Cer aneene 10. 12 13. 4 15, 16, V7 18, 19. 20. 2 22. 23. LIST OF CASES REFERRED Main Bashir Ahmed v. State of J&K AIR 1982. Hamdard Dawakliana v. Union of ludia AIR 1960 SC 554. D, Sudhakar _v.D.N. Jeevaraju and others, 2011(5) RCR (Civil) 318. Prakash Singh Badal v. Union of India AIR 1987 P & H 263 Ravi. S. Naik v. Union of India 1994(2) SCC 641 Banjak Phom v. Thenucho (1993) 1 Gau, LR 356. Mayawati v. Matkandeya Chand AIR 1998 SC3340 Laxinan Jaidev Satpathy v. Union of India 1992 ($2) SCC 744. G.Viswanathan ¥. The Hou’ble Speaker of Tamilnadu 1996 SCC (2) 353. Amar Singh v. Union of India (2011) 1 SCC 210 Dr. Luis Proto Barbosa v. Union of India and others Writ Petition No. 324/1990 High court of Bombay, Goa bench at Panaji dated 18-12-1990. Dr. Luis Proto Barbosa v. Union of India and others AIR 1992 SC 1812 dated 10-12-1991 Kihoto Hollohon v. Zachillhu, AIR 1993 SC 412. Narasimha Rao V. State AIR 1998 SC 2120. Indian National Congress v. State of Goa and others, SLP(C) No. 2942/2018 Sti Filipe Nery Rodrigues v. Sri Sadanand Mahalu Shet 2006(2) BOMCR 424, (2006)108 BOMLR227 Dharmappa Sabanna Madar v.Chief Secretary ILR 1990 KARNATAKA 1637. Jayashankara Gowda v.Chief SecretaryILR 1988 Kamataka 1005. Matiyappa Narasappa Halavagala_v.Chief Secretary, ILR 1988 KARNATAKA 2675. C\S. Kale Gowda v. Chief Secretary, Hassan Zilla ParishadILR 1990 2781 Dharmappa Sabana v. Chief Secretary, Zilla Parishad ILR 1991 KAR 3723 Devaraj v. State Election Commissioner, Karnataka ILR 2000 KAR 1493. ‘Ali Chandrappa v. The Deputy Commissioner and Another, 2001 (2) KCCR 791.26. 39, 40. AL ‘Viswanath Kappathanavar v. Channu Patil and Another, 2000(2) KCCR 1250. N. Shivanna v. The Deputy Commissioner and Others, 2004(4) KCCR SN429. Ramachandra v. The State Election Commission and Others, 2002(6) KarLJ324, Ananda Lakshmi v. Deputy Commissioner, Mysore ILR 2002 KAR 5199, Shobha v. State Election Commission ILR 2003 KAR 3104. Treppa Thirakappa v. The Deputy Commissioner, 2005(2) Karl.1193 Kitrur Yasmin Riyaz v. Deputy Commissioner, ILR 2009 KAR 47, Byrappa and Others. v. The Deputy Commissioner and Others, ILR 2010 KAR 397, Rajamma v, The Deputy Commissioner, The City Municipal Council 2010(6) KarLJ 281. 3. Chandrashekar_v. The Deputy Commissioner 2011(2) KCCR912. B.C. Parthasarathy v. Deputy Commissioner Mysore District 2012(1) Karl.1646. Byrappa v. The Deputy Commissioner, Mandya 2012(2)KarLI34. Geetha Lakshmi v.The Indian National Congtess ILR 2012 KAR 18. HP. Satish Kumar, v, The Deputy Commissioner, 201 1(4)KatL 1625. Makandat Zakit and Another v.The Deputy Commissioner, Bijapur District 2013(1) AKR 686. Lokamma v.The Deputy Commissioner, Raichur 2013(2)Karl.1169. Punishothama v. SM. Nandakumar Writ Appeal Nos. 15436/2011 decided on 06.08.2012. Anitha H. Basavaraj and Others v.Kamataka State Election Commission and others 2016(1)KarLJ403 Sadashiv H Patil v. Vithal D.Teke and others AIR 2000SC 3044. Hemalata v. Deputy Commissioner, Bagalkot District 2017(4)KarLJ607. Srimathi Bangera v. President, District Congress Committee and others 2017(4)KarL3318. Digambar Rao & S.S. Gundaiah v. State of Kamataka 21/07/1987 Jayashankar Gowda v. Chief Secretary 14.3.1988 ILR 1988 KAR 1005.47. 