2020 01 TAS 101X-Treme WEB
2020 01 TAS 101X-Treme WEB
16 Pages of Music
Top Ten rock, jazz, and classical releases of 2019,
Abbey Road 50th anniversary, Nat King Cole box set,
new titles from Neil Young, Sheryl Crow, and more!
The meticulously hand-crafted MBL Radialstrahler tweeter and midrange drivers in the Omni tower’s solid stainless steel exoskeleton.
T
he exceedingly large, extremely heavy (better the studio venue in which this were the audiophile rage. Of
than a ton and a half), eight-chassis, twenty-six-driver, set was recorded way back in course, it was the much-ma-
$263,000, omnidirectional MBL 101 X-tremes are, in 1959—is to feel the time-ma- ligned Bose 901s that chiefly
almost every way possible, the best loudspeakers I’ve chine chill that you only get spurred this craze, followed
heard in my home—or anyplace else, for that matter. As true when an approximation of by a busload of three-sid-
point sources (which is to say, literal pulsating spheres), they are musicians playing in a hall or a ed, four-sided, and six-sided
capable of feats of sonic legerdemain that neither dipoles nor studio suddenly verges on the imitators. Though the Boses
direct-radiating loudspeakers can match, chief among which is real thing. were not true omnis, which is
How the 101 X-treme is to say they weren’t generating
capable of turning water into equal amounts of sonic ener-
The Cutting Edge MBL 101 X-treme Omnidirectional Loudspeaker
gy in all directions at all fre- behave like point sources, know, when you move right or left of center, so does the sound-
quencies, they did use the lis- loudspeakers should, too— stage, which tends to collapse towards the speaker you’re nearing,
tening room, and particularly that to accurately reproduce as if the instruments and vocalists were gradually sliding off a
the wall behind them, in a way what an instrument sounds tabletop tilted in the direction you’re heading.
that most other loudspeakers like in a concert hall or a This does not happen in real life. If you move from center-
of their day did not—and studio, speakers should also stage to a seat at stage left or stage right in a concert hall (or a
that acoustic instruments in mimic that instrument’s 3-D rock club, for that matter), the soundstage does not “collapse.”
concert halls always do. radiation pattern, which is so Oh, the instruments located in the direction you’ve moved sound
You see, better than 70% intimately tied to our percep- louder and more prominent (because they are, in fact, louder due
of what we hear at a live event tion of its tonality, dynamics, to your closer proximity to them), but the rest of the orchestra
is not direct sound but indi- durations, and presence. or band still spans the stage in the opposite direction, the solo-
rect sound bounced off the That’s the theory, at least. ist/vocalist still sounds roughly centered, the hall’s ambience still
walls, floor, and ceiling of the And as I pointed out on the encompasses all instruments evenly, rather than thinning down
venue—reflected energy that Gerry Mulligan/Ben Webster in the distant direction and thickening up in the proximate one.
profoundly affects the timbre, LP, with the 101 X-tremes With an omni, you get the very same effects you hear in real life.
the dynamics, the durations, the theory proves out be- Sitting, standing, shifting your head or your seat, you experience
the imaging, the very charac- yond highest expectations. I the same stable imaging and soundstaging.
ter of the sonic presentation. personally have never before As a dyed-in-the-wool audiophile, listening alone with your
Why hall reflections play heard a baritone or tenor sax- “head in a vise” may be something you’ve grown used to (as I
such a large part in what we ophone (or a piano or a bass have), but it is certainly not the most natural or relaxing way to
hear has to do with the way fiddle or a drumkit or…you enjoy music; nor, when it comes to your non-audiophile visitors,
instruments make music. A name it) reproduced with the is it the most congenial. I don’t know how many times I’ve told
violin, for example, doesn’t same density of color, weight, some bewildered newbie to “sit in the center”—and if, as is often
launch a series of notes in a solidity, and three-dimension- the case, there is more than one such visitor, to “let so-and-so
single plane or in a single di- ality—the sheer in-the-room- have the sweet spot.” It’s rude and embarrassing—and one of
rection, as if it were emitting with-you presence—that the the chief reasons, beyond the baffling complexity and absurd
a tightly focused beam aimed 101 X’s bring to the party. expense, that so many FNGs find high-end audio off-putting.
