Strategies For Developing 6-8 Year-Old Children's Singing Intonation
Strategies For Developing 6-8 Year-Old Children's Singing Intonation
net/publication/323812951
CITATIONS READS
0 55
4 authors, including:
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
The coordination between 6-8-year-old children’s musical hearing and vocal organs during the process of singing: comparative studies in Latvia, Lithuania and Taiwan
View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Asta Rauduvaitė on 14 May 2019.
Pedagogika / Pedagogy
2017, t. 128, Nr. 4, p. 206–216 / Vol. 128, No. 4, pp. 206–216, 2017
1
Daugavpils University, Faculty of Education and Management, Department of Pedagogy and Pedagogical
Psychology, 13 Vienibas St., LV-5402 Daugavpils, Latvia, jelena.davidova@du.lv
2
Daugavpils University, Institute of Humanities and Social Sciences, 13 Vienibas St., LV-5402 Daugavpils, Latvia,
g.zavadska@inbox.lv
3
Lithuanian University of Educational Sciences, Faculty of Education, Department of Music, 39 Studentų St., LT-
08106 Vilnius, Lithuania, asta.rauduvaite@leu.lt
4
National Taichung University of Education, College of Education, Department of Music, 140 Min-Shen Road
Taichung City, 40306 Taiwan, mjc557@eahoo.com.tw
Abstract. On the basis of the diagnostic study carried out in the framework of the inter-
national project “Coordination between 6–8 Year-Old Children’s Musical Hearing and Vocal
Apparatus during the Process of Singing: Comparative Study in Latvia, Lithuania and Taiwan”
the following problems were defined for those involved in the experiment in Latvia: children’s
voice diapason and intonation (undeveloped voice diapason, which does not at large surpass
quarto-tertian; inaccurate intonation of melody, bordering “speaking voice”; intonation of the
general ascending and descending movement of melody by inaccurate inner filling), typical
cases of inaccurate intonation in the process of singing at every age group of children; as well as
strategies and didactic material was elaborated for forming and developing singing intonation
at different stages of 6–8 year-old children in the framework of case study.
Singing is the basis for musical education and one of the types of musical activity of
children. Child’s emotional, musical and cognitive development takes place in the pro-
cess of singing (Davidova, Zavadska, Rauduvaite & Chuang, 2017). However, teachers of
music face the problem of inaccurate intonation of 6–8 year-old children in the process
of singing. Children singing off key hamper the development of all the other children
in the group/class/choir. Different levels of musical development among children create
great problems in organising the teaching process and developing personality’s singing
206 Pedagogika / 2017, t. 128, Nr. 4
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15823/p.2017.64
ISSN 1392-0340
E-ISSN 2029-0551
culture as a whole: this is a topical issue in modern musical education (Welch, 1991;
Hennessy, 2002; Pribujsiene, Uloza & Kardisiene, 2011; Davidova, Zavadska, Šeršņova,
Rauduvaite & Chuang, 2015). Thus, elaboration of singing teaching strategies for chil-
dren is important. Furthermore, these strategies must be based on building a sequence
of teacher’s activities and creation of teaching environment for further development of
intonation and singing skills.
In 2015, an international project “The Coordination between Musical Hearing and
Vocal Apparatus of 6–8 Year-Old Children during the Process of Singing: Comparative
study in Latvia, Lithuania and Taiwan” was launched. The aim of the project is to deter-
mine and experimentally verify teaching strategies for the development of coordination
between musical hearing and the vocal apparatus of 6–8 year-old children during the
process of singing in Latvia, Lithuania and Taiwan, and to identify and determine the
levels of the development of coordination between 6–8 year-old children’s musical hear-
ing and the vocal apparatus during the process of singing.
In the framework of the project, a diagnostic study was carried out and 225 children
aged 6–8 years were tested: 75 children in each age group were tested in Lithuania, Latvia,
and Taiwan. The researchers randomly selected one class (group) from the pre-primary
groups, first and second forms. The number of children in each form equaled 25 (in total)
in every country (Rauduvaite, Lasauskiene, Abramauskiene, Davidova & Chuang, 2016).
Сhildren’s voice was tested by using the Children Singing Voice Measure Scale. The
Children Singing Voice Measure (CSVM) elaborated by M-J. Chuang (Chuang, 2010;
2011a; 2011b; 2012) was used in this study (for more details see Davidova, Zavadska &
Ming-Jen Chuang, 2016).
