MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

www.fea-academy.com

MASTERCLASS #1

PREPARING AN THE 50 MOST FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS WITH ANSWERS

FEA INTERVIEW

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 1

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
I decided to cover this topic because many students all over the world recently
contacted me asking this question.

Since I am not a job interviewer, I contacted people around me who are involved in
such a role from various industries, and I asked them which questions they ask to
the candidates they interview for an FEA position.

Then, I selected the 50 most frequently asked questions and in this document I am
going to give you the best answers, I mean the answers that an interviewer wish to
hear.

After each answer I give you the chapter number of my book “Practical Finite
Element Analysis for Mechanical Engineers” in which you can find more details
related to the questions. It’s always good to give a short answer to the questions
but it is good also to be prepared to answer in detail if the interviewer asks for
more details.

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 1

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #1
DEFINE FINITE ELEMENT METHOD (FEM)

Answer: FEM is a numerical technique for finding approximate

solutions of partial differential equations by solving boundary
value problems in which a large domain is divided into smaller
pieces called elements.
The solution is determined by assuming certain polynomials. The
small pieces are called finite elements and the polynomials are
called shape functions.

See more details in Chapter 1: Defining Finite Element Analysis

and Chapter 2: Working with FEA

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 2

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
QUESTION #2
LIST OUT THREE ADVANTAGES OF FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS

Answer:
1. FEA allows for modeling of complex geometrical and
irregular shapes with complex load conditions that we
cannot solve using classical methods.

2. Many different types of boundary conditions can be

considered.

3. Since the properties of each element are evaluated

separately, different material properties can be
considered for each element.

See more details in Chapter 2: Working with FEA

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 3
By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #3
WHAT ARE THE BASIC STEPS FOR BUILDING AN FEA?

Answer:
1. Cleanup of geometry
2. Discretization of the structure (meshing)
3. Applying the element properties
4. Applying the boundary conditions (restraints and
loading)
5. Setting the solution
6. Solving
7. Verification and Post-processing

See more details in Chapter 2: Working with FEA

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 4

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
QUESTION #4
WHY TO DO FEA?

Answer: We do FEA because this kind of analysis uses

mathematical models to understand and quantify the
effects of real-world conditions at the three stages of the
product lifecycle:
• Before, to define the product, to help the engineers
create a feasible design.
• After the product is designed, to permit the validation
of the defined design.
• After the product is released, to investigate product
failures.

See more details in Chapter 2: Working with FEA

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 5

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #5
HOW ACCURATE IS FEA?

Answer: FEA can yield spectacularly accurate results when

compared with physical test results. However, in a complex FEA,
it is still not possible to obtain an error of less than 1% in the
whole model. Generally, a target of ±10% global error allows for
very good predictions, but this target does not prevent the
occurrence of better accuracy in some local regions of the FEA.

An FEA will give accurate results if the analyst pay attention to

many parameters like geometrical and material properties, mesh
quality, loading conditions, boundary condition, to name a few.
But at the end it is not possible to obtain a better accuracy than
the input data permits.
See more details in Chapter 2: Working with FEA

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 6

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
QUESTION #6
WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE FINITE
DISPLACEMENT METHOD (FDM) AND THE FINITE
ELEMENT METHOD (FEM)?
Answer:
FDM is a numerical method for solving differential equations
by approximating derivatives while FEM is a numerical method
for finding approximate solutions to boundary value problems
for partial differential equations.

FDM is an older method than FEM that requires less

computational power but is also less accurate in some cases
where higher-order accuracy is required. FEM permits to get a
higher order of accuracy but requires more computational
power and is also more exigent on the quality of the mesh.

See more details in Chapter 1: Defining Finite Element Analysis

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 7

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #7
WHAT IS MEANT BY DISCRETIZATION?
WHAT IS MEANT BY MESHING?

Answer: Discretization (or meshing) is the process of

subdividing the components into a number of elements
which results in a system of equivalent finite elements.

