Impact of Contextualizing and Localizing Teaching-Learning Processes To Students' Academic Performance in Social Studies
Impact of Contextualizing and Localizing Teaching-Learning Processes To Students' Academic Performance in Social Studies
IN SOCIAL STUDIES
JED I. BETE
Davao City National High School
Davao City Division
September 2018
I. Context and Rationale
ensure better understanding of the lesson remains relevant in the field of education.
Several approaches have been introduced already to the teachers and students have
been exposed also to various types of classroom strategies. However, the issue of
ensuring the retention and application of what the students learned in the actual world
Teaching methods used by the vast majority of teachers that may have worked
well enough for past generations are not working well enough today. There is a need to
change educational strategies, and the place to begin is in the classroom (Crawford,
2001). Moreover, there are also some inconsistencies in the execution of policies as to
their actual implementation in the field. This could somehow be taken as one of the
reasons why students’ performances are weak because some policies and programs
which are aimed at improving the quality of education are not properly delivered.
and the place begins in the classroom. This is due to the fact that teaching methods
used by the vast majority of teachers that may have worked well enough for past
generations are not working well enough today Moreover, there are also some
This could somehow be taken as one of the reasons why students’ performances are
weak because some policies and programs which are aimed at improving the quality of
workforce (Baker, Hope, and Karandjeff 2009). According to America’s Perfect Storm
Karandjeff (2009), there is a widening chasm between the literacy and numeracy skills
needed to effectively compete in both the global and national economy and the
numbers of students who have mastered these skills, with minority students showing
With this, America’s human capital has declined its ability to compete
academically while the changing labour market is rapidly raising its demand for higher-
level skills. However, employers increasingly require broad academic skills in reading,
writing and computation for career advancement in occupations that formerly required
Report (2000) has always taken pride in its achievements in education, particularly its
high adult literacy rate and high enrolment rate. However, such high achievements are
not translated into higher levels of development. The disparity stems from the unequal
access to low quality and marginal relevance of basic education in the country.
According to the report, poor quality of education is evident in the low scores obtained
The performance of the country’s public high school students in the NAT has
been on the decline and is significantly lower than the scores of public elementary
students. DepEd data showed that the average NAT score of public high school
students for School Year 2011 to 2012 was significantly lower at 48.9 percent compared
to the elementary students' 66.79 percent. This trend has been apparent for the past 5
years. DepEd data showed that public high school students posted an average score of:
48.9 percent (Average Mastery) - SY 2011 to 2012, 47.92 percent (Average Mastery) -
SY 2010 to 2011; 45.56 percent (Average Mastery) - SY 2009 to 2010; 46.71 percent
2008. The average NAT scores of public elementary students were: 66.79 percent
(Moving Towards Mastery) - SY 2011 to 2012; 68.15 percent (Moving Towards Mastery)
- SY 2010 to 2011, 68.01 percent (Moving Towards Mastery) - SY 2009 to 2010; 65.55
percent (Average Mastery) - SY 2008 to 2009; and 64.81 percent (Average Mastery) -
curriculum. This new curriculum is seen as one of the answers in improving the quality
education in the country. K to 12 Curriculum highlights some key features which are
geared in addressing students’ differences and learning styles. One of the key features
Contextualization and localization can be done not only in Social Studies, but in all
learning areas.
desire of the state to promote the preservation of culture, local history, symbols, and
identity. With this premise, the concept of contextualization and localization, which is
also labelled in many studies as Contextualizing Teaching and Learning (CTL), truly
aligns with the thrusts and mandates of the Department of Education. In its vision-
education (DepEd Vision, Mission and Core Values). Article XVI Section 14 of the 1987
Philippine Constitution states that the State shall foster the preservation, enrichment,
and dynamic evolution of a Filipino national culture based on the principle of unity in
diversity in a climate of free and artistic and intellectual expression. Section 5 of the
same article stipulates that the State shall take into account regional and sectoral needs
and conditions and shall encourage local planning in the development of educational
In Davao City, the decrease in the mean percentage score (MPS) in most of the
learning areas in the secondary level is also evident. In Social Studies (Araling
Panlipunan) for example, the decline in the MPS is noticeable, from 60.07 in SY 2013-
2014 to 49.85 in SY 2014-2015 (DepEd Division of Davao City Report, 2015). This
alarming result in the National Achievement Test (NAT), as the standardized tool in
measuring students’ academic performance in the division, has challenged not only the
teachers but also the school administrators and DepEd officials to revisit the current
improved comprehension, and retention skills of the learners which will lead to the
encouraged to use the process to make learning not only effective, but also meaningful,
relatable, and significant. This should be reflected not only in the teachers’ lesson logs
or lesson plans, but most importantly on the actual teaching and learning process.
