Auditing Report 5 (269-272)
Auditing Report 5 (269-272)
Where:
PDR = Planned Detection Risk
AAR = Acceptable Audit Risk
IR = Inherent Risk
CR = Control risk
As an alternative to numeric representations for planned audit risk, inherent risk, and control
risk, some auditors use the terms high, medium, or low. Most auditors are conservative in
making these assessments. In other words, an auditor assessing inherent risk to be between low
and medium sets the risk at medium which will require him to gather a medium amount of
evidence.
The audit risk model for evaluating audit results is:
AcAR = IR x CR x AcDR
Where:
AcAR = Achieved Audit Risk. A measure of the risk the auditor has taken that an account in the
financial statements is materially misstated after the auditor has accumulated audit evidence,
IR = Inherent Risk. It is the same inherent risk factor discussed in planning unless it has been
revised as a result of new information.
CR = Control Risk. It is also the same control risk discussed previously unless it has been
revised during the audit.
AcDR = Achieved Detection Risk. A measure of the risk that audit evidence for a segment did
not detect misstatement exceeding a tolerable amount, if such misstatements existed. The auditor
can reduce achieved detection risk only by accumulating substantive evidence.
Although research indicated that it is not appropriate to use the formula to calculate achieved
audit risk, the relationships in the formula are valid and should be used in practice.
The formula shows that there are three ways to reduce achieved audit risk to an acceptable level:
Reduce Inherent Risk. Because inherent risk is assessed by the auditor based on the
client’s circumstances, this assessment is done during planning and is typically not
changed unless new facts are uncovered as the audit progresses.
Reduce Control Risk. Assessed control risk is affected by the client’s internal controls
and the auditor’s tests of those controls. Auditors can reduce control risk by more
extensive tests of controls if the client has effective controls.
Reduce Achieved Detection Risk by Increasing Substantive Audit Tests. Auditors
reduce achieved detection risk by accumulating evidence using analytical procedures,
substantive tests of transactions, and tests of details of balances. Additional audit
procedures assuming that they are effective, and larger sample sins both reduce achieved
detection risk.
Combining these three factors subjectively to achieve an acceptably low audit risk requires
considerable professional judgment. Some firms develop sophisticated approaches to help their
auditors make those judgments, while other firms leave those decisions to each audit team.