Art As A Diversification Tool of Investment Portfolios: January 2012
Art As A Diversification Tool of Investment Portfolios: January 2012
net/publication/268603215
CITATIONS READS
2 1,320
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Daiva Jureviciene on 27 August 2015.
Abstract. The paper constitutes an argumentation of art investments as portfolio diversification tool, pre-
sents the analysis of the specifics and conception of investments in art. Moreover, it represents the struc-
ture of art market participants. Analysis of the statistical data reveals that the biggest art markets having
long traditions of investing in art yield ground to emergent Eastern markets. The main objective of this
paper is to investigate art as an investment tool for diversification of investment portfolio. In order to as-
sess whether the investments in art can be used to diversify investment portfolio correlation regression
analysis was made. For calculatin of optimal portfolios and finding efficient frontiers teaching material of
C. W. Holden from Indiana University “Excel Modelling and Estimation in Investments” was used. The
comparison of return and risk of the portfolios comprised with art investment are presented in the article.
84
D. Jurevičienė, J. Savičenko, A. Miečinskienė
2. Distinctiveness of the art investments knowledge of art and the art world itself and a
large amount of capital to acquire well-known
Investing in art is becoming fashionable among
artists’ creation (Worthington, Higgs 2004). Insta-
alternative investments. It is validated by recorded
bility, irrationality and illiquidity of investment in
art creative prices paid at auctions, the establish-
art make it practically incomparable to traditional
ment of new private funds of investments and
investments (Mamarbachi et al. 2008). Thus, all
creations of some tools, which help to analyse art
major investments in the arts should be based on
market trends. Art creations become not only the
the mutual relationship between the artist and lo-
collecting tool, but also as a real object for trade
gistical support, i. e. based on economic, human
and monetary relations. Thus, investing in art or in
and material resources (Isakovič 2011).
the alternative investments – is purchase of art
According to art experts (Raškinis et al. 2008;
works (such as paintings, icons, antiques, antique
Makselienė 2007; Postrigaj 2009 etc.) one of the
furniture, etc.) with investment objectives, i. e. to
most important features of investment in art is the
maintain or increase the available capital (Postri-
lasting of investments (Fig. 1). International art
gaj 2009).
market consultants say that the optimal investment
History of investment in art dates back to the
in art is the period from 5 to 10 years (Krasnov
17th century. Since the year dot the rich and fa-
2011). I. Vasilevskaja (2008) says that the acquisi-
mous old European families followed a simple
tion art works and holding them for 3-5 years
strategy of capital formation: one-third of stocks,
don’t ensure whether the work can be profitably
bonds and other securities, one third of real estate
sold.
and one third of investments in art and precious
Investments have different degrees of risk and
metals, gemstones and etc. (Makselienė 2007).
reliability. So, another important feature of in-
The art market is characterized by high illiq-
vestment in art is risk (Fig. 1). In this regard, there
uidity, information asymmetric, high transaction
is no consensus. Art critic S. Makselienė argues
costs, long transaction time and the absence of
that investing in art is a stable and easily over-
hedging mechanism (Ralevski 2008) (Fig. 1).
comes the inflation and the shares’ crisis (Skirke-
vičius 2008). However, there is the opposite opin-
ion about art investment risk. A number of
inefficiencies in the art market stress the fact that
art remains a highly risky investment. Unlike other
investments art investors cannot calculate the risk
and return profile (Ralevski 2008). Buying a crea-
tion can be tricky because every painting, print or
sculpture is unique. If people buy art as an invest-
ment they need to investigate the artist and his
work before purchase. In other words, the risk
should be assessed (Resnick 2010). At a time
when the art in financial markets is considered an
attractive investment, as earning more income than
traditional investments, it is also a very risky in-
vestment (Mamarbachi et al. 2008). Investment in
art is not only profitable but also very risky
(Kancerevyčius 2009:27). In spite of the fact that
investments in art are risky, unlike other invest-
Fig.1. Main features of investment in artworks (Source: ments, an investor in the art can calculate the val-
Jurevičienė, Savičenko 2011) ues of risk and return (Ralevski 2008).
