Important
Important
5 for
males and 1.24 for females) among the population 15-49 years old in 2009. Sudan launched
its national policy in 2004 and the Government has shown strong commitment to the effort.
The main focus of the national HIV/AIDS control program (SNAP) has been on advocacy,
involvement of all sectors in the national response, testing, prevention, treatment and control
services for sexually transmitted diseases, and monitoring and evaluation. HIV treatment and
care services have been introduced in all the states, with 32 Anti-retroviral sites in the
country in 2009. The HIV/AIDS efforts have received assistance from the Global Fund, UN
agencies, and the private sector.
127. Health Facilities: Overall coverage with basic health facilities is poor. In 2009, there
were 365 hospitals and over 4,800 primary health care facilities in North Sudan. This works
out to one hospital to 90,000 people primary health care facility to 7,000 people. The health
system employed a total of 97,303 health workers in all Sudan comprising over 20 different
professions. However, according to the WHO criteria Sudan falls within the critical shortage
zone considering the density of physicians, nurses and midwives of 1.23 per 1,000 people).
There are substantial regional variations in the availability of health services. For instance,
Khartoum state has 65.5 general practitioners per 100,000 people, compared to 12.1 in
Kassala, 7.7 in North Kordofan and 3.6 in West Darfur state. Together, Khartoum and El-
Gezira states account for more than 50 percent of the public hospitals and private clinics, the
practicing physicians and medical technicians.
128. Health Expenditures: Total health expenditure amounted to 6.2 percent of the GDP
and US$122 per-capita for the year 2008, with 66.8 percent of total expenditure on health
out-of-pocket, exposing many to catastrophic health expenditures. This compares with an
average of 41 percent in sub-Saharan Africa and 47 percent in the low-income group ¹0.
Also, health spending is skewed towards curative and hospitals care, and most of the
allocation is for salaries. As a consequence, primary and first-referral care, particularly in the
poorer states, suffers from lack of resources¹¹,
129. The states have become dominant in health expenditures, with he states accounting for
63 percent of all federal and state expenditures. Not surprisingly, there are significant
variations between states in the levels of spending (total and per capita). States that receive
high per capita levels of federal transfers (Blue Nile) or mobilize significant amounts of own
revenues (Khartoum, Red Sea) tend to spend more per capita on health services. The recent
public expenditure tracking
survey (PETS) of the health sector found that some states generate revenue from the sector in
the form of various facility level fees. It found significant disparities among the studied
regarding the retention or transfer of fees to state and local governments. The PETS study
noted that there was scope to allocate more resources to service delivery levels in several
states. It made a number of recommendations towards improving service delivery in health
facilities, including the harmonization of systems of allocation of resources across states at
all levels and types of facilities,
___________________________________
9. Human Resources for Health (HRH), Strategic Work Plan for Sudan, (2008-2012)
10. http://healthsystems2020.healthsystemsdatabase.org accessed on 13 September, 2009
11. National Health Account preliminary report, 2010
12. World Bank (2011): Sudan, Public Expenditure Tracking Survey of the Health Sector.
The study is the first of its kind in Sudan, looking at the operations and management of
resources at primary care facilities in Sudan.
strengthening the management and monitoring of inputs from state and local governments to
facilities; provision of incentives to attract/retain staff in rural communities, harmonize the
administration of user fees across states and increase the share retained by the facilities while
ensuring that user fees do hinder access to services by vulnerable groups.
• Bridging the gap between States in enrolment and thereby raising the average
enrolment and increasing the completion rate in primary school from 57 percent in
2009 to 70 percent in 2011, with further improvements in subsequent years;
• Bridging the enrolment gap between boys and girls that persist in some states so as to
eliminate gender disparities in access to education at the basic level and achieve
gender
equality;
• Improving the literacy rate of those between ages 15-24 through programmes
targeting
school dropouts especially those between 9 and 14 years of age; and
• The preparation of a medium sector education sector strategy to bring focus to these
priorities as well as on the quality of education, and help to develop concrete actions
and targets.
118. The above priorities will be implemented with the concentration of the expansion of
primary education in disadvantaged States. This programme would entail the building of an
estimated 2519 classrooms, training of 14000 teachers and improving the school
environment by providing every child and teacher with educational aids books as well as
school furniture. In recognition of the large size of the country and the effect this has on
attendance, the programme calls for the establishment of boarding schools for pupils from
distant areas within each State. In
_________________________
UNHCR 2010; The Joint Assessment Mission (2005).
national and international fund raising and advocacy efforts are in place to mobilize the
required funding for the sector. The Nile Trans-boundary Environmental Project (NTEP) has
prepared a draft paper on River Nile environment safeguarding for monitoring the Nile water
quality.
140. Community Action for Total Sanitation (CATS) approach for community-based
sanitation promotion is currently under implementation to scale-up sanitation interventions.
The signing of Khartoum Declaration by 6 federal ministers reflects their commitment to the
promotion of community-based sanitation and to a clear institutional setup for sanitation
within the governmental structure.
