CB2 Booklet 2
CB2 Booklet 2
Subject CB2
Revision Notes
For the 2019 exams
covering
CONTENTS
Contents Page
Links to the Course Notes and Syllabus 2
Overview 4
Past Exam Questions 7
Solutions to Past Exam Questions 74
Final comments 127
Checklist 128
Exam Preparation Checklist 147
Copyright agreement
Legal action will be taken if these terms are infringed. In addition, we may
seek to take disciplinary action through the profession or through your
employer.
These conditions remain in force after you have finished using the course.
The module numbers refer to the 2019 edition of the ActEd Course Notes.
2.4 Discuss the production function, costs of production, revenue and profit
in order to understand a firm’s price and output decisions.
3. Explain how output and price are determined in such markets in the
short and long run.
4. Describe how monopolies emerge, how a monopolist selects its
profit-maximising price and output and how much profit a
monopolist makes.
5. Describe the barriers to entry in an industry and a contestable
market and explain how these affect a monopolist’s profit.
OVERVIEW
Module 6 covers the key issues faced by firms in making their supply
decisions. Economists typically assume that firms aim to maximise profits,
which are equal to revenues less costs. In this module we therefore:
build up a theory of production and costs in both the short run and the
long run
consider revenues
put costs and revenues together to determine profit and the level of
output at which it is maximised
consider the circumstances under which it is better for a firm not to
produce anything at all.
Different firms face different costs, which are often highly dependent on the
type of market in which they operate. Modules 7 and 8 consider four
different types of market structure, namely:
1. perfect competition
2. monopoly
3. monopolistic competition
4. oligopoly.
These modules apply the concepts developed in the previous module to firms
operating in the different types of market. They also discuss their main
characteristics, such as:
the number of firms
the degree of competition that exists
the equilibrium price and output levels
the level of profits made by the firms
the degree of efficiency.
In addition, the concept of the optimal output level is introduced here. This is
also covered in Module 10 on market failure.
Module 8 then goes on to consider the market structures that lie between the
extremes of perfect competition and monopoly, namely monopolistic
competition and oligopoly. These are collectively referred to as imperfect
competition.
When a firm has just a few competitors, as in oligopoly, it considers the likely
behaviour of these competitors when making its own decisions. In
particular, it must decide whether to collude with the other firms, or to
compete with them. Several different models of oligopolistic firm behaviour
have therefore been developed, including collusive models (eg cartels, price
leadership) and non-collusive models (eg Cournot, Bertrand and kinked
demand). Alternatively, game theory may be used to model the strategic
interaction between firms.
This section of the course contains many diagrams, some of which have
appeared frequently on past exam papers. It is therefore important to both
understand what the diagrams show and also to be able to reproduce them
clearly and accurately.
The traditional theory of the firm (as described in the previous modules)
requires the firm to determine its profit-maximising price and output level by
equating marginal cost and marginal revenue. In practice, however, a firm is
unlikely to know its exact costs and revenues, and so a variety of other
strategies are used to determine the price to charge.
This module therefore considers the different pricing strategies that firms use
in practice, having regard to the above factors and also a number of other
relevant issues. Bear in mind that a combination of pricing strategies could
be used for a particular product.
This section contains all the past exam questions from 2008 to 2017 that are
related to the topics covered in this booklet. These questions are taken from
the exam papers for Subject CT7. The questions are divided into three
sections – multiple-choice questions, short-answer questions and long-
answer questions.
Solutions are given later in this booklet. Answers only are provided for
multiple-choice questions. Other solutions give enough information for you
to check your answer, including working, and also show you what an
adequate examination answer should look like. Further information may be
available in the Examiners’ Report, ASET or Course Notes.
6 1-5, 7, 9, 10, 12, 17, 22, 24, 28, 2-4, 10, 11,
30-33, 35-37, 39, 41, 46, 49, 51, 12, 17, 20, 22,
52, 56, 57, 59, 60, 62, 63, 69, 24, 25, 30, 31,
70, 72-75, 78, 79, 82, 83, 89, 94, 34, 37, 38, 43,
95, 99, 101, 106, 107, 112-114, 44, 46, 48
119
7 14, 16, 18-20, 23, 34, 40, 42, 44, 5, 7, 26, 27, 2, 3
45, 47, 48, 53, 54, 68, 84, 85, 29, 36, 40, 41
88, 90, 96, 100, 102, 103, 109,
115-117, 122
8 8, 11, 13, 15, 21, 25, 26, 38, 43, 1, 9, 13, 14, 16 1
55, 58, 61, 64, 66, 76, 77, 81, 19, 23, 28, 32,
86, 92, 97, 104, 111, 123, 124 33, 45, 49, 50
7&8 6, 50, 71, 91, 105, 110, 121 6, 8, 18, 35 4
9 27, 29, 65, 67, 80, 87, 93, 98, 15, 21, 39, 42,
108, 118, 120 47
Multiple-choice questions
A firm selling only one good has positive marginal revenue where:
A firm faces the following relationships between capital, labour and output:
10 5 20
20 10 28
30 15 35
40 20 41
50 25 45
From the information given in the table what will be the output of the firm?
A product differentiation.
B the large number of firms operating in the industry.
C ease of entry into the industry.
D cost minimisation.
A inelastic.
B elastic.
C equal to unity.
D indeterminate.
5 7 100
5 8 140
5 9 170
5 10 190
A The marginal physical product of the 8th worker is lower than the
marginal physical product of the 10th worker.
B The marginal physical product of the 8th worker is higher than the
marginal physical product of the 9th worker.
C The marginal physical product of the 9th worker is lower than that of the
10th worker.
D The marginal physical product of the 10th worker is negative.
Which one of the following is NOT a barrier to entry into a monopoly market?
Assuming that the marginal and average cost curves are unchanged,
following an increase in demand, firms in a perfectly competitive market
may:
A raise their price in the short run but the price will fall back to its original
level in the long run.
B keep their price constant both in the short and in the long run.
C raise price in both the short run and the long run.
D keep price constant in the short run but raise their price in the long run.
A monopolist can sell 25 units of output per day for a price of £11.50 each
and 26 units of output per day for a price of £11.25 each. The marginal
revenue earned from the 26th unit sold is:
A £11.50.
B £11.25.
C £5.00.
D £0.25.
The kinked demand curve model of oligopoly is based upon the assumption
that:
A a firm’s competitors match both its price increases and price reductions.
B one firm in the industry sets the price for all other firms.
C a firm’s competitors match its price reductions but not its price
increases.
D the price charged by a firm can either rise or fall depending on what
happens to its competitors’ prices.
The total output and the average physical product of the variable factor
increase as long as the marginal physical product of the variable factor is:
A positive.
B above its average physical product.
C increasing.
D below its average physical product.
A firm that produces a main product and a by-product will maximise profits if
it:
A decides on the viability of producing the by-product after it has made the
decision to produce the main product.
B selects the level of output of the by-product where marginal cost of the
by-product equals its marginal revenue.
C selects the combined output where the combined marginal cost equals
the combined marginal revenue.
D uses cost-based pricing for the main and the by-product.
If a firm incurs a total cost of £874 when it produces 10 units of output and a
total cost of £950 when it produces 11 units of output, the marginal cost of
the 11th unit is:
A 1,824
B 950
C 54
D 76
Suppose that in a firm the amount of capital and plant size are fixed. If with
10 workers, the firm can produce 180 units of output and with 11 workers
190 units of output, then the:
A average product of labour when 10 workers are hired is lower than when
11 workers are hired.
B 11th worker has a higher average product of labour than marginal
product of labour.
C firm has not yet passed the point of diminishing returns to labour.
D marginal product of the 11th worker is negative.