See more details in Chapter 1: Defining FEA

See more details in Chapter 8: Meshing

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 8

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
QUESTION #8
WHAT ARE THE FACTORS GOVERNING THE SELECTION OF
ELEMENT TYPES?

Answer:
1. The geometry of the parts I want to analyze
2. The behaviors I wish to capture

Mention that the knowledge of the Library of

Elements related to the FEA package we are using to
do our models is fundamental for a good selection of
elements.

See more details in Chapter 7: The Library of Elements

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 9

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #9
WHAT IS MEANT BY STIFFNESS MATRIX?

Answer: In order to find a solution to the governing

partial differential equations, the finite element method
is used as the numerical method to find the solution.
In the process, the stiffness matrix represents the system
of linear equations that must be solved in order to find an
approximate solution to the differential equations.

See more details in Chapter 5: Basics of FEM Theory

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 10

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #10
GIVE THE MAIN PROPERTIES OF THE GLOBAL STIFFNESS
MATRIX OF A SYSTEM MODELED BY FEM
Answer:
1. The order of the global stiffness matrix corresponds to
the total number of degrees of freedom
2. The global stiffness matrix is singular (needs boundary
conditions to solve the system)
3. Each column of the stiffness matrix is an equilibrium
set of nodal force required to produce unit respective
degree of freedom
4. The global stiffness matrix of a system is a square
matrix, is symmetric and sparse (most of the terms
are null)

See more details in Chapter 5: Basics of FEM Theory

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 11
By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #11
DEFINE THE TERM SHAPE FUNCTION

Answer: The shape function is the function which

interpolates the solution between the discrete values
obtained at the nodes of a mesh. Low order polynomials
are typically chosen as shape functions.

See more details in Chapter 5: Basics of FEM Theory

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 12

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #12
WHY POLYNOMIALS ARE GENERALLY USED AS SHAPE
FUNCTION?

Answer: Polynomials are generally used as shape function

due to the following reasons.
1. Differentiation and integration of polynomials are
quite easy.
2. The accuracy of the results can be improved by
increasing the order of the polynomial.
3. It is easy to formulate and solve the finite element
equations using polynomials with a computer.

See more details in Chapter 5: Basics of FEM Theory

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 13

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #13
WHAT ARE THE DIFFERENT TYPES OF ELEMENTS USED IN
FEA? GIVE EXAMPLES.

Answer: The various elements used in FEA are classified

as:
- One dimensional elements (truss, beam, spring)
- Two dimensional elements (shell)
- Three dimensional elements (tetrahedron, hexahedron)

See more details in Chapter 7: The Library of Elements

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 14

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #14
GIVE FOUR POSSIBLE LOCATIONS FOR NODES?

Answer:
1. Point of application of a concentrated load.
2. Location where there is a change in intensity of loads.
3. Locations where there are discontinuities in the
geometry of the structure.
4. Interfaces between materials of different properties.

See more details in Chapter 7: The Library of Elements

See more details in Chapter 8: Meshing

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 15

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #15
WHAT IS MEANT BY PLANE STRAIN CONDITION? GIVE AN
EXAMPLE.

Answer: Plane strain is a state of strain in which normal

strain and shear strain directed perpendicular to the
plane of the body are zero.
The plane strain assumption is used for long bodies in the
normal direction with a constant cross section, subjected
to loads acting only in the xy-plane. A dam is a good
example.

See more details in Chapter 7: The Library of Elements

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 16

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #16
WHAT IS MEANT BY PLANE STRESS CONDITION? GIVE AN
EXAMPLE.

Answer: Plane stress is a state of stress in which the

normal stress and shear stress perpendicular to the plane
are zero.
A thin member, with a small normal dimension compared
to the in-plane x and y dimensions, on which loads act
only in the xy-plane can be considered to be under plane
stress.

See more details in Chapter 7: The Library of Elements

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 17

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #17
WHAT IS ASPECT RATIO?