48. 49. 37. 58, 59, 60. 61 64. 65. 6. 67. 68. Siddaramaiah v.Anwari Basavaraj Patil ILR 1994 KAR 552 Peoples Union of Civil liberties v. State of UP 2011 (87) ALR 338. ‘Narayanadevi Tulasiram v. Sattatraya Maniti Bawalekar ,1993(95) BOMLRI29 PandurangaDagaduParte v, Ramachandra Baburao Hire and others, AIR 1997 BOM 387, ‘Uday Singh v. The State of Maharashtra 2007(2) ALLMR36, 2007(1) BOMCRS8S '2. Manoj BansilalBiyani v. Sameer Krishnandan & Collector NP. 3744/2008 Bombay, '3. Sahebrao v.The collector 2011(1) ALLMR 781, 2011(6) Bom CR 115. Shantabai v. State of Maharashtra &others. 2011(1)ALLMR27. ‘Vinubhai Devjibhai Yadav v. Bhikhabhai Kurajibhai Sadadiya and others. Amrubbai Nagbhai Maitra v.Competent Authority under Gujarat Provision for Disqualification of _ Members of Local Authorities for Defection Act, 1986. Devabhai Parbat bhai and others.v.Competent Authority AIR 2008 Guj20 Kaminiben $ Padhya v. District Collector (2008)2 GLR 1833, Bhagawati Prasad Himatlal Joshi v. Pinakin Pravin 2009 GLH(3)14. Padhya Kaminiben v. Manish kumar suresh (2009)3GLR2737. Pravinji Shattaji Thakote v. State of Gujarat Spl.Civil Application 5505/2008. 2. Rajeshriben Vinayakbhai Dave v. A.K. Rakesh and Others 33. Devabhai Parbhatbhai and others v. Competent Authority, Anti-Defeetion Act 2009 GLH (3)385 Lalsingh G Ratwa v. Competent Authority 2010 GLH (1)401 Bachubhai Rimbhai Makwana v. State of Gujarat AIR 2012 Guj170. Madhuben and Others v, State of Gujarat Special Civil Application No 7A1 of 2011. Raiyabhai Mohanbhai Savalia v, Settlement Commissioner and others.201 GLH (2)511. Shardaben Premjibhai v. Settlement Commissioner Letters Patent Appeal No. 506 of 201169. Chamanbhai Maganbhai Vinzula v.The Designated Authority and Others (2013)3GLR 2233. 70. Laxmiben v. Designated Authority under the Defection Act and others (2015)3GLR2453 71, Mukundkumar v, Chief Election Commissioner (2013)3GLR2753. 72, Naranbhai v. State of Gujarat, Special Civil Application No. 382 of 2013. 73, fiviben Gemabhai v. A.J. Shah Special Civil Application No.9167 of 2016. 74, Asif Jehan v. Executive Officer, Doda Municipal Corporation 2008(2)KI748, 75, Jose Puthenkala v. Kerala State Election Commission, W.P. (C) Nos. 10046- 49 of 2005, 76, Sunny Varkey v, Jose P, Puthenkala W.A, Nos. 1855-1857 of 2005. 77. Khadeeja v. T.P. Siddique 2000(1)KLI195, 78, Faisal P.A. v. KA. Abdulla Kunhi 2008(2) KarL 3849. 79. S. Shajahan v. Chathannoor Grama Panchayat 2000(2) KLJ451 80. Madhu ¥. State Election Commission 2004(1) KLT49. 81. Abdul Haque v. Pathumma 2005(1) KLT980. 82, Anitha v. Kanjirappilly Block Panchayat 2004(3) KLT21 83, Pathumma v. State Election Commission 2004(2) KLTS68. 84, Mohandas K.P. y. State Election Commissioner & Others, 2009(3) KLI746. 85, Nattakam Suresh v. The Kerala State Election Commission & Others 2009(3) KL1482. 86, Ramaswamy v. Kamaraj Ponnuswamy 2010(1) KLT255, 87. Varghese v. Kerala State Election Commission 2009(2) KLJS16. 88, Vijayam, L. v. Parassala Block Panchayat W.P. (C) No. 318 of 2009, 89, Chinnamma Varghese v. State Election Commission 2010(3) KLT426. 