Thirdly, all investments are characterized by
If we compare it with the stock or real estate return (Fig. 1). Investments in art are profitable.
markets, the art market is very inefficient, opaque, Art market is sufficiently inert, and return on in-
and its products are differentiated (Pesando, Shum vestment can be compared with investment in
2007). Therefore, it can be said that the art market bonds rather than shares (i. e. lower profitability
is fundamentally different from the financial but higher guarantees) (Makselienė 2007).
markets and this potentially limits the strict M. Ščerbenko notes that return of investment in art
applicability of well known financial techniques. can range from 20 % to 300 %. Return may de-
Artworks are almost never divisible; there are pend on a variety of reasons: one of them can be
delays between the decision to sell and actual sale. author’s death; other reason can be media interest
Investing in art typically requires extensive in a particular author's works (Vasilevskaja 2008).
85
ART AS A DIVERSIFICATION TOOL OF INVESTMENT PORTFOLIOS
86
D. Jurevičienė, J. Savičenko, A. Miečinskienė
87
ART AS A DIVERSIFICATION TOOL OF INVESTMENT PORTFOLIOS
and first in Europe, the UK art market is character- that the value of time for Lithuania's investment is
ized by stable sales volume and as sufficiently de- very important (Kutkaitytė 2010).
veloped. According to S. Makselienė, Lithuania has a
The third-largest art market in the world was 4–6 important collectors, who make very happy
France till 2006. Even after the World War II galleries of their art works purchases. A significant
France was the leading art market, as the environ- collection of art works has Danguolė and Viktoras
ment was very conducive to Paris artists. Such fa- Butkus. They collect a private collection, includ-
mous artists’ as Picasso, Matisse, and Kandinsky ing Modern Lithuanian art from the period 1960.
paintings particular from Paris were accessed for The collection includes more than 1 500 works of
the global art market. Their works are called mas- famous Lithuanian artists (Makselienė 2011).
terpieces. France is well known art market, but Summarizing the Lithuanian art market, it can
according to recent data it should be noted that be argued that professional investment in art mar-
since 2003 the relative weight in the world market ket is still developing in Lithuania; only a very
share continued to decline from 7.2 % to 3.9 % small part of the population tries to invest in art.
(Fig. 4).
Since 2004 art professionals claimed that
5. Portfolio optimization using art as one of the
China in the future become a new and auspicious
investment tools
art market displaying France from the third place,
because China’s share in the art market grew rap- In order to measure whether the investments in art
idly in 2004-2009 period, rising from 1,9 to 17,4 can be used to diversify the investment portfolio
percent (Fig. 4). Already in 2007 China became there was performed correlation regression analy-
the third art market in the world, but in 2010 the sis. Art price Global Index (Artprice… 2011) as
China became art market leader. Nowadays global the dependent variable and S&P 500 index (Econ-
art market is characterized by readjustment of the stats… 2011) as the independent variable where
market towards Asia. used in this analysis. Correlation regression analy-
Lithuanian art market is very young, though sis showed that Art price Global Index weakly cor-
there is shortage of investment in art but it is related with United States stock indices S&P 500,
steadily growing during last few years and can and analysis is statistically important. Thus,
also be assessed as emerging one. Only a small changes in the stock market don’t affect the art
part of Lithuanian population invests in art. This is market changes. Therefore scientists’ claim, that
due to the fact that it is not easy to grasp the sub- art is an appropriate measure of portfolio diversifi-
tleties of this market. Ordinary Lithuanians use to cation, can be confirmed.
