Experimental Extraction of Parasitic Capacitances For High-Frequency Transformers
Experimental Extraction of Parasitic Capacitances For High-Frequency Transformers
Abstract—Parasitic capacitances of the high-frequency (HF) to achieve galvanic isolation and voltage level transformation
transformer used in dc–dc converter impact harmonic analysis [1]–[5]. On the condition that requirements of switching losses
of the transformer and interactions with the converter. Resonant for the semiconductors and insulations for the transformer are
frequencies of open- and short-circuit impedances characteristics
(ICs) have been widely used to extract parasitic capacitances of HF satisfied, enhancing operating frequency is helpful to reduce
transformers, but it was reported that some resonant frequencies volume of the transformer. For dc–dc converters with bridge
were unobtainable as they were too high where the ICs fluctuated topologies, operating frequencies of the transformers may
heavily, and parasitic capacitances remained unevaluated. In this be dozens of kilohertz [3], some even up to decades of kilohertz
paper, resonance features of ICs and voltage transfer character- [4], [8], and [9]. Considering that excitations of the transform-
istics (TCs) are investigated, and a new frequency of voltage TC
is used for extracting parasitic capacitances. By analyzing inner ers in these converters are usually square waves, when conduct
links of known impedance resonant frequencies, why and which harmonic analysis on the transformers, the concerned frequency
resonant frequencies are likely to be unobtainable is revealed. Fur- range may be up to several megahertz. At these high frequen-
thermore, a new frequency corresponding to zero of TC, account- cies, impacts of parasitic capacitances on harmonic analysis of
ing for parallel resonance between leakage inductance and mutual the HF transformer and interactions with the converter should
capacitance of the two windings, is used to extract parasitic ca-
pacitances. With this new frequency mutual capacitance of the not be ignored. Parasitic capacitances seen from the excita-
windings is evaluated, and missing equation due to unobtainable tion side are responsible for natural resonant frequencies of the
impedance resonant frequency is added. Besides, merits and limi- transformer, and parasitic capacitances between windings con-
tations of extracting parasitic capacitances based on ICs and TCs tribute to the electromagnetic interference [5]–[7]. Furthermore,
are analyzed. These techniques are verified with several HF trans- current waveform on the excitation side may be distorted by par-
former prototypes in the laboratory.
asitic capacitances of the transformer, and overall efficiency of
Index Terms—Capacitance measurement, high-frequency trans- the converter may be decreased [8]. Besides, for resonant dc–dc
former, resonance, transfer functions. converters, parasitic capacitances of the transformer are desired
to be utilized as resonant elements of the converter in order to re-
I. INTRODUCTION
duce the overall system size [8]–[10]. Therefore, it is necessary
ITH the rapid development of large-scale renewable
W energy power generation, power sources that generate
megawatt-scaled direct current (dc), including photovoltaics,
to investigate parasitic capacitances of the HF transformer.
Many efforts have been made to model capacitive effects of
the HF transformer. When investigate transient behaviors of the
wind generators (without the last converter stage), etc., have transformer, refined models considering distributed parameters
proliferated in recent years, and the demands for dc–dc connec- of every single turn may be developed [11], [12], as wavefront
tions in power system have significantly increased. The dc–dc duration of the waveform applied to the winding may be shorter
converters with intermediate high-frequency (HF) transformers than the charging time and the potential at each turn of the trans-
are essential for these dc sources to integrate into the dc bus, former does not form a linear distribution [13]. When investi-
and the HF transformer is key equipment for the dc–dc converter gate harmonic analysis of the transformer where the frequency
is not very high and the propagation delay may be ignored
Manuscript received April 29, 2016; revised June 27, 2016; accepted July (usually below several megahertz which are concerned in this
29, 2016. Date of publication August 2, 2016; date of current version February paper), magnetic and capacitive effects of the transformer may
11, 2017. This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation be equivalent to lumped parameters and the models focused on
of China under Grant 51277065, by the National Energy Board under Project
NY20140301A-1, and by “111” Project of China B08013. Recommended for winding level have been established [5]–[10], [14]–[21]. The
publication by Associate Editor J. Biela. three-capacitance model with π-shaped was widely used for
C. Liu is with Beijing Key Laboratory of High Voltage & EMC, modeling transformer in system analysis and circuit simulation,
North China Electric Power University, Beijing 102206, China (e-mail:
liuchen12315@ncepu.edu.cn). where the transformer was regarded as a two-port network con-
L. Qi and X. Cui are with State Key Laboratory for Alternate Electrical Power sidering the two independent winding current [6]–[9], [21]. The
System with Renewable Energy Sources, North China Electric Power Univer- six-capacitance model was used to investigate whole electro-
sity, Beijing 102206, China (e-mail: qilei@ncepu.edu.cn; x.cui@ncepu.edu.cn).
