NDBI
NDBI
net/publication/248977308
CITATIONS READS
811 10,020
3 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Yong Zha on 04 April 2016.
Y. ZHA
College of Geographical Sciences, Nanjing Normal University, Nanjing 210097,
China; e-mail: yzha@njnu.edu.cn
J. GAO*
School of Geography and Environmental Science, University of Auckland,
Private Bag 92019, Auckland, New Zealand; e-mail: jg.gao@auckland.ac.nz
and S. NI
College of Geographical Sciences, Nanjing Normal University, Nanjing 210097
Abstract. Remotely sensed imagery is ideally used to monitor and detect land
cover changes that occur frequently in urban and peri-urban areas as a con-
sequence of incessant urbanization. It is a lengthy process to convert satellite
imagery into land cover map using the existing methods of manual interpretation
and parametric image classification digitally. In this paper we propose a new
method based on Normalized Difference Built-up Index (NDBI) to automate the
process of mapping built-up areas. It takes advantage of the unique spectral
response of built-up areas and other land covers. Built-up areas are effectively
mapped through arithmetic manipulation of re-coded Normalized Difference
Vegetation Index (NDVI) and NDBI images derived from TM imagery. The
devised NDBI method was applied to map urban land in the city of Nanjing,
eastern China. The mapped results at an accuracy of 92.6% indicate that it
can be used to fulfil the mapping objective reliably. Compared with the max-
imum likelihood classification method, the proposed NDBI is able to serve as a
worthwhile alternative for quickly and objectively mapping built-up areas.
1. Introduction
Land covers in urban areas tend to change more drastically over a short
period of time than elsewhere because of incessant urbanization. Urbanization has
led land covers to change especially frequently in peri-urban areas in China as a
result of rapid economic development. These changes are ideally monitored and
detected from remotely sensed images as they are relatively up-to-date and give a
panoramic view.
Remote sensing materials in the form of aerial photographs and satellite images
are usually converted into useful information such as land cover maps using two
*Corresponding author.
International Journal of Remote Sensing
ISSN 0143-1161 print/ISSN 1366-5901 online © 2003 Taylor & Francis Ltd
http://www.tandf.co.uk/journals
DOI: 10.1080/01431160210144570
584 Y. Zha et al.
et al. 1996), derivation of snow cover products (Slater et al. 1999), discrimination
of areas affected by volcanic eruption (Kerdiles and Diaz 1996) and so on. Multi-
temporal NDVI data were also classified to characterize phenological responses on
a spatially dissected landscape (Fleischmann and Walsh 1991) and to monitor
dynamic parameters of vegetation (Azzali and Menenti 2000).
In addition to NDVI, Normalized Difference Snow Index (NDSI) has been
devised from Landsat Thematic Mapper (TM) bands 2 and 5 to map glaciers (Sidjak
and Wheate 1999). This index is based on the difference between strong reflection
of visible radiation and near total absorption of middle infrared wavelengths by
snow (Hall et al. 1995). It is effective in distinguishing snow from similarly bright
soil, vegetation and rock, as well as from clouds (Dozier 1989).
Unlike NDSI, Normalized Difference Water Index (NDWI) has been developed
to delineate open water features and enhance their presence in remotely sensed
imagery based on reflected near-infrared radiation and visible green light. NDWI
may allow turbidity of waterbodies to be estimated from remotely sensed data
(McFeeters 1996). NDWI is sensitive to changes in liquid water content of vegetation
canopies. It is complementary to, but not a substitute for NDVI (Gao 1996).
In this study we propose a new and simple method for the rapid and accurate
mapping of urban areas. This method is based on the combinational use of NDBI
and NDVI. The mapping is accomplished through arithmetic manipulations and
recoding of NDBI and NDVI images derived from a 1997 TM image. This method
does not involve any subjective human intervention in the mapping process. The
effectiveness of this method was tested through the mapping of urban areas in the
Chinese City of Nanjing. Comparison of the results obtained using this method
with the manually interpreted ones demonstrates that it is highly reliable. This
method also produces very accurate results more efficiently than the supervised
classification method.
