Notes No 3 Risk
Notes No 3 Risk
Risk
of risk.
Every invesiment is characterised by return and risk. The concept
is intuitively understood by investors. In general, it refers to the possibility
of incurring a loss in a financial transaction. But risk involves much more
than that. The word 'risk has a definite financial meaning.
MEANING OF RISK
to get some rehurn fron the
A person making an investment expects
investment in the future. But, as future is uncertain, so is the future expected
return It is this uncertainty associated with the returns from an investment
that introduces risk into an investment.
We can distinguish between the expected retun and the realised return
froin an investment. The expected return is the uncertain future return that
an investor expects to get from his investment. The realised return, on the
contrary, is the certain return that an investor has achually obtained from
his investment at the end of the holding period. The investor makes the
investment decision based on the exped return from the in nt.
The actual return realised from the investment may not correspond to the
expected return. This possibility of variation of the actual returrn from the
expected return is termed risk. Wher realisations correspond to expectations
exactly, there would be no isk. Risk arises where there is a possibility. of.
variation between expectations and reaisations with regard to an investment.
Thus, risk can be definéd in terms of variability of returns. "Risk is the
potential for variability in returns." An investment whose returns are
fairly stable is considered to be a low-risk investment, whereas an investment
whose returns fluctuate significantly is considered to. be a high-risk
investment. Equity shares whose returriS are likely to fluctuate widely are
considered risky imvestmernts. Govermment securities, whose refuns are
fairly stable are considered to possess low risk.
19
20 POATFOLKO MANAGEMENT
ELEMENTS OF RISK
r e t u r n s . This
variation in its
is the
investment factors which
of risk in an factors. These
The essence
number of
variation in retums is caused byfrom a n i n v e s t m e n t constitute the elements
a
in the returns
variations
produce
debentures,
of risk. such as shares,
the risk in holding securities, The
Let us consider into two groups.
The elements of risk may be broadly classified and affect a
etc.
are external to
a company
factors that
first group comprises
are mostly uncontrollable
number of securities simultaneously. These to
large which a r e internal
nature. The second group includes those factors
in
cormpanies. These are controllable
companies and affect only those particular
is known
to a greàt extent. The risk produced by
the first group of factors
is known a s
as and that produced by the second group
systematic risk,
unsystematic risk.
the total risk of
The total variability in returns of a security represents
that security. Systematic risk and unsystematic risk are
the two components
of total risk. Thus,
risk Unsystemaic risk
Total risk =
Systematic +
Systematic Risk
As the society is dynamic, changes occur in the economic, political and
social.systems constantly. These char have an influence on the
performance of companies and thereby 1 their stock prices. But these
changes affect all companie_ and all semauities in varying degrees. For
example, economic and political in1stability adversely affects all industries
and companies. When an economy moves into recession, corporate profits
will shift downwards and stock prices of most companies may decline.
Thus, the impact of economic, political and social changes is system-wide
and that portion of total variability in security returns çaused by such
system-wide factorS -is referred to as systematic risk. Systematic risk is
further subdivided into interest rate risk, market risk, and purchasing
power risk.
Interest Rate Risk
Interest rate risk is a type of systematic risk that particularly affects debt
securities like bonds and debentures. A bond or debenture normally has
a fixed coupon rate of interest. The issuing company pays interest to the
bond holder at this coupon rate. A bond is normaly issued with a coupon
. rate which is equal to the interest rate prevailing in the market at the time
of issue. Subsequent to the issue, the market interest rate may change but
the coupon rate remains constant ill the maturity of th instrument. The
RISK 21
change in market interest rate relative to the coupon rate of a bond caises
changes in its market price.
A bond having a face value of Rs. 100
issued with a coupon rate of ten
is also ten per cent will have
a
market interest rate
per cent when the rate
of Rs. 100. If, subsequert to the issue, the market interest
market price cent
to 12.5 cent; no. inivëstor will buy the bond with ten per
moves up per to
of the bond reduces the price
coupon interest rate untess the holder, of the bond gets
Rs. 80, the purchaser
Rs. 80. Whénthe price is reduced to to a return
80 which is equivalent
interest of Rs. ten on a n investnent of Rs. rate.
the prevailing market interest
of 12.5 per cent which is the s a m e as relation to
rate m o v e s up in
Thus, we that as the market interest
see
Similarly,
rate, the market price of the bond declines.
the coupon interest is a drop.in
move up when there
the market price of the bond would other words, the
market interest rate compared to
the coupon rate. In
to the market
debentures is inversely related
market price of bonds and fluctuates in
of debt securities
market price
interest rates. As. a result, the
This variation in bond
to variations in the market interest rates.
response known as interest
due to the variations in interest rates is
prices caused
rate risk. on stock prices
The interest rate variations have
an indirect impact
ie. purchasing stock on
Speculators often resort to margin trading,
also.
