QCS 2014 Section 09: Mechanical and Electrical Equipment Page 1

Part 06: Surge Control System

6 SURGE CONTROL SYSTEM ........................................................................ 2

6.1 GENERAL ...................................................................................................... 2

6.1.1 Scope 2
6.1.2 References 2
6.1.3 System Description 2
6.1.4 Submittals 3
6.1.5 Quality Assurance 3
6.1.6 Warranty 4
6.2 PRODUCTS ................................................................................................... 4
6.2.1 Design Conditions and Performance Characteristics 4
6.2.2 Materials 4
6.2.3 Fabrication 5

nt
6.2.4 Factory Inspection and Testing 6
6.2.5 Spare Parts and Tools 7

la
6.3 INSTALLATION AND COMMISSIONING ...................................................... 7
6.3.1 Installation
tP 7
al
6.3.2 Site Inspection and Testing 7
ph
As
a
er
ze
Ja
Al
QCS 2014 Section 09: Mechanical and Electrical Equipment Page 2
Part 06: Surge Control System

6 SURGE CONTROL SYSTEM

6.1 GENERAL

6.1.1 Scope

1 The Part specifies the requirements for the design, manufacture, construction, installation,
testing and commissioning of complete surge protection systems, including flywheels, surge
vessels, compressors, air valves and necessary accessory items.

2 Related Sections and Parts are as follows:

This Section
Part 1, General
Part 2, Submersible Pumps
Part 3, Centrifugal Pumps

nt
Section 1, General

la
Section 8, Drainage Works

tP
Section 10, Instrumentation, Control and Automation
Section 21, Electrical Works al
6.1.2 References
ph

1 The following standards or revised/updated versions and documents of other organisations

are referred to in this Part:
As

BS 449, ......................The use of structural steel in building

BS 729 (ISO 1459, 1460, 1461) Hot dip galvanised coatings on iron and steel articles
a

BS 970 (ISO 683) .......Wrought steels for mechanical and allied engineering purposes
er

BS 1387 (ISO 65) .......Screwed and socketed steel tubes and tubulars and for plain end
tubes suitable for welding or screwing to BS 21 pipe threads
ze

BS 1571 (ISO 1217) ...Testing of positive displacement compressors and exhausters

Ja

BS 2872,.....................Copper and alloy stock and forgings

BS 3601 (ISO 2604) ...Specification for carbon steel pipes and tubes with specified room
temperature properties for pressure purposes
Al

BS EN 1092,..............Circular flanges for pipe, valves and fittings

BS 5304,.....................Code of practice for the safety of machinery

ASME VIII Div. 1, ........Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Design and Fabrication of Pressure
Vessels

6.1.3 System Description

1 Hydraulic Design. Surge control devices are to be provided where necessary at all pumping
stations. The Contractor shall assume no inertia assistance from any air valves fitted. Air
valves will not be accepted as a primary means of surge suppression. Flywheels may be
used. In the case of multiple pumping mains separate surge suppression systems shall be
provided for each main. The design shall include for the worst case i.e. surge conditions
existing when the system is pumping at maximum rate and a power failure occurs. Surge
analysis shall be based on the friction factor used for new pipelines. Pump manufacturer
shall carry out surge analysis for the whole system including the pipe work within the
pumping station.
QCS 2014 Section 09: Mechanical and Electrical Equipment Page 3
Part 06: Surge Control System

2 System Design. The following types of system may be used for surge protection:

(a) flywheels. These shall be used where there is sufficient reserve capacity of liquid in
the wet well or surge tower {see (b)} at all times to allow the flywheel to continuously
recharge the main with liquid
(b) surge towers. Their use is only applicable when the total head developed by the
pump is low
(c) hydropneumatic atmospheric surge vessels. Their use is only applicable when the
static head in the rising main is low. They shall incorporate a dip tube and a float air
valve which allows air in and out of the vessel depending on the liquid level in the
vessel.
(d) bladder type pressure vessels. Their use is only applicable when no negative
pressures occur in the main in either a surge condition or normal operation
(e) hydropneumatic surge vessels with compressors. Their use is only applicable where
there is a substantial static head in the rising main

nt
3 Air Valves. Air valves shall be installed on the rising main as specified or required to optimise
the hydraulic efficiency of the main. They shall comply with Section 8 Part 5.

