Ney, J. (2019) - Empathy in Content Marketing
Ney, J. (2019) - Empathy in Content Marketing
Empathy in
Content Marketing
Using Social Data and the Science of Psychology
to Create Content that Connects
Why Empathy Matters
Introduction
What to expect 1
How to use this guide 1
Why did we produce this guide? 2
Footnotes 29
Disclaimer 30
Introduction
What to expect
This guide is for marketing professionals who are committed to pursuing
data driven content strategies and connecting with their audiences on
an emotional level.
It also acts as a guide for how to use social data to find empathetic
connections with your audience. Use it for inspiration on how to get
more value from your social data with a specific focus on insights for
content marketing.
1
Introduction
2
The Challenges of Human Connection Online
You’re told that a great customer experience starts with human insights,
but these insights can be difficult to get (and act on). When it comes to
creating content, success is often held back by ineffective positioning of
what drives preferences, choices and behavior among audiences. The
trouble is that when analyzing customer preferences, most of the
market research is based on claimed data. By asking people what they
think about brand communications, whether they remember it and why
they do what they do.
3
The Challenges of Human Connection Online
This is where Meltwater Social can help you get to the psychology
behind online behaviors. It’s true that people can’t often voice their
needs, but their non-conscious online interactions can uncover hidden
insight into their psyche. How people talk about and engage with
content leaves clues as to what is important and subtle indications on
their future behaviors. Instead of chasing the latest trend, this guide will
help you to empathetically connect with your audiences’ true desires -
their underlying psychology.
This approach will help you stand out online, to build trust with your
audience, and ensure long-term brand health. The rest of this
whitepaper will explore why empathy is needed to standout online,
where current approaches to social data analysis have been leading
you down the wrong path, why brand storytelling must be rekindled, and
how to analyses social data to spark content ideas that have empathy
baked-in from the start.
4
Decisions, decisions, decisions…
It’s more than likely that there was an emotional connection of some
kind because, put simply, people need to ‘feel’ in order to take action.
We each make thousands of decisions every day and we don’t go
through a process of logical reflection for each one. In actual fact,
there’s lots of research that shows the majority of our decisions are
made unconsciously and driven by emotions.
5
Decisions, decisions, decisions…
All this unconscious thought also affects the content that people engage
with, and the bonds that they form around brands or even influencers.
In the advertising world, studies have found that campaigns that
perform well have a higher emotional appeal (31%) in comparison to a
rational rhetoric (16%)(2).
6
Decisions, decisions, decisions…
In terms of the British influencer, the staged and unnatural feel of the
post didn’t reflect reality or even a desired fantasy. There was no
emotional connection to the post. Emotions should always be hardwired
into the fabric of your brand and your content – this requires a good
understanding of consumer motivation. Taking this a step further,
studies show the emotion of ‘likeability’ is the measure most predictive
of whether an advertisement will increase a brand’s sales(4).
The same can be said for content marketing. So how can we get people
to like us?
Most of all, in your content, they need to see themselves either the real
or desired self. The big thing is to get them to imagine what it’s like to
be part of your brand.
7
Why Empathy is Your Secret Superpower
What is Empathy?
8
Why Empathy is Your Secret Superpower
Of course, you’ll likely know that empathy is the route to success, but
it’s often easier said than done. Take the creative process, for
example. It’s hard enough to create an amazing piece of content that
perfectly reflects your brand and your business objectives. Adding a
third dimension, your customer, complicates things even further.
9
Why Empathy is Your Secret Superpower
10
Using the Wrong Social Data in Content Creation
Maybe you’re one of these people. While it’s great that you have a
desire to create content that resonates with audiences but, if you’re
spending too much time on social trend data to inspire content
creation, that’s a dangerous place to be.
Why?
Even so, there’s still a few reasons why trends insights are so
appealing.
11
Using the Wrong Social Data in Content Creation
Availability heuristic
What’s the easiest data to get when analysing social data? The areas
where the largest conversation is happening – trends. The solutions
we use to analyse social data can lead us in a direction with easily
available insight.
Immediate gratification
Generally speaking, as humans we want things now rather than later
– we seek immediate gratification. This means we have a strong
tendency to grab smaller, immediate rewards and skip the larger but
delayed reward. Social media is causing the same to happen in
marketing – short term needs (likes and clicks) over long term
objectives.
The ability to track click through rates, likes, comments and shares
and reporting these results is killing what really matters – brand value
and customer lifetime value. If you’re only chasing the latest trends,
you’re trading culture and short-term metrics which leads to short-
term customers.
12
Using the Wrong Social Data in Content Creation
Cultural Relevance
There’s so much pressure for brands to act and be perceived as
“culturally relevant”. We live in world at the whim of the latest trends,
where good creative ideas have become disposable. But just because
something is trending doesn’t mean you should be engaging in that
topic if it doesn’t make sense for your brand to be there.
Your brand values and principles should dictate where, when and how
you speak about different topics and trends. Don’t forget about the
power of ideas to sustain long-term effects.
A few things: they have a consistent brand image that relates to their
brand values; they talk deeply about skincare and issues surrounding
skincare types; they relate their brand into other areas that ‘nourish’
their audiences’ soul and intellect.
13
Using the Wrong Social Data in Content Creation
14
Using the Wrong Social Data in Content Creation
None of this means that you should stay away from trends all together.
Instead, ensure they connect with the larger picture you’re trying to
communicate with your brand. You don’t need to post about every
holiday or major event if it doesn’t make sense for you to be there.