A 20
B 250
C 160
D 25
In a perfectly competitive market, the typical firm cannot affect the price of its
output, and so it maximises profits or minimises losses when marginal cost
is:
A £20,000
B £15,000
C £7,000
D £12,000
5,000 bottles of a soft drink are demanded when the price for each bottle is
£5. When the price is £6 only 4,000 bottles are demanded. The marginal
revenue from increasing the price is:
A +£1,000
B £1,000
C +£1
D £1
Given that a firm’s fixed costs are £1,000, the average total cost of its output
is £4 and its average variable cost is £3.50, which one of the following will
represent its total output per period?
A 2,000 units
B 1,750 units
C 250 units
D None of the above
If firms in a perfectly competitive industry are making a loss in the short run
then in the long run firms will:
A attempts to maximise sales after assuming that the other firm will
attempt to maximise sales.
B assumes the other firm will produce a given output and then chooses its
profit-maximising output.
C assumes the other firm’s price is given and then chooses its
profit-maximising price.
D will attempt to collude with the other firm so as to set a price and output
level which will maximise industry-level profits.
Which one of the following is NOT a barrier to entry into a monopoly market?
A not run the extra flight as it will expect to lose £2,500 from its profits.
B not run the extra flight as its expected profit of £500 is insufficient to
cover its fixed costs.
C run the extra flight as it will add £500 to its profits.
D not run the extra flight as the expected revenue of £2,500 is less than its
fixed costs.
A costs of entry and exit are zero and potential entrants can enter the
market quickly.
B existing companies charge identical prices.
C the barriers to entry are substantial but the existing firms compete so
hard that industry profits are kept to the normal level over both the short
and long run.
D existing firms compete on price and quality so as to maximise industry
abnormal profits in the long run.
A economies of scale
B constant returns to scale
C diseconomies of scale
D diminishing marginal productivity
A Under perfect competition, in the long run only some firms can make
excess profits.
B Under oligopoly all firms make decisions without taking into account the
possible reactions of their competitors.
C For a monopolist facing a linear demand curve, average revenue is
always less than marginal revenue.
D Firms under monopolistic competition charge a price above their
marginal revenue.
Which one of the following is TRUE when economies of scale are present?
A the firm has to charge a price higher than the marginal cost of producing
the last unit.
B any decision by the monopolist to sell an additional unit of output does
not affect price.
C the firm has to reduce price on all units sold in order to sell an additional
unit.
D of the law of diminishing returns.
The range of output over which average variable cost falls will be the same
as the range over which:
A price-inelastic.
B price-elastic.
C of unit price elasticity.
D of infinite price elasticity.
The following data is for a perfectly competitive firm producing Good X in the
short run:
5 7 100
5 8 140
5 9 170
5 10 190
A The marginal physical product of the 8th worker is lower than the
marginal physical product of the 10th worker.
B The marginal physical product of the 8th worker is higher than the
marginal physical product of the 9th worker.
C The marginal physical product of the 9th worker is lower than that of the
10th worker.
D The marginal physical product of the 10th worker is negative.
A The long-run average total cost curve is derived by joining all the
minimum points of the short-run average total cost curves.
B The minimum efficient scale is the point at which long-run average costs
must begin to fall.
C In the long run a firm cannot alter its fixed costs of production.
D If a firm trebles all its inputs and its output doubles then this is indicative
of diseconomies of scale.
Total costs of production for a firm producing 100 units of output are $5,000
and fixed costs are $2,000. If output is increased by 1 unit in the short run,
the total costs of production are $5,030. Which one of the following
statements is TRUE with respect to the extra unit of output?
A The marginal cost of production is less than the average fixed cost of
production.
B The average cost of production is rising.
C The average fixed cost of production is rising.
D The average cost of production exceeds the marginal cost of production.
The idea that an oligopolistic firm faces a kinked demand curve is based
upon the assumption that:
A a firm’s competitors match both its price increases and price decreases.
B one firm in the industry sets the price for all other firms.
C a firm’s competitors match its price decreases but ignore its price
increases.
D prices can either rise or fall; it depends on what happens to a firm’s
competitors’ prices.
The profit payoffs to Firm X from various strategies 1 to 4 and the presumed
responses of the other firm in a duopoly industry is given below:
1 90 15 90 100
Strategy of 2 40 70 –20 –80
Firm X 3 25 50 120 130
4 10 40 70 60
A Strategy 1
B Strategy 2
C Strategy 3
D Strategy 4
A the firm has to charge a price higher than the marginal cost of producing
the last unit.
B any decision by the monopolist to sell an additional unit of output does
not affect product price.
C the firm has to reduce the price on all units sold in order to sell an
additional unit.
D of the law of diminishing returns.
A A firm doubles its inputs of capital and labour and its output more than
doubles.
B A firm doubles the number of products it produces and also doubles its
research budget.
C A firm produces a new product and in so doing lowers the average cost
of producing its existing products.
D A firm produces a new product and in so doing lowers the price it
charges on its existing products.
A For a firm under perfect competition in the short run, marginal revenue
will be equal to the average revenue.
B In an oligopoly industry, firms make decisions taking into account the
possible reactions of their competitors.
C For a monopolist facing a linear demand curve, average revenue is
always less than marginal revenue.
D A profit-maximising monopoly firm with positive marginal costs of
production charges a price in the region of the demand curve where
demand is price-elastic.
During the winter season, a hotel has fixed costs of £4,000 per week, total
variable costs of £5,000 per week and prospective total revenue of £4,500
per week. In such circumstances a profit-maximising hotel will:
A close down during the winter season since it would make a loss of
£4,500 during the winter season.
B close down during the winter season since its revenue is insufficient to
cover its fixed costs.
C stay open during the winter season as it will add £500 per week to its
profits.
D stay open during the winter season as the expected revenue of £4,500
is greater than its fixed costs.
The price of labour is £100 per unit; the price of capital is £200 per unit.
The kinked demand curve model of oligopoly is based upon the assumption
that:
A a firm’s competitors match both its price increases and price reductions.
B one firm in the industry sets the price for all other firms.
C a firm’s competitors match its price reductions but not its price
increases.
D the price charged by a firm can either rise or fall depending on what
happens to its competitors’ prices.
A firm’s total costs are £150 when 10 units are produced and the marginal
cost of the 10th unit is £40. The marginal cost of the 11th unit is £15. Which
of the following is TRUE?
A The average cost for 11 units is greater than that for 10 units.
B The total fixed costs for 11 units are £165.
C The average fixed cost for 11 units is the same as the marginal cost of
the 11th unit.
D The average fixed cost for 11 units is less than the marginal cost of the
11th unit.
The total output and the average physical product of the variable factor of
production both always increase as long as the marginal physical product of
the variable factor is:
A positive.
B above its average physical product.
C negative.
D falling.
A Strategy 1
B Strategy 2
C Strategy 3
D Strategy 4
A not run the extra flight as it will expect to lose £4,500 from its profits.
B not run the extra flight as its expected profit of £500 is insufficient to
cover its fixed costs.
C run the extra flight as it will add £500 to its profits or reduce losses by
£500.
D run the extra flight as the expected revenue of £5,500 is more than its
fixed costs.
A The firm will equate its marginal costs to its average revenue.
B The firm will equate its marginal costs to its marginal revenue.
C The firm’s average revenue exceeds its average variable costs of
production.
D The firm will make only normal profits.
A the firm has to charge a price higher than the marginal cost of producing
the last unit.
B any decision by the monopolist to sell an additional unit of output does
not affect the price.
C the firm has to reduce the price on all previous units sold in order to sell
the additional unit.
D the law of diminishing returns directly affects the price of an imperfectly
competitive firm’s product.
The prisoners’ dilemma, applied to a situation involving the only two firms in
an oligopoly industry, illustrates that:
A each firm will not take account of its rival’s reactions when making its
decision.
B the price set by one firm will not influence the price of the other firm.
