pendulum, NES on the primary system and voltage
output from NES parametric study on the system are considered. It is to be noted
that the parameters of primary systems are not changed. Therefore, the influence of
frequency ratio r, electrical damping ξ2e , mass ratio ε and excitation level f is con-
sidered. Following parameters shown in Table 1 are used unless otherwise changes
are mentioned.
Figure 2 shows the response of the primary structure without any absorber. The
structure exhibits peak amplitude at resonance as expected. To safeguard the structure
from failure at resonance, it is necessary to minimize the response of the primary
structure at resonance. This can be done by adding secondary structure as shown in
Fig. 1.
The response of the primary structure and voltage generated from NES is shown
in Fig. 3. With the introduction of NES, the amplitude of the primary system at
resonance has been reduced drastically. Ratio of primary and pendulum structure
Analysis of Pendulum-Based Nonlinear Energy Sink for Energy … 1069
1.5
1
u
0.5
0
0.5 1 1.5
Ω
1 2
r=0.9 F R
r=1 F R
r=1.1 F R
1
v
0.5
u
r=0.9 F R
r=1 F R
r=1.1 F R
0 0
0.5 1 1.5 0.5 1 1.5
Ω Ω
(a) (b)
Fig. 3 Effect of frequency ratio of primary system and pendulum NES a on primary system,
b voltage generated from NES. (Continuous line-F-forward sweep, dotted line-R-backward sweep)
1070 P. V. Malaji
frequency r is varied to study its effect. With an increase in r, the response curve
of primary and NES structure shifts toward right. For r < 1, the amplitude u of the
primary system is almost zero at resonance when r > 1 the amplitude of primary
structure increases as shown in Fig. 3a. Multi-frequency voltage can be generated
from NES indicating broadband harvesting. Spring softening effect can be observed
at the second frequency which further increases frequency band as in Fig. 3b.
Effect of electrical damping on system performance is shown in Fig. 4. The elec-
trical damping is varied between 0.005 and 0.02. With the increase in electrical damp-
ing, the amplitude of primary structure away from resonance decreases indicating
vibration reduction. This also will affect the bandwidth of the voltage generated by
NES. Hence, an optimal value of electrical damping has to be selected to optimize
the amplitude of the primary structure and voltage generated.
1 1.5
2e =0.005 F R
2e =0.01 F R
2e =0.02 F R 1
v
u
0.5
2e =0.005 F R
0.5 2e =0.01 F R
2e =0.02 F R
0 0
0.5 1 1.5 0.5 1 1.5
Ω Ω
(a) (b)
Fig. 4 Effect of electrical damping ξ2e a on primary system, b voltage generated from NES
4
2 f=0.01 F R
f=0.01 F R
f=0.03 F R
f=0.03 F R
f=0.05 F R
f=0.05 F R
2
u
0 0
0.5 1 1.5 0.5 1 1.5
Ω Ω
(a) (b)
Fig. 5 Effect of excitation amplitude a on primary system, b voltage generated from NES, ξ2e =
0.01
Analysis of Pendulum-Based Nonlinear Energy Sink for Energy … 1071
Figure 5 shows the effect of excitation amplitude f on the system which is varied
from 0.01 to 0.05. With the increase in excitation level, amplitudes of primary struc-
ture away from resonance increase as expected whereas the amplitude at resonance
remains the same as shown in Fig. 5a. Voltage amplitude and bandwidth from NES
increase with the increase in excitation level as shown in Fig. 5b. Spring softening
effect at the first frequency can also be observed at higher excitation.
Mass of the pendulum m has to be much smaller than the mass of primary system
M. The effect of mass ratio on the system performance is shown in Fig. 6. Increases
in mass ratio shift the response curve toward left. For the low value of mass ratio ε =
0.1, the amplitude of primary structure at resonance will be more compared to when
ε = 0.2 as shown in Fig. 6a. Voltage generated by NES at a low mass ratio will have
higher amplitude at both frequencies and peaks are nearer as shown in Fig. 6b.
To highlight the benefit of the NES with compared to the classic TMD, even at r =
1, a comparison is shown in Fig. 7. For the sake of comparison, all other parameters
are kept the same for both NES and TMD. The amplitudes with both NES and TMD
1 3
ε =0.1 F R ε=0.1 F R
ε =0.2 F R ε=0.2 F R
2
0.5
v
u
0 0
0.5 1 1.5 0.5 1 1.5
Ω Ω
(a) (b)
Fig. 6 Effect of mass ratio a on primary system, b voltage generated from NES. ξ2e = 0.01
1 NES Forward 2
NES Backward
T MD
v
0.5 1
u
NES Forward
NES Backward
T MD
0 0
0.5 1 1.5 0.5 1 1.5
Ω Ω
Fig. 7 Comparison of TMD and NES at r = 1 a primary system, b voltage generated from NES.
ξ2e = 0.01, r = 1
1072 P. V. Malaji
at resonance remain the same for the primary structure, whereas TMD produces
comparatively low amplitudes away from the resonance. The voltage generated by
NES has higher amplitude and better bandwidth compared to TMD.
4 Conclusion
From the analysis carried out in the manuscript, it can be mainly concluded that
regular damped pendulum with electromagnetic conversion provision can be used
as a nonlinear energy sink to mitigate vibration of primary structure and harvest
useful energy from NES. Also, NES exhibits better performance at a broader range.
Parametric study is carried out to understand the effect of parameters on system
performance. Further, a theoretical and experimental study with an optimization
study will be considered in the future.