15
Using the Wrong Social Data in Content Creation
1. Relevance: what does your brand stand for, what’s your brand
values? You also need to think about the common associations to
your brand, so the pattern fits when your customer is scanning
content.
2. Empathy: what is the customer thinking and feeling, what are they
trying to achieve and what is stopping them?
3. Creative: how can you tell this story in a way that inspires action
and creates an emotional relationship?
It’s one thing to know the topics and emotions that will create an
empathetic bond with your customer, it’s another to frame the
messages and content effectively. In the next section, we’ll take a
look at storytelling in the digital age.
16
Prioritizing Brand Storytelling
It’s natural that brands want to be the central character of their story, but
this can be a mistake. Great content is often about getting inside the
world of the consumer and becoming part of it. Unfortunately, even with
access to unprecedented amounts of social data, giving you previously
unquantifiable insights from actual people, it’s still incredibly difficult to
translate these insights into creative ideas.
17
Prioritizing Brand Storytelling
It’s no coincidence that the best leaders and brands are amazing
storytellers. In a world of noise, information overload, hype, and
misinformation, stories can cut through to get your message across,
and influence people.
18
Prioritizing Brand Storytelling
4. Having a goal in mind but not more than one, and don’t
preach. No one want to hear that!
Luckily, when used right, social data can help us tap into and
understand the three types of empathy - cognitive, emotional and
compassionate empathy.
19
Social Data’s Role in Empathetic Content Inspiration
You can use all "voice of the customer data" from product reviews,
social customer service channels, user generated content, forum
content, and other forms of online text and visual "voice of the
customer" content. The process is about understanding your
audiences' intentions and beliefs through reasoning about the state of
mind. Simply, the purpose of following data driven empathetic insights
is to make more informed decisions and build better experience by
putting your customers at the heart of your brand.
20
Social Data’s Role in Empathetic Content Inspiration
21
Social Data’s Role in Empathetic Content Inspiration
22
Social Data’s Role in Empathetic Content Inspiration
23
Social Data’s Role in Empathetic Content Inspiration
24
Social Data’s Role in Empathetic Content Inspiration
Empathy has been found to inspire creativity. One study found that
designer think more creatively and produce more unique, effective
products when their primary focus is to imagine how their potential
customers might feel when using the products in question(8). To use
compassionate empathy when creating new content and experiences,
you must brief teams in a new way - encouraging them to "feel" what
it is like to interact with the brand and content.
Your brand identity should still be present in the aesthetic, design and
feel but it should be empathetically connected to your audiences'
emotions surrounding the use of your brand in their lives.
25
Social Data’s Role in Empathetic Content Inspiration
This work highlights that even niche and sensitive topics can be
researched using social data. In fact, the research found that the
anxiety and uncertainty people feel about returning to work after a
miscarriage is widely discussed on social media but not in the
workplace, wider media or wider world.
26
Social Data’s Role in Empathetic Content Inspiration
Now imagine the type of empathetic insights that are waiting for you.
27
Conclusion
Footnotes
(1) Soon, C.S., Brass, M., Heinze, HJ. And Haynes, JD. (2008).
‘Unconscious determinants of free decisions in the human brain’,
Nature Neuroscience, Vol 11, No 5: pg543-545.
(2) IPA dataBANK case studies of successful advertising campaigns,
Accessed online: https://ipa.co.uk/awards-events/effectiveness-
awards/ease.
(3) Brandt, D. (2019). ‘Emotions Give a Lift to Advertising’, Nielsen,
Accessed online: https://www.nielsen.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/
3/2019/04/whats-next-emotions-give-a-lift-to-advertising-
jan-2016-1.pdf
(4) The Advertising Research Foundation. (2016). ‘Taking Charge in the
Wild West Era of High Impact Advertising via Advertising Week,
Accessed online: https://thearf.org/category/news-you-can-use/
taking-charge-in-the-wild-west-era-of-high-impact-advertising-via-
advertising-week-source-rob-garber-managing-director-undertone-
emea/
(5) Steimer, S. (2019). ‘How Does Empathetic Marketing Make You
Feel?’, American Marketing Association, Accessed Online: https://
www.ama.org/marketing-news/how-does-empathetic-marketing-
make-you-feel/
(6) The Social Intelligence Lab. (2019). The State of Social Intelligence
2019, Accessed online: https://thesilab.com/report/state-of-social-
intelligence-2019-report/
(7) O’Shaughnessy, J. and O’Shaughnessy, N.J. (2002). The Marketing
Power of Emotion, Oxford University Press: United Kingdom.
(8) Hall, C. (2019). ‘The Power of Empathy in Product Development’,
University of Connecticut, Accessed online: https://today.uconn.edu/
2019/05/power-empathy-product-development/#
(9) Hollow, J. (2019). Back to Work After a Miscarriage, Listen and
Learn Research, Accessed online: https://
listenandlearnresearch.com/back-to-work-after-a-miscarriage/
29
Disclaimer
Disclaimer
Although the information and data used in this report have been produced and
processed from sources believed to be reliable, no warranty expressed or
implied is made regarding the completeness, accuracy, adequacy, or use of
information. The authors and contributors of the information and data shall
have no liability for errors or omissions contained herein or for interpretation
thereof. References to any specific product or brand by trade name, trademark
or otherwise does not constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation of
favouring by the authors or contributor and shall not be used of advertising or
product endorsement purposes. The opinion expressed herein are subject to
change without notice.
Dr Jillian Ney
The Social Intelligence Lab
Tontine
20 Trongate
Glasgow
G1 5ES
30
Meltwater is the global leading media
intelligence platform.
meltwater.com