X. Wei is with the Global Energy Interconnection Research Institute, Beijing static behavior of the transformer, where the transformer was
100192, China (e-mail: weixiaoguang@sgri.sgcc.com.cn). regarded as a three-port network considering the third current
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available online running between the two windings via parasitic capacitances
at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TPEL.2016.2597498 [10], [14]–[20]. In high-power and high-voltage (HV) applica-
0885-8993 © 2016 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See http://www.ieee.org/publications standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
Authorized licensed use limited to: MINCYT. Downloaded on February 23,2021 at 13:14:00 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
4158 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER ELECTRONICS, VOL. 32, NO. 6, JUNE 2017
Authorized licensed use limited to: MINCYT. Downloaded on February 23,2021 at 13:14:00 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
LIU et al.: EXPERIMENTAL EXTRACTION OF PARASITIC CAPACITANCES FOR HIGH-FREQUENCY TRANSFORMERS 4159
the two windings. Combining the magnetic part and capacitive represented as follows:
part, the circuit model with three capacitances is established.
This model is a common lumped parameter model for the 1
f1 =
two-winding transformer, which has been widely used for trans-
2π Lm Cp + n2 Cs + (n − 1)2 Cps
former modeling in resonant converter, dynamic circuit model-
ing and numerical simulation [6]–[9]. Furthermore, although 1
more complicated models with six or ten capacitances have f2 =
2π Ls (Cs + Cps )
been developed in order to investigate whole electrostatic be-
haviors of the transformer under different winding conditions 1
f3 =
(such as one winding terminal is linked to another terminal or 2π Ls (Cp + Cps ) /n2
grounded), these models may still be equivalent to the three-
1
capacitance model as long as external wiring which links the f4 = (5)
C p C s +C p C p s +C s C p s
windings together or to different conductive parts (screen, core, 2π Ls C +n 2 C +(n −1) 2 C
p s ps
clamping, shielding, etc.) stays unchanged [5], [14]. Therefore,
in this paper we are mainly focused on capacitance experimental where f1 , f2 and f4 are the first parallel, serial and the second
extraction of the three-capacitance model. parallel resonant frequency of open-circuit impedance (Z1o c ),
Admittance matrix of the model shown in Fig. 1, which is respectively, and f3 is parallel resonant frequency of short-
sufficient to depict external behaviors of the transformer, is de- circuit impedance (Z1sc ). The expressions of f1 to f4 shown
duced in order to provide rigorous mathematical foundations for in (5) may also be deduced from the admittance matrix, as
external measurements. In the magnetic part, admittance of the impedance functions with the secondary winding open and short
leakage branch and the magnetizing branch may be represented circuit, i.e., Z1o c and Z1sc , may be represented as Z11 and 1/Y11 ,
as yl and ym , respectively respectively, where Z is inverse matrix of Y. For open- and short-
1 1 1 circuit impedance seen from the secondary side, i.e., Z2o c and
yl = , ym = + (1) Z2sc , corresponding resonant frequencies may also be obtained
Rs + jωLs Rm jωLm
from (5) by permutating indexes p and s of the capacitances
and admittance matrix of the magnetic part may be represented and replacing n with 1/n. Expression of f1 and f4 show that
as Y M the two parallel resonances of Z1o c and Z2o c occur at the same
2 frequency, and expression of f2 and f3 show that the serial
n yl + ym −nyl
YM = . (2) resonance of Z1o c occurs at the same frequency as the parallel
−nyl yl
resonance of Z2sc .
Besides, admittance matrix of the capacitive part may be These impedance resonant frequencies may be measured with
represented as Y C an impedance analyzer. Simultaneously, magnetizing and leak-
age inductance, i.e., Lm and Ls , may be extracted from the
Cp + Cps −Cps
Y C = jω . (3) measurement results of impedance characteristics [22], or de-
−Cps Cs + Cps
termined by open- and short-circuit tests at low frequencies
Considering the capacitive part is parallel to the magnetic [23]. Accordingly, parasitic capacitances, i.e., Cp , Cs , and Cps ,
part in the model, admittance matrix of the whole model may may be deduced with equations shown in (5). In practice, usually
be deduced as Y f1 , f2 and f3 are used to extract parasitic capacitances, whereas,
f4 is used as a checkpoint to validate the deduced capacitances,
Y = YM +YC as f4 contains high-order terms of capacitances. This method is
2
n yl +ym +jω (Cp +Cps ) −nyl −jω (Cps ) the traditional IC-method which has been widely used to extract
= . (4)
−nyl −jω (Cps ) yl +jω (Cs +Cps ) parasitic capacitances of HF transformers.