Answer: Aspect ratio is defined as the ratio of the largest

dimension of the element to the smallest dimension.
In many cases, as the aspect ratio increases, the
inaccuracy of the solution increases. The aspect ratio
should be close to unity as possible.

See more details in Chapter 8: Meshing

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 18

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #18
WHAT IS A TRUSS ELEMENT?

Answer: The truss elements are the part of a truss

structure linked together by point joints, which transmit
only axial force to the elements.

See more details in Chapter 7: The Library of Elements

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 19

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
QUESTION #19

THE FINITE ELEMENT METHOD IS AN APPROXIMATE METHOD

(TRUE OR FALSE)? JUSTIFY YOUR ANSWER.
Answer: True, because the finite element method is a
mathematical procedure used to calculate approximate solutions
to differential equations.
During the process, the differential equations governing the
modeled behavior are transformed into a set of linear equations
obtained by discretization. The simple equations that model
these finite elements are then assembled into a larger system of
equations that models the entire problem.
The finite element method then uses techniques based on the
calculus of variations to approximate a solution by minimizing an
associated error function.

See more details in Chapter 1: Defining FEA

See more details in Chapter 5: Basics of FEM Theory
www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 20
By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #20
GIVE THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN GLOBAL AND LOCAL AXES.

Answer: Local axes are established in an element. Since it

is in the element level, they change with the change in
orientation of the element. The direction differs from
element to element.
Global axes are defined for the entire model. They are
same in direction for all the elements even though the
elements are differently oriented.

See more details in Chapter 7: The Library of Elements

See more details in Chapter 8: Meshing

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 21

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #21

HOW DO YOU CALCULATE THE SIZE OF THE GLOBAL STIFFNESS

MATRIX?

Answer:
Global stiffness matrix size =
Number of nodes * Number of DOFs

See more details in Chapter 5: Basics of Finite Element

Method Theory

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 22

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
QUESTION #22

GIVE THE GENERAL EXPRESSION FOR AN ELEMENT STIFFNESS

MATRIX.

Answer:

𝑘 = න[𝐵]𝑇 𝐷 𝐵 𝑑𝑣

[B] – Strain displacement matrix. Formed by the global

derivatives of the shape functions associated with the
type of elements being considered.
[D] – The constitutive matrix. Formed by the material
properties.

See more details in Chapter 5: Basics of Finite Element

Method Theory
www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 23
By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #23
WRITE DOWN THE EQUILIBRIUM EQUATION USED TO SOLVE
DIFFERENT TYPES OF STRUCTURAL PROBLEMS. Keep in your mind the variations of the general equilibrium equation

Answer:

See more details in Chapter 5: Basics of FEM Theory

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 24

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #24

WHAT IS CST ELEMENT?

Answer: The three-node triangular element is known

as Constant Strain Triangle (CST). It has six unknown
displacement degrees of freedom (u1, v1, u2, v2, u3, v3).
The element is called CST because it has a constant
strain through it. It explains also why the CST elements
are stiffer than quadrilateral elements.

See more details in Chapter 5: Basics of FEM Theory and

Chapter 7: The Library of Elements

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 25

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #25

WHAT IS A SINGULARITY? GIVE EXAMPLES.

Answer: Point in a model where values tend toward an

infinite value. A typical example is an infinite stress in a
small region of the model.
Usually, it is caused by wrong boundary conditions like
local infinite stiffness or a force applied on a very small
surface.

See more details in Chapter 11: Defining Loads and

Boundary Conditions and Chapter 16: Validating and
Correlating your FEA

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 26

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
QUESTION #26

WHAT IS MEANT BY STRESS CONCENTRATION & HOW WILL

YOU MESH FOR SUCH REGIONS?

Answer: A stress concentration is a place of the mesh

where the stress raises above the applied nominal stress.
It behaves in a similar fashion than stress singularities, but
the stress will converge towards a finite value, not
infinite, given that the mesh is sufficiently refined.
The convergence study is the method uses to find the
appropriate mesh size in a region experimenting a stress
concentration.

