THM 117
THM 117
MIDTERM HANDOUT
Department: CHTM
Subject/Descriptive title: THM 117 – Strategic Management with Total Quality Management
Term: 1st Trimester, AY 2023-2024
Strategy and Strategic Objectives for Tourism, Hospitality and Event Organizations
Historically the term strategy has military roots with commanders employing strategy in dealing with their
opponents. Indeed dictionaries often continue the military theme defining strategy as ‘the art of war’. In viewing
strategy in such a way the fundamental underlying premise of strategy becomes the notion that an adversary can
defeat a rival (even a larger more powerful one) if it can out maneuver the rival.
As in the military arena, so in business: organizations attempt to outmaneuver rivals. In so doing strategies have to
be developed that rely on various disciplines such as marketing, finance and human resource management.
WHAT IS STRATEGY?
Strategy is the determination of the basic long-term goals and objectives of an enterprise, and the adoption of
courses of action and the allocation of resources necessary for carrying out these goals.
(Chandler, 1962)
The adoption of courses of action refers to the actions taken to arrive at the objectives that have been previously
set.
The allocation of resources refers to the fact that there is likely to be a cost associated with the actions required
in order to achieve the objectives. If the course of action is not supported with adequate levels of resource, then
the objective will not be accomplished
Financial resources– Money for capital investment and working capital. Sources include shareholders, banks,
bondholders, etc
Physical (tangible) resources– Land, buildings (offices, accommodation, warehouses, etc.), plant, equipment, stock
for production, transport equipment, etc
Human resources– Appropriately skilled employees to add value in operations and to support those that add value
(e.g. supporting employees in marketing, accounting, personnel, etc.). Sources include the labor markets for the
appropriate skill levels required by the organization
Intellectual (intangible) resources– Inputs that cannot be seen or felt but which are essential for continuing
business success, for example ‘know-how’, legally defensible patents and licenses, brand names, registered
designs, logos, ‘secret’ formulations and recipes, business contact networks, databases, etc
Mintzberg’s Five Ps
Mintzberg suggested that nobody can claim to own the word ‘strategy’ and that the term can legitimately be used
in several ways.
Plan Strategies
▸ A plan is probably the way in which most people use the word strategy. It tends to imply something that is
intentionally put in place and its progress is monitored from the start to a predetermined finish. Some business
strategies follow this model. ‘Planners’ tend to produce internal documents that detail what the company will do
for a period of time in the future (say five years). It might include a statement on the overall direction that the
organization will take in seeking new business opportunities as well as a schedule for new product launches,
acquisitions, financing (i.e. raising money), human resource changes, marketing, etc
Pattern Strategies
▸ A ‘pattern of behavior’ strategy is one in which progress is made by adopting a consistent form of behavior.
Unlike plans and ploys, patterns ‘just happen’ as a result of the consistent behavior.
▸ Such patterns of behavior are sometimes unconscious, meaning that they do not even realize that they are
following a consistent pattern. Nevertheless, if it proves successful, it is said that the consistent behavior has
emerged into a success. This is in direct contrast to planning behavior.
There is a key difference between two of Mintzberg’s Ps of strategy – plan and pattern. The difference is to do
with the source of the strategy. He drew attention to the fact that some strategies are deliberate whilst others
are emergent
Deliberate strategy
(sometimes called planned or prescriptive strategy) is meant to happen. It is preconceived, premeditated and
usually monitored and controlled from start to finish. It has a specific objective
Emergent strategy
has no specific objective. It does not have a preconceived route to success but
it may be just as effective as a deliberate strategy. By following a consistent pattern of behavior
an organization may arrive at the same position as if it had planned everything in detail
Ploy Strategies
▸ A ploy is generally taken to mean a short-term strategy, and is concerned with the detailed tactical actions that
will be taken. It tends to have very limited objectives and it may be subject to change at very short notice. Mintzberg
describes a ploy as ‘a maneuver intended to outwit an opponent or competitor’ (Mintzberg et al., 2002: 3). He
points out that some companies may use ploy strategies as threats. They may threaten to, say, decrease the price
of their products simply to destabilize competitors.
Position Strategies
▸ A position strategy is appropriate when the most important issue to an organization is perceived to be how it
relates or is positioned in respect to its competitors or its markets (i.e. its customers). In other words, the
organization wishes to achieve or defend a certain position.
▸ In business, companies tend to seek objectives such as market share, profitability, superior research, reputation,
etc. It is plainly obvious that not all companies are equal when such criteria are considered.
Perspective Strategies
▸ Perspective strategies are about changing the culture (the beliefs and the ‘feel’; the way of looking at the world)
of a certain group of people – usually the members of the organization itself. Some companies want to make their
employees think in a certain way, believing this to be an important way of achieving success.