2. Study area
The study area is largely the urban area of Nanjing City, East China, located at
118° 47∞ E and 32° 04∞ N in the lower reaches of the Yangtze River (figure 1). Most
of the urban areas lie to the south of the river. Situated in the Yangtze River delta,
the city has a mostly gentle topography with little relief. Hilly areas are found in the
outskirts. The tallest mountain of Zijin is 448 m above sea level. Thus, little topo-
graphic shadow is present on the satellite imagery. Apart from the Yangtze River,
another major waterbody is a recreational lake next to the mountain.
As the capital of Jiangsu province, Nanjing has a total area of 976 km2. Land
covers present in this area are mainly urban residential, commercial and industrial.
Woodland is found in the adjacent mountainous areas. Natural vegetation occurs in
the form of mixed coniferous trees. Artificially planted trees are mostly deciduous.
In addition, there is farmland in the surrounding rural areas. Rice, wheat, vegetable
oil seed, as well as vegetables are cultivated throughout the year. Some crop fields
at the early stage of their growth may appear as barren on the TM image. Due to
rapid economic development, farmland adjacent to the urban periphery has been
converted to urban uses over the last two decades. Therefore, it is necessary from
time to time to monitor these changes from satellite imagery.
4. NDBI
Figure 2 is the standard false colour composite (TM4—red, TM3—green, TM2—
blue) on which various surface covers (e.g. built-up, woodland, farmland, barren and
water) are clearly distinguishable. Through repeatedly clicking on the representative
Mapping urban areas using NDBI 587
Figure 2. False colour composite of TM bands 4 (red), 3 (green) and 2 (blue). Typical land
covers are urban (bluish yellow), woodland (dark red), barren (yellow), river (green),
lakes (dark), and farmland (orange). Image size: 800 by 800 pixels.
pixels of each of these covers, their values in all seven bands are averaged and
displayed graphically in figure 3. This profile illustrates that their spectral disparity
is the largest in bands 3, 4 and 5. An examination of the minimum, maximum and
standard deviation of each of the covers in the seven TM bands (table 1) confirms
the same conclusion. Namely, these values are most distinctive from one another for
each cover in bands 3, 4 and 5. Therefore, they are the most useful bands from which
some of the land covers may be potentially differentiated spectrally. Rivers and lakes
have a similar shape of profile. Their Digital Number (DN) value is markedly lower
in the fourth and fifth bands. They experience a sharp rise in reflectance in band 6,
but a low reflectance in band 7. The curve for rivers lies above that for lakes because
they are laden with more silt.
A close scrutiny of figure 3 reveals that except for barren, vegetation (woodland
and farmland) has a higher reflectance on band 4 than other covers. Moreover, its
value on band 4 still exceeds those on band 3. By comparison, all the non-vegetative
categories have a smaller DN on band 4 than 3. Therefore, the subtraction of band
3 from band 4 will result in positive DNs for vegetation pixels only. The afore-
mentioned relationships exist for the minimum and maximum DNs as well (table 1).
This outcome allows broad vegetative covers to be distinguished easily. This
processing is commonly referred to as NDVI (equation 1).
NDVI=(Band 4−band 3)/(band 4+band 3) (1)
In order to facilitate the subsequent processing, the derived NDVI image was
recoded with 254 for all pixels having positive indices (vegetation) and 0 for all
remaining pixels of negative indices (table 2).
588 Y. Zha et al.
Figure 3. Spectral profiles of six typical land covers in the study area.
Table 1. Minimum, maximum and standard deviation of DNs of the six covers in the seven
spectral TM bands.
TM spectral band 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Built-up areas and barren land experience a drastic increment in their reflectance
from band 4 to band 5 while vegetation has a slightly larger or smaller DN value
on band 5 than on band 4 (figure 3). This pace of increment greatly exceeds that of
any other covers. The minimum and maximum DNs in band 4 are much smaller
than those in band 5 for the same cover. The standardized differentiation of these
Mapping urban areas using NDBI 589
Table 2. Pixel values of representative land covers after differencing and binary recoding.
two bands (equation 2) will result in close to 0 for woodland and farmland pixels,
negative for waterbodies, but positive values for built-up pixels, enabling the latter
to be separated from the remaining covers.