As a result of the diagnostic study, problems were identified that cause inaccurate
intonation for children. Based on the conducted research in Latvia, the percentage data
highlighted problems related to children’s voice diapason and intonation:
• undeveloped voice diapason, which does not at large surpass quarto-tertian;
• inaccurate intonation of melody, bordering “speaking voice”;
• intonation of the general ascending and descending movement of melody by inac-
curate inner filling.
An inaccurate intonation of even a few students has a negative effect on the general
sounding, it interferes with children who sing well by spoiling their musical ear. Typical
cases of inaccurate intonation were identified in each age group of children in the singing
process and specific strategies were developed in the framework of the case study. Ac-
cording to F. Abrahams and P. Head (Abrahams & Head, 2005), in music pedagogy case
study both a strategy and a method, which should contribute to defining the research
problem and to its solution in a form of a dialogue.
The aim of research: to elaborate strategies and didactic material for forming and
developing 6–8 year-old children’s singing intonation in the framework of a case study.
Research methods: theoretical analysis, generalization of pedagogical experience.
Pedagogika / 2017, t. 128, Nr. 4 207
ISSN 1392-0340
E-ISSN 2029-0551
Peculiarities of 6–8 year-old children’s singing intonation. Intonation – from the Latin
intono – 1) pronounce in singing, 2) sing. Musically and acoustically, correct reproduction
of the height and nature of the sounds (harmonies). The definition of intonation is the
sound pattern of phrases and sentences produced by pitch variation in the voice (http://
www.thefreedictionary.com/intonation).
In turn, musical intonation, unlike speech, has its own peculiarities, since it contains
a musical image. The musical intonation in European musical culture operates with tones
of precisely fixed height, and is based on a special musical-sound system and rhythmic
organization (Терентьева, 1990).
The famous Russian scientist B. Asafiev (Асафьев, 1971) claimed that all musical art
has an intonational basis, and any thought, to be expressed musically, takes the form of
intonation.
75 children aged 6–8 years participated in the diagnostic study from Latvia. The
number of children who do not know how to intone and intonate approximately, is very
significant. On average, in each of the three age groups of 25 people, there are only five
to six children who intone accurately, that is approximately 20%. The rest of the chil-
dren intone - more often approximately, or sing on two, three notes, or just completely
“speech-sing” (such singers are called “buzzer”).
What is the reason for the appearance of such children – “buzzers”? The Russian
psychologist A. N. Leontiev (Леонтьев, 2000) writes that most of the world’s languages
are “timbre-articulate”; they are based on the recognition of vowels and consonants, and
not on the distinction of the voice’s pitch. By 30% of the “timbre-articulate” population
speech is perceived by the colour of vowel sounds. For example, if you sing the vowels “e”
and “u”, then for many it will seem that “u” sounds lower than “e”. A child, first, learns
to speak; it means that, as stated by A. Leontiev, “speech hearing” develops earlier. The
development of speech hearing “blocks” the development of the ear for music. The melody
of the song is “recognized” indirectly, through speech. Therefore, the speech hearing is
at the head of the auditory perception. Will it develop into musical, in the opinion of the
psychologist; it largely depends on the environment.
However, in languages such as Chinese or Vietnamese, pitch is an integral part of the
speech. Therefore, we can assume that the children – participants of the project from
Taiwan – are endowed with a more subtle ear for music.
All children (project participants) with intonation difficulties can be divided into
three groups, each of which can be characterized as follows:
• children have a limited diapason, the sound attack is either aspirated or very hard,
which can also cause inaccurate intonation. Some sing very quietly, others very
loudly. Many of them lack the skill of connecting sounds legato – these are children
with violated vocalization. Some children also sing in a “whisper”;
• children who have difficulty with adaptation in a group (class), they are self-
conscious, shy, “blocked” children;
208 Pedagogika / 2017, t. 128, Nr. 4
ISSN 1392-0340
E-ISSN 2029-0551
• children whose disorders are caused by any of the chronic diseases of the organs
of voice formation, as well as diseases of the central nervous system. More often
than not, children with psycho-neurological disorders remain “buzzers” for the
entire period of education. It is extremely difficult to teach such children to sing
accurately.
Strategies for forming and developing accurate intonation. By taking into account
the above mentioned diagnostic results, strategies for forming and developing 6–8 years
old children’s accurate intonation were elaborated.