Key challenges
113. The literacy rate in northern Sudan for both sexes in the age group 15-24 in 2008 was
77 percent, according to the NBHS (2009), and 84 percent for males and 71% for females. In
basic education drop outs have remained high. About 90 percent of children enroll in the first
grade of basic school but only about 57 percent of them remain in school by grade 8,
indicating a drop-out rate that averages 7 percent per grade. As a result, the primary
completion rate-a key indicator of progress towards universal primary completion-was only
57 percent in 2008/09. Retention at the secondary level, at 74 percent, is lower than in
primary education when adjusted for length of the cycles. A retention rate of 74 percent
corresponds to a dropout rate of 13 percent per year in the first two years of the cycle.
Student dropout is therefore a serious concern. A high rate of dropout could indicate that
students are not learning enough, i.e. that the quality of schooling is simply too low to justify
students' time and the direct cost in terms of parental contributions. More research is needed
to understand the causes and risk factors for dropout in North Sudan so that appropriate
measures to improve retention can be put in place.
114. With a gross enrollment rate of 77 percent, the number of those who have never
attended school is high. Out of the population of six million 10-17 year-olds in northern
Sudan, it is estimated that one in six, or close to one million, never attended school in 2010.
Of these out of school children, 62 percent are girls, and 84 percent are from rural areas. The
longer distances to schools in rural areas may pose more of a constraint to school attendance
for girls than for boys in addition to early marriage for girls and the lower value assigned to
girls education by parents in rural areas. The low levels of public expenditures in education
have resulted in physical deterioration of schools and facilities and limited geographical
spread. Since 2000 the share of education in total
6 Developing Human Resources
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
87. The conflicts in Sudan and neighboring countries have created a large number of
internally displaced people (IDPs) and internationally displaced persons (refugees) fleeing
conflict from neighboring countries. Estimates of IDPs range from 2 million to 5 million,
with major concentration in the in the Darfur states, and significant presence in Khartoum
state and East Sudan. Sudan is host to over 200,000 refugees and asylum seeker from
neighboring countries, mainly Eritrea, Ethiopia, Somalia, Chad, Central Africa Republic and
the Democratic Republic of the Congo. These are concentrated in East Sudan. Both Darfur
and East Sudan have histories of internal conflict and also have large populations of poor
people. The Darfur states are among the poorest regions in Northern Sudan while the Eastern
states are in the mid range in terms of poverty in Northern Sudan (see Table 5). It is not the
presence of these displaced persons that rendered these regions poor but the continuing
presence in the temporary and dependent conditions will make the fight against poverty more
difficult in these regions.
88. Reintegration involves a systematic approach to end the temporary, uncertain and
dependent status of these displaced populations by providing permanent access to shelter and
sustainable livelihoods in new or existing communities, to economic and social opportunities
such as land, credit, market places, schools and heath facilities, and participation in civic
activities and decision-making in the communities. Integration programs cover several
sectors and activities such as health, education, water supply, agriculture, permanent shelter,
infrastructure, capacity building and formal and informal community dialogue. Integration
could involve the specification and agreement on the legal rights of the new settlers,
equivalent to those in the communities. For refugees, reintegration could involve sending
them back to their countries of origin or to a third country where they could have access to
the same legal rights and opportunities available to the residents in that country.
Financial Controls
79. For Strengthening monitoring and financial controls, Government is introducing the
Government Financial Management System (GFMS), a computerized budgeting, accounting
and reporting application and implementation has started in the Ministry of Finance and
National economy, and will extended to the state governments. The implementation of the
GFMS will permit the timely preparation of budget preparation reports that can be made
available for public scrutiny.
Procurement
80. Procurement is an important function in public service delivery and good, efficient and
transparent procurement systems ensure value for money and effective service delivery.
Government procurement in Sudan is the responsibility of the Contracting and Purchasing
Department (CPD) at the Ministry of Finance and National Economy (MOFNE). The CPD is
also responsible for the orderly disposal of government assets. The legal framework for
procurement was revised in 2010 and subsequently the regulations and implementation
guidelines were prepared and issued MoFNE has both regulatory and management
responsibilities for procurement. The procurement process is decentralized; procurement
units in implementing agencies carry out the procurement in collaboration with CPD and in
accordance with the law and regulations. A representative of CPD serves on the committee
for the procurement and CPD also reviews the final decisions of the committee to ensure its
appropriateness. State and local governments carry out their procurements independently of
CPD using their own supervisory and oversight arrangements.
81. The main challenge in procurement is the limited capacity at MONFE and CPD as well
as the implementing units at central and decentralized governments. Given the importance of
procurement for good governance and public service delivery, investments in building
capacity and supporting systems is likely to have a high payoff if the right approaches are
taken. The Government, with the support of the World Bank, has engaged a team of experts
to help it develop its procurement systems and capacity and facilitate the implementation of
procurement operations under the new law. This team will help in the preparation of manuals
of procedures, revise bidding documents and provide training to procurement staff at federal,
state and local levels. Beyond this one-off capacity building exercise, the government should
aim to develop a cadre of procurement specialists in the public and private sectors in Sudan
and private firms to provide training as well as expertise in procurement regulations.