C in avoiding the worst possible outcome the firms will fail to reach the
best possible outcome.
D in avoiding the worst possible outcome the firms will succeed in
reaching the best possible outcome.
The short-run supply curve for a firm in a perfectly competitive industry is its:
A firm’s fixed costs are £1,000 per period, the average total cost of its output
is £4 and its average variable cost is £3.50. Which one of the following will
represent its total output per period?
A 250 units
B 1,750 units
C 2,000 units
D none of the above
The short-run supply curve for a firm in a perfectly competitive industry is its:
A marginal cost.
B average total cost.
C average fixed cost.
D average variable cost.
In the short run, the range of output over which average total cost falls will
be the same as the range over which:
The short-run supply curve for a firm in a perfectly competitive industry is its:
A Some degree of monopoly power ensures that in the long run firms can
make supernormal profits.
B There is freedom of entry and exit into the industry in the long run.
C Firms in the industry produce differentiated products.
D Firms in the industry charge prices above their marginal costs of
production.
A Under perfect competition, in the long run only some firms can make
excess profits.
B Under oligopoly all firms make decisions without taking into account the
possible reactions of their competitors.
C For a monopolist facing a linear demand curve, average revenue is
always less than marginal revenue.
D Firms under monopolistic competition charge a price above their
marginal revenue.
A not run the extra flight as it will expect to lose £4,500 from its profits.
B not run the extra flight as its expected profit of £1,500 is insufficient to
cover its fixed costs.
C run the extra flight as it will add £1,500 to its profits.
D not run the extra flight as the expected revenue of £4,500 is less than its
fixed costs.
A When the input of both capital and labour doubles, output doubles.
B When the input of both capital and labour doubles, output remains
constant.
C When the ratio of labour to capital doubles, the output of the firm also
doubles.
D When more labour is added to a given amount of capital, the marginal
physical product of labour remains unchanged.
A firm that produces a main product and a by-product will maximise profits if
it:
A product proliferation
B constant returns to scale
C investment in spare capacity
D high advertising expenditure
A A firm doubles its inputs of capital and labour and its output more than
doubles.
B A firm doubles the number of products it produces and also doubles its
research budget.
C A firm produces a new product and in so doing lowers the average cost
of producing its existing products.
D A firm produces a new product and in so doing lowers the price it
charges on its existing products.
A The firm can make only normal profits in the long run.
B There are no barriers to entry into the market.
C The firm can make only normal profits in the short run.
D Marginal revenue is equal to average revenue.
A monopoly firm faces a linear demand schedule and has positive but
constant marginal costs which are currently below its marginal revenue. If
the firm wishes to maximise profits then it should:
A costs of entry and exit are zero and potential entrants can enter the
market quickly.
B existing companies charge identical prices.
C the barriers to entry are substantial but the existing firms compete so
hard that industry profits are kept to the normal level over both the short
and long run.
D existing firms compete on price and quality so as to maximise industry
supernormal profits in the long run.
A firm that produces a main product and a by-product will maximise profits if
it:
A decides on the viability of producing the by-product after it has made the
decision to produce the main product.
B selects the level of output of the by-product where marginal cost of the
by-product equals its marginal revenue.
C selects the combined output where the combined marginal cost equals
the combined marginal revenue.
D uses cost-based pricing for the main product and the by-product.
A the firm has to charge a price higher than the marginal cost of producing
the last unit.
B any decision by the monopolist to sell an additional unit of output does
not affect price.
C the firm has to reduce the price on all units sold in order to sell the
additional unit.
D the law of diminishing returns directly affects the price of an imperfectly
competitive firm’s product.
Short-answer questions
0 10
10 45
20 75
30 100
40 120
50 145
60 175
70 210
(ii) Construct three further columns showing the average variable costs,
marginal costs and total revenue for each level of output. [3]
(iii) State the profit-maximising level of output and the amount of profit at
that level of output. [1]
[Total 5]
Explain the difference between the law of diminishing marginal returns and
diseconomies of scale. [4]
0 50
1 60
2 78
3 105
4 140
5 195
6 264
(i) Construct a table which gives marginal cost and average total cost at
each level of output. [2]
(ii) State the level of output at which profit will be maximised. [1]
(ii) Explain and illustrate on this diagram the short-run and long-run effects
of a permanent fall in the fixed costs of production facing all of the firms
in the perfectly competitive industry. Use the number 2 (AC2 etc), for
any new cost curves, new revenue curves or price and quantity where
appropriate. [2]
[Total 4]
Draw a diagram which illustrates the argument that monopolies are bad for
society. Show clearly consumer surplus, producer surplus and social cost. [4]
(i) Draw a diagram to illustrate the profit-maximising price and output for an
oligopolist with a kinked demand curve. Use the following labels: AR1
for the average revenue curve, MR1 for the marginal revenue curve,
AC1 for the average cost curve, MC1 for the marginal cost curve, P1 for
price and Q1 for quantity. [2]
(ii) Use the diagram drawn in part (i) to show an increase in the marginal
and average costs of production which does not affect the firm’s
profit-maximising price and output. Use the labels MC2 and AC2 for the
new cost curves. [2]
(iii) Explain what you would expect to happen to total revenue if the firm
decided to raise its price above P1. [1]
[Total 5]
0 30
1 40
2 58
3 84
4 120
5 170
(ii) State the level of output that will maximise profit. [1]
[Total 4]
Company A incurs fixed costs of £200 per week to produce Good X. The
table below shows how the weekly production of Good X increases as more
workers are employed. The weekly wage rate is £120 per worker. Company
A can sell all it produces of Good X at a price of £25 per unit.
0 0
1 3
2 10
3 20
4 33
5 39
6 42
7 40
(ii) Determine the output level at which profits are maximised. [1]
[Total 3]
(i) Describe two reasons for firms experiencing ‘economies of scale’. [2]
(i) Draw a diagram to illustrate the total market demand curve Dm and the
demand curve facing Company X, D X . Add to the diagram, the
marginal revenue curve facing Company X, MR X and the marginal cost
curve MC . [3]
(ii) Denote the output Q X Company X will produce and the price PX that it
will charge in order to maximise its profit. [1]
Assume now that Company X believes that Company Y will double its
output to 2QY .
(iii) Show on your diagram the new demand curve facing Company X D X 2
and the new marginal revenue curve facing Company X, MR X 2 . [2]
(iv) Denote the new output Q X 2 that Company X will produce and the new
price PX 2 that it will charge in order to maximise its profit. [1]
[Total 7]
(i) Draw a diagram to show the market demand curve for loans at different
mortgage interest rates and label it DM . On the same diagram draw the
demand curve facing Bank X and its marginal revenue curve MR X .
Add the marginal cost curve MC of Bank X and depict Bank X’s
profit-maximising mortgage interest rate r1 and the quantity of
mortgages sold by Bank X as Q X . [2]
(ii) Show on your diagram the mortgage amount provided by the rest of the
banking sector as Q X QR . [1]
(iii) Bank X takes over all the other banks and becomes the sole provider in
the mortgage market. Bank X has the same marginal cost as before the
takeover. Show on your diagram the new marginal revenue curve
facing the new monopoly firm MRM , the new mortgage interest rate r2
and the new quantity of mortgages offered by Bank X as Q X 2 . [2]
[Total 5]
(i) Draw a graph showing the four stages of the product life cycle. [2]
(ii) Describe the stages of the life cycle of basic mobile phones. [2]
(iii) Explain the pricing policies of the basic mobile phone companies during
the cycle, including the later introduction of more sophisticated smart
phones. [2]
[Total 6]
There are two companies, Iceberg and Easifreeze, producing a single model
of identical freezers in a country. Both companies face identical demand
curves and costs and do not collude in deciding their pricing strategy. The
following table shows the possible prices they could charge and the profits
they could make.