As interest rates increase, margin trading
margin using borrowed funds. push down
becomes less attractive. The lower demand by speculators may
when interest rates fall.
stock prices. The opposite happens finance their operatión. When
companies use borrowed funds to
Many borTOwed funds have to make
interest rates move up, companies using
to lower earnings, dividends and share
higher interest payments. This leads
interest rates nay push up earnrings andd
prices. On the contrary, lower
in interest rates may indirectly influence
prices. Thus, we see that variations
risk which affects bonds
stock prices. Interest rate risk is a systematic
directly and shares indirectly.
Market Risk
Market risk is a type of systematic risk that affects shares. Market prices
of shares move up or down consistently for some time periods. A general
rise in share prices is referred to as a bullish trend, whereas a genieral fal
in share prices is referred to as a bearish trend. In other words, the sháre
market altenates between the biullish phase and the bearish phase. The
alternating movemernts can be easily seen in the movement of share price
indices such as the B^E Sensitive Index, BSE National Index, NSE ndex
etc.
.Business cycles are considered to be a major determinant of the timing
and extent of the bull and bear phases of the market. This would suggest
that the ups and downs in share markets would follow the expansion and
2PORTFOLUO MANAGEMENT
true in the long
r u n , but it
This may be
r e c e s s i o n phase
of the economy. m o v e m e n t s in
the m a r k e t .
short-term
does not sufficiently
explain the market is caused by sweeping
in the stock reactionns
The short-term volatility the result of investor
expectations which
are reaction
changes in investor of the
as intangible events. The basis
to certain tangible as well such a s
events, political, economic or social,
may be a set of real tangible in monetary policy, etc. The change
the fall of a government, drastic change events.
is usually initiated by the reaction to real
in investor expectations emotiornal
the intangible factor of
But the reaction is often aggravated by
and irrationady, leading
instability of investors. They tend to act collectively
to an overreaction.
leads to variatiorns
The stock market is seen to be volatile. This volatility
in the returns of investors in shares. The variation in returns
caused by the
volatilityy of the stock market is eferred to as the markef risk.
Purchasing Power Risk
Another type of systematic risk is the purchasing power risk. It refers tao
the variation in investor returns caused by inflation.
When
nflationresults in lowering of the purchasing power of
an investor purchases a
money.
security, he foregoes the opportunity to buy sorme
goods or services. In other words, he is postponing his consumption.
Meanwhile, if there is infiation in the economy, the prices of goods arLd
services would increase and thereby the investor acttualy experiences a
decline in the purchasing power of his invesiments and the return fron
the investment. Let us consider a
simple exnple. Suppose a person lends
Rs. 100 today at ten per cent interest. e winili
get back Rs. 110 after one
year. If during the year, the prices have mcreased by eight per
Rs. 110 received at the end cent
of the year wi hav a purchasing power of
only Rs. 101.20, ie. 92 per cent of Rs. 110. Xtns, inflation causes a variation
in the purchasing
power of the returns from an nvestment. This is known
as
purchasing power risk and its impact is wniformly felt on all securities
in the market and as such, is a
The two important sources of
systematic risk.
inflation are rising costs of
and excess demarnd
for goods and production
are known as cost-push and
services in relation to their
supply. They
demand-pull inflation
supply cannot be increased,respectively.
demand is increasing but When
increases thereby forcing out some of the excess demandprice of the goodss
and bringing the
demand and supply into
equilibrium. This phenomenonis known as demand
pull inflation. Cost push inflation occurs
increases and this încrease in cost is passedwhen the cost of production
on to the consumers
producers
n an,
through higher prices öf goods.
by the
inflationary economy, rational, investors would include arn
allowance for the purchasing
a e of power risk in their estimate of the
retum from an investunent. In
refurn would be
expected
other words, the expected rate of
adjusted upwards by the estimated annual rate of
inflation
FISK 223
Unsystematic Risk
factors
The retyurns from a security may sometimes vary because ofarecertain
raw material
affecting only the company issuing such security. Examples
labour strike, management inefficiency. When variability of returns
scarcity, it is known as unsystematic
occurs because of such firm-specific factors,
industry and affects
risk. This risk is unique or.peculiar to a company or
all securities.