References
1. Ali SF, Ramaswamy A (2009) Optimal dynamic inversion based semi-active control of
benchmark bridge using MR dampers. Struct control Health Monitor 16:564–585
2. DeBra DB (1992) Vibration isolation of precision machine tools and instruments. CIRP Ann
Manuf Technol 41:711–718
3. Rivin EI (2003) Dynamic properties of vibration isolation systems. In: Passive vibration
isolation, Chapter 1, ASME press, New York, USA
4. Yilmaz C, Kikuchi N (2006) Analysis and design of passive band-stop filter-type vibration
isolators for low frequency applications. J Sound Vibration 291:1004–1028
5. Ibrahim RA (2008) Recent advances in nonlinear passive vibration isolators. J Sound Vib
314:371–452
6. Peng Z, Lang Z, Zhao L, Billings SA, Tomlinson GR, Guo P (2011) The force transmissibility of
MDOF structures with a non-linear viscous damping device. Int J Non-Linear Mech 46:1305–
1314
7. Ahn HJ (2008) Performance limit of a passive vertical isolator using a negative stiffness
mechanism. J Mech Sci Technol 22:2357–2365
8. Vakakis AF (2001) Inducing passive nonlinear energy sinks in vibrating systems. J Vib Acous
123:324–332
9. Kopidakis G, Aubry S, Tsironis GP (2001) Targeted energy transfer through discrete breathers
in nonlinear systems. Phys Rev Lett 87:165501
10. Ertuk A, Inman DJ (2011) Broadband piezoelectric power generation on high-energy orbits of
the bistable duffing oscillator with electromechanical coupling. J Sound Vib 330:2339–2353
11. Liuyang X, Tang L, Liu K, Mace BR (2018) On the use of piezoelectric nonlinear energy
sink for vibration isolation and energy harvesting. In: Conference on smart materials, adaptive
structures and intelligent systems, pp 1–6
12. Malaji PV, Rajarathinam M, Jaiswal V, Ali SF, Howard IM (2019) Energy harvesting from
dynamic vibration pendulum absorber. Rec Adv Struct Eng 2:467–478 (Springer Singapore)
13. Malaji PV, Ali SF (2018) Analysis and experiment of magneto-mechanically coupled
harvesters. Mech Syst Signal Process 108:304–316
14. Malaji PV, Ali SF (2017) Magneto-mechanically coupled multiple energy harvesters. In:
1st International Conference on Power Electronics, Intelligent Control and Energy Systems
(ICPEICES 2016), IEEE, pp 1–5
Analysis of Pendulum-Based Nonlinear Energy Sink for Energy … 1073
15. Rajarathinam M, Ali S (2018) Energy generation in a hybrid harvester under harmonic
excitation. Energy Convers Manage 155:10–19
16. Kumar KA, Ali SF, Arockiarajan A (2017) Magneto-elastic oscillator: modeling and analysis
with nonlinear magnetic interaction. J Sound Vib 393:265–284
17. Xiong L, Tang L, Liu K, Mace BR (2018) Broadband piezoelectric vibration energy harvesting
using a nonlinear energy sink. J Phys D Appl Phys 51:1–2
Effect of Input Velocity on the Output
of Vertical Axis Wind Turbine (VAWT)
Abstract Vertical axis wind turbines (VAWT) are finding applications in the
advanced scientific fields and seem to be a promising and rapidly growing inno-
vation. A rarely researched field regarding VAWT is on analyzing the effects of
various input velocities for bidirectional wind flow on the vertical axis wind turbines
due to the complex and unsteady wind flow characteristics. In the current study, three-
dimensional simulations are carried out, and the static and dynamic results are then
reported for different values of rotational speed. The outcomes like output velocities
and pressure are analyzed for a range of input velocities in a Savonius wind turbine.
Different input velocities in the range of 10 m/s, 15 m/s, 20 m/s and 25 m/s were
studied. The model for the rotor was designed on Solidworks 2018, and numerical
analysis was carried out for a bidirectional wind input on commercial CFD software,
ANSYS Fluent v16.0. From the analysis, the output velocity and pressure graphs
were plotted with respect to the input air velocity and compared.
1 Introduction
Over the past few years, development and modernization in the form of natural
alterations and over-exploitation of available resources have led to global concern
over pollution, global warming and possible depletion of non-renewable sources of
energy, such as oil. This has led us to the exploration of renewable and sustainable
energy resources. Conventionally, wind energy is harnessed on a large scale using
horizontal axis wind turbines (HAWTs) spread over a large area. But, HAWT has
several disadvantages like the requirement of large wind speeds, large area, high ini-
tial cost and more maintenance. Vertical axis wind turbine (VAWT), unlike a HAWT,
is one whose axis of rotation is vertical with respect to ground. This arrangement
allows the generator and gearbox to be located close to the ground facilitating easy
maintenance and repair. They have gained more interest for their excellent adapt-
ability to the urban environment in terms of visual impact and noise pollution. Being
axis symmetric, they are omnidirectional turbines, which respond well to changes
in wind direction. A typical wind turbine, which utilizes natural wind power, faces
problems regarding lack or excess of wind speed. But in this case, a considerable
amount of wind energy is produced due to the pressure difference created by the
moving vehicles on the highways. We need a system to recycle otherwise wasted
energy of highway traffic. Moreover in remote locations extending power supply
would itself be a tiring task which can be solved by having this type of turbine which
could generate power enough to illuminate the road cautions or indicators needed
for the road users. By setting VAWTs in highways, artificial wind can also be used
to produce electricity. The other major advantage of this system is that it is depen-
dent only on the number of vehicles on the road and not on other resources such as
sunshine or wind, which are seasonal or location specific. Out of the two types of
VAWT, called Darrieus VAWT and Savonius VAWT, the latter is known as quite a
wind power source because of its lowest tip speed ratio and compact size. Savonius
rotor was firstly developed and introduced by Finnish inventor S.J. Savonius. Though
the Savonius rotor has low aerodynamic efficiency, it is preferably used because it
runs at wind speeds as low as 2 m/s.
