【Compiled】Technical Guideline
【Compiled】Technical Guideline
December 2014
FUTABA INC.
CONTENTS
Page
1 Introduction................................................................................... 1-1
i
4.3.3 Transmission of Warning and Evacuation ..............................................4-21
4.3.4 Landslide Warning without Instruments ..................................................4-22
ii
LIST OF FIGURES
Page
iii
LIST OF TABLES
Page
iv
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
0 Preface
0.1 Definition of Landslides
The term “Landslide” is defined variously in different literature. For example, United States
Geological Survey (USGS) defines “Landslide” referring to Cruden, 1991, and Varnes 1996
as follows:
A landslide is defined as "the movement of a mass of rock, debris, or earth down a slope"
(Cruden, 1991). Landslides are a type of "mass wasting" which denotes any down slope
movement of soil and rock under the direct influence of gravity. The term "landslide"
encompasses events such as rock falls, topples, slides, spreads, and flows, such as debris
flows commonly referred to as mudflows or mudslides (Varnes, 1996). Landslides can be
initiated by rainfall, earthquakes, volcanic activity, changes in groundwater, disturbance and
change of a slope by man-made construction activities, or any combination of these factors.
- Varnes, D. J., 1996. Landslide Types and Processes, in Turner, A. K., and Schuster,
R. L., Landslides: Investigation and Mitigation, Transportation Research Board
Special Report 247, National Research Council, Washington, D.C.: National
Academy Press.
The classification by Varnes, 1978 through USGS is widely adopted worldwide. Table 0.1.1
presents the updated classification.
0-1
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
0-2
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Generally speaking, a landslide is classified as follows, when you take countermeasures for
each phenomenon.
(1) Landslide
A slope failure is equivalent to “FALLS” of debris and earth material in the Table 0.1.1, but it
does not include “Rock fall”. The slope failure mass detaches from a steep slope/cliff along a
surface with little or no shear displacement. It may be called a “Surface Failure“. Compared
to landslides, the slope failure moves quickly on a small-scale and the inclination angle is
relatively high (over 20 degrees).
A debris flow is equivalent to “FLOWS” of debris and earth material in the Table 0.1.1. A
debris flow is a phenomenon where soil and boulders are liquefied by surface water or
groundwater and tend to flow downward rapidly through a mountain torrent. It usually has
huge energy and destructive force. Debris flows tend to occur in places where there is a
massive amount of unstable sediment along a steep torrent, or a large risk of slope failure due
to heavy rain in the catchment basin.
A rock fall is equivalent to “FALLS” and “TOPPLES” in Table 0.1.1. A rock fall is a
phenomenon where foliated rocks and gravel due to enlarged cracks in the bedrock or
outcropped rocks start to fall down a slope.
In this manual, “a slope disaster” is defined as the four (4) above mentioned types of natural
disasters.
Table 0.2.1 shows type classification of landslides which have slip surfaces and repeated
activity. Landslides are classified into several types by the topographic and geological
characteristics. This classification makes it possible to estimate the cross-section, longitudinal
profiles and depths of landslides. As a result, the estimations are used as significant
information to plan landslide surveys.
0-3
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
0-4
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
A landslide is a phenomenon where the soil mass on one or more slip (failure) surfaces deep
in the ground gradually shifts downward (Figure 0.2.1). As one of the characteristics, the
inclination angle of the landslide slope is a relatively low angle (about 5-20 degrees).
Mechanism and movement direction of landslides are able to be estimated by checking the
following points:
・ Main scarp, tension crack, compression crack, radial crack, lateral crack
0-5
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
0-6
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Groundwater Level
River Faults
Figure 0.2.3 Schematic Cross Section of Basic Factors of Landslides (source: JET)
Inducing factors: In areas prone to the basic factors of landslides, floods during the rainy
season, and other changes to the natural environment (wash out of the slope toe by rivers,
formation or blockage of new waterways at surface and subsurface) are triggers of landslides
(inducing factors).
Artificial cause: such as embankment at the upper landslide mass, cut slope at the toe of a
landslide, slope submersion under water and blockage of surface drainage.
Figure 0.2.4 Schematic Cross Section of Inducing Factor and Artificial Cause (source: JET)
The 37 landslide hazard areas, selected based on the "Cyclone and Other Natural Disasters
Scheme 2011-2012", includes several disaster forms besides landslides. Therefore the 37
hazard areas are classified into nine (9) kinds of disasters, given in Table 0.3.1, while Table
0.3.2 gives a description of nine (9) kinds of disasters.
0-7
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
General classification:At first, the 37 hazard areas selected based on the "Cyclone and
Other Natural Disasters Scheme 2011-2012" are classified into two kinds of disaster, Slope
disasters and Other disasters.
Sub classification:Then, Slope disasters are classified into Landslide, Slope failure, Rock
fall, and Debris flow. Other disasters are classified into Stream erosion, Damage of
embankment, Damage of wall, Damage of house, and Cavern.
Total 37 areas
0-8
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
A slope failure is a mass becoming detached The collapse of the road embankment is
from a steep slope/cliff along surface with little often triggered by rainfall, infiltration of
or no shear displacement. Compared to underground water, erosion by surface water,
landslides, the failure is rapid and on a or a partial catchment. It can be caused by
small-scale, the inclination angle is a weak embankment material or by lack of soil
relatively high (over 30 degrees). compaction. Concentration of
Slope Damage of Surface surface water
Rainfall
failure embankment water
Surface
water
A rock fall is a phenomenon where foliated The disaster of a retaining wall doesn't occur
rocks and gravel start to fall down a slope as a suddenly as with a rock fall etc., rather the
result of enlarged cracks in the bedrock or deformation occurs over a comparatively long
outcropped rocks. time. The survey should investigate:
・ condition around the retaining wall
Damage of ・ main body of the retaining wall
Rock fall ・ history of the retaining wall
wall
A debris flow is a phenomenon where soil A crack that occurs on the wall of a house
and boulders are liquefied by surface water or may be caused by:
groundwater and tend to flow downward ・ Lack of bearing capacity
rapidly through a mountain torrent. ・ Subsidence of foundation ground
・ Shoddy workmanship, etc.
Damage of
Debris flow
house
settling
A cavern may be caused by:
・Infiltration of water from soak away
Ground
・Infiltration of water from improved pit,level
etc.
Soak away
improved pit
Cavern
Cavern
0-9
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
The landslide location map in Mauritius is indicated in Figure 0.3.1 and the characteristics are
compiled in Table 0.3.3.
0-10
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
0-11
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
0-12
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Reference
1
Varnes, D. J., (1978, Slope movement 43. types and processes, in Schuster, R. L., and Krizek, R. J.,
eds., Landslides—Analysis and control: Transportation Research Board Special Report 176,
National Research Council, Washington, D.C., pp. 11-23.
2
Public Works Research Institute, 2004, Manual for Highway Earthworks in Japan Technical
Memorandum of Public Works Research Institute, No.3924-2
3
Fujiwara, A., 1979, Analysis and Prevention Plan of Landslides, Rikoh Pub. Co., Tokyo. (in
Japanese)
0-13
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
1 Introduction
“Technical Guideline for Initial Survey (hereinafter the Guideline)” has been prepared as a
procedure guideline for landslide survey/countermeasures on emergency landslide disasters.
The Guideline is specialized for landslide disasters in Mauritius.
The Guideline covers what actions should be taken in the event of a landslide disaster, and
includes the procedures the Ministry of Public Infrastructure and Land Transport (MPI)
should implement in such an event. The procedures are composed of a literature survey, an
initial site survey, emergency response, a detailed survey plan etc. The detailed
survey/analysis/monitoring and the design/construction after the discussion of the survey plan
are described in “Procedure Manual for Landslide”.
