Science of Extruder #2
Science of Extruder #2
MA202
The Art & Science of Extrusion
for Wire & Cable – Part II
Instructor: Dr. Yimsan Gau
1. INTRODUCTION
* OVERVIEW OF WIRE EXTRUSION AND POLYMERS
2. POLYMER PROPERTIES
* SOLID, THERMAL, MELT
3. EXTRUDER COMPONENTS
* SCREW/BARREL, DRIVE
* HEATING/COOLING, INSTRUMENTATION
4. FUNCTION OF EXTRUDER SCREW
* SOLIDS CONVEYING, MELTING, MELT CONVEYING
5. MIXING/MIXING ELEMENTS
6. TYPE OF SCREWS
7. EXTRUSION DIE
8. EXTRUSION STABILITY
9. EXTRUSION OPTIMIZATION
10. CABLE EXTRUSION
11. TROUBLESHOOTING/CASE STUDY
12. NEW TREND IN EXTRUSION TECHNOLOGY
13. REFERENCES
2
YGWCE12
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 WIRE EXTRUSION LINE
Wire & Cable Extrusion
Pay Off Pre Heater Extruder Control Panel Cooling Tanks Test Equipment Capstan/Puller Take Up
•••
POLYETHYLENE
ETHYLENE BUTENE
MONOMER HOMOPOLYMER COPOLYMER
ETHYLENE
H H H H H H H H H H
C=C -- C -- C -- C -- C -- -- C -- C -- C -- C --
H H H H H H -C- H H H
C -- CH3
LINEAR
WEIGHT FRACTION
CRYSTALLINE THERMOPLASTIC BROAD
NARROW
AMORPHOUS CROSSLINKED
BRANCHED MOLECULAR WEIGHT
(THERMOSET)
4
YGWCE12
1. INTRODUCTION
1.2 POLYMERS -- ADDITIVES/FILLERS
Wire & Cable Extrusion
PROCESSING STABILIZERS
ANTIOXIDANTS
UV STABILIZERS
FLAME RETARDANT ADDITIVES
IMPACT MODIFIERS
FILLERS/REINFORCEMENT
FOAMING AGENTS
CROSSLINKING AGENTS
COLORANTS
PROCESSING AIDS
5
YGWCE12
1. INTRODUCTION
1.2 POLYMERS IN WIRE & CABLE: PYRAMID CLASSIFICATION
Wire & Cable Polymers
COPA
SPECIALTIES PA 11/12
POLYMERS PEEK
PA 4/6
INCREASING VOLUME
PI
PERFORMANCE
ELASTOMERS
TEMPERATURE
FP
PET COPE TPU/TPV
PRICE
ENGINEERING PA 66 NITRILE
POLYMERS TPE CSPE
PBT EPDM
PC PA 6 TPO
PS EEA/EVA
ESSENTIAL ABS PP BUTYL
POLYMERS CPE SBC
PVC PE
NR
AMORPHOUS CRYSTALLINE
6
YGWCE12
1. INTRODUCTION
1. 3 EXTRUSION PROCESS -- OVERVIEW
Wire & Cable Extrusion
FEED PREPARATION
MECHANICAL HEATING
ENERGY COOLING
COOLING
POSTFORMING
PRODUCTS
CABLE, PIPE
SHEET, FILM
7
YGWCE12 MOLDING
1. INTRODUCTION
1.4 PARAMETERS AFFECTING EXTRUDER PERFORMANCE
Wire & Cable Extrusion
INPUT OUTPUT
EQUIPMENT
EXTRUDER
SCREW DESIGN DIE DESIGN
LENGTH FLOW CHANNEL
PERFORMANCE
HELIX ANGLE APPROACH ANGLE
CHANNEL DEPTH LAND LENGTH
MIXING SECTION
OPERATING PARAMETERS
BARREL/DIE/SCREW TEMPERATURES
PRODUCTION RATE
SCREW SPEED
HEAD PRESSURE (DIE DESIGN, SCREEN PACK)
POWER USAGE
STABILITY
8
YGWCE12
2. POLYMER PROPERTIES
2.1 SOLID PROPERTIES
Wire & Cable Extrusion
BULK DENSITY
WEIGHT OF MATERIAL IN A CONTAINER DIVIDED BY VOLUME OF CONTAINER --
ASTM D 1895
COEFFICIENT OF FRICTION
RATIO OF SHEAR STRESS TO NORMAL STRESS AT INTERFACE
STATIC AND DYNAMIC COEFFICIENT OF FRICTION
INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL
f
yx
yy
9
YGWCE12
2. POLYMER PROPERTIES
2.2 THERMODYNAMIC PROPERTIES
Wire & Cable Extrusion
THERMAL CONDUCTIVITY
ABILITY TO CONDUCT HEAT, “K” IN [J/ms oC]
.
