CH 1
CH 1
Introduction:
1
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
Current transformers:
Construction :
CTs are usually designed, so that the primary winding is the
line conductor, which passes through ring core which carries the
secondary winding. Most of the CTs are of this type and are known as
bar-primary or ring wound CTs. The high voltage C.Ts with the above
formation will be of live tank and instead some C.Ts are designed with
bell formation of primary winding which will have graded
insulation .The bell type C.Ts are the conventional ones in most
applications.
Design :
CTs conform to normal transformer e.m.f equation where the
average induced voltage is proportional to the product of the rate of
change of flux and the number of turns. The normal criterion for the
design of CT is to limit the flux to a value where the core saturation
starts, known as knee-point flux. The current that produces this
saturation flux is the maximum magnetizing current. The magnetizing
current and consequently the flux changes from zero to maximum per ¼
cycle and there fore the rate of change of flux is
f-0
¾¾¾ = 4f webers/cycle
¼
or at a frequency of f cycles
4ff webers/sec
giving an average induced voltage of
Vav = 4ffN where N is the number of turns
2
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
3
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
To protect instruments and meters from high fault currents the metering
cores must be saturated 10-40 times the rated current depending upon
the type of burden. At lower burdens the saturation value increases. To
fill the accuracy class and to secure saturation for a lower current then
instrument/meter thermal capability the rated burden of the core must be
relatively well matched to the burden connected.
4
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
1. A fault at voltage maximum , the fault current will be pure sin wave
and to transform the fault current without saturation the ALF must
be more than the ratio of the instantaneous value of the fault current
and the rated current.
2. A fault at the zero voltage the short circuit current will have full
symmetry with a maximum DC component
The DC component will build up a DC flux in the core and an
interposed AC flux. The flux will increase and decrease according to the
time constants. The rise is dependent of the network time constants
(L/R) and the decay follows the current transformers secondary time
constant(Ratio of inductance of CT secondary winding/resistance of the
secondary winding)
Rated burden:
The rated burden is the maximum load impedance, expressed as rated
power, with which the current transformer can be loaded bearing in
mind the specified accuracy limit factor.
The maximum load impedance is calculated as follows:
Zmax = Sn/I²n where Sn = rated burden In = Rated secondary current
of the CT.
P1 S1
S2
S3
P2 S4
5
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
Operation :
The equivalent circuit of a ring type CT is shown in fig 1.1. Ie
is the magnetizing current Rct is secondary winding resistance and R b &
Xb are burden resistance and reactance. In a CT the primary AT must
equal to the secondary AT and the magnetizing AT
N1I1 = N2( I2 + Ie)
In practice Ie is small compared to I2 and is therefore ignored in
all CT calculations with exception of those concerned with ratio and
phase angle error.
fig 1.1
6
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
fig 1.2
The vector diagram of the CT is shown in the fig1.2. The
difference between the I1 and I2 is the ratio error and q is the phase angle
error.
The magnetizing current Ie lags V2 by 90°. It can be seen that if
the burden was wholly resistance then the ratio error would be
minimum. Whereas if the burden was wholly reactive then the ratio
error would be maximum and the phase angle error minimum.
fig 1.3
The magnetizing characteristic of a CT is shown in fig1.3.
Since Ie small compared to the secondary current up to the knee-point of
7
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
the magnetizing characteristic, the ratio and phase angle error will be
small in this region. This means the primary / secondary current
relationship will be maintained in this region.
i.e. the product I2 ( Rct + Rb + jXb ) is Vk
e.g. Rct = 1W, Rb + jXb = 7 + j0 W, and Vk = 150V
then linearity is repeated up to a secondary current of
V2 150
I2 = ¾¾¾¾¾¾¾ = ¾¾¾ = 18.75 A
Ö( Rct + Rb + jXb ) 1+7
If linearity is to maintain up to 20 times CT rating the total impedance
should not exceed
150
( Rct + Rb + jXb ) = ¾¾ = 7.5W
20
8
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
9
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
reduced. The reduction for over current relays is about half the
impedance at setting, which means that in the above case the knee-point
voltage of 60V would be satisfactory.
In many cases the CT associated with over current protection
must cater to earth fault relays also. If the earth fault relay having a
minimum setting of 20%,
the voltage at relay setting = 3VA /0.2A = 15V and
impedance = 15V / 0.2A = 75W
If the characteristic of the relay is to be maintained up to 10 times the
relay, the knee-point voltage should be greater than 10´15 = 150V or
allowing saturation 75V.
In this case the size is determined by earth fault relay. A
suitable CT would be 7.5VA, 5P10. This would produce a voltage of
7.5V at rated current when connected to 7.5 ohm burden and would have
only 5% error at 10 times rated current. i.e.at a voltage of 10´7.5= 75V.
As rough guide the knee-point voltage is the product of the VA
rating and the ALF divided by the rated secondary current. So for as
7.5VA, class 5P10, 5A CT
7.5 ´ 10
the knee-point voltage Vk = ¾¾¾¾ = 15V
5
If more than one relay is to be connected to one set of CTs the
total burden must be considered. It is usually sufficiently accurate to add
series burden impedance arithmetically.
