Healthcare Facilities For Elderly People: January 2003
Healthcare Facilities For Elderly People: January 2003
net/publication/290605099
CITATIONS READS
0 2,540
1 author:
S A Tabish
Sher-i-Kashmir Institute of Medical Sciences
435 PUBLICATIONS 1,187 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by S A Tabish on 16 January 2016.
Changes in health care are not simply adding years services and legal assistance. Investment in research
to life—they are also adding an increased quality of and training to enhance the quality and cost-
life to those years. Older people make much heavier effectiveness of care is important. Rational planning,
demands on health and social services than do young supported by research evidence need urgent
adults. The most elderly make the heaviest demands attention. Emphasis need to be placed on setting and
of all. The very elderly also tend to be maintaining high standards of community, hospital
proportionately highly represented in the most and residential facility care. The work done in
intensive forms of non-home-based care (such as hospitals and the way in which this work interlocks
increasingly important. Identifying and assessing with that carried out by community and volunatry
need and then organising an appropriate response is organisations will determine the effectiveness of
essential. Elderly people can benefit from measures geriatric services. Old age can be a time of
to improve their health and well-being. Care of the continuing participation in the life of the community
aged will depend on the effectiveness, the adequacy and personal fulfillment. A holistic approach is
of provision and the degree of coordination of the required to respond to the challenges posed by
services. A comprehensive system must be evolved to increasing number of elderly population.
provide education, leisure activities, health, social
Advances in health care are not simply adding years to the people 65+have long-standing illness, over 70
life they are also adding increased quality of life to those percent of the people 80+ have some form of disability,
years. Most people can now expect to live to old age in 7 percent of people 75+ live in long- stay hospital or
developed economies. In developing countries, average care homes and this rises to near 30 percent for 85+, 5
life expectancy is less but their massive populations percent of the people 65+ and 20 percent 80+ suffer to
mean that the old are numbered in millions. The impact some degree from senile dementia, the number of people
of these demographic developments have been reflected 80+ will increase by 50 percent over the next 20 years
in medical sciences by increasing research and and will double over the next 40 years.1
knowledge, in society by improved services and among
elderly people themselves by increasing expectations in Demographic Revolution
health and social support. As the elderly are far more
likely than the young to experience health problems, By the year 2000, more than 410 million persons were
their use of health care facilities is high, and this of aged 65 and over, with about 41 percent living in
course is one of the reasons why planners are concerned developed countries. Sweden’s population has the
about the economic implications of increases in the size highest proportion of elderly persons: 17 percent. 2 By
of the very old population. With aging, the need for the turn of the century developing nations will have 59
support for old people becomes increasingly important. percent of the world’s population over 65, up from 54
Identifying and assessing individual need and then percent in 1985.3
organising an appropriate response is essential. The
elderly population is getting bigger. Simultaneously the
working population is declining. Estimates suggest that
within 50 years, the UK could see 25 percent of the
population supporting the rest.1 More than 60 percent of
Design and Construction The Clinical Zone n 499
In 1985 China, India, the USA and the USSR each had in England.5 The number of people over 85 will have
more than 25 million citizens aged 65 and over. China grown by over uses its resources. In 1994/ 95 the NHS
had 80 million in 1985 and expects 240 million by 2040. (UK) spent £ 2,455 for every person aged over 85
By 2020, 72 per cent of people over age 60 will be in the compared with just £ 235 for every person aged 16-44.5
developing world.3 Japan has the highest life expectancy
at birth of any nation: 77.1 years (1985). The speed of Country Experiences
the aging of Japan’s population is remarkable. While it
took 45 years for the UK to move 7-14 per cent of its The elderly populations of many developing countries
population aged 65 and over, Sweden required 85 years are increasing rapidly. These demographic changes are a
and France 115. It took Japan only 26 years. The USA direct result of the success of socioeconomic
will reach the 14 per cent in 2010, or 66 years. The USA development that has led to declines in mortality rates at
will reach the 14 per cent. This worldwide demographic all ages and reductions in fertility.6 Adequate disability
revolution is a major success story of 20th century and life expectancy data are essential for planning health
(Table 34.3). and social policy but are century insufficient.