While it is true that there is a provision of contextualization and localization in the
curriculum, however this is not religiously practiced by some teachers in the local
schools. This is evident during class observations conducted by the master teachers,
head teachers, and school heads. Although teachers are aware of the need to
contextualize and localize their lessons, teachers tend to forget it during the actual
Thus, this study aims to find out the impact of the school’s practices of
Social Studies (Araling Panlipunan). Social Studies as one of the key learning areas in
basic education focuses on the preservation and enrichment of Filipino national culture
this study will be beneficial especially for the stakeholders: DepEd officials, school
This study is beneficial because this will check whether teachers in the field
by the Department of Education. This also will highlight the different practices of
contextualizing teaching and learning and how these affect the students’ academic
The results of this study will also benefit the DepEd officials especially the
Education Program Supervisors and School Heads. Results of this study can be used
Jean Lave and Etienne Wenger in the early 1990s, and followed the work of Dewey,
Vygotsky, and others who claim that students are more inclined to learn by actively
Cullata, 2015) argued that situated learning as it normally occurs is a function of the
activity, context and culture in which it occurs. This contrasts with most classroom
learning activities which involve knowledge which is abstract and out of context. Social
As the beginner or newcomer moves from the periphery of this community to its center,
they become more active and engaged within the culture and hence assume the role of
deliberate. These ideas are what Lave and Wenger (1990) call the process of
experiences. Another appropriate name for this strategy, according to Nikitina (2002),
linking of theoretical knowledge to the situation or the context of those who pursue it.
Hence, contextualization of the curriculum embraces relating the content, the teaching
learning process and the materials to meaningful situations that are relevant to students’
lives. In contextualizing the lessons, teachers start with real-life contexts and weave
these contexts into every stage of the teaching and learning process. When curriculum
is contextualized, the child’s experience is a fundamental starting point in the teaching
learning process and every effort is made to help him/her relate whatever learned into
This falls on the idea that there is enduring understanding on the part of the
learners when the lessons and their experiences in the classroom have meanings and
significance in their daily lives. As Wiggins and McTighe (1998) stated that enduring
understanding refers to the big ideas - the important understandings. This is what the
teachers want students to ‘get inside of’ and retain after they’ve forgotten many details.
principles, or processes.
Students will learn better if they experience the curriculum that is personalized,
taking into account different learning styles, meaningful, and relevant to their lives in the
“real world”. Teaching in broad generalizations, to cover all of the required standards
and prepare students for a standardized test can take away from the learning
applied learning, and manipulative learning apply. Learning by doing means learning
from experiences resulting directly from one’s own actions, as contrasted with learning
2011). According to Pendor (1997), effective teaching occurs when students participate
and not just made recipients of information and knowledge delivered by the teacher.
internalization of lessons. Further, Bonwell and Eison (2000) defined learning as simply
having the students engage in some activity that forces them to think about and
comment on the information presented. Students will not just simply be listening but will
school practices such as in lesson planning, learning resources, teaching strategies and
classroom assessment.
Lesson Planning
Lesson planning is one of the vital roles of a teacher. Planning is the systematic
process of deciding what and how students should learn. Planning is mostly the
responsibility of teachers. Teachers decide about the form and content of their
instruction, such as how much presenting, questioning, and discussing to do; how much
materials to cover in the allotted time; and how in-depth to make their instruction
questions of what the teacher intends that the pupils should learn and how this is to be
since a lot of studies have already proven its significant contribution to the academic
performance of the students. Research shows that effective teachers organize and plan
their instruction (Misulis 1997; Stronge, 2007 as cited in DepEd Order 42, s. 2016). With
content and performance standards and learning competencies firmly articulated in the
K to 12 curriculum, it is easier for teachers to carry out both short-term and long-term
instructional planning. Under the K to 12 Basic Education Program, teachers can in fact
plan student learning for a year, a semester, a unit, or a lesson and secure coverage of
the curriculum (DepEd Order No. 42, s. 2016). In preparing the daily lessons, DepEd
integrated is through the use of localized learning resources and teaching strategies.