90. Ms, Shiney Augustine v. Kerala Election Commission W.A. No. 2324 of 2009. 91. SR. Chudhuri v. State of Punjab & Others, 2001 (7) SCC 126. 92. M. Nagaraj and Others v. Union of India & Others 2006 (8) SCC 212. 93. Mannadi Satyanarayana Reddy v. Andhra Pradesh (W.P.No: 28453 & 28624/2008.)94, Kanhaiya Lal Omar v. R-K. Trivedi and others, 1984(4) SCC 628, 95. All Party Leaders conference, Shillong v.Captain Sangma and others, 1977(4) SCC 161 96, Nabam Rebia and Bamang Felix v. Deputy Speaker & Others, 2016(8) SCI. (Civil Appeals Nos. 6203 - 6204/2016). 97. Vinod Kumar Binny v, The Speaket, Delhi Legislative Assembly, W.P.(C) 1154/2014, 98, Avatar Singh Bhadana v. Sri Kuldeep Singh, Indian National Congress, Lok Sabha Bulletin, 10.09.2008. 99. Rajesh Verma v. Sri Mohammad Shahid Akhlaque, Civil Mise.Writ Petition No: 9750/2008. 100. Kunwar Pranav Singh Champion v. The Speaker (W.P No: 826/2016(M/S). 101. Subodh Uniyal and Others v, Speaker (Writ Petition No: 828/2016(M/S), 102. Indian National Congress v. State of Goa (W.P. 688/2017 Dated: 11.11.2017) 103. Surendra Vassant Sirsat v. Legislative Assembly of Goa, ATR 1996 BOM 10, 104, P. Vettivel v, P. Dhanabal (W.P. No 25260-25267/2017 dated: 14.06.2018. 105. NarsingRao GurunathPatil y, Arun Gujarathi, Speaker 2003 105(3)BOM LR 354, 106. PemaKhanduv. The Speaker, Arunachal Pradesh (MANU, HG/0118/2016 decided on 03-03-2016) 107. Alagaapuram R Mohanraj and Others v. Tamilnadu Legislative Assembly, 2016(6) SCC 82 108, Ridge v, Baldwin 1964 Appeal cases 40, 1963(2) All England Reporters 66 (HL). 109. J, Mahopatra& Company v. State of Orissa (1984) 4SCC 103. 110. State of Uttar Pradesh v. Sheo ShankerLal Srivastava, (2006) 3 SCC 276. 111. Dr-Kashilnath G Talmi v. The Speaker, Goa Legislative Assembly, AIR 1993 SC 1873.112. Tyoti Basu v. Debi Ghosal, (1982) 3 SCR 318 (326). 113. Durga Shankar Mehta v. Ranghuraj Singh,(1955)ISCR 267, 114. Union of India v. Tulsiram Patel, 198SAIR 1416. 115. Keshav Singh’s Case: Special Reference No: 1, 1965(1) SCR 413 116. Keshavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala and others, AIR (1973) 4 SCC 225. 117. Raja Ram Pal. Speaker, Lok Sabha and Others 2007(3) SCC 184 118. Tata Cellular v. Union of India, 1994 (6) SCC 651 119. D.Sudhakar v.D.N. Jeevaraju& Others, (2012)2 SCC 708 120. C.B.Gautam y. Union of India, (1993) 1 SCC 78. 121. ChandramaTewari_ v. Union of India, 1998 SCR (1) 1102 122. KL. Tripathi v. State Bank of India and others, 1984(1) SCC 43 123, Schedule Caste and weaker Section Welfare Association and others v State of Kerala & Others 1991 (2) SCC 604, 124. Suresh Koshy George v. University of Kerala AIR 1969 SC 198 125. Union of India v. Jesus sales corporation 1996 (4) SCC 69. 126. Escorts Farms Limited v. Commissioner 2004 (4) SCC 281 127. ECILv. Karnakar 1993(4) SCC 727. 128. Haryana Financial Corporation v. Kailash Chandra Ahuja (2008) 9 SCC 31 129. Malloch v. Aberdeen Corporation, 1971(1) WLR 1578. 130. DharmapalSatyapal Ltd v, Commissioner of Central Exercise, Guwahati, 2015(8) SCC 519. 131. Ramakrishna Verma v. State of UP (1992) 2 SCC 620. 