By the beginning of 1990’s an estimated 15.7 per Japan has put in place a health care financing
cent of population were aged 65 and over and 7 per cent system that gives essentially free care (only a 5% of
were aged 75 and over in UK. There were 23 people copayment is required) for all persons over age 70. The
aged 65 years for every 100 people aged between 15 and system for delivering health care emphasise
64 years, by the year 2030, 31 over 65 year olds will be hospitalzation a “Golden Plan” was announced in 1990
present in population for every 100 younger adults. 4 By for expanding home and community-based service
the year 2025, there will be more than 10.7 million particularly rehabilitation and adult day care.
people over
retirement age compared with 7.7 million in 1995, Japan is creating a national institute on aging. The Table 34.3:
discussion of the costs and potential benefits of acute programmes of social and personal care (e.g. respite
care hospitalization. Such an approach may facilitate care, home helps, adult day care); services are allocated
limitations on the use of costly procedures that are based accoridng to need. Among goals commonly found in
on factors other than age, such as effectiveness of long-term care services in developed economies is the
outcome.14 It is felt that Medicare could be imporved by prevention of impoverishment (a major exception is the
the addition of comprehensive geriatric assessment, USA where the only available public funding is part of
coordination of care, and integration of short-term and public assistance for the poor medicaid).
long-term care. A recent study15 showed that Expansion of hospital, nursing home and com-
comprehensive geriatric assessment of older people munity-based services is recognised as necessary
living in the community has already proved to be adaptation to population aging in most developed
clinically effective and less costly than conventional countries.
care, since it helps reduce the need for nursing home Sweden has one of the most systematic approaches
admissions and other forms of extensive care. There is to long care system. A continuum of services is
also scope to offer Medicare beneficiaries more choice available to elders, including nursing home care and
in the health care plans available to them and to ensure housing. About one third of GNP goes for health and
that the government pay the same amount no matter social security.
what plan a beneficiary chooses. Elderly people who In UK, commerialism in long-term care has
want to receive care in more expensive settings or who burgeoned; in 1986, about 168000 of the 426800 beds
want to buy more benefits than come with the basic plan were in the private, non-voluntary sector.18
may do so, but at their own expense akin to the Federal In Australia, long-term care is mostly in the private
Employee Benefits Plan (FEHPB). Under FEHPB, the sector counting retirement villages, hospitals and
federal government sets its dollar contribution to the nursing homes operated by voluntary agencies and
premium, offers a large choice of plans to its employees private corporations. State governments provide a
during annual! open-enrollment period, makes smaller portion of aggregate service.19
information available to its employees to help them In Japan, the government announced (in 1990) a 10
choose wisely, and monitors the plans to make sure they year “Golden Plan” for the welfare of aged, in
are fulfilling their contractual obligations.16 preparation for having a population of 16.3 percent
elderly in 1000 AD and 23.6 percent in 2020,
Long-term Care Systems approximately the proportion expected in Sweden and
Germany. The comparable proportions expected in the
Long-term care is the lifeline for all elderly persons USA are 12.8 percent and 17.2 percent and in the UK
currently in nursing homes and who live in the 15.4 percent and 18.7 percent. Japan at present is well
community.17 The prevailing bioethical model of below the other countries (at 10.3%). A prominent
decision making, with its emphasis on individual feature of the plan is support of family care gives in a
autonomy and life-sustaining medical care at the very way that permits them to continue in paid employment
end of life, is inadequate. It is inadequate because the away from home during working hours. It also includes
chronically ill person who depneds on multiple supports systematic development of personnel and faiclities,
for survival, in a nursing home or at home, cannot particularly in the community a tripling of spending in
function as an isolated person in making decisions any the 1990’s compared with the 1980’s. Day care services,
more than in the rest of daily life: that person’s intimate including functional training will be provided in 10,000
involvement with family and professional care givers centres in 1999. The programme will innovate
necessitates their “domicilliary care support” centres, offering home
17 visiting, counselling and care coordination. The plan
participation. examplifies attempts to systematize and balance the
Most developed countries have publicly supported
institutional and community-based aspects of management-major goals and essential service.20 The
comprehensive geriatrics, the social and medical key function of case management is to develop
components and the housing and family considerations. integration of services. the specific interventions of case
The plan calls for primary prevention, rehabitation and management include: liaison activities to appropriately
prosthetic extending, to housing and other integrate clients into the health care system, health
environmental modifications to assist mobility and other promotion, counselling, disease prevention, health
functioning. education and screening, and community resource
In the Canadian province of Manitoba, a set of well- linkage. The case management team usually consists of
integrated elements of comprehensive geriatrics can be nurses, therapists and social worker. To provide
found. The financial framework is tax-based plan of comprehensive services to aged there is need to develop
universal coverage of health. A strong home care co-operative relationship and mechanisms for
programme makes possible the maintenance of patients information exchange with providers at all system levels
with their families for as long as feasible. that will serve as a bridge across the great divide
In the USA, a novel approach to systematizing is between all levels of care.
the Social Health Maintenance Organisation (SHMO). Triage- a non-profit organisation has been able to
The key feature is “Case Management” offering provide a broader range of comparable services for its
framilies’ advice and service. The SHMO pool funds population at the same cost as Medicare and Medicaid.
