Chapter 11. Estimating Smoke Detector Response Time: Input Parameters
Chapter 11. Estimating Smoke Detector Response Time: Input Parameters
INPUT PARAMETERS
METHOD OF MOWRER
References: Mowrer, F., "Lag Times Associated With Fire Detection and Suppression," Fire Technology, August 1990, p. 244.
tactivation = tpl + tcj
Where tactivation = detector activation time (sec)
tpl = transport lag time of plume (sec)
tcj = transport lag time of ceiling jet (sec)
METHOD OF MILKE
References: Milke, J., "Smoke Management for Covered Malls and Atria," Fire Technology, August 1990, p. 223.
NFPA 92B, "Guide for Smoke Management Systems in Mall, Atria, and Large Areas," 2000 Edition, Section A.3.4.
tactivation = X H4/3/Q1/3
Where tactivation = detector activation time (sec)
X = 4.6 10-4 Y2 + 2.7 10-15 Y6
H = height of ceiling above top of fuel (ft)
Q = heat release rate from steady fire (Btu/sec)
Before estimating smoke detector response time, stratification effects can be calculated.
NFPA 92B, 2000 Edition, Section A.3.4 provides following correlation to estimate smoke
stratification in a compartment.
Difference in Temperature Due to Fire Between the Fuel Location and Ceiling Level
DTf->c = 1300 Qc2/3 / H5/3
Where DTf->c = difference in temperature due to fire between the fuel location and ceiling level (°F)
Qc = convective portion of the heat release rate (Btu/sec)
H = ceiling height above the fire source (ft)
DTf->c = 1375.90 °F
Summary of Results
Calculation Method Smoke Detector Response Time (sec)
METHOD OF ALPERT 0.42
METHOD OF MOWRER 0.74
METHOD OF MILKE 0.26
NOTE
The above calculations are based on principles developed in the NFPA Fire Protection Handbook 19
2003, method described in Fire Technology, 1990, and NFPA 92B, "Guide for Smoke Management Systems i
Atria, and Large Areas," 2000 Edition, Section A.3.4. Calculations are based on certain assumptions and
have inherent limitations. The results of such calculations may or may not have reasonable predictive capabil
for a given situationsand, and should only be interpreted by an informed user.
Although each calculation in the spreadsheet has been verified with the results of hand calculation,
there is no absolute guarantee of the accuracy of these calculations.
Any questions, comments, concerns, and suggestions, or to report an error(s) in the spreadsheet,
please send an email to nxi@nrc.gov or mxs3@nrc.gov.
Additional Information
TER BOXES.
n values specified in the input
a wrong entry in a cell(s).
Calculate
134.28
6.07
Answer
Answer
13.03 ft
mounted smoke detector.
Answer
Organization
Organization
Date
January 2005
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Plant Systems Branch
Fire Protection Engineering and Special Projects Section
INPUT PARAMETERS
14
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Plant Systems Branch
Fire Protection Engineering and Special Projects Section
15
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Plant Systems Branch
Fire Protection Engineering and Special Projects Section
NOTE
The above calculations are based on principles developed in the NFPA Fire Protection Handbook
19th Edition, 2003. Calculations are based on certain assumptions and have inherent limitations.
The results of such calculations may or may not have reasonable predictive capabilities for a given
situation, and should only be interpreted by an informed user.
Although each calculation in the spreadsheet has been verified with the results of hand calculation,
there is no absolute guarantee of the accuracy of these calculations.
Any questions, comments, concerns, and suggestions, or to report an error(s) in the spreadsheet,
please send an email to nxi@nrc.gov or mxs3@nrc.gov.
