Factor Influencing Nurses Job Satisfaction Attending in Hargiesa Group Hospitals, Hargeisa Somaliland
Factor Influencing Nurses Job Satisfaction Attending in Hargiesa Group Hospitals, Hargeisa Somaliland
SUBNITTED BY:
NUURAABDI DAHIR.
ADVISOR:
HARGEISA SOMALILAND
MAY, 2022
I
Approval
This thesis report is submitted for review with my approval as an advisor of the candidates.
Signature____________________
NAWAL ABDIRAHMAN
(DEAN SCHOOL OF NURSING )
MAY, 2022
Signature____________________
Signature:_____________________
II
DECLARATION
We, the undersigned, declare that this thesis book is our original work and has not been
presented for a Degree in any other University and that all sources of material used for the
assessment report have been duly acknowledged.
Names signature
1. Najma Mahamed Abdillahi _________________________________
2. Salma Abdirahman Jama ________________________________
3. Ayaan Abdirashid Mohamed _________________________________
4. Faysa Khaliif ismaciil _________________________________
5. Nuura Abdi Dahir _________________________________
MAY,2022
III
DEDICATION
This work is dedications to our to our beloved parents who give us a continuous support during
our study in bachelor degree of nursing, success is in our side, because we have parents like you,
besides dedicated to our dear brothers and sisters.
IV
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We would like to first thank the Almighty Allah who has made this study possible. Without this generous
support, nothing would have been achieved. We would also like to express our sincere gratitude and
appreciate to (MRS. Yasmin Abdi Sooran) who provided tangible supervision and support throughout
our study. His kind criticism and moral support made us to reach to this level without his technical skills
and professionalism, this proposal would not have been as strong as it is now.
We must also give deep thanks to the staffs of Edna Adan University and also we express our gratitude to
Mrs. Nawal Abdirahman Dean, Department of nursing.
We also give thanks and respect to our beloved family fathers and mothers who have been with us all the
time, providing 100% of support and motivation. We also wish to appreciate the honourable participants
of this project, from their endless support during the writing and multiple visits for collecting the data.
We cannot forget the entire administration and management of Edna Aden University. Also, we cannot
forget to thank our class-mates who were inspirational and supportive throughout our study
V
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
HR Human Resource
VI
LIST OF TABLES
Table 4: How the remuneration influence Nurse’s job satisfaction in Hargeisa Group of Hospital
Table 5: Influence of opportunity for personal advancement on nurse's job satisfaction in HGH
Table 6: Descriptive statistics of working conditions, remuneration and personal development
Opportunity of nurses in Hargiesa Group Hospital
Table7: The correlation of overall respondent result in Hargeisa Group of Hospital, Hargeisa
Somaliland,
VII
ABSTRACT
Background:
Job satisfaction is a feeling of fulfilment or enjoyment that a person derives from their job., which is
widely discussed and studied because it aims at the physical and mental well-being of individual
employees not only from the angle of organizational psychology, but also, from the angle of
organizational management and human resource management, concerns with establishing policies for
management to improve employees' job satisfaction and their job-related behaviour and, hence, to
improve the productivity and profitability of organizations(1).
Objectives:
The main objective of this study is the factors influencing nurses job satisfaction attending Hargiesa
Group hospital, in Hargeisa Somaliland
Methodology:
A cross sectional analytic study was used for raising question of the Presence of an association of the
factors influencing nursesjob satisfaction in Hargiesa Group Hospital its very suitable for this study
because its one step one time collection of data, and less expensive and more expedient to conduct.
Result
Table 6 show us the working conditions mean (3.7722)(std .78925) also the remuneration of nurses were
(3.8481)(.99154) and the working Opportunity were (3.9108)(.89425)
Recommendation
We recommendthe ministry of health MOHD and Hargeisa group of hospitals management team
to provide better working conditions for the nurses to increase their job satisfaction.