from Medicare (primarily an acute care programme for Moreover, vulnerable persons were able to remain at
elders) and Medicaid (acute and long-term care home and presumably with greater life satisfaction than
programme for the poor). In 1990, a congressional in a nursing home.21
commission advocated a geriatrics- informatic plan for Triage (the process of establishing criteria for health
universal coverage of long-term care through social care prioritisation) permits society to see cases in the
insurance, with a supplementary role for private context of diverse moral perspectives, limited resourc
insurance. The policies offer indemnity payments for and competing health care demands. Triage planning
individuals determined by physicians to need nursing offers a useful model for identifying and eliminating
home care. wasteful medical care. Prioritising cases require a triage
Case Management has evolved as a flexible, method that is rational, fair and consistent-evaluating
pragmatic and compassionate strategy for improving prospective cases according to seniority, acuity
client access and care continuity within fragmented (severity) and risk.
systems of health care continuity within fragmented The Living At Home Programmes fill gaps in the
systems of health care and social services. The first existing social service/medical care system by co-
generation case management programmes have been ordinating service for groups of frail elderly at risk for
designed for various settings that serve different target institutionalisation, thereby allowing them to remain at
populations with varying social, medical and home.
psychological needs. This proliferation of categorical Hospice (which focus on support for dying patient
case management progrmames is a mixed blessing. and their families), is not an institution but a service that
While a categorical focus reflects both historical and may be rendered in various settings and the care is
public financing priorities, it creates a potentially covered by a few insures.
duplicative and an inefficient system in an era of limited There is growing movement to develop Adult Day
resources. Efforts are being made (in USA) to introduce Care facilities to provide treatment for the patient assist
accountability demonstrating value-added benefits and families in making adjustments and finding aid. The cost
identifying best practices for structuring case of care is less than of nursing home.
management-client focused. The first step is reaching
agreement on two critical dimensions of case
Design and Construction The Clinical Zone n 503
Older people make much heavier demands on health and Age is an inaccurate means of classifying health cre
social than do young adults. The most elderly make the need, alternative organisational approaches that avoid
heaviest demands of all. The very elderly also tend to be age-related admission policies need to be rapidly
proportionately highly represented in the most intensive developed to avoid age-rationing of health care. In the
forms of non-home-based care (such as hospital based use of specialized acute care unit, emphasis should be on
inpatient care). In addition to having their highest rate of rehabilitation, independence in self care, and detailed
hospital admissions this group also have a much longer planning for home discharge.
average length of stay in such care when compared to
other sections of elderly population. Elderly people with
In-patient Care
acute illness present a particular challenge for the
service seeking to provide the most effective clinical Various models that have evolved are:
management of their condition and to maximize their
level of independence. Elderly people will often have Age-defined approach (usually 75 years and over)
several problems coexisting which require skillful provides a ward environment and care team.
assessment and treatment, but their functional capacity
will be equally as influential in determining both Integrated approach all acutely ill persons are
recovery and future living status. Older people need admitted to an acute medical ward, which deals with
support to enable them to enjoy active, fulfilling and other groups and are care for by a group and are cared
independent lives. for by a group of physicians.
Health workers based in clinics or in their own US Census Bureau International Population Reports
communities play an importnat role in delivering these Series 95(78): Washington DC, 1987.
services. The traditional health practitioners have 3. Kinsella K: Ageing in the third world US Census
Bureau International International. Population Reports
enormous potential as public health workers and
Series 95(75): Government Printing Office,
providers of essential clinical services, if governments Washington DC, 1988.
can give them the appropriate training, information and 4. Donaldson RJ, Donaldson LJ: Essential Public Health
incentives. Medicine. Kluwer Academic Publishers 357-87, 1993.
Terminal Care 5. NHS Executive: Annual Report 1994/95. NHSE,
Leeds, UK, 1995.
Care of dying must be patient-centered, holistic with due 6. Jitapunkul S, Bunnag S, Ebrahim S: Health care for
attention paid to physical, emotional, social and spiritual elderly people in developing countires: a case study of
need and to be comprehensive, it must be team care. Thailand. Age-Ageing: 22(5): 377-81, 1993.
7. Kobayashi Y, Reich MR: Health care financing for the
Terminal care means a commitment to pain and
elderly in Japan. Soc Sci Med 37(3): 343-53, 1993.
symptom control, the relief of social and emotional 8. Lubitz JD, Riley GF: Trends in Medicare payments in
problems, a sensitive recognition of spiritual needs and the last year of life. NEngl JMed 328: 1092-96, 1993.
concern for the needs of the relatives. HOSPICE care 9. Bureau of Census, Day JC: Population Projections of
requires an integrated team who are energetic about the United States, by age, sex, race, and Hispanic
rehabilitation. Most Home Care services aim to origin: 1993 to 2050. Current population reports, 25,
compliment the work of primary health care teams, with 1104. Washington DC: Government Printing Office,
20 patients per specialist nurse. Palliative care services 1993.