▸ They may, for example, try to get all employees to think and act courteously, professionally or helpfully.
Different ‘levels’
It is useful at this stage to gain an understanding of what characterizes strategic decisions. Management decisions
in an organization can be classified in three broad and sometimes overlapping categories: strategic, tactical and
operational. These can be illustrated as a hierarchy in which higher level decisions tend to shape those at lower
levels of the organization
Levels of Strategic Decision-Making
Strategic, tactical and operational
decisions within an organization differ
Strategic Level
from each other in terms of their:
● focus;
● level in the organization at which they Tactical Level
are made;
● scope; Operational
● time horizon; Level
● degree of certainty or uncertainty;
● complexity.
21
The decision-making framework can be visualized as a pyramid-shaped hierarchy. The top, where the strategic
decisions are made, is thin whilst the bottom (operational decisions) is fatter. This representation is meant to show
that strategic decisions are taken infrequently, whilst tactical and operational decisions are taken more often.
Strategic decisions are few and far between, tactical decisions are taken with increasing frequency, whilst
operational decisions are taken weekly, daily or even hourly. For every one strategic decision, there may be
hundreds of individual operational decisions.
intangibility
ownership inseparability
heterogeneity perishability
INTANGIBILITY
Services cannot normally be seen, touched, smelt, tasted, tried on for size or stored on a shelf prior to purchase.
Their intangibility makes them harder to buy, since you cannot test them, but easier to distribute, since there is no
physical product to distribute.
For example – a buyer working for a tour operator, event manager or travel intermediary might be able to sample
the food and accommodation prior to contracting the supplier. However, the exact quality of the accommodation
and meals that the customer will receive is still intangible. This is because the quality of the accommodation or the
meals that the customer receives (or their perception of them) may be different from those sampled prior to
contracting.
INSEPARABILITY
The production and consumption of services, including those in THE sectors, are inseparable.
For example – to take advantage of a festival music event you have to be at the event at the time it is taking place.
In other words, the event is being delivered (produced) at the same time as you are listening to it (consuming).
Similarly, for you to make use of an air flight or a bus service, both you and the means of transport must make the
journey at the same time, i.e. the service is provided and consumed simultaneously
PERISHABILITY
Since production and consumption are simultaneous, THE services are instantly perishable; if the services are not
sold at the time they are offered, then they perish and no income is received
For example– an event which takes place and is not full to capacity; an empty train seat; an unoccupied hotel
bedroom; or, an unsold holiday, all represent lost opportunities. They are sales that have not taken place and that
can never be recovered because they are services offered on a certain date and cannot be ‘stored’ for when
demand increases. The income foregone cannot be recovered
HETEROGENEITY
Services, unlike mass-produced manufactured goods, are never identical. One hotel in a chain of hotels, one
person’s holiday or one person’s experience of an event will never be identical to another. The human element and
other factors in delivering services, ensures that services will be heterogeneous, i.e. varied.
THE products are human resource intensive i.e. ‘people oriented’, and the human factor plays a key role.
For example– the enjoyment gained from a foreign holiday cannot be separated from the personalities who go to
make up that holiday: the personnel employed in the travel agency; the airline crew; the hotel staff; the tour
operator’s representative; employees at destination attractions; and, of course, the other holidaymakers. All of
these have a role to play in ensuring that the holiday lives up to the customer’s expectations.
Similarly, the experiences in all hotels and hospitality outlets and events are closely linked to the attitude,
competence and personality of those charged with delivering the particular service.
OWNERSHIP
When a customer buys a manufactured product there will usually be a document, such as a receipt, which transfers
ownership from seller to buyer. When a consumer buys a service he or she does not usually receive ownership of
anything tangible.
For example– a car is hired, but ownership is not transferred; a hotel room is reserved for a period of time but
nothing in it is ever owned by the customer; a concert ticket provides access to the concert venue only for the time
that the concert is taking place. Even a credit card actually remains the property of the issuing company.
Service buyers are therefore buying only access to or use of something, which has important management
implications. Since transfer of ownership is not involved, the task of building a relationship with customers, of
retaining their custom, and building brand loyalty becomes more difficult.
ional services
e characteristics
rtainly applicable to
hese sectors, but Impact on society seasonality
ctors.
e identified, which
se sectors (though
sectors). Interdependence Ease of entry/exit
tics have a
making for
ee sectors.
The five characteristics of services cited in the preceding sections change the emphasis of a manager’s task when
compared to dealing with physical products. The characteristics apply to all service products to some degree –
which includes banking, insurance and professional services (legal accounting, etc.). Thus the characteristics
considered previously, whilst certainly applicable to THE sectors are not unique to these sectors, but applicable
across all service sectors.