The scope of application of the Guideline is indicated in the following figure and the contents
of it are in the table on the following page.
LANDSLIDE
Technical
Guideline for
Initial Survey
Literature survey
Emergency response
Procedure
Manual for
Survey and analysis Landslide
Consensus building
for local residents
Design of structural
countermeasures
Relocation and
compensation
Construction of
countermeasures
Completion
Figure 1.1.1 The scope of Application of the Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
(source: JET)
1-1
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Table1.1.1 The contents of the Technical Guideline for Initial Survey (source: JET)
The Landslide Management Unit (LMU) of MPI should renew appropriately the contents of
the Guideline to make it more usable and rational based on the case examples and issues in
Mauritius.
1-2
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
2 Literature Survey
In case of an emergency landslide disaster, literature survey is necessary to understand the
rough outline and general information of the landslide before visiting the landslide site. The
literature survey is mainly composed of 1) data collection and 2) confirmation of related laws
and regulations on landslides. In this chapter, the methods and the significance of the
literature survey are elaborated.
The objectives of data collection are to grasp the features and characteristics of the targeted
landslide before visiting the landslide site. The data to be collected are geomorphology,
geology, vegetation, meteorology, hydrology, landslide history and disaster records in the
area. The necessary information on the landslide should be extracted from the collected data.
The following table indicates the data to be collected as a preliminary survey of the landslide.
Interviews of local residents and local municipalities are able to provide useful and practical
information on the landslide disaster as well as the data collection. The following items
should be confirmed in the interview survey:
Landslide prone areas are areas likely to have active landslides and are associated with
2-1
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Micro landforms, historical landslide formations, land use and vegetation are identified with
aerial photograph interpretation. The micro landforms caused by landslide movement are
interpreted using a large scale aerial photograph such as 1:10,000 or larger. Aerial
photograph interpretation is a useful method of finding several causes of landslides over a
wide area. In case that it is impossible to obtain the stereo images of an aerial photograph, a
topographic map can be substituted for the aerial photograph.
Stereoscopic images are obtained from stereo type photographs using a stereoscope. The
micro landforms and the geomorphologic features caused by landslide movement are
identified with the stereo image.
Figure 2.1.2 Aerial Photo Interpretation using a Stereo Scope (source: JET)
Characteristics of the conditions which may cause landslides are shown below:
A topographic map also provides information of the slope conditions which may be related to
landslide movement. Larger scale of topographic map, 1/10,000 or larger, is preferable for
2-2
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
the interpretation with topographic maps. Characteristics of the conditions which may cause
landslides are shown below:
Figure 2.1.4 Comparison of Contour Lines in a Landslide Area (left) and Area with no
Landslides (right) (source: JET)
2-3
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Table 2.1.2 shows the classification of landslides. Landslides are classified into several types
by topographic and geological characteristics. The table classifies the type of landslide based
on topographic and geological features, most of which are able to be identified with aerial
photograph (geomorphological) interpretation.
2-4
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
The schemes of emergency response for cyclones, torrential rain, tsunamis, high waves and
landslides are indicated in National Disaster Scheme (NDS) 2015 in Mauritius.
2-5
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
The chapter on landslides in the scheme contains monitoring, actions by Local Authorities,
response by related ministries/agencies and warning/evacuation system.
The warning/evacuation system has three stages based on monitoring data of rainfall and
displacement.
2.2.2 Confirmation of the proposed Landslide-Prone Areas and Landslide Hazard Zones
• An area which poses a danger to the lives/bodies of the residents and building damage
when a landslide disaster occurs in a Landslide-Prone Area.
2-6
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
• Area within a distance equivalent to the length of the landslide mass from the bottom
end of the landslide area (250 m if the length of the landslide mass is longer than 250 m)
The following figure shows an example of sample image of a Landslide-Prone Area and
Landslide Hazard Zone.
Following figure shows an example of the settlement boundary and a landslide prone area.
According to the Outline Planning Scheme (hereinafter OPS), which covers areas that are
prone to landslides, such areas are designated as developable land upon gaining approval for
development from the Local Authority (see figure below, orange coloured boundary shows
the developable area and black frame shows the landslide prone area).
2-7
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
National Parks should be protected from development except as allowed under the National
Parks and Wildlife Act and are shown on the Development Strategy Map and Development
Management Map in OPS, conservation management plans prepared or being prepared by the
Ministry responsible for Agro-Industry, Food Production and Security and Fisheries’
National Parks and Conservation Service, or for educational purposes, visitor facilities or in
the national interest. Development in National Parks which would destroy or adversely affect
the area’s natural environment should not normally be permitted.
If the landslide site is in a National Park, a landslide countermeasure plan should be prepared
and assessed in conjunction with the Ministry responsible for Agro-Industry and Fisheries,
Ministry responsible for Environment and Ministry responsible for Housing and Lands.
All Nature Reserves designated under the Forests and Reserves Act and shown on the
Development Management Maps in OPS should be protected from development except as
allowed under the said Act, or for educational purposes, visitor facilities or in the national
interest or are being prepared by the Ministry responsible for Agro-Industry and Fisheries’
National Park Conservation Service. Development in protected Nature Reserves which would
destroy or adversely affect the area’s natural environment should not normally be permitted
unless supported by an approved environmental management plan and an Environmental
Impact Assessment in accordance with the EPA (Amendment of Schedule) Regulations.
All River Reserves should normally be protected from development by the Forests and
2-8
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Reserves Act. Exceptions may be made for works deemed essential for water abstraction,
flow regulation, flood control and for road crossings. Clearing and replanting of river
reserves shall only be carried out with authorization from the Conservator of Forests.
If the landslide site is near a river, a landslide countermeasure plan should be prepared and
assessed in conjunction with the Ministry responsible for Agro-Industry and Fisheries,
Ministry responsible for Environment and Ministry responsible for Housing and Lands.
Where the ESAs are indicated on the Development Management Maps in OPS there should
be a general presumption against development other than for educational or environmental
management purposes or in order to sustain local economies or where development is
deemed to be in the national interest and is acceptable on planning and environmental
grounds. In case of discrepancy between the ESAs shown on the Development Management
Maps and the ESA map at the Ministry of Environment, the project proponent should consult
the Ministry of Environment.
If the landslide site is within an ESA, a landslide countermeasure plan will be required to first
obtain an Environmental Impact Assessment license under the Environment Protection Act as
subsequently amended, prior to seeking a building and land use permit.
The existing and proposed dams/reservoirs and their catchment areas and the rivers that
supply water into them should be safeguarded against pollution, erosion and deforestation.
Development within thirty metres of the high water level of the dams and adjacent to rivers,
rivulets and streams, open canals or within the catchment areas should not normally be
permitted, unless the developer has obtained written agreement from the Water Resources
Unit/Ministry of Public Utilities and the Sanitary Authority that the proposals do not pose a
threat to the quality or quantity of surface or groundwater resources. A passage one meter
wide shall be left along one or other side of every canal along its whole length and kept free
from obstruction. No development should be permitted within a two hundred metres radius of
a borehole or spring without consultation and prior written approval of the Water Resources
Unit/Ministry of Public Utilities.
If the landslide site is near a water resource, a landslide countermeasure plan should be
prepared and assessed in conjunction with Water Resources Unit/Ministry of Public Utilities
and the Sanitary Authority.
2-9
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Reference
1
Varnes, D. J., 1978, Slope movement 43. types and processes, in Schuster, R. L., and Krizek, R. J.,
eds., Landslides—Analysis and control: Transportation Research Board Special Report 176,
National Research Council, Washington, D.C., pp. 11-23.
2
JASDM & JCTC, 1995, Japan Association for Slope Disaster Management and Japan Construction
Training Centre. Textbook of landslide prevention technical training.