See more details in Chapter 8: Meshing

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 27

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
QUESTION #27

WHAT IS SHEAR LOCKING? HOW CAN WE AVOID IT? HOW IT

AFFECTS THE FEA RESULTS.
Answer: Shear locking is a numerical problem which
produces bending displacements that are smaller than
they should be in an element.
Consequently, the element becomes over-stiff, or locked,
VS
when subjected to a bending moment. The shear locking
effect ultimately induces incorrect displacements,
stresses, and natural frequencies.
To prevent shear locking, the suggested solutions are :
• Refine the mesh
• Use first order elements with a reduced integration

See more details in Chapter 7: The Library of Elements

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 28

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
QUESTION #28

WHAT IS HOURGLASSING? HOW CAN WE AVOID IT? HOW IT

AFFECTS THE FEA RESULTS.
Answer: Hourglassing is a spurious deformation mode of
a Finite Element mesh, resulting from the excitation of
zero-energy degrees of freedom.
It typically manifests as a patchwork of hourglass like
element shapes, where individual elements are severely
deformed, while the overall mesh section is undeformed.
This is a non-physical mode that produces incorrect
results because of excessively flexible behavior. To avoid
hourglassing, the two suggested solutions are:
• Refining the mesh
• Using fully integrated elements

See more details in Chapter 7: The Library of Elements

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 29
By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #29

GIVE TWO CONSEQUENCES OF A WRONG SHELL NORMAL

SETTING?

Answer:
1. Wrong pressure loading (positive pressure is
considered by the solvers to be pressure acting in
the same direction as the normal)

2. Shell offset considered at the wrong location

See more details in Chapter 8: Meshing

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 30

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #30

WHAT IS SUBMODELING?

Answer: Submodeling is a technique used to compute a

refined solution from a previous coarse analysis that
employs two separate models: a coarse model and one
that is more refined.
The results from the coarse model are used as boundary
conditions and mapped onto the refined model.

See more details in Chapter 15: Submodeling

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 31

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #31

GIVE TWO SUBMODELING METHODS.

Answer:
1. A first submodeling approach involves refining a
critical region of the global model and creating a
transition mesh between the refined region and the
global model. The original global model loading is
directly applied to the local model.
2. Another submodeling approach involves extracting
the region of interest from the global model and
refining it as needed. Then, the displacement/load
fields are extracted from the global model and applied
to the standalone local model as boundary conditions.

See more details in Chapter 15: Submodeling

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 32
By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #32

WHAT IS STATICALLY INDETERMINATE STRUCTURE?

Answer: A structure is statically indeterminate when the

static equilibrium equations - force and moment
equilibrium conditions - are insufficient for determining
the internal forces and reactions on that structure.

See more details in Chapter 11: Defining Loads and

Boundary Conditions

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 33

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #33

HOW DO YOU SOLVE THE PROBLEM OF INCOMPATIBLE

DEGREES OF FREEDOM BETWEEN ELEMENTS?

Answer: The problem of incompatibility of DOFs

between elements is solved by using specific
multi-point constraints (MPC) elements like
interpolation elements (called RBE3 or distributing
coupling).
See more details in Chapter 12: Rigid Body
Elements and Multi-Point Constraints

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 34

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
QUESTION #34

WHAT IS RESIDUAL STRESS? GIVE TWO EXAMPLES.

Answer: Residual stresses are stresses that remain in a

component even in the absence of external loading or
thermal gradients.
In some cases, residual stresses result in significant plastic
deformation, leading to warping and distortion of a body.
Residual stresses can affect the susceptibility to fracture
and fatigue.
Examples: Residual stresses can occur:
• In a welded component
• After a gap has been closed in a bolted joint

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 35

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #35

GIVE EXAMPLES OF ASSUMPTIONS WHICH CAN INFLUENCE

THE ACCURACY OF AN FEA PREDICTION.