Six further characteristics can be identified, which are particularly applicable to these sectors (though to varying
degrees in the three sectors). Consequently these characteristics have a particular influence on decision making for
managers operating in these three sectors.
HIGH COST
THE products often represent a relatively high-cost purchase for the consumer. The high cost of many THE products
has important managerial implications when formulating strategy, especially with regard to marketing aspects.
Potential customers will want reassurance about the reliability of the product, the value for money the purchase
represents, and the quality and value provided.
For example –with regard to some events, demand far exceeds supply. In such cases there is little chance for
reflection and comparison and a speedy impulse decision is necessary. Where a popular band announces they are
to give a series of concerts or a popular sporting event is scheduled, often potential buyers have to react quickly to
ensure success in purchasing tickets. There is thus little chance for reflection, comparison or negotiation in such
cases.
SEASONALITY
THE products often have some of the most seasonal patterns of demand for any category of product or service.
This seasonality has important managerial implications in terms of aspects of management such as: managing cash
flow; product pricing; managing the quantity of products supplied; and dealing with labor (and wider societal)
issues relating to the need to employ, motivate and retain seasonal employees.
For example –the seasonality of demand often leads to a highly seasonal pattern of cash flows for organizations in
these sectors which has to be carefully managed if staff and suppliers are to be paid promptly at low points in the
cycle. Consequently, at some times of the year, companies in these sectors may have relatively large surplus cash
balances to invest whilst, at other times, only small amounts of cash may be available or it may even be necessary
to borrow to meet cash requirements (Evans, 2002:358)
EASE OF ENTRY/EXIT
In many areas of THE it is relatively easy to set up in business or indeed to exit from the industry, i.e. entry and exit
costs are relatively low (compared to some other industries). To establish an oil refinery or a vehicle manufacturing
plant would require a large initial capital outlay (i.e. they are capital intensive industries), but this is not the case in
many parts of THE.
For example –the capital outlay to set up a tour operator, or an event organizer, is generally quite low (when
compared to other industrial sectors). Many of the services included in the product are leased, or are purchased as
and when required. The greatest (up-front) cost involved is often in producing brochures and other promotional
materials and marketing the products to agents and the public. Similarly, travel agents do not generally purchase
products from tour operators until the customer pays for them, and so do not incur the risk of unsold stock or
stock- holding costs.
INTERDEPENDENCE
THE, can be viewed as comprising six component sectors:
● hospitality
● events management
● attractions
● transport
● travel organizers
● destination organizations.
The important point to note in this context, however, is that the sectors are all linked and depend upon one
another; there is interdependence between them.
For example –the hospitality sector relies upon the transport sector to transport guests to and from the
accommodation. Similarly, the transport and hospitality sectors both rely upon the travel organizers and event
managers to provide them with customers
IMPACT OF TOURISM
The focus of attention is usually upon the impact tourism has upon host destinations. The impacts can be classified
as economic, social and environmental and classified into positive and negative impacts. However, it is important
to point out that the issues involved are often complex, interrelated and involve tourism together with other
industrial sectors including hospitality and events
For example –if a piece of land is cleared to make way for a new hotel development next to a beach, the overall
economic effect may be highly positive for the region in which it is built. However, those residents who have been
displaced may not feel so positively disposed towards the development.
Vision
Nature and importance of a clear vision
- A vision statement is a vivid idealized description of a desired outcome that inspires, energizes, and helps
firms create a mental picture of their target.
- Vision is what keeps the organization moving forward. It is the motivator in an organization
- An organization’s vision statement answers the question: “What do we want to become?” or “What can
we become?”
Mission
Nature and importance of a clear mission
- A company’s mission statement outlines the core purpose of the organization.
- It answers the question: “Why does the company exist?”
The form of government, political stability, the party in power, attitude towards foreign companies, laws
on various matters.
Economic factors
GDP, interest rates, exchange rates, unemployment rates, net disposable income, and money supply.
Socio-Cultural factors
Buying and consumption patterns of the people, their beliefs and values, customs and traditions, tastes
and preferences, social taboos, and societal expectations of the business.
The number of suppliers available in an industry can give those suppliers leverage over businesses.
If a business has few suppliers for the materials required to produce its products, the suppliers can raise
prices.
In industries with a larger number of suppliers, businesses typically have more bargaining power since they
can source their materials from different vendors.
External Evaluation Matrix (EFE), Internal Factor Evaluation Matrix (IFE), Competitive Profile Matrix (CPM), and
SPACE Matrix
Prepared by:
Ruel F Ramirez, MHRD, Faculty