it in addition to the systematic risk affecting from
The unsystematic or urnique risk affecting
specific securitjes arises the
(6)
two sources: (a) the operating
ènvironment of the company, and
unsystematic
company. These two types of
financing pattern adopted by the isk respectively.
risk and financial
risk are referred to as business
Business Risk
environment. This
within a particular operating
Every company operates internal environment within
the
environment comprises. both of thesé
operating
firm arnd external environment
outside the firm. The impact
costs of the company.
conditions is refected in the operating
operating fixed costs and variable costs.
costs can be segregated into. the
The operating disadvantageous toa company. If
costs is
A larger proportion of fixed to s o m e reason or
the other,
of such a company declines due
total decline in its operaing profits
r e v e n u e
debt.
. ,
4 PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT
MEASUREMENT OF RISK
that he
to anticipate the kind of risk
An intelligent investor would
attempt
to estimate the
extent of risk
He would also attempt
i_ likely to face. proposals. In other words, he tries
to
associated with different investment before
risk of each investment that he considers
quantiky the
is thus necessary for
measure o r
R=
RForecasted dividend +Forecasted end of the period stock price
Initial investrient
175
RR= Rs. Rs. Rs.
5+
120 1 = 0.5 or 50er KNT
In this case the investor expects s get a retum of 50 per cent in the
future. But the future is uncertain. The diridend declared by the company
may turn out to be either more or less thar1 the figuie anticipated by the
investor. Similarly, the selling price of the stock may be less than the price
anticipated by the investor at the time of investment. It may sometimes be
even more. Thus, there is a possibility that the future return may be mor
than 50 per cent or less than 50 per cent. Since the future is uncertain the
investorhas to consider the probability of several other possible returns.
The expected returns may be 30 per cent, 40 per cent, 50 per cent, 60 per cent
or 70 per cent. The investor now has to assign the probabílity of occurrence
of. these poss+bBe alternative returns. An example is given below:
Possible
.
returns (in per cent) Probability of occurrence
PRAD
30 0.10
40 :0.30
50 040
60 0.10
0.10
RISK 25
Expected Returr
The expected return of the investmernt is the probability weighted.average
are denoted by X, and the
of all the possible returns. If the possible returns
be represented as
related probabilities are p(X), the expected return may
a n d can be calculated as:
Xp(X) = 48.0
example.
calculations in the c a s e of our
the required
The table below provides
Product
Deviatiom
Probability
Deviation ( Kp(X)
Possible (X-X squared
retura p(X (X-
X 32.4
-18 324
0.10 19.2
30 64
0.30 8 1.6
40
50 0.40 14.4
12 144
60 0.10 48.4
484
70 0.10 22
= 116.0
root
Standard deviation is the square 10.77 per cent.
example is.116
=
in our
a. The standard deviatiorn
the extent of variability
variance and standard deviation measure
The other measures such
returns from the expected returrn Several
of possíble used to
semi-variance and m e a n
absulte deviation have been
as range, most popularly accepted
measure
standard deviatiox1. Faa benn the
risk, but
measure. distribution of possible
In the method described above. he robability
propOsal is t
investment expected return
to stimate the
returns from a n valuee
i}em e a n gives the expected
from the investnent and its variability.
deviaticn gives the variability. This widely
and the variance or standard
risk is known as the mean-variance approach
used procedure for assessing
a m e a s u r e of
The standard deviation or variance, however, provides
Total risk comnprises of two
the total risk associated with a security.
components, namely systematic risk and uunsystematic risk. Unsystematic risk
risk is risk which unique to a company. Unsystemnatic
is specific or
can bé reduced by
associated with the security of a particuBar company
characteristics. This
combining it with another security having opposite As a result of
process is known as diversification of investment. with
diversification, the învestment is spread over a group of securities
different characteristics. This group of securities is called a' portfolio:
AS far as an investor is concerned, the unsystematic risk is not very
be reduced or eliminated through diversification. It is
important as it can
AUSK 27
where
Correlation coefficient betweern the retiarns of stock i and the
T
returns of the market index. .
Standard deviation of returns of stock i.
o Standard deviation of returns of the market index.
o=Variance of the market returns.
The second method of calculating beta is by using the regression method.
The regression model postulates a linear relationship betweena dependent
variable and an independent variable. The model helps to calculate the
vauès of two constants, namely a and B. B measures the change in the
dependent variable in response to unit change in the independent variable
while a measures the value of the dependent variable even when the
independent variable has zero' value. The form of the regression equation
is asfollows:
Y= a+ BX
28 PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT
where Dependent
variable.