Iceberg price
£ 200 £250
£120,000 Easifreeze
£200 £80,000 each
Easifreeze £50,000 Iceberg
price £50,000 Easifreeze
£250 £100,000 each
£120,000 Iceberg
(i) Determine the price for each firm when the equilibrium outcome of the
game is a Nash equilibrium. [2]
(ii) Describe the likely result of a Nash equilibrium outcome in the context of
expenditure on advertising. [2]
[Total 4]
(i) Draw one fully labelled diagram to illustrate the long-run equilibrium
position of a firm under perfect competition and a firm under
monopolistic competition. Assume that both firms have the same
long-run average total cost curve. [2]
(ii) Identify, with reference to your diagram, the excess capacity relating to
the firm in monopolistic competition. [1]
(iii) Explain how, compared to perfect competition, the price and output
decision under monopolistic competition affects the consumer. [1]
[Total 4]
(i) Draw a diagram to illustrate the profit-maximising price and output for an
oligopolist with a kinked demand curve. Use the following labels: AR1
for the average revenue curve, MR1 for the marginal revenue curve,
AC1 for the average cost curve, MC1 for the marginal cost curve, P1 for
price and Q1 for quantity. [2]
(ii) Using the diagram drawn in part (i) show an increase in the marginal
and average costs of production at each output level which do not affect
the firm's profit-maximising price and output. Use the labels MC2 and
AC2 for these new cost curves. [2]
(iii) Explain what you would expect to happen to the firm’s total revenue if
the firm decided to raise the price above P1. [1]
[Total 5]
You are given the following data concerning the production costs and the
average revenue of a profit-maximising firm that produces Good X. The
fixed costs of production are £100.
1 110 300
2 95 250
3 80 210
4 75 180
5 82 150
6 85 120
7 90 100
8 100 90
9 110 80
10 120 70
(ii) State the level of output at which average total costs are minimised. [1]
(iii) State what will happen to the production in the short run if the fixed
costs of production rise from £100 to £400. [1]
(iv) Calculate the smallest rise in total variable costs (to the nearest pound)
that would force the firm to cease production in the short run. [2]
[Total 5]
A perfectly competitive firm sells Good X at a market price of £18 per unit.
The firm’s short-run total fixed cost is £450 per day and the daily wage rate
paid by the firm is £130 per employee. No other costs are involved in
production.
The output of the firm varies with the level of employment as follows:
0 0
1 22
2 42
3 58
4 66
5 67
If the firm employs three workers per day, determine the firm’s daily:
When the firm is operating efficiently, the total cost of production per day is
as follows:
0 50
1 60
2 78
3 105
4 140
5 185
6 264
(i) Construct a table which gives marginal cost and average total cost at
each level of output. [2]
(ii) State the level of output at which profit will be maximised. [1]
(iii) State the level of maximum profit at the profit-maximising output. [1]
[Total 4]
Outline the major factors which explain the shape of a firm's average cost
curve in the short and the long run. [4]
Read both parts (i) and (ii) before answering the question.
(ii) Show on the average revenue line a point N at which only normal profits
will be made and the corresponding price (P2) and output (Q2). [2]
[Total 4]
(iii) Explain what is meant by ‘sunk costs’ and comment on how sunk costs
can be a barrier to entry. [2]
[Total 6]
(i) Explain with the aid of a diagram how, in the Cournot model of duopoly,
Firm A which has positive marginal costs will decide on its equilibrium
price and output for a given output level of its rival Firm B. [3]
(ii) Comment on how in the Cournot equilibrium for a duopoly industry, the
price and output compares with that of a monopoly industry. [2]
[Total 5]
The diagram below shows a firm’s short-run cost and revenue curves.
(i) State at what level of output the total revenues of the firm are
maximised. [1]
(ii) State all levels of output where supernormal profits are being made. [1]
(iii) If the above diagram were to depict a monopoly, state at what level of
output it would be making normal profits. [1]
(iv) State all levels of output at which the absolute value of the price
elasticity of demand is greater than one. [1]
(v) State all levels of output where the firm would be making an overall loss.
[1]
[Total 5]
The owner of an orchard can choose to grow apples or pears on their land.
Apples sell for £200 per tonne. Pears sell for £350 per tonne. The costs of
seed, fertiliser, labour and storage costs are £140 per tonne for both goods.
Calculate the owner’s cost and profit per tonne if the orchard owner decides
to grow pears instead of apples on their land. [2]
(ii) Now assume that consumer demand for hot drinks increases. Show,
with the use of a new diagram, the effect this will have on the market
price and quantity traded in the short run, assuming that the firm now
makes a profit. [2]
[Total 5]
List four factors which favour collusion amongst oligopolistic firms. [2]
You are given the following data concerning the average product of labour,
which along with 4 units of capital are the only two factors of production used
in the short-run production process.
Each unit of capital costs £100 and each unit of labour costs £75.
(i) Calculate the marginal product of the 4th unit of labour. [1]
(ii) State whether the average product of labour in the above table is always
greater than or equal to the marginal product of labour. [1]
(iv) Calculate the total cost of production when output is 490 units. [1]
[Total 4]
Discuss the types of market structure that would make it difficult for firms to
experience economies of scale. [3]
Firm A produces Good X, has fixed costs of £10,000 per year and has a
variable cost of £5,000 per year for each worker. Firm A can sell all of
Good X produced at a price of £200 per ton. The table below shows the
total production of Good X per year as additional workers are employed.
0 0
1 25
2 75
3 127
4 179
5 212
6 225
(ii) Calculate the total revenue, total cost and profit/loss per year when four
workers are employed. [3]
[Total 6]
0 10
1 20
2 26
3 30
4 38
5 50
6 72
7 105
(i) Calculate the average cost and marginal cost of production at each level
of output. [2]
(ii) Determine the level of output at which the average and marginal cost of
production are equal. [1]
(iii) Determine the profit-maximising level of output and the maximum profit.
[2]
(iv) Explain why achieving economies of scale is not compatible with perfect
competition. [1]
[Total 6]
The company Toshisoni sells a memory stick in Japan for ¥700 but it offers
three memory sticks for ¥1800 and five memory sticks for ¥2500.
(i) Identify the type of price discrimination strategy that the company is
exercising. [1]
Assume now that Toshisoni sells the memory stick at a single price of ¥600
in Japan and at a price equivalent to ¥900 in pounds in the UK.
(iii) Comment on the type of price discrimination that the company exercises
in this case. [2]
[Total 3]
Explain with the use of appropriate examples the difference between first-
and second-degree price discrimination. [4]
Consider the following data for a perfectly competitive firm, where the market
price for the good is £30:
Output Total
per week cost (£s)
0 5
1 45
2 78
3 99
4 114
5 132
6 162
7 210
(i) Prepare a table showing the marginal cost and average variable cost at
each level of output. [2]
(i) State ALL the options that indicate the firm is neither seeking to
maximise its profits nor minimise its losses. [1]
(ii) State ALL the options that indicate that the firm is making excess profits.
[2]
(iii) State ALL the options that indicate that the firm could increase its output
and increase its profits. [1]
(iv) State ALL the options which could correspond to the firm operating in a
long-run perfectly competitive environment. [1]
[Total 5]
(ii) Demonstrate on the diagram you have drawn in part (i) above, the
short-run impact of a fall in wages using new cost curves AC2 and MC2.