In order to intone, it is necessary to imagine the sound image – a kind of “pattern”
which one’s own attempt at reproduction is compared with. According to this pattern,
the motor system is regulated, when the sound image causes a corresponding motor
representation, therefore it is called the regulatory image (Кравченко, 1993). The forma-
tion of sound occurs not only in the sound and motor form: this includes visual, vibra-
tional representations. Based on this, a motor command is given from the centre to the
muscles, which is manifested during reproduction. By evaluating the result, a system of
analysers turns on in the head with the auditory ones, sending the information back to
the centre. This allows us to talk about feedback. Based on the analysis and synthesis of
information, the result is compared with the pattern. In the case when the sound of the
pattern and the attempt do not agree, corrective amendments are made: odd, unneces-
sary movements are removed, others are added and the attempt to reproduce the sound
is repeated. Only a large number of repetitions makes it possible to develop and polish
the many motor and vocal skills, corresponding to the most different sound results for
creating the desired palette of sounding (Морозов, 2002).
Work with inaccurately intoning children takes place with a musical accompaniment
or with the help of a teacher. As a teaching material only simple melodies are used with
a small diapason, only after repeated preliminary listening. It is advisable to begin with
the formation of vocal and intonation coordination. The child hears that he/she sings not
the same sound as the teacher, but he/she cannot sing it correctly, that is, these children
do not have coordination between the hearing and the voice. Often such children use
the chest register for voice formation. There are also counter cases when the child only
intones on high sounds and cannot reproduce lower sounds: such children try to sing
in the same manner as they speak. They are not able to go beyond the primary tones,
because they cannot use other ways to manage voice cords.
Vocal practice teachers J. Shaw (2013) and E. Leshchinskaya (Лещинская, 2011)
recommend not to separate such inaccurately intoning children from the group of good
singers. Julia Shaw also talks about the need to reduce distracting physical impact and
notes two points for students’ physical placement in classroom:
• place inaccurate singers on outside edges near accurate singers. They will be able
to hear both themselves and an accurate model, promoting self-monitoring;
• place two accurate singers together, rather than isolating single accurate singers
between inaccurate singers (Shaw, 2013).
E. Leschinskaya (Лещинская, 2011) recommends to put inaccurately intoning chil-
dren in the first row, so that they can hear the correct singing.
The main task of the initial stage of the formation of vocal and intonation skills is
the use of such methods that would allow the child to create a vocal and musical im-
age as soon as possible. The simplest way is the method of demonstration – showing
the sound by the teacher him/herself. In the beginning, the movement necessary for
correct voice formation (lower jaw, lips, form of mouth opening, yawn, movement of
the respiratory muscles) is also applied. All this must necessarily be combined with an
explanation. Thus, children develop knowledge about the basic laws of vocal sounding
and its reproduction.
At the age of 6–8 years, children are more likely to perceive exercises that form and
develop not only articulation, but also contribute to the development of imagination,
musical ear, memory, and also help the child to reveal the artistic image (Zavadska &
Davidova, 2017).
terial more easily, to mobilize attention. As an example, you can consider the game-like
vocal exercise “Acquaintance”:
Vocal exercise “What’s your name?” The aim of the exercise: learn to intonate the
interval of the descending minor third.
The course of the exercise: a) children stand in a circle, the teacher is in the center; b) the
teacher performs the singing, while showing by hand which of the children he/she asks and
simultaneously invites to answer; c) the child addressed by the teacher sings his/her name
(for example, My name is Sandra, and so on) to the chant of the descending little third.
The task in this creative game is complicated by the fact that the teacher can change
the tonality every time the question is asked, sing the melody at different heights. By this
the teacher provokes children to different tonal answers.
This kind of exercises should not be changed often, as their repetition contributes to
the formation of vocal-intonation skills, in addition, it is good, if the vocal exercises are
connected with the studied material, this allows to reinforce it once again.
B. The development of vocal skills of intoning with the help of warm-up singing
One of the types of work on the formation and development of vocal skills is warm-up
singing. Warm-up singing consists of special vocal exercises and represents a material on
which specific qualities of singing voice are purposefully developed in children. Warm-
up singing is done at the beginning of classes and perform the function of setting up,
preparing the vocal apparatus for work on the singing repertoire.
It is necessary to consider the following requirements for the selection of material
for warm-up singing:
• warm-up singing should have be universal character, which is especially important
in collective, choral classes;
• relative stability, persistence of individual techniques used by the teacher for a
long period;
• it is necessary to periodically supplement the group of vocal techniques.
Warm-up singing on half-tones strengthens intonation and develops hearing. The
most comfortable vowel for singing is “e”. Half-tones are sung on “e” up and down from
the primary tone, first with piano support, then without it. In order for the children
to hear themselves, they must sing quietly, without forcing the sound. Small songs are
better to sing without accompaniment. The vowel “a” also liberates the voice apparatus.