Y =
X Independent variable.
constants. below.
a and ß are
of a and B a r e given
calculation
used for the
The formula
'a Y-BX
A nXY-(EXYE)
nEX-(EX
where
n Number of items. variable scores.
= Mean value of the dependent
Y variable scores.
X = Mean value of independent
Dependent variable
scores.
Y=
scores.
X Independent variable
security is
=
individual
the return of the
For the calculation of beta, the market
index iS
variable, and the return of
taken as the dependent variable. The regression equation is represented
taken as the independent
as follows:
R;= a +BR»
where
individual secuzity.
R=Return of the
market index.
R Return of the market is stationary.
of the secuiity nhen the
return
a =Estimated in response to unit
in the return of the indivicdiiai security
B Change the measure
of the narkei index. It is, thus,
change in the return
of systematic risk of a security.
or zero.
A security can have betas that are positive, negative
of that asset
The beta of asset, B, is a measure of the variability
an
index of the
relative to the variabiity of
the market as a whole. Beta is an
asset."2
systematic risk of an the
As beta m e a s u r e s the volatility
of a security's returns relative to
1.0
volatile the security. A beta öf
market, the larger the beta, the more 1.0 has
risk. A stock with beta greater than
indicates a seçurity of average market
would be more volatile than the
above average risk. Its returns
For example, when market
returns. returns move up by five per cent, a
stock with beta of 1.5 would find its returns moving up by 7.5 per cent (i.e.
five per cent would produce
5 x1.5). Similarly, decline in market returns by
decline of 7.5 per cent in the return of the
individual security.
a
below average risk. Variability
have
A stock with beta less than 1.0 would lesser
than the market variability.
in its returns would be comparatively
move in a directiorn
Beta can also be negative, implying that the stock returns
opposite to that of the market returns.
RISK29
Solution
25 0.05
0.10
-10
0.10
15 0.15.
0.25
20
30 0:20
35. 0.15
i':.***i, *****
PORTFOLJO MANÃGEMENT
30
Solutio
Calculation of Expected Return
Product
Possible returns Probability Kpp (Xi)
-1.25
-25
0.05
-1.00
0.10
0.00
0.10
225
15 0.15
5.00
20 0.25
6.00
30 020
5.25
35 0.15
16.25
Variance, o =
2[(X - Xp{X)] = 274.69 per cent
Standard deviation, o =
N274.69 =1657 per cent"
Example3 A stock costing Rs. 120 pays no dividends. The possible prices
that the stock might sell for at the end of the year with the respective
probabilities are
AISK 31
Po
Returns
Calculation of Probable
CP- PoUPod x 100
Possible prices (P) P-Po Return per cent)
Rs. Rs.
4.17
115
0.00
120
5 4.17
125
10
8.33
130
12.50
15
135 16.67
140 20
Return
Calculation of Excpected
Product
Probable return Probability
p(X) Xp(X
-0.417
4.17 0.1
0.1 0.000
0.00
4.17 02 0.834
0.3 2.499
8.33
2500
12.50. 02
0.1 1.667
16.67
**
X 7.o83
*
32PORTFOLJO MANAGEMENT
Deviation of Returns
Calculation of Standard
Deviation Product
Probable return Probability Deviation
squared
(X- KPp(X)
p(X
12656 12.66
-4.17 0.1 -11.25
-7.08 50.13 5.01
0.00 0.1
8.47 1.69
4.17 0:2 -2.91
1.25 1.56 0.47
833 0.3
12.50 0.2 5.42 29:38 5.88
. 16.67 959 91.97 9.20
o= 34.91
55 12 27.91
60 17 39-53
Variance, o 33.76
=
funds
cent on borrowed
Less: Interest at the rate of 12 per
8600x 12 =
1,032.00
100100
Net returns 2,592.90
' ** .*
34 POATFOLIO' MANAGEMENT
formula:
Solution Correlation coefficient is calculated with the following
where
X = Ore datà series (R).
Y = Other data series (R).
= Number of iterns.