3
Ministry of Environment, Sustainable Development, and Disaster and Beach management, 2015,
National Disaster Scheme (NDS) 2015 edition
4
JICA Study Team, 2013
5
Ministry of Housing and Lands on behalf of the Town and Country Planning Board, 2006, Outline
Planning Scheme for Grand Port Savanne District Council Area (as subsequently modified in
November 2011)
2-10
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Because a landslide may occur in a large number of areas in the case of cyclones and the
heavy rains of the rain season, it may be necessary to select the target landslide area from a
large number of landslide areas to take precedence for the initial site survey. When there is a
report that multiple landslides have occurred, the target landslide area for the initial site
survey shall be chosen promptly based on the information from the local government and
other organizations concerned. However, if it is not possible to determine the target landslide
area from the information provided, site confirmation by the engineer is necessary.
The flowchart for determining the target landslide area is shown below.
Yes
There is already damage
on a house and the road
No
Yes
House and the road may
be damaged in future
No
On-site confirmation
Yes
An additional survey
is necessary
No
Figure 3.1.1 Flowchart for Determining the Target Landslide Area (source: JET)
3-1
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
During the initial site survey, the following items are investigated. These items are listed in
the order they are usually carried out. However, in an emergency situation, they should be
carried out in parallel.
When a landslide occurs, the first item performed is to confirm the landslide area and
movement direction.
When confirming the landslide area, it is important that the neighbouring landforms and
deformations are investigated as well as the main landslide body. Therefore, the backward
and neighbouring slopes of the landslide body should be investigated carefully. The
viewpoints of the investigation are as follows:
a) Upper end of the main body b) Bottom end of the main body
c) Lateral border of the main body d) Movement direction
e) Crack and other deformations of the backward/neighbouring slope
f) Damage to a house / road / other structure
g) Geological features h) Spring water/surface water
g) Geological feature
d) Movement direction
b) Bottom end of the main body
* It is corrected Varnses, D. J. (1978)
Figure 3.2.1 Viewpoints of the Investigation (source: JET)
3-2
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
In an emergency situation, it is not possible to carry out monitoring by drilling from the
viewpoint of the time and security of the work. Therefore, for emergency monitoring,
measurement of the ground surface displacement of the landslide is effective. The method for
monitoring the landslide earth surface displacement is shown below.
A scalp (cliff) of the landslide head and the cracks are monitored by an extensometer and/or
simplified extensometer. Cracks on buildings and roads are monitored by vernier calipers
and/or a laser distance meter. The results of the monitoring are used to estimate the landslide
cause and the activity, as well as for early warning and evacuation.
type Equipment
Extensometer Measuring the amount of movement, * It is effective for monitoring the upper
recording data continuously part of the landslide where the
deformations are not seen from the
ground surface.
Extensometer
Others Crack monitoring with Vernier Caliper Using a Total-Station, the displacement of
on concrete wall. the landslide is measured from a
distance.
3-3
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
It is very important that the cause of the landslide occurrence is estimated in predicting future
landslide activity. The cause of the landslide occurrence is divided into a basic factor and an
exciting cause (trigger).
The examples in the study of the cause of the landslide are shown below. Because a method
to remove an exciting cause (trigger) is effective for an emergency countermeasure, the
estimate of the exciting cause is extremely important.
Table 3.2.3 Examples in the Study of the Cause of the Landslide (source: JET)
1) The case that landslide mass completely slides down has low activity in future, and the
stability is relatively high.
Original surface
1
Figure 3.2.2 Case 1: Landslide Mass Completely Slides Down
2) As for the case that a distal end of landslide mass rises, the landslide activity often
becomes dormant, because it is estimated that the sliding surface is a horizontal or
reverse incline.
3-4
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
1
Figure 3.2.3 Case 2: Distal End of Landslide Mass Rises
3) The case that the inclination of the downward slope is gentle, the landslide activity often
becomes dormant for a reason same as case 2.
1
Figure 3.2.4 Case 3: Inclination of the Downward Slope is gentle
4) The case that the inclination of the downward slope is steep, the landslide does not stop
easily.
1
Figure 3.2.5 Case 4: Inclination of the Downward Slope is Steep
Generally, because the displacement of the landslide suddenly accelerates just before collapse,
the activity of the future landslide is estimated by monitoring landslide displacement. It is
necessary to be careful about future sudden displacement increase even if there is not the
movement of the landslide at present.
3-5
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Collapse!
Collapse?
Displacement
Displacement
Now
Stillness?
Time Time
a) Case of collapses b) Case before the collapse
When a landslide area spreads, there is the risk that heavy damage will occur. The possibility
of the landslide area expanding should be sufficiently considered in the initial site survey.
If a landslide movement area is identified, the danger zone where a landslide mass will reach
must be estimated. As a result of a study of landslide disasters in Japan1), in 95% of
landslides, the danger zone where the landslide mass reached was less than two times the
length and width of the landslide body. Therefore, the danger zone shown below should be
referred to when an early warning and/or evacuation is considered.
A: Landslide block
B: Zone with a basic factor same as A
C: Danger zone where a landslide mass reaches
A+B: Landslide hazard zone
A+B+C: landslide prone area
L: Length of landslide block
W: Width of landslide block
1
Figure 3.2.7 Landslide Danger Zone
3-6
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Reference
1
Public Works Research Institute, 2007, A guidance and commentary of the prevention technology of
the landslide, Japan
3-7
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
4 Emergency Response
4.1 Structural Countermeasure Work
The aim of the emergency structural countermeasure is to mitigate landslide activity, to
minimise damage by landslide disaster and to release the warning status at an early stage. As
there are cases where premature measure work may foment landslide activity, the type and
layout of the emergency measure shall be decided carefully in consideration of the cause of the
landslide and actual site conditions. Otherwise, the result of the work will have insufficient
effect or even worse conditions. At the very least, before consideration of countermeasure
works, the area and cause of the target landslide shall be recognised.
It is thought that the main causes of landslides in Mauritius are artificial topographical changes
by excavation work or soil filling work and hydraulic environment changes by runoff water or
the rising groundwater level in the rainy season.
In the case of landslides caused by artificial topographical changes, the site shall be
rehabilitated to its original condition as far as possible. If the rehabilitation of site conditions is
difficult or the landslide occurred due to natural causes such as changes in hydraulic conditions,
the following works can be considered as emergency countermeasure work:
The aim of the work is to increase the stability of the landslide block by removing soil at the
head of the landslide. The work is simple earth work and has high workability. However, there
are cases where the landslide itself or another slope behind the landslide might become unstable
depending on the location of the applied work (refer to (i) and (ii) in the figure below).
Therefore, the location of the applied work shall be considered and decided on carefully.
Additionally, debris at the toe of the landslide shall not be removed rashly (refer to (iv) in the
figure below). Otherwise, it will encourage further landslide activity.
It will be difficult to apply the work in residential areas or on private land because the work
will change the environmental conditions at the work site. According to the impact on
environmental conditions at the site, the area of excavation shall be minimal. It is recommended
that the area of excavation be decided based on the results of simple stability analysis to achieve
4-1
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
New landslide?
Potential
Target Landslide slip surface
Excavation line
ce
surfa
Slip
(i) Soil removal work at the head of a landslide will have a good effect on stability itself but it
may also trigger a new landslide behind the target landslide.
ce Excavation line
rfa ce
su rfa
Sl
ip su
ip
Sl
(ii) Excavation work conducted as shown in the (iii) Excavation at the head of the landslide block
above figure will contribute to the instability with an appropriate slope gradient will
of the target landslide due to lack of soil at contribute to the stability of the target
the lower part of the landslide block1 landslide
Target Landslide
su rface
Slip
Excavation line
(iv) Excavation at the toe of a landslide will encourage instability of the target landslide.