132. Bank of India and others v. T. Jogram, ATR 2007 SC 2793 133. Government of Andhra Pradesh & Others v. Mohd. Nasrullah Khan, AIR 2006 SC 1214. 134, Kalinga Mining Coxporation v. Union of India, 2013(5) SCC 252. 135. Union of Indiav.V.T-R Verma, AIR 1957 SC 882. 136. Narayan BhagwantRao Gossari_ v. Gopal Vinayak Gosavi, AIR 1960 SC 100. 137. Kanungo and Company v. Collector of Customs and Others, 1373(2) SCC 438 138. Union of India v. G. Ganayutham , 1997 (7) SCC 463,139. Mafatlal Industries Limited v. Union of India, 1997(5) SCC 536. 140. BR. Kapoor v. State of Tamilnadu (2001) 7 SCC 231 141. Fareed Mahfooz v. The Speaker, U.P Legislative Assembly.201 1(10) ADISS?. 142. Kailash Nath Singh Yadav v. Speaker, Lucknow, AIR 1993 All 334. 143, Ashok Kumar Mishra v. Collector Raipur & Others, 1980 ISCR 491. 144. Dr. Wilffed A Desouza v. Hon'ble Speaker, Goa 1991(1) BOMCR594 145. NarsingraoGurunath Patil v. Arun Gujarathi, Speaker 2003(1) BOMCR363 146. Matanhy Saldanha v. Hon’ble Speaker, 2012(1) BOMCR 138. 147. MorSalin S.K v. The State of West Bengal, (2010) 4 CALLT 248 (HC). 148. Smt.Sabitti Mitrav. The Hon'ble Speaker, West Bengal, (2013)2 CALLT 145 HC. 149. SamataAndolan Samiti v. UOI W.P(C) No: 2249/2013 decided on 29.04.2013. 150. Kulabidhu Sing v.The Speaker, Manipur(1986) 2GLR 91 151. Keshab Gogoi v. Hon’ble Speaker, Assam (1995) 1 GLRS2 152. ThangminlienKupgen v.Amutombi Singh, W.P 6335/2000 dated: 23.11.2000. 153. Amutombi Singh v. ThangminlienKipgen and others, 2000(3) GLTS79. 154. Maniher Singh v. Speaker, Manipur Legislative Assembly, CR 5049/94. 155. Nipamacha Singh v. Speaker, Manipur and others, CR 5185/94.2001(2) GLT 130 156. Speaker, Jammu and Kashmir v. Abdul Jabbar AIRI98SI&K 1 157. Brabot__v.Speaker, Manipur Legislative Assembly, (2004) IGLR 236, 158. _Imkonglmchen& Others v. Union of India, AIR 2006 Gaul decided on 28.7.2005. 159. Yitachn v. union of India, 2008(2) GLT 284 decided on 12.03.2008, 160. ImtilembaSangtam y.Speaker, Nagaland, 2014(5) GLT443 161. BanjakPhom and Others v. The Nucho and Others, Civil Rule Nos, 110-119/1991, decided on 27.01.1992162. Md Ayub v. Speaker U-P Legislative Assembly,2016(8) ADJ281 dated 09.08.2016 163. DilipSinh\Vakhatsinh Parmar v. Speaker of Gujarat (1998) 3 GER 2119. 164. Kuldeep Bishnoi v. Speaker, Haryana Vidhana Sabha (2011), ILR P & HL. 165. Kashmir Singh v. Monsa Ram and Others, 2001(3) ShimLC21. 166. State of Kerala v. Sudarshan Babu, ATR 1984 Ker 1, Paragraph 31 167. NE. Horo, President, Jharkhand Party v. State of Tharkhand 2005(2) BLIRISS9 168. Asif JehanGatter v. Executive Officer, Municipal Corporation, 2008(2) IKI7A8. 169. A.K. Subbaiah v, Sti Ramakrishna Hegde and others, AIR 1994 Kant35. 170. Gopala Krishna Belur& Others v. B.S. Yeddyurappa , ILR 2010 Kamataka 4767. 171. D. Sudhakar v. D.N. Jeevaraju and others, 201 1(5) RCR (Civil) 318. 172. AzhaguThinmarukkarasu v.Speaker, Tamilnadu Legislative Assembly, 1995(1) CTC 217, 173, P.C.George v. The Hon'ble Speaker, Kerala , 2016(2) KHC 137. 174, _$, Rathinam v.Speaker, Legislative Assembly Pondicherry, and Writ Petition No 83/2001 decided on 08.02.2001 175. NarendraSingh v. Bihar Legislative Council & Others, Letters patent Appeal No: 1130/2016 decided on 17.07.2017. 176. The Bihar Legislative Assembly, Patna v. Gyanendra Kumar Singh, Letters Patent Appeal No: 83/2015 decided on 07.04.2015 177. Renu Kumari v.The Bihar Legislative Assembly and others, 2015(1) PLIRS35. 178. Madan Mohan Mittal.The Speaker, Punjab1997 (4) RCR (Civil) 597. 179, Baljit Singh Bhullar v, Hon'ble Speaker, Punjab 1997(4) RCR (Civil) oll 180. Ram Bilas Sharma v. The Speaker, Haryanal997(4) RCR (Civil) 519 181. Vasudev Sharma v.Speaker, Haryana Vidhana Sabha 1997(4) RCC (Civil) 515.182. Dr Mahachandra Prasad Singh v. Chairman, Bihar Legislative Council 2004)8SCC747, 183. Jagajit Singh v. State of Haryana and others (2006)11 SCC 1 184. Rajendra Singh Rana v. Swamy Prasad Maurya and others(2007)4 SCC 270. 185. Balachandta Jarkiholi v. B.S. Yeddyurappa and others (2011) 7SCC1 186. In Speaker Orissa v. Utkal Keshari Parida(2013) 11 SCC 794. 187. Renu Kumari v. The Bihar Legislative Assembly and Others 2015(1)PLIRS35. 188. Jaswant Singh Gurjar v. Hon ble Speaker, Rajasthan 2011 (1) LR (Raj) 436. 189. Amrita Rawat and Others v. Speaker Legislative Assembly 2017(1)UC 786. 190. Godavri Mista vy, Nandakisore Das, AIR 1953 Orissa 111 191. Saradhakar Supakar v. Speaker, Orissa AIR 1952 Orissa 234 192. M.S.M. Sharma v. Dr-Shree Krishna Sinha ATR 1960 SC 1186. 193. Manilal Singh v. Dr. H-Borobabu Singh 1993 SCR(1)769. 194. Majji Dharma Rao v. Goutu Syamasunder Sivaji. AIR 1996 A.P 354. 195. The Bihar Legislative Assembly Patna and Others v.Gyanendra Kumar SinghLetters Patent Appeal Nos. 83 and 128 of 2015 in Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.18807 of 2014, 196. Narendra Singh v. The Bihar Legislative Council and Others Letters Patent Appeal No. 1130 of 2016. 197. Zachilhu Khusantho v. State of Nagaland. 7(1993) Supp. (1) Gau LR 359 (378) 198. GS. Iqbal v. KM. Khader (2009) 11 SCC 198. 199. Kuldip Nayar v. Union of India, AIR 2006 SC 3127. 200. Mian Bashir Ahmed y, State of Jammu & Kashmir.AIR 1982J&K26, 201. Vinod Kumar Binni v. Speaker, Delhi Legislative Assembly WP(C) No. 1154/2014, 202. Jagadambika Pal v Union of India and others (1998)2 SCALES3 203. Jagjit Singh’s case 2006(11) SCC 1 204. Bhajaman Behera v. Speaker Orissa Legislative Assembly AIR 1990 Orissa (FB)205. Ananga Udaya Singh Deo v. Ranga Nath Mishra and others ATR 2001 Ori 24. 206. Pashupati Nath Sukul v. Nem Chandra Jain AIR 1984 SC 399. 207. Kuldip Nayar v. union of India. AIR 2006 SC3127. 208. Shrimanth Balasaheb Patil v. Honb’le Speaker Karnataka 20198CC Online $C1454, 209. R.Bhoopathi Reddy v. The Chairman, Telangana State Legislative Council W-P No: 2698/2019 dated 17.07.2019. 210. Shravan Kumar v. GyanendraKumar Singh Letters Patent Appeal No.83/2015 dated 07.04.2015 211. Keisham Meghachandra Singh v. The Speaker Manipur Legislative Assembly dated 18.03.2020. 212. Khumukcham Joykishan Singh v. The The Speaker Manipur Legislative Assembly W.P No: 82/2020 dated 8,06.2020, 213. Subodh Uniyal & others v. Speaker Legislative Assembly& another WP No.826/2016 dated 9 May 2016 214. ML Sachde v. Union of India, ATR 1991 SC 311 215. Amar Singh and others v. Speaker, State of U.P decided on Jan.,2013