Oversight of Public Financial Management
82. The office of the Auditor General existed since the early days of the colonial era and has
a rich history and tradition of independence. Its oversight scope has recently been extended
to cover environmental and performance audits. This is one link in the PFM chain that is
working well. The Audit Chamber, headed by the Auditor General prepared audits of
government operations and with recommendations, submits the audits to the legislature, in
accordance with the law. The legislature discusses the reports and makes recommendations
to the Executive, which follows up with appropriate actions. The Assembly decided recently
to transfer the report on imported agricultural seeds to the Ministry of Justice for action. To
enhance its ability to perform its traditional financial audit functions and to cope with new
responsibilities for performance audits, the capacity of the Chamber needs to be
appropriately strengthened.
Property Rights
69. An environment of secure and enforceable rights to property is critical for enabling
private investment and productivity growth. In particular the lack of secure long-term land
rights is an obstacle to the commercialization and rapid growth of agriculture and livestock
activities, a key pillar of the growth strategy for Sudan. As land is an essential asset in the
livelihoods of the majority of Sudanese, as the population grows, the competition for tends to
raise the risks of communal land disputes and harm agricultural productivity, in the absence
of secure land rights. While the land law vests the ownership of land to the state, in practice
for most of rural lands, decisions on land use has been delegated to community leaders who
provide farmers with usufruct rights. This practice is an obstacle to investments in the land
and the commercialization and growth of agriculture. The federal, state and local
governments need to work together, in consultation with the civil society, for a land policy
that provides long-term rights to land, and put in place the institutions for enforcement of the
land rights and conflicts arising from land use and disputes.
4.3 Decentralization
70. Sudan has been a federation for several years, and in 2005, the CPA divided the country
into 25 states. With the independence of the South, Sudan is now a federation of 15 states,
with three levels of Government - the federal, state and localities (local government), with
elected legislatures at each level and elected state governors. Each state has its own
constitution while Local Government Act (LGA) provides the legal framework for the local
governments. The federal and state constitutions as well as LGA stress the principle of
autonomy of the different levels of government and the need for mutual respect of this
autonomy. A High Council on Governance, headed by the President and consisting of
selected federal ministers, the 15 state governors and 3 experts nominated by the President,
monitors progress in decentralization and resolves issues arising between states such as
border disputes. The key challenges of a functioning decentralization in Sudan include the
lack of technical and institutional capacity at all levels, the inadequacy of financial resources
at the state and local government governments to meet the constitutionally assigned
responsibilities, and the lack of real autonomy and participation of the population at the local
government level.
71. Revenue sharing at the federal level is the principal source of funds for sub-national
governments. A Fiscal and Financial Allocation and Monitoring Commission (FFAMC) has
the mandate to set criteria for sharing resources between the three levels of government; the
horizontal allocation of resources among the 15 states; and the monitoring of deposits of
national revenues into the National Revenue Fund, the transfer of funds to sub-national
levels and the uses of these funds. However, no mandated revenue sharing allocation
mechanism between the three levels of government is place and the sharing is decided each
year, with the federal government deciding how much goes to the states and the states
deciding the shares of the localities. This introduces significant uncertainty in the budget
planning at sub-national levels of government. Work is underway in designing the revenue
transfer mechanisms including the revenue sharing formula and the institutional framework
for an effective fiscal decentralization.
72. Local governments in Sudan are responsible for the delivery of key social services such
as education and health and through the popular committees, play a critical role in security,
development and dispute resolution in the locality. However, local governments have very
limited autonomy and participation of the citizens to be effective in carrying out their
mandates. The Governor appoints the political head of the locality, the commissioner, and
the state government appoints and pays staffs of the locality from the share of revenue of the
locality. The members of the
is responsible for children-related policies, plans and programmes and coordination with the
other levels of government in the field of child welfare. It also collects statistics, runs
seminars, trains personnel and prepares periodic reports for regional and international
organizations. On the protection of children's rights and welfare, the Labour Code of 1997
prohibits the employment of children less than 16 years of age in dangerous or strenuous
activities and sets the working hours for children. The Armed Forces Act of 2007 prohibits
the recruitment of any person under-18 years of age into the armed forces.
66. Freedom of belief and religious practice: The Sudan is a multiracial, multicultural and
multi-religious country. Muslims make up the majority of inhabitants but Christianity and
customary beliefs have a considerable number of followers. The Constitution does not
prescribe an official State religion, asserting that the Sudan is an all-embracing homeland
where religions and cultures are sources of strength, harmony and inspiration, that cultural
diversity is the basis of national cohesion and may not be used to create division, and that all
the indigenous languages of the Sudan are national languages that must be developed and
promoted. Thus, the Constitution guarantees to every individual the right of freedom of
conscience and religious creed, and the manifestation and dissemination of religion or creed
through worship, teaching or practice, and the performance of religious ceremonies or rites.
It also provides that no person shall be coerced into adopting a creed in which he/she does
not believe or into engaging in ceremonies or acts of worship without voluntary consent.
Further, the assumption of high State office is predicated on citizenship not faith or ethnicity.
Documents of proof, such as identity cards and passports, contain no details of religion, nor
is any statement of religion required to access to State-provided services.