Indicate the new price P2, new average cost C2 and new quantity Q2.[2]
(iii) Explain the effect of the fall in wages in (ii) above on profits in the short
run. [1]
(iv) Explain what will happen to the demand and profits in the long run. [2]
[Total 7]
(ii) Describe the difference between the short-run and long-run shut-down
points. [2]
[Total 6]
(i) Describe the term ‘loss leader’ and the main factor that a firm should
consider in using a ‘loss leader’ as a successful pricing strategy. [2]
(ii) Discuss how a sports clothing store may use a successful ‘loss leader’
pricing strategy. [2]
[Total 4]
(i) Prepare a table showing the total profit and marginal revenue at each
price level. [2]
(ii) Calculate the price elasticity of demand using the average formula when
the price falls from £10 to £8. [2]
(iii) State over what price range the absolute value of the price elasticity of
demand is equal to, or greater than, 1. [1]
[Total 5]
The table below shows the annual profits for Company A and Company B
which produce Good X. The profits vary according to whether each charges
£15 or £10.
B’s price
£15 £10
£6 million for Company A
£15 £12 million each £18 million for Company B
price
A's
(ii) State the price Company A should charge if it makes its pricing decision
completely independently of Company B. [1]
(iii) Explain why this situation is known as a dominant strategy game. [2]
(iv) State the Nash equilibrium in terms of the price and profits of both firms,
if the game is played only once. [1]
[Total 5]
(ii) (a) Explain, with the aid of a diagram, how a price-leading oligopoly
firm that seeks a constant market share will set its price assuming it
faces a linear market demand curve.
Label the price set by the leader firm PL , the output of the leader
firm QL and the total market demand QD .
Long-answer questions
In a large city there are many pizza restaurants serving similar but not the
same products. Initially the market is in long-run equilibrium, then a change
in taste and fashion increases demand for eating out at pizza restaurants.
(ii) Explain what you would expect to happen to economic profit, price and
output in the short run and long run assuming no change in costs. [6]
[Total 14]
In a large city there are many taxi firms which can provide identical services.
(i) State the type of market structure under which the city’s taxi firms
operate. [1]
(ii) Explain and show on a diagram the possible changes in a taxi firm’s
economic profit, price and output given the following events. Use
diagrams which are initially in long-run equilibrium and take each event
separately.
(a) The city council decides to ease traffic congestion by banning cars
from inner city areas but not taxis.
In a large city there is only one inner city public transport system, Cititravel,
which provides bus services only, operates under a free licence from the
government and does not exercise price discrimination.
(ii) If the city council imposes an annual licence fee on Cititravel, use a
diagram to explain what you would expect to happen to Cititravel’s
economic profit, price and quantity. [4]
(iii) Assume that the market for bus travel is deregulated, reducing the
barriers to entry and enabling new firms to enter the market to provide
bus services. Assume further that Cititravel, as the established leader in
the market, sets the price and maintains 50% of the market, with other
firms following the price it sets. Use a diagram to explain how
Cititravel’s price and quantity are determined. [3]
[Total 10]
Multiple-choice questions
1 A 11 A 21 D 31 B 41 A
2 B 12 D 22 D 32 B 42 A
3 A 13 C 23 D 33 B 43 B
4 C 14 A 24 C 34 C 44 D
5 C or D 15 D 25 B 35 D 45 D
6 D 16 D 26 C 36 A 46 C
7 C 17 B 27 B 37 C 47 A
8 C 18 A 28 B 38 B 48 C
9 B 19 D 29 C 39 D 49 D
10 B 20 A 30 D 40 A 50 D
51 D 61 A 71 C 81 C 91 D
52 D 62 D 72 A 82 C 92 D
53 A 63 D 73 C 83 C 93 C
54 C 64 C 74 A 84 D 94 C
55 A 65 C 75 D 85 C 95 C
56 B 66 C 76 D 86 C 96 C
57 C 67 A 77 C 87 B 97 B
58 C 68 C 78 B 88 B 98 D
59 B 69 C 79 B 89 A 99 B
60 B 70 B or D 80 A 90 C 100 A
Short-answer questions
£ MC
AC
p*
supernormal
profit
MR AR
Q* output
£
MC
AC
p*
MR AR
Q* output
When output is zero, total cost is £10, therefore the fixed costs of production
are £10.
From the table, profit is maximised at 50 and 60 units. The profit at these
output levels is £5. If it is possible to produce single units of output, profit
might be higher at an output level between 50 and 60 units.
The short run is the period of time in which at least one of the factors of
production is fixed. The long run is the period of time in which all factors of
production are variable, (however the factors are of fixed quality).
In the long run, all factor inputs can be varied and hence the scale of
production is variable. If factor inputs are all increased by x%, ie the scale of
production is increased by x%, but output increases by less than x%, then
the firm is said to experience decreasing returns to scale.
If, in addition, factor costs do not change with the level of output, then the
firm experiences diseconomies of scale, ie the long-run average costs
increase. Diseconomies of scale can occur for a number of reasons,
eg managerial problems of co-ordination and communication.
(i) Marginal cost and average total cost at each level of output
Output per day Marginal cost of the last Average total cost (£)
unit (£)
0 – –
1 10 60
2 18 39
3 27 35
4 35 35
5 55 39
6 69 44
Output per day Total revenue (£) Total cost (£) Profit
0 0 50 –50
1 50 60 –10
2 100 78 +22
3 150 105 +45
4 200 140 +60
5 250 195 +55
6 300 264 +36
AC1
£ MC
supernormal AC2
profit
P1 AR1 = MR1
P2 AR2 = MR2
Q2 Q1 output
(ii) The short-run and long-run effects of a permanent fall in the fixed
costs
If the firm’s fixed costs fall, its average fixed cost falls and so the average
cost curve falls to AC2. However, the marginal cost curve will not be
affected since it reflects variable costs and not fixed costs.
Short run
As neither the marginal cost nor the marginal revenue changes, in the short
run the firm will continue to produce Q1 at price P1. As average revenue
exceeds average cost at this level of output, the firm will make supernormal
profits, indicated by the shaded area.
Long run
In the long run, the existence of supernormal profits in the market will induce
new firms to enter the industry. The resulting increased market supply will
reduce prices.
An oligopoly:
has a larger number of firms and needs to consider the effect of its
policies on other firms
will have less control over the prices that it charges than a monopolist
will typically face a higher elasticity of demand (and flatter demand
curve) for their products
is likely to spend more on advertising in order to steal customers from its
rivals
has a greater incentive (due to competition) to invest in research and
development, to reduce costs and hence prices.
A monopoly:
has only one firm and hence faces the market demand curve
typically experiences stronger barriers to entry than firms in oligopoly,
giving it greater power to make supernormal profits in the long run
may produce at the socially optimal output level if it is able to practise
first-degree price discrimination or if forced to do so by regulation
may be better placed to exploit economies of scale, leading to lower
costs and prices.
MC
£
a b
PM
c d e
PPC g h
f
MR AR=D
QM Q*=QPC output
The social cost to society from the actions of the monopolist is therefore
equal to the area e + h .
The price where the firm would maximise profit is approximately 5.5.
The largest output that can be produced without incurring a loss is 51.
M C2
£ M C1
AC2
P1
AC1
M R1 AR1
Q1 quantity
Output per day Total cost (£) Total fixed Marginal cost of Average
cost (£) the last unit (£) cost (£)
0 30 30
1 40 30 10 40
2 58 30 18 29
3 84 30 26 28
4 120 30 36 30
5 170 30 50 34
Total production Total cost (£) Total revenue (£) Profit (£)
per week
0 200 0 – 200
3 320 75 – 245
10 440 250 – 190
20 560 500 – 60
33 680 825 + 145
39 800 975 + 175
42 920 1,050 +130
40 1,040 1,000 – 40
MC
PX1
PX2
DX2 DX1 Dm
MRX2 MRX1
QX2 QX1 Q
QY1
QY2 = 2QY1
mortgage
rate MCX
r2
r1
MRX MRM DX DM
sales
per period
product doesn't
become obsolete
product becomes
obsolete
Growth: Rapid sales growth as early problems are ironed out and customers
gain confidence in mobile phones; firms make supernormal profit and
therefore new firms are attracted into the market.