Therefore, the excavation shall not be conducted at the toe of a landslide even though
there is a possibility that houses or public facilities are damaged by further landslide
activity.
Figure 4.1.1 Example of Soil Removal Work at the Head and Unstable Part of Target
Landslide (source: JET)
4-2
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
The aim of the work is to increase the load of the lower part of the landslide block and shear
resistance force by installation of filling at the toe of the landslide.
In the case that bulging at the lower part of a landslide block is found, the counter weight work
will be quite an efficient countermeasure against landslide. However, there is a possibility that
the foundation of the embankment will fail if the lower part of the landslide becomes loose due
to disturbance by landslide activity, and also another landslide block may potentially exist
below the location of the embankment.
The surface of the embankment slope shall be covered with a gabion or sandbags to avoid
erosion of the embankment soil.
It shall be noted that there may be cases where the effect of the work will not be as expected
according to shape of the slip surface (refer to (i) and (ii) of the figure below).
Generally, water springs or seepage are found at the toe of landslides. In that case, counter
weight work may cause the groundwater level in the landslide block to rise as a result of
blocking the discharge of spring water. Therefore, in the case that the counter weight work is
installed where there is a spring or seepage, highly permeable material shall be used for the
work with a gabion or drainage pipes shall be installed to discharge spring water properly.
It is recommended that the location, figure and volume of the embankment are decided based
on the results of simple stability analysis.
Since a huge space of land will be required for the work, it might be difficult to apply the work
in residential areas or on private land.
4-3
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Counter weight
Counter weight
ce
rfa
p su
Sli ce
rfa
p su
Sli
(i) In the case that a slip surface appears (ii) In the case that a slip surface appears
straight, the safety factor of the landslide curved, an increase in the safety factor of
will not be drastically changed by the the landslide can be expected by the
counter weight work. counter weight work.
(iii) The slope of the counterweight filling (iv) In the case that a spring or seepage is
work shall be covered by a gabion or found at the toe of the landslide, weep
sandbags to avoid erosion. holes shall be installed in the
filling/embankment to avoid a rise of the
groundwater level in the landslide.
Figure 4.1.2 Points of Installation of Counter Weight Work (source: JET)
Figure 4.1.3 Large-sized Sandbags2 Figure 4.1.4 Gabion wall for Counter Weight
(source: JET)
In the case that a pond or swamp is found at the upper part of the landslide, the pond shall be
cut drainage to discharge as much as possible. The opened crack shall be covered by a plastic
sheet to avoid intrusion into the landslide block. A plastic pipe shall also be provisionally
installed at the water spring and existing water course.
4-4
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
E
AG
AIN
EDR
FAC
Landslide
R
SU
Drainage shall be installed outside the landslide block. Drainage in the landslide block is at risk
of being damaged by landslide activity. In the case that drainage is damaged, water will
infiltrate the landslide block through the damaged drainage and encourage landslide activity.
Therefore, drainage shall not be installed in the landslide block whenever possible. If drainage
has to be installed in the landslide block, the drainage shall have a flexible structure to follow
the changes in topographical features due to landslide activity.
4.1.4 Detour
In the case that a lifeline such as a national road is damaged by landslide, a detour shall be
made to secure the traffic route temporarily. The detour shall be made out of the landslide block.
After stopping landslide activity by installation
of a permanent countermeasure, the damaged
road can be rehabilitated and used on the
original route.
4.2.1 Evacuation
In the Project of Landslide Management in the Republic of Mauritius (hereinafter the Project),
4-5
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
the draft contingency plan has been made for the three pilot sites which are Chitrakoot, Quatre
Soeurs and Vallée Pitot (hereinafter CK: Chitrakoot, VP: Vallée Pitot, QS: Quatre Soeurs). The
contingency plan contains the followings (for details of the below, refer to the end of this
guideline.)
- Evacuee list: it is a list of all evacuees in a landslide site which have the name and contact
of inhabitants.
- Early waning and evacuation system flow: it is a guide for how to response when landslide
occurs.
- Instruction manual of simple rain gauge: it is a guide for how to deal with a simple rain
gauge.
- Location map of the designed refugee centre and the route: it has information of refugee
centre and the route from residence on a map
If a landslide occurs in the pilot sites, the above contingency plan can be utilized. Table 4.2.1
shows the flow of early waning and evacuation in the pilot sites. And Figure 4.2.1 shows task
flow of related ministries/agencies for early waning and evacuation in the pilot sites.
4-6
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Table 4.2.1 Early Waning and Evacuation in the Pilot Sites (source: JET)
Category Content
Information MPI will collect the following information.
collection - Displacement
- Rainfall (by MMS)
- Anomalies (cracks, subsidence, etc.),
However, under the situation of Cyclone/Torrential Rain which is
described in the disaster scheme, the Special Mobile Force will take
readings of extensometers on hills and will communicate the
information to the MPI and the MMS.
Information Based on the above information collection, if one of the following
provision regarding conditions is confirmed, MPI informs the observation result to
the stage 1 (waning NDRRMC
stage) - MMS and MPI observes rainfall 75 mm (CK, VP)/100mm (QS),
or
- MPI confirms that the yellow light revolves, which means the
extension on ground is over 10 mm/day (CK, VP) , or
- MPI confirms minor anomalies (cracks, small substances, etc.)
Information Based on the above information collection, if one of the following
provision regarding conditions is confirmed, MPI inform the observation result to
the stage 2 NDRRMC
(evacuation stage) - MMS and MPI observe rainfall 100 mm (CK, VP)/200mm (QS),
or
- MPI confirms that the red light revolves and/or the sound beeps,
which means the extension on ground is over 20 mm/day (CK,
VP) , or
- MPI confirms the heavy damage to buildings.
Information Based on the above information collection, if all of the following
provision regarding conditions is confirmed, MPI inform the observation result to
the stage 3 NDRRMC
(Termination stage) - No rainfall of 0 mm in 6 hours (CK, VP, QS), and
- No ground displacement of 0 mm being recorded (CK, VP), and
- No new anomalies being confirmed
In case of sudden If the designated inhabitants obtain information regarding a sudden
landslides landslide occurrence, the information will be transferred to police and
NDRRMC to issue the stage 2 (evacuation stage)
In case of When MMS observes the designated threshold which is shown the
landslides during above under the situation of the issue of a Cyclone Warning
Cyclone Class/Torrential Rain Warning, MMS inform the observation result to
Warning/Torrential NDRRMC.
Rain Warning
4-7
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Information collection
- Displacement - The Police Department (PD) will visit
- Rainfall the landslide-prone areas and advise
- Anomalies (cracks, subsidence, etc.) the residents to start all preparations
for an eventual evacuation
- The MBC and Private Radios will be
broadcast the warning.
- The Ministry of Health and Quality of
- Rainfall 75 mm (CK, Life and the PD will make
VP)/100mm (QS), or arrangements for the transfer to
- Yellow light revolves, or hospitals of disabled people.
- Minor anomalies - First Aid Service providers may be
invited to extend their assistance
- Ministry of Social Security, National
MPI informs the observation result to NDRRMC Solidarity and Reform Institutions,
Ministry of Gender Equality, Child
Development and Family Welfare will
Issue of the Stage 1 (waning stage) ensure that all Refugee Centres under
their respective control are opened
and made ready for use
Figure 4.2.1 Task Flow of Related Ministries/Agencies for Early Waning and Evacuation in
the Pilot Sites (source: JET)
(2) In case of landslide site other than pilot sites by the Project
If a landslide occurs in a site other than the pilot sites by the Project which are Chitrakoot,
Vallée Pitot, the following task shown on Table 4.2.2 by MPI will be required. And Figure
4.2.2 shows the task flow of MPI related ministries/agencies.