2 Literature Review
Although the concept of vertical axis wind turbines (VAWTs) was proposed by
Darrieus as early as 1931, the research and development in this area are still of interest
and in progress nowadays. In order to determine the performance of the VAWT,
analytical and numerical approaches, as well as experimental tests, are generally used
among others [1]. The Sutherland report on the stream tube model and vortex models
allows one to analyze the aerodynamic response of VAWTs [2]. The first simplest
approach developed by Templin is the single stream tube numerical model. Templin
calculates the performance for a single blade whose chord equals the sum of the
chords of the actual rotor’s blade through the application of the blade element theory
[3]. Strickland extends Templin’s approach into a multiple single stream tube model
by considering a number of adjacent smaller steam tubes, applying the conservation
of momentum and blade element theory to each steam tube. Further improvement
in the multiple steam tube model has been reported by Paraschivoiu, namely the
double-multiple steamtube model (DSMT) [4]. A second class of models is those
based on vortex representation of the blades and their wakes. Strickland et al.’s
model is based on the replacement of the rotor blade by a bound vortex filament,
called a lifting line, whose strength is a function of the azimuthal position [5]. Wang
presents a potential flow 2D vortex panel model. Experimental tests can be performed
by means of wind tunnel or open-field measurement in order to evaluate the real
performance of wind turbines [6]. Bedon describes the results of an experimental
Effect of Input Velocity on the Output of Vertical Axis Wind … 1077
3 Experimental Setup
4 3D Modeling
The shaft rod has been modeled using Solidworks 2018 software and is shown in
Fig. 1.
5 CFD Model
The sequence of operations involved in the modeling and analysis is shown in the
flowchart (Fig. 3 and 4).
The profile of the rotor is symmetric and is extruded off the 2D geometry. The
analysis was done in ANSYS Fluent v16.0. The finite element method (FEM) is used
to perform the analysis. The finite element method is a powerful tool to obtain the
numerical solution of a wide range of engineering problem. The method is general
Effect of Input Velocity on the Output of Vertical Axis Wind … 1079
enough to handle any complex shape or geometry, for any material under differ-
ent boundary and loading conditions. The generality of the finite element method
fits the analysis requirement in the current application. It is a method of piecewise
approximation in which the structure or body is divided into small elements of finite
dimensions called finite elements, and then, the original body or the structure is
considered as an assemblage of these elements connected at the finite number of
1080 S. Vennila Sigamani et al.
joints called nodal points or nodes. The constraints of the body are given through a C
program. The enclosure has inlets and outlets diagonally on opposite sides of a box
enclosure. The adjacent inlet and outlet are separated by a small region of nil effect
considering practical conditions of bidirectional fluid flow. Re-meshing (as shown in
Fig. 5) is carried out for each time step and smoothing is defined. The time steps are
taken as 0.0025 s considering the accuracy and calculation time. A dynamic mesh is
defined for the fluid domain. The procedures are repeated for each input velocities
(Fig. 6 and 7).
6 Results
For the Savonius wind turbine with a blade thickness of about 2 mm and by fixing
the temperature, the input velocity is changed. The corresponding output velocity and
pressure are noted. As seen from the graph, we increased the input velocity, which in
turn reduced the pressure (on the blades) drastically and increased the output velocity
linearly. We found that, at 15 m/s input velocity, the pressure and the output velocity
are near to each other which make the turbine mechanically efficient. For a particular
input velocity, both low and high pressure makes the blade unstable. And thus at
15 m/s, the turbine is efficient.
7 Conclusion
In this project, we investigated different velocities which exert on the vertical axis
wind turbine. Here, the analysis is taken for the different velocity values such as
10, 15, 20, 25 m/s. The Savonius wind turbine is designed in Solidworks and which
is imported in ANSYS Fluent launcher for the flow analysis, and the variations in
the pressure and velocity values are obtained for each condition. The wind speed is
taken into account, and it is given as angular velocity to the fan. An analysis was
performed on ANSYS Fluent simulating the process, and it was concluded that, in
case of complex bidirectional wind flow, a Savonius rotor with a curved blade of
Effect of Input Velocity on the Output of Vertical Axis Wind … 1083
References
1. Darrieus G (1931) Turbine having its rotating shaft transverse to the flow of the current. U.S.
Patent1, 835, 018, 8 Dec 1931
2. Sutherland HJ, Berg DE, Ashwill TD (2012) A retrospective of VAWT technology; Sandia
Report, SAND 2012-0304; Sandia National Laboratories: Albuquerque, NM, USA, Jan 2012
3. Islam M, Ting DSK, Fartaj A (2008) Aerodynamic models for Darrieus-type straight-bladed
vertical axis wind turbines. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 12:1087–1109
4. Templin RJ (1974) Aerodynamic performance theory for the NRC Vertical-Axis Wind Turbine;
Technical Report N-76-16618; LTR-LA-160; National Aeronautical Establishment: Ottawa,
ON, Canada, 1 June 1974
5. Paraschivoiu I (1988) Double-multiple stream tube model for studying vertical-axis wind
turbines. J Propuls Power 4:370–377
6. Brusca S, Lanzafame R, Messina M (2014) Design of a vertical-axis wind turbine: how the
aspect ratio affects the turbine’s performance. Int J Energy Environ Eng 5:333–340
7. Strickland J, Webster B, Nguyen T (1979) A vortex model of the Darrieus turbine: an analytical
and experimental study. J Fluids Eng 101:500–505
8. Wang L, Zhang L, Zeng N (2007) A potential flow 2-D vortex panel model: applications to
vertical axis straight blade tidal turbine. Energy Convers Manag 48:454–461
Radiative Heat Transfer of Magnetic
Nanofluid Flow Past a Porous Inclined
Plate: A Mathematical Model
M. Shanmugapriya
1 Introduction
M. Shanmugapriya (B)
Department of Mathematics, Sri Sivasubramaniya Nadar College of Engineering, Chennai
603110, India
e-mail: shanmugapriyam@ssn.edu.in
word nanoparticle to improve the thermal conductivity of base fluids. Eastman et al.