Answer:
1. The boundary conditions (restraints and loadings)
2. The simplifications of the CAD geometry
3. The discretization (meshing)
4. The assumptions made for the modeling of joints
5. The material models
See more details in Chapter 6: Defining Your FEA Strategy

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 36

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
QUESTION #36

GIVE TWO TYPES OF CONTACT INTERACTION, WITH THEIR

PROPERTIES, AVAILABLE IN COMMERCIAL FEA PACKAGES.

Answer:
• Glued contact: Glued contact allows two bodies to be
fixed at the contact surface, even if they do not have
the same mesh on both sides of the bodies.

• Touching contact: The bodies involved in a touching

contact can move relative to one another, with the
additional condition that one body is not allowed to
penetrate the other.

See more details in Chapter 14: Modeling Contacts

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 37
By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #37

GIVE THE THREE TYPES OF NONLINEARITY

ENCOUNTERED IN MECHANICAL STRUCTURAL
ANALYSIS.

Answer:
1. Geometric nonlinearity (large displacements)
2. Material nonlinearity (the material behavior
does not follow the Hooke’s law)
3. Boundary nonlinearity (contact problem)

See more details in Chapter 21: Nonlinear Static

Analysis

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 38

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
QUESTION #38

WHAT ARE THE CHARACTERISTICS OF A NONLINEAR STATIC

SOLUTION?
Answer:
1. The displacements are not related to the original stiffness of the
structure
2. The stiffness of the analyzed structure is not constant and varies with
the applied loads
3. Stresses and strains are not related to a linear function
4. The results cannot be scaled
5. The principle of superposition cannot be applied
6. The initial state of stress (residual stresses, temperature, pre-
stressing) may be extremely important in the overall response
7. The structure’s response is related to the load history
8. The deformation of the structure is not fully recovered once the
applied loads are removed

See more details in Chapter 21: Nonlinear Static Analysis

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 39

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #39

WHAT ARE THE MAIN ALGORITHMS USED TO SOLVE

NONLINEAR PROBLEMS?
Answer:
1. The Newton-Raphson method
2. The Modified Newton-Raphson method
3. The Arc-Length methods mainly used for buckling
problems (Crisfield and Riks Methods)

See more details in Chapter 21: Nonlinear Static Analysis

and Chapter 23: Nonlinear Buckling Analysis

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 40

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #40

GIVE THE THREE BASIC OPERATIONS EMPLOYED TO SOLVE A

NONLINEAR PROBLEM.

Answer:
1. Gradual loading
2. Iterations with convergence test for equilibrium
3. Stiffness matrix update

See more details in Chapter 21: Nonlinear Static Analysis

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 41

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
QUESTION #41

HOW DO YOU DECIDE IF YOUR PROBLEM IS A LINEAR STATIC

OR A NONLINEAR STATIC PROBLEM?
Answer:
1. If the stiffness of the structure does not change when
a loading is applied, it is a linear problem, otherwise it
is a nonlinear problem.

2. If the strains in the model are less than 5%, it is a

linear problem, otherwise it is a nonlinear problem.

3. If the strains or stresses of the model do not exceed

the proportional limit, it is a linear problem, otherwise
it is a nonlinear problem.

See more details in Chapter 20: Linear Static Analysis and Chapter
21: Nonlinear Static Analysis
www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 42
By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
QUESTION #42

IN A CONTACT PROBLEM, HOW TO DECIDE THE MASTER AND

SLAVE SURFACE? GIVE ONE RECOMMENDATION FOR
MESHING.

Answer:
1. The master surface is on the touched body
2. The slave surface is on the touching body

Meshing recommendation: The slave body should have a

finer mesh than the master body

See more details in Chapter 14: Modeling Contacts

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 43

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #43

WHAT ARE THE RULES APPLYING TO THE NODES OF THE

SLAVE AND MASTER BODIES?