dT
Q KA
dX
LOW THERMAL CONDUCTIVITY OF POLYMER -- PROBLEM OF
HEATING/COOLING THROUGH CONDUCTION
SPECIFIC HEAT
ENERGY REQUIRED TO RAISE POLYMER TEMP. , Cp IN [kJ/ kgoC]
Q m C (T T )
p f i
10
YGWCE12
2. POLYMER PROPERTIES
2.2 THERMODYNAMIC PROPERTIES
Wire & Cable Extrusion
LATENT HEAT
ENERGY REQUIRED TO MELT POLYMER AT MELTING TEMPERATURE
A FUNCTION OF LEVEL OF CRYSTALLINITY IN POLYMER
MELTING TEMPERATURE, Tm
- MELTING POINT OF CRYSTALLITES
- USUALLY A RANGE DUE TO NON UNIFORMITY OF CRYSTALLITES
- OFTEN TAKEN AS TEMPERATURE AT PEAK OF DSC CURVES
PROCESSING TEMPERATURES
- CRYSTALLINE/SEMI CRYSTALLINE POLYMERS: 60 TO 100oC OVER Tm
- ARMORPHOUS POLYMERS: 60 to 100oC OVER Tg
11
YGWCE12
2. POLYMER PROPERTIES
2.3 PROPERTIES OF A NUMBER OF POLYMERS(4)
Wire & Cable Extrusion
12
YGWCE12
2. POLYMER PROPERTIES
2.3 SOLID AND THERMODYNAMIC PROPERTIES
Wire & Cable Extrusion
EQUIPMENT
6” - 24 L/D EXTRUDER, BARRIER SCREW WITH MIXING HEAD
NO ELECTRICAL/MECHANICAL PROBLEMS
REVIEW
MATERIALS
SWITCH FROM ONE GRADE OF PVC JACKETING COMPOUND TO AN
EQUIVALENT GRADE
PROBLEM
ERRATIC OUTPUT, HEAD PRESSURE AND AMPS ON THE EQUIVALENT
GRADE OF PVC
QUESTIONS
ACTIONS TO DEFINE THE CAUSES OF THE PROBLEM?
RECOMMENDATIONS TO CORRECT THIS PROBLEM?
13
YGWCE12
2. POLYMER PROPERTIES
2.4 MELT FLOW PROPERTIES
Wire & Cable Extrusion
CAPILLARY RHEOMETER
APPARENT VISCOSITY
CW FP DC3
WALL SHEAR STRESS a
aw 2DP4VP
F D P D
CW P C2 C C
LC DP 4 LC 15
YGWCE12
2. POLYMER PROPERTIES
2.4 MELT FLOW PROPERTIES
Wire & Cable Extrusion
MELT INDEXER
A SIMPLE CAPILLARY RHEOMETER
WEIGHT = 2 .16 (I2), 5 (I5), 21.6 kg (I21)
SHORTER CAPILLARY LENGTH, Lc/Dc OF 4 vs. 20 TO 30 FOR A RHEOMETER
A MEASURE OF FLOW RATE, g/10 min.
TESTED TEMPERATURES: PE @ 190 C, PP @ 230C
APPARENT VISCOSITY
CW DC4 P
a
aw 128QLC
16
YGWCE12
2. POLYMER PROPERTIES
2.4 MELT FLOW PROPERTIES
Wire & Cable Extrusion
LINEAR POLYMER
BRANCHED POLYMER
17
YGWCE12
2. POLYMER PROPERTIES
2.4 MELT FLOW PROPERTIES
Wire & Cable Extrusion
QUESTION
WHICH IS THE POLYMER THAT IS EASIER TO PROCESS?