[2] have studied that the thermal conductivity of the base fluid (water) was increased
up to 60% when CuO nanoparticles of volume fraction 5% were added to the water.
Furthermore, Eastman et al. [3] have also noticed that the effective thermal conduc-
tivity has shown to be increased 40% when copper nanoparticles of volume fraction
less than 1% are added to the ethylene glycol or oil. Xuan et al. [4] reported that with
a small volumetric fraction of nanoparticles less than 5% the thermal conductivity of
the base fluid is enhanced by 10–20%. Xie et al. [5] have studied that Al2 O3 -ethylene
glycol-based nanofluid thermal conductivity is increased in the range 25–30% when
alumina nanoparticles are added. Therefore, these nanofluids are capable of promot-
ing energy efficiency, improving thermal conductivity and thermal properties of heat
transport of base fluid. Nanofluids have therefore found significant applications in
major process industries, including material and chemicals, food and drink, oil and
gas, paper and printing and textiles.
The word magnetohydrodynamics has several industrial applications such as
MHD generators, pumps, petroleum technologies and liquid metal cooling blan-
ket for fusion reactor. The MHD flow in electrically conducting fluid can control
the rate of heat transfer at the surface, and hence, desired cooling effect can be
achieved. Magneto-nanofluid has specific applications in biomedicine, optical mod-
ulators, magnetic cell separation, magneto-optical wavelength filters, silk flood sepa-
ration, nonlinear optical materials, drug delivery, etc. A magnetic nanofluid has both
liquid and magnetic properties. Hamad et al. [6] introduced a one-parameter group
to represent similarity reduction for the problem of MHD-free convection flow of a
nanofluid past a vertical semi-infinite flat plate. Sudarsana Reddy et al. [7, 8] have
discussed the effect of chemical reaction on MHD natural convection boundary layer
flow, heat and mass transfer characteristics of nanofluids over a rotating disk through
a porous medium and vertical cone, respectively.
The radiative effects have important applications in physics and engineering. The
radiative heat transfer effects on different flows are very important in space tech-
nology and high-temperature processes, and very little is known about the effects of
radiation on the boundary layer of a radiative MHD fluid past a body. Shanmugapriya
[9] has studied the effect of thermal radiation Cu-water nanofluid past a moving
wedge using Gyarmati’s variational principle. Shanmugapriya et al. [10] investigated
the effect of entropy generation and thermal radiation of Cu-water nanofluid over a
moving wedge using the shooting technique together with Runge–Kutta fourth-order
integration scheme. Thiripathi Thumma et al. [11] have presented heat source/sink
effects in addition to viscous dissipation for two different magnetic nanofluid flows
from a nonlinear inclined stretching/shrinking sheet. Sudarsana Reddy et al. [12]
have discussed the influence of thermal radiation and chemical reaction on MHD
boundary layer flow over a nanofluid saturated inclined porous plate under boundary
conditions. Sudarsana Reddy et al. [13] have reported MHD boundary layer flow, heat
and mass transfer analysis of nanofluid over an inclined vertical plate saturated by
the porous medium with thermal radiation and heat generation/absorption by using
versatile, extensively validated, variational finite element method.
Radiative Heat Transfer of Magnetic Nanofluid Flow Past … 1087
The main objective of this work is to address the impact of thermal radiation and
viscous dissipation on MHD boundary layer flow and heat transfer over a porous
inclined plate saturated by Cu-water and Al2 O3 -water-based nanofluid. The effects
of the magnetic parameter, mixed convection parameter, radiation parameter, porous
medium parameter, Eckert number, suction parameter, Prandtl number and angle of
inclination on velocity and temperature fields are presented via figures and tables.
Consider the steady two-dimensional laminar MHD flow and heat transfer of an
incompressible nanofluid past a porous inclined plate with a linear stretching veloc-
ity u w (x) = ax where a(> 0) being the stretching constant. The stream function ψ
can be defined as u = ∂ψ
∂y
and v = − ∂ψ∂x
, and similarly, the temperature at the surface
and free stream are denoted as Tw and T∞ , respectively. The viscous dissipation and
radiation effects are considered in the energy equation. The Rosseland approxima-
tion is used to describe the radiative heat flux in the energy equation. The uniform
magnetic field B0 is applied to the flow direction. The basic governing equations for
such type of flow can be written as (Tiwari and Das [14]).
∂ 2ψ ∂ 2ψ
− =0 (1)
∂ y∂ x ∂ x∂ y
∂ψ ∂ 2 ψ ∂ψ ∂ 2 ψ ∂ 3ψ g(ρβ)n f (T − T∞ ) cos α
− = γ n f +
∂ y ∂ x∂ y ∂ x ∂ y2 ∂ y3 ρn f
2
σ B0 ∂ψ γn f ∂ψ
− − (2)
ρn f ∂ y K ∂y
2 2
∂ψ ∂ T ∂ψ ∂ T ∂2T μn f ∂ ψ
− = αn f 2 +
∂y ∂x ∂x ∂y ∂y ρc p n f ∂ y 2
1 ∂qrad
− (3)
ρc p n f ∂ y
∂ψ ∂ψ
= Uw (x) = ax, = Vw , T = Tw at y = 0 (4)
∂y ∂x
∂ψ
→ 0, T → T∞ as y → ∞ (5)
∂y
nanofluid, ρn f is the
density of the nanofluid, αn f is the thermal diffusivity of the
μ
nanofluid and ρc p n f is the heat capacitance of the nanofluid, γn f = ρnnff symbolizes
the kinematic diffusivity of the nanofluid, βn f is the thermal expansion coefficient of
the nanofluid, α is the angle of inclination, B0 is the strength of the magnetic field and
K is the constant permeability of the porous medium. By the use of the Rosseland
estimation for radiation in Eq. (3), we get the following form of the equation.