la
tP
6.1.4 Submittals

1 In addition to the submittal requirements of Part 1 of this Section, the Contractor shall submit
al
data and information as the following paragraphs.
ph

2 Design Data:
As

(a) Hydraulic Calculations. The Contractor shall submit a complete computer

based hydraulic transient analysis showing the performance of the surge control
system under various model scenarios. Normal operating modes and the sudden
shut down of the pump following a power failure shall be simulated. The program
a

shall have the facility to model the characteristic of the different manufacturer’s air
er

and reflux valves, and any other proprietary equipment

ze

(b) structural calculations. Structural calculations for the design of the pressure vessel
and its supports shall be provided.
Ja

3 Shop drawings: Shop drawings shall be provided for the fabrication and erection of the whole
system, including air compressors, air valves, surge vessels. Layout drawings, pressure
vessel calculations, schematic drawings and electrical drawings shall be provided.
Al

Catalogue pages, manufacturers’ detail instructions, templates and installation methods shall
be provided.

4 Operation and Maintenance Manuals and Instructions. The Contractor shall include all the
documentation required by Part 1 of this Section on the surge protection system in the
operation and maintenance manuals. A copy of the surge analysis and site tests as
described below shall also be included. Documentation for the compressors in accordance
with BS 1571 shall be provided

6.1.5 Quality Assurance

1 Both the Company carrying out the surge analysis and the software used for the computer
transient analysis shall have a proven record in surge analysis. Software used shall be a
recognised water industry standard.

2 The Contractor shall employ Third Party Agency (TPA) to oversee the design, fabrication and
testing of pressure vessels as defined in PD5500. The independent testing authority shall
report direct to the Engineer.
QCS 2014 Section 09: Mechanical and Electrical Equipment Page 4
Part 06: Surge Control System

6.1.6 Warranty

1 In addition to the guarantee requirements of Part 1 of this Section, the Contractor shall
ensure that the Company carrying out the surge analysis provides a warranty of the
performance of the entire surge protection system. This shall not in any way relieve the
Contractor of his contractual obligations.

6.2 PRODUCTS

6.2.1 Design Conditions and Performance Characteristics

1 Unless specified otherwise in the particular Project Specification, transient surge pressures
shall be limited as the following paragraphs.

2 Positive (over) pressure - Positive surge pressures shall not exceed the design pressure of
the pipeline, taking into account any de-rating for temperature. The rating of pipeline
restraints and thrust blocks shall be considered in limiting the positive pressure.

nt
3 Negative (under) pressure - Negative surge pressures shall not exceed the following:

la
(a) GRP, asbestos cement, and cement lined ductile/cast iron and steel-limit 1 metre of

tP
vacuum (-1 metre)
(b) Bitumen lined ductile/cast iron and steel-limit 3 metres of vacuum (-3 metres)
al
(c) uPVC, ABS, HDPE, MDPE - limit 3 metres of vacuum (-3 metres).
ph

4 Stress cycling. Certain types of plastic pipeline can fail prematurely due to duty cycling.
Where the pump start/stop cycling is likely to be high this should be considered.
As

5 Pipeline Manufacturer’s Recommendations. In all instances the recommendations of the

pipeline manufacturer with respect to positive and negative pressures and stress cycling
a

must be followed. Pipeline seals must be included in these recommendations.

er

6 Surge Vessels. These must be designed, inspected and tested in accordance with PD 5500
ze

Code 2 with a 2.0 mm corrosion allowance Design pressure ratings shall be 1.25 times the
greatest pressure the vessel will be subject to. Vertical vessels shall be used wherever
possible for sewage. Any supports or plinths shall designed for the vessel to be completely
Ja

full of liquid.

