PH Ysicsguide: Problems and Solutions in Ideal Bose Systems
PH Ysicsguide: Problems and Solutions in Ideal Bose Systems
gu Sk Jahiruddin*
Suchismito Chatterjee
ics
*Assistant Professor
Sister Nibedita Govt. College, Kolkata
Author was the topper of IIT Bombay M.Sc Physics 2009-2011 batch
He ranked 007 in IIT JAM 2009 and 008 (JRF) in CSIR NET June
ys
2011
1
©Sk Jahiruddin, 2020 Ideal Bose Systems
Contents
1 Problems from NET, GATE,
ide
JEST, TIFR & JAM papers 3
1.1 Basics, Bose Einstein condensation supercon-
ductivity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
1.2 Photon gas: Blackbody radiation . . . . . . 7
gu
1.3 Ans Keys . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1.4 Solutions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
16
17
ics
ys
Ph
ide
1.1 Basics, Bose Einstein condensation and
superconductivity
Prob 1.1. Which of the following atoms cannot exhibit
2010] gu
Bose-Einstein condensation even in principle?
2015]
(a) have strong inter-particle attraction.
(b) condense in real space.
(c) have overlapping wave functions.
(d) have large and positive chemical potential.
Prob 1.4. The chemical potential of an ideal Bose gas at
ide
Prob 1.5. An ideal Bose gas in d-dimensions obeys the
dispersion relation: ε(~k = Ak s ) where A and s are con-
stants. For Bose-Einstein condensation to occur, the occu-
gu
pancy of excited states
Ne = c
Z ∞
e
d−s
s
ics
0 eβ(ε−µ)−1
where c is a constant, should remain finite even for µ = 0.
This can happen if [NET June 2015]
d 1 1 d 1 d 1 d
ys
(a) < (b) < < (c) > 1 (d) < < 1
s 4 4 s 2 s 2 s
Prob 1.6. Consider an ideal Bose gas in 3-dimensions with
energy-momentum relation ε ∝ ps , with s > 0. The range
Ph
ide
(a) 2.17mK (b) 21.7mK (c) 21.7µK (d) 2.17µK
Prob 1.8. Non-interacting bosons undergo Bose-Einstein
gu
condensation (BEC) when trapped in a 3-dimensional isotropic
simple harmonic potential. For BEC to occur, the chemical
potential must be equal to
(a) ~ω/2 (b) ~ω (c) 3~ω/2 (d) 0
[NET Dec 2012]
ics
Prob 1.9. Two identical bosons each of mass m are placed
in a 1-dimensional potential V (x) = 21 mω 2 x2 . The bosons
interact via a weak potential V12 = V0 exp[−mΩ(x1 −x2 )2 /4~]
ys
ide
that state is [NET Dec 2014]
(a) 8 (b) 9 (c) 10 (d) 11
Prob 1.11. Consider a quantum system of non-interacting
bosons in contact with a particle bath. The probability of
gu
finding no particle in a given single particle quantum state
is 10−6 .The average number of particles in that state is of
the order of [NET Dec 2017]
ics
(a) 103 (b) 106 (c) 109 (d) 1012
Prob 1.12. Two identical bosons may occupy any of two
energy levels 0, where > 0 lowest energy state is doubly-
degenerate and the excited state is non-degenerate. Assume
ys
mω 2 r2
V (r) =
ide
2
The bosonic system is kept at temperature T which is much
lower than the Bose-Einstein condensation temperature Tc .
The chemical potential (µ) satisfies [GATE 2019]
gu
(A) µ ≤ 32 ~ω
(C) 3~ω > µ > 2~ω
(B) 2~ω > µ > 23 ~ω
(D) µ = 3~ω
ics
1.2 Photon gas: Blackbody radiation
Prob 1.14. The blackbody spectrum of an object O1 is
such that its radiant intensity (i.e. intensity per unit wave-
length interval) is maximum at a wavelength of 200 nm.
ys
ide
1 1 1
(a) 256 λ (b) 64 λ (c) 16 λ (d) 14 λ
Prob 1.17. In the radiation emitted by a black body, the
ratio of the spectral densities at frequencies 2ν and ν will
vary with ν as [JAM 2017]
gu
hν/k T
(a) e B − 1
(c) ehν/kB T − 1
−1
hν/k T
(b) e B + 1
(d) ehν/kB T − 1
−1
given as:
π 2 V (kB T )3
ln Z =
45~3 c3
[GATE 2010]
(i) The specific heat of the photon gas varies with temper-
ature as
ide
gu
ics
(ii) The pressure of the photon gas is
π 2 (kB T )3 π 2 (kB T )4
(a) (b)
15~3 c3 8~3 c3
ys
ide
body of radius R at temperature T is P1 . Let P2 be the
power emitted by another spherical blackbody of radius R/2
at temperature 2T . The ratio (P1 /P2 ) is [GATE 2016]
(Give your answer upto two decimal places.)