Calculation of Correlation Coefficiern
FTC reiurns BSE Index return
Y2 XY
Y (R X (R
54.91 69.88
9.43 7A1 88.92 00.00
0.00 -5.33 O0.00 28.41
-4.31 -7.35 18.58 54.02 31.68
- 18.92 -14.64 357.97 214.33 276.99
-6.67 1.58 44.49 2.50 -10.54
26.57 15.19 705.96 230.74 403.60
20.00 5.11 400.00 26.11 102.20
2.93 0.76 8 58 0.58 2.23
5.25 0.97 27.55 0.94 -5.09
2145 10.44 $.19 108.99 223.94
23.13 1747 535.00 305.20 404.08
32.83 20.15 406.02 661.52
111.69 4982 323. 1432-75 2160.49
25,925.88-5564.40
17193-2482.0344,699.64 12, 474.66
20,361.448 20,36148
14,710.97 x 32,224.98 21,772.94
r =0.935
Standard deviation,.and varianice can be calculated by using the following
formula
**
AUSK 35
NEX(EXY
Standard deviation, o = N
where
X-Original data.
N Nwnber of items.
Standard deviation of FTC returns From the above table, the following
data are available:
N = 12
ER =111.69 ER? = 3724.97
44,699.64- 12,474.66
(12 x3724.97-(111.69)2 144
12x 12
=223.78 = 14.96
2 (12x 1432.75)-(49.82)2
12 x 12
17.193-2482.0314,710.97 102.16
144 144
o = 102.16 = 10.11
Beta
Om
(0.935)(14.96 x 10.11) 141.41
102.16 102.16
B-1.384
Example 6 With the data given in example 5, calculate beta of ITC stock,
using the'regression model.
Solution
Dependent variable Y = R;
Independent variable X = R
2 111.6=931
12
" 4.15
anEXY-(2X)2)
P nEX2 - (EX
17,193-2482.03
20,361.48
14,710.97
B 1.384
= 9.31 - 5.74 3 . 5 7
ONGC stock and the
7 Monthly return data (n per cerat) for
Example ure sesented below:
12 month perkxd
.
NSE Indez
Month
-0.35
.7
-0.49
5.45
-1.03
-3.05
1.64
3.41
6.67
9.13
5 1.13
2.36
6 0.72
-0.42
0.84
5.51
4.05
6.80
1.21
2.60
10 0.29
-3.81
11 -1.96
1.91
12
ONGC stock."
Calculate and beta for the
alpha cent next
to move up by 15 per
NSE index is expected from ONGC?
2 Suppose would you expect
month. How much return
RISK 37
Solution Since alpha and beta of the stock are to be calculated, the
regression model nay be u_ed.
Calculation of a and ß of ctock
nXY- (2XEY)
B nEX-(EX2
25.32)
(12x107.55)- (12.72
x
(12x 72.89)
-
(12.72)
= 1290.60-322.07 968.53
874.68-161.80 712.88
B 1.359
a= -BR
-(1:359) 2
(1.359) (1.06) 2.11- 1.44 =0.67a d
= 2.11
NSE inderm
The expected relum fron ONGC .pajadxa s,J0}sAAUI
stock when YISeJE
io]saAuI
uy
aIeu
R=0.67 +1.359PR ( 9
uoy
paSAjEue
pue sey
Saop su
req
3ou
"***
*
38 POATFOLIO MANAGEMENT
we get
R as 15 in the equation,
Substituting
the value of 21.055
0.67 + 20.385
=
1.359 (15)
=
0.67 +
Ri
EXERCISES
deviation of retuns
atandard
return and thé
Caleulate the expected distribution:
3. stock having the
following probability
for a
Probability of
Probable Occurrence
returns (per cent)
0.05
-24 0.15
- 10
0.15
0.20
12
0.20
18
0.15
22
0.10
30 4**wraN********
the.
possible prices that
.
n o diviclevc~s.
The
2 . A stock costing Rs. 250 pays of he ycar and the probability of éach
the end
stock might sell for at
are:
Possible prises (Rs.)
Probability
0.10
200
.25
230
0.35
250
0.20
280
0.10
310
cted return?
returns?
deviation of the
There
k for a one-year holding period.
will sell
currently selling at Rs. 60,
on
A. The investor c a n borrow '
4Monthly return data (in per cent) for IPCL stock and the NSE index for
a 12 month period are presented below:
Month IPCL NSE Tndex
10.27 11.00
9.31 3.69
6.73 4.20
-5.68 4.93
2.60 3.05
2.86 5.88
7 3.74
2.78
8 3.84 2.63
-2.10
9 -6.51 -21.35
10 -23.42
11 0.00 -4.55
2.80
12 6.64
REFERENCESS
389,
1.. Ramesh K.S. Rao, Fundamentals of Financial Managemen, p.
Macmillan, New York, 1989.
2. Tbid., p: 416.