Forecasting MySQL Scalability

Baron Schwartz
O'Reilly MySQL Conference & Expo 2011
 Consulting
Support
Training
Development

For MySQL
Percona Server

● Replaces MySQL
● Faster Queries
● More Consistent
● More Measurable
● More Features

www.percona.com
Percona XtraBackup

● Backs Up InnoDB
● Non-Blocking

www.percona.com
Forecasting Performance Scalability
● Performance == Response Time
● Scalability is a mathematical equation (function)
● This is about scalability, sorry about the bad
title in the conference program.

www.percona.com
Throughput
The Scalability Function

Threads or Nodes
1

www.percona.com
Throughput
This is Linear Scalability

Threads or Nodes
1

www.percona.com
Throughput
This is Not Linear Scalability

Threads or Nodes
1

www.percona.com
 What Causes Non-Linearity?

What's this about?

Threads or Nodes
1

www.percona.com
 Factor #1: Serialization
● Some portion of the work cannot be done in
parallel
● “Sigma” is the serial fraction
● It grows linearly
● This is Amdahl's Law

www.percona.com
 Factor #2: Coherency
● Some portion of the work relies on IPC, cross-
node communication, etc
● “Kappa” is the synchronized fraction
● It grows quadratically
● This is Neil Gunther's University Scalability Law

www.percona.com
Real Systems Usually Have Both
● Most systems have serialization & coherency.
Coherency causes retrograde scaling.

www.percona.com
 How To Forecast Scalability
● Measure throughput -vs- nodes or concurrency
● Plot the points
● Perform curve-fitting to find sigma, kappa
● Examine results carefully, throw out bad points,
tweak, etc etc.

www.percona.com
 Is it Cheating to Cull Bad Data?
● The model correctly describes the factors
involved in scalability.
● It is a reference without which there is nothing
to discuss.

www.percona.com
 Case Study #1
● Percona Server on Cisco UCS Server

www.percona.com
Applying the Model

www.percona.com
How Good Was the Model?

www.percona.com
 What Does Capacity Mean?
● We can't run systems at peak throughput
● Performance (response time) would suck
● Capacity is maximum throughput that maintains
acceptable response time
● Latency is important
● Consistency is also important
● The Universal Scalability Law doesn't predict
response time as used here, only throughput

www.percona.com
 Case Study #2
● This is a real MySQL server under load tests.
● How close is the server to its limits?

www.percona.com
 Measurements
mysqladmin ext -ri10 \
| grep -e Uptime -e Threads_running -e Questions
Questions 118357171
Threads_running 8
Uptime 614909
Questions 118364376
Threads_running 6
Uptime 614920
Questions 118370320
Threads_running 4
Uptime 614930
Questions 118377196

www.percona.com
 Transforming the Data
● We need Throughput Versus Concurrency
● Throughput is simple: Queries Per Second
● Concurrency? That's tougher
● I averaged Threads_running over each sample

www.percona.com
Plotting The Result

www.percona.com
 That Doesn't Look Usable
● Peak throughput prediction is too low
● Peak concurrency prediction is too high
● This data is too messy to work with

www.percona.com
 What's The Problem?
● Threads_running is instantaneous samples.
● We need to know the average.

www.percona.com
Averaged over 150-sec Intervals

www.percona.com
 Better, But Not Good Enough
● There are clearly outliers
● The plotted points don't “point at the axis”

www.percona.com
 What's Wrong?
● SHOW STATUS increments Threads_running
● There are 3 replication slaves connected
● We need to subtract these to get concurrency
closer to reality
● Let's try again with “Threads_running - 4”

www.percona.com
Adjusted Concurrency

www.percona.com
 Take-Away
● This server is approaching its peak capacity
● Don't count on sustained QPS over 1000 or so
● If Threads_running > 10, you're in trouble

www.percona.com
 Important Background Info
● This is a complex workload...
● On a virtualized server...
● With 8 cores...
● Running MySQL 5.0.51dogslow
● MySQL can do a lot better. This MySQL can't.

www.percona.com
 Existing System
● This technique models the existing workload on
the existing system.
● It doesn't model what happens if you change
things in the system.
● We might be able to optimize queries and get a
different outcome, for example.

www.percona.com
Once You've Learned This, It's Lots Of Fun.

www.percona.com
Does it scale linearly?

www.percona.com
 Benchmark at the Clustrix Booth
#nodes TPS
3 58344
6 115193
9 167831
12 218004
15 266178
18 315842
20 343838

www.percona.com
 Looks Pretty Linear To Me!
● But it's not. Do the math.
● 3 nodes = 58344 TPS
● 18 nodes = 6 * 58344 = 350064?
● No, 18 nodes = 315842
● Not linear scaling.
● But it's still impressive. Let's plot it.

www.percona.com
 Using “usl” Tool from Aspersa
ginger $ usl -e -o model-vs-actual clustrix-scalability.txt
# Command-line: /home/baron/bin/usl -e -o model-vs-actual clustrix-
scalability.txt
# Using gnuplot 4.2 patchlevel 6
# Parameters to the model:
min(N) 3
max(N) 20
max(C) 343838
C(1) 19448 (pre-adjustment by 1)
N=1 ??? no
# Fitting the transformed data against a 2nd-degree polynomial.
a 0.000154677 +/- 6.938e-05 (44.85%)
b 0.00406757 +/- 0.001111 (27.3%)
R^2 0.991981
# Re-fitting against the USL with (a, b-a) as a starting point.
# Treating (1, 19448) as a point in original measurements.
sigma 0.00508683 +/- 0.0008785 (17.27%)
kappa 8.79207e-05 +/- 4.883e-05 (55.54%)
C(1) 19448 (not a regression parameter)
R^2 0.999978

www.percona.com
Clustrix is Very Scalable.

www.percona.com
 Important Notes
● Clustrix didn't pay me for this.
● I just did a drive-by shooting at their booth.
● These benchmarks are over a year old.
● They have done a lot of work since then and
the system “should be much higher
performance.”
● Scaling to 106 nodes is extremely good.

www.percona.com
 Further Study
● Learn the underlying theory
● Learn how to apply the model
● Read the white paper on percona.com
● You can use Aspersa's “usl” tool to help

http://www.perfdynamics.com/ http://perfdynamics.blogspot.com/ @DrQz

www.percona.com
Percona Live, May 26, New York

www.percona.com/live
 baron@percona.com

We're Hiring! www.percona.com/about-us/careers/