Authorized licensed use limited to: MINCYT. Downloaded on February 23,2021 at 13:14:00 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
4160 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER ELECTRONICS, VOL. 32, NO. 6, JUNE 2017
it is necessary to investigate inner links of these impedance Based on above analysis, the cause of unobtainable
resonant frequencies. impedance resonant frequencies reported in [5], [9], and [21]
Actually, based on (5) ratios of f1 , f2 , f3 and f4 may be may be revealed. Specifically, in [5] turn ratio of the trans-
deduced as follows: former was 91.4, and f2 measured from the LV side was 74 kHz,
which meant that f3 and f4 seen from the LV side were higher
f2 Lm (Cp + n2 Cs + (n − 1)2 Cps ) than nf2 = 6.8 MHz, while the measurement range was within
=
f1 Ls (Cs + Cps ) 1 MHz. In [9], turn ratio of the transformer was 11, and f2 mea-
sured from the LV side was about 1.4 MHz, which meant that f3
Cp Cp s 2C p s
n2 Lm 2 + n2 − and f4 seen from the LV side were higher than nf2 = 15.4 MHz,
= 1+ n n
Ls Cs + Cps while measurement results fluctuated heavily at about 10 MHz.
In [21], turn ratio of the transformer was 30, and f2 measured
n2 Lm from the LV side was about 800 kHz, which meant that f3 and
n increases (6) f4 seen from the LV side were higher than nf2 = 24 MHz, while
−−−−−−−−−−−−−−→ Ls
measurement results fluctuated heavily at about 10 MHz. There-
f3 Cs + Cps fore, f3 , f4 seen from the LV side (as well as f2 , f4 seen from
= n >n (7) the HV side) of those three HF transformers were unobtainable.
f2 Cp + Cps
IV. TC-METHOD FOR EXTRACTING PARASITIC CAPACITANCES
(Cp + Cps ) Cp + n2 Cs + (n − 1)2 Cps
f4
= A. Resonant Frequencies of TCs
f3 n2 (Cp Cs + Cp Cps + Cs Cps )
Based on admittance matrix of the HF transformer, voltage
(Cp + (1 − n) Cps )2 transfer function with the secondary winding open-circuit (Hu )
= 1+ 2 > 1. (8)
n (Cp Cs + Cp Cps + Cs Cps ) and current transfer function with the secondary winding short-
circuit (Hi ) may be deduced as
Supposing that n ≥ 1, which means that f1 to f4 are all mea-
sured from the low-voltage (LV) side. Magnetic couplings be- U2
Y21 nyl + jωCps
Hu = I =0 = − = (10)
tween the two windings will be very strong due to the magnetic U1
2 Y22 yl + jω (Cs + Cps )
core, and thus, magnetizing inductance will be far larger than I2
Y21 −nyl − jωCps
leakage inductance referred to the same side, i.e. n2 Lm >> Ls . Hi = U =0 = = 2
I1
2 Y11 n yl + ym + jω (Cp + Cps )
Therefore, from (6) it may be found that usually f2 > f1 , and
f2 /f1 is close to n2 Lm /Ls as n increases. Furthermore, con- nyl + jωCps
= − (11)
sidering that the ratio of Cs and Cp is closely related to turn ratio n2 y l + jω (Cp + Cps )
n, f3 is very close to f2 when n = 1. However, as n increases, where admittance of the magnetizing branch may be neglected
Cs tends to be larger than Cp , and f3 /f2 will increase faster than compared with that of the leakage branch referred to the same
n. Besides, from (8), it may be found that f4 is always higher side, i.e., ym <<n2 yl . From (10) and (11), it may be found that
than f3 . Therefore, for f1 , f2 , f3 and f4 , we have at low frequencies capacitive components are very small and we
have |Hu |→n, |Hi | → 1/n. As frequency increases, impacts of
f2 n2 Lm f3 parasitic capacitances on Hu and Hi may not be neglected as
f1 < f2 < f3 < f4 , and n increases , > n.