Maturity: Growth in sales slows down and the market becomes saturated;
non-primary uses for mobile phones (eg texting) might be promoted to
extend the life of the phone; competition intensifies and firms engage in
promotions and offer discounts.
(iii) Pricing policies during the product life cycle of basic mobile
phones
Launch: The price was high as there was little competition and the early
adopters had a relatively inelastic demand for the product.
Growth: Although new firms entered the market, demand was growing
rapidly and prices remained high. Price competition was weak and firms
tended to compete in other ways (eg various payment schemes).
Decline: This is probably where the basic mobile phone is now, as more
people are buying the new generation mobile phone, the smart phone.
Further price reductions on the basic mobile phones may occur in order to
retain some customers, although companies that also produce the smart
phone might aim to reduce the price differential between the smart phone
and the basic phone in order to make the smart phone more attractive.
A Nash equilibrium exists when, given the other firm’s decision, neither firm
could improve its payoff and therefore neither firm would change its decision.
Since both firms have a dominant strategy (to charge £200), the dominant
equilibrium and hence the Nash equilibrium is that they both charge a price
of £200.
Firms are likely to get caught in a dominant and Nash equilibrium position in
which both spend large amounts on advertising. Given the high amount
spent by the other firm(s), each firm would not have any incentive to reduce
the amount spent. If they did reduce the amount spent, they would lose
market share and lose profit.
Since they all spend a large amount on advertising, advertising does not
achieve any change in market share (though it might increase market
demand). It becomes an onerous fixed cost for oligopolists, who get caught
in a prisoners’ dilemma, spending more than is optimal on advertising.
price LRAC
P MC
DPC = ARPC
P PC
DMC = ARMC
excess capacity
In the long run, firms under monopolistic competition will maximise profit and
produce at an output qMC, which is below the cost-minimising output, qPC
(which will be produced under perfect competition). The shortfall of actual
output below the cost-minimising output is known as the excess capacity.
(iii) How the price and output decision affects the consumer
M C2
P1 M C1 AC2
AC1
AR1
M R1
Q1 Q
(iv) Smallest rise in total variable costs that would force production to
cease in the short run
If total variable costs increase by £421, then at 4 units of output (which is the
profit-maximising level of output), the firm would not be covering its variable
costs and so would cease production in the short run.
£ £ £
PX
P*
PY DM
MC
DY
DX MRM
MRX MRY
QX Q QY Q Q* Q
loss MC
£
AC2 AC2
P1 AC1
AC1
supernormal
profit
MR D = AR
q1 q
(i) Marginal cost and average total cost at each level of output
Output per day Marginal cost of the last Average total cost (¥)
unit (¥)
0 – –
1 10 60
2 18 39
3 27 35
4 35 35
5 45 37
6 79 44
Short run
In the short run, some factors of production are fixed, so if a firm wants to
increase output in the short run, then it can only do this by increasing the
use of the variable factor of production, which is usually taken to be labour.
As the level of output increases in the short run, it is likely that workers will
be able to specialise, which should cause the short-run average cost to fall
as output increases.
Long run
In the long run, all factors of production are variable, so if a firm wants to
increase output in the long run, it can change all its factors of production, ie it
can change the whole scale of operation.
As the level of output increases in the long run, it is likely that firms will
initially benefit from economies of scale, such as the benefits of
specialisation and bulk-buying. These economies cause the long-run
average cost to fall as output increases.
P
MC1
AC1
A
P1
N
P2
MR1 AR1
Q1 Q2 Q
Potential rivals will therefore be able to enter / exit markets quickly and
easily.
Sunk costs are costs that cannot be recouped. If a firm buys a machine that
has no alternative use, then its cost cannot be recouped and it is a sunk
cost.
If high sunk costs are required in order for a firm to be successful, eg high
advertising costs are required in order to generate sales, then the firm may
be reluctant to enter the market. This is because it will fear that it might fail
and then be unable to recoup these (high) costs.
Price
MCA
PA
Dindustry = ARindustry
DA = ARA
QA Quantity
QB
MRA
Firm A will choose its quantity in order to maximise its profits. This is where
MRA = MCA , ie at quantity QA .
It will determine its equilibrium price ( PA ) using QA and the demand curve
( DA ).
Price
MCA
PM
PA
Dmonopoly = ARmonopoly
MRM = Dindustry = ARindustry
DA = ARA
QA QM QA+B Quantity
QB
MRA
Under the Cournot model of duopoly, the total output for the industry is
QA + QB ie QA + B in the diagram above and the price charged by Firm A is
PA . It is likely that Firm B will charge a similar price.
Therefore under the Cournot model, it is very likely that prices will be lower
and output higher than under a monopoly industry.
Supernormal profits are being made at Q1, Q2, Q3, Q4 and Q5.
Price elasticity of demand is greater than one (in absolute terms) at Q1, Q2,
Q3 and Q4.
2. Indivisibilities
Some equipment, such as a car assembly line, and some processes, such
as research and development, have to be of a certain minimum size. A
small firm would not be able to make full use of such equipment and
processes but large firms benefit from the lower average costs that such
facilities allow.
4. Economies of scope
A large car manufacturer will probably produce a large range of cars and this
might enable the cost per car to be lower than it would be if it were a
single-car producer. For example, technology that it develops for one car is
transferable to other cars; experience gained in marketing one car in a
particular country makes it easier to market other cars in that country.
Other economies of scale that you could have discussed include: the
container principle, multi-stage production, by-products, organisational
economies, spreading overheads, financial economies.
£ AC
loss MC
AVC
AC1
P1
AVC1
AR
MR
Q1 quantity
£ supernormal
AC
profit MC
P2
AC2
P1
AR2
MR2 AR1
Q1 Q2 MR1 quantity
Credit was also given for listing the benefits of collusion to the firms involved
since the question was open to this interpretation. The major benefit is, of
course, likely to be increased profits.
90 ¥ 3 = 270 units
No, the average product of labour isn’t always greater than or equal to the
marginal product of labour, ie at 2, 3 and 4 units of labour.
The total output from four units of labour is 400 units and the total cost of
producing these units is:
75 ¥ 4 + 100 ¥ 4 = £700
700
= £1.75
400
Seven units of labour at a cost of £75 each (together with the four units of
capital at a cost of £100 each) are required to produce an output of 490
units.
7 ¥ 75 + 4 ¥ 100 = £925
Economies of scale refers to the situation where long-run average costs fall
as the scale of production is increased. Economies of scale are therefore
associated with large firms.
For new firms entering the airline industry, there would be very high entry
costs (eg planes) and high sunk costs, as it may be difficult to transfer its
investments to other uses.
However, for existing firms, the costs of switching to new routes should be
relatively low. Similarly, the cost of switching from existing routes should be
low (ie low sunk costs).
Given that airlines already exist, and could therefore switch to new routes
fairly easily, potential competition exists for all airline routes (whether new or
not!).
The cost of offering savings products for the first time will be high as there
will be high costs of investing in computer systems, an administrative
infrastructure, and expertise. Furthermore, these costs will generally be
sunk costs, because they will generally not be able to be transferred to other
uses if the firm decided to exit the industry. In this sense, this market is not
a potentially contestable market.
However, for existing lenders, the entry and exit costs of offering a new type
of savings account should be fairly low.
However, the firm that has the current contract with a particular hospital or
group of hospitals is likely to have a local monopoly, at least in the short run.
Therefore, in the short run, the market is not potentially contestable.
In the long run, if the service provided by the current firm is seen to be poor
value for money and/or of poor quality, then the hospital is likely to seek a
new supplier. Therefore in the long run, the market is likely to be potentially
contestable.