67. Freedom of expression and the press: Freedom of expression is a fundamental freedom
that is closely related to freedom of belief and is one of the features constituting a modern
democratic State. The Constitution accordingly attaches particular importance to this
freedom, guaranteeing to every citizen the right to express views freely, to receive and
disseminate information, and to access the press, without prejudice to security, safety or
public morals. The Constitution sought to establish the general principles of freedom of the
press, while the Press and Publications Act of 2009 regulates freedom of expression through
the press and guarantees broad freedoms of expression and access to information. Under the
Act, oversight of the press is entrusted to an independent council that has responsibility for
granting licenses to the press and considering complaints from persons damaged by the
publication of press articles. In practice, 50 newspapers are published in the Sudan, covering
a wide range of areas. Twenty seven of these papers are politically oriented, often privately
owned but aligned to the positions of the different political formations. The other papers
cover sports, society events, economic affairs, entertainment and advocacy. Sudan has 6
Internet service provider companies as well as 8 television and 17 radio stations. Although
media operators are privately owned, the state remains dominant in the media, a situation
that has to change for greater openness essential to meet its aspirations for an open and
democratic society.
68. War crimes, crimes against humanity, torture and slavery: The Criminal Act 1991
was also amended in 2009 to cover war crimes, genocide and crimes against humanity as
internationally defined and thus stretches the national jurisdiction over such crimes. The
Constitution and various Sudanese legislations prohibit the subjection of any person to
torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment. Hard labour is not included as a
punishment in Sudanese laws and the Criminal Code of 1991 and the National Security Act
of 2009 provide that detainees under investigation must be treated in a manner conducive to
the preservation of their dignity, must not be subjected to any physical or mental harm and
must receive suitable medical care.
61. Sudan now has two main institutions dealing broadly with the issue of human rights: the
Advisory Council on Human Rights (ACHR) and the proposed Human Rights Commission
(HRC). In addition, the Human Rights and Public Duties Committee of the National
Assembly provides legislative oversight over the human rights performance of the executive
authorities. The ACHR, created in 1992, provides advice to the State on human rights;
carries out research and studies; disseminates the human rights culture across the different
media; provides training for State and civil society personnel on human rights standards and
principles; reviews national legislation to harmonize it with international human rights
instruments, coordinates human rights matters with international human rights institutions
and prepares periodic reports to international human rights treaty mechanisms. The ACHR
also handles complaints about human rights violations from individuals and organizations in
Sudan. The INC provided for the creation of HRC to monitor application of the Bill of
Rights and receive complaints on violations of rights and freedoms. The Human Rights
Commission Act, which regulates its activity, was promulgated in 2009. The 15 members of
the HRC, to be selected from independent, competent, non-partisan and impartial citizens,
will be appointed in the near future to commence their duties.
62. The State has established a number of mechanisms for the promotion of human rights in
the context of law enforcement, including, for example, the Ministry of Interior's
Coordinating Council on Human Rights and International Law, community police stations
and family and child protection units. In addition, the National Security and Intelligence
Service established a detainee affairs department and a medical unit in order to improve
conditions of confinement. The enquiries and complaints office was also established to
receive queries and complaints from citizens directly.
63. Women's rights: The INC grants women equal rights with men, without discrimination,
stating as it does that "any reference to the masculine also includes the feminine". Moreover,
in the Bill of Rights provides that: "The State shall guarantee the equal right of men and
women to the enjoyment of all civil, political, social, cultural and economic rights." The
Constitution also incorporates the principle of equal pay for equal work and affirms positive
discrimination in favor of women. The principle of equal pay for equal work was reaffirmed
in the Public Service Act of 2007. The Nationality Act promulgated in 1994 and amended in
2005, accorded women the right to pass on their nationality to their children. Provisions for
the special protection for women during armed conflict were included in the 2009
amendment of the Criminal Code of 1991 and the Armed Forces Act of 2007.
64. In addition to the legal reforms, Sudan has taken a number of actions to advance the
rights and role of women including a quota system included in the Electoral Act of 2008 that
guarantees a minimum of 25 per cent of parliamentary seats for women. Representation of
women stood at 28.3 per cent in the elections held in 2010. Actions taken to advance to
address issues relevant for women include the adoption of a national plan to combat violence
against women in 2005, and the adoption of a national strategy for the elimination of female
circumcision. The Violence against Women and Children Unit was established in 2005 in the
Ministry of Justice to monitor the implementation of the national plan to combat violence
against women. Similar units have been established in the three states of Darfur and in a
number of the other states in the Sudan.