gu
Prob 1.22. A cavity contains blackbody radiation in equi-
librium at temperature T . The specific heat per unit vol-
ume of the photon gas in the cavity is of the form Cv = γT 3 ,
where γ is a constant. The cavity is expanded to twice its
ics
original volume and then allowed to equilibrium at temper-
ature T . The new internal energy per unit volume is [NET
June 2011]
(a)4γT 4 (b)2γT 4 (c)γT 4 (d)γT 4 /4
ys
ide
[NET June 2014]
gu
ics
ys
Ph
ide
temperature is of the order of [NET June 2018]
gu
radiation whose intensity spectrum peaks at 600nm. If the
temperature is reduced to 300K, the spectrum will peak at
[JEST 2015]
ics
(a) 120µm (b) 12µm (c) 12mm (d) 120mm
Prob 1.28. Blackbody radiation at temperature Ti fills a
volume V . The system expands adiabatically and reversibly
to volume 8V . The final temperature Tf = xTi , where the
ys
ide
Prob 1.30. A binary star is observed to consist of a blue
star B (peak wavelength 400 nm) and a red star R (peak
wavelength 800 nm) orbiting each other. As observed from
the Earth, B and R appear equally bright. Assuming that
the stars radiate as perfect blackbodies, it follows that the
gu
ratio of volumes VB /VR of the two stars is [TIFR 2013]
(a) 1/64 (b) 64 (c) 16 (d) 1/16
Prob 1.31. A gas of photons is enclosed in a container
ics
of fixed volume at an absolute temperature T . Noting that
the photon is a mass less particle (i.e. its energy and mo-
mentum are related by E = pc), the number of photons in
the container will vary as [TIFR 2014]
ys
ide
gu
ics
Prob 1.33. The cosmic microwave background radiation
in the Universe has a blackbody distribution corresponding
to a temperature 2.735 K. In a certain cosmological model,
it was assumed that the universe consists purely of radiation
ys
ide
2019]
(a) 0.30 (b) 0.18 (c) 0.46 (d) 0.06
Prob 1.35. Consider a radiation cavity of volume V at
8πV
gu
temperature T .
8πV 8πV
[GATE 2006]
(i) The density of states at energy E of the quantized radi-
ation (photons) is
8πV
(a) 3 3 E 2 (b) 3 3 E 3/2 (c) 3 3 E (d) 3 3 E 1/2
ics
hc hc hc hc
ergy state
ε= ~ω is [GATE 2008]
(a) exp k~ωBT
+1 (b) exp k~ωBT
−1
−1 −1
~ω
(c) exp kB T + 1 (d) exp kB T − 1
~ω
ide
1.2. b 1.14. a 1.26. d
1.3. c 1.15. c 1.27. b
1.4. b 1.16. d 1.28. a
1.5. c
1.6. a
1.7. b
gu 1.17. b
1.18. c
1.19. (i) b, (ii) c
1.29. a
1.30. a
1.31. c
ics
1.8. c 1.20. a 1.32. d
1.9. c 1.21. 0.25 1.33. c
1.10. b 1.22. d 1.34. c
ys
1.4 Solutions
Sol 1.1. to be able to show the Bose Einstein condensation
ide
then system should have the proton no+neutron no+electron
=even as they are all spin half if the even no produced then
they can as whole can be treated as a bosonic system but
for only potassium the value becomes 49 which is not even
gu
so potassium will never exhibit Bose Einstein.
Sol 1.2. 1)one of the possible con figuration is 3 particle is
in the lowest sate and 1 particle in the upper sate of energy 2
times the initial energy . but the upper sates are degenerate
ics
state so possible sates are 3 so only 3 possible states .
Sol 1.3. as in the Bose Einstein condensation more and
more particle comes down to the lower energy state hence
ys
ide
option c is correct.
Sol 1.6. from the previous discussion we have d/s¿1 .here d
is the dimension so d=3 hence we have lowest possible value
of 1 which is possible when s =3 hence the range would be
1¡s¡3.
gu
Sol 1.7. for the ideal Bose gas we have the condition that
the critical temperature is following the relation given below
ics
2/3
N
Tc ∝
v
so we say that He condensed at 2.17 K when it has density
ys
ide
V12 = V0 exp[−mΩ((x1 − x2 )2 )/4~]
= V0 (1 − [−mΩ(x1 − x2 )2 /4~] + ....)
so average of
gu
< V12 >=
V0 1 − [−mΩ(< x1 2 > −2 < x1 >< x2 > +x2 2 )/4~] + ..
= V0 (1 − ω/4w) u V0 (1 + ω/2w)−1/2
ics
Sol 1.10. the unoccupied state has probability 0.1 that means
that in 10 of the state 1 state remain un occupied and the
remaining 9 states are fulfilled and we are considering the
single particle state so the average number of the boson in
ys
the state in 9.
Sol 1.11. the probability of finding no particle in the par-
ticular single particle state is 10−6 this means that 1 in the
Ph
106 single particle state remains empty hence the total num-
ber of the particle is 106 so option b is correct.