7 Surge protection equipment shall be chosen in the following order of preference:

Al

(a) flywheel – to be used in all cases where high head is involved to protect against valve
slamming,
(b) surge vessel
(c) combination of flywheel and surge vessel

6.2.2 Materials

1 Surge Towers. If these are constructed in concrete, then Section 8 shall apply. If in the
same material as the pipeline, then the specifications applying to the pipeline shall apply.

2 Surge vessels. These shall be constructed from steel in accordance with PD 5500.

3 Coatings. Surge vessels shall be coated internally with an epoxy paint system of minimum
thickness 300 microns. The system shall be proven in use in this application. The external
coating system shall be in accordance with paint system in Section 8 Part 8.
QCS 2014 Section 09: Mechanical and Electrical Equipment Page 5
Part 06: Surge Control System

6.2.3 Fabrication

1 Flywheels. These shall comply with the requirements of Part 3.

2 Surge Towers (stand pipes). These may be constructed in concrete, G.R.P or steel. The top
of the tower shall be vented back to the wet well or through a suitable de-odouriser. An
emergency overflow shall be provided, routed to a drain. They shall be capable of
withstanding the maximum pressure generated by the pumps or surge transients, assuming
the tower is full of liquid. Means shall be provided for draining the tower and cleaning it out.

3 Hydropneumatic Atmospheric Surge Vessels. These shall be constructed in steel as

specified above for surge vessels. They shall include the following features:

(a) facility for draining the vessel. If possible, this shall be using the pressure pipeline
(b) manway access if the vessel is large enough to accommodate this, or inspection
hatch for cleaning the vessel out
(c) air/float valve on top of the vessel. This shall be readily accessible for cleaning and

nt
maintenance

la
(d) vent back to the wet well or a suitable drain for the above valve

tP
(e) pressure gauge with isolating cock to measure the maximum and minimum pressures
(f) flanges shall be to BS EN 1092 PN 16.
al
4 Bladder Type Pressure Vessels. These shall be constructed in steel as specified above for
ph
surge vessels. They shall include the features (a) (b) (e) and (f) described in 3 above and in
addition the following:
As

(a) food grade iso-butyl rubber bladder. This shall have a guaranteed life of three years
in contact with the liquid pumped and at the specified temperatures
(b) bladder pressurisation valve and gauge. This is for recharging the bladder. Access
a

ladders/platforms shall be provided as necessary.

er

5 Hydropneumatic Surge Vessels with compressors. The vessel shall be constructed in steel
ze

as specified above. The vessel shall include the features (a) (b) (e) and (f) described in 3
above and in addition the following:
Ja

(a) liquid level gauges

(i) tubular glass, liquid-level gauges with 20 mm tube outside diameter shall be
Al

provided. The minimum viewing length shall be 600 mm per gauge. Sufficient
gauges shall be provided to view the entire operating range of water levels in
the pressure vessel. Threaded 20 mm connections shall be provided. Isolation
valves with ball checks shall be provided to prevent loss of liquid upon gauge
breakage. Valves shall be of an offset pattern with integral bonnet. Valve
bodies shall be bronze. A drain cock shall be provided on the lower valve.
Valves shall have pressure ratings of 1.5 times the maximum surge pressure
anticipated, or NP 16, whichever is greater
(ii) flanges shall be provided, NP 16 for the maximum and minimum level probe
locations, respectively.
(b) safety relief valves. These shall comply with the PD 5500 and shall be
capable of passing air and water. Valves shall have a bottom inlet and side outlet.
The inlet shall incorporate a calibrated spring set to allow the valve to open at the
vessel design pressure.
(c) air pipework. Air piping shall be galvanised to BS 729 and conform to BS 1387 or
BS 3601, of a minimum of 25 mm diameter. A brass ball valve shall be
provided as a block valve at the pressure vessel. Brass check valves shall be
provided in the air line. All shall be rated for 16 bar.
QCS 2014 Section 09: Mechanical and Electrical Equipment Page 6
Part 06: Surge Control System