65. Children's rights: The Constitution makes education is a right for every citizen and
requires the State to guarantee access to education, without discrimination as to religion,
race, ethnicity, gender or disability. Since 2004, the Sudan has experienced significant
progress with the provision of education for all, particularly at the basic level, reflecting the
constitutional mandate. The National Council for Child Welfare, established in 1991, and
chaired by the President of the Republic, with State governors and federal ministers
concerned with children's issues as members,
are responsible for adjudicating conflicts between the state governments and central/state
governments. Each locality is expected to have a popular committee responsible for conflict
resolution at the local level. A broad process of national reconciliation could enhance these
efforts, with the national reconciliation body providing support and capacity building to the
popular committees at the local levels
52. National reconciliation is an essential for building peace, security and national unity, and
restoring trust for national institutions and between individuals. The open, participatory and
frank discussions of the issues facing the country, particularly those related to peace, security
and national unity, and the grievances of different communities, help to get a good feel for
the views of the population and raise awareness on national issues. Discussions and dialogue
throughout the country, particularly targeting hitherto neglected areas and populations, can
be helpful in formulating inclusive national political, economic and social policies. Sudan
has started a process of national reconciliation with the Governor's forum on national
reconciliation held in 2009. However, the Government will consider and institutionalized
national effort, driven by credible people not holding public offices, that will help to
sensitize the people on the importance of national reconciliation and keep conflict resolution
in the national spotlight.
Political institutions
55. The INC provides for a national legislature composed of an elected National Assembly,
and the Council of States, composed of two representatives from each state elected by the
state legislative councils. Each state likewise has a legislative council composed of members
elected in accordance with the provisions of the State constitution and the law.
56. Right to participate in political life: The conduct of free and fair elections is among the
political institutions in the CPA and the INC and the right to vote in such elections as an
inherent
right of all Sudanese citizens. In 2007 the Parties Act provided for the establishment of a
multi- party system and in 2008, the Electoral Act was adopted for the conduct of elections
in the different states of the Sudan. Subsequently, the National Election Commission was
established; and the chairman and its members were selected by the consensus of all political
parties, to secure its independence. With the independence of the South, the Commission
will be reorganized along the same procedures.
57. Elections: The Commission conducted the presidential and general elections, the
referendum on self-determination in the South, and the special elections of South Kordofan.
The April 2010 elections, the first multiparty elections in Sudan in 20 years, were held at the
national, state and local levels, with the seats of President of the Republic, state governors
the national and state legislative council fully contested. A quota of 25 per cent of legislative
seats was reserved for women. In addition, women contested other seats. The elections drew
a wide turnout from all segments of society, including women, displaced persons, refugees,
prison inmates and hospital inpatients. These elections were conducted in peaceful and
secure atmosphere; closely observed by national and international observers. Administrative
and logistical difficulties encountered in the electoral process were dealt with in accordance
with the law.
Human rights
60. The Republic of Sudan, including all levels of government, is committed to complying
fully with its obligations under the international human rights treaties to which it is a party.
These include the international covenants on civil political, economic, social and cultural
rights, and the international conventions on the elimination of all forms of racial
discrimination and the rights of child. In this context Sudan has included related human
rights provisions in its constitutional and legal framework. These include the creation,
character and responsibilities of the Human Rights Commission (HRC), provisions on the
rights and protection of women and children, freedom of beliefs and religious practice and
the protection of the freedom of expression and the press.
right of all Sudanese citizens. In 2007 the Parties Act provided for the establishment of a
multi- party system and in 2008, the Electoral Act was adopted for the conduct of elections
in the different states of the Sudan. Subsequently, the National Election Commission was
established; and the chairman and its members were selected by the consensus of all political
parties, to secure its independence. With the independence of the South, the Commission
will be reorganized along the same procedures.
57. Elections: The Commission conducted the presidential and general elections, the
referendum on self-determination in the South, and the special elections of South Kordofan.
The April 2010 elections, the first multiparty elections in Sudan in 20 years, were held at the
national, state and local levels, with the seats of President of the Republic, state governors
the national and state legislative council fully contested. A quota of 25 per cent of legislative
seats was reserved for women. In addition, women contested other seats. The elections drew
a wide turnout from all segments of society, including women, displaced persons, refugees,
prison inmates and hospital inpatients. These elections were conducted in peaceful and
secure atmosphere; closely observed by national and international observers. Administrative
and logistical difficulties encountered in the electoral process were dealt with in accordance
with the law.
Human rights
60. The Republic of Sudan, including all levels of government, is committed to complying
fully with its obligations under the international human rights treaties to which it is a party.
These include the international covenants on civil political, economic, social and cultural
rights, and the international conventions on the elimination of all forms of racial
discrimination and the rights of child. In this context Sudan has included related human
rights provisions in its constitutional and legal framework. These include the creation,
character and responsibilities of the Human Rights Commission (HRC), provisions on the
rights and protection of women and children, freedom of beliefs and religious practice and
the protection of the freedom of expression and the press.
4 Strengthening Governance and Institutional Capacity
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
47. To achieve sustained growth, with employment creation and poverty reduction, and
avoid the gyrations of the past economic performance, the new Sudan will put priority on
building a strong, inclusive, transparent and effective state and the institutional capacity to
govern and deliver public services to the population. Important elements of this good
governance include effective public financial management (PFM) and decentralization,
peace and security, fighting corruption, promoting human rights, and improving justice and
law enforcement. Further, there is empirical evidence that poor governance and poverty as
causes of civil wars. Although the separation of the North and South Sudan has presumably
reduced the risks of conflict in the sub-region, civil conflict remains a reality, for example in
Darfur. Thus, continuing vigilance and an orientation to resolving existing and latent
conflicts in a peaceful manner will remain essential for peace and stability.