Sol 1.12. let us first calculate in how many ways we can
arrange the two boson in the 2 state of which one is de-
generate . so we have 6 possible configuration . Of which
the maximum energy configuration has energy 2 and the
ide
2e−β + e−2β
E=
3 + 2e−β + e−2β
so at lower temperature temperature we have
gu
Sol 1.13. the bose Einstein statistics gives us
f (ej ) =
1
ics
e(ej −µ)β − 1
now we see that if µ is greater that the energy then the
occupancy becomes negative which is meaning less so the µ
must be less than that that of the energy of the system . we
ys
A is correct.
Sol 1.14. first use the λ1 T1 = λ2 T2 so we have T1 /T2 =
600 σT1 4
200 = 3 and we have E 1 /E2 = σT 4
= 81
2
E1 1 1
Sol 1.15. E2 = 24 = 32 so energy would be 32 times the
initial one .
ide
Sol 1.17. the ratio of the spectral density we have
exp(hνβ) − 1 exp(hνβ) − 1 h
hν/kB T
i−1
= = e +1
exp 2hνβ − 1 exp hνβ − 1exp hνβ + 1
gu
Sol 1.18. we know from the wien’s displacement law that
λT = constant so we can say λR TR = λw tw but we know
that λR > λw hence we can say from the upper condition
TR < Tw and we know E = σT 4 hence we have σTR 4 rR 2 =
ics
σTw 4 rw 2 from this condition we say that as TR < Tw we will
have rR > rw
Sol 1.19. i) the average energy of the system we can define
ys
∂(ln Z)
− =< E >
∂β
here we have
π2V
Ph
ln z =
45~3 c3 β 3
so we have the
π2V
< E >=
15~2 c3 β 4
hence the specific heat
∂ < E > 4π 2 V (kB T )3
cv = =
∂T 15~3 c3
jahir@physicsguide.in 21 physicsguide CSIR NET, GATE
©Sk Jahiruddin, 2020 Ideal Bose Systems
so option a is correct.
ii) first let us calculate the Helmholtz free energy of the
system and it is given by
ide
π 2 V (kB T )3
F = −kB T
45~3 c3
and we know that
∂F
− =p
gu
so we have the pressure
∂V
π 2 (kB T )4
P =
45~3 c3
ics
Sol 1.20. as the chemical potential of the photon is zero
that is photon number is not conserved hence we can say
that photons are created and annihilated due to emission
and absorption and it does not affect the system.
ys
P1 = 4σT 4 πR2
P2 = 4σ(2T )4 π(R/2)2
ide
∂U
cV =
∂T
hence we have dU = γT 3 dT and integrating we get
γT 4
U=
gu 4
hence the internal energy is just depending on the temper-
ature of the system as the temperature is unchanged the
internal energy of the system is also become the same. and
ics
hence the answer is option d.
Sol 1.23. the Helmholtz free energy of the system is F =
5
(kB T )4
− 8π45~ 3 c3 V then we can say that S ∝ T 3 for the blackbody
ys
P1 T4
= 4 4
P2 2T
jahir@physicsguide.in 23 physicsguide CSIR NET, GATE
©Sk Jahiruddin, 2020 Ideal Bose Systems
ide
Sol 1.26. we know that λs Ts = λx Tx Ts is surface temper-
ature of sun and the Tx is the surface temperature of the
unknown star. hence we get by putting the values Tx = 107
k.
gu
Sol 1.27. we know that λs Ts = λx Tx . which is wien’s
displacement law hnce we are putting the given values and
get λx = unknown wavelength peak = 12µm
Sol 1.28. for the black body radiation we have total en-
ics
ergy of the system E = σT 4 Ar2 and finally we have the
energyE = σTf 4 Arf 2 so we have σT 4 Ar2 = σTf 4 Arf 2 but
we know intial volume is V and final is 8V so we have
V r3
ys
λM T = constant
3
rR 1
hence we have VB /vR = rB = 64
ide
Sol 1.32. as T1 > T2 so the peak of the curve in the case
one will be higher than that of the peak of the 2nd one hence
the option d is correct.
Sol 1.33. the volume would be tripled in the future times
gu
now the energy radiated per unite area is E = σT 4 in future
we will have E1 = σT1 4 but total energy radiation would be
3
same 4πr2 σT 4 = 4πr1 2 σT1 4 we have been given that rr13 = 3
ics
so we have the final temperature is 1.896 K.
Sol 1.34. the Stephen Boltzmann constant is σ so the earth
is radiating energy is given by E=σT 4 per unit area per unit
time . and the value is E = 5.67 × 10−8 (273 − 18)4 watt
ys
8πV E 2 dE
have n(K) = c3 h3 so option a is correct. ii) the average
number ∞
8πV E 2 dE
Z
1
ide
n=
0 c3 h3 eβE − 1
where E is the energy of the photon so integrating we get
Z ∞ 2
3 l dl
n∝T
0 el − 1
gu
where the l =βE
so option c is correct.
n ∝ T 3 Γ(3)ζ(3)
ics
Sol 1.36. the photons are bosonic system hence we have
1
f = e( ~wβ)−1 hence the occupancy or you can say that mean
number of photons per state is given by (exp(~wβ) − 1))−1
ys