Conclusion
According correlation analysis was conducted to examine whether there is a relationship between
working conditions with remuneration. The results revealed that there was a significant and positive
relationship between the nurse's working conditions and remuneration = 0.314 condition and nurse's
opportunity
VIII
Contents
Approval..................................................................................................................................................II
DECLARATION.............................................................................................................................................III
DEDICATION...............................................................................................................................................IV
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS...............................................................................................................................V
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS.............................................................................................................................VI
Table 2: Distribution of respondents by the demographic information nurses.....................................VII
CHAPTER ONE:.............................................................................................................................................1
INTRODUCTION...................................................................................................................................1
1.2 Problem statements..........................................................................................................................3
1.3 Significance........................................................................................................................................4
1.4 General objective...............................................................................................................................4
1.4.1 Specific objectives.......................................................................................................................4
1.5 Research Questions...........................................................................................................................4
CHAPTER TWO:............................................................................................................................................6
LITERATURE REVIEW................................................................................................................................6
2.1 Introduction.......................................................................................................................................6
2.2 Concept of Job Satisfaction................................................................................................................6
2.3 Influence of Working Conditions and nurse's Job Satisfaction in Hargeisa Group Hospital...............6
2.4 Influence of Remuneration on nurse’s Job Satisfaction in Hargeisa Group Hospital.........................7
2.5 Influence of Opportunity for Personal Advancement on nurse's Job satisfaction in HGH Hargeisa
Group Hospital........................................................................................................................................7
2.7 Summary............................................................................................................................................9
2.8 Conceptual framework......................................................................................................................9
CHAPTER THREE:.......................................................................................................................................11
METHODOLOGY.................................................................................................................................11
3.1 Study area........................................................................................................................................11
3.2 Study period....................................................................................................................................11
IX
3.3 Study design........................................................................................................................................11
3.4 Study population.................................................................................................................................11
3.5 Sample size......................................................................................................................................11
3.5.1 Sample technique.........................................................................................................................12
3.6 Inclusion and exclusion Criteria.......................................................................................................12
3.6.1 Inclusion criteria.......................................................................................................................12
3.6.2 Exclusion criteria.......................................................................................................................12
3.7 Variables..........................................................................................................................................12
3.8 Data collection techniques and tools...............................................................................................12
3.9 Operational Definitions of Variables................................................................................................13
3.10 Data processing and analysis.............................................................................................................13
3.11 Pre-Test.........................................................................................................................................13
3.12 Ethical consideration.........................................................................................................................13
3.13 Dissemination................................................................................................................................14
PRESENTATION AND DISCUSSION OF THE STUDY RESULTS...................................................................15
4.0 Introduction.....................................................................................................................................15
4.1 Socio- Demographic Characteristics of respondents.......................................................................15
Table 2. Distribution of respondents by the demographic information nurses (n=158) in....................16
4.2 Influence of working conditions on nurse's job satisfaction in Hargeisa Group of Hospital............16
CHAPTER FIVE:...........................................................................................................................................22
SUMMARYOF FINDINGS, DISCUSSION, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS..............................22
5.1 Introduction.....................................................................................................................................22
5.2 Summary of the findings..................................................................................................................22
5.2.1 The influence of working conditions on nurse’s jobsatisfaction...................................................22
5.2.2 The influence of remuneration on nurse's job satisfaction...........................................................22
5.2.3 The influence of opportunity for personal advancement on health workers’ job satisfaction.....22
5.3 DISCUSSIONS OF FINDINGS............................................................................................................22
5.3.2 The influence of remuneration on health workers’ job satisfaction.........................................22
5.3.3 The influence of opportunity for personal advancement on health workers’ job satisfaction. 22
5.5 Recommendations of the study ......................................................................................................22
SECTION A: DEMOGRAPHIC DATA.............................................................................................................22
SECTION B: WORKING CONDITIONS AND NURSES JOB SATISFACTION IN HGH.......................................22
X
SECTION C: REMUNERATION AND NURSES JOB SATISFACTION IN HGH...................................................22
SSECTION D: OPPORTUNITY FOR PERSONAL ADVANCEMENT AND NURSES JOB SATISFACTION IN HGH..22
XI
XII
CHAPTER ONE:
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background
Job satisfaction is a feeling of fulfilment or enjoyment that a person derives from their job.,
which is widely discussed and studied because it aims at the physical and mental well-being of
individual employees not only from the angle of organizational psychology, but also, from the
angle of organizational management and human resource management, concerns with
establishing policies for management to improve employees' job satisfaction and their job-related
behaviour and, hence, to improve the productivity and profitability of organizations(1). Many
studies are based on the assumption that job satisfaction and job competence are interwoven. In
other words, people who are satisfied with their jobs tend to perform better.
The World Health organization report in 2006 shows that nursing can be characterized as a
mobile profession. It shows that majority of the nurses especially women migrate in search of
better working conditions and salary, career mobility, better quality of life, personal safety,
sometimes for adventure or for professional development(2).
An approximated amount of 30,000 African nurses are currently employed in seven,
Organisations for Economic Co-operation and Development OECD countries (3).However, there
are barriers that limit the migration of nurses and these same factors may affect the foreign
nurses that had already moved and acquired jobs in foreign countries. These factors include;
adapting to new clinical skills, process of requalification, need to learn a new language, cultural
differences and cost of physical transfer(4)
The prevalence of global shortage of nurses and high turnover among nurses has become a major
problem in the society today in both developed and developing countries. It affects the efficiency
and the effectiveness of the health services being offered and also consumes a lot of time and
resource trying to replace the workers who have left. In regard to this, the question of job
satisfaction sets in(5).