REACT Strategy is also defined by Center for Occupational Research and Development
Relating refers to linking the concept to be learned with something the student
already knows. For example: When teaching about “houses,” ask students to name
different kinds of houses that they see around them such as terrace houses, semi-
attention is focused to everyday sights, events, and conditions. When they are able to
relate to these everyday situations, new information is better absorbed. Crawford (2001)
described relating as the most powerful contextual teaching strategy. It is also at the
pre-existing knowledge. Teachers use relating when they link a new concept to
something completely familiar to students, thus connecting what students already know
to the new information. When the link is successful, students gain almost instant insight.
discover new knowledge. For example, when teaching about parts of a house, assign
students a small group project such as making a model house complete with roof, walls,
floor, rooms, and mini-furniture. Learning takes place far more quickly when students
Applying refers to how students apply their knowledge to real-world situations. For
example, ask students to name house-related professions. Their list could include:
architect, interior decorator, bricklayer, floor tiler, electrician, sanitation worker, and so
on. This allows students to project into an imagined future or into an unfamiliar
workplace.
and develop cooperating skills. For example, in small groups, ask students to discuss
ways to safeguard their houses from fire, floods, break-ins, termite destruction, and so
on. The collaborative experience and practice that is nurtured in the classroom not only
assists them to learn new material; it also helps them in the workplace where
employees who are team players, information sharers, and effective communicators are
Lastly, transferring means that students take what they have learned and apply it to
new situations and contexts. For example, ask students to engage in problem-solving a
situation where sink holes appear in the living room, water marks on the bathroom
ceiling, clogged drains, and so on. This is similar to relating as it calls upon the familiar
situations. Students will thus become more confident in their problem-solving skills and
abilities when they go out into the world of work later on in their lives.
The REACT strategies are not the result of a single research project. Instead
they are based on the most relevant research by educators, psychologists, and
cognitive scientists and reinforced by observation of how the best teachers teach for
Classroom Assessment
provided the policy guidelines for classroom assessment in the K to 12 Basic Education
part of curriculum implementation. It allows the teachers to track and measure learners’
learners, as well as their parents and guardians of their progress (DepEd Order No. 8,
helping students perform well in relation to the learning standards. Learning standards
comprise content standards, performance standards and learning competencies that
performance of the students inside the classroom. In a study conducted by the Hanover
Research (2014), it says that most of the research conducted, although the focus is not
on summative test scores, findings indicate that students who have receive formative
assessment perform better on a variety of achievement indicators than their peers do.
While many of these studies exhibit methodological limitations, experts agree that the
practice of assessment for learning shows promise in its ability to improve student
achievement motivation.
The study focused on the level of practices employed by the Social Studies
effects of this to the academic performance of students in Davao City National High
School. The respondents of this study were the Social Studies teachers and students
from all grade levels in the Junior High School (JHS). Given the limited time, the primary
source of students’ academic performance was only their first quarter grade in Social
Studies for School Year 2018-2019. Since the school also implements ‘No Disruption of
Classes’ policy, the data gathering was done during the vacant time of the teacher-
respondents and the researcher. Moreover, the researcher did not also have flexibility of
time to conduct the study. Aside from full time teaching, the researcher has ancillary
(SBM).
a. Sampling
All students in Social Studies were involved in this study. All teachers were asked
to submit the general scholastic aptitude (GSA) of their students for the first quarter.