Answer:
1. The node of the slave body CANNOT penetrate a
segment of the master body
2. A node of the master body CAN penetrate a
segment of a slave body

See more details in Chapter 14: Modeling Contacts

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 44

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #44

WHAT IS STABILIZATION IN CONTACT ANALYSIS?

Answer: The FEA packages offer contact stabilization to

help automatically control rigid body motion in static
problems before contact closure and friction restrain such
motion.
However, it is recommended to try to stabilize rigid body
motion first through modeling techniques (modifying
geometry, imposing boundary conditions, etc.).

See more details in Chapter 14: Modeling Contacts

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 45

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
QUESTION #45

IN A CONTACT PROBLEM, EXPLAIN HOW THE SETTING OF THE

CONTACT TOLERANCE INFLUENCES THE SOLUTION IN TERM OF
COMPUTATIONAL COST AND ACCURACY.
Answer: Two scenarios:
1. The contact tolerance is too small:
• Detection of the contact is difficult.
• More nodes can potentially be considered penetrating.
• Increment splitting increases.
• The computational time increases.
2. The contact tolerance is too large:
• The nodes are considered to be in contact prematurely.
• A large number of nodes are detected as penetrated.
• A loss of accuracy occurs in the final solution.

See more details in Chapter 14: Modeling Contacts

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 46

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
QUESTION #46

HOW TO DO YOU DETERMINE IF YOUR PROBLEM NEEDS A

STATIC OR A DYNAMIC ANALYSIS?
Answer:
1. If the loading is constant over a relatively long period of time,
it is a static problem, otherwise it is a dynamic problem.

2. If the inertial and damping effects are negligible, it is a static

problem, otherwise it is a dynamic problem.

3. If the structure is subjected to vibrations, and the excitation

frequency is less than one third of the structure’s lowest
natural frequency, it is a static problem, otherwise it is a
dynamic problem.

See more details in Chapter 20: Linear Static Analysis

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 47

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #47

WHICH FE SOLUTION IS USED TO DETERMINE NATURAL

FREQUENCY?

Answer: Modal analysis is used to compute the natural

frequencies and the associated mode shapes of a system.

See more details in Chapter 24: Normal Mode Analysis

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 48

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
QUESTION #48

WHICH ALGORITHM DO YOU SUGGEST FOR COMPUTING THE

NATURAL FREQUENCIES OF A STRUCTURE? JUSTIFY YOUR
RECOMMENDATION.

Answer: The recommended algorithm for computing the

natural frequencies and mode shapes of a structure is the
Lanczos method because, unlike the inverse power
method, the Lanczos method does not require the analyst
estimates the range of frequencies.
Moreover, this algorithm is proven to be efficient,
accurate and fast in all situations. It gives good correlation
with the natural frequencies measured during a tap test.

See more details in Chapter 24: Normal Mode Analysis

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 49
By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #49

IN MODAL ANALYSIS, HOW THE STIFFNESS AND THE MASS Spring-Mass System
INFLUENCE THE NATURAL FREQUENCIES?

Answer: If the stiffness K of the structure increases, the

natural frequencies fn increase, while if the mass M of the
structure increases, the natural frequencies fn decrease.
1 𝑘
𝑓𝑛 =
See more details in Chapter 24: Normal Mode Analysis 2𝜋 𝑚

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 50

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview

QUESTION #50

GIVE THE 3 GROUPS OF ERRORS IN FEA

Answer:
1. Modeling error due to simplifications
2. Discretization error (wrong mesh)
3. Numerical error of the solution

www.fea-academy.com The 50 Most Frequently Asked Questions with Answers 51

By Dominique Madier
 « PRACTICAL FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS FOR MECHANICAL ENGINEERS »
AVAILABLE IN THE FEA ACADEMY BOOK STORE: www.fea-academy.com

Available in paper and e-Book format

www.fea-academy.com 52
 www.fea-academy.com

Reach me at:
dominique.madier@fea-academy.com
or

www.fea-academy.com 53
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
Here are few tips and hints for you related to the interview itself.