4-8
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Table 4.2.2 MPI’s Task for Early Waning and Evacuation in a Site Other than Pilot Sites by
the Project (source: JET)
Category Content
Information collection On being informed that the 30mm rainfall in 12 hours has been
recorded, MPI will start taking daily readings of extensometers to
measure ground displacement. MPI will also collect the following
information.
- Displacement
- Anomalies (cracks, subsidence, etc.),
- Other related information (such as date and time of
occurrence of landslide, location information of the landslide,
scale/extent of the landslide, degree of landslide disaster
damage)
However, under the situation of Cyclone/Torrential Rain which is
described in the disaster scheme, the Special Mobile Force will
take readings of extensometers on hills and will communicate the
information to the MPI and the MMS.
Information provision If MPI confirms ground displacement of 1cm in 24 hours, MPI
regarding the stage 1 inform the observation result to NDRRMC
(waning stage)
Information provision If MPI confirms ground displacement of 2mm in an hour, MPI inform
regarding the stage 2 the observation result to NDRRMC
(evacuation stage)
Information provision If MPI confirms no ground displacement and no new anomalies,
regarding the stage 3 MPI inform the observation result to NDRRMC
(termination stage)
In case of sudden If MPI obtains information regarding a sudden landslide
landslides occurrence, the information will transfer to NDRRMC to issue the
stage 2 (evacuation stage)
In case of landslides When MPI observes the designated threshold which is shown the
during Cyclone above under the situation of the issue of a Cyclone Warning
Warning/Torrential Class/Torrential Rain Warning, MPI inform the observation result
Rain Warning to NDRRMC.
4-9
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
- Ground displacement of
1cm in 24 hours - The PD will order the inhabitants to
evacuate
- The MBC and Private Radios will
be broadcast the evacuation
MPI informs the observation result to NDRRMC - Ministry of Social Security, National
Solidarity and Reform Institutions,
Issue of the Stage 1 (waning stage) Ministry of Gender Equality, Child
Development and Family Welfare
will ensure that all Refugee Centers
under their respective control are
- Ground displacement of opened and made ready for use
2mm in an hour - Ministry of Health and Quality of
Life will dispatch ambulances on
site for the conveyance of
MPI informs the observation result to NDRRMC handicapped, old and sick people,
and any casualty cases to hospital
Issue of the Stage 2 (evacuation stage)
Figure 4.2.2 Task Flow of Related Ministries/Agencies for Early Warning and Evacuation in a
Site Other than Pilot Sites by the Project (source: JET)
In the initial survey, the information which is shown on the following table will be collected
through an interview survey of inhabitants and reconnaissance of a site. Based on the survey
4-10
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
result, the basic policy of the response to the landslide disaster damage area such as
countermeasure works, non-structural countermeasure and necessity of the relocation is
considered by the related ministries/agencies.
In case the deliberation reaches a conclusion that relocation is necessary, the explanation of the
relocation project will be conducted for the inhabitants (explanation of the survey result, the
purpose of the relocation project and its schedule; as well as to obtain consent of detailed survey,
etc.)
Table 4.2.3 Items and Content of the Initial Survey for Relocation (source: JET)
4-11
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
(2) Detailed Survey of the Land, Building and Others for Relocation
The information regarding the right of the land, buildings and others should be confirmed to
implement the appropriate and effective work for relocation. In the detailed survey, the
information which is shown on the following table will be collected through an interview
survey of inhabitants, reconnaissance of a site, investigation of cadastral data/registration
records, land survey and investigation of the buildings.
4-12
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Table 4.2.4 Items and Content of the Detailed Survey for Relocation (source: JET)
The confirmation of the possessor, right holder and other stakeholders is required through the
clarification of the location of the land/building and the registration record based on the
investigation of the cadastral map of Ministry of Housing and Lands. The collected data and
4-13
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
materials by the investigation of the cadastral map and registration record contain the personal
information. The information must not be used for anything besides the intended purpose and
the information must be managed carefully.
The land survey will be conducted after the location of the subject land of relocation, detailed
address, cadastral data, possessor, right holder and other stakeholders are confirmed based on
the investigation result of the cadastral map and registration record. The surveyors have to enter
the land of the stakeholders to conduct the land survey. It is needed to obtain the stakeholder’s
consent for and notify them of the intention to enter their land for the survey.
For the investigation of the buildings the consent of the stakeholders needs to be obtained in
order to enter their buildings to conduct the investigation. The objects of the investigation are
building, machinery, productive facility, barn, plumbing, garden tree, farm product and others.
When the land survey and investigation are finished, the record for each land/building
stakeholder should be prepared. And the records are required to be confirmed by stakeholders
with their signature.
The landslide area (includes areas of landslide activity and/or extremely high risk of landslide
damage) and areas adjacent to a landslide area (has a possibility of triggering a landslide or to
have a negative effect on the landslide area) will be examined by the related ministries/agencies
based on the survey result to consider the implementation of the relocation.
A landslide warning system is a system which predicts landslide disasters and allows people in
landslide risk areas to escape from the disaster. A landslide warning system cannot protect the
property of the people in a landslide risk area. It can only protect the lives of people in the area
from the landslide. A landslide warning system can be a temporary measure. This is the most
important matter when we consider landslide disaster management. To implement a landslide
warning system, we must find where the landslide risk areas are and predict when the landslide
disasters will occur.
4-14
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Information Transfer
Once we predict the landslide disaster, the information must be transferred from the tools or
instruments to all residents in the landslide risk area. Therefore, a person to receive the
information from the tools or instruments and a person to transfer the information to all
residents must be appointed.
c. Evacuation
Injuries to people in a landslide disaster are mostly due to being buried under the debris of the
houses destroyed. The victims of landslide disasters are usually only the people in residential
houses in the landslide risk areas. Therefore, when a landslide warning is issued, the residents
in the landslide risk area should escape to a place away from the landslide risk area or at least
from their houses. It is not necessary for the people in the area to go to a refuge.
4.3.2 Warning
a. Phenomenon Initiate the Warning and Sensors
To issue a warning, we must find where the landslide risk areas are and predict when the
landslide disaster will occur. Once the location of the landslide had been identified and a
landslide warning system is established, the landslide warning system must predict the timing
of the landslide disaster. In order to predict the timing of the landslide disaster, we should find
and monitor the small phenomena which arise prior to the landslide There are two kinds of
phenomena in landslide risk areas we have to keep our eyes: a) small phenomena such as cracks
or deformation on the ground surface or structures caused by landslides and b) phenomena
which can cause landslides.
a) Small phenomena which can be seen everywhere in a landslide area should be found and
monitored. The movement of the ground surface, cracks on the ground, cracks on a
structure and movement of the subsurface are all possible phenomena caused by landslide.
b. Instruments
The instrumentation for the landslide warning system generally consists of a sensor, a logger
and an alarm devise. An extensometer which can detect small movements of the ground surface
is often employed as an instrument for detecting small phenomena in a landslide. Because it is
easy to install, less trouble with a simple structure, easy to monitor automatically and easy to
attach a warning devise to, the extensometer is especially popular in Japan where less
protection barrier is required, as there are fewer burglars.
Other than extensometers, tiltmeters and crack gauges are employed for the monitoring of
landslides. However, they are not so popular compared with extensometers because they cannot
obtain the absolute value of the movement of a landslide.
Because rain gauges are also easy to handle and easy to install, rain gauges can be employed
for the landslide warning system in order to detect an increase in groundwater level indirectly.
4-15
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
The advantages of a rain gauge are that it does not require construction works such as drilling
works and can be installed anyplace where there is open air around the landslide area.
Extensometer
Extensometers should be installed at the top centre or bottom centre of the landslide block
where it can detect the movement of the landslide precisely.