directly at you, the listener; it Those saxes (and other in- While omnis like the 101 X’s certainly won’t solve the complexity
radiates its energy through- struments) are just there, play- or expense problems, they will go far towards making listening to
out 360 degrees, both verti- ing for you in your listening music the non-conditional joy it is (and ought to be).
cally and horizontally, casting space. As I said ten years ago And then there’s the felicitous way omnis deal with an audio-
sound into space the way a in my review of the origi- phile’s chief bugaboo—the listening room and its inevitable “is-
softly glowing bulb casts light. nal version of the X-tremes, sues.” While some of our contributors seem to believe that every
Of course, that violin isn’t “while we all listen, perforce, room problem can be solved via a good dose of DSP salts, I
generating the same amount blind to stereo, the 101 X’s do not. EQ’ing outboard subs (whose output is inherently om-
of energy at every vector or go farther towards compen- nidirectional) to iron out room modes in the bass is one thing
at every pitch. But it is always sating for our hunger to see (and generally a salubrious one); DSP’ing an entire system (whose
radiating in three dimensions, what we hear—to fulfilling output is highly directional) to make it measure “flat” or rolled
and therefore always merging the definition of the word or whatever flavor you choose is another. In my experience, you
its direct sound with the indi- ‘stereo’ (which literally means may be able to get things close to the way you want them to be
rect sound it is reflecting off ‘three-dimensional’ or ‘sol- at one roughly microphone-sized spot right smack between your
the walls, floor, and ceiling of id’)—than anything else I’ve loudspeakers, but what is being scanted or ignored here is just
the hall in which it is being auditioned.” how much more completely and unavoidably such adjustments
played. Another way to put In addition to their incom- lock you into a single listening “sweet spot.” Talk about having
this is to say, as Amar Bose parably full and realistic re- your head in a vise! In a DSP’d system, if you move your noggin
famously did, that instru- production of tone color and sufficiently right or left or up or down, or (God forbid) switch
ments behave acoustically like 3-D presence, omnis have to a different chair, all that painstaking digital manipulation will
“pulsating spheres” (or point obvious sonic benefits when be audibly compromised. Sometimes, it will go right down the
sources), which because of it comes to soundstaging and drain—in fact, moving off-DSP’d-axis may make room problems
their spherical wavelaunch al- imaging—one of which you much worse.
ways produce a mix of direct can demonstrate to yourself Omnis in general (and the 101 X’s par excellence) deal with room
and reflected sound in any by merely abandoning the modes in an entirely different, rather more “generalized” and
room at any listening position. “sweet spot” midway between purely acoustic way—by flooding the entire listening space with
It is only a small (though those cone loudspeakers cur- full-range sound, coming (because the speakers radiate omnidi-
daunting) step to conclude rently ensconced in your lis- rectionally both horizontally and vertically) from a nearly infinite
that if instruments invariably tening room. As you already number of different elevations and a nearly infinite number of
January 2020 the absolute sound
The twin-layered 12” aluminum membrane subwoofer
driver, one of twelve in an X-Treme system.
The X-Treme’s master subwoofer control center, Subwoofer power amplifier with umbilical cord.
one for each channel .
The Cutting Edge MBL 101 X-treme Omnidirectional Loudspeaker
different angles. You might think that en-
ergy being broadcast in equal amounts at Specs & Pricing
all frequencies toward literally every sur- Type: Four-way omnidirectional loud- MBL AKUSTIKGERATE GMBH
face of your room would make the sound speaker system with separate powered & CO. KD
you end up hearing a confusing, echo- subwoofer towers Kurfurstendamm 182
chamber-like mess. That it doesn’t has Drivers (per speaker side): Two Radi- 10707 Berlin, Germany
to do with two interrelated phenomena: al TT100 woofers, two Radial MT50/E +49 030-230-05840
a true omni’s (like the 101 X’s) frequen- midrange, two HT37/E Radial tweet- mbl.de
cy-independent, constant-directionality ers, one “ambience” dome tweeter, six
dispersion, and the Precedence Effect. 12" aluminum cone subwoofers MBL NORTH AMERICA, INC.
