Relief and Flare System (Eng)
Relief and Flare System (Eng)
• Name: …
• Social Status: Student / Employee / Talent Ready Etc.
• Expected results from this training: …
2
• To give introduction and the understanding on how
importance is Relief, Blowdown and Flare System in a
Chemical Plant, Oil and Gas Facilities, Refineries and
Petrochemical,
• To explain to the audience on how to size, select and
properly installed a Pressure Relieving Devices (PRD)
based on API STD 520 Pt I and Pt II and also API STD
OBJECTIVES 521,
• To explain about the standard PRD orifice size based
on API STD 526 and the difference with ASME PRD
The objectives of this training are: orifice size,
• To give understanding about API STD 521; in regards
to pressure-relieving and depressuring system,
• Final Objective:
So that the audience will understand more about the
importance of Relief, Blowdown and Flare System
and able to properly design the system properly 3
based on the applicable code and standard.
• Definitions of RELIEF, BLOWDOWN and FLARE,
• The importance of Relief, Blowdown and Flare
System,
• Causes of over-pressure and relief rate
determination,
TRAINING
CONTENTS
• Types of Pressure Relieving Devices (PRD),
• Choosing the right Pressure Relieving Devices
(PRD),
Contents of this training are: • Sizing a Pressure Relieving Devices (PRD) in this
case PRV,
• Installation Criteria of Pressure Relieving Devices
(PRD),
• Blowdown/Depressuring (criteria and noted item),
• Flare/Vent network and Flare system, 4
• Optimization
DEFINITION
Definition of RELIEF, BLOWDOWN (DEPRESSURING), FLARE and VENT
5
RELIEF
What is RELIEF by definition?
• DEPRESSURING in a plant?
• Release the pressure of the gas inside, Is a process of reducing the pressure in a
closed system by reducing the amount of
• To become lower in pressure,
gas or liquid inventory from the closed
system to the environment.
7
FLARE
What is FLARE by definition?
8
VENT
What is VENT by definition?
9
PRESSURE
Relation between
pressure level for PRD in percentage vs pressure vessel
pressure
10
IMPORTANCE OF
RELIEF, BLOWDOWN AND
FLARE SYSTEM
Why RELIEF, BLOWDOWN and FLARE system is needed in a plant
11
WHICH ONE TO CHOOSE?
A B
12
PAY ATTENTION TO
THE VIDEO
Video is courtesy of
youtube.com
13
IMPORTANCE OF RELIEF, BLOWDOWN
AND FLARE SYSTEM IN A PLANT?
14
CAUSE OF OVER-PRESSURE AND
RELIEF RATE DETERMINATION
API STD 521 (2014)
15
WHAT CAUSE
OVER-PRESSURE?
16
PROTECTION HEIRARCY
1. Avoiding for the over-pressure to happen,
17
No. Condition No. Liquid-relief Vapor-relief Guidance*
Item SubSection Guidance*
API 521
1 Closed outlets 4.4.2 Maximum liquid Total incoming steam and
pump-in rate vapor plus that generated
therein at relieving
conditions
2 Cooling-water failure to 4.4.3 --- Total vapor to condenser at
condenser relieving conditions
DEFINING RELIEF 3 Top-Tower reflux failure 4.4.3 --- Total incoming steam and
vapor plus that generated
DEFINING RELIEF 13
a) Cold-fluid shut in 4.4.12 See 4.4.12 ---
20
No. Condition No. Liquid-relief Vapor-relief Guidance*
Item SubSection Guidance*
API 521
Power failure (steam, 4.4.15 --- Study the installation to
electric, or determine the effect of
other) power failure; size the relief
valve for the worst condition
that can occur
a) Fractionators --- Loss of all pumps, with the
DEFINING RELIEF result that reflux and cooling
water would fail
21
TYPES OF
PRESSURE RELIEVING DEVICE (PRD)
Currently available in the market
22
• Spring Loaded PRV/PSV
• PSV Conventional
• Balanced PSV
TYPES OF PRESSURE
RELIEVING DEVICES (1)
23
• Rupture Disk
• Forward-acting, tension loaded
• Buckling Pin
24
CHOOSING THE RIGHT
PRESSURE RELIEVING DEVICES (PRD)
API STD 520 Pt. I (2014)
25
Guidance in Selecting Pressure Relieving Devices
Maximum
Types of Gas Multiphase Liquid
Allowable Remarks
PRD Application Application Application
Back Pressure
YES, but watch YES, but watch
PSV Up to 10% max
YES out of back out of back
Conventional #
pressure pressure
Balanced PSV YES YES, moderate YES 10% to 50% #
Or when max
Pilot Operated YES, YES, for clean More than 50% operating Pressure is
YES
PSV recommended liquid service # above 90% of design
pressure
For application where
Rupture Disk * YES YES YES immediate closure is
not required
For application where
Buckling Pin YES YES YES immediate closure is
not required
26
* Refer to individual installation, not application of rupture disk + PSV
# At higher backpressure capacity correction factors shall be applied to account possible flow reduction
SIZING OF
PRESSURE RELIEVING DEVICES
API STD 520 Pt. I (2014)
27
PRV ORIFICE SIZE API STD 526 (2012)
DESIGNATION AREA ORIFICE AREA ORIFICE AREA ORIFICE
EFEKTIF (in2) EFEKTIF (ASME) *
(mm2) EFEKTIF (in2)
D 0.110 70.9676 0.134
E 0.196 126.4514 0.273
F 0.307 198.0641 0.373
SIZING OF PRV G 0.503 324.5155 0.589
H 0.785 506.4506 0.881
J 1.287 830.3209 1.457
What do we sized?