Major Opportunities
45. The list of challenges seems to be long but there are opportunities available to Sudan for
tackling those challenges and achieving shared growth and poverty reduction. These include:
• Natural Resources: Sudan is endowed with natural resources including fertile land
and water resources to develop vibrant farming and livestock production and related
geoprocessing industries. Sudan has significant irrigation infrastructure and its
agriculture is not wholly dependent on rain-fed agriculture. It also has a mix of small
and large mechanized agriculture; the large farms could provide the nucleus for
improving the productivity of small farms and facilitate the marketing of produce.
Sudan has oil and gold, products that are high demand globally, with the potential for
generating surplus that can be used for creating additional national wealth.
• Sudan is in the neighbourhoods of wealthy countries to the north: This provides a
strong market for the products of Sudan as well as foreign direct investment and
project financing. For instance, livestock is a major export from Sudan to the Middle-
Eastern neighbours. Sudan can take proactive action to secure and grow its livestock
exports. Sudan could even develop some tourism attractions and facilities targeted at
tourists from the wealthy Middle-East countries.
• Foreign Direct Investments (FDI): With the discovery and production of oil, Sudan
enjoyed healthy inflows of FDI mostly from Asia and the Middle-East and targeted at
the oil sector. This opening up provides an opportunity for Sudan to seek FDI from
these growing economies for other sectors.
• Momentum for change and development since the CPA: Change has come to
Sudan, particularly since the adoption of the CPA. Internally, there has been progress
in building the foundation for sustained development with rapid improvements in
education, the decentralization of government and improvements in infrastructure.
The rapid growth of school enrolment in recent years, particularly in conflict affected
regions, is a sign that the people of Sudan are eager to move on to working to
improve their lives. While the secession of the South can be regarded as setback, it
removes a major uncertainty as to the future of Sudan and reduces the risks of future
internal conflicts. North Sudan can now move forward at its own pace, utilizing its
own enormous capabilities and focusing on the prosperity of its over 30 million
people. Sudan's relations with the international community have improved, with
better prospects for the removal of sanctions, and the provision of debt relief and
concessional financing. The GoS needs to work with determination to take advantage
of these openings.
• Learning and partnerships: There is a great deal of knowledge and experience
globally on many of the challenges that Sudan faces -post conflict socio-economic
recovery including national reconciliation and reintegration of displaced people,
economic restructuring and reform, partnership with external development agencies.
Sudan can learn from the accumulated experience of development partners and relief
agencies. Besides, they are countries in Africa that have gone through the process and
could share their experiences with Sudan.
aim to close these gaps so that all Sudanese have the opportunity to contribute to and share in
the benefits of growth.
• Employment creation: Unemployment is estimated to be about 20 percent. Educated
young people are finding difficult to obtain jobs; a situation that raises security risks.
Creating employment requires the growth and diversification of the non-oil economy,
not only in terms of sectors of economic activities but also in terms of locations in the
country. Good jobs are needed in the lagging areas emerging from conflict.. New
discoveries and production of oil will not have much direct impact on job creation.
The oil sectors and the emerging gold extraction will absorb the top cream of the
labour force with their high salaries and benefits but have limited impact on overall
unemployment. Employment creation will therefore need to come from
manufacturing, services and agriculture. Increasing investments and productivity in
these sectors will enable Sudanese firms to grow, be competitive in global markets,
export and create jobs.
• The economy needs to become more diverse: The economy has become dependent
on petroleum production and exports. The non-oil sectors are still strong but most of
their dynamism is derived from the inflows of oil revenues. Non-oil exports now
account for about 5 percent of exports. Productivity in agriculture, the main
contributor of non-oil exports and production remains low. Diversification of the
economy, including a strong and productive agricultural sector is critical for shared
growth and poverty reduction.
• Human capital, technical and institutional capacities need to be continuously
developed and reinforced. Access to quality education and healthcare males and
females builds an informed and healthy society and is crucial for enabling more and
more citizens to take advantage of the opportunities presented by a growing economy,
escape the trap of poverty, and add more value to the economy. Creating employment
requires that the education and knowledge systems produce the skills that employers
need to be innovative and to raise productivity. The knowledge base, a critical
ingredient of sustained economic growth, is built on high quality primary and
secondary education, and relevant and high quality education at universities, technical
institutes and other tertiary institutions. For the public sector, institutional reforms
with focus on the promotion of knowledge, innovation, results, efficiency and
effectiveness are essential for positive contributions of public actions to socio-
economic progress. Planned and coordinated learning opportunities should be
provided to public employees to enhance their knowledge. For the private sector,
professional associations should be organized to promote technical and managerial
knowledge and provide linkages to the global knowledge system. Foreign direct
investment also provides linkages to the global knowledge system.
• Institutional and Structural Reforms: Over the last decade, Sudan has carried out
significant reforms to stabilize the economy, improve transparency and accountability
of public financial management and safeguard public finances. It needs to carry out
structural and institutional reforms to enable shared growth and diversification of the
economy. The public services, including the public finance system, need to be
reformed for the efficient and effective delivery of priority social and economic
services that are essential for economic growth and improving welfare. The budget
needs be aligned to the development objectives and related priorities and the
established budget institutions should be reformed to ensure this alignment. The
regulatory environment for private sector development, the financial sector, the
education sector and knowledge infrastructure and the labour laws need to be
reformed to support a growing and diversifying economy.