2
∂ψ ∂ T ∂ψ ∂ T ∂2T μn f ∂ 2ψ
− = αn f 2 +
∂y ∂x ∂x ∂y ∂y ρc p n f ∂ y2
1 16σ ∗ T∞ ∂ T
3 2
+ (6)
ρc p n f 3k ∗ ∂ y 2
The relation between the physical quantities of nanofluid, water, copper and
aluminum oxide is written as follows:
The thermophysical characteristics of the nanofluid with nanoparticle concentra-
tion ϕ are defined as (Oztop et al. [15])
μf
μn f = , ρn f = (1 − ϕ)ρ f + ϕρs ,
(1 − ϕ)2.5
κn f
αn f = , ρc p n f = (1 − ϕ) ρc p f + ϕ ρc p s ,
ρc p n f
Using these variables in Eqs. (2) and (6), we get the following nonlinear ordinary
differential equations:
ρs ρβs
f + (1 − ϕ)2.5 1−ϕ+ϕ f f − f 2 + λ 1 − ϕ + ϕ θ cos α − M f
ρf ρβ f
− K1 = 0 (9)
4 kf ρβs
1 + R θ + Pr 1−ϕ+ϕ
3 kn f ρβ f
Radiative Heat Transfer of Magnetic Nanofluid Flow Past … 1089
⎡ ⎤
Ec
⎣ f θ − f θ + f 2 ⎦=0 (10)
ρc
(1 − ϕ)2.5 1 − ϕ + ϕ ρc ppsf
f = 0, θ (η) = 0 at η → ∞. (12)
σ B02
where the prime denotes differentiation with respect to η,M = aρ f
is the magnetic
gβ f (Tw− T∞ )x 3 Uw (x)x
parameter, (Gr x ) f = ϑ 2f
is the local Grashof number, (Rex ) f = ϑf
(Gr x ) f gβ(Tw −T∞ )
is the local Reynolds number, λ = (Rex )2f
= a2
is the mixed convection
4σ ∗ T∞ 3 ϑf
parameter, R = k ∗ kn f
is the radiation parameter, K 1 = aK
is the porous medium
Uw (x)2
−1
parameter,Ec = c p f (Tw −T∞ )
is the Eckert number, S = −vw (x) aϑ f 2 is the suction
γf
parameter,Pr = αf
is the Prandtl number and α is the angle of inclination.
The important physical quantities in this study are skin friction coefficient C f and
the Nusselt number N u x , which are defined by the following equations:
μn f ∂u
Cf = ,
ρ f Uw (x)2 ∂ y y=0
∗
4
−kn f ∂∂Ty − 4σ
3k ∗
∂T
∂y
y=0 y=0
N ux = (13)
k f (Tw− T∞ )/x
Using Eqs. (8) and (13), the skin friction coefficient and the Nusselt number can
be expressed as
1 1
−1 −kn f 4R
(Rex ) f C f =
2
f (0), (Rex ) f N u x =
2
1+ θ (0). (14)
(1 − ϕ)2.5 kf 3
1090 M. Shanmugapriya
Table 2 Comparison of − f (0) and −θ (0) for various values of M
M Ishak et al. [16] Anjali Devi et al. [17] Present result
− f (0) −θ (0) − f (0) −θ (0) − f (0) −θ (0)
0.0 0.5607 1.0873 0.5608 1.0873 0.5606 1.0873
0.1 0.5658 1.0863 0.5659 1.0863 0.5659 1.0863
0.2 0.5810 1.0833 0.5810 1.0833 0.5810 1.0833
0.5 0.6830 1.0630 0.6830 1.0630 0.6830 1.0630
1.0 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000
2.0 1.8968 0.8311 1.8968 0.8311 1.8968 0.8311
5.0 4.9155 0.4702 4.9155 0.4703 4.9155 0.4703
4 Numerical Method
Fig. 10 Temperature
profiles for different values
of Ec
Fig. 12 Temperature
profiles for different values
of α
1096 M. Shanmugapriya
6 Conclusion
The boundary layer flow and heat transfer of a nanofluid over a porous inclined
plate with the effect of viscous dissipation, radiation and magnetic field have been
studied numerically. The nonlinear ordinary differential equations with given bound-
ary conditions were solved using Runge–Kutta–Fehlberg fourth-fifth-order method
along with shooting technique. This study investigates the effect of various physical
parameters on the fluid flow and heat transfer characteristics. The following results
can be drawn from the present study.
• When the magnetic parameter (M) raises, it reduces the velocity, skin friction
coefficient and enhances the temperature, Nusselt number due to the effect of
Lorentz force.
• The hydrodynamical and thermal boundary layer was increased by increasing
radiation parameter (R), and this trend is reversed in the viscous dissipation
parameter (Ec).
Radiative Heat Transfer of Magnetic Nanofluid Flow Past … 1097
• Skin friction coefficient decreases for increasing the values of the suction
parameter (S) and Prandtl number (Pr ).
• Suction parameter (S) and Prandtl number (Pr ) increases the thermal boundary
layer thickness.
• It is found that, in general, the non-dimensionless heat transfer rate for the copper–
water nanofluid is more compared with the alumina–water nanofluid.