make money investing in securities or real estate. In order to calculate the optimal portfolios and
Moreover, in Lithuania there are no such a good to draw the efficient frontiers C. W. Holden from
conditions to invest in art as in the United States, Indiana University teaching material “Excel Mod-
United Kingdom, China or elsewhere. elling and Estimation in Investments” was used
A limited supply of artworks dominated in (Holden 2008). According to C. W. Holden mate-
Lithuania. Lithuanian modern classical paintings rial and “MS Excel” program two optimal portfo-
retain the biggest price growth. Art experts believe lio computing models were created: from five and
that good art collection can still earn up to 20% two tools of investment. In total 8 different in-
return (Skirkevičius 2008). vestment portfolios (3 portfolios including five
Comparing the price of artworks of Lithua- instruments and 5 portfolios each including two
nian artists with their counterparts abroad, the instruments) were prepared. Correlations between
Lithuanian artists' creations are really an excellent various investment tools, profitability (return) and
type of investment not only by actual price but risk (standard deviation) where estimated using
also because of its possible increase. Lithuanian mentioned above models and S&P, Bloomberg,
artists are supported by a small country and a dis- NAREIT, NCREIF, Per Track, The Federal Re-
tinctive art style, well-bought abroad (Kutkaitytė serve, Mei&Moses researches and Art price annual
2008). reports (Asset… 2009).
Lithuanian Art Market Agency seeks to pro- At the beginning of research there were com-
mote investment in art in Lithuania. This is the posed investment portfolios from three identical
only auction in Lithuania, which organizes several structures, but different periods (i. e. 1900–2009,
sales per year. Lithuanian top ten auction sales are 2000–2009 and 2005–2009 periods) (Fig. 5).
already late authors. Therefore, it can be claimed
88
D. Jurevičienė, J. Savičenko, A. Miečinskienė
Fig.5. Efficient frontiers of investment portfolios of time periods 1990–2009, 2000–2009, 2005–2009, without art
investments
Figure 5 shows, that the most beneficial in- which is the starting point of 2000–2009 period
vestment portfolio for investor is the one com- portfolio efficient frontier.
posed from 2005–2009 period data that invested in For further calculations were chosen invest-
U. S. Stocks, Gold, Real Estate, Risk-Free Bonds ment portfolios, composed using 2005–2009 pe-
and T-Bills. Comparing with the other two portfo- riod data, because it is the most profitable and
lios, when the risk is 25 %, the portfolio of 2005– least risky portfolio. Five investment portfolios
2009 time periods is the most profitable. The dif- were composed from two investment tools, using
ference of return between 1990–2009, 2000–2009 the 2005–2009 year period data (Fig. 6) in order to
periods’ portfolios efficient frontiers is little and compare the return and risk of different structure
intersect at the point A2 (6.85 %, 8.57 %), portfolios.
Fig.6. Efficient frontiers of optimal portfolios, composed from two investment tools including art
Figure 6 shows, how differ portfolios con- portfolio of art and gold is highest among all the
structed by two investment tools, where one of rest. So this portfolio provides investors with the
them is art. Each portfolio return and risk is differ- biggest return (28.5 %). The lowest portfolio prof-
ent, what is not visible in portfolios, composed itability with the risk 14.3 % is composed by art
from five investment tools. Efficient frontier of and US Real Estate (2 %). This portfolio is the
most risky, because the endpoint of its efficient
89
ART AS A DIVERSIFICATION TOOL OF INVESTMENT PORTFOLIOS
frontier is farthest to the right side compared to vestment tools including art was constructed for
other efficient frontiers of investment portfolios. mentioned most favourable period (2005–2009).
Investment portfolio from art and US T-Bills is the Investment portfolio composed from art and gold
lowest risk (0.4 %) and one of the least profitable is the most profitable for investor and portfolio
(2.3 %). from art and US T-Bills is the least risky. In con-
Thus, it can be concluded that modelling port- clusion, it could be stated that art as investment
folios, composed from two investment tools, in- tool can be used to diversify investment portfolio.
cluding art investment as one of them, is very im-
portant correctly to chose the second tool, because References
presented calculations show that for similar portfo-
lios, where the risk is the same, return can be very Artprice. Art Market Trends 2003–2010 [online] [ac-
different. cessed 20 September 2010] Available from Internet:
<http://web.artprice.com/ami/ami.aspx>.
Artprice. Art price Global Indices [online] [accessed
6. Conclusions 18 October 2011] Available from Internet:
<http://imgpublic.artprice.com/pdf/agi.xls>.