Nursing is a demanding profession, whereby the nurse is responsible of promoting health in the
society, maintaining health, taking care of patients and the family and a duty to ensure a healthy
environment. Nursing is a very important part of the health care system. Nurses are present in
hospitals, rehabilitation centres, nursing homes, outpatient centres, clinics, schools and homes (6).
1
In any Job setting, nurse work plays an important role for organizational achievements. Thus, it
is very important for management to recognize employees' work and provide them with an
opportunity to grow and to look after their well-being. It is true that work has predominantly
occupied most of employees' time than any other single activities, and it also provides an
economic well-being. Therefore, job satisfaction is one of the most important areas of research
for many researchers (7) .
There is high migration of nurses from different countries in search for jobs and also many
international students who are studying abroad. And therefore one has to adapt to the new
culture, which is part of his or her new environment. Culture has a great influence on
relationships with the people that surround us in all areas of our lives including work. At the
place of work the foreign nurse interacts with the patient, the employer and co-worker and these
relationships have an influence on the job satisfaction of the nurse. Every culture has its own
way of delivering care and doing things and to some extent have a contribution to how an
individual reacts and see things (8)
In Denmark, several companies regularly conduct their own job satisfaction surveys and an
employee satisfaction index has been computed for a number of European countries. The
European Union has called the attention of member states to the quality aspects of work and
highlighted the importance of improving job quality to promote employment and social
inclusion(9)
Kenya remains committed to making significant improvements in its human resources for health
situation. However, the country will not achieve the ambitious health milestones set, including
achieving the Millennium Development Goals, without improving the quality, quantity and
distribution of the health workforce. Skilled providers, health workers, nurses and midwives,
assist in only 44% of births, and there are great inequalities in access to health services across
provinces, speaking, the Central region and Nairobi are deemed to have the best facilities,
whereas the North-Eastern region is the most underdeveloped and therefore has the fewest health
facilities. Poor people in rural areas who are ill and choose to seek care usually only have the
option of treatment at primary care facilities. These facilities are often understaffed and
underequipped and have limited drugs and other medical supplies (10)
2
1.2 Problem statements
According the 2014 data from National development plan II (NDPII) the 'Somaliland Women of
reproductive age mortality Survey,' the maternal mortality rate is less than 416 per 100,000 live
births, under-five death rate was 91 per 1,000 live births in 2011, with infant mortality rates of 71
per 1,000 live births179 and neonatal mortality rates of 41 per 1,000 live births (11).
Many variables may have contributed to these accomplishments, including low socioeconomic
status, weak health sectors, and unskilled health staff. It's also linked to a low level of health
care professionals job satisfaction. Job satisfaction is an important factor. Many academic fields,
including psychology, sociology, economics, and management sciences, have investigated job
satisfaction, It has been discovered through research(12)
Therefore In Somaliland, national surveys show a positive trend in terms of health-related issues,
Report Ministry of health development of Somaliland (MOHD) in year 2011 that there was a
shortage of qualified health professionals as a result of war and immigration law socio-economic
status, weak health sectors, health workers work very short hours and attribute this low wage
performance assessment is weak, lack of work promotion and preferential treatment and salaries
are extremely low and this lead to employees spending less time at work These factors effect
woman productive and health of infants(13)
The global scarcity of nurses, as well as high turnover among nurses, has become a major
problem in both developed and developing countries today(14).
The importance of job satisfaction by practicing nurses in increasing the steadiness of the
workforce and addressing the challenges of high turnover and shortage of nurses is undeniable(15)
Generally In 2006 study Naguru Hospital in Kampala Uganda the main factors influencing nurse
job satisfaction were fairness, salary and responsibility and workload (16). Another study in Kenya
speciality public Hospital in Mombasa, kwale and kilic countries factors influencing job
satisfaction low salaries, working poor environment workload and fairness (17) .In the above
countries, when we see Somaliland, there is nothing better than the problem.
The World health report 2006 shows that many countries the salaries of nursing are below the
minimum living wage. Since equal pay will be hard to achieve in many countries, health workers
3
will search for ways to supplement their low income. Remuneration policies should be carefully
developed bearing in mind the interests of the management and society at large(18)
Therefore, this thesis book was focuse on assessing the factors affecting the job satisfaction
nurses attending Hargiesa Group Hospital. Hargeisa, Somaliland. Results from this study will be
helpful government which is involved on the effectiveness of healthcare delivery, hence
improving it.
1.3 Significance
Several problematic aspects in the delivery of excellent services have influenced the nurses and
continue to do so. As a result, the quality of nurse services provided has decreased, reducing
nurse work satisfaction and, as a result, reducing patient satisfaction. Policymakers and other
healthcare stakeholders will be able to use the findings of this study to pinpoint particular areas
where nurses' job satisfaction needs to be improved. Other scholars and academicians may find
the information gathered useful in the future. The study could be highly useful because it will
add to the existing literature for the government, which is interested in increasing healthcare
delivery efficacy. The researcher will be able to examine the elements that influence nurses as a
result of this investigation.
