Unit-Iv Patent Rights: Scope of Intellectual Property Rights
Unit-Iv Patent Rights: Scope of Intellectual Property Rights
Patent Rights
Scope of Intellectual Property Rights
Intellectual property rights include copyright, patent, trademark, geographic indication of
origin, industrial design, trade secrets, database protection laws, publicity rights laws, laws
for the protection of plant varieties, laws for the protection of semi-conductor chips (which
store information for later retrieval), etc.
There is a conventional mode of classification of intellectual property as industrial property
and copyrights. Industrial properties include inventions (patent), property interest on minor
invention (Utility model certificate) and commercial interests (Trade Marks, trade names,
geographical indications, and industrial design), plant breeder rights, biodiversity, etc.
Patents
A patent is a type of intellectual property right which allows the holder of the right to
exclusively make use of and sale an invention when one develops an invention. Invention is a
new process, machine, manufacture, composition of matter. It is not an obvious derivation of
the prior art (It should involve an inventive step). A person who has got a patent right has an
exclusive right. The exclusive right is a true monopoly but its grant involves an
administrative process.
Copyright
It is an intellectual property which does not essentially grant an exclusive right over an idea
but the expressions of ideas which makes if different from patent law. Patent is related with
invention - technical solution to technical problems. Copyright is a field which has gone with
artistic, literary creativity- creativity in scientific works, audio-visual works, musical works,
software and others. There are neighbouring rights. These are different from copyright but
related with it – performers in a theatre, dancers, actors, broadcasters, producers of sound
recorders, etc. It protects not ideas but expressions of ideas as opposed to patent.
Copyright protects original expression of ideas, the ways the works are done; the language
used, etc. It applies for all copyrightable works. Copyright lasts for a longer period of time.
The practice is life of author plus 50 years after his/her life. Administrative procedures are
not required, unlike patent laws, in most laws but in America depositing the work was
necessary and was certified thereon but now it is abolished.
Industrial Design Law
Some call this design right (European) and some call it patentable design, industrial design
(WIPO and other international organization). A design is a kind of intellectual property
which gives an exclusive right to a person who has created a novel appearance of a product.
It deals with appearance: how they look like. Appearance is important because consumers
are interested in the outer appearance of a product. It is exclusively concerned with
appearance, not quality.
The principles which have been utilized in developing industrial design law are from
experiences of patent and copyright laws. It shares copyright laws because the design is
artistic. It shares patent law because there are scientific considerations. Design law subsists
in a work upon registration and communication. It makes them close to patent law since
they are also founded in patent law. Duration is most of the time 20 years like the patent law
trademark Rights law.
Trademarks Rights Law
It is a regime of the law giving protection to graphic representation to words or logos or
depending on the jurisdiction question such as sound or smells which are distinctive in
nature and serve as source identification. There is also a recent phenomenon which is
representing goods in their smell and sound. It is to be found on the goods associated with
them. It enables the customer to identify the goods from others. They serve as a source
identifier. Trademarks perform communication function. Once there is a valid
representation, it gives the mark owner an exclusive right. It begins with registration and
publication of the mark. But there are exceptions which serve what trademarks registered
serve which are not registered. It means they deserve protection even though they are not
registered. They exist forever so long as the good with which they are associated continue to
be sold. But they require renewal.
Right of Publicity
It protects the right to use one’s own name or likeness for commercial purposes.
Geographic Indication
It is indications on products of the geographic origin of the goods. It indicates the general
source. The indication relates to the quality or reputation or other characteristics of the
good. For example, “made in Ethiopia” is not influenced by the geographical Indication.
Geographical indications are sometimes called appellations of origin. For example, “Sheno
lega”, “Shampagne” (name of a region in France) are geographical indications.