Investment in art is referred as alternative invest-
ment. The main features of investment in artworks Asset Class Data, 1990–2009 [online] [accessed 20
October 2011] Available from Internet:
are: lasting, risk, return, value and the aesthetic
<http://www.scribd.com/doc/30965250/AssetClass-
perception. A number of inefficiencies in the art Data-1900-2009>.
market stress the fact that art remains a highly
Campos, N. F.; Barbosa, R. L. 2008. Paintings and
risky investment, though according to some inves- Numbers: An Econometric Investigation of Sales
tors art can offer attractive returns (up to 20 %). Rates, Prices and Returns in Latin American Art
The cost of materials and creative aesthetic value, Auctions, Institute for the Study of Labour, Discus-
rarity and authenticity of the author’s name and sion Paper 3445.
goodwill, sales history – are basic elements of art- Econstats, S&P 500 Index [online] [accessed 17 Octo-
works’ value. Moreover, investment in art has to ber 2011] Available from Internet:
provide visual pleasure. <http://www.econstats.com/eqty/eqeq_mi_1.htm>.
The basic art market participants in the world Holden, C. W. 2008. Excel Modelling in Investments
there are museums, galleries, collectors and auc- [online] [accessed 25 September 2011]. Available
tions. “Sotheby’s” and “Christie’s” auctions are from Internet: <http://www.excelmodeling.com/
the most important art market participants all over Free%20Samples.htm>.
the world. In Lithuania the main art market par- Isakovič, S. L. 2011. Sponsorship in Music Arts – So-
ticipants are Art Market Agency and association cial Responsibility or a Profitable Investment?
of Independent Vilnius Art Galleries, which en- Megatrend Review 8(1): 1–20 [online] [accessed 10
October 2011] Available from Internet:
courage interest for investing in art in Lithuania.
<http://www.megatrendreview.com/files/articles/01
Analysis of the statistical data reveals that the 5/SmiljkaIsakovic.pdf>.
biggest art markets – the USA, United Kingdom,
Jurevičienė, D.; Savičenko, J. 2011. Trends of Invest-
having long traditions of investing in art – yield ments in Art, Economics and Management 16:
ground to new countries like China, Russia that 1115–1124.
are gaining more and more interest from investors. Kancerevyčius, G. 2009. Finansai ir investicijos [Fi-
Lithuanian art market is very young and there is nance and Investment] Kaunas: Smaltija. 904 p.
shortage of investments in art but it was steadily Kudaras, P. 2009. Ar tinka menas investicijoms? [on-
growing in the last few years and can also be as- line] [accessed 12 September 2011] Available from
sessed as emerging one. In Lithuania there are Internet: <http://petras.kudaras.lt/archyvas/
some difficulties to invest in art and only after 2009-10-14/ar-tinka-menas-investicijoms.html>.
tackling those problems Lithuanian art market will Kutkaitytė, M. 2008. Investicijos į meną: tik malonu, ar
turn like other developed world art markets. ir saugu? [online] [accessed 2011 September 19]
Correlation regression analysis showed that Available from Internet: <http://www.vtv.lt/
art can be used for diversification of investment naujienos/ekonomika/investicijos-i-mena-tik-
portfolios. In order to calculate the optimal portfo- malonu-ar-ir-saugu.html>.
lios and to draw the efficient frontiers eight in- Kutkaitytė, M. 2010. Geri darbai kainą išlaiko ir per
vestment portfolios were composed. First three krizę [online] [accessed 21 September 2011] Avail-
were constructed from the most popular among able from Internet: <http://www.lrt.lt
/news.php?strid=5082&id=5450849>.
investors’ instruments excluding art and were
made for 20, 10 and 5 years. The most favourable Lietuvos meno galerijos [online] [accessed 3 January
2012] Available from Internet: <http://www.culture.
investment portfolio for investor was in the period lt/galleries/>.
2005–2009. The next five portfolios from two in-
90
D. Jurevičienė, J. Savičenko, A. Miečinskienė
Lubytė, E. 2007. Apie dailę ir pinigus rašyti reikia Ralevski, O. 2008. Hedging the Art Market: Creating
[online] [accessed 12 September 2011]. Available Art Derivatives. Dissertation Presented for the De-
from Internet: <http://www.culture.lt/7md/?leid_id= gree of Master of Business Administration. Univer-
779&st_id=7791&txt=al%C4%97>. sity of Edinburgh Management School.
