Scribd
Upload
156 views1 page

Language Policy Critique Paper

This document summarizes Bernard Spolsky's article "Language Policy" which discusses key issues in language policy including bilingualism, language choice, endangered languages, and language education. It examines how language policy can be understood by analyzing language practices, beliefs, and interventions. While the article provides a useful framework for understanding language policy, the summary argues it overlooks factors like economic forces that contribute to language loss and does not sufficiently analyze the dominance of English in a globalized world. The push for English acquisition in some developing countries has increased inequality, and the degree of genuine choice in language policy is questioned within the context of globalization. Overall, the article serves as a provocative starting point for discussion, though it may lack some

Uploaded by

Bianka Sylvee
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
156 views1 page

Language Policy Critique Paper

This document summarizes Bernard Spolsky's article "Language Policy" which discusses key issues in language policy including bilingualism, language choice, endangered languages, and language education. It examines how language policy can be understood by analyzing language practices, beliefs, and interventions. While the article provides a useful framework for understanding language policy, the summary argues it overlooks factors like economic forces that contribute to language loss and does not sufficiently analyze the dominance of English in a globalized world. The push for English acquisition in some developing countries has increased inequality, and the degree of genuine choice in language policy is questioned within the context of globalization. Overall, the article serves as a provocative starting point for discussion, though it may lack some

Uploaded by

Bianka Sylvee
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 1

BiankaSylvee M.

Dumlao

SEEL 106

Language Policy Critique Paper

The article, “Language Policy”, by Bernard Spolsky seeks to probe a great number of discourse at
the facade of language policy: ideas of bilingualism and multilingualism, accuracy and bad language,
language choice as a civil and human right, language death and efforts to conserve endangered
languages and language education policy. We now come to the problem which is being addressed, first,
how can language policy be recognized?; and second, how can language be managed?

As to its substance, the nature of language policy was discussed. Spolsky contended that
language policy has three components: language practices, language beliefs and interventions detailed
to alter practices or beliefs. He argued that language policies are frequently implied wherein they are
being recognized through a scrutiny of practices rather than official documents. Further, policies may
aim language elements like words, spellings, sound, as well as whole varieties. Many of these issues are
revisited wherein the basis of a theory of language policy, Spolsky introduces further concepts and
distinctions. He argues, for instance, that policy-making may be undertaken at a variety of levels – from
the family up to the national level and beyond, and less controversially, that language policy interacts
with a variety of other social, economic, political factors. He also illustrates the range of domains (e.g
schools, workplaces, nations) over which language policy may range.

Unfortunately, the article appears to have over-emphasized language death as a failure for
native speakers. The social, economic, technological, and political factors that contribute to language
loss were not taken into consideration. Hence, a limitation of this article is that it is insufficient on the
analysis of linguistic dominance of the English language. The presence of English-based consumers
driven by pop-culture and marketing strategies in industrialized and developing countries is an
indication of language’s power within the global economy.

Moreover, within many developing nations the push towards English language acquisition has
had the residual effect of creating greater polarization between the rich and poor as reflected in the
growing divide between linguistic have and havenots. Therefore, while many nations have choice in
their language policies, how much genuine agency exists within the context of globalization? While
Language Policy may lack some argumentative nuance, it serves as a useful resource for understanding
the core issues within current language diversity debates. The arguments put forth in this article,
substantiated by the author’s 30-plus years of experience in language policy research, serves as a
provocative read for emerging, as well as established, scholars in this field.

You might also like

pFad - Phonifier reborn

Pfad - The Proxy pFad of © 2024 Garber Painting. All rights reserved.

Note: This service is not intended for secure transactions such as banking, social media, email, or purchasing. Use at your own risk. We assume no liability whatsoever for broken pages.


Alternative Proxies:

Alternative Proxy

pFad Proxy

pFad v3 Proxy

pFad v4 Proxy