NDBI=(TM5−TM4)/(TM5+TM4) (2)
The derived NDBI image was then recoded to create a binary image. The
resultant ratio was assigned a new value of 0 if the input pixel had a negative index
or 254 if its input index was larger than 0 (table 2). The spectral profiles in figure 3
suggest that the ratio for vegetative covers can be larger or smaller than 0, depending
upon pixels in the surrounding environs. While many vegetative pixels may have
been coded 0 correctly in the output binary image, this handling cannot effectively
ensure that all vegetative pixels will receive the new value of 0. In order to avoid
mistakenly grouping those vegetative pixels into the built-up category, a further step
of processing is imperative. According to the results in table 2, subtraction of the
recoded NDVI image from the recoded NDBI image will lead to only built-up and
barren pixels having positive values while all other covers have a value of 0 or −254,
thus allowing built-up areas to be mapped automatically. Through three arithmetic
manipulations of TM bands 3, 4 and 5 followed by recoding, it is thus possible to
differentiate urban areas (including barren land). In order to enhance the appearance
of the final difference image, the derived urban built-up image was spatially filtered
using the median filter with a window of 5 pixels by 5 pixels (figure 4). The filtered
image was vectorized and later overlaid with the original colour composite to check
for its spatial accuracy.
5. Results
5.1. NDBI-derived result and its accuracy
Since this study concentrates on the mapping of built-up areas, all the mapped
land covers are categorized into only two groups, built-up and all others. There are
166 180 built-up pixels in the study area, or an area of 15 403.148 ha (each pixel is
30.445 m by 30.445 m in dimension). Built-up areas account for nearly 26% of the
entire study area. As implied previously, no further attempt was made to differentiate
the specific uses of these areas.
The accuracy of the mapped built-up areas was assessed both spatially and
aspatially. The spatial discrepancy between the mapped and actual boundaries of
built-up areas is illustrated graphically in figure 5. It shows that the vectorized
boundary of the mapped built-up areas matches closely with the actual border of
built-up areas in this part of the image. In order to provide a quantitative assessment
of the accuracy for the entire urban area, 68 pixels were randomly selected from the
mapped results (figure 4). Their genuine identity on the ground was verified under
the guidance of a global positioning system (GPS) receiver in the field according to
their coordinates. It was found that of these checkpoints, 63 were correctly mapped
590 Y. Zha et al.
Figure 4. Results of automatically mapped urban land use after spatial filtering with a
window size of 5 pixels by 5 pixels.
Figure 5. The agreement between built-up areas and the vectorized boundaries of filtered
built-up areas on the false colour composite (an enlargement). Refer to figure 2 for
the colour codes.
Table 3. Results of maximum likelihood classification using various training sample sizes.
Samples were selected from the standard colour composite. Classification was carried
out using all seven bands.
transitional areas and beaches, were not classified as separate groups. Certainly,
the accuracy would be much higher had built-up areas first classified as subgroups
that were merged in a post-classification session. This, undoubtedly, will prolong the
already time-consuming process of supervised classification.
long as this assumption is not violated. Because the reflectance of urban areas
exhibits little seasonality, this method is not prone to its impact. However, its
performance may be adversely affected indirectly by the presence of other covers
whose reflectance is seasonal, such as forest. This problem may be overcome with
the selection of images recorded when defoliation is minimal or non-existent. The
mixture of built-up areas with barren farmland may be overcome with the use of an
image taken when vegetative cover is at its maximum.