In the warm-up singing can be presented the elements found in the vocal-choral works
in different versions. In the work on the formation and development of vocal intonation,
it is necessary to take into account the following factors:
• voice should be developed on the basis on the primary sounds;
• the diapason of the voice which you can work within, for weak, singly little devel-
oped voices – just a few tones (mostly from three to five), for correctly intoning
singers – an octave. In both cases, there should be no tension;
Pedagogika / 2017, t. 128, Nr. 4 211
ISSN 1392-0340
E-ISSN 2029-0551
• the pace of work should not be rapid, it is necessary to work gradually, without haste;
• do not force the sound. Singing follows a moderate sound’
• the greatest attention should be paid to the quality of sound and freedom when
singing, to remove any barriers;
• of great importance is the work on the evenness of the sound power (on one, on
different sounds, on the whole phrase). It is advisable to carry out this work in
an even more limited diapason. It is necessary to equalize all sounds in terms of
sound quality.
In this context, as an example can serve the exercises and warm-up singing for the
reception of glissando. “Glissanding” on vowel sounds is one of the ways for achieving
pure intoning. Glissanding is done in a small diapason at different speed and relatively
long stops on low or high sound.
Game and warm-up singing “Clowns”. The aim of the game: liberation of the vocal
apparatus from impaction, mobilization of attention.
The course of the game: a) children line up in two rows (groups) opposite to each
other, between them there is a teacher; b) the teacher explains the rules of the game: from
the first group, the children indicated by the teacher will glide “roll” from a certain note
on the vowel “a” to a fifth down, and children from the other group from the same lower
sound will “swim up” to the fifth up on the sound the vowel “u”; c) the teacher demon-
strates the singing and then shows by his/her hand up or down, while pointing to one of
the children, inviting to glissanding.
For greater brightness of the musical image, children’s faces can express “surprise”
when moving upwards or, vice versa, “regret” when moving down. Emotion can not only
be intoned, it must invariably be supplemented by facial expressions, gestures, plasticity
and movement.
After several sessions with this song, you can switch to alternating separate sounds
of different heights without glissading (all children participate in this), completing the
exercise with the sound of maximum duration.
An interesting fact is that a child cannot sing a sound one tone higher than his
primary zone (Welch, 1991). However, six or seven steps higher, while using a different
manner of sound generation – he/she can do it, and, as a rule, the child begins to im-
mediately correctly intone the given tones. It is established that it is easier for children
to hear higher sounds of the first octave than the lower ones (Леонтьев, 2000). Based on
this fact, it is possible to work on the accuracy of intoning and switching registers (from
breast to falsetto).
There is a method when, skipping an octave up from the primary tones, the child is
asked as if to squeak some sound in a thin voice. This will help to switch it to another
register, falsetto. In this study, a game and warm-up singing is used, which allows to fix
individual intonation turns:
Game and warm-up singing “Octave echo”. The aim of the game: mastering of octave
interval intonation.
The course of the game: a) the teacher sings on a low note a quarter note; b) the chil-
dren “mimic” this sound with two eighth notes, taken an octave higher.
Conclusions
Vocal intonation is the exact reproduction of sounds in height. The purity of intona-
tion depends on the degree of development of musical ear and on the volume of auditory
representations. Typical problems of impure intonation of the studied age group of chil-
dren (6–8 years) include: undeveloped voice diapason, inaccurate intonation of melody,
sound attack either aspirated or very hard.
The strategies of formation and development of vocal intonation developed in the
study can be used with similar intonation problems in working with children 6–8 years
old. Vocal exercises, warm-up singing exercises, “intonational” games are the basis for
the formation of accurate intonation.
Purity of intonation in singing requires constant work on accurate reproduction of
sounds in height and direction of movement of the melody. Intonation develops sing-
ing data (widens the diapason), the sense of tonality, musical memory and imagination,
which in turn further facilitates the learning of two and three part works.
References
Abrahams, F., & Head, P. D. (2005). Case Studies in Music Education. Chicago: GIA Publications.
Asafev, B. (1971). Muzykal’naja forma kak protsess. Moskva: Muzyka. [Асафьев, Б. (1971).
Музыкальная форма как процесс. Москва: Музыка.]
Chuang, M. J. (2010). A Cross-cultural Investigation of Children Singing Voice Development. Taipei:
KAWAI Music Publishers.
Chuang, M. J. (2011a). A cross-cultural Investigation of Children’s Use of Singing Voices and Echo
Singing Pitch-matching Accuracy: Examples in Taiwan, Vietnam, and China I. Taipei: KAWAI
Music Publishers.
