#15 Adhesion Test Report (3M VHB APT & Alpolic Panels)
#15 Adhesion Test Report (3M VHB APT & Alpolic Panels)
Company: Mitsubishi Plastics Composites America, Inc.
401 Volvo Parkway, Chesapeake, VA 23320
Contacts: Mitsubishi Plastics Composites America, Inc:
Bill Yanetti, 757‐382‐5768
3M Specified Construction Specialists:
Blake Brown, SE and South Central US, bmbrown@mmm.com, 678‐596‐1831
Erik Katchur, NE & Midwest US, ekatchur@mmm.com, 330‐554‐9491
Carl Piplick, Western US, capiplick@mmm.com, 650‐520‐5698
Project(s): Adhesion Testing of 3M™ VHB™ Architectural Panel Tape G16F to Alpolic® Composite
Material Panels
3M TSR #: USA‐IATD‐6814‐2
Date: January 3, 2012
I. Application Description:
Mitsubishi Plastics Composites America is a manufacturer of Alpolic® metal composite material panels
for architectural applications. 3M™ VHB™ Tapes have been used for years in the bonding of Alpolic®
composite panels for exterior and interior architectural applications. This includes stiffener bonding,
panel to frame bonding, and trim bonding applications with 3M™ VHB™ Tapes.
II. Test Objective(s):
The purpose of this test study was to evaluate the adhesion of 3M™ VHB™ Architectural Panel Tape
G16F (3M™ VHB™ Tape G16F) to several Alpolic® panels with common finishes and metal surfaces. 90°
peel adhesion tests were performed with 3M™ VHB™ Tape G16F applied to these substrates. The 90°
peel adhesion test is the most sensitive test for determining how well the adhesive tape will bond to the
substrate finish. The 3M™ VHB™ Tape G16F evaluated in this study is 0.062” (1.6 mm) thick.
III. Test Procedures:
Adhesion was measured using a 90° peel adhesion test based on test method ASTM D3330. 1.0” (25
mm) wide strips of tape were used for this test. The strips of tape were applied to the customer
supplied substrates after the application surfaces were prepared utilizing the surface preparation
methods listed in Section IV. Three strips of tape were used for each different surface preparation
method. The tape was then backed with a 5 mil (0.13 mm) thick anodized aluminum foil strip and
allowed to dwell for 3 days at 70°F/50% RH (21°C/50% RH) conditions to allow bond strength to
develop. The 90° peel adhesion tests were completed at these same environmental conditions.
Laboratory retained production samples of the 3M™ VHB™ Tape G16F were used for this study and
average peel test data is reported in pounds per inch width (lbs/in) and Newtons per centimeter width
(N/cm) of adhesive tape.
IV. Surface Preparation:
The following different surface preparation methods were evaluated in this study. Proper surface
preparation is critical for achieving high bond strength. Kimberly‐Clark WypAll X60 towels were utilized
for all surface preparation techniques involving a wiping/cleaning procedure.
a. IPA/Water ONLY ‐ Clean bonding surface area with a 50:50 mixture of isopropyl alcohol (IPA)
and water.
b. 3M Adhesion Promoter 111 (AP 111) ‐ Clean bonding area with 50:50 IPA/water solution first
and then prime surface with AP 111 solution. This primer was applied by wiping the bonding
surface with a clean wetted towel. Tape was applied at least one minute after
cleaning/priming.
c. 3M Primer 94 ‐ Clean bonding area with 50:50 IPA/water solution first and then prime surface
with 3M Primer 94 solution. This solution is applied wet with a Designetics dauber bottle and
then allowed to dry without further wiping.
d. Abrasion – Lightly abrade bonding area with a 3M Scotchbrite™ 7447 pad mounted to random
orbit sander and then wipe surface clean with 50:50 IPA/water solution.
e. Abrasion + AP 111 – Lightly abrade bonding area with 3M Scotchbrite™ 7447 pad mounted to
random orbit sander and then wipe clean with 50:50 IPA/water solution. Follow cleaning step
with an application of 3M AP 111 as described in Section IV.b.
f. Abrasion + 3M Primer 94 – Lightly abrade bonding area with 3M Scotchbrite™ 7447 pad
mounted to random orbit sander and then wipe clean with 50:50 IPA/water solution. Follow
cleaning step with an application of 3M Primer 94 as described in Section IV.c.