The main objective of this study was factors influencing job satisfaction nurses attending
Hargiesa Group hospital, in Hargeisa Somaliland
4
1.5 Research Questions
5
CHAPTER TWO:
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Introduction
This chapter outlines the concept of job satisfaction, working conditions and nurse's job
satisfaction and job satisfaction, remuneration and employee job satisfaction, opportunity for
personal advancement and employee job satisfaction. The chapter also presents summary of
literature review and the conceptual framework of the study,
According to(20) he defines fairness as equal treatment, receiving the same services and benefits
as other people.
Defined working condition as: “working conditions are created by the interaction of nurse
employee with their organizational climate, and includes psychological as well as physical
working conditions’’ Therefore, working conditions refers to the working environment and
aspects of an employee’s terms and conditions of employment (21).
6
According to (22)work conditions are defined as an employee’s work place, work instruments, the
work itself, organization policy, and organizational rules. Arnold and Feldman (1996), promoted
factors such as temperature, lighting, ventilation, hygiene, noise, working hours, and resources as
part of working conditions. The worker would rather desire working conditions that will result in
greater physical comfort and convenience. The absence of such working conditions, amongst
other things, can impact poorly on the worker’s mental and physical well-being (23)
Advocates that working conditions will influence job satisfaction, as employees are concerned
with a comfortable physical work environment. In turn this will render a more positive level of
job satisfaction. (22)
The World health report 2006 shows that in many countries the salaries of health workers are
below the minimum living wage and that the pay levels of public sector workers are often unfair
compared to others in similar jobs (25). Since equal pay will be hard to achieve in many countries,
health workers will search for ways to supplement their low income. Certain principles have to
be adhered to: job descriptions should be periodically checked and kept up to date; remuneration
policies should be carefully developed bearing in mind the interests of the management,
satisfaction of nurses employees and the society at large.
7
are making career progress, promotions refers to a sign of assignment from a job at a lower level
to another at a higher level within the organization (26). Spector carried out a study on local
authorities employees in Britain and found out that employees were likely to be satisfied by their
ability to harness and input into work planning, opportunity to show initiative, ability to have a
say in management decisions, a feeling that their local authority kept them well informed and
that any change was well communicated to them on time. (27)
Explained that the shortage of nurses is a worldwide phenomenon and is a contributing factor to
resignations and nurses leaving the profession(28). In Hong Kong the nursing profession is highly
valued, due to its high pay and job security, however the shortage of nurses and increased
turnover have increased over decades (29).
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development report indicated that Norway,
Denmark, Finland and Swaziland have the highest number of nurses per capita with a ratio of 14
nurses or more per 1 000 of the population, while Colombia, Indonesia and Brazil had less than
1.5 nurses per 1 000. In Turkey, job satisfaction among nurses is at a moderate level with an
average satisfaction level of 58%(30). These authors identified poor working conditions, adverse
perceptions of the nursing profession, contingent rewards, fringe benefits and pay as the main
causes of job dissatisfaction in this country
In Indonesia the average job satisfaction among nurses we rerated at a level of 48% (26). Japan had
the highest rate of dissatisfied nurses with 66%, followed by China with 55%, South Korea with
50% and UK with 42% (25).
The East African nurses show high levels of somatic complaints, and nearly one‐third of the
sample would be labelled as burned out. In comparison with a Western European nurses
reference group, the nurses score unfavourably on job conditions that require financial
investment (e.g. workload, staffing, equipment and materials). On aspects related to the social
climate (e.g. decision latitude, cooperation), however, they score more favourably. In
comparison with private hospital nurses, public hospital nurses score similarly on aspects related
8
to the social climate, but worse on the other job conditions. Public hospital nurses have a lower
job satisfaction than private hospital nurses, but show comparable levels of somatic complaints
and burnout. Strongest correlates of low job satisfaction are low supervisor support and low
financial reward. Burnout is mainly associated with high workload and inadequate information
provision, whereas somatic complaints are associated with demanding physical working
conditions(31).
Lastly, Opportunity for advancement Employees are more motivated when they have fascinating
projects to work on and prospects for growing responsibility. This is because people prefer to
feel like they're progressing in their careers. Employees were likely to be satisfied by their ability
to harness and input into work planning, as well as having a say in management decisions (26).
2.7 Summary
The main goal of this chapter was to examine characteristics that influence nurse job satisfaction
by reviewing literature authored by diverse experts from around the world. This chapter briefly
discussed the history of job satisfaction as well as theories linked to job satisfaction. The job
happiness of nurses in South Africa and around the world was investigated. Finally, the chapter
discussed job satisfaction's implications on registered nurses, the organization, and patient care,
as well as elements that influence job satisfaction.