K 1.838 1185.8041 2.097
Note * L 2.853 1840.6415 3.284
In ASME BPVC VIII Section I, it was mentioned that the
Coefficient of Discharge (Kd) on API formula shall be M 3.600 2322.5800 4.093
multiplied by 0.9. Which means the Kd in ASME
calculation will be smaller and makes the required N 4.340 2799.9940 4.987
orifice based on ASME become higher. Thus the PRD
that required ASME certification always has larger P 6.380 4116.1210 7.215
orifice than the required orifice area calculated by API
Q 11.05 7129.0180 12.91
28
R 16.00 10322.60 17.81
T 26.00 16774.20 28.87
• Defined the Governing Relief Rate Requirement (API STD
521),
• Define the Coefficient of Discharge (Kd) from Vendor or use
Preliminary Value: 0.975 for Gas service PRV, 0.65 for Liquid or
Gas-Liquid service PRV and 0.62 for Gas service Rupture Disk,
• Define the effect of back pressure, by determine the
PROCEDURE FOR Coefficient back pressure (Kb) from Vendor or from graph in
ORIFICE SIZE API 520 Pt. I Figure 30
CALCULATION OF PRV • Defined (Kc); factor which is used if any rupture disk or not
installed before PRV (1.0 no rupture disk, 0.9 rupture disk
installed (combination); generic factor) .
29
A is the required discharge area of the device; in2 (mm2)
W is the required flow through the device; lb/h (kg/h)
C is a function of the ratio of the ideal gas specific heat (k=Cp/Cv) of the gas or
vapor at inlet relieving temperature
SYMBOLS Kd Coefficient of Discharge; 0.975 (Gas PRV), 0.65 (Liquid or Gas-Liquid PRV)
P1 set pressure + allowable over pressure (10%, 21%); psia (kPa(a))
Kb Coefficient Back-pressure from Vendor or from graph in API 520 Pt. I Fig. 30
From Equation on Previous Slide Kc Coeeficient for rupture disk installation (combine or not), (1.0 no rupture disk,
0.9 rupture disk installed (combination)
T Relief temperature; oR(oF + 460) (K(oC+273)
Z compressibility factor (gas ideal = 1)
M is the molecular weight of the gas or vapor at inlet relieving conditions
V is the required flow through the device; SCFM at 14.7 psia dan 60oF (Nm3/min at
0oC and 101.325 kPa)
30
Gv is the specific gravity of gas at std referred to air at standard conditions (normal
conditions). In other words, Gv = 1.00 for air at 14.7 psia and 60°F (101.325 kPa
and 0°C).
STUDY CASE PC
33
• Installed near to the protected equipment/pipe,
• Max. 3% pressure drop from the set pressure for the
inlet pipe,
• Installed in area of equipment/pipe where the pressure
RECOMMENDED fluctuation range is not high,
INSTALLATION • Inlet and Outlet Pipe shall be free draining away from
CRITERIA FOR PRD the PRD,
• Inlet pipe size minimum same size as inlet flange size
of PRD,
In general, based on API STD 520
Pt. II (2015)
• PRD shall be able to be accessed for maintenance
purpose.