V. Summary of Results:
A 90-degree average peel force result of >25 lbs/in (>44N/cm) is generally desired for most construction
applications as well as a cohesive failure mode (foam split, partial foam split, or mostly foam split).
Cohesive failure demonstrates the adhesive bond line strength is greater than the internal strength of
the acrylic foam core. This is the most desirable failure mode demonstrating maximum achievable
adhesive bond strength.
As mentioned above, a number of different surface preparation methods were evaluated in this study.
The attached table provides average test results for each substrate and a specific surface preparation
method. Results are provided only for those tape (3M™ VHB™ Tape G16F) and surface preparation
combinations which meet 3M’s adhesion requirements for construction applications (>25 lbs/in (>44N/cm)
cohesive failure mode type).
Appropriate Surface Avg Peel
Substrate
Preparation Method lbs/in N/cm
IPA/Water only 37.2 65.1
IPA/Water + AP111 38.1 66.7
Alpolic® SWT IPA/Water + Primer 94 35.8 62.7
(Polyester) Abrasion + IPA/Water 39.9 69.8
Abrasion + AP 111 38.8 67.9
Abrasion + Primer 94 37.0 64.7
IPA/Water + Primer 94 35.7 62.4
Alpolic® HPP
Abrasion + IPA/Water 38.4 67.2
Polyester TRD -
Abrasion + AP 111 41.0 71.7
Red
Abrasion + Primer 94 36.4 63.7
Abrasion + IPA/Water 38.8 67.9
Alpolic® SMX
Abrasion + AP 111 37.2 65.1
(FEVE)
Abrasion + Primer 94 37.4 65.5
. 2
V. Summary of Results (Continued):
Appropriate Surface Avg Peel
Substrate
Preparation Method lbs/in N/cm
IPA/Water + Primer 94 36.7 64.3
Alpolic® CUX Abrasion + IPA/Water 39.4 68.9
(Polyester) Abrasion + AP 111 38.8 67.9
Abrasion + Primer 94 39.0 68.4
Alpolic® CUX
Abrasion + Primer 94 38.7 67.7
(Kynar)
IPA/Water only 38.0 66.6
IPA/Water + AP111 36.9 64.7
Alpolic® ZCM
IPA/Water + Primer 94 37.2 65.2
(Umicore Quartz
Abrasion + IPA/Water 38.2 67.0
Zinc)
Abrasion + AP 111 39.4 69.1
Abrasion + Primer 94 38.3 67.1
Alpolic® CCM
(Natural Copper IPA/Water + Primer 94 37.5 65.6
Skin)
Alpolic® CCM IPA/Water + AP111 42.8 74.9
FR
Sample #1 IPA/Water + Primer 94 39.8 69.7
Alpolic® CCM
FR IPA/Water + AP111 44.6 78.1
Sample #2
Alpolic® CCM IPA/Water only 36.9 64.6
with "Stuart IPA/Water + AP111 35.8 62.7
Dean" Coating IPA/Water + Primer 94 36.0 63.0
Alpolic® TCM Abrasion + IPA/Water 39.1 68.5
(Natural Titanium Abrasion + AP 111 38.4 67.3
Skin) Abrasion + Primer 94 37.9 66.4
IPA/Water + AP111 37.7 66.0
Alpolic® 220M
IPA/Water + Primer 94 35.0 61.4
Stainless
Abrasion + IPA/Water 37.8 66.2
(NSS220M
Abrasion + AP 111 40.0 70.0
Stainless Steel)
Abrasion + Primer 94 37.8 66.3
VI. Conclusion:
3M™ VHB™ Tape G16F formed high bond strength to all the Alpolic® composite panel substrates
evaluated in this adhesion study. The different Alpolic® composite panel types and finishes required
specific surface preparation methods to achieve high bond strength. Please refer to the data table in
Section V for the appropriate surface preparation method(s) for the specific Alpolic® composite panel
type. To validate acceptable adhesion performance, an independent adhesion test should be
conducted on all panel finishes for each project.
. 3
Please note: the adhesion results in this test report are only relevant for the specific Alpolic® composite
panel finishes/types tested in this study. Alternative Alpolic® composite panel finishes/types should be
tested for adhesion by 3M prior to the commencement of a bonding project.