Effect magnetizing current on relay setting :
The overall setting of the protection system is affected by the
magnetizing current of the CTs. The effect may not be significant in
over current relays, whereas in earth fault relays it will have some effect
on the overall setting. In differential protection system the effect of
magnetizing current is considerable where a large number of
transformers are connected together. For example, a bus-bar protection
scheme.
The primary operating current (POC) of a protective system is
the sum of the relay setting current and the magnetizing current of all
the connected CTs at the voltage across the relay at setting multiplied by
the CT ratio.
10
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
Illustration 1:
A 2000/5 bar primary CT has 20 cm2 of iron and a secondary
winding resistance of 0.32 ohm. The maximum current for which the CT
has to operate is 40 KA, 50Hz. The relay burden 2ohm.
Given Bmax for stally 1.0 tesla
Bmax for cross 1.48 tesla
Determine the suitable core material without saturation.
40,000
Secondary current = ¾¾¾ = 100A
400
Assuming no saturation
Vk = 100 ( 2 + 0.32 ) = 232 volts
Vk = 4.44BAf N
232
B = ¾¾¾¾¾¾¾¾¾¾¾
4.44´1´20´10-4´50´400
= 1.36 tesla
Bmax for cross is 1.48 tesla. So more suitable core material
without saturation is CROSS.
Illustration 2 :
A 100/5 bar primary CT supplies to a 3VA over current relay
set at 10% with a stalloy core. The maximum dimension of the CT
housing on the circuit breaker are 22 cm dia and 19cm deep. It is
required to cater for a current of 10 times the relay setting.
Find 1) Knee-point voltage
2) Cross sectional area of the core
3) CT dimension.
11
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
A = ¾¾¾¾¾¾¾ = 0.0135 m2
4.44´1.0´50´20
i.e. 0.0135´104 = 135 cm2
So the core dimension may be 11.25cm ´ 12cm.
Illustration 3 :
Three 100/5 bar primary CT with secondary resistance of
0.08W are connected to cater to three phase fault protection set to125%
and earth fault relays set to 40%. The relay burden at setting is 3VA for
phase fault relays and 2.4 VA for earth fault relays. What is the
maximum primary current to operate (POC) both phase and earth fault
relays?
3 3
O/C Relay impedance = ¾¾¾¾ = ¾¾¾ = 0.077W
(5´1.25)2 6.252
2.4 2.4
E/F Relay impedance = ¾¾¾¾ = ¾¾¾ = 0.4W
2
(5´0.4) 22
Phase fault relay setting :
Total impedance = Rct + Rrelay
= 0.08 + 0.077 = 0.157W
Volts from CT = 0.157 ´ 6.25 = 0.98 volts.
Assuming the magnetizing current from the magnetizing characteristic
curve at 0.98 volts is 0.25Amps.
Primary current = N( Is + Imag)
= 20 ( 6.25 + 0.25) = 130 Amps.
Earth fault relays setting :
Voltage across the earth fault relay = 2 ´0.6 = 1.2 Volts
Assuming the magnetizing current from the magnetizing characteristic
curve at 1.28 volts is 0.3Amps.
Now the energized CT must supply exciting current to the other two
CTs.
Current through Rph relay +
exciting current to Yph & Bph = 2 + 0.3 + 0.3 = 2.6Amps.
Volts from CT = 2.6 ( 0.077 + 0.08 ) + 1.2
= 1.608 volts
Assuming the magnetizing current from the magnetizing characteristic
curve at 1.608 volts is 0.41Amps.
Total secondary current = 0.41 + 2.6 = 3.01Amps.
12
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
100
Primary fault current = ¾¾ ´ 3.01 = 60.2 Amps.
5
fig 1.4
Illustration 4 :
An earthed 132 KV transformer is protected by REF protection
using four CTs and an earth fault relay with stabilizing resistor set at
40%. The system fault level is 3000MVA and loop lead impedance from
CT to relay is 2 ohms. The ratio of the CT is 500/1A and Rct is 0.7
ohms. Find the primary fault setting and the minimum stabilizing
resistor value. Assume relay burden at 1VA.
3500
E/F current = ¾¾¾¾ = 15.3KA
Ö3 ´ 132
15300
CT sec. Current = ¾¾¾ = 30.6A
500
Relay voltage setting = 30.6 (0.7 + 2) = 82.6 volts.
Assuming the magnetizing current from the magnetizing characteristic
curve at 82.6 volts is 0.0246Amps.
Primary fault setting = 500{ (4´0.0246) + 0.4 }
= 250 Amps.
Stabilizing resister = ( Vk / Is ) - (VA / Is2 )
82.6 1
= ¾¾ - ¾¾
0.4 0.42
13
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
= 250.25W
Selection of CT cores:
14
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
Voltage transformers :
Voltage transformers can be of two types, magnetic voltage transformers
(VT) and capacitive voltage transformers (CVT) The magnetic voltage
transformers are most economical for voltages up to about 145kV and
the capacitive voltage there above.