(ii) Total revenue, total cost and profit/loss when four workers are
employed
When four workers are employed, total revenue per year is:
0 – –
1 20 10
2 13 6
3 10 4
4 9.5 8
5 10 12
6 12 22
7 15 33
(ii) Output at which average cost and marginal cost are equal
Four units
TR - TC = price ¥ quantity - TC = 14 ¥ 5 - 50 = 20
Economies are scale, which arise when long-run average cost falls with
output, are not possible as the industry consists of a very large number of
very small firms, each of which too small to exploit economies of scale.
(i) The type of price discrimination strategy and the reason for it
It will do this because the elasticity of demand is different in the two markets.
In fact, the higher price charged in the UK will be due to demand being more
inelastic in the UK than in Japan.
loss
MC
price AC1
C1 AVC1
P1
MR D = AR
Q1 quantity
Economies of scope
Firms that produce a larger range of products also tend to experience lower
average costs, as they can pool some of their activities and costs such as
research, marketing, storage and transport across a range of products and
so reduce their average costs of production on each individual product.
Again this makes it very difficult for new entrants to enter the market.
A firm that has a high degree of control over inputs (eg by owning a
components supplier) and/or outlets (eg by owning a chain of retailers) will
be able to prevent others from using them.
Aggressive tactics
A large existing firm may be able to sustain losses for a longer time period
than a new entrant. Hence it may choose to threaten a price war, expensive
advertising campaigns or after-sales packages that would deter new
entrants.
Legal protection
FDPD can occur in any market where there is some scope for bargaining
over the price, eg buying a car, negotiating fees for legal services.
This approach is often used to entice consumers to buy more units of small
discretionary items, such as packets of crisps or bars of chocolate, and
sometimes takes the form of ‘buy-two-get-one-free’ type offers.
B (as MC = AC = AR = MR)
A fall in wages will lower the marginal cost and average cost and so shift
these curves downwards. The result is the new higher output, Q2, the lower
price, P2, and the lower average cost, C2. As P2 > C2, the firm makes
supernormal profit.
The absence of barriers to entry means that in the long run, new firms will
enter the market, attracted by the supernormal profits to be earned.
The increase in the number of firms will reduce the market share of, and
hence the demand for goods produced by, each existing firm.
In addition, the increased market supply will reduce the price each firm
receives until they are once more making normal profits.
£ AC
AVC
P=AVC
D = AR
Q Q
In the short run, a firm should continue to produce provided it can cover its
variable costs, ie AR > AVC, so it is making some contribution to its fixed
costs. This is because if it were to stop producing, although it would have no
variable costs, it would still have to pay the fixed costs (in the short run).
In the long run, however, the firm must cover all of its costs, both fixed and
variable, otherwise, it will make a loss and will need to exit the industry.
The long-run shut-down point is therefore where AC = AR. Since AC > AVC,
it must also be the case that AR > AVC.
(i) Loss leader: description and main factor in its successful use
A loss leader is a good that has had its price cut – often to below its average
cost – specifically in order to attract consumers into a store. The idea is that
once in the store, consumers will also buy lots of full-price products.
The main factor the firm needs to consider is whether the use of a loss
leader will increase overall profit across a range of products, which in turn
depends on:
the loss leader having a price-elastic demand, so that additional
customers are actually attracted into the store
whether these customers will also buy a sufficient number of other
goods at full price.
A sports clothing store may use one item (eg running shoes) as a loss
leader, which it sells at a very low price to attract additional customers into
its store.
It hopes that once in the store, these customers will buy the reduced price
item, and also a selection of other (often complementary) goods at full price,
(eg running tops and bottoms, or GPS watches).
If successful, the loss leader strategy enables the store to increase its total
sales, and more specifically, its total profits. In addition, the promotion of a
loss leader might be used to increase awareness of the shop’s brand,
leading to increased long-run sales and profits.
DQ average Q +1 5.5
e= = = -0.82
DP average P -2 9
(iii) Price range where the absolute value of the PED is greater than or
equal to 1
The price range in which the absolute value of the PED is greater than or
equal to 1 is £20 – £10.
If Company A and B agreed to each charge £15, they would make total
profits of £24m, which is greater than the £16m total profit they would make
if they each charged only £10. Company A could renege on this agreement
by starting to charge £10. Assuming Company B continued to charge £15,
this would increase Company A’s profits from £12m to £18m.
The Nash equilibrium is for each firm to charge £10 and make a profit of £8m.
If both firms are charging £10, there is no incentive for either firm to change
strategy. All dominant equilibria are Nash equilibria.
£
MC
PL
D
AR
QL QD Q
MR
Other firms adopt the same price and the industry level of output is
determined by the market demand curve D , ie at QD .
Long-answer questions
Monopolistic competition.
£
MC
AC
P*
MR D = AR
Q* quantity
Suppose the initial long-run equilibrium is at output level Q1, with the
restaurant selling its product at price P1.
MC
£
AC
P2
P1
AC2 AR2 = D2
MR2
MR1 AR1 = D1
Q1 Q2 quantity
The change in taste and fashion will increase the demand for the pizzas
produced by each individual restaurant, with the result that both the average
revenue and marginal revenue curves faced by the individual restaurant shift
to the right, from AR1 and MR1 to AR2 and MR2 respectively. The profit-
maximising output level therefore increases to Q2, with a corresponding
price P2.
MC
£
AC
P2
P3
AR2 = D2
M R2
MR3 AR3 = D3
Q3 Q2 quantity
In the long run, the existence of supernormal profits, together with the
absence of barriers to entry, means that new pizza restaurants will open and
enter the market. The resulting increase in market supply will reduce the
demand for the pizzas produced by each individual restaurant, with the
result that both average revenue and marginal revenue curves shift to the
left, from AR2 and MR2 to AR3 and MR3 respectively. The profit-
maximising output level therefore decreases to Q3, with a corresponding
price P3.
(ii) Economic profit, price and output in the short run and long run
Initial equilibrium
Short run
The change in taste and fashion will result in an increase in the total market
demand for pizzas. In the short run, this will in turn increase the demand for
the pizzas produced by each restaurant. The profit-maximising output level
of each restaurant consequently increases, from Q1 to Q2. At the same
time, the corresponding price charged by each restaurant will rise from P1 to
P2. Finally, as average revenue exceeds average total cost at Q2, so the
restaurant will make supernormal profits in the short run (equal to the area
(P2 – AC2) Q2 on the diagram in part (i)(b) above).
Long run
In the long run, the opening of new pizza restaurants will increase the total
market supply, which means that the existing restaurants will lose market
share and so face reduced demand. New restaurants will continue to open
until it is no longer possible to make supernormal profits, so in the long run,
normal profits only will again be made. Consequently, the profit-maximising
output level for each restaurant will reduce from Q2 to Q3, with a
corresponding fall in price from P2 to P3.
In addition, if costs are assumed not to change at any point, then the new
long-run profit-maximising price and output, P3 and Q3, will be the same as
the original equilibrium price and output, P1 and Q1. Consequently each
original restaurant must end up with a smaller share of the larger total
market.
Perfect competition.
There will be an increase in the demand for taxis, and so the industry
demand curve will shift to the right (represented by D1 to D2 in the diagram
below).
Prices will increase from P1 to P2, and since firms are price takers, their
demand (ie average revenue (AR) curves) and hence marginal revenue
(MR) curves will shift upwards.
The firm will maximise its profits by producing where MR = MC, and since
the MR curve has shifted upwards, the firm will maximise its profits by
increasing production from q1 to q2.
This will mean that it will make a supernormal profit in the short run.
Industry Firm
S MC
P P supernormal
profit
AC
P2 AR2
AR2 = MR2
AR1
P1 AR1 = MR1
D1 D2
Q1 Q2 Q q1 q2 q
In the long run, new firms will be attracted by the supernormal profits and will
enter the industry (as there are no barriers to entry). The market supply
curve will therefore shift to the right, which will reduce prices until all
supernormal profits have been competed away. So, if costs remain
unchanged, then the market price and the output of each firm will both return
to their original level.