It is must also be noted that the bonding of 3M™ VHB™ Tape G16F to the Alpolic® CCM (Natural Copper
Skin) and CCM FR composite panels should only be considered for interior panel bonding applications
due to the corrosive nature of copper in exterior environments. A protective coating should be applied
to the bond area of the Alpolic® CCM and CCM FR composite panels if they are to be used for exterior
panel or stiffener bonding with 3M™ VHB™ Tape G16F. A “Stuart Dean” copper protective coating was
evaluated in this adhesion study on the Alpolic® CCM composite panel. High bond strength of the 3M™
VHB™ Tape G16F was observed to this copper coating. However, 3M makes no statements regarding
the durability of this protective coating and suggests the user contact the coating manufacturer for
further details about the performance and durability of this coating. The adhesion of the 3M™ VHB™
Tape G16F to alternative protective coatings should be tested by 3M prior to commencement of the
project.
VII. Additional Considerations – Design & Fabrication:
1. Work Area & Substrate Temperatures: While surface preparation is critical to achieving good
bonding performance of 3M™ VHB™ Tapes, it is equally important to apply the adhesive tape in a
work area with a temperature >60°F (15°C). In addition, the bonding substrates must be at the
same temperatures (thermal equilibrium). The use of an adhesion promoter will likely lower the
minimum application temperature to approximately 50°F (10°C) if this is a requirement for an
application. This should be verified by the customer prior to fabricating parts at temperatures <60°F
(15°C). Once fabricated and full bond strength is achieved, the bonded parts are capable of
withstanding cold exterior temperatures.
2. Application Pressures: It is also important to provide adequate pressure to the tape after it has
been applied to the first prepared substrate surface and then after the two parts are joined
together. The application of pressure facilitates good contact and adhesion of the adhesive tape to
both substrate surfaces. Hand pressure alone should not be considered adequate pressure for the
final application of pressure to the assembled parts. The use of pressure application equipment (J‐
roller, clamps, etc…) is strongly encouraged for the final pressure application step.
3. Static Loads: 3M™ VHB™ Tapes have a static load design guideline strength of 0.25 psi (1.7 kPa).
This means that there should be 4 in² of 3M™ VHB™ Tape for every 1 lb of weight (60 cm² of tape
per 1 kg) it will support on a constant basis. If a panel bonding application will involve a constant
static load acting on the 3M™ VHB™ Tape, the customer should verify that an appropriate amount
of adhesive tape is utilized to satisfy this design guideline.
4. Dynamic Loads: 3M™ VHB™ Tape has a dynamic load design guideline strength of 12 psi (85 kPa).
Dynamic loads are short term forces applied to the 3M™ VHB™ Tape such as a high wind gust. The
customer should verify that their design will satisfy 3M’s design guideline should the architectural
panel substrates be subject to dynamic loads such as wind loads in exterior applications when the
3M™ VHB™ Tape is utilized for panel attachment.
5. Equipment: The application of adhesion promoters, 3M™ VHB™ Tape, and pressure can be
enhanced through the use of equipment. This can result in faster and more robust manufacturing
. 4
processes. Please consult with a 3M Specified Construction Field Specialist for more information on
application equipment.
Testing should be conducted by the customer to determine if a 3M™ VHB™ Tape will meet all the
performance requirements for their application. The data reported in this document is to be used
as a representation of how well the tested 3M™ VHB™ Tape G16F will bond to the specific
customer‐supplied substrates with the same surface preparation methods and environmental
conditions. A thorough evaluation should be done by the customer to verify if a 3M™ VHB™ Tape is
capable of meeting the total needs of the application, including those that were not anticipated with
this testing.
Sincerely,
Steve Austin
Steve Austin
3M Global Technical Service Specialist
3M™ VHB™ Tapes ‐ Architectural Markets
3M Center, Bldg 230‐2S‐29
St. Paul, MN 55144
Tel: 651‐736‐1259
www.3m.com/vhb/architecturalpanel
Important Notice: All physical properties, statements, recommendations, opinions and technical information contained in this Report are based on
tests we believe to be reliable, but the accuracy and completeness of the Report is not guaranteed. The use of this Report is at the sole discretion
of the Report recipient and other users. Before using, the Report recipient and other users must determine the suitability of this Report for their
intended application, and assume all risk and liability whatsoever in connection with any use of this Report. 3M MAKES NO OTHER WARRANTIES,
EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO, ANY IMPLIED WARRANTY OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A
PARTICULAR PURPOSE. This limited warranty does not cover damage resulting from the use or inability to use 3M™ VHB™ Tape due to misuse,
workmanship in application, or application or storage not in accordance with 3M recommended procedures.
. 5