9
Independent variable( IV)
Working conditions .
Organizational workload
Physical working condition
Sufficient equipment
Remuneration.
DepedentvariDependent variable (DV)
Pay system
NURSES JOB
Salary structure
Special awards SATISFACTION
10
CHAPTER THREE:
METHODOLOGY
3.1 Study area
This study was conducted in Hargeisa group hospital which located in the western part of
Hargeisa and it’s a part of 26 June district, Hargiesa city, also is the largest hospital in
Somaliland, the hospital was established in 1953.
N= population
11
n= sample
So
Formula n=N/1+N(e)2
n= 260/1+260(0.05)2
=260/1+260(0.0025)
=260/1.65
=157.57
3.7 Variables
Independent variable:
Dependent variable
12
The dependent variable was nurse job satisfaction in the Hargiesa Group of Hospital.
Working condition the physical surround the job that make specific demands of an
employee’s capacity
Nurses remunerations a faire process to reward people according to their satisfaction
contra
Opportunity is process of enabling nurses acquire skills in their areas of specialization.
13
3.11 Pre-Test
The questionnaire in this study were pretested in a similar locality to check for its quality,
validity and consistency and to ensure that feedback for improving the questions are obtained
and for data collectors get an exposure of what kind of data they might obtain.Thepre-test were
done by giving the questionnaire to the nurses staff working in Edna Adan Hospital
3.13 Dissemination
The finding of the study was presented at Edna Adan University it was also disseminate in
Hargiesa Group Hospital
14
CHAPTER FOUR:
The range is determined by (5- 1=4) and then divided by five as it is the biggest value of the
scale (4/5=0.80) since the question items used in the questionnaire were constructed according to
the 5-point Likert scale to establish the lowest and maximum length of the 5-point Likert type
scale. Following that, number one, which is the scale value, was added to determine the
maximum value of the first cell, and a similar approach was followed for the subsequent cells.
The length of the cells is calculated as follows:
15
Table 1: Scoring range of likert scale of the survey.
Value Mean Interpretation
1 1-1.80 Highly dissatisfied
2 1.81-2.60 Dissatisfied
3 2.61-3.40 Neutral
4 3.41-4.20 Satisfied
5 4.21-5.00 Highly satisfied
16
Master 9 5.7%
PhD 0 0%
Total 158 100%
Professional experience 1-5 107 67.7%
6-10 35 22.2%
11-15 12 7.6%
16 and above 4 2.5%
Total 158 100%
Table 3 demonstrates results about the factors influencing job satisfaction nurses attending in
Hargeisa Group Hospital in Hargeisa Somaliland, which is 14.6% of the respondents agreed to
that hospital environment determine workers ability to do their job effectively and efficiently
while 85.4% disagreed to the question , while 14.6% of the study participant’s respond states that
they have responded positively to the researcher’s question relating to the design features of the
work place and how it affects the employees job satisfaction, while 85.4% of the study
participant’s responded negatively to his particular questions. While Statement mean responses
on the influencing of working condition of nursing job satisfaction that (1.6709)(std
0.63289)were highly dissatisfied with work relationships with people around them. Also
(2.6013)(st1.59992)were l were dissatisfied with working environment of the hospital.(2.4177)
(std 1.15221)were dissatisfied with their overall job security .(2.5886)(std:1.45912) also they
were dissatisfied with their job location.(3.5570)(std:1.15925) were satisfied of work conditions
is significant factor affecting job satisfaction.(2.5000)(std:1.53826) dissatisfied that they were
satisfied with relation of their colleagues. (2.3608) (std:1.44195) were dissatisfied with the
organizational culture. .(2.6013)(st:1.46700) also dissatisfied with their condition of employee
17
Table 3; Influence of working conditions on nurse's job satisfaction in Hargeisa Group of
Hospital, Hargeisa Somaliland, May 2022 (1= highly dissatisfied 2=dissatisfied 3=neutral
4=satisfied 5=highly satisfied)
18
employment?
Polled mean and std 2.5372 1.3063 Dissatisfied
Table 4.How the remuneration influence Nurse’s job satisfaction (n=158) in Hargeisa
Group of Hospital, Hargeisa Somaliland, May 2022 (1= highly dissatisfied 2=dissatisfied
3=neutral 4=satisfied 5=highly satisfied).