An increase in the price of fuel will increase both marginal and average costs
and the MC and AC curves will shift upwards.
The firm will maximise its profits by producing where MR = MC, and since
the MC curve has shifted upwards, the firm will maximise its profits by
reducing production from q1 to q2.
As the price is unchanged but average cost has increased, firms will make a
loss in the short-run.
AR1
P1 AR1 = MR1
D
Q2 Q1 Q q2 q1 q
As a result of this, some firms will exit the industry. The industry supply
curve will therefore shift to the left (from S1 to S2 ) and the price will
increase from P1 to P2 , so that losses fall to zero and the remaining firms
make normal profits again.
A new licence fee will increase the average costs and the AC curve will shift
upwards.
The firm will maximise its profits by producing where MR = MC, and since
neither the MR or the MC curve has shifted, there will be no change in price
or output.
However, as costs have increased, firms will make a loss in the short run.
Industry Firm
P P MC AC2
S2 loss
S1
AC1
P2 AR2 AR2 = MR2
AR1
P1 AR1 = MR1
D
Q2 Q1 Q q1 q2 q
As a result of this, firms will exit the industry. The industry supply curve will
therefore shift to the left (from S1 to S2) and the price will increase from P1 to
P2, so that losses fall to zero and firms make normal profits again. The
quantity produced by each firm will increase from q1 to q2.
£ supernormal
profit MC
AC
P1
AC1
MR D = AR
Q1 Q
(ii) How annual licence fee affects price, quantity and economic profit
supernormal
£ profit
MC AC2
AC
P1
AC1
MR D = AR
Q1 Q
The annual licence fee is a fixed cost and so it will increase Cititravel’s
average costs but not its marginal cost. As marginal cost and marginal
revenue are both unchanged, so will be the equilibrium quantity ( Q1 ) and the
corresponding equilibrium price ( P1 ).
Consequently, the increase in average cost will lead to a fall in the level of
supernormal profit. This is represented by a fall in profits from the larger
shaded rectangle to the smaller, upper rectangle.
£
MC
PCiti
Dind = ARind
DCiti = ARCiti
QCiti Qind Q
MRCiti
Without barriers to entry, new firms will enter the market. However, the new
firms will take the price set by Cititravel.
Assuming that it maintains 50% of the market, the demand (AR) curve for
Cititravel will be twice as steep as the market demand curve, and Cititravel’s
marginal revenue curve will be twice as steep again.
Cititravel will maximise its profits by producing where its marginal revenue
equals its marginal cost and will price accordingly (ie it will charge PCiti). This
price, which the other firms are assumed to follow, is lower than under the
monopoly market structure.
FINAL COMMENTS
There is a lot to learn for Subject CB2. One useful way of learning lists of
ideas is via acronyms and mnemonics, and the best ones are probably those
that you create yourself. Beware though that you don’t just write down what
you have learned without considering carefully the specific situation given in
the question. The examiners are keen to see that you can apply your
knowledge intelligently to the question. By intelligently, we mean that only
those points from the list that are relevant to the specific question being
asked should be included in your answer. It is by selection that you
demonstrate understanding to the examiner, rather than just the ability to
memorise lists of facts.
We also stress that learning definitions, formulae etc is not a substitute for
understanding. Many of the explanations we have described in this booklet
(and in the course) become ‘obvious’ once you have fully understood the
concepts involved. So, if you do not feel that the subject has become
‘obvious’ to you, then it may be that you need to take a step back and revisit
the Course Notes, or maybe do some more Q&A Bank questions.
We hope that you have found this booklet to be a useful revision aid. If you
have any comments that might help us to improve this set of booklets then
please email your ideas to CB2@bpp.com.
CHECKLIST
This checklist can be used as a detailed set of learning objectives that you
need to have mastered for this part of the Subject CB2 exam. Note that the
objectives listed below correspond to those in the checklists in Modules 6 to
9 of the Course Notes.
You can use the boxes that follow each item to indicate when you have first
understood the objective (a), and when you have become fully fluent with it
(z) (ie you have reached exam speed – being able to perform the task
required under exam conditions and in the time available).
4 Calculate numerical values for TPP, APP and MPP. (a): ______(z): ______
5 Draw the typical TPP, APP and MPP curves. (a): ______(z): ______
7 Explain how to measure the opportunity cost of any production decision for a
firm. (a): ______(z): ______
17 State the condition for the cost-minimising combination of factors in both the
two-factor and multi-factor case. (a): ______(z): ______
18 Distinguish between the very short run, the short run, the long run and the
very long run. (a): ______(z): ______
22 Explain, with the aid of a diagram, the relationship between short-run and
long-run average costs. (a): ______(z): ______
25 Draw typical TR, AR and MR curves for both a price taker and a firm with a
downward-sloping, straight-line demand curve. (a): ______(z): ______
26 Explain the relationship between elasticity and revenue for a firm with a
downward-sloping, straight-line demand curve. (a): ______(z): ______
29 State the two components of normal profit (%). (a): ______(z): ______
31 Explain how a firm decides whether or not to produce in the short run and
the long run. (a): ______(z): ______
35 Explain the factors that determine the firm’s degree of control over price,
ie its market power. (a): ______(z): ______
39 Sketch the firm’s cost and revenue curves for perfect competition.
(a): ______(z): ______
41 Explain and illustrate the derivation of the short-run supply curve for the firm
and the three possible long-run supply curve for the industry.
(a): ______(z): ______
48 Describe the barriers to entry that may exist. (a): ______(z): ______
49 Explain and illustrate how monopolists determine the equilibrium price and
output. (a): ______(z): ______
59 Discuss whether contestable markets are good for the public interest both in
theory and in practice. (a): ______(z): ______
62 Sketch the firm’s cost and revenue curves for monopolistic competition.
(a): ______(z): ______
73 Draw the equilibrium diagram for a price leadership model that assumes
that:
the dominant leader takes the part of the market not taken by the other
firms (a): ______(z): ______
the dominant or barometric leader takes a constant market share.
(a): ______(z): ______
75 Discuss the reasons for collusion breaking down. (a): ______(z): ______
77 Sketch the cost and revenue curves for the Cournot model of duopoly and
illustrate and explain the Cournot equilibrium. (a): ______(z): ______
79 Discuss the likely industry profits under the Cournot and Bertrand models.
(a): ______(z): ______
81 Describe and illustrate the equilibrium position in the kinked demand curve
model. (a): ______(z): ______
82 Discuss the link between the kinked demand model and price stability and
state the two major limitations of the theory. (a): ______(z): ______
86 Identify and discuss the different strategies that firms might adopt.
(a): ______(z): ______
87 Identify and discuss the dominant and Nash equilibrium positions of a game.
(a): ______(z): ______
89 Discuss the benefits and limitations of game theory. (a): ______(z): ______
92 Explain and illustrate limit pricing using cost and revenue curves.
(a): ______(z): ______
94 Discuss how each of the three types of price discrimination are applied in
practice. (a): ______(z): ______
97 Illustrate how the firm (a) increases total revenue and (b) determines the
profit-maximising prices and total output, under:
first-degree price discrimination (a): ______(z): ______
third-degree price discrimination (a): ______(z): ______
peak-load pricing. (a): ______(z): ______
100 Give examples of situations in which a firm considers the pricing of its
products as a whole rather than as individual products.
(a): ______(z): ______
101 Describe the four stages of the product life cycle. (a): ______(z): ______
102 Explain and illustrate how pricing varies with each stage in the life of a
product. (a): ______(z): ______
NOTES
NOTES
NOTES
NOTES
NOTES
NOTES
NOTES