Scribd
Upload
163 views6 pages

Technical Evaluation and Comparison Report For TDD

The document reviews proposals from five companies - Tractebel, Saudi Water Partnership Company (SWPC), WSP, ILF, and Mott MacDonald - to conduct a technical due diligence of a desalination plant in Oman. It provides details on each company's team size, review methods, data requirements, site visit plans, timelines and costs. Based on the information provided, Mott MacDonald is concluded to be the most aligned with requirements and offers past experience as an advantage, though SWPC may provide similar services at optimal cost.

Uploaded by

Vuthpalachaitanya Krishna
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
163 views6 pages

Technical Evaluation and Comparison Report For TDD

The document reviews proposals from five companies - Tractebel, Saudi Water Partnership Company (SWPC), WSP, ILF, and Mott MacDonald - to conduct a technical due diligence of a desalination plant in Oman. It provides details on each company's team size, review methods, data requirements, site visit plans, timelines and costs. Based on the information provided, Mott MacDonald is concluded to be the most aligned with requirements and offers past experience as an advantage, though SWPC may provide similar services at optimal cost.

Uploaded by

Vuthpalachaitanya Krishna
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 6

Myah Gulf O

Technical D

Breifing about company No of visits Rqd


Tractebel is home to five of the world’s leading water
engineering companies:
Over 100 years of experience in Water
Over 1000 ongoing water projects in all continents
TRACTABLE Involved in O&M of desalination plants 2 site visits

Saudi Water partership company estblished in 2003,


SWPC involve water business with the objective tendering of 1 visit 5 days
plants and projects of desalination. Water transmission

WSP is recognised as a leading technical and project


management consultant on seawater desalination
projects based on Thermal (MSF/MED) and Membrane
(SWRO) desalination technologies as well as Hybrid
technology utilizing a combination of these. 
Worked on prestigious projects such as Shuweihat S1
WSP 5 days visit
IWPP & Fujairah F2 IWPP in UAE, Ras Laffan C
IWPP in Qatar, Shuaiba Phase 3 IWPP & Shuaiba
Phase 3 Expansion II IWP in Saudi Arabia, Al Hidd
IWPP in Bahrain, Barka, Sohar & Salalah IWPs in
Oman, Al Dur Phase II IWPP and other many projects
in the region.

The ILF Group is an international engineering and


consulting firm that helps its clients successfully
execute technically demanding industrial and no vists due to
ILF
infrastructure projects covid
500,000 m³/d world’s largest RO plant (Magtaa
IWPP, Algeria)
operating in Oman for over 40 years providing design
engineering and consultancy services.
MOTT MC Projects completed range from small village water 3 to 5 days
DONALD supplies, to water supply for the whole of capital area.
MM were the owner’s engineer for the 42 MIGD
Ghubrah Independent Water Project, in Muscat.

Comments/Conclusion: After having glance on all the proposals submitted by the parties technically Mot
shown very high ,
Since ILF is being planned to do the report without any personal visit & not requesting any special docum
SWPC ( saudi water partership comapny) with YAS engineers which is the part of ILF who is providing s
Myah Gulf Oman Desalination Company, S.A.O.C.
Technical Due Diligence Proposals Review Report

Team size Method of review & data reqd

Project documents ,
Plant Technical specification
Design report of various process units
team of 6 RO Membranes gaurantees and replacement
Annual performance test reports

site visit will be by local YAS


engineering(sub contractor) . Plant design data, Review of RCAs
(A team of 5 will work on project Actual wear & tear of equipment,
(YAS Consulting Engineers LLC (YAS CE) corrosion,
established in 1983 and it is part of the ILF Membrane historical trends,
Group which consists of several international Frequency of CIPS,
and independent engineering and consulting Membrane flux and recovery
companies with more than 45 years of Pretreatment system performance history
experience in various fields of competence.

Last 6 months O&M reports, Interation with


1 engineerwill visit site .
O&M team, Desktop review , project
agreements,EPC contract,As built drawings,
Team of 10 will work on project
performance parameter,O&M Reports

Not specially enclosed


team of7
Operation data for last 6 months,
O&M Logs and scada history
team of 6
etc

parties technically Mott MC Donald is much aligned with requirement and though it is having past assosiation with

uesting any special documents , Accuracy of the report cannot be justified,


f ILF who is providing similar services at Optimum cost can be considered /awarded.
Time for report Cost Cost in USD

1 month after data room 41917


access USDexcluding 41917
2 weeks after accepting draft VAT

79000 AED
Excluding covid
6 weeks 21507
requirement and
taxes

4 weeks for draft


25000 excluding
2 weeks for final report aftr 25000
taxes
accepting draft

44716 excluding
10 weeks to provide draft 44716
taxes
draft will be 6 weeks after
reciving all documens. 18985 OMR 49361
Final will be 2 weeks after excluding taxes
accepting the draft

ng past assosiation with the project as an added advantage cost wise is as

You might also like

pFad - Phonifier reborn

Pfad - The Proxy pFad of © 2024 Garber Painting. All rights reserved.

Note: This service is not intended for secure transactions such as banking, social media, email, or purchasing. Use at your own risk. We assume no liability whatsoever for broken pages.


Alternative Proxies:

Alternative Proxy

pFad Proxy

pFad v3 Proxy

pFad v4 Proxy