(d) air compressor assembly

(i) the compressor unit shall be self-contained and consist of a single-acting, two-
(ii) stage, if necessary, air-cooled, reciprocating-type compressor motor with V-belt
drive and regulation, on a fabricated steel skid. Valves shall be of stainless
steel and shall be easily removed or inspected without use of special
tools.
(iii) the compressor shall be driven by an electric motor which shall comply with
Section 21
(iv) the air inlet filter silencer shall be of the dry replaceable cartridge type
(v) the compressor shall shut down at unsafe oil level and shall not restart without
adding oil
(vi) if necessary, the compressor shall be provided with finned tube, air-cooled
intercooler to remove the heat of compression. The compressor shall have an
automatic centrifugal starting unloader valve which will cause the pressure in

nt
the compressor cylinders to be vented to atmosphere upon compressor
stopping, thereby allowing the compressor to start against minimum load

la
(vii) rotating parts shall be guarded in conformance with BS 5304

tP
(viii) the oil sump on each compressor shall be fitted with a valve and drain
extension pipe of sufficient length to enable the oil to be drained without spilling
over the base. Sumps containing 1.0 or less may be fitted with a capped pipe.
al
(e) automatic air volume control system
ph

(i) the automatic air volume control system, in conjunction with pressure vessel-
mounted sensor probes and the air compressor unit, shall control the air/water
As

ratio in the hydropneumatic pressure vessel and maintain the air/water ratio
within a range compatible with the surge control system design and established
system static and maximum operating pressures
a

(ii) contacts shall be provided for remote indication of excessive high or low water
er

level in the vessel. Capacitance type level probes with a probe well
plumbed to the side of the hydropneumatic vessel shall be provided as
ze

Section 10. A control panel with all necessary controls, relays and time delay
circuits to actuate the air add/vent solenoid valves, and signal a high or low
Ja

tank water level shall be provided.

(f) Solenoid Valves
Al

(i) solenoid valves of sizes 5 mm through 40 mm for air service shall have forged
bronze bodies to BS 2872 with Teflon seats. Internal plunger, core tube,
plunger spring, and cage assembly shall be stainless steel BS 970 Part 1
316S12. Solenoid enclosures shall be IP 68. Valve actuators shall be 240Va.c.
Seals shall be Teflon. Valves shall have a maximum operating pressure and a
maximum differential pressure of 16 bar. Solenoid valves shall be energised to
open.

6.2.4 Factory Inspection and Testing

1 The Contractor shall secure from the pump manufacturer certification that the following
inspections and tests have been conducted at the factory and submit to the Engineer prior to
shipment.

2 Surge Vessels. These shall be inspected and tested in accordance with ASME VIII Div.1
sewer class (Welding, Non Destructive Testing (NDT), Hydro test, etc.)

3 Compressors. These shall be inspected and tested in accordance with BS 1571.

4 Motors and control panels. These shall be inspected and tested as described in Section 21.
QCS 2014 Section 09: Mechanical and Electrical Equipment Page 7
Part 06: Surge Control System

5 Control System. This shall be inspected and tested as described in Section 10.

6.2.5 Spare Parts and Tools

1 The Contractor shall provide from the specialist manufacturers of the surge equipment all the
spares and tools required during the commissioning and maintenance periods as specified in
Part 1, including those required below.

2 Special tools, if required for normal operation/or maintenance of any component of the surge
control system, shall be supplied with the equipment.

3 Air Valves. A complete seal/gasket set shall be provided for each air valve installed.

4 Control panels and control systems.

5 Compressors.

nt
6.3 INSTALLATION AND COMMISSIONING

la
6.3.1 Installation

tP
1 All equipment shall be installed and commissioning in accordance with the manufacturer’s
recommendations and under the supervision of the surge control system supplier’s factory
al
trained personnel.
ph

6.3.2 Site Inspection and Testing

As

1 Surge protection system performance shall be verified by field tests at pumping rates
specified for each pressure main and for power failure at the maximum pumping rate. The
surge control system supplier shall provide a chart recorder and pressure transducer system
a

to develop a permanent record for each pressure main test.

er

END OF PART
ze
Ja
Al