Makselienė, S. 2007. Investavimas į meną: ar jau lai- Raškinis, D.; Zigmantienė, S. 2008. Meno kūrinių, kaip
kas? [online] [accessed 5 September 2011]. Avail- potencialios investicinio portfelio diversifikavimo
able from Internet: priemonės, vertinimas, Taikomoji ekonomika: Sis-
<http://archyvas.vz.lt/news.php?strid=1052&id=736 teminiai tyrimai [Applied Economics: Systematic
332>. Research] 2(2): 115–134.
Makselienė, S. 2008. Aukcionams prigyti reikia laiko, Resnick, R. 2010. Fine Art of Investment. Entrepreneur
darbo ir kantrybės [online] [accessed 23 August 38 (5): 66–67.
2011]. Available from Internet: Skirkevičius, D. 2008. Investicija į meną periferijoje
<http://kauno.diena.lt/dienrastis/priedai/menas/s- nepopuliari [online] [accessed 19 October 2011].
makseliene-ldquo-aukcionams-prigyti-reikia-laiko- Available from Internet: <http://www.sekunde.lt/
darbo-ir-kantrybes-rdquo-54215>. content.php?p=read&tid=47071>.
Makselienė, S. 2011. Apie meno rinką be sentimentų Worthington, A. C.; Higgs, H. 2004. Art as an Invest-
[online] [accessed 21 October 2011] Available ment: Risk, Return and Portfolio Diversification in
from Internet: Major Painting Markets, Accounting and Finance
<http://vz.lt/article/2011/12/4/apie_meno 44(2): 257-271 [online] [accessed 25 October 2011]
_rink%C4%85_be_sentiment%C5% B3>. Available from Internet: <http://eprints.qut.edu.au/
Mamarbachi, R; Day, M; Favato, G. 2008. Art as an 2323/1/2320_2.pdf>.
alternative investment asset [online] [accessed 12 Vasilevskaja, I. 2008. Могут ли инвестиции в
October 2011] Available from Internet: искусство принести до 300% годовых? [online]
<http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id [accessed 20 September 2011] Available from Internet:
=1112630>. SSRN-id1112630>. <http://dengi.ua/clauses/40547_Mogut_li_inv
Mikalajūnas, V. 2008. Meno kūriniai – netikėta išeitis esticii_v_iskusstvo_prinesti_do_300_godovyh.h
išgąsdintiems recesijos [online] [accessed 5 October tml>.
2011]. Available from Internet: Krasnov, А. 2011. Инвестиции в искусство:
<http://www.traders.lt/page.php?id=5530>. сложности украинского арт-рынка 2011 [online]
Pesando, P. J.; Shum, P. M. 2007. Investing in Art: A [accessed 14 October 2011] Available from Internet:
Cautionary Tale, The Journal of Wealth Manage- <http://intercredit.com.ua/42/article64
ment 9 (4): 80–87. 09>.
http://dx.doi.org/10.3905/jwm.2007.674810 Postrigaj, А. 2009. Инвестиции в искусство [online]
Plečkaitis, V. 2008. Menas ir pinigai – kasdien tvirtė- [accessed 10 October 2011]. Available from Inter-
janti sąjunga [online] [accessed 11 August]. Avail- net: <http://www.antiq-art.com/artinvestment.html>.
able from Internet: <http://www.lrytas.lt/- Willett, R. D. 2011. Инвестиции в искусство: стра-
12175649321216460282-menas-ir-pinigai-kasdien- тегия и тактика [online] [accessed 15 Octo-
tvirt%C4%97janti-s%C4%85junga.htm>. ber 2011] Available from Internet:
Prickett, R. 2004. The Color of Money, Financial Man- <http://pbwm.ru/articles/investitsii-v-iskusstvo-
agement: 24–29. strategiya-i-taktika--2>.
91