Acknowledgements The author wishes to thank the Management of Sri Sivasubramaniya Nadar
College of Engineering for providing the necessary facility to carry out the present work.
References
1. Choi SUS (1995) Enhancing thermal conductivity of fluids with nanoparticles, developments
and applications of non-Newtonian flows. In: Siginer DA, Wang HP (eds) FED-vol 231/MD,
vol 66, pp 99–105. The American Society of Mechanical Engineers
2. Eastman JA, Choi SUS, Li S, Thompson LJ, Lee S (1997) Enhanced thermal conductivity
through the development of nanofluid. In: Komarneni S, Parker JC, Wollenberger HJ (eds)
Nanophase and Nanocomposite Materials II. Pittsburg, PA, MRS, pp 3–11
3. Eastman JA, Choi SUS, Li S, Yu W, Thompson LJ (2001) Anomalously increased effective
thermal conductivities of ethylene glycol-based nano-fluids containing copper nano-particles.
Appl Phys Lett 78:718–720
4. Xuan Y, Lin Q (2003) Investigation on convective heat transfer and flow features of nanofluids.
J Heat Trans 125:151–155
5. Xie H, Wang J, Xi T, Liu Y, Ai F, Wu Q (2002) Thermal conductivity enhancement of
suspensions containing nanosized alumina particles. J Appl Phys 91:4568–4572
6. Hamad MA, Pop I, Ismail AI (2011) Magnetic field effects on free convection flow of a nanofluid
past a vertical semi-infinite flat plate. Nonlinear Anal Real World Appl 12:1338–1346
7. Sudarsana Reddy P, Sreedevi P, Chamkha AJ (2017) MHD boundary layer flow, heat and
mass transfer analysis over a rotating disk through porous medium saturated by Cu–water and
Ag–water nanofluid with chemical reaction. Powder Technol 307:46–55
8. Sudarsana Reddy P, Suryanarayana Rao KV (2015) MHD natural convection heat and mass
transfer of Al2 O3 —water and Ag–water nanofluids over a vertical cone with chemical reaction.
Proc Eng 127:476–484
9. Shanmugapriya M (2018) Analysis of heat transfer of Cu-water nanofluid flow past a moving
wedge. J Inf Math Sci 10(1&2):287–296
10. Shanmugapriya M, Sangeetha P (2018) Entropy generation analysis of copper–water nanofluid
flow over a moving wedge. Desalination Water Treatment 121:14–21
11. Thumma T, Anwar Beg O, Kadir A (2017) Numerical study of heat source/sink effects on
dissipative magnetic nanofluid flow from a non-linear inclined stretching/shrinking sheet. J
Mol Liquids 232:159–173
12. Sudarsana Reddy P, Sreedevi P, Chamkha AJ (2016) Heat and mass transfer flow of a nanofluid
over an inclined plate under enhanced boundary conditions with magnetic field and thermal
radiation. Heat Transfer-Asian Res 46(7):815–839
13. Sudarsana Reddy P, Chamkha AJ, Al-Mudhaf A (2017) MHD heat and mass transfer flow of a
nanofluid over an inclined vertical porous plate with radiation and heat generation/absorption.
Adv Powder Technol 28(3):1008–1017
14. Tiwari RK, Das MK (2007) Heat transfer augmentation in a two-sided lid-driven differentially
heated square cavity utilizing nanofluids. Int J Heat Mass Trans 50(9–10):2002–2018
1098 M. Shanmugapriya
15. Oztop H, Abu-Nada E (2008) Numerical study of natural convection in partially heated
rectangular enclosures filled with nanofluids. Int J Heat Fluid Flow 29(5):1326–1336
16. Ishak A, Nazar R, Pop I (2008) Hydromagnetic flow and heat transfer adjacent to stretching
vertical sheet. Heat Mass Trans 44:921–927
17. Anjali Devi SP, Suriyakumar P (2017) Effect of magnetic field on Blasius and Sakiadis flow
of nanofluids past an inclined plate. J Taibah Univ Sci 11(6):1275–1288
A GA-ANFIS Model for the Prediction
of Biomass Elemental Properties
1 Introduction
As of 2017 the United Nation, UN projected population growth from 7.6 billion
to 9.8 billion by 2050 [1]. The clean and sustainable energy is the viable solution
to achieve safer and energy-efficient world since the rising population is leading to
increasing concentration of CO2, which was reported at 1.4% as at 2017 as the highest
ever recorded. Considering the yardsticks such as availability, sustainability, energy
efficiency, applicability, environmental impact, and flexibility, biomass is promising
option to address over-dependence on fossil fuel and provide attractive feedstocks for
energy generation [2]. Biomass elemental composition is an indispensable parameter
required for the design and operation of biomass-to-fuel conversion technologies [3].
The carbon, hydrogen, oxygen content, and other constituents in negligible quantity
have an impact on the gross heating value, the emission, and corrosion of conver-
sion equipment. The knowledge of elemental composition helps in: calculating the
material balance in bioprocess, development of biomass handling equipment such
as boilers, gasifiers, combustors, estimating the volume and constituents of combus-
tion gases, and fixing the amount of oxidant required for biomass gasification [4].