Additional Information
16
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Plant Systems Branch
Fire Protection Engineering and Special Projects Section
17
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Plant Systems Branch
Fire Protection Engineering and Special Projects Section
RESPONSE TIME
1000.00 kW
130 (m-sec)1/2
165 °F 73.89 °C
9.80 ft 2.99 m
e than 0.707 or 1/2√2 of the listed spacing** 9.80 ft 2.99 m
77.00 °F 25.00 °C
298.00 K
0.70
Calculate
18
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Plant Systems Branch
Fire Protection Engineering and Special Projects Section
19
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Plant Systems Branch
Fire Protection Engineering and Special Projects Section
Organization
Organization
20
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Plant Systems Branch
Fire Protection Engineering and Special Projects Section
Date
January 2005
21
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Plant Systems Branch
Version 1805.0
The following calculations estimate fixed temperature heat detector activation time.
Parameters in YELLOW CELLS are Entered by the User.
Parameters in GREEN CELLS are Automatically Selected from the DROP DOWN MENU for the Detector Selected.
All subsequent output values are calculated by the spreadsheet and based on values specified in the input
parameters. This spreadsheet is protected and secure to avoid errors due to a wrong entry in a cell(s).
The chapter in the NUREG should be read before an analysis is made.
INPUT PARAMETERS
Activation
Temperature Tactivation
T= 128 UL Listed Spacing Response Time Index
F r (ft) RTI (m-sec)1/2
10 490
15 306
20 325
25 152
30 116
40 87
50 72
70 44
User Specified Value Enter Value
32
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Plant Systems Branch
User Specified Value Enter Value
Fire Protection Engineering and Special Projects Section
32
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Plant Systems Branch
T
Fire Protection Engineering and Special Projects Section
activation
= activation temperature of detector (°C)
NOTE
32
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Plant Systems Branch
NOTE
Fire Protection Engineering and Special Projects Section
The above calculations are based on principles developed in the NFPA Fire Protection Handbook 19
2003. Calculations are based on certain assumptions and have inherent limitations.
The results of such calculations may or may not have reasonable predictive capabilities for a given situation,
and should only be interpreted by an informed user.
Although each calculation in the spreadsheet has been verified with the results of hand calculation,
there is no absolute guarantee of the accuracy of these calculations.
Any questions, comments, concerns, and suggestions, or to report an error(s) in the spreadsheet,
please send an email to nxi@nrc.gov or mxs3@nrc.gov.
Additional Information
32
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Plant Systems Branch
Fire Protection Engineering and Special Projects Section
32
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Plant Systems Branch
5720.00 kW
e than 0.707 or 1/2√2 of the listed spacing** 4.00 ft 1.22 m
ure Heat Detector (Tactivation) 135 °F 57.22 °C
404.00 (m-sec)1/2
20.00 ft 6.10 m
77.00 °F 25.00 °C
298.00 K
0.70
Calculate
RESPONSE TIME
Activation
Temperature (°F) Select Detector Spacing
128
128 Scroll to desired spacing then
128 Click on selection
128
128
128
128
128
Enter Value
Activation
Temperature (°F) Select Detector Spacing
135
135 Scroll to desired spacing then
135 Click on selection
135
135
135
135
135
32
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Plant Systems Branch
Enter Value
Fire Protection Engineering and Special Projects Section
Activation
Temperature (°F) Select Detector Spacing
145
145 Scroll to desired spacing then
145 Click on selection
145
145
145
145
145
Enter Value
Activation
Temperature (°F) Select Detector Spacing
160
160 Scroll to desired spacing then
160 Click on selection
160
160
160
Enter Value
Activation
Temperature (°F) Select Detector Spacing
170
170 Scroll to desired spacing then
170 Click on selection
170
170
Enter Value
Activation
Temperature (°F) Select Detector Spacing
196
196 Scroll to desired spacing then
196
Enter Value Click on selection
Appendix B, Table B-3.2.5.1, 1999, Edition.
TECTOR RESPONSE TIME
32
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Plant Systems Branch
e of detector (°C)
Fire Protection Engineering and Special Projects Section
209.48
32
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Plant Systems Branch
Fire Protection Engineering and Special Projects Section
Organization
Organization
Date
January 2005
32
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Plant Systems Branch
Fire Protection Engineering and Special Projects Section
32
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Division of Systems Safety and Analysis
Plant Systems Branch
Fire Protection Engineering and Special Projects Section
32