34
BLOWDOWN / DEPRESSURING
API STD 521 (2014)
35
• Is a process of reducing the pressure in a closed system by reducing
the amount of gas or liquid inventory from the closed system to the
environment,
• 2 conditions; Fire Case (emergency cond. 15 minutes blowdown) and
Adiabatic Case (maintenance cond. From Normal Operating
Condition up to “zero” barg; no time constraints),
BLOWDOWN/ • Initial pressure for Fire case is PSHH ; Final Pressure : 50% of Design
Pressure or 690 kPa whichever is lower,
DEPRESSURING
• Initial temperature: Normal Operating Temperature,
• Depressuring time 15 minutes for vessel with thickness > 25.4 mm (1
inch) (general approach),
Important Points
• Blowdown Calculation is done using depressuring tools, in process
simulation software such as HYSYS, UNISIM, PRO-II and PROMAX,
so we calculate size of orifice to depressurize the system from PSHH
to 50% or 690 (whichever is lower in 15 minutes; governing fire case)
• Minimum Design Metal Temperature, obtain from Adiabatic Case,
• If vessel thickness < 25.4 mm (1 inch) to check the material strength
36
mapping to set depressuring time before the material rupture.
WORKFLOW FOR FIRE
DEPRESSURING
CALCULATION
37
FLARE/ VENT NETWORK
AND FLARE SYSTEM
API STD 521 (2014)
38
TYPICAL GAS FLARE
ARRANGEMENT
Courtesy of
Chemical Engineering World
39
FLARE SYSTEM
Types and Components
Types of Flares
• Non-smokeless Flares (Gas)
• Smokeless Flares (Gas)
• Fire or Endothermic Flares (Liquid)
Flare Components
• Liquid KO Drum
• Flare liquid seal
• Flare structure stack (self-support, guy
support, derrick support)
• Flare stack molecular seal
• Flare tip 40
• Ignition system
CRITERIA OF FLARE NETWORK SYSTEM DESIGN
• Stack Height for FLARE is
determined based on the required
radiation effect to operator and/or
operation equipment and the
required dispersion effect which can
cause unsafe conditions to operator
and/or operation equipment.
• Stack Height for VENT is determined
based on the required dispersion
effect which can cause unsafe
conditions to operator and/or
operation equipment.
purging
• Segregate header HP & LP/ toxic, non-toxic Where:
• Design pressure, based on maximum back pressure uc dropout
velocity
• Design temperature decided from maximum and minimum
g gravity
temperature that may happen
acceleration
• Size of tail pipe, sub-header and header to concern on back D particle
pressure of each PRD Diameter;
• ρv2 < 100,000 kg/m/s2; OK no AIV study. 150,000 < ρv2 < 300 to 1000 µm
200,000 kg/m/s2 AIV Mandatory ρl Liq density
• Minimum Speed 0.5-0.7 Mach min in flare stack, flare header ρv Vap41density
purging
and sub-header, up to 1 Mach in lateral/tail pipe C Drag coef.
API STD521
• Sound level limitation 85dB @ 8 hour and to 94dB @ 1 hour Fig.12
FLARE NETWORK
HEADER & SUB-HEADER SIZING
42
FLARE HEIGHT SIZING
43
OPTIMIZATION
ENGINEERING
44
RELIEF LOAD CUMMULATIVE (OPTIMIZATION)
Conventional Semi-dynamic approach Dynamic approach
approach
UNIT 4
UNIT 3
relief loads
Cumulated
relief loads
Cumulated
UNIT 2
Cumulated
relief loads
UNIT 1
45
”
THANK YOU
Ir. Erwin Apriandi AER CEng.
erwin.apriandi@gmail.com
https://www.linkedin.com/in/ir-erwin-apriandi-ipm-asean-eng-ceng-b665631a/
46
REFERENCES
• API STANDARD 520 - Sizing, Selection, and Installation of Pressure-relieving Devices, Part I; Sizing and
Selection
• API STANDARD 520 - Sizing, Selection, and Installation of Pressure-relieving Devices, Part II; Installation
• API STANDARD 521 - Pressure-relieving and Depressuring Systems
• API STANDARD 526 - Flanged Steel Pressure-relief Valves
• https://joinoilandgas.com/flares-types-parts-components-operation-and-troubleshooting/
• https://joinoilandgas.com/pressure-relief-safety-valves-prv-psv/
• http://www.mechanicalengineeringsite.com/rupture-disk-types/
• DEP 80.36.00.30-Gen - Relief devices - Selection, sizing and specification
• DEP 80.45.10.10-Gen - Design of pressure relief, flare and vent systems (amendments/supplements to API
RP 520 Part II and API STD 521 Chapter 5)
• DEP 80.46.30.11-Gen - Interlocking systems for pressure relief valves
• PTS 16.52.04 - Design of Pressure Relief, Flare and Vent System
• www.chemicalengineeringworld.com
• www.youtube.com 47