2.5 Food Poverty:
37. The food deprivation refers to the proportion of the population whose dietary energy
consumption is below the minimum dietary energy requirements (MDER) which is defined
in Sudan at 1751 kcl. The HHBS (2009) was used to estimate food deprivation. The
proportion of the population below the minimum level of dietary consumption in northern
Sudan is estimated at 31.5 percent. This amounts to about 13 million people that are food
deprived. The proportions of the urban and rural populations that are food deprived are 31
percent and 34 percent respectively. Across the Northern states the level of food deprived
varies significantly by region, estimated at 44 percent in Red Sea, and 15 percent in Gezira
and River Nile.
38. Food deprivation is higher in female-headed households (37 percent) than in male-
headed households (31 percent) due to better education and higher income in male-headed
households. Also the survey showed that the rate of food deprivation differed by household
size ranging from 5 percent for household of one or two members to 49 percent for
households with more than 9 members. The survey identified income as the most important
determining factor for food- deprivation. Twenty percent of the poor population was food
deprived compared to almost nil in the higher income category. Expenditure on food
constituted a large share of household consumption in Sudan; accounting for 61.4 percent.
The food ratio decreased with income, the lowest income quintile spent 71.5 percent
compared to 57 percent in the highest income.
39. A manifestation of the food poverty is the underweight prevalence among children in
Sudan. The underweight prevalence is the percentage of children under five years of age
whose weigh for age is less than minus two standard deviations from the median for the
international reference population age 0-59 months. According to SHHS, in 2006, 29.6
percent of children under five in North Sudan were found to be underweight, with 7.2
percent severely underweight. This means in lay terms that almost 30 percent of children
have weights that are very low for their age. There is considerable variation among states in
underweight prevalence between states, from 21.7 percent in Khartoum state to 38.1 percent
in West Darfur. The highest prevalence is in the Darfur region, North Kordofan and Blue
Nile, among the poorest regions/states in the country. In addition, the proportion of children
who were stunted (low height for age or chronically malnourished) was 31.3 percent with 9.5
percent severely stunted. Around 13.7 percent of children under-five suffered from acute
malnutrition, evidenced by low weight for height (wasting), with 3.4 percent with severe
acute malnutrition.
2.6 Unemployment
40. The low growth of employment, rising unemployment and low levels of productivity are
at the core of high and persistent levels of poverty in Sudan. As noted in Section 1.2, total
employment in Northern Sudan grew at 0.9 percent per annum between 1993 and 2008. With
the labor force growing at an estimated 1.3 percent per annum over the same period,
unemployment has increased from 11.1 percent in 1993 to 16.8 percent in 2008.
Unemployment rates have been higher in the rural areas compared to urban areas, at 19.8
percent and 12.1 percent respectively in 2008, and also higher for females than males, at 24.7
percent compared to 13.9 percent. Labor participation rates are very low, which might
indicate that many unemployed people are discouraged from
__________________________________________________________________________
See Republic of Sudan, Ministry of Welfare & Social Security, National Population General
Secretariat: Sudan Millennium Development Goals Progress Report 2010, pages 18-20.
3 The Poverty Reduction Strategy: Core Elements and Pillars
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
42. Sudan is facing significant challenges to sustained growth and poverty reduction in the
short and medium-term. These are associated with the loss of access to oil wealth, with the
secession of the South, the imperative of ending conflicts and building peace in the new
country, and reengaging fully with the international development community to gain access
to financial and technical assistance. With the secession of South Sudan in July 2011,
Northern Sudan (the new. Sudan) urgently needs to refocus its efforts on building now
smaller territory into a united and economically prosperous country, at peace internally and
with neighbouring countries. Efforts to foster national reconciliation, integrate the internally
displaced people (IDPs) and refugees into viable communities and sustainable livelihood,
and adopt inclusive governance institutions, will be essential for building peace, security and
shared economic growth. For post-secession Sudan, tackling unemployment and poverty
should be the top priorities and essential for avoiding the cycle of civil war and conflict that
has plagued the country for several years.
43. For the last decade, the economy of Sudan grew rapidly, due in part to the growing oil
production and exports as well as the prudent macroeconomic management. The new Sudan
faces a future with limited oil resources and thus must find other factors to drive the growth
of the economy. The effects of the secession on South Sudan would be largely through the
fiscal and external accounts. With roughly 75 percent of the GONU oil revenues generated
from southern oil production, the oil revenues to the Government and the foreign exchange
receipts from oil will be severely reduced. This will be a challenge for the management of
the budget, the exchange rate and the external balance. Painful, unpopular but necessary
fiscal and external balance adjustments will have to be made to sustain the macroeconomic
stability essential for reviving and sustaining growth. Sudan will have to engage its
significant human and non-oil natural resources to build a prosperous future for its citizens.