18
YGWCE12
3. EXTRUDER COMPONENTS
3.1 SCREW NOMENCLATURE
Wire & Cable Extrusion
19
YGWCE12
3. EXTRUDER COMPONENTS
3.2 EXTRUDER DRIVE
Wire & Cable Extrusion
MOTOR
GENERALLY A VARIABLE SPEED DC MOTOR COUPLED TO A GEAR REDUCER
OTHER TYPES OF MOTOR USED: AC, HYDRAULIC DRIVE
IMPORTANT CHARACTERISTIC: CONSTANT TORQUE
THRUST/RADIAL BEARING
COUNTERACT AXIAL/RADIAL P max
FORCES DURING OPERATION
N max
SCREW SPEED
20
YGWCE12
3. EXTRUDER COMPONENTS
3.3 HEATING AND COOLING
Wire & Cable Extrusion
HEATING/COOLING REQUIREMENTS
21
YGWCE12
3. EXTRUDER COMPONENTS
3.4 INSTRUMENTATION
Wire & Cable Extrusion
RECOMMENDED INSTRUMENTATION
HEAD PRESSURE GAUGE
MELT TEMPERATURE THERMOCOUPLE
TACHOMETER
MOTOR AMPS, VOLTS (POWER)
ZONE TEMPERATURE OF BARREL AND DIE
AMPS ON HEATING ZONES
22
YGWCE12
3. EXTRUDER COMPONENTS
23
YGWCE12
4. FUNCTION OF EXTRUDER SCREWS
4.1 SOLID CONVEYING
Wire & Cable Extrusion
FLOOD FEEDING
PROPER DESIGN OF HOPPER DISCHARGE ANGLE AND OPENING
24
YGWCE12
4. FUNCTION OF EXTRUDER SCREW
4.1 SOLID CONVEYING
Wire & Cable Extrusion
25
YGWCE12
4. FUNCTION OF EXTRUDER SCREW
4.1 SOLID CONVEYING
Wire & Cable Extrusion
CONTAMINANTS IN GROOVE
LOW COMPRESSION RATIO SCREW PRESSURE
SMOOTH FEED
DIE
26
YGWCE12
FEED SECTION
4. FUNCTION OF EXTRUDER SCREW
4.2 MELTING
Wire & Cable Extrusion
SOURCES OF HEATING
VISCOUS HEATING THROUGH SCREW
HEAT CONDUCTION TO SOLID BED
27
YGWCE12
4. FUNCTION OF EXTRUDER SCREW
4.2 MELTING
Wire & Cable Extrusion
SEQUENCE OF CALCULATIONS
28
YGWCE12
4. FUNCTION OF EXTRUDER SCREW
4.2 MELTING
Wire & Cable Extrusion
29
YGWCE12
4. FUNCTION OF EXTRUDER SCREW
4.3 MELT CONVEYING
Wire & Cable Extrusion
SEQUENCE OF CALCULATIONS
EFFECT OF CLEARANCE
30
YGWCE12
4. FUNCTION OF EXTRUDER SCREW
4.3 MELT CONVEYING
Wire & Cable Extrusion
NEWTONIAN EQUATIONS
VOLUMETRIC DRAG FLOW RATE INDEPENDENT OF ANY FLUID PROPERTIES
VBZ D N cos
W ( S E ) cos
1 dZ dL / sin
QD VBZ W H D SCREW DIAMETER
2
N SCREW SPEED
1 dP
QP W H3 HELIX ANGLE
12 dZ S PITCH
QNET QD QP E FLIGHT WIDTH
dL AXIAL DISTANCE
YGWCE12
H CHANNEL DEPTH 31
4. FUNCTION OF EXTRUDER SCREWS
QUESTION
DO YOU AGREE? WHY OR WHY NOT?