19
No extent 67 42.4%
20
4.4Influence of opportunity for personal advancement on nurse's job
satisfaction in HGH
Table5 Shows that mean (4.1962)(st:.94740)are satisfied that fulfilling abilities gives them a
feeling of satisfaction and personal achievement .(3.6582)(std1.19585) are satisfied that they
are satisfied and able to minimum a healthy balance between work and family life . (3.7532)
(st:1.23478) also are satisfied that human resource department is always notified of the
promotion vacancies . (3.8291)(st:1.18479) were satisfied which means some were agree while
others disagree that promotion is done on merit while (3.8038)(st:1.16454) are also satisfied
that promotion is accompanied by pay rise. According the frequency and percentage shows , that
118(74.7%) said yes that means they have challenge opportunities at their work , while rest of
the participants 40(25.3%) said no and never meet any challenge in their work. Also 113(71.5%)
said yes that they have received training since they joined this hospital and other participants
have not received any training since they joined to the hospital and the nurse leadership style
were 48(30.4%) were on authoritarian, the majority said 89(56.3%) were democratic leadership
style. Also 11(17.0%)of nurses were said that they were laissez faire style and lastly 10(6.3%)
Autocratic leadership style.
21
Iam satisfied and able 3.6582 1.19858 Satisfied
to maintain a health
balance between work
and family life
Democratic 89 56.3%
Laissez-faire 11 7.0%
22
Autocratic 10 6.3%
23
analyse between working condition and nurse's opportunity. The results revealed that there was a
significant and positive relationship between nurse's working conditions and nurse's opportunity
r = 0.234,which statically (p= 0.01) N = 158. The correlation positive relationship in both nurse’s
working condition and nurse's opportunity. Therefore the correlation analysis was conducted to
examine whether there is a relationship between nurse's remuneration and Opportunity results
revealed r=0.518 ,which statically (p=<0.05) N=158 that there was a significant and positive
Note n=158
* P (<0.05)
**p(<0.01)
24
CHAPTER FIVE:
SUMMARYOF FINDINGS, DISCUSSION, CONCLUSIONS AND
RECOMMENDATIONS
5.1 Introduction
This chapter presents the summary of the findings, discussions, conclusions reached, study
recommendations and suggestions for further investigations. The objectives of the study was to:
establish how working conditions influence health workers’ job satisfaction , to assess how
health workers’ working conditions influence job satisfaction, determine how remuneration
influence health workers’ job satisfaction, establish the influence of opportunity for personal
advancement on health workers’ job satisfaction. Findings of the study confirm that health
workers’ job satisfaction is determined by institutional and individual factors.
25
5.2.1 The influence of working conditions on nurse’s jobsatisfaction.
responses on the influencing of working condition of nursing job satisfaction that (1.6709)(std
0.63289)were highly dissatisfied with work relationships with people around them. Also
(2.6013)(st1.59992)were l were dissatisfied with working environment of the hospital.(2.4177)
(std 1.15221)were dissatisfied with their overall job security .(2.5886)(std:1.45912) also they
were dissatisfied with their job location.(3.5570)(std:1.15925) were satisfied of work conditions
is significant factor affecting job satisfaction.(2.5000)(std:1.53826) dissatisfied that they were
satisfied with relation of their colleagues. (2.3608) (std:1.44195) were dissatisfied with the
organizational culture. .(2.6013)(st:1.46700) also dissatisfied with their condition of employee
5.2.3 The influence of opportunity for personal advancement on health workers’ job
satisfaction.
The mean (4.1962)(st:.94740)are satisfied that fulfilling abilities gives them a feeling of
satisfaction and personal achievement .(3.6582)(std1.19585) are satisfied that they are satisfied
and able to minimum a healthy balance between work and family life . (3.7532)(std1.23478) also
are satisfied that human resource department is always notified of the promotion vacancies .
(3.8291)(st:1.18479) were satisfied which means some were agree while others disagree that
promotion is done on merit while (3.8038)(st:1.16454) are also satisfied that promotion is
accompanied by pay rise.
26
5.3 DISCUSSIONS OF FINDINGS
5.3.1 The influence of working conditions on nurses job satisfaction in
Hargiesa Group Hospital
The study confirmedthat majority (52.2 %) of nurses in Hargiesa Group Hospital were satisfied
with their working conditions, and that they had poor working relationship with the people
around them and that they were dissatisfied with their working environment while others
(47.8%) were dissatisfied with their work conditions .
As pointed out(21), Working conditions include equipment and supplies, infrastructure, support
services, regulations at work and lines of authority and decision-making, all of which are
important determinants for job satisfaction. However, nurses was not dissatisfied with the
hospitals work environment and the hospital management team should act on it.
States that, work conditions are defined as an employee’s work place, work instruments, the
work itself, organization policy, and organizational rules. Arnold and Feldman (1996), promoted
factors such as temperature, lighting, ventilation, hygiene, noise, working hours, and resources as
part of working conditions(22).