The GSA in Social Studies primarily served as the basis of identifying the academic
performance of the learners in the subject. Moreover, 25 Social Studies teachers also
served as the respondents of the survey questionnaire that was facilitated by the
researcher.
b. Data Collection
Before the study was conducted, a research proposal was submitted first to
DepEd Regional Office XI for approval. In order to gather the needed data, the
validated by not less than three (3) experts. After the questionnaire was validated, the
researcher administered the test to the Social Studies teachers of Davao City National
High School.
gathered. Teachers were made to submit the general scholastic aptitude (GSA) of their
students in Social Studies. The researcher asked for the approval of the school principal
Lastly, the responses collected from the teacher-respondents and the grades of
the students were tabulated, correlated and analyzed using the appropriate statistical
treatment.
c. Ethical Issues
In conducting research studies, certain protocols, standards, and procedures
were observed. These were done so that problems concerning ethical issues will be
avoided. The ethical challenges that are relevant to this study encompass the issues of
the right to conduct the study, the data gathering procedures and the confidentiality of
the respondents. On the right to conduct the study, a proposal was submitted to the
regional office for approval. On the data gathering procedure, a letter was written first to
the school principal allowing the researcher to have an access on the first quarter
respondents, both the students and teachers were not be disclosed to ensure
anonymity.
To facilitate the analysis of data, the following were the statistical tool that were
Mean and standard deviation. This was used in getting the level of school’s
implementation, daily lesson plan and teaching-learning process, and teachers training
and learning materials. Mean was also employed in getting the level of performance of
relationship between the school’s practices of contextualizing teaching and learning and
Moreover, the following parameter limits were also used to determine the level of
Mean Interpretation
90-100 Excellent
85-89 Very Satisfactory
80-84 Satisfactory
75-79 Fairly Satisfactory
Below 75 Did Not Meet Expectations
This portion presents the analyses and interpretation of the computed data to
answer the problems raised. The sequence of the presentation is based on the
Table 1
Level of School’s Practices of Contextualizing Teaching and Learning
and learning in Social Studies. Among the school’s practices, the Curriculum
Implementation is the highest with a mean of 4.58 or Very High. This is followed by
Teachers’ Training and Learning Materials with a mean of 4.54 or Very High and Daily
Lesson Plan and Teaching and Learning Process with a mean of 4.46 or High.
Discussion
The high results in the level of school’s practices of contextualizing teaching and
learning means a high regard into its implementation. Social Studies teachers in Davao
City National High School, highly regard the process of contextualization and
contextualization means that they implement what Republic Act 10533 mandates. It
says that the curriculum should be contextualized and flexible enough to enable and
allow schools to localize, indigenize, and enhance the same based on their respective
Table 2
Level of Performance of the Students in Social Studies
Subject Mean Standard Descriptive
Deviation Interpretation
Araling Panlipunan 87.80 4.53 Very High
Table 2 is the performance of the students in social studies. From the table, the
mean performance of the students is 87.80 with a descriptive interpretation of very high.
This means that the students are doing well in their social studies subject.
Discussion
students, the results show that students performance in the subject is very high. This
indicates that students perform very well in the subject. As a learning area, social
studies is designed not only to teach the students about the significant events of the
past. Moreover, it teaches the students to learn from the history to become better,
responsible and accountable citizens of the nation. The good performance of the
teaching the subject. The study of Igu, et. al, (2014) revealed the implications of the
effectiveness of social studies teaching and learning in primary education level. The
study has shown that instructional materials facilitate the teaching of social studies. The
implication is that students’ performance is enhanced when teachers use different types
Table 3
The Relationship between the School’s Practices of Contextualizing Teaching and
Learning and Students Performance in Social Studies
School Practices Computed p-value Decision on Ho
R-Value
Presented in table 3 is the test for significant relationship between the school’s
was used. Performing the Pearson-R Correlation Test, the three (3) school practices
yielded R-values of 0.886, 0.698, and 0.654, all with 0.000 p-value. Since the probability
value is less than .005 level of significance, then the null hypotheses are rejected. This
Discussion
important in improving the performance of the learners. The need to contextualize the
lessons helps the learners to bitterly appreciate and understand the concepts that they
are learning. According to Kenea (2014) when curriculum is contextualized, the child’s
experience is a fundamental starting point in the teaching learning process and every
effort is made to help him/her relate whatever learned into his/her everyday life
Table 4
Predictors of School’s Practices of Contextualizing Teaching and Learning
School Practices p-value Remarks
Curriculum Implementation .000 Significant Predictor
Daily Lesson Plan and Teaching .282 Insignificant Predictor
Learning Process
Teachers’ Training and Learning .353 Insignificant Predictor
Materials
To test which variable is the best predictor, multiple linear regression was
utilized. Based from the data presented on the table, the Curriculum Implementation
has a p-value of 0.000, Daily Lesson Plan and Teaching and Learning Process has
a p-value of 0.282, and Teachers’ Training and Learning Materials has a p-value of
0.353. Among the variables, it is only the Curriculum Implementation which has a p-
value that is less than 0.005 level of significance. This therefore means that
Discussion
are expected to implement fully what the curriculum requires. The result shows that the
learning. This means that if the teachers truly apply and implement what is expected
from them, students can surely benefit. Teachers, being the primary movers and
implementers of the curriculum can strengthen a learner’s efficacy and increase their
motivation for school work. As stated by Margolis and McCabe (2004), increasing
motivation can be evidently shown by linking new school work to recent successes,
Based on the above-mentioned findings of the study the following conclusions are
drawn:
followed by Teachers’ Training and Learning Materials and Daily Lesson Plan
2. The level of students’ performance in Social Studies is high. This means that the
VII Recommendations
school head.