Rain Gauge
A rain gauge can be installed in any open area around the landslide because precipitation does
not very much in a limited area. The rain gauge should be installed in a place away from trees
and buildings which can obstruct the rain falling on the rain gauge. Also, the rain gauge should
be at the height of one meter (1m) or more from the ground surface to prevent water and mud
splashing up from the ground surface.
Simple Devices
Simple devices such as an extensometer, a tiltmeter and a rain gauge can be used to monitor
the small phenomena which arise prior to a landslide in order to predict the timing of the
landslide disaster. Since these simple devices do not have either a logger or an alarm, someone
must always watch them.
4-16
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
50 mm of precipitation = 643 cc
75 mm of precipitation = 965 cc
100 mm of precipitation = 1286 cc
200 mm of precipitation = 2572 cc
c. Criteria of Warning
The most important thing to establish the criteria of warning is to recognize the limit of
landslide movement or the limit of precipitation to keep the people secure. “People in danger”
means that houses are being destroyed by the landslide. The warning to evacuate the houses
must be issued a few hours before destruction by the landslide. In order to determine the timing
of when the houses are destroyed in the landslide, we must find the relationship between the
deformations recorded by the extensometers and the destruction of houses or precipitation and
the destruction of houses. However, there are no such records in Mauritius so we need to
accumulate such data to improve the landslide warning system.
The following are examples of establishing the criteria of warning in Chitrakoot and Vallée
Pitot in Mauritius.
There are three ways of using the displacement of extensometers for the landslide warning
system: total displacement, daily displacement and hourly displacement. Small landslides,
which account for most of the landslides in Mauritius, move fast immediately after they are
activated and their moving speeds are not constant. A short period of displacement of the
extensometer such as an hourly displacement is not suitable for the warning system in
Mauritius. The total displacement of the extensometer is not suitable in Mauritius either
because many landslides in Mauritius are constantly moving, even in the dry season. Therefore,
landslide management based on the daily displacement is the best way in Mauritius.
Automatic wire extensometers were installed in two landslide risk areas, Chitrakoot and Vallée
Pitot. The criteria are obtained based on the relationship between the displacement of the
extensometer and the landslide disaster. A landslide disaster occurred in Vallée Pitot on
February 25, 2013, and a house was partially destroyed. The extensometer (EV1) had been
installed near the site of the disaster, and it recorded a big displacement of the landslide. The
start of the displacement was recorded by the extensometer three days before the disaster. The
total displacement in the three days leading up to the disaster was 54.2mm, the maximum daily
displacement recorded two days before the disaster was 30.7mm, and the maximum hourly
4-17
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
displacement was 1.9mm, as shown in Figure 4.3.4. The daily displacement of 30.7mm was
the biggest daily displacement recorded by all extensometers installed in the project. Based on
the relationship between the landslide disaster and the records of the extensometer in Vallée
Pitot, a displacement of 30.4mm/day is the critical value to be evacuated. For the criteria for
evacuation and warning, we decided that a 20mm/day displacement of the extensometer is the
criterion for evacuation with a safety factor of 50%. A 10 mm/day displacement of the
extensometer, which is half of the evacuation criterion, is the criterion for warning. These
criteria have been decided based on only one landslide disaster. They may be reconsidered with
the accumulation of records by the extensometers and on landslide disasters.
Figure 4.3.5 Record of the Extensometer on the Event of Disaster in Vallée Pitot (source:
JET)
As there are not many records of the hourly precipitation at landslide disasters in Mauritius,
the accumulated rainfall method is the best method in Mauritius. Figure 4.3.5 shows the
relationship between precipitation and disasters in Chitrakoot and Vallée Pitot in Mauritius.
In Vallée Pitot in 2007, landslides damaged houses with 385mm of accumulated rainfall. In
2013 in Vallée Pitot, a landslide damaged a house with 100mm of accumulated rainfall and the
extensometer recorded big displacements.
The criterion for the risk level of landslides in Vallée Pitot is 100mm of accumulated rainfall.
4-18
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Sudden
displacement
Based on the results of the extensometers and rain gauges and the records of disasters in
Mauritius, the criteria for the risk levels of landslides were determined. Table 4.3.1 shows the
proposed criteria for the risk levels of landslides determined based on the monitoring records
in this project and the disaster records.
d. Warning
There are two ways to emit the warning, by in-site alarm or by remote alarm. Although there
are many types of in-site alarm devices, sound and light are the most popular for landslide
warning systems. Sirens are mostly used for sound alarms, but horns, bells and loud speakers
can also be used. For light alarms, beacons are mostly used but light bulbs and flushes are
sometimes used. In order to transfer the sound and light warning to all of the residents in the
area, a designated inhabitant must be assigned to monitor the light and sound devices.
4-19
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Therefore, the light and sound devices must be installed in a place where the designated
inhabitant can see and hear the alarm. The sound alarm in a warning system emits a loud sound
to warn all people in the area like a fire alarm system in a building. As the sound is expected
to warn all people in the area, a number of sound alarms should be installed. When installing
the sound system, all people in the area must be able to recognize the alarm system.
Communication among residents is even more important to help warn people in the area who
may not hear the alarm due to bad ears or because they are listening to music with head phones.
Without an automatic warning system, someone must always watch devises such as the
extensometers and rain gauges and once the reading reaches the warning level, he must send
out a warning immediately. It is necessary to decide who the designated inhabitant will be, how
the instruments will be monitored and how the warning will be sent. Someone must be
appointed to watch the devices 365 days a year and there should be more than one designated
inhabitant. Regular monitoring such as hourly and daily should be carried out every day by the
designated inhabitant. The interval of monitoring depends on the landslide activity but
monitoring is usually once a day and becomes more frequent if the landslide is more active.
The following is an example of the instructions given to a watchman who monitors a simple
rain gauge in Chitrakoot. Monitoring of a simple extensometer can also be done this way.
4-20
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Transmission of the landslide warning can be considered as a fire alarm system. In a fire alarm
system, a warning is transferred to all people in the building and building management by the
sound of a fire alarm. The information is transferred to a fire station directly from the alarm
system or through building management. When we adapt the fire alarm system to the landslide
warning system, people in the building are people in the landslide risk area, building
management is MPI, and the fire station is the police station, In the case of a fire, the fire
fighters must arrive as soon as possible to put out the fire whole in the case of a landslide, the
police must warn all the residents and guide them to a safe place.
4-21
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Since the police is concerned with the evacuation of residents in Mauritius, the police should
receive the warnings of the landslides and transfer the warning to all the residents in the area.
MPI who managements all landslides in Mauritius must receive all the warnings from the
instruments and watchmen and transfer the warnings to the police. Figure 3.1.1 shows the
recommended flow of a warning in the landslide warning system in Mauritius. All the warnings
and information from the warning devices and watchmen should be concentrated to MPI
because the warning system and instruments are installed and maintained by MPI and are MPI’s
responsibility. Therefore, all the information from the instruments, devices and watchmen must
be transferred to MPI.
The role of MPI is very important in landslide management. MPI should be responsible for the
following matters:
In ordinary times
Install and manage the instruments for landslide management
Explain the landslide warning system to people in the landslide risk area
Observe and inspect the landslides regularly
In an emergency or imminent situation
Receive the warning from the instruments or the watchmen
Transfer the warning to the police
Observe site as soon as receiving the warning
Inspecting the landslide area for new cracks, the opening of old cracks and deformation to
confirm whether the landslide disaster is serious (For all of our sleep in peace, MPI must make
people in the landslide risk area relocate as soon as possible instead of the landslide warning
system).