• Start by researching the company and your interviewers. Understanding key information about the company you are interviewing with can help you go into your
interview with confidence. Using the company’s website, social media posts and recent press releases will provide a solid understanding of the company’s goals
and how your background makes you a great fit.

• Take at least five copies of your printed resume on clean paper in case of multiple interviewers. Highlight specific accomplishments on your copy that you can
easily refer to and discuss.

• Bring a pen and a small notebook. Prepare to take notes, but not on your smartphone or another electronic device. Write information down so that you can refer
to these details in your follow-up thank-you notes. Maintain eye contact as much as possible

• If it is a phone call, control your environment: it is better to have the call in a quiet environment so that you and the other person can hear each other speak. In
the same vein, if, during the call, communication gets difficult, agree with the person to call them back as soon as possible.

• During the conversation, do not hesitate to restate your interest and enthusiasm for the position. You want to make a good impression, so make sure to answer
questions well. Take your time, be precise, control your delivery, articulate and do not forget to smile. If you do not understand something, do not hesitate to ask
questions, and ask the person to repeat themselves if needed. The interviewer always appreciates when the candidate asks a clarification instead of answering a
question she/he did not understand.

www.fea-academy.com Interview Tips & Hints 54

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
• Make sure to sell yourself well. End the conversation by thanking the person for their time. An important detail is to remember to ask about the next steps in the
hiring process. If you think it is appropriate, do a follow-up by email or by phone in the days following the call or the interview. This shows that you are interested
and serious in your approach.

• You are interviewing the company too. Ask questions to learn more about the job and the company. This will help you figure out if it is a good fit for you.

• Plan your schedule so that you can arrive 10–15 minutes early. Map out your route to the interview location so you can be sure to arrive on time. Consider doing
a practice run. If you are taking public transportation, identify a backup plan if there are delays or closures. When you arrive early, use the extra minutes to observe
workplace dynamics.

• Make a great first impression. Do not forget the little things—shine your shoes, make sure your nails are clean and tidy, and check your clothes for holes, stains,
pet hair and loose threads. Display confident body language and a smile throughout.

• Treat everyone you encounter with respect. This includes people on the road and in the parking lot, security personnel and front desk staff. Treat everyone you do
not know as though they are the hiring manager. Even if they are not, your potential employer might ask for their feedback.

• Practice good manners and body language. Practice confident, accessible body language from the moment you enter the building. Sit or stand tall with your
shoulders back. Before the interview, take a deep breath and exhale slowly to manage feelings of anxiety and encourage self-confidence. The interviewer should
extend their hand first to initiate a handshake. Look the person in the eye and smile. A good handshake should be firm but not crush the other person’s fingers.

www.fea-academy.com Interview Tips & Hints 55

By Dominique Madier
 MasterClass #1: Preparing an FEA Interview
• Win them over with your authenticity and positivity. Being genuine during interview conversations can help employers easily relate to you. Showing positivity
with a smile and upbeat body language can help keep the interview light and constructive.

• Respond truthfully to the questions asked. While it can seem tempting to embellish on your skills and accomplishments, interviewers find honesty refreshing and
respectable. Focus on your key strengths and why your background makes you uniquely qualified for the position.

• Tie your answers back to your skills and accomplishments. With any question you answer, it is important that you tie your background to the job by providing
examples of solutions and results you have achieved. Use every opportunity to address the requirements listed in the job description.

• Keep your answers concise and focused. Your time with each interviewer is limited so be mindful of rambling. Practicing your answers beforehand can help keep
you focused. Use this PDF to practice the interview with a friend or a member of your family. You will find you gain confidence as you get used to saying the words.

• Do not speak negatively about your previous employers. Companies want to hire problem solvers who overcome tough situations. If you are feeling discouraged
about your current job, focus on talking about what you have gained from that experience and what you want to do next.

www.fea-academy.com Interview Tips & Hints 56

By Dominique Madier