Comparison of Jef Ecosafe Vs Conventional Grounding
Comparison of Jef Ecosafe Vs Conventional Grounding
COMPARISON OF DIFFERENT
TECHNOLOGIES OF EARTH SYSTEMS
Sl. Parameter Jef Ecosafe Conventional Grounding
No.
17.2 mm dia, 2 mtrs or 3 mtrs long electrode made of high tensile Commercial grade GI pipe electrode having galvanization thickness
Brief description of the low carbon steel circular rod, molecularly bonded copper having a of approximately 20 to 40 microns is normally used and the pit is
1
system thickness of 250 microns on the outer surface. The rod conforms to filled with charcoal and salt. In special sases, copper plates are
UL 467-2007. The backfill compound is ecofriendly used.
Applicable Standard for The electrode is manufactured, tested and approved as per UL 467
4 Commercial grade G.I Pipe/Copper plate used in most cases
electrode Standard, UL467, IEEE 80, IEC 60364, IS 3043
Applicable standard for
5 BS-7430, IEEE-80, IS-3043 Indeterminate amount of Salt & charcoal mixed with soil
Backfill
6 Type of Backfill Carbonacious Backfill Natural Salt & Charcoal / Pure Bentonite
Electrically conductive through flow of electrons (Like in metals) and Electrolytic / Ionic conduction with salt & water. Either mixed with
7 Type of conduction
is not depend on moisture to dissipate the fault & lightning currents normal soil / Bentonite clay.
Backfill compound and its Only salt and charcoal are normally used. However, salt corrodes
Special environment friendly backfill compound which does not react
8 effect on environment / the electrode and drastically reduces the efficiency of the grounding
with electrode & does not harm environment.
Primary electrode system, typically within a few months.
LORESCO POWERFIL grounding backfills used by us is safe for
9 Pollution of ground water use near potable ground water sources. It carries ANSI/NSF Salt and Charcoal are not known to have dangerous effects
Standard 60 certification to this effect.
Diffusing / Leaching into Will not leech/diffuse in to the ground because of its hardening Will diffuse / leach into ground. Also Bentonite will shrink away from
10
ground characteristics. electrode.
Water evaporates reducing conductivity. Bentonite if used, will shrink
11 Effect in dry condition No Effect in dry conditions away from electrode increasing resistance.
-- Ref Clause 14.5 (b) of IEEE-80
Effect of compound on Not mixed with soil while pouring. The Powerfill compound does not Salt and Charcoal react with the electrode resulting in corrosion and
12
earth electrode react with copper. Hence, it does not harm the electrode hence the life of the grounding system reduces drastically.
JEF Eco Safe Earthing Solutions are purely Activated Carbon based.
Effect of back fill on PH So it is not depended on pH value for quick dissipation of fault &
13 Adding salt & water can alter the PH value.
value of soil lightning currents and there is no influence of changing of
atmospheric temperature.
Reliability of the grounding Very stable for a long period. Carbon is one of the most stable Unreliable as salt and charcoal dissolve in water very fast and the
17
system substances known to man & doesn’t degrade for decades. ground resistance becomes unstable thereafter