The voltage transformer for use with protection schemes has to
fulfill only one condition, which is the secondary output voltage of the
voltage transformer must be an accurate representation of the primary
voltage in both magnitude and phase angle. To meet this requirement
voltage transformers are designed to operate at very low flux densities.
Magnetizing current at low flux densities will be very low, and therefore
the ratio and phase angle errors are also will be small. To achieve this
the core area for a given output is larger than that of power transformer,
which increases the over all sizes of the voltage transformer. In addition
a five limbed construction is used instead of three one in power
transformers in order to reduce the magnetic interference between
phases. The condition of magnetic interference doesn’t arise when three
single phase units are used as is common in EHV system, since each
phase unit will have a core with a closed magnetic circuit.
Accuracy :
Ratio error : The error in the secondary voltage due to incorrect ratio is
commonly known as the ratio error and is expressed as a percentage as
follows:
(KnVs - Vp)
¾¾¾¾¾¾ ´100%
Vp
where Kn is the nominal ratio (rated
primary/secondary
voltage
Vs is the actual secondary terminal voltage
15
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
Table 1
Accuracy 0.8 to 1.2 times rated voltage
class 0.25 to1.0 times rated burden at 0.8pf
Ratio error (%) Phase difference
(minutes)
0.1 ± 0.1 ± 5
0.2 ± 0.2 ± 10
0.5 ± 0.5 ± 20
1.0 ± 1.0 ± 40
3.0 ± 3.0 ---
Limits of error for measuring voltage transformer.
Table 2
Accuracy 0.5to Vf (voltage factor) times rated voltage
class 0.25 to1.0 times rated burden at 0.8pf
Ratio error (%) Phase difference
(minutes)
3P ± 3 ± 120
5P ± 6 ± 240
Limits of error for protective voltage transformer.
Voltage factor :
the voltage factor Vf is the upper limit of operating voltage,
expressed in per unit of rated voltage. Earth faults cause a displacement
16
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
Table 3
Voltage Ratin Method of primary connection and
factor Vf g System earthing
1.2 contin Between lines in any network
uous Between transformer star-point and earth in
any network.
1.2 contin Between line and earth in an effectively
uous earthed neutral system.
1.5 30s -do-
1.2 contin Between line and earth in an non effectively
uous earthed neutral system with automatic earth
fault tripping.
1.9 30s -do-
1.2 contin Between line and earth in an isolated neutral
uous system without automatic E/F tripping or in
an resonant earthed system without
automatic E/F tripping.
1.9 8 hrs -do-
17
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
18
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
fig 1.5
that phase, then the difference between the normal voltage and that
voltage is delivered to the relay.
It necessary for the primary winding neutral of the voltage
transformer to be earthed for the zero sequence exciting current to flow.
If the primary winding is not earthed, an broken-delta winding may
develop a voltage. This broken-delta voltage so developed is not related
to any residual in the primary system, but entirely third harmonic.
Voltage transformers are usually provided with a normal star connected
secondary winding and a broken-delta connected tertiary winding.
Alternatively the residual voltage can be obtained by using a
star/broken-delta connected auxiliary Voltage transformer connected
from the secondary of the main voltage transformer. For this condition
to be successful, the main voltage transformer must fulfill the
requirements for handling zero sequence voltage i.e. it must be of five
limbed construction, have an earthed primary neutral and rated for
suitable voltage factor. The star point of the main voltage transformer
secondary winding and the auxiliary voltage transformer primary
winding must be interconnected to complete the zero sequence circuit.
19
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
Ferro resonance:
Ferro resonance can occur in circuits containing a capacitor and a
reactor incorporating an iron core (a non linear inductance). Both the
CVT and a magnetic VT can be involved in Ferro-resonance
phenomenon.
Ferro resonance in magnetic VT is an oscillation between the inductance
of the VT and the capacitance of the network. Ferro resonance can only
occur at ungrounded networks, but note the risk that some part becomes
ungrounded under certain circumstances. An oscillation is normally
triggered by a sudden change in the network voltage. Ferro resonance
phenomenon can occur both with sub – harmonic frequencies or with
harmonic frequencies.
Generally it is difficult to state when a risk of ferro resonance occurs but
as soon as a system with a voltage transformer is left ungrounded,
preventive actions should be taken (also consider the risk of capacitive
charged systems with a VT) . The damping of ferro-resonance is
normally done with a 27-60W 200watts resistor connected across the
open delta winding.
The CVT with its capacitor and IVT is by itself a ferro resonance circuit.
The phenomenon is started by a sudden voltage change. A sub hormanic
oscillation can be started and must be damped to prevent damage of the
transformer. The IEC standard specifies that CVT;s must be provided
with ferro-resonance damping devices which is normally a saturating
reactor and a resistor in each phase.
20
INSTRUMENT TRANSFORMER FOR PROTECTION
21