MPI does not have sufficient capacity to respond to an emergency as of early 2014. Therefore,
the police receives the warning from the landslide risk area and respond to the emergency for
the moment. Even so, MPI must go to the site immediately after receiving the warning from
the police. MPI must also establish the necessary organisation to respond to emergencies as
soon as possible.
b. Evacuation
Instruction to residents about evacuation should be done by the police, not by MPI. However,
MPI should explain the following technical matters about landslides to people:
Landslide disasters are caused by only the motion of the ground. Even with heavy rain, a
4-22
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
landslide disaster would not arise without ground deformation. On the other hand, without
rainfall, a landslide could be activated by an increase in groundwater pressure caused by water
from out of the landslide other than rainwater or by human activity. In this sense, a warning by
the extensometer may be more accurate than by the rain gauge. However, the extensometer
cannot cover the entire landslide risk area if the landslide consists of a number of blocks. Even
if the extensometer of the warning system is not issuing a warning, a landslide disaster at
another landslide block could arise. In other words, the rain gauge can cover a wide area but is
not so accurate while the extensometer is accurate but can only cover a limited area.
Since the residents normally do not have professional knowledge of landslides, anomalies the
residents find may not be caused by a landslide. MPI must confirm the cause of the anomalies
the residents find. MPI should also educate the residents in the landslide risk area about
landslides (i.e. what are the signs of landslides). MPI should request the residents to inform
MPI any signs of landslide immediately after they are found, and MPI should inspect the signs
of landslide immediately after receiving the information from the residents.
The signs of a landslide are listed as follows by the United States Geological Survey (USGS).
• Springs, seeps, or saturated ground in areas that have not typically been wet before.
• New cracks or unusual bulges in the ground, street pavements or sidewalks.
• Soil moving away from foundations.
• Ancillary structures such as decks and patios tilting and/or moving relative to the main
house.
• Tilting or cracking of concrete floors and foundations.
• Broken water lines and other underground utilities.
• Leaning telephone poles, trees, retaining walls or fences.
• Offset fence lines.
• Sunken or down-dropped road beds.
• Rapid increase in creek water levels, possibly accompanied by increased turbidity (soil
content).
• Sudden decrease in creek water levels though rain is still falling or just recently
stopped.
• Sticking doors and windows, and visible open spaces indicating jambs and frames out
of plumb.
• A faint rumbling sound that increases in volume is noticeable as the landslide nears.
• Unusual sounds, such as trees cracking or boulders knocking together, might indicate
moving debris.
4-23
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Reference
1
Japan Road Association, 2009, Highway Earthwork Series: Manual for slope protection, p. 435
2
<http://shear.nagaokaut.ac.jp/Information/Niigata716earthquake/Niigata070802/
Niigata0 70802.html>
4-24
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
A survey and analysis on landslides should be implemented to establish preventive plans and
to discuss countermeasures for landslides. The survey is generally divided into two stages: a
preliminary survey and a main survey.
The preliminary survey is composed of the collection of documents, data and maps and the
searching and analysis of related literature.
The main survey for landslides chiefly consists of a hydrological survey, geomorphologic
survey, geological survey, drilling and slip surface surveys, physical testing, monitoring and
geophysical exploration. The analysis of landslides such as the preparation of geological
cross sections, establishment of the safety factor and stability analysis should be implemented
based on the specific results of the above mentioned surveys. Figure 5.1.1 below summarizes
the flow of the survey and analysis of landslides and the scope which is described in this
manual. The survey items and survey methods are shown in Table 5.1.1. In order to properly
examine the items listed in the table, a detailed survey which will satisfy the study objectives
should be planned by selecting appropriate survey methods and instruments described in the
table.
【Preparation in Japan】
Document/data/maps collection/Literature searching/analysis
【Main survey】
Topographic survey /Geomorphologic survey/Geological survey
Drilling survey/Slip surface survey/ Laboratory soil test
Monitoring/Geophysical exploration /Hydrological survey
【Analysis】
Landslide cross section/Safety factor for landslide/Stability
analysis
【Evaluation】
Activity/vulnerability/susceptibility/Integrated analysis
【Countermeasures】
Structural measures (Hard)/Early-warning system (Soft)
5-1
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
5-2
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
The preliminary survey is composed of the collection of documents, data and maps and the
searching and analysis of related literature. In the initial survey to be carried out just after the
landslide occurrence, the above should be performed, although it will be difficult to complete
due to time limitations. Therefore, it is necessary to collect as much data as possible in the
detailed survey. (Refer to Chapter 2, Table 2.1.1)
As a geomorphologic survey, topographic map reading and aerial photo interpretation are
carried out, the results shall be compiled into the landslide distribution maps. Then, the map
shall be used for the field survey. The geomorphologic survey should be carried out in the
area that is bigger than active landslide block and topographic survey area, and the
topographical characteristic is confirmed in the wide area including the landslide block.
5-3
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
d. Drilling Survey
Borehole points should be located along the centre line of the direction of landslide
movement, at least 3 boreholes in the landslide area and 1 borehole in the upper part of the
landslide at 30-50m intervals in principal (Figure 5.1.3). Additional boreholes should be
implemented along sub-lines which run parallel at 30-50m intervals when the landslide area
is larger. In the case that the landslide area is small, two or more drillings are needed along
the movement direction to understand the geology of the area. When there are faults, fracture
zones and/or complicated structures in the landslide area, supplemental drillings are
preferable. It is desirable for the standard penetration test (SPT) to be carried out every 1m.
Because the boreholes are used for the installation of the monitoring devices, the contents of
the landslide monitoring should be considered when deciding on the placement and depth of
the drilling.
Ground surface
Borehole
e. Laboratory Soil Testing
f. Geophysical Exploration
[Movement of a landslide] Extensometers are installed over cracks and/or gaps to measure
movement and stress in an active sliding mass. Because the movement of the landslide is the
biggest in the main scarp of the head part, it is required that the extensometer be installed in
the main scarp.
[Slip surface survey] The borehole inclinometer and the pipe strain gauge investigate the
5-4
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
position of a slip surface, and measure the amount of landslide movement on the slip surface.
Though the borehole inclinometer has high precision, it cannot be used for active landslides.
The pipe strain gauge records data continuously and is durable (1-2 years). These devices are
chosen (or combined) in consideration of the activity of the landslide and shall be installed in
combination in the boreholes.
[Hydrological survey] The aim of the survey is to judge the correlation between
precipitation and changes in groundwater by measuring the precipitation which is a source of
the supply of groundwater. The water level meter is installed in multiple boreholes and
monitors the change in the groundwater level in the landslide area. The rainfall data are
observed in a rain gauge set in the landslide area or the neighbourhood.
crack
Rain Gauge
crack Tipping-bucket
groundwater
Bore hole
Piezometer
5-5
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
The countermeasure shall be planned after the evaluation of landslide hazard based on the
hazard rank in the table below.
Hazard Activation
Deformation and Topographical feature of landslide
Rank Rank
Cracks, subsidence, collapse and uplift caused by landslide are Condition a
found on the slope. Deformation caused by landslide is found on an Condition b
existing facility such as a side ditch. No landslide countermeasure
A
works have been installed even though there is a history of previous
landslides. It has a high potential for landslide hazard to the road
directory despite no artificial landform changes.
Clear landslide characteristic features are found even though Condition c
evidence of landslide activity are not clearly recognized. It has high
B
potential for landslide hazard to the road directory by artificial
landform changes.
The slope shows landslide characteristic features but they are not There is
clear. Even if landslide occurs due to large-scale changing of possibility
C environment conditions, the possibility for expansion of damage is to be
low and treatment of the landslide damage can be done promptly at condition c
that moment.
Daily Accumulated
Activation Rank displacement displacement Activation
(mm/day) (mm/month)
Rank a More than 1 More than 10 Active movement t
5-6
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
considered. The policy of countermeasure work shall be decided according to the feasibility
study and EIA study results. In some cases, combining structural countermeasures and
non-structural countermeasures shall be considered.