10. Olshansky SJ, Carnes RA, Cassel C: In search of
need to be separately identified and funded.
Methuselah; estimating the upper limits to human
longevity. Science 250: 634-40, 1990.
SUMMARY 11. Butler RN: On behalf of Older Women: Another
reason to protect Medicare and Medicaid. N Eng JMed
In meetings the challenges of health care and productive March 21: 794-96, 1996.
aging, roles are played by the individual, family, 12. Davis K: The unfinished agenda. Improving the well-
community, employers and government. Care of the being of elderly people living alone. Final report of
The Commonwealth Fund Commission on Elderly
aged will depend on the effectiveness, the adequacy of
People Living Alone. New York: The Commonwealth
provision and the degree of coordination of the services. Fund. 1993.
The work done in hospitals and the way in which this 13. Manton KG, Stallard L, Tolley HD: Limits to human
works interlocks with that carried out by community and life expectancy: evidence, prospects, and implications.
voluntary organisations will determine the effectiveness Popul Dev Rev 17: 603-37, 1991.
of geriatric services. A comprehensive system must be 14. Kramer AM: Health care for elderly person myths and
evolved to provide education, lesion activities, health, realities. NEngl JMed 332: 15, 1027-29, 1995.
social services and legal assistance. Investment in 15. Stuck AF, Aronow HU, Steiner A et al: A trial of
annual in-home comprehensive geriatric assessment
research and training to enhance the quality and cost-
for elderly people living in the community. N Engl J
effectiveness of care is important. Rational planning, Med 333: 1184-89, 1995.
supported by research evidence is not an urgent 16. Wilensky GR: The score on Medicare reform.minus
attention. the hype and hyperbole. NEngl JMed. 333(26): 1774-
77, 1996.
17. Lawrance B, Mc Cullouhgh and Nancy L Wilson:
REFERENCES
Longterm care Decisions: Ethical and Cenceptual
Dimensions. Baltimore, Johns Hopkin University
1. Patrick Sharp: Chronic care in old age: who will
press, 1995.
provide? Geriatric Medicine, 25th anniversary issue;
18. Johnson ML: Long-term Care for the Elderl/in
9, 1995.
England in Schwab T (Ed): 175, 1989.
2. Torrey BB, Kinsella K, Taeuber C: An Ageing World.
19. Moss B: Long-term care for Elderly in Australia in
Schwab T (Ed) 242, 1989.
20. Falik M et al: Case Management for special
Population- Moving Beyond Categorical Distinctions.
J Case Manag Summer 2(2): 39-45, 74, 1993.
21. Kane RA, Kane RL: Long-term Care Principles,
Programmes and Policies Springest-Veriag New York,
1987.
22. Melillo KD: Utilising Nurse Practitioners to provide
health care for elderly patients in Nursing Homes.
National Academy Press Washington DC, 1986.
23. Melillo KD: Utilising nurse Practitioners to provide
health care for elderly patients in Massachusetts
nursing homes. J Am Acad Nurse Pract 5(1): 19-26,
1993.
24. Incalzi RA, Bernabei R, Carbonin P: The orthopaedic-
geriatric unit: a new model of hospital care. Ann Ital
Med Int. 10(1): 49-52, 1995.
25. DHSS Geriatric Hospital Service, DHSS London,
1971.
26. Barnes CL, Given BA, Given CW: Caregivers of
elderly relatives, spouses and adult children. Health-
Soc-Work, 17(4): 282-89, 1992.
27. Mein AL, Bygren LO: Efficacy of the rehabilitation of
elderly primary health care patients after short-stay
hospital treatment. Med-Care 30(11): 1004-15, 1992.
28. Campion EW: New Hope for Home Care. Editorial. N
Engl JMed 333 18: 1213-14, 1996.
29. Peterson CC: The accuracy of older and younger
Australian’s understanding of mental health and
ageing. Int J Ageing Hum Dev 36(2): 129-38, 1992-93.
30. Reid J, Kennie DC: Geriatric Rehabilitation Care after
fracture of femur: one year follow-up of a randomised
clinical trial BMJ 299: 25-26, 1989.
31. Swinson MM: Primary health care of elderly women. J
Am Acad Nurse Pract 4(4): 143-47, 1992.
Design and Construction The Clinical Zone n 509
APPENDIX A