32
YGWCE12
5. MIXING/MIXING ELEMENTS
33
YGWCE12
5. MIXING/MIXING ELEMENTS
TYPES OF MIXING
DISPERSIVE
DISTRIBUTIVE
DISPERSIVE DISTRIBUTIVE
WELL MIXED
34
YGWCE12
5. MIXING/MIXING ELEMENTS
5.2 DISTRIBUTIVE MIXING
Wire & Cable Extrusion
35
YGWCE12
5. MIXING/MIXING ELEMENTS
5.3 STATIC MIXERS
Wire & Cable Extrusion
36
YGWCE12
5. MIXING/MIXING ELEMENTS
5.1 DISPERSIVE MIXING
Wire & Cable Extrusion
37
YGWCE12
5. MIXING/MIXING ELEMENTS
QUESTION
THE SCREW MANUFACTURER ASKS FOR YOUR RECOMMENDATION ON
THE LOCATION OF THE MADDOCK HEAD AND THE SET OF PIN
38
YGWCE12
6. TYPE OF SCREWS
THREE SECTIONS
FEED
TRANSITION
METERING
39
YGWCE12
6. TYPE OF SCREWS
6.1 METERING SCREWS
Wire & Cable Extrusion
40
YGWCE12
6. TYPE OF SCREWS
6.1 METERING SCREWS
Wire & Cable Extrusion
41
YGWCE12
6. TYPE OF SCREWS
6.1 METERING SCREWS
Wire & Cable Extrusion
BARRIER TYPE SCREWS
42
YGWCE12
6. TYPE OF SCREWS
6.3 RATING OF SCREWS
Wire & Cable Extrusion
SELECTION CRITERIA
COST
PERFORMANCE
43
YGWCE12
6. TYPE OF SCREWS
6.3 RATING OF SCREWS
Wire & Cable Extrusion
1 1/2 40 24 50 - 60 23 - 27
2 50 24 90 - 120 42 - 54
2 1/2 60 24 150 - 250 68 - 113
3 1/2 90 24 300 - 400 136 - 181
3 1/2 90 30 350 - 450 159 - 204
4 1/2 120 24 700 - 1000 317 - 453
6 150 24 1200 - 1600 564 - 725
44
YGWCE12
6. TYPE OF SCREWS
QUESTION
45
YGWCE12
7. EXTRUSION DIE
BREAKER PLATE
MINIMIZE ROTATING MOTION
SUPPORT SCREEN PACK
Breaker Plate
PROVIDE SEAL
Conductor Die
SCREEN PACK
REMOVE IMPURITIES
IMPROVE MIXING
INCREASE BACK PRESSURE
IMPORTANCE OF SCREEN STACKING
46
YGWCE12
BREAKER PLATE
47
YGWCE12
BREAKER PLATE
48
YGWCE12
7. EXTRUSION DIE
Die
Die
QUESTION
50
YGWCE12
8. EXTRUSION STABILITY
51
YGWCE12
8. EXTRUSION STABILITY
MELT TEMPERATURE
DIFFICULT TO MEASURE
DEPTH OF THERMOCOUPLE INTO MELT STREAM > 1/8”
NOT CONSTANT: HAS SOME VARIATIONS
PEAK TO PEAK VARIATIONS: A MEASURE OF MELT HOMOGENEITY
MELT PRESSURE
NOT CONSTANT -- HAS SOME VARIATIONS
PEAK TO PEAK VARIATIONS -- A MEASURE OF EXTRUSION STABILITY
52
YGWCE12
8. EXTRUSION STABILITY
53
YGWCE12
8. EXTRUSION STABILITY
QUESTION
54
YGWCE12
9. EXTRUSION OPTIMIZATION
EQUIPMENT
SCREW DESIGN (L/D, CHANNEL DEPTH, PITCH OF DIFFERENT SECTIONS)
DIE DESIGN
55
YGWCE12
9. EXTRUSION OPTIMIZATION
4
SPECIFIC ENERGY INPUT
3 COOLING
100%
2
80%
BARREL VISCOUS
HEATING HEATING
1
0%
SCREW SPEED
57
YGWCE12
9. EXTRUSION OPTIMIZATION
RATE
RATE/RPM ~ CONSTANT
KEY PROCESS CURVES
RPM
MAX AMPS
AMPS
RPM
MELT TEMP
CURVES DEPEND ON
BARREL TEMPS
RPM 58
YGWCE12
9. EXTRUSION OPTIMIZATION
RATE
SHALLOW SCREW MORE VISCOUS
PRESSURE
PRESSURE OPERATING POINT 59
YGWCE12
9. EXTRUSION OPTIMIZATION
300
RPM kg/hr
20 90
250
40 170
60 240
REVIEW