However, experimental determination of elemental composition using the essential
apparatus is becoming very expensive and time-consuming compared to proximate
analysis which can be conducted much easily. Therefore, the rapid and economical
approach would be to develop a model which can be used to estimate the elemental
constituent from the proximate value since it has been established that there is a rela-
tionship between these two experimental methods. Against all these odds, artificial
intelligence, AI, has emerged with a potential to assist in fulfilling the objectives of
biomass-to-energy exploration which centres around the estimation of the proper-
ties of biomass, such as the elemental composition and enthalpy of combustion [3,
5–10]. AI has the capability for modelling of complex systems with high degree of
accuracy. AI can be grouped into artificial neural network (ANN), adaptive neuro-
fuzzy inference systems (ANFIS), evolutionary algorithms (EA), and support vector
machines (SVMs) [11–16]. Several optimization methods have been proposed by
researchers to improve the accuracy of ANFIS [17–19], one of these methods is the
genetic algorithm, GA. GA is an optimization technique which can be applied to
solve problems built on natural selection process among the population such that a
population of candidate solutions is advanced towards improved solutions [20–22].
It was developed in the 1970s by Holland with the basic idea of abstract modelling of
natural evolution [23]. The GA has been extensively used in different fields [24–26]
and most closely in the prediction of the heating value of biomass [13], but there
is no any know GA application for the prediction of the elemental composition of
biomass which covers different sources. There are quite a few published models
which predict the elemental composition of solid biomass based on proximate anal-
ysis [3, 5, 8–10, 27–30]. Nhuchhen [30] developed a correlation which estimated the
carbon, oxygen, and hydrogen constituent of untreated and torrefied biomass on the
basis of proximate analysis. Similarly, Mahmudul et al. [9] developed an empirical
correlation towards the prediction of the elemental composition of torrefied woody
biomass. Also, the correlation developed by Vakkilainen [29] is only limited to black
liquor. Parikh et al. [10] and Shen et al. [5] considered a data set for proximate values
which are volatile matter, fixed carbon, ash for an equivalent elemental composition
of carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen. The range of the data considered is as shown in
Table 1. It can be observed that the present study has a wider datapoint coverage
A GA-ANFIS Model for the Prediction … 1101
Table 1 Datapoint coverage for the proximate and ultimate properties of biomass
Reference Constituents Datapoint range %
[10] C 36.2–53.1
H 4.4–8.3
O 31.4–49.5
VM 57.2–90.6
FC 4.7–38.4
ASH 0.12–77.7
[5] C 36.2–53.1
H 4.7–6.6
O 31.4–48.0
VM 57.2–90.6
FC 9.2–32.8
ASH 0.1–24.6
Present study C 22.35–92.86
H 0.52–11.42
O 2.32–52.06
VM 5.04–89.60
FC 7.40–94.73
ASH 0.10–56.10
compared to previous studies in the same domain. The performance of these corre-
lations was evaluated as shown in Table 2. The contribution of ash content in the
prediction of elemental composition was considered by Shen [5] which made the
correlation to be more robust with better prediction than Parikh et al. [10].
All the mentioned correlations are linear and have not satisfactorily predicted
the properties of the biomass since the elemental constituent of biomass and other
dependent variables do not constantly follow a linear pattern, particularly when tested
with various samples. Ghugare et al. [3] has proposed a hybrid genetic programming
algorithm, support vector regression (SVR), and artificial intelligence in order to
predict the elemental composition biomass. The result of their investigation showed
that the model developed was more accurate than the existing linear and polynomial
models.
Since there is no known GA-ANFIS model which has been used to predict the
elemental composition of solid biomass with such a large data coverage, this article
proposed a prediction model based on a hybrid adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system
(ANFIS) optimized with GA. The model inputs were the proximate properties of
biomass which are ash content (ASH), fixed carbon (FC), and volatile matter (VM).
These were used to predict the hydrogen (H), oxygen (O), and carbon (C) content of
biomass fuels.
ANFIS combines the dual benefits of fuzzy logic and the neural network in a sin-
gle framework, which enables it to solve complex problems in a way that optimal
parameters of membership function are obtained from input to output mapping [15,
31]. It is a variant of the Takagi–Sugeno fuzzy inference system [32, 33]. It consists
of input–output parameters and fuzzy rules of Takagi–Sugeno class [15]. It is a class
of adaptive multilayer feed-forward network which assumes a framework of two
inputs H1 , H2 and output G such that the entries are evaluated by linguistic variable
(A1 , B1 ). The first-order Takagi–Sugeno fuzzy model can be expressed as:
Principle 1: If H1 is A1 AND H2 is B1 then G 1 = b1 J1 + c1 J2 + z 1 .
Principle 2: If H1 is A2 AND H2 is B2 then G 2 = b2 J1 + c2 J2 + z 2
where b1, c1 , z1 , b2, c2 , z2 are output function parameters. In this article, the two rules
above were adapted with input Ji (i = 1 . . . 3), output G i (i = 1 . . . 3) and cluster
C j ( j = 1 . . . 10) with the same weights using a fuzzy c-means clustering method.
Typically, the ANFIS network has five layers [16] in the following sequence:
fuzzification layer, multiplication layer, rationalization layer, defuzzification layer,
A GA-ANFIS Model for the Prediction … 1103
and summation layer. It should be noted that the first and fourth layer include the
adaptive parameters capable of modification and update based on a learning tech-
nique used. The estimated output ultimately depends on the five layers in the ANFIS
after the completion of the training phase. From previous studies, the model per-
forms optimally when the fuzzy rules based on the Gaussian membership function
are applied. This study also applied the Gaussian membership function on the input
variables. The readers can refer to [15, 16, 22, 25, 32, 34, 35] for further informa-
tion on ANFIS models. In this study, elemental constituents comprising of three
inputs which are VM, FC, and ash were mapped to the output which is the principal
elemental constituents (C, H, O) of biomass.
The Gaussian membership function (Eq. 1) was used due to its less disruptive effect
and robustness when applied to the system [43, 44].