Chuang, M. J. (2011b). A Cross-cultural Investigation of Children’s Use of Singing Voices and
Echo Singing Pitch-matching Accuracy: Examples in Taiwan, Vietnam, and China II. Taipei:
KAWAI Music Publishers.
Chuang, M. J. (2012). Children Singing Voice and Sense of Tonality in Singing. Taipei: KAWAI
Music Publishers.
Davidova, J., Zavadska, G., & Chuang, M.-J. (2016). Level of the development of coordination
between 6–8 year-old children’s musical hearing and vocal apparatus: Diagnostics results
in Latvia. Journal of Teaching and Education, 6(1), 131–136. Retrieved from http://www.
universitypublications.net/jte/0601/pdf/M6K50.pdf.
Davidova, J., Zavadska, G., Rauduvaite, A., & Chuang, M.-J. (2015). Physiological features of
developing 6–8-year old children’s vocal apparatus. Problems in Music Pedagogy, 14(1), 119–129.
Hennessy, S. (2002). Music 7–11: Developing primary teaching skills. London: Routledge.
1
Daugpilio universitetas, Edukologijos ir vadybos fakultetas, Pedagogikos ir pedagoginės psichologijos katedra,
Vienibas g. 13, LV-5402 Daugpilis, Latvija, jelena.davidova@du.lv
2
Daugpilio universitetas, Humanitarinių ir socialinių mokslų institutas, Vienibas g. 13, LV-5402 Daugpilis, Latvija,
g.zavadska@inbox.lv
3
Lietuvos edukologijos universitetas, Ugdymo mokslų fakultetas, Muzikos katedra, Studentų g. 39, 08106 Vilnius,
Lietuva, asta.rauduvaite@leu.lt
4
Nacionalinis Taichungo pedagoginis universitetas, Edukologijos koledžas, Muzikos katedra, 140 Min-Shen Road
Taichung, 40306 Taivanas, mjc557@eahoo.com.tw
Santrauka
Dainavimas yra viena iš pagrindinių vaiko muzikinio ugdymo formų, daranti didelę įtaką
bendram vaiko ugdymuisi (Welch, 1991; Hennessy, 2002; Pribujsienė, Uloza ir Kardisiene,
2011; Davidova, Zavadska, Šeršņova, Rauduvaite ir Chuang, 2015). Nepaisant vaikų dainavimo
mokymosi studijų gausos, stokojama empirinių tyrimų apie 6–8 metų amžiaus vaikų muzikinės
klausos įtaką lavinant dainuojamąjį balsą. Nuo 2015 m. vykdomo trišalio tarptautinio projekto
„6–8 metų amžiaus vaikų muzikinės klausos ir balso aparato koordinacija dainavimo proceso
metu: lyginamoji studija Latvijoje, Lietuvoje ir Taivane“ tikslas – apibrėžti 6–8 metų amžiaus
vaikų muzikinės klausos ir balso aparato koordinacijos dainavimo proceso metu mokymosi
strategijas (kryptis) ir patikrinti jas eksperimentiškai.
Tarptautinio projekto tyrime dalyvauja 225 6–8 metų vaikai, po 75 Lietuvoje, Latvijoje,
Taivane. Atsitiktiniu būdu buvo pasirinkta po vieną ikimokyklinio ugdymo grupę bei po vieną
pirmą ir antrą klasę pradinio ugdymo mokyklose. Kiekvienoje klasėje ir grupėje pasirinkta po
25 vaikus (Rauduvaite et al., 2016). Vaikų balsai buvo testuojami taikant Vaikų dainuojamojo
balso vertinimo skalę (Chuang, 2010, 2011a, 2011b, 2012).
Tyrimu nustatytos 6–8 metų amžiaus vaikų netikslaus intonavimo dainavimo metu priežastys:
siauras balso diapazonas (iki kvartos apimties), dainavimas „šnekamuoju balsu“, nepakankamas
garso aukščio suvokimas keičiantis melodinei linijai; ir apibrėžtos vaikų intonavimo lavinimo
dainavimo metu strategijos: tikslesnės intonacijos formavimas jau pirminiame vaikų muzikinio
ugdymo etape; specialūs dainavimo pratimai, padedantys reguliariai lavinti intonavimą,
intonavimo koordinacijos fiksavimas.
Esminiai žodžiai: 6–8 metų vaikų dainavimo procesas, intonavimas, strategijos, didaktinė
medžiaga.