The worker would rather desire working conditions that will result in greater physical comfort
and convenience. The absence of such working conditions, amongst other things, can impact
poorly on the worker’s mental and physical well-beinglikewise, the study findings strongly
suggests that working conditions is a significant factor affecting job satisfaction and if not taken
care of it would lead to dissatisfaction. However, the study also found out that the nurse were
dissatisfied with the organizations’ culture and conditions of employment and this has decreased
their job performance and satisfaction(23)
27
Remuneration is an important element because it is believed to enhance job satisfaction of
employees and is thought to be a fair process to reward people according to their satisfaction
contribution and competence(27).The study also concurs with the World health report 2006 which
states that in many countries the salaries of health workers are below the minimum living wage
and that the pay levels of public sector workers are often unfair compared to others in similar
jobs(28). Remuneration policies should be carefully developed bearing in mind the interests of the
management and satisfaction of employees.
5.3.3 The influence of opportunity for personal advancement on health workers’ job
satisfaction
According to our study , it confirmed that the nurses had a challenging opportunities at work ,
And that majority of nurses (44.7%) were satisfied and while others (55.3) were not satisfied. As
noted by (29)
, Employees are more motivated when they have challenging opportunities at work,
including participating in interesting projects, jobs with satisfying degree of challenge and
opportunity for increased responsibility.
The study further established that, majority of health workers in the middle level management
was satisfied with the existing opportunities for personal advancement especially in promotions.
However the top and lower management level disagreed that the human resource is notified of
promotion vacancies and that they were done in merit.
28
revealed r=0.518 ,which statically (p=<0.05) N=158 that there was a significant and positive
relationship between remuneration and opportunity .
REFERENCES:
1. Cranny, CJ., Smith, P.C., & Stone, E.F. (1992) Job satisfaction: how people feel about
their jobs and how it affects their performance. New York: Lexington Books, Ellis. S., &
Dick, P. (2003). Introduction to organizational behaviour England: McGraw-Hill.
2. Herzberg, F., Mausner, B., & Snyderman, B.B. (1993). The motivation to work with a
new introduction by Frederick Herzberg. New Brunswick: N.J. Transaction Publishers,
cop.
29
3. World Health organization report in 2006 shows that nursing available on
https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/nursing-and-of-OECD-
countries_Africa
4. Kingma 2007. Nurses on the move; a global overview. Health services research, volume
42, series 3p2, published March 2007, accessed 12Novembr
2012.http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1475-6773.2007.00711.x/pdf
5. The prevalence of global shortage of nurses available on this
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK493175/
6. While and Barriball 2004. Job satisfaction among nurses: literature review. International
journal of nursing studies, Volume 42, Issue 2, February 2004, Pages 211-227, Accessed
12th November 2012. Available on this
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/50020748904001592
7. Alam and Mohammad 2009. Level of job satisfaction and intent to leave among
Malaysian nurses. Volume 3, No. 1, Article 10, Accessed 12th November 2012.
http://www.saycocorporativo.com/saycoUK/BIJ/journal/Vol3No1/Article_10.pdf
8. Nursing theories; Transcultural Nursing, Updated January 26 2012. Accessed
http://nursingerib.com/nursing-notes-reviewer/roles-responsibilities-of-a nurse/
12 November 2012,http://currentnursing.com/nursing theory/transcultural_nursing.htmlE
9. European Commission (2002). Employment Europe. Download on 15 June 2012 from
http://www.eurofound.europa.eu/eiro/2002 /10/feature/eu0210204f.htm
10. Okemwa K. O. (2004). An Investigation into Job Satisfaction among Secondary School
Teachers: A Case Study of Borabu Division in Nyamira District, Kenya. Unpublished
MEd Project, Kenyatta University.
11. NDPII maternal mortality, neonatal mortality prevalence Somaliland health system
available PDFNPII .
12. Job satisfaction is widely studied across many academic disciplines, (Jung, 2007)
Available on 1468-Article Tex-2714-1-10-2010.
13. Ministry of health development of Somaliland (MOHD) in year 2011 job satisfaction
available http://www.nhpcsomaliland.organstion 17-18 2011
14. global scarcity of nurses. The World Bank, Overview, 2019.
30
15. job satisfaction by practicing nurses available on this
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8898860/
16. In 2006 the main factors influencing nurse job satisfaction available on
http://dspace.ciu.ac.ug/handle/123456789/840
17. Kenya speciality public Hospital in Mombasa, kwale and kilicavailable on Pdf factors
influencing in public health Hospital 123-134.
18. The World health report 2006 shows that many countries the salaries of nursing available
on this, 9241563176_eng.pdf
19. The study of job satisfaction is a topic of wide interest to both people available
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/339401568_Impact_of_Job_Satisfaction_on_O
rganizational_Commitment. AL-Hussami M (2008). A Study of nurses' job satisfaction:
The relationship to organizational commitment, perceived organizational support,
transactional leadership, transformational leadership, and level of education. Eur. J. Sci.