∅(z) = e− 2 ( )
1 z−μ 2
σ (1)
Shown in Fig. 1 is the flow diagram of GA-ANFIS model developed for the prediction
of C, H, O components of biomass-based on VM, FC, and ash contents as the input
Initialize GA
Generate
Initial population
Evaluate individual
fitness
No
Generate new population
Selection
Crossover ANFIS-GA
Mutation End
variables. Genetic operators are applied to facilitate breeding in GA. Using GA, the
ANFIS model was trained until the optimal solution was obtained.
The initial conditions used for the computation is presented in Table 3. The con-
vergence values, which minimize the training error objective function, were made a
stopping criterion. The computation was done on a desktop computer workstation
with configuration 64 bits, 32 GB RAM Intel (R) Core (TM) i7 5960X. In general
terms, the principle guiding the GA-ANFIS is as highlighted in the steps below:
Step 1: Generate the first-string population
Step 2: Assign and determine the fitness of each member of the population.
Step 3: Choose a membership pair from the population string for breeding
Step 4: Rank the fitness of the members of the population
Step 5: Allocate the pair into passing population membership
Step 6: Repeat step 5, until temporary population membership is filled up
Step 7: Replace the existing population with members of passing population and
some members of existing population to complete the membership
Step 8: Use the optimal population value for the ANFIS parameters then end
GA-ANFIS
Step 9: If the termination criteria are not met, return to step 2.
Statistical estimation of errors was carried out to evaluate the performance of GA-
ANFIS model which was designed in this study as follows: computation time (CT)
was also estimated as a measure of the overall prediction time as to evaluate the
time cost of the forecasting and to further underline the economic significance of
this model.
1106 O. O. Olatunji et al.
1
N
MAD = |yk − ȳk | (4)
N k=1
3 Results
To satisfactorily predict the elemental component of biomass, the model was trained,
and the prediction capacity of the models was evaluated at the testing phase. Each
elemental composition was considered independently during the training and test-
ing phase. Each predicted elemental constituents and corresponding experimental
values were plotted against the data index. Figures 2, 3 and 4 were plotted for car-
bon, hydrogen, and oxygen, respectively, at both testing and training phase to show
the prediction progression from training to testing. The results show a satisfactory
concurrence between the actual and predicted elemental constituents with a slight
variation at training and testing phases. The concurrency between the actual and
predicted carbon and oxygen revealed a closer pattern compared to hydrogen. In
case of hydrogen, the lower accuracy could be as a result of experimental errors and
narrower data range when compared to other experimental constituents [3].
A GA-ANFIS Model for the Prediction … 1107
For each model, the error was statistically calculated for the predicted and actual
elemental constituents at training and testing stages as presented in Table 4. The
RMSE, MAD, and STD are consistently lower for hydrogen at the training and
testing phase when compared to carbon and oxygen. However, despite the lowest
RMSE, MAD, and STD reported for hydrogen, the magnitude of MAPE and CC
1108 O. O. Olatunji et al.
shows that the model does not predict as much data correctly as the models for
carbon, though it does better than the oxygen. The computation time of the carbon
and oxygen were approximately the same, but significantly different from hydrogen.
This further validates the initial observation that the hydrogen model is not as accurate
and economical as the others. The MAPE revealed that around 80% of the datapoint
were correctly predicted for hydrogen. Of all the three constituents, carbon was the
most accurately predicted with 95% of the data set followed by hydrogen (>80%)
and oxygen (>70%). This is at variance with various models (GP-MLP, GP-SVR,
A GA-ANFIS Model for the Prediction … 1109
MLP-SVR) developed by Ghugare [3] which proposed that the MAPE of carbon and
oxygen constituents is generally and constantly better than hydrogen for all testing
cases. The CT results revealed that the model can be tested in less than 1 min, though
closely related to the computing power of the computer used. The result is important
in the conversion of biomass to energy since the properties of biomass feedstock
determine the energy quality.
The comparative analysis of the GA-ANFIS model with the models developed
by other authors is indicated in Table 5. The RMSE of hydrogen is significantly
1110 O. O. Olatunji et al.
lesser than that of the other two models, while the CC is also significantly higher
[5, 10]. Also, the MAPE calculated based on Shen et al. [5] and Parikh et al. [10]
are pointed of a lower order of magnitude with about half of the value estimated in
this study. For carbon, CC is lower and RMSE is also significantly lower by more
than 50% for the model developed in this study. However, the MAPE was close
as against a significant disparity in case of hydrogen constituent prediction model.
Also, for oxygen model developed in this study, RMSE value shows a significant
order of difference and the CC, though not as much as RMSE. But MAPE showed
that the other linear correlation could only accurately predict around 50% of the
data. This further underlines the significance of the model developed in this study.
The overall observation revealed that the GA-ANFIS model developed in this study
provides more satisfactory performance for all the elemental components which were
predicted in compared to the existing linear models.
A GA-ANFIS Model for the Prediction … 1111
The regression analysis was based on the test results for all the predicted elements.
The objective is to determine the model of greatest fitness based on minimum error
criterion and the data dispersion along the line of the best fit (Figs. 5, 6 and 7). It can
be inferred from the plots that carbon in Fig. 5 shows the lowest dispersion compared
to other constituents with regression equation given as: F(C)predicted = 0.83F(C)exp
+ 8.2 in %weight.
4 Conclusion
The elemental constituents of biomass were predicted based on the proximate val-
ues using ANFIS model which was optimized by GA. The accuracy of the model
developed in the study was more satisfactory compared to the other linear models
since it resolved nonlinear dependencies inherent in biomass properties. Regression
analysis was also carried out to determine the level of dependence among the corre-
lated variables and the data scattering along the line of best fit. The report shows that
GA-ANFIS can be used in the computation of the elemental composition of biomass-
based on proximate properties. This result is significant for strategic decision-making
regarding biomass-to-energy conversion operation.
1112 O. O. Olatunji et al.
References