3. Regular classroom observation should be conducted by those school heads or
learning process.
performance not only in Araling Panlipunan (Social Studies) but also in other
VIII. References
Baker, E. D., Hope, L. & Karandjeff, K. (2009). Contextualized teaching & learning: a faculty
primer. Reasearch and Planning Group and Academic Senate for California Community
Colleges.
Bonwell, C. C., & Eison, J. A. (2000). Select active learning articles: creating excitement in
the classroom. ERIC Digest
Cicek, V. And Tok, H. (n.d). Effective use of lesson plans to enhance education in U.S and
Turkish kindergarten thru 12th Grade Public School System: a comparative study.
Retrieved on August 25, 2016 from http://www.iises.net/download/Soubory/soubory-
puvodni/pp10-20ijote_V2N2.pdf
Demerin, A. (2009). The learning performance of students in high school physics using
differentiated instruction. Unpublished Master’s Thesis. Holy Cross of Davao
College, Davao City
DepEd Division of Davao City National Achievement Test Result for SY 2014- 2015
DepEd Order No. 8, s. 2015. “Policy guidelines on classroom assessment for the K to 12 basic
education program”. Retrieved from www.deped.gov.ph.
DepEd Order No. 42, s. 2016. “Policy Guideline on Daily Lesson Preparation for the K to 12
Basic Education Program.”
De Leon, H.S. (2005). Textbook on the Philippine Constitution. Rex Book Store.
Hanover Research (2014). Impact of Formative Assessment and Learning Intention of Student
Achievement. Retrieved from http://www.hanoverresearch.com/media/The-Impact-of-
Formative-Assessment-and-Learning-Intentions-on-Student-Achievement.pdf on
September 26, 2016.
Igu, N.C.N, Ogba, F. N., & Igwe, I.O. (2014) Effects of instructional materials on
students’ achievement in social studies in lower basic education in
Nigeria. Retrieved on September 14, 2015 from
http://www.21caf.org/uploads/1/3/5/2/13527682/igu- ogba-igwe.pdf
Jones, J. (n.d.). Lesson planning: towards purposeful learning and effective teaching. Retrieved
on August 25, 2016 from http://www.encuentrojournal.org/textos/10.9.pdf.
Lave, J. (1988). Cognition in Practice: Mind, mathematics, and culture in everyday life.
Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University < Press.
Lave, J., & Wenger, E. (1990). Situated Learning: Legitimate Periperal Participation.
Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Ordinario, C. U. (2013). Low NAT scores may worsen under k to 12. Retrieved on August
10, 2015 from http://www.rappler.com/nation/24205-low-nat- scores-may-
worsen-under-k-12
Pendor, R. (1997). The effects of laboratory-augmented method of teaching trigonometry
on heterogeneously grouped engineersing students’ achievement. Unpublished
Master’s Thesis. Holy Cross of Davao College, Davao City.
Philippine Human Development Report (2000). Quality, relevance, and access in basic
education: executive summary. Retrieved on August 20, 2015 from
http://hdn.org.ph/2000-philippine-human-development-report-quality- relevance-
and-access-in-basic-education/#download
Reese, H. W. (2011). The learning-by-doing principle. Retrieved on August 10, 2015 from
http://www.baojournal.com/BDB%20WEBSITE/archive/BDB- 2011-11-01- 001-
019.pdf.