Nevertheless, this proposed method does have a number of limitations. First of
all, it can map only broad urban land covers. For instance, urban industrial, commer-
cial and residential areas are impossible to be separated. This, however, may not
prove to be a liability in most Chinese cities where they are highly intermixed
spatially. They are difficult to be satisfactorily mapped even using the conventional
supervised classification method anyway. Secondly, the NDBI method is unable to
separate urban areas from barren (e.g. sandy beaches) because both of them have a
similar spectral response in all TM bands. This limitation may be overcome with
the use of spatial knowledge, as the latter is located next to water. Another remedial
method is to select an image recorded in a season when the water level is so high
that sand beaches are submerged under water. By comparison, the effect of drought
on the performance of the NDBI method is more difficult to counteract. The loss of
moisture from soil and disappearance of vegetation as a result of drought will
assimilate the spectral characteristics of both urban and agricultural areas, debilitat-
ing the validity of the proposed method. Predictably, the reliability of this method
is lowered in mapping peripheral urban areas where barren or fallow land is wide-
spread. Thirdly, the universality of this proposed method needs to be tested in other
geographic areas. The success of the proposed method lies in the NDVI value of
vegetation being larger than 0. However, the spectral response of vegetation varies
from location to location due to different kinds of species and nature of underlying
soil and moisture conditions. Besides, the response pattern for vegetation varies with
its density. Under these circumstances it is uncertain whether vegetative NDVI value
still exceeds 0. It is speculated that the specific reflectance values may vary with
these conditions, but the general pattern of the spectral response of vegetation in all
seven TM bands will remain identical, ensuring a positive NDVI value and thus
maintaining the validity of the method.
Acknowledgments
The comments made by two anonymous referees helped to improve the quality
of the manuscript considerably.
References
A, F., and E, C., 1995, Forest classification of Southeast Asia using NOAA
AVHRR data. Remote Sensing of Environment, 54, 198–208.
A, S., and M, M., 2000, Mapping vegetation–soil–climate complexes in southern
Africa using temporal Fourier analysis of NOAA AVHRR NDVI data. International
Journal of Remote Sensing, 21, 973–996.
D, J., 1989, Spectral signature of Alpine snow cover from the Landsat Thematic Mapper.
Remote Sensing of Environment, 28, 9–22.
F, A., I, P., and C, J. L., 1997, Automatic mapping of surfaces affected
by forest fires in Spain using AVHRR NDVI composite image data. Remote Sensing
of Environment, 60, 153–162.
F, C. G., and W, S. J., 1991, Multi-temporal AVHRR digital data: an approach
for landcover mapping of heterogeneous landscapes. Geocarto International, 6, 5–20.
594 Mapping urban areas using NDBI
G, B. C., 1996, NDWI—a normalized difference water index for remote sensing of vegetation
liquid water from space. Remote Sensing of Environment, 58, 257–266.
G, J., and S, D., 1998, Capability of SPOT XS data in producing detailed land
cover maps at the urban–rural periphery. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 19,
2877–2891.
H, D. K., R, G. A., and S, V. V., 1995, Development of methods for
mapping global snow cover using Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer
data. Remote Sensing of Environment, 54, 127–140.
K, H., and D, R., 1996, Mapping of the volcanic ashes from the 1991 Hudson
eruption using NOAA–AVHRR data. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 17,
1981–1995.
L, M. P., W, C. E., C, J. B., and H, H., 1996, The status of
agricultural lands in Egypt: the use of multitemporal NDVI features derived from
Landsat TM. Remote Sensing of Environment, 56, 8–20.
L, C. P., 1981, Land use mapping of Hong Kong from Landsat images. An evaluation.
International Journal of Remote Sensing, 2, 231–252.
L, C. P., and N, W. E. Jr, 1990, Detailed urban land-use and land-cover mapping using
Large Format Camera photographs: an evaluation. Photogrammetric Engineering and
Remote Sensing, 56, 197–206.
MF, S. K., 1996, The use of the Normalized Difference Water Index (NDWI) in the
delineation of open water features. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 17,
1425–1432.
S, R. W., and W, R. D., 1999, Glacier mapping of the Illecillewaet icefield, British
Columbia, Canada, using Landsat TM and digital elevation data. International Journal
of Remote Sensing, 20, 273–284.
S, M. T., S, D. R., R, W. G., and S, A., 1999, Potential operational
multi-satellite sensor mapping of snow cover in maritime sub-polar regions.
International Journal of Remote Sensing, 20, 3019–3030.
S, J., C, P. R., and B, M. E., 2000, Integrating contextual information with
per-pixel classification for improved land cover classification. Remote Sensing of
Environment, 71, 282–296.
T, P. M., H, P. J., and G, P., 1992, Application of satellite and GIS technolo-
gies for land-cover and land-use mapping at the rural–urban fringe: a case study.
Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing, 58, 439–448.