200
80 280
Output, kg/hr
150 OUTPUT, kg/HR
QUESTION 100
COMMENTS ON SCREW
PERFORMANCE? 50
0
0 20 40 60 80 100
RPM
60
YGWCE12
10. CABLE EXTRUSION
10.1 WIRE & CABLE SEGMENTS
Wire & Cable Extrusion
TELECOM
SOLID INSULATION
FOAM, FOAM/SKIN INSULATION
CHEMICAL FOAMING
PHYSICAL FOAMING
JACKET
SLOTTED CORE/BUFFER TUBE
POWER
SOLID INSULATION
CV (CONTINUOUS VULCANIZABLE) PROCESS
JACKET
FLAME RETARDANT
SOLID INSULATION
CV PROCESS
JACKET
61
YGWCE12
10. CABLE EXTRUSION
10. 2 CRITICAL PARAMETERS
EXTRUDATE QUALITY
MATERIAL
MELT HOMOGENEITY
EXTRUSION STABILITY (CABLE DIMENSIONS)
DIE DROOL/MELT FRACTURE
SURFACE SMOOTHNESS/GLOSS
ELECTRICAL PROPERTIES
MATERIAL
PROCESS STABILITY 62
YGWCE12
10. CABLE EXTRUSION
10.3 PRODUCTION - PE SOLID/CELLULAR INSULATION
Wire & Cable Extrusion
FOAMED EXTRUSION
% Expansion (1/Capacitance)
Solid Extruder
Homogenization
Gas
Injection Melt
Homogenization
Nucleation
Final
Dimensional
Control
Triple head
Cooling Section
Cooling Length: 60 to 150 m
Take-up Reel
66
YGWCE12 Cable
10. CABLE EXTRUSION
10.3 PRODUCTION – ZERO HALOGEN FLAME RETARDANTS
Wire & Cable Extrusion
TIPS
DRYING OF COMPOUNDS ARE CRITICAL DUE TO HIGH FILLER LOADINGS
67
YGWCE12
10.CABLE EXTRUSION
10.4 PRODUCTION – PVC/PE JACKETING
Wire & Cable Extrusion
CORE
TUBE
CORE
68
YGWCE12
10 CABLE EXTRUSION
10.4 COOLING
Wire & Cable Extrusion
GRADIENT COOLING
LONG AIR GAP AND/OR
FIRST WATER THROUGH OF 6-8 m FILLED WITH WARM WATER, 60 – 70°C
69
YGWCE12
10 CABLE EXTRUSION
10.4 EXAMPLE OF COOLING CALCULATIONS
Wire & Cable Extrusion
Simplified Model
• Cable insulation/jacket as a thick slab with
100
width equal to 2 times the wall thickness
• Calculate heat transfer coefficient from Nu
80 nb of turbulent flow over a flat plate:
Nu=hLw/kP=0.036*Prw^0.33*Re^0.8
• Calculate Biot nb= hLP/kP
Temperature, C
60
• Select ratio temp=(Tinner –Tw)/(TPini-Tw)
• Go to Heisler chart for slab
40
• Read Froude nb=aP t/LP^2
• Calculate t to reach temperature
• Calculate Cooling Length=t*line speed
20
h=heat transfer coefficient - k=thermal conductivity - LP= Wall Thickness
Lw= Cooling Length - Nu=Nusselt nb – Pr= Prandtl nb - RerP*V* Lw/w -
t=time
0 a= thermal diffusivity – r = density - Subscript P= PE or PVC, w=water
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Cooling Length, m
Example of cooling profile for:
PE Inner Temp PE Outer Temp LP =30 mils wall of polyethylene
PVC Inner Temp PVC Outer Temp V =400 ft/min (2m/s) line speed
TPini =392oF (200oC) PE, 338oF (170oC) PVC
Tw =86oF (30oC) 70
YGWCE12
10. CABLE EXTRUSION
QUESTIONS
ADDITIONAL INFO TO DEFINE AND ADDRESS PROBLEMS?
RECOMMENDATIONS TO RESOLVE PROBLEMS?