f1 −−−−−−−−−−−−−−→ Ls f2 resonances may occur between L and C parameters. Ignoring
(9) winding resistances of the transformer, frequencies correspond-
Relation (9), which will be verified with several transformer ing to poles of Hu and Hi , i.e., fu and fi , may be deduced
prototypes with n = 3.5, 4 and 91.4, respectively, as presented as
in Section V, shows the inner links of known impedance reso-
1
nant frequencies. From (9) it may be found that f1 and f2 are fu = = f2
usually easier to be measured due to their lower frequencies, 2π Ls (Cs + Cps )
while f3 and f4 may be very high when the transformer has a 1
large turn ratio, as f3 is higher than n times of f2 , and f4 is fi = = f3 . (12)
2π Ls (Cp + Cps ) /n2
even higher than f3 . Considering that f1 to f4 are all derived
from the lumped parameter model, if f3 and f4 are too high Especially, Hu and Hi have the same zero, and corresponding
to exceed available frequency range of the model, ICs of the frequency is fzero
transformer may fluctuate heavily due to the impacts of dis- 1
tributed parameters, and these resonant frequencies may not be fzero = . (13)
2π Ls Cps /n
accurately measured [13]. Considering that f3 seen from one
side of the transformer is equal to f2 seen from the other side, The relationships between resonant frequencies of ICs and
if measured from the HV side, f2 and f4 may be very high TCs are shown in Fig. 2. It may be found that fu is equal to
and are hard to be measured when the transformer has a large f2 , and fi is equal to f3 . Besides, the first parallel resonant fre-
turn ratio. quency of open-circuit impedance, i.e., f1 , may also be deduced
Authorized licensed use limited to: MINCYT. Downloaded on February 23,2021 at 13:14:00 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
LIU et al.: EXPERIMENTAL EXTRACTION OF PARASITIC CAPACITANCES FOR HIGH-FREQUENCY TRANSFORMERS 4161
Fig. 2. Relationships between resonant frequencies of ICs |Z| (upper) and TCs Supposing that f1 , f2 (fu ) and f3 (fi ) are all measured from
|H| (bottom).
the LV side (n ≥ 1). From (15), it is found that fzero will be
higher than f2 , and fzero /f2 is larger than square root of n.
From (16), it is found that the ratio of fzero and f3 is uncertain
as it is determined by the ratio of Cp + Cps and nCps . Specifi-
cally, when n = 1, fzero is higher than f3 . However, if turn ratio
n and mutual capacitance Cps are large enough which makes
(n−1)Cps > Cp , fzero will be lower than f3 . Actually, no mat-
ter higher or lower than f3 , fzero is always a useful frequency
which deserves to be measured, because with fzero mutual ca-
Fig. 3. Equivalent model with all parasitic capacitances referred to the sec-
ondary side. pacitance between the two windings (Cps ) may be evaluated
with (13). Adding another two resonant frequencies which are
lower than fzero and easier to be measured, i.e., f1 and f2 (fu ),
from voltage TC (Hu ) if the input voltage and current (U1 and
all parasitic capacitances may be deduced as follows:
I1 ) are simultaneously measured. Because, when phase differ-
ence of U1 and I1 changes from 90° to 0° at the first time as n
Cps =
frequency increases, it indicates that the first parallel resonance Ls (2πfzero )2
occurs, and f1 will be obtained. 2 2
Cp Ls fzero nfzero
Especially, with (13) it may be found that a new resonant fre- = − + 2n − 1
quency, i.e., fzero , is deduced from zero of TCs compared with Cps nLm f12 f22
impedance resonant frequencies. This new frequency may be il- Cs f2
lustrated by an equivalent model with all parasitic capacitances = zero − 1. (17)
Cps nf22
referred to the secondary side, as shown in Fig. 3, where C1 , C2
and C3 may be represented by Cp , Cs and Cps as follows [6]: From (17), it may be found that after determining inductance
parameters of the transformer, Cps may be directly evaluated
1 1 1 with fzero , and Cp , Cs may also be deduced with fzero /f1 and
C1 = 2 Cp + − 1 Cps
n n n fzero /f2 . For some HF transformers where Cps is very small,
maybe no resonance is occurred between Ls and Cps in the
1
C2 = Cs + 1 − Cps concerned frequency range, and fzero will not be effectively
n
measured. In this case, Cp /Cps and Cs /Cps are usually very
1 large as fzero is relatively high, which indicates that Cps may
C3 = Cps . (14)
n be neglected compared with Cp and Cs . Therefore, Cp and Cs
may still be estimated by neglecting Cps with equations related
It may be found that C3 = Cps /n is actually the mutual ca- to f1 and f2 (fu ) shown in (5).