Res., 22(2): 286-295.
20. Khokher, p.. I. L. Bourgeault, and I. Sainsaulieu. (2009). “Work culture within the
hospital context in Canada: professional versus unit influences”. Journal of Health
Organization and Management 23:3, 332-345.
21. Yumkella F (2005). Retention: health workforce issues and response actions in low
resource settings. Chapel Hill, USAID Capacity project.
22. Robbins, S., Judge, T., &Sanghi, S. (2009). Organizational Behavior (13th ed.). New
Delhi: Pearson Education.
23. Greenberg, J., & Baron, R. A. (2003). Behavior in organizations (4th ed.). Needham
24. Ololube, N. P. (2005). Benchmarking the Motivational Competencies of Academically
Qualified Teachers and Professionally Qualified Teachers in Nigerian Secondary
Schools. The African Symposium, Vol. 5, No. 3. pp. 17-37.
25. WHO (2006). World health report 2006. Working together for health. Geneva, World
Health Organization (http://www.who.int/whr/2006/en/, accessed 25 April 2006)
26. Odhiambo, G. O. (2005). Teacher Appraisal: the Experiences of Kenyan Secondary
School Teachers; Journal of Educational Administration Vol. 43 No. 4, pp. 402-416
31
27. Spector, P. E., (1997): The Role of Frustration in Anti-Social Behavior at Work. In R. A.
Giacalone& J. Greenberg (Eds), Anti-Social Behaviour in the Workplace. Thousand
Oaks, CA: Sage. 1-17
28. Yang, H., Lv, J., Zhou, X., Liu, H. & Mi, B. 2017. Validation of work pressure and
associated factors influencing hospital nurse tumover a cross-sectional investigation in
Shaanxi Province, China. BMC Health Services Research, 17:112.
29. Chien, W. & Yick, S. 2016. An investigation of Nurses' Job Satisfaction in a Private
Hospitaland Its Correlates. The Open Nursing Journal. 10:99-112.
30. Masum, A.K.M., Azad, MAK, Hoque, K. E. Beh, L, Wanke, P. & Arslan, O, 2016 Job
Satisfaction and intention to quit an empirical analysis of nurses in Turkey. Peer
Journal.4:1896. Doi 10.7717.
31. The eastern African job satisfaction available in ,Journal of clinical nursing 21 (11 ‐12),
1763-1775, 2012 .
32
EDNA ADAN UNIVERSITY
DEPARTMENT OF NURSING
We are senior nursing students at Edna Adan University, who are currently working on a thesis
book project titled “ factors influencing nurses jobsatisfaction attending in Hargiesa group
hospital, Hargiesa Somaliland”. The major reason of this study is to fulfil a partial requirement
for the eligibility of a bachelor’s degree in nursing.
Kindly requesting you to fill in this questionnaire accurately as it is for only academic purpose.
Your views will be treated with confidentiality. It is an essential for us to complete a research
paper, so you can help us to complete this study by responding to below mentioned question.
Please answer all question in the questionnaire it is important information for my study make
tick one of best appropriate answers Tick the option of your choice
Sincerely,
33
SECTION A: DEMOGRAPHIC DATA
1 Please tick against your gender
Male [ ] Female [ ]
20 – 30 years [ ] 30 – 40 years [ ]
40 – 50 years [ ] 50 – 60 years [ ]
PhD [ ]
1 – 5 years [ ] 6 – 10 years [ ]
Do the design features of the work place, ventilation, lighting, arrangement of furniture
increases job satisfaction and staff turnover?
No [ ] Yes [ ]
34
b) If no, indicate why
……………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………
6. Indicate the extent to which you agree with the following items using the provided key:
Item SD D N D SA
I am satisfied with work relationships with the people
around me.
I am satisfied with the working environment of the
hospital
I am happy with my overall job security.
I am satisfied with my job location.
Work conditions is significant factor affecting job
satisfaction
I am satisfied with relations with my colleagues
I am satisfied with the organizational culture
I am satisfied with my conditions of employment
35
SECTION C: REMUNERATION AND NURSES JOB SATISFACTION IN
HGH
9. To which extent are you rewarded for working hard in the hospital?
No extent [ ]
10. When employees are highly satisfied, does the production in the organization increase?
Yes [ ] No [ ]
Indicate the extent to which you agree with the following items using the provided key:
Item SD D N A SA
36
SSECTION D: OPPORTUNITY FOR PERSONAL ADVANCEMENT AND
NURSES JOB SATISFACTION IN HGH
11. Do you have challenging opportunities at work?
Yes [ ] No [ ]
12. Have you ever received any training since you joined this hospital?
Yes [ ] No [ ]
13. Indicate the extent to which you agree with the following items using the provided key:
SD Strongly disagree D Disagree
Item SD D N A SA
37