First, unlike conventional loudspeaker Frequency response: 20Hz–40kHz (U.S. Distributor)
drivers (particularly tweeters) that tend Sensitivity: 88dB/2.8V/2pi 217 North Seacrest Blvd. #276
to send intense spotlight-like beams of SPL: 109dB Boynton Beach, FL 33425
inherently more distorted off-axis sound Power handling: 500W (continuous), Contact: Jeremy Bryan
toward sidewalls, an omni doesn’t “se- 2200W (peak) (CEO & President)
lectively” energize specific spots on your Weight: 3600 pounds (561) 735-9300; (917) 306-7588
walls. As I noted, it doesn’t work like a Price: $263,000 the pair info@mbl-northamerica.com
specular flashlight. It works like a glowing mbl-northamerica.com
ball. It energizes your room uniformly at all
frequencies, so that any reflections will
comprise the entire signal and not a small
piece of it. JV’S REFERENCE SYSTEM Digital sources: MSB Reference DAC,
Of course, an omni is (by design) still Loudspeakers: MBL 101 X-treme, Berkeley Alpha DAC 2,
creating far more broadband room re- Magico M3, Voxativ 9.87, Avantgarde Cable: Crystal Cable Ultimate Dream,
flections than a direct radiator, but we Zero 1, MartinLogan CLX, Magnepan Synergistic Research Galileo UEF, An-
don’t hear them as echoes or distortions 1.7 and 30.7 suz Acoustics Diamond, Synergistic
because of the Precedence Effect. The Subwoofers: JL Audio Gotham (pair), Research Foundation
Precedence Effect is a psychoacoustic Magico QSub 15 (pair) Power cords: Crystal Cable Ultimate
phenomenon whereby the acoustic signal Linestage preamps: Soulution 725, Dream, Synergistic Research Galileo
arriving first at our ears suppresses our Constellation Audio Altair II, Siltech UEF, Ansuz Acoustics Diamond
ability to distinguish any other signals, SAGA System C1, Air Tight ATE-2001 Power conditioner: AudioQuest
including echoes and reverberations, that Reference, MBL 6010 D Niagara 5000 (two), Synergistic Re-
arrive up to about 40ms after that initial Phonostage preamps: Clearaudio search Galileo UEF, Technical Brain
signal (provided that the delayed signal Absolute Phono, Walker Proscenium Support systems: Critical Mass Sys-
is not 15dB or so louder than the first V, Soulution 755, Constellation Audio tems MAXXUM and QXK equipment
one). Instead of those late-arriving wave- Perseus racks, amp stands, and Center Stage2
fronts being heard independently, they are Power amplifiers: Soulution 711, Room treatments: Stein Music
“fused” by the brain with the first-arriving Constellation Audio Hercules II H2 Harmonizer system, Synergis-
wavefronts and perceived as coming from Stereo, Air Tight 3211, Air Tight ATM- tic Research UEF Acoustic Panels/
the same spatial location. (These later-ar- 2001, Zanden Audio Systems Model Atmosphere XL4/UEF Acoustic Dot
riving broadband reflections also add vol- 9600, Siltech SAGA System V1/P1, system, Synergistic Research ART
ume level and spaciousness—particularly Odyssey Audio Stratos, Voxativ Inte- system, Shakti Hallographs (6),
a sense of width—to the sound source, grated 805, MBL 9008 A Zanden Acoustic panels, A/V Room
which helps account for the greater sense Analog source: Clearaudio Master In- Services Metu acoustic panels and
of presence, openness, and dimensional- novation/TT1-M1, Acoustic Signature traps, ASC Tube Traps
ity that omnis, and the 101 X’s in particu- Invictus Jr./T-9000, Walker Audio Accessories: Symposium Isis and Ul-
lar, offer the listener.) Proscenium Black Diamond Mk V, tra equipment platforms, Symposium
Far from being more colored by room TW Acustic Black Knight/TW Raven Rollerblocks and Fat Padz, Walker
reflections, drivers, and enclosures, so- 10.5, AMG Viella 12 Prologue Reference equipment and
phisticated (and in the 101 X’s case, box- Tape deck: United Home Audio Ulti- amp stands, Walker Valid Points and
less) omnis can, in principle, be much mate 4 OPS Resonance Control discs, Clearaudio
less colored by all these things and much Phono cartridges: Clearaudio Gold- Double Matrix Professional Sonic
more faithful to sources (about which I finger Statement, Air Tight Opus 1, record cleaner, Synergistic Research
will have more to say) because with prop- Ortofon MC Anna, Ortofon MC A90 RED Quantum fuses
er setup they essentially take the room
Construction of a push-push subwoofer cabinet. Attaching structural copper rods to the woofer.
Jonathan Valin
mbl-northamerica.com