pacitance of the two windings (Cps ) referred to the secondary Considering that the three frequencies used in (17), i.e.,
side, and fzero accounts for parallel resonance between leak- f1 , f2 (fu ), fzero , may all be deduced through measuring TCs
age inductance Ls and mutual capacitance Cps referred to the of the HF transformer, this method for extracting parasitic ca-
same side. Therefore, at fzero admittance of the leakage branch pacitances is taken as the TC-method. Resonance features of
Authorized licensed use limited to: MINCYT. Downloaded on February 23,2021 at 13:14:00 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
4162 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER ELECTRONICS, VOL. 32, NO. 6, JUNE 2017
TABLE I
COMPARISONS OF IC-METHOD AND TC-METHOD
TCs and corresponding analysis on the TC-method are also 1) apply sinusoidal excitation to the LV winding of the trans-
verified with several HF transformer prototypes in Section V. former, and detect input current (I1 ), input voltage (U1 )
and output voltage (U2 ) at different frequencies with the
C. Comparisons of IC-Method and TC-Method HV winding open-circuit, when phase difference of U1
and I1 changes from 90° to 0° at the first time as frequency
IC-method has been widely used to extract parasitic capaci- increases, it indicates that the first parallel resonance oc-
tances. This method works fine for transformer with small turn curs, and f1 will be obtained;
ratio, and ICs and corresponding resonant frequencies may be 2) calculate voltage transfer function Hu , and find frequen-
automatically acquired by using an impedance analyzer. How- cies corresponding to pole and zero of Hu , i.e., fu (f2 )
ever, when the transformer has a large turn ratio, f3 seen from and fzero ;
the LV side (or f2 seen from the HV side) may be unobtainable 3) deduce Cp , Cs and Cps with f1 , fu (f2 ) and fzero based
as it is too high where the ICs fluctuate heavily, and no capaci- on (17).
tance is deduced due to the missing equation. Furthermore, both A measurement system is established in order to imple-
open- and short-circuit measurements are needed in order to ment above procedures, as shown in Fig. 4. In this system, a
obtain open and short ICs. Tektronix AFG3101 signal generator is used to provide the si-
In comparison, TC-method provides a new frequency (fzero ) nusoidal excitation to the LV winding of the transformer, with
to evaluate parasitic capacitances of the HF transformer. Mutual the HV winding open-circuit. A Yokogawa DLM2054 oscillo-
capacitance of the windings (Cps ) may be evaluated with fzero , scope is used to record the voltage and current of the transformer.
and missing equation due to unobtainable impedance frequency Specifically, voltage and current of the LV winding (U1 and I1 )
may be added. Even if fzero is unobtainable in the measurement are measured by a voltage probe and a current probe, which are
range, it indicates that Cps is very small and Cp , Cs may still connected to channels 1 and 2 of the oscilloscope, respectively.
be estimated with f1 and fu . Besides, only open-circuit mea- Voltage of the HV winding (U2 ) is measured by another voltage
surement is needed in the method, as f1 , fu , fzero may all be probe, which is connected to channel 3 of the oscilloscope. It
deduced from voltage TC with HV winding open-circuit. is to be noted that output voltage of the signal generator should
Merits and drawbacks of the traditional IC-method and the be carefully chosen. In low frequencies, the value of the output
proposed TC-method are shown in Table I. It is found that voltage should be small in order to avoid magnetic core satura-
the proposed TC-method provides new information on mutual tion; while in high frequencies, the value may be raised in order
capacitance of the windings through the new frequency fzero , to insure a sufficient signal noise ratio. Therefore, in order to en-
which is useful to extract parasitic capacitances of the HF trans- sure accuracy of measured voltage TC, multiple metering with
former, especially when impedance resonant frequency used in different output voltages of signal generator is recommended.