Disparities in Development
23. Sudan's growth process has been unbalanced, with the majority of its manufacturing
firms and irrigated land concentrated in the centre with a huge disparity in development
indicators between the best and worst performing regions in Sudan. Outcomes from the
NBHS 2009 for a number of individual MDG-related indicators confirm that the major
challenge facing Sudan's progress towards the MDGs is the massive inequality in outcomes
and access to services (Table 4). Overall, there appears to be little evidence of aggregate
improvements in social indicators such as poverty and educational enrolment. The
significant development disparities between urban and
_______________________________________
1.Government of Sudan (2011); High Committee for Studying the Present Status of
Agriculture and Articulate a Future Vision and Action Plan for Agricultural Revival (in
collaboration with FAO): Executive Programme for Agricultural Revival;
2 World Bank (2009), Sudan Investment Climate Assessment
experienced two regime transitions, extreme political repression and predatory economic
measures in favour of the ruling party and against traditional entrepreneurs. Expansionary
fiscal policy, rising interest rates and overvalued currency drained the country's resources
during the 1980s and early 1990s. Arrears accumulated, relations with creditors worsened
and the country plunged into external debt distress.
11. After successful stabilization in the mid-1990s, Sudan maintained a strong track record
for macroeconomic management that resulted in a low and stable single-digit inflation rates
and a steady exchange rate. Real GDP growth rate averaged nearly 8 percent during the nine-
year period ending in 2009 (see Table 1) and per capita income increased from US$776 in
2004 to US$1,570.4 in 2009. Oil was discovered in Sudan in 1978 but the petroleum sector
became a major contributor to the economy in 2000 when it accounted for 6.8 percent of
GDP compared to 1.5 percent in 1999. The expansion of the petroleum sector, to 15 percent
of the GDP in 2009, contributed to the rapid growth of the economy after 2000. Apart from
the direct impact, the growing receipts from petroleum exports and the related sharp
increases in government revenues and expenditures and inflows of foreign direct investments
(FDI) stimulated other sectors in the economy. Construction and the service sectors boomed
and by 2009 the service sector contributed 40 percent of GDP, surpassing agriculture as the
leading sector in the economy. Trade, hotels and restaurants have flourished, mainly in the
country's capital (Khartoum), generating about one-fifth of the GDP during 2004-2009.
1.1 Introduction
1. Sudan has had one of the highest growth rates amongst Sub-Saharan African countries and
a rapidly rising per capita income, with per capita GDP of US$1,500. Nonetheless, the
country's human development outcomes remain weak. Sudan ranks 154 out of 169 countries
in UNDP's 2010 Human Development Index, especially relative to the fact that income per
capita GDP exceeded $1,500 or roughly 25 percent higher than the Sub-Saharan Africa
(SSA) average. In 2009, Sudan was the third largest producer of crude oil in SSA, behind
Nigeria and Angola, although Sudan's production was only about 30 percent of Angola's.
Despite the rising per capita income, the incidence of poverty is high, with 46.5 percent of
the population is below the poverty line. There is also significant variation in the incidence
of poverty between urban and rural areas as well as between states in the Federation. The
incidence of poverty in Khartoum state is 26.0 percent and 69.4 percent in North Darfur.
2. The road to sustainable broad-based development in Sudan has been hampered by a
number of country-specific challenges that render Sudan's experience unique from other
post- conflict countries in the region. Since its independence in 1956, Sudan has been mired
in several conflicts, with the exception of 1972-1983; the period after the Addis Ababa Peace
Agreement was signed. These conflicts have led to huge loss of life and have severely
debilitated the country's capacity for development. Development projects in areas affected by
armed conflict were often undermined by insecurity and weak and disintegrating socio-
economic fabric of communities. Exodus or influx of IDPs created environments not
conducive for meaningful development initiatives. International isolation, the Darfur
conflict, and the tenuous North-South relationship diverted attention from the development
agenda and its impact on bringing peace and security. In recent years, most of the civil
conflicts, including the rebellion in Southern Sudan have been resolved. But armed conflict
continues in Darfur, with risks of conflict emerging in some other areas. These past and
ongoing conflicts pose challenges for governance, human development, and poverty
reduction in Sudan.
3. The people and Government of Sudan will need to build institutions for peace and
development and shift resources and attention from war to investing in the future. With the
three peace agreements and ongoing efforts for a lasting and comprehensive peace agreement
in Darfur, Sudan has its greatest opportunity in a generation to concentrate on improving the
lives of Sudanese and consolidate and sustain peace. Support from the international
development community, particularly drawing from the accumulated international
experience on post-conflict recovery and peace building, will enhance the prospects for
sustained peace and economic developments. As building peace and security creates
additional expenditure obligations such as financing the reintegration of displaced persons
and new institutions associated with the peace agreements, the financial support from the
international community will be crucial.
4. Sudan's debt problems can be traced back to the 1960s when the country embarked on
large-scale industrialization, financed in part by foreign borrowing on non-concessional
terms, and accompanied by government heavy regulation of the economy. The resulting
heavy debt burden has shaped the evolution of the country's economy and its performance
over the past 20 years. The arrears to International Development Association (IDA), the
African Development Bank (AfDB) and other development agencies have prevented normal
relations with these agencies and constrained access to concessional financing. Sudan's
external debt, which amounted to US$37 billion at end-