71
YGWCE12
11. TROUBLESHOOTING
Wire & Cable Extrusion
TIPS
NO SUBSTITUTE FOR EXPERIENCE
MURPHY’S LAW WILL APPLY -- IF IT CAN HAPPEN IT PROBABLY WILL
ALL PARAMETERS ARE IMPORTANT. DON’T OVERLOOK THE TRIVIAL
AS LINE SPEEDS INCREASE, SO WILL PROBLEMS 72
YGWCE12
11. TROUBLESHOOTING
73
YGWCE12
11. TROUBLESHOOTING
LED TO
POOR SURFACE APPEARANCE -- SHARK SKIN
SEVERE DEFORMATION OF EXTRUDATE
CONTROLLED BY
STREAMLINING FLOW CHANNEL
ENLARGING EXIT FLOW CHANNEL
CHANGING DIE MATERIAL OF CONSTRUCTION
INCREASING TEMPERATURE OF DIE
INCREASING MELT TEMP/REDUCING THE MELT VISCOSITY
REDUCING FLOW RATE/LINE SPEED
USING AN EXTERNAL LUBRICANT
74
YGWCE12
11. TROUBLESHOOTING
MELT VISCOSITY
SHEAR RATE/SHEAR STRESS IN EXIT FLOW CHANNEL
SMOOTHNESS AND MATERIAL OF CONSTRUCTION OF DIE
DEGREE OF MIXING
MINIMIZED BY:
LOW PRESSURE DIE
STREAMLINED FLOW IN DIE
USE OF DIE COATING (SMOOTHNESS)
HIGH MELT/DIE TEMPERATURE
LOW LINE SPEED
PROCESSING AID
75
YGWCE12
11. TROUBLESHOOTING
76
YGWCE12
11. TROUBLESHOOTING
Wire & Cable Extrusion
78
YGWCE12
11. TROUBLESHOOTING -- COMMON PROBLEMS
EQUIPMENT
2 1/2” -- 24 L/D EXTRUDER
CONVENTIONAL METERING SCREW WITHOUT MIXING HEAD
NO MECHANICAL OR ELECTRICAL PROBLEMS
REVIEW
MATERIALS
SWITCH FROM PVC TO PP
PROBLEMS
PROCESSING OF PVC WITHOUT PROBLEM
SEVERE SURGING REPORTED WITH PP
QUESTIONS
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION TO RESOLVE THE PROBLEM?
RECOMMENDATIONS TO ADDRESS THIS PROBLEM?
80
YGWCE12
12. NEW TREND IN EXTRUSION TECHNOLOGY
EXTRUSION
- GOOD MATCHING OF L/D TO COMPOUNDS
- LARGER MOTOR
- BETTER TEMPERATURE CONTROL
- BETTER INSTRUMENTATION
- WIDE CHOICE OF SCREWS/MIXING HEADS/DIES
WIRE LINES
- HIGHER LINE SPEEDS
- MORE AUTOMATED/LESS HANDS ON
- SOPHISTICATED SET UP TO PRODUCE COMPLEX CABLE DESIGNS
81
YGWCE12
12. REFERENCES
2. S. LEVY, “PLASTICS EXTRUSION TECHNOLOGY HANDBOOK,” INDUSTRIAL PRESS INC.., N.Y., 2nd EDITION, 1989.
3. M.J. STEVENS, “EXTRUDER PRINCIPLES AND OPERATIONS,” ELSEVIER APPLIED SCIENCE PUB., N.Y., 1985.
5. Z. TADMOR AND I. KLEIN, “ENGINEERING PRINCIPLES OF PLASTICATING EXTRUSION” R.E. KRIEGER PUB., N.Y.,
1978.
6. W. MICHAELI, “EXTRUSION DIES FOR PLASTICS AND RUBBER,” HANSER PUB., N.Y., 2 nd EDITION, 1992.
7. N.S. RAO, “DESIGNING MACHINES AND DIES FOR POLYMER PROCESSING WITH COMPUTER PROGRAMS,” HANSER
PUB., N.Y., 1981
8. R. BARTNIKAS, K.D., STIVASTAVA, EDITORS, “POWER AND COMMUNICATION CABLES THEORIES AND
APPLICATIONS” MC GRAW-HILL 2006
9. I.K. GILLETT, M.M. SUBA, EDITORS “ELECTRICAL WIRE HANDBOOK” THE WIRE ASSOCIATION INTERNATIONAL,
1983