IC-method is unobtainable due to large turn ratio of the trans- Obviously, fu and fzero used in TC-method may also be di-
former. Features of the two methods are further verified through rectlyobtained by measuring TCs with a network analyzer. How-
extracting parasitic capacitances of several HF transformer pro- ever, the network analyzer is sophisticated equipment, which is
totypes presented in Section V. usually used in the laboratory but may not be widely applied
in engineering practice. Furthermore, for certain network ana-
V. EXPERIMENTAL VERIFICATION lyzers, the start frequency is relatively high (for example, for
For IC-method based on f1 , f2 , f3 of ICs, an impedance an- Agilent E5061 equipped in our laboratory the start frequency
alyzer may be used to measure these resonant frequencies. For is 300 kHz), if fu or fzero is lower than start frequency, it will
TC-method based on f1 , fu , fzero of TCs, resonant frequencies not be effectively measured. Therefore, the measurement sys-
may be deduced through open-circuit measurement by testing tem used in this paper provides an alternative to measure fu and
voltage TC of the transformer as follows: fzero based on a signal generator and an oscilloscope, which is
Authorized licensed use limited to: MINCYT. Downloaded on February 23,2021 at 13:14:00 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
LIU et al.: EXPERIMENTAL EXTRACTION OF PARASITIC CAPACITANCES FOR HIGH-FREQUENCY TRANSFORMERS 4163
Fig. 4. System for measuring resonant frequencies of voltage TC. (a) Schematic diagram of the measuring system. (b) Photo of the measuring system.
Fig. 5. Transformer prototypes used in this paper. (a) Prototype 1 with 4.5 kHz, 5kVA. (b) Prototype 2 with 400 Hz, 1.5 kVA. (c) Prototype 3 with 20 kHz,
30 kVA.
Authorized licensed use limited to: MINCYT. Downloaded on February 23,2021 at 13:14:00 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
4164 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER ELECTRONICS, VOL. 32, NO. 6, JUNE 2017
TABLE IV
PARASITIC CAPACITANCES DETERMINED BY THE TWO METHODS
FOR PROTOTYPE 1
Method Cp Cs Cp s
Authorized licensed use limited to: MINCYT. Downloaded on February 23,2021 at 13:14:00 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
LIU et al.: EXPERIMENTAL EXTRACTION OF PARASITIC CAPACITANCES FOR HIGH-FREQUENCY TRANSFORMERS 4165
TABLE VI
PARASITIC CAPACITANCES DETERMINED BY THE TWO METHODS
FOR PROTOTYPE 2
Method Cp Cs Cp s
b
Cp and Cs shown in TC-Method are both calculated
with Cp s = 0.
Authorized licensed use limited to: MINCYT. Downloaded on February 23,2021 at 13:14:00 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
4166 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER ELECTRONICS, VOL. 32, NO. 6, JUNE 2017
TABLE VIII
PARASITIC CAPACITANCES EXTRACTED BY TC-METHOD FOR PROTOTYPE 3
Parasitic capacitances
Cp Cs Cp s
68.6 pF 112.8 pF 99.6 pF
VI. CONCLUSION
Resonance features of ICs and TCs of HF transformers are
investigated, and a TC-method for extracting parasitic capaci-
tances is proposed with a new transfer resonant frequency. The
merits and drawbacks of TC-method are analyzed compared
with existing IC-method, and several HF transformer prototypes
are tested for verifications. The results show that:
1) Some impedance resonant frequencies used in the IC-
method may be unobtainable when the transformer has
a large turn ratio, and parasitic capacitances remained
unevaluated. By investigating missing links of known
Fig. 10. ICs of prototype 3. (a) HV winding is open-circuit. (b) HV winding impedance resonant frequencies, why and which resonant
is short-circuit. frequencies are likely to be unobtainable is effectively
revealed.
2) A TC-method for extracting parasitic capacitances
is proposed with a new frequency corresponding to
zero of voltage TC. This new frequency accounts
for parallel resonance between leakage inductance and
mutual capacitance of the two windings, by which the
mutual capacitance is evaluated and missing equation due
to unobtainable impedance frequency is added. Even if the
new frequency is unobtainable, it indicates that the mutual
capacitance is very small and parasitic capacitances may
still be estimated.
3) The proposed TC-method has advantage over existing IC-
method when some impedance resonant frequencies are
unobtainable. Furthermore, only open-circuit measure-
ments are needed to conduct, with conventional instru-
Fig. 11. Voltage TC of prototype 3 with HV winding open-circuit. ments, i.e., a signal generator and an oscilloscope, which
makes TC-method a promising way for capacitance ex-
traction of HF transformers in engineering practice.
TABLE VII
MEASUREMENT RESULTS OF RESONANT FREQUENCIES FOR PROTOTYPE 3 REFERENCES
[1] L. Thomas, M. M. C. Merlin, T. C. Green, F. Hassan, and C. D. Barker,
“High-frequency operation of a DC/AC/DC system for HVDC appli-
ICs Voltage TC
cations,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 29, no. 8, pp. 4107–4115,
f1 f2 f3 , f4 f1 fu f zero
Aug. 2014.
1.8 kHz 53 kHz > 1 MHz 1.8 kHz 53 kHz 740 kHz
[2] S. Kenzelmann, A. Rufer, D. Dujic, F. Canales, and Y. R. de Novaes,
“Isolated DC/DC structure based on modular multilevel converter,” IEEE
Trans. Power Electron., vol. 30, no. 1, pp. 89–98, Jan. 2015.
e.q. (9) f 2 /f 1 = 29.4 → n 2 L m /L s = 30.0 e.q. (12) f u = f 2
√ [3] S. Inoue and H. Akagi, “A bidirectional isolated DC-DC converter as
e.q. (15) f zero /f u = 14.0 > n =9.56
a core circuit of the next-generation medium-voltage power conversion
system,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 22, no. 2, pp. 535–542,
Mar. 2007.
Authorized licensed use limited to: MINCYT. Downloaded on February 23,2021 at 13:14:00 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
LIU et al.: EXPERIMENTAL EXTRACTION OF PARASITIC CAPACITANCES FOR HIGH-FREQUENCY TRANSFORMERS 4167
[4] H. Tao, A. Kotsopoulos, J. L. Duarte, and M. A. M. Hendrix, “Transformer- Chen Liu was born in Shandong, China, in 1990. He
coupled multiport ZVS bidirectional DC-DC converter with wide in- received the B.Sc. degree in electrical engineering
put range.” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 23, no. 2, pp. 7711–781, in North China Electric Power University, Beijing,
Mar. 2008. China, in 2012, where he is currently working toward
[5] C. Liu, L. Qi, X. Cui, Z. Shen, and X. Wei, “Wideband mecha- the Ph.D. degree in electrical engineering.
nism model and parameter extracting for high-power high-voltage high- His research interests include advanced transmis-
frequency transformers,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 31, no. 5, sion technology in power systems and electromag-
pp. 3444–3455, May 2016. netic modeling of high-power high-frequency trans-
[6] H. Y. Lu, J. G. Zhu, and S. Y. Ron Hui, “Experimental determination of former for HVDC application.
stray capacitances in high frequency transformers,” IEEE Trans. Power
Electron., vol. 18, no. 5, pp. 1105–1112, Sep. 2003.
[7] K. L. Kaiser, Electromagnetic Compatibility Handbook, Boca Raton, FL,
USA: CRC Press, 2005.
[8] M. Borage, K. V. Nagesh, M. S. Bhatia, and S. Tiwari, “Design of
LCL-T resonant converter including the effect of transformer winding
capacitance,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 56, no. 5, pp. 1420–1427, Lei Qi was born in Henan Province, China, in 1978.
May 2009. He received the B.S., M.S., and Ph.D. degrees in elec-
[9] W. Shen, F. Wang, D. Boroyevich, and C. W. Tipton IV, “High-density trical engineering from North China Electric Power
nanocrystalline core transformer for high-power high-frequency reso- University, Baoding, China, in 2000, 2003, and 2006,
nant converter,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 44, no. 1, pp. 213–222, respectively.
Jan./Feb. 2008. He is currently an Associate Professor of elec-
[10] J. Biela and W. Johann, “Using transformer parasitics for resonant trical and electronic engineering at North China
converters—A review of the calculation of the stray capacitance of Electric Power University, Beijing, China. His re-
transformers,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 44, no. 1, pp. 223–233, search interests include electromagnetic (EM) field
Jan./Feb. 2008. numerical computation, EM compatibility on power
[11] F. de Leon and A. Semlyen. “Efficient calculation of elementary pa- systems, and ultrahigh-voltage power transmission
rameters of transformers,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 7, no. 1, technology.
pp. 376–383, Jan. 1992.
[12] M. M. Kane and S. V. Kulkarni, “MTL-based analysis to distinguish high-
frequency behavior of interleaved windings in power transformers,” IEEE
Trans. Power Del., vol. 28, no. 4, pp. 2291–2299, Oct. 2013.
[13] S. Okabe, M. Koto, G. Ueta, T. Saida, and S. Yamada, “Development of
high frequency circuit model for oil-immersed power transformers and
its application for lightning surge analysis,” IEEE Trans. Dielect. Elect. Xiang Cui (M’97–SM’98) was born in Baoding,
Insul., vol. 18, no. 2, pp. 541–552, Apr. 2011. China, in 1960. He received the B.Sc. and M.Sc.
[14] B. Cogitore, J. P. Keradec, and J. Barbaroux, “The two-winding trans- degrees in electrical engineering from North China
former: An experimental method to obtain a wide frequency range equiv- Electric Power University, Baoding, China, in 1982
alent circuit,” IEEE Trans. Instrum. Meas., vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 364–371, and 1984, respectively, and the Ph.D. degree in accel-
Apr. 1994. erator physics from China Institute of Atomic Energy,
[15] F. Blache, J. Keradec, and B. Cogitore, “Stray capacitances of two wind- Beijing, China, in 1988.
ing transformers: Equivalent circuit, measurements, calculation and low- He is currently a Professor and the Head of the
ering,” in Proc. IEEE Ind. Appl. Soc. Annu. Meet., Oct. 1994, vol. 2, Electromagnetic Fields and Electromagnetic Com-
pp. 1211–1217. patibility Laboratory, North China Electric Power
[16] L. Dalessandro, F. da Silveira Cavalcante, and J. W. Kolar, “Self- University. His research interests include computa-
capacitance of high-voltage transformers,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., tional electromagnetics, electromagnetic environment and electromagnetic com-
vol. 22, no. 5, pp. 2081–2092, Sep. 2007. patibility in power systems, insulation, and magnetic problems in high-voltage
[17] Z. De Grève, O. Deblecker, and J. Lobry, “Numerical modeling of ca- apparatus.
pacitive effects in HF multiwinding transformers—Part I: A rigorous for- Prof. Cui is a Standing Council Member of the China Electrotechnical So-
malism based on the electrostatic equations,” IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 49, ciety, a Fellow of Institution of Engineering and Technology, and a Member
no. 5, pp. 2017–2020, May 2013. of CIGRE C4.02.01 Working Group (electromagnetic compatibility in power
[18] Z. De Grève, O. Deblecker, and J. Lobry, “Numerical modeling of ca- systems). He is also an Associate Editor of the IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ELEC-
pacitive effects in HF multiwinding transformers—Part II: Identification TROMAGNETIC COMPATIBILITY and a Member of the Editorial Advisory Board
using the finite-element method,” IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 49, no. 5, of the International Journal for Computation and Mathematics in Electrical
pp. 2021–2024, May 2013. and Electronic Engineering.
[19] R. Asensi, R. Prieto, J. A. Cobos, and J. Uceda, “Modeling high-frequency
multiwinding magnetic components using finite-element analysis,” IEEE
Trans. Magn., vol. 43, no. 10, pp. 3840–3850, Oct. 2007.
[20] A. Schellmanns, K. Berrouche, and J. P. Keradec, “Multiwinding trans-
formers: a successive refinement method to characterize a general equiv-
alent circuit” IEEE Trans. Instrum. Meas., vol. 47, no. 5, pp. 1316–1321,
Oct. 1998.
[21] S. Baek, S. Bhattacharya, and G. Ortiz, “Accurate equivalent circuit mod-
Xiaoguang Wei received the bachelor’s and mas-
eling of a medium-voltage and high-frequency coaxial winding DC-link
ter’s degrees in engineering from North China Elec-
transformer for solid state transformer applications,” in Proc. IEEE Energy tric Power University, Baoding, China, in 1999 and
Convers. Congr. Expo., Raleigh, NC, USA, 2012, pp. 1439–1446.
2003, respectively, and the Ph.D. degree in engineer-
[22] X. Margueron and J. P. Keradec, “Identifying the magnetic part of the
ing from China Electric Power Research Institute,
equivalent circuit of n-winding transformers,” IEEE Trans. Instrum. Meas.,
Beijing, China, in 2007.
vol. 56, no. 1, pp. 146–152, Feb. 2007. He is currently working at Global Energy Inter-
[23] H. Y. Lu, J. G. Zhu, and V. S. Ramsden, “Comparison of experimen-
connection Research Institute. His research interests
tal techniques for determination of stray capacitances in high frequency
include HVDC transmission, dc power grid and its
transformers,” in Proc. 31st Annu. Power Electron. Spec. Conf., 2000,
key equipment research and development, and con-
vol. 3, pp. 1645–1650.
nection of new energy to power grid.
Authorized licensed use limited to: MINCYT. Downloaded on February 23,2021 at 13:14:00 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.