For the non-structural countermeasure work, an early warning system using monitoring
instruments or relocation can be considered. Regarding non-structural countermeasures, refer
to the Manual for Landslides prepared in the Project.
The structural landslide countermeasure work can be divided into control work and restraint
work. The control work is the work to stop or mitigate landslide movement by improvement
of natural conditions such as topographical and hydrological aspects. The restraint work is the
work to stop a part or all of the landslide block by the restraint force of structures installed in
the landslide area.
It is not necessarily the case that only one type of countermeasure is installed. Rather,
several types of structural landslide countermeasures are applied in combination. The general
types of structural countermeasures are shown below.
Control Work
・ Surface drainage work (drainage work, infiltration prevention work)
・ Groundwater drainage work
Shallow groundwater drainage work
(conduit work, open-blind ditch, horizontal drainage work)
Deep groundwater drainage work
(infiltration well, drainage tunnel work, horizontal drainage work)
・ Soil removal work
・ Counter weight work
・ River structural facility (dam, consolidation work, water control work, revetment work)
Restraint Work
・ Pile work
Pile work (steal pipe pile work)
Shaft work
・ Ground anchor work
In the case that the landslide is active, the restraint work will not have the expected proper
effect and the construction work will also be extremely dangerous. Therefore, in such a
situation, the restraint work shall be installed at an appropriate time after mitigating the
landslide movement by control work. Selection of the structural countermeasure can be done
according to the flowchart below.
5-7
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
START
Landslide countermeasure
work is required
CONTROL MEASURE
Surface/groundwater drainage work
Surface drainage or
Decision of Optimum
Groundwater drainage
Yes countermeasure work
works can be applied
No Is it achieved
Consideration of additional No
countermeasure planned factor
of safety
CONTROL MEASURE
Soil removal /counter weight work Yes
Soil removal Yes Decision of Optimum
work/Counter weight
countermeasure work
work can be applied
No No Is it achieved
planned factor
of safety
RESTRAINT MEASURE
Comparative design of Piling work Yes
restraint works Shaft
Anchor work
Detail design
Implementation plan
Final decision of the works
No
END
The topographical, geological, and landslide activity conditions, relevancy between rainfall
and landslide movement, and safety of the target area shall be clarified when countermeasure
work is planned. Furthermore, the mechanism of the landslide shall be clarified based on the
figure or landslide block, the figure and depth of the slip surface and the distribution of
groundwater. In particular, countermeasures shall be planned according to the following
issues.
1. In the case that a relationship between precipitation and landslide movement is found,
groundwater drainage works shall be applied to prevent rainfall from infiltrating into the
ground.
5-8
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
the type of groundwater, the groundwater drainage work shall be selected based on a
study of the influence of the target groundwater on landslide movement.
3. In the case that a relationship between long-term rainfall and the occurrence/movement
of landslide is found, it is recommended to apply countermeasure work focusing on deep
groundwater drainage work.
4. For an active landslide which consists of cohesive soil such as highly weathered tuff or
mudstone, countermeasure work focusing on shallow groundwater/surface water drainage
work shall be selected. In the case that the landslide consists of very loose cohesive soil,
the landslide shall be settled gradually by a groundwater block wall or groundwater
drainage work to prevent groundwater from flowing into the landslide area.
5. In the case that the target landslide is individual* and has a circular slip surface, removal
soil work at the head of the landslide or deep groundwater drainage work will be an
effective countermeasure. (* A landslide area where other landslide blocks are not found
around it.)
6. In the case that the landslide is divided into several blocks and the blocks are
neighbouring each other or the slip surface shows a nearly linear shape, groundwater
drainage work will be an effective countermeasure work. However, in such cases,
counterweight filling work and removal work is not recommended because the works
will not have proper effectiveness depending on the location and shape of the works.
7. The restraint work will be an effective countermeasure for a small-scale landslide. Even
if the target landslide is large-scale, the work will be effective for stabilization of part of
the landslide block. In addition, the work can be applied in cases where control works
such as groundwater drainage work or soil removal work are difficult to apply. Since a
huge deterrent force will be required against a large-scale landslide, restraint work is
often applied in combination with several types of restraint works. Also, as each restraint
work has a different mechanism to exert its effectiveness, the acting timing of
effectiveness of the countermeasure works, the estimated damage for the period and the
economic effect shall be considered carefully in advance.
5-9
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
should be conducted for the above. It will also require to refer the following information for
review of the development restriction/land-use control. If the following information regarding
the landslide site is available, the data collection and confirmation should be conducted.
- Disaster record
- Risk map
- Hazard map
- Research/study regarding the disaster risk management
It is required to comprehend the basis acts of legal systems and schemes regarding the
development restriction and land-use control to coordinate with related
ministries/agencies/local authorities and review existing regulation.
The following figure shows legal systems/schemes which have a relationship with landslide
disaster risk management (hereinafter LDRM) in Mauritius. The existence of the relevant
legal systems/schemes in the object area should be confirmed for each site.
Acts
Building Local Town and Planning and Environment Business
Act Government Country Development Protection Facilitation
Act Planning Act Act Act Act …
Figure 5.3.1 Acts and Schemes Related with LDRM (source: JET)
The following table shows the detailed content of the principal legal systems/schemes related
to LDRM.
Table 5.3.1 The Existing Mauritian Legal Systems/Schemes for LDRM (source: JET)
Legal Content
system/scheme
Planning and ・ The Planning and Development Act (PDA) is a new and modern
Development Act piece of legislation enacted to bring the planning exercise more in
(PDA) line with the requirements of today's changes and challenges
(globalization, structural changes in the economy, the need to
provide for new sectors of activities).
・ It gives legal status to the National Development Strategy which had
5-10
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
5-11
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
If a landslide site is not applicable development restriction for sloping site by Planning Policy
5-12
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
・ As a general guide, development should not be any higher than 45 meters above the
mountain base or, in the case of slopes facing the sea, 45 meters above Mean Sea Level.
・ Buildings and structures should be set back far enough from ridges and cliff edges so that
the structure does not appear to be perched on the edge.
・
Table 5.3.2 The Design Guidance for Sloping Sites in the PPG 9 (source: MHL)
Slope height General guidance development should not be any higher than 45m above the
mountain base, or in the case slopes facing the sea above the Mean Sea
Level.
Slope gradient: Generally suitable for Generally suitable for all development and uses.
0% to 3%
Slope gradient: Suitable for medium density residential development, agriculture, industrial and
3% to 8% institutional uses.
Slope gradient: Suitable for moderate to low-density residential development, but
8% to 20% great care should be exercised in the location of any commercial, industrial or
institutional uses.
Slope gradient: Only used for open space, limited agricultural and certain recreational uses.
Over 20%
5-13
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Additionally the following information should be considered, if the object area is applicable
with the disaster record/hazard map, and if there is an applicable area with the above
regulation in/around the object area. Furthermore, it is required attention for location/position,
extent, degree of risk and other factors in the record/hazard map.
The development record regarding a landslide site will be useful for identification of the
cause of the landslide, examination material for emergency countermeasure and others. Also,
the confirmation of the development plan in the future is important to consider the disaster
prevention measures. When the development record/plan will be confirmed, it will be require
to refer the following information. If the following information regarding the landslide site is
available, the data collection and confirmation should be conducted.
5-14
Technical Cooperation Project: Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)
Landslide Advisor for Mauritius Kokusai Kogyo Co., Ltd.
Technical Guideline for Initial Survey
Reference
1
Japan Landslide Society, 2002, Landslides in Japan (The Sixth Revision), p.21.
2
Japan Road Association, 1999, Road Earthwork Manual -Cut slope and Slope Stability- , p. 340
3
Ibid, p. 116
4
Ibid, p. 355
5-15