Trade Secrets
It gives the owner of commercial information that provides a competitive edge the right to
keep others from using such information if the information was improperly disclosed to or
acquired by a competitor and the owner of the information took reasonable precautions to
keep it secret. It protects confidential secrets of some commercial value. The holder of the
secret wants this information to be protected; some protect the holder from an unauthorized
disclosure of the information. A tort law, unfair competition or contract law can protect such
information which is secret /confidential information/. The holder (owner) has to do
his/her best to keep the information secret. Trade secrets exist without registration as it is
to make the information public, for example, the formula of Coca Cola. Information that are
protected in trade secrets can be patentable if they are novel and non-obvious. But it is, most
of the time, not to make the secret public. However, their full-fledged IP rights are
contestable.
Patent Databases
It is a repository of data related to the issued patents and published applications. All the
relevant data related to patents, i.e. patent number, claims, specification, review, reference
etc., are collected and maintained in a patent database. The first large public patent database
was launched by USPTO in November 1995. The USPTO database now contains information
regarding 326,033 granted patents and 615,243 patent applications as per United States
(US) Patent Statistics Chart, 2014. The database is updated weekly on every Tuesday when
new patents are issued. The EPO’s ESPACENET system is the largest public database, which
contains more than 90 million patent documents from 80 countries, containing information
about inventions and technical developments from 1836 onwards. The commercial online
patent databases appeared in the early 1980s, followed by Compact Disc-Read Only Memory
(CD-ROMs) a few years later. Currently there are more than 100 free and subscription patent
and patent-related databases on the World Wide Web. The list of different types of patent
databases available.
National and Multinational Patent Databases
Patent offices of various countries collect, maintain and store all the information about the
patent applications filed and granted in their respective areas. This information is stored in
patent databases which is freely available online. These databases also contains link to
patent database of other countries. They provide full text, CD ROMs, and search tools for
accessing the patent information stored in patent database. Multinational patent databases
are the most comprehensive database of patent documents available in the world. They
provide access to patent-related publications; provide multilingual support, contains
bibliographic collections, co-citation analysis, machine translations, PDFs, drawings,
simple/extended families with legal status, corporate tree, etc. The various regional, national
and multinational patent databases are freely available and their websites are listed.
Commercial Patent Databases
There are many commercial patent databases that offer more useful services, such as,
translations of patent information, additional systematic classification based on chemical
structures, reactions, biological sequences, etc. These commercial databases provide value
added services such as patent family based data, manually corrected bibliographic data,
graphical patent family analysis, identification of top assignees, top classifications, and top
countries of filing, etc. The major commercial fee based patent databases are listed in Table.
Patent Databases in Indian Context
In India, the IPR related issues came into prominence after a while when global community
started implementing it. As India started moving into a global trade regime, the necessity of
Indian patent databases also rose into prominence. There are few relevant patent databases
in Indian context. The major databases in this regard are:
INPAIRS Version 2 – It is freely accessible online patent search engine maintained by
Government of India to search Indian patents. The patents filed and granted in India can be
accessed through INPAIRS. The database also provides information on published
applications and application status. We can also access the Patent Agent Register and the
Patent validity with renewal fee. The database also provides access to PCT patents using the
international patent number. There is patent search engine help tool, which helps to easily
access the database for patent information.
MCPaIRS (Molecular Connections Patent Information Retrieval System) – It is a
commercial patent database maintained by Molecular Connections. MCPaIRS helps to search
the full text of patents published in India. The data is processed by experts and is available
for use through web interface. The database comprises an elegant front page with
bibliographic details, application status, legal status information, etc. for all patents. The
database contains patent information from 1981 and is updated weekly. It is also supported
by commercial patent literature databases i.e. PatBase, Thomson Innovation, Questel Orbit,
STN, SciFinder, Lexis Nexis, etc. and Non-Patent Literature databases.
EKASWA A, B and C Database – These are the first Indian patent searchable databases
available in CDROM and Web. Ekaswa A contains patent applications filed in India from
January 1995 to December 2004. Ekaswa B contains patent applications notified for
opposition in India from January 1995 to December 2004. Ekaswa C has access to patent
applications published in Official Journal of Patent Office published from January 2005 to
June 2007. This database is managed by Technology Information, Forecasting and
Assessment Council (TIFAC)
INPAT(Indian Patent Database)– It is a bibliographic database which provides information
on 52,624 patents granted in India during the period spanning between 1975-2002. The
database delivers information on patent title, applicant(s) name(s), inventor(s) name(s),
patent number, application number, application date, publication date, IPC code, etc.
Searching a Patent Database The awareness on how to search a patent database is
essential in order to get maximum information on several areas of patent search. There are
different tasks for which patent search are conducted, such as:
(i) Patentability search – This is the first step in patent search in order to check whether
your invention is valid, original and also to check whether there exist inventions
similar to yours. Thus it would be best if we conduct patentability search before the
development of the invention.
(ii) State-of-the-art search – The search is done to get information related to prior
technology in particular fields. The researcher or the inventor will get a better idea
about prior inventions in their new technical field of research. The state of the art
search will help to widen scope or to conduct more effective and strategic research
work.
(iii) Monitoring/legal status search – It helps to monitor the legal status of a granted
patent or patent application.
(iv) Bibliographic search – The search is done to get background information on the work
done in the specified area in chronological order. The search is performed as personal
background search, history search, and chronological search.
(v) Infringement search – An infringement search is done to check whether our patented
product can infringe already existing patents in other countries. It will monitor the
claims of non-terminated patent to check for infringement.
(vi) Validity search – It helps the inventor to monitor the validity of non-terminated
patents. The search will also help to get knowledge on the technological defects in the
patent which can hamper its validity before termination. The validity search requires
the usage of advanced analysis techniques in order to determine the relevance of
patent claims and its originality.
(vii) Patent to product mapping search – This is a comprehensive method to get
information on technology development trends, competitor styles, market
involvement, product growth, and determining the scope and utilization of
information for patent procurement through examination and mapping of data to
enable research and development.
For an effective prior art search in various patent databases, the patentee should have
a basic idea about the terms and techniques related to the invention. This awareness will
ease patent search. The several search criteria’s to retrieve patent information are keywords
or phrases, patent classification Systems i.e., International Patent Classification (IPC),
Coopérative Patent Classification (CPC), etc., date of filling/grant/publication etc., patent
reference or identification numbers (application number, patent number, PCT number) and
names of applicants/ assignees or inventors and invention title.
The detailed patent search will help the applicant/patentee to answers various
questions regarding his invention like what does the invention do? What should be the end
result of the invention? How does it work? etc. The patent databases can be searched
normally using keywords or phrases describing the technology or invention. However,
keyword searching in patent databases is sometimes problematic. When we search using
English keywords in patent databases using foreign languages we won’t get accurate search
result, e.g. If we conduct a keyword search in JPO patent documents about half the total
issued patents are undetectable to keyword searches. Multinational patent databases like
PatentScope and Espacenet cover patents in many languages hence it would be more useful
for keyword searches.
The best way to search in patent database without any error is to perform
classification search. The patent offices worldwide have developed classification systems - a
standard system to identify technology groups to which the innovation belongs. The three
commonly used patent classifications are the U.S. Patent Classification, International Patent
Classification and the European Classification. The Cooperative Patent Classification (CPC)
up-to-date and internationally compatible classification scheme covers the USPTO and EPO
patent documents. These classification systems are based on the international nature of the
patents and hence are independent of languages. Searching patent documents by patent
classification will help to overcome the pitfalls caused by keyword searching.
Searching of patent documents is a step-by-step process; initially the search should
be done in broad and related area followed by fine and more focused searches. Patent
information is obtained through various patent databases and there are patent search
tutorials available in most free online patent databases. To begin with patent search; the
major patent databases i.e. USPTO, WIPO (PatentScope), EPO (Espacenet) and JPO should be
accessed. Similar searches should also be done in different regional and national patent
databases to do a comparative study and get more information related to our invention at
regional level. For value added services such as, patent family based data, manually
corrected bibliographic data, graphical patent family analysis, identification of top assignees,
top classifications